Latest / The Jeremy Ryan Slate Show / Rome Killed the Man Who Was Saving It
Transcript
- 0:00We tend to think Rome fell because of the Barbarians
- 0:02finally breaking through, that the Goths gather at the gates,
- 0:05that Oliver came over the walls with some screaming hoard behind
- 0:08him, and that civilization itself ended at the point of a
- 0:12foreign sword. That's the Hollywood version of
- 0:14history. The reality is actually worse.
- 0:17More accurately, it's more revealing.
- 0:20Rome didn't fall because it ran out of soldiers, it fell because
- 0:23it executed the one man still holding the system together. 1/2
- 0:27Vandal general named Silica. He defeated Ulurich 3 separate
- 0:31times. He held the Rhine frontier
- 0:33together. He kept the grain moving, kept
- 0:36the armies paid, and somehow kept a collapsing political
- 0:39structure functioning with silver he had to drag out of the
- 0:43Senate that hated him for forcing the issue.
- 0:45For 13 years he was basically the only thing standing between
- 0:48the Western Empire and total disintegration.
- 0:52And then Rome killed him. Not because he was incompetent,
- 0:56not because he betrayed the empire.
- 0:57They killed him because he was never considered Roman enough.
- 1:00The Senate issued the order and the Emperor signed it and the
- 1:03machine, because that's what the late Empire had become by this
- 1:06point. The machine looked the one man
- 1:08still making it work and decided he was a threat.
- 1:12What happens next unfolds almost immediately, not over
- 1:15generations or even decades. The Legion's mutiny Around
- 1:1910,000 Germanic auxiliaries defect directly to Ulurich's
- 1:23camp, the borders don't really break so much as dissolve.
- 1:26And then Ulrich walks into an undefended Italy and then sacks
- 1:30Rome in 410. Without silico, there's no
- 1:32resistance and there's no real realm anymore.
- 1:34And this is where the story changes.
- 1:37Because this isn't really about Barbarians at the gate anymore.
- 1:39It's about what happens when a system becomes so consumed by
- 1:43fear of the outsider that it destroys the 1 insider still
- 1:46capable of saving it. Empires don't usually die from
- 1:50the outside in. They destroy their own immune
- 1:52system first and then call it patriotism.
- 1:54And if you understand what happened to Stillico, not just
- 1:57the dates or the personalities, but the mechanics underneath it,
- 2:01you start recognizing the same pattern in other places,
- 2:04including now. Welcome back to the Roman
- 2:25pattern. I'm Jeremy Ryan Slate, CEO of
- 2:28Commander Brand can check us out over at commanderbrand.com.
- 2:32And now our story. To understand what really died
- 2:35in August of four O 8, you first have to understand what Rome had
- 2:39already become by that point. This was not the Rome of
- 2:42Augustus. It wasn't even the realm of
- 2:44Constantine. By 395, the Western Roman Empire
- 2:47was basically a hollow administrative shell wrapped
- 2:50around a functioning military structure.
- 2:53The border still stretched from Britain all the way down to
- 2:55North Africa. On paper, it remained the most
- 2:57powerful state on earth, but on the ground it was a body being
- 3:01kept upright by 1 remaining muscle.
- 3:04That muscle was the army, and the man commanding it was
- 3:07Flavius Stilico. What's interesting about Stilico
- 3:10is that he really should not have existed inside the Roman
- 3:13system at all. His father was a Vandal, one of
- 3:16the very tribes Rome had spent centuries fighting against.
- 3:20His mother was Roman. In an earlier era, that alone
- 3:23would have disqualified him from serious power.
- 3:26But by the late 4th century, the empire was running out of
- 3:28options. It had run out of Romans willing
- 3:30to fight. It had also run out of Romans
- 3:32willing to pay taxes. Honestly, it had run out of
- 3:35Romans willing to keep the bureaucracy functioning at all.
- 3:38The machine did what systems often do when they start
- 3:41breaking down. It began recruiting from the
- 3:43outside because it no longer had enough strength inside itself.
- 3:46And Silico rises through that environment, but he rises
- 3:50through a system that's already dying.
- 3:52If you really want to understand why Rome collapsed later, you
- 3:55have to look at the fault lines already running underneath it by
- 3:58this point. Not just the dates, but the
- 4:00mechanics. The first fault line which we've
- 4:03beaten to death at this point was money.
- 4:05By 395, the Roman currency had been debased for more than a
- 4:09century. The old silver denarius was gone
- 4:12and replaced by what were mostly bronze covered in a thin silver
- 4:15wash. The empire could no longer pay
- 4:17its soldiers in hard money consistently, so instead it paid
- 4:20them in promises, land, taxes, exemptions and the right to
- 4:24loot. Conquer territory.
- 4:26And once that happens, loyalty changes.
- 4:29The army stops being loyal to Rome itself and becomes loyal to
- 4:32the general capable of actually rewarding them.
- 4:35Rome is no longer the source of stability, but their commander
- 4:37is. The second fault line was
- 4:39borders, which has been our largest reaching expost this
- 4:42point. The Roman frontier stretched
- 4:44from roughly 3000 miles across the Rhine, the Danube and the
- 4:48eastern deserts. Every mile required soldiers,
- 4:51supplies, roads and money. But the population of the
- 4:54Western Empire was shrinking at the same time.
- 4:56Plague, civil war, economic collapse, all of it feeding into
- 5:00each other, which, by the way, Kyle Harper has a great book on
- 5:03fewer people meant fewer recruits.
- 5:06Fewer recruits meant thinner frontiers and thinner frontiers
- 5:10that meant more crossings. And that's actually an important
- 5:13distinction here. Most of these groups are not
- 5:15evading in the way that people imagine they were crossing.
- 5:19They were farmers, families, mercenaries, refugees, and
- 5:23entire communities moving into Roman territory because Rome
- 5:26still represented relative stability.
- 5:29Rome needed them for labor and military manpower, but Rome also
- 5:33feared them culturally and politically.
- 5:35The Empire could never fully resolve that contradiction.
- 5:38Then you get the third fault line, which was power itself.
- 5:41The political system of the late Empire had evolved into
- 5:43something strangely functional and deeply monstrous at the same
- 5:47time. The Emperor was no longer really
- 5:49a battlefield leader, but he was a symbol, almost a sacred
- 5:52figure, surrounded by a court of officials, advisors, eunuchs,
- 5:57and layers of insulation. Real power belonged to whoever
- 6:00controlled access to him, whoever could whisper into his
- 6:03ear, whoever could convince him that someone else represented a
- 6:07threat. The system had a name, the
- 6:09Consortium, the Imperial Council.
- 6:12It rewarded survival far more than competence, which meant
- 6:16Stillico was eventually going to collide with it.
- 6:19Because Stillico doesn't rise through court politics, he rises
- 6:22to results. He gets them.
- 6:24As a younger officer, he served on diplomatic missions to
- 6:27Persia. He negotiates treaties.
- 6:30He commends cavalry in the battle.
- 6:32He develops A reputation for effectiveness, not charisma.
- 6:35And actually, that's probably the key thing about it.
- 6:38He wasn't especially political, but he was useful, and
- 6:41Theodosius the Great notices that usefulness immediately.
- 6:45Theodosius, who becomes the last man to rule a united Roman
- 6:48Empire, understands something that later systems forget
- 6:51completely. Competence matters more than
- 6:54blood when the system is under stress.
- 6:56So he promotes Silico to Magister Milito, the Master of
- 7:00Soldiers, which is the highest military office in the Western
- 7:03Empire. Then he does something even more
- 7:05significant. He marries Silico to Serena, his
- 7:09adopted niece and a member of the Imperial family, a daughter
- 7:12of the Imperial House handed to 1/2 Vandal General.
- 7:16That wasn't romance anymore, but strategic planning.
- 7:19Theodosius knew his sons were children, not just physically,
- 7:23but likely would be children for a very long time the more we
- 7:26learn about them. Honorius was 10 years old.
- 7:29Arcadius was 17, neither had military experience and had
- 7:32never really governed anything serious.
- 7:35He built a structure around them.
- 7:37Steilaco commands the armies and Serena, well, she provides the
- 7:40dynastic legitimacy. Together they stabilize the
- 7:43empire until the boys mature, which to some points never
- 7:46happened. But Theodosius dies in January
- 7:49of 395 and suddenly Steilaco at 35 years old becomes the most
- 7:53powerful man in the Western Empire.
- 7:56Which also means the machine immediately starts preparing to
- 7:59destroy him. Now, at the same time, another
- 8:01figure enters the story, Alaric the Goth.
- 8:04And Alaric is important not just because of some mindless
- 8:08barbarian warlord. He served inside the Roman
- 8:10military system, and he understands Roman tactics,
- 8:13logistics, and their weaknesses. He also has a legitimate
- 8:17grievance. The Goths have been promised
- 8:19land and payment for military service under Theodosius, and
- 8:23after his death those promises, well, they basically collapse.
- 8:26So Alaric does what commanders throughout history tend to do.
- 8:29When agreements fail, he begins extracting payments by force.
- 8:33In 395 he marches through Thrace and Macedonia, and eventually he
- 8:38reaches the gates of Athens. Stillico mobilizes immediately.
- 8:42He gathers the Western Field Army, crosses into Greece and
- 8:46corners Alaric and Arcadia, and then Constance and Opal
- 8:49intervenes. They order him to stand down the
- 8:52Eastern court, which is controlled by officials like
- 8:55Eutropius and Rufinus. They don't want Silico becoming
- 8:58too powerful in the East. They don't want 1/2 Vandal
- 9:01General becoming the savior of the empire.
- 9:03They don't want the Western Empire gaining leverage through
- 9:05military success. So they declare Silico a Public
- 9:08Enemy and order him to withdraw. He obeys.
- 9:12And that's where you start seeing the real pattern emerge.
- 9:15Here, the machine is no longer optimizing for victory, but
- 9:18internal control. It's better to let a hostile
- 9:21army escape than allow the wrong men to become indispensable, and
- 9:25that pattern repeats constantly in declining systems.
- 9:28We see it modernly. Competence becomes threatening
- 9:30because competence creates independent authority.
- 9:33Alaric isn't defeated here, but he's delayed, and eventually
- 9:36that delay runs out. By four O 1, Alaric conveys
- 9:40Italy itself not with just a raid, but an actual invasion.
- 9:44He crosses the Julian Alps, bypasses Milan, which is the
- 9:47western capital at this point, and he moves toward Rome.
- 9:50The Senate panics because at this point they're just men who
- 9:53spent decades managing estates and debating philosophy.
- 9:56They don't have armies of their own.
- 9:57They haven't dealt with a real existential military threat on
- 10:00Italian soil in generations. But what they have is Flavius
- 10:05Stilico. And Stilico responds with what
- 10:07is honestly an extraordinary military and provision.
- 10:11He strips troops from the Rhine frontier and pulls garrisons out
- 10:14of Britain. He recruits Federate forces,
- 10:16Allens, Huns, Goths, and basically anyone who's capable
- 10:20of fighting at this point. Then he marches towards Alaric
- 10:22and meets him at Palentia in four O 2.
- 10:25It's Easter Sunday. The Goths believe no Roman
- 10:28commander would attack on a holy day, but Silico isn't any
- 10:31commander. He attacks anyway.
- 10:33The battle becomes chaotic and Roman cavalry crash into the
- 10:37Gothic camp. Alaric's family is captured and
- 10:40thousands of Goths are taken prisoner.
- 10:42Alaric retreats, but he'll be back.
- 10:44Silico does something afterward that becomes politically fatal
- 10:47for him. He makes a deal.
- 10:49Instead of exterminating the Goths or driving them completely
- 10:52out of Italy, he offers Olarich a Roman military position.
- 10:55Strategically, it makes perfect sense.
- 10:58Olarich's forces could become a buffer against war threats and a
- 11:02deployable military asset for the Empire itself.
- 11:04But the Senate doesn't see strategy.
- 11:06They see 1/2 Vandal General negotiating with Barbarians.
- 11:09That's when the whispers begin. Silico is too close to the
- 11:12Goths. He's too ambitious.
- 11:14He wants his son on the Western throne.
- 11:17None of this is likely true, but systems like this eventually
- 11:20stop needing truth. They just need targets.
- 11:23Then the real catastrophe arrived on the last day of
- 11:26December in Four O 6. The Rhine freeze is solid.
- 11:29For centuries, that river had functioned as a barrier between
- 11:32Rome and the dramatic world. Legions guarded those crossings
- 11:36for generation after generation, but many of those troops had
- 11:40already been pulled away by silico to defend Italy from
- 11:42Alaric. Now the frontier is exposed and
- 11:4510s of thousands cross in a single winter.
- 11:48Vandals, swevy Allens entire emigrating populations moving
- 11:52into Gaul again. This isn't really a traditional
- 11:55invasion, it's more like a mass movement of peoples through a
- 11:59collapsing border structure. Sounds a lot like the southern
- 12:01border. And there are no legions left to
- 12:04stop him. They sweep across Gaul and burn
- 12:06City, seize farmland and keep pushing South.
- 12:09This is exactly the kind of border failure that Silico has
- 12:12spent years trying to prevent, but the political system never
- 12:15gave him resources to actually stabilize the frontier for the
- 12:18long term. The Senate refuses major
- 12:20taxation increases, the Eastern Empire withdraws reinforcement,
- 12:25and Honorius, now Emperor, barely understands what's
- 12:28happening around him. In fact, he's interested in his
- 12:30chickens. He's not an evil man, but he's
- 12:33quite irrelevant. He's raised inside the palace at
- 12:36Ravenna, isolated from military life, administration and reality
- 12:41itself. He doesn't read military
- 12:43dispatches. In fact, he doesn't care.
- 12:44He raises those chickens we just talked about.
- 12:47And honestly, that detail matters because it shows the
- 12:49system has been selecting for over generations.
- 12:53Bureaucratic survival has gradually filtered out leaders
- 12:56capable of commanding armies or understanding a real crisis.
- 12:59What remains is a ceremonial figurehead.
- 13:02But the figurehead still has one crucial power.
- 13:05He can sign execution orders. And the people surrounding him,
- 13:08they're ready for him to use that.
- 13:10The man who ultimately destroys Stilico is named Olympius.
- 13:14Most people haven't heard of him, which is fitting because
- 13:16figures like this almost always operate indirectly.
- 13:19Olympius is a palace official. He's a master of court politics,
- 13:23and he whispered accusations, maybe even a eunuch.
- 13:26He understands the fastest route to power is eliminating who
- 13:28currently holds it. He starts constructing A
- 13:30narrative around Stilico. He tells Hunorius that Stilico
- 13:34is secretly conspiring with Alaric.
- 13:37He intends to place his son Eukaryus on the eastern throne.
- 13:40His barbarian blood guarantees he's going to eventually be
- 13:43betrayed. None of it's true.
- 13:46Stilico has spent 13 years fighting to hold the Western
- 13:48Empire together. He's defeated Alaric repeatedly,
- 13:51preserved the Rhine frontier as long as possible, and maintain
- 13:54the state largely through force of competence.
- 13:57But proximity to power changes how systems process information.
- 14:01Facts begin mattering less than the actual narrative.
- 14:03Olympius tells the clearer story than Silico does.
- 14:07In August of 408, Honorius signs the order.
- 14:10Silico has declared a Public Enemy in the West.
- 14:12Now his allies are arrested and his family becomes a target.
- 14:15His life is forfeit. The man who saved the Empire
- 14:18multiple times is suddenly defined as its greatest threat
- 14:22because the machine has decided that he is.
- 14:24Silico hears the news before they even arrive to arrest him,
- 14:27and this is one of the greatest turning points of the story.
- 14:30Because he absolutely could have resisted, but he chose not to.
- 14:3310,000 Federate troops are personally loyal to him.
- 14:36He could March on Ravenna, seize power, and likely win.
- 14:40I don't think those chickens are stopping him.
- 14:41He could become exactly what his enemies claim he already is, but
- 14:45he doesn't want to. Instead, he takes refuge in a
- 14:48church and claims sanctuary. He's trying to de escalate the
- 14:50situation, but he's not really winning.
- 14:53The soldiers alive swear he'll be safe and promise him mercy if
- 14:56he comes out. So Silica walks out of the
- 14:58church. They seize him immediately, read
- 15:01the charges, and draw their swords.
- 15:03Flavia Silico is executed on the 22nd of August and 408 at 48
- 15:07years old. Soon after, his son Eukaryius is
- 15:10haunted down and killed. His wife Serena is eventually
- 15:13strangled. During Oliver's later siege of
- 15:15Rome, they purge his supporters. His Federate troops lose their
- 15:19positions. The machine completes the purge
- 15:22expertly, and the consequences begin almost immediately.
- 15:25First, the Federate soldiers who served under Silico for years,
- 15:29Goths, puns, islands, men whose loyalty to Rome had depended on
- 15:33their relationship with Silico. Well, now their commander's
- 15:36dead. Their families are being
- 15:37targeted so they leave. Roughly 10,000 of them marched
- 15:41directly to Alaric's camp. The army Stilico built to defend
- 15:45Italy becomes the army that will later destroy it.
- 15:48Then the Gothic auxiliary is serving in the regular Roman
- 15:51legions. Watch what happened and they get
- 15:54the message. Your service doesn't make you
- 15:56Roman, but your blood matters more, and your blood is never
- 16:00going to be Roman enough. So they desert too.
- 16:02Not in the dozens, but in the thousands.
- 16:05Then the borders collapse even further.
- 16:07Without a functioning field army, the Rhine crossing spread
- 16:10unchecked through Gaul and Spain.
- 16:12Constantine the Third rises out of Britain and seizes power in
- 16:15Gaul. The Western Empire starts
- 16:17fragmenting into competing regional territories.
- 16:20And all this happens in less than two years.
- 16:22That's the part that people often miss.
- 16:24Steiliko have been holding the entire system together, through
- 16:27his relationships, through competence, through his force of
- 16:30personality. But there is no deeper
- 16:32institutional structure underneath him capable of
- 16:34surviving his removal. No replacement, no succession,
- 16:38and no mechanism. There's no stable St.
- 16:41bureaucracy behind him. The emperor kills the only
- 16:43person capable of saving the system, and then he discovers
- 16:46there's nobody left by four O 8 Alaric marches directly into
- 16:50Rome. The city hasn't faced a foreign
- 16:52army in roughly 8 centuries. Rome is still the symbolic
- 16:56center of the world psychologically, even if the
- 16:58administrative capital has moved elsewhere.
- 17:00And Ulrich actually doesn't want to destroy it.
- 17:03He just wants leverage. He demands payment and land for
- 17:06his people, and also a formal military office.
- 17:10That thing he'd been refused. The Senate negotiates a ransom,
- 17:13and Ulrich accepts it. Then Hon Orius, who's safe
- 17:16behind the marshes of Ravenna, refuses to ratify the agreement.
- 17:20He's still got those chickens. The system can no longer even
- 17:23negotiate rationally its own interests.
- 17:26Alaric besieges Rome three separate times, four O 8, four O
- 17:299, and again in 410, four. Ten seems to be the one we
- 17:32always talk about. Each time the Senate negotiates,
- 17:36each time Hanorius refuses. Then on August 24th, 410,
- 17:40somebody opens the gates. We don't know who.
- 17:42Maybe a slave sympathizer, maybe someone desperate enough to end
- 17:46the siege. Alaric enters the sea for three
- 17:49days. Rome is sacked.
- 17:51Now, historically, the sack itself is not the literal end of
- 17:54the empire, but psychologically it changes everything.
- 17:57For 8 centuries, Rome had represented invincibility,
- 18:00eternal power, the center of the civilization itself.
- 18:03Now the city is stripped, humiliated, and violated by our
- 18:07army that Rome itself once employed, and the man most
- 18:09capable of preventing it has already been executed by his own
- 18:12government. And that's why this story
- 18:14matters beyond Rome, because the pattern keeps repeating.
- 18:17Even if the chickens disappear, the system encounters crisis and
- 18:20begins recruiting talented outsiders from the margins,
- 18:24people that are valued for competence rather than pedigree.
- 18:27The outsiders perform well and they solve the problem the
- 18:30establishment can't solve. They actually build authority
- 18:32from results, and initially the establishment tolerates that
- 18:36because it doesn't have an alternative.
- 18:37But tolerance, it's not acceptance.
- 18:40The moment the crisis appears manageable again, the
- 18:43calculation changes. Now those outsiders, well, they
- 18:46look dangerous. What if they become too popular
- 18:48or indispensable? What if their loyalty is to the
- 18:51mission rather than the institution itself?
- 18:53And Rome knew it was. And slowly the machine turns
- 18:56against them. There's whispers and
- 18:58accusations, questions about their loyalty.
- 19:00Not because they failed, but it's because they succeeded.
- 19:03And actually, that's usually the most dangerous point in any
- 19:06institutional crisis. Not the crisis itself, but the
- 19:10moment afterward, when the old order attempts to reassert
- 19:12control over the people who navigated the emergency.
- 19:16Stillico is officially executed for being half vandal.
- 19:19But the real crime? It's competence.
- 19:21He's too effective and independent and too difficult
- 19:24for the system to fully control. And because the system can't
- 19:27absorb him, it destroys him. Then in destroying him, it
- 19:31destroys itself. So when you look at Rome's three
- 19:34major fault lines, the parallels become uncomfortable.
- 19:36First, there's money, and we're living through the largest
- 19:39monetary experiment in history. Debt levels would have seemed
- 19:43impossible a generation ago because central banks are
- 19:46constantly expanding liquidity just to keep the system
- 19:48functioning. Purchasing power is eroding
- 19:50gradually rather than through quick coins.
- 19:53It's a different mechanism on the surface, but it has the same
- 19:56underlying dynamic. As for those porous borders,
- 19:59Rome couldn't decide whether migrants represented a threat or
- 20:03a resource. The Empire needed labor and
- 20:05military manpower. While simultaneously fearing
- 20:08cultural transformation and political instability.
- 20:11That contradiction never gets resolved, and honestly the same
- 20:14debates exist now almost word for word.
- 20:16Then there's the power, or lack thereof.
- 20:18The late Roman Empire was an authoritarian in a simplistic
- 20:21way that people imagine. It was procedural.
- 20:24It had councils, laws, administrative structures, and
- 20:27formal decision making systems. But eventually the procedures
- 20:30become hollow. Real authority belongs to
- 20:33whoever controls access, information, and the narrative
- 20:36inside the bureaucracy itself. The system's primary purpose
- 20:39shifts from functioning effectively to preserving
- 20:42itself. And Rome tells itself all the
- 20:44way through the decline that its institutions are permanent,
- 20:47stronger than anyone realizes. Too advanced to truly collapse,
- 20:51maybe too big to fail. For centuries they believe it.
- 20:54Then, eventually, the structure reaches a point where it can no
- 20:57longer distinguish between a threat and a solution.
- 21:00And that's the real tragedy of Steilaco.
- 21:02Not simply that he dies, but his death was completely
- 21:05preventable. His body received no great
- 21:07honors afterward. His monuments are torn down.
- 21:10His memory is officially erased from the system he spent his
- 21:13life defending. But history remembers him
- 21:15differently. The man condemned for not being
- 21:17Roman enough turns out to embody Rome more than the people who
- 21:21executed him. Some even call him the last
- 21:23Roman he fought for the empire. He held the line for years.
- 21:27And then when the system came for him, he didn't burn it down,
- 21:31even though he probably could have.
- 21:32He walked out of the church and accepted his fate because he
- 21:35still believed in something larger than himself.
- 21:38And at that point, the system no longer did.
- 21:41Rome doesn't fall because it's suddenly overwhelmed from
- 21:43outside forces. Rome falls because internally it
- 21:46lost the ability to distinguish between competence and danger,
- 21:50between loyalty and threat, between the man holding the
- 21:52structure together and the forces actively pulling it
- 21:55apart. This is the pattern.
- 21:57Same mechanism, different century.
- 22:00This has been the Roman pattern. I'm Jeremy Ryan Slate.
- 22:03Be sure to like this video, leave us a comment, and smash
- 22:06the subscribe button if you want more of the Roman pattern.