Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / The Psychology of Josh Powell (Chapter 1 - Exposure)
Transcript
- 0:00Hey deserve listeners. So the patrons asked us to do a deep dive on
- 0:05the story of Josh Powell, and I have done a lot of research and
- 0:12so first I have a fairly long introduction burto if you'll allow it, I
- 0:18will stand in your way as much as I can. OK. So,
- 0:21first off, trigger warning. Throughout this series, we're going to talk about
- 0:25spousal abuse, stalking, sexual abuse, murder, including the murder of small
- 0:32children. There will be long discussions on these topics, and I am also
- 0:38going to provide some of the relevant details about these crimes. So if you
- 0:43have trauma reactivity in these areas, either don't listen honestly, or talk to
- 0:51your therapist before listening. And also for everybody, take breaks to check in
- 0:55with yourself as we go. So I want to do you set the scene
- 1:00because I've been talking with people about what I've been up to lately. People
- 1:07say, oh, what have you been up to, and I was like,
- 1:07Oh, I've just been investigating or researching or doing a deep dive on
- 1:14the story of Josh Powell. And I find that a lot of people,
- 1:15even local people, haven't heard of it or they don't remember it. So
- 1:21I want to set the scene, and I'm going to skip to the end
- 1:25of the story, and then once I'm done with that, we'll start from
- 1:29the beginning, just so y'all know where this ends up. So it's February
- 1:33fifth, twenty twelve, Super Bowl Sunday, just as the game is about
- 1:38to start. It's just after noon. A social worker pulls up to a
- 1:44house in her personal car. She's at work. She's bringing two young boys,
- 1:49age five and seven, name Braden and Charlie, respectively. She's bringing
- 1:55them for a supervised visit to their father's house in Graham, Washington, which
- 2:00is about fifty miles south of Seattle, not far from where Berto you went
- 2:06to high school. The father, Josh Powell, he is required to have
- 2:12a social worker present when he visits with his two boys because the authorities are
- 2:15still investigating whether or not the children are safe to be in his custody.
- 2:22On the previous Wednesday, because it's Sunday on this day, but on the
- 2:25previous Wednesday, some new evidence was presented in court, some very shocking evidence,
- 2:32evidence about the father, Josh Powell, evidence that Josh did not like
- 2:38revealed, and so people in the case, including Josh himself had reasons to
- 2:44believe that this new evidence could result in Josh never seeing his children again.
- 2:50And in a couple of days, he's supposed to show up for a very
- 2:53detailed psychosexual evaluation by a court appointed psychologist, and that psychologist happens to be
- 3:00a friend of mine, a colleague. Even at that time, I knew
- 3:04him the psychologist, and that psychologist after the events of this Super Bowl Sunday,
- 3:12he will later reach out to me because he will want to come on
- 3:16this podcast Psychology in Seattle to tell his story, I think, to clear
- 3:22his name and maybe to clear his conscious And I'll get into more of that
- 3:24later. But anyway, that psychosexual evaluation that Josh Powell is required to have
- 3:35is going to be a little invasive for Josh Powell, and he knows this,
- 3:42but it's justified. And people involved in the case thought that his evaluation
- 3:46might not only determine his viability as a father, revealing that he isn't safe
- 3:53to have the kids, but also they are wondering and hoping that this psychosexual
- 3:58evaluation will uncover what happened to Josh Powell's wife three years prior to this moment.
- 4:04You see the wife named Susan. She disappeared off the face of the
- 4:10earth three years ago during a blizzard in Utah. Her disappearance immediately became an
- 4:15international news story, and everyone, and I mean everyone, suspected Josh of
- 4:20killing Susan, but the police were never able to charge him. So this
- 4:28test, this psychosexual test, could provide evidence to finally put him behind bars
- 4:33for the murder the disappearance of his wife Susan. So a lot of people
- 4:40were interested in the results of this test, not only people in the family,
- 4:44but people around the world because they were following this story. So that's
- 4:49the state of mind that Josh was in that Super Bowl Sunday. He knew
- 4:55he was possibly going to lose his children for good, and he knew that
- 4:58he might go to prison for their of his life, and he knew that
- 5:01the whole world would be watching and would perhaps know what sort of sexual deviancy
- 5:12because and I'll get into the actual test later, but it involves a measure
- 5:18of arousal. Let's just put it that way. So the social worker,
- 5:24she walks the two boys up to Josh's house, the father's house. Josh
- 5:28opens the front door and the boys run inside. The house like they reportedly
- 5:32always did on these supervised visits. The social worker is just a couple steps
- 5:39behind the boys and she is entering the house because she's there to supervise,
- 5:44but Josh pushes her backward and he slams the door in her face and he
- 5:46locks the door. The social worker is stunned at first, naturally, this
- 5:51has probably never happened to her before, this is what she does for a
- 5:55living. But then when she realizes what's happening, she starts ringing the doorbell.
- 6:00She starts pounding on the door, telling Josh to open the door,
- 6:04and eventually she hears from behind the door, she can hear Josh saying,
- 6:12Charlie, I have a big surprise for you. Then she smells gasoline and
- 6:17a lot of gasoline, and she knows that Josh is capable of terrible things,
- 6:24allegedly because the thought was that he had killed his wife three years earlier.
- 6:30So she runs back to her car and calls nine one one. Frantically,
- 6:34she tells the nine one one operator about the situation, and she tells
- 6:40him the nine one one operator that he needs to send the police and emergency
- 6:44services immediately, but the nine one one operator seems like he just woke up
- 6:47from a nap. At times, the nine one one operator seemed like he
- 6:51just wasn't really listening. At other times he seemed skeptical about her claim that
- 6:57it was an emergency, and other times he sees seemed completely dismissive of her.
- 7:02So after a few minutes of being brushed off by him, she looks
- 7:06up and sees the house erupt in flames, and not just a small fire,
- 7:12but the entire house is suddenly a blaze. So this clip is from
- 7:17KOI N six TV. Now check out this video. You can see roaring
- 7:24flames, thick smoke, and ash coming from the home of Josh Powell.
- 7:28Police say when the children got close to the door, Powell dragged them inside
- 7:30and locked the caseworker out. Moments later, a fiery blast leveled the house.
- 7:36It happened just days after Powell was denied custody of his boys by a
- 7:41Washington judge who ruled they should remain with their grandparents. Police say Powell was
- 7:46a person of interest in the case of his missing wife, Susan Cox.
- 7:49Powell hasn't been seen since December of two thousand and nine, so thoughts on
- 7:55this so far, birtle Man, this when this story came out, you
- 8:01know, you watch these horrific movies sometimes where you know, horrific things happen
- 8:05in them, and you're glad that it's just a movie. But this stuff
- 8:09being real life really darkens the universe. And just it's such a vivid in
- 8:15my mind, such a vivid moment because I can picture it. I can
- 8:18picture those two little boys running in in excitement to see their father, and
- 8:24in that moment of terror for the social worker, the helplessness of you know,
- 8:33first trying to do something, being thwarted for even trying, but then
- 8:37seeing the flames like yeah, no, what can you say? It's horrible.
- 8:43So later, after the firefighters put out the fire, the investigators conclude
- 8:50that Josh Ed struck the boys in the head multiple times with an axe and
- 8:56then he let the gasoline, killing himself along with the two boys and Charlie.
- 9:01And then later medical examiners determined that the boys ultimately died from smoke inhalation,
- 9:07not from the multiple acts injuries. So apparently the axe injuries didn't kill
- 9:13the boys and they died from the fire ultimately. And of course there was
- 9:22always this question as to whether or not Josh had murdered his wife three years
- 9:26prior, but after he killed his two children in such a brutal way,
- 9:31no one had any doubt as to what had happened to Susan. They just
- 9:35didn't know the exact details of it. So all this raises the question why
- 9:41did Josh do this? And why do so many people do things like this?
- 9:48Why have we heard stories like this? Have so called family annihilators this
- 9:54kind of thing? And also how could he do this? How could anyone
- 9:58do this? So in this deep Dive series, I want to answer those
- 10:03questions. I want to know at least try to answer them, along with
- 10:07a lot of other questions like what is Josh's diagnosis? Was he narcissistic,
- 10:15psychopathic, antisocial, something else? And because my friend and colleague evaluated him,
- 10:22we can actually get at that answer. Also, what about the father
- 10:26Steven? I haven't even mentioned him. That's a whole other part of the
- 10:30story. What was going on with him? How can we detect these traits
- 10:35in the people around us so we can steer clear of them right and maybe
- 10:41help our loved ones steer clear. What could Susan have done? Maybe to
- 10:46protect herself. What could the government have done in Washington State to protect the
- 10:50children? Did the police in Utahs grew up the case, because there's a
- 10:56lot of allegations about that. My friend and colleague, doctor Jim Manley,
- 11:03did he screw up the case? And also if Josh murdered Susan Howe.
- 11:09Because there's a lot of theories out there and I'll provide mine and Burtle you
- 11:15can provide yours. So in this deep Dive series, I want to get
- 11:18at all of these questions. But in order to do that, we need
- 11:22to go through the full story. Because the devil's in the details, so
- 11:26to speak, and there are many, many details to this story. I
- 11:31had already done a deep dive on the story years ago, but in preparation
- 11:37for these episodes, for this deep dive, I went even deeper. There's
- 11:43a lot of details, and we have an inordinate amount of details because almost
- 11:48everyone involved in the story kept detailed diaries, written diaries, audio diaries,
- 11:52video diaries. Josh Powell himself kept a detailed diary for years. Susan wrote
- 12:01in a diary, and she frequently emailed her friends personal stories and her feelings.
- 12:07So we have all those emails, we have all those journals. We
- 12:11have Josh's full journal, we have Susan's full journal, we have Stephen the
- 12:16father his and that's a whole other story that we'll get into. Also,
- 12:22like I said, my friend doctor Jim Manley, he conducted a full psychological
- 12:24evaluation of Josh. So there's just so much data. And also a lot
- 12:31of investigators and journalists have interviewed a lot of witnesses and people close so that
- 12:37there's all that data. And I've reviewed much of that data and I have
- 12:43distilled it down to its most relevant, detailed details. And that's what I'm
- 12:50gonna present to you, Burdo, and then we will discuss as we go.
- 12:56What do you say sounds like a lot. I hope my brain doesn't
- 12:58fry. Yeah, this is the Psychology in Seattle podcast. I'm your host,
- 13:03doctor Kirkhana. I'm a therapist and I'm also a professor. My name
- 13:05is Fromberto Castagne and I trained. Do you know what fireflies are? So
- 13:11you know how like they're crunchy on the outside. Mm hmm that's my doing.
- 13:16Ah So, Burdo, Well, first off, did you hear about
- 13:20the Susan disappearance. No, when this happened, I had not heard.
- 13:24I've talked about this before on the podcast. When O. J. Simpson
- 13:28was first being chased, it was a famous moment in our history where we're
- 13:33watching live on TV, this person being chased on the freeway, you know,
- 13:39in a white Bronco for allegedly murdering two people. And I remember when
- 13:46I was watching that, I was going to be clear. He wasn't he
- 13:50was. It wasn't like a high speed chase, but it was he was,
- 13:52from my memory, going to be questioned by the police, right right,
- 13:56Actually they weren't like trying to arrest them. They were just trying to
- 14:00They were just trying to talk to him because his hiding in the back seat
- 14:03of the Bronco. He jumped into a car with his friend. His friend's
- 14:05driving, and he has a gun and they get on the phone with nine
- 14:11one one and he's saying, I'm gonna kill myself, Yeah, because I
- 14:15don't see a reason to go on living. Right. So for me,
- 14:18when I watched that, because I remember and I was younger and even more
- 14:22naive, I remember watching that and I had such a little understanding of how
- 14:26the justice system works that in my mind, I just assumed, oh,
- 14:31okay, well they've got him dead to rights, like he obviously did it,
- 14:35because you know it's obvious, and I guess they'll just catch him and
- 14:39send him to jail. That's what I figured. Little did I know,
- 14:41No, it was going to be like the trial of the century and ultimately
- 14:43he'd walk like that was so mind blowing. So similarly, when this story
- 14:48was breaking and they were saying, oh, you know what, mysteriously his
- 14:52wife disappeared, and so the story of the fire, the fire, Yeah,
- 14:56I'm hearing the fire and it's like this horrific situation and I and again
- 15:00I'm sitting there at the time. I remember kind of really embodying the moment
- 15:05and feeling the horror that those those last moments must have been the ultimate horror,
- 15:11like of confusion. And yeah, and I don't I don't want to
- 15:16just get into the gory details just for the sake of getting into the gory
- 15:20details. But I think it's important because if we're going to analyze Josh Powell's
- 15:26psychology, then we have to look at some of these details. And the
- 15:31detail that just I cannot get out of my head is that, and I
- 15:37get I don't know, I'm just really icky feeling inside my body right now
- 15:41that he has an axe, he knows he's going to kill his boys,
- 15:46and he he acts is one of the buttons, I know. And the
- 15:52other boy is watching and sees it happening and is watching his father just brutally
- 16:03multiple injuries, right, because it probably took a while for the child to
- 16:08be unconscious or subdued enough or something. And then the father turns to the
- 16:17boy that's witnessing this grabs him, right. You just imagine and thinks,
- 16:22oh, I'm next. Yeah, I mean, and not comprehending what they're
- 16:27seeing, why they're seeing what they're seeing, you almost must go into a
- 16:33fugue state of like, you know, I had a near death experience in
- 16:37a car crash, and everything slowed down right before we hit a tree,
- 16:41Like time really slowed down. It was bizarre. I saw everything going in
- 16:45slow motion. So I'm almost imagining like kind of going into a weird delusion,
- 16:51like I'm not even awake, is this even real? Like? Yeah,
- 16:53So when all this was developing and their reporting on the news, and
- 16:57then it came out like well, his wife had gone mysteriously missing. I
- 17:00felt such rage in that moment because and of course I didn't have all the
- 17:03details, but that the quote unquote trauma from the OJ thing came back because
- 17:10it was like, wait what it was like this anger, like this anger
- 17:15of how could this have happened? That how can someone's wife go mysteriously missing?
- 17:21And then well, you were probably told, you were probably told the
- 17:26you know, the broad strokes of the disappearance, which was that she disappeared
- 17:32one night. And his alibi is that during one of the biggest blizzards that's
- 17:38ever happened in Utah, and Utah knows blizzards, nos, snow right,
- 17:44he takes his two young boys, one and four years of age for a
- 17:48camping trip at mid after midnight, he gets in his mediev it's what people
- 17:53do. And then he came back and she was mysteriously gone. And they'd
- 17:57been fighting all this time, and she had said to multiple people, including
- 18:03her own journals, if I end up dead, Josh probably killed me.
- 18:07So and so at the time I only knew a little bit of these things,
- 18:11but even the little I heard just in the news, I was in
- 18:15such a rage of you know, like, how is this possible. How
- 18:19can people not connect the dots? How can how can this man be free?
- 18:25How can this have happened? And then, sadly, the more I
- 18:30the more that came out over the subsequent weeks, it didn't help. It
- 18:33just made things worse. Yeah, so we're going to get into that.
- 18:37The police, the d s HS, you know, child services, Social
- 18:41Services in Washington State. I've got a lot to say about it. So
- 18:45we're going to get into that. But first Berto, let's take a break.
- 18:48What do you say? Let's do it all right back from the break.
- 18:55So for me, I don't remember this story of Susan Powell's disappearance,
- 19:00even though it was a very popular news story going around the time. But
- 19:04I didn't really pay attention to the news back then, and I didn't have
- 19:08cable TV, so I just probably didn't know about it. But I do
- 19:15remember hearing the story of the murder, suicide and the fire because it was
- 19:18local and it was so sensational and what was this twenty twelve and then the
- 19:26so the wife disappeared and nine two thousand and nine. Yeah, And I
- 19:32learned the details of the story because when doctor James Manley asked to come on
- 19:38the podcast. I basically used that as an opportunity to learn about the details,
- 19:45and so I learned about it then. And by the way, burto
- 19:48on Wikipedia the page for Susan Powell and Josh Powell and the kids, they
- 19:55referenced the podcast. It's one of the of the you know those little numbers
- 20:00that you click on, Is that like the doctor appeared on a podcast?
- 20:06Blah blah blah. Yeah. I also wrote a paper about the whole thing
- 20:11and had it on my website, but it's no longer there, but the
- 20:15wayback Machine still has it apparently, so I got to see that. Okay,
- 20:21So I want to tell everyone where I got all my information from,
- 20:26because I mostly I just want to praise some main sources. The main source
- 20:33of the information is from The Cold podcast hosted by journalist Dave Caley. He
- 20:41did an amazing job on this podcast. It's it's a rare podcast in that
- 20:45it's like classic journalism where he investigates, he asks questions, he presents first
- 20:52hand sources. He doesn't speculate, he doesn't talk about his own experience.
- 20:57He doesn't even really talk about his own emotional experience. I mean that style
- 21:03of podcast is certainly great, like we're doing it here, right, But
- 21:07classic journalism, I feel is on the on the wane. It's waning,
- 21:14right, And I listened to it years ago, but I listened to it
- 21:15all over again. And I also didn't realize just how much story he actually
- 21:22discovered because he interviewed so many different people. Wow, he interviewed police,
- 21:27and he interviewed family members, he interviewed you know, he interviewed doctor Manley,
- 21:33and it's just a great podcast to cold podcast. I also found a
- 21:40lot of information on YouTube and on the internet's you know, other news outlets,
- 21:45but it's just a lot of different sources, you know. So that
- 21:52is where most of my information comes from. Okay, So the format of
- 21:56this series is going to be chronological instead of the typical format of providing data
- 22:03in the order that it was discovered by the police. That's usually what happens,
- 22:07right, It'll just be like the surface of the information, and then
- 22:12they'll reveal more information as they go. I just want to go chronological because
- 22:18it is easier for me to do that, and also I want to provide
- 22:23an analysis as we go, and I think if I do it the typical
- 22:27way of providing like frequent flashbacks that'll get confusing. So that's what I'm going
- 22:33to do. So let's start from the very beginning. We have Josh Powell
- 22:37born nineteen seventy six in Pewallup, which is near Seattle, and the Townallop
- 22:44is infamous as being a litmus test for locals because if you can pronounce it,
- 22:51then you're a local. And if sort of like tuckwilla or if you
- 22:55call you know, pike Place Market Pike's Place Market or something, pull up.
- 23:00If you look it up, it's it doesn't look like the way it's
- 23:03pronounced, or Gui duck for example. So Josh Pall born nineteen seventy six
- 23:08Inllup in a Mormon family. His parents Stephen and Teresa. Teresa's name is
- 23:17spelled t E R R I c A Tarika. I've never heard of that
- 23:22they Stephen and Teresa were married in a Mormon temple, meaning that they were
- 23:27very Mormon, because to be married in a temple means that you jumped through
- 23:32a lot of hoops. Oh really, yeah, I didn't know that.
- 23:34Oh you didn't know that. No. I just assumed that was like what
- 23:37you do if you're Mormon. No, you're a Catholic. You don't have
- 23:40to dump too many hoops. Well I imagine there's some. Yeah, actually,
- 23:44I mean sure, but but it's expected, like you just like if
- 23:45you're Catholic, you're getting married a Catholic church. Yeah, I mean,
- 23:48unless you're like a known problem in the church. But in the Mormon religion,
- 23:56there's a lot of things you have to do, and I think it's
- 23:59fairly easy for the elders of the church to say no, you you aren't
- 24:06worthy for whatever reason. Really yeah, yeah, I mean I'm speaking as
- 24:11a person who have who has heard a lot of Mormon people describe as to
- 24:15me, so I can't speak from it. I got married in an Episcopalian
- 24:18church and the only prerequis because I wasn't a member of that church. But
- 24:22I did have to go to counseling with the priest. We did, and
- 24:26he advised us not to get married. Oh really you and your wife?
- 24:30Yeah? Why, oh you know the usual He said, listen, uh,
- 24:36you're Latin, and I mean, you know what that means, So
- 24:41like it's probably not before what Yeah, so this is a minister in Tacoma,
- 24:49Yeah, near near where they got married. Did I mean, did
- 24:55he say anything more than that? Or was he just I feel like the
- 24:57combination of implication was that I would potentially beat my wife and or cheat or
- 25:03both. Oh my god, I'm not entirely sure because we were very young,
- 25:07and shock was it was No, it wasn't it was, but it
- 25:15wasn't your It was my mom's church at that time. It's no longer her
- 25:19church. But yeah, wow, it was very bizarre, and I was
- 25:22too young to like, I was so upset, but I was. I
- 25:25mean, did you say anything in the meetings that were along those lines.
- 25:30No, I mean I wasn't like, well, you know I'm Latin.
- 25:33Yes, no, no, I but did you tell stories about how because
- 25:40you guys were young, you know, and there's conflict? Well, I
- 25:41I'm sure that he probably was picking up that. You know, we were
- 25:45young and we did not necessarily a lot of things. But so fine,
- 25:52so say, like, you know, I noticed a lot of tension.
- 25:52Are you guys sure you're ready? Stuff like this? But like, I
- 25:56mean, you're Latin, you know what that means. So he refused to
- 26:02marry you? No, no, he married us? But how great?
- 26:06How great is that that your minister like begrudgingly. How we're to do it.
- 26:11I mean, I'll do it, but he's Latin. I'll do it.
- 26:15I mean I'm not going to do it in Spanish. If that's what
- 26:17you think. Wow. Yeah. Also, to get married in the Mormon
- 26:22temple, the guests have to be worthy to enter the temple as well.
- 26:26And it's common that the people you invite can't actually attend the wedding because they're
- 26:32like if like if we had friends that were getting married, and we would
- 26:36not be interested to attend the wedding, but or if you are a Mormon
- 26:40but you haven't, you've been kind of off and on, you know.
- 26:45So the point is that they were they were definitely in. They were in.
- 26:48Yeah, and that's relevant, you know, for later. And I'm
- 26:52only eighty five percent sure of everything I'm saying about the Mormons. There were
- 26:56five children, eventually Jennifer the oldest, I think, and then Josh was
- 27:02the second, and then John Michael and Alina was the youngest. Jennifer as
- 27:07an adult, she's the oldest. She was the only child to distance herself
- 27:11from Stephen and Josh, and later as an adult during the police investigation,
- 27:18Jennifer was the only family member who worked really hard to figure out what happened
- 27:23to Susan and to protect the children. For example, she wore a wire
- 27:30on her own behalf. She was just like, I'm going to get Josh
- 27:34to confess. Wait, this wasn't in conjunction with the police, Like it
- 27:38was just she told the police. But the police are like, well,
- 27:42we can't stop you, but I don't know if we recommend it, and
- 27:47she's like, I'm gonna do it. So she wears a wire and I've
- 27:49listened to that whole tape, which is interesting. So Jennifer worked really hard
- 27:53to get justice for Susan and to protect the children, and you know,
- 28:00in the end it didn't work. So with Josh being the second and then
- 28:07we have John. Jennifer would later say that as an adult, John suffered
- 28:11from bipolar and schizophrenia. There's also a lot of reports of him exhibiting very
- 28:15disturbing behavior, which we'll get into you later. Do you remember anything about
- 28:19John that's so he's younger, right, yeah, yeah, no, I
- 28:22don't. I So when we started this deep dive process researching it, at
- 28:30some point I told you to stop researching it because I wanted to reveal details
- 28:34to you. This is one of those details which we'll get to you later.
- 28:37Okay. Michael as an adult, he was very close to Josh.
- 28:42More on him later as well. He might have been their theories that he
- 28:47was involved in the in the disposal of Susan's body. Alina the youngest.
- 28:52As an adult, she was a very adamant defender of Stephen through everything Elena,
- 29:00So we'll get into that more later. And I think the family lived
- 29:04in the Spokane area for most of Josh's childhood, but I couldn't find confirmation
- 29:11of that. Okay, So that's Josh his family. Then we have Susan
- 29:15Cox, his eventual wife. She's born nineteen eighty one in New Mexico,
- 29:19also to a Mormon family. Seemingly Susan was raised well enough. However,
- 29:26Susan seems to have some issues later in life. We'll get into all this
- 29:30later. But she could be assertive, but she could also be dismissive of
- 29:36her own needs and would allow Josh to trample her needs at times, and
- 29:41she didn't seem to push back enough. She also seemed to have an obsession
- 29:45with having children, regardless of the circumstances. More on that later. She
- 29:49enters the story later. So that's Josh and Susan. But now let's get
- 29:55to Stephen because the father needs to be discussed here. So his parenting obviously
- 30:03is a relevant detail here because that can shed some light on Josh's personality and
- 30:10his behavior. So Stephen Powell reportedly he vacillated between being too passive and too
- 30:18punitive. So the too passive part was that he didn't enforce limits on his
- 30:22son's behaviors. In particular, on his daughter's he was less passive, less
- 30:29permissive, but with his sons it was like he just didn't care if his
- 30:34boys did whatever they wanted to do, and it almost seemed like he encouraged
- 30:40the bad behavior at times, particularly if it bothered his wife, the boy's
- 30:45mom. But then at times he would explode and become too punitive. He
- 30:52would suddenly get angry at the children for bad behavior, even though normally he
- 30:56had zero limits. Said he was quote far more violent than was necessary or
- 31:03fair, far more violent. So he was violent. That's a creepy phrase
- 31:10when you're talking about parenting, right, because it's bad enough to be like,
- 31:14yeah, he was a football player, and he was far more violent
- 31:17than he needed to be when we were talking about like he was a parent
- 31:19of young children, and he's far more violent, like, right, I
- 31:22didn't think about that because that implies, you know, the full phrase,
- 31:26far more violent than was necessary. Well, some amount of violence violence is
- 31:32necessary is usually you couch it. You don't even call it violence. Usually,
- 31:36especially when we were growing up, it might be like, well,
- 31:37a little bit of physical punishment goes a long way. This isn't even called
- 31:41physical punishment. This is violence. And this is far more violent, you
- 31:47know, than is necessary. Right, So even if he was only violent
- 31:52in the fair and necessary way, we might still, as outside observers say,
- 31:57the mom's bar is set to problematically wherever, and it wasn't more violent,
- 32:05it was far Yeah. For example, he would yell and he would
- 32:09scream at the children. In addition to being violent, he would call them
- 32:14names and he would hit them, and he was particularly abusive with Josh.
- 32:21Teresa reported quote for years, Steve pointedly attacked Josh very frequently, nearly every
- 32:28day for a time, nearly every day. I wonder how common this is,
- 32:32you know, I saw some of these dynamics in my family, not
- 32:36like in my direct family, but like cousins and things like that, where
- 32:39the oldest male seemed to get, you know, the harshest treatment. And
- 32:45I mean it makes some intuitive sense. It's like, Okay, well he's
- 32:50not the baby anymore, and he's he's a guy. He can take it,
- 32:52you know. So I wonder if that's like a common pattern where the
- 32:58at least that particular not particularly. I mean, it's attempting to draw those
- 33:05kinds of generalizations, but it's across the board. There's a lot of different
- 33:10possibilities as to why one person, whether it's related to gender or their personality
- 33:17or the circumstances around their birth or whatever. There's just various reasons why a
- 33:22child would be targeted in that way. But anyway, so for whatever reason,
- 33:28Josh was targeted, and I'm just trying to think, given everything that's
- 33:30in my head, if I have any kind of speculation as to why Stephen
- 33:34would particularly attack Josh. The only very loose speculation I would have is that
- 33:40Stephen his childhood, of which I know nothing about, which I wish I
- 33:45did, but it was never reported on in all the stuff I was looking
- 33:51at. But Steven's childhood might have had something along these lines of being abused,
- 33:58and maybe he was the oldest, or he was targeted in particular,
- 34:01or his older brother was some kind of recreation as my guess, I don't
- 34:07know. Also, another factor can be that when you have young parents,
- 34:13they tend to lack in skill to the greatest degree. You know, as
- 34:19parents get older, they learned things, and so the later children can sometimes
- 34:24experience less problems. That's kind of what I was saying, is because like
- 34:29first, your first kids, First of all, it's the most stressful.
- 34:32You don't know what you're doing, so you might also resent them without knowing
- 34:37more. But of course this sounds like agreedious way beyond that, because when
- 34:40I'm describing sort of like maybe normal parental situations, but this sounds way worse.
- 34:45Yeah, it could also be that Josh actually put himself in the line
- 34:49of fire. Some older kids will sacrifice themselves. I didn't hear anything along
- 34:53those lines, and he certainly didn't exhibit any well maybe he'd anyway, hard
- 34:59to know, but he did target Josh in particular. And when Josh was
- 35:04a teenager, Stephen wrote this in his diary quote, at times, I
- 35:09have no idea how to handle Josh he is very independent, and he is
- 35:15a little taller than me now, and he may be a little stronger and
- 35:20bulkier than me. Spanking didn't even help when he was younger. That's an
- 35:25interesting transition, you know. It's funny. This happened to me with my
- 35:30dad when I was I think I was maybe fourteen or fifteen. I was
- 35:36I was starting to be close to him in height and at the time,
- 35:39I was like doing lots of pull ups and everything. And you know,
- 35:44I wouldn't say I was stronger than him yet, but I was certainly no
- 35:46longer a little boy. And one time he was very upset at me about
- 35:51something. I was being a complete brat, and for the first time ever,
- 35:54he punched my arm like he had never laid hands on me, but
- 35:59he was so upset, like punched my arm. I don't know if he
- 36:00wasn't trying, but I was like, I was into kwondo at the time.
- 36:05So I got punched every Saturday and Sunday for two hours straight. So
- 36:07I was like, I was just like eh, and it just frustrated him
- 36:10so much, And of course I was being a complete jerk. But looking
- 36:15back on it and now me being a father, I'm like, yeah,
- 36:17that's got to be an interesting transition. When you're able to tell your kids
- 36:22go to your room, do whatever, you know, and then when you're
- 36:27much bigger and older and your voice is deeper, there's kind of an implicit
- 36:30like, oh yeah, dad's saying blah, but all of a sudden,
- 36:35your boy or girl might be bigger, more athletic, more whatever. And
- 36:39in a culture where physical imposition was and still is in many cases a factor,
- 36:46that would be a weird transition. And then if you're a parent who
- 36:50actually thinks of physical punishment as a tool and that tool is basically like eroding,
- 36:53then you'd be like, well, now what do I do? Right?
- 36:57That's the key here, Yeah, is it's not like that you with
- 37:00your two daughters, You're going to have thoughts like this, of course,
- 37:06like oh, she's big now, she could maybe kick my ass. I
- 37:09should think about how I'm parenting the kid. What if you're in this mindset
- 37:15of I am now unable to bank on the fact that I can physically harm
- 37:22this person, this child, and not fear retribution or defending themselves like that
- 37:30mindset says something that he and he wrote it in his journal. It also
- 37:36kind of is in the vein that we'll get to later of envy that he
- 37:40has regarding his narcissism. So that's his parenting. But there's more details to
- 37:45his parenting. But first, let's take a break. What do you say,
- 37:49Burtle, Let's do it all right, We're back from the break.
- 37:55So going on with more details about Stephen and parenting was that he had quote
- 38:01unquote bad boundaries. For example, he talked about adult concerns in front of
- 38:07his young children. He would later do this with Josh and Susan's kids,
- 38:13Brandon and Charlie, the ones who were murdered by Josh, And we have
- 38:16that on audio recordings because eventually there was a wire and he would just and
- 38:23Josh would do this as well. There's just open comment there was. There
- 38:27didn't seem to be any concern about editing ones topics or words in front of
- 38:32the children. And Steven did that with all of his kids. And I
- 38:37want to ask you, Burtle, like, how do you manage this with
- 38:39your daughters regarding like you'll have an impulse to maybe turn to your wife and
- 38:45say, oh, you know, we need to talk about this thing that
- 38:47happened. How do you figure out what and what not to say in the
- 38:52context of them doing something wrong. No, like something happens at work,
- 38:58or you're worried about your health or something. Oh, I see, and
- 39:01when not to include the kids in those convers Yeah, and the kids are
- 39:05there, Oh dude. No. Actually, I have been not good at
- 39:07that stuff. I've had to I've had to learn to be better, and
- 39:12I'm still not good basically. I have definitely, I've definitely incurred cases where
- 39:19I've done cases where I was talking, for example, about my health and
- 39:22then my daughter ends up being super worried and probably a bit traumatized from the
- 39:29conversation. And it wasn't you know, in my mind, it was just
- 39:32like me just sharing my worries and like, oh gosh, I'm going to
- 39:35go to the doctor. Blobbah. Yeah. I remember this, just the
- 39:37details. I remember as you were telling me about how your house was under
- 39:43renovation, right, the flooring was being changed, the wood flooring, and
- 39:47there was all this glue and material around, and you were concerned that the
- 39:55inhalance, the particulates and the chemicals were seeing problems with your breathing and your
- 40:02your lungs, and it was scary to you, and you were talking about
- 40:07it freely in front of the children, and then like a day later you
- 40:12hear one of your daughters just completely anxious about something that they weren't anxious about
- 40:17before. Yeah, and so I've been guilty of that. And it's not
- 40:22not only with health. There's definitely been times where basically where the right approach
- 40:27is you as adults go discuss it and then maybe actually have a version of
- 40:32the conversation with the kids. That's like, now what we have done which
- 40:37is positive? Is there? I mean, does that partially do because your
- 40:39dad wasn't very good at that, like you didn't have good models about certainly.
- 40:45Yeah, I'm imagining that's because because for me, my parents never talked
- 40:50about adult stuff and like ever right, whereas in my house in Colombia,
- 40:55I was the one separating my dad and my grandma often because they were yelling
- 41:00and it was quite dramatic. Yeah, does your wife have a gauge around
- 41:07that as well? Yes, except she's got the opposite damage because she had
- 41:12this whole thing in her household where her dad would get super angry and do
- 41:15the silent treatment on his mom for days on her mom for days, and
- 41:20then her mom would just be quiet and not bring things up. Like all
- 41:22these kind of like opposites. She probably kind of likes hearing communication. You're
- 41:28saying, it's the opposite, meaning there was a problem, but no one
- 41:31was acknowledging it or saying it. And then also I have found that,
- 41:37especially when the kids were younger, that at times she my feeling, I
- 41:43could be wrong, was that she was a little too protective of the kids,
- 41:47you know. But in either case, one thing that we have learned
- 41:52to do well, I think is whenever we've had like an argument about something,
- 41:57we make sure the kids hear us kind of discussing our way out of
- 42:00it and like reaching a resolution, which is something I never heard. Yeah.
- 42:07Ever, Yeah, isn't that weird? No, I have I think
- 42:10it's almost universal, fair enough, It's just that. But I guess what
- 42:14I mean by where it is. I have countless memories of arguments and problems
- 42:20and things. I don't have one memory of like, oh but there was
- 42:23that one day where they shook hands and things were nice, yeah, or
- 42:30someone apologized, or responsibilities if someone said, you know, I see it
- 42:34from your site. Nothing, Yeah, Yeah, it's it's common. Yeah,
- 42:39so apparently Stephen had and I would say, way worse boundaries than what
- 42:46you're talking about, because not only did he lack that editor in his mind,
- 42:52but he also would talk about a lot of really what we might call
- 42:55toxic things, which we'll get into later. He also, oh, shared
- 43:00pornography with his three sons. Did you know this detail? Yeah, I
- 43:06do remember something about the pornography. Yes, So I want to get into
- 43:09this in detail. But first, Brito, let's take a break. And
- 43:15after the break is just going to be for patrons of the podcast. We're
- 43:17going to do a deep dive on early exposure to pornography and it's pretty complicated.
- 43:24I'm going to tell stories from my own life. I'm going to tell
- 43:28stories clinical stories as well, and I'm going to talk about the research because
- 43:32it's a lot more nuanced than is typically talked about. But to hear the
- 43:36rest of this episode, in the end of every one of these episodes in
- 43:40this series is going to be for patrons because they were the ones that were
- 43:43asking for this, and they're the ones that fund this whole operation. So
- 43:49become a patron and you can hear this. Otherwise, please take care of
- 43:52yourself because you deserve it.