Latest / The Office Politics Podcast with Fexingo: Workplace Dynamics, Influence, and Getting Things Done / How the IKEA Effect Can Boost Your Office Influence
Transcript
- Lucas: You know those flat-pack furniture boxes from IKEA where you spend a Saturday assembling a bookcase, and by the end you're convinced it's the best piece of furniture you've ever owned, even though it's basically particleboard? Luna: Oh, I have a Billy bookcase in my living room that I'm irrationally proud of. I get it. Lucas: Right. That's the IKEA Effect in action. Behavioral scientists call it the 'IKEA Effect' — we place a disproportionately high value on things we helped create, even if the result is objectively mediocre. And in office politics, this bias can be a powerful tool for building influence. Luna: So you're saying we can use people's tendency to overvalue their own contributions to get them on our side? Lucas: Exactly. And there's a specific case I want to walk through. A couple of years ago, a product manager at HubSpot — I'll call her Sarah — was trying to get her team to adopt a new feature that required significant engineering resources. The feature was controversial because it wasn't directly tied to revenue, but it was critical for user retention. Luna: So she had to convince engineers to spend time on something that didn't obviously benefit them. Lucas: Right. And here's where the IKEA Effect comes in. Instead of presenting a fully baked plan, Sarah went to the lead engineer and said, 'I have a rough idea, but I need your help to design the architecture. I'm not sure how to make it scalable.' She invited him to co-create the solution. Luna: She basically made him a co-author of the feature. Lucas: Yes. And once he invested a few hours in designing the technical approach, he became the feature's biggest advocate. He started championing it in engineering stand-ups, defending the extra work, even recruiting other engineers to help. Because it was now his idea, too. Luna: That's a great example. But I wonder — does it always work? What if the engineer had said no? Lucas: That's the risk. The IKEA Effect only works if the person actually contributes something meaningful. You can't fake it. If you ask someone to 'help' but then ignore their input, they'll feel manipulated. The key is to genuinely leave room for their contribution — around 30 to 40 percent of the total work, according to research. Luna: Interesting. So it's not about letting them do everything, but about giving them enough ownership to trigger the bias. Lucas: Exactly. In one study from Harvard, researchers found that participants who assembled IKEA boxes valued them 63 percent more than identical pre-assembled boxes. But they also found that if the assembly was too easy — like just putting on a few knobs — the effect disappeared. The effort needs to feel real. Luna: So in an office context, you need to give people a task that's challenging but not overwhelming. Lucas: Right. And there's a second layer to this. The IKEA Effect also works when you're the one receiving help. Say a colleague helps you refine a proposal. You'll end up valuing that proposal more because you've put effort into incorporating their feedback. So it's a two-way street. Luna: That reminds me of something I read about the Not Invented Here syndrome — where teams reject ideas from outside. The IKEA Effect seems like the antidote: if you let them contribute, they'll adopt it as their own. Lucas: That's exactly the mechanism. The Not Invented Here bias is basically the inverse of the IKEA Effect. So if you're trying to introduce a new process or tool, the worst thing you can do is present it as a done deal. You want to leave a loose end that someone else can tie. Luna: Can you give a second example? Maybe outside of product management. Lucas: Sure. Think about a marketing director who wants to shift the company's social media strategy from LinkedIn to Instagram. She could present a detailed deck with all the data. But instead, she asks the social media manager to 'help her understand the Instagram algorithm' and to co-create a content calendar. The manager invests time, feels ownership, and soon becomes the internal champion for the shift. Luna: So the key is to identify the specific contribution you want from the other person and frame it as essential to the project's success. Lucas: Exactly. And here's a nuance: the contribution has to be visible. If the engineer's work on the architecture is buried in a code review that no one else sees, they might not feel the same ownership. You want to create moments where their contribution is acknowledged publicly — even if it's just a quick shout-out in a meeting. Luna: That ties into what we talked about in Episode 101 with the Benjamin Franklin Effect — asking someone for a favor makes them like you more. This is similar, but it's about asking for their expertise. Lucas: Right. The Benjamin Franklin Effect is about getting someone to do a small favor for you, which creates cognitive dissonance — 'I did him a favor, so I must like him.' The IKEA Effect is about getting someone to invest effort in a project, which makes them value the project more. They're related but distinct. Luna: So which one should you use when? Lucas: I'd say use the Benjamin Franklin Effect when you need to build a personal rapport with someone you don't know well. Use the IKEA Effect when you need to build buy-in for a specific idea or project. They complement each other. Luna: Let's talk about risks. What if someone over-invests and becomes too attached to their contribution? Like, what if the engineer insists the feature must be built exactly the way he designed it? Lucas: That's a real risk. The IKEA Effect can lead to what psychologists call the 'endowment effect' — we overvalue our own creations. To mitigate that, you want to keep the collaboration iterative. You say, 'This is a great starting point, let's test it and see what we learn.' That frames the contribution as a prototype, not a final product. Luna: So you're creating ownership but also leaving room for change. Lucas: Exactly. And there's a time component. The IKEA Effect is strongest right after the effort is completed. Over time, the bias fades. So if you need someone to champion your project, get them involved early, and then keep them looped in with small updates that remind them of their contribution. Luna: That makes sense. So let's say I'm trying to get my team to adopt a new project management tool. How would I apply the IKEA Effect? Lucas: First, don't pick the tool yourself. Invite two or three team members to evaluate options with you. Give them a specific criterion to focus on — like integration with existing systems. Then, when you finally choose a tool, you can say, 'Based on your research on integrations, we decided on Asana.' They'll feel ownership over the decision. Luna: And if they resist adoption later, you can remind them, 'Remember, you helped pick this because of the integrations.' Lucas: Right. But you have to be genuine. If you already decided on Asana and just go through the motions, people will see through it. The IKEA Effect is not a manipulation tactic; it's a recognition that people value what they create. Use it to genuinely collaborate. Luna: So the takeaway is: if you want buy-in, don't sell. Invite co-creation. Lucas: That's a great one-line summary. And it's backed by research. A 2012 study by Norton, Mochon, and Ariely — the same team that coined the term — showed that the IKEA Effect holds even when the end product is objectively worse. People who built their own origami crane valued it five times more than those who saw a professionally folded one. Luna: Wow. So even if the result is imperfect, the effort creates value in the creator's eyes. Lucas: Exactly. And that's the superpower. In office politics, you don't need the perfect plan. You need a plan that people feel they helped build. Because once they own it, they'll defend it, improve it, and push it through obstacles you couldn't overcome alone. Luna: Speaking of things people own and defend — I know this is a bit of a pivot, but it's related. We've been doing this podcast ad-free since the beginning, and a lot of listeners have asked how they can support us. If you've found these strategies useful, especially if you've applied any of them in your own work, one way to support the show is to buy us a coffee. It's at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. It helps us keep the episodes free and focused on the substance, not ads. Lucas: Yeah, I'm glad you brought that up. We really do this for the listeners who want to get better at navigating workplace dynamics, and knowing that it's helpful is what keeps us going. So thank you to anyone who's contributed. Now, back to the IKEA Effect — I want to talk about one more application: using it on your boss. Luna: Oh, that's interesting. How do you get your boss to invest effort in your project? Lucas: Suppose you want to launch a new initiative. Instead of presenting a full proposal, go to your boss with a rough draft and ask for their strategic input. Say, 'I've got a first pass, but I'd love your perspective on the scope. What do you think we should prioritize?' They'll invest a few minutes, and suddenly, the initiative becomes theirs too. Luna: And if they offer suggestions, you incorporate them and then come back with a revised plan that reflects their ideas. Lucas: Exactly. Now they see the plan as partially theirs. And when it comes time to pitch it to senior leadership, your boss becomes a co-advocate. They'll say, 'We discussed this, and I think it's a smart approach.' That's a lot more powerful than you going alone. Luna: That's a great tactic. But what if your boss is the type who doesn't like to be bothered with details? Lucas: Then you need a different approach. The IKEA Effect requires willingness to contribute. If your boss prefers to delegate entirely, you might be better off using the Contrast Principle we covered in Episode 97 — present two options where one is clearly better. The IKEA Effect is for collaborative bosses. Luna: Good point. So it's not a one-size-fits-all. Lucas: No, and that's true for most office politics tools. The key is to read the person and the situation. But when it fits, the IKEA Effect is remarkably effective because it taps into a deep psychological need: the need to feel competent and impactful. When you help create something, it's a signal of your own value. Luna: So final question: if someone listening wants to try this tomorrow, what's the single smallest step they can take? Lucas: Identify one project or idea you're working on. Find one person whose buy-in you need — it could be a teammate, a boss, or a cross-functional partner. Then schedule a 15-minute conversation where you ask for their specific input on one aspect of the project. Not general feedback — a specific, solvable problem. After they contribute, acknowledge their input publicly, even if it's just in an email. That's the seed. Luna: And watch the IKEA Effect do the rest. Lucas: Exactly. Thanks for listening, and we'll see you next time with another tool for your office politics toolkit.