Latest / CXOTalk / What Really Happens Inside Big Money Exchanges? | CXOTalk #885
Transcript
- 0:00Today on CXO Talk Episode 885, we explore the world of global
- 0:07financial exchanges with Chris Isaacson, Chief Operating
- 0:11Officer and Executive Vice President of SIBO Global
- 0:15Markets. We'll discuss real world
- 0:18examples of market resilience, the strategic balance between
- 0:22institutional and retail investors, the role of
- 0:26technology such as generative AI and ultra low latency systems,
- 0:32and much more. SIBO Global Markets is one of
- 0:35the leading derivatives and securities exchanges in the
- 0:38world. We operate 27 markets around the
- 0:41world, including the largest options exchange in the world.
- 0:45We have bell bellwether products like the SPX and the VIX Index
- 0:50that you've likely heard of before.
- 0:53And I'm the Chief Operating Officer, as Michael mentioned,
- 0:56overseeing all of technology operations and risk for SIBO as
- 1:01well As for business lines that we run.
- 1:04You talk about resilience. Explain that to us.
- 1:08Tell us why that's so important for you.
- 1:11Our purpose is building trusted markets and resilience and
- 1:14trust. Go, go directly together.
- 1:18Most people don't understand the exchanges because they're kind
- 1:21of behind, behind the front door.
- 1:23Investors usually interact with the market through an
- 1:26application on their phone or application on the desktop, but
- 1:30don't really think about how the exchange operates.
- 1:33And we, we match buyers and sellers in a fully electronic
- 1:37way. And they expect that that's just
- 1:40going to work 100% of the time. So resilience is, is part and
- 1:45parcel with how we operate our exchanges every day.
- 1:48It just has to work all the time, every time.
- 1:52And therefore we design and engineer our systems so that
- 1:57when things do fail, which any system that's ever been created
- 2:00there, there are failure scenarios.
- 2:03You first assume that something can go wrong and you plan for
- 2:07those so that you can fail over very, very quickly and make it
- 2:11seamless to the users so they don't even recognize if a
- 2:15failure has occurred in the system.
- 2:17So when we think about our systems, they need to be fault
- 2:20tolerant in order for them to be resilient for the investors, for
- 2:24the markets, especially during the most volatile times.
- 2:28This issue of resilience, and let's face it, you have to be
- 2:32up, obviously, right? If you go down, that's very
- 2:36expensive for a lot of people. So when you talk about
- 2:40resilience, is it primarily technology?
- 2:45Are there cultural dimensions behind the scenes?
- 2:49Like I've like, you know, every time a pager goes off, do does
- 2:52everybody in the company sort of jump and say, Oh my God, we have
- 2:55to respond instantly? Like how does that work?
- 2:57So it's not just the platforms or the systems, it's it's the
- 3:01people, it's the processes we have in place.
- 3:05It's even the places where we work.
- 3:07We're always thinking about how to build and and run resilient
- 3:11teams. And those resilient platforms
- 3:13come from resilient people. So in the process we put in
- 3:17place demand that we we operate in a resilient way.
- 3:21So as we think about it, yeah, fail safe systems, we need to
- 3:24have automatic failures. Of course, that is engineered
- 3:28from the start. But also people, we have very
- 3:30rigorous incident management protocols and we have very
- 3:34rigorous change management protocols.
- 3:36We run through and we run a consistent testing of all of the
- 3:40backup systems both in our primary, primary sites and our
- 3:45secondary sites. And on weekends, there's really
- 3:49consistent testing through many, many, many different layers that
- 3:53are really engineered and run by people and then bolstered by
- 3:58processes that serve the people and the platforms to make us
- 4:01resilient. So resilient people build
- 4:04resilient platforms using resilient processes.
- 4:08So that's, that's the way we think about it holistically.
- 4:12And it's it's a mindset as much as it is a technology platform.
- 4:16And you're chief operating Officer, which means that you
- 4:21are ultimately responsible for these operations.
- 4:26Can you describe the kind of behind the scenes demands that
- 4:31this places both on the technology as as well as on the
- 4:37people and, and again, how you, how you kind of think about
- 4:40this, how you manage this and is it the same or is it different
- 4:44from managing a business where there's less real time pressure?
- 4:49It is different than than managing maybe a, a business
- 4:52where there's not mission critical systems.
- 4:54We consider these mission critical, you know,
- 4:57systematically important infrastructure that we're
- 4:59operating around the world in different, different countries.
- 5:03So it does require a different level of intensity and
- 5:06intentionality. And it, it forces you to have
- 5:09very, very good communication both electronically and you
- 5:13know, person to person to make sure that everyone is in the
- 5:18loop immediately when any issue comes up because things will,
- 5:22things will go wrong. And when they go wrong to ensure
- 5:25that you have very rigorous playbooks that you can follow
- 5:28and you can systematically and consistently follow them to
- 5:32solve whatever problem might come up.
- 5:34It's a very fast-paced environment because in the
- 5:37markets seconds and nanoseconds count.
- 5:41And so whenever anything comes up, we want to address it
- 5:44immediately in a way that's as seamless to customers as
- 5:48possible. So there's that's actually part
- 5:50of the fun of running markets is markets of technology are very,
- 5:54very dynamic. And over the last 20 to 30
- 5:57years, you've seen the electronification of markets
- 5:59from from trading pit. Trading pits to really fully
- 6:03electronic, we still have one trading pit that's quite active,
- 6:06but. The rest of our 26 markets are
- 6:09fully electronic and therefore they're, you know, operating at
- 6:13the speed of light. And when something goes wrong,
- 6:15it can go wrong very quickly. And therefore we're we are very
- 6:19quick in our response in the communications.
- 6:22It also requires a level of monitoring around the system and
- 6:25observability around each one of our exchanges, each one of our
- 6:29platforms. That we have it instrumented in
- 6:32a way that we can see not just the front door, but every aspect
- 6:37of that system. And the alerting is is.
- 6:39So dynamic and so pointed that it can highlight the exact issue
- 6:44that might be going on that we need to address in a very
- 6:48precise way at the point at the point of issue.
- 6:52Tell us about the the training that you do of these folks
- 6:56because the folks that are doing this monitoring, I have to
- 7:00assume are very, very experienced and have that
- 7:06intuition of how to respond in case of whatever type of blip
- 7:12issue would that that may arise. We operate 27 markets around the
- 7:16globe and the way in which we train our associates is is based
- 7:22on a globally consistent platform.
- 7:25So we operate a platform called SIBO Titanium.
- 7:28Which runs all of our equities options in futures and markets
- 7:31around the world. And I, I mentioned that because
- 7:34when you're training great associates, great colleagues, it
- 7:39increases the ability to train. Them in a.
- 7:42Consistent way on a consistent platform so that somebody
- 7:45sitting in Sydney, Australia or Chicago or New York or London,
- 7:50they're looking at similar a very, very similar platform that
- 7:53is globally consistent, but locally optimized to the nuances
- 7:58of that country or region or market.
- 8:00So we can train them on the common aspects of a global
- 8:02platform and then they can learn the nuances of their specific
- 8:06market. And that allows us to have a, a
- 8:09follow the sun model where somebody out of region, but when
- 8:13the sun is up for them but not for us in the US, they can know
- 8:17the market, know the technology and respond very quickly in an
- 8:21appropriate way. We've invested a lot over the
- 8:24last three to four years in making sure that we just don't
- 8:27have somebody at the end of the line, but somebody who really
- 8:30knows what they what they're doing in an immediate way if
- 8:34something were to come up. And I assume that all of this
- 8:37falls under into that category of resilience that you were
- 8:40talking about earlier? Absolutely.
- 8:42It's all part of resilient people building resilient
- 8:45platforms using resilient processes.
- 8:48We, you know, I think I, Michael, I grew up on a farm in
- 8:53Nebraska. In a little personal anecdote
- 8:56here, I was thinking about where did the resilience come from?
- 9:00And, you know, I saw my parents go through ups and downs and,
- 9:04you know, it's a very cyclical business that they're in.
- 9:07And invariably on the farm, things would go wrong, things
- 9:10would break. And then I also thought about, I
- 9:14was a decathlete in college and you run 10 events over 2 days
- 9:20and you have to think about, OK, did the last event go well?
- 9:24It doesn't really matter. I have to have to get to the
- 9:26next event and I have to be resilient through that next
- 9:29event and be focused and keep calm and, you know, carry on in
- 9:34the, in the moment. So I just we try to hire people
- 9:38that are really humble, hungry and smart and are willing to
- 9:41really stay cool and calm during during crazy times in the
- 9:46market. I want to make sure everybody
- 9:48knows that you can ask questions.
- 9:50If you're watching on Twitter X, use the hashtag CXO talk.
- 9:56If you're watching on LinkedIn, just pop your question into the
- 10:00chat. And we have some questions that
- 10:03are coming in. But Chris, just tell us about
- 10:08volatility and how you respond to market volatility.
- 10:13It's a very broad and expansive topic.
- 10:16You know, SIBO, we actually created the VIX index decades
- 10:20ago. So if you look on, you know, if
- 10:23you're watching financial news, you'll see the VIX and you'll
- 10:26see it across Bloomberg and other tickers you might see.
- 10:28So we've we've measured. Volatility created an index for
- 10:32it and trade trade futures products on the VIX index.
- 10:36So there's a whole volatility ecosystem of product and trading
- 10:39around it. But your question is around how
- 10:42do we handle volatility and volatile times in the market.
- 10:46And I just want to mention even, you know, recent history.
- 10:49So of course in April there was, there was a lot of terror for
- 10:53talk, there was Liberation Day, there was an incredible amount
- 10:56of volatility that occurred at the beginning of April and.
- 11:00You. Don't prepare for volatility
- 11:02during volatility. You.
- 11:04Prepare for market volatility and the stresses that will come
- 11:08to your exchanges and platforms in the quiet times well before
- 11:12it arrives. So that goes into the
- 11:14engineering discipline we have. We're always building our
- 11:18systems to handle at least 2X what we've ever seen on the
- 11:21largest day. And then, you know, on more
- 11:24micro level, you know, we handle much multiples of that on a
- 11:28second time frame or a minute time frame so that you're ready
- 11:32when the market bursts. Very episodically, the way the
- 11:37markets work is that it's there's a lot of times where
- 11:40it's low volatility in the, the messaging is roughly directly
- 11:44related. The messages we must handle
- 11:46orders and quotes and trades, they're roughly directly related
- 11:51to how volatile the market is. So times of extreme volatility
- 11:55when the VIX goes above 50 or 60 or 70 or even 80 during, during
- 12:00COVID, you would see extreme messaging traffic as as firms,
- 12:06customers, investors are trying to manage their risk.
- 12:10And so you must be prepared before.
- 12:13And that's where we're testing on a very regular basis at
- 12:16multiples of what we've ever seen.
- 12:19And I'm extremely grateful to the team that that I get to
- 12:23lead. Everything we do here is a team.
- 12:25There's there's no single person who does it all.
- 12:29And because of all their great preparation in April, we're able
- 12:33to handle things with without issue because we'd prepared for
- 12:37months and really years of engineering discipline in
- 12:39advance to handle on a single day in April, for instance, we
- 12:44handled more than a trillion messages without issue.
- 12:48And that's, you know, it's very rare to be in a business where
- 12:51you can talk in trillions of messages managed in a day.
- 12:54And yeah, very grateful for the team that we we made it through
- 12:58as did frankly the the market ecosystem, other exchanges,
- 13:01clearing houses. While there was great
- 13:04volatility, the market infrastructure handled it well.
- 13:08Subscribe to the CXO Talk newsletter.
- 13:11Go to cxotalk.com. You're part of our community and
- 13:14we want you back. To what extent do you see your
- 13:18role as being at least partially responsible for maintaining
- 13:24market stability during periods of extreme volatility?
- 13:30I view my role as CEO of an exchange operator and really
- 13:34overseeing exchanges to, to be a steward of the markets, to
- 13:39operate fair and orderly markets.
- 13:41As much as it depends on us now, we don't, you know, we don't
- 13:45trade our customers who are broker dealers, they trade,
- 13:48they're the ones who put in the orders, the bids and offers, and
- 13:52so they determine the price. Our job is to steward the
- 13:55markets, to create fair and equal access, and then to
- 13:59operate fair and orderly markets and to put trading mechanisms in
- 14:04place and safeguards in place so that if prices get dislocated,
- 14:09they don't get dislocated for very long or too far.
- 14:14So, you know, in my history in the markets, which is now 20
- 14:17years, 20 plus years long, I've been through a lot of different
- 14:21points of crisis and volatility, from the great financial crisis
- 14:24to the flash crash to COVID to, you know, recent tariff wars.
- 14:29And each time the market, the collective market and not just
- 14:32SIBO, we learn lessons and then we apply those.
- 14:36So for instance, the flash crash, which occurred in in 2010
- 14:40in the US really had to do with how electronic tronified the
- 14:45markets had become. But there weren't quite enough
- 14:48safeguards in place to avoid runaway prices going too high or
- 14:52too high or too low. And so after that limit up limit
- 14:55down was implemented in the US equities market and that has
- 15:00that has been incredibly effective since then in avoiding
- 15:06stock prices in the US going going awry beyond certain
- 15:10trading limits. And it was an idea frankly that
- 15:12was borrowed and copied from the futures market.
- 15:16This limit up, limit down. That's just one example of good
- 15:21trading risk management measurements that have been
- 15:23taken in improvements. Also market wide circuit
- 15:26Breakers have been put in place. So if the S&P 500 goes down a
- 15:29certain amount, believe it's 713 or 20%, the markets will take a
- 15:33pause overall and not not keep trading to give people a chance
- 15:38to catch their breath and then come back with with with a more
- 15:42cool head and then the market can decide what the right price
- 15:45is. So it's been rewarding to be
- 15:48part of those changes in the market because I view our role
- 15:51as a steward of the market to create fair and orderly markets
- 15:55for the good of investors. So you are creating the context
- 16:01or the the container if you will, within which the markets
- 16:05can operate. And your job, as you're
- 16:08describing it, is to make sure that that context, that
- 16:12environment, is fair, balanced, and works no matter what.
- 16:16Is that our accurate way to put it?
- 16:18I think you're spot on, Michael. That's exactly right.
- 16:21We need to create a fair and equal playing field for for all
- 16:25investors and trading participants to operate and to
- 16:30come and trade. So, you know, the rules need to
- 16:33be very fair and open and transparent and the playing
- 16:36field needs to be level. And so we we take that with
- 16:39incredible seriousness. We've got 2 questions.
- 16:43The 1st 2 questions are very similar relating to generative
- 16:50AI with a little bit of a, A twist in each case.
- 16:54So let me let me take the first one.
- 16:57This is from Anthony Scrifignano, who is the former
- 17:02chief data scientist of Dun and Bradstreet.
- 17:05He's been a guest on CXO Talk and now does all kinds of
- 17:08interesting things that he's not allowed to talk about.
- 17:11And so I know not, I know well enough not to even ask.
- 17:14And Anthony says this. In particularly in times of
- 17:19disruption and geopolitical volatility, small perturbations
- 17:25can cause significant short term market effects.
- 17:29Please share your thoughts on the need to detect Gen.
- 17:33AI introducing disinformation allowing malefactors to capture
- 17:39short term gains. The use of generative AI in
- 17:43financial markets is not new. And I think in our customers we
- 17:48don't have full visibility into how they're using generative AI
- 17:51to to then inform and to inform their trading decisions or
- 17:56investment decisions. We're using generative AI to
- 18:01help as a productivity multiplier.
- 18:03Primarily. We've formed an AI center of
- 18:05excellence and have, you know, 1200 of our associates that have
- 18:10been trained as I think about answering your, your direct
- 18:13question, how do we, how do we avoid, you know, small changes
- 18:18coming from Gen. AI having an outsized impact on
- 18:22the market? I think it goes back actually to
- 18:24those maybe less, less interesting, but very important
- 18:29risk controls that we have in place.
- 18:32Regardless of how the order was generated or how the order was
- 18:37informed. The risk controls are really
- 18:40important to make sure that if, if an algorithm goes amuck
- 18:45because of because of generative AI, the risk controls are going
- 18:49to stop it from going too far awry.
- 18:52And we've seen those risk controls that have been added
- 18:54over and over and over that have have stopped bad things from
- 18:58happening where you might have an algorithm or whatever cause,
- 19:02cause an issue in the market. So that that's not maybe as as
- 19:08sexy or whatever as you would expect to hear from an answer.
- 19:11But I, I think it's, it's the truth is that good risk controls
- 19:16like limit up, limit down, like drill through protection, like
- 19:19market wide circuit Breakers, etcetera, help prevent runaway
- 19:24algorithms from from having an outsized impact on the market.
- 19:28Let's go to LinkedIn now. And this question is, is very
- 19:32similar and it's from Preeti Narayan.
- 19:36And she says, given the rapid rise of generative AI and
- 19:41trading strategies, how is SIBO preparing to manage the risk of
- 19:46herd behavior where multiple market participants may act on
- 19:51similar AI generated signals? Preventing that is probably
- 19:56impossible. We we can see the effect of it
- 19:59if there is herd of behavior and the effect of it would be that
- 20:03price movements are outsized for whatever the triggers in the
- 20:07market might be. And that goes back to where how
- 20:10are the risk controls within the trading firms set, which really
- 20:16all trading firms have chief risk officers that this is this
- 20:19is their day-to-day work thinking about what orders go
- 20:22out the door to the exchange. So there's multiple layers of
- 20:26controls and then that within the exchange, there's risk
- 20:29controls as well to say how much of A price movement is allowed
- 20:33before, before the order is rejected that might be generated
- 20:37by AI. And then if for some reason
- 20:40orders get get out there that that become clearly erroneous or
- 20:44are obvious errors. There's, there's actually rules
- 20:48in securities law in the US and elsewhere that define what is an
- 20:52erroneous trade and it's called obvious air and options are
- 20:56clearly erroneous in US equities.
- 20:58And those are very well defined criteria.
- 21:02And so that those trades or are adjusted or they're, they're
- 21:05actually taken down as air trades in unique situations.
- 21:10So multiple layers of controls in order to preserve fair and
- 21:14orderly markets. So essentially, as you said, you
- 21:19are focused on the activity, you don't worry about the
- 21:27intentionality, what's in the mind of the trader, but you are
- 21:31looking at the actual trade that's made and then you have
- 21:35systems to evaluate those, those trades, the risk and so forth as
- 21:40he was just describing. That's right.
- 21:42We look at the effect rather than we, you know, understanding
- 21:45the exact intent or the origination of the order is
- 21:48sometimes not clear to us. I will mention as as an exchange
- 21:52operator we also have an obligation and to take it very
- 21:56seriously to do regulation on our exchanges.
- 21:59So we do market surveillance of all of our markets looking for
- 22:04any manipulative behavior or behavior that might be out of
- 22:08out of order. And there are well, well worn
- 22:11patterns of what manipulative trading behavior looks like.
- 22:15And then, you know, our independent regulatory
- 22:18department with with their separate staff look at that and
- 22:22they follow up with trading participants if they see
- 22:24anything that does not look like it's fair, orderly or with with
- 22:28wrong intent. So that's a key part of the way
- 22:31that the exchange industry has been created.
- 22:34That's that was part of, you know, securities law put in
- 22:37place at least in the US in the 1930s.
- 22:40And I think it's good, it's good regulation that that exchanges
- 22:45have market supervision or market regulatory departments
- 22:49that look after the fair only markets from a manipulation
- 22:53perspective to ensure there is none going on.
- 22:56And that again that's independent of our trading
- 22:59platforms and systems. The the data flows into the
- 23:02regulatory system, but that's done by separate people that are
- 23:06really focused on making sure that there's no manipulation
- 23:10whatsoever. How do you divide the regulatory
- 23:15or the, the evaluation function between the exchange versus
- 23:22external regulators and and really quickly please, because I
- 23:25there's so many questions stacking up now.
- 23:27We take that responsibility on in different jurisdictions as
- 23:30there's different stories and some some countries the the
- 23:34prudential regulator will do a lot of the surveillance.
- 23:37In other countries do we do a lot of surveillance on each
- 23:40market and then there's shared surveillance sometimes depending
- 23:44on the market. So it's varies by country and by
- 23:46region, but one way or another it's covered either by us, the
- 23:50exchange, or by the prudential regulator.
- 23:53On Twitter X, we have a question from Chris Peterson.
- 23:57This is more on the technology side.
- 23:59He's wondering if, number one, you've seen an evolution in
- 24:04trading speeds over time or it's been big step changes and #2 do
- 24:10you see any floor where trades just can't get faster with
- 24:15current technology? There have been a constant
- 24:18evolution of trading performance and speeds, you know, going
- 24:23latencies going down, throughputs going up, etcetera,
- 24:26with data rates going, you know, very, very large and always
- 24:30increasing. But then there's been a few
- 24:33times where there's been step functions in performance.
- 24:37So 20 plus years ago when I started in the industry, you
- 24:39know, it was a few 10s of milliseconds mattered and that
- 24:43was, that was kind of state-of-the-art.
- 24:45And now it's single digit or 10s of nanoseconds is really what,
- 24:50what matters to people. So that's been a constant
- 24:52evolution. But there's been times when
- 24:54technology has, has had a step function forward with, you know,
- 24:59the introduction of field programmable gate arrays.
- 25:02So Fpgas that most trading, you know, highly sophisticated
- 25:06trading firms use. I think that that really had a
- 25:10step function of how fast our customers can respond to our
- 25:13market data to enter orders. And also I think the different
- 25:17well I know the the different vendors we use, you know,
- 25:21network equipment vendors, server vendors, switch vendors,
- 25:25etcetera. They've made step functions at
- 25:27certain times that allow for much more deterministic and fast
- 25:32delivery of market data or or inbound messaging.
- 25:36So it's been a constant evolution and been it's been
- 25:39actually really fun to be part of.
- 25:41And your second question I think was how is there is there a
- 25:45limit to how fast things can go? And, and I the real answer is
- 25:49yes, of course, because the speed of light is the speed of
- 25:52light and are we approaching that?
- 25:55I would say yes, but there will always be an incentive to get
- 26:01faster. It will just be the the marginal
- 26:07in the marginal improvement or reward from being faster, I
- 26:11think will decrease over time. But we've seen it's just, you
- 26:15know, as I said, the time scales have gone from milliseconds or
- 26:18seconds down to nanoseconds. But those nanoseconds matter
- 26:23enough that trading participants will continue to invest very
- 26:27heavily to ensure they can respond.
- 26:31And, you know, and I think other people might have the different
- 26:35opinions about whether or not fast markets are good or not,
- 26:37but the fact of the matter is fast, efficient markets create
- 26:42good competitive prices for investors.
- 26:45So on the whole, I think this evolution has been been great
- 26:48for investors. Elizabeth Shaw has an add on
- 26:51question to this and she says when is speed not your friend?
- 26:55Speed can not be your friend when, if the market is moving
- 26:58super fast and and if if you're not trading, if you're
- 27:03investing, and I think speed doesn't necessarily matter that
- 27:07much to you. If you're, if your time horizon
- 27:10is days or weeks or years, which frankly, I'll tell you I'm, I'm
- 27:15an investor, not a trader, then speed doesn't really matter as
- 27:19long as I can log into whatever app I might have and with
- 27:23whatever broker and I can, you know, get a fill whenever I need
- 27:26it within a few seconds. So I'd say that in that way,
- 27:31it's that it doesn't really matter.
- 27:33It may not be my friend, but it isn't doesn't matter as much.
- 27:37If I'm a training participant of a timescale is very, very tight,
- 27:41then then I think it can be your friend or your enemy, depending
- 27:44on whether or not the training participant has has invested
- 27:48enough in their technology infrastructure to be
- 27:50competitive. Let's grab another question
- 27:54here, and this is from Twitter from Tishiana Johnson, who says
- 27:59you talked a lot about resilient people.
- 28:03What is something you have found helpful when leading during
- 28:08turbulent times? And I'm going to add not just
- 28:12turbulent times, but what have you found helpful in leading
- 28:18when the market is melting down? For people that are not familiar
- 28:22with the markets to kind of be overcome by the moment when it's
- 28:26very volatile and things can be moving very fast.
- 28:29But I've had the great pleasure of working with incredible
- 28:32people for 20 plus years in the market.
- 28:34Many of the people I work with today, I've worked with for, for
- 28:37more than a decade and they've learned to keep their calm and
- 28:41think very clearly during times of stress when the market is is
- 28:46going, going quite crazy. And, and that, that calmness to
- 28:53keep calm and carry on, I think is absolutely vital.
- 28:57And I think it's vital. And if you're investing, if
- 29:00you're trading, but also if you're running exchange
- 29:02platforms, you need to keep your head, keep composure, keep
- 29:07poised to make clear, quick, concise decisions that are in
- 29:14the best interests of the markets and investors.
- 29:17And I've seen the team that I get to work with do that
- 29:20consistently, always thinking about what's the best for the
- 29:23market and on what time frame do we need to make this.
- 29:27And you need to prioritize the things that have to be done
- 29:29immediately and do it with excellence.
- 29:31Sounds like the airline pilot model.
- 29:35Have you ever heard airline pilots that their talk during
- 29:39times where there's some problem going on?
- 29:42It's traffic, air traffic controllers.
- 29:44It's extraordinary the level of calm rationality that they have
- 29:49as literally their world is potentially ending.
- 29:53Yes, I think that's a great analogy, a great example.
- 29:57Clearly the stakes are higher there 'cause people's lives are
- 30:00at risk here. You know, people's lives are
- 30:03thankfully not at risk in the markets, but it's very important
- 30:06'cause people's livelihoods and their financial well-being is.
- 30:10And so we take that seriously and we need to make great
- 30:12decisions with a clear minds and and not be ruled by emotions or
- 30:16hysteria. On Twitter, X again, Craig
- 30:20Dorchester says speaking on market volatility, he's heard a
- 30:26lot about 24 by 5 trading. How does SIBO view the
- 30:31practicality of moving to it? And are there any hurdles you'd
- 30:36anticipate with this shift? And I'm also curious about not
- 30:41just 24 by 5, but 24 by 7 because we've all been in
- 30:48situations where we see trading happening outside of normal
- 30:54hours and us investors are like, you know, twiddling our thumbs
- 31:00as either the market is shooting up or the market is tanking and
- 31:05we can't do anything about it. 24 by 5 and 24 by 5.
- 31:08Trading is is here and is and the markets that don't already
- 31:13offer it is going to come even more so SIBO, we already offer
- 31:1724 by 5 trading or nearly 24 by 5 trading in our futures market.
- 31:22So VIX futures and other futures products as well as SPX and VIX
- 31:26options as well as our FX markets all trade 24 by 5 today
- 31:32are nearly 24 by 5. Now I think your question maybe
- 31:35more specifically about the equity markets or more
- 31:38specifically about the US equities markets that today on
- 31:42exchange we're really open. We are open from 4:00 AM to 8:00
- 31:46PM Eastern. And there's a lot of industry
- 31:49chatter and good discussion about making that 24 by 5.
- 31:54And we at SIBO will be ready for 24 by 5 trading as soon as I'll
- 31:58say the industry plumbing is ready, which is includes the
- 32:00consolidated tapes as well as the DTCC, which is where all
- 32:05clear, which where all trades are cleared in US equities.
- 32:09So as soon as the industry infrastructure's ready, we will
- 32:12be ready to offer that. I think it's good you can trade
- 32:16off exchange 24 by 5 today. But you know, I think investors
- 32:20really want a more stable transparent way to trade between
- 32:25those hours that aren't covered today, which would just be 8 M
- 32:28Eastern to 4:00 AM Eastern that that 8 hour window which we
- 32:32lanned to close. We have the technical capability
- 32:35to do it, but the industry needs to be ready because there's a
- 32:38lot of industry processes that depend upon some sort of change
- 32:43window, the trading day, rollover, you know, cash
- 32:47movements, margin movements. There's a lot of stuff that goes
- 32:50on overnight, for instance, in the US or whatever overnight
- 32:53might mean in that in that country that need to be
- 32:56reengineered to make sure that trading can be seamless.
- 33:00Because we want the investor experience to be good when, when
- 33:03they when they sell, we want them to get their cash when,
- 33:08when that trade settles. And when they buy, we want to
- 33:11make sure they get the security in their account.
- 33:13And all that back office stuff needs to needs to be worked
- 33:18through very clearly. Now 24 by 7, Michael, I want to
- 33:21answer that question. Yeah, clearly digital assets
- 33:23have been trading 24 by 7 for years now and we we actually
- 33:28have a clearing system Cibo clear US that that can clear
- 33:32transactions 24 by 7. And so that's where I eventually
- 33:38think a lot of asset classes will go.
- 33:41But what doesn't happen on the weekend is right now at least, I
- 33:46mean, you have Fed wire windows and banks, the banking system,
- 33:49traditional finance, a lot of that is closed on the weekend.
- 33:53So are you going to have a huge margin call on Friday to make
- 33:57sure there's enough capital in a clearing house to trade over the
- 34:00weekend and handle any volatility that might happen
- 34:03over the weekend? I think there's probably a place
- 34:06for stable coins or things like or tokenized assets to play in
- 34:11truly getting to an efficient 24 by 7 market.
- 34:16But in this way, I think digital assets are probably leading and
- 34:19we'll probably get there over time with more standard
- 34:21equities. Very interesting.
- 34:23The influence of digital assets, digital crypto currencies on
- 34:31existing markets. That's a it's a kind of a
- 34:34fascinating connection, I think. Yeah, it is.
- 34:36I think there's a lot to be learned both ways.
- 34:38And you see now the kind of what is the, what is the proper and
- 34:42good connection of traditional finance with digital assets or
- 34:47decentralized finance and a bit more clarity coming to what is a
- 34:53digital asset and how should be, how should it be regulated.
- 34:56So we welcome the greater clarity so that under proper
- 34:59regulation, you know all assets that customers really want to
- 35:03trade and invest in can be done in a seamless and consistent
- 35:07way. Folks, now would be a very good
- 35:10time to subscribe to the CXO Talk newsletter so we can keep
- 35:15you up to date on shows that we have coming up.
- 35:18You're part of our community. You guys are awesome and we love
- 35:22your questions. So go to cxotalk.com right now
- 35:26and sign up for our newsletter and that way you can join us
- 35:30every time we do this. It's really fun.
- 35:33OK, let's go to another question.
- 35:35I'm just taking these in order. And on Twitter, ex Tishiana
- 35:40Johnson comes back and she says, how do you manage and build
- 35:45culture among teams that are spread out across multiple
- 35:50countries and time zones? Cause for me, I don't want my
- 35:53passions is leadership development.
- 35:56I help. I help executive sponsor the
- 35:59SIBO, lead the way with our head of HR here at SIBO.
- 36:01And I'm just really passionate about building leaders because
- 36:06as leaders get better, then everybody gets better and then
- 36:09the culture gets better. From the very beginning of my
- 36:12career, you know, I've, I've read a bunch of leadership books
- 36:14and, and whatnot. It's, I think it's a discipline.
- 36:17Leadership is a discipline that people can get better AT.
- 36:22And so leaders set culture. And here at SIBO and across my
- 36:27career, really wanted to work with people that are humble,
- 36:29hungry and smart. That comes from a book.
- 36:32You know, Patrick Lincione wrote a book called The Ideal Team
- 36:35Player. And I just really enjoy reading
- 36:38his books amongst others and tried to live those values here
- 36:43at SIBO amongst other values about being Better Together.
- 36:46And so if you find people that are humble, hungry and smart,
- 36:49that live our values and are competent, then they can connect
- 36:54in a distributed fashion around the world in person.
- 36:58Collaboration's also very important.
- 37:00So we, you know, we fly around the world a fair amount in order
- 37:03to have those really critical in person connections, especially
- 37:08to do intensive training in different regions so they can
- 37:11learn that common platform, but then be able to execute when the
- 37:15time comes. So it's it's a continual
- 37:19investment to build culture. I think culture is as are more
- 37:23important than strategy. And even though this is a highly
- 37:27technology driven business, I believe it starts and ends with
- 37:32people. I care deeply for people and I
- 37:35want people to to be led by great leaders doing great things
- 37:40that are that are humble, hungry and smart.
- 37:43This is from Anthony Scrifignano comes back and he says your
- 37:47decathlete background is perfect for your role.
- 37:50It's definitely not a Sprint. Crisis and volatility also
- 37:55demand the ability to pivot immediately.
- 37:58What skills do you rely on to get others to move with you
- 38:02quickly but thoughtfully during uncertainty that demands action?
- 38:09I think this is built with experience, so you have folks
- 38:12that we work with, folks that have worked, have been in the
- 38:14markets for decades, that have learned.
- 38:17You have to be agile in the way you think 'cause the market is
- 38:20new every day. No market is the same as it was,
- 38:23you know, an hour ago or a day ago or a year ago.
- 38:26So they need to be agile in their thinking.
- 38:28And then as as we hire young people out of school, out of
- 38:31college, they learn how to deal with the dynamism of the market
- 38:36and to respect humbly that this is going to be a different
- 38:39situation. We're not never going to see two
- 38:41situations that are exactly the same.
- 38:43And with that humility, you say, OK, we're just going to learn.
- 38:46We're going to apply what we've learned from past experience and
- 38:50then we're going to modify it as need be to deal with whatever
- 38:53might come in, in, in new market conditions.
- 38:56So that's that's what I'd say from a how to handle new dynamic
- 39:01situations. Andy on Twitter X says it sounds
- 39:07like you have a tough job as there's been so much volatility
- 39:10in the markets lately, putting additional stress on financial
- 39:14market systems. What do you enjoy most about
- 39:19your role and what do you enjoy the least?
- 39:22Most dealing with really, really smart, humble, hungry, smart
- 39:26people that are dead they're just super dedicated and
- 39:29committed to building trusted markets.
- 39:32They, they believe in our purpose and they believe in what
- 39:35we're doing that it helps building trusted markets, helps
- 39:38people eventually and ultimately invest their capital and it's
- 39:43about their financial well well-being.
- 39:45So that's, I think that's by far the best part is working with
- 39:48great, great people. You know, it can be stressful,
- 39:51but you know, being a former athlete, I kind of like the
- 39:56intensity that comes with the market.
- 39:58So at times it can be a bit much in the, in the most stressful of
- 40:02times, but I do really like an intense work environment.
- 40:05I think it's very competitive work environment.
- 40:08And one of our guiding principles is competitive team
- 40:11spirit. So we can match the intensity of
- 40:14the markets together. I love the questions that come
- 40:18in, and I always try to prioritize questions from the
- 40:21audience over my questions. And this is now from Arsalan
- 40:27Khan, who has an interesting question.
- 40:29He said what processes should be abolished to make things more
- 40:35efficient, and he also wants to know the role of data in all of
- 40:40this. The markets need to continue to
- 40:42evolve to make things more efficient.
- 40:44And you've seen in the last couple years we've, you know,
- 40:47there's been a settlement cycle in, in the US and other
- 40:50countries. It's taken 2, maybe 3 days and
- 40:53that's been been the standard practice for decades, many,
- 40:58many, many decades for trading for settlement of trades to
- 41:02happen. That's now gone to T + 1.
- 41:04So on AT plus one basis, I just think there's a lot of
- 41:07disruption and and reengineering to be done on the post trade
- 41:12side to ensure that there's even more timely settlement clearing
- 41:15and settlement of transactions that will allow for easier
- 41:19movement and access to capital in a very capital efficient way
- 41:23around the world. So I'd look for more kind of
- 41:26disruption and reengineering there.
- 41:28And Michael, can you remind me of the second question of this
- 41:31caller? Arsalan is asking about the role
- 41:34of data, and I'm sure that's a big important topic, obviously.
- 41:39Yeah. You can imagine our salon with a
- 41:41trillion, at least a trillion messages in a day.
- 41:44We have an enormous amount of data that's growing within our
- 41:48enterprise and it's highly sensitive confidential data, but
- 41:51from our trading participants. But we've built a a unified data
- 41:56platform that where we put the all the data that comes from our
- 42:00exchanges around the world into this platform.
- 42:03It happens to be running Snowflake on AWS in the cloud.
- 42:07And then we're giving access to our data analysts or data data
- 42:10engineering team and creating insights from that that we can
- 42:14use to inform our discussions with trading participants about
- 42:18how they might trade Better to inform them maybe to educate
- 42:22them of what we're seeing that they may not see yet.
- 42:25And also when we're using that data to then provide insights to
- 42:29them and saleable products like time stamping services and other
- 42:33market data products, they give them insights into how they
- 42:36might trade better on our exchanges.
- 42:38So yeah, data is incredibly important to us and to our
- 42:44customers. In many ways.
- 42:46Data is the fuel of the markets and the sale of data or the use
- 42:51of data is a precursor to people trading on our markets and in
- 42:56our products. So we are we definitely want to
- 42:58get our data closer to customers in the formats they can use.
- 43:02Derivatives like options and futures can lead to tremendous
- 43:07gains and losses very quickly. How do you, and you kind of
- 43:11touched on this, but how do you manage risks to SIBO, your
- 43:14platforms, partners and customers from derivatives
- 43:18trading that goes wrong, that goes awry?
- 43:23I might actually disagree with you on this point in that I
- 43:25think derivatives while they any asset can be misused, but
- 43:30derivatives really were created to manage risk and reduce risk
- 43:35if used correctly. So we're very intent on
- 43:38education of investors, both retail and institutional in the
- 43:44proper use of of options. For instance, I mean SIBO
- 43:47created the the listed options of industry in 197352 years ago
- 43:52and the Options Institute was created about 40 years ago by
- 43:56SIBO because we're passionate about education, because
- 44:00derivatives, especially options, they're actually there to reduce
- 44:05risk, enhance income and cap your risk while giving you
- 44:09changing your return profile. The goal is that you can
- 44:12actually increase your risk adjusted returns without
- 44:16increasing your risk. So give an example of that is,
- 44:20you know, one of the things that's been talked about in the
- 44:22news is 0 days to expiry options that have really taken off in
- 44:27the last few years and retail investors have used heavily.
- 44:31The level of sophistication of those retail investors has come
- 44:34along. And what we found is that 90% of
- 44:38those trades have capped risk either through simply capped at
- 44:43the cost of the premium or they're complex trades that are
- 44:47multi legged. So they've capped their offset.
- 44:50So we think that's a really healthy indication of the
- 44:54ecosystem that if derivatives used correctly, they reduce
- 44:57risk. And then for those, you know,
- 45:00very rare situations where people are misusing, we have all
- 45:04sorts of controls in place, risk controls in place to, to cap
- 45:09them or to, to reject their orders, as do the brokerages
- 45:14themselves and the trading systems that they offer their
- 45:17customers. You use the phrase used
- 45:20properly, and I think we all know examples of retail
- 45:26investors who were told by their broker, you know, by these
- 45:31options and they didn't, the, the investor relied on the
- 45:35broker didn't have an understanding of these complex
- 45:39trades and therefore lost very significant amounts of money.
- 45:45To to what extent is, or what role does SIBO play in helping
- 45:51ensure that that kind of thing doesn't happen?
- 45:54That's where the Options Institute comes in.
- 45:56You know, our customers are the broker dealers or the retail
- 46:00brokerage platforms broker dealers around the world that
- 46:04connect directly to our exchanges and they themselves
- 46:07have pretty substantial education programs that then we
- 46:11seek to help augment with the Options Institute and investor
- 46:15education. And education is never done and
- 46:19it's it's never uniform across every single last investor.
- 46:23And we'll say there's, you know, there's good regulation and
- 46:26controls in place too around know your customer and the level
- 46:30of education or sophistication you must have before you can get
- 46:33an options account. For instance, when you sign up
- 46:36for a brokerage account, usually what happens is you, you can
- 46:39only trade equities or stocks before you would get anything on
- 46:43margin. Then you'd before you would be
- 46:46able to trade options, before you'd be able to trade futures.
- 46:49And you have to progress in your maturity and sophistication.
- 46:52I think that's that's good, good practice.
- 46:55And so again, education, sophistication, it's not
- 46:59uniform. But there are a lot of controls
- 47:01in place. And this is again from Andy, who
- 47:04says she's she or he is a retail trader and Sibo's SPX options.
- 47:13What are your views on the growth of retail trading in
- 47:17general, Anything SIBO is doing to expand market access and
- 47:23products? And I'll just ask more broadly
- 47:28of how do you balance the needs of institutional versus retail
- 47:33investors, including maintaining the fairness that you've spoken
- 47:36about? It's actually leans directly
- 47:39into some multi decade trends, secular trends we've seen.
- 47:43So the growth of the retail investor is one of those those
- 47:46major trends. The retail investor at least in
- 47:49the US has been growing in importance in number since the
- 47:52late 90s, at least with the electronification of markets and
- 47:57the enablement of technology. So growth of retail investors is
- 48:001 something that's very connected to that.
- 48:03Interconnected with that is the growth of options.
- 48:06And then finally the, the, the desire to have access to the US
- 48:11markets, which are still the leading, you know, financial
- 48:14markets in the world as far as size and access to liquidity.
- 48:17So those 3 all, all speak to the retail investor and that we view
- 48:22that as a very positive development in that.
- 48:25Look back 20 or 30 years ago, a lot of the products, services,
- 48:29systems that were available to institutional investors,
- 48:33sophisticated tooling, sophisticated risk controls,
- 48:36they, they were only available to institutions.
- 48:38Now they're really at the fingertips of the retail
- 48:40investor. As I mentioned previously, that
- 48:42retail investor's much more sophisticated because of those
- 48:45tools, because of that education.
- 48:47So we're very excited about that and we're here to serve the
- 48:50needs of all types of investors. They have different needs, they
- 48:55have different profiles and we want to offer them products and
- 48:58markets that that can satisfy them all.
- 49:00And we have a question from Chris Peterson.
- 49:05SIBO runs many markets. Are there any moves towards
- 49:10mixing asset classes, for example, Chris, crypto plus
- 49:13legacy within markets or markets merging slash breaking national
- 49:19or regional boundaries and more or fewer markets over time and
- 49:27obviously the your view towards the future of where this is all
- 49:31headed? There are examples where we have
- 49:33cross asset order types, for instance, where you have an
- 49:37options trade with a futures leg or an options trade with an
- 49:41equity leg and a cash equity leg.
- 49:44Today certain order types. I think I will see more of that
- 49:48within each country or region over time to the extent it
- 49:51doesn't already exist connecting markets globally.
- 49:56Cross jurisdiction I think is more difficult potentially
- 50:01outside of digital assets that's more difficult because of the
- 50:05regulatory structures and jurisdictions that are in place.
- 50:09So more cross asset may be more cross geography, but that will
- 50:13take coordination amongst, you know, government authorities or
- 50:16regulators within those countries.
- 50:19Any thoughts on where digital assets cryptocurrencies are
- 50:23going? They become more mainstream as
- 50:26you've seen in the last year or two.
- 50:30Assets under management will continue to grow.
- 50:33I would mention a couple things. The introduction of crypto ETFs,
- 50:38of which SIBO listed six of the 1st 11 in January of 2024, I
- 50:43think was a milestone moment in digital assets where people that
- 50:48normally just invest in equities then would have access to
- 50:51digital assets through the ETF wrapper.
- 50:53I think that's open up a whole new level of users.
- 50:56We have indices on digital assets.
- 50:58I think there'll be more and more indices, more and more
- 51:00access to digital assets, at least for the top, the top few
- 51:05names or digital assets out there.
- 51:07Any final thoughts on what we, investors and technologists and
- 51:14people listening really need to know about exchanges like SIBO
- 51:20that we probably don't know because it's hidden behind the
- 51:23scenes? Building trusted markets is a
- 51:25passion for us and as an investor, retail investors, I
- 51:31would mention that because it's, it's a passion for us, which I
- 51:34think ends in a good result for investors.
- 51:38Institutional retail. Like if I look back to when I
- 51:42started in this industry in the early 2000s and the access that
- 51:48investors had to different tradable products and how long
- 51:52it took for them to trade, that was that took quite a while and
- 51:56it would be measured in seconds, sometimes minutes.
- 51:58And the commissions were very, very high.
- 52:01If you look at how things have changed over time, you have near
- 52:04immediate access to almost any asset you want to trade or
- 52:09invest in at an incredibly low cost with very low friction,
- 52:14which I think is is incredible in in this industry that that
- 52:18retail investors have the tools and sophistication at their
- 52:22fingertips like I can institutional investors do from
- 52:2620 to 25 years ago. On that topic, Arsalan Khan has
- 52:30jumped in with a a last question.
- 52:33That's a really interesting one, he says.
- 52:37Do we need humans when AI can do options?
- 52:41But let me turn that question around and say, should we people
- 52:48be relying on our judgement when we can use machines, data and AI
- 52:55to make trading decisions that can analyze more data faster
- 53:00than we ever possibly could? Humans will always be needed and
- 53:04humans will need to be in the loop at least during different
- 53:07time frames, at least in the developing of those strategies
- 53:10over time. Of course, markets will continue
- 53:13to evolve and strategies will involve and the level of human
- 53:16involvement will vary based on the strategy, but.
- 53:19I. Think humans will always be
- 53:20needed, but humans will need to embrace AI in order to harness
- 53:24it and use it for our benefit. Fair enough.
- 53:27And with that, we're out of time.
- 53:30A huge thank you to Chris Isaakson, Chief Operating
- 53:33Officer and Executive Vice President of SIBO Global
- 53:36Markets. Chris, thank you so much for
- 53:39being here with us. I'm very grateful to you.
- 53:41Well, thank you, Michael, and thank you all of your followers
- 53:44for for all the great questions. It's been my pleasure.
- 53:47Folks, before you go, subscribe to the CXO Talk newsletter.
- 53:50Go to cxotalk.com. You're part of our community and
- 53:54we want you back. Thank you guys are you guys are
- 53:58awesome. Such great questions.
- 54:01There's no show next week, but the following week we're back
- 54:05into it. We have amazing shows coming up.
- 54:07So check it out and we'll see you again next time.
- 54:10Take care, everybody.