Latest / Earnestly Speaking Media / Reaction To Bleacher Report’s WWE Top 50 List With DJ Minter & Rob The Genius
Transcript
- 0:02The Earnestly Speaking Podcast is a show that is founded on free flowing conversation and
- 0:07may it times venture into mature subjects. Listener discretion is advised. Yeah,
- 0:15earnestly speaking, hard cus it's kidding how much youngan in New York give Miyammy
- 0:27carry heed so much more to storm my product can blood the street in your
- 0:31nation? Godfather see e oh hop fit the late ninety's gonna see me.
- 0:37I'm a hustle on no limitation, no bad only your matutapules, opinion nations
- 0:43name never went off season homemade and check the numbers for dropping my own right
- 0:48supply your son the comfort. Earnestly speaking, my ego is well paid.
- 0:52Earnestly speaking to people they don't bread. See, I'm like a hurricane Dura
- 0:57mile breeze. Earnestly speaking, first speaking podcast coming to you Able third,
- 1:12twenty twenty four. Back here, of course. Well, the guy on
- 1:18the left corner, left left fan corner, on the northwest corner, he's
- 1:21been I think i've in just the span of ten days long as it's been
- 1:26a while. At least four episodes we've done together run between this show and
- 1:30the wrestling Wrestling Retro show, I think so. Yeah, Rob the Genius
- 1:34is back again and he was on the show yesterday, back and again,
- 1:38and of course DJ Vinders is his side kick also of the medical of podcast
- 1:42podcast DJA. How you doing, Buddy, I am hanging in there,
- 1:46boss, just relaxing for a change. Yeah. So this is kind of
- 1:52on an emergency podcast sort of because we saw and for the last four weeks
- 1:57have been doing this. But they finished a list this uh today, Beach
- 2:02Report put out their top fifty uh w w ee all time Superstars and I
- 2:12didn't. I really didn't. I didn't really see the list because they real
- 2:15one through ten today. Well I didn't see them through them through fifty until
- 2:20was it yesterday? Someone was it was yesterday. I saw it, well
- 2:23Monday, Hell, what the hell it was? And Rob Robin was talking
- 2:27about it and was like, Yo, we need to react to this at
- 2:30some point, like asap, and I said, you don't want to get
- 2:32an extra body here to also kind of maybe maybe we can have a little
- 2:36bounce nuanced conversation on this. That's why DJ came in the first place.
- 2:40Let's just say that the list controversial, say the least depends on how you
- 2:46look at it. But yeah, and they reveal one through ten today and
- 2:53Inada, what was that? What in the world again? Beat me out,
- 3:01Scottie, what's that? I have no idea that noise? Yeah,
- 3:07yeah, I'm sorry. I was like, what the was that? That's
- 3:13funny? I was like, we gotta do. You got a fourth guest
- 3:15on the podcast now, So anyway, we want to react to the list
- 3:22because we have a lot to say about it. We want if you see
- 3:24our text machine in the last twenty four hours, it's it's, uh,
- 3:28let's just say there's a lot of to unpack here. Before I do that,
- 3:35in fairness of the Beat report, I want to read their criteria because
- 3:39I think it's it's important to to see what went into this list, what
- 3:44they considered. It was a panel of six guys, and I know one
- 3:46guy I'm frequently with, uh Grand Grand Matthews, who's uh a big co
- 3:53host with my good friend Rendye Dae Cruz on the podcast. They do rest
- 3:57in the podcasts together. He's on the panel. But basically the criterias list
- 4:02of superstars. The Terminile panel used the spawn criteria to compile Discountdown Countdown of
- 4:08iconic competitors of different eras. So they considered the following historical significance. Did
- 4:15they have a meaningful impact on the history of W Championships? Were they among
- 4:18the most decorated in company history? Popularity? However, was a superstar with
- 4:24W fans meal mover? Did they make a meaningful distance difference in ratings,
- 4:29ticket sales and overall business time active? Was a star successful over a sustained
- 4:35period of time or just a flash in the pan? Uh? Paper appearances?
- 4:41Were they fixtures on the biggest shows in W And of course skills,
- 4:45which of course is in ring Mike charisma? Were they more than this arrest
- 4:48or did? Did their skills set stop at the microphone? Were they charismatic?
- 4:54So that was Beach Report's criteria into how they came up with this list
- 4:58of one to fifty. Before we get started, just begin to the list
- 5:01itself. We're gonna we're gonna break it down. DJ. What was the
- 5:05reaction, because you see the list already, What was the reaction with what
- 5:09you saw? Uh? The top ten is and I say this, one
- 5:14of my all time favorites is sitting in right, and we can we can
- 5:17break that down a little bit more. Right, I'm looking at just the
- 5:20top ten by itself, and I've got a lot of questions right now,
- 5:25their list of criteria, their number one doesn't change. Yeah, you know,
- 5:31and like I said, we'll break that down, but I really had
- 5:34some real quick Your mic is cutting out, like I still hear you,
- 5:39but yeah, cut it out. I don't if you notice that that may
- 5:42be me, because yeah, okay, then then it's me. I'll talk.
- 5:46Okay, No, no, it was anything that it goes out,
- 5:47because then again when it goes out, it's still low. But right,
- 5:51all right, uh Rob, what was the first reaction to see the list?
- 5:56Okay, well I was, I mean it it's thanks. I mean
- 6:02it really does. I mean, and starting at the very boy even that
- 6:06at the bottle of the distinct, and I was, I was in the
- 6:10car going home today and I was thinking of names that we're not on the
- 6:15list, and I just got like more and more irritated. Yeah yeah,
- 6:23and I want to know also to the panel, because I didn't. I
- 6:27mean, it's not only I only feel with one writer of the six that
- 6:29voted on this thing or rank this thing, rather the age group of these
- 6:33of these guys, this reeks real. It reachs of like thirty five and
- 6:39under thirty another even Yeah, I definitely want to break this down. I
- 6:45would not want to see that. But okay, so we're gonna do.
- 6:48But we're gonna take this down. We're gonna go into inwards of ten.
- 6:53Well, I'll read offf fifty to forty one backwards and we'll go from there
- 6:56and react to what we like and don't like and what's wrong and so fifty
- 7:02The Big Show forty nine, Lida forty eight, Vader forty seven, Dan
- 7:10Ambrose forty six, AJ Styles forty five, Oscar forty four, KOFE Kingston
- 7:16forty three, Jeff Hardy forty two, Rabbits, Mcrude and forty one Sasha
- 7:24Banks. I think that that to me personally, that the big Stanel here
- 7:29is Vader Vader. Probably she emailed this list at all, No whit as
- 7:35captain he did not at all, not when you go by their criteria,
- 7:39I absolutely agree as the first one that stuck out at me when you're reading
- 7:42off the list. Yeah, because remember we're talking about the WWE career wgw
- 7:46Right exactly. Yeah, mean, because if we're talking we're talking total careers,
- 7:49Invader, Yeah, it could be on it should be on top fifty.
- 7:55Yeah, but no, but his WWE career was not It wasn't very
- 7:59long, and it wasn't very good. No, it was. It was
- 8:01dreadful. And I look at here's some names that are not on this list
- 8:05at all who very clearly had better w W careers than Vader. Okay,
- 8:11Paul Ordorf, Santana, m h, how do you? How do you
- 8:18not have Tito Santana in your top fifty? I agree, two times intercontinental
- 8:24champion and full attime champo to yes and back when being a two time intercontinental
- 8:28champion was something that did not happen. He was with the company for like
- 8:31a decade or more more than Yeah, So no Titos Santana, no Paul.
- 8:37And here's a guy who's whose title reign wasn't particularly good, but his
- 8:41career was better than Vaders, and that's Diesel. Yeah was like you know,
- 8:48his world title ring was nothing to write at home about, but his
- 8:52career he was I mean he won all of the titles. Yeah, he
- 8:56he was champed for almost a year. Vader won titles. Vader barely mainvaited
- 9:03a couple of shows, and some of that wasn't his own fault. Some
- 9:05of that was because Sean didn't want work with him anymore. Yeah, but
- 9:11Diesel was tag jamp Jamp world champion. He main evented some pain per views.
- 9:16He defended the world title at WrestleMania. He fought the Undertaker at WrestleMania.
- 9:22I mean, how I mean, that's better than Vader. Okay,
- 9:26I'm sorry, that is better than Vader's w w REE career. Okay,
- 9:31I mean, come on, now, what are we doing. I agree,
- 9:35I am not the biggest big show fan in the world. I've always
- 9:39said his career so we have a lotdown considering dissertations, but him being this
- 9:43low is pretty egregious. I'm gonna lie, well, yeah, because he
- 9:46he main innovated WrestleMania. He's been world champion a few times, he held
- 9:50every title. He had a long he had a very long run there.
- 9:56He was over like twenty years. Yeah, I mean, I mean,
- 9:58yeah, I'm you know, the maytimes he's been if a joke as a
- 10:03character, right, But I mean, okay, and here's another one who's
- 10:07not on the list, British bulldog Dad Boy Smith. Yeah, Invader.
- 10:11Yeah. Absolutely. I mean he was interc Champion, European Champion, Tag
- 10:16Teams Champion. I mean, I mean that's better than Vader. I mean,
- 10:24I will say one thing about this this first ten here, pretend that
- 10:28they get most of these guys are pretty much okay where they're at. I'm
- 10:31really glad they recognized Rick Rude because Rick Rud is actually where he should be,
- 10:37because had Rick Rud had a longer career in the company, he would
- 10:41have been a lot higher because that character. And we discussed an Unrestling Gretchal
- 10:43podcast quite a few times when we deal on watching lungs and he's involved in
- 10:46these in these matches and the impact he had this those three years between eighty
- 10:50seven and ninety. He wasn't there long, but those those three years he
- 10:54made a mark. Yeah, I think I think I said that on one
- 10:58of our episodes. He did one I think about Rick Rude. I think
- 11:01I feel like his run was a lot longer, but it really was only
- 11:05three years. And that just means he crammed so much good, iconic stuff
- 11:11into a short period of time and that's a credit to him. And you
- 11:13know how they were booking him at the time. Yeah, you know,
- 11:16his view with Warrior, his viewed with Jake, his viewed with I mean
- 11:20with Piper, you know, I mean he had a lot of significant fusing
- 11:24in that company. He really in an era where the mid card really mattered
- 11:28a lot. He was right in the mix of that absolutely, you know,
- 11:31so I thought I got that right. Other than that, no other
- 11:33issues really in this list on this on this first group KOFE forty four whatever,
- 11:37I'm cool with that. Do you think Sasha Banks is a little low,
- 11:43I say, compared when you look at some of the people who are
- 11:45ahead of her, I'd say, yeah, I'm there too. He also
- 11:50made in a few other pay per views. He's a multi time champion.
- 11:56She won every title that there was to win at the time. You know,
- 12:03I feel like you could have placed her above China. I mean we're
- 12:07there definitely. Yeah, China is interesting. We'll get to that. That's
- 12:11the discussion of itself. Go ahead, okay. I mean when look at
- 12:16who's ahead of her, I mean some of the names are head of her,
- 12:20and I'm going to get that in the next ten I think she's definitely
- 12:24had a better career than some of the some of these people who are ahead
- 12:26of her. Yeah, even males. Yeah, I'm talking about males.
- 12:33I'm talking about and especially things also if you want, if you even include
- 12:35her NXT stuff also too, well, yeah, because it's definitely do so
- 12:41youclude that as well too, to work with you the NXT that puts her
- 12:45in on top of her discussion at that point in my opinion, So there's
- 12:48that any of us stand ups to this, this group of ten de Ambros
- 12:54know, everything's fine there. I think he if he'd stuck around longer,
- 13:00we having a different discussion. Yeah. Is he a tough with the guy
- 13:03though? Yes? Oh yeah, okay, okay, he's part of one
- 13:05of the biggest acts in the last twenty years. He was. He held
- 13:11every title, he was working, made event a bunch of paper views.
- 13:13The only thing he didn't do was meeting at WrestleMania. So yeah, I
- 13:18mean he done the top fifty. Yes. The only reason I might make
- 13:22a case of Jeff Harty being a little higher is because he was in one
- 13:24of the best tax teams of all time and he did hold the world title
- 13:28once and had a solid solo career too. Yeah, I'm not saying put
- 13:35him like in the twenties. I'm just saying this to maybe a little bit
- 13:39bump maybe to the low thirties. But got to see the hero right there
- 13:41though. You know what I mean, it is what it is. Everybody
- 13:43else here is fine, honestly. Yeah. So so before this the next
- 13:50ten, you guys, look, go to this one. I think I'm
- 13:52good. Okay, We've got the forty forty through thirty one forty. We
- 13:58got Superstar Billy Graham for you, not Rob Van Dam thirty eight, Owen
- 14:01Hart thirty seven, Mister Perfect thirty six, Batista thirty five, Ultimate Oaryer
- 14:09thirty four, Rickey Dragon, steave Boat thirty three, Booker t thirty two,
- 14:13Jaco Snake, Roberts and thirty one Kine. All right for me with
- 14:18stands out here, and I can't believe in dependent this guy here. I'm
- 14:22on my podcast, considered my history with him, and I can't stand the
- 14:26guy since I was a child. Ultim Warrior is too low. I'm sorry.
- 14:30I get the shit, the dislike and all that, but Ultimo Warrior
- 14:35in an era where it was hard to stand up because of Hogan and he
- 14:37means established in some parts Ltimore, Warrior made a mark He's Alrea one of
- 14:43raised Icy champs all time. Wasn't a great title reign, but that match
- 14:48of Hogan at Mania six was was fantastic and for the character itself, he
- 14:56was for the character what it was supposed to do. He played a perfection.
- 15:01So I get I'm sorry to play penalizing a him because of the shortness
- 15:05of the run. But again, this guy. One reason why I always
- 15:11said that, the reason why he's my number one IC champion all the time
- 15:15is because he's the only guy in my lifetime that made the ICY title actually
- 15:20feel like I was on level of the world title when he when he held
- 15:22it in eighty eight three ninety. So that's why they war was a little
- 15:26bit lower. He's starting should be lower. He should be below of Ricky
- 15:30steam Beat because Ricky stem had a short I had even a shorter run,
- 15:33a shorter rick was way too high. Yeah, and I love it.
- 15:37Is he top fifty. I'll come top fifty, but not not thirty thirty
- 15:39four. So that's yeah, he was He's going there like three years.
- 15:46Yeah, I'm gonna say something rather controversial. Go ahead. I love Ricky
- 15:50the Dragon Steamboat. I don't feel like aside, he gets way too many
- 15:56marks for that one really good match with Randy said, well, yeah,
- 16:00three matches. But I feel like people overinflate his importance in WWE because of
- 16:06that one match. He was only there for three years. He made a
- 16:10much bigger impact in w CW Yes, I did a much bigger player over
- 16:14there. Amazing worker. One of my all time favorites. If you if
- 16:18you had to give me, if you had to ask me my personal list,
- 16:21he makes my top twenty. But in the WWE, as we're as
- 16:26we're discussing this, and with the criteria that they laid out, how is
- 16:29he even on this list? Yeah, and ahead of guys that won the
- 16:33title or did more in the company by virtue of what the list criteria says,
- 16:38you know, to expends this kind of thing like perfect and owen Hart
- 16:41for example, Heart that's ridiculous, Like, well, like you, because
- 16:47I think you know there were times where he was was he and Tito got
- 16:49there around the same time. I mean just kind of comparing the two.
- 16:53I mean Titlesantana did far more than Steamboat. And we're talking about people who
- 17:00were head of Sasha that I think should be watched, should not be.
- 17:03I was mainly looking at Steve Boat. Yeah, and I hate saying that
- 17:07because he's one of my own. Going on the list criteria, this is
- 17:12how did he make the top fifty because I mean the vast bulk of his
- 17:19best work was in the n w A and w c W. It was
- 17:25in the w w F. It was you know, I get his best
- 17:29match in the w w F was that one match with Savage. But I
- 17:33mean you measured that the matches he had Rick Flair and the magic he had
- 17:37with Steve Austin in w c W, and you know, and the matches
- 17:41when he tagged team Wrestler with one of the young Bloods and they were tag
- 17:45team champions a bunch of times in the W. All of that far eclipses
- 17:52either he did w E eclipses that one Wrestle Media three match. Sorry it's
- 17:57a it's an iconic match, but it was one moment in time. I
- 18:00mean, he had three matches in one year with Rick Flair that that stand
- 18:03up to that Wressell Meania match. Okay, And and the worst part is
- 18:08that Savage does would have benefit of that match. Word but yels because you
- 18:11know, Steam on the match Savage's profiles went through the roof at that point.
- 18:15Yep, you know what I'm saying. By the way, a little
- 18:18sidebar with Steamboat, you know about great matches, one low key great match
- 18:22he had actually just gonna talked about obviously because the show got panned the hell,
- 18:27which, by way, I just watched the entire thing for the first
- 18:30time in a bit rest many four. His match with Greg Valentine in the
- 18:33opening round of that tournament got those boys on the work. Yeah, that's
- 18:38Valentine being a good match. Valentine actually had two great matches on that show
- 18:44with him and Savage, but with Steam won and Savage in the second round.
- 18:45Boat Max is really good. Well, I think Steam on Valentine they
- 18:48had history going back to n W as they know, they worked together.
- 18:52Bad chemistry already, Yes, not surprising that they you know, But yeah,
- 18:57Steam Steamer was just way too high. I mean, if you're doing
- 19:00like, if you're doing an n W a top fifty, he'd be way
- 19:03up there. But it's not just I mean, Rob van dam real quick.
- 19:11We want to Rob Robert quick. So was w Graham. This was
- 19:15the Hogan for Hogan. He's hard to see all right. So he's hard
- 19:18to figure because he was worked in for almost a year, but of course
- 19:23that was before pay per views and before WrestleMania and all that stuff. He
- 19:29beat Bruno and Yx said he is. He was basically the model for Polk
- 19:33Hogan in terms of look and all that. But his I mean his WWE
- 19:45career, I don't know how long he was there, but the good stuff
- 19:49pretty much all happened within that one year. He was champed a lot of
- 19:53his And this is where the list kind of gets a little muddy because some
- 19:57of the superstars rear overlaps with Vince Senior still owning and running the company.
- 20:03Yeah. Correct, So are we are we judging WWE from its roots or
- 20:10from the Vince McMahon WrestleMania era. Ford obviously with names like Superstar and Bruno
- 20:15San Martino on this list where we're fluffing the we're fluffing the list a little
- 20:19bit to go to pass uncertain guys. Yeah. And now since we're talking,
- 20:25there's another name that is not here, should be there, Yeah,
- 20:30Petry Morales. He was. He was world champion three years yeah, and
- 20:33he was inter Continental champion. He was he was the first Grand Slam champion.
- 20:37He was the inaugural intercontinental champion, wasn't he? He might have been,
- 20:41but he was. He was. He was the first Patterson I'm sorry
- 20:45again, Okay, okay, Patty Patterson was the inaugural Yeah, he was
- 20:49the first guy to win all the all the w WS titles. He was
- 20:53the first greens lamb champion. While we're talking intercontinental champion, how the hell
- 20:57is Honkey talk man not on here? Ye? And that's tough that hell
- 21:03is Honky talking? Let me, let me, let me I'll defend that
- 21:07part because while I agree Honky is arguing one of the greatest is arguing one
- 21:12of the greatest ice champions on the history of the company. In our good
- 21:17friend Duke Bennett say hes number one all the time because of what he did
- 21:19in that one rain. That's all he has is that one year. That's
- 21:23true. Once it was over, that's the problem. Once he once,
- 21:26once Warri beat him in SummerSlam, he fell off like a He fell off
- 21:30quick. So that's why it gets harder to put him in the list,
- 21:37you know it. It would be the same way with Steamboat trying to squeez
- 21:40him in the same way with Steamboat I think we could have booted Vader off
- 21:44this list and shoehorned about a half a dozen other guys. If you're saying
- 21:48Vader a honkey, give me honky all day long, right, yes,
- 21:51you know what I mean. And and to not have Peedro Morales on here
- 21:55at all, I mean, that's ridiculous. That it's just that is just
- 22:00yeah, it's ridiculous. I mean, come on then, all right,
- 22:03you Bendad. What's that? Okay? Well, because I mean he had
- 22:07a very brief run his world champion. Yeah, he was just I mean
- 22:17comparing him to like like Sast has far more accolades than him. Yeah,
- 22:22he's too high. He's too high. I'm not saying he shouldn't be on
- 22:26here at all, but he's too high. I mean, mister perfect,
- 22:32I mean people love. I mean he was actually obviously a great bean ring
- 22:36worker and the gimmick was great. He didn't win, which he didn't win
- 22:42a whole lot of stuff though he was hit a couple of short icy title
- 22:48reigns he had done being the streak to going to restate his six. Other
- 22:52than that, I think I think he's actually placed well here. I think
- 22:56it's high, too long I think no. I think in the thirties middle
- 23:02If anything, Owen Hart is way too low. Al not way too Owen's
- 23:08a difficult discussion as well because the way his life in his career ended.
- 23:15If you're sweeping the tragedy off the table for a minute, Owen was what
- 23:21was he? I didn't think he was intercontinental champion? Was he? He
- 23:23was? Okay, he was intercontinental. He was a tag champ I know
- 23:26for sure with Yokozuna and Bulldog and Bulldog. He was a regular on a
- 23:34lot of the going over there criteria. In my head, he was on
- 23:40a you know, if he was healthy, he was on the show.
- 23:45So he did a lot of pay per view events. My question would be
- 23:48is how you know they use the term over how over really was Owen Hart?
- 23:56It's hard because that the era, the era was raw. It's raw.
- 24:02Yeah, misused, dude. I just watched to watch along with last
- 24:06night with the his match of brett Amania ten. It's on the top ten
- 24:10discussion of best matches the history of the history of the Wrestmania's. Hey,
- 24:14quick question for you guys. I'll kick this to you first. J Okay
- 24:18Owen Hart, good hel or terrible heel because in my opinion, he was
- 24:22a terrible heel. Really, I didn't like Owen as a heel. I
- 24:26never believed him as a heel. I did. I would much rather see
- 24:30a babyface run from him. I thought it was a good heel actually,
- 24:33I mean, only he was baby face. Blazer was a babyface character.
- 24:36Yeah, so totally was it wasn't. It wasn't Owen heart. No,
- 24:38I thought it's a good heel because he was. He was annoying, little
- 24:41snarly, you know, you know, he maybe Brent. Maybe he did
- 24:47his job in a bread in a Brett feud. He did his job in
- 24:49the Brett feud. It worked. But everything else I looked at Owen like,
- 24:52this guy's a baby face. He's not a heel. Hmm, interesting,
- 24:56Rob. It was a good heel, but it's just to me,
- 25:00I never saw him as world champion material the way a lot of people did
- 25:06so for me, like, I mean, because when I see people saying,
- 25:10well, one should have been a world champion, I'm just kind of
- 25:11like really chambly still. I just just I mean, looking at who else
- 25:19was I mean, I just I you know, I look at the field,
- 25:25at the time and Owen Heart falls down the ladder real quick. I
- 25:27mean, well he could have been. He could have taken back on his
- 25:30place when he beat Bretton lost the Diesel two days later. I mean,
- 25:33okay, I mean, but I mean that's about it as far as I
- 25:37can see it going, you know, I just I mean because in term
- 25:45of just cure stature, I mean Brett had him beat there Sean had him
- 25:49beat their diesel, had him beat there the undertaker head. I mean,
- 25:55if you, if you're a booker, you pick any of those guys be
- 25:57world champion before Owen? Oh yeah. And if Vader had panned out right,
- 26:03you would you picked him before Owen. Yeah. So I mean we're
- 26:07talking five or six guys there already, and I mean I don't I think
- 26:17I think he was great at what he did, and I think he was
- 26:22about as far as the spot in the car, I think he was about
- 26:25where he hit right. What we do, what we'll go individually. We'll
- 26:29do the ten reveal ten and we'll go into each restler and see how we
- 26:32feel about it a wrestler. So we did. We did perfectly own Heart
- 26:34thirty six Batista, Oh is he too low? I don't. Well,
- 26:41that's not that's not my error. Really, I checked out when he when
- 26:44he well, because his al right, he his continuous run was about seven
- 26:52or eight years. He was injured a lot. He was world champion a
- 26:57couple of times, and Wrestledmania a couple of times. A few times you
- 27:03did that well, like he beat Triple h and one of them, and
- 27:07then like at thirty against Daniel Bryant, he was in there with Okay,
- 27:12okay, okay, but I think I mean, he's alright thirty, he's
- 27:23thirty six. I asked you lean that he's in the right spot. I
- 27:29lean that, But again I'm coming from an Ingram point of view, though
- 27:32I'm gonnadmit that because I missed most of his run. Also, but if
- 27:36you're asked, but like he's another guy who asked me who had a better
- 27:38career him on Sasha Banks? I think Banks did interesting? Okay? Then
- 27:45yeah, I mean because again he was injured a lot and he missed it
- 27:49and he was not a great innery worker at all. I mean, if
- 27:57he had a good dance part, Batista looks better in the ring than right
- 28:03then he gave then he gave credit for yeah, but it's but like on
- 28:07his own he was. I mean he wasn't like okay, I mean he
- 28:11wasn't he was better than like people say Goldbergs or whatever. He wasn't.
- 28:15I mean, but he was limited. He wasn't dangerous, he wouldn't injured
- 28:19in people or whatever. But I mean he was. But like I said,
- 28:22he had the right opponent, then yeah, you could have you could
- 28:26have, you know, you could get something that was good out of him.
- 28:27But if you ask me who had a had a better career overall,
- 28:33I mean yeah, I mean, you know, I mean there are people
- 28:38I wouldn't say, Hey, you know, I think I mean the grand
- 28:42scheme of things. I mean, Kobe didn't made event WrestleMania, but in
- 28:45terms of everything else, yeah, I mean i'd say he had a better
- 28:48career than Patista, if nothing else longevity, Yeah, you know, i'd
- 28:55say, you know, same thing I said, as you know, Oscar
- 29:00didn't mean it WrestleMania, but in terms of everything else that means you know,
- 29:07so I know he touched a Warrior, but did you have a reaction
- 29:11to Warrior A thirty five DJ? I remember asking you if you had.
- 29:15I think that's probably about right, and only because again longevity. The guy
- 29:21could never sustain any time in the company to really build that legacy. I
- 29:26mean, yeah, the character is iconic and during those moments in time he
- 29:33was super super popular. But one of the criteria on their lists, and
- 29:37again I'm gonna get a little controversial here, is were they a flash in
- 29:41the pan? Ultimate Warrior had one World Heavyweight Championship run, he had one
- 29:47fairly brief Intercontinental Championship run, and then he was gone. You know,
- 29:53I think if he had had more championships run, championship runs and a longer
- 29:59tenure at the company, you know, maybe a little higher. But yeah,
- 30:04that's where I'm at with that. And I'd say that as an Ultimate
- 30:07Warrior fan. You know, I defended the guy on multiple podcasts on multiple
- 30:11occasions. M hm, well, you're Robbie. The Warriors find thirty five
- 30:15who should be higher? Lower? We think pro I think he's probably about
- 30:22right. There are people, there's some people below him. I probably I
- 30:25might put over him, but then there probably some people ahead of him that
- 30:29I would put behind him. So like, I mean, I couldn't every
- 30:33steamboat just like you said, I mean, right, I mean, he
- 30:37I mean he had longer runs with titles than the Steamboat did. He didn't
- 30:41wrestle Maia, only that he actually had two, you know, for a
- 30:45guy that that wasn't considered a big worker, he has two back to back
- 30:48Mania matches that were classics. Yeah, Hogan and then Savagely at seven.
- 30:55So I mean he's probably about right. Yeah, I say, yeah,
- 30:59probably about right. I mean, get their people behind him, I'd put
- 31:02ahead of him, and there're people ahead of him, and I put behind
- 31:03him. He's probably right all right. So he did steave Boat already thirty
- 31:08three, Booker T. That sounds low. He feels a little a little
- 31:15low though, because I feel like his his career w when once he got
- 31:18there. He's probably one of the only guys that came WW that really took
- 31:22off immediately when he made landing. He's one of the few guys that Vince
- 31:26didn't really change anything with, right, Like usually Vince brings people over from
- 31:30w CW or from some somewhere else. He had to put his thumbprint on
- 31:34it, like we've got to change something about you so that it's mine.
- 31:37And Booker T he pretty much brought him over, and you know, put
- 31:42on TV what he paid for. Yeah, And I guess I'm trying to
- 31:47look and see how long he was there because that's where it's. So he
- 31:51got there one, right one, and it was there for a good at
- 31:55least got six seven years, right seven, at least eight he all right,
- 32:00So yeah, he got there one when after w one because he's one
- 32:06of the few guys didn't have one of those big contracts with the Warner Yeah
- 32:09home, So it's he left in two thousand and seven, so he was
- 32:20six years. That's that's still pretty good. But it was a consistent six
- 32:22years day and it was an impactful six years because i mean he won,
- 32:27you know, a couple of world championships. He had a hell of a
- 32:29run as king booker. Yeah. Yeah, I mean he was over as
- 32:31a character, and that's one of their criteria. Yeah yeah, I mean
- 32:37beginning five six years as as a top as a semi top guy. That's
- 32:40that's you're you're doing doing a good job, opinion. And it is not
- 32:44like his start in his career. He's like he ended his career, not
- 32:46just like w A wrestling in general. Yeah, you know, uh three
- 32:51two, Jake Roberts, I'll say, as a Jake, as a Jake
- 32:53Mark, I love, he's gonna gona respect her because he's probably he might
- 32:58be the only guy in the top three two that didn't well, Andre made
- 33:04all the one I guess, but didn't have been the title. Well I
- 33:07think if you ask me, he very well might be the best WW wrestler
- 33:13to never win any title outside Andre. Well, Andre was he was tach
- 33:17champions. Oh yeah, it class collection. I forgot that. I mean
- 33:22yeah, so i'd say, because Jake didn't win any titles, Jake rarely
- 33:27got any title matches. Okay, yeah, so it's for w W wrestlers
- 33:32who never basically sniffed a championship. I mean he I think he's probably the
- 33:38best one. I mean because everyone els you can think I had at least
- 33:42one somewhere. So yeah, he's probably the best WW wrestler to never win
- 33:47a championship of any kind. He's actually in I think looking at because we
- 33:52had such a talent in Flux last, like you know, generation for you
- 33:58two, that's not that bad. Actually yeah, and when you can said
- 34:01it again, he won no championships, so I mean you do have to
- 34:06consider that. So's I'd say he's the best ww wrestler to never win any
- 34:10championships. DJ, you have anything on Jake, I would argue you could
- 34:15probably put them a little bit higher because he does check off most of the
- 34:19boxes. I'm looking at the criteria, you know, historical significance. Obviously,
- 34:23thirty years later, we're still talking Jake to Snake Roberts and his influence
- 34:28on the industry, being not only a great in ring worker in terms of
- 34:30psychology, but in cutting promos. You know, that's still a learning tree.
- 34:37Kids should be sitting under. Popularity. He was easily at one point
- 34:39a top three babyface character in the easily easily. He was there a needle
- 34:45mover. You bet your ass. If Jake the Snake was on the card,
- 34:49he was selling tickets, he was mervid merchandise. You know, these
- 34:52things are all important pay per view appearances. Again, if Jake was healthy,
- 34:54Jake was on the show, you know. So yeah, I mean
- 34:59he he checks off five of the seven criteria. You know, so him
- 35:05putting him at thirty two may actually be a little bit low if you're going
- 35:07on there, you know, he loses points for never winning a championship and
- 35:10probably a couple other little things, But yeah, I would probably put him
- 35:15higher than thirty two. Okay, And I mean, you know, and
- 35:19according to him, you know, from what he's you know, basically canceled
- 35:23the few with him and Hogan because they were, yeah, we're gonna get
- 35:29the right reaction. Yeah, there you go. I believe that put a
- 35:32record that's oh yeah, because people love Jake back in eighty six. Man,
- 35:36you couldn't. Oh yeah, I think people don't. People who are
- 35:40younger than us don't understand how over that guy was. Yeah, and absolutely
- 35:49exactly. And I mean they had to turn a baby face because I mean
- 35:53it's you know, the same with Savage, same as Savage. They had
- 35:55to turn the baby face because they were just the reaction to crowd the boom.
- 36:00Man. You know, they're both them too cool to keep going and
- 36:05too cool, too good and what they did. Yeah, yeah, you
- 36:07know, uh, thirty one Caine, this feels low because alone, Kane
- 36:14doesn't get Kane doesn't get the credit he deserves, I think from a lot
- 36:17of people, because you know, Kane basically, just like the Undertaker,
- 36:25Kine is a gimmick. This should that have worked? Yeah, absolutely that
- 36:30that gimmick absolutely should not have worked that GIMMI should or it should have been
- 36:32a short term thing at best. You know, he should have done the
- 36:37feud with the Undertaker, and that should have been the end of it.
- 36:38You know, he took what twenty almost twenty years out of that thing,
- 36:40twenty years almost, yeah, out of that character because he came in and
- 36:45he did he minted at the end of ninety seven. He didn't actually he
- 36:50didn't atually wrestle on ninety eight and he didn't, actually he didn't. It
- 36:55was his last match. His last match was a sixteen seventeen, yeah,
- 37:02a little earlier or maybe eighteen. Yeah. So yeah, and so that's
- 37:08what we're talking. That's twenty years. And then I look at it and
- 37:12to like Dday's point here, like you look at the criteria, he hits
- 37:15all the boxes here. Historal significance, arguably the greatest debut history of w
- 37:20arguably, yeah, because we're still saying now that's got to be king.
- 37:22Yeah, the championships, he's won titles, he won world say, won
- 37:25the title. On popularity. He certainly when he was in a baby face,
- 37:30he was definitely you know, definitely over. And then when he's a
- 37:32heel he deb had heat uh w neilill mover again the debut, you know,
- 37:37and then changing the gimmick over and keeping it fresh. I mean time
- 37:39active obviously. I mean that he has that in spades. Yeah, people
- 37:43her parents definitely has that now in skills, I mean skills. I mean
- 37:45it wasn't the greatest, like worker, but you know he he played the
- 37:51character well like warrior so to me. To me, he was a little
- 37:53long. I'm not saying put him in top fifteen to twenty, but you
- 37:57know, thirty one, thirty one low. I think you hired in thirty
- 38:01one. Yeah, yeah, dj yalton K. I agree with you,
- 38:06guys. I mean I'm actually I'm we're going to get into the thirty thirty
- 38:08through what twenty one here in a minute. He could definitely I have an
- 38:13argument that I could make that he could be above the guy that's right above
- 38:15him. Oh, I agree. We'll get there now, because here you
- 38:19go thirty to twenty one thirty we got mister Scott Hall twenty nine, Tristratus
- 38:27twenty eight, China twenty seven, Charlotte Flair That's Robin's Girl of course twenty
- 38:31six, Seth Rollins twenty five, Edge twenty four, Rick Flair twenty three,
- 38:37Becky Lynch twenty two, Daniel Bryant in twenty one chiple h All right,
- 38:42we to thirty first Razor Ramone, Uh DJ, what you gotta say?
- 38:45He should have been below Kane and I love Razor Ramone like his time
- 38:50period where he was Icy Champ is one of my favorite heiress of the intercontinental
- 38:53Champion. I loved him as Icy Champion. But again, if we're talking
- 38:57about all the other criteria, he checks all of the multi time champion with
- 39:00the Intercontinental Championship, he was over like a million bucks both as he had
- 39:06heat is a heel, and he had everything going for him as a baby
- 39:08face. So he checks those off. He loses points because he never had
- 39:12a world championship. His longevity wasn't there. He ended up going back to
- 39:15going to WCW, you know, with the nWo gimmicks, So he loses
- 39:20a couple of points there. For me, it's you know and I don't.
- 39:23But he also has historical significance because again, how many of us are
- 39:30still doing that walk, how many of us are still flipping toothpicks at people?
- 39:34I mean, it's there's there's a cultural significance there with him in terms
- 39:38of you know, wrestling, wrestling history, and you can argue he has
- 39:44about russmore arguably about rushmore MENIU match with a lot of matches against Saw Michaels
- 39:50and it had a Rus wore SummerSlam match of match a year after that in
- 39:52SummerSlam ninety five and in my opinion a top five finisher, the Razor's Edge
- 39:57has been one of my top five finishes. Oh yeah, absolutely love the
- 40:00racers love it. And it's about Owen Hart being like, did you get
- 40:06a world to push? This guy should have got a world tip push.
- 40:08Yes. I scratched my head to this day. How he never got a
- 40:14main event world championship push. I guess because he probably because he left those
- 40:19because if he's stuck around longer, I think he would have. Do you
- 40:22think so? Well? Because Sid got the world title. So Sid got
- 40:28the world title twice after he left. But I think a lot of that,
- 40:30it's been a lot been. Vince was still in that whole era of
- 40:35I need my world champion to be this big, bulky, strong guy like
- 40:38the Hogans and the right there he was that he was not. He was
- 40:47all of that, and he can work circles around Sid and he can cut.
- 40:52So I think if he's stuck around, I mean, like I said,
- 40:54Sid won the world title twice after he left, after left, that's
- 40:59a fair point. I think you could have easily plugged him in for Sid
- 41:02in that same spot if he stuck around. I mean, I think they
- 41:08might have made more money in that time period if they don't. But but
- 41:12they you know, and but you know that that goes against him. He
- 41:19never he didn't quite get to the main event, you know, so he
- 41:23was always in you know, the mid card or whatever. You so that
- 41:29that kind of works against him. Yeah, but I would probably put Kane
- 41:31ahead of him because Kane had you know, Kane did all the things Razor
- 41:36didn't accomplish. Kane did accomplish. Right, definitely, all right, twenty
- 41:40status. I think she's too low. I agree she I mean, I
- 41:45know, people, she is still at her peak. She is still the
- 41:51most popular regular woman wrestler by far at her peak. People people do not
- 41:55understand how mainstream popular she was at her peak. It is more than in
- 42:01any any woman who not counting Rohnda, because Ronda was already had an outside
- 42:08thing when she came in. But as far as like women who got popular
- 42:13within any world of professional Wrestlingue Trish got more popular than any woman ever since
- 42:21she came in. People do not Again she was in mainstream magazine back twenty
- 42:27some years ago. She became what they wanted canby Sich to be without all
- 42:32the problems. Yeah, and so people don't and so people like and her
- 42:37and Leader main Limited Monday Night Raw twenty two years ago, back when that
- 42:43was not a thing that happened. It was a banger too, had awesome
- 42:46chemistry, Yeah, and so and they did that back when that when again,
- 42:51when when that was not a thing that happened, you know. Ever,
- 42:57so I think she should be higher. Honestly, I think she gonna
- 43:00be the highest woman on the list. So I won't say that he's she's
- 43:04too high, too low, but she should she should should be a lot
- 43:07higher than the next person to list. China twenty eight. Now, to
- 43:10me, China look kinda stump in the ring to me, to listen at
- 43:15all twice is kept well just I mean, at one point she was really
- 43:17super popular and she was really over. But other than that, she looks
- 43:22she I'm going, Look, okay, I mean Ron, that's one Cartier
- 43:25that was the five. Well, she she stuck. She stunk as a
- 43:28wrestler. She's stump. The only reason like when she looked good is because
- 43:32she was in there with like Jazz Jeff Jarrett and yeah, because she's remember
- 43:38she's a former intercontinental champion, right and she has one there's one mark done.
- 43:43I guess there go. Look, I don't think she she didn't have
- 43:45one good match with a woman wrestler. I don't think No, this was
- 43:49a squash match. She had a squash match with Ivory that you know wasn't
- 43:52bad, but that was all Ivory working. But and if look, if
- 43:55you had as good as workers Ivory was, if you had to book a
- 43:59squash match against that means that the person beating her wasn't very good. Yeah,
- 44:04if you couldn't book a regular match with her and Ivory back then,
- 44:07then that tells you that she wasn't very good. So she stunk as any
- 44:10wing worker. She was over as a character and as part of d X
- 44:15and all of that. But but that's it. Yeah, I mean again,
- 44:19Trish, come on now, no again, I think Trich should be
- 44:24the highest rank wherever she would fall, Trisha should still be the highest rank
- 44:30woman. Possibly possibly you say that, but in twenty seven is your girl
- 44:34tean flair Trish? And yes, and well we gotta keep it real here
- 44:43man, tri Trish Again, Trish is by far the most mainstream popular woman
- 44:49who was an actual wrestler in the history of that company. Okay, and
- 44:54she won the championship, this existed. Then several times she innimited raw back
- 45:00when that did not happen, and not to mention, I mean her if
- 45:07this if and within the last five years she had to you know, she
- 45:13has a banger singles back to Someone's slaying with Charlotte and a banger match with
- 45:16Becky payback last year. So she came back almost fifty years old over the
- 45:23last two years, at the last five years. And can you argue this
- 45:27feels a little low though for Charlotte, I think, okay, I think
- 45:30she should be higher than rick because, oh my question, I argue this
- 45:36list. I argue that I mean, well, maybe lower, I mean
- 45:38definitely lower. But again, well, Rick is the same thing with Ricky
- 45:42stein Boat the boat their work was elsewhere, outside else in the second definitely,
- 45:51But like with Charlotte. I think Charlope was at low because O the
- 45:53long jety things is in play now, titles in play over what else I'm
- 46:00missing a lot of criterist She's as all these boxes that they have this criteria
- 46:05time at pay your Appearances Neil Moover, Yeah, all he's me and Petty
- 46:14right now. One thing I want to say about Trish to kind of piggyback
- 46:17on what Rob was saying. Trish became the template twenty years ago for the
- 46:22modern WWE female superstar because she was out there having really good wrestling matches and
- 46:30she was trying to break past that women are here for sex appeal stereotype.
- 46:36And obviously she was very much the sex appeal was there, but she was
- 46:39also excellent in the rent and what started off as a you are just here
- 46:45because you are a smoke show turned into a woman who revolutionized at least WWE's
- 46:52interpretation of women's wrestling, and really was with that main event with her and
- 46:57Lita on Raw showed us what women could do and what WWE could have done
- 47:04with their women instead of parading them out and putting in jello matches. And
- 47:08so she's the template for what we're now getting from the current women's division.
- 47:15So yeah, I agree with Rob. She should be the highest rated woman
- 47:19on this list for cultural significance, you know, because her as a wrestler
- 47:23changed the women's culture. It just took them twenty years to catch up to
- 47:27it. I will confess, though, but what Rob, Gwen, she
- 47:30turned herself into a good wrestler at the time where they weren't really trying to
- 47:34turn them into wrestlers. That's all of that a good point. That's a
- 47:37good point. And I will confess though. Tricia's peak, which when he's
- 47:40not taking her series of the wrestler is when I checked out, Like I
- 47:43know who she was even you know as the era of the whole nine.
- 47:45But she was more about the smoke show than about the actual in ring in
- 47:49ring products. Well that's why they hired her, but she wanted more,
- 47:52right and when when it's not taking the seriusces when I checked out anyway,
- 47:55and I would say, in hindsight, I see the impact and mind says
- 48:00she's lower not all things that she's been hiring China much more influential on the
- 48:07women's and that's you know, again not a knock to China's significant. She
- 48:12paid some ways. She she definitely blazed some trails for what she was trying
- 48:15to do. But for me, Trish will always be more culturally significant in
- 48:20the in the history of wrestling. Right. So twenty sis got Seth ronalds
- 48:22Now, if business was done two years ago, I would have I would
- 48:25have seen their point. Not No, this is way too low. Sorry,
- 48:32I gotta agree with you. Seth Robbins is the top twenty for me.
- 48:37And I mean looking at some of the people ahead of him, there's
- 48:39one name that's in the next room. Yeah, well the ext there a
- 48:45few people that we're going to get too weird that are Yeah. I think
- 48:49he is definitely better careers than those people. Yeah. So yeah, I
- 48:55don't know exactly where. I probably he's really tough for me. Yeah,
- 49:00I mean, he get better comage than lot of these people were hit.
- 49:04I agree twenty five edge that feels a little low to also, not not
- 49:07not just not not egregious, but a little low if you include his work
- 49:12with Christian also with the ZAC team, and what he did also in the
- 49:15mid two thousands after you know, the transition. To answer to the question,
- 49:19he's one of the top guys. The radars started a whole nine.
- 49:22He feels a little low. I've been putting in twenty is putting like least
- 49:23twenty one, twenty two, but not twenty five. And I'll give him
- 49:28credit for also, I mean those last three years when he came back,
- 49:32yeah again, after spinal feuding surgery that almost fifty years old, he came
- 49:37back. He may be across the name. Yeah, he had a second
- 49:40Hall of Fame career in w W. He really did. Yeah, yeah,
- 49:47twenty four Rick Flair fucking agreed, fucking egregious. Yeah, I mean
- 49:52again, it's recent. I mean, like, I don't know where that
- 49:58because, I mean it's funny. I mean, Rick has gotten more culturally
- 50:02popular and culturally relevant over the last ten years and anytime he was wrestling.
- 50:08But yeah, I mean his and I think I think that's what that is.
- 50:13I think people are looking at how he came this kind of kind of
- 50:15almost pop culture figure past ten years or so, and not the fact.
- 50:21I mean again, his his best career work was in the n W a
- 50:29by far. Yeah, and look and now, And I mean it's not
- 50:36w W was bad. It's not that he wasn't bad, but it's just
- 50:43you know, I mean his again, I mean, his best word was
- 50:46outside. It's outshined by anything he did outside of w W A Yeah,
- 50:52and so I mean, hell, the guy was on this on the side
- 50:54of forty when he really made the full full time transition. Hell was on
- 50:59the other side of fifty when he became part of evolution. Yeah. And
- 51:05I mean as far as his I mean his w Yeah, I mean,
- 51:09and honestly, you could say his best moment during his w W career was
- 51:14the last one where Sean retired him. Yeah, ninety two I mean regards
- 51:22rumble of all time is regarded. Yeah, I mean, I guess we'll
- 51:25see, because when that happened, I was still pissed because he won the
- 51:29end of you anyone. I would say, if we're talking cultural significance,
- 51:36more people parody, I love you, I'm sorry than parody with a tear
- 51:42in my eye now, because yeah, when you think about wrestling fans and
- 51:47popularity and what we remember his moments, they remember that more than they remember
- 51:52the ninety two rumble. Yeah. Probably, yeah, maybe maybe maybe today,
- 51:58I guess. But my point, I think my largest point two also
- 52:00is this, It's like aside from the Rumbo ninety two. I'll give you
- 52:06Mania eight with Savage and then Evolution, and then that moment was with Shawn
- 52:10Michaels. What does he have in WU that even Worlds you think, you
- 52:14know, considers great work. The only other thing he did was a very
- 52:17brief run as World Tag Team Champions with Roddy Piper. That is it.
- 52:22That's it. And then I'll say the match you had with the Undertaker,
- 52:25it maybe eighteen was very underrating. Okay, okay, but still that's not
- 52:31not but not twenty four Cood, No, you cannot be twenty four burn
- 52:35Edge, No, you're not not very not bearing said Realms. Not better
- 52:37than Charlotte, not very not Betim trash Razor not very most people. Yeah,
- 52:45yeah, you put him on the list if he's if he landed in
- 52:49the forties somewhere, I wouldn't I wouldn't complain. But yeah, it's twenty
- 52:55four, right, all right? Twenty three beck you Lynch. I'm gonna
- 53:00be honest with you. This was a little high. Oh Rob, you
- 53:07want to tell us about the Orchard lady. I think it's all right.
- 53:13I mean they're again, there are people behind her. I might put ahead
- 53:15of her. There are people definitely put behind her, such as Charlotte,
- 53:20such as Edge, such as Seth, such as Trish. I would say
- 53:25there's a period of time where she was out shining her husband over overall popularity
- 53:31and importance to the company. And I think that's been waged in this conversation
- 53:35because in twenty nineteen when I came back to watching wrestling, she was that
- 53:39year the biggest star in the company. Yes, male or female. So
- 53:45that's the way that, Yeah, that's the way end. Yeah, but
- 53:52it feels Ulti Warriors though, But rob it feels the Ultimate Warriors too.
- 53:54Though, is that she's not that she's flamed out though, she's still pretty
- 53:58good, but she's nowhere close to when she was in significance five years ago.
- 54:04In the last two three years, that's because Tarner has focused solely on
- 54:08Ria Ripley. Like real Ripley is his creation. Yeah, Like yeah,
- 54:14basically Rea Ripley. I'm gonna say, really he hoped China would have become
- 54:19right, Really, that's what that's what she is. You make an argument
- 54:24put her even I mean, I'll put her in the forties if she was
- 54:28on those but I mean I would who Betty nothing about really number fifty.
- 54:35If she was like number fifty, I wouldn't know anybody over if it put
- 54:38Ria and on Alyssa Pithy didn't then be that here too, also bankers.
- 54:44I would love to see this list revisited in about ten years when Ria and
- 54:49Bianca have you know, cemented their legacies. But let me say we're gonna
- 54:53be having a very very different discussion. Well, they're they're both better in
- 54:58Vader right now? Yeah, yeah, I look, we can go through
- 55:04this list. I mean they both, I mean they got better careers in
- 55:07Vader. They both got better careers than really steamboat. This is true if
- 55:13you look at it. I mean, there are a lot of people on
- 55:15this list. They both. There's some people on those listen that they already
- 55:17got better careers that I wonder if like they were they the panel is a
- 55:22fan of his music. Is the music which I love? By the way,
- 55:24Is that why he's on the list? Maybe so Vader is one of
- 55:34the but Vader's I guess, well, I think was suandered. Yeah,
- 55:42we're picking on Vader on this podcast. I love it. I love Beata
- 55:44for the records that was a big Vader fan. His w W run pisses
- 55:50me off more than just about anybody that Vince from w c W in that
- 55:54time period, Like, how do you up? How do you shrew up
- 55:58Vader? I mean, look, Vader should have I mean he's like central
- 56:02casting for face mcmon heel after. I mean, after having worked all three
- 56:07in King Kong, Bundy and all those guys, you couldn't have You couldn't
- 56:09have figured out Vader. Again, it's someone that the Shawn because Sean was
- 56:14in a jerk and also later not take dot Duck doing as good works as
- 56:19he didn't. Yeah, but but I'm going by but I keep going,
- 56:24oh yeah twenty two Daniel Ryan, Oh okay, that's one of those that
- 56:30you had to be there to understand it. I got to be there,
- 56:31if you, like I wasn't watching, I got to yes, one like
- 56:36I was kind of I got a little bit of it being on Twitter all
- 56:37the time but not watching West. Yeah, twenty fourteen, So I get
- 56:39the significance of that. Wint smel thirty. I think it's fine in twenty
- 56:45two. I don't problem with that. Yeah, I think ultimately that's probably
- 56:50about right. Yeah, great worker. Yeah, consistently on TV. He
- 56:57was a needle mover. I mean, if you're looking at the criteria,
- 57:00yeah, he's a multi time champion, he main evented a couple of Russell
- 57:05Manias, and he was probably one of the best pure in ring workers in
- 57:12the last twenty years. Oh question, So yeah, he checks off all
- 57:15the boxes. No, I guess no, no, you know now,
- 57:20of course to the work rate Nerd, the work rate Nerd that his best
- 57:23work was outside of the I know, but but down side that sells short.
- 57:30Yeah, yeah, what do you do? Everything everything he did is
- 57:34really damn good. So all right, this one, to me's egregious twenty
- 57:37one tripleation way too fucking low when you when you look at the people,
- 57:44some of these people who are ahead of them. Yes, he's arguably top
- 57:49ten. He's argably a top ten guy. And not saying he is he's
- 57:52arguable. There's the conversation we had about that. But yeah, and there
- 57:55are people ahead of him who absolutely should not be ahead of it. That
- 58:00that that is agreed. I mean, tuples out every box here. Historical
- 58:04significance, yes, championships, yes, popularity, He was you know,
- 58:09mostly a heel, but he was way way over heel, Neil Moover,
- 58:15Yes, time active obviously, Yes, paper review pearances, he was consistent,
- 58:20Yeah, he was healthy, he was on TV, was on yeah,
- 58:22and then entering Charisma Michael whole night, he has all that. What
- 58:27are we doing here? Oh no, man, there's a lot. There's
- 58:31a few of these entrances that are on here because I really like that guy,
- 58:36or they're really low because I don't like that, and there's a bit
- 58:38a bias going on getting there. There's one particular I'm we're gonna talk about
- 58:42in a second. So no twenty one because all great's agreed to's right,
- 58:46twenty one too low, it is? Yeah, all right, let's go
- 58:50from eleven to twenty backwards. I've twenty you'll see him Punk nineteen, Ran
- 58:54New Orton eighteen eighty, Guerrero seventeen, Rock Lessner sixteen, Chris Jericho fifteen
- 59:01mc foley fourteen, Andre the Giant thirteen, Roman Reigns, Wow, twelve,
- 59:08raymis Stereo and eleven Kurt Angle. All right, Oh, this is
- 59:14this is where it goes bad, bad bad. It was before it gets
- 59:19really bad here. Ok, we'll really get the ships here, all right.
- 59:22So number twenty see him punk. Okay, I think twenty is fine,
- 59:28but there are people behind him who should be agreed. The case we
- 59:34made him can be lord to be higher is put that way. Yeah,
- 59:37I think Tripple should be ahead of him. I mean because he came in
- 59:44like was it like six six? I mean, if we're looking at a
- 59:49career, I mean, right now, I'll put suth rounds at hell.
- 59:52Yeah. Now, now, I'd say his tick popular clarity is probably higher
- 1:00:00than seth rollins peak popularity, and he very well might be at his peak
- 1:00:06popularity right now. Pump, No, I'll give eleven and twelve ten eleven
- 1:00:09twelve is his peak? For me? This basic it's I mean, okay,
- 1:00:15I mean it's but right now, it's still it's still it's crazy right
- 1:00:22now. I love them. I guess maybe maybe it's maybe it's a matter
- 1:00:24of how popularity he is right now versus maybe what we expected right right,
- 1:00:31you know, when he came back. But I think twenty twenty think there
- 1:00:37are people again, there are people who should be ahead of him and behind
- 1:00:39them. Yeah, I agree, Yeah, twenty to twenty five is about
- 1:00:45right, right. I think I think the case we made that is the
- 1:00:46case we made from me Lord and higher with that way. DJO for Chicago,
- 1:00:52absolutely agree. I think no lower than twenty five, but definitely not
- 1:00:55in the top twenty, right right, I mean the pipe bomb. We
- 1:01:00can't understate the these As much as I have my own thoughts about the pipe
- 1:01:04bomb, we can't understate it's again cultural and historical significance to the industry.
- 1:01:09It really got the WWE looking at a different type of wrestler, or at
- 1:01:15least open to looking at a different type of wrestler. And he really kicked
- 1:01:21that door open. So I mean, he gets points for that. He
- 1:01:22loses points for longevity because he left. He gains points because he obviously was
- 1:01:29the most popular star during that little you know, ten through thirteen, you
- 1:01:35know time period. Excellent ingreen worker, excellent promo. He checks off all
- 1:01:39those boxes. He's obviously a needle mover. He's shown that in twenty twenty
- 1:01:43four he's still moving the needle. So I mean, yeah, I mean,
- 1:01:47no lower than twenty five. But there's I agree with you guys,
- 1:01:50there's some people that are lower than him that you could put ahead of them.
- 1:01:52Yeah, all right, nineteen men new yorton this feels way low.
- 1:01:57Yeah, yes, I mean, yeah, he's one championships, he's may
- 1:02:04have been well, not just trust Amenia, but a ton of other paper
- 1:02:07views. If he's he's another one. If he's healthy, he's on TV.
- 1:02:14There's the run of opponents that he's had matches, great matches with.
- 1:02:19Yeah, I think, well, there again people ahead of him who should
- 1:02:23definitely be behind him. I think I think he to he he should be
- 1:02:29top fifteen. I think, m hm, yeah, he's all. He's
- 1:02:34also another guy. I was saying, borderline top borderline top ten. Yeah,
- 1:02:39you can make but if you made it, if you made a strong
- 1:02:42enough argument, you know I wouldn't fight if put him on the top,
- 1:02:44right right? Uh? DJ go ahead? Uh in nineteen Randy were in
- 1:02:49nineteen is way too low. And you know, I'm not the biggest s
- 1:02:52Wharton fan in the world. I think he loses a little bit of points
- 1:02:53because he's While he can cut a promo, he's not the best promo in
- 1:02:59the world. But he has a hell of a lot of charisma in the
- 1:03:00ring. Again, multi time champion on multiple shows in multiple eras, and
- 1:03:07just a consistent presence on TV. So you know, absolutely and again one
- 1:03:15of those people that they built from the ground up. Yeah, all right,
- 1:03:20eighteen and a Guerrero. I'm gonna pay for this one. A lot
- 1:03:23of marks love him, and the hell I do. I think. I
- 1:03:27think he's great. I think he's phenomenal. We're all getting in trouble together
- 1:03:31because I know where you're going with this. He feels too high. Wait,
- 1:03:36and the always I say that is because I think long jevity is actually
- 1:03:39one of the biggest facts in wrestling history. Long Jeviy should be should be
- 1:03:43a massive weight because that equals relevancy, that equals you know, hell,
- 1:03:50the whole nine. Yeah. He was there what four years and he died.
- 1:03:54Yeah, and we're having a similar conversation about him that we did about
- 1:03:58Owen Hart. If he had lived and his career went on longer, we
- 1:04:04could make an argument for him to be where he's at, but or higher.
- 1:04:11Yeah, potentially, because Eddie Guerrell was that dude. I mean,
- 1:04:14I was all in and I hate having this discussion. But before looking at
- 1:04:16this list objectively and you know, kicking personal bias aside, you know,
- 1:04:21I have to be honest about Eddie Guerrero's career. I love the guy.
- 1:04:26And again he's probably a top twenty all timer for me if I'm looking at
- 1:04:29the wrestlers that I've liked over the years, but on this list and by
- 1:04:32their criteria, I can't rank him that high. Well, it's funny because
- 1:04:36the criteria thing, he actually checks a lot of boxes too, because his
- 1:04:40now significance of he's actually one of the most influential wrestlers for this generation of
- 1:04:45wrestlers. Like as has a bank. She'll tell you that he was a
- 1:04:47pioneer for this style, that these like championships. He has a title,
- 1:04:53he want some bi big matches, very popular, moved a needle. Yes,
- 1:04:58the act of parts is when he get it was his points. He
- 1:05:00didn't it was only only four years your appearances. I'm assuming he was consistent
- 1:05:03in the years he was there. And then skills in the ring, charisma
- 1:05:06he had all that. Yeah, so I can see the panels. It
- 1:05:12didn't be a rob on this on this one point, Yes, he's high.
- 1:05:15I don't think he's too high. He's like the punk. It wasn't
- 1:05:19in the mid twenties. I'm okay with that because it was it wasn't in
- 1:05:24pact for four years. I think eighteen is wa it's just way too high?
- 1:05:30How low? How lolo are you bottom mounted? Then? I mean
- 1:05:33I think the longevity. I think again, he was there for him from
- 1:05:39two thousand and he wasn't there straight through either because he because he was either
- 1:05:44fired or suspended or something because yeh, diction problems. So he was there
- 1:05:49for but what like year five years total? Five or six years total,
- 1:05:58and a lot of that was I mean, yeah, I mean he was
- 1:06:01a great worker, yes, But if you asked me what was his best
- 1:06:06matches? Best match was Halloween Havoc. It's a great my stereo in w
- 1:06:12W. For me, his best match was when he won the World Championship
- 1:06:15against Brocklesner. That match, to this day it just gets me. Who
- 1:06:20was that that surviv series or what was that from? Yeah, I want
- 1:06:27a match, my god, what a match. I gotta see that one
- 1:06:30it were check it out, man. But I don't want to insulting the
- 1:06:34guir marks out there that has a lot of guir like Diehard stands. I
- 1:06:38gotta say, what the hell are you talking about? But I'm going by
- 1:06:40basic to the criteria. Yeah, this one's also way too low. Seventeen
- 1:06:45Bront Lester. Yes, the next two numbers pissed me off. Brock is
- 1:06:50too low brought. I mean Brock, I think is he the fastest world
- 1:06:57champion ever? I think so from debut to winning. He debuted April two
- 1:07:02one in August, yeah, four months from his professional debut. It's crazy,
- 1:07:11four months from his professional take view, I think the impact to also,
- 1:07:15that's an impact when he when he's around, like the world changes w
- 1:07:20That's why I love people can play about all like I I hate less.
- 1:07:25He's not there a week and this and that. No, you don't want
- 1:07:27him there a week because it doesn't feel the same, it doesn't work the
- 1:07:30same way. Well. Lenard comes in in spots as an intraction. It
- 1:07:34makes the company better in spots. It moves the needle. He moves merchandise.
- 1:07:41Lester can't cut a promo. But I defy you to find to I
- 1:07:45defy you to tell me that he's not charismatic. Right, And let me
- 1:07:49tell you something. If as much as people complain about him, if you
- 1:07:54are ever in, if you've ever been in an arena, when his music
- 1:07:58gets oh yeah, number two themes all time for me, I mean beyond
- 1:08:03Austin. It's like it's like when god It's like Godzilla showing up. It's
- 1:08:06like everybody's like, oh, ship, somebody's about to get sucked up.
- 1:08:10Yep, exactly. And look when when he came back, it was a
- 1:08:16summers lamb in twenty twenty one, right when you know, we wanted beating
- 1:08:20John Cena and everybody thought the show was over. And then we heard like
- 1:08:26the sirens, you know everything. I mean, everybody was like, oh
- 1:08:29my god, he's back. Yep. That's fun times. And also i'll
- 1:08:35throw in terms of and I've said this a few times in a few different
- 1:08:41places. I'm here, Uh, this current you know, turnaround in business
- 1:08:45was cemented by the Road to Presselvania thirty eight, which and people were and
- 1:08:51there were people on the internet saying, you know, we're doing broking over
- 1:08:55the good and those three months that led up to the match, just when
- 1:09:00that was the foundation cemented the turnaround, like all that stuff, everything like
- 1:09:08everything was cemented, like everything just comes sense. Then his piggy blacking off
- 1:09:13of those three months, Yeah, and that and that's that Roman and broc
- 1:09:16list okay, and then you know, and then and then looked at that
- 1:09:23as much as you know, again you talk about that off much whatever.
- 1:09:27I mean, him doing the cowboy Brock things the last couple of years he
- 1:09:30saw coming. You know, nobody saw that coming, and he pulled that
- 1:09:34out. I mean, and so yeah, again, another guy who's had
- 1:09:40two separate Hall of Fame runs. Yeah, yeah, I mean, I
- 1:09:43would make it. I would listen to an argument to put Leisure in the
- 1:09:45top ten, the arguments he's my top ten. So yeah, he would
- 1:09:49probably be in my top ten. He's actually number eight on my list,
- 1:09:54the number list, eight eight and on my list. And and I'll say
- 1:09:57it here, he was. He was the right person to break the street.
- 1:10:00Absolutely, I depended on his day ten years later get over. Yeah,
- 1:10:03I mean, nobody else was going to take that win and do with
- 1:10:06it what he did, so because that street parlayd what you saw after that
- 1:10:10for that next year one of the most dominant title reigns in history the company.
- 1:10:15Yeah, I agree with you. I'm sending that rub all right.
- 1:10:18Sixteen Chris Jericho, j You pissed on this one? Why way too fucking
- 1:10:24high and above Lessner Chris Jericho above Leser, fucking stop fucking stop, get
- 1:10:30out of here, and like you said, not discounting anything Jericho did in
- 1:10:34WWE. He had an amazing career, he really did. I mean he
- 1:10:39again pinned the Rock and Stone Cold on the same night. Huge, We're
- 1:10:43still talking about it, multi time champion over multiple years. But overall,
- 1:10:49you're gonna tell me on paper, a better career, a better draw,
- 1:10:55a better attraction than Brock lesser stop, full stop. Yeah, question,
- 1:11:00how about that one, rob your thoughts? Look look at it and look
- 1:11:04I was at one time. I was at car carrying Jericho all again one
- 1:11:06time. Okay, what are you? Oh wait, okay, hell yeah,
- 1:11:11I mean going back. Jericho was a lot of fun in the late
- 1:11:14nineties early two thousands. Man, he was. He was a hell of
- 1:11:16a lot of fun. Yeah, But I mean, looking at it now,
- 1:11:21I mean comparing his career now to get the Brock, but also to
- 1:11:27Punk, to Suck Rowlins, to Yep, you know somebody, and you
- 1:11:34know some of these folks. And if we were, if if we were,
- 1:11:40if we were making this list what like ten years ago? Sure,
- 1:11:45but not now it's too long. Now. Well then we also have to
- 1:11:49talk longevity. How many times did Jericho leave and come back? A couple
- 1:11:54of few times he left to go do the fozzy thing, then he left
- 1:11:57to go do the game show thing, then he left to go do uh
- 1:12:00uh what was the singing competition he was on the one time? I forget
- 1:12:03but that he was on the singing competition and he left too many times?
- 1:12:10Yeah, yeah, I mean, look, I mean punk Orton triple ah,
- 1:12:14I'll be ahead of him, ahead of him now yeah, yeah,
- 1:12:18yeah, but ahead of him now, be honest. I mean I will
- 1:12:21say his early run though, when he got there nine nine, amazing,
- 1:12:26Oh, legendary, legendary, and that might that might be waited here too,
- 1:12:30also, but movie reason, Yeah, I mean it's it's but again,
- 1:12:33we're making this list ten years ago. Sixteen probably about right, not
- 1:12:38right, it's probably it's probably waiting because of that early run. Early,
- 1:12:41I mean, because I agree he was a little a little high. Now,
- 1:12:43I don't think it's agreed. I think I think nineteen twenty twenty one,
- 1:12:46that's right, that's the sweet spot. That's fair. I think that's
- 1:12:49fair. Yeah, Okay, fifteen, ley, I think that's correct.
- 1:12:56I think's fine. I think fifteen is the right slot. Yeah, he's
- 1:13:00not a top ten guy. But he's he's historical stnificant check championshipsy won his,
- 1:13:05his, his one, No. One, but the title he won
- 1:13:09what Austin came out and helped him. That was his day and then obviously
- 1:13:14a needle mover because that changed the landscape. Yeah, yeah, mistaken.
- 1:13:19The eighty three weeks ended that night, isn't it. It was well,
- 1:13:25not almost I think, No, it didn't end it, But what that
- 1:13:29night did was that they still never never got back in the lead again.
- 1:13:32Okay, that point on popularity as a heel, he was phenomenal when he
- 1:13:39when he was David bankind and then as a Bay face, he was way
- 1:13:43over. You know. He was like after Austin Rock. He was one
- 1:13:45of the biggest faces in the company. Yeah, he was three active.
- 1:13:48I mean his style, style of wrestling, not a long time, but
- 1:13:54he I thought you I thought you would as long as he could give him
- 1:13:56the style of wrestling he was doing. Yeah, people of your pearances.
- 1:13:59He was consistent, chrisma, skills and ring that was good. Chris charismatic
- 1:14:04definitely. Yeah. Yeah, he's fine. Fifteen, He's fine. I'm
- 1:14:08no problem. Yeah, I'm not unhappy with fifteen at all. For mcfuley
- 1:14:11Robbie. Well, he gets to me, he loses some points of longevity
- 1:14:18because he got there and what like ninety six when he got there, six
- 1:14:23got there, Yeah, and he was going in two thousand, so he
- 1:14:27did come backuple times though he came back for one off matches. Yeah,
- 1:14:32as a full time wrestler. He's only there like four years. Yeah,
- 1:14:35but no, unlike some other people, I think his best work was there,
- 1:14:41of course, but I think you know because to me right now,
- 1:14:45I mean, uh, triple h that all put ahead of him, Brock
- 1:14:50I put ahead of him. They're just guys out put ahead of him.
- 1:14:56So maybe fifteen isn't too high, but there are people out ahead of a
- 1:15:00letter behind him, right right, all right? Buy that? Okay?
- 1:15:03All right? Fourteen Andre Dunant way too well to wait. I thought it
- 1:15:09was way too low. But thelo No, he was the he was the
- 1:15:13other than Bruno. He was the attraction in up until he got too old.
- 1:15:19Okay o, Katie, all you say he's a top ten guy all
- 1:15:25the time. Yes, it's hard. It gets harder though when all these
- 1:15:30other guys are now coming into into the fold. Also we go back to
- 1:15:34the same argument that we made a superstar Billy Graham. He was a Vince
- 1:15:38Senior era guy. So a lot of people, again younger than us,
- 1:15:43didn't see Pete. Andre didn't understand significant Andre was to the business, and
- 1:15:49we didn't. We didn't. We didn't see it either because by the time
- 1:15:54we got to wrestle Ania three, we got broken down over the hill.
- 1:15:57Andre. Yeah, you know, so it's supposed to get still need to
- 1:16:00move the whole nine still all the above, yes, but not as good
- 1:16:04as he was he was prior, right in the seventies. So like,
- 1:16:10Andre feels low, but I don't. I don't think this as the greatest
- 1:16:13yet thing. I think if you put like the closet between nine and eleven
- 1:16:15and twelve, I'm okay with that because there are guys that had this moved
- 1:16:19up the ladder in the last thirty forty years that you have to kind of
- 1:16:24give it to them. Yeah it is, you know, So I'm not
- 1:16:28I love Andre. You know that I'm a big mark, So DJ,
- 1:16:31you're with him. Andre. Uh. This is a tough discussion to have
- 1:16:35because it feels like him being at fourteen downplays his significance to the industry.
- 1:16:43But again, if we're looking at the criteria, Andre didn't win a whole
- 1:16:46lot of championships. He was the thing was. He was an attraction,
- 1:16:51He was a needle mover, he was a merch mover. He was the
- 1:16:56top heel in the company at one point. Begins with the rest many three
- 1:17:00other things he's done. Yeah, it's hard to really again because he was
- 1:17:03not our era. It's hard to judge his in ring work because what we
- 1:17:08saw was the shell of what he was. So you really have to go
- 1:17:12back to the late sixties into the seventies to find out what a workhorse Andre
- 1:17:16was. And he was a workhorse. Like if you ever want to find
- 1:17:18out peak Andrea giant, go find any match with him and Stan Hansen.
- 1:17:23Him and Stan Hansen beat the bag out of each other man and Andre,
- 1:17:27you know, because Hanson didn't give a shit that Andrea was a foot taller
- 1:17:30and two hundred pounds eavery year. He went in there fighting him like he
- 1:17:32was the same size and it was fun. And Andre had to really step
- 1:17:36up his game so to appreciate how good he would. And that's where I
- 1:17:41have a hard time with the in ring skills because what most people think of
- 1:17:46when they think of Andrea giant Is from WrestleMania three till you know, hit
- 1:17:50the end of his career without looking at the work prior to that, Right,
- 1:17:56So they may rate him lower because of what they think his Z ring
- 1:18:00work was, but that ain't representative of what he could do in the ring.
- 1:18:04Yeah, Rob, Yeah, I agree with the DJ said. I
- 1:18:10just think put him at four. Yeah, it's I mean, again for
- 1:18:15his significance again other than you know, like he was the attraction in the
- 1:18:19business. But again the championship things is that's legit because problem is you couldn't
- 1:18:28put a bill on him because you couldn't take it off of him realistically.
- 1:18:32And yeah, but that, I mean that does work against him though.
- 1:18:38So yeah, maybe the fourteen may end up being right, but I think
- 1:18:44it feels too low for me. Yeah, yeah, I guess you're saying
- 1:18:47it feels low, but I could understand. Okay the logic here you go.
- 1:18:53I'm sure you reaction to thirteen road rings too damn low. Get the
- 1:18:57fuck out of here. At this point, Romans made an argument for top
- 1:19:01ten. Yes, top ten, I mean people talking about Rushber Now I
- 1:19:05was there. Now you you hear your boy Duke last night on our on
- 1:19:11the last episode we recorded on this on this podcast, made it, made
- 1:19:15it, made it a point by him and about Rushmore and take Austin offer
- 1:19:16aout Rushmore and put Roman in there. But I disagree with some one of
- 1:19:19that, but not that's the whole other lum No to day thirteen is egregiously
- 1:19:24low. Yeah. Now I feel like these writers, are you still using
- 1:19:29the first eight years of his career prior to the heel turn twenty twenty as
- 1:19:32a way to keep keep him low? And I think and I think he's
- 1:19:35being penalized also for like the last couple of years when he with the lighter
- 1:19:40schedule. Yeah, go ahead, Rob, I'm sorry, but look,
- 1:19:45even when he was quote unquote rejected and I'm putting it in quotes, he
- 1:19:50was still the top merchant seller in the company. He was. Okay,
- 1:19:55that was Duke's point yesterday on the podcast. You know he main invented,
- 1:20:00so this will be eight and nine main events for the main events after this
- 1:20:04weekend the record and he's been there for twelve years, so you can't.
- 1:20:13You can't. There's no there's no longevity argument. He has gotten in spades.
- 1:20:17I mean, the only thing you can really hope, the only thing
- 1:20:20you can really hold against them, I say, is that the first half
- 1:20:27of his career business wasn't It wasn't. It wasn't in the crapper, It
- 1:20:31wasn't like in the early nineties. It was flat. Even though the overall
- 1:20:38business was flat, it wasn't going down, but it was plan during the
- 1:20:43first half of his career. I wouldn't put that all on him again,
- 1:20:46I wouldn't put I wouldn't put much of it. I wouldn't put I wouldn't
- 1:20:49put that on him at all. Is if they were cyclical anyway, and
- 1:20:54right now we're in and up cycle. It's about every seven years. About
- 1:20:57every seven years the business goes through cycle. We're in a hot cycle right
- 1:21:00now. And in his his first couple of years where he was being pushed
- 1:21:04at the top, were also the years the scene that was cycling down.
- 1:21:09Yeah, and you can't, I mean, you can't when somebody like that
- 1:21:14goes with full time to part time and you're gonna take a hit. It's
- 1:21:16like Hogan in ninety two. Yeah, but that's but if I mean,
- 1:21:21if there's a knock against him, that is really the only knock against him.
- 1:21:26But again again he turned his turn and his bloodline story Aline literally turned
- 1:21:32around the fortunes of not just the company, but the entire industry. Oh
- 1:21:38yeah, and have him fourteen and when you and thirteen and and looking at
- 1:21:44some of these people who are ahead of him. No, no, no,
- 1:21:47no, no no no. That that that's yeah, I'm going to
- 1:21:50the other humbercent. That that to me, it feels like ourageous man and
- 1:21:54a Neil moving happened with with the with the He'll turn. Ever since then,
- 1:21:59that's always been doing before you're moving. The needle and the Shield was
- 1:22:01one of the most again, that was one of the most over factions.
- 1:22:06You know, popular factions, you know, needle moving factions. The Shield
- 1:22:13is right there with I mean in history, I mean they're right there with
- 1:22:16like the free birds and those guys right all right? Number twelve, raymisterio
- 1:22:21Okay, I love Ray? What am I missing? This is way too
- 1:22:27high? Am I missaying a thing? Here? Say it's too high?
- 1:22:31Yes? Too high? Especially hit Roman because there's there are people defending that
- 1:22:35he should be here, like people outside of the panel here that voted on
- 1:22:39this saying that no he's actually should be like, what am I missing?
- 1:22:42Like, I know he's donejevity, Yes, twenty plus years in a company,
- 1:22:45get that a couple of years he did. Okay, there you go.
- 1:22:49But again, I had the guys like Andre, guys like Roman,
- 1:22:54guys like Foley. Honestly, Lester, you're gonna, you're gonna, you're
- 1:22:58gonna look me in the eye with a straight face and tell me that raymisterio.
- 1:23:02Yeah, And I love Ray. This is not a This is such
- 1:23:05a just difficult discussion to have because it feels like we're trashing people that we
- 1:23:10actually genuinely enjoy. I love Raymond Stereo. But if we're objectively looking at
- 1:23:15this list, I can't put him above guys like Orton, guys like Roman,
- 1:23:19Range, guys like Brock Lesnar. I mean not with a straight face.
- 1:23:24When I look at their criteria and I look at the reality and the
- 1:23:27totality of their careers. He's too high. I would pay an auree.
- 1:23:32I'm sorry. Yeah, And so I think I think Ray is Ray gets
- 1:23:39Yeah, I mean he's his most legendary status is outside of As much as
- 1:23:44he's a legend, he's a bigger legend outside of w W Yeah, and
- 1:23:50I think people have giving him some points for that here, I think what
- 1:23:56they should adobe Again, he's a guy who pioneered the style that a lot
- 1:24:01of these kids love nowadays, So we have to take that into consideration when
- 1:24:05we're looking at his cultural and historical significance in the business. He is,
- 1:24:10without a doubt, the greatest luchador of the last twenty years, if not
- 1:24:15all time. I mean, you have to rank him up there with mill
- 1:24:17Mascarus and you know, Ultimo Dragon and you know people like that. He
- 1:24:21has to sit on on that Mount Rushmore when you look at those type of
- 1:24:28guys. Absolutely, but again, a lot of that was built outside of
- 1:24:32WWE. He should be between eighteen twenty five. I think that's fair.
- 1:24:36But okay, I would say eighteen. I wouldn't put him into lower in
- 1:24:41eighteen because I think I think Ray's significance to WWE history is important. Right,
- 1:24:46all right, last one of this bunch of number eleven Krode Angle,
- 1:24:49good care. He's top twenty. Yes, yeah, I think he's a
- 1:24:54little high. He's high. No, no, no, eleven, No,
- 1:24:56I'll put him on top. I think him a top fifteen one too,
- 1:24:59But eleven. Man, he was all right, yuh now put a
- 1:25:05record though he's put a lot of bangers though. Man, to be honest,
- 1:25:09he's work is amazing. He was over charismatic the whole nine. I
- 1:25:13mean, he checks off all the boxes. But but again, I'm the
- 1:25:16following guys will take over at cardangle. Right now, I'm taking Romano a
- 1:25:18Kardanngle, I'm taking Andrea with a Kardangle, I'm taking fully of a kred
- 1:25:21Angle. I'm taking Lessner and Orton. That's five guys and triple and Trible.
- 1:25:28Ah, that's six guys and it's not twenty, but it's about it.
- 1:25:33But he's not right now at this point that we had that car.
- 1:25:39So Kardanngle, is he top twenty? Yeah, I'll give him to twenty.
- 1:25:42He's on a low end of that. Gorge your thoughts, uh No,
- 1:25:46I have no disagreement there. I mean, and again a hard discussion
- 1:25:50to have because I absolutely freaking love kurd Angle, you know, but again,
- 1:25:56we have to be realistic on these lists. When we get into the
- 1:25:58top ten, I mean, there we go. I've got some discussions to
- 1:26:00be here. I'm not gonna deal with the entire ten right now, I'm
- 1:26:05just gonna go at ten to one in the military right now. Okay,
- 1:26:09I think, well, who went to the podcast don't know the list yet?
- 1:26:12Because number ten right off the bat, I might, I might just
- 1:26:14lead to fucking John did you finish it? I'm that angry. Number ten
- 1:26:16is hult Cogin. I'm fucking real. What do you know your fucking history
- 1:26:23that the list is qualified yourself for? There? Like we I understand hull
- 1:26:30Cogan, the man behind Hulkgin went full blown white trash about fifteen years ago,
- 1:26:36yeah, and then capped it off with a horrible racist remark and then
- 1:26:43just disgusting language that went along with that all at the same time. So
- 1:26:46the guy behind hul Cogan we hate, I get it, I understand it.
- 1:26:50But this rewriting of history as to how significant and how important he was
- 1:26:58to the industry and how actually good at his job, he was absolutely just
- 1:27:04straight up just bullshit. And he checks off every fucking box here historical significance
- 1:27:12that speaks for itself. Who Comania the show? Doing this show without Comania?
- 1:27:17Thank you? We're not having this conversation right. Wrestle does not exist
- 1:27:23in the whole comania. It was getting paid the money they're being paid because
- 1:27:29of Hull Cochin. Yes, championships, are we greatest world champion history of
- 1:27:33company? Arguably to you Aunt Rushmore, Popularity speaks for yourself. Do was
- 1:27:40not only the biggest wrestling name obviously in his peak he was at the time
- 1:27:45and Rob the podcast, he was mentioned among the greatest stars in Hollywood.
- 1:27:53We say, oh, Michael Jackson anywhere for you, Hull Cokin, Yeah,
- 1:27:57he say, not just a wrest culture. He saw pop culture,
- 1:28:00pop culture phenomenon. He still is now people let me Yes. Popularity argued
- 1:28:09the greatest babyface and greatest heeled history of wrestling, not as WU wrestling in
- 1:28:15the not got include it here, but obviously yeah, time active. I
- 1:28:18mean that first run alone, he went nine years as a top that's a
- 1:28:21top guy. The entire WAYE paid your appearance is obviously he was consistent with
- 1:28:25that when he was when he was not doing movies and skills, he was
- 1:28:28in ring charisma and he carried broken down Andre. He carried Ultimate Warrior,
- 1:28:32who was one of the worst workers history to the company. I mean,
- 1:28:35what more do you want from holl Cocaine? He checks up every single box
- 1:28:40period. And look at the Wrestlingia eighteen match with him and Rock where they
- 1:28:45had to flip it in yeah, fact because of the crowd reaction. How
- 1:28:49many people can do that? He had just he just felt the energy in
- 1:28:57the crowd and he could adjust on the fly based on that energy. He's
- 1:29:02a good worker. And also yes, and look, if you're that much
- 1:29:06a stickler for how many moves people do in the match, just go watch
- 1:29:10some of the matches he had in Japan. Damn yeah, thank you,
- 1:29:13thank you. Yeah. All right, Number nine, this is egregious.
- 1:29:19Why do Roddy Piper oh Man ahead of whole? There are easily ten people
- 1:29:25and I love Piper. There are ten people on this list I would put
- 1:29:28ahead of him immediately. And Piper is one of those guys like that singular
- 1:29:33moment that from like nineteen eighty five, you know, he was. He
- 1:29:40was as important to the first WrestleMania as Hogan was. Yeah, as far
- 1:29:45as being a villain. But he well, he retired the first time in
- 1:29:51eighty six, so he wasn't even there that long. He was there from
- 1:29:55like eighty four to eighty six. Yeah, and then after that he was
- 1:30:00a part timer. Yeah, so, I mean, but I mean,
- 1:30:04he's such a culturally, culturally significant figure, but he had a very short
- 1:30:09run. But you know, relatively speaking, he was never a world champion,
- 1:30:17and so honest, man, it's just for how significant he was at
- 1:30:24his very peak, it's hard to imagine him being low. Him him should
- 1:30:31be lower, but now he should probably be in the twenties or maybe thirties.
- 1:30:36Yeah, because because because it was because of how much has happened.
- 1:30:41To your point, based on this list, I'm taking the Pauling Guys old
- 1:30:44Pipe right now, Hogan, obviously, Kurt angle Pipe or Piper, I
- 1:30:48might say, with Mysterial maybe definitely, Roman, definitely, Andre Brock,
- 1:30:57probably, Pi Batetfolio, also Ran ne Orton, Yeah, Triple Hs Yeah,
- 1:31:02probably as well at this point. Now, yeah, Piper, Yeah,
- 1:31:05that's about that. That lines up with my list of people that I
- 1:31:09would have put ahead of Piper. I mean, Mike said, Piper gets
- 1:31:12points for being one of the pioneers of what we now watch. I mean,
- 1:31:15obviously he was a huge part of WrestleMania one and two, so you
- 1:31:19have to give him points for that, but there's so many other areas where
- 1:31:23he just there's a couple other areas where he loses loses. Some of that
- 1:31:28is some of the big one his longevity. Is he top twenty Okay,
- 1:31:31fine, I'll get top twenty, but bottom twenty yeah all right. Well,
- 1:31:35if we're talking like career peak popularity, he's top ten, oh yeah,
- 1:31:42yeah, peak, but he loses. But all these other categories,
- 1:31:47yeah, I mean he comes up with. And one of the other big
- 1:31:51criteria is in ring worker. Roddy Piper was a punch and kick guy.
- 1:31:56He had a few moves that he could do, but he was a brawer.
- 1:32:00He was a punch and kick. He was an I like, I
- 1:32:02like to call it I hate your face wrestlers. Yeah, yeah, Like,
- 1:32:06I like how you say that. He said, I hate your face.
- 1:32:10I want to punch it wrestler, right, all right. Number eight
- 1:32:13Shawn Michaels so like I so, okay, okay, okay, I don't
- 1:32:23hate this. I don't hate it. He's definitely a top ten guy.
- 1:32:28I find my first off of me personally, my personal favorites all the time
- 1:32:30is top five all time for me, and he's probably looking at the business
- 1:32:33as a whole between six and nine. So I don't hate him. At
- 1:32:41an eight, he's definitely the best, arguably the best big match wrestler in
- 1:32:47history of port wrestling. I still think Brett's a better overall worker, consistently
- 1:32:54not to no matter what Hall shows, paper viewers doesn't matter. So Sean
- 1:33:02has two careers obviously, oh three really the Rockers. Then he has the
- 1:33:06Solar Rub nineteen ninety eight. It goes away four years cause back it's virginally
- 1:33:13a part time I rightly at the end of his career. You know,
- 1:33:17I don't hate the number eight. I don't hate it. I really don't,
- 1:33:20because when he was a top guy, he wasn't necessarily moving the needle
- 1:33:24into the business, but he was everything else on on the on the list,
- 1:33:29I think he checks mark, he marks Softwell, Goody. What do
- 1:33:32you think about Michael's eight. I think it's fine. Yeah, this is
- 1:33:35a tough conversation to have because at during the original click era Boyhood Dream seawn
- 1:33:43Michael's run with his first World Wrestling Federation Championship. It's a terrible run.
- 1:33:47It was a terrible time in the business. Some of that wasn't his fault,
- 1:33:53it was just the business in general. And two it was the way
- 1:33:55he was booked. I I'm trying to come up with cultural significance as to
- 1:34:02why Seawn Michaels should be ahead of a hul Cogan or Roddy Piper, and
- 1:34:08I'm honestly having a hard time there is any culturgnificance. Well, there's not
- 1:34:12none. There's not because while it's wild and when I look at the singing
- 1:34:17from up broader picture, there have been many, many wonderful matches that Sewn
- 1:34:21Michaels has had that are in my top ten, top twenty favorite matches of
- 1:34:27all time. But when I think of did he did his career, Like
- 1:34:35if Shawn Michaels were never a thing, we would still be having conversations,
- 1:34:40not unlike unlike Hogan, where if Hogan never happens, we're not doing what
- 1:34:45we're doing right now. Like Rob said Shawn Michaels, you can't say that
- 1:34:47same thing about like if he never existed, the business kept going and the
- 1:34:53business would have continued to a point it did in four years when he got
- 1:34:57heard it did the business kept moving, It picked up right. Not saying
- 1:35:00you don't use the problem, but you know, I don't want to discredit
- 1:35:03his career because it was an amazing career and he's one of my all time
- 1:35:06favorite performers. But I cannot in clear conscience put him ahead of Hogan and
- 1:35:13I would bump him down to like eleven or twelve. Ooh, you're worse
- 1:35:16than me. Oh my god. I think I would probably say eleven or
- 1:35:19twelve and I and I I hate saying that I drew. I truly hate
- 1:35:24saying that. See I think it's fine. I mean say, I probably
- 1:35:29put like the seven at six, six and seven, but that's as fi
- 1:35:30as it goes. But woow, I think his his not There's easily seven
- 1:35:35or eight guys that I think culturally are more important to the business than Sean
- 1:35:40Michaels was. I just think, I think what what what saves him from
- 1:35:43me and why I'm okay with eight is because his big matches on WrestleMania,
- 1:35:48they all stand out. The the the Ron Man match, people don't like
- 1:35:53it whatever, but that that that match, the the uh, the the
- 1:35:57Taker matches at at Mania latest career, the Triple h mat of Summer Slam.
- 1:36:00He has so many classic big match credentials that I think ways that argument
- 1:36:08should be in top ten at least. I don't recording to Dave Meltzer.
- 1:36:11He's never had a five star, has he? Well, he's a moron,
- 1:36:13so I mean he's you know that twice in a row. Might be
- 1:36:16mine Meltzer. But yeah, it's fine. I'm okay with eight. Oh
- 1:36:23said you said he said ten? Eleven? He said he was saying I
- 1:36:26would say eleven. Okay, okay, okay. He should absolutely not be
- 1:36:30ahead of k Well, yeah, man, all right, this is probably
- 1:36:39the toughest discussion, is he talk also find for Robert? Now is Tob
- 1:36:43Michaels top ten? Yes? Or no? I don't. I don't.
- 1:36:46I'm actually I'm thinking this through what we're doing in here, because he should
- 1:36:50not be ahead of Okay, that's Oh, who'd the following guys on this
- 1:37:00list that you would take over right now for career? Yeah? On this
- 1:37:04list that began, yes, Hogan, Yes, I would take I would
- 1:37:12take Roman. I had him right now. Roman was yeah that one,
- 1:37:15yeah, roman Ian? Because look, Roman was consistently doing four star mattresses.
- 1:37:24Oh sorry, it's the wrong thing, No, you got okay.
- 1:37:30I mean Roman had to stretch from like twenty sixteen to through twenty nineteen,
- 1:37:36where he was just doing four star matcs on TV every almost every week and
- 1:37:42gets forgotten because you know all the you know people were doing about him,
- 1:37:46you know, and then there's the run he's had, you know, the
- 1:37:53last four years. And you know what I would, I would take Roman
- 1:37:57ahead of him, would take Hogan obviously called keep talking, right, Okay,
- 1:38:03man, Okay? So I think Triple A to Randy Orton have longevity
- 1:38:14over him, but I would but I would not watch either one if you
- 1:38:18if you gave me, like, you know, here ten Triple Age matches.
- 1:38:20Here's here's ten Randy Orton matches. There's ten Shawn Michaels matches. I
- 1:38:25would take ten Shawn Michael's matches every day, right, And that's that's kind
- 1:38:30of the what makes this discussion so difficult is because you don't want to make
- 1:38:34it sound like we're discrediting it, discrediting his work. It's certainly not the
- 1:38:39case. But when I look at his overall impact on the industry, I
- 1:38:45think he's going to have more impact running NXT than he ever did as a
- 1:38:49WWE superstar probably, And and yeah, it's just I mean, man,
- 1:39:03I mean, because how long so he got there and when he was doing
- 1:39:10the Rocker. Yeah, stayed through ninety eight when he went out with the
- 1:39:14Last ten Years, and he came back in two thousand and two and stayed
- 1:39:18uh what twenty ten. Yeah. Yeah, he was active until twenty ten
- 1:39:24and then he just did appearances and it was an attraction after that. So
- 1:39:27I mean the longevity is there. He had a little break because of his
- 1:39:30injury, but he was a consistent person on WWTV and then yeah. Yeah,
- 1:39:39it's man, it's tough. So you would put Sean not in top
- 1:39:43ten or come like at the cusp, I put I put Hogan and Roman
- 1:39:48ahead of him. Right now, those are only two guys I put there,
- 1:39:51only two guys I put ahead on his list. That is it?
- 1:39:57Maybe andre I, I don't know if I can go Andre there. At
- 1:40:01this point, Searentinos only getting loved because of they're shoehorning older guys. So
- 1:40:10even put Sean, like, I think if you ten is perfect. I
- 1:40:14think if tenst the sweet spot for Sean. Ten or eleven? Yeah,
- 1:40:20okay, all right, seven the rock Man. That's that's low. Well
- 1:40:30yeah, we'll see now see see that we're at the point where we're arguing
- 1:40:33like semantics Jordan Kobe Lebron Magic. Yeah, we're getting close to that.
- 1:40:40That Yeah. Yeah, the top five gets a little dicey because because now
- 1:40:44we're we're splitting hairs. But there's also guys in the top in the top
- 1:40:45five that she even beat in the first place, So I mean he was
- 1:40:47spending here is based on what? So for me, it's it's a simple
- 1:40:50because there are guys at my favorite rest of all times in the top three.
- 1:40:56And I'll think, what you long there? Okay stuff if we're talking
- 1:41:01okay, so if we're talking like peak popularity, peak, that's Rocky.
- 1:41:09He might be number one. Yeah, just mainstream, you know, because
- 1:41:15Hogan is as much of mainstream figure as Hogan was. He didn't I mean
- 1:41:20he was doing b movies other than three Yeah, yeah, okay, the
- 1:41:27Rock was has been doing like main so when we're talking cultural significance, cultural
- 1:41:35reach or whatever history wrestling that has that Rock took it, you know,
- 1:41:42took it further. But now where he started and what and then oh four
- 1:41:54he was done. He was done as a full time or two basically that's
- 1:41:59not it's not really short, but it's not really long either. But to
- 1:42:03me, though, I think the launch everything, you know, because he
- 1:42:08has had like, you know, an eight year gap here, a four
- 1:42:11year gap here. But when he comes back, he moves the needle immediately
- 1:42:15every single time, whether or not it's the rock, Rocky my Via to
- 1:42:19the Rock, then rock to corporate rock, and then you know that got
- 1:42:24still a couple of years and he goes to Hollywood Rock was argue the best
- 1:42:27rock in my opinion of his entire tire twenty something near run and then you
- 1:42:30have that too. Okay, he goes away for eight years and then all
- 1:42:32a suddenly you get the scene of stuff and that was phenomenal in terms of
- 1:42:36that brought you guys. I'm not mistaken right again. And the Scena stuff
- 1:42:42helped, I mean it didn't it basically it's stabilized things. And then you
- 1:42:46have the city is doing now and when seen in this run right here,
- 1:42:53even though it hasn't even you know, had any matches, this run right
- 1:42:57here is as far as character working, all that is as good as I
- 1:43:00think he's ever doing. Yeah, he's too low seven is yeah? I
- 1:43:04mean honestly, when you when you add you think up seven probably is too
- 1:43:08low. Yeah, DJ the rock he's too low. Okay, he easily
- 1:43:12should be the top three. Top three. Yeah, interesting, okay,
- 1:43:16top three. W argument there, argument he about Russell, argument for me
- 1:43:20all the time? Number six windle Si Martinez. I mean, like I
- 1:43:24said, I think the Simon things, he's just shoe horning to. He's
- 1:43:28a sentimental right voted on by a bunch of guys who probably never even watched
- 1:43:33anything in e that's acknowledge that guy. That's all. Okay, I think
- 1:43:40he should still be top five, Okay, mad, I'm not mad about
- 1:43:44it. Okay, Remember, okay he was he was world champion for almost
- 1:43:46eight years, and then he came back and wanted again and was champed for
- 1:43:50like over three years. And you don't get your world champ for eight years
- 1:43:56for similar reasons. Okay. And well, I mean it's hard, yes,
- 1:44:02to mean, there were no pay per views, there was no WrestleMania.
- 1:44:05If there was WrestleMania when he was a champion, he would have manament
- 1:44:09it every year. Okay, if if there was an if there was a
- 1:44:13WrestleMania back then, he would have manimented every single year. Yeah, both
- 1:44:16times he was champion, if they were there were pay per views back then,
- 1:44:19he would have made in all of them. Okay, So I think
- 1:44:25for him, you gotta kind of look at it that way. You gotta
- 1:44:30kind of play well. I said that because because he made them in so
- 1:44:32many shows, he sold out so many shows, you have to kind of
- 1:44:35look at it like if they had pay per views, if they had WrestleMania,
- 1:44:41he would have been on top of all of those things for eight years,
- 1:44:48and then for another three years the second time, and then maybe even
- 1:44:55a couple of times as a spot show when he was a part time Okay,
- 1:44:59I mean he made a minute the Garden one last time when he was
- 1:45:00like fifty years old. You know, for my money, that's cage men
- 1:45:10wrestler history. You look at some little I mean you look at some of
- 1:45:14the little see some of the video. Yeah, go back to some of
- 1:45:15those videos. Yeah, for my money, best cage wrestling history. Right,
- 1:45:27So I think, yeah, I think top five is fair. He
- 1:45:29looked he threw money man, and he drew the money as champion like Grey
- 1:45:32wasn't attraction, was attract Bruno drew the run was champ as a as the
- 1:45:38core guy, the main guy of a company. Yeah. Yeah, which
- 1:45:41which again we when I when I do myut, Rush wore. That's that's
- 1:45:44my number one thing. Was your company growing around you, And that's why
- 1:45:48I hope it's my mind. In my mind, this was Austin for example,
- 1:45:51Smartino. Go ahead, yeah he's top five. Bruno's top five for
- 1:45:56me. Okay, yeah, for all the reasons Rob said, Bruno's obviously
- 1:46:00a top five, And it's for a lot of people that are going to
- 1:46:02look at this list and and like we were saying a minute ago, kind
- 1:46:04of in there as the sentimental a lot of people really didn't watch for now,
- 1:46:11so to them it's their grandfather's wrestler. So technically he's too low for
- 1:46:15you guys then, because this number five is John Cena, I mean because
- 1:46:17look, man, look my dad was a black man from Ortonburg, South
- 1:46:20Carolina, and he was a big mark for the Italian immigrant from San Martino.
- 1:46:27I mean, you know, and back in a time where you didn't
- 1:46:30have that kind of cross cultural fandom, you know as much. Okay,
- 1:46:39John Cena five, I mean I can argue about it. The top five
- 1:46:44guy, I mean, he argued to hire but you know that's either here
- 1:46:46or there sitting the hairs games. Yeah, that means a Mount Russell candidate,
- 1:46:55obviously, which puts you in a number five you define in a conversation.
- 1:46:58And now in his case, I mean he held the title a bunch
- 1:47:00of times. And in his case, even when he was not champion,
- 1:47:03he was still cool, the top guy in the company. Correct, charismatic,
- 1:47:09you appearances, active, a long time longevity, you'll be all over
- 1:47:15titles, historical significance, historic signficans. I guess more so with just sustaining
- 1:47:18against the you know posts at the era. I guess I'm assuming well,
- 1:47:24and he kept that company afloat during the down years, right, yeah,
- 1:47:28And he's got he's got the that mainstream cultural reach. He has it more
- 1:47:33than people realize. Right now. There are a lot of people who don't
- 1:47:38you know. Yeah, there are people who were not watching wrestling and they
- 1:47:44can't see me Rob. Yeah, but who knew exactly knew that, and
- 1:47:46he knew about him. So I think five, yeah, top five,
- 1:47:53Yeah, top five, easy to five, I mean, could be higher,
- 1:47:57be honest. So yeah, I mean so right now, I mean
- 1:48:00as far as people who should be top five, rock Hogan seen, No,
- 1:48:04we've got four guys here who haven't the top five yeah, all right,
- 1:48:10here we go the top four here going to four the Undertaker, So
- 1:48:14for stability reasons, I see why he's in love here. But if I'm
- 1:48:17doing my top is he top ten be all time? Yes, let's go
- 1:48:21there. Let's he's done top ten. He's not a top four. He's
- 1:48:25the greatest character history of absolutely, Yes, he's top ten. Definitely,
- 1:48:30He's not a top five though, No greatest character. Greatest job in making
- 1:48:36a gimmick work? Yeah, yeah, so I say, you know,
- 1:48:42perform greatest Everett performing a gimmick, I would say, because that gimmick should
- 1:48:47not afford cool that absolutely he should not have worked for thirty years and it
- 1:48:54did. But well, to his credit, he timetime again retold that make
- 1:48:58it fresh. Yeah. So where should he be? Uh dj? If
- 1:49:02not top top four? Uh seven? Eight or nine? Yeah, I'm
- 1:49:08the same way too, same way nine Yeah, seven, eight or nine
- 1:49:11awesome? Just legacy also and a bit of a cultural influence. I mean
- 1:49:15people outside of wrestling know who the Undertaker is, yes, correct, I
- 1:49:19mean that it's a guy they know and they know about him because the gimmick
- 1:49:24was just again, like rom said, it never should have worked, and
- 1:49:27somehow or another. He fucking made it cool. Yeah, and consistent assistant.
- 1:49:30Yes, and probably the most trust worth of the employee Vincent had.
- 1:49:34Yeah, he was right or died for Vince McMahon. Absolutely batter indifferent,
- 1:49:40yep, yep. He was never intobordinate and he never he did screwed Vince
- 1:49:44any kind of way. Walk out on Vince at any point. Are this
- 1:49:51they only knock on him that They never made him the fun question. Number
- 1:49:57one guy. Yeah, and yeah, and that thing that's't hurt to him
- 1:50:02about restur conversation. It was never built around him. He was just a
- 1:50:05stable guy. He was just di stability guy, you know. So all
- 1:50:10right, Number three my als time favorite wrestler, maunch Myriny Savage. So
- 1:50:13I'm gonna tell right now it feels high. However, looking at the criteria,
- 1:50:19he's the only guy that not only checks parked every single box here on
- 1:50:25the other criteria, he does it all on a high level. Every single
- 1:50:29one titles check historical significance. First Mania three. That match, though,
- 1:50:33is regarded as one of the best mens, if not debates bets of all
- 1:50:36time. Rest history popularity was the biggest heel and one point a huge face
- 1:50:42behind Hogan. Oh, with Hogan, Neil mover check it was very active
- 1:50:46when he went when he was healthy. Was there heavy reparatives, was consistent
- 1:50:50skills? Charisma? Come on now we know that already, Mike, Come
- 1:50:55on now, we know that already in ring phenomenal. So he's he's one
- 1:50:58of the only guys in history rusts that. That's what Box makes a very
- 1:51:01superstar. Yeah, just he wasn't Hogan. I mean, that's it.
- 1:51:06It's a booking thing. Yeah, yeah, No, he wasn't good enough.
- 1:51:14Well, I mean, we'll never I guess, of course we would.
- 1:51:16We'll never know that if had Held swapped him in Ogan in nineteen eighty
- 1:51:21three, would you have got the same result? Probably not, because Hogan
- 1:51:25had the Hogan had the recognition from Rocky three on his back, you know,
- 1:51:30put you know on his back, that's true. But if Randy Savage
- 1:51:34had been in Rocky three instead, could you have gotten the same result with
- 1:51:40him? Maybe? Maybe? I think behind the scenes, Randy Savage was
- 1:51:45just a little too volatile of a person, whereas I think Hogan was a
- 1:51:50better businessman. Yes, yeah, And I think that's part of what made
- 1:51:56Hulk of Mania work. Was it Hogan just had a overall better fundamental understanding
- 1:52:01of the business. And that's not you know, to say Savage wasn't awesome
- 1:52:05and you know, equally as much of a presence. But looking backstage,
- 1:52:12peeling back the curtain, I think Hogan probably had an edge there because I
- 1:52:15mean, Hogan was running his own merchant before he came there. Yeah,
- 1:52:19so he already I mean yeah, so he yeah, I mean he already
- 1:52:26do things about the business and those that other people hadn't gotten yet. It's
- 1:52:32just yeah, I mean he's well top ten, be sure, but number
- 1:52:38three number three is too high. Yeah, he's dobably top ten, definitely,
- 1:52:44he's probably between six and eight. Also two for me because six or
- 1:52:46seven. Yeah, Like to me, if somebody were to say Maddie Johnson
- 1:52:49was number one, I'd be like, yeah, it's too hot. Top
- 1:52:55five, yes for my list, correctly, Yeah, so all right or
- 1:53:00two. This is probably a little controversial, I guess not really, Yeah
- 1:53:04it is for me. Uh still, go Steve Boston, what I think
- 1:53:09he's my fifth top five guy. So Austin Rock saying that Ogan Bruno those
- 1:53:14are those are my five Austin should have one. My opinion, Bus it's
- 1:53:16me. Well, I think I think now I think Rock is casting with
- 1:53:23the leader stuff. I think. The only thing I will say is that
- 1:53:27Austin had to walk before the Rock could run. Yeah, because if Stone
- 1:53:31called Steve Austin as a character had never taken off, we would never have
- 1:53:35gotten the Rock true. And that's the only way. That's the only reason
- 1:53:41that I'll give Stone called the edge over Rocky is because he laid the foundation
- 1:53:47for what the Rock built upon. And I guess look at it, it's
- 1:53:53kind of like it's like Magic and Bird and Michael Jordan's almost like Michael took
- 1:54:01them to greater heights than Magic and Bird did, but Magic and Bird saved
- 1:54:06the league. Yeah, yeah, Yeah, It's tough because Rock has some
- 1:54:14of the longevity moments, and he's been active even far after Austin's retirement in
- 1:54:18two thousand and three. But high the powers. There's been no bigger superstar
- 1:54:23history with W than SoCal See Boston was in those those three four years in
- 1:54:27W and the one more popular ever to this day than SoCal see Boston and
- 1:54:31then I mean and again nineteen ninety eight. Oh, his whole his his
- 1:54:36ascension is what turned around the Monday night warves. Yep, he and for
- 1:54:43and he was for a good bit. He was like the thing that was
- 1:54:48keeping them relevant versus and he was culture to also pop culture. For that
- 1:54:54one, he very much. I remember reading an article on him, and
- 1:54:57I think it was Rolling Stone. They did like a big two or three
- 1:55:00page right up on Stone called Steve Boston and how culturally significant he was.
- 1:55:03And all of a sudden, you know, white dudes were growing Goate's are
- 1:55:06shaving their heads, and you know, he again for that time period,
- 1:55:12reached outside of that wrestling bubble. Yeah, yeah, I think he's been
- 1:55:15number one. That's my opinion. He's definitely about Rushmore Locke for me.
- 1:55:19Yeah, number one. For me, I'm somewhat shot when not shot,
- 1:55:28because at the end of the day, this guy is, in my opinion,
- 1:55:31the gradest worker in the history of port wrestling. We'll go the company
- 1:55:34and that's Brett Hart. Number one. There was no better worker consistently night
- 1:55:40after night, doesn't give a ship what event it is, WrestleMania, house
- 1:55:44show, sen that main event, whatever. He works one hundred percent the
- 1:55:47same way no matter what. And Brett Hart is that guy. So so
- 1:55:51and one and in retrospect, I do actually respect the fact they want to
- 1:55:56acknowledge his work. He's still too high though. It's top ten, but
- 1:56:00not to He's just too high, though, Rob, you want to go,
- 1:56:05you want me to go? Britt is too high. I mean I
- 1:56:10named my top five, so Bred's top ten. So but number one is
- 1:56:19yeah, number one is way too high. Yeah, DJ, Yeah,
- 1:56:25this is This is absolutely the toughest part of conversation for me, because Brett
- 1:56:29Hart is on my mount rushmore of workers, Like, I agree with everything
- 1:56:32you say. He's absolutely probably the best pure worker in the history of the
- 1:56:36business. He's one of my all time favorites. But when I look at
- 1:56:42the people below him on this list, I cannot in clear conscience say that
- 1:56:46Brett Hart was a bigger draw than Stone Cold, Steve Boston, Hulkog and
- 1:56:50Randy Savage the Rock. He was a draw, and he was definitely,
- 1:56:56you know, a guy who kept WWE afloat during the absolute worst you know,
- 1:57:00his World Championship run from like ninety three on up kind of gets overshadowed
- 1:57:09by the fact that the New Generation era was a terrible era and he was
- 1:57:14putting send some really, really good work in a terrible time in WWE business.
- 1:57:19So it's it's unfortunate that that's the legacy that Brett Hart carries forward.
- 1:57:25But as far as they were never gonna we just talked about Stone called Steve
- 1:57:31Austin. WWE was never gonna do that with Brett Hart, and I love
- 1:57:36Brett, but they tried Brett as a heel and it worked in the dynamic
- 1:57:43with Steve Austin because it was something different. Steve Austin was an asshole and
- 1:57:47everybody loved him for it. So we needed Brett Hart to try and be
- 1:57:51a bigger asshole that we could hate because we loved Steve Buston so much.
- 1:57:56But they were never gonna build WWE's popularity where they went from ninety nine on
- 1:58:02off the back of Brett Hart, right, you know, the character,
- 1:58:06not the wrestler, you know. But yeah, that's a tough one for
- 1:58:10me to have. I agree he's in the top ten, he's definitely not
- 1:58:13number one, and I hate that being a Brett Hart mark. Yeah,
- 1:58:17I'm with you, and you it's funny. I did watch along of Brett
- 1:58:20Reres West Wing of ten, both both matches. It's all on the course
- 1:58:26the message yokozud as a pretty good two also, yeah, Brett, both
- 1:58:30guys really, but Brett especially plus worker shoes. On that night, there's
- 1:58:33another match. I just did a watch along. I'm doing a project with
- 1:58:36a couple guys on the Chair Shop Radio Network, the Big Four Project,
- 1:58:40right, and we just did SummerSlam ninety two and the main event was Brett
- 1:58:45Hart and Davy Boy for the Intercontinental Championship with the one over in one way,
- 1:58:48And there were some nuggets that Dave the Lawyer dropped. Honest, I
- 1:58:53didn't even know that Brett basically carried Davy through that entire match because Davy had
- 1:58:59been if he was all cooked up, like days before that match. And
- 1:59:04when you watch it with that knowledge, you see it like they had this
- 1:59:09amazing match, like you remember it. You're like, that match was fucking
- 1:59:12awesome. Brett was every reason why that match was fucking awesome because Davy was
- 1:59:17You look at it, Davy's body is there. But that's it now,
- 1:59:25as you said it, Now, I gotta watch that now with the same
- 1:59:26that of mind. Now watch it with that in mind. It's a totally
- 1:59:29different experience. It's still a great match. It really is. But it
- 1:59:31is a much different watching experience. Now, does Brett have a bad match
- 1:59:35at all his career, because I don't. I don't know that Fred's ever
- 1:59:38had a bad match. You mean he's got some matches that he would tell
- 1:59:42you we're bad. Yeah. Yeah, but he's also greating on a curve,
- 1:59:45he's like, he's probably harder himself than anybody else's to him. Yeah.
- 1:59:49So yeah, but yeah, Brett hard's top ten. Definitely, He's
- 1:59:53not six to eight range, maybe six and nine range, because I think,
- 1:59:57do you move the needle? No, His so significance obviously mount in
- 2:00:00the Montfield screw job, the whole nine that that's obviously huge. Worker.
- 2:00:05He was a phenomenal worker. Charisma, It's funny, was in the middle
- 2:00:10somewhere with charisma. He was okay with charisma. But I think his ninety
- 2:00:14seven run is what turned it on his Is his best promo work was in
- 2:00:17ninety seven? Yeah, he was in his bag in ninety seven. No,
- 2:00:21I would say Breadhouse ninety seven on argument the best one of the most
- 2:00:24fast thing and arguing in the best years of any super superstar has ever had
- 2:00:27in wrestling. Yeah, I know, but yeah, they're they're they're their
- 2:00:31list. Here's is mostly garbage, though I'm sorry leave report. Well,
- 2:00:35yeah, I mean because you know, like the people that are not there,
- 2:00:40you know, no Clow, no Cho, no pepri In Morales,
- 2:00:44No Bob Beckland, Bob back the world champion for sixty years? How do
- 2:00:46you not have one? You miss? Still, Also, you're gonna hate
- 2:00:49me playing this probably, I don't know how you feel about this, because
- 2:00:51I know it's it's probably the most The most controversial name is christ bin wa
- 2:00:57fuck it. Yeah, but well you can't say that. Okay, again,
- 2:01:02what's about his work? But even then, I mean, okay,
- 2:01:08there more better in Vader. Yeah, but there's probably six other guys ahead
- 2:01:14of Chris ben Wah, and Chris ben Waugh's best work was not in w
- 2:01:16W eight. No, that agrees to also, and well yeah what four
- 2:01:21year five years w Yeah, because he passed away, but about a ye
- 2:01:26or so after Eddie that this should happened with him about a year or so
- 2:01:29after Eddie, So yeah, what tragic situation. Yeah, But also I
- 2:01:33mean, like, yeah, it's no Bob Backland, yeah, Lord Vader,
- 2:01:44because he just we're gonna be stuck on this Vader thing for a minute,
- 2:01:47he just he just shouldn't be there. I mean, I don't disagree
- 2:01:54again, I put in Bianca hit of Vader. How funny is it that
- 2:01:58Vader is the one that's stuck out at all three of us? Is like,
- 2:02:00how the fuck did he end up on this list? Right? And
- 2:02:02then I mean, yeah, Bailey ahead of Vader, And as far as
- 2:02:06career, yeah, Ria and Bianca and you know, Tito Santana, Bob
- 2:02:15Backlund, Diesel. He even said Davy boy Smith were his bulldog not on
- 2:02:21the list. I mean, I mean, I'm joking around, no,
- 2:02:29but but he had a better career in w W E than Vader. He
- 2:02:31was a tag team champion and he was a king, so he was so
- 2:02:36that I mean, that is a better career than Vader had. Yes,
- 2:02:41and wait a minute, hold up, what you've got to be kidding me?
- 2:02:46What he's not here? Who's that Ted dB Oh ship? Wow?
- 2:02:54How did we just go through two hours worth the show fifty names on the
- 2:02:58list and Ted Dibiassi didn't pop up once. I'm ashamed. And the sick
- 2:03:01part two also is that Dbias was for a good year, I mean two
- 2:03:05years. One of the most red hot heels in the company. Oh,
- 2:03:09he was the top heel in the company. And then at one point he
- 2:03:13was in the conversation for best entering worker in the world. He's to cut
- 2:03:16a promo. He had the entring skills and he's not he I think he
- 2:03:23loses a little points to think. The only real championships he ever won was
- 2:03:26Tag Team Champions with Money, Inc. But again the Era two where Hogan
- 2:03:30Savage Warrior old hoggin it. Yeah, okay then and Vince didn't want to
- 2:03:35put the championship on the heel exactly. Yeah, but he's not here.
- 2:03:42The Miz had a better career than Vader and Ricky Steambok and some of these
- 2:03:45other guys. Yeah, I am sick and tired of the mis hate.
- 2:03:50Yeah, sick and tired of it. I'm going to cut a whole promo
- 2:03:53on our show one day, Rob So. I mean, I mean,
- 2:03:57now, I don't know where you put the Miz. But he's had a
- 2:04:00better career in Vader. He had a better career in Ridgy Steamboat China,
- 2:04:02China, a better career in China, you know, I mean, you
- 2:04:08guys had a better even guys like Razor, I mean because almost twenty is
- 2:04:12this arguably the greatest im of all time arguably and he's in a conversation and
- 2:04:16the top three and he's been he's been doing it almost twenty years. Yeah,
- 2:04:25I mean, he main invented WrestleMania money in the bank twice world,
- 2:04:30he has a TV show with him his wife. Yeah, I mean,
- 2:04:32so how is he not in the top fifty courageous list launching into the sun?
- 2:04:40I mean, and so when out we're doing is I'm you know,
- 2:04:43I'm still looking looking because there are more people give me other one? We
- 2:04:48got here, jbl better than Yes, he had a better and in some
- 2:04:53of these people rubbers short though the runway is to your runs as a solo.
- 2:04:59We was like, yeah, but you got account his entire career.
- 2:05:01I mean he had He was a solo act as Justin Hawk Bradshaw or Justin
- 2:05:08Hawk Layfield. And then he teamed up with Ron Simmons and they were you
- 2:05:12know, the ANPA for a while and then he had his sing you gotta
- 2:05:15you gotta do the cumulative thing, right, Yeah, I mean I mean
- 2:05:20who else, I mean just somebody's Yeah, I mean, and obviously you
- 2:05:26can't squeeze all these people into a top fifty people who are there, but
- 2:05:30Mark Henry List he has an argument. I'm not a big fan of his
- 2:05:33boy, he's argument for it. But I mean, those are all people
- 2:05:36who had who they have had better WW careers, Invader China, Yeah,
- 2:05:45and or even somebody like like like I said, Billy Graham had that one
- 2:05:49year where he was a big deal, right, still bigger than Vader.
- 2:05:57I mean, yeah, it's just trying to think because now I'm sorry,
- 2:06:00now I gotta I gotta run through my little mental just this could be a
- 2:06:06whole other show. Yeah, it's just what I mean, it's I mean,
- 2:06:11but yeah, some of the just omissions and just I mean it's egregious.
- 2:06:15Yeah, I mean I'm like like like, yeah, it's bad.
- 2:06:17It's really bad, really bad. You know, well, hell, who
- 2:06:24had a better career Dolph Zigler Vader is out on the list. Yeah,
- 2:06:29okay, I'm not saying we could do this the rest of the night.
- 2:06:32I'm not saying Dolf should be you should even be top fifty. But if
- 2:06:35you're doing better careers or Vader, Dolph Zigler, Ricky Steamo in w W
- 2:06:42E, you know, I mean yeah, I mean, I mean yeah,
- 2:06:46yeah, yeah, yeah, we can do so. I'll behalf of
- 2:06:49almost of the podcast. Uh, Vader, we apologize recipes. Yeah,
- 2:06:54because look, look Vader, you know, to the to the White Family,
- 2:06:58if if any of you were listening to this, we actually love of
- 2:07:00your dad, brain dad, whatever he wrote you know to you. Yeah,
- 2:07:03it's just we love everything he did outside of the Big Big Van Vader
- 2:07:09not Vader was not awesome and also the the the one Final Payday Vader was
- 2:07:18awesome. Suckered will Osbury into doing a match with him that one. Yeah
- 2:07:28so, but unfortunately that was in w Yeah. All right, fella,
- 2:07:35this is awesome. Long Long once Long was gonna go. But I got
- 2:07:39a lot a lot to react to here. We got a lot to unpack.
- 2:07:41Man. Yeah, yeah, we did plug away. I want to
- 2:07:44go Robert the first. Well, as always, you can listen to us
- 2:07:46every week Minleas Wrestling Podcast, d J and Jason. You can hear me
- 2:07:50every couple of weeks on the Robin Genius podcast, and I will plug this
- 2:07:56last episode. We did the of your podcast, Ernest the I've listened to
- 2:08:01with me and Duke and it was it was hilarious. DJCE. That's I'm
- 2:08:07going to try and fit that in either tomorrow or Friday. I'm gonna be
- 2:08:09kind of busy tomorrow, but Friday, I've definitely got some free times A
- 2:08:13characters. Yeah, I told Rob. I was like, damn, I'm
- 2:08:16sorry I missed it. I've been hoping to chop it up with Duke for
- 2:08:20quite a while. He and I have gone back and forth on Twitter a
- 2:08:22couple of times, but he just never never materialized. But he's a character.
- 2:08:26Yeah, I mean, I never thought I would hear somebody talking about
- 2:08:30punk was trying to expext me Jack okay and or, and I never thought
- 2:08:37he attempted. This fucking guy went straight lawyer and on the whole Sam,
- 2:08:43oh my god, is he prone to hyperbole? Is this what we're And
- 2:08:48then I respect the hustle? Yeah, listen the character play. I'm okay
- 2:08:54with it. Respect it again with Rob and Jason on the Mindless Wrestling Podcast.
- 2:09:01We drop on Saturdays on the chair Shot Radio Network. You can find
- 2:09:05me on the app formally known as Twitter at the Mindless Pod still Saturdays.
- 2:09:11Dude, Come on, yeah, that's it's her time slot. Man,
- 2:09:13I have no control over it. I'm not the boss. I'm not even
- 2:09:16like I'm not even like the under boss or like the street level thug.
- 2:09:20It's crazy like you guys do a preview recipators week example, anything they get
- 2:09:24their fever like I starts that come up instead of watching n x T Stand
- 2:09:28and Deliver, Listen to our rest, Listen to me recite a bunch of
- 2:09:41It's all about It's okay, Greg, I'm not making fun of it saying
- 2:09:43that Damn, it's too late anyway, but fellas good jobs always, man.
- 2:09:46I don't get late, so I'll get out here. I had a
- 2:09:48good time, man. I'm going to bed. You guys have a good
- 2:09:50night. You got it. Thank you. P S.