Latest / Educating All Learners Alliance / Beyond the Rubric: Insights from a New Champions Judge
Transcript
- 0:03Hi, this is Aurora from the Educating All Learners Alliance,
- 0:07and today we're speaking to Symon Hayes for insights from the EALA New Champions Fund.
- 0:12Starting in 2022, the New Champions Fund has granted an annual unrestricted
- 0:16competitive sub-grant and a year-long mentorship to support leaders in education
- 0:20who are actively working to support students with disabilities.
- 0:24The applications are reviewed and evaluated by a panel of judges who represent
- 0:28a wide variety of industry leaders, all of whom are committed to advancing the education field.
- 0:33And I'm excited to be joined today by one of those judges, Symon Hayes.
- 0:37He's a creative leader at the intersection of design, learning,
- 0:41and systems change, whose work centers on building more responsive,
- 0:45learner-driven environments that reflect the real needs of real students and educators.
- 0:50Thanks for joining us today, Symon. It's great to have you.
- 0:52Thank you, Aurora. It's a pleasure to be here with you. It's always great when
- 0:55our paths cross and we get to chat.
- 0:57So just start out by telling us a little bit about you, your work,
- 1:01and what brought you to serve as a judge for the 2025 New Champions Fund.
- 1:06I was a classroom teacher, district coach, and worked in a number of nonprofit
- 1:10educational organizations,
- 1:11designing and facilitating professional learning, supporting educators and school
- 1:15leaders in embracing learner variability and designing learning experiences
- 1:19that are accessible to all learners.
- 1:21I'm the founder and lead at Designed, and I'm focused on supporting educators
- 1:26and leaders embracing and designing for learner variability and creating a sense
- 1:31of belonging for all learners.
- 1:32I've been a part of the ELO community for almost four years and appreciate the
- 1:36work that the ELO community does.
- 1:39I serve as a judge for a couple of reasons. Firstly, to support and validate
- 1:44the work of the ELO community, partners,
- 1:46and UChampions applicants and share some of my experiences advocating for all
- 1:51students to have access to learning and support.
- 1:54And I'm really interested in what is going on in the educational landscape.
- 1:58And this is an opportunity to learn about what others are thinking about,
- 2:01what problems they are trying to solve, and the creative solutions that they
- 2:05are bringing to this work.
- 2:06And it's also an opportunity to think about and develop more support for the ELO community.
- 2:11What perspective or experiences did you bring to the judging process?
- 2:17I bring curiosity and an open mind, knowing that there's more than one way to support our learners.
- 2:22And at the center of my work, I'm a learner, and this is an opportunity to learn
- 2:26about other approaches and solutions to the work.
- 2:28I love that. This was a historic year for the New Champions Fund.
- 2:32We had over 400 people expressed interest in applying, 200 completed applications.
- 2:39Almost 50 judges lending their support and expertise.
- 2:44And so how did you and the fellow judges approach evaluating such a varied group of applicants?
- 2:54Great question. We have a rubric to ground us and keep the scoring objective,
- 2:57and we go through a collective calibration process to work towards inter-rater reliability.
- 3:02So although the problem being tackled are different and solutions are varied.
- 3:06Each application is consistent with the format and content requested.
- 3:10So that really helps us as we assess the application against the rubric.
- 3:14And each application has multiple judges, so it's scored multiple times.
- 3:18We need to bear in mind that the applications are being submitted by educators, not grant writers.
- 3:23And acknowledging that, I think I and other judges approach this work with a
- 3:27desire and I think an ability to understand the intention behind the application,
- 3:32sometimes read between the lines,
- 3:34connect the dots, so that the idea of the project described in the application
- 3:37is elevated, and we don't get bogged down in the technical writing aspect of the application.
- 3:43I think as fellow educators and leaders supporting students with disabilities
- 3:46and marginalized students, we bring in an ability to visualize and imagine.
- 3:50It's like, oh, that's what this project or idea could be like when fully formed.
- 3:55And there is a wide variety of projects that are submitted. I think you said
- 3:58there was 400 originally submitted.
- 4:01Each one serves youth in a variety of ways, and each one has its merits.
- 4:07Yeah, I really love what you said about focusing on the idea,
- 4:12the intention, connecting the dots.
- 4:13These are written by educators, not grant writers.
- 4:16I think that that's something that we really try to try to get across with this process.
- 4:23So what stood out to you during the application review process?
- 4:26Were there any trends, big ideas, you know, common challenges that you notice across submissions?
- 4:32What was common for me in the dozen or so applications I reviewed from,
- 4:36as we said, the few hundred and then the two hundred, I think,
- 4:39that we actually then sort of looked through as a rubric,
- 4:42I think was the incredible variety of alternative solutions to support students
- 4:47designing solutions to do things differently.
- 4:50It does make me wonder about how far away we are from supporting students who
- 4:54learn differently in our traditional public schools.
- 4:57And I work in these schools regularly, so I'm aware of the good work and the
- 5:00great work that's going on there.
- 5:02But it does make me think about how we can be successful by adopting a variety of approaches.
- 5:07Is there anything that surprised you during the process? Maybe something you
- 5:11didn't expect to learn or see?
- 5:14I'm not sure whether this surprised me, but being aware of the number of applications,
- 5:18I believe a significant increase from last year and also an increase in the
- 5:22number of judges was impressive.
- 5:23But the variety and the creativity of applicants was, to me, a pleasant surprise.
- 5:29Yeah. And to Ila as well, you know, we're working hard to get the,
- 5:32to spread the word, make sure folks have access to our resources and opportunities.
- 5:37So it was a big win for us as well to see just the increased interest and traction.
- 5:44So when you're thinking about, at least for me, when I'm thinking about all
- 5:48of these applications, where they're coming from, what are some of the needs?
- 5:52What did this experience teach you about the current landscape of education,
- 5:57especially for students with disabilities and learning differences?
- 6:00For me, from what I observed, and from the evidence presented during this process,
- 6:05there's a significant movement to support students with disabilities and embrace learner variability.
- 6:10From classroom support to coaching and enrichment, to programs that are focused
- 6:14on support outside of the classroom.
- 6:16I remember learning about a project based around a bakery, learning in nature,
- 6:21designing and opening a new school, to projects designed to support families
- 6:25in deepening their understanding of their students' rights. It's all really exciting work.
- 6:30Why do you think these opportunities are important for elevating innovation
- 6:34and leadership in this space?
- 6:36For me, there's a couple of things. I think for some applicants,
- 6:39the grants awarded, particularly the dollar amount awarded to the winning application,
- 6:43can significantly impact what the program can do in the future.
- 6:47The money can be the tipping point for a new and or a small organization to
- 6:51establish itself and actually get a foothold in the work.
- 6:54It's about sustainability for them.
- 6:57And another aspect of writing and submitting an application is the opportunity
- 7:00to tighten and gain clarity of purpose from experience, being asked to focus on goals,
- 7:07impact and evidence to clearly articulate the what, why and how of the program
- 7:11can really help leaders develop and help the program move forward,
- 7:14even if not successful in winning one of the grants.
- 7:17I really like that. You know, there's out of all the applications,
- 7:21you know, only four people are going to be awarded any type of grant.
- 7:25We do a new champion. And then this year we did three runners up.
- 7:29But what we at EALA are committed to is just like you said, giving folks the
- 7:34opportunity to practice, right?
- 7:37Or in the act of explaining your work, it really does help you narrow down your clarity, your focus.
- 7:44And one of the things that we really tried to do is make sure that each application,
- 7:49that the judges left some feedback or some written responses so that even if
- 7:55you're not awarded a grant, you're still walking away with something tangible.
- 8:00And thinking about the future, you know, ELO, we're always trying to,
- 8:04you know, go bigger and bring more people into the ELO-verse.
- 8:08So is there any advice that you'd share with future applicants or future leaders
- 8:13working to solve these challenges?
- 8:15I think for a successful application, being very specific and very clear about
- 8:19the what and the why of the work that you're doing and or hope to do,
- 8:23I'm looking for the intended impact of the project. Who is it helping?
- 8:27How is it helping? Impact data is often difficult to collect,
- 8:31but at the very least, be clear about what impact you intend to have and on whom.
- 8:35And I'm also interested in the level of impact that the grant award will have.
- 8:39Will this award be a catalyst to something that simply won't happen without it?
- 8:43Is it a startup or is it an established organization?
- 8:46If you had to sum up your biggest takeaway from being a judge in this process,
- 8:51if you could do it in one sentence, what would that be?
- 8:54Okay, this may be more than one sentence. Yes.
- 8:58There's really powerful work going on out there. Wonderful ideas,
- 9:01solutions, and committed people supporting learner variability.
- 9:04Students with disabilities and marginalized students. As part of the EALA community,
- 9:08we're looking to support each other and push the work forward.
- 9:12And the biggest takeaway for me is that the idea of being connected in this
- 9:15work is both powerful and essential.
- 9:18I love that. The connection piece. That's great.
- 9:21Well, that's it for us today. Symon, thank you so much for joining us and for
- 9:25chatting with you. It's been really great to have you.
- 9:28Thank you, Aurora. Right. That's it for us today, folks. Thank you to Symon
- 9:31Hayes. And to learn more, visit us at educatingalllearners.org.
- 9:36I'm Aurora from EALA, and this was a deep dive into the new champions.