Latest / Energy Voice – Out Loud / EVOL: OEUK Conference 2025
Transcript
- 0:00Hello and welcome to Energy Voice Out Loud, the weekly news
- 0:05podcast that keeps you up to date on the hottest stories from
- 0:09the UK energy market. This week, Offshore Energy's UK
- 0:14hosted its annual conference in Aberdeen as it fended off
- 0:18protesters and hosted some industry heavy hitters.
- 0:22I'm Aberdeen features lead Ryan Duff, and at the conference I
- 0:25spoke to Anna Surya operating company CEO, Richard Beattie.
- 0:30Now this conversation did last 20 minutes, which is longer than
- 0:34the usual 10 minute segments on this show.
- 0:36So we've broken it up into two so you can have a bathroom break
- 0:39or grab a snack or whatever you need to do.
- 0:41But up 1st, we spoke to Richard about the future of the North
- 0:45Sea. We're here at the OEUK
- 0:47conference in Aberdeen and I'm joined by Anasuria Operating
- 0:50Company CEO. Richard, how are you doing
- 0:53today? Excellent.
- 0:54How are you doing? Not bad.
- 0:55I missed the first session. My colleague Michael Baer was in
- 0:58it, so maybe I'm going to have to ask you.
- 0:59What the skinny? Was on that what was?
- 1:01The main take away for. You I think good context there
- 1:04from you know looking hearing from GB Energy, you know, I
- 1:07think Dave Whitehouse set out the challenges that the industry
- 1:10is facing. I thought that was set out well
- 1:13and it was nice to hear from GB Energy about their plans moving
- 1:17forward. So it's the first time we
- 1:18personally have had the kind of opportunity to hear that.
- 1:21So I think that's an important voice in the room.
- 1:23I think all Energy we need to hear about them and we need to
- 1:26look at all of them. So that was great.
- 1:29And then the final session there was looking at some of the data
- 1:32for the potential of the North Sea.
- 1:34So, you know, we tend to maybe look at the the low case in
- 1:38terms of what's left talking about.
- 1:40Yvonne was talking about terminal decline and that phrase
- 1:43not being you know one that we all like, but but it's showing
- 1:47that there is a big upside and that that personally is
- 1:49something I believe very much so.
- 1:52And later on this afternoon I'll show some of what we've done on
- 1:55Anasuria in terms of trying to rest some of that decline.
- 1:58But I think it was really good to see the opportunity that's
- 2:01there because we talked down the North Sea sometimes in terms of
- 2:04see it as it's at it's end. I've been in the industry for 25
- 2:09years and I don't look that old or young maybe.
- 2:14But yeah, for for half of the time it's been in the UK.
- 2:17And you know, when I joined, people were talking about
- 2:20decline and this was the end of the road.
- 2:22But we've got amazing people, amazing engineers, problem
- 2:27solvers, supply chain. And when we apply that we can
- 2:31overcome a lot of these challenges and really maximize
- 2:33what's left. And I believe there is a a long
- 2:36and fruitful and positive story left for for oil and gas as part
- 2:41of the the energy mix in the UK I'd.
- 2:43Say and Yvonne Telford from Westwood would have been
- 2:46speaking about the the report they produced in collaboration
- 2:50with the UK over the weekend where they found that 7.5
- 2:54billion barrels is left at the North Sea.
- 2:57I think an interesting point to be made about that was like 7.3
- 3:00billion of those barrels are near pubs that are already
- 3:05producing. Yeah.
- 3:06And you know, so they can be used as tie backs.
- 3:08Yeah. And you know an awful lot about
- 3:09that. Yeah.
- 3:10Teal recently had a little bit of an announcement recently with
- 3:14with Mermaid. Can you tell me a little bit
- 3:16about what's happening out there?
- 3:17Yeah, I think for context, you know, I agree with what was
- 3:19shown today. I mean, I look around Asura and
- 3:21I draw a circle around 30 kilometres, what's in and around
- 3:25it. And there's about 100 million
- 3:26barrels of oil in the ground which could be tied back to the
- 3:31FPSO. And you know, at the moment, to
- 3:33be honest, it's only the the fiscal regime that is the big
- 3:36impediment to that. And there's a real risk if we
- 3:39don't make changes and I won't come on to that yet, but if we
- 3:41don't make some changes that we leave this stranded in the
- 3:44ground. And so, yeah, looking at our own
- 3:46hub, our goal has been to, we're a joint operating company.
- 3:51Our goal has been to maximise the value from the hub.
- 3:54So you know, increasing the uptime as we've talked about
- 3:56before, you know, strong safety record, that's been our goal.
- 4:00You know, we've increased, we've got Anasuria online about 70 or
- 4:0380 days more than it was before we took it over and we're we're
- 4:08up at a 90% operating efficiency on the asset.
- 4:13So, so that's a 30 year old asset.
- 4:16So that shows what can be done. Teal is one of our key fields.
- 4:19So recently we had a scale squeeze.
- 4:21So a scale squeeze is obviously as the the well builds up over
- 4:24time, scale can form. We put chemicals into that to
- 4:28make sure that we don't scale up the the the pipeline and to make
- 4:31sure that we can maximize production.
- 4:33So that's just part of our strategy of ongoing going
- 4:36maintenance. It's routine if you like, you
- 4:38know, in terms of making sure that we can extract all of the
- 4:41existing oil and every couple of years based on chemistry.
- 4:45And we, we, we squeeze the well, but you know, executed on time,
- 4:48on plan, on budget, you know, with excellent collaboration
- 4:52across the supply chain, you know, again, delivering for us
- 4:55on that. So yeah, good to get that done
- 4:57safely first and foremost. And yes, successful outcome for
- 5:00us. And on that 100 million barrels
- 5:04you've you've used the number in front of a journalist?
- 5:07That maybe regret it, but yeah. 100 million barrels, does that
- 5:10include the existing tie backs existing field or is that as you
- 5:15untapped opportunity around? So it's it's, it's a bit of all
- 5:18of that. Some of the fields that we've,
- 5:20you know, discussed for coming back to Anasuri, you know, that
- 5:23are in the public domain around, you know, Teal West and fine.
- 5:27But there are others. And when you look at the, the
- 5:31whole hub, if you like, in and around us, you know, there's
- 5:34other producers, other assets in that region as well.
- 5:37So, yeah, I mean, you know, those are numbers.
- 5:39Those are real numbers. There's discoveries behind that.
- 5:42There's wells that have been drilled on these licenses and on
- 5:45these acreage that have been stranded there.
- 5:48And that's, that's been the story of the North Sea.
- 5:49You know, we've drilled things that maybe weren't, you know, 30
- 5:53years ago or 25 years ago that maybe weren't the highest
- 5:56priority in terms of production or volume.
- 5:59But you know, as time goes on, they go up the hopper if you
- 6:02like, and we do that. So for me, you know, as I say,
- 6:05what I focus on Fran Asuria is really just making it a safe,
- 6:08attractive, high uptime hub. And that will, you know,
- 6:12hopefully encourage investment in into that.
- 6:15Although I don't directly control that investment.
- 6:17I'm, I'm trying to encourage others and our shareholders and
- 6:20other parties to, to invest in that see Anasura as a safe and
- 6:24efficient hub. And so how important are those,
- 6:27those hubs that are as yet untapped around Anasuria, how
- 6:31important are they for this continued existence of the
- 6:35company? This is your one.
- 6:36Asset, right, Yeah, a massive, I mean, you know, that's part of
- 6:38our strategy and we'll talk about that later today.
- 6:41You know it's become an attractive host and become
- 6:43attractive to third parties and I think that's the goal for all
- 6:46assets. We as a hub are trying to
- 6:48maximize it. We want as much production to
- 6:50come through it. We've really managed the cost as
- 6:53we'll show you later on today. You know we've we've actually
- 6:55reduced the cost on Anasuri on our OpEx in real terms about 18%
- 7:00over the last five years. And that means that it is a very
- 7:04low cost asset, but we need volume to come through it.
- 7:08You know, when you have high tax rates and etcetera, then that
- 7:11becomes even more critical and that you get that investment in
- 7:16and you bring the volumes through.
- 7:17Because, you know, if theoretically, you know, you're
- 7:20paying close to 80% and it's going straight to tax, then you
- 7:24know, you need a high volume to to offset your costs and to, you
- 7:27know, to make it investable. So yeah, absolutely vital and
- 7:30and really important. But it's not just tax, we're
- 7:33also waiting on the consultation results for future licensing.
- 7:37If you're looking for new tie backs, you need to compete in
- 7:39licensing rounds or get licenses outside of rounds from the NSDA
- 7:45right now. What's what's happening for your
- 7:48plans while we wait for autumn? Not August.
- 7:52Waiting for Autumn to find out what the results.
- 7:55Of the consultation are yeah, I mean again for Anasuria, you
- 7:58know, I'm focused really on operating the the asset and
- 8:02maximising that and trying to encourage others to invest in.
- 8:05But it is absolutely important that on the consultations that
- 8:08there's a lot of uncertainty, you know, so it's, it's holding
- 8:11things up. People are not sure what you
- 8:13know, what's required. We've seen some clarity, you
- 8:16know, this week around some of the emissions plan in terms of
- 8:20what will be in terms of a scope 3 emissions that we will be and
- 8:24some guidance on there. But yeah, I think there's a huge
- 8:27amount of uncertainty. Things are on hold and we need
- 8:31to move past that. You know, we need to get into a
- 8:34position where we can provide clarity.
- 8:35You need, you know, 2345 years to plan and execute, you know,
- 8:42some of these scopes and with all of the outstanding
- 8:45consultations, etcetera, that's just adding a bit more
- 8:48complexity and uncertainty to that.
- 8:50So I welcome the conclusion of that.
- 8:53You know, we as operators and whatever, you know, we're, we
- 8:56adapt. We're just, you know, we, we
- 8:59don't want to just say this is too difficult.
- 9:01We always want to try and find a way.
- 9:03The UK North Sea has done that over decades.
- 9:05It's adapted, it's adjusted and we will continue to do that.
- 9:09But what we do need and what we do ask, is a fair and an
- 9:12attractive fiscal and regulatory environment in order for for us
- 9:15to compete with what is a global product.
- 9:18And I believe you took part in that consultation process
- 9:21earlier in the year. Now I, I've heard with
- 9:25consultation processes in the past various things that
- 9:28sometimes your trade bodies and the likes come forward and go.
- 9:31Well, the question seemed very skewed.
- 9:34It seemed like they already wanted a specific answer and
- 9:36they were trying to get that. Did you get that feeling?
- 9:39Compete. You know all.
- 9:40Participating, if I'm honest, I did a little bit.
- 9:42I felt, you know, I ended up reshaping a lot of the the
- 9:45answers maybe. And I try not to look at things
- 9:48not just from an oil and gas lenses say like, I'll be clear,
- 9:52you know, I'm a supporter of all energy.
- 9:54The demand is growing in the UK. You know, we need all energy
- 9:58types. It's not one or the other.
- 10:00You know, we need to get away from this divisive talk.
- 10:03And you know, winding down 1 doesn't necessarily help the
- 10:06other or accelerate it. In fact, you know, I believe
- 10:08that's the opposite in terms of that.
- 10:11So yeah, I think the questions were quite difficult to
- 10:14interpret sometimes. We did share it with our
- 10:15organization and kind of the general feedback was I don't
- 10:19really know how to answer some of these points, but you know,
- 10:22in general, I think it's positive that we are consulting,
- 10:25we are asking the questions. You're never going to be able to
- 10:28put a subset of questions together that's going to please
- 10:30everyone. So we fully recognise that.
- 10:32So, you know, I think to be fair on that side, you know, so
- 10:35everyone's looking at maybe from their own lens.
- 10:37So it's difficult to find something.
- 10:39But I wholly welcome consultation.
- 10:42You know, as I say as an oil producer, when we talk about
- 10:45emissions, you know, we're doing everything that we can.
- 10:48You know, the UK should be proud of its record and what it's
- 10:50doing across the basin to to manage emissions and safety on
- 10:55the asset. So you know, as I say, I welcome
- 10:58it and I look forward to kind of concluding those phases so that
- 11:02we can move away from consultation and move towards,
- 11:05you know, having a criteria that we can we can apply to future
- 11:09investment. So some interesting stuff there
- 11:11from Richard in the first half of this two-part interview up
- 11:15after the break. So you've joined us after the
- 11:58break As for a way to dive back into our conversation with
- 12:01Richard BT And in this part we're speaking about tax.
- 12:05He's a chartered accountant. We always had to speak about tax
- 12:08and he's got some strong opinions about it.
- 12:11So why don't can't we hear what he's got to say now you've
- 12:14mentioned tax a couple of. Times through it not like me.
- 12:16Yeah, no, of course the last. Time.
- 12:19I am an accountant by background.
- 12:21Well, the last time we spoke, we were speaking about tax quite
- 12:24heavily. We just had an EPL update, a
- 12:26windfall tax update, whatever you want to.
- 12:28Call it. And now again, the outcome of
- 12:31those consultations again later in the year when we last spoke,
- 12:36you said that that's too late and we need a decision now.
- 12:39We need clarity now. I suspect I know the answer.
- 12:44You're the answer you're already giving me, Richard.
- 12:46Has anybody think of a different one?
- 12:49Has anything changed, do you think that, you know, having
- 12:53that end goal goal, that sort of end date or not end date, but
- 12:56that sort of period of well, we find out or not, we find out if
- 13:00the, you know, how the tax regime is changing.
- 13:03Is that soon enough? So no, it's not soon enough when
- 13:08you change now, let's be absolutely clear about that.
- 13:11However, I do welcome the consultation.
- 13:13We should know what the consultation is about what's
- 13:15happening to replace the EPL in 20-30, not necessarily a
- 13:20replacement now. So there would need to be and we
- 13:22hope and encourage there to be discussion Now what I would say
- 13:26from the models that I've seen, I would welcome those changes.
- 13:30I think, you know, we also recognise that when windfalls
- 13:34exist, the industry should play its part and we would welcome a
- 13:38progressive tax regime as we have applied to as I've stated
- 13:41before around income tax and things like that, you know, but
- 13:44this one-size-fits-all regardless of what your profit
- 13:48level is that you know, takes the same level of tax that's not
- 13:53inducive to investment and it's not reflective of the different
- 13:58scales of companies and operators that we have.
- 14:00So as I say, when windfalls exist and, and we need to be
- 14:03clear about when that is. It's certainly not now.
- 14:06It's certainly not, you've seen the volatility over the last
- 14:08week, right? You know, we had the, the, the
- 14:11challenges in the Middle East and oil price went up and now
- 14:16it's dropped back down to below what it was 12 days ago before
- 14:19we had the issues with that with it with Israel and Iran.
- 14:22So you're seeing it extreme volatility in oil price, but
- 14:26it's not spiking up into the 90s and into the hundreds, which is
- 14:31where we would see, I would see a windfall level being in and
- 14:36around the mid 90s personally is where you would start to say
- 14:40that's there. So I welcome what's been put
- 14:42forward, but I absolutely will reiterate, I do believe that if
- 14:47we do not make that change before 20-30 that we are facing
- 14:51a Cliff edge here for the industry.
- 14:53And I'll, I'll talk about that this afternoon on the spoiler
- 14:56alert of this will go afterwards.
- 14:57But but yeah, you know, I believe that that threat to the
- 15:00industry is genuine and it's real.
- 15:03And, you know, we are losing people, we are losing companies,
- 15:06we are losing assets and, and that is happening now.
- 15:09And once that starts, it's almost impossible to reverse it,
- 15:14you know, So we need to, you know, be considerate.
- 15:17I believe the oil and gas industry can be the heartbeat of
- 15:21the the UK energy, you know, going forward, as it's been for
- 15:24the last 50 years. And it can support the additions
- 15:28of, you know, wind and solar and nuclear and, you know, whatever
- 15:33additional sources are, because my understanding from what I've
- 15:36seen is we need them all. So, so, you know, let's not wind
- 15:39down one before we wind up the other.
- 15:42So getting that piece correct is really important.
- 15:45You've touched on investment a lot, as as an accountant would.
- 15:50Used to be, haven't been for a long time.
- 15:53I'm still charted. Let's speak a little bit about
- 15:56about your financial back, as you mentioned stakeholders
- 15:59obviously Anasurius sort of joint venture between two major.
- 16:05Joint operating company Joint. Operating company between two
- 16:08major international operators when it comes to that tax
- 16:14regime, when, when they're assessing where they're
- 16:16allocating funds year on year, it must be exceptionally
- 16:22difficult even with that high operating efficiency rate that
- 16:24you spoke about earlier. Yeah, to say to Peg, to say
- 16:27Hibiscus, hey, we're here, give us give us cash because we need
- 16:31to continue investing. Yeah, when they look at, they
- 16:34look at West Africa. Yeah.
- 16:36Asia Pacific and go, well, it's easier there, right?
- 16:39Yeah, no, you bang on there. I mean, but I don't think that's
- 16:42a new challenge. You know, fighting for capital
- 16:45allocation is something that we should welcome actually.
- 16:49You know, for me, we should win on merit.
- 16:51And so, you know, the difficulty is that we're constrained, but
- 16:55every basin has a constraint. Regardless of where you go.
- 16:58There's, there's pros and cons. What I focus on is making sure
- 17:02that, you know, the things that I can control around, you know,
- 17:04first and foremost a safe asset. You know, that's the absolute,
- 17:08you know, bottom line in terms of, you know, focusing on safe
- 17:11production and then maximizing what we can.
- 17:13So we will have to compete for that.
- 17:16I accept that. That's something I thrive on.
- 17:19I don't want to win by default. We're not just sitting back and
- 17:22saying, well, you should give us your money.
- 17:24We're business people, right? So we're business people
- 17:26regardless of background. What we're doing here is we're,
- 17:28it's, it's a business and we're trying to invest into that.
- 17:32So we have to take that seriously and we do.
- 17:36And competing for capital doesn't scare me.
- 17:40It's, you know, I like a challenge, I'm competitive.
- 17:42But as I say, I think, you know, the playing field is difficult.
- 17:47You know, you've got to have a fair playing field to be honest.
- 17:50But yeah, we'll, we try and optimize or maximize from what
- 17:53we have to be honest and we'll keep speaking up.
- 17:56I think it's important to speak up.
- 17:59You know, I believe you should always speak up for what you
- 18:01think is right. And I don't want to wait five
- 18:04years time and say I told you so.
- 18:06You know, I think the industry has been talking about some of
- 18:08these challenges for the last few years and you could already
- 18:10probably say I've told you so. Well, nobody's winning in that
- 18:14situation. So yeah, we need to stay
- 18:16competitive. We need to manage costs, we need
- 18:19to keep safe operations. That's the business that we're
- 18:22in. And as I say, you know, I, I
- 18:24welcome that, but as I say, I, I do ask for a, a fair playing
- 18:28field. It is, it is difficult to
- 18:30compete globally as you're seeing more so with with other
- 18:32companies who are, you know, pulling away or investing
- 18:35outside of the North Sea. Do you know I've got one last
- 18:38question for you. We had quite, quite an
- 18:40interesting set up for protest outside the the conference hall
- 18:44this morning. Extinction Rebellion protesters
- 18:47dressed as Daleks and they were they were arguing against
- 18:52arguing against lobbying and the in the UK and Scottish
- 18:56Government for oil and gas. We've been speaking with tax
- 19:00regime, we've been speaking about policy that will allow
- 19:03companies to further invest. I'd imagine that's kind of the
- 19:06law or the lobbying language that they're campaigning
- 19:10against. And the main issue they had was
- 19:13the idea that if we're lobbying for oil and gas, the energy
- 19:18transition, the roll out of renewables slows down.
- 19:21You've touched on, yeah, the, the sort of the two markets that
- 19:24I know the energy sector in the UK don't like calling 2 markets.
- 19:28They like to say it's all together.
- 19:30Do you do you have anything in response?
- 19:32In response to? That I think it's a really good
- 19:35point. I totally disagree.
- 19:36I, I take the other end of it actually, you know, I think that
- 19:39the oil and gas industry is an enabler to renewables.
- 19:44And if we wind it down with the skill set and the supply chain
- 19:48and the people that we have that, then it is going to slow
- 19:51things down. I mean, I think that's that's a
- 19:53fact. Like, you know, so I don't want
- 19:55to talk about politics, you know, but the Climate Change
- 19:59Committee and the government will tell you that we are going
- 20:03to require oil and gas as an important part of our energy
- 20:06mix. Beyond 2050, right?
- 20:09That's not me saying that's an oil and gas operator or
- 20:12whatever. I mean that is a fact based on
- 20:15what the government has said and the Prime Minister himself has
- 20:18has said that. So therefore oil and gas is
- 20:20going to exist. Every single drop that we have
- 20:23in the UK, we need. There's not.
- 20:26Do we need it or do we not? So the question is not do we
- 20:29need oil and gas? We do as part of an energy mix.
- 20:33And like I say, I support, you know, moving toward all
- 20:37energies, but we need oil and gas.
- 20:38It's a continuous, I talk about it's the heartbeat.
- 20:41It's there all the time. It's not dependent on weather
- 20:44conditions or whatever. It's been, it's been the
- 20:46heartbeat of the the North Sea for the last 50 years.
- 20:50We take it for granted because it's, we don't see it.
- 20:52It's offshore, we don't think it.
- 20:54But, you know, in terms of going forward, I see it as an enabler.
- 20:58And if we wind down the oil and gas industry too quickly, you're
- 21:00going to see a gap forming that is going to mean that we're
- 21:03unable to progress with some of the, you know, the other
- 21:07alternative energies at the pace that we would like.
- 21:10So I think we need to get away from good versus evil
- 21:13discussions and things like that.
- 21:16It's a, it's a global demand for the product.
- 21:20We're going to still use it in the UK for that time.
- 21:23I believe the question is quite simply, does it come from the UK
- 21:27or does it come from elsewhere? My strong belief is if we're
- 21:30going to need from what we saw this morning, we're going to
- 21:32need for, you know, up to we need 15 billion barrels
- 21:35potentially equivalent to meet the demands 32050.
- 21:39We're on track to produce between 3:00 and 4:00.
- 21:42And then as the information that was shown by Yvonne this
- 21:44morning, and you know, we could get up to 7 1/2 for me as a no
- 21:48brainer and investing in the UK, you know, to get in the tax
- 21:52receipts, you know, encouraging the jobs and the economic growth
- 21:56and using the oil and gas industry, which is a phenomenal
- 21:59industry. I mean, if you look at the
- 22:00people in it, the safety culture that's embedded, you watch
- 22:03people in here today, silly thing, but I do watch people and
- 22:05they come up and downstairs, they're all holding hand rails,
- 22:08right? You can see who's in the
- 22:09industry. We're ingrained.
- 22:11That is such a, and it's a simple example, right?
- 22:13But it is ingrained in US in terms of safety and performance.
- 22:17You've got highly trained and skilled people who are here.
- 22:21So we need them to stay in the industry in oil and gas.
- 22:25And some of those can also transfer over and support with
- 22:28the right sort of culture and the right sort of mindset into
- 22:32some of the other alternative energies.
- 22:33So the other thing I would say is like, I welcome all
- 22:35discussion. I, you know, I don't like
- 22:38painting good versus evil. I respect the people who are out
- 22:40there today. I would, you know, I think it's
- 22:43we need to sit down and talk about these problems shouting at
- 22:45each other over barriers or you know, causing divisions over
- 22:49that is not going to solve anything.
- 22:50So you know, welcome any discussions.
- 22:53You know, we certainly try as operators to try and be as
- 22:57focused on decarbonisation or reducing our missions and you
- 23:00know, the impact on the environment.
- 23:01We take extremely seriously, if you see the level of detail that
- 23:04we go in a day-to-day to make sure that we are being as
- 23:07environmentally responsible as possible and reducing our
- 23:11emissions and managing our flair etcetera.
- 23:13It's it's an absolute focus for us and that's got to be the case
- 23:17and we want to do that. So I don't see that as a
- 23:20difference to maybe what they're saying.
- 23:22I think there's maybe a maybe a misunderstanding.
- 23:24And as I say and any misunderstanding, I would always
- 23:27welcome discussion to try and find a middle grind because the
- 23:30division and the polarization I don't think is helpful.
- 23:34Well, thank you very much for joining me today, Richard.
- 23:36I know you're busy. You're away to go on stage, so
- 23:38I'm going to leave you to no. Worries.
- 24:34So that does it for our Richard BT bumper interview on this very
- 24:38special OUK Conference edition of Energy Voice Out Loud.
- 24:42But we're not quite done yet. The fun just keeps on rolling.
- 24:46We spoke to Bob Keeler, the former CEO of Wood and the man
- 24:50fronting the Save Our Union Street campaign in Aberdeen.
- 24:54We spoke a little bit about tax and that debate with
- 24:56politicians, but also about job losses in the northeast of
- 25:00Scotland and how it's impacting Aberdeen City centre, or maybe
- 25:04it's not. And we're here at the Offshore
- 25:06Energy's UK Conference 2025. You're just off the stage
- 25:10literally a couple of minutes ago and we've managed to corner
- 25:13you. I want to speak a little bit
- 25:15about, you had a really interesting point right at the
- 25:18top of the, the speeches before the panel session about the
- 25:22debate. And you can frame the, the
- 25:24conversation we've had so many times about the EPL, the energy
- 25:29profits levy, the windfall tax, whatever you want to call that.
- 25:32We've, we've heard people say, oh, yeah, but you'll get more,
- 25:35you'll get increased revenues from tax if more of companies
- 25:38are spending. We'll reduce our CO2 emissions
- 25:41if if we produce gas here rather than internationally.
- 25:46But you framed it from a politician standpoint that in a
- 25:49way that I found really interesting.
- 25:52So all I'm trying to do is to acknowledge that logic depends
- 25:56on what perspective you've got, because I can come up with
- 25:59something that's completely logical that somebody else will
- 26:01see is highly irrational. And I think it's the same when
- 26:05you've got complicated policy discussions and decisions that
- 26:10what appears to be logical from the standpoint of, for instance,
- 26:13the the oil and gas industry depends, is it logical if you
- 26:17take another starting point to look at that.
- 26:19And therefore, I think it's more nuanced than that.
- 26:22And it's only when you see things from different
- 26:23perspectives do you realize that actually it's more than simply
- 26:26having a logical argument. It's about what can you bring to
- 26:29the table and how can you make sure that you satisfy the other
- 26:32people's needs? And you can't get that if you
- 26:36don't understand what those needs genuinely are.
- 26:39So it starts with this dialogue and this deep understanding and
- 26:42listening up front. And, and I'm not convinced that
- 26:45we, we always take that we, we started off the first session
- 26:49this morning. We used the word must, so
- 26:52somebody else must do something rather than saying can we
- 26:56persuade them that this is in their interests?
- 26:59And I think it's that more newest approach I think is
- 27:01necessary. So it's a less a stance from
- 27:06industry of saying I'm standing here and you have to move.
- 27:09Rather, it's let's talk about this.
- 27:12There's there's a, there's a conversation to be had, there's
- 27:14a nuanced debate. I think when you look at it, so
- 27:18the industry can quite rightly point out and say there are some
- 27:20advantages definitely of changing the tax regime, but
- 27:25what is the industry offering? Because in the past, the
- 27:28industry's took a lot of the, the, the profits that were
- 27:32generated from high oil prices, for instance, and just gave them
- 27:36back to shareholders and bought back shares and, you know,
- 27:40dividends, anything. So where was the investment
- 27:42then? And therefore, what's going to
- 27:45be different this time if the energy profits levy was changed,
- 27:48for instance? And why would we believe that to
- 27:52be the case? So there's a bit of trust
- 27:54building required. There's a bit of thinking, well,
- 27:56what's the offer here? What's the commitment?
- 27:59And how does that in some way satisfy the broader objectives?
- 28:03That that's a really interesting point because, you know, we had
- 28:05protesters outside the PNG live this morning and yeah, they
- 28:09were, they were arguing, well, a against oil and gas lobbying.
- 28:13And considering the conversation through the House there was
- 28:18dominated by talk on policy and, you know, on fiscal regime, you
- 28:24could understand why they're they're saying that this is
- 28:26about lobbying and making sure that the governments are, you
- 28:29know, does sorry, as, as you put it, yeah, sort of bend to big
- 28:32oil or that's the way that some people would see it.
- 28:36When it comes to protesters and people that are against the oil
- 28:40and gas industry, they point to exactly that.
- 28:42They say, well, the big oil companies aren't investing in
- 28:45oil and renewables. They're not investing in
- 28:46hydrogen or offshore wind or whatever it may be.
- 28:50So why should we trust them with profits when we should be
- 28:53backing firms like, let's say, flotation energy, which is
- 28:57purely offshore wind focused, you know?
- 29:00Yeah, I mean, again, it's perspective.
- 29:02What appears to be completely logical from one perspective,
- 29:06one person's perspective is completely opposite from
- 29:09somebody else's. So I I kind of understand this
- 29:12idea about protesting against the the indigenous oil and gas
- 29:17industry. However, however, when you look
- 29:20at the skills we will need going forward to transition into a
- 29:24post hydrocarbon economy, a lot of these skills are already part
- 29:28of the energy sector. And therefore there's something
- 29:30there about retaining these skills in the UK long enough for
- 29:34us to take the advantage of them.
- 29:36And that requires us to have a sufficiently large industrial
- 29:39base on which to to develop those skills.
- 29:43And oil and gas industry is a key part of that.
- 29:46So depends what angle you look at it.
- 29:47If you look at it from a point of view of jobs, you look at a
- 29:50point of future skills. If you look at about communities
- 29:53and family, you can make a strong case for saying we should
- 29:55be investing in our local oil and gas industry.
- 29:58If you look at it through an angle purely of who's going to
- 30:01make profits out of this and wanting to do with the profits,
- 30:03you might come to a different conclusion.
- 30:06I'm glad you touched on jobs because it was something I
- 30:08wanted to speak to you about Bob, because obviously you front
- 30:11the our Union Street campaign, you're really trying to
- 30:14rejuvenate the the city centre out here in Aberdeen.
- 30:18But with oil and gas being such a large employer of the people
- 30:22in the northeast of Scotland, we have seen in recent months and
- 30:26years hundreds of job cut announcements when it when it
- 30:32ties back to this policy discussion we're having.
- 30:35How is that impacting the the initiative that you're trying to
- 30:39run to support Aberdeen says that.
- 30:42I mean, obviously not trying to downplay what has happened, but
- 30:47if you do look at Aberdeen's economy in relation to other
- 30:50parts of Scotland and the UK, we still have a relatively healthy
- 30:55and vibrant economic landscape there.
- 30:58And again, I'm not talking, I'm not talking down specific
- 31:01neighborhoods in Aberdeen that face real challenges about
- 31:05poverty and deprivation. But overall we have lower
- 31:10property costs and higher income levels than many parts of the
- 31:14country. So we still have the potential
- 31:17there for us to enjoy that in terms of a more vibrant city
- 31:21centre. I mean, if you look at Union
- 31:23Square, for instance, it's got a really high occupancy rate.
- 31:27You could argue with hindsight that having Union Square has
- 31:30potentially had an impact on Union Street, but connecting the
- 31:34two together would would help. And also understanding that
- 31:38Union Street needs to move from being what it previously was,
- 31:41was, was was retail into more food, drink, activities, places
- 31:45to see art, whatever that will encourage people to come back
- 31:50into the city centre. Now that challenge is not unique
- 31:53to Aberdeen. That challenge is being replayed
- 31:55across hundreds of communities across the UK and beyond.
- 31:59As as our behaviours change. You know, a big part in that is
- 32:03our online buying habits. You know, about 30% of
- 32:06everything we buy now we're buying online and every time
- 32:10somebody orders a Deliveroo or whatever, they're not going into
- 32:15a restaurant and and therefore they're not necessarily the
- 32:17sport in the same amount of city centre spend or jobs or, or the
- 32:22other things that come from that.
- 32:24And so it's a really interesting point there.
- 32:26So it's quite interesting to contextualizing this as well,
- 32:29because as an energy reporter, obviously everything comes back
- 32:32to the energy sector. So you see, oh, well, not, you
- 32:35know, people aren't spending as much money in the city centre.
- 32:37There's lots of job losses in the city.
- 32:40Maybe those two things are connected, but you don't see
- 32:42that as a. No, I, I, I, I'm, again, I'm not
- 32:46diminishing that at all. However, if you look at some of
- 32:50the work that's that takes place through Opportunity Northeast,
- 32:52for instance, they're supporting different sectors.
- 32:55So food, drink and alcohol sectors, the, the, the, the
- 32:58biomedical sectors, the tourism sectors, the digital sectors.
- 33:04All of these have the potential to create good high quality jobs
- 33:08in the local economy. Most of the work they do,
- 33:11however, is pretty much unknown beyond the people that are
- 33:14directly involved in it. And it's pretty much unknown by
- 33:17the broader public. So if I was to ask some people
- 33:20on the street and on your street, what do you think of the
- 33:22the company startups in the digital space in Aberdeen?
- 33:26I'm sure unless they were involved directly, they would
- 33:28say, I've got no idea about who they are and how many jobs
- 33:31you're talking about. But I do see that there's been a
- 33:34lot of work put in by by Opportunity Northeast and others
- 33:39to recognize that we need diversification in the local
- 33:42economy and that's beginning to happen.
- 33:45So we are getting much more, many more startups and there's
- 33:48investment in buildings and seed pods and the Biohub and new
- 33:52buildings and all that kind of stuff.
- 33:53You think? Yeah, this is encouraging from
- 33:55from my perspective to look at people taking high quality jobs
- 33:59in Aberdeen that are not necessarily so tightly attached
- 34:03to the energy industry, whether that's the the renewables and
- 34:06carbon capture or whether it's oil and gas.
- 34:08So that does it for this OE UK conference edition of Energy
- 34:12Voice Out Loud. Thank you very much for
- 34:14listening. And if you want a sneak peek at
- 34:17what's happening next week, my colleague Michael Baer was
- 34:20speaking about an industry legend who's leaving his mark on
- 34:23Edinburgh. But if you need to find out who
- 34:25that is, well, you're just going to have to stick around and
- 34:28listen next week. But that does it for us.
- 34:31So thank you very much for listening and we'll see you same
- 34:33time, same place on your podcast platform of choice.