Latest / Family Troubles with Dr. Joshua Coleman / Noelle Mering: Understanding the 'Going No Contact' Movement
Transcript
- 0:10SPEAKER_00: Well, welcome everybody to another episode of the Family Troubles Podcast.
- 0:16SPEAKER_00: Today I'm very excited to welcome my guest, Noelle Maring.
- 0:21SPEAKER_00: She's the author of the new and I would say very important book, No Contact: What Family Estrangement Is and How to Heal It.
- 0:28SPEAKER_00: She is currently a fellow in the Life and Family Initiative at the Ethics and Public Policy Center at Washington Base, D.C., a basic think tank.
- 0:37SPEAKER_00: As many of you know, family estrangements move from something rarely discussed in public to a subject of enormous cultural attention.
- 0:44SPEAKER_00: Noelle approaches this issue not only as a family problem, but as part of a larger cultural shift in how we think about identity, autonomy, obligation, forgiveness, and what we owe people closest to us.
- 0:57SPEAKER_00: In addition to her newest book, she's also the author of Awake, Not Woke, and much of her work examines the ideas and cultural forces that shape our most intimate relationship.
- 1:06SPEAKER_00: So welcome, Noel.
- 1:08SPEAKER_01: Thanks so much for having me.
- 1:09SPEAKER_01: Great to be with you.
- 1:11SPEAKER_00: Yeah, great, great to have you here.
- 1:12SPEAKER_00: I'm so so excited to talk to you.
- 1:15SPEAKER_00: Um there are so many observations you made in your in your book that I hadn't really um thought about.
- 1:21SPEAKER_00: And one is, you know, we psychologists talk a lot about the concept of of differentiation.
- 1:26SPEAKER_00: And as you note in your book, it's a concept that originates from Marie Bowen in the 1960s.
- 1:31SPEAKER_00: He's kind of considered one of the fathers of um family therapy.
- 1:36SPEAKER_00: And um yeah, so do you want to define differentiation?
- 1:40SPEAKER_00: Would you like me to?
- 1:42SPEAKER_01: I mean, I a lot of people most people probably know what it is at this point, but um well, I will defer to you because you're this is more your mind, although if you'd like me to, I can.
- 1:51SPEAKER_01: You might be more expert at doing that, though.
- 1:53SPEAKER_00: Well, I'll give the psychological definition and then you can you can sort of explore some of the points that you make, which I think are really original and important.
- 2:02SPEAKER_00: So differentiation is the idea that as we become um individuals in a family, we have kind of have to have the capacity both to feel separate from them, but also a feeling of interdependence and join with them.
- 2:16SPEAKER_00: And one of the ways that I explain it to people is that it's you know, in in romantic love, you have to have the capacity both to merge with that person and have that kind of oceanic feeling of merging, I, you know, you begin where I end, and I lose myself in you, and all of that kind of thing, uh, which is an important feeling.
- 2:32SPEAKER_00: But you also have to have the capacity to hold on to your own sense of autonomy and individuality and identity.
- 2:39SPEAKER_00: And that's a psychological achievement, both in romantic love, but I would argue in parent-adult-child relationships.
- 2:46SPEAKER_00: And so in many ways, estrangement is a a kind of an act of attempted differentiation, but in some ways I would argue it's a failure of differentiation because it's cutting the person out because you actually don't know how to tolerate the ways that you feel triggered by them or upset by them or in conflict with them.
- 3:05SPEAKER_00: Um but you make a larger point, which I thought was very interesting, about how our current cultural moment, particularly in more progressive psychology, more progressive circ circles, um, is actually a kind of a call for lower differentiation.
- 3:21SPEAKER_00: And could you talk about that some?
- 3:23SPEAKER_01: Sure.
- 3:23SPEAKER_01: Yeah, I mean it's really fascinating to me.
- 3:25SPEAKER_01: Um I think it is a collapsing of unity into uniformity, you know, which I think interestingly we traditionally think about as being a problem more with kind of fundamentalist religious um families and communities and cultures.
- 3:41SPEAKER_01: Um and I think that's apt because uh I, you know, part of my contention is that I think that the progress progressive ideology sort of mimics a uh fundamentalist religion.
- 3:52SPEAKER_01: Um and so it demands kind of total uniformity in order to hang together in any sort of unity.
- 3:57SPEAKER_01: And if that uniformity is not present, then that can be justification enough to not only feel threatened, but also to feel justified in in in cutting that person off.
- 4:06SPEAKER_01: And so I think that that is a driver in you know the the this kind of newer version of no contact, which maybe it's not altogether new.
- 4:15SPEAKER_01: I don't want to m make too much of that, but I do think that the phenomenon that we're seeing now, and you can speak probably more uh adeptly about that, but um seems like there's an escalation and an acceleration and maybe a different tone that it's taking.
- 4:30SPEAKER_01: And I and I so in the book I'm really exploring how our ideological kind of moment is playing into it in a new way and driving the forces of no contact, um, particularly through that habituating us into low differentiation.
- 4:44SPEAKER_00: Yeah, no, I think it's really interesting.
- 4:46SPEAKER_00: Well, the idea is that if you have ideas that are different from mine, whether it's about my past or my childhood or my or my identity or my aspirations, not only is that a difference, but that's an actual threat to my identity.
- 5:00SPEAKER_00: Um that's an actual form of violence, the whole words are violence kind of perspective.
- 5:06SPEAKER_00: So can you say more and you're gonna be able to do that?
- 5:08SPEAKER_01: Yeah, it's interesting.
- 5:09SPEAKER_01: I mean, I I mean I in a Wake Not Woke, I talked a lot about there are two messages that we that were really promulgated over the last few years.
- 5:16SPEAKER_01: One is um words are uh silence is violence, but also um to you know, stand up and use your voice.
- 5:23SPEAKER_01: You know, and so I think those two things put together means the only real option you have is neither to be neutral nor to be dissenting, but is to be affirming um the ideology that is dominant at the moment or in that environment you're in.
- 5:36SPEAKER_01: So um, you know, I there's a militancy and sort of an authoritarianism to that that I think people are in some ways starting to recognize.
- 5:45SPEAKER_01: But in the meantime, you know, there's a whole host of people who I think in young in the younger generation in particular, um, really got um sort of um pulled into this.
- 5:56SPEAKER_01: I mean, particularly through a very online culture that was certainly exacerbated in 2020 when so many kids, the um the amount of time being online uh daily was astronomical and incredibly unhealthy, I think.
- 6:09SPEAKER_01: And so then it was very easy to get pulled into subcultures that are you know online communities.
- 6:14SPEAKER_01: I mean, this is from it was before it was Tumblr, now it's maybe more TikTok, but you know, this always evolving into different spaces.
- 6:21SPEAKER_01: Um, but I think a lot of kids found uh sort of a real sense of um tribalism, you know, in those subcultures that they felt like here's where I belong.
- 6:30SPEAKER_01: But then they also got enculturated to certain norms of behavior that are online that were very um incredibly progressively social justice oriented and very into uh you know militant in the cancellation, and they were canceling each other.
- 6:43SPEAKER_01: And, you know, there I think is probably a psychological element and the need to belong is incredibly primordial for us.
- 6:49SPEAKER_01: And so once you kind of got it get into a community where you feel like this is where I belong, and now we're canceling people left and right, then that incentivizes us to kind of be the last person on the chopping block or to do whatever it takes to not be the person who is vulnerable to that cancellation.
- 7:02SPEAKER_01: And so I think part of the way you keep that yourself from being that being vulnerable is to be quick to cancel others.
- 7:08SPEAKER_01: And so I think that there's sort of that that le lends to it, that um low differentiation, and also to that sort of understanding that there's a currency to our grievances, you know, that we can kind of have a standpoint position, we can have a platform, we can um be protected if we can claim uh trauma and grievance and um the other side of that coin is accusation, right?
- 7:31SPEAKER_01: That there's no kind of victim narrative that I can claim for myself without always having a perpetual person to accuse.
- 7:38SPEAKER_01: Um so that creates a society that's really roiling in contempt and accusation and conflict and friction.
- 7:44SPEAKER_01: And um at this all the while we have developed like a real fear, I think, of friction.
- 7:49SPEAKER_01: You know, that you know, the there's a paradox there that online culture is also kind of seamless, you know, that it's disembodied.
- 7:55SPEAKER_01: So you don't have sort of the nitty-gritty embodiment of life that kind of creates like two wills butting up against each other and having to confront people.
- 8:05SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 8:05SPEAKER_01: And so there's a seamlessness to that too.
- 8:07SPEAKER_01: So it's it's both um a high conflict environment, but also a fear of friction, real embodied friction.
- 8:13SPEAKER_01: So in a disordered way, maybe.
- 8:16SPEAKER_00: No, I think that's right.
- 8:17SPEAKER_00: I think that this moment where we've become very atomized and um alone, and there's record high rates of mental illness and social isolation and loneliness, and people have fewer and fewer friends, and everything is moving online.
- 8:30SPEAKER_00: I think people are starving for a community, and that just makes them much more vulnerable to a certain kind of propaganda for for lack of a better word, where the family becomes kind of the nexus or the source of their suffering.
- 8:44SPEAKER_00: It's a kind of uh uh referred pain, where they're sort of imagining or being told that, well, if you have anxiety, depression, suicidal ideation, social dislocation, loneliness, all you have to do, it's kind of what you you described, you know, in the in the book is the the PT the Barnum effect, basically.
- 9:00SPEAKER_00: That you know, it's this idea that a sucker is born every minute.
- 9:02SPEAKER_00: And if you take a survey and you you know, and the questions are something like, Do you ever feel lonely?
- 9:07SPEAKER_00: Do you ever go into a party and feel anxious?
- 9:09SPEAKER_00: You know, do you ever feel like some people are better than you?
- 9:12SPEAKER_00: Well, that means you have this kind of a parent.
- 9:14SPEAKER_00: And a lot of these self-help books are like that, like emotionally mature parent or some of these other books that are these enormous million, you know, sellers have this c these kinds of surveys, where Patrick Tihan, who you mention in the book, who's this huge, you know, anti-who's a pro-estrangement influencer.
- 9:32SPEAKER_00: They're they're very shoddy in terms of they have actually very poor scientific basis in terms of their um the way that they establish their their methodology.
- 9:42SPEAKER_00: But they're incredibly compelling as a kind of a propaganda and uh blaming parents for the source of our miseries rather than this moment that we're in.
- 9:51SPEAKER_01: Yeah, no, I think that's right.
- 9:52SPEAKER_01: And you know, I so appreciate your work.
- 9:54SPEAKER_01: And you know, I quote you bench in the book and read a lot of your work.
- 9:57SPEAKER_01: So thank you you were such a compelling measured voice in all this, and I I recommend your stuff to people all the time.
- 10:03SPEAKER_01: So if you just want as a sidebar, say that.
- 10:05SPEAKER_01: Um yeah, no, I think that's right.
- 10:07SPEAKER_01: And it's so interesting how, you know, this you know, I talk about progressive ideology, but I also am very quick in the book to say, you know, this is not particular necessarily to politics.
- 10:16SPEAKER_01: I'm not making a political point so much as I'm making a point about how we are framing the world.
- 10:21SPEAKER_01: And I think right now progressivism is kind of that ideology is um coercive in that way.
- 10:26SPEAKER_01: But you know, the the reason it's compelling is because it's playing on very universal human temptations, right?
- 10:32SPEAKER_01: I am not immune.
- 10:33SPEAKER_01: And in fact, we are also we all are tempted to kind of deflect from our responsibility to reframe our past with a negative bias.
- 10:40SPEAKER_01: And I think about my relationships and you know, I think we don't pay enough attention to um the the the ongoing narrative that we have in our in our heads, you know.
- 10:50SPEAKER_01: I mean, maybe people like you probably do, and a lot of people who are, you know, advanced in their emotional maturity and all these things, but I don't hear it talked about maybe it as much as it could be.
- 11:00SPEAKER_01: And how, you know, I think when I took a I took some Patrick Tihan's quizzes you know to determine if I had childhood trauma.
- 11:07SPEAKER_00: Of course you did, I'm sure.
- 11:08SPEAKER_01: Yeah, and I had my friends, my friends, I had my friends take him too.
- 11:11SPEAKER_01: And it was interesting, and you know, we were maybe an unfair uh sample because I was ha asking them to take it.
- 11:16SPEAKER_01: They weren't seeking it out themselves.
- 11:18SPEAKER_01: But um it was interesting.
- 11:19SPEAKER_01: We had a great discussion about how, you know, there's some some people in this in this group of friends who really truly have had serious trauma, you know, and and it the but the framing of it is uh going to determine how they see it, and they could go back and easily create this whole narrative um that would really cripple them in both the relationships and also in their uh their their future relationships and their um ability to reframe their future.
- 11:44SPEAKER_01: So um yeah, it's it's it's wild how easily we are kind of uh prey to that type of um reframing and how much we can, once we're aware of it, I think can use it to the good, you know, and uh and I think the no contact movement oftentimes kind of uh abuses that temptation and that tendency-ness.
- 12:06SPEAKER_00: Yeah, well said.
- 12:07SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 12:08SPEAKER_00: And one of the ways I think about it is that we live in a supposed meritocracy where you have nobody to blame but but yourself if your life isn't going well, if so many people aren't.
- 12:17SPEAKER_00: But you can always blame your parents, right?
- 12:19SPEAKER_00: So that's what I mean by this kind of referred pain is like, oh, that's that's the reason I'm not happy, successful, thriving, good and romantic relationships have attachment issues that can all be dialed back to my to my parents.
- 12:31SPEAKER_00: It's what I call the uh lose your parent, find yourself phenomenon, this kind of uh purification.
- 12:37SPEAKER_00: And you talk about social hygiene um in your in your book, kind of removing people from our lives that we experience as toxic or or threatening.
- 12:45SPEAKER_00: So do you have thoughts about when that's healthy?
- 12:48SPEAKER_00: I mean, I'm asked this question all the time by journalists, so I'll have to ask you too when is that healthy and when is it uh conflict avoidance or intolerance or that kind of thing?
- 12:57SPEAKER_01: Yeah, no, it's such a good question.
- 12:59SPEAKER_01: Um, yeah, I I have a couple of people in my life who have had to, you know, go no contact, they didn't put that label on it, but have had to.
- 13:06SPEAKER_01: Um and not necessarily even physical abuse, but um just having exhausted every possible opportunity and sought objective voices in their lives to be like, how what am I missing here?
- 13:17SPEAKER_01: You know, how and then even some of us trying to help that other person and realizing like wow, this this is there's really no way to penetrate the you know, sort of this world that this person's built up around himself, um and and seeing how much manipulation was happening and stuff.
- 13:32SPEAKER_01: So um so I I mean I think that it there's not really probably a formula so much as um or some it's not gonna look the same probably for in every case, but it will look like somebody who has, I think, sought objectivity, um, has tried everything possible, you know, has not been hasty, and understands that this is not um something that a celebratory moment of courage and liberation, this is actually sort of a tragic necessity.
- 13:57SPEAKER_01: And those are two different, very different things.
- 13:59SPEAKER_00: Um like that.
- 14:00SPEAKER_00: Yeah, that's well said.
- 14:01SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 14:01SPEAKER_01: And so um it's interesting because you know, there it really is such a I think I think we have to realize how easy it is to kind of um move in the no-contact direction.
- 14:11SPEAKER_01: One way in particular, I think, is that it becomes bonding.
- 14:14SPEAKER_01: Like when you were saying just now about finding your parents and your parents the source of trauma.
- 14:18SPEAKER_01: I think that that's a very bonding, can feel like a very bonding experience for a lot of people.
- 14:23SPEAKER_01: And in fact, a lot of the kids that I profiled in the book, you know, realized that they were, you know, they're moving to sort of the chosen family narrative and very uh very hyper-ideological.
- 14:33SPEAKER_01: And um, you know, I realized, you know, they're replicating the f the lack of history that they have with their new community by having this shared trauma history, you know, and that it's sharing it's almost like how um evangelical Christians will share their testimony, you know.
- 14:47SPEAKER_01: And that's how they that's how they're brought into the into the tribe, you know.
- 14:50SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 14:50SPEAKER_01: Um this is sort of sharing your testimony, not of you know, maybe what God's done for me that's been transformative in a positive way, but what might the harm might the harm my parents have inflicted on me and how that has brought me to you.
- 15:01SPEAKER_01: Um so it's sort of an inversion of that kind of um bonding, it's bonding through negativity in a way, you know.
- 15:08SPEAKER_01: Um it is, yes.
- 15:09SPEAKER_00: I agree.
- 15:10SPEAKER_01: And I understand that I, you know, but belonging again is such a primordial need that I understand why these kids are um pulled into that.
- 15:17SPEAKER_01: And oftentimes they they likely do have sources of pain that are really real and they have not learned how to navigate them.
- 15:23SPEAKER_01: Um but the ideology takes and hold uh seizes upon that pain, I think, and exacerbates it and make and take them to a place that is not a place of healing, but it's a place of uh fracture.
- 15:34SPEAKER_00: Right.
- 15:34SPEAKER_00: And I think that that capitalism and all of its um all of its processes kind of fuel all of these things.
- 15:41SPEAKER_00: Because as soon as you post online that I'm lonely or depressed, then you're sent a video of of a um a no contact person, and then you're sent some kind of better help ad and then some other product that can help you with that.
- 15:53SPEAKER_00: And so that becomes this kind of melange of of different sources that all funnel the person away from the people that could actually improve their lives and help their lives and give them a certain kind of strength and resilience.
- 16:05SPEAKER_00: So one of the things I I think about Noelle is, you know, I mean at this point it seems like it to be a pretty purely Western phenomenon, you know, especially in the United States, but in largely Anglo Anglophere um Anglophone countries.
- 16:20SPEAKER_00: Um and so the question is sort of like, well, you know, other societies, other whole continents don't do estrangement, and and we have to assume that they have abuse of parents and the like.
- 16:32SPEAKER_00: And so I mean, what's their what's their method?
- 16:35SPEAKER_00: I mean the if they're not metabolizing parental or family conflict with this lens of individuality and identity, um what are they what do you think about that at all?
- 16:44SPEAKER_00: Do you have any of that?
- 16:45SPEAKER_01: Yeah, no, definitely.
- 16:46SPEAKER_01: I think it's fascinating.
- 16:47SPEAKER_01: Um I think most ideological beliefs are, you know, what's what I think Robert Henderson calls luxury beliefs.
- 16:53SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 16:53SPEAKER_01: You know, that they are you you can afford to kind of believe uh a narrative of fracture when you have the buffers of um, you know, wealth or you know, a social safety net or what have you.
- 17:06SPEAKER_01: And so I think for you know, going no contact in other societies might be a matter of life or death in a way that it's not for us.
- 17:14SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 17:15SPEAKER_01: Um so there is a certain way in which an indul um a decadent society can breed sort of indul these sorts of indulgent fracturing beliefs because we become um uh not only we have the capacity to endure or we have the veneer of seeming to be able to endure the fracture.
- 17:33SPEAKER_01: But also I think that um when things are really easy and things are kind of tend towards decadence, we find find a way to blow things up.
- 17:41SPEAKER_01: You know, because the human person in some ways I think wants some ground struggle or something to contend with or some real um adventure to have or some you know triumph to overcome.
- 17:52SPEAKER_01: And so this might be a sort of a uh a false way of sort of um having this dramatic narrative, moral struggle that we can endure in our own life and then triumph over that because we don't have maybe a wor World War II or something or or um, I think you're absolutely right.
- 18:07SPEAKER_01: Yeah, yeah.
- 18:08SPEAKER_00: No, I've I've sort of been thinking about writing an article with the title, How Can I Have a Rebellious Adolescence when my parents are so nice?
- 18:14SPEAKER_00: You know, I think you know, one of the things that my generation of parents and every generation since then has kind of deprived our children of is sort of people to rebel against because we have been so nice and so conscientious and given up our hobbies and extracurricular activities and everything else to give our children this rarefied existence.
- 18:33SPEAKER_00: And the problem is that they haven't really they have nothing to kind of oppose.
- 18:37SPEAKER_00: And so I think that for a certain percentage, I don't even I don't assume it's the majority, but I clearly see that for some, it is a kind of a wandering into the woods.
- 18:45SPEAKER_00: It is kind of a, you know, the old days where maybe you went off and joined the army or, you know, you became a missionary or something where you were kind of like went out into the world and developed your strengths and assets.
- 18:55SPEAKER_00: In some ways, estrangement can be kind of like a courageous act.
- 19:00SPEAKER_00: Jennifer Silver, I don't know if you've read her book, Coming Up Short, um, about working class um um uh youth.
- 19:07SPEAKER_00: And she's how what she says is, well, now that that working class youth no longer have unions and marriage as sources of stability and of identity and strength, it's now become the family, the liberation from the families.
- 19:19SPEAKER_00: And it's also testimony to the fact that it isn't just it isn't just happening in in progressive families.
- 19:24SPEAKER_00: It's kind of a it's more of a national phenomenon.
- 19:27SPEAKER_00: But I but I think that point is really interesting and well said.
- 19:30SPEAKER_01: Yeah, we want to slay a dragon.
- 19:32unknown: You know.
- 19:33SPEAKER_00: Yeah, exactly.
- 19:34SPEAKER_01: And in some ways, I think, you know, that there's um there can be some way in which we find that dragon within ourselves, right?
- 19:40SPEAKER_01: More properly, that's what maybe an interior life kind of invites us to.
- 19:44SPEAKER_01: So um there is an attenuation of our religious life that I think is plays into this, where um, you know, I mean, so I'm Catholic, that's my my my my faith background, but um in Catholicism, we are contending with our internal interior struggles, you know, all the time.
- 20:00SPEAKER_01: And invited to look at ourselves, you know, examination of conscience, go to confession, um, say a mea culpa.
- 20:06SPEAKER_01: And I think that part of that, the wisdom of that is that there's such an there's such a human tendency to point our finger outside.
- 20:11SPEAKER_01: And so that kind of an invitation to look back at ourselves.
- 20:14SPEAKER_01: But then, you know, when you really start like that interior life of prayer, kind of invites you kind of to see, oh, there are all sorts of things going like intern interior pollution in my own soul that I'm you know, pride of ego, of selfishness, of self-aggrandizement.
- 20:28SPEAKER_01: You know, there's a whole whole host of things that I got to deal with and contend with.
- 20:32SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 20:32SPEAKER_01: And I would not know about those things if I weren't really trying to seek them out because my nature is to not see them.
- 20:39SPEAKER_01: You know, at the human nature, which is your human nature.
- 20:42SPEAKER_01: Yeah, yeah.
- 20:43SPEAKER_01: We're so it's so easy to see the worst in other people and and to gloss and excuse ourselves.
- 20:47SPEAKER_01: So a part of this, I think, I do think, than trying to slay the dragon is that we're not slaying the dragon in our own soul and um going down that rabbit hole.
- 20:56SPEAKER_00: Right.
- 20:56SPEAKER_00: Or if we are being invited to do it, it's it's in the process of excising our parents.
- 21:01SPEAKER_00: That's that's the dragon that we're slaying.
- 21:02SPEAKER_00: We're like excising them as a way to become to our purest, authentic self, which is the problem with expressive individualism, is kind of the how much it empowers this idea that there's this pure, unfettered self that you just have access to, that if you'd gotten the proper kind of parenting, uh you wouldn't have the struggles that you have.
- 21:20SPEAKER_00: So what you need to do is just figure out how you were traumatized and then get rid of your parents, and then you'll be free to become the person that you really were meant to be.
- 21:28SPEAKER_00: And so many parents get letters from their adult children saying, Well, I need time to heal, I need space to heal, and you know, and to figure out they rarely will say something as, you know, like figure out who I am, but that's kind of the implicit message.
- 21:43SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 21:43SPEAKER_01: Well, what do you think of?
- 21:44SPEAKER_01: I'd be curious what you think about this.
- 21:45SPEAKER_01: I touched on this in the book too.
- 21:47SPEAKER_01: Um, I think some a lot of parenting theories over the last century have been informed by expressive individualism and the psychological sense of man.
- 21:55SPEAKER_01: And so the ability to shape the character or to help form the character of a children, I think was relocated to not a character issue but a psychological issue, a behavioral issue.
- 22:05SPEAKER_01: And so parents I think have felt that they are sort of out of their depths.
- 22:08SPEAKER_01: And I think that's sort of why why you know it spawned, you know, friendship parenting and gentle parenting, which in some ways is a corrective of something that needs to be corrected, maybe.
- 22:16SPEAKER_01: But um I think was too reactionary and went too far.
- 22:19SPEAKER_01: And uh and parents in some ways have kind of abdicated that that benevolent authority because I think we've collapsed this idea of authority into authoritarianism.
- 22:28SPEAKER_01: But I'm I'm curious what you think about the parent evolution of parenting and how that might keep play at play.
- 22:34SPEAKER_00: Yeah no I 100% agree.
- 22:36SPEAKER_00: You know if you look at parenting surveys in the 1920s what parents wanted from their children was to obey them if not to fear them.
- 22:43SPEAKER_00: And then over the course of the 20th century became much more parents became more concerned about hurting their children than Spock in the 1950s developed the idea that well parents should sort of trust themselves on the one hand, but then he gave them a bunch of ideas about how they could mess up their children.
- 22:59SPEAKER_00: And then in the 1960s the idea began to shift away from kind of raising a you know a morally upstanding child and therapy kind of fought along with it to it to raising a child who was really in touch with themselves and could express themselves.
- 23:14SPEAKER_00: And particularly it began in the middle classes and now it's expanded to all the classes where um helicopter parenting, hothouse parenting, concerted cultivation, all these things are kind of dancing around the ideal that that parents have to be very deeply invested in their child's psychological well-being in order for them to become sort of realize as full functioning adults.
- 23:38SPEAKER_00: And what doesn't get talked about enough is the way that economics has informed that because from economics we learned that in countries like ours which have really high rates of social inequality where parents can no longer in the way that they could in in the period between 1945 the post-war period between 1945 and the mid-1970s parents still got enormous support from businesses and from the government in terms of raising their children, low-cost college, you know union father could put three kids through college on a union job, people could count on a pension and now all that's been taken away.
- 24:12SPEAKER_00: It's what the political scientist Jacob hacker calls the great risk shift where the risk that the society had absorbed for parents which most Western democracies um in in the European in Europe anyway still do.
- 24:26SPEAKER_00: All of that's been taken away.
- 24:27SPEAKER_00: So it's now all on the parents um shoulders.
- 24:30SPEAKER_00: So parents have had to become helicoptering and uh concerted cultivation because they can't really count on the fact that if their children don't make it into the narrow bottleneck of adulthood that they're going to be able to to have a good life.
- 24:44SPEAKER_00: So it's made patients very parents very anxious, very guilt-ridden very preoccupied.
- 24:49SPEAKER_00: It's made them give up on things that they um would been you know that my parents in my you know boomer generation would you know my parents you know they were they were preoccupied with how I was going to turn out because they could sort of count on the fact that I was probably going to turn out better than they did in terms of success and the like whereas parents can no longer count on that.
- 25:08SPEAKER_00: So what that's meant is that that parents are have just been much more anxious over the past four decades, much more intrusive, much more surveilling.
- 25:16SPEAKER_00: So a certain percentage of estrangements happen because adult children just get too much of their parents too much safety and insulation but also too much contact also because childhood has moved indoors as well.
- 25:30SPEAKER_00: So all those things I think really have have shaped some of the some of the dynamics that we're seeing now.
- 25:36SPEAKER_01: Yeah so so it strikes me that that then that instinct and you kind of intimated this earlier to diff to to separate is some ways is seeking something that is a a good reaction to something that ought ought to have been different.
- 25:50SPEAKER_01: But then seeking it in in a bad way.
- 25:52SPEAKER_01: Yeah I also think that you know with the with the ch you know Tocqueville and Democracy in America I think he talks about you know the importance of mediating institutions, little platoons in that our culture, you know, you we used to think about things like the the the town dance or you know the community um that we had these sorts of um mediating institutions that kind of were a buffer for the so it was not as you said like all on the parents' shoulders and how um how weakened that those have gotten if not entirely gone.
- 26:20SPEAKER_01: I mean even think about um at my daughter's wedding she you know her bridesmaids and groomsmen they they could they at their college they all learn swing dancing and it's this really sweet thing it's very normal and so the first bridal party dance they all started doing this beautiful swing dancing to earth, wind and fire.
- 26:35SPEAKER_01: And it's really from the throwing girls up in the air and it's just soyful.
- 26:39SPEAKER_01: And um several people turn to me like did they just learn this for the when it's like no this is just how they are this is just how they dance.
- 26:45SPEAKER_01: And I thought you know we that the the fact that you know we've even sort of um uglified dancing down to kind of just bumping and grinding or whatever.
- 26:52SPEAKER_01: You know the culture has just gotten so degraded on so many levels.
- 26:56SPEAKER_01: And I think that that's um you know that that the human being being longs for beauty truth and goodness.
- 27:02SPEAKER_01: And the insofar as we've given a generation that doesn't really have many places to turn for beauty truth and goodness that that that um I think leads to a lot of um soul jaundicness you know in in in our in our gener in a generation and in culture.
- 27:16SPEAKER_00: Yeah no I think that's well said I think people don't know where to look and they're being particularly if you're living online you're being misdirected in so many different ways in this much more of a narcissistic um kind of enterprise thinking about how many likes you have in social media and how popular you are and how attractive you are and if you don't feel that way then you can get an app that will make you look more attractive and be more more popular.
- 27:38SPEAKER_01: So it's it's a really kind of a dystopian moment particularly for younger younger generations whether it's leads uh yeah kids are prone to neuroticism too right that they're not able to lose themselves in something in a hobby or in a passion or and an otherness or in love or service or something.
- 27:55SPEAKER_01: It's such a I'm locked in on myself and um that's a real miserable way to live.
- 28:02SPEAKER_00: It is yeah I'm glad that you know I didn't wasn't raised in the era because I would have been very vulnerable to that.
- 28:08SPEAKER_00: I mean as a teenager I really wanted to be popular and with the in-crowd and if I was like competing not only against my peers but you know against millions of other people worldwide I would have been miserable.
- 28:18SPEAKER_00: I get why these kids are suicidal or you know anxious or depressed or want to find some other reason because they don't really understand the the toxic environment of downward social comparison that they're I totally agree.
- 28:29SPEAKER_01: I totally agree.
- 28:29SPEAKER_01: I mean that's the thing is that you know in researching this and you've been in this topic so far longer than I but yeah it really doesn't you know I I can see I I see clearly what the lies are but I don't see clearly the um that the the the people doing cutting off are villains in any way.
- 28:45SPEAKER_01: It seems to me that they're yeah in some ways just as victimized by the forces that are pre have preceded them and are informing them beyond their even understanding that they're being informed by.
- 28:56SPEAKER_01: Agreed so yeah that's that's um in some ways that that feels m more dis discouraging it might feel easier to have some pretty obvious villains here but um it's so other ways it's more hopeful, right?
- 29:09SPEAKER_01: Because um you know there are lies that we can dismantle and you know culture to rebuild and maybe things to be tweaked and aided and people to be persuaded.
- 29:21SPEAKER_00: Yeah I think people are constantly directed to find the enemy and the other person whether politically it's immigrants or on the familial level it's your parents or but people aren't really being invited to look at the underlying cultural of moment that we're in that where um yeah where there's so much so much misdirection of where all the suffering lies.
- 29:42SPEAKER_00: One of the many interesting points that you make in your your book Noelle is the um that when somebody goes no contact there's they may develop a psychological need to maintain that narrative that that justified the cutoff and you cite some research about what happens to to memory after estrangement.
- 29:59SPEAKER_00: Can you talk a little bit about that?
- 30:00SPEAKER_01: Yeah and and this makes total sense to me I mean so um so once you've gone no contact then you sort of reduce that other person um in your in your understanding of who they are right that that you know I think we all have the experience where maybe there's some tension in a relationship and you know I'm annoyed by this person but you know we're still living in daily life together and so eventually like I see oh they're just a human being and oh they did that funny foible and they're human again to me.
- 30:27SPEAKER_01: Yeah of tenderness again.
- 30:29SPEAKER_01: But when you go no contact you don't have any possibility of those sorts of normal human moments of tenderness and foible and you see their humanity.
- 30:38SPEAKER_01: And so you only see them in that one way in a frozen kind of frozen memory.
- 30:43SPEAKER_01: And then you struggle inevitably on some level I think consciously or unconsciously with uh questioning your decision.
- 30:50SPEAKER_01: You know, did I should I why am I in no contact with my mom or my dad or whomever um did I make the wrong decision.
- 30:57SPEAKER_01: And I think there's such a human temptation at that moment to say to double down and just say no I had to do that because X, Y, and Z.
- 31:05SPEAKER_01: And this is why I was right and this is justifies it because I it's really hard to face the idea that I might have made that the wrong decision and that this sadness in my life might in some ways be partially self-inflicted.
- 31:16SPEAKER_01: And so I think we're invited to kind of rehearse our narrative of that justifies ourselves and impugns them and rehearse that over and over again and then that further not only free then not only are they frozen in our memory and our understanding of them, but the whole source of conflict and uh and no contact is now sort of reinforced and buttressed and then um becomes like a statue in our in our minds.
- 31:40SPEAKER_00: Right.
- 31:41SPEAKER_00: Yeah and if you're an estranged adult child and you're like on a Reddit forum or some other forum that's sort of more pro-estrangement, there's going to be a certain amount of policing around that oh I'm thinking about contacting my parent no don't do it don't be weak they haven't changed they're a narcissist you've already said said that so that's this the community can become kind of the enforcer or of that reducing those feelings of of ambivalence.
- 32:03SPEAKER_00: Yeah I mean it it sort of begs the question of so if you're the estranged parent um there's a little bit of a debate in my field of people who work with this about how how much should parents be reaching out if the adult child is no contact.
- 32:15SPEAKER_00: And my belief is parents should write one really good strong letter of amends because all parents are flawed in the same way that we're all flawed and it should really seek to understand to show curiosity and interest and empathy and responsibility taking.
- 32:30SPEAKER_00: And then if they get no response from that maybe six to eight weeks later do a follow-up just to see if the adult child um got the letter and was open to any kind of conversation or there are things that were left out of the letter.
- 32:41SPEAKER_00: But then if they don't get anything from that then I typically recommend that they don't do anything um for at least a year because I think for us if you're an ambivalent if you're sort of in that state of mind that you're describing where you're kind of like trying to justify it to yourself.
- 32:56SPEAKER_00: If the parent reaches out I find that most of the time that's sort of quote triggering to the adult child.
- 33:02SPEAKER_00: The kind of you know what I often tell parents is your child may have to forget you in order to remember you.
- 33:07SPEAKER_00: And that's particularly true for those kids who are low differentiation because they don't really feel separate enough from the parent.
- 33:12SPEAKER_00: You know I've I've had two different adult estranged daughters say to me I just don't know any other way to get my mother's voice out of my head.
- 33:18SPEAKER_00: And it's not a cruel critical voice it's just that the there's a kind of an anxious you know depressed sort of you know over involved voice.
- 33:27SPEAKER_00: So for those that percentage of of kids and it's a very heterogeneous group but for that for those adult children the parent reaching out could be more um more um ill-advised because it sort of would force a re up a refreshing of the of the why am I I doing this so so for those kids if they're not particularly in our era of expressive individualism where we don't really owe anybody anything and if we're gonna re-engage with our parent we're doing it because we want to you know rather than because we're doing so out of guilt or obligation God forbid right um so if we're doing that then we need to feel like we're coming as the adult child out of our own kind of um impulse and desire and the like and so if the if the parent isn't reaching out then the adult child can feel like oh I haven't heard from my mom or dad for nine months.
- 34:17SPEAKER_00: That's unusual.
- 34:18SPEAKER_00: Oh right I've been no contact with them for three years.
- 34:20SPEAKER_00: So I really want to be no contact whereas if the parent's continuing to kind of circle around with letters and cards, even if they're more benign, I think that might rob them of that opportunity.
- 34:29SPEAKER_01: But just wondering if you have any thoughts about all that yeah no I think that you're that's utterly wise and prudent all of what you just said.
- 34:37SPEAKER_01: It reminds me in some ways that um I I think part of that reason I love what you said about forget you in order to remember you.
- 34:44SPEAKER_01: And I think part of what's at play there is that as long as you're engaging in their life or trying to kind of get get them to come back to you, then they can sort of keep deflecting things onto you because you're still a very obvious source of whatever they're being triggered or what have you.
- 35:00SPEAKER_01: And in some ways they you have to be totally removed.
- 35:02SPEAKER_01: And it reminds me of years ago talking to a friend who um she was having true trouble in her marriage and um and her husband had you know a struggle and she kept trying to kind of help him to see that he had this struggle and like change the struggle and stop doing the struggle stop with the struggle.
- 35:18SPEAKER_01: For some reason it didn't work right there's just like you know as long as you are the the person engaging with him in it then you are the struggle.
- 35:26SPEAKER_01: You know that he's not able to see um what what he has on his own, you know, what he has to deal with on his own because he can just be like she won't get off my back and da da da right.
- 35:35SPEAKER_01: And so I think it's sort of similar to that that you can you are continually going to be in some ways scapegoated so long as you are like pushing yourself and that is the sort of um integral to whatever struggle that they are dealing with.
- 35:48SPEAKER_01: They kind of have to see that they might have some things to face on their own and that might require your your removal but I think that's such such a wise advice in men's letter um particularly because you can say exactly what you want to say and not say too much or too little and then it it's in print, you know, it's or it's in an email or your words can't be misremembered.
- 36:07SPEAKER_01: If they need, if they really want to revisit that conversation, they can look at it and know just what you said.
- 36:13SPEAKER_01: And also the ownership I think is so is so important too.
- 36:15SPEAKER_01: But yeah, I think that's absolutely right.
- 36:17SPEAKER_01: And the the things I found are the two parents tend to and you can tell me what you from your experience if you think this is right, there tend to be two broad extremes that parents fall into out of reactivity.
- 36:27SPEAKER_01: One is to kind of capitulate and kind of do whatever it takes to keep that relationship going.
- 36:31SPEAKER_01: And the other is to um try to control the person, right?
- 36:35SPEAKER_01: Or to try to send them too many articles or, you know, because I'm dealing so much with political disagreements and ideology stuff that parents just say they think they can argue their way back into relationship with the with a kid.
- 36:45SPEAKER_01: You know and both are sort of ways of trying to control the situation although they they look different.
- 36:50SPEAKER_01: And so yeah it seems like there's a happy meet mean between those two extremes which is um del acting with deliberation you know that we're not acting out of its place of panic or control but rather just deliberating and I think the uh the method that you outlined with that timeline seems like something very deliberative and something that you can kind of um put play a place to put your feet in the kind of emotional turmoil after an estrangement.
- 37:15SPEAKER_00: Yeah which is what parents are desperate to have and um you know I find that fathers have an easier time with that directive than than mothers do.
- 37:22SPEAKER_00: For moms I just think you know the the ideology of motherhood is so powerful and then the ability to resist the idea that if your child cuts you off you know it doesn't mean that you're a terrible mother is so it's such a big challenge for for most mothers.
- 37:37SPEAKER_00: So you know when I tell tell mothers in particular well let's write a you know good amends letter and and do the follow-up and then you get nothing back don't do anything for a year they're like a year you know what about their birthday?
- 37:50SPEAKER_00: What about you know other things and um it just feels so unmaternal to do that.
- 37:55SPEAKER_00: But it's kind of a cruel I mean it's not the the option is cruel but I mean the the it's what I call parenting at a distance you're kind of you're still being a parent but you're doing it from from the remove of actually actively parenting which from others is it's really quite frankly excruciating for the vast majority.
- 38:14SPEAKER_01: Right and there there's I mean there's a there's sort of not a toxic there is a motherly trait to kind of mother too long and be you know yeah it's what have you but um but you know one uh one of the things I talk about in the book is that you know when their kids are little I think about this with you know I have six children and half of them are adults now um you have moral control when they're little and you don't really have earned moral authority but as they grow up you should be you should be lowering control and or growing you know ideally in authority so that ultimately you want them to come to you but out of their full freedom.
- 38:45SPEAKER_01: And the things we embrace out of our full freedom we embrace more deeply.
- 38:49SPEAKER_01: And so I so I think about that with just kind of letting go a little a bit with kids um I want to you know that their freedom is something I value as their mom and I want to foster their freedom.
- 39:00SPEAKER_01: And fostering their freedom means not fostering this relationship.
- 39:04SPEAKER_00: Yeah right yeah yeah I forget the name of this person um he was he wrote about um about parenting adolescents and he said you know when your kids become adolescents you have to shift from the managerial role into the consultant role.
- 39:17SPEAKER_00: And I think that's where you kind of have to remain you know for the rest of your adult children's lives as a consultant.
- 39:22SPEAKER_00: I mean you can maybe you know occasionally tell them what you think that would be good for them to change but it's really a hundred percent up to them and you can easily alienate an adult child by staying in the managerial role.
- 39:33SPEAKER_00: And I think it's a very confusing place for for parents whether they're estranged or not kind of how much to be involved and what to say and what not to say.
- 39:41SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 39:41SPEAKER_01: I think that's right okay I was just gonna say also you know mother mothering is so much part of the identity of a woman in a way that maybe fatherhood is integral to the identity but it tends to be not quite as held so deeply I think in a way.
- 39:55SPEAKER_01: But the other thing I was going to mention before um and then I'll let you go on because I think I interpreted you but um but just on this topic is do you think that there is a dynamic of because I f I find this that we can try to say and convince ourselves that you know our kids' successes and failures are you know you know somewhat we might have some effect on those but you know ultimately they have free will and but I there is a temptation when kids are doing really well to be like oh look at me I think part of the pain of estrangement is that you know it it's embarrassing because you can't help but be like oh all these other moms get to be like oh my kids doing this and you know and I'm you know it's there's a humility there and a humiliation there.
- 40:35SPEAKER_00: Absolutely no no question.
- 40:36SPEAKER_00: And that's why it's still a somewhat closeted issue.
- 40:39SPEAKER_00: It's beginning to come out of the closet but it's still somewhat closeted.
- 40:42SPEAKER_00: I mean most estranged parents in my practice say they don't talk to anybody about it because they're worried that people are going to say and some do well you must have done something.
- 40:50SPEAKER_00: I mean adult children don't reject a parent for no reason which is true.
- 40:53SPEAKER_00: It's just that they don't necessarily reject them because of bad parenting and I think to your point you know some people are very mediocre parents who have these kids who turn out amazingly and make the parents look fantastic.
- 41:04SPEAKER_01: And some super dedicated loving involved parents have kids that either don't turn out well or turn out well but then reject the parent and make the parent look like they're somehow you know bad parents and so it's really it's just so hard to I think it's so hard to um break out of that framework and think like this might not be a reflection of me as a failure in my you know and so that's what I have heard from these moms, you know, that that's just really hard to talk themselves out of that.
- 41:31SPEAKER_00: It's really hard to yeah there's no question absolutely yeah well I like what you were saying earlier about the way the Catholicism sort of invites more self-investigation kind of assuming that we're all flawed and all have tendencies to turn the attention away from ourselves and one of the things I like about a family who are in AA and the fourth step of AA I really like because the the fourth step of AA is make a searching and fearless moral inventory of your character flaws.
- 41:58SPEAKER_00: And I think that you know it's that's usually the the principle that I help parents apply when they're writing the amends letters but I don't necessarily feel like adult children are applying the same thing in regards to their parents.
- 42:08SPEAKER_00: I mean again I think that they're this sort of this idea of you know this John Locke idea that you know they're kind of born as this blank slate and whatever problems that they've had is due to the parental influence.
- 42:18SPEAKER_00: And you know I think the research on parental influence is like maybe it's 20, 25% in terms of adult outcomes, but you know the rest is genetic, social class, random good luck, random bad luck, cohort, siblings, other relationships.
- 42:34SPEAKER_00: But we're in this moment where everything is being kind of brought back down to parents and adult children are not not being asked to kind of look at their how they're contributing to it.
- 42:43SPEAKER_00: And some some estrangement happened because the adult child was just really a tough kid to raise.
- 42:48SPEAKER_00: They had oppositional defiance they had learning disabilities they had ADD as adolescents they had they had maybe mental health issues they had addictions the parents may have had to send them heroically to a therapeutic boarding school which cost them you know tens of thousands of dollars or to a psychiatrist or therapist and then the adult child later looks back and says well I didn't really need that you know you would just that was you were doing that out of your own narcissism.
- 43:10SPEAKER_00: If you just left me alone I would have been fine and it's like well first of all how the hell do you know but second of all your parents like doing everything in their power to try to save you from either killing yourself or becoming a lifelong addict.
- 43:24SPEAKER_00: And I think again this this what Freud called the ego ideal this idea to kind of to preserve this idea that I'm inherently under the right circumstances would have you know I could have been a player I could have been a contender I could have been anybody that I wanted to be but because you failed as a parent I'm not that way I think is highly problematic in our society right now.
- 43:43SPEAKER_01: Yeah gosh and um you know what a miserable that almost sounds like you know a movie you know this the person who's just you know at an old age just bitter about what he could have been you know what could have been if I had been treated better or something you know I mean that sounds to me like uh you're living in you've created hell in you're around yourself, you know, like resentment and anger and bitterness and um yeah.
- 44:06SPEAKER_01: There's two, I I think there's this is simplistic, but this is uh I think about this all the time in various circumstances.
- 44:12SPEAKER_01: I think there's two choices we have in how we walk through life.
- 44:15SPEAKER_01: One is through gratitude and one is with grievance.
- 44:17SPEAKER_01: And which one you're gonna choose is going to determine your happiness.
- 44:21SPEAKER_01: It's gonna determine you know your your success of your relationships.
- 44:24SPEAKER_01: You know that that that's it's such a transformative way to walk through life is through gratitude.
- 44:28SPEAKER_01: And every situation, every relationship I have, everyone has, I can look at that filter that relationship through one of those two lenses.
- 44:36SPEAKER_01: You know, I mean most of us have imperfect parents and you could look at your imperfect parents and be like wow they did this wrong with it.
- 44:42SPEAKER_01: But but look at what they triumphed over.
- 44:45SPEAKER_01: I know they had a really hard childhood themselves and you know look at what they um what they gave me and you know the you know or even with motherhood I mean thinking about how there's a lot of kind of turmoil over what the happiness or misery of motherhood these days.
- 44:59SPEAKER_01: And um I think you know I struggled with that for a while in my younger years too just having a litany of complaints and at some point realized wow I I get you know I have I I'm able to be home with my children today and I get to you know have fresh water and I have food food I have we have a roof over heads I have these sweet faces in front of me who are sometimes crying but that's okay too that's just being a kid.
- 45:22SPEAKER_01: But you know I had to I had to reframe that whole situation to gratitude.
- 45:27SPEAKER_01: But that is a daily struggle that we have to reorient ourselves to see in this daily struggle just pulls us away from that um into a different current.
- 45:34SPEAKER_01: And so um I you know I I I think that that's it's sort of a simplistic and kind of maybe um esoteric answer, but I think it informs so much of the struggle that we're we're seeing right now.
- 45:48SPEAKER_00: I love that I think it's beautiful.
- 45:49SPEAKER_00: And one of the things I loved about your book Noelle is that I feel like it provides a moral framework for how to resist estrangement because I think so much of estrangement ideology in this moment is all about liberation from destructive parents, destructive family finding my true self, being my you know finding my identity et cetera and I feel like that kind of perspective um offers a way for people to think about kind of what you know what is sort of yeah you know other than those most extreme examples which of course we know know what those are but other than those the case against estrangement and I think having a a perspective of gratitude not grievance um is an important one.
- 46:31SPEAKER_00: Because one of the questions I often get from estranged adult children is well look I'm happier not having contact with my parent you know I'm I'm my life is much better.
- 46:40SPEAKER_00: What's in it for me basically they might not put it so crudely but that's the implicit question.
- 46:45SPEAKER_00: What why should I reconcile?
- 46:48SPEAKER_00: I mean how do how do you answer that question?
- 46:50SPEAKER_01: Yeah no I think that's such an important question.
- 46:52SPEAKER_01: And I you talked about that.
- 46:54SPEAKER_01: So um I I think the the the missing um undercurrent there is what do I owe?
- 46:59SPEAKER_01: You know not that what's in it for me.
- 47:01SPEAKER_01: It's what do I owe to these people who you gave me life.
- 47:04SPEAKER_01: And so one of the things that I um found in the book in my research is that there was over and over again I would hear people saying I didn't choose to be born.
- 47:13SPEAKER_01: Right I know that would be yeah um which means that you you owe me, I don't owe you, you know, which is obviously a rejection of the commandment to honor their father, their mother but it's also um underlying that as an nihilism I think is really scary.
- 47:27SPEAKER_01: You know that the they're saying my life isn't a blessing it's a burden.
- 47:30SPEAKER_01: Right.
- 47:31SPEAKER_01: You know you've inflicted me with life.
- 47:33SPEAKER_01: And it's also denial of first principle of philosophy.
- 47:36SPEAKER_01: You know it's so irrational and it's so um unin it's so it's self being being the fact that being is good and life is good should be self-evident but it's not anymore.
- 47:44SPEAKER_01: And I think that's coming from a really dark place.
- 47:47SPEAKER_00: Yeah good point.
- 47:48SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 47:48SPEAKER_01: So but yeah so what do you tell those kids about um what do you what do you say then if they say what what what what why?
- 47:54SPEAKER_01: Why would I reconcile?
- 47:55SPEAKER_01: I mean other than just saying you know there might be something that the relationships are about sort of mutual inter interdependence and owing each other things out of love.
- 48:04SPEAKER_00: Yeah it's not a very compelling argument.
- 48:05SPEAKER_00: I mean I I'm compelled by it but for the estranged child who's been raised in this much more of era of expressive individualism and identitarianism and uh pursuing my mental health and my personal happiness is the dominant ideologies that just it's not a very the idea that they owe anybody anything that's that's considered that's being you know that's gaslighting them that's being toxic that's being using my authority to compel them to to um do something that I'm saying they should do and that they have obligations that they don't believe they do.
- 48:35SPEAKER_01: The fascinating though is that it's a generation that talks about love all the time.
- 48:39SPEAKER_01: Right exactly they have such a jaundiced understanding of love.
- 48:43SPEAKER_01: You know if you don't love people when that who are unpleasant in heart, you know what is your love worth?
- 48:49SPEAKER_01: It's just self-serving at that point.
- 48:50SPEAKER_01: If it's like you love when it's pleasant and you love when you can get something out of it.
- 48:53SPEAKER_01: Okay that's not love.
- 48:54SPEAKER_00: Yeah that's really well said I I think in your book you talk about a relationship that's all choice and no duty is is unstable and when it's only duty and no choice is is impersonal, which I think is really a poetic way to to put it.
- 49:08SPEAKER_01: So what so what is what is the balance there would you say well well and in the book I talk about I think that the balance the richness is love is choosing what you've been given.
- 49:18SPEAKER_01: So your duties are not just your duties, you choose what you ought to do you know so and you can think about that in suffering you can think about that you know um it you know in marriage is born out of a choice but at at some point you know you it feels like an obligation and there is when yeah the richness of love is choosing that person again and again and again um so the people your your your your parents who are aging and ill and maybe don't have anything to c uh to give you back to you know how do I choose to love you and see you as that person again you know when my father died a few years ago and I so I have my children I helped take my mom take care of him and you know there's lots of like carrying an old man to the toilet and you know there's a lot of things that are very unpleasant.
- 49:58SPEAKER_01: But it was so good for his grandchildren to you know and for me to do that.
- 50:02SPEAKER_01: And I just I would look at him and see the man in him, the that magical person from my youth you know like I was seeing him anew and you're recreating you're it's a recreation.
- 50:12SPEAKER_01: You know you're introducing this element of liveliness and dynamism that's sort of timeless you know that we are not stuck in the present materialistic world that we think we're in but we actually are the same people we were 20 years ago and the we're gonna outlast this life too and you know there's all these dynamic ways that you can kind of infuse and inject that relationship with a lot of spirit and a lot of love and a bullion that I think is really missing is this sort of flat kind of what do you own what do I owe you?
- 50:39SPEAKER_01: I don't owe you anything you know I'm not gonna get anything you know this is transactional.
- 50:42SPEAKER_01: And I think it's emanates out of a materialistic understanding that's really reductive of the human person.
- 50:47SPEAKER_00: Completely yeah 100% agree.
- 50:49SPEAKER_00: You know and my I had moved my parents out here from Dayton Ohio to to uh a um um what's it called assisted living place near here um and you know every weekend and I go visit them every weekend and um um but I'd always kind of dread it a little bit I'd be like because my kids were still young it's like oh you know I don't want to go out there it's a big hassle.
- 51:10SPEAKER_00: But every time I did I just felt I felt good being there.
- 51:14SPEAKER_00: I felt good having done it.
- 51:16SPEAKER_00: I felt like a good son.
- 51:18SPEAKER_00: It was meaningful just to have that that time with them.
- 51:20SPEAKER_00: And so I think you know being directed towards obligation we're sort of in this moment where we're sort of being led to assume that well obligations are you know they're they're uh unnecessary and everything should be based on what you really want in that moment.
- 51:35SPEAKER_00: But if we're only doing what we really want in that moment first of all the research on on cult cultures like ours with high rates of individualism is that people are actually less happy because they're constantly being directed towards their own personal happiness and growth.
- 51:48SPEAKER_00: And that turns out that's not actually what makes people happy what makes people happy are the kind of things you're talking about, which is being more involved in taking care of other people and giving and not just receiving not making it so much about what am I getting out of this this much more transactional ideal of family.
- 52:06SPEAKER_01: Yeah absolutely I I have a question for you if you if you um I found in after writing this book that um no matter how many times I say you know this book is not about people who have gone no contact over abuse or you know that there are serious reasons.
- 52:20SPEAKER_01: If somebody told me that they went no contact, I would assume necessity, respect their privacy, express con con uh compassion.
- 52:27SPEAKER_01: You know, this book is but I find that people who have come have gone through it, they'll say, you know, I'll always get comments oh well I my dad sexually abused me and I guess I should have stayed in contact with that's what you're saying.
- 52:36SPEAKER_01: You know and I I can say it as clearly as possible you know but it's um I I don't know if it's just that they feel insecure with their decision so they're or maybe they're worried that that the idea that this might be um done unnecessarily kind of impugns them and their decision.
- 52:51SPEAKER_00: I and anyway I'm just curious if you've encountered any of that sort of that that defensiveness that sort of you can't penetrate that and assuage that enough their fears enough or in my experience and say as clearly as possible some people have to go no contact and I get that you know right I think there's still you know a residue of shame and guilt around it and that's why people who've done it feel obligated to devalue or you know vilify people who are you know like you or me who are writing sort of saying well not all estrangements are um are necessary or are justified that there's a huge percentage of them that don't stem from molestations or physical abuse or abject neglect.
- 53:31SPEAKER_00: And so I think that there is a a a certain amount of guilt or tension about it.
- 53:35SPEAKER_00: And I think we're kind of in this moment you know um Yashua Monk talks about in his book The Age of Responsibility that really in the past four decades we've really changed our ideals about what we consider to be responsible behavior.
- 53:47SPEAKER_00: Sort of the idea that now people have to earn their way into a relationship.
- 53:51SPEAKER_00: The poor have to earn their way and demonstrate that they've tried everything before we're gonna help them.
- 53:56SPEAKER_00: You know parents have to earn that they're still you know that they're gonna be responsive to the adult child's complaints about childhood or their boundaries, et cetera, in order to have a relationship with them.
- 54:07SPEAKER_00: And so we're kind of in this this tense tense moment and what the um sociologist um Alison Pugh calls the the um the therapists have become detachment brokers and what they're helping adult children or their clients detach from is an earlier ideal of, which I would say a healthier ideal of obligation, duty and responsibility as we've shifted away from that in the past really half century, much more towards this identitarian self-esteem mental health preoccupied culture, therapy and therapists have stepped in as kind of the arbiters of who's healthy and okay to have in one's life and who we should cut out and um and that kind of thing.
- 54:45SPEAKER_00: And so just to circle back to your your your question I I get a a lot of that I can write I wrote an article for the Washington Post a few months ago you know what point should you go to a contact and like probably three times in the article I said look there's clearly cases where you know it's understandable and of course a lot of the letters were like oh you're just gaslighting you know you're just kind of you know telling adult children that they're not they don't have the right to do this.
- 55:09SPEAKER_00: It's like did you read the article?
- 55:11SPEAKER_00: Because three times I said no matter what, you know I'm gonna get that.
- 55:14SPEAKER_00: So to me it just shows kind of the the people who are doing it if you felt really secure in it you wouldn't need to defend or attack people who are sort of saying well maybe it's not such a good idea.
- 55:24SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 55:25SPEAKER_01: Well and the irony is that you know it's it's it's sort of the people who are conflating and drawing just drawing a blanket justification for all cases of no contact they're the ones are actually degrading the people who have a just reason.
- 55:37SPEAKER_01: It's good.
- 55:37SPEAKER_01: You know it's that conflation of it that is um uh disrespecting sort of the the gravity of their reasons and by trying to tease out the ones that maybe are unnecessary I think that's redignifying the people who are not done it out of necessity.
- 55:51SPEAKER_00: Yeah I think that's well said yeah yeah in your book you talk about the way that parents are memory keepers that a parent's memory of the child is longer than the child's memory of themselves which again I think is so poetic.
- 56:02SPEAKER_00: Your book is so it's so quotable.
- 56:04SPEAKER_00: Noelle there's so many so many things in it that I would read and go, oh my God, that's that's such beautiful writing and observations.
- 56:10SPEAKER_01: Can you say a little bit more about that the the idea that parents are memory keepers and the like well um I think ideological ages tend to be memory erasers you know that um part of ideology is that it's a partial truth that you're trying to totalize into a whole truth and become the only lens of seeing reality.
- 56:27SPEAKER_01: And you know to the idea is that we can re-engineer our social life you know that everything we that's been given to us is a construct so we can deconstruct it and then reconstruct life in a more um perfect way and reengineer the human person.
- 56:42SPEAKER_01: And um and part of uh what stands athwart that is any s any sort of memory.
- 56:48SPEAKER_01: You know so I talk about in you know Mao's China for example you know they want to eradicate the four olds old culture old ways old you know habits um old religions and um everything that can preced them and I think parents are an existential threat to a very ideological moment because there is a reinvention of the human person that requires self-rejection.
- 57:08SPEAKER_01: And you see this very acutely for example in the transgender and in transgenderism with them with minors in particular and um how um what a social contagion that's been online I think in particular but um part of that is uh you want to kill your old identity.
- 57:24SPEAKER_01: I mean that's why they say you dead name me because that person is dead.
- 57:27SPEAKER_01: In fact one family I interviewed um this didn't make it into the book but the daughter who was transitioning she said you know to her mom you don't do nice things for me you do them and then she said her original name say it's Jane it wasn't Jane but she's you do that for Jane who doesn't exist anymore.
- 57:44SPEAKER_01: You know so this is this real self-rejection and we have a canon of memory of our children that they don't have for themselves.
- 57:50SPEAKER_01: You know I remember my kids when they're one and I remember like it was yesterday.
- 57:54SPEAKER_01: They for them that's like a foreign planet you know or you know that's a that doesn't even that didn't even happen.
- 58:00SPEAKER_01: And so the parent is always going to be an existential reminder of an identity that just won't die.
- 58:05SPEAKER_01: Yeah so I think that that's so that's why there's I mean in the in the transgender movement there's a there's a ton of parents that are even very progressive affirming parents agree yeah that find that they get rejected.
- 58:16SPEAKER_00: I've seen that in my practice as well that that parents who are like look I'm I'll I'm happy to or will certainly willing to to give you to call you by your chosen name and uh you know accept you and maybe even to help you with surgery or you know hormones or whatever in the adult child is just saying saying no.
- 58:35SPEAKER_00: And the things that the parents being rejected for I mean you know these are parents to your point they're often parents who are very loving and dedicated and willing to do anything and yet the the identity of of becoming trans or even gender non-binary I don't see it nearly as much for for um LGB kids.
- 58:55SPEAKER_00: But but in the trans community I think it's very vigilant around almost any statement that the parent makes is prove positive.
- 59:01SPEAKER_00: And what's missing from that from that community is some degree of empathy for the parent.
- 59:06SPEAKER_00: It is a big freaking deal to have your daughter who you raise as a daughter say oh no I'm actually a boy and so you need to start referring to me as a boy.
- 59:16SPEAKER_00: That's a big deal.
- 59:16SPEAKER_00: I mean the parent has to go through a certain amount of grieving for that um adult client of mine said um in in regards to this topic he said you know um it took me three years to be able to feel comfortable in my own feelings about being gay to come out to my parents the idea that I should just come out to them and they're gonna immediately be fine with it is completely irrational.
- 59:37SPEAKER_00: And I think it's even more true for for kids who are coming out as as trans, the idea that the parents should just kind of like immediately go, okay, you're trans, let's go.
- 59:45SPEAKER_00: You know, and not say well maybe you have other I mean if they do have other psychiatric issues which is not um which is not uncommon, maybe those need to be examined as investigated as well.
- 59:56SPEAKER_00: So again it sort of highlights this very uneven field of examination where the adult child you know always believe the adult child no matter what and always assume that the parent is somehow lying or suspect.
- 1:00:09SPEAKER_01: Yeah that's right and the you know one father I profile in the book he you know he pro he he gave back some very gentle hesitation about you know some surgeries or some medical interventions and was immediately cut off and um you know the way he to spoke to he took to some forums to you know tr try to figure out what he could do to get his get back in touch with his child and he just was excoriated and I realized and he's he was self-flagellating the whole time and you know just saying oh I've I don't deserve this I I screwed up you know and I realized he has the posture of a penitent before before a tribunal.
- 1:00:41SPEAKER_01: You know this doesn't feel like this feels like a really cultish kind of um uh sort of um of self-flagellation um so yeah it it it's um harsh and you know I think and interestingly you know what happens in oftentimes a cultural revolutions is that we become the opposite of what we are you know so I think in some ways the parent become the child becomes takes on the posture of the parent like scolding I have to I'm gonna educate you you know they take a but it's a it's a it's not a benevolent path parent role it's an authoritarian parent role you know so they become in some ways the exact thing that they're decrying you know that they feel like their parent is um um constraining them or oppressing them but they become oppressive on um on on of their own so you know anyway it's just it's certainly fascinating dynamics and um and and really uh you know really really sad.
- 1:01:32SPEAKER_01: I mean that the the nihilism and the self-rejection underlying it over and over again I find to be um disheartening and um but the you know the the the good news is that I think um these types of ideological lies tend to be have a shelf life right because they take a lot of coercion and manipulation to keep them um they can't withstand scrutiny so they have to constantly be kind of intimidating and fear-based and um canceling and but eventually they become exposed I think through shining more light on them.
- 1:02:04SPEAKER_01: So you know I think the more that we were talking about this you know I I my hope is that this is going to help both parents be more aware of it but also you know younger generations see that this is not an empowering way to be this is not in this so when they're they might be presented with that all that that road to that pathway that they might be able to identify it more quickly.
- 1:02:23SPEAKER_00: Yeah that's that's my hope as well.
- 1:02:26SPEAKER_00: Well so final question Noelle so what given your research and writing do you do you recommend to parents who are being faced with no contact statements?
- 1:02:36SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 1:02:37SPEAKER_01: Well a lot of stuff we already talked about you know kind of that avoiding those two extremes being deliberate um I also talk about being curious you know becoming I think curiosity can slow a process of reactivity um I find that even in relationships that aren't fractured or even you know even on the verge of being fractured that if there's just differences of beliefs, if you can stop and shift and think, okay, well why do you believe that and what am I missing and you know curiosity is such an important um thing to foster in relationships.
- 1:03:04SPEAKER_01: So you know um yeah yeah and also maybe not even why do you believe what you believe you know intellectually but also uh with particularly with a child who might be seeming like disorderedly pursuing some sort of belief just start trying to become curious about what wounds are they trying to kind of resolve or cover up through this you know what what hurts might that be underlying this and how might I got kind of address those or help them to see those wounds so that we might be able to heal the root of this, you know, of what's actually happening here.
- 1:03:32SPEAKER_00: Yeah no I completely agree.
- 1:03:34SPEAKER_00: And for the parent it's a a matter of sort of self-soothing because you're going to be you're kind of doing this in the field of um being accused of being a bad parent or a hurtful parent or rejecting parent and being able to kind of tolerate that while you remain curious it's a it's not a small feat psychologically but it is it is sort of a necessary one.
- 1:03:53SPEAKER_00: It's what I call being a co-investigator kind of well let's let's look at that together.
- 1:03:56SPEAKER_00: Maybe you're maybe you're right.
- 1:03:57SPEAKER_00: Maybe there were it's clear that I have blind spots or I might have had blind spots about how hurtful that was to you or how much I contributed and to not not get into the rightness or or the wrongness of it but more to kind of be to be open and curious as as you say.
- 1:04:12SPEAKER_00: Well this has been really great conversation Noel I'm really glad that we got to got to talk.
- 1:04:16SPEAKER_01: What's the best way for people to to reach you or to find out about you and the like um my think tank epppc.org I uh have my work there but also my substack called Family Revival um under Noelle Maring is where I I post that's probably the best easiest way to keep in touch with me.
- 1:04:32SPEAKER_00: Yeah and and I highly recommend your book No Contact What Family Estrangement is and how how to heal it is that it's not even out yet as it's September 8th and actually that might be an old subtitle the subtitle is um oh you could change it how seductive ideology broke families and friendships and how we can repair them.
- 1:04:50SPEAKER_00: Oh didn't it's long mouthful okay well it's yours is yours is more interesting.
- 1:04:55SPEAKER_00: Um okay great well such a pleasure noelle and we'll I'm sure we'll stay in touch thank you so much.
- 1:05:01SPEAKER_00: Okay thanks a lot if you found this helpful please follow the podcast and leave a review.
- 1:05:07SPEAKER_00: It helps other people find the show who could benefit from it.
- 1:05:10SPEAKER_00: If you want to learn more about my work you can visit me at www dot drjoshuacoleman dot com.
- 1:05:17SPEAKER_00: That is D R J O S H U A C O L E M E N dot com or subscribe to my Substack Family Troubles.
- 1:05:24SPEAKER_00: Hope to see you in one of those places soon take care