Latest / Engineering Influence from ACEC / Navigating Economic Turbulence with Sarah Wolfe
Transcript
- 0:00Hello, and welcome to another episode of the Engineering Influence podcast.
- 0:03My name is Diana O'Lear, and I am the Director of Market Intelligence for the
- 0:07American Council of Engineering Companies here in Washington, D.C.
- 0:10If you're viewing us on YouTube, don't forget to like or subscribe and follow
- 0:13ACEC for more recordings.
- 0:16Now, today's podcast comes to you from The Market Edge, a new podcast series
- 0:20driven by the Market Intelligence Committee here at ACEC.
- 0:23On The Market Edge, we will feature industry experts that address member-specific
- 0:28questions with a focus on market trends and economic insights aimed to empower
- 0:33engineering firms to drive growth, adapt to change, and maintain their competitiveness.
- 0:38Today, we will be joined by Senior Economist and Strategist of Morgan Stanley
- 0:42Wealth Management, Sarah Wolf, where we will cover everything from tariffs to
- 0:46inflation, immigration,
- 0:48the overall economy, and if there might be any bright spots or opportunities
- 0:51in all the volatility we are seeing today.
- 0:54Sarah, thank you so much for joining the podcast today. Thank you for having me, Diana.
- 0:58Absolutely. A little bit more about Sarah before we dive in.
- 1:02She's a senior economist and strategist at Morgan Stanley Wealth Management,
- 1:06covering macro and thematic investing.
- 1:08Prior to this role, she was on the U.S. economics research team for five years.
- 1:12She received her B.A. in international studies and economics from Johns Hopkins University and M.A.
- 1:18In international economics from the Johns Hopkins School of Advanced International Studies.
- 1:22She's also worked at the World Bank in Washington, D.C. while completing her master's.
- 1:26And she also mentors and teaches economics and financial literacy to high school
- 1:30students in the Morgan Stanley Jumpstart Finance Program and is a visiting lecturer
- 1:34at Johns Hopkins University and chairs the Policy Survey Committee for the National
- 1:38Association for Business Economics and Programming Committee for the New York NAEP chapter.
- 1:43I first heard Sarah speak on a panel at an event for the National Retail Federation,
- 1:48and I thought engineering firms would be very interested in what she had to
- 1:51say. So let's jump right into some questions.
- 1:55So my first one I have for you, Sarah, is there's a lot going on right now.
- 1:58And one of the top mind topics is tariffs.
- 2:01So can you tell us what sectors have the most exposure due to tariffs?
- 2:05Our members will be interested in construction materials, manufacturing market and auto sales.
- 2:11Yeah, definitely. And unfortunately, the sectors that you just covered are probably
- 2:17the most impacted by tariffs.
- 2:19If we look at which industries have the most exposure to tariffs by their input
- 2:24costs, the ones that come up as the highest are computer and electronic products.
- 2:29Then you have electrical equipment and appliances, machinery.
- 2:34You also have furniture, plastics and rubber, apparel.
- 2:38So it really is broad across both the industrial sector and the consumer sector.
- 2:44And what we're seeing already in some of the business surveys and consumer surveys
- 2:49is that there's already a lot of concern across both parts of the economy because
- 2:53it's going to raise input prices for companies and consumer prices at the end.
- 2:57And even beyond just more of the industrial sector construction,
- 3:03so if we think about home building, lumber prices are going to be impacted.
- 3:07We've already heard that home builders are trying to source lumber from the U.S.
- 3:13Instead of Canada to reduce costs.
- 3:16And even beyond that, if we think about input costs that are going to impact
- 3:19the manufacturing and construction sector, labor is a really big thing to consider
- 3:24as well in addition to tariffs.
- 3:26And we could talk a little bit more about that later on on what's happening
- 3:29with immigration policy and what that's going to mean for businesses' bottom line.
- 3:34Now, when you and I talked before this call, you mentioned how the soft data
- 3:39wasn't lining up with the hard data, at least not yet. It kind of reminds me
- 3:43of the longest awaited recession that we all feared for the last four years that never came.
- 3:48And we're seeing from our members that industry sentiment is starting to come
- 3:52in and is trending down again.
- 3:54But will a recession, do you think, follow this time?
- 3:58Will there be a cliff coming in this hard data that seems to be showing that
- 4:02everything's okay right now?
- 4:04Yeah, so maybe I'll take that in two parts.
- 4:07The first is how are tariffs impacting the sentiment data, what that means for
- 4:11the economy, and then what are some of the sources of a recession?
- 4:15So if we look first at the second part, there's a lot of sources of a recession right now.
- 4:19We compared today to six months ago, recession probability six months ago,
- 4:24or probably somewhere around 10 to 15% in the next 12 months.
- 4:27Today, you have estimates all the way from 40% to 80%. So people think that
- 4:32there's a fairly significant chance that we could enter a recession.
- 4:36And if you just look at the median forecast for US GDP growth this year,
- 4:41it's hanging around 1% relative to 3% last year.
- 4:45That's not negative, so it's not a recession, but that significant slowdown
- 4:49from 3% is going to feel recessionary for a lot of sectors.
- 4:52And there may be certain sectors within that that can track while others perform relatively better.
- 4:58For example, the services sector is going to be more insulated from tariffs
- 5:02than the good side of the economy.
- 5:04So there's definitely a lot of channels for a recession, whether it's financial
- 5:08market volatility, the wealth effect, trade policy, trade policy uncertainty.
- 5:14A slowdown in immigration.
- 5:15But that doesn't necessarily mean we're going to enter a recession.
- 5:18If we think about the fundamentals of the U.S. economy, We're still in good shape.
- 5:23We're entering all this turmoil. I'm very healthy standing.
- 5:27Household balance sheets are still in a good place.
- 5:29Corporate balance sheet and leverage is still fairly low. So there's a little
- 5:33bit of room to weather the storm.
- 5:35And of course, if we do see a type of slowdown, the Federal Reserve will be
- 5:39likely to lower interest rates and that'll alleviate some pressure.
- 5:43So now quickly turning to the first part of your question, how are tariffs actually
- 5:47filtering through the economy?
- 5:50And it's really a four-step process. The first, which we saw immediately,
- 5:54was through financial markets, right?
- 5:56We saw a pretty sharp decline in equity markets.
- 5:59We saw interest rates, expectations fall quite a bit off of elevated recession
- 6:06risk, but then they kind of bounce back off because it bounce back up because
- 6:10now investors are also expecting higher inflation.
- 6:13So it's a little bit of a tricky situation.
- 6:15And then we saw also the U.S. dollar has weakened about 10% this year as well
- 6:20off of some of the trade news.
- 6:23The second channel that we've seen in order is through sentiment.
- 6:28And this is from consumers and businesses. So consumer sentiment now is looking
- 6:32a lot more pessimistic for the economic outlook and for their financial outlook.
- 6:36A little bit more pessimistic about labor prospects, the ability to find a job.
- 6:41But also, I would say most significantly about inflation expectations.
- 6:45Consumers are very worried that we're going to see a reacceleration in prices
- 6:49after we've seen extreme inflation now for about five years.
- 6:53So consumers are very price sensitive.
- 6:55The second place we've seen it is in the business surveys. And this really gets
- 6:59to the industry that matters the most for all of you.
- 7:03When we look at the ISM surveys that come from the manufacturing sector,
- 7:07that's really where the sentiment has declined the most. I mean,
- 7:10you could look at it on a regional basis and on a national basis.
- 7:14And what it showed is that new order expectations for manufacturers have plummeted.
- 7:19So people are not placing new orders because of all this uncertainty around
- 7:23tariffs and prices paid expectations have skyrocketed.
- 7:28And so that it kind of looks like what we would call in the economics world,
- 7:31a stagflationary like environment where growth is slowing, where prices are
- 7:36rising, which creates a very difficult situation for the U.S.
- 7:39Economy and for policymakers.
- 7:42So a little bit more on inflation and interest rates and what those impacts might be.
- 7:47Some of our members have talked about developers stockpiling materials like
- 7:51steel and lumber in advance of these tariffs, anticipating the increase of price.
- 7:56You know, do you think that this will be similar to COVID times where we saw
- 8:02a spike in construction material pricing? Is that what we're going to see, do you think?
- 8:08Yeah, so we're hearing about this across the business sector and the consumer
- 8:12retail sector where there's been a pull forward of demand.
- 8:16And so what's actually happening in the economic data is that things are accelerating,
- 8:21things are looking better, because businesses and companies are buying more right now.
- 8:26So if you look at consumer spending on autos back in March, it was up 5% month
- 8:32over month, huge month over month increase in auto sales because of that concern
- 8:36around tariffs and what it's going to mean for car prices.
- 8:39And so you're seeing this pull forward of demand and you're seeing a pull forward
- 8:41of inventory stockpiling.
- 8:43And I was recently talking to a leading data provider for the retail sector,
- 8:48and they said they're hearing from their companies that they're pulling forward
- 8:51about four to 12 weeks of inventory.
- 8:54And so we have about two to three more months, right, of inventory that's going
- 8:59to be priced at roughly pre-tariff prices.
- 9:03And we're not seeing that businesses are trying to raise prices ahead of tariffs.
- 9:08They're not trying to get ahead of it. I think there's also a little bit of
- 9:11a customer satisfaction.
- 9:12Nobody wants to be the first business to take advantage of tariffs and raise
- 9:16prices. It doesn't look great.
- 9:18But what's going to happen in, you know, on a rolling basis in four to 12 weeks
- 9:23from now, we're going to start to see empty shelves.
- 9:26And one of the things that we've heard is that businesses that import more than
- 9:3150% of their goods from China are not only telling their Chinese manufacturers
- 9:36to stop shipments, but also to stop production.
- 9:40So that has pretty significant implications for what's going to happen in a
- 9:44few months from now when inventory starts to deplete.
- 9:46The economic data is going to start to turn and prices are going to start to
- 9:50accelerate because not only are you getting the tariff pass through,
- 9:54but businesses are intentionally not ordering more supply because they don't
- 9:57know how much price they can pass through to consumers.
- 10:00You're almost getting this double whammy that's going to cause this reacceleration in prices.
- 10:05That's very scary stuff there. Let's pivot over to policy on immigration and
- 10:10its impact on the overall labor supply.
- 10:12Is there a long game there with implementing tariffs? Will the tariffs give
- 10:16the intended desired result and bring more jobs back to the U.S.? How is that playing out?
- 10:23Yeah, so I would look at these agendas as separate policy agendas, immigration and trade.
- 10:29I think for trade, there's three
- 10:31possible long-term outcomes of what the administration is trying to do.
- 10:37And I think what's very difficult for business owners and for market participants
- 10:41is to figure out which is the end goal and to prepare for that.
- 10:46So on one hand, you know, Trump could be pushing for free global trade and using
- 10:51strong arming or trading partners to remove their trade barriers.
- 10:55And the U.S. will remove ours as well.
- 10:57And that would be a really positive situation outcome for global trade.
- 11:00On the other hand, we could be using tariffs as a negotiating tactic to increase
- 11:05business investment in the U.S.
- 11:07That seems to be a little bit more where we're in the camp, right?
- 11:10Because we put tariffs on, but we've taken them off once countries and businesses
- 11:14have agreed to stay overable terms to the U.S.
- 11:17And have agreed to increase investment in the U.S. So that means that tariffs
- 11:22maybe won't be here to stay and they're just going to be for a few months or a year.
- 11:25And then the third outcome is that we need tariffs because we need revenues
- 11:30to offset tax cuts for the U.S. deficit.
- 11:34And what that means is that tariffs are here to stay. We need these consistent
- 11:38revenues coming into the U.S.
- 11:40To help offset the decline in tax revenues.
- 11:43And so that's probably the worst case scenario for global trade and for businesses.
- 11:47And what's really tricky is understanding which is going to be the outcome and
- 11:53what is the angle, because they're all very different.
- 11:55And in my opinion, I do think that we're somewhere in that middle range where
- 11:59tariffs are being used as a negotiating tool.
- 12:02We've seen that increasingly in the last couple of weeks with the 90 day pause
- 12:06on reciprocal tariffs, with recent headlines that the U.S.
- 12:09Is working on trade agreements with India and Japan and even with China as well. So.
- 12:15Of course, in that scenario, increasing business investment in the U.S.
- 12:18Should help increase jobs in the U.S. as well.
- 12:21But it's also not so clear cut because you do get job loss from less imports
- 12:27coming to the U.S. You have a lot of people that work at the ports.
- 12:29They're going to be negatively impacted by less trade coming to the U.S.
- 12:33And so it's really hard to figure out if in the end this will benefit the U.S.
- 12:38Labor market, because what we've seen over the last couple of decades is even
- 12:42though our manufacturing sector has declined and we've lost almost 5 million
- 12:46jobs in the manufacturing sector in the last 20 years,
- 12:49we've gained 5x in the broader economy, right? Our economy is still grown and benefited.
- 12:55And then just quickly on the second point that you asked about immigration.
- 13:00If we think about what happened during the Biden administration,
- 13:02we saw a massive surge in net immigration into the US.
- 13:06We typically have about 800,000 to a million people coming to the country in
- 13:10a given year through various measures, legal immigration like green cards and
- 13:14H-1B visas, through asylum programs, and undocumented through the southern borders.
- 13:19There's a lot of different channels that immigrants come into the U.S.
- 13:23That more than tripled over the last three years.
- 13:26So net 3 million for three consecutive years. We had almost 6 to 7 million more
- 13:32immigrants come into the country.
- 13:33And that really helped resupply labor post-COVID in the U.S.
- 13:38And it was huge for the construction sector, for agriculture, for retail.
- 13:43That really lost a lot of workers during the pandemic.
- 13:47To put some interesting numbers around that, if you look at the Custom Border
- 13:51and Protection Agency, they report flows across the southern border on a daily basis.
- 13:56And at the peak, we had 250,000 to 350,000 people coming through the southern border in a given month.
- 14:04Tremendous amount of people. Under the Trump administration,
- 14:07just in his first few months, that has fallen to zero through the rhetoric,
- 14:12through increased resources at the southern border.
- 14:15And so this is really a negative labor supply shock to the U.S.,
- 14:20and it's going to slowly impact these sectors that rely very heavily on low-skill, undocumented workers.
- 14:28And it's going to increasingly impact our labor market over the next 6 to 12
- 14:32months because there's a bit of a lag between when an immigrant comes across
- 14:35the border and when they are able to enter the workforce and become employed.
- 14:40Lots of ripple effects there that not everyone, I think, considers.
- 14:44I wanted to maybe look at maybe where the bright side might be.
- 14:48So what about any potential positive catalysts? For example,
- 14:52in particular, we know the 2017 Tax Cuts and Jobs Act is set to expire next year.
- 14:58What could come of this renegotiation? Any bright spots or any other positives outside of that?
- 15:04Yeah, I think that the next big catalyst that we're going to be looking at is
- 15:08first is positive negotiations on trade.
- 15:11I think that there's room for downside surprise and there's room for upside surprise.
- 15:16So hopefully we get the latter. We get that upside surprise.
- 15:20But the other thing is going to be deregulation and taxes, which I think are
- 15:23the more pro-growth pillars of Trump's policy.
- 15:28So deregulation would benefit the energy sector, would benefit the auto industry,
- 15:34would benefit the financial services.
- 15:37Biden spent almost $2 trillion on regulation over the course of his administration.
- 15:43Trump spent barely any money in his first presidential term,
- 15:46so he's made it very clear that he's pro-deregulation.
- 15:49That really benefits small, medium-sized businesses.
- 15:52The other big one is tax cuts. So we've had the Tax Cut and Jobs Act that was
- 15:57rolled out in 2016 as a new policy.
- 16:00It was a 10-year tax cut program, benefited businesses and upper-income consumers.
- 16:07That's set to expire in 2026. So we're currently in the process of renegotiating the tax bill.
- 16:12And you're seeing that the House and Senate are both putting forward new bills
- 16:15on how to see the extension of the Tax Cut and Jobs Act.
- 16:19And the fact that we have a Republican majority in the House,
- 16:23in the Senate, and in the executive branch looks pretty good for a full extension
- 16:27of the Tax Cut and Jobs Act, and even possibly further tax cuts beyond what we already have.
- 16:34So maybe increased business deductions, possibly a lower corporate tax rate,
- 16:39no taxes on bonuses or overtime or Social Security payments.
- 16:44I mean, we've heard all these different ideas thrown out. I think in reality,
- 16:47it might be a little bit harder to implement additional tax cuts because everything
- 16:52has to get paid for somehow.
- 16:54So this is going to add to the U.S. debt. But I do think that that's going to
- 16:58be a positive catalyst that comes this summer.
- 17:01You mentioned deregulation. I know our members here are very interested in that,
- 17:06especially when it comes to permitting reform.
- 17:08Members here are looking for the successful acceleration and the permitting
- 17:13process and expediting and reducing delays and improving the predictability of project timelines.
- 17:20So that's definitely a bright spot that they're looking for.
- 17:22Just a couple more questions here and then we'll wrap up.
- 17:25So on to tech. So what are you seeing and hearing about CapEx and the technology,
- 17:30and the data center market?
- 17:32Some members have cited that projects are being significantly postponed or canceled altogether.
- 17:38Do you think this is a tariff-related effect or market uncertainty or a new trend potentially?
- 17:45Yeah, I think there's some near-term headwinds, but this is still a very powerful
- 17:50and positive catalyst for U.S. growth and productivity.
- 17:54As you mentioned, some of the
- 17:55near-term headwinds are financial market volatility, tariff uncertainty.
- 18:00There's a lot of resources that go into building these data centers.
- 18:04And then also interest rate uncertainty. Is the Fed going to cut interest rates
- 18:08and lower borrowing costs, which would support some of the financing needed for these projects?
- 18:12The other one, which I think matters to a lesser extent, though,
- 18:16is DeepSeek in China, which basically
- 18:19showed that you need less energy to produce similar results on AI.
- 18:23And I think that disrupted the market a little bit. But more broadly,
- 18:26if we look at what some of these big AI companies are saying,
- 18:30there's still a very significant amount of demand and almost an unlimited amount
- 18:34of demand that they need for power.
- 18:36So there's going to be a need for these projects.
- 18:39And even if there's headwinds that delay the start of these projects over the
- 18:42coming year, we're still going to see that this type of, you know,
- 18:45to the tune of hundreds of billions of dollars of capital invested in CapEx
- 18:49technology and the data centers that support them.
- 18:53All right, one more question. I'm going to talk about another market here.
- 18:56So U.S. airlines reported a recent dip in demand for 2025.
- 19:01Conversely, cruise lines are reporting strong revenues expected in 2025.
- 19:06Do you foresee any tariff travel where Americans would go to Canada,
- 19:10Mexico, or Europe to buy a car, computer, cell phone, mixed vacation to avoid tariffs?
- 19:15Also talk about the potential of countries boycotting U.S. products in return and their impact.
- 19:22Yeah. So I think what we're seeing the divergence between the airlines and the
- 19:26cruises is sentiment versus the actual health of the consumer.
- 19:29So I think the airlines are getting hit a bit by this boycott U.S. mentality.
- 19:34International travel to the U.S. is down 15% year over year.
- 19:38We've seen the sharpest decline, right, from our Canadian partners traveling to the U.S.
- 19:43And so less about the health of the consumer and the ability to travel and more
- 19:47about not wanting to come to the U.S.
- 19:50And that could also impact some of the travel that we get from Europe as well
- 19:53as some of these relations deteriorate.
- 19:56On the other side, the health of the consumer is still intact.
- 19:59We still have a solid labor market.
- 20:03Wealth has been volatile, but there's still a pretty powerful wealth effect from the last few years.
- 20:08And so consumers are still spending on discretionary services,
- 20:11in particular in the U.S., and that's going to benefit things like the cruises.
- 20:15In terms of U.S. residents traveling overseas to purchase cheaper goods,
- 20:21I think a lot of it is going to depend on how everything shakes out.
- 20:24I do think that, especially with Canada, we will likely see a rollback in these tariffs as the U.S.
- 20:31MCA gets renegotiated over the course of this year, and the same with Mexico as well.
- 20:38All right. Thank you, Sarah. So that is probably all the time that we're going to have for today.
- 20:43Please join us in person for our next Market Intelligence Committee meeting
- 20:46on May 20th in Washington, D.C.
- 20:49During ACEC's annual convention and legislative summit.
- 20:52Also, registration for our next market briefing will open soon.
- 20:56This will be hosted on June 3rd online with speakers from the National Association
- 21:00of Home Builders who will provide an update on the specific housing market.
- 21:04Lastly, a special thank you to Sarah Wolf of Morgan Stanley for your economic
- 21:09commentary today. Thank you, Sarah.
- 21:13Thank you diana thanks for having me and thank you to everyone for tuning in
- 21:18for the latest intelligence on the market edge this has been another episode
- 21:21from the engineering influence podcast my name is diana o'leir see you next time.