Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / Special Feature: Onramp & Arch on Bitcoin-Backed Lending with Peter Duan
Transcript
- 0:00All right, what's up everyone? My name is Peter Duan.
- 0:04I am an ex wealth advisor. I'm trying to break into the
- 0:09Bitcoin world and I'm here very excited to have both On Ramp and
- 0:15Arch Lending talk about a financial product that the
- 0:20Bitcoin community has been clamoring about, which is the
- 0:24Bitcoin bonds. So with me, I have again the On
- 0:28Ramp team in Arch Lending. Would you guys like to let's
- 0:31start with On Ramp. Would you guys like to introduce
- 0:33yourself in your role at the company?
- 0:36Yeah, sure. Thank you, Peter.
- 0:39My name is Brian Cabelson, Chief Strategy Officer at On Ramp
- 0:43Focus. A lot of my efforts on all the
- 0:45education, content and research that we produce as well as
- 0:49helping out, you know, various facets of the business,
- 0:51everything from sales to to product and everything in
- 0:54between. So been with the firm for really
- 0:58since the early days, almost two years now, which is crazy to
- 1:01think about. Time has time has flown by, but
- 1:03it's a bit. It's been a lot of fun.
- 1:06Mitch Kochman, I'm Chief Revenue Officer at Onramp.
- 1:08My job is building products and services around our multi
- 1:11institution custody framework. My background started at IBM for
- 1:17about 12 years, went to Bitco for two.
- 1:21During that time it helped exchanges make it through the
- 1:22bear market of 2223 FTX, Silvergate Prime trust, Fortress
- 1:27trust. When the idea of for multi
- 1:30institution custody came to us at at Bitco and you know,
- 1:34building resiliency to, you know, to custody, it was it was
- 1:38no brainer for me that Bitco needed to be a part of it.
- 1:40And then I made the jump to on ramp and I've been here for a
- 1:43year. Wow, wow, awesome.
- 1:46So you, it sounds like you have seen quite a lot and yeah, on
- 1:49ramp is very, very, very lucky to have you.
- 1:52OK, perfect. What about over at Arch Lending?
- 1:56Alright, hey guys. My name is Himantra Sahay, I'm
- 1:59the Co founder CTRV at Arch. And my background is primarily
- 2:03in consumer tech. All the apps on your phone,
- 2:06Snapchat, Tinder, etcetera and also have been encrypted for a
- 2:10while, investment companies as an Angel and ran a small fund.
- 2:14And my friend Dhruv and I have actually been noodling on things
- 2:19for a long time, and we will tell you a bit more about what
- 2:23we're building here in a second. Yeah.
- 2:25Hey everyone, Dhruv Patel, Co founder, CEO.
- 2:28My background was in fintech and financial services, so I started
- 2:31my career off at Bridgewater associates because there is a
- 2:33quant on the research team and then left them to join a fintech
- 2:37startup called Brex early on. Spent a couple of years there
- 2:39launching and scaling different lending products.
- 2:42And as Sumatra mentioned, we teamed up just over three years
- 2:44ago to build, you know, the best Bitcoin back lending product.
- 2:48And, you know, we have a broader vision besides that as a
- 2:51company, but I think, you know, your viewers and that the focus
- 2:55of this is really to hone in on that product and the specific
- 2:58nuances and things that set us apart in the industry there.
- 3:01And so happy to dive deeper there.
- 3:04Perfect. That's a great start.
- 3:05Yeah. What why don't we go into why we
- 3:09all joined this call today, which is talking about Bitcoin
- 3:13bonds. Could you kind of explain what
- 3:15are Bitcoin bonds and how do they generally work?
- 3:20Yeah, so I think there's been a lot of talk about Bitcoin bonds
- 3:23as a thing. I, I, I would say what we're
- 3:26offering is, you know, there's some similarities to what people
- 3:28have talked about around Bitcoin bonds, but it's really a, a
- 3:32Bitcoin back lending product. You know, and the, the real main
- 3:36use case that we're aiming to solve for here is people don't
- 3:39want to sell their Bitcoin and they have liquidity needs,
- 3:42whether it's, you know, various expenses in, in, you know, daily
- 3:46life, a a big purchase, you know, different occasions within
- 3:49life that you, you have liquidity needs.
- 3:51But as we all know, we don't, we don't want to sell the Bitcoin.
- 3:54You don't want to lose out on that upside.
- 3:56And you also don't want to take the taxable event.
- 3:57And so I think there's, you know, there's long been real
- 4:02demand for, you know, high quality Bitcoin back lending
- 4:06products in this space. And frankly, you know,
- 4:08everything we saw in 22 into 23, you know, it, it wasn't all of
- 4:14those products and services weren't built on a very strong
- 4:17foundation and, and therefore you saw the things like
- 4:20rehypothecating collateral and, and various pitfalls of, of that
- 4:26space. And I think that's sort of, you
- 4:29know, a lot of those players got knocked out of the game back
- 4:32then and, and there weren't many left, left standing.
- 4:35And so I think, you know, our thought process and, and
- 4:38thinking through this was one, we know there's huge demand for
- 4:41this, but more importantly, we know we need to do this in a
- 4:44very conservative way and in a way that protects our clients
- 4:48assets at the end of the day. And so that was a lot of the
- 4:52impetus for us finding the guys from March and realizing that
- 4:56they were on to something with doing things in a prudent
- 4:59conservative manner, which it's really aligned with our ethos.
- 5:02And we thought it, you know, it would make sense to to dig in
- 5:06with them and figure out how to do this the right way.
- 5:08Perfect. Yeah, sorry, please.
- 5:12I was just going to say, Brian touched in a few things on why
- 5:18like we've been through a couple of iterations of lending now and
- 5:21we've actually learned from the mistakes of everybody else and
- 5:24what not to do. So as Brian mentioned, there's
- 5:26no hypothecation. We actually above a certain
- 5:29amount we will segregate assets and share the the address with
- 5:32the consumer so they can actually track exactly where
- 5:35their collateral is in all stages.
- 5:37And a few things about how we do things differently from even the
- 5:40other lenders today is we don't take retail capital on one end
- 5:45and lend it on the other end. We're not taking deposits and
- 5:47using that as lending capital. We actually have a very
- 5:51traditional financial facility which is it's quite large in
- 5:55size and it's longer duration. So we don't have the ability to
- 5:59call capital from any borrower and we go longer duration on our
- 6:04loans up to two years. So essentially in, in the
- 6:08traditional world when you have assets, what do you do?
- 6:10Like especially if you have a certain amount, you go to your
- 6:13private bank at UBS or Square or else and you employ the buy,
- 6:17borrow, die strategy, right. You're never going to use your
- 6:19assets as currency. You're always going to borrow
- 6:22against them and extract funds out of that.
- 6:24So you can do that now with us and through the partnership
- 6:27allows the the clients around ramp and obviously the clients
- 6:31that we have over time like benefit significantly by
- 6:35borrowing up to two years and then continuously beyond that.
- 6:38So you can borrow now, in two years, you can roll over into a
- 6:43new loan and keep doing it. And you're just spending the
- 6:46interest on that, not the principal.
- 6:48Got it, got it. And so we do you know,
- 6:52Bitcoiners in general are pretty financially savvy, but for those
- 6:57who are still a little bit newish, you know, we want to be
- 7:00a little bit careful in, you know, using terminology that can
- 7:04confuse people. So would you guys mind kind of
- 7:08re explaining what rehypothecation means and why
- 7:13you guys not doing that? And then what does it mean to be
- 7:16a long duration? Yeah.
- 7:18So essentially rehypothecation and this is this existing
- 7:22financial markets broadly. It's not just a Bitcoin term,
- 7:25but it's essentially when you take out a loan against your
- 7:28Bitcoin, your Bitcoin is now collateral.
- 7:30Rehypothecation means the lender is taking your Bitcoin and doing
- 7:34other things with it to generate further yield.
- 7:36Maybe they're lending it out to other kind of parties.
- 7:39And you can quickly see how in this scenario now there's more
- 7:42risk in the system because you posted your Bitcoin as
- 7:45collateral. That party has since then set
- 7:48your Bitcoin to somebody else. And now if a third or fourth
- 7:50party in the ecosystem goes, you know, sort of bankrupt or has
- 7:55some insolvency event, it impacts everybody along the way.
- 7:58And So what we've strictly done and don't do as a company is
- 8:01touch any client collateral. So we don't rehypothecate.
- 8:04What that means is it sits squarely at our custodian
- 8:07partners, namely Anchorage Digital, which is a federally
- 8:09Chartered Bank and a qualified custodian in the US And we can
- 8:13prove it to our clients as Hemansh, you mentioned earlier,
- 8:16with loans above a certain size where we segregate the Bitcoin
- 8:19on chain and share that address with our clients so that they
- 8:23can see during the duration of their loan and nothing has come
- 8:27in or out and their funds have not moved.
- 8:30So that's the first on the rehab application.
- 8:32And then to answer your second point about duration, this
- 8:36really just means for how long you're taking out the loan for.
- 8:39You'll see typically, you know, in in this industry, most people
- 8:43are doing shorter term loans. And what I mean by that is maybe
- 8:4690 days, six months or less. But as Amash you mentioned,
- 8:50given the way we've raised our financing as a business in a CLO
- 8:54traditional structure, we actually allow our clients to
- 8:57take out loans up to two years and at the end of that cycle,
- 9:00they can go and roll that over into another two year loan.
- 9:04And so this really allows them to borrow continuously and as
- 9:08the price of their Bitcoin appreciate, they can easily
- 9:12access more cash again. Got it.
- 9:14So could you tell us about the loan terms?
- 9:20So you already mentioned that you guys have up to two years.
- 9:24What about the loan to value, also known as LTV?
- 9:28And what about the interest rates that you charge?
- 9:31Yeah. So in our partnership with
- 9:32Onramp, we offer 50% loan to value or anything up to 50% loan
- 9:38to value on Bitcoin. There is a model call event at
- 9:4270%. So when that happens, you have
- 9:4524 hours to either post a little bit more collateral or pay down
- 9:48some principle in the interests of bringing your LTV down to a
- 9:52healthy LTV again. If it does hit 80%, there's a
- 9:56liquidation trigger. We never liquidate the full
- 9:58amount, just a small amount to bring you back to a healthy LTV
- 10:01again. And then the interest rate that
- 10:04we mentioned. So it's 14% interest and then
- 10:07there's a 1 1/2 percent origination fee.
- 10:10Got it. Why?
- 10:11Why did you guys establish that as an interest rate?
- 10:16Yeah. I think sort of like the
- 10:18interest rate is, it's not just like a set number.
- 10:20It comes from various like a variety of different ways to
- 10:24back out of it. The first is where the federal
- 10:27funds rate is in general, which you know after the last few
- 10:31years of us being at nearly zero interest rates, the baseline
- 10:34interest rate is much higher now nearing sort of like 5:00-ish
- 10:37percent. And then as a result of that
- 10:40lenders are more priced as a spread on top of that.
- 10:44So when you look at us as a non bank lender, we're raising
- 10:47capital from large financial institutions that allow us to
- 10:51then generate like lend out to our end clients and our business
- 10:55model is really the spread in between and that's how we get to
- 10:58this 14% number. And then I will say that the
- 11:01cost will be going down over the current months and definitely
- 11:04over the coming years. Why do you say that?
- 11:08It's just a function of scale. And then also as well one, I
- 11:13think like the macro environment is looking like, and, and don't
- 11:17quote me on this, but it is looking like rates will be
- 11:21dropped over the coming months. And then as we scale our
- 11:25facility and we have, I mean, we can get into the nuance of the
- 11:29capital that might be less interesting to this audience.
- 11:31But there is a mezzanine charge. The senior tranche senior
- 11:35challenge is cheaper because they're the 1st to get paid
- 11:37back. Those guys are slightly lesser
- 11:39yield than the mezzanine tranche.
- 11:41And then as a result, our cost goes down when there's more of
- 11:45people coming in. Yeah.
- 11:46And then one other point and then maybe to answer Lord's
- 11:50question, the interest rate is 14% annualized.
- 11:55And then the other point of why rates will come down over time.
- 11:59I think, you know, the folks on this call and people listening
- 12:01in understand Bitcoin as a pristine collateral and, and you
- 12:06know, one that is very ideal from like a lender standpoint.
- 12:10But the fact of the matter is the capital markets are just now
- 12:13understanding this and catching up to this.
- 12:16And so as more and more people do their diligence, the largest
- 12:19credit funds, the banks, as they get more and more involved here,
- 12:23you'll start to see the capital cost come down in a big way.
- 12:26And and we've had conversations with many of them and that's why
- 12:29we're excited about sort of the future of this and where we can
- 12:32bring and rates down to. Amazing.
- 12:36I I have one question for you guys before I ping it over to
- 12:39the on ramp guys. So I love the fact that you guys
- 12:43say Bitcoin is a pristine collateral.
- 12:46For those who don't understand what that means, how would you
- 12:49describe what that is? So if you look at the other
- 12:53forms of assets that you hold, maybe you own a house, maybe you
- 12:56own stocks, they're getting marked to market at different
- 13:00times, right? There's no continued
- 13:02understanding or agreement on all the prices.
- 13:04Your house might be marked to market every quarter, every
- 13:06year, or when you do a refinancing, your stocks are
- 13:09marked to market between 9:30 and 4:00 every day.
- 13:14With Bitcoin, a trade 24/7, 365, the market can now be stopped.
- 13:19So it's a very clear understanding of value on both
- 13:22sides from the lender side of understanding how much the
- 13:24collateral is worth and as a result of what the LTV is on the
- 13:27borrower side, also understand the same numbers.
- 13:30So we're always on the same page on when some liquidation event
- 13:37or some marginal call event or on the flip side, actually when
- 13:40there's an upsize event. So like one thing we didn't
- 13:41mention is as relatively drops and with the Onrap partnership
- 13:46as it drops under 40%, you can actually use in two clicks on a
- 13:49dashboard, go and borrow more without putting any more
- 13:51collateral up. I see there's another question
- 13:54from work. So does rate automatically
- 13:56adjust over time? It is locked in when the loan
- 14:01starts. However, you have the ability to
- 14:03refinance at any point. Amazing.
- 14:06OK, so I'll wrap guys. I'm sure you guys before you
- 14:11teamed up with Arch Lending have really scoured the whole entire
- 14:15Bitcoin lending landscape to ultimately decide to team up
- 14:20with Arch Lending. I would love to hear about your
- 14:23due diligence process and what was it about Arch Lending that
- 14:27made you guys want to stick your, you know, really good
- 14:31Bitcoin reputation on on on this team?
- 14:35Appreciate the kind words there. So first and foremost, what was
- 14:40absolutely critical for us with going with, with our vendor
- 14:43selection for who we were partnering with for, for the
- 14:46loan product, it was that our clients Bitcoin remained their
- 14:49Bitcoin. And at the end of the day, with
- 14:53everything that had gone on the lending space with Lokfi and
- 14:57Celsius, you know, we, we were getting the ask for loans from
- 15:02our clients, you know, every day it needed to be part of the
- 15:06portfolio, but we, we had to make sure we were going with a
- 15:09partner that, you know, we could be aligned with for the long
- 15:12term. You know, my background is, like
- 15:14I said, is in infrastructure. The product of the arch team is
- 15:17built is, is truly fantastic. And they looked around all the
- 15:21corners that of the things that can go wrong, you know, first
- 15:26and foremost, the, you know, the product is built at Anchorage
- 15:28where you got OCC chartered qualified custodian.
- 15:32It's a bankruptcy remote vehicle.
- 15:33So if something happens to Anchorage, client funds remain,
- 15:36you know, client funds. Secondarily, you know, as far as
- 15:41you know, something happens to Arch, there's a, you know, arch
- 15:45bankruptcy for, for some reason, there's a backup lender that
- 15:48will step in and assume these loans up and through through
- 15:50term. You know, if there's a
- 15:53liquidation, you know, that needs to occur.
- 15:55And even if Arch were to make a mistake on the liquidation,
- 15:59there's, you know, a backup in Galaxy that would help execute a
- 16:03liquidation to ensure that, you know, no loan was underwater.
- 16:06And heaven forbid there's some ugly Wick in a loan was
- 16:09underwater. You know, the responsibility for
- 16:12an underwater loan that falls on the actual, on the capital, on
- 16:16the lending side, not on the lender, not not on the the
- 16:19borrower. So ultimately you look at all
- 16:22that it's a bulletproof system and it's the kind of product
- 16:26that we wanted our clients to be on.
- 16:28And the last point that, you know, we, we, we touched on a
- 16:31little bit, But for, for the most part, if you canvas the
- 16:34lending space, you know, the, I'd say the majority of, of the
- 16:40alternatives out there are going to have open term loans, which
- 16:44you know, is great when you know, when times are good, But
- 16:48when the, when times are not, what happens?
- 16:51It's open term and they can call back capital.
- 16:53And you know, that doesn't happen when Bitcoin's at 180 K
- 16:57and you know, on the way up. It happens when you know, prices
- 17:01are falling and when you generally don't, you know, it's,
- 17:04it's when FTX happens. It's, it's when, you know, three
- 17:07hours happens. That's what's when capitals call
- 17:09back. And it's generally the very
- 17:12worst time that, you know, you might need to go sell an asset
- 17:15to go, you know, get the, you know, cover, cover the loan.
- 17:21And you know, the fact that, you know, these guys have gone
- 17:24through the work to, to do term loans to, to raise the, you
- 17:28know, the, the, the credit facility that they have.
- 17:30That's really a differentiator where I I, I've been talking to
- 17:35clients and the majority of the clients that that we have that
- 17:38interest in the loan product. And you know, a lot of these
- 17:41people are, you know, buying houses with this collateral.
- 17:44A lot of these people are doing things that are very, very long
- 17:47term in nature. They appreciate the two year
- 17:49term. They appreciate the ability that
- 17:51it's a two year term. I can roll over, you know, again
- 17:54in a year from now and get another two years based off of
- 17:56that. And it allows you to to make
- 17:58decisions and with this capital rather than and, and really
- 18:04upsize a loan because you can have confidence in it rather
- 18:07than, you know, just kind of hope for the short term.
- 18:10It really opens up the harder possible there.
- 18:12Amazing. So Speaking of interest rates,
- 18:17you know, so right now you said it's around 14% and you expect
- 18:21that to go down. So talk about that.
- 18:26How are these interest rates going to be adjusted?
- 18:28Is it a very manual process for you guys or would it be
- 18:32automatically adjusted based upon some proprietary formula
- 18:36that you guys have back there? Yeah, for for us, you know, a
- 18:41lot of our product like everything is automated.
- 18:43The the human touches is really our client services aspect.
- 18:47And so anybody can go onto our website, book a call with the
- 18:50team, message us via the chat functionality and you'll see
- 18:54someone from our team come to the call video on and you can
- 18:57answer and ask any questions that you may have with respect
- 19:00to like how rates come down as well.
- 19:02This is this will automatically happen.
- 19:04It's just a function of two, our costs going down as we continue
- 19:08to scale the lenders that we bring on on our side.
- 19:12And then the second is as the the government sort of drops
- 19:15rates in the federal funds rate, our costs come down as well.
- 19:18And so as both of those happen in last step, you'll see the
- 19:21rates on our side reflected immediately.
- 19:24Got it. So I believe the the new
- 19:28regulation repeal is of Saab 121, which allows banks to
- 19:35custody digital assets like Bitcoin.
- 19:38So that is both in my opinion and a great opportunity, but
- 19:43also a potential headwind when you come to a smaller shop like
- 19:47you guys. So what would you say is your
- 19:50big differentiator once big banks start getting their heads
- 19:53around Bitcoin? How do you guys plan to provide
- 19:58the best services when that does happen?
- 20:01Yeah, for sure. I think one Ave. where we really
- 20:05shine is our product experience. And I'd encourage you and
- 20:07everybody else to just go sign up, try it out.
- 20:11You'll basically sign up and having your collateral sent and
- 20:15getting funded. It can happen while we're on the
- 20:16spaces live. It's that quick and that simple.
- 20:19And on the flip side, as we've mentioned, we have very high bar
- 20:22to customer service. You can chat with us at any
- 20:25point on the website at the bottom right of the chat bum,
- 20:27but you can book a call and someone's always going to be
- 20:30there to answer your questions, to guide you through the process
- 20:34and really just to hold your hand because you are at the end
- 20:36of the day, giving us a significant amount of your
- 20:38assets, which we want to make sure that it's in the right
- 20:41hands and it's safe as banks come in, Banks are not known to
- 20:45win on technology. And we've spoken to a lot of the
- 20:48bigger ones who are looking at the space.
- 20:50They may be partnerships coming out of some of them in the
- 20:53future and those banks are going to look to you know people like
- 20:58us on the lending side, people like on ramp on the custody
- 21:01side, really partner for the best in class product versus
- 21:05being able to build it themselves.
- 21:06Because this is a 2 to three-year time to really fresh
- 21:10out and build a product to the scale and service required for a
- 21:14bank to use this. And then having said that, from
- 21:19the conversations we've had with banks, at least on the retail
- 21:22side, this will not be a priority initially.
- 21:25The ones that will offer this an issue would be more on the one
- 21:28off OTC basis to bigger institutions and and clients
- 21:32where they can serve $100 million loan not 1100 K loans.
- 21:39Wow. Yeah.
- 21:40And just just to add a little bit to that, you know, I think,
- 21:43I think there's this assumption that now that the banks are are
- 21:46allowed to come in that they're just going to turn on all these
- 21:48services overnight. And I think, you know, the
- 21:52reality of the situation is that Bitcoin is an extremely unique
- 21:57asset from multiple dimensions, but you know, primarily like
- 22:02custodially, you know, private key management, securing
- 22:05cryptographic material is totally foreign to these guys.
- 22:08And, and you know, to give some of them credit, I think there's,
- 22:11there's been, you know, they've been doing work on this stuff in
- 22:15preparation for this. So it's not like they're
- 22:16starting fully from zero, but it is very different from from any
- 22:21other asset that they've managed or handled or built products and
- 22:25services around. And so I think at least on the
- 22:27on ramp side, you know, I, I'm very confident in our
- 22:30differentiation, particularly on the custody element, which we
- 22:34can go and go more into. But you know, it's another
- 22:36reason why we decided to partner with Arch is because they see
- 22:40our, our vision of sort of how custody evolves in this
- 22:43landscape, particularly around using multi signature, using
- 22:47quorums with multiple institutions involved.
- 22:50And so, you know, in my mind, like realistically we're
- 22:54probably two to three years ahead of the banks in terms of
- 22:56setting up up all this stuff, but it's probably even longer
- 22:59than that because they haven't gone through the learnings and,
- 23:02and all the things that we have to understand that like custody
- 23:06needs to be done differently for this asset.
- 23:08You need to segregate keys across distinct entities.
- 23:11You need to really eliminate single points of failure.
- 23:13And that's completely foreign to how banks operate, right?
- 23:16Like they want to custody all the assets, they want full
- 23:19control. So there's going to be, I think,
- 23:21a long and arduous learning process for, for these guys when
- 23:24they do sort of start to turn these things on because it's,
- 23:28it's, you know, we joke, it's, it's alien technology.
- 23:30Bitcoin is very different from anything else that they've
- 23:33they've managed in the past. I want to harp, harp on that for
- 23:37one second because I, I've said, you know, the majority of my
- 23:40career working, you know, with the banking sector and their
- 23:42infrastructure, First and foremost, like you can lose this
- 23:47asset. It's not a row in a database.
- 23:49You can just go repopulate, which is, which is the entire
- 23:53world that they're used to. But secondly, like bench are run
- 23:57by risk departments and it keeps them afloat and keeps them in
- 24:01business. And it's a good thing, you know,
- 24:03they're conservative in nature. These risk departments make sure
- 24:08that the the banking infrastructure that exists
- 24:10today, your checking account is running on a database and an
- 24:14application that has been hardly touched since the 1970s.
- 24:19Their COBOL applications run by IBM.
- 24:22These are not banks that are are going to jump in with two feet
- 24:26and all of a sudden, you know, just start standing up, you
- 24:29know, custody, custody offerings.
- 24:30It's as a manager said, it's going to be partnerships.
- 24:33They're going to want battle has the tech they're going to want
- 24:37people like both the on Rep and the arch team that that move
- 24:41this, these these assets in this collateral all the time.
- 24:45Like you can't. There's no price on, on being on
- 24:48the experience that that these teams have for really handling
- 24:51people's life savings and ensuring they, they get moved
- 24:54safely. You know, doing the checks of
- 24:56addresses, you know, doing, you know, making sure, you know,
- 25:01whether it's the wires or, you know, USCC, which a lot of
- 25:04clients are, are choosing, making sure we're doing test
- 25:06deposits. And you know, there's, there's
- 25:08processes and learnings in place of that like you, you get from
- 25:13moving billions of dollars of capital.
- 25:15So yeah, they're, they're not going to be able to do that
- 25:19overnight. And so they're, they're, you
- 25:22know, it will be through partnerships and I think both of
- 25:24our products and you know, the price was building together in
- 25:27the long run will will ultimately be be the direction
- 25:31these banks go because you know, they're not going to just spin
- 25:33up new, you know, new wallet tech and go, go, go, go announce
- 25:38products off of that. Got it.
- 25:41So I really want to understand if I am a client who is sitting
- 25:46on Bitcoin and I want to get access to my equity in my
- 25:49Bitcoin, who do I go to? Do I go through on ramp or do I
- 25:53go through Arch who's ultimately supporting and servicing the
- 25:57loan at the end of the day? So Arch is is servicing the
- 26:01loan. If you are coming to us for the
- 26:04partnership here, you would just go to archlearning.com/onram.
- 26:10But you can also just sign up on the website and let us know that
- 26:12you can't Swan rank. We're credit here.
- 26:14But basically you're signing up as an Arch client.
- 26:18You'll configure the loan on our dashboard, you'll sign our loan
- 26:20docs, it's all automated in the platform.
- 26:23And then you'll send collateral to our custody of Anchorage.
- 26:27We'll service the loan. We'll everything from
- 26:30statements, module calls, hopefully not no liquidations,
- 26:34but if that does happen and then also at the end of term when we
- 26:38send the collateral back to you. And this is all very easily
- 26:41trackable in our dashboard. So I'd encourage people to go
- 26:43check it out, see how simple it is, how easy to manage it is.
- 26:47It is quite different from what you're used to in in the
- 26:50traditional banking world. I certainly don't get that level
- 26:53of experience for my Chase or Bank of America accounts, so I'd
- 26:57encourage you to try it out. Amazing.
- 26:59I feel like there's going to be an opportunity down the road
- 27:03where we can do a live demo down the road where it's like, hey,
- 27:07if I'm a client and I'm already custodied with on ramp, you
- 27:11know, what does that look like? What happens if I'm not custody
- 27:13with on ramp? I, I believe there's a, there's
- 27:16a big appetite to see a live demo for that.
- 27:19OK, So I, I'm curious, right, because I believe all of us are
- 27:24here because we're at a very interesting inflection in the
- 27:29Bitcoin timeline, right? I believe this is the one cycle
- 27:33where we don't have the FT XS or the three arrows and we have a
- 27:38crypto friendly administration and therefore going to have a
- 27:43clear SEC guidelines. So this is the first cycle in
- 27:47which it's not just the institution are coming, but the
- 27:50solvents are coming. So I want to peek into both of
- 27:55yours at your company's minds a little bit of upon the services
- 27:59that you're looking to add on or create in the near future.
- 28:03So between now and the next cycle and four years, what are
- 28:07you really excited to create for your existing clients and new
- 28:11clients alike? I can, I can jump on that first.
- 28:15So first, I'm not naive enough to think that there won't be
- 28:19won't be blow ups and events, you know, that happened.
- 28:23You know, whether whether the cycle's done, you know, for, you
- 28:26know, the four year cycle, the Bitcoin typically operates or
- 28:28not. You know, there there will be,
- 28:31you know, over leveraged events, there will be, you know, there
- 28:34will be fraud. And you just like the you know,
- 28:36that exists outside of Bitcoin too.
- 28:38So, you know, we'll be ready for it and you know, ultimately it's
- 28:44in the industry to go build resilience systems that that are
- 28:48going to be the flight to safety when such events occur.
- 28:52Primarily at Onramp, we're focused on building products and
- 28:55services around multi institution custody, custody
- 28:58being the core product where we multi institution custody.
- 29:03And let me let me just frame that for, you know, we've got a
- 29:05pretty large audience here, primarily how custody works
- 29:10today in in broadly the crypto space, but also in Bitcoin is
- 29:15you're building your strongest wall around a two or three multi
- 29:17sick, two or three keys to to move, to move, you know,
- 29:23Bitcoin, you know, to to a natural stuff.
- 29:25If you're choosing realistically, traditionally
- 29:30that all sitting with one firm with multi institution.
- 29:33And I'd say we saw, you know, in the last cycle, prime trust,
- 29:37fortress trust, we've seen the issues that arise when a single
- 29:41party is holding all those keys on ramp was born out of that.
- 29:45And you know, the, the premise is rather than one party holding
- 29:49all those keys for, for custody, you can build a more resilient
- 29:52system by separating key security responsibilities
- 29:56between 3 firms and the end user having a relationship with all
- 30:00three of those firms. So when there's a withdrawal
- 30:03request in the on ref UI and we help orchestrate that, we'll go
- 30:07video verify our end user for the withdrawal request, Then
- 30:10we'll go sign with our key. Then once you know the
- 30:13transactions are verified on our side, we sign, we'll pass a half
- 30:16sign transaction to Bitco. Those are our second signer.
- 30:20Bitco will then verify the end client before doing their
- 30:23signature as well. It's a better system, you know,
- 30:26for when you think about collusion, when you think about
- 30:30loss in infrastructure hacks like the buy bid situation,
- 30:33there's there's a lot of security reasons and
- 30:39fundamentally just building better products that you know,
- 30:43that become possible when when leveraging multi sig.
- 30:45But you know, we have that for the custody solution today.
- 30:48What do we want to do? We want to build a full suite of
- 30:50financial products, IRA lending trade that you know we offer to
- 30:56our clients today, but ultimately end up on that
- 30:58architecture that you know is more bulletproof, you know, not
- 31:03having to go through things like bankruptcy or insurance if there
- 31:06is a, you know, a mistake that that that does happen.
- 31:09So I'd say that's the vision for for what we're doing on the
- 31:12individual side, but we're also on the enterprise and
- 31:16institutional side. We have been and we'll continue
- 31:19to roll out products that that hit that demographic as well.
- 31:22Amazing. What about your arch?
- 31:25Yeah. I think for us, we've, we've had
- 31:28rapid growth in the past year. We know we now serve everything
- 31:31for miners, hedge funds, lots of finance with individuals across
- 31:36the US We have publicly traded companies that hold Bitcoin that
- 31:39borrow from us. So there's a huge variety of
- 31:43needs and we're kind of tailoring our offerings based on
- 31:46different needs of different clients.
- 31:48So one, we're working at the moment is a fully regulated way
- 31:52for you to get yield on Bitcoin and dollars who are offering
- 31:57that can be coming sometime in the summer.
- 31:59And then one, I think service that everyone in the space
- 32:04should offer, they already aren't is the ability to trade.
- 32:08So buy, sell and hold assets on and off from on ramp data today
- 32:12as well. And I think everybody who's
- 32:14holding assets should have that flexibility.
- 32:16So we'll be having that too, again, working with the partners
- 32:18there. And then on the last piece, so
- 32:22one, and this is going to be a very fun one for us, we're quite
- 32:25excited about it is a Bitcoin rewards credit card.
- 32:30So that's going to be coming, I want to say later this year.
- 32:34Amazing, amazing. Got it.
- 32:38So when people hear Bitcoin yield, they get a little bit
- 32:42skittish because of what we mentioned in the last cycle,
- 32:45right, because of, you know, Celsius and so on and so forth.
- 32:50So when you guys say Bitcoin yield, what does that mean and
- 32:53how do you guys generate that yield?
- 32:56Yeah, great. Question, we're still evaluating
- 32:58offerings. The focus really is on
- 33:00maximizing risk and counterparty risk in particular.
- 33:04So there, there may be different buckets that we offer with all
- 33:10the yield generating mechanisms offered upfront.
- 33:14So I can't give you an exact answer on what that is today
- 33:16because we are still evaluating different options.
- 33:18But maybe we'll come back here when that is about to go live
- 33:22and we'll discuss the offering then.
- 33:24Yeah. Perfect, perfect.
- 33:26Yeah, we are coming up about 45 minutes in.
- 33:30For those who are are joining us live, there's almost 700 of you
- 33:35guys. So first of all, we appreciate
- 33:37you. If you do have any questions for
- 33:40either on Ramp or Arch Lending, please go ahead and type it out
- 33:44into the chats. But while we wait for those to
- 33:48come in, just curious to hear in the next 6 to 12 months, what
- 33:53are you guys most excited to work on respectfully within your
- 33:57company? I mean, frankly, I'm, I'm most
- 34:01excited to just give people Peace of Mind.
- 34:04Like that's ultimately what on ramp does at the end of the day
- 34:07is is we help people with their Bitcoin journey for for many of
- 34:11our clients, you know, Bitcoin is a large percentage, if not,
- 34:16you know, close to the entirety of their net worth.
- 34:19It's, you know, what they've worked their whole lives to, to
- 34:21accumulate and the reality of the situation prior to, I think,
- 34:27you know, what we're doing with multi institution custody was
- 34:29there was always something in the back of your head in terms
- 34:32of, you know, securing your Bitcoin, whether you were
- 34:35trusting a single third party or you were managing keys yourself,
- 34:39There was always something in the back of your head that, you
- 34:42know, if something were to go wrong, you know, my my life's
- 34:45worth, my savings could be, could go to 0.
- 34:47Not because I was wrong about Bitcoin, but because I, I chose
- 34:51to, to custody the asset in a way where there was, you know,
- 34:55various pitfalls. And, and, you know, on the self
- 34:57custody side, that's anything from the proverbial wrench
- 35:00attack to getting social engineered or just losing keys,
- 35:06like literally losing the cryptographic material and then
- 35:08it's gone. And then on the other side, you
- 35:11obviously have, you know what, what has been historically the
- 35:15common way, the common alternative to doing it yourself
- 35:18was trusting a single entity. And So what I'm most excited
- 35:21about is just, you know, letting people know that there's
- 35:24another, there's another Ave. outside of those two.
- 35:27And it's what we call multi institution custody, where you
- 35:30don't have to manage keys yourself, but you also don't
- 35:33have to cede unilateral control to any single entity.
- 35:35And that's that's the really critical part about what Mitch
- 35:38was describing earlier, where again, we're distributing keys
- 35:42in a two of three quorum across distinct entities.
- 35:45The result of that is that although the end client is not
- 35:50managing key material themselves, they still control
- 35:52the keys because none of their counterparties can move assets
- 35:55unilaterally. They can, the only way assets
- 35:58move is if the, the client explicitly directs the key
- 36:02holders to work on their behalf. And so that just hasn't existed
- 36:05in, in Bitcoin for the 1st 16 years.
- 36:08And, you know, we're, we're a relatively new firm and we're
- 36:11just trying to, to let you know, let people know that there's a,
- 36:13there's a better way to do this. And, and frankly, you know, from
- 36:17all the sort of testimonials and, and, you know, happy
- 36:20clients that we have it, it gives them Peace of Mind.
- 36:23It gives them, you know, 1 less thing to worry about.
- 36:26They can set up an inheritance plan in minutes.
- 36:29They can know that, you know, the assets that they've worked
- 36:32really hard to accumulate are going to be passed down to their
- 36:34loved ones or, or children, You know, if something were to
- 36:37happen to them. It's just not the case with, you
- 36:39know, other custody models where you're leaving a treasure map
- 36:42and hoping that your, your family can recover assets.
- 36:46And so that, that's ultimately what I'm excited about.
- 36:48It's just giving, giving, you know, people Peace of Mind and
- 36:51and helping our clients ultimately.
- 36:54Amazing, amazing. And by the way, for those who
- 36:57are not familiar with the term $5 wrench attack, it's for you
- 37:01know, it's it's a it was originally a meme where, you
- 37:05know, we do all these pre precautions, right?
- 37:07But then somebody with a $5 wrench will hit you upside the
- 37:10head and just take your keys. So on ramp obviously helps avoid
- 37:14that through multi custody. OK, so here is an interesting
- 37:20one that I want to show on the screen.
- 37:22Shout out to solar symbol. He or she asked, have you had a
- 37:28third party security on it and is it publicly?
- 37:32Available I can, I can speak from our perspective and then
- 37:36maybe Major Brown, you guys can add it from onramp.
- 37:38So we've had a third party vulnerability on it now very
- 37:43recently. It isn't publicly available, but
- 37:46the fact that it's done I believe is I can double check
- 37:50that we also are doing a financial audit at the moment
- 37:53from a represent a consulting firm.
- 37:56Yeah. So for context, we don't do any
- 37:58on chain activity. So a traditional crypto
- 38:01security, a crypto security audit is less relevant here.
- 38:05It's more of a vulnerability audit and a vulnerability test.
- 38:09So it's more like a pen test. And likewise, so we, we've done
- 38:16security odds penetration testing.
- 38:19We, we do share those findings only under NDA.
- 38:23Just, you know, it's a, you know, better security best
- 38:27practice across the industry is, you know, generally that that's
- 38:29the standard. Our and our key agents are SoC
- 38:35audited and I've gone through that process for having external
- 38:39auditors look at the keys as well as there's for don't want
- 38:46to tease and hint that too much. But you know, we, we've had
- 38:50other firms that are up come in and we have not spent later this
- 38:54week, you know, on, on insurance and protecting the platform that
- 38:58way. But we we've done a lot of
- 39:01verification but for our key and also the the keys in the quorum.
- 39:05Well, as someone like me who's not so familiar with the
- 39:08compliance lingo, what is penetration testing?
- 39:11And sock I, I don't know, sock something that you mentioned.
- 39:16Could you explain that a little bit?
- 39:17Yeah, for sure. So on the penetration testing
- 39:20side, you've got an external, you know, third party that is
- 39:25looking at your systems and you know what's publicly available,
- 39:28you know, anything from website to your databases and they're
- 39:31trying to get access. So it's looking at the attack
- 39:35vectors and services and, and seeing if they can get in.
- 39:40So we've, we, we go through that, that those testing, that
- 39:44testing fairly regularly. And then on the, the sock side,
- 39:49it's, it's having accounting firms step in, look at your key
- 39:55process, look at the video verifications, looking at what,
- 40:00what's, what takes part, you know, for, you know, the signing
- 40:03of shards to who has access to the keys compared to, you know,
- 40:07who's verifying transactions. It's separation of duties and
- 40:10making sure that all signings occur with the separation of
- 40:16duties in a very controlled fashion.
- 40:18And we, we've got the form where every single, you know.
- 40:26The agent is, is stock audited for, for those on the
- 40:30institutional side, they did look for that, but it's, it's in
- 40:37the industry, it's it's fairly standard for, for further
- 40:40control process. And this is just my own
- 40:43curiosity, but what are the insurance policies behind both
- 40:48on ramp and arch lending do? You want to speak about the
- 40:55business insurance. Yeah.
- 40:57So I, I think like there's, there's two different aspects of
- 41:00it. 1 is a corporate insurance that you have and this covers
- 41:05things like cyberattacks, ENOD and O different types of
- 41:08insurance that exist at the company level.
- 41:11The secondary is acid insurance and for us or client collateral
- 41:16insurance, this anchorage is insured up to $100 million per
- 41:21incident I believe by boys in London.
- 41:23And so for us and our clients it is full coverage there.
- 41:27And maybe Mitch or Brian, you can elaborate on the on ramp
- 41:32side? Here and then also as Mitch
- 41:34mentioned earlier, assets and Anchorage are in back to remote
- 41:37trust. So they are remote from
- 41:41Anchorage digital entity because it is a separate trust entity
- 41:45and also from our entity. Perfect.
- 41:50So like I mentioned, we do have announcements come in, come in,
- 41:54in, in very at the end of the week, but but at the at the risk
- 42:00of yeah. More to come and come in come.
- 42:04In but but we. We like to say internally like
- 42:08the the best form of of quote UN quote insurance is actually like
- 42:14just key management. Like how are you actually
- 42:16managing the keys is the best form of insurance.
- 42:18If you have a redundant fault tolerance set up with multiple
- 42:22layers of controls, then that's that's the best form of
- 42:26insurance. You just prevent anything from
- 42:27going wrong in the 1st place. But yeah, more, more to come on
- 42:31that front. Perfect, perfect.
- 42:33The the the key there, though, and like what you didn't have
- 42:37with the buy bit hack is you get the separation of infrastructure
- 42:41and if something, let's say there's an attack vector, let's
- 42:43say there's a loss, let's say collusion.
- 42:46You know that happens at on ramp.
- 42:48You still have two key agents in Bitco and coin cover that have
- 42:53totally different infrastructure stacks that have different
- 42:55people that are running those firms that have multiple people
- 42:59that are are involved with signing transactions.
- 43:03It's it's building fault tolerant solution that is the
- 43:05best insurance. So that's why we choose to build
- 43:10on the multi institution custody, you know, framework and
- 43:12standard here. Amazing.
- 43:14OK, we got another question. Most likely this is for Arch
- 43:19lending. Sorry, I don't speak whatever
- 43:21language that is. I can't shout you out.
- 43:22But it. Says Robbie.
- 43:26I can read out, but yeah. Baller, how would prepayment of
- 43:33loans work? Do you see Bitcoin ETFs working
- 43:37as collateral? Yeah.
- 43:40So there is no early prepayment penalty on our loans.
- 43:44So you can go out, choose A2 year term, pay us back in three
- 43:48months, you owe us nothing beyond that month.
- 43:50That's it. So in effect, our loans function
- 43:54as lines of credit. So you can borrow today after
- 43:58two years, keep rolling lower or pay us back.
- 44:01And then also as the price of Bitcoin goes up and the LTV goes
- 44:05down, you can use in two clicks, borrow more, or you can add more
- 44:08collateral and borrow more at any time.
- 44:10Anyway, we actually see significantly more than half of
- 44:15our customers borrow 2 or more times in a year just because
- 44:18they have continuous needs with Bitcoin as their collateral.
- 44:23The second piece is do we see Bitcoin ETFs working as
- 44:26collateral? There have been early
- 44:28conversations here. I would say our difficult
- 44:31customers are holding Bitcoin like spot Bitcoin, not Bitcoin
- 44:34ETFs. So they prefer to use use that
- 44:37as a collateral. I know ibed is working on
- 44:40something with Bitcoin ETFs as collateral.
- 44:44I don't think any of the other ones have anything in the works
- 44:46at the moment, but I could be wrong.
- 44:48Got it, got it. Well, perfect.
- 44:51I'm just going to end on a little bit more fun one and I'll
- 44:55probably answer this one. Dylan Gardner asked, how did you
- 44:59guys get started in the Bitcoin world professionally?
- 45:02What recommendations would you have for a college student
- 45:05attempting to learn internships and future jobs in the industry?
- 45:09Now, I don't think we have time for all of us to talk about our
- 45:13Orange code histories. However, this is just my
- 45:17personal recommendation for myself.
- 45:20Like I said at the very beginning of this call, I used
- 45:22to be a wealth advisor and but I also had many, many different
- 45:26finance experiences. What I found to be extremely
- 45:30helpful is to, I call it make waves for other people, right?
- 45:36So I think this call is a great example of that in the regards
- 45:40that I saw on ramp and Arch lending having this amazing
- 45:45partnership. I saw that this is going to be
- 45:48greatly needed for Bitcoiners, and so I was already going to do
- 45:53the research for myself anyways, but I just decided to distill it
- 45:57down into a easy to understand, simple to implement and readable
- 46:03format for the community. And the community rewarding that
- 46:07by, you know, liking it, sharing it, retweeting it.
- 46:11And here we are just a week later with 841 live viewers.
- 46:16So really this world, whether it's in Bitcoin or not, is
- 46:21really your oyster in the regards that you can just go out
- 46:24and do things right. Especially now with just a
- 46:28Twitter account, you can make a name for yourself.
- 46:31Now, there are obviously, you know, ways that you can do that,
- 46:35that that is beyond the scope of this conversation.
- 46:38But really I think a big need in the Bitcoin world is always
- 46:43Bitcoin education and Bitcoin marketing, OK?
- 46:47Fundamentally speaking, Bitcoiners are very, very
- 46:51logical people, OK? While that makes understanding
- 46:55Bitcoin very well, it does not make orange piling very easy and
- 46:59it definitely does not make marketing your Bitcoin product
- 47:02and service easy as well. So find what is the lack in the
- 47:07industry and just simply add value through your own unique
- 47:12zone of genius. OK so we have about 3 minutes
- 47:17before the top of the hour. I just want to go around
- 47:20everyone to to have a a a parting thoughts and also share
- 47:25your personal Twitter handles if if you want to do so.
- 47:29Yeah, sure. So I'm at back slash BTC, the
- 47:33word backsplash, back slash spelled out.
- 47:37And yeah, thanks for having us on Peter.
- 47:38This is a a great combo and always happy to answer folks
- 47:43questions and and let people know what we're doing.
- 47:45So I appreciate the the airtime, Mitch.
- 47:49Under score Kochman on Twitter parting thought is actually
- 47:54because we the the question we just, we just got asked is, is
- 47:58one we get all the time because people get so passionate about
- 48:02the space and and they want to do it for a living.
- 48:05One piece of advice that I, I tried giving, because we all had
- 48:08to go through it was take, you know, I, I, I was an IBM exec
- 48:13and what did I do? I did enterprise sales.
- 48:16And what I ultimately found success after a few failures was
- 48:22I tried to find what was most similar to what I was doing in
- 48:27the Fiat world and how did I go apply that to Bitcoin.
- 48:31And once I went B to B enterprise sales to B to B
- 48:35enterprise sales in, in Bitcoin, it was, it was crypto to start,
- 48:38but and you know, I end up selling to custody services to
- 48:43exchanges and platforms. It was very similar to what I
- 48:47was doing at IBM. Once I found that, and it's not
- 48:50always easy, but to research the companies and do the work, it
- 48:55became much easier and I got a lot more open doors.
- 48:57So, you know, if you've got questions, you know, reach out.
- 49:01I'm, I'm happy to help and share, but you know, we, we do
- 49:05need talent, the Bitcoin space. So, you know, and it's, it's not
- 49:09easy breaking in, but I just, if, if you've got the passion
- 49:13for it, I encourage you to do so.
- 49:16Yeah, I think I want to add to that as well.
- 49:18Like this is a very new space in the grand scheme of things and
- 49:21skills from other industries definitely translate.
- 49:24You know, if you're a good engineer, you don't have to be
- 49:26an engineer that understands Bitcoin, but you can pick it up.
- 49:29Same thing with if you're good at marketing, you're good at
- 49:31sales or something else. So definitely reach out.
- 49:34We're actually maybe hiring an interest.
- 49:37So if you're an engineer, Dylan, shoot us a note and we'll chat.
- 49:42And just to end on my notes, so I'm at HH Sahay, that's HHSAHAY.
- 49:51And then we tweet a lot from the Arch Lending account every day
- 49:55as well. Yeah.
- 49:56And then I'm at D Patel under score 34.
- 50:00And then yeah, so much. You mentioned the arch lending
- 50:03is where we're all most active. Perfect.
- 50:08Well, thank you, guys. We are up to the top of the
- 50:11hour. And I know that there are a lot
- 50:12of you guys out here, but yeah, we want to be respectful of
- 50:16every, everyone's time. Don't worry, there's going to be
- 50:20plenty more of these conversations, and if you guys
- 50:24do want more of these conversations, please go ahead
- 50:26and follow me. Follow me at BTC Bolt rider.
- 50:31You can see it on the screen below for more.
- 50:34But yes, there'll be plenty more of these down the road, so stay
- 50:37tuned guys take care. Thanks.
- 50:39Peter, bye. Thanks, Peter.