Latest / Forgotten Hollywood / Episode 170- Alfred Hitchcock & The Hollywood Studio System with author Lesley Coffin
Transcript
- 0:01You're listening, you've Forgotten Hollywood with Doug Hess here on j L JBDIA.
- 0:21Hello everyone, and welcome to Forgotten Hollywood, your podcasts and memories of Yesterdayear
- 0:26my name is deck Hess And if you're tuning in and Forgotten Hollywood for the
- 0:29first time, what I do on this podcast is take you on a journey
- 0:32back in time and share with you pieces of Hollywood that you may or may
- 0:36not know about. And in this episode, we have a very special guest
- 0:41who has been on the podcast before, Leslie L. Coffin, and she
- 0:45is here to talk about her book, Hitchcock Stars, Alfred Hitchcock and the
- 0:50Hollywood Studio System. Leslie, welcome back to Forgotten Hollywood. Oh, it's
- 0:56such a pleasure to be back. Thank you well, thank you for taking
- 0:59a few minutes out of your time to come and talk about Hitchcock Stars,
- 1:03your book that you have out, and it's been out for some time.
- 1:08But Leslie, maybe share with the audience a little bit about how this book
- 1:15came about and what this book is about, because it's not a traditional biography
- 1:21of Hitchcock, and so maybe kind of let the audience know what this is
- 1:26about. Yeah, So like you said, it is not a traditional biography.
- 1:32It is more of a survey on Alfred Hitchcock films in terms of the
- 1:37casting and the performances and his use of what they consider star studies or star
- 1:45theory. And that actually was sort of my introduction to the topic. Was
- 1:51I was completing my master's degree and I was considering sort of more of a
- 1:57traditional focus on biography, and when I started to really look at film theory
- 2:04in this one area called star studies, it really got me excited because I
- 2:09think the sort of psychological aspect of star theory is something that we all understand,
- 2:15but it takes a little bit of sort of digging down to understand what
- 2:21we're really talking about when we talk about people being cast and the expectations of
- 2:29this performer versus that performer on the audience, and especially in the star system
- 2:36era, where everybody was often coming from a very sort of similar perspective of
- 2:44they've all gone to see this one movie. You know, these movies were
- 2:47going from city to city and a lot of people would see almost every movie,
- 2:52so they had a great palette to build off of. So when all
- 2:57of a sudden, someone like Alfred Hitchcock would come in and say, you
- 3:00know, what I really want to do is past someone like Harry Grant as
- 3:05a villain. What did that? What impact did that really have on the
- 3:08audience? Did that scare an audience? Did that get an audience of kilter
- 3:15more? Did the audience outright just rejected and say we don't buy it?
- 3:20And that's an aspect of film theory that I think we don't talk about enough.
- 3:23But because it because it's a lot about celebrity, it's a lot about
- 3:29sort of this area film that isn't as easy to sort of analyze as something
- 3:34like you know means unseen or editing, but it is just as important,
- 3:38and it's especially important, I think when we talk about the audience's relationship with
- 3:45these stars and why start stardom and celebrity is so important to our film watching.
- 3:52So that was how I got into it, into the into the area
- 3:57of star studies, and and I was considering sort of what to focus on.
- 4:02I was looking at the film Psycho and Anthony Perkins in that performance,
- 4:10because I think I'm not the only one who says that that's probably one of
- 4:14the greatest performances of all time in film. But the impact that that performance
- 4:20would have had on audiences in nineteen sixty is very different from that impact it
- 4:27would have on audiences today, because in nineteen sixty, if you had been
- 4:31a fan of Anthony Perkins or knew just who Anthony Perkins was, that persona
- 4:38was very, very different from the persona that basically got you know, replaced.
- 4:45And so as soon as Psycho came in, a lot of those performances
- 4:48got erased from public memory and people just thought of Norman Bates and they didn't
- 4:54think about these other performances that he gave that built off of the kind of
- 5:00you know, to light that at that Alfred Hitchcock took and casting him,
- 5:06you know that he found it so funny to cast this guy who had played
- 5:11a Quaker in an Oscar winning in an Oscar nominated actually an Oscar winning movie.
- 5:17Right. Well, No, I think you're spot on to where Hitchcock
- 5:23brought in a little shock value, and I think he kind of enjoyed that
- 5:28a lot. I won't say a little, but a lot in terms of
- 5:30that. I did the actors and actresses feel when was that something that they
- 5:39had this image and they said, oh, I can't tarnish it, or
- 5:43were a lot of these actress and actresses wanting to jump in to break the
- 5:46mold, because sometimes you get started stereo cast of a particular image of you
- 5:55and you'll see an actor and actress wanting to break that. Did did that
- 6:00happen? Then, let's just say the nineteen sixties, it definitely happened.
- 6:05I think what was interesting was it varied very much by the actor and how
- 6:13cemented that performer was in their persona. Anthony Tony Perkins was still kind of
- 6:21a young actor at the time, and I think he had felt a little
- 6:26bit constrained by the Hollywood studio system. So suddenly getting this very kind of
- 6:31rich role where he got to play a lot of layers and you know,
- 6:35kind of tricked the audience was a pretty fun thing. Ironically. He immediately
- 6:41then went to Europe and he did a lot more challenging performances that people just
- 6:46didn't see in America, like the Trial, like Goodbye Again. He had
- 6:51a lot more opportunity in Europe than he had in America, and Psycho was
- 6:56one of the reasons why I got those opportunities. But of course came back
- 7:00and he said that you know, pretty much Psycho had in some ways to
- 7:04railed his career or totally altered his career. Other actors, however, really
- 7:10took it as, you know, a delightful opportunity. I think the interesting
- 7:15things is someone like Carry Grant, who always kind of wanted to challenge himself
- 7:20a little bit more. I think he really enjoyed something like Notorious, where
- 7:27he gets to play this very you know, he's the anti hero, he
- 7:30is not the hero character. He's not the goofball that he wasn't a lot
- 7:34of those nineteen thirties screwball comedies. But then by the nineteen fifties he was
- 7:41less comfortable with challenging that public image than he had been. James Stewart,
- 7:47I think was one of those people who really wanted to challenge himself more.
- 7:51And I think as much as Hitchcock, I think liked challenging him. And
- 7:58certainly James Stewart was a great actor. I don't think they ever mashed as
- 8:01well as they would have wanted to. I think that there was something apprehensive
- 8:07and some of James Stewart's performances for Hitchcock like rope, you know, like
- 8:15something like Rope where that character really should be pretty evil. You know,
- 8:20he's basically talking about you know, he's talking about people having worthless lives and
- 8:28you should really feel like this guy is not a good guy. But he
- 8:33never digs into that character as much as maybe he should have. It may
- 8:37have been a connection of there being a discomfort with the subject matter, but
- 8:41James Stewart certainly was somebody who loved playing with his image. We see it
- 8:46in other performances that he gives in films like you know, even It's a
- 8:52Wonderful Life, you know, where it's a pretty dark performance about it.
- 8:58And then there are other actors who literally Hitchcock couldn't get to do movies.
- 9:05He tells a great story and it is one of those you know, would
- 9:09have could have should have been performances that I think would have been great.
- 9:13Is Shadow of a Doubt, which is one of my all time favorite Hitchcock
- 9:16movies. His initial thought was, wouldn't it been great to have William Powell
- 9:22play Uncle Charlie? And I'm like, it would have been great to William
- 9:26Powell play Uncle Charlie. But William Powell knew his persona, he knew,
- 9:33he knew what he knew what people wanted from him, and he knew that
- 9:37he had developed somewhat of a limited repertoire for himself, and whether it was
- 9:46the studio system that said no, or William Powell saying, now, of
- 9:50course he doesn't. He's not in that movie. It's the Cotton who does
- 9:54not have as much of a persona at the time he did that movie.
- 10:01Now, one of the other people to think about is Bruce Dern, who
- 10:09is actually kind of the reverse of that. You know, he was known
- 10:13in the seventies for playing these sort of very swarthy, villainous characters, and
- 10:20if you watch Family Plot, he's delightful as a romantic comedy league and it's
- 10:28so charming, and I think Bruce Stern actually really enjoyed it. You know,
- 10:31he's talked about other films where he actually got to play nice guy characters
- 10:39and lovable characters and funny characters. And the fact that Hitchcock thought to himself,
- 10:43you know, for my last film, he didn't know it was going
- 10:46to be his last film, but he knew that he was kind of sending
- 10:48himself up a little bit with Family Plot because it's a comedy. To Casper
- 10:54Stern, who had you know, pretty much played a lot of villains at
- 10:58that time, was pretty in fact, didn't have that relationship. I think
- 11:05with as many of his female actresses, he I think thought more about developing
- 11:13their personalities on screen. But he certainly cast some actresses who were very develop
- 11:22a signature at the time. Doris Day is a great example of that.
- 11:28The Telulah Bankhead is another one. You know, there's not really an opportunity
- 11:33for Hitchcock to play with that character, right, Yeah. Well, and
- 11:39I think as an actor or an actress, a lot of times that is
- 11:43the big challenge, is to challenge yourself, throw yourself into a role that
- 11:48that's kind of bigger or allows you to be creative. I think, and
- 11:56this is my own personal opinion, I think actors and actresses today are more
- 12:00willing to play with their image than you were back in the fifties and sixties.
- 12:05I think a lot of that had to do with the studios controlling and
- 12:09having their thumbs on the actors and actresses, where today everybody's kind of like
- 12:13a free agent exactly. And I think even by the nineteen sixties when the
- 12:22television, when television became so much more popular by then. Hitchcock knew start
- 12:31was not what had happened in the nineteen thirties and forties to be a star.
- 12:35A lot of these people were coming from television. He was actually doing
- 12:39television at the time, and I think Hitchcock's image had become bigger than a
- 12:46lot of his movie stars that he was considering using at the time, So
- 12:52that relationship is so different. The other thing is, like you said,
- 12:56the star theory, the way that studios could cultivate an image was like nothing
- 13:05else. You know, they would not let certain actors do films because they
- 13:11basically said, we don't want to just we don't want to have an impact
- 13:16on our actors personal personality with the audience. Well, we don't want Univisa
- 13:24in the villain because we need him to be a hero. Right, Because
- 13:26at the end of the day, it was all about money with the studios,
- 13:30and that was our cash cow. Exactly what I think was so interesting
- 13:35with Hitchcock was when he came to America to work in the Hollywood system after
- 13:43having had a lot of success in England. He said, one of the
- 13:46things that was bringing him to America was this opportunity to use stars that they're
- 13:56just were not stars in England the way that there were stars in America.
- 14:01English actors usually came from the stage. They were shakespeare and trained. They
- 14:07didn't have there was not the control system of the studio system, and Hitchcock
- 14:13really saw it as an opportunity to build more tension, more anxiety with audiences
- 14:22than he could with actors that people maybe didn't know, even if they were
- 14:26great actors, which is always where it gets so funny where he's known for
- 14:33this one one comment he made about cattle, and you know he said it,
- 14:43but I don't totally buy it. I think I think he's one of
- 14:50those directors and this isn't taken into account his in some ways very bad relationship
- 14:58with some of the women that he worked with and you know, some of
- 15:01the men that he worked with as a director. I think he did appreciate
- 15:07actors in terms of them as participants in his art. I think that he
- 15:20saw them as having real value too, and bringing real value to his films,
- 15:26and having very different relationships with some of them. You know, someone
- 15:30like Carol Lumberg, you just kind of let do whatever she wanted. Someone
- 15:35like like I said, Bruce Dern and Barbara Harris. He just said,
- 15:39you entertained, do something interesting, and I will be entertained. Other actors
- 15:45he was very controlling with, and he said, you stand here, you
- 15:48do this. It's a it's not a one size fits all relationship with actors.
- 15:54And I think one of the things that probably had a impact on his
- 16:00relationship with actors was the uh, the rise of method acting in the nineteenth
- 16:11fifties and sixties. He did not seem to be much of a fan of
- 16:15that, and he seemed to have a very bad relationship with some actors who
- 16:21were students of that type of performing. Leslie, what did anythink surprise you
- 16:30during your research? Yes, I think I think one of the things that
- 16:41really surprised me was, you know, I had I had always kind of
- 16:48thought of Vera. Sorry, I'm forgetting her name, Vera from Psycho and
- 16:57I'm forgetting her name, and I feel so so terrible. Hold on one
- 17:03second, the right, I know, I know, I feel okad sorry,
- 17:12Vera Miles, said Vera Ellen, which would have been that Vera Miles
- 17:18often comes up as this victim of Hitchcock. And you know, I think
- 17:26that there's certainly elements of that relationship, but her performance in something like The
- 17:34Wrong Man and then her performance and something like Psycho. While Hitchcock was very
- 17:41unfair to her with Psycho and he gave her very little to do, that
- 17:47performance she gives in the Wrong Man is so remarkable that you can understand why
- 17:53Hitchcock really thought that he had found not another Grace Kelly, but another opportunity
- 18:02like Grace Kelly. In her Grace Kelly, if you think about her performance
- 18:07in dial in for Murder, this you know, beautiful victim of circumstance and
- 18:15injustice, and you know her just moments of true sadness and silence that she
- 18:22gives, and then for her to blossom in films like Rear Window and to
- 18:29Catch a Thief Vera Miles is so remarkable. And you can see her performance
- 18:34and her death as an actress in the Wrong Man, that you know,
- 18:40the idea of her being in something like Vertigo would have been really exciting because
- 18:47and it's not to say anything negative about Kim Novak, because she gives a
- 18:51really wonderful performance in Vertigo, but she was not She didn't have the same
- 19:00performance skills set that some of like Barren Miles had and Barren Miles never really
- 19:06got her career back after her relationship with Alfred Hitchcock, you know, went
- 19:15away a little bit. And I'd always been really interested in that because it
- 19:21was like, well he still got to work with her in cycle, why
- 19:25why not give her more to do? And I think he was sort of
- 19:30if he found somebody boring, you know, if he found an actor born,
- 19:33and I think he definitely found John Gavin a little bored fare of Miles
- 19:41up with her, he could be kind of mean to the performers that he
- 19:48thought were not living up to that opportunity, and he did the same thing
- 19:52with The Birds. I think now his treatment of Tippy Hedren, which is
- 19:56not something I get into. There's incredible books by Tippy Hendron. There's incredible
- 20:00books about Alfred Hitchcock's relationship personal relationship with Tippy Hendron in The Birds. But
- 20:07one of the things that's interesting is, you know, he found Susan Plaschet
- 20:12to be really an interesting actress and then in a way kind of felt Tippy
- 20:18Hendron wasn't as great an actress as he wanted to make her, even though
- 20:25she was not a trained actress. So it's sort of like, well,
- 20:29what were you thinking? You know, it takes, it takes. You
- 20:33know, it's not just about being beautiful. It's not just about having that
- 20:37image, but you also have to come in with a certain set of skills.
- 20:41She came in, she didn't have the skills, and then he kind
- 20:45of treated her as if she was doing something wrong and then showed favoritism towards
- 20:49other actresses. You know, Diane Baker was another actress that he treated better
- 20:56than someone like Tippy Hendron. And I think that he did that quite quite
- 21:00a lot with actresses of if you were not living up to what he wanted
- 21:07you to bring to that performance exactly. He could be very very cruel on
- 21:11a professional level, not even thinking about the personal stuff, but on the
- 21:17professional level he could be really neat. Yeah, which is unfortunate because you
- 21:22know, he was a great director, but also some of this gets overshadowed
- 21:29and maybe it's a little bit of the greatness out if I can say it
- 21:33that way of him, which is, like I said, unfortunate. And
- 21:37you know the other thing is I think because we put so much stock in
- 21:45which Alfred Hitchcock did on a whole with movies, that some of the wonderful,
- 21:51wonderful performances of the actors and actresses, including individuals who he didn't necessarily
- 21:57think we're great, get overshadowed and they don't get the credit that they deserve.
- 22:03You know, like I said something like there are miles in the wrong
- 22:07man. I mean, that should have been an OSCAR nominated performance. It's
- 22:11so you know, she just tugs at your heart strings from the moment she's
- 22:15on screen. Grace Kelly has three incredible performances that are all very, very
- 22:22different, and I don't think I don't think Grace Kelly ever got as much
- 22:27respect because so much credit has gone to Alfred Hitchcock, as if he was
- 22:36creating these performances out of thin air, or that he was picking randomly people.
- 22:41He was very specific about the actors and actresses that he was picking,
- 22:45and there were films that he didn't make when he didn't get the actors that
- 22:52he wanted to have in the film. You know, it's not in the
- 22:56book, and I kind of wish I had. But Audrey Hepburn he didn't
- 23:00get to work with, and he would have worked with her in a film
- 23:06where he got to play with her. You know, good girl image.
- 23:10But then when she dropped out of the movie, he just was like,
- 23:12yeah, I'm doing that movie now because I don't have her as the asset
- 23:18he was. So it sounds like he was really competing against himself in a
- 23:22lot of these films. Yeah. And I think also once he created some
- 23:26of these you know, modern day classic performances and classic films like Rear Window,
- 23:37like Notorious, once he had it in his head of oh, well,
- 23:42what of my films are these films going to be compared to? He
- 23:48started to think of it more of well, I need the next Carry Grant,
- 23:52I need the next Grace Kelly, which is a terrible way to look
- 23:56at work, because you know, Kim Novak did a great job in Vertigo.
- 24:03She wasn't Grace Kelly, and she wasn't Fair Miles. But Kim Novak
- 24:07the actress in terms of what performance she gives in Vertigo and what she brings
- 24:12to Vertigo as this you know, actress with a lot of depth in history,
- 24:18in terms of sort of the more horrible size of Hollywood and Hollywood's connection
- 24:22to Vertigo, it's a it's a great performance. She's not Grace Kelly,
- 24:27which was like the thing that she got compared to, you know, way
- 24:32too much. Yea, Tippy Hendrick is not Grace Kelly. And I think
- 24:38she also felt like, you know, the minute, you're not living up
- 24:42to this image of a person that he wants you to sort of be the
- 24:51qualities that some of like Tippy Henmeron brings to a film, even though she
- 24:55maybe wasn't you know, as well trained and actress as she became or would
- 25:00become. And I think her performance in Marnie is a lot better than her
- 25:03performance in The Birds in a lot of ways because she had a little bit
- 25:07more experience. But that that devious side of her that, you know,
- 25:11that sort of mischievous quality to Tippy Hendron that Grace Kelly didn't necessarily have,
- 25:18that's a great quality to bring to a performance. So I think he was
- 25:25often, like you said, competing with himself and competing with images that he
- 25:30just you know. Yeah, yeah, well let's I know we're getting short
- 25:36here on time, but I have to ask you. I mean, we've
- 25:37had your own twice here and uh, and I've enjoyed talking to you.
- 25:44You bring a lot of great and I really like the subject matters that you're
- 25:49you're picking and I really mean that. I mean you're you're really diving into
- 25:56things that make us think and bringing the new layer to to to the approach,
- 26:00which leads me to my last question. Yeah, we expect something else
- 26:04in the future. Yes. So I'm in the research stage for two potential
- 26:14projects, and I'm trying to figure out sort of what what I can research.
- 26:23The fact both projects I would hope eventually would get work done, but
- 26:27I'm trying to figure out sort of which ones I can work on, and
- 26:30also because of the amount of material available, which one I can work on
- 26:37and which one I have to wait until more material becomes readily available. Both
- 26:44both would be a little bit on film history. One is probably going to
- 26:47be more of a survey and one is going to be more of a biography
- 26:52about a Hollywood dancer. And I should probably leave it there. Excellent.
- 26:59I love the teams. I will the fact that wants to come back for
- 27:03more wealth exactly, although the strikes and everything make it difficult because you know,
- 27:08you know, everyone is not as readily available as you would like,
- 27:14because I think everybody's a little bit nervous about doing interviews and stuff like that,
- 27:18which we totally understand. Yeah, you know, we definitely want to
- 27:25support them exactly, exactly in their fight. In terms of that, well,
- 27:30Leslie, the invitations open to hopefully you'll be able to u come back
- 27:40when your when your next book is Actually we enjoy speaking with you. Like
- 27:45I said, you do some wonderful research and a lot of great work,
- 27:49and so thank you and hopefully you won't forget us here. I'm forgotten Hollywood
- 27:53and me to come back absolutely well, it's such a pleasure to get to
- 27:59talk to you. I appreciate it. Well, well, thank you,
- 28:02and to the audience, please go out and get a copy of Leslie's book,
- 28:06Hitchcock Stars Alfred Hitchcock and the Hollywood Studio System. You can find it
- 28:11on Amazon, Roman and Littlefield is the publishers. So please go out and
- 28:17get a copy of the book. You're not going to be disappointed. It's
- 28:19really fascinating. And again, Leslie, thank you for coming on and spending
- 28:23a few minutes with us today. Thank you. I want to thank you
- 28:27for listening to this episode. I Forgotten Hollywood. Just search for Doug Hast
- 28:30Forgotten Hollywood. You can also find me on Twitter and Instagram and HASTEC fourteen.
- 28:34If you listen to this podcast on iTunes or another podcast service, please
- 28:38subscribe, or rate and review this episode. Tune in next time for the
- 28:42latest episode of Forgotten Hollywood. Thank you for listening, and we will see
- 28:47you soon.