Latest / Free Cities Podcast / 171 - The Truth About Special Economic Zones | Lotta Moberg
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the Free Cities podcast. My name is Timothy Allen and this is the official podcast
- 0:17of the Free Cities Foundation.
- 0:30Hello and welcome to this episode number 171 of the Free Cities Podcast.
- 0:36This episode is, as always, brought to you by the wonderful Veritas Villages,
- 0:42our lead sponsor here at the Free Cities Podcast.
- 0:45They're building off-grid, freedom-oriented communities in Latin America.
- 0:50Check out their new 340-acre acquisition that just got the go-ahead in Costa Rica.
- 0:57That's going to have almost 400 residences on it.
- 1:00Click on the link in the show notes to inquire about this project and all their other ones.
- 1:06They have places in Nicaragua, Panama, and as I said, Costa Rica.
- 1:10And if you're a Bitcoiner like me, well, you can buy any of your properties in any of their villages with Bitcoin.
- 1:18And they have a policy that you should be able to spend Bitcoin at communities.
- 1:23Basically, they're building Bitcoin citadels.
- 1:25that's what i call them anyway veritasvillages.com forward slash free cities don't forget to mention
- 1:35we sent you hey we've got another sponsor as well this month arc pad which is mitchell such and his
- 1:41company's planning a second iteration of their groundbreaking reef resort in the philippines
- 1:47this time they're planning one off the coast of prospera in honduras which is obviously one of the
- 1:54most important free cities projects in the world and you can purchase ownership in the Prospera
- 2:01Reef Resort. You either do it outright or via fractional shares from as little as one percent
- 2:07right up to full ownership and this I believe is a rare chance to get involved early. If you watch
- 2:13this episode on video about a third of the way through you'll see a little ad that's got nice
- 2:18footage of what's planned for more info tinyurl.com forward slash arc pad that will take you to our
- 2:28sponsorship page and of course we'll get a little commission on top of that so please be sure to
- 2:34mention us if you choose to do business with them right today's show today's guest is a lady by the
- 2:41name of Lotta Moberg. Lotta is an economist, author of our, at the Free Cities podcast that is,
- 2:49favourite book on special economic zones. She spent years studying them, not just as slogans
- 2:55like many people do, but as real political and economic systems. This conversation starts with
- 3:02the standard pitch from me that zones are policy sandboxes. Lotta pushes back on that
- 3:10and we begin to test the claim against incentives.
- 3:14If the experiment, in inverted commas, is simply lower taxes and fewer barriers,
- 3:19was it ever really an experiment or just politics in a lab coat?
- 3:24From there, we zoom out to why zones so often disappoint, actually.
- 3:30Governments can keep subsidising weak results to avoid admitting failure.
- 3:33Local legitimacy can matter more than technocratic design.
- 3:37And the popular story about the success of China's early zones after the communist regime change is actually more complicated than the neat version that certainly I presented in the film, at least.
- 3:53But many other people believe would say.
- 3:55Lotta has a lot of views on things like this.
- 3:58She's very academic about special economic zones and she studied them deeply.
- 4:02And in this conversation, she doesn't hold back, which is great to have all our ideas challenged.
- 4:09In the end, obviously, we connect all the lessons learned to the newer wave of zone thinking,
- 4:15including free cities and charter cities, projects like Prospera,
- 4:20where the bet is, of course, that clearer rules, contract style governance and more credible exit can change the incentive structure
- 4:28that makes conventional zones drift into a sort of theater.
- 4:33Anyway, this is a great episode.
- 4:35Lotta is one of the most notable thinkers on special economic zones,
- 4:41certainly in our game.
- 4:43So take note, lots of alpha here for you all.
- 4:47Quick reminder before we go, also about another offer
- 4:50that I mentioned last week for the first time, Alex Martinov.
- 4:54he's offering pro bono coaching to free city projects if you want to know who alex martinov
- 5:04is go and check out episode 111 that's me basically getting coached by him in the form of a podcast
- 5:10you may remember that my chat with alex was pivotal in my decision to go full-time on this
- 5:16podcast which was obviously a great decision anyway he says um if your project's at a stage
- 5:22where you can't quite afford paid coaching support that's kind of like business coaching
- 5:27alex has created a few spots in his calendar for pro bono coaching which is essentially free of
- 5:35course and this is his way to contribute to the free cities community get in touch with alex at
- 5:42alex at alexmartinov.com to schedule a call with him everything is of course in the show notes as
- 5:50normal right top subs this week on fountain here's the top five might make this a new feature
- 6:00justin bianchi well done mate and this also includes if you're a subscriber this includes
- 6:05the fact that you're subscribing as well justin bianchi number one bullish mike number two
- 6:11nicholas number three shadrach number four and new subscriber there darcy number five well done
- 6:18Darcy and I hope you have a good time on your Bitcoin journey. Darcy contacted me asking for
- 6:25a good starter point on Bitcoin. If anyone else wants to know about that, just drop me a line.
- 6:31I can recommend good ways into the space and to start understanding what's going on. Right,
- 6:37comments. A couple here from last week. Cifrant says the cypherpunks are not bullish enough.
- 6:45That's about the episode.
- 6:46Oh, it's going back a bit.
- 6:47143 with Max Hillebrand, the Praxeology of Privacy.
- 6:51That's something Max said in the interview, and I would tend to agree with him,
- 6:56mainly because he's just really a deep thinker and knows about a lot of stuff.
- 7:01And who have we got here?
- 7:02Ascot.
- 7:04Oh, this is rather nice.
- 7:05If you are interested in real alternatives to the status quo,
- 7:09you need to subscribe to Timothy's Free Cities podcast.
- 7:14deep unfiltered conversations and actionable insights from people doing the work those who
- 7:20build real world pathways to freedom free cities is top tier high signal content concentrated
- 7:27practical and absolutely worth your time that's just an overall comment about the whole podcast
- 7:33well i should basically frame that and make make it our advert shouldn't i many thanks ascot many
- 7:39thanks for listening and many thanks for the kind words right it's time for your top tier content
- 7:44then you lucky things better take it easy this week it's a pretty academic one so you'll
- 7:50definitely need to sit back relax while you enjoy my conversation with lotta moberg
- 8:09So introduce yourself and I'll just check the levels.
- 8:13Hey, my name is Lada Moberg.
- 8:15I written a book on special economic zones Yeah you have And in fact I got a message from Peter our CEO and he said we were talking about who we going to interview on this trip
- 8:30And he said, make sure you do Lotto. I said, why? She said, he said, she's written the best book on SEZs in existence.
- 8:36That's flattering. Thank you.
- 8:36and I mean I haven't read it obviously I've got a feeling Peter's actually read it because I think
- 8:42he used it as source material for our film um in that we made zones of progress yeah did he talk
- 8:49to you about zones of progress when he was making it or no because he we researched he researched
- 8:54the kind of storyline that we I directed it but he he was basically the main bulk of the the
- 9:01narrative okay but I know he was reading lots of books about stuff and I would imagine there
- 9:06aren't a huge amount of books on sez's are there it was wonderful to see the the that video come out
- 9:12and uh there are certainly a lot of lessons that i recognize that i am that i take both that i took
- 9:19away from my analysis my book but also that were kind of a little bit conventional wisdom that i
- 9:23kind of synthesized when i when i wrote my book um so yeah but so what do you think of that film
- 9:30then and the narrative because the narrative was i don't know it was probably the first time it was
- 9:35committed to film was the the kind of evolution to places like prospera of sez sez of the old
- 9:44stuff from like you know shannon airport and and you know maozi and like china and all that stuff
- 9:51and difc was is well known but the kind of new the new iteration is like where we are now is
- 9:59wasn't that well known about really i don't think and there wasn't a lot out there i don't think
- 10:04there were many people making the connection the evolutionary connection of them is that fair to say
- 10:09yeah and if i if i would take a step back to think about when i started looking at these things so
- 10:13when i um as you mentioned the question in the beginning like the scholarship of special economic
- 10:19zones this was something that i wanted to read myself and i wanted to write about free cities
- 10:25and it was really so this is to take even further back this was in uh like 2009 i think it was when
- 10:32Paul Romer had his talk on charter cities. So that was the talk of the town, the charter cities.
- 10:38And I wanted to write about that. And I wanted to use the research on special economic zones to
- 10:44then draw lessons from what this means, the implication, what goes right or wrong
- 10:48from a political economy perspective. But that's kind of where I'm coming from in my studies.
- 10:54So, and I started digging into it and I realized there was no research to really use to do the
- 11:00studies that I wanted to do. So I just ended up writing on special economic zones. And I thought,
- 11:04okay, well, I'll take that first step then. And then somebody can build upon that. And that
- 11:08happened pretty quickly. I'm kind of surprised it's not more both research on special economic
- 11:13zones, because I don't think my words is the final word at all. But on that topic, and then
- 11:18we have seen after that, I would point out Mark Lutter, who was my classmate at George Macy
- 11:25university we both did a phd there and also vera kichanoa she also wrote her dissertation
- 11:32and that was under mark pennington on this new kind of songs and i know that they both were aware
- 11:38of my work especially her because she was i think she's a little bit younger in terms of her
- 11:42educational when she did her phd so but that is when it comes to the lessons and we started talking
- 11:49about this from that video,
- 11:52there were tidbits that were out there
- 11:55of studies of special economic zones
- 11:57and hints at this might be right,
- 11:59this might be wrong,
- 12:00this might be how it kind of happened,
- 12:01but no framework really out there
- 12:03floating about how to think about zones,
- 12:06both the economics of it
- 12:07and the political economy of it,
- 12:09especially that I was focusing on.
- 12:11I'm not sure, Lotta,
- 12:12that I know what political economies are.
- 12:15What does that mean?
- 12:16Can you give me that 101
- 12:18on what a political economy is.
- 12:20I mean, that's also the name of the book,
- 12:22The Political Economy of SEZs.
- 12:24But you're talking,
- 12:25you've just mentioned political economies twice.
- 12:27And I'm not sure I know what they are.
- 12:29I might be a little bit too George Mason for this,
- 12:31but I think that you can't talk about political economy
- 12:33without talking about public choice.
- 12:36And public choice is basically the extension
- 12:38of utility maximization to people in political positions.
- 12:43So in neoclassical framework,
- 12:44often you have,
- 12:46there's an assumption that the economic man optimizes perfectly their economic decisions
- 12:51to maximize utility. The policymaker optimizes to maximize the economic man's utility. The
- 12:58policymaker in these neoclassical frameworks is not actually a person. It's kind of this omniscient
- 13:02and well-wanting, benevolent kind of dictator person who then sets the optimal tax rate,
- 13:10who sets the optimal regulations and everything like that. And of course, what's optimal in that
- 13:14case might not agree with the people who are creating those models. The political economy
- 13:19says, the political economy aspect is thinking about it from how policymakers then actually
- 13:25like taking the political part of our world, which unfortunately is such a big part of where
- 13:31we're living here now, and saying that's also a part where maximization happens. You can't
- 13:36understand why decisions are made without thinking about the people who actually make the decision
- 13:42what they're actually pursuing.
- 13:43And just assuming that they're trying to maximize utility of you, the citizen,
- 13:47is just incorrect.
- 13:49So it has a different axiom.
- 13:51It's not we used the model and used different data
- 13:55and then concluded that policymakers have different utility functions.
- 14:00You can, of course, do that.
- 14:01There's a lot of studies also.
- 14:02Usually they support the political economy view of things.
- 14:06But at its foundation, it's a different axiom that says,
- 14:09wait a minute, how can you classify people?
- 14:11these are humans over here they're trying to do what's best for themselves and these are these
- 14:15benevolent dictators sitting here and they're like not people even though my uncle isn't you know
- 14:20it might be a senator or whatever and i know he's a person you know is it i mean so that's a function
- 14:26of um i mean did it always used to be like that thinking about it is that a function of a modern
- 14:33politics that i mean was there a time when politicians did try to maximize the utility of
- 14:39people oh i mean because i don't know i maybe i look back with rosy rose tinted glasses but
- 14:46it seems like maybe they had our best interests at heart at some point is that is that not true
- 14:53you probably know i don't it it kind of demands an historian to think about the different regimes
- 14:58that have happened in the past and have they ever been benevolent i mean if you think about why the
- 15:03roman empire fell it wasn't because they wasn't they weren't benevolent enough for something like
- 15:08that. They inflamed the currency for their own purposes. So I think humans have always been
- 15:15humans. We care about ourselves. We care about our family. We care about the people around us.
- 15:20We're at our foundation. I believe that we're good people. But we're flawed in that sense that
- 15:25we also do have these models that are not just about, I'm going to sacrifice for being this
- 15:30civil servant, right? And just maximize everybody else's utility. It just kind of doesn't make
- 15:36sense um the scholarship of this also goes back hundreds of years there is um and this you have to
- 15:42ask one of my professors george mason who is now retired with richard wagner is the one who's
- 15:47written about this there's an italian economist hundreds of years ago who was really the maybe
- 15:54foundational person of political economy and then way later you have americans like jim buchanan and
- 16:00things like that writing on on these kind of topics developing the field so to speak
- 16:04I'm just thinking as well probably it's I mean the misunderstanding that
- 16:11benevolent actors exist is probably due to the I mean the way people view economics as well I mean
- 16:21Keynesian economists would probably misunderstand that but maybe
- 16:27Austrians wouldn't is that fair to say Austrians might see that political people are acting in their
- 16:33own interest and so are other people that the other the members of the society and stuff I don know It a little moot point I suppose I think it a contradiction in a way of the when we talk about
- 16:46so Keynesian is kind of an offshoot of neoclassic economics,
- 16:49but it's not really neoclassic economics
- 16:51because there's a lot of things built onto that,
- 16:53which says that, well, you don't get the supply and demand equilibrium there.
- 16:57You also get excess, often a deficient demand,
- 17:01animal spirits somehow suppress demand
- 17:03And therefore, the benevolent government has to step in to rectify that.
- 17:09And there's a kind of a disconnect between saying, well, people, everybody's maximizing their own self-interest.
- 17:17But at the same time, so that means that, oh, we have to really like police everybody's behavior then because they're going to walk around and, you know, and shoot each other down and take their money.
- 17:27But on the other hand, any neoclassical model suggests that if everybody optimizes, then you get the optimal kind of outcome from that.
- 17:34So then the Keynesians step in and make it a case for big government by saying, well, sure, but the models don't really work out that way.
- 17:42It doesn't really work that way.
- 17:44You have deficient demand sometimes.
- 17:45Animal spirits kick in and distort this neoclassical picture.
- 17:49So that's how you kind of explain why you have business cycles and things like that.
- 17:53so I am from the Austrian school so I definitely think that's the more proper way of looking at it
- 18:01we have most of us reverence for a lot of the insights of Adam Smith thinking about this way
- 18:08of how the economy actually is self-governing you have Frederick Hayek writing a lot about
- 18:12the emergent order of things it's he doesn't say that things are perfect he says that when we come
- 18:18together and we're trying to figure things out and I come up with something I'm good at and I
- 18:22discovered that if I do this little thing in in a world where our skills are complementary I can
- 18:28actually live a good life just doing that so Paul Romer got you into free cities right that's
- 18:34interesting and I mean is it is it free cities all the way or was the SEZ thing just something
- 18:40that you did because there was nothing out there really to pursue in the in the in the realm of
- 18:47free cities, which at the time there already wasn't, was there? That's how it started. And then
- 18:52when I also realized another thing, being at George Mason and being a free market person,
- 18:59I have biases. Everybody's got biases. And we, in this school, would be more conscious about our
- 19:04biases than others. But being conscious of bias means that you also are very conscious about
- 19:08policing those biases and coming from a standpoint when your biases doesn't lead you to a conclusion
- 19:13that might in any way be wrong from a scholarship kind of perspective.
- 19:17And I started thinking about special economic zones.
- 19:20And the more I thought about it, the less obvious it was.
- 19:23And that's how it actually became a lot of these questions.
- 19:25Like, why are they even there?
- 19:26Do they make sense?
- 19:27I started talking to some of my professors.
- 19:29I was floating the idea.
- 19:30How about special economic zones?
- 19:31What do you think?
- 19:32And these people who would agree on basically everything
- 19:35when it comes to economics, you know,
- 19:36they're for small government and all of that,
- 19:38they could have 100% opposite views on special economic zones from the, obviously it's a good
- 19:45thing because if they lower taxes and lower tariffs and things like that, if there's any
- 19:50loosening of regulation, it's a good thing. We should support that. And the other camp would be
- 19:54100% by definition. It was all by definition based on the first step from their axioms, right,
- 20:00of a free market would be absolutely clearly it's a bad thing because if you think that
- 20:05liberalization is good you should do it for the country as a whole if you in any way have power
- 20:09over a country and that's kind of per definition what a special economic zone is it's choosing
- 20:14not to implement a policy over the full territory but instead picking up this little sliver of the
- 20:19territory um then it's clearly wrong like it's clear something distorted about that and it was
- 20:26interesting coming out of those meetings that i'm like there is no clear answer now i have some now
- 20:31i have a kind of a question to answer that it doesn't like that doesn't answer itself from the
- 20:35What did those people say when you mentioned the idea of a sandbox, an SEZ being a sandbox, like in China, for example?
- 20:43You know, when you go from communism to a free market, if you tried rolling out some free market ideas throughout China, it would be complete mayhem.
- 20:52But there was this opportunity.
- 20:54OK, well, let's try it in a small geographic region, Xinjiang or, I don't know, Zhuhai or something.
- 20:59And if it works, which it obviously will, you and I both know it will work anyway.
- 21:04then you get the option to to to roll it out because that's hard to argue again isn't it
- 21:10argue against isn't it no it's not hard to argue against i don't think that i can i don't think i
- 21:16really got into that in that early stage because i wasn't really sure myself what i would have
- 21:20thought would be the strength and then what the real promises was in special economic zones
- 21:25the argument against saying well it's a sandbox is first well if it's if you're pursuing
- 21:33policies that amount to just lowering the cost of doing business, such as lowering the taxes,
- 21:41tariffs. We already know you get more activity. You're going to get, you don't need to test
- 21:45anything out. Now you're just playing with us to say like, oh, we're going to see what happens.
- 21:49Like, you know, what's going to happen. So that's just theater. And I like that. I agree with that.
- 21:55Like that's, I think is a good argument for it. I'd like to take a couple of minutes just to tell
- 22:00you about what I think is one of the most interesting real-world freedom projects that
- 22:04we've come across recently. If you've been listening to this podcast for a while, you'll
- 22:08know that I'm always looking for things that actually exist, not the concepts, not the
- 22:13renderings, but real projects where people are already building the future. And this brings me
- 22:17to the Reef Resort, developed by the seasteading company ArcPad, founded of course by Mitchell
- 22:23Suchner, who many of you will remember was the winner of the Innovation Award at the 2025
- 22:28Free Cities Conference. The Reef Resort, as far as we're aware, is the world's first operational
- 22:34seasteading resort. It's located just off the coast of Samal Island in the Philippines,
- 22:39where ArcPad currently operates. 14 floating units available through Airbnb and other platforms,
- 22:45a project that has already hosted thousands of guests in both their accommodation and floating
- 22:51restaurant. Now, here's the development that will be especially interesting to listeners of this
- 22:56podcast. ArcPad is planning a second reef resort, this time off the coast of Prospera in Honduras,
- 23:03one of the most important Free Cities projects in the world. And construction is intended to align
- 23:08with the 2026 Free Cities Conference. So this is where the opportunity comes for you. You can now
- 23:14pre-purchase ownership in the Prospera Reef Resort. Ownership is available either outright
- 23:19or through fractional shares, allowing you to purchase from as little as 1% up to full ownership.
- 23:25Your ownership percentage determines your usage rights, your share of rental income from the
- 23:30eco-resort operations, and your voting power in property decisions. This also gives you the
- 23:35opportunity, of course, to be part of a pioneering ocean-based development within the Free Cities
- 23:40ecosystem. Full units at the Prospera site start from $95,000, but with fractional ownership
- 23:47available, you can participate at whatever level suits you. If you'd like to explore this
- 23:52opportunity, I've included a link in the show notes where you can register your interest and
- 23:57access the pre-purchase information. If you're interested in free cities, frontier living and
- 24:02the future of ocean-based communities, then this is a chance to get involved at the ground floor.
- 24:08Seasteading is no longer just an idea. It's happening and now it's coming to prosperer.
- 24:15But what about, I mean, China's a really specific case. They had no property, for example. So they're
- 24:21going from communism to you know property markets for example i mean there must be a element of
- 24:29truth to the to the idea that if you tried rolling that out to one point whatever billion people
- 24:35that's crazy well i would ensue mayhem would ensue whereas if you try it out in a small area
- 24:42um it's a good political transition or a good maybe that's part of the political economy i don't
- 24:47a good transition would occur better than otherwise.
- 24:52That sounds good in theory I have not found good examples of how that actually how it works I don want to like dismiss people make that argument It possible that that happens sometimes but it is a kind of benevolent dictator view of how nation states work
- 25:07And that's quite uncommon to see that.
- 25:10And it actually, but when I went in too, that's what was written on special economic zones in depth was mostly kind of World Bank papers, case studies.
- 25:19And there were some like interesting observations and with some ideas out there.
- 25:23And Thomas Farol was a person who was at the World Bank at the time.
- 25:26We ended up co-authoring together later on Special Economic Zones, who was influential in the sense that he'd written things, but without really trying to have an academic framework around it.
- 25:37In the China case, it might look like that.
- 25:40It was like, so here is one story.
- 25:42Deng Xiaoping was this free market person, or he wanted to reform, but he wanted to do it in a cautious way.
- 25:48Came up with Special Economic Zones, and boom.
- 25:50He was against Special Economic Zones.
- 25:51He was just like the other caterers.
- 25:53They launched it in 78, really 79 kind of is when it got going, the first zone.
- 26:00And he was against it up until 84, I think it was.
- 26:02And that's when they kind of allowed for expansion of the program.
- 26:05What happened was it was a bottom-up process.
- 26:07It was people, it was businessmen in Guangdong kind of area on the other side of Hong Kong
- 26:13that wanted to do business across the pond with Hong Kong.
- 26:17And so they lobbied the local governments to allow for this zone.
- 26:21And the local governments somehow,
- 26:24regardless of the gene,
- 26:24there were probably a lot of brown envelopes
- 26:26on the table involved.
- 26:27They said, okay, have this zone then.
- 26:29Not a big deal.
- 26:31And then they saw all of a sudden,
- 26:33there's a trade-off if you're a,
- 26:35what I can assume in this case,
- 26:39a lot of, it wasn't this case,
- 26:41but a lot of countries, it's this case,
- 26:43we can assume that they are quite corrupt.
- 26:45And there's a trade-off between,
- 26:47am I protecting my local cronies
- 26:48or am I going to allow for less regulation,
- 26:51not protect them through regulations and other things,
- 26:54and allow for a free market, which would maybe increase,
- 26:57which will increase business activity, increase the tax revenues I'm getting.
- 27:01And all of a sudden they saw that, wow, all of a sudden we have a growing economy here.
- 27:06And now, of course, we have Shenzhen becoming a zone and growing in that area.
- 27:11So what happens then is that business starts flowing from other regions to them.
- 27:16And now this region is saying, wait a minute, this is not working out as well.
- 27:19my cronies are disappearing. I'm not getting as much pay anymore. So they start looking at what
- 27:24are they doing right? And it spread like that. So it was very much a local process that was not
- 27:30because of the communist party were benevolent and thinking they should reform. But they saw that,
- 27:36actually, this could actually be good for us. So they saw the experiment, but it wasn't really
- 27:41a conscious kind of, we have a lab, kind of very conscious experiment, kind of became an experiment
- 27:48that they could observe and then say, okay.
- 27:50And then like it was 1992 that they allowed
- 27:53for all the regional capitals to become their own kind of zones.
- 27:56And that's when they really put their green stamp on it.
- 28:00Like, yeah, we're supporting this now.
- 28:01We may have told a little fib in the film then.
- 28:04Well, at least the way I interpreted it,
- 28:07the four main zones at the beginning
- 28:10were kind of like a thoughtful process by the government.
- 28:14All right, let's do this.
- 28:15You're saying it's not?
- 28:16No, I think it's a little bit.
- 28:17But they kind of cashed in on it.
- 28:19They cashed in on it.
- 28:21Yeah, it depends on how you tell the story.
- 28:22And there's not that much written.
- 28:24So I'm not going to say that the sources that I have is like the perfect truth.
- 28:28But there is a book called, I think it's called The Political Economy of China,
- 28:33Special Economic Zones or something like that.
- 28:35Oh, wow. Perfect.
- 28:36Right. And it sounds like, oh, well, you just copied that.
- 28:38No, it wasn't The Political Economy of it in terms of a framework.
- 28:42The book was just telling what happened.
- 28:44And then they met.
- 28:45And then this happened.
- 28:46And then these had a meeting and then they decided this, you know, so you can then understand the process and putting your framework around and building a framework around it.
- 28:56I mean, one thing I did, I have always thought in the case of China is that I think no matter what you would have cited opposite Hong Kong would have done really well inside China.
- 29:08Doesn't matter. Do you know what I mean? Like Shenzhen was if when you say, well, Shenzhen is one of the powerhouses of, you know, China now.
- 29:15And that's because of, you know, the fact that it was a special economic zone.
- 29:19I can't help thinking, well, yeah, it's also right near Hong Kong.
- 29:23So obviously Hong Kong is going to do business.
- 29:26Hong Kong is super successful and really does, you know, generate a lot of wealth and a lot of everything.
- 29:32So I don't know. I'm you're the expert, though.
- 29:36but that's new i hadn't heard that before so i wonder what else we got wrong in the film
- 29:40so so um i don't remember that was a lot that i thought that was wrong so well but the thing is
- 29:47in the film peter because peter spent quite a while in china right and he speaks he speaks
- 29:52is cantonese or whichever whichever one it is and he talked about a policy that the chinese
- 29:59government had and he says it in the film and it's like or whatever you know something like that
- 30:05And it means feeling for the stones under your feet when you're crossing a river or something like that.
- 30:11Crossing a river by feeling the stones.
- 30:12Right.
- 30:12You know this thing, right?
- 30:14But that was the way they decided.
- 30:16He connected that with special economic zones, which was they want to reform, but they're going to do it in a tentative way to begin with.
- 30:24And that involves the zones.
- 30:26I think that's right.
- 30:27A little bit later.
- 30:28It's just that it's not quite how it started.
- 30:30It was just a messier start than people want to.
- 30:32It's fine.
- 30:33We always want to tell a story that is neat so that people don't get too confused, which is absolutely fine.
- 30:38It's just these first few years, it was a more trembling thing and it did start.
- 30:43And I do think that it's a good case for bottom-up processes and decentralization, that it actually did happen on a local level.
- 30:52And this was very much thanks to this.
- 30:53And here there's a good amount of scholarship about how decentralized, both politically and economically, China was for a period.
- 31:01It has gone up and down. And I don't think it's that decentralized, as decentralized anymore. But I do think still people underestimate how decentralized China is. And there's quite a lot of papers written on, and I won't be able to cite them now, but about how various reforms came about through, thanks to the political and economic fiscal, I should say, decentralization of China. And both of those are necessary conditions.
- 31:25because if you can't, political means I can do something.
- 31:28I can change it and it changes where I live.
- 31:31And fiscal means I have an incentive to do it.
- 31:33If I make things better and increase tax revenues in my local area,
- 31:38it doesn't all flow to the center and I won't see it.
- 31:40So I have an incentive to make those reforms.
- 31:42How far back did you go historically then in your research?
- 31:46Not a lot.
- 31:47I focused on, I think China is the one that goes back furthest really
- 31:54when you look deeply into kind of a process that happened.
- 31:58I mean, I tell the story of special economic zones.
- 32:01There's a little bit like you can think about the Hanseatic League
- 32:04as a kind of league of different zones.
- 32:05But you mentioned Shannon in the beginning of our conversation here.
- 32:09And that was really the first kind of industrial park
- 32:11where it's like the government says we're going to have this zone here.
- 32:14And that was famously because it used to be that
- 32:16if you're going to fly across the Atlantic,
- 32:18you have to stop somewhere to refuel.
- 32:21And Ireland is the perfect place to stop and refuel.
- 32:24and um so thanks to that there was an economy around that and then technology advanced and
- 32:30you don't have to stop in ireland anymore and they said oh no what are we going to do
- 32:33so they created this zone to boost the economy which is a perfect example of why zones work i
- 32:39think you can get a better version of a zone than that because it's it takes a lot to fly a plane
- 32:44that you don't you don't need to fly via shannon but oh let's do it anyway because you know there's a
- 32:50there's a benefit to us, which is the whole point of special
- 32:52economic zones as far as I'm concerned. How far back can you
- 32:55go? What do you know, just from my own personal interest here, in
- 32:59the a lot of people site a lot of different places as I was
- 33:03modeling SEZs historically and stuff.
- 33:06Yeah, I haven't looked that far. So so they're probably going
- 33:09to be better people out there to think about equivalents,
- 33:14historical analogies. But in terms of zones, like we know
- 33:18them, and those are traditionally
- 33:20Additionally, your, you know, your industrial zones.
- 33:23Before you have industry, it's hard to say that you have industrial zone.
- 33:26Before industry, then it was more about trade generally.
- 33:29But trade was free.
- 33:31Like the transaction costs were still high because of technology.
- 33:34But in many episodes, it hasn't like trade was disrupted by wars and things like that, invasions.
- 33:41but I don't I think it's fair to say that the stone concepts that we can actually learn from as a
- 33:47in the form that we're seeing it now is not as doesn't go back hundreds of years I don't know
- 33:54if it's helpful it could be helpful if you're a historian to make the analogies and maybe draw
- 33:58some lessons but that has not been my focus and do you think there's a lot of research out there
- 34:02now because what there's over 6 000 zones right it's very well tried and tested methodology
- 34:08behind zones, the kind of, the core.
- 34:11Is there a lot known and written and said about them?
- 34:14Not that I know of.
- 34:16I don't think there's much that come out.
- 34:17There are specific countries.
- 34:18There's one scholar that writes about
- 34:20the special economic zones of India, for example.
- 34:23I think her name is Agarwal.
- 34:24And things like that, that I see coming through, but.
- 34:29Why is that then?
- 34:30They seem like they're, I don't know,
- 34:32maybe because we're in this place, in this world,
- 34:36and it's all about, you know, creating zones and maximizing the zone
- 34:41and all this kind of stuff.
- 34:43I'm surprised that there aren't more people talking about it
- 34:46because, all right, and I suppose I have quite a brutal view of it.
- 34:52You're a much deeper thinker than me on stuff like this,
- 34:55but it does seem a bit obvious why zones work
- 34:59and why you should use zones to do things.
- 35:03Yeah.
- 35:03So why aren't more people either doing it?
- 35:06Well, I suppose 6,000 zones is quite a lot of people doing it.
- 35:09But why isn't it more commonly understood that this is a brilliant tool?
- 35:15Yeah.
- 35:15So why there's not much scholarship?
- 35:17I think you hit on one.
- 35:18One is that people think it's going to be obvious.
- 35:20So if I'm going to have this big, if I'm going to write my dissertation on it or something like that, then you might have, if you have a preconceived notion that you already know your answer, if you're a wise enough scholar, then you might not pursue it for that reason.
- 35:31The second reason I think is just like I said, in terms of the motivation behind it, a government doesn't really want to have an answer they don't like.
- 35:41If they are decided that they want a zone program, they are not going to commission people to study, figure out whether the zones is a good idea because they already made up their mind.
- 35:52They don't want that to come out in any different direction.
- 35:55And as I explain in my book, zones are often pursued for political reasons.
- 36:02That doesn't mean it's always a bad thing.
- 36:04They can still, you know, all the things that we talk about, you know, increase employment and exports and economic activity as a whole.
- 36:12It can definitely do that.
- 36:13But it's their pursuit often for political reason that sometimes suggest that had this tool had not been available, they would actually have maybe liberalized more broadly in the whole country.
- 36:27Now, a third reason I would say, why isn't more scholarship?
- 36:30Because it would be obvious that it should be in the field of economics.
- 36:36It's like an export policy.
- 36:38So economists go out and look at zones.
- 36:40And there are papers trying to do this, answering the question, is this good for an economy?
- 36:44And it's actually really hard to do.
- 36:46There are two ways usually you see people studying this.
- 36:48One is to compare the special economic zones area with the economic development of the rest of the country over, say, the 10, 20 years after a zone in this area was open.
- 36:58So that's fair enough.
- 36:59We have a zone.
- 37:00We know that it's a zone.
- 37:01We know people are working there.
- 37:02So we know there should be some kind of impact.
- 37:03Is it good or bad?
- 37:04And they conclude that the zones are good because there's more economic activity here in the rest of the country.
- 37:09That doesn't answer, in my mind, was the zone a good idea?
- 37:12Because if the companies that were already in the country just moved from outside the zone to inside the zone,
- 37:17all you did was the transaction cost of moving from one place to the other.
- 37:21And yeah, there's a marginal.
- 37:22Of course, they got paid lower taxes, so they could employ more people.
- 37:27So maybe on net, but just saying that the economic activity was higher in the zone doesn't answer the question where there was a good idea for the economy as a whole.
- 37:34Did you get economic development and all that?
- 37:35The other way that you see people doing it, and I've seen two papers of this, not well cited because they can't be good papers, is to try to compare GDP growth between countries that have some programs that don't have some programs.
- 37:48Now, anything GDP growth is very difficult, right?
- 37:51You have to have many decades.
- 37:53And the more decades you have, the more factors you have to control for.
- 37:56You know, regime changes and wars happen.
- 37:59And how many dummies do you want to throw in there?
- 38:01And once you have your very multivariable thing, you have to then decide what kind of model you're going to use because of the time series aspects of it.
- 38:10There's a lot of issues with your data.
- 38:12And at the end, you might come up with a coefficient or not.
- 38:15And often it's going to be a coefficient in one direction, but not statistically significant, meaning you can't really determine whether this was a random noise or not that we saw that it was a good or a bad thing for the economy.
- 38:29and you also have to be very careful that the zone program actually was launched in terms of the
- 38:33were they allowed for the the permits to open the zones and actually have them working because
- 38:39that sometimes happens too like oh there's a program in this country and it might take 20
- 38:43years until they actually come into effect um lada you're the first person i've spoken to about
- 38:48this is making me think they're not a good idea now i mean like i'm glad to hear all this stuff
- 38:54because you're painting, I like it,
- 38:57painting a very neutral picture, which is good
- 38:58because I think we talk always in the positive
- 39:02about these kind of things.
- 39:03But it makes sense because we're not in the business
- 39:05of special economic zones, right?
- 39:07We should remember when I talk about special economic zones,
- 39:09I talk about these things that governments start
- 39:12often for meeting certain criteria,
- 39:15meeting certain metrics like increase exports
- 39:18or increase employment and things like that.
- 39:20And that is not our business, right?
- 39:21We are thinking about how to create communities from a bottom-up level that actually attracts people in a very different way, right?
- 39:29We don't have...
- 39:30Part of our strength is that we don't have the resources that a government has, right?
- 39:35Because what you often see with special development zones, unfortunately, is that the less profitable or less beneficial they are for the economy,
- 39:44the more money is being invested in them from the government standpoint.
- 39:49Why?
- 39:49because they put their name on it and they don't want it to fail so they want to make sure they
- 39:53fail so they increase taxes for the rest of the economy to put more and more money into this so
- 39:57one i wrote one paper on ghana and the temais the port there that um have a zone and people cite this
- 40:06now as a it was such a great project and all that but forever it was just a dump of money they didn't
- 40:12there wasn't any road going to it really so they just kept having to subsidize it because
- 40:17not enough industry wanted to establish themselves there.
- 40:22So if you look at the whole history of that zone, for example, in Ghana,
- 40:26it's like, look, of all I can tell, this was a big waste for the government.
- 40:32And then what happened, this was early 2000, 2006, around there, I think,
- 40:37World Bank stepped in and said, we're just going to throw money at this.
- 40:40Well, where does that money come?
- 40:42It's not because the World Bank is a profitable industry, right?
- 40:44So they now throw a lot of money.
- 40:47And now it is its own. It works, absolutely.
- 40:49But it's like from a very long history of not working,
- 40:53not working in terms of they have to throw so much money at it,
- 40:57I would say that was not like,
- 40:58it did not benefit the people of that country, would be my guess.
- 41:01What do you think then about the idea or the notion
- 41:04that governments might create free city type projects?
- 41:10Sounds like it would be a bad idea.
- 41:13But really, I mean, by its nature, you're working,
- 41:16well, most people are working in corroboration
- 41:19with the government, but for governments to then look
- 41:23at that in other countries and go,
- 41:24that seemed to work in say Honduras, oh, that worked.
- 41:29Why don't we try our same thing?
- 41:31Do you think that's not a good idea?
- 41:34No it a great idea in the way that I all the projects that I seeing have these the two components that I think are necessary for it to be successful and beneficial for the
- 41:45country is, one, there has to be some incentive for the government to keep it running, which
- 41:50often is some kind of share agreement.
- 41:52There's some kind of fees that get paid royalties that go to the government where you say, when
- 41:57we're profitable, or maybe even before we're profitable, we're going to be paying you money.
- 42:01So you're not going to lose any revenue from this.
- 42:03you started an area often
- 42:06where it's very sparsely populated.
- 42:07So if you're going to say you're going to lower taxes,
- 42:09you can see how much money
- 42:11is on the line here for the government.
- 42:14So it's definitely like,
- 42:16then you can definitely create the areas
- 42:20if the government has the right incentive.
- 42:22And the other part is not having the people on the side
- 42:26and seeing that it's beneficial,
- 42:27making them understand what this is doing.
- 42:29It's that it's not a neocolonial kind of project
- 42:31or anything like that.
- 42:32Because that creates sustainability, of course, of, you know, when you have the next election, next government comes in and then paints it in a bad light because it was the prior regime and things like that and convinces the people that, you know, this is a bad thing for you.
- 42:45If people see that there is money flowing out of it or the people living there seeing that there's more jobs created, that's beneficial for everyone.
- 42:54Then you actually have a test bed, so to speak, a sandbox, as you said, for a form that could be showcased for others to other companies coming in and striking the same deal with the government.
- 43:08maybe the government doing a similar thing and understanding that this kind of regulatory freedom and autonomy can be beneficial.
- 43:17I mean, it's...
- 43:18But I wouldn't call that special economic zones in the classical sense, right?
- 43:20We're starting from a very like bottom-up perspective as an outsider for the government.
- 43:26Especially, I think, in the form we see them now in Honduras as well.
- 43:30It makes the government look really bad.
- 43:32And in fact, I was chatting to, oh my brain, it's too late in the day, Mr. Morazan, the guy, Massimo, I was speaking to Massimo, Jesus.
- 43:48Took me a couple of seconds for you.
- 43:49Yeah, it's too late in the day, Lotta.
- 43:52Massimo basically is saying there's actually been a really interesting change in public attitude,
- 43:59especially in the locale, in the locale, locality of Morazan recently.
- 44:06Okay.
- 44:06Because, and as you know, the government there is doing really badly as well.
- 44:10And I think it seems to be happening quite commonly that they,
- 44:14it's certainly with regards to the special with regards to the ZAs that people are now looking at
- 44:19them going wait a minute all that stuff they told us it was crap it was bullshit and he told me that
- 44:25he said that this is what is known in Chaloma it's spoken about and maybe we should clarify for
- 44:30those who don't know you said ZAs very quickly so these are the zones for economic and development
- 44:34that are that the Honduran government set up right in the 2010s I hope the audience knows that
- 44:40I talk about them a lot well hopefully you're getting new people to listen to this all the time
- 44:44So there might be new people here.
- 44:45How far did you go in the book?
- 44:47Did you touch on any of the sort of modern iterations?
- 44:50No, it was really in the end where I have a chapter on kind of saying
- 44:54where are the kind of two things.
- 44:56One is where are the zones that are leading the way towards
- 44:59more regulatory reforms as opposed to just fiscal
- 45:02and pointing at the, you mentioned the financial center in Dubai
- 45:07and things like that.
- 45:08And South Korea had some interesting things.
- 45:11And then I also kind of did a little bit speculation.
- 45:13but about how the zones of the future can be these more autonomous areas
- 45:20and how the lessons from the industrial parks kind of point in that direction.
- 45:26The big thing that I think is common wisdom now that I feel wasn't at the time,
- 45:32but the World Bank writer on this, Thomas Farol,
- 45:36I remember mentioning in one publication kind of in passing
- 45:39was that privately developed zones are better than government-run zones,
- 45:44government-run and developed zones.
- 45:45And so that points to a direction that all the initiatives should be on the private basis.
- 45:52But that still points to, when I make that just a position,
- 45:57it's still like government initiatives,
- 45:58but whether the government allows for the private sector to develop and run the zones
- 46:03as opposed to running them themselves.
- 46:04Really? So that's commonly understood now?
- 46:07I think that most people would say that, yeah.
- 46:10That's a good, I think it's pretty good.
- 46:12Doesn't mean that all the new zones that are, you know, follow that model at all.
- 46:15Well, I mean, there aren't that many new zones really, are there?
- 46:17I mean, are you talking about, you know, real free city type projects or just even new special economic zones?
- 46:25Special economic zones.
- 46:26There are new ones that happen.
- 46:27I mean, there's a lot of governments.
- 46:29I don't follow it 100%.
- 46:30I know that there are zones in Africa where you do have a mixed bag between government throwing concrete at a place.
- 46:37And usually that doesn't go very far.
- 46:38they run out of money um and or people who understand that you need the private sector and
- 46:45and you have a developer and people pursuing this is for to make money which means that they
- 46:50want to invite companies that are promising promising to stay promising to develop and
- 46:55and hire people and things like that so yeah i think um i would think that there are more and
- 47:01more private zones and but it's hard to say i haven't seen any like really good surveys coming
- 47:08at like lately on trying to list them and compare them i feel like there was a drive there was a
- 47:14greek interest from the world bank side there um in the kind of early 2000s to write a lot about
- 47:19that and the people who were writing at the time i know have moved on to like other things
- 47:22part of it being practitioner and setting up zones absolutely so yeah do you know do you happen to
- 47:29know what people at that level think of say prosper for example and the z8s i don't know i
- 47:34I don't know in what circles you revolve,
- 47:36but I certainly don't revolve in anything to do with the World Bank
- 47:40or anything like that.
- 47:42Are they considered a cute little experiment?
- 47:45Or are they like we think of them as probably game-changing projects
- 47:50that might lead to who knows what?
- 47:53I'm not in those circles either.
- 47:56I'm in the private sector, so I can only speculate.
- 47:59I think most people think of it as a cute experiment
- 48:03and don't look at that carefully.
- 48:05It's not, if you're in the World Bank,
- 48:07you're not paid to think about the new things
- 48:09that are not kind of, haven't existed on the ground
- 48:14that long or made a big economic impact.
- 48:16But for sure, if you're the Honduran,
- 48:20the economist covering Honduras very soon,
- 48:23you won't be able probably.
- 48:25So that would be encouraging, right?
- 48:26You can't be, you might not be able
- 48:28to seriously write your report on the country
- 48:30without mentioning what happens in a big part of the economy
- 48:35once it is a big part of the economy.
- 48:36So what do you think about it then?
- 48:38What do you think about the whole ZA thing
- 48:40and the new versions that are sort of popping up
- 48:44and in the pipeline, you know, of a few,
- 48:45there's some that we can't mention.
- 48:47What do you think of it?
- 48:49Cute or life-changing?
- 48:50No, I think it's, well, per definition,
- 48:52it's life-changing for the people who are there.
- 48:54You know what I mean?
- 48:54I think it's, no, I think it is the way to go.
- 48:57Like that's, it's exactly, it's really cool
- 49:00to see that there are so many projects coming up.
- 49:02And I think it's going to change the world.
- 49:04But we are still in the early stage of it.
- 49:08And I do know that, I mean, most people think that it's,
- 49:13yeah, most people think it's not a big deal.
- 49:16But that's because, you know, any change happens like this, right?
- 49:21If things grow by 10% from very small,
- 49:26you don't notice it until it actually is starting to take off
- 49:28and becoming very big.
- 49:29So I definitely think we're doing the right thing.
- 49:34It's moving the right direction.
- 49:35I don't think it can move much faster than it is now.
- 49:38You see how people are working hard to make these projects happen.
- 49:42I started speaking at these kind of like free cities conferences,
- 49:45probably back in 2011, maybe, when I started kind of looking into these things.
- 49:50And at that time, you could never fill a room with free cities people.
- 49:54It was always blockchain and free cities together like you kind of pair them together to create a conference So it was certainly not you know men in suits sitting in a filling up a room
- 50:05And now it's like, it's that, you know,
- 50:07it's people with serious plans and serious budgets,
- 50:11serious, you know, business plans around it.
- 50:14When was the last time you came to this event then?
- 50:17This is the first time.
- 50:18Oh really?
- 50:19Yeah, I've done other conferences before this was a thing,
- 50:21but yeah.
- 50:22So what do you think?
- 50:23I mean, was it a surprise?
- 50:24Did you already know that you might, was it what you expected?
- 50:28The quality of people, the number of people, the projects talked about, you know.
- 50:32Yes, you're good at advertising it.
- 50:34Are we?
- 50:35And showing pictures.
- 50:36So I've been looking at the pictures.
- 50:37Oh, right, right.
- 50:37No, you know what I mean though.
- 50:39Yeah.
- 50:39Like the way you just described it, you would never fill a room with people into this.
- 50:47I just assumed you would.
- 50:49I've watched it grow, but maybe I haven't noticed it change as much.
- 50:53I know there's definitely loads of projects coming online and especially now, like I am absolutely pumped.
- 50:59I'm so excited now based on just new things happening every day and nothing to do with us even just watching things.
- 51:08I know what Optiflis are doing and I know what the people close to us are doing.
- 51:11But just new little things like Destiny the other day, you know, this one in Nevis and some kids, you know, and this is now really happening.
- 51:20I mean it's weird because it was you know what it's like it was I was a bit like this with bitcoin
- 51:25you know it used to be a edgy thing to do and now all of a sudden everyone's a bitcoiner you know
- 51:31and and it's a bit like it's happening with free cities now it's like you're not pushing against
- 51:36I mean we are still it's still very early but um it's always it's been one of those places where
- 51:42it's always oh something's something's gonna happen but it's just around the corner you can
- 51:46feel it it's happening but I actually feel like it's actually happening now I really do and
- 51:50obviously Prospera and Morazan, yeah, they've always been there. But even their story has been
- 51:56amazing. They've had a full on socialist government say, you're illegitimate shutting you down. And
- 52:03then they just didn't do anything about it. You know, that's a that's an incredible win. You know,
- 52:07all these little wins added to the fact that there are new projects coming up. You know,
- 52:13that's amazing. Yeah. And that's the progress that you know, that's the process, you know,
- 52:17things go through. If I think of like three areas, if you think of Bitcoin, I would single out
- 52:22Bitcoin as opposed to just any blockchain related thing or cryptocurrency. If you think of Bitcoin
- 52:30and you think of longevity and you think of free cities, I would take them in that order.
- 52:36And you want to look at it. I think that the game changer is when VCs sit in a room and you're
- 52:43looking cool and impressing people by saying, well, we put such and such million dollars in
- 52:48this space, then you won, right? Bitcoin got there a good few years ago now. It was kind of cool to
- 52:55say they were in this space, not institutional money. And that's, you know, Bitcoin went from
- 53:01VCs, it's cool to be here. And then the next step being institutional money, it's already there,
- 53:06right? Now you have pension funds putting their money into that. And at least university endowment
- 53:13and pension funds talking about it.
- 53:16So the, and then the next one,
- 53:19if you think about the longevity space,
- 53:21which I think is another one,
- 53:22it's smaller in a way because it's more niche.
- 53:24It's within the healthcare space,
- 53:26but still that too, I feel like it was such,
- 53:30it was a niche, it was laughed at.
- 53:32And then now they're at the stage
- 53:34that VC is a cool, cool person
- 53:37talking about investing in it,
- 53:38far away from institutional.
- 53:41Free cities are not at the stage of VC.
- 53:43cool to talk about it yet that you say that you would put million dollars in it but you show a few
- 53:48projects that are profitable and people um posting on social media that they became billionaires from
- 53:55investing in free cities projects and that's part of you know that's how it sounds very superficial
- 54:02but that's a lot of progression of just like how money starts flowing into an industry and and that's
- 54:08Well, what's also quite evident about what you just said is that the longevity industry is supremely connected with the Free Cities ecosystem.
- 54:17Because, I mean, longevity, by all accounts, is a bit of a regulatory quagmire.
- 54:24And I mean, just before you, I was interviewing Vladimir Leshko.
- 54:29He runs Unlimited Bio, which is based in Prospero.
- 54:32They do gene therapy.
- 54:33and um yeah he he that he could he said we were we couldn't really be doing this
- 54:40unless prosper existed so they're they're intricately connected by the way he said
- 54:44you sound like you're into are you into the longevity stuff you you sound like you're into
- 54:49i know some and i've made some investments in that space yeah okay he said well he said he
- 54:55reckoned he's a engineer he's a bio and he's a qualified bloke he's a you know he said i will
- 55:02in my lifetime, and I'm 54, so I think, you know, 35, 40 years, I'm going to live to,
- 55:09I'd be 90, I think, I hope. I will be able to live forever. What do you think about that?
- 55:15I hope he's right, obviously.
- 55:17Yeah, of course, I hope he's right.
- 55:19I don't know. I can't bet my money on it.
- 55:23So come on, what have you got into in longevity? Are you into longevity? Or is it a financial
- 55:30decision do you look at the market and go like you just explained to me there oh look capital's
- 55:35moving there if i get in good blah blah blah or do you think i'm really interested in that
- 55:40therefore i want to be a part of it and i want to put my money into it yeah there are two things
- 55:46right do you think it's valuable and do you think that the market is underestimating how valuable
- 55:49it is and the answer is yes on both of those for me so yes it is a financial decision in the sense
- 55:55that I think that it's still underestimated how big this space is going to be.
- 55:59But it's also something, yeah, and I think it's valuable in its face
- 56:02and I want to be part of it.
- 56:04So it becomes a personal thing in the sense that you want to be close to
- 56:10and touch it a little bit and have that kind of connection to it.
- 56:14But it's also, yeah, I guess it's a little bit that when you're drawn to something,
- 56:20you also want to be contributing to see it grow because you like it,
- 56:24which is not a way that you should make too many financial decisions.
- 56:27There's a little bit of that.
- 56:28Is that right?
- 56:30That's how I make financial decisions.
- 56:32Do you know what I just thought of, actually?
- 56:34It's interesting.
- 56:36You can change your time horizon, investing in longevity products, can't you,
- 56:43when you think about it?
- 56:44Because you might have a 10-year plan.
- 56:47I'm going to put some money in.
- 56:49You could have a 100-year plan.
- 56:51If you really believe in that, you could say, right,
- 56:54Well, all right, I'm going to see the benefit of this when I'm 200.
- 56:58I mean, really.
- 56:59I mean, it's an interesting concept because all that, if that's true and all this longevity stuff really does,
- 57:05then that blows the hot lid off lots of investing plans, I suppose,
- 57:11because most people wouldn't think 100 years into the future, would they?
- 57:14People will be holding suboptimally high amounts of bonds because right now anyone who is a wealth manager
- 57:20will often have a sliding, kind of this gliding scale, where over the course of a lifetime,
- 57:26where you use the projected lifetime, you load off, you sell off your equities and invest more
- 57:32in bonds, right, to keep it steady, which I think is not the right way to think about it all.
- 57:36But that's a great point. People are going to say, but you said I was going to be dead by now,
- 57:41and now I'm holding 100% bonds. What's going on here? And now I just learned that I'm going to,
- 57:45you know, live another 50 years, am I going to reallocate? And like, sorry, you kind of have to
- 57:50recalculate your model there. And it is interesting because I, so I'm in starting a company in the
- 57:55wealth management space. So I think about this a lot. And it's actually exactly in line in this
- 57:59topic, because our way of thinking about allocation is not asset classes, but time horizons.
- 58:06And we think of a, the longest time horizon where you kind of think of the world as being in
- 58:11equilibrium as a few decades because most people who are seriously placing their money do so when they have a few more decades to live which could be a complete miscalculation right It still you know a good way to go in terms of well
- 58:25okay, a few decades or more. Okay, fine. But it might be that you end up having too many people
- 58:29with that kind of passive allocation for sure. Presumably you could have your, you know,
- 58:35you have your 10, 5% allocation to, you know, 200 years into the future. We're going to put some
- 58:42money into one of these longevity companies and it's like yeah but it's a very long time horizon
- 58:47the rest of it yeah we'll stick to the you know i mean i don't yes not a lot i have no idea really
- 58:53what wealth management is i i don't really know i'm assuming let me guess it's you get a load of
- 58:59people's money and you allocate it and you make like family offices what they do is that wealth
- 59:03management yeah right okay so so and you can think of it as when we talk about wealth management
- 59:08if you think about allocating money, there's kind of two ways of doing it. Either you take a very,
- 59:14very small sliver of something and you're very specialized. And that's often in the institutional
- 59:19space where it's like, here's a pension fund. They have many, many billions and you get,
- 59:23they have allocated already how they're going to do. They have their own office, right? And they say,
- 59:28like I used to work in Chicago and I was part of a macro allocation strategies team,
- 59:34which meant that we did macro means top down.
- 59:38You don't look at specific companies.
- 59:40You'd look at everything in a country level basis.
- 59:42So if I like the US, I like the S&P.
- 59:44I don't like the specific company, right?
- 59:46And there you will have like an allocation of somebody,
- 59:51some fund out there have said,
- 59:53we want something that we call alts,
- 59:55which is a stupid label for stuff
- 59:57that we can't put in any other bucket.
- 1:00:00And by the way, that alts bucket is very big now
- 1:00:02because there's so much out there.
- 1:00:03It's real estate.
- 1:00:03It's currencies, it's macro, it's everything.
- 1:00:07So we're going to call that alt.
- 1:00:08And then within that alt, you might have a macro sliver.
- 1:00:10And then within that macro sliver, we're going to have an allocation to, we've decided, three or five different allocators.
- 1:00:15And then you get the mandate.
- 1:00:16So now you know that whatever they're doing with the rest of the portfolio, I'm not touching that.
- 1:00:21I'm just going to do my best to do what they want me to do.
- 1:00:24Whereas wealth management is generally more holistic.
- 1:00:28You might have a full portfolio that you're now allocating.
- 1:00:31So now you have to think about it like as a total portfolio and, you know, with the passive or active parts.
- 1:00:38And you mentioned, you know, you could have whether it seems silly to have like, should you have the passive or a little bit of this, a little bit of that?
- 1:00:46Absolutely, right?
- 1:00:47I don't think anybody should have just passive or active.
- 1:00:50And there's a lot of people because they're in one or the other space say this is the best and that's the best.
- 1:00:54And most wealth managers selfishly want more passive because they can do less work.
- 1:00:58but I think that everybody should have some of each
- 1:01:03and it's very individual
- 1:01:04so that's the individual choice
- 1:01:06like are you the kind of person
- 1:01:07who wants the long horizon
- 1:01:08or the shorter horizon kind of investment
- 1:01:10How do you get new clients?
- 1:01:13So you've just started a new
- 1:01:14We're starting it, yeah
- 1:01:15we're not managing money yet
- 1:01:17we're hoping to start this
- 1:01:18How do you get new clients then?
- 1:01:19Do you have to go phone people up and say
- 1:01:22you know, businesses, companies, I don't know
- 1:01:24and say who's managing you well?
- 1:01:26Yeah, I have colleagues who are more in the wealth management space.
- 1:01:30So it's a new space for me.
- 1:01:31So I'm not the one with the best connections there myself.
- 1:01:36But how does that all work?
- 1:01:38I'm just fascinated.
- 1:01:39Tell me if I'm asking too deep.
- 1:01:41No, the wealth management space is an industry of relations.
- 1:01:46And it's part of why I mentioned my talk here at the conference.
- 1:01:51I can only describe the industry as quite bad.
- 1:01:55it's because there's a lot of just money being spent on relation building there's less and less
- 1:02:03money spent actually allocating the money correctly so if you ever go to a party this
- 1:02:08probably has happened to you if you ever networked somebody's a wealth manager and they're like
- 1:02:12starting to ask you and they're very nice then they're not too obvious about it but they're
- 1:02:16hoping that you could maybe be a client and they're having hundreds of these conversations a week
- 1:02:20and maybe they'll end up with, you know,
- 1:02:23they're trying to fill up as many lunches
- 1:02:25and taking people out, wining and dining
- 1:02:28to make others like them
- 1:02:30and eventually get you as a client.
- 1:02:33You know, say, I'm going to manage your money.
- 1:02:35You're going to help you also, you know, plan your taxes and insurance.
- 1:02:39You know, you should probably have some life insurance
- 1:02:40and then they get a commission for the people that, you know,
- 1:02:43provide the life insurance and things like that.
- 1:02:45And when you pay the one, one and a half percent of your wealth every year
- 1:02:49for them to do this, you are also paying for all the dinners that they had with the other people,
- 1:02:55you know, that never became their clients. So part of it is, it is an industry that
- 1:03:00does rely on relationships, it should function in more kind of efficient way. But it's also hard to
- 1:03:06say, like, how will it function different way? Well, you can have people who are, you know,
- 1:03:10have good reputations, and everybody comes to them. Well, that doesn't maybe work, because you
- 1:03:14can't have one person managing everybody and but um yeah but that's that's that's kind of where the
- 1:03:19industry is the best we can do at this point is um when you have a client to come up with a more
- 1:03:25efficient way of working and and we think a lot about like how to you know how to make things
- 1:03:31more efficient like our our macro way of investing um we're working on automating quite a lot of that
- 1:03:36so that we can have like value-based investing without having we were 13 people in a team before
- 1:03:42And now it's me and a business partner doing the investment part.
- 1:03:45And we think we can pull through, do a lot of good work with maybe one other person on the investment side.
- 1:03:52And presumably you're using your contacts or your ideas about the world you revolve to specifically allocate to those kind of things.
- 1:04:03If the people want.
- 1:04:04I mean, how does it work?
- 1:04:06Presumably you say, I can get you 8% on all your wealth or something.
- 1:04:10Is that how it works?
- 1:04:11and they go, okay, good, or whatever it is.
- 1:04:15I don't know.
- 1:04:16It can't just be about relationships.
- 1:04:18There must be an element of this guy makes us more money than that guy.
- 1:04:22There's some of that, but there's return and there's also risk.
- 1:04:25So managing your risk is, I would say, often more important for people
- 1:04:29because it's kind of less obvious to whether you promise a –
- 1:04:34one, you can never promise a return.
- 1:04:36That's just not in line with the law.
- 1:04:39But you can say that we're targeting returns for certain allocations.
- 1:04:44So if we're thinking about whether you're looking at your long-term allocation, short-term allocation, the long-term allocation, you might have a projection for the global market to grow at a certain rate.
- 1:04:56And that's just going to be what you're expecting for your returns.
- 1:05:00If you have a shorter term and more active allocation where you're trading a lot, you have, of course, trading costs of that, but you don't incur more of those, then you know that you can still maintain a good return.
- 1:05:12So there you would expect a higher return, obviously, as well.
- 1:05:15So there it depends on, well, are you willing to take on the potential risk that comes with periods where if you have a value-based investing, meaning if value is higher than the price, I am going to buy this.
- 1:05:28If value is below the price, I am going to sell this actually going short.
- 1:05:33And if you want a lot of that kind of allocation, right, you can then, you know, your return profile of your portfolio will be different, will be higher.
- 1:05:44But your risk may also be higher, right?
- 1:05:46because you are incurring the risk of not wanting to touch your portfolio
- 1:05:51as periods sometimes stretch out for a long time of value diverging,
- 1:05:57prices diverging from value for a long time.
- 1:05:59And you see this, for example, we had a long period,
- 1:06:01you probably recall, where interest rates were very low.
- 1:06:04All the bonds look so expensive.
- 1:06:05And you could keep shorting bonds until the cows come home
- 1:06:08and you were not making any money, you know,
- 1:06:10and you're losing money, you know.
- 1:06:12And after a while, your clients might say, you know,
- 1:06:15stop doing a bond thing.
- 1:06:16And often that happens right before everything changes.
- 1:06:19But so, yeah, that's a little bit,
- 1:06:21I hope I've given you a little bit of picture of how it works.
- 1:06:24There's a lot to say.
- 1:06:25Well, no, I mean, I get the general gist, which is, you know,
- 1:06:31marrying risk and return and making sure that you keep your client happy.
- 1:06:35But I'm just wondering what they expect, what kind of return you expect?
- 1:06:40As a whole.
- 1:06:41Yeah.
- 1:06:41I mean, what is a good return?
- 1:06:43You get 8% from the S&P if you just put it all into that, wouldn't you?
- 1:06:47But then you run the risk of, you don't want to put all your eggs in one basket.
- 1:06:51Yeah, I mean, I would say, right, like S&P means that you're focusing on only one country.
- 1:06:57So you're putting your money kind of in one big basket, but still one basket, right?
- 1:07:03And if you're having an active allocation, I would say maybe five real, so five plus inflation,
- 1:07:09because it's also an inflation thing, right?
- 1:07:11I was going to say.
- 1:07:12Yeah.
- 1:07:12Right.
- 1:07:12So it beats inflation.
- 1:07:14Right.
- 1:07:14You want to beat inflation.
- 1:07:16And over time, you could just put into gold if you want to do that.
- 1:07:19But that's not a very good risk allocation there.
- 1:07:22Because then you'll have long periods when you might not be happy
- 1:07:24and sometimes you want to sell.
- 1:07:26So the risk part is very important, right?
- 1:07:29And that's something where I would say that a lot of allocators,
- 1:07:33a lot of allocators will completely not want to talk about risk
- 1:07:37because they know they don't have a really good way of managing it.
- 1:07:41And so they focus on only the return part.
- 1:07:44And then you can go to a cocktail bar and you say,
- 1:07:46oh, my manager made me 20% this year and it's so cool.
- 1:07:51And it turned out that it was all like in, say,
- 1:07:54one real estate project or something like that.
- 1:07:57Yes, you made 20%.
- 1:07:58There are a lot of alternatives realities out there
- 1:08:01where that project did not go well.
- 1:08:03If it's a very concentrated position,
- 1:08:04you didn't really manage your risk that well.
- 1:08:06and understanding a total risk of portfolio is a very complicated thing.
- 1:08:12I am not the one to create the framework around this,
- 1:08:16but our colleague who is focused on risk is very, very proficient in this.
- 1:08:22And so without a framework like that,
- 1:08:26I think we wouldn't have as good an offering, so to speak.
- 1:08:30So what's your role then?
- 1:08:31What would your role be?
- 1:08:32finding good new unusual investments or just you know i don't know yeah i'm bringing in a lot of the
- 1:08:39just the macro investing that i've done since i started in finance really and putting that
- 1:08:44together like putting our valuation models in place and things like that and then i'm going
- 1:08:48to be managing that and hopefully handing over some of the day-to-day on that to
- 1:08:51to a new colleague that we're looking for um so but um yeah so so then but i will also be involved
- 1:09:02to a larger, larger extent
- 1:09:04and a holistic kind of portfolio composition,
- 1:09:06which are going to be individual for each client.
- 1:09:08Will it have a personality like, you know,
- 1:09:10I'm just wondering because, you know,
- 1:09:13you're obviously into some interesting things,
- 1:09:15as in, you know, I mean, in investing terms, even.
- 1:09:18You used to be a cannabis investor, right, in the past.
- 1:09:21Yeah.
- 1:09:21That's an unusual thing.
- 1:09:22I still am.
- 1:09:23Oh, you still are, right.
- 1:09:24But also the free cities thing, you know, whatever.
- 1:09:27So you could argue that you've got
- 1:09:28an interesting eye for investments.
- 1:09:31is that what the personality of the company would be if you see what I mean like it's not just some
- 1:09:36boring oh we'll do that that no we're kind of like we've got an eye on a few things that you
- 1:09:42probably don't know anything about yet or something I don't know I I've never really
- 1:09:47been into any of that stuff I've never had an I mean interested in it now it was a bit late in
- 1:09:53life but um I thought it was boring for the whole of time yeah it can be boring well yeah it can be
- 1:09:59It's boring, but markets are interesting, really interesting.
- 1:10:03And I didn't realize that for a long time.
- 1:10:05I didn't think it could be interesting until I started working a little over 10 years ago in this field.
- 1:10:11And I'm an economist by background.
- 1:10:13So coming out of economics, and I did my PhD in economics, I would never think that I would even be in the private sector,
- 1:10:18especially as writing, we were talking about the special economic zones.
- 1:10:21That was my dissertation, the topic of my dissertation.
- 1:10:23And doing political economy and macro does not fit well with my thinking of what finance is,
- 1:10:28and looking at picking companies, I thought it was all about.
- 1:10:32And what's interesting for me, which has been tremendously rewarding,
- 1:10:36has just been to bring in all the economics, everything I learned,
- 1:10:39and just putting that into our models and our way of thinking.
- 1:10:43And seriously, after, say, two years of doing macro investing,
- 1:10:48I looked through the curriculum and the syllabi of all the classes that I took at George Mason,
- 1:10:54and it was like one that I had not used material from the classes.
- 1:10:57It was like everything was useful.
- 1:10:59And I bet my professors would never have thought that.
- 1:11:03One simple example is just to think about, you might be familiar with the Economic Freedom Index by Fraser Institute.
- 1:11:10It's a Canadian think tank.
- 1:11:12But it's been run by professors mainly at the University of Florida.
- 1:11:18So they rank countries by economic freedom and they see how it's changed over the years.
- 1:11:26and their scholarships looking at, well, what's the growth implication of economic freedom?
- 1:11:30And there's a lag, right?
- 1:11:31You see economic freedom, you see subsequently some growth implication of that.
- 1:11:34And just putting that into models in the sense that if you believe that a country will grow faster on the basis of this,
- 1:11:42you also believe that that has an impact on the equity market with some scale.
- 1:11:47And therefore, you'll have a model where you're seeing dividends from your equity position growing over time, say, faster.
- 1:11:55So that can work. I mean, you talked about how the difference between investing because you have a high valuation versus investing because you think that the valuation is underestimated.
- 1:12:09And you can still, I can definitely say that I made mistakes in that field.
- 1:12:13So let's say when Macri became president of Argentina, I was really, I've been really optimistic about the potential of reforming Argentina.
- 1:12:21And even though I visited, I talked to people.
- 1:12:26There's a great think tank in Argentina called Libertari Progreso.
- 1:12:30And Estebas is his name, Agustin, that I met with.
- 1:12:34And he was so skeptical.
- 1:12:35And I just want to believe.
- 1:12:37And I dismissed his views on this.
- 1:12:39And I put money into it.
- 1:12:40So that was more, we allowed for a little bit more like kind of the tactical, like not necessary value base.
- 1:12:45But I also like overestimated what the probability was that the reforms were actually going to stick.
- 1:12:51And they didn't stick.
- 1:12:52They failed.
- 1:12:53Right.
- 1:12:54So things like that, like you can still, you can definitely, we all have our biases.
- 1:12:58And it's something just always remember, I'm going to keep making mistakes probably.
- 1:13:03Can you notice them in yourself though?
- 1:13:04I fully recognize that experience of listening to negative news, but knowing that I really want it to happen and that overriding my opinion on what's going to happen.
- 1:13:16Yeah.
- 1:13:16Do you notice it when you're doing it now?
- 1:13:18Like, can you see when it's you're not being purely analytical or purely, you know, neutral on us on something?
- 1:13:26In most cases, I think we all do.
- 1:13:28But the fact that you can still make these mistakes suggests that if one out of 100 cases you don't notice it, that can lead you astray.
- 1:13:35And I think that you often just have to talk to your colleagues and friends and say, I think like this.
- 1:13:40And just like get the pushback.
- 1:13:42And sometimes just talking about it reveals to yourself.
- 1:13:45In the Argentina experience that you just had there, someone who knew told you something and you kind of disbelieved them.
- 1:13:54Is it?
- 1:13:54Why?
- 1:13:55Because I wanted to believe.
- 1:13:56Yeah, right.
- 1:13:57That's what I mean.
- 1:13:57So the lesson is if someone's a specialist, then just believe them or not.
- 1:14:02Probably not.
- 1:14:03No, no, no, exactly.
- 1:14:04I know we wouldn't want to go that far, but it's more in the line where you were going,
- 1:14:10which is just recognize yourself, that your biases can kind of push you somewhere sometimes.
- 1:14:15So, yeah.
- 1:14:16That would be me.
- 1:14:17I'd be a terrible investor.
- 1:14:19I'm in the same reason I'd be a terrible trader of anything.
- 1:14:23Markets just, I'm that guy.
- 1:14:25I'm the person in the market who gets,
- 1:14:30well, I just stay out of the market now
- 1:14:32because I know that if I,
- 1:14:34in fact, I know if I'm starting to,
- 1:14:37oh, I want to buy.
- 1:14:38I know this is the worst time to buy.
- 1:14:40That's my signal, whatever.
- 1:14:42Don't buy that thing now
- 1:14:43because the fact that you're suddenly animated to buy it
- 1:14:47means so is everyone else
- 1:14:48and that's the actual time to be selling it.
- 1:14:51It's the complete opposite.
- 1:14:53But I just do neither
- 1:14:54because I haven you know It is hard it is hard and it the equivalent of my experience say the anecdote from Argentina in the market is you buy something it goes up and that confirms that you right
- 1:15:05You either hold onto it, you buy more
- 1:15:07and you buy more and buy more as it goes up
- 1:15:09until it goes down.
- 1:15:10And then you are not happy.
- 1:15:12What's, I want to talk about cannabis.
- 1:15:14Well, not just cannabis, but before we do,
- 1:15:17what's the difference between the way you would
- 1:15:20invest or wealth manage your own money versus one of your big clients or one of your clients
- 1:15:29there's no difference and i as soon as we get online with a with our product i i want to put
- 1:15:34the money my money into it um and it would be great because then i don't have to i don't try
- 1:15:40to do what i'm we are going to do as a whole because there's too much work for my own money
- 1:15:44so I'm just a passive investor mostly myself now like value-based if I know that something
- 1:15:50just looks way too overvalued then I would sell it and vice versa but I don't make a lot of trades
- 1:15:56or anything like that you know I mean gold has been an interesting one recently for example we
- 1:16:01are speaking at a time now where people have been talking about a gold bubble and it was hyperbolic
- 1:16:05and then it came down a bit it came down like six and a half percent one day and then it stayed a
- 1:16:10little bit and then it went down again and now people are like oh should I buy or sell sell and
- 1:16:14so things like that that really became becomes big stories you kind of start having to look at
- 1:16:19and often I do kind of think that I want to sell when everybody's super super excited about it like
- 1:16:24I go to a networking event and you ask everybody like I was asking actually the day before gold
- 1:16:31started going down we were we were having a group together of free market people actually and
- 1:16:35I was just asking everybody what do you do now with the gold are you gonna when are you gonna
- 1:16:39to sell gold and most people said never i never said and they and i bet several of them will change
- 1:16:45their mind too when when it goes down you know well i mean i mean also there were lines of people
- 1:16:51on the news buying physical gold literally the day before it started tanking so that those i i
- 1:16:59because i'm a bitcoiner i think i've got used to noticing exuberance in in various shapes and forms
- 1:17:06and like Twitter, for example, even places like that,
- 1:17:09it's a really easy way to notice exuberance.
- 1:17:12If you have a network like I do of Bitcoiners,
- 1:17:15you can notice when they start talking
- 1:17:18in an exuberant way about Bitcoin.
- 1:17:22And it's really a good signal.
- 1:17:24Not that I care, really.
- 1:17:25I'm not buying and selling Bitcoin, you know.
- 1:17:27I'm a buyer whenever.
- 1:17:29I'm always a buyer of Bitcoin.
- 1:17:30You're not a micro strategy investor?
- 1:17:32No, no, I'm not.
- 1:17:33I'm not.
- 1:17:34I
- 1:17:36I was a part
- 1:17:39of the groups when people were talking
- 1:17:41about all that kind of stuff I'm really
- 1:17:43don't I just want something
- 1:17:45really simple like you said
- 1:17:47you put your money in your own fund
- 1:17:49and let it
- 1:17:51follow what we're doing
- 1:17:53I'd be the same
- 1:17:54I have no investments
- 1:17:57other than Bitcoin and I own
- 1:17:59a house you know I don't
- 1:18:01care I just
- 1:18:02it's too cold I don't want to think about that I don't want to wonder about that I don't want to
- 1:18:08worry about that I'm not someone who wants to sit I love watching the markets but you you're
- 1:18:16probably consumed by it right because it's your job as it should be like investing should consume
- 1:18:22you whole you know like and it but it doesn't I don't want to be consumed by investing I've got
- 1:18:27I want to spend time with my kids.
- 1:18:29I want to chop wood and spend time in the countryside and stuff.
- 1:18:34And I'm not here to give you investment advice,
- 1:18:36but you are very concentrated in one asset.
- 1:18:39Of course. Absolutely.
- 1:18:40Just like if somebody who holds only US dollars and say,
- 1:18:45well, I'm safe.
- 1:18:46Well, you're not safe because the government can inflate that away for you.
- 1:18:48So having something with real kind of asset exposure is often a good thing.
- 1:18:53And it's pretty cheap to have some passive equity exposure
- 1:18:57or passive on exposure.
- 1:18:58I agree.
- 1:18:59I agree that the theory of diversifying
- 1:19:02should apply to me.
- 1:19:06I don't know.
- 1:19:07Maybe I'm either stupid
- 1:19:10or I think that Bitcoin,
- 1:19:14I think I understand Bitcoin
- 1:19:16and what's happening.
- 1:19:16A bit like what you were saying
- 1:19:17about free cities
- 1:19:18and ZAs and all this kind of stuff.
- 1:19:22What surprises me always
- 1:19:24is like amongst us,
- 1:19:25Take the 400 people in the room over the weekend.
- 1:19:29Amongst us, there's so many of these things, which are so normal.
- 1:19:33Like we talk about all kinds of weird shit.
- 1:19:35And it's absolutely normal to mention this, that and the other.
- 1:19:38You go outside that bubble and people haven't got a clue that this world even exists.
- 1:19:44Because I had the same experience with Bitcoin.
- 1:19:46Outside of the Bitcoin world, in the older days especially, no one had a clue what was going on.
- 1:19:52And even now, you know, biggest ETF in history, you've got BlackRock doing this, you've got sovereign wealth funds buying it, you've got, you know, and still people are like, yeah, it's a bit risky.
- 1:20:06It's like, it doesn't appear to be a bit risky for me.
- 1:20:09And if you understand the technology, obviously, which takes a lot to get underneath the surface of the technology, you could argue, right, you can just write that part off.
- 1:20:18All right, there's never, there's always a bit of risk, but it's a very small amount of risk.
- 1:20:22And other than that, it just becomes down to you whether or not you understand it. Like you might say, you understand that the special, you know, the kind of free city model is happening. And we're, but because we have a lot of data to back that up, your average person isn't going to clue what's going on. But we have, we know what's happening. So we can see the market happening.
- 1:20:46right right and and i feel the same about bitcoin and now i don't care anymore because now it's just
- 1:20:51so mainstream it's it's kind of like and i i i think and also i i i want it i want it i believe
- 1:20:58in the parallel system that it's it's forming so i i i don't really want my wealth in a place
- 1:21:04where um where's where yeah yeah on the other rails oops on the you know what i mean there's
- 1:21:12there's two parallel rails running next to each other yeah i'm not trying to convince you at all
- 1:21:16no no no because you you know but so am i and that would be my thesis so there's a winner yeah and
- 1:21:23you know it's why why diversify away from the winner if you see what i mean well so there are
- 1:21:29two kind of i feel like two senses of what you're saying one is the return versus risk
- 1:21:33aspect and the other one is a little bit of social impact investing because you're like
- 1:21:36i want to also see it and that and i would be like it's absolutely there absolutely is a place
- 1:21:41for that but i wouldn't put all my mind into that so now we have the return versus risk
- 1:21:45i understand a lot of things in life that sounds hyperbolic wow that's amazing i i know i lot of
- 1:21:57moberg that is not what i mean i mean that i can understand like my neighbor's kiosk around the
- 1:22:05corner and how that operates but even if i understand it to its core and i know exactly
- 1:22:09what ice creams go through the shelves,
- 1:22:11something can happen.
- 1:22:13You know, there might be an earthquake.
- 1:22:14There might be the government somehow
- 1:22:15made a mistake in the accounting
- 1:22:17and now they had to shut down
- 1:22:19and they have to open there
- 1:22:20and it becomes too costly.
- 1:22:21There's so many things.
- 1:22:22Governments exist out there.
- 1:22:23They get involved.
- 1:22:25And so, and there are disasters out there.
- 1:22:29There is key man risks.
- 1:22:30I don't think that even if you understand something,
- 1:22:33you can ever,
- 1:22:35if you would honestly be able to say,
- 1:22:38I know there's nothing threatening this.
- 1:22:40And I bet there are Bitcoiners out there who can say that.
- 1:22:42Then I would say, wow, wow.
- 1:22:45Then I could justify putting all the money into something.
- 1:22:48But I think that what you're making a good case for
- 1:22:52is both free cities movement, Bitcoin is,
- 1:22:56well, one, I understand that the return is higher
- 1:22:59than people anticipate and the risk is actually lower.
- 1:23:02And I think that the risk part is a really big one
- 1:23:04when it comes to the free cities movement
- 1:23:05that we're actually seeing,
- 1:23:06like we understand what the relationship is to the government.
- 1:23:09Most people will say, ah, they're just going to shut it down.
- 1:23:11They're going to be going to an election.
- 1:23:12So we know that the risk is lower It not zero And as long as it not serious if you would have a good risk model and you plug it in what your expected returns and risk are for the Bitcoin part and the free cities part
- 1:23:26it still wouldn't be, I'm going to allocate everything here. You're going to realize that
- 1:23:29you understand that the value is higher than others understand it to be. And therefore,
- 1:23:35it warrants an allocation. But the interesting thing about Bitcoin and probably to a degree
- 1:23:41free cities is there is a there is like i have a belief in for example um my my my culture is a
- 1:23:50bitcoin culture and most of my friends are bitcoiners and there is a camaraderie amongst us
- 1:23:56which basically stipulates that if this thing goes down we're all going down together like we really
- 1:24:02don't care i really i don't care if like if like i say i've got cash flow enough i own a house
- 1:24:10there's no mortgage on it so i've got a house and i've got cash flow and if this thing does what i
- 1:24:16expect it to do we're all good it's already doing what i expected to do we're all good
- 1:24:21but it's kind of a pact of helping each other out like no it's a it's a life-changing technology
- 1:24:26just like free cities are i mean the reason i'm so interested in free cities now is is because
- 1:24:30i actually think that my my my introduction to free cities was through bitcoin um because a lot
- 1:24:38of Bitcoiners are free city people. But what you realize when you sort of study Bitcoin is Bitcoin
- 1:24:44is a perfect, not only is Bitcoin perfect property, perfect property, it's basically just nailed the
- 1:24:51digital realm for all the things that we want in the physical realm. You get them with Bitcoin in
- 1:24:56the digital realm, unconfuscatable, actual property rights, actual property rights. And then you
- 1:25:02realize, okay, right, that's done. That's done. We've got it. We don't need to invent anything
- 1:25:07new but in the physical world we we still we want this version of it you know there's no such thing
- 1:25:15as cryptography of the physical realm if you create a bit of property in the physical world
- 1:25:20you've got to protect it you in in the digital world you can crypt cryptographically protect it
- 1:25:26it's amazing no you know it's amazing but in in the physical world this is a different totally
- 1:25:32different and much gray much more gray area in how do you live free and protect your property and
- 1:25:40and make sure that you you know you you have a good life and now i'm interested i'm like the
- 1:25:47because bitcoin's a part of that because bitcoin can sort of fund it basically but really free
- 1:25:52cities are all about this why i'm so interested in it all is they're all about trying to secure
- 1:25:58that freedom, that property in the real world, which is very murky.
- 1:26:04I mean, there's no such thing as property in the real world.
- 1:26:07At the end of the day, someone can come out with a gun and take your property.
- 1:26:10So you haven't got property.
- 1:26:12It's about whether you can maintain property.
- 1:26:14Whereas with Bitcoin, it's like you have property,
- 1:26:17providing you don't leave your private seed on a table written down,
- 1:26:21and then someone can take your property.
- 1:26:22In theory, somebody can come put a gun on your head and say,
- 1:26:25give me your codes.
- 1:26:26And what are they going to say?
- 1:26:26And what am I going to, when my mouth doesn't open, what happens?
- 1:26:30Well, we don't want to think about that, right?
- 1:26:33No, but all right.
- 1:26:34There's a theoretical aspect to it, correct.
- 1:26:37But that's what I'm interested in now is, and so the Bitcoin thing is like, cool, great tool.
- 1:26:44Money, it's money.
- 1:26:46It's real money.
- 1:26:47It's not, it's not, all the characteristics of money.
- 1:26:50We've got money sorted in the new world, in the digital world.
- 1:26:54like this is this new frontier has arrived we had no access to the digital world until what 30 years
- 1:27:00ago or whatever it didn't even exist and now we've got money in it as in you know money as in
- 1:27:08this is you know fungibility portability all that kind of crap you know and and this is the world
- 1:27:14we're in we're in the world of things moving digitally there you know but physically yeah
- 1:27:21Free CDs are a way of us all trying to understand how to protect property rights and to live free in the real world, in this world, not the digital world.
- 1:27:34And so I don't have a problem with just like saying, cool, you know, that's what I want.
- 1:27:40I want money in Bitcoin.
- 1:27:43I want real money in the digital world.
- 1:27:45But what I also want in the physical world is what we're working towards.
- 1:27:49And that is tricky as hell.
- 1:27:51And I don't have an answer for it.
- 1:27:53I don't actually think there is an answer for it.
- 1:27:55I think.
- 1:27:57Well, no, but I mean, like Prosper is a pretty good, you know, like there is ways to protect property that, you know, legally.
- 1:28:04Yes.
- 1:28:04Like physically.
- 1:28:05Which we have outside of the zones as well, you know.
- 1:28:08Sure.
- 1:28:08Sure.
- 1:28:08That's what I mean.
- 1:28:09But I mean, you know, it worked.
- 1:28:12It seems the legal one, which I always thought, you know, you know, governments are going to be governments.
- 1:28:18They don't often respect legality.
- 1:28:20it's not it's not they're not well known for it especially sort of like far left ones but
- 1:28:25they kind of did the legal the legal protection worked really well it seems to have if you look
- 1:28:33at what's happening in in honduras now and the narratives change yeah they got to rescind the
- 1:28:38the law okay which is crazy anyway i mean they had a constitution change and now they've said it's
- 1:28:44they've changed it back so the whole thing's a farce anyway but the government which was saying
- 1:28:49right, we're going to shut you down, and now not doing that.
- 1:28:53And now they're saying, oh, well, we won because there's going to be no new ZAs.
- 1:28:57But the ZAs that are there, they're chugging them on.
- 1:28:59I mean, I think it's important to point out that, at least my opinion,
- 1:29:03is that the big protection of property rights in something like a Prospera,
- 1:29:08something like an autonomous city that is run as a business
- 1:29:12as opposed to the national states that we're used to,
- 1:29:16is just a different incentive structure.
- 1:29:18It's not perfect by no means, but you have, if you're running a company, you have the incentive to protect that.
- 1:29:25And if you're going to sign a contract and live here, and you might ask, is there eminent domain?
- 1:29:31And if the answer is no, then that's a good thing.
- 1:29:33And you move in and you don't have those things that, you know, we talk about how governments protect property rights,
- 1:29:39but at least you don't have the government being able to infringe on the property rights because you don't have that incentive.
- 1:29:45and so that's that's a big win right there so i wouldn't i wouldn't need to we don't need to
- 1:29:52necessarily go into are we 100 you know sure that nothing can happen because we know that people
- 1:29:58with guns exist that can you know have bad intent and and sometimes it's it takes a while to get
- 1:30:03your property back and they destroyed it meantime and things like that that can happen but yeah it's
- 1:30:07just how the governance works and just the the a priori incentives of the people running the place
- 1:30:12It's just different when it's by contract rather than by birth, so to speak.
- 1:30:19We're born into a country often, and it takes a lot if you want to live anywhere else.
- 1:30:23Yeah, and I'm one of those people that probably I would have thought the contract idea would have been,
- 1:30:30that's not going to work too well.
- 1:30:31But Prosper is proving that that kind of seems to work really well.
- 1:30:37And now I'm a total convert.
- 1:30:39I can't see another way, actually.
- 1:30:44I can't see a fairer way.
- 1:30:46Like, here's my obligation.
- 1:30:48This is your obligation.
- 1:30:50Do you want to kind of go into business?
- 1:30:52I mean, why wouldn't it be that?
- 1:30:53Why have I never thought about that before?
- 1:30:56Why have I always assumed that we need this kind of, like,
- 1:31:00despotic person with a gun telling me what to do and taking my money?
- 1:31:04Because you've never experienced anything else,
- 1:31:05and the people governing you are telling you that it's very well good.
- 1:31:08But Lotta, that's a crazy thought for a 54-year-old.
- 1:31:11Do you know that?
- 1:31:12Seriously, it doesn't.
- 1:31:14I still wonder about it because no one I know.
- 1:31:17All right, I revolve in certain circles now, but I didn't used to.
- 1:31:22And my old life hasn't got a clue what's going on.
- 1:31:25They don't know any of this stuff.
- 1:31:27They don't know anything to do with anything, even finance, really.
- 1:31:31Most people are completely financially illiterate.
- 1:31:33they they think buying you know bonds means whatever premium bonds or something crap like that you know what premium bonds do You know we have them in the UK It like a lottery ticket
- 1:31:45It's called a premium bond.
- 1:31:46Oh, my God.
- 1:31:47It's so retarded.
- 1:31:48But like, you know, all those things.
- 1:31:51I think it's changing.
- 1:31:52I think people are becoming far more into certain ideas.
- 1:31:57Inflation just used to be, oh, price is going up.
- 1:32:00Now it's, oh, is it overt government spending?
- 1:32:03You know, those kind of ideas are getting out there slowly.
- 1:32:08No, they are.
- 1:32:09I really do think they are.
- 1:32:11Because I live in a village, you know, small one, not a village,
- 1:32:14but there's a village pub and people talk about this stuff.
- 1:32:18And inflation is talked about now.
- 1:32:21But the reasons for it are starting to get wondered about and things like that.
- 1:32:26But I don't know where I'm going with this necessarily.
- 1:32:29but um but um yeah it's always hard to know when you as you're stepping in as you're saying you
- 1:32:35know your accumulated friends who have a certain who are i don't know if i should use the word red
- 1:32:41pill but that's kind of what you've been now um and just understanding more and more of it and so
- 1:32:47you know is it the world changing around or how much is it you changing or you know the that you're
- 1:32:51the people around you that you're inviting in your life but um i i want to you know you could
- 1:32:56definitely be right we know that there's a big contingency out there who have no clue about what
- 1:33:00we're talking are you red building like or were you red build yeah i think i was written college
- 1:33:05in college probably yeah yeah not before that and i was old when i started college by the way i was
- 1:33:1123 when i started undergrad what what was it like what what made you realize that everything's a scam
- 1:33:16or you know like in loosely speaking yeah and i i think that's when i started when i q when i
- 1:33:24adopted my framework of thinking and then realizing how much scam there is there i think
- 1:33:28takes a few years probably so maybe it wasn't only there it was probably so i did my undergrad in
- 1:33:34sweden and that's when i um when i what was it economics yeah yeah and in sweden you can't do a
- 1:33:42phd in economics unless you've done your undergrad economics with at least 60 of the classes in that
- 1:33:46in that field and you come to the u.s and you realize you start from scratch where people have
- 1:33:50done in other fields. It's a very different system here, there in the US. So I started
- 1:33:58just having a good framework of how the world works, I think, in college. So, and again, like,
- 1:34:04that's not very, you know, a very young age. Before that, I wasn't that interested in high
- 1:34:08school. I wasn't, I was kind of clueless and I was out just working in different places all around
- 1:34:14the world and kind of thing. And yeah, I don't know if there was anything specific. I think it
- 1:34:21is the kind of people you are drawn to. Like if you're a curious person and somebody says something
- 1:34:26outrageous and people kind of turn their head like, and you'll go like, oh, that's interesting.
- 1:34:30You know, I want to learn more. What is he talking about? And so I just accumulated those kind of
- 1:34:35friends through college. So I then I started reading a lot of like the libertarian literature
- 1:34:39And that was kind of my friends.
- 1:34:42And people are very free thinkers in that kind of space.
- 1:34:48I would say that I like calling myself a liberal, but you can't say that in the US, right?
- 1:34:55Because liberal means the opposite, it means socialist.
- 1:34:58But I have a lot of liberal values in that way.
- 1:35:02The social freedoms is important to me.
- 1:35:05And I think that I don't know a lot of people call themselves libertarians in the U.S. also have very illiberal values when it happens to freedom of movement.
- 1:35:16And abortion is an interesting one because there you can have different kind of the same axioms can lead to, you know, being for or against and the gender issues and things like that.
- 1:35:26I definitely think that anybody should be able to call themselves whatever gender they want and change gender if they want.
- 1:35:32And but of course, if we wouldn't be, you know, that people are talking about forcing kids and all that, like, yeah, that sounds like a bad thing and all that.
- 1:35:40But so that's kind of where I'm coming from.
- 1:35:42I think that I am liberal throughout both on the social and fiscal part.
- 1:35:48And yeah, I just have those kind of axioms.
- 1:35:51It's very it's very simple.
- 1:35:52It's like non-aggression principle.
- 1:35:54And, you know, do be good to other people and you can't hurt anybody unless they hurt you or threaten to hurt you.
- 1:36:01and from there you can derive a lot of things right and from there you uh if you are a curious
- 1:36:07person you accumulate good people who infuse you with new ideas that's kind of my progression in
- 1:36:12life i think i think i i can attribute almost everything to just ideas or people that i have
- 1:36:18chosen to you know surround myself with and i keep doing that so yeah i think i'm the same except
- 1:36:22i had just i just had completely different ideas and they weren't bad people at all they were you
- 1:36:30know i i've loved my life up until this point it's just there were there were a number of things that
- 1:36:36we all thought at a base level in the background that i i i find it astonishing to think that i
- 1:36:43that i didn't address and there's probably a bunch now as well i'm probably working from a baseline
- 1:36:50of all kinds of weird things that really i'm not noticing you know like the most common one that
- 1:36:56fortunately i've i've kind of seen through is this notion that the government exists and it should
- 1:37:03basically be able to tell you what to do and that's a really big one to get over
- 1:37:07especially like and this is the one i see most in the uk that people have no idea it even exists
- 1:37:13and when you see a lot of people really well-meaning people arguing um against certain
- 1:37:19things they're basically arguing in favor of the state without even realizing it do you know what i
- 1:37:24mean like i've seen a number of people there's a number of you know people who are noticing like
- 1:37:30we this the problems we have at the moment the bad you know like the bad the the way the economy
- 1:37:36is terrible the you know the way the this is terrible and that's terrible and you can say you
- 1:37:40can see the symptoms of what's bad but the answer then is the get the government to fix it without
- 1:37:47even wondering whether the government either might be the problem or is even the right person to fix
- 1:37:52it if you see what I mean you know and it's it's so common I was that I would I would have been that
- 1:37:57person if I if I even cared whether the government need to fix anything I didn't really think about
- 1:38:02any of that stuff until you know I discovered bitcoin and basically that's what turned me on
- 1:38:06to all that stuff but what's the cannabis story then talking of yeah the cannabis story I went
- 1:38:11into that industry in the spring of 22 um I left the finance world macro and kind of took a break
- 1:38:17from that it was together with brian singer is uh was my boss at the team in chicago and we became
- 1:38:25then business partner and and started learning the ropes of the industry set up a credit fund
- 1:38:29in the summer of 22 we created it did the legal work around it credit fund meaning that we lend
- 1:38:36money we we set ourselves up so that we can raise money and then you charge a management fee and you
- 1:38:41lend it out to companies. Cannabis has been on a wild ride. And there was a huge bubble in cannabis.
- 1:38:51There was a time where everybody wanted to be in it. And we were kind of on the other side of that
- 1:38:55bubble where it was still a lot of excitement at 22. And what happened was that you had COVID,
- 1:39:00right? Spring of 2020. The story started emerging throughout that year about, well,
- 1:39:07we're all going to be in lockdown now for a while. So everybody's going to sit at home and smoke pot.
- 1:39:11and then Biden won the election
- 1:39:14so now it's like oh
- 1:39:15Democrats now increase probability
- 1:39:17of federal legalization
- 1:39:19because cannabis is legal in many states
- 1:39:22but it's still this like weird thing
- 1:39:23where there's not been a law passing
- 1:39:26on a federal level that it's legal
- 1:39:27so then you got this bubble
- 1:39:30it peaked around like September 2021
- 1:39:32where
- 1:39:34and it just went hyperbolic
- 1:39:36and it was a bubble in like private
- 1:39:37it's a lot of like equity
- 1:39:38But it's like this was that magnified.
- 1:39:41And so that made for kind of a good story.
- 1:39:44That was not obviously why we got into it, but it became, it was a lot of real things happening on the ground in terms of like in each state, you could see more and more states allowing for cannabis or passing laws to make it worse.
- 1:40:00medical and then recreational. So those are the kind of two levels where you can have cannabis
- 1:40:04legalization in a state in the US. So we thought this was very interesting. And we thought, wow,
- 1:40:09this is a more inefficient market. Macro is a very efficient market. So this is going to be
- 1:40:14something very different that, you know, will be very interesting to start doing business in.
- 1:40:19And problem was that we looked around and saw, you know, a lot of people were very interested
- 1:40:24in throwing money at, you know, anything having to do with like a credit fund in cannabis space.
- 1:40:28but it still looked like valuations
- 1:40:31that the industry were going to consolidate
- 1:40:35and it was going to be on a rough ride
- 1:40:37even though the peak of the bubble had passed.
- 1:40:40So we were like, okay, we can raise money easily
- 1:40:43but it doesn't look like a good time
- 1:40:45to really create wealth with the money that we're raising.
- 1:40:48Like, can you do it?
- 1:40:49Yeah, maybe, you know,
- 1:40:50but if you have the probability against you,
- 1:40:52you shouldn't go into it.
- 1:40:54So we decided we shouldn't go into it
- 1:40:55but we kept just learning about the industry.
- 1:40:57We thought, well, we can learn more
- 1:40:58and be wiser about it.
- 1:40:59So we went around,
- 1:41:01we made our personal investments in the space
- 1:41:03and we decided now recently to,
- 1:41:07we found some good people to work with to launch this.
- 1:41:10So it's part of alleviating people's fear about cannabis
- 1:41:14is we're actually taking a real estate focus on it.
- 1:41:17So our CEO really has a real estate background.
- 1:41:22So it's always going to be a collateral,
- 1:41:24which a real estate collateral of alternative use.
- 1:41:27So not the cannabis use, but if you have to sell this, you know, I have to close down and, you know, somebody is going to, instead of this dispenser, it's just going to be a regular corner shop.
- 1:41:35Like what's the value of this property?
- 1:41:37So, and then you lend, lending on the base of collateral means that if you default, you know, we can take the value of that, of the collateral.
- 1:41:46So that's where we are now.
- 1:41:47And we just started launching it now and raising money now.
- 1:41:50And so you're investing in properties that are connected to cannabis.
- 1:41:55Yeah.
- 1:41:55Not like cannabis farms and stuff like that.
- 1:41:57It can be, yeah.
- 1:41:58So the three areas of cannabis you can think of is like grow, manufacture, and then sell.
- 1:42:05And then that would be like the last one is dispensaries or what it's called where you can sell cannabis dispensary.
- 1:42:12And it's a different, you know, universe in different states.
- 1:42:15In some places you can just go in.
- 1:42:17Often you have to show your idea, but you don't have to have any special like card or anything like that.
- 1:42:22Some states will have, you can have a medical card and then you can not pay a certain tax on it.
- 1:42:29So you have a bigger payment up front to get the medical card.
- 1:42:33But if you're a big consumer, that might make it worth it.
- 1:42:36But you can also walk in and just show your ID and then you pay the full price with all the taxes, for example.
- 1:42:41And then in some states like Florida, there's only medical.
- 1:42:44So then you cannot go in.
- 1:42:47They want your medical card and you cannot enter if you don't have the medical card.
- 1:42:51so you get the medical card by just paying the right people does it sound funny to you discussing
- 1:42:56like running a business it sounds like my mates when i was like 17 in a but not in a you know like
- 1:43:02you're you're saying it in a very in a very upmarket way but it's like well we need to
- 1:43:07grow it and then we need to get it out to the people and this is how you can get it but it does
- 1:43:12seem weird isn't it like cannabis is for me has always been something that's illegal always you
- 1:43:17You know, I don't know.
- 1:43:18Where did you, of course, Sweden?
- 1:43:20Was it legal in Sweden?
- 1:43:21No, 100% not.
- 1:43:22No, I grew up with like, we have a word for all drugs that is not alcohol or coffee or sugar.
- 1:43:27You know, like all these other drugs that it's like, you know, that word is like, you know, cannabis would be in that bucket.
- 1:43:33And it would be as bad as like heroin, you know, like whatever, meth, whatever, like all this stuff.
- 1:43:38I would never have seen it.
- 1:43:39No, I never.
- 1:43:40The first time I saw cannabis was when I was 17.
- 1:43:42And I went to Australia as an exchange student.
- 1:43:45Yeah.
- 1:43:46And I didn smoke it though until I was 18 because I promised my parents not to smoke No it just seems it just seems funny hearing you discuss basically a grow It like I say it a program for growing cannabis and then selling it
- 1:44:04which I've never thought of it.
- 1:44:06Well, no, but I mean, it is mostly illegal.
- 1:44:10I mean, even in the States, is it relatively recently?
- 1:44:13so it was in in the 90s where you start it was like california and colorado were the pioneers
- 1:44:21i think colorado was first like with medical and california first recreational the other way around
- 1:44:26but that's kind of it starts it starts growing by now most states have cannabis either i think it's
- 1:44:3340 or so states have either recreational or medical and so most of the country you can you
- 1:44:42can buy cannabis. It's important to note though that because it's not federally legal, it's the
- 1:44:50interstate laws don't apply. You're not allowed to ship cannabis between states. So that also
- 1:44:56makes an interesting investment case. You can, each state is its own country that has 100, you know,
- 1:45:01complete sealed off. You cannot import export. It's not like with very high tariffs. It's like,
- 1:45:07no, it's like complete restrictions. So that means that you have to grow it everywhere,
- 1:45:12that you're also going to sell it,
- 1:45:13which means that you're going to have to grow it
- 1:45:15where it's very cold, like in Alaska.
- 1:45:18I think Alaska is recreational
- 1:45:19and you grow in maybe greenhouses,
- 1:45:22but often like indoor.
- 1:45:24So basically like a box, a warehouse.
- 1:45:26And you're just putting the lights in there.
- 1:45:28And yeah, it's definitely an industry.
- 1:45:30It's a serious industry.
- 1:45:31When I went into it, it was less serious.
- 1:45:32You go to the conference
- 1:45:33and everybody was kind of hippie, you know?
- 1:45:35So it was a scene, it was interesting,
- 1:45:37but it's also a time where everybody thought
- 1:45:40thought that you could just print money by setting up a cannabis grow and that was part of our
- 1:45:45apprehension of like going into it with other people's money but now it's really grown up
- 1:45:54in just a few years and you have you go to conferences you're it's serious people people
- 1:45:58realize that you can't just wing it and swing it it's more and more companies are cleaning up their
- 1:46:04their finances and looking more kind of similar in any way to the free cities movement in the sense
- 1:46:10that it's maturing a little bit?
- 1:46:12Well, you haven't had the kind of the silliness
- 1:46:15that has been going on in Free Cities mode.
- 1:46:16I think we're starting on the right side already,
- 1:46:20which is small, you know.
- 1:46:21I know what you mean, is that there are some,
- 1:46:23I don't know.
- 1:46:25What do you think about the idea
- 1:46:28that the Free Cities ecosystem
- 1:46:30is a bit of an umbrella term now?
- 1:46:33You know, like it kind of began
- 1:46:34as the free private city thing, didn't it?
- 1:46:36And now it's more about,
- 1:46:37it's the marketplace of governance.
- 1:46:38is like from, you know,
- 1:46:41intentional communities right off the end to Liberland
- 1:46:44or somewhere like that,
- 1:46:45looking for complete autonomy and stuff.
- 1:46:48Do you think that's a good move?
- 1:46:51Because they're part of,
- 1:46:54in a way that you could argue
- 1:46:55they're not part of the same system.
- 1:46:57But you come from very sort of,
- 1:47:01you know, the kind of SEZ part,
- 1:47:03which is very business-like
- 1:47:04and very like pre-private city, I would imagine.
- 1:47:08The intentional community stuff is completely different.
- 1:47:12And a lot of the time it's just people coming together in one place
- 1:47:16and saying, right, let's just live here.
- 1:47:17But we are interested in all of them,
- 1:47:20and we kind of created this umbrella term in a way.
- 1:47:23Yeah.
- 1:47:24I think, oh, there's so much in there.
- 1:47:26So one, like the word, what word to use for the umbrella terms,
- 1:47:30it's something I've had discussions about during this conference,
- 1:47:33and I don't have a good answer to it.
- 1:47:34I would say the first, the more original word for this was,
- 1:47:39there was a, there used to be an organization around this.
- 1:47:42It was we refer to as startup cities So there was a startup cities institute I think it was called It was based out of UFM the university in Guatemala And that is no longer an assistance
- 1:47:55but most people in this space
- 1:47:58have been affiliated or know about them
- 1:48:00and talk to these people one way or the other.
- 1:48:02And what is a better word for it?
- 1:48:04Because at its core,
- 1:48:06my philosophy is that
- 1:48:08I think the world would be better
- 1:48:09if everybody could live in a,
- 1:48:11have a more decentralized world
- 1:48:13where everybody can sign a contract in the kind of society you want to live in.
- 1:48:17Everybody's not going to want to live in what we would think of
- 1:48:20as some kind of libertarian utopia or anything like that.
- 1:48:23I think that if you're a Marxist and want to have a Marxist utopia,
- 1:48:25you should be able to have that and run it like that.
- 1:48:29And should we then call it free cities?
- 1:48:30It's a freedom to join, but it's in a way...
- 1:48:34So I'm a little bit on two sides.
- 1:48:36In a way, we can say it's startup cities
- 1:48:39because we're all just saying this is something new.
- 1:48:41On the other hand, if the movement grows, we can't call it startup cities anymore, right?
- 1:48:45So I don't really know.
- 1:48:47Decentralized cities.
- 1:48:48I think intentional communities, just like you were going to, it sounds a little bit too much maybe like we're just a bunch of hippies putting out some tents in the forest.
- 1:48:58So I think that in terms of attracting the serious money investments into the space, we do need a good word for it.
- 1:49:04And I think maybe free cities is as good as anything I can think of.
- 1:49:07But I think it's interesting to juxtapose to the startup cities goes more into this kind of, look, it doesn't have to be any specific.
- 1:49:13It's not ideologically driven.
- 1:49:15It's just us realizing that if people can choose to live in a place and start learning from birth that just because you're born in the place doesn't mean you're governed by that place.
- 1:49:26And if you don't have kids and think you're going to have kids, I would never sign papers saying that your kids are hereby governed by this.
- 1:49:33It has to be that after the age of X at least, you can always exit.
- 1:49:36you know um then you know that's kind of what we want to capture right that it's more of this
- 1:49:42voluntary community voluntary cities or something like that contractual the startup cities monica
- 1:49:47has really been adopted by the kind of network state people that's where you sit well that's
- 1:49:54where you hear that's spoken the most a lot of you know like the sort of longevity people those
- 1:50:00kind of you know pop-up cities startup cities you know it it's definitely a um a personality to those
- 1:50:08you know i think on the on one end you get the free city people which tend to be more bricks and
- 1:50:13mortar and on the other hand you get the kind of network state people who are a bit more like
- 1:50:18online dreamers i know i don't know i don't know what you think is but it's very much a personality
- 1:50:24thing it's like it's like feet on the ground head in the clouds kind of thing yeah okay yeah i never
- 1:50:30thought about that i'm just thinking from the perspective of if you want to pitch this as an
- 1:50:35investment to somebody yeah right now it's not like i'm investing we talk about the investment
- 1:50:40of real estate in these places that's where it's at right it's real estate maybe with the land value
- 1:50:45as well um but the economics of it the risk profile is more like an equity investing investment
- 1:50:51could be really high returns if this take off,
- 1:50:54but it's also a big risk that, you know,
- 1:50:55it is a startup project in that way.
- 1:50:57So that's why I'm thinking the label of startup city
- 1:51:02is more of this, hey, there's exciting return here.
- 1:51:05Like, look at this.
- 1:51:06Hey, VC, bro.
- 1:51:08On the other hand, right?
- 1:51:09Again, if it grows up,
- 1:51:10then we don't want to call it a startup anymore.
- 1:51:13So, yeah.
- 1:51:14Well, also it might not be a city.
- 1:51:15That's the other thing that bugs me.
- 1:51:17Yeah.
- 1:51:18But I think it happened naturally.
- 1:51:20And I think all of those things they turn into, you know,
- 1:51:24it's like when you name your child, you, it sounds weird at the beginning,
- 1:51:27but then once you've called them that for 10 years,
- 1:51:30you would never want anything any different, you know? Um, but, um,
- 1:51:34a lot of, we've been speaking for almost two hours.
- 1:51:37So I think we should wrap it up maybe but I like to finish with some kind of positive looking to the future type
- 1:51:48You know, put Lott's eye on where we're going,
- 1:51:52what's happening and where you think.
- 1:51:55Give us a positive future.
- 1:51:58I mean, actually, maybe not.
- 1:52:01Give it your analytical eye like you did at the start.
- 1:52:03I enjoyed that because I'd like to hear the truth
- 1:52:06rather than my sort of fairy story.
- 1:52:09No, I understand.
- 1:52:10Ending on a positive note too.
- 1:52:11No, I think, I do think it's interesting
- 1:52:15that you took the parallel to the cannabis space
- 1:52:19and the startup space.
- 1:52:21I think that the overturned window
- 1:52:23of what is acceptable to talk about
- 1:52:25and say that you're involved in can move quite rapidly.
- 1:52:29And I think we're going to see it.
- 1:52:31The focus on creation in the space
- 1:52:34is completely the right thing.
- 1:52:35I'm an advisor to TIPOLIS and Titus Gable there is doing a tremendous job and like really is professionalizing this conference and helping with that of course together with Peter Young and really just thinking about it as a business very serious how that project is being like pursued and how that company is going.
- 1:52:57So just, you know, when you have the right kind of people and the right kind of image, and then you have some case studies of not the founders, but other people who came in who put their money in and made a good return and also the political stability, you know, it just kind of beat a little bit of time.
- 1:53:19You know, it's people going to sit and they're going to wait and going to see just like we see in Bitcoin.
- 1:53:23We know that the Satoshi paper was published in 2008 and now we really have the adoption.
- 1:53:29It takes time.
- 1:53:30But I mean, we are we'll keep fighting the good fight.
- 1:53:33I mean, it's we are we haven't had big setbacks, you know, like we haven't.
- 1:53:39Jesus, don't say that out loud.
- 1:53:42I think the whole world is going to collapse now.
- 1:53:44That just made me clench.
- 1:53:45Oh, I'm not like that at all.
- 1:53:47I'm like, this is awesome.
- 1:53:49there's a lot of things that go forward at setbacks when you say something like that out loud though
- 1:53:54that's dangerous we've not had any major setbacks i'm not superstitious like you then no i am so no
- 1:53:59i think we're i mean i think we're in the good track i think the right people are here i'm really
- 1:54:02it's been super exciting to be here and see everybody who's involved and talk to people
- 1:54:06and there are people coming through so many angles so the investments of in the longevity you mentioned
- 1:54:11but general health care is is something that you have an opportunity to pursue so much faster and
- 1:54:17it's so important for the whole world of course the longevity but it's also just to get the longevity
- 1:54:22right we have to have more people who you know survive the the diseases that are out there and
- 1:54:27we're seeing more and more there we know how how hard that is to and how long it takes you know to
- 1:54:31go through the the passage of of acceptance in in legalization all that in u.s but really anywhere
- 1:54:38in the world just to see how many fronts that come together yeah it changes the world and it
- 1:54:43starts with the steps that we're taking now wonderful right i'm back i'm back thank god
- 1:54:50i was getting despondent momentarily no i wasn't thanks lotta appreciate it i've been looking forward
- 1:54:57to speaking to you and it's been it's been exactly what i expected so thank you thank you thank you
- 1:55:02and um good luck on the way you're going back to america to do whatever so good luck and good
- 1:55:08luck with your wealth management company might bung you a bit of money if you want put some of my
- 1:55:13money in there no and yeah thanks for coming in it's been awesome thanks thank you