Latest / Politics with Paul / Wave Elections and Their Implications | Politics With Paul #118
Transcript
- Episode 118 Wave Elections and Their Implications: Welcome back to another episode of the Politics with Paul podcast, your home for nonpartisan discussion of political science and civics. I'm your host, Paul Rader. Today is about wave elections and their implications. With another election in the books, you'll undoubtedly have heard of this term wave election being used repeatedly. It's used to describe elections that have so massively swung toward either the Democratic or the Republican Party. And one party has flipped such a significant number of elected seats that it is particularly noteworthy. It's above what you would normally expect. And there have been quite a few of these wave elections in American history. And the 2026 election has been described as the latest example, even sometimes being called a tsunami. But few places actually describe what makes an election a wave election. So what is this threshold? For a wave election. There are many interpretations for why a wave election happened, but how do you know which analyses are backed up by evidence and which are just biased? And lastly, how much of a wave was the twenty twenty six election and what are the implications going forward? These are the questions we are answering today. And first, it makes sense to talk about what is a wave election? This term gets thrown around a lot, but it isn't always clearly defined. You say, well, this was a wave election, this one was, this one was. No real actual explanation for why that's the case. It's just, well, a lot of seats got changed to between the parties. And if you watched previous episodes of this podcast before, you'll know how important it is in politics that we specifically define things. Now, a lot of people don't define things. Especially those who have a vested interest to make certain words mean what they want it to mean, but that's beside the point. But even when there is a clear definition of a wave election offered, it's not agreed upon. So what should we consider when defining wave elections? Well, you can look at the type of office. Typically we look at US House seats, US Senate seats, governorships. State legislatures and whether it's state legislative control of specific chambers like a state house or a state senate, or the number of seats that are won or lost between the parties. And you could potentially use local offices, but that's much more difficult to gather and analyze the data for because you have to gener generally dig deeper for all that. And also there are a lot more local offices to research than there are federal level or state level offices. And so the reason why you would distinguish between these types of offices is that waves might happen for some types of offices, but not others. Maybe the U.S. House sees a wave, but not governorships, or maybe state legislatures see a wave, but not the U.S. Senate. In the U.S. Senate, the reason that can oftentimes differ is because there's only a third of those seats That are up for elections. So depending on how many of those are being defended by Democrats and how many of those are being defended by Republicans, if the party that would have experienced a wave already has a lot of those seats on lock for the U.S. Senate, it's it's pretty hard for them to actually make a wave happen there. Another factor to look at when defining wave elections is vote share. Even if a seat isn't flipped, a significant change in margin of victory From the last election is still noteworthy. So even if Democrats didn't flip a certain seat, if they gained another twenty percentage points on the margin victory, so they only lost by instead of twenty-five percent of the vote, they only they lost by five percentage points. That can still be a wave. Now, obviously, ultimately what makes a wave is the number of seats that change hands between the parties. But it is still noteworthy to look at vote share. And then lastly, how do we define the threshold for what makes a wave election? Is it the specific number of seats in a type of office, or is it the highest X percent, like the highest 20%, highest 25%? One definition that actually is offered for wave elections is from Ballotpedia in a 2018 report. They offered the definition of a wave election as the 20% of elections where the president's party lost the most seats, though they had limited the analysis to the prior 100 years. So maybe it's not the specific number of seats, but you look at it as 20% or 25% of the highest of elections that had the highest loss of seats between of of a party. So specific number of seats can be a pretty arbitrary number. Like if you looked at the US House and we said any election where 30 seats were lost. Well, why isn't it 35? Or why isn't it 25? And 30 is still a pretty large number, but what if it's not enough to be considered a wave? Or what if there are too many elections that have that many seats lost? Wave elections imply that it's an unusually high number of seats that are being lost. So if that threshold is too low, then does that really count as a wave? But if you look at it as highest X percent of elections where the most seats were lost by the president's party, that could still be arbitrary. And eventually that could deem elections that were once considered wave elections to no longer be one. So if you had a in that 100 prior years and you s looked at the US House and the the 20th percent is like 30 seats were lost. But then you have another election that comes and 33 seats were lost. Well, now is that 30 seat loss no longer a wave election just because another one supplanted it? That's another issue you can run into. So it's very difficult to come up with a clear definition of wave election and one that people would agree upon. But a wave is pretty much always against the sitting president's party. Because in large part the wave is because it's a response to the sitting president. And their party's performance. But regardless of how we define wave election, how do we interpret them and why they happen? There are a bunch of contributors to wave elections, because there's a lot of elections to look into. And you also have to look at whether they happen for a specific type of office or across the board. And so prominent contributing factors to why there is a wave election. So We're looking at large-scale macro level stuff instead of specific elections and their own unique factors going into them, like specific to a state or specific to a particular seat. So these prominent contributing factors include things like the popularity of the president. The job approval rating is the most clear indicator of that. That tends to be a very strong indicator of whether the president's party is in for a bumpy ride. Whether the president's is on the ballot or not, or whether they're going to be doing relatively okay. So if the president has a lower popularity, there's more likely to be a wave election. There's also the number of open seats in each respective type of office, like in the US House where somebody retires or they decide to run for US Senate. Open seats are generally harder to defend due to the lack of incumbency advantage. The incumbency advantage is well documented. If you have somebody already in office, they tend to have some advantages at their disposal simply because they are already in office and they're more well known and they have the connections from being in office and they tend to be more well financed. So if there are more open seats in an election, there are it's more likely that there's going to be a wave. The success or failure of a major policy initiative is also a huge factor in things, or at least the public perception of that initiative's effectiveness. So if there is a major failed policy, or the perception of that major policy is that it's failed, there's more likely to be a wave election. And then lastly, the economy. It's often, if not always, the leading determinant in sentiment. Toward the president and the party in power. So if the economy is weaker, unemployment rate is higher, wages are depressed, there's not necessarily unemployment, but there's underemployment, there's more likely to be a wave election. But the interpretation of why a wave happened is not entirely objective, even if you're using those factors, those data points. Whichever party won is. Has the incentive to say that it's well, it's because of how great we are and how wonderful we are. And people have finally seen through all the lies that the other side has put out there. People are tired of the status quo and we're here to change things. And the party that lost has the incentive to both downplay the backlash to their party and their president and to get their base back in gear. So publicly they might say, This is not a big deal, but more privately they might. be trying to get their base energized, hey, look guys, if we don't shape up, this is going to keep happening. We need to fight back next election. Even if the president's party gets trounced, is it because the opposing party had a good message and they were effective at getting that message out? Or is it simply because of anger at the president? Now, of course, the opposing party, when they have a wave election that is in their favor, they have incentive to say that it was because their message was great, because it makes them look better. It makes it look like people actually want them. for them, not just they want somebody different than the president or people in the president's party. Or if you look at it from that policy view, was a policy that is seen as a defining factor in the way of election really a failure, or was it only painted as such? So the president's party often has incentive to say that the policy wasn't a failure, or they'll at least downplay how much it failed, or they'll say that it's well, the opposition actually tanked this policy because of XYZ reasons. Now, before we get to the 2026 election, let's look at some historical waves in US history. Because there isn't a clearly objective way to define waves. We'll just frame it as some of the biggest changes in the number of seats a party holds for a given type of office. So what most people would agree are wave elections. So here are Arguably the top three. I'm not gonna say that they are the top three, because there's a lot of object objective data to it, but what is considered the top three might be a little bit subjective. But here are three of the most prominent w wave elections that you'll find in history, or three of the biggest wave elections that you'll find in US history. These are not necessarily agreed upon, but as the top three, but they would definitely consider these three to be up there. And I'm using the US House, U.S. Senate, governorships, and state legislative chambers and seats in this regard. Now it's not a straightforward process. It's not straightforward to assess these wave elections because the US Senate, only a third are up for election, and it depends on how many Democrats and Republicans there are that have to defend. Governorships over time, some have shifted from two year to four year terms. Even a few of them used to have one-year terms, and then they shifted to two-year terms. And of course, well mostly the 19th century, the number of states being added has drastically changed how many U.S. House and U.S. Senate seats there have been to assess and state legislatures as well. And state legislatures have also dealt with redistricting and sometimes major fluctuations in the number of seats available. And more recent decades have seen the adoption of term limits. So you've seen more open seats. And like we said a moment ago, more open seats means that there's more likely to be a wave election. But all that being said, here are three years that saw particularly huge wave elections across the board. 1894. So this was during Democrat Grover Cleveland's second term in office. Before Donald Trump, he was the only president who had had two nonconsecutive terms as president of the United States. And right near the beginning of his second term, there was a serious economic recession, the panic of 1893. Alongside a railroad strike and jobless workers marching on D.C., unemployment was shooting up. And there was a lot of dissatisfaction with Grover Cleveland and the Democratic Party. And this culminated in the eighteen ninety-four election, which saw Democrats lose over one hundred seats in the US House. They went from two hundred and eighteen to ninety-three seats. The biggest change in US House history. In the US Senate, depends on your definition of a waiver chamber, but Democrats still lost four seats, which is still a pretty Big loss. Governorships, Republicans took a handful of seats that were previously won by Democrats, something like four or five of them. And state in the state legislatures, Democrats lost over 900 state House seats and over 250 state Senate seats. And it also set the stage for 1896, where Republicans made further gains, and they also won the presidency when William McKinley came into office. And that was one of the First examples, if not the first example, of the current urban rural divide in voters that you see today. There was also the 1932 election, which was we're in the midst of the Great Depression, th about three years on at that point. And Democrats had already made major gains in the 1930 midterms. This was when Republican Herbert Hoover was in office, and Republicans had control of both chambers of Congress. And even though they got Democrats got a boost in 1930, they got an even bigger boost in 1932 as the depression deepened and the public blamed Republican Hoover and his party. And this was also a presidential election year. Unlike a lot of wave elections. You sa you see them a lot of times happen in midterm years, but they do still happen sometimes in presidential election years, and this was one of them. So Franklin D. Roosevelt, a Democrat, won very handily, be the first of four election victories for him. And his victory also broke a streak of three successive Republican presidents. Before him was Herbert Hoover, then there was also Calvin Coolidge, and then Warren Harding. And in the U.S. House. Democrats won ninety-seven seats, and this was the beginning of an era of thorough dominance of the Democratic Party in the U.S. House, where they would, for all but two terms of the next sixty years, had majority control of the U.S. House. The U.S. Senate, Democrats also won twelve seats. Governorships, Republicans lost ten seats, and in state legislatures, Democrats gained over six hundred state house seats and over two hundred and fifty state senate seats. And then the last election that we'll look at here in terms of major wave elections was in 2010, where we saw Tea Party anger, which was a faction of Republican Party that was much more conservative than the mainline Republican Party. Their anger at both Democrats and moderate Republicans that they saw as not real Republicans led to the most recent widespread wave election, meaning that it hit multiple types of offices, just like The previous two that we listed here. The US House, Republicans gained sixty-three seats. In the US Senate, Republicans gained six seats. Governorships, Republicans gained seven seats, and in state legislatures, Republicans gained about six hundred and fifty state house seats and around one hundred state Senate seats. And this was the turning point for a bunch of state legislative chambers we see as Republican controlled today, where either in that election or or the election before they were Democrat and then were then became Republican and now we typically see them as Republican controlled chambers, although a couple of them have changed in the twenty twenty six election results. But speaking of which, was twenty twenty six a wave election or even a tsunami as some people have described it? Well, the dust hasn't fully settled because there are still votes being counted and some election winners have not been declared yet. So we don't have exact numbers yet of how many Democrats and Republicans there will be at every level of government. But there are things that we do know already based on who we know have already won their elections. So in the US House Democrats have gained at least 42 seats. In the US Senate, Democrats have gained at least seven seats. Governorships, Democrats have flipped at least five seats, and Alaska is projected to join that group, so they could have six seats flipped. In state legislatures, Democrats have flipped at least five hundred seats and have a net gain of about four hundred and eighty-seven so far. And then if you look at more general control of state governments, we have a data point called trifectas, which describes states where one party controls the governorship, the state house, and the state senate in that state. And at least five Republican trifectas have been broken, and at least six Democratic trifectas have been formed. State legislative chamber control more specifically, at least 12 chambers have flipped to Democratic control. At least six Republican supermajorities have been broken. And a supermajority is when you have enough members in that party that they can override a governor's veto on their own in that chamber, as long as all that whole party stayed unified. Though, just because the supermajority hasn't been broken, the control didn't actually flip. parties. But still particularly noteworthy with these chambers where they've been trending towards more and more clearly unified under one party. Now that's tide has been turned back a little bit. And there have been at least three Democratic supermajorities that have been formed. And then lastly, twenty-two state executive offices apart from governor have also flipped to Democrats. When those things include Lieutenant Governor, Attorneys General, Treasurers, Superintendents of Education, or Superintendents of Instruction. Several different names that states have for what is basically the Education Commissioner. And then even in places where Democrats lost, they still sometimes overperformed. And one of the examples is my state, Florida, where the Florida governor's race was within a couple percentage points this time. And it was more than 17% percent. percentage points closer than the twenty twenty two governor election was when Ron DeSantis was reelected. And this is despite Republicans having well over a million registered voters more than Democrats do. So even though the exact definition of a wave election is somewhat vague, you'd be incredibly hard pressed to look at the results of 2026, even the ones that we know already, and say that this wasn't a wave election. It even though it's technically not agreed upon what a wave election was, pretty objectively it was a wave election. But is a tsunami an apt description? Because I Tsunami is even more nebulous of a term and less commonly used. Balipedia does offer a definition of it though. They call it or they call a tsunami election one where there was a wave election in at least three of the election groups we looked at. So US House, U.S. Senate, Governor, State Legislatures. So if there was a wave election in at least three of those, it was considered a tsunami election in Ballopedia's definition. But other than that, I haven't seen any sort of clear cut definition for what a tsunami could be. And there's some bias in inherent in that term. It's been more often used by left-leaning groups and they have an incentive to use that term, and that's because they are energized from the election results. They're they're riding high with all these gains that they've made, and they want to paint themselves as having this huge wave of popular support. And then right leaning groups want to downplay what happened. Some have blamed the lack of turnout rather than on Backlash to Donald Trump or the message of Democrats, they've said that it's just a lack of turnout from Republicans rather than energized Democrats. Or they are privately panicking about the election results, and so they are reluctant to use the term. And also tsunami is an inherently more value-laden term than simply a wave, because tsunami implies it's bigger than a wave. And it's also more eye-catching, so it means more critical. clicks and views on election coverage that uses that term. People say, yeah, wave election, wave election, tsunami. Hmm, what? wow. Is it really that bad? And then they'll look into it. Especially if they already have that incentive of, well, the people that they voted for w were winning or the people that they supported were winning. And so they want to look at more confirming information. Now, whether I think that's a tsunami election I'll leave that for you to decide, but this was undoubtedly a big democratic wave. So, where does that leave us now? Where do we go from here? What does it all mean going forward? What are the implications of the 2026 election? Well, that partly depends on how each party interprets the 2026 results. And as we have said before, some of these interpretations are biased. By what campaigners and politicians and pundits and voters want to believe, especially the more polarized ones. But you have to do your best to take your personal feelings out of the equation. And that sounds obvious, and some people would theoretically agree with that, but a lot of times they still put their feelings into the analysis, or they have their conclusion and then they look for data that confirms that conclusion. But if you want to interpret this properly, it doesn't matter whether you like, love, dislike, hate Democrats, Republicans, Donald Trump. If you work in politics and you let your personal opinions dictate your strategy, there is a good chance you're going to lose next time. And without naming names or any specific groups, I have seen that time and time again, and people that I know that work in this industry have told me about how they have seen it time and time again themselves. So I said earlier that a big question that has to be asked as to why a wave election happened is this. Was it because of the party's the party out of powers message or because of a backlash against the sitting president? Was the opposing party that enjoyed this wave election so good at crafting their message and getting it out there and connecting with people and showing how great and wonderful they are? Was it because of all that, or was it that people were just pissed off at the commander in chief? The president of the United States. So, in this case, were people just loving the Democrats' message, or were they just pissed at Donald Trump? Well, lots of voters vote against somebody rather than for them. Not necessarily a majority of voters, but a lot of them do. And Democrats obviously have a lot of incentive to say that people were voting for them instead of against Donald Trump, because it makes it sound like People are voting for them because they are Democrats or because they have a good message. And so a lot of Democrats want to believe that they were messaging effectively. And that may have been the case to some extent, and I'm sure it was the case for some Democrats. But let's be clear here. This was far, far more a rebuke of Trump and the Republican Party under him. Again, this has nothing to do with my personal feelings on Either of the parties or Donald Trump. The evidence just indicates that. You saw considerably low approval ratings of Donald Trump, even as low as in the mid thirties. You see frustrations with the economy, especially with maybe not as as much unemployment rate, but inflation. You have anger over the Iran war and then subsequent rising of gas prices from the war there. And you saw an overperformance of Democrats despite major gains made by Republicans in voter registration over the past four to five years. And lots of Republicans simply just stayed home that would have otherwise voted Republican. But they would rather just sit home then vote against their party, even if they are upset with their party. So Democrats need to, if they want to carry this momentum forward, they need to recognize that a lot of this was just backlash against Trump. And I will say, even though this is not necessarily public opinion like polling or more concrete data, I could tell you from seeing interviews with various people, some people have who voted for Democrats made it clear that it was not because of Democrats' message they were voting against Donald Trump and a lot of the policies that have been espoused by Donald Trump. It's not anything about whether I like the policies or not or whether you like the policies or not. There's a lot of anger about those policies and about Donald Trump in general. So what does this all mean for twenty twenty eight and beyond? Well we'll need more data to Fully assess what went right for Democrats and what went wrong for Republicans before we can fully address what this all means. But there are some things that we can say for sure. If too many Democrats misinterpret the reason for the 2026 results, they may very well lose the gains they just made, or even more than that. And Republicans have somewhat of a tightrope to walk between keeping a hold of the MAGA base and and being able to pull back people outside of it. How close do you align yourself with Trump? How far do you pull away from it? Especially when you're about to enter an era of divided government where Democrats control both the US House and the US Senate, but Republicans still hold the presidency. We should be skeptical of whether this is a long-term change versus a short-term swing, even if this does carry over into 2028. Because you don't know if you're in the midst of a trend until you're several elections down the line. So some people may want to say this is the beginning of a new era, but we don't know that. We need it and we won't even really know that two years from now, because the next midterm elections, even if Democrats win the presidency in twenty twenty eight and they keep the House and the Senate, who knows what twenty thirty is going to bring. These last twenty-five to thirty years of politics have shown that it's a pendulum. It swings back and forth between Republicans and Democrats. When Republicans were winning in 2024, Democrats were so despondent about the results and many of them thought they were never going to come back and Republicans were on a high horse. Now it's 2026 and now Republicans, a lot of them are despondent and think they're never coming back, and that Democrats aren't a high horse. Whenever you lose an election, all the alarms are sounded and everything is doom and gloom, and we really need to do something to reverse everything now. Even after elections are over, there's a lot of fear mongering. But at some point the pendulum is going to swing back again. So both parties would do well not to get ahead of themselves. Very easy to get carried away with election results, no matter how they happen. But You always have to remember that lots of things can change very quickly in politics. And if Democrats don't, at least according to public perception, deliver on what they say they're going to do, twenty twenty-eight might not bode well for them. And if Republicans don't respond based on what the public told them in twenty twenty-six, things might not go well for them in 2028 either. So you always gotta make sure you take your personal feelings out of it and constantly reassess where you are at. And always remember that your constituents are not just the people that voted for you. They are also the people that didn't vote for you. And they are also the people that sat at home. Something that both parties would do well to remember. But that's going to end things for today's episode of the Politics with Paul Podcast. As always, thank you so much for listening. Please like, comment, share, subscribe to the podcast. My links are in the show notes, my five day educational email course on how we can more effectively mitigate polarization and toxicity, my book on political independence and my writings on medium dot com. And then there are also my other links, my LinkedIn, my Facebook, and my email paulrader rights at gmail dot com and my website paulraider.org. So thank you again so much and we will see you next time.