Latest / Newcomer Pod / Keeping Tabs on the Oligarchs (w/Teddy Schleifer)
Transcript
- 0:06Welcome salad. Hey, it's Eric newcomer here
- 0:15with dead cat. We've got Tom and Katie, and our
- 0:18friend, Teddy schleifer, who we got to know back when he was at
- 0:24recode. And now he's at puc, the
- 0:27dominant player on the bill. Millionaire beat beat of his own
- 0:32invention. And so he's also a regular
- 0:38listener of this podcast. I believe that he actually won a
- 0:42contest that we run weekly for our listeners.
- 0:44If you bother us enough times, we'll let you be on the show.
- 0:47Look, people people like, Eric people like Karen Griffith.
- 0:50We're getting on the show. Wow, maybe five something big
- 1:00Weakness here. He wanted to be on the show so I
- 1:03feel like we wanted you to test. This is not really how we treat
- 1:07people guys, that's not really it.
- 1:11Folk night coming in like Mom here.
- 1:16No, we love teddy. He's he's been very aggressively
- 1:19pursuing in the way that he pursued us for not giving him
- 1:22the credit that he deserves. He's also pursued billionaires
- 1:26and their they're growing power. And I feel like one of the Great
- 1:30Moments we've had on this show was when we had been Smith on a
- 1:33couple months back and he basically described this
- 1:37generation of people, I guess Austin and the older ones as
- 1:41people who are like constantly fighting for attention in the
- 1:43court of billionaires and I think it's one of the truest
- 1:46things I've heard about the kind of the state of this country and
- 1:51media and power these days and so who better to explain the
- 1:55court of billionaires, and the person who spends all his days,
- 1:58pestering them and chronic In their their foibles, you know,
- 2:02understanding the way deep, the cooties corpse work is you know
- 2:06not to get onto high horse here but like is a public service for
- 2:09sure but it's also just issue and fun and like that's a that's
- 2:12okay too. So one of the things that you're
- 2:14beat has sort of touched on in current events is the idea of
- 2:18oligarchs, which is so fascinating to me.
- 2:20I think there was a moment a few years ago when thanks to was at
- 2:24the paradise papers. It was finally confirmed that
- 2:28Yuri Milner whose fields. So, much of Silicon Valley did
- 2:31have Kremlin ties via sort of his largest financial backer,
- 2:35and work that he'd done. And at the time, that that story
- 2:38came out, it was it kind of like made a small flare in the sky
- 2:43and then just fizzled out, pretty quickly.
- 2:46How do people in Silicon Valley thinking about folks, like Yuri
- 2:49today and whether or not, it's even possible to impose any kind
- 2:54of like economic sanctions on people, but those sorts of ties
- 2:57to Putin who have embedded themselves.
- 3:00Only in Silicon Valley, but kind of threw out wherever you find
- 3:03wealth in the United States. I have.
- 3:05Do you think, do you think that was that small storage time?
- 3:09I got really that broke through. I think it's difficult when it
- 3:12broke through but it what it didn't do is change.
- 3:15I think the way people regarded kleptocrats and their money in
- 3:19the valley it's like well people only talk about this issue when
- 3:22there's an issue in the new try like everyone's like you know
- 3:25when the the paradise papers came out or we can show you is
- 3:28killed people. Oh, suddenly care about it.
- 3:31Then, like when's the last conversation that any of us have
- 3:34had about like foreign money in like 2019 or 2020?
- 3:38Or the first up in 2021. I guess I do not believe the
- 3:41bullshit that this is an issue that actually will change
- 3:45anything about society. And that's not just me being a
- 3:47cynic. Like look I mean if if the
- 3:50reaction was so intense around khashoggi, there would have
- 3:54been, you know, a major Reckoning about Saudi money in
- 3:57the valley which I don't think really happened.
- 4:00In step. Like, what what's the think that
- 4:02any other Foreigner crisis will fare any differently?
- 4:05I guess the word, the word Reckoning is kind of broad,
- 4:08right? I mean, just thinking back to
- 4:09khashoggi there, definitely was for a period as I remember.
- 4:12I didn't cover, you know, Finance the way that you and
- 4:14Eric and maybe katydid as closely.
- 4:16But I know like, for example, Endeavor, which is this giant
- 4:19talent agency media company in Hollywood, they were in the
- 4:23process of raising a huge amount of money that was going to be
- 4:26coming from, you know, the Saudi royal family that they pulled
- 4:29out of Of now, it's complicated. So, what actually happened
- 4:32there, but their explanation at least was that, you know, it was
- 4:35beyond the pale. What their involvement was with
- 4:37khashoggi. He's killing.
- 4:38And they actually did pull out. So, at least for a period of
- 4:40time, it seemed like people were trying to distance themselves
- 4:43from, you know, the worst of their financial backers.
- 4:46I guess I'm thinking more long-term.
- 4:48Like I mean, like I mean like what think about the Saudi
- 4:50conference that they host? Like, you know what everyone
- 4:53canceled that year, that year because of conflicts of
- 4:59scheduling For any other meat, a very it's a boxer in response to
- 5:04the invasion of Ukraine was a lot of scrutiny on your team
- 5:07owner and his firm DST. And DST is said that if you look
- 5:11at the total amount of money raised by DST over the last
- 5:15whatever 15 years or. So only 3% of the money comes
- 5:19from Russia and you could argue could see you could see that at
- 5:23third offense, basically saying we're not a you know, Kremlin
- 5:26run firm so it's big but you can also look at that data and that
- 5:29same Fact. And say like it only 3% of the
- 5:32money goes to Russia, doesn't to make it sort of easy to sneak
- 5:34out, right? Like, if it's resume Lee, he's
- 5:37got to be more entrenched in the Russian system than that though.
- 5:40Just because I mean, I mean his, yeah, his life is intertwine.
- 5:45I would I would assume you look. So so it's the other part of
- 5:50this and then I'm Karen. Just what you guys think.
- 5:53So in response to the time story 2017, that Katie was mentioning
- 5:57like urea was sort of alleging Not like racism but I got
- 6:01xenophobia or you know, the idea that like hey why can't I just
- 6:05be a got, you know, a VC with foreign LPS before I trust sort
- 6:10of ridiculous. Why not proactively disclose, if
- 6:14it's not some big Scandal, he could have been much.
- 6:17I think we all agree that lb transparency would be great.
- 6:20Like I do think the lack of disclosure creates some of the
- 6:24problems here because it signals that you have something to hide
- 6:27on sure. But I've got so the time story
- 6:29that came I'm out in 2017 was all about.
- 6:32He had to give his disclosing. This like I said of speak
- 6:34because he was under an Eco under attack, right?
- 6:38I mean his point is he was just closing.
- 6:57There should be much more pressure on them.
- 6:59Do you guys? The idea that like just because
- 7:02someone is from Rush is like a Russian Elite businessman that
- 7:07they can be independent of the Kremlin like can usually.
- 7:10Oh, I'm just a Russian like there's a difference between
- 7:12being an investor who is Russian and being like a Russian
- 7:15government, all active investor. Yeah, I don't know, I mean, I'm
- 7:18not an expert on the oligarchy, but he came in Israeli citizen
- 7:21right. Interesting because the entire,
- 7:23but the entire rationale for the Crackdown on oligarchs is if you
- 7:28if you impose enough Financial pain on the people who have a
- 7:32symbiotic relationship with Putin in Moscow that they are
- 7:36better, positioned to convince Putin to change course then.
- 7:41Literally anyone else that is that is the rationale for doing
- 7:44this. And so, yes, that.
- 7:48So what we're saying is that, that rationale doesn't really
- 7:50work if people like Yuri Milner are unwilling to speak to his
- 7:56backers and the other wealthy oligarchs with whom he does
- 7:59business. In order to apply pressure on
- 8:01Putin sound, right. Right.
- 8:04I mean, I guess that's different than I guess Katie like a core
- 8:07kind of assumption of that, is that Russian economic pressure
- 8:12and political Pressure Works differently than a wouldn't say
- 8:14like, Germany, right? We're like Angela, Merkel might
- 8:17set her now, or any foreign leader might say, like, I'm not
- 8:22like, my constituency is not the other Business Leaders.
- 8:24Like in Russia, your efficiency is literally the business
- 8:28people. That's it.
- 8:28That's it. Yeah.
- 8:29There is almost, is almost like a voter in this election.
- 8:33Yeah. They're only like eight voters.
- 8:35They're very wealthy and they're the people who have had this
- 8:38sort of symbiotic mutually reinforcing relationship with
- 8:43with the Kremlin, right where they were given control over
- 8:47Banks over, large oil companies, in order to mass extreme
- 8:51fortunes. But they were also given an
- 8:52ability to work with and live in the west and enjoy parts of the
- 8:57West that nobody else in Russia could write.
- 8:59I mean Seems like anytime the realities of these regimes you
- 9:02know are exposed and westerners or Americans really have to
- 9:06confront the source of the wealth that they have been also
- 9:10enjoying it ends up, requiring some sort of a reckoning on the
- 9:13part of these large businesses. I mean that was certainly the
- 9:16case with the Saudis right. You can you know be hosted and
- 9:19feted by MBS and the entire Saudi royal family and then you
- 9:23start to recognize I mean you can talk about khashoggi.
- 9:26But also you know what they've been doing in Yemen, over the
- 9:29last couple of Of years, which doesn't get new no discussed
- 9:31that much. But is horrifying in as much as
- 9:35everything that's going on in Ukraine is you know you have
- 9:37these points where you can have a reckoning and it happens at
- 9:41the margins but there's never like a full accounting for it.
- 9:44I mean look we've all kind of become Russian experts over the
- 9:46last couple of weeks here so I don't want to speak like too
- 9:49much out of my depth of knowledge but my sense of like
- 9:52the Russian oligarchs over the last decades, a few decades is
- 9:56that we've always kind of been amused by them.
- 9:58You know, they own Ball clubs in the UK, you know, they have
- 10:02these super Yachts, they are huge buyers of high-end fashion
- 10:07and that's kind of as far as the think the general populace likes
- 10:10to think about it. You know, you don't really think
- 10:11about like the source of that wealth, the source of that power
- 10:14and you know we've come to a point now where maybe there is
- 10:17some analysis on someone like a URI where his wealth comes from
- 10:22the fact that that some of that wealth has helped fuel a huge
- 10:25amount of the success in Silicon Valley.
- 10:28But how long is it going to go? On for like, how long are we
- 10:31going to actually feel the need to hold him to account and have
- 10:34him forced to, you know, to pressure Putin.
- 10:37I have no clue. Yeah, I guess this would be
- 10:39easier call if like, okay, so the Uris kind of original
- 10:43business partners guy, Allah, surely movement of who were now
- 10:46all experts on because his, he's the guy with the Yahoo received
- 10:50yesterday. So I like, I like to say.
- 10:53Yeah, super yacht. That's too big.
- 10:56But you actually clear, like, Yuri Milner is not an oligarch
- 10:58like his, I don't think. We like he is an oligarch, he is
- 11:02a, an oligarch Ally at our something like that or you know
- 11:07what one step removed your. So like I feel like work,
- 11:10there's like he's backed by the powers that be in Russia but
- 11:14only key necessarily really is a power.
- 11:16That b is a power of. It should be easier call for
- 11:20Silicon Valley, it was like alisher usmanov is a, you know,
- 11:23DC is investor in, you know, stripe.
- 11:27And then they'll be like an easier called Here there's a I
- 11:31think the reason It's Tricky, there's a little bit of distance
- 11:33between URI and the Kremlin and like, you know, obviously people
- 11:37can in good faith disagree about whether or not at that distance
- 11:40is still, whether or not. He was, like, being used as a
- 11:43front or whether he was just somebody who likes his friend
- 11:46and wanted to take his money and invite reckon.
- 11:48Because this point is like, you know, this sort of guilt by
- 11:51association like just because I'm a rich guy from Russia
- 11:53doesn't mean that I am like you know Putin's buddy here that's
- 11:57for sure. That's precisely what makes this
- 11:59tough I think more broadly also speaks to this idea that
- 12:02billionaires and Teddy, if this is wrong, tell me I'm totally
- 12:04wrong. But that billionaires are kind
- 12:06of not a part of whatever country it is, that they are
- 12:10floating above taking Russia out, obviously, because of their
- 12:12unique relationship with the government that allows them to
- 12:15get that wealthy. But when you're looking at ultra
- 12:18wealthy people, whether in the United States or whether and
- 12:20Europe in South America, it's kind of like they are their own
- 12:25club. And even as geopolitical events
- 12:28rage around And that they would have be able to bring influence
- 12:33to bear on basically because of their money and because of their
- 12:35status that they declined to do. So, I mean, like, pardon that
- 12:40is, it's obviously a stronger argument for the Russians.
- 12:43Like, I've talked with some people over the last couple of
- 12:46days, you know, on the left who have been like, well, it's like
- 12:50Russia really that different in the United States like isn't as
- 12:52in America really an oligarchy where, you know, Elon Musk is,
- 12:56is no different than Allah sure she can be catered to your to
- 12:59your question. Yeah, look, I mean there there
- 13:01is an element of, you know, Elon musk's life or Jeff Bezos his
- 13:06life at where your ignorance life that is more in common
- 13:10with, you know, alisher huisman. I was life and it is with our
- 13:13lives, even though, we're all Americans, right?
- 13:14I mean these are forests. Well, whether whether it's, you
- 13:18know, the they are what we would call this look, I mean, there's
- 13:26obviously doesn't take Bernie Sanders.
- 13:29To say there's two sets of different rule, two sets of
- 13:31rules for people, depending on your amount of wealth.
- 13:35And some people can have access to heads of state and way that
- 13:38we cannot. And let the there's, there's a
- 13:41reason that I named what would, what I'm doing a puck.
- 13:45The stratosphere it's because like, there is destroy a
- 13:48rarefied air that wealthy people travel in that is inaccessible
- 13:53to the rest of us. I just want to outline a point
- 13:57like go for you. Take this outing.
- 13:59Issue. Right?
- 14:00So the Saudis poor bunch of money into Uber, and we work by
- 14:06via SoftBank and their own direct Investments, right?
- 14:10Like, on the one hand people we used to love to joke.
- 14:13They like Saudis were burning a bunch of money.
- 14:16So Americans could take cheap car rides and drivers would get
- 14:20a bunch of money. And, you know, people could
- 14:23stay. And we were like those things
- 14:25were all subsidized by Americans subsidized for Americans by the
- 14:29Saudis. He's so when it was the poor
- 14:31investment, it's sort of like, okay, great, they're like
- 14:34throwing their money away, the wrong way.
- 14:36Obviously, some of these funds are great.
- 14:38And on the flip side, then American funds are giving them a
- 14:41big return and then they make a bunch of money.
- 14:45I guess. I'm saying that to some degree.
- 14:47I mean, it's the global interconnectedness of the market
- 14:51and they, if they're giving the money to American investors to
- 14:54deploy often in ways that it is good for American consumers.
- 14:58There's a fair Sort of conflict on whether it's better to take
- 15:02their money and use it for what we want.
- 15:05And to not not have the money at all given, how much money there
- 15:09is sort of in the world right now that wants to go into
- 15:11Silicon Valley. Do you think that if the, you
- 15:14know, to the small percentage of money that makes up, you know,
- 15:18these see the VC World in total. If the Russian money were taken
- 15:22out, what it crushed nature for a job where they not only, are
- 15:24they not operate, would they not be able to fight other LP's to
- 15:27fill the Gap? I'm just not really sure why.
- 15:29Why pre Global crisis status quo?
- 15:32Like it makes more sense. You know, why Saudi money
- 15:36Russian money? There is sort of a he can't sort
- 15:39of criticize Russia, you know. But he's taking the money but
- 15:43he's investing things we like and there are these sort of like
- 15:46okay something's he's not going to comment on certainly, I
- 15:49agree. Now that Russia has done
- 15:51something terrible Beyond The Pale where we're actively trying
- 15:54to get Putin to change would be the time for him to like totally
- 15:59Zone rush. I mean, this is what I mean
- 16:01Teddy and your column you basically.
- 16:03Or I don't know if you call them columns, whatever you're calling
- 16:06them newsletters. The I mean you said he's
- 16:08basically probably going to have to say something.
- 16:10I mean that depends how much heat there is.
- 16:13I certainly do believe. Yeah, I mean, now is the time to
- 16:17be principled and to defect and you can't sort of straddle this
- 16:20sort of global position anymore. So, I don't mean to say now that
- 16:26we're at this sort of war that he's like, fine.
- 16:29I'm just sort of saying from the pre-war period.
- 16:32You can see why it's sort of, he has to keep his Russian
- 16:36affiliation while navigating the global system.
- 16:39It is a complicated situation, pre a red line are cute.
- 16:44You agree that you didn't have to say something.
- 16:46Or do you think that there's a chance?
- 16:47He can weasel out of it. I think you can see he's gonna
- 16:49Escape. I just feel like, he's just
- 16:52like, not high enough on the list.
- 16:54I mean, I think. Yeah.
- 16:55I mean, as reporters, we should try to keep the pressure on it
- 16:59and You're doing better than any of us on it.
- 17:02Part. Part of this is just like the
- 17:03like the Western Union Amity from different business on this
- 17:07issue. Like I mean it's pretty rare.
- 17:09I mean by the time that you mean comes out.
- 17:11I'm sure it'll be some new some new twists, like every company,
- 17:14you know, is under pressure to distance themselves from Russia
- 17:18or like you've seen, you know, major well it's a combination of
- 17:21under pressure and it being I mean, sorry, but somewhat
- 17:24cynically and opportunity to Market yourself, for sure, for
- 17:27sharply, okay. During this period of complete.
- 17:29Agreement on an issue to say, hey, look at us.
- 17:32We're you know, whatever donate to the ukrainians through your
- 17:36Uber app. Well, think about, I mean, think
- 17:38about the China situation, where everybody in Tech was terrified,
- 17:42the Jack ma had basically been disappeared.
- 17:45And that like, obviously anyone Intex, true opinion, was that
- 17:50like the Chinese government cracking down, on powerful Tech
- 17:54Elites in their own country was bad for business terrifying.
- 17:59Not They thought China would do like that's obviously their
- 18:02position but if you're ggv or Sequoia China articulating it
- 18:07publicly like as a reporter, I desperately wanted them to do it
- 18:11but I can see why it's like okay.
- 18:14That would basically mean like shutting down your Chinese
- 18:17operation. So there is sort of an ebb and
- 18:20flow where obviously you know I think in the interest of global
- 18:24understanding reporters are going to push them on it and try
- 18:28to sort of surface. Us that contradiction but I can
- 18:31understand why if you're the firm on the ground it's sort of
- 18:34hard to say. Like you can't you know call it
- 18:36the Chinese Communist Regime and expect to operate very
- 18:40successfully there for long. Here's the thing though where I
- 18:43guess run sympathetic to these firms it's like there's so much
- 18:46fucking money right now out there and I understand if you're
- 18:48a late-stage firm like you know there's only some sovereigns and
- 18:52every every dollar is conflicted in some way or another what need
- 18:54to raise as much as you do but like for like an earlier, look
- 18:58kind of mid-stage firm. Do you really need to raise you
- 19:02know, LP cash from any that? Anybody from anybody, that's a
- 19:06tall conflicted. Like this is like much.
- 19:08This is the, like I honestly feel like even.
- 19:10Even since khashoggi in 18 like amount of money that's flowing
- 19:14into the lp base and look like it's competitive, everyone wants
- 19:18to raise the biggest phones and have the best LPS yada yada yada
- 19:21but I would be interested in like a candid conversation.
- 19:25Well that's why I think someone who I mean is closures always
- 19:27such a lame thing. Disclosure is always a lame
- 19:30reporter thing to call for but it is if Sequoia could say,
- 19:34okay, we've got the Ford Foundation XYZ versus soft pink
- 19:39with the Saudis. I mean they basically made that
- 19:41argument but given that they don't fully disclose their LPS
- 19:46it's less you know it's not front and center.
- 19:49Whereas if they were just wearing sort of the benevolence
- 19:52or terribleness of their LPS on their sleeves then yeah we could
- 19:57the Brand's would be much more associated with that.
- 19:59But I think the LPS are scared to do it and the VC, you know,
- 20:05that's just hasn't been how it's been done, but it would be great
- 20:08to see a firm. It's much more leading publicly
- 20:11with here are the LPS. We represent, I mean, I wrote
- 20:13about a firm Base Tens growth fund, which you know, is
- 20:18basically getting in deals in part because, you know, some of
- 20:21the money they're investing is a historically black colleges and
- 20:25universities and they're giving them more favorable economics.
- 20:28Like that's I feel like that's real change.
- 20:33That's like change. That's at the core of how the
- 20:36Venture system works. Yeah.
- 20:38So I'd love to see more of that. So I don't like speaking him
- 20:41like disclosure in Albie's. I always loved the bullshit that
- 20:43like lots of firms say about, you know go to Susie's like
- 20:46euphemisms described it all peas as foundations or family offices
- 20:51or hospitals or Pension funds. Like and you know the they make
- 20:57it sort of argument that like Alder LPS Like you know working
- 21:00in pursuit of the public good by, you know, we're saying like
- 21:04oh family offices like we're talking about billionaires here
- 21:09like we're like it's like we're like foundations that like you
- 21:12know and Rich the Flint philanthropic institutions of
- 21:14like extraordinarily wealthy people.
- 21:16And yes like I understand that like you know the Canadian
- 21:20Teachers Fund or you know a public Hospital chain like does
- 21:23have some public Mission but like ultimately this is like
- 21:27financier, right? This is theirs.
- 21:29Some people use the, they all lied, or these groupings.
- 21:33I would say to, like describe their all peas in a way that
- 21:36like are the most generous possible big difference between
- 21:40like the Oregon teachers, pension fund or whatever and
- 21:43like, L'Oreal Carver office. Yeah.
- 21:45Well that yeah. Carver or her.
- 21:47Yeah, right. So interesting Teddy because I
- 21:50mean, the sort of masking of where the money comes from.
- 21:53It's from the top down, you know, it's like the madrone, you
- 21:57know, madrone Investments people here.
- 21:59They're like oh I don't know exactly what that is sounds kind
- 22:02of futuristic it's like no that's the Walton family they
- 22:04could just call it the Walton Family Foundation or the Walton
- 22:07family fun, but they want to Brand it in a way that doesn't
- 22:09make it sound like it's coming from you know the richest
- 22:11retailer family in the country. And so I mean I'd be interested
- 22:16to know post this, you know what your thoughts are?
- 22:19If we are going to start seeing more pressure for their there to
- 22:23be LP or investor transparency and a lot of these big things
- 22:26because one of the big turns that maybe is going to Come
- 22:29from. This Ukrainian invasion is a
- 22:33recognition that there is a number of pressure points that
- 22:38can be placed on a government. We obviously can see what the US
- 22:41government can do when like, they're sanctioning.
- 22:43But also we've seen pressure from large corporations, not
- 22:46doing business in Russia anymore.
- 22:48And then now what we've been talking about with billionaires
- 22:50and their connections to the Kremlin and they're putting
- 22:52pressure on Putin to do something about it.
- 22:54If we're going to start seeing all of these individual Parts as
- 22:57actors in a political conflict, Shouldn't we impose some sort of
- 23:01public pressure on them to be almost like quasi, government
- 23:05requirements, that would have transparency.
- 23:07You know, in the same way that we know who donated to a
- 23:09political campaign, shouldn't we know who is funding, you know, a
- 23:13large Venture firm because that in turn, we don't really know
- 23:16who donates to a lot of political campaigns anymore.
- 23:18I mean, disclosure rules or hair the better?
- 23:21It's sure. I mean, there's there's dark
- 23:23money and there's, you know, it's not entirely clear, but
- 23:26it's at least closer to some level of transparency.
- 23:29And see that we have with anything else.
- 23:31Certainly with any sort of vent, you know, a private Equity or
- 23:34Venture funds who is we hear like, I mean, I feel like that's
- 23:38one of the things. Obviously, your pods about like
- 23:40Tech and meteorite, like G, like, I've wondered and, you
- 23:44know, is it, is it like should like journalists and the media
- 23:48be like, you know, vocally and explicitly like anti-russia
- 23:53right now. Like I feel like that's sort of,
- 23:54like, an assumption baked into nice.
- 23:57A pop, when you, when you, when you say like public, Sure.
- 23:59Like me is the mere Act of like asking the area.
- 24:03Like, in some way a like pro-america anti-russia
- 24:07pro-ukraine kind of construct, I just wonder like, who is the we
- 24:11in, what should we do about this?
- 24:13Well sort of part of what's happening?
- 24:15I think they're two different conversations Tom's and then
- 24:18Teddy's Tom. I mean I think part of what
- 24:20you're reflecting is just the shift to the private markets,
- 24:24right? Like the SEC has a whole
- 24:25disclosure regime. It's super controlled.
- 24:28Everyone runs away. To the private markets.
- 24:31And so there's way less disclosure and but the private
- 24:34markets have become a huge part of the American economy.
- 24:37All sorts of investors are allowed in investors that get in
- 24:40the public markets are operating in the private markets.
- 24:43There's sort of a laughable. It's laughable the idea that the
- 24:46private markets are important to the American sort of business
- 24:50world and sort of the health of the economy.
- 24:53So if that's the goal of the SEC, shouldn't the SEC have much
- 24:56more power to force disclosure. I agree.
- 25:00I think there should be much more transparency in the private
- 25:03markets. Obviously, I've a bad business
- 25:06interest in that. I mean Teddy, I mean you're sort
- 25:10of interested in who we should be rooting for or is for the
- 25:14media ethics of it. Or what was yours is the mere
- 25:17construct of this conversation based on an assumption that you
- 25:22know, American Media, or American Tech media, should be,
- 25:26you know, pro-ukraine and and look I mean there's always
- 25:29Nicely in war subscribers. Always questions about, you
- 25:33know, whether the media is on either party side.
- 25:35But like, look, I think the mere fact of of reporters publicly
- 25:40keeping the key on Russian investors or an American
- 25:43companies business interest in Russia.
- 25:45Like I feel like that reflects an assumption that American
- 25:51Media should be at least quote, unquote, scrutinizing, Russian
- 25:56interests. I don't know.
- 25:57I mean, I don't I think that that Area that has accepted as
- 26:01an article of faith that the unprovoked war was wrong.
- 26:06That's true. Yeah.
- 26:07And I don't know that that's wrong.
- 26:10I don't know that that I just I don't know that that's wrong.
- 26:14And I think that the reason why we were talking about people who
- 26:17have great wealth is because the way that the West has chosen to
- 26:20respond to the act of war, is to apply pressure to the people who
- 26:25have the most influence over Putin core, very wealthy people.
- 26:27If the people had most of the most influential However, Putin
- 26:30were not a group of very wealthy people than we probably wouldn't
- 26:36be having this conversation. So I don't think that the
- 26:38conversation is driven by whether or not people are pro or
- 26:41anti Russia and its Act of War. I think the conversation is
- 26:47driven by the fact that the West has decided.
- 26:50The people most able to have influence over Putin happened to
- 26:55be this group of individuals, but I think it's, I mean, I
- 26:59think it's Good. The media is basically except as
- 27:02a premise that the invasion was bad and in some ways.
- 27:06What? Right?
- 27:07Katie. I mean, yeah, I mean, yeah,
- 27:09right. I'm just not, I'm not sure like
- 27:11what the argument is. I would be interested to hear
- 27:14the argument that what Putin did was right?
- 27:16I would be in here. Oh, let me introduce me to
- 27:20people. I know.
- 27:20It is Remy to worry about all of this.
- 27:23She tell you, I think like your question is, like, whether the
- 27:27media should be like in lockstep with You know, this belief that
- 27:31or, you know, the sentiment that, you know, Ukraine is the
- 27:35victim here, which I understand is.
- 27:36It's just a matter of fact, but I also think that the media is
- 27:39also in many ways, a reflection of what the public wants to hear
- 27:43about. And at this moment, there is
- 27:45almost unanimous agreement on the part of the public that, you
- 27:48know, what Russia did is wrong here.
- 27:49And there's a huge amount of pressure as part of that saying.
- 27:51Alright, if Russia is the bad actor here we want to understand
- 27:54what are the pressure points that can be brought to bear to
- 27:56do something about this. And so the media is like, well,
- 27:59Let's answer that question for you here.
- 28:01If one of the pressure points here are the Oleg arcs and the
- 28:03money that is Flowing out of Russia into US companies, it is
- 28:07the duty of the media to inform the public.
- 28:09Well, here's if you want to know more about this, here's the road
- 28:11we can tell you exactly one. Here's what we can tell you.
- 28:14Yeah, percent. It's as it's answering a
- 28:17question. Well what what is, what is the
- 28:20West doing to apply pressure to bear?
- 28:22This is what they're doing. And I think if they chosen
- 28:24something else, if they hadn't chosen, The wealth of a few
- 28:28people then we would not be talking about oligarchs.
- 28:31That's just it is what it is, right?
- 28:33And if we thought that the huge amount, you know, the biggest
- 28:35pressure that could be brought to bear was us companies that
- 28:38are doing business in Russia. Like let's pretend that Netflix
- 28:41is, you know, largest countries. Outside the US was in Russia,
- 28:44you would probably asking people which they do have a presence in
- 28:47Russia but I can't imagine it's very big because I love piracy
- 28:50over there is like all right well what is Netflix doing it?
- 28:54So anyway I think the biggest pressure to bear was Military.
- 28:57We just be talking about military campaigns, right?
- 28:59If we thought that the United, the table because of nuclear
- 29:02war, but if we thought that the biggest pressure points that
- 29:05could be brought to bear on Putin were the US Army going
- 29:09into Ukraine, we would not be talking about oligarchs at all,
- 29:13right? That's it.
- 29:14We're just talking about the practicalities of what can be
- 29:16done to apply pressure to Putin. Yeah.
- 29:19Can I see Teddy like from your conversations with the ultra
- 29:22wealthy or the people in their orbit over the last couple of
- 29:25weeks? I mean, how much Reflection, are
- 29:27they doing on? You know, they're intertwined
- 29:29meant entwine met with with Russian money.
- 29:32I mean, do you see any more recognition on their part that
- 29:35like, they feel closer to it than they initially had thought
- 29:38or hoped? I mean, the reality is, this is
- 29:40sort of an aberration. No.
- 29:41I mean, I do not think that there's, that many people write
- 29:45like, the Curie is, sort of in the exception that I don't think
- 29:48that there is, you know, massive Russian Albert.
- 29:50He's in like, Andreessen Horowitz.
- 29:53I remember better idea than I do, but like, in to some extent,
- 29:56makes it Than Saudi cash or other ethically compromise.
- 29:59Cash in the Middle East where it's more pervasive like like
- 30:04can you guys think of a single other like major russian-backed
- 30:08investor, a proper breads. So I don't know if this is
- 30:11really like I ate a billionaire question or even a b c question,
- 30:14especially like the area question, unlike I would say
- 30:17with sound with the Saudis, we're like their money is and
- 30:20lots of firms right on. This is sort of a one-off know,
- 30:24right? And with assess my sense.
- 30:26I mean we I was it was like a one year or not even, you know,
- 30:29a several month period of reflection on the part of the
- 30:33valley. And then it's amazing how
- 30:34quickly they got over it and they all showed up at, you know,
- 30:38the Riyadh conference or whatever it was that MBS had
- 30:41been hosting. So yes, I think the fact that it
- 30:44probably is easier for the valley to extricate itself from
- 30:47Russia, because it is such a specific and non-residential
- 30:52source of capital, right? So basically all of us coming
- 30:56from On all of us sound like we are massive cynics about the
- 31:00idea that like any Silicon Valley investor company.
- 31:03Like actually has like is guided primarily by moral calculus here
- 31:09and that obviously the business incentives or disincentives like
- 31:13kind of ruled the day, I just think to the extent of morality,
- 31:17they think building great businesses is a moral document
- 31:21which is an easy thing to convince yourself, if that's how
- 31:23you make money and therefore, In people's money and using it to
- 31:28build businesses that you think are good for society, which many
- 31:31of them are. I think let some sleep mostly
- 31:34pretty easily. I don't even think it's his
- 31:35randian, is that? I honestly think when it comes
- 31:37down to it, a CEO does feel the same sort of moral paintings
- 31:41that any other person does and things will what can I do
- 31:44personally and they feel like it's within their power to do
- 31:47something. So I do, I mean like even Elon
- 31:49Musk who people are again giving shit 24 involving himself in the
- 31:53situation, you know? I you know like the case.
- 31:56Of like, the, the Thai soccer team or something and his
- 32:00involvement in that, that was clearly a self-serving move
- 32:02strictly to promote his own brand.
- 32:04And, you know, he deserved all the bullshit he got from that,
- 32:07the criticisms that he's getting now because, you know, he's
- 32:09offering starlink internet. So, Ukraine at a time where
- 32:13their internet is threatening to be shut off and suddenly, you're
- 32:16hearing people criticize him saying, oh, this could be, you
- 32:18know, a huge security nightmare because Russia could use that to
- 32:21be able to track individual ukrainians.
- 32:22I mean, sure, let's have that discussion.
- 32:24Maybe there's some argument to it but I honestly believe.
- 32:26Believe and maybe I'm being naive here that he is certainly
- 32:29well. And I think it's well
- 32:30intentioned. I honestly think he is seeing
- 32:32the same footage that we all are in thinking like, well, jeez, I
- 32:34can beam internet into and Ukraine.
- 32:36Cannot use it. If they don't think it's
- 32:38helpful. It feels weird to be like, oh,
- 32:40here's a not. So I'm actually maybe not as
- 32:42cynical as you're suggesting and maybe I'm the outlier here,
- 32:44Teddy. But for once I'm actually like,
- 32:46no, I actually think they are trying to do what they think
- 32:49they can do it. There's like no dissent in
- 32:51Western business about this right now, which is why it makes
- 32:54the one exception. So unusual and flagrant.
- 32:59So like I mean like what I think I think by the end of the end of
- 33:03March, you're a wolf said something.
- 33:05When I went, they want to take a bet on that before.
- 33:07Teddy, you did the interesting list of the power players in
- 33:12Silicon Valley, American politics splitting it between
- 33:16Democrats and Republicans. Do you remember your list off
- 33:19the top of your head? Can you give us the names real
- 33:21quick and then a few observations?
- 33:23Sure. So this was the the American
- 33:25oligarch list, I guess. I'm basically we, you know, but
- 33:28more important than who has power and Silicon Valley
- 33:32Politics as who has the most power because everyone loves
- 33:36stealing is from Sports. Media work, people rank things
- 33:39for, absolutely no reason, you know, purely to stir shit up.
- 33:43So we basically did, we called it the teal index, which was
- 33:46basically a list of who, we thought the political donors
- 33:49attack with the most juice were so the top of the list was what
- 33:54Steel on the right? And his college, buddy?
- 33:56Popcorn on the left. Some other folks were run Conway
- 34:00Carla jurvetson. Larry Ellison, who's doing a lot
- 34:04more politically than he ever owned the rights Larry Ellison.
- 34:07Sorry. I used to be Frank Lloyd ylenne.
- 34:09Ellison, is he on the right? You've been through David sacks
- 34:12on there? I mean they were the fact is is
- 34:14it easier to become a conservative Power Player?
- 34:16This incredible power player attack.
- 34:19I uh yeah you tell people that they give you if you want to
- 34:21give you have like a couple hundred K year which is nothing
- 34:25for these people, you Could be like you know a grand poobah of
- 34:29Silicon Valley. Republican politics you, you put
- 34:31a Hamas on the right. Did he go ballistic or does that
- 34:36was a joke now basically joke. Yeah.
- 34:38I mean, but he was and he's basically been cancelled by, you
- 34:41know, I mean, I wonder how his powers feeling is about the
- 34:44party system of changed since like you know you try to
- 34:47canceled by the Tom cons of the world from the right music,
- 34:51abusing a Bloomberg in Democrat, right?
- 34:53He's all over the place. It's it's hard to discern a
- 34:56Political valence to his stuff. He's so self-interested and so
- 35:00interested in promoting him. Yeah.
- 35:03Promoting his own personal brand that it seems to just be all
- 35:06over the map is my, is my assessment Teddy with no butter
- 35:10on our on our Republican list? Like yes, the David Sachs.
- 35:14I mean, I'm obsessed with David Sachs, he's a smart guy, very
- 35:17frustrating politics in my view. Do you think it's mostly about
- 35:20just like getting low taxes and plane into sort of the social
- 35:24issues to the degree? That that's, Like necessary or
- 35:29you think they are also True Believers on sort of the Trump
- 35:34assist. I would not talking about peel,
- 35:36teal. Sorry.
- 35:37Not talking about teal, the rest of the sax.
- 35:40Larry, Ellison. Yeah.
- 35:42I do you think this is just about sort of keeping taxes low?
- 35:45At the end of the day? I don't, I mean, like, I mean,
- 35:47like, like, I mean, people are genuinely conservative free
- 35:53marketers, right? And that's not like, I don't
- 35:55think everyone who thinks that is, you know, Looking at their
- 35:58own kind of wealth management account and trying to lower
- 36:01their tax burden. Like people should be genuinely
- 36:04laissez-faire. Sure services.
- 36:06Not just there like a book but it's a, it's a nice.
- 36:09Yeah, yeah. It's like having people people
- 36:11think that like, just because but the viewed only party, I
- 36:14mean, literally the Republican party.
- 36:16I mean, the most embarrassing thing that happened was Rick.
- 36:20Scott accidentally said he wanted to raise taxes on most
- 36:23Americans and Mitch McConnell's. Like absolutely, that's not
- 36:26going to happen. So sure.
- 36:27The Republican Elites can pretend like tax policy as sort
- 36:31of a ideology is animating the party but they have to run and
- 36:35hide from that when it comes to the that's not what the voters
- 36:39want to hear about. So I'm just do you think the
- 36:41elites are aligned with sort of what Mitch McConnell will
- 36:44actually deliver or do you think they are starting to share some
- 36:49of what the Republican voters want?
- 36:53You mean you mean like truck-based wants?
- 36:56Yeah, I just sort of the constant culture were fighting
- 36:59sort of the truth. I mean, we're seeing trans
- 37:02issues and the Republican governor race, right?
- 37:07I mean I mean like I mean socks, obviously, as felt this way
- 37:09since the Sanford review that you know, he's a provocateur and
- 37:13like, why not both? I'm sure he genuinely believes
- 37:17that low taxes are good for economic growth but like, even
- 37:21he's not my butler. I didn't even draw a distinction
- 37:23Haystacks and T on your, I know people start grouping together.
- 37:26One is very rich, much more Rich than the other.
- 37:29So it like, when you're comparing just like Power
- 37:32Center, I wonder sure. But like, socks is, you know,
- 37:36socks is not pro-trump in a way that you'll is just to give him
- 37:39credit there. I mean, there is, there is,
- 37:41there is anti anti Trump. He's, I'm going to be okay.
- 37:45Yeah, I'm not going to articulate my view so that I can
- 37:47have fun on Twitter sort of antagonizing Democrats.
- 37:50Even though the alternative to the Democrats was the president
- 37:55at the time. Donald Trump.
- 37:56I also partially think, like, some of like the teal
- 38:01Machiavelli in takeover of Republican politics storyline, I
- 38:05think is an over, say, the little bit like part part of
- 38:07this is honestly very much that Blake Masters and JD Vance
- 38:12happened to be running this year and the same year, which was not
- 38:15a guarantee. Both of them had looked at
- 38:17running in 18 and 20 and it just so happens that you know, they
- 38:22both ran the same year, Peter was getting more and more.
- 38:26Not the politics that I feel like sometimes this is casted
- 38:29this like takeover of you know the United States Senate and it
- 38:33kind of is a coincidence and socks and you know whose knows
- 38:37Peter sorry knows Blake and JD as well.
- 38:40I think he's donated to both of them.
- 38:42Yeah that is is is that is that really like a belief in trumpian
- 38:47politics or is that just like hey to people he's known for a
- 38:49long time or running for Senate like I'll give but of course, JD
- 38:52Vance's, whole political posture has been Basically, to try to
- 38:57get angry dunking tweets from the left on Twitter.
- 39:01So it is very front of my right to people in Silicon Valley.
- 39:05You know, it's like you're aligning yourself with the very
- 39:08person who's seems like trying to just annoy your colleagues.
- 39:14I mean Vance is losing, right? I mean it seems like Josh Mandel
- 39:16is more likely to come out of the primary.
- 39:18It's a kind of it's a, it's a, it's a complicated music, five,
- 39:21or six candidates there. I mean, I could keep the Peter
- 39:23money has definitely not been determinatives.
- 39:26You know, 10 million dollars sounds like a lot each of their
- 39:28super Pacs but it's really not that much.
- 39:31I've honestly been surprised it's not more and I would expect
- 39:34more to come. So for now though like Peter has
- 39:37not really been a kingmaker. So maybe walk to moving down the
- 39:39list but also he stepped off of the Facebook boards that he
- 39:42could commit himself more to the political project that he is
- 39:46apparently. You know, captaining so you
- 39:49could you could also see a moving up the list if he you
- 39:52know really donates more of his time to it, right.
- 39:55Did you put Eric? Schmidt on your Democratic list.
- 39:57Yeah, sure. It was a number three or number
- 39:58four. Sure.
- 39:59It's just like a Survivor. Should just like a survivor.
- 40:01He's like, never gonna think I call him a cockroach and I know,
- 40:04you know, I was actually a compliment he just he will never
- 40:07ever lose a spot on the list because he's just a, he's always
- 40:11in that he's always in the mix like even during the Trump are,
- 40:13I even like, you know, talking with Kushner and just being
- 40:16being around the hoop which I guess I sort of respect just
- 40:19from a tactical standpoint. What are your thoughts on Reed
- 40:21Hastings? I always find his political
- 40:23involvement, very interesting because he's obviously an Spoken
- 40:27liberal, and will support very publicly, most Democrats that
- 40:31are running for office, but he's also very deeply aligned with
- 40:34Charter Schools and once you push those, which I think.
- 40:38Yeah, I mean, yeah, that's complicated.
- 40:41And he gave a ton of money to hbcus to, right?
- 40:44Yes. I mean, so read last week showed
- 40:46up or to excuse should have been met in Jackson, Mississippi with
- 40:49stone and to an HBCU there. And part of this is the
- 40:52influence of his wife, Patty quillin, who is, you know, A
- 40:56big, you know, social justice Lefty so to speak and she has
- 41:01spent a ton of money on Criminal Justice Reform issues.
- 41:03But right read is nominally a Democrat.
- 41:06But his touch. The another third rail of
- 41:09California. Politics or national politics
- 41:11left, 20 years, which is he's very, very, very vocally
- 41:14ProCharger in a way that makes him a little bit of a thorn in
- 41:20the side of kind of the Progressive Movement.
- 41:22Sure if teachers unions and of public schooling.
- 41:24I mean those those Chardonnay Not exist compliment in
- 41:27complementary Fashions. It takes it did, I mean read is
- 41:30not that we gave like four million or three million bucks
- 41:33to Gavin campaign, to prevent the recall of Gavin.
- 41:37Ultimately, he is a kind of a single-issue voter at this
- 41:40point, he cares most about Charters and I guess, Gavin's,
- 41:43not horrible on that issue. But certainly is someone who
- 41:46maybe should be scrutinized for interviewed or Look into little
- 41:51more. Who's your like favorite
- 41:53budding, political influence, or billionaire, like who's slightly
- 41:57under the radar, but I think guess who he's gonna pick on
- 41:59this? Yeah, okay, yes.
- 42:01Well Sam, the eat the crypto guy, penguin, Freaks and beggar,
- 42:06thank God for you. Yeah, I mean I'm very interested
- 42:09in sort of the hysterics sort of right just the the effect of
- 42:16altruist political sets. So people who are Are very
- 42:21data-driven trying to, you know, almost bring a PhD level
- 42:26statistical analysis to political donations.
- 42:28So I've been running a lot about send backbut free, it is the CEO
- 42:32of FTX the crypto exchange and is he's my age.
- 42:36I guess he's younger than the new you husbands.
- 42:39But Samm is Samm. He's sort of an X like attempt
- 42:43to me you represent s next generation of donor which is
- 42:47like total fucking hacks who like love the game.
- 42:50Enter like that, I do their own complex data analysis and
- 42:54writing like out sort like Outsourcing it to some staff.
- 42:57There's now like this new class and effective alterus donor, who
- 43:00is just obsessed with the game and the map, I guess.
- 43:04That's the moskovitz is another sort of example, that Sam is
- 43:08sort of taking the taken the World by storm.
- 43:09Something running. A lot about him over the last
- 43:11but dust it is getting less involved.
- 43:14Yeah, according to your reporting in politics, and Sam
- 43:17is getting more involved in the generals correct direction.
- 43:20Mallet e. Okay, that's right.
- 43:21Yeah. What about Mackenzie Scott
- 43:25right? Is her strategy working or, what
- 43:26sort of the mood on? I don't know, the, in the know,
- 43:30sort of philanthropy type mood on her donation strategy.
- 43:34I mean, yes, she is probably the most like like the media
- 43:37narrative is sort of obsessed with her and his major until
- 43:39like isayah look I you know she's giving away I think
- 43:43probably around 10 billion dollars by this point she
- 43:46certainly is different, right? She's doing this basically with
- 43:49very very minimal. Staff doing it, very quietly.
- 43:53Sort of the opposite of the effect of altruist might say,
- 43:55just let s go where she is not running the numbers on
- 43:59everything and being extremely exacting on nonprofits.
- 44:02I do think that there is I mean, this is a contrarian opinion
- 44:05that I do think that the it is possible.
- 44:08This is ends up as a massive fuckup.
- 44:10Like let's just like keep that as a possibility, like some of
- 44:13the narrative has almost been two positives and that's not to
- 44:17say that I'm bearish on Mackenzie but Like she the
- 44:21mirror would be people who would, otherwise love process
- 44:25expertise in systems suddenly love the person who's just like
- 44:28throwing the money around, right?
- 44:30I mean, that the sort of the argument like, like I mean, the
- 44:35other kind of lumbering force in the hunter, oldest Gates
- 44:37Foundation, and they 1500 staff, right?
- 44:40And they're sort of the opposite of Mackenzie.
- 44:44And it's like, I'm just I'm not saying that, like MacKenzie
- 44:46experiment is not going to work and it very well could show that
- 44:50Don't need 1,500 staff, The Gates Foundation, but let's
- 44:52like, let's cool. The Jets a little bit.
- 44:54Yeah, I where I worry given your sourcing base.
- 44:57You, you have a rooting interest here.
- 44:59I'm sure many of the the philanthropy world don't want to
- 45:02be told that they're irrelevant. And in fact, detrimental to
- 45:07benevolence and and good at was the fact that came out.
- 45:10That was that was basically the premise of that book.
- 45:13What was it called? It was it was basically a book
- 45:16about how like the idea of philanthropy especially globe,
- 45:20Well, philanthropy was just winners, Nicole winner s all,
- 45:23thank you. Just did not work and it was a
- 45:25huge failure. Yes, very controversial and
- 45:29successful book. Yeah.
- 45:30They're looking for like, four examples of books that like make
- 45:33an impact when or Segal has been enormous impact in just pissing
- 45:37off an entire South Africa. So kudos to Anand 4:04 like
- 45:44succeeding, you did it, we're getting people to read your book
- 45:46which is honestly, an accomplishment, because most
- 45:48people don't read anyone's mind, right?
- 45:50At least in within the court of billionaires, everyone was
- 45:52sitting around, starting book. Clubs being all angry about it.
- 45:55There is a story that I don't know if this is true or not, but
- 45:58a non has said it is true that like there was a big
- 46:01philanthropy in Silicon Valley, I guess I shouldn't say which
- 46:03one because on confirmed, but that there was a delivery of
- 46:07boxes of anons book to the philanthropy for like a book
- 46:10club at the world. I'm thrown out in a very Vivid
- 46:14demonstration of these peoples openness to critique.
- 46:17That's like the donor version of like pouring like champagne down
- 46:19the toilet. It fits like right.
- 46:20Let's throw out an odds book but then we had to buy it too.
- 46:23So actually this benefited him or the one.
- 46:25I'm gonna burn it right? Yes.
- 46:27We do. You think we pay too much
- 46:29attention to billionaires? Like that is weird kid.
- 46:31Like we're so obsessed with them.
- 46:33We're so obsessed. Fire, Teddy.
- 46:35Yeah. Thatís a said, he's gonna leave
- 46:36his beat at the end of this podcast.
- 46:38We're so obsessed with like, no, no Hollywood Washington, and New
- 46:42York, Wall Street, Washington and Hollywood.
- 46:46That's all we kind of care about largely writ large.
- 46:50The media but do you mean Sarah is on Katie's mind.
- 46:53That's the yeah. That is that is totally the
- 46:57audience of this podcast. Exactly the Milwaukee Master
- 47:01everybody everyday person is the audience, it's just like yeah we
- 47:07are we are we giving billionaires too much credit for
- 47:10how much power they actually have such a very sophisticated
- 47:14point. I think is quite possibly true
- 47:16and saying about a lot. Look even in politics like Like,
- 47:20yes, billionaires and a lot of power, especially, in, like,
- 47:23down ballot races, where he know, someone could decide to
- 47:26fund a random candidate who has no money, and suddenly they do
- 47:29have money, but like Michael Bloomberg burned through a
- 47:32billion dollars in God, you know, a couple delegates from
- 47:35American Samoa to some extent. I feel like the peak of
- 47:37billionaire, power politically with almost in like the mid
- 47:402010's like 2012 2013 2015 kind of before the ride probably Koch
- 47:46brothers. Yeah before the rise of
- 47:49especially at You know, George Soros mauled, small dollar money
- 47:53and philanthropic Lee. I don't know, I guess I'm less
- 47:55convinced philanthropically look.
- 47:57If if Sergey Brin decides that he wants to fund Alzheimer's
- 48:01research, instead of Parkinson's research said of cancer
- 48:04research, like people's lives could depend on that decision,
- 48:08right? Butters?
- 48:08What disease they die from or don't die from.
- 48:11So I think on the margins, there are these like Niche Fields were
- 48:15billionaires have enormous philanthropic power.
- 48:18Like you were talk about Reed Hastings.
- 48:19Like there could be a charter school or not.
- 48:21Be a charter school because of what Reed Hastings decides to do
- 48:25or three dates things change his mind on an issue like that could
- 48:28spell out and have a major impact on society.
- 48:32So I don't think that like this is the most important being in
- 48:35the world and there are certainly some Lefty critiques.
- 48:39But billionaire power that I like, vehement Lee disagree
- 48:42with. But I do think it is, certainly
- 48:44under-covered still, even though, you know, I've been
- 48:47doing this effort for four years and I wonder if our Desire for
- 48:50there to be a narrative that billionaires are in control.
- 48:54It's because at least gives us the idea that at least someone
- 48:57is, right? Yeah, at least someone is
- 49:00driving this fucking ship in the world if it's not Nancy pricey
- 49:04and it's not Mitch McConnell it's not Joe Biden.
- 49:06Well yeah it's not your filner and it does well.
- 49:10Thank you very yeah give me somebody somebody I think you
- 49:14know to bring it back to Ukraine.
- 49:16We've seen the pressure points that the u.s. and the richest
- 49:19people People and it's companies are trying to put here to stop
- 49:23this from going on, but it could be that if the campaign in
- 49:27Ukraine Putin's campaign, Ukraine is on successful, it
- 49:30could largely be due to the fact that militarily.
- 49:33It was a failure because of the resistance on the part of
- 49:36ukrainians and that's something that the West had no control
- 49:38over that is strictly something. That was the human decision by
- 49:42millions of people to resist it and, you know, in one sense,
- 49:45obviously that's very heartening.
- 49:48But also shows that like the things that we Side or power in
- 49:51this world and you know, what can change the destiny of
- 49:54millions and billions of people are way out of way more out of
- 49:57control than we initially thought.
- 49:59And it's both comforting and kind of terrifying at least and
- 50:02the B Administration. I mean, they really manage the
- 50:04story about this was happening. The intelligence apparatus like,
- 50:07I think, you know, we've been living in this post, Iraq war,
- 50:11you know, government, Security State is irrelevant, and this
- 50:14has been a case that they're far more relevant than.
- 50:18Yeah, the business I really do. Jesus but I do think it's also
- 50:21true that the u.s. government has been extremely relevant in
- 50:27sort of navigating this situation.
- 50:29Sure. Or at least helping to shape the
- 50:31narrative which is important and like an on foreign policy realm.
- 50:35I think, in which we've seen billionaires, their efficacy
- 50:39questioned is education, right? So if you look at New Orleans
- 50:44and Louisiana so much money including from Michael
- 50:47Bloomberg, Believe The Waltons was poor.
- 50:50And two different School braces there, Reed Hastings, in order
- 50:54to basically affect an outcome because they believe that by
- 50:57introducing more school choice and D.
- 50:59Emphasizing public schools, there would be a radical shift
- 51:02in education, outcomes in New Orleans.
- 51:04Now, that radical shift and outcomes has not happened.
- 51:07It hasn't happened in New Orleans or Louisiana despite all
- 51:10of the money and despite the fact that several of those races
- 51:12were won by the candidates backed by outside money for
- 51:16sure. And so it's like when you, when
- 51:17you look at this data driven group of billionaires.
- 51:19Ears. Do they ever?
- 51:21You know, when you talk to them, they look at data like that and
- 51:23pause and go. Maybe there was some human
- 51:26nature stuff in there or there were some infrastructure stuff
- 51:28in there that we didn't really account for and that we can
- 51:31control. There's meat, there's been like
- 51:33some Reckoning on Ed reform, specifically, I mean, like the
- 51:35Gates Foundation is basically said that the education push was
- 51:39a failure to say that about couple years two or three years
- 51:41ago, this point which was a rare treat to cater your point, a
- 51:44rare admission of a faults and in a world where every, you
- 51:48know, Billy I think that they are The Savior when you talk to
- 51:52these and I'm gonna let you, we're going to like when you
- 51:54talk to these billionaires. All right.
- 51:57Let's wrap this up with yeah ring but now we're like, let's
- 52:00dive back is just New Orleans. We hold them hostage, just a
- 52:07human eyes. I mean like when you talk to the
- 52:09actual just to humanize Teddy billionaires and I'm here.
- 52:13Well, I don't know what the Princeton like.
- 52:14When you talk to the billionaires, do they still
- 52:16think philanthropy is like an unequivocal?
- 52:19Good? It or if they sort of accepted
- 52:21that you might come at them with sort of as a premise that their
- 52:25philanthropy is suspect. Like, do they think it's just a
- 52:29matter of whether they were successful in their goals?
- 52:31Or are they open to sort of questions on just sort of the
- 52:34general project? Yeah, that's a good question II.
- 52:39Do not think that they are open to the question of it as a
- 52:42general project yet, like for all the success of like the
- 52:45Ananda but we're just talking about a moment ago.
- 52:48Ultimately He is sort of treated as almost like it's like a
- 52:53basketball game where you know, you want to score more points
- 52:55and you score more points by doing more.
- 52:57Like the question is good. Philanthropy is more
- 53:00philanthropy and and it's like almost it's almost covered like
- 53:04sports at times where there's very little critical coverage of
- 53:08these people and I think they're also extraordinarily thin
- 53:10skinned. I don't think my coverage is
- 53:12necessarily that quote, unquote confrontational and and likes
- 53:17asking basic questions about, like, how is your foot Anthropy
- 53:20structure. You know who runs it?
- 53:23Like stuff like that you know right.
- 53:25They say I think the the Baseline level of scrutiny that
- 53:29they're prepared for is very very low.
- 53:30I'd like say, you know, venture capital or tack where I think
- 53:33people at this point like get the reporters are going to dig
- 53:36around and like I've had flax in philanthropy be upset that I'm
- 53:41like contacting like former employees.
- 53:43Just like basic shit that, right?
- 53:46Because I think I, you know, every every field has its own Of
- 53:50media culture and there is not strong investigative or honestly
- 53:55just sophisticated reporting about this stuff so everyone can
- 53:59be a bunch of babies sometimes. So in conclusion, Teddy is
- 54:02saying that Federal governments are better.
- 54:04Allocators, have tapped out towards public good.
- 54:06Then the millionaires? Yeah.
- 54:09If I could say, I have a friend that loves just like basically
- 54:14Miss just like, you know, you just, you just grab one thing
- 54:17someone says and, you know, Twisted in Different ways and
- 54:20move on, move on as quickly as possible before they had a
- 54:23chance to correct. Its the, yes, we'll definitely
- 54:25title this podcast by philanthropies failed.
- 54:31Thank you, teddy for doing this. This was great.
- 54:33Thank you. Yeah, glad to have you, I'm sure
- 54:35we'll have you back Silicon Valley.
- 54:50Goodbye. Goodbye.
- 54:51Goodbye, goodbye, goodbye. Goodbye.
- 54:50Goodbye. Goodbye.
- 54:51Goodbye, goodbye, goodbye. Goodbye.