Latest / Tech IPO Conversations with Fexingo: Public Software Companies and Capital Markets / How Post-IPO Companies Use Insider Trading Windows
Transcript
- Lucas: So here's a scenario that plays out thousands of times a year at every public company. You're a director of engineering at a company that IPO'd eighteen months ago. Your R-S-U's just vested. The stock has doubled since the offering. And you are legally barred from selling a single share for most of the quarter. Luna: And that's not paranoia — that's the insider trading window. Or rather, the absence of one. Lucas: Right. Today we're going to talk about how post ipo companies design these windows. Because the window isn't just a compliance checkbox — it's a piece of corporate machinery that affects everything from employee retention to how the stock trades around earnings. Luna: And it's one of those things that sounds simple — you can only trade during certain weeks — but the details get messy fast. Lucas: Yeah. So the basic rhythm is this: companies generally open the window right after they release quarterly earnings, and close it again a few weeks before the next earnings call. The open period is typically two to four weeks. During that time, insiders can trade, subject to their own compliance approvals. Luna: And the closed period is the blackout. That's when you absolutely cannot trade — because you're sitting on material non-public information about how the quarter went. Lucas: Exactly. The idea is to prevent insiders from trading while they know things the market doesn't. And the SEC comes down hard on that. But here's the thing — the blackout isn't just about earnings. Companies can close the window early for other reasons. If they're in the middle of a big acquisition, a major contract negotiation, or a cybersecurity incident, they might shut everything down. Luna: So the window is really a default — but it's a default that management can override at any time. That adds a layer of unpredictability for employees. Lucas: And that unpredictability is one reason some companies are moving away from the old model. Let's talk about that. But first — actually, Luna, you were looking at how some companies handle this differently. Luna: Yeah — you mentioned it. Some companies have tried to open the window for a short period right before earnings, but that's actually illegal under current rules. The SEC requires that all insiders — and I'm talking about officers, directors, and anyone deemed an 'insider' — be in a blackout during the period leading up to the earnings release. So the window is typically after earnings, not before. Lucas: Right — the blackout is strict. And for a post ipo company, the first few years are especially tricky because you're still building your internal processes. You don't have a dedicated compliance team yet; it might be one person in legal juggling this on top of everything else. Luna: And the stakes are high. One misstep — an executive trades in a blackout — and it's a scandal. Not just a fine, but a reputational hit that can dent the stock. Just look at how the market reacts to any whiff of insider impropriety. Lucas: Let's get into a real example. We've got Palantir in the data here — up about three percent over the last five days. Palantir went public in 2020, and they've been a poster child for aggressive insider selling after the IPO. But what people don't always realize is that a lot of that selling is structured through Rule 10b5-1 plans — pre-arranged trading schedules that insiders set up during the open window, so they can sell automatically even when the window closes. Luna: Right — 10b5-1 plans are the workaround. You set it up when you have no material information, and then the trades happen on autopilot. It's a way to sell without being accused of timing the market. Lucas: But here's the catch — the SEC updated the rules in 2023 to add a cooling-off period. You can't just set up a plan and sell the next day. For directors and officers, it's now a mandatory waiting period. So even the workaround has guardrails. Luna: That's a good point. And it ties into something employees often misunderstand — they think the window is about preventing insiders from profiting unfairly. But it's really about preventing the appearance of impropriety. The optics matter as much as the act. Lucas: Exactly. And for a company like Airbnb — down a bit over the last five days — they've had to navigate this carefully. Airbnb has a huge base of employee shareholders, and their lockup expiry in 2021 was one of the biggest in tech history. After the lockup, the window structure became critical because so many employees were finally free to sell. Luna: And if the window is too narrow, you get a bottleneck — everyone tries to sell in the same three weeks, which can put downward pressure on the stock. Lucas: Which is a real concern. So companies have to balance legal compliance with market mechanics. Some companies open longer windows after earnings, some stick to a strict two-week calendar. There's no one-size-fits-all. Luna: And then there's the human factor. Employees who join pre ipo often have a huge chunk of their net worth tied up in stock. If they can only sell a few weeks a year, that affects their financial planning, their tax strategy, even their decision to stay at the company. Lucas: And that's why some companies are experimenting with more flexible models. There's a trend toward what you might call 'open trading' — letting employees trade during any open market period, as long as they're not in possession of material non-public information. But that's risky. The compliance burden is massive. Luna: So most stick with the classic window. But here's a question — what happens when earnings get delayed? Or a company changes its fiscal year? The window can shift, and suddenly employees are locked out for months. Lucas: That happened a lot during the pandemic — companies postponed earnings, and windows stayed closed. Some employees were stuck for six months or more. That's a real morale issue. Luna: And a retention issue. If you can't sell your shares, and the company is the main thing you own, you might start looking for the exit — even if you love the work. Lucas: Which brings us to a practical tension — the compliance people want tight windows, but the HR people want flexibility to keep talent happy. And the CFO wants to avoid a flood of supply that tanks the stock. It's a three-way tug of war. Luna: And the board has to weigh in too. Especially when it comes to approving the calendar for the year. Lucas: So let's talk about the actual mechanics of setting up a window. The process usually starts with the legal team drafting a trading policy — that's the document that defines who is an insider, what the window periods are, and what the approval process looks like. Then the compliance officer — or the CFO's office — maintains a calendar that they share with employees. Luna: And that calendar is usually published internally, but it's not public. Outsiders don't know exactly when the window opens — they just see the trading activity on Form 4 filings. Lucas: Right — Form 4s are the tell. When you see a cluster of insider sales in the first two weeks after earnings, that's the window doing its job. And market watchers use that as a signal. Heavy insider buying after a dip can be bullish; heavy selling, even routine, can spook investors. Luna: But routine selling is often just that — routine. People need cash, they diversify, they pay taxes. The market sometimes overreacts to insider sales that are really just part of a pre-planned 10b5-1. Lucas: That's a good reminder. And it's one reason companies try to educate employees about the policy — so they don't accidentally trade in a blackout and trigger a media cycle. Luna: So, practically speaking, what should a post ipo company do in its first year? Any best practices? Lucas: First, start planning the window calendar before the IPO. Don't wait until the lockup expires. Second, use a standard window — like the day after earnings through the end of the second full week after. That gives everyone clarity. Third, have a clear approval process — even if it's just a sign-off from the legal team. And fourth, communicate, communicate, communicate. Employees need to know the rules before they're stuck with non-tradeable shares. Luna: And maybe most importantly, make sure the policy is in place before the first lockup expiry. That's when the pressure hits. Lucas: Yeah — and that's a whole episode on its own. But for now, the takeaway is that the trading window is more than a legal formality. It's a piece of infrastructure that keeps the market fair, keeps the company out of trouble, and keeps employees from feeling trapped. Luna: And next time you see a headline about insider selling, you'll know it's probably just someone taking advantage of their open window — not a signal of doom. Lucas: Exactly. All right, that's a wrap for today. Thanks for listening — we'll see you next time.