Latest / Reclamation Radio / Listener Mailbag: Reclamation Criteria, End Land Use Challenges
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to another episode of Reclamation Radio.
- 0:03My name is Elise Newman, and today will be a listener mailbag episode.
- 0:09So today's question comes from LinkedIn.
- 0:13The question is, "Love that we finally get a podcast dedicated to reclamation efforts.
- One topic I always struggle with is how to assess oil and gas leases that have been changed to end land uses that aren't really covered in the 2010 reclamation criteria.
- Some examples are sites that are now located in cattle corrals, which have no desired vegetation, or dry land corners, which aren't seeded to any tame species, they're just weeds.
- 0:42Just wondering if this could be a discussion."
- So thank you so much for your question, and it's great to hear that other people feel like this podcast is filling a need in the industry.
- I actually think this is a really good example of where reclamation practitioners can balance what is written in the criteria with professional judgment and an understanding of the intent of reclamation certification.
- So we'll start with some background.
- This podcast is really geared towards people that are getting into the industry.
- So, to Go back a little bit, Alberta recognizes four end land uses under the 2010 criteria, and those are cultivated lands, native grasslands, forested lands, and peatlands.
- So these land, end land use categories are defined in the introduction of the criteria documents.
- So if you need to go back and take a look, that's where they are.
- Based on the examples in this question, the site sounds like they would most likely fall under the cultivated land criteria.
- Uh, so the introduction describes cultivated lands as lands managed for agricultural purposes, including lands under zero till practices, so that's kind of where that would fit.
- Before I go much further, one of the first things I would want to know about this specific site, what was the land use before the lease existed? Because the criterias really depend on that.
- The reason that matters is because reclamation is ultimately about achieving equivalent land capability.
- So the conservation and reclamation regulation, we talk about that a lot in the courses, defines equivalent land capability as the ability of the land to support various land uses after reclamation that is similar to the ability that existed before the activity occurred, even though the end land uses themselves do not necessarily have to be identical.
- So if a end land use change has occurred, for example, from native grassland to cultivated land, there should be some level of land manager involvement and documentation supporting that change So for the purposes of this discussion, I'm going to assume that we're talking about privately titled land.
- There are corrals and grazing s-situations on public land, but the examples in this question sound more like privately managed agricultural operations.
- In that case, the land manager would be the private landowner, and if you need the definition of land manager, that's in the criteria as well.
- So speaking from personal ex-experience, I grew up on a cattle farm, and I've worked on sites very similar to what's being described here.
- In heavily used corrals or livestock concentrated areas, vegetation starts getting trampled down until there's very little plant cover remaining.
- It just looks like disturbed soil, and that continuous disturbance can result in large areas of bare soil and a plant community dominated by mostly weed species.
- So you'll see patchy vegetation and just, like, an occasional plant or clumps of plants.
- Once we've identified the applicable end land use and then we understand a little bit about the site history, then the next step is looking at how the specific criteria parameters apply, so we can start getting into the different assessment parameters.
- So the first parameter that comes to mind in this case is bare ground.
- So that's one of the parameters that we consider under the landscape assessment.
- So one thing I would consider is the size and extent of the unvegetated areas, which is what we define as bare ground areas.
- Are the bare areas on the former lease comparable to the bare areas found immediately offsite within the same management unit? So if it's a fenced area within the same fenced area that receives the same amount of pressure, grazing pressure, and use pressure.
- And this is important because the 2010 criteria are based on onsite and offsite comparison.
- If the surrounding corral or management area contains large expanses of bare soil as well, and the reclaimed lease exhibits similar conditions, there may be a reasonable argument that equivalent land capability has been achieved.
- So that's under Section 9 of the cultivated land criteria.
- That's the land assessment section where this is covered.
- It does contemplate bare areas within the broader assessment of site conditions.
- In situations like this, professional judgment becomes important when determining whether onsite condition is actually different from the surrounding area, or is it due to some sort of limiting factor due to the operator disturbing that well site.
- So moving on to another parameter, my guess is that the weed assessment, particularly noxious weeds, are probably where most people are going to run into difficulty from a pass or failed perspective in this example So when you read section 1012 of the criteria, there's a reminder that offsite assessment locations should be representative of the surrounding area or that parcel that is being managed.
- That's really important in cases like this because the offsite comparison points need to reflect the actual condition of the land being managed.
- So when you're collecting weed ratings off lease, you don't necessarily have to limit yourself to the area immediately adjacent to the lease.
- You may be able to look a little farther out, maybe 200 to 500 meters from the lease area, provided it's being managed all in the same way if that's more representative of the overall offsite conditions.
- So that brings me to another policy document that I think is relevant here, third-party impacts to reclamation, and that's the Conservation and Reclamation Information Letter published by the government of Alberta in 1997.
- This guidance addresses situations where actions outside the reasonable control of an operator adversely affect the operator's ability to achieve equivalent land capability or meet reclamation requirements.
- So I could see that potentially applying in some of the scenarios desc- described in this question.
- For example, if a reclaimed site is subsequently incorporated into a heavily used livestock area and ongoing land management practices create conditions that affect vege- vegetation establishment or maintenance, that would warrant consideration under the third-party impact guidance.
- The information letter also discusses obtaining written acceptance of the land condition from the affected land manager or land owner.
- So I think in this case, um, I would be discussing with the landowner and getting things in writing I think in any ser- scenario like this, you would want some sort of, like, written documentation that you've had a conversation with the private landowner, and of course, documenting those site conditions, documenting land management practices, documenting those communications and your rationale, and then retaining that supporting evidence for the reclamation certificate application.
- So to summarize the way that I would approach this, first determine whe- whether there has been a change in end land use and ensure the land manager or private landowner supports and documents that change if required.
- So for instance, if you're changing from forested to cultivated over the lifespan of that lease, this is going back into looking when was the lease first constructed That's where the reviewing those phase ones are important, knowing when the well was constructed.
- You can look at air photos.
- What did that lease look like when it was initially dis- constructed? And that really is the end land use that we're aiming towards when we're thinking about reclamation certification.
- And it's okay to move between the end land uses or maybe an alternate end land use, so one other than the four identified, but kind of the default is going back to one of those four.
- And then the second step, remember that the criteria parameters such as bare ground and weeds are s- assessed in the context of comparable offsite conditions, and you can adapt them to site-specific circumstances.
- That's where professional judgment comes in.
- And then the third step, consider whether s- the situation would qualify as a third-party impact outside of the operator's reasonable control.
- And then finally, s- you gotta document.
- Landowner s- sign off are always going to strengthen a reclamation certificate application, showing that you've had those conversations.
- So at this point in the discussion, I'd like to say I'm a consultant, but I'm not your consultant, so take everything that I say with a grain of salt.
- And if you want a regulatory site-specific answer to this I would encourage you to contact the AER.
- Their, um, their email address for these kind of questions is recremquestions@aer.ca.
- So it's a good idea to kind of check with the regulator if you have questions along the way to check your thought process with them.
- So that was a great question, and it's something that I've thought about as well.
- You know, like, do we need more end land uses or can we work within the framework that we have? Um, I'm fundamentally, like, a creative person, so I like this creative thinking process, but I understand also that, you know, it has its limits, so I'm very interested in hearing what others think about this, if they think that's a feasible line of thinking or, you know, do we need to fun- fundamentally change things, s- something about our policies? I'm really interested in what people think about that you can send questions to me, reclamationradiopodcast@gmail.com,
- or you can contact me on LinkedIn like this person did.
- I welcome that as well.
- So thanks for listening, and I'll talk to you again next time