Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / $150 Billion Later: The Truth About Bitcoin ETFs and Who’s Buying
Transcript
- 0:00What you're telling me is that music is about to stop, and
- 0:04we're going to be left holding the biggest bag of odorous
- 0:07excrement ever assembled in the. History of darkness. 1974.
- 0:151980790297. 2000 and whatever we want to call this, it's all just
- 0:19the same. Thing over and over we can't.
- 0:21Help ourselves. I say when we sell.
- 0:26Hey, OK. I say when we sell.
- 0:33All right, so this week we had James Seifert on the podcast.
- 0:36James is from Bloomberg Intelligence, he's an ETF
- 0:39analyst. We actually had Eric Balchunas
- 0:41on the show a few weeks ago. Who's James colleague?
- 0:45James and Eric, they both really made a name for themselves in
- 0:47the past two years with the really the pre approval of the
- 0:52Bitcoin ETFs by the SEC and then the launch of them in 2024.
- 0:57And since then, I mean, they've been really top of my list in
- 1:00terms of following fun flows, 13F filings and just the the
- 1:06magnitude of success that these products have had.
- 1:09So we talked quite a bit about the Bitcoin ETFs.
- 1:11We dug into a little bit of Q2 filings, discussed things such
- 1:15as the Harvard allocation to Bitcoin that was uncovered in Q2
- 1:19of this year. And then also we discussed just
- 1:22why it's still early from understanding Bitcoin in the
- 1:25traditional wealth management space, how a lot of firms
- 1:28actually haven't participated yet and some that have
- 1:31participated are still quite restricted in terms of what they
- 1:34can recommend to their clients. So really supported the idea
- 1:38that while Bitcoin is maybe something that we understand
- 1:41deeply on the show, most of the investors, both retail and in
- 1:46the traditional finance space, the advisors, we're actually in
- 1:50many ways gatekeepers or allocators of capital are still
- 1:53coming up the curve. And it's incredibly early for
- 1:55actually trillions of trillions of dollars of capital be flowing
- 1:58into the space. And so that kind of ties into a
- 2:01broader thesis here at on Ramp that is adoption scales, price
- 2:04increases and individuals, businesses, institutional
- 2:08investors are just going to need better solutions, quite frankly,
- 2:11to secure the asset without compromise.
- 2:15And so that's what we do here at On Ramp where we provide our
- 2:18clients with really secure foundation and multi institution
- 2:22custody. But then you can access on top
- 2:23of that Bitcoin back loans, inheritance, Iras, trade, you
- 2:29name it, this product is also insured.
- 2:30We could talk about that if you want to reach out.
- 2:32But the way I see this personally is multi institution
- 2:36is really the standard for scaling Bitcoin adoption without
- 2:39having to trust a single institution, which is
- 2:41historically led to a lot of losses and failures, but also
- 2:44not having to be a technical expert.
- 2:46Your family doesn't have to be a technical expert.
- 2:48So it's really just bridging the gap, meeting people where
- 2:51they're at. And that's why I'm so excited
- 2:52about what we do here now. I hope you enjoyed the episode
- 2:55and let me know if you ever have any feedback you can reach out
- 2:58to me directly. Welcome back to The Last Trade.
- 3:01We're back to our standard programming this week.
- 3:04Last week, James, we had only three of us, Michael Bryan
- 3:07myself. This week we're joined by James
- 3:09Seyfert from Bloomberg. James, we just had your
- 3:12colleague on Eric Balchunas just a few weeks ago.
- 3:15We had a fun one with Eric and I'm excited for this one as
- 3:17well. And I know you guys work very
- 3:19closely together and so think we'll be able to go deeper on
- 3:22some of the topics we discussed with Eric and then also get your
- 3:24perspectives on a lot of the things that are going on in the
- 3:26market. We have the deadline tomorrow
- 3:29for the 13 F filings for the second quarter.
- 3:31So we'll be talking quite a bit about what we're seeing in terms
- 3:34of flows and appetite, you know, from the retail side, the
- 3:36institutional side, US global, etcetera.
- 3:39But James, thank you for joining us today.
- 3:41How are you doing? Yeah, happy to be here.
- 3:44I'm doing pretty well. There's a lot happening across
- 3:47the entire crypto ecosystem is a lot happening internally at
- 3:49Bloomberg actually too. But yeah, ready to dive in.
- 3:53I mean things are looking pretty optimistic as far as anyone with
- 3:56some sort, any sort of crypto allocation at the moment.
- 3:59Yeah. I mean I would say things were
- 4:01looking optimistic as long as you're not looking at the
- 4:03Bitcoin price from all time high since yesterday.
- 4:05If you have a little bit longer of a orientation to this asset
- 4:09class, things are looking great. But if you if you're just trying
- 4:12to trade the markets, maybe not on the top.
- 4:14Last night, yeah. Yeah, you jumped in at 124.
- 4:18You're not feeling good right now at 1:18.
- 4:21Yeah. Well, I'm excited for this
- 4:22conversation. Go ahead and get into it, James.
- 4:25Maybe the best place to start would just be if you could share
- 4:28a little bit more about your background.
- 4:29We'd love to hear how. I'd love to hear more about your
- 4:33background professionally at Bloomberg covering the ETF
- 4:36markets. And then if you could weave that
- 4:38into how you got interested in Bitcoin and the broader crypto
- 4:42space, that would be helpful because I did say this on the
- 4:45podcast with Eric, but you and Eric have been really the two go
- 4:49to voices as related to reliable coverage, let's say pre approval
- 4:55of the ETFs in 2023 and then leading up to the approval in
- 4:592024. And since then, the two of you
- 5:02have really put together a lot of great data analysis.
- 5:05And I would certainly recommend following James on X if you're
- 5:08not doing so already, if you do want to be, you know, go further
- 5:11into the conversation we have today.
- 5:12So James, I'll hand it over to you.
- 5:14If you could tell us more about your background.
- 5:16Yeah. Thank you for the kind words.
- 5:17I really do appreciate that. Yeah, let's dive in.
- 5:21So I started at Bloomberg in 2014 full time.
- 5:26I also interned there, but really I started in our data
- 5:29department basically doing any sort of back end infrastructure
- 5:33for anything in the asset management industry thing,
- 5:35mutual funds, ETFs, hedge funds actually was a big part of it.
- 5:38So anything along those lines I'm well versed in.
- 5:42I'm, I've got a couple of certs and stuff to back that up as
- 5:45well. But really the, my research
- 5:48background started in 2017 when I moved to the Bloomberg
- 5:51Intelligence department, which is essentially just Bloomberg's
- 5:53research. And we have like over well over
- 5:55300 people, a lot of people from sell side and buy side on Wall
- 5:58Street covering anything from equity markets in general to
- 6:01specific stocks, specific credit, commodities, you name
- 6:04it. We have a lot of really smart
- 6:07people that I work with, including policy and litigation
- 6:09analysts, which were huge in covering, you know, the
- 6:11Grayscale lawsuit and things like that and what's going on
- 6:14with the Clarity Act and the genius, genius bill and all
- 6:17these different things that are happening.
- 6:18We have, I have like a large swath of people to lean on for
- 6:22things that are out of my expertise.
- 6:23So that brings me back, what is my expertise?
- 6:26Really it's the asset management industry.
- 6:29Think anybody that's launching funds, ETFs, mutual funds, you
- 6:31name it, we're looking at that from like a holistic point of
- 6:35view. Where's money going?
- 6:36What are people interested in? What's going on with flows?
- 6:38It's almost like a little bit of macro.
- 6:40We can get very mile wide, an inch deep.
- 6:42But then when you get to certain products, we also do tend to go
- 6:45mile deep as we have with like, you know, the Bitcoin types of
- 6:47products. But the stuff you guys really
- 6:49care about. I got involved in crypto
- 6:51personally in really if we if we got to go real far back
- 6:56technically I was mining Bitcoin in this in the spring of 2011
- 7:00because of my floor mate in college wanted me to do it
- 7:03because he wanted to buy things on Silk Road.
- 7:05And I was just like whatever you can use my computer and that
- 7:08blew up my computer. I'm pretty sure.
- 7:09I'm pretty sure Bitcoin mining software caused my laptop to
- 7:11implode. I lost like a 12 page paper and
- 7:14a bunch of other stuff, had to get extensions like I so I, my
- 7:17initial information was this is stupid fake Internet money and
- 7:20it destroyed it almost gave me like a bad grade.
- 7:24So I came into a really negative view.
- 7:25I'm like anyone else you went in, this is stupid.
- 7:27OK, sure, I'll do it. And then I'm just like, OK, it's
- 7:30definitely stupid. I'm not interested.
- 7:32I kind of got orange peeled and got interested in all of this.
- 7:36Ironically enough, I was at like trad Phi conference, ETFs,
- 7:40mutual funds run by Morningstar in Chicago.
- 7:42And Kathy Wood, who I had known and her and her right hand man
- 7:47Tom were basically in this side room at this conference.
- 7:51And they were talking about Bitcoin and how the the future
- 7:53of it. And they had written a white
- 7:55paper in 2016 with Arthur Laffer, which for those
- 7:58listening who don't know it is he's like a legendary economist,
- 8:00has been involved in many Republican administrations.
- 8:03He has a lot. He has something called the
- 8:04Laffer Curve that's like named after him because of like with
- 8:07stuff to do with taxes. Basically, the more you tax
- 8:10people, not necessarily the greater increase you're going to
- 8:13get in in tax receipts. So he's like this famous guy and
- 8:16he saw he's like in his 80s now, I think, or at least his 70s.
- 8:20And back then he was even a believer in Bitcoin to some
- 8:22extent. So she was speaking about this
- 8:24white paper. So technically it's Arc Kathy
- 8:27Wood and Arthur Laffer that got me to like, OK, maybe this fake
- 8:30Internet money was something real.
- 8:32And that was September of 2016. So that's when I personally
- 8:35started going down the rabbit hole, didn't really buy much.
- 8:38I didn't really buy go into the rabbit hole deeply enough to
- 8:41fully understand and become a full believer in this space
- 8:44until, you know, crypto was running up in the summer of
- 8:472017. And that's when I joined BI and
- 8:49I reported to Eric Belchinus, who you said was on the show
- 8:51already, obviously, and his side was the ETS and asset
- 8:54management. I also reported to Mike Mcglone,
- 8:56who's also kind of well known if you if you pay attention to
- 8:59crypto in this space, he's our commodities analyst.
- 9:01He was like, we need to cover crypto.
- 9:02Do you know anything about crypto?
- 9:03I was like, oh boy, do I like I'm trading these shit coins.
- 9:06I'm doing all this stuff in the side because at the time, our
- 9:09compliance didn't care, which unfortunately is no longer the
- 9:11case. So yeah, we started up our
- 9:13coverage and some of us like one O 1, what is a blockchain?
- 9:16What is mining? What is proof of work like all
- 9:19these really simple things. So yeah, I've been doing it
- 9:23professionally since then. And from there I kind of became
- 9:26like the expert on the Grayscale trusts.
- 9:28I was doing a lot of research because I covered closed end
- 9:30funds and the Grayscale trusts were very similar to that,
- 9:32discounts and efficiencies, premiums.
- 9:35And so I've been doing this professionally since 2017.
- 9:38But for the most part, as you mentioned, like most people
- 9:40don't know me until either what we called the Bitcoin futures
- 9:44getting approved in 2021. That's when we got, I started
- 9:48getting a bigger following. And the real following obviously
- 9:50came as we were very bullish and calling for one, Grayscale to
- 9:53win their lawsuit against the SEC and two, for the Bitcoin
- 9:57ETFs to launch. And that's basically what most
- 9:59people know me for. That was long winded.
- 10:02I apologize, but it's. It's a great summer.
- 10:05It also gives a lot of insights into Bloomberg being ahead of
- 10:09the game from a research and education perspective, because
- 10:12it's still like this today. But back in 2018 specifically
- 10:16that Bloomberg, I think was the only mainstream, you know,
- 10:20representation of understanding anywhere near what was happening
- 10:22in Bitcoin and and digital assets in general.
- 10:24I had this like previous life for a short stint at a firm
- 10:27called the block. This is when very early days
- 10:29when they started and that was the the angle.
- 10:32It was like, you know, research for institutional investors and
- 10:36we remember looking and then the news that coming out, it was
- 10:39either coin desk, the block and then everyone else would talk
- 10:42about digital assets. But it would be anybody knowing
- 10:45that the sector would be like this is all just like garbage.
- 10:48But Bloomberg really had kind of a deep understanding of the the
- 10:51market and then it's naturally grown since there are from
- 10:54there. I would also say like that's
- 10:58from people pushing it internally top down.
- 11:01They didn't, they were like, OK to cover it from a news
- 11:03perspective. But like really even still to
- 11:06this day, Bloomberg isn't really a huge believer in this space.
- 11:09They're kind of just covering it because it's, it's a huge demand
- 11:12source and clients are asking for it.
- 11:13But for the most part, it's not from like in many cases,
- 11:17Bloomberg obviously responding to client demand, but also
- 11:19they're like trying to predict what's happening and trying to
- 11:21get in front of it and invest in spaces.
- 11:23And like, this is not a space that Bloomberg has invested in
- 11:25at all. We have like trading volume, not
- 11:28even trading volume. We have prices that are really
- 11:30awesome. Like we can see intraday pricing
- 11:32across like a whole bunch of exchanges.
- 11:33We have great stuff like that. But when you start getting like
- 11:36metrics like actually understanding a blockchain,
- 11:38active addresses, revenues, fees, you name it, what we don't
- 11:42have any of that on there. There is no investment
- 11:44whatsoever in doing that aside from allowing third party people
- 11:47to put their stuff on the terminal.
- 11:48So it was kind of like from a media news perspective, they're
- 11:52going to cover it, but they never there was number real
- 11:54investment from like the actual terminal side of things.
- 11:56For the most part, there's like been bits and starts.
- 11:58So like, oh, we're going to do it.
- 11:59And then oh, we're not doing this at all.
- 12:01And it's funny, like usually when they lean in over the last
- 12:04three years, they leaned in pretty heavy.
- 12:05Like in end of 2017, early 2018, they're like, oh, we need to
- 12:08start doing this. And then they did the same thing
- 12:10in 2021, but they leaned out in like 20/22/23.
- 12:15And now what they're starting to like, oh, maybe we should do
- 12:16this again. So if you ever see Bloomberg
- 12:19hiring a bunch of crypto specific people and stuff, that
- 12:21might be a sign of the top is, is what I would say.
- 12:24Sell all the corn if you see that happen.
- 12:27Yeah, yeah, that's, that's interesting, James.
- 12:29And, and I think to be fair to your firm and to many of the
- 12:31other traditional finance firms out there, I'm of the mindset
- 12:36that there really weren't many options to get involved.
- 12:39I mean, your business is a little bit different on like the
- 12:42market intelligence news research side.
- 12:44But for the firms that are actually offering product prior
- 12:47to the space that you cover with the ETFs launching in 2024,
- 12:52there were very few avenues for people to get exposure through
- 12:55traditional rails. And so I almost just think of
- 12:58like 2024 to present, call it 18 months or so have really been
- 13:03just the start of the unlock for traditional finance to start
- 13:05bridging the gap into, you know, Bitcoin and digital assets.
- 13:09And I'm curious to hear your thoughts.
- 13:11I do want to get into this quarter in particular because
- 13:14people like to hear topical and what's going on.
- 13:16But I would just love to hear your perspective since you were
- 13:19at the forefront of it from pre approval to the approval in
- 13:222024. And particularly if you could
- 13:25just walk us through kind of your expectations covering the
- 13:29space for a while prior to the approval and launch in January
- 13:322024 to where we are today. Have things exceeded
- 13:36expectations, met them, you know not met them.
- 13:39Just would love to hear your thoughts on the demand that
- 13:42we've seen and interest in the past 18 months.
- 13:45Yeah, I mean, anybody saying that they didn't exceed their
- 13:48demands is a liar or just a crazy Uber Bitcoin bulls
- 13:53psychopath. I guess this is what I would say
- 13:54like we were very bullish. We were very bullish even before
- 13:58they were getting approved, they were going to be approved and
- 14:00had the potential to be the biggest launch of all time.
- 14:02And I can't tell you how many trad fi people who like there's
- 14:05a lot of people that just hate this entire space.
- 14:07They hate everything about it. They don't like a lot of the
- 14:10people, they don't like what it stands for.
- 14:12They don't believe in anything that's happening.
- 14:14And so the, every time we were putting out bullish pieces on
- 14:17our, what we saw for demand, which again vastly exceeded
- 14:21anything we were saying. I mean, this is, these are the,
- 14:24this is the most successful launch of all time.
- 14:26I mean, these products have 130 plus billion dollars in them.
- 14:30They have taken in $55 billion. The Bitcoin ETFs alone, I mean,
- 14:35they're, they're like in a world all their own, no matter how you
- 14:38slice this. So one, we had very high
- 14:41expectations and the ETFs exceeded them both from a volume
- 14:44perspective and assets perspective, a flows
- 14:47perspective. Like no matter how you look at
- 14:49this, these things have done exceptionally well.
- 14:51Part of that has to do with, you know, the they launched, a lot
- 14:55of demand came in, the price went up.
- 14:56So that's more about the asset side of things.
- 14:58But price doesn't matter for flows.
- 15:00I mean, theoretically higher price and momentum could bring
- 15:02in more money. But like when you think about
- 15:05assets in a fund, a lot of people don't realize this, but
- 15:07there's two things that go into the AUM of the fund, right?
- 15:10It's new money coming in that's flows, but it's also the value,
- 15:14the underlying. So like $54 billion has come
- 15:16into the space on a net basis since the launch in January of
- 15:192024. But again, these have over $130
- 15:21billion in assets, right? So the difference there is one
- 15:25money that was already in there from the Grayscale products to
- 15:27some extent, but also the other difference is the price
- 15:30appreciation of Bitcoin. So, yeah, I mean, no matter how
- 15:33you select this is this has been a massive success.
- 15:36And I think we're like basically I think we accelerated things a
- 15:40lot faster because I always saw a lot of demand coming from the
- 15:42advisor space and the hedge fund space, but more so from the
- 15:46advisor. I think that's the next big leg
- 15:48up. And I think we're kind of rather
- 15:51early innings in that, in that part of things.
- 15:54That's what makes this conversation interesting and
- 15:57just the market in general. And you probably feel this in
- 16:00what I mean, this conversation is a lot of our clientele and
- 16:03listeners and growing or somewhat native to the space and
- 16:07they understand kind of the different ways to get exposure,
- 16:10why they would make those trade-offs.
- 16:11But historically, this asset class had been bottoms up.
- 16:14And so there's a strong reason where different financial firms
- 16:18or legacy firms kind of hated it because it's like, how do I make
- 16:20money? I thought it was a Ponzi
- 16:22forever. I still think it's a Ponzi, but
- 16:23my clients want it and it's growing like crazy.
- 16:25It's the best performing asset of all time.
- 16:28So what do I do and then how do I make money?
- 16:31And the ETF's to your point, I think surpassed everyone's
- 16:34thought, but it also showed because forgot who it was, it
- 16:37was somebody very senior at BlackRock referencing that they
- 16:40kind of went in a roundabout way of like why would somebody want
- 16:43an ETF? Because you could just buy
- 16:44Bitcoin and Cash app. But then the recognition that
- 16:46most people don't feel confident in doing that the ETF and
- 16:48BlackRock and these other names gave that air cover for real
- 16:52material exposure. But then the other side of it,
- 16:55as you referenced before the pod, we'll we'll talk about here
- 16:57is like the basket of goods like the basket of good mirror is
- 17:01what Tratify loves to make money basket of you know, the other
- 17:03all coins. But you can go back test for 15
- 17:05years they've done this. Bitwise is probably the most
- 17:07prominent and if you look at that versus Bitcoin, Bitcoin
- 17:10always just outpaces. So it's going to be an
- 17:13interesting dynamic to see how Tratify tries to create
- 17:16structure products. But traditionally the the
- 17:20structure product, that one was just spot Bitcoin exposure or an
- 17:23ETF like Grayscale versus a basket.
- 17:26We're just curious how you how you think about that.
- 17:27And then like there's just natural inherent friction going
- 17:30to be built in today and then growing forward.
- 17:32But the market's still so early, they don't know, they don't know
- 17:35this. So they'll go into the XRP top
- 17:3710 weighted and then on a long enough people will look at it
- 17:41and be like, wait, what was I buying?
- 17:42When the next cycle, if we're still in cycles wakes up and is
- 17:45like what was ton coin for good for?
- 17:49Yeah, I mean, so the, the main thing I would pull out of what
- 17:53you just said is, is really like this gave cover.
- 17:57Like if you look at Bitwise was doing surveys, there was a bunch
- 18:00of other places doing surveys of advisors and investors of like,
- 18:05do you want to invest in crypto? Do you want to invest in
- 18:07Bitcoin? If you're not investing now,
- 18:09what would you need to see? And almost every single time it
- 18:12was 1 regulatory clarity, they were concerned about whether or
- 18:15not the government was going to go after it, and they viewed
- 18:18that as a downside risk. But the other one that sometimes
- 18:21actually I'll beat that regulatory clarity side was they
- 18:23wanted an ETF essentially, they wanted a wrapper that they felt
- 18:26comfortable getting exposure to. And that's what the ETF did
- 18:29really, right. So it basically took this D Phi
- 18:31decentralized crypto asset in Bitcoin and wrapped in an ETF, a
- 18:36structure that advisors love, investors love.
- 18:38It's like the ETF itself is a technology.
- 18:41It's an extremely successful wrapper for providing asset
- 18:44management because it basically takes in everyone.
- 18:46So like most other fun wrappers or structures before this, they
- 18:50kind of differentiated things out.
- 18:52So you had like the high net worth, people could get certain
- 18:54aspects and the the retail investors had to pay up a little
- 18:58bit and they got other things. An ETF like your grandmother, a
- 19:01hedge fund, an institution, an endowment.
- 19:04We all are dealing with the same thing.
- 19:06And it basically brings everyone together and it creates like
- 19:08this flywheel of liquidity and benefits and low cost and like,
- 19:12although everyone playing in the same pool has a lot of benefits.
- 19:15So that's what the ETF wrapper did for Bitcoin itself.
- 19:19And if you look at it, it's actually kind of impacting spot
- 19:21Bitcoin to an extent because that's where a lot of
- 19:24institutions are using to get their exposure because in many
- 19:27cases, those institutions are not allowed to touch a commodity
- 19:29like Bitcoin. So by wrapping it in an ETF, it
- 19:32becomes a security that a lot of other institutions are allowed
- 19:34to touch. And the other thing you said
- 19:36that I think it's critical that a lot of people, normies in the
- 19:40Bitcoin world and crypto world don't understand Larry Fink and
- 19:43BlackRock launching a Bitcoin ETF, you know, Invesco, that
- 19:47gives a lot of cover for these advisors and investors to
- 19:50allocators to like actually allocate to the space.
- 19:53They were full throated endorsers of this.
- 19:55We always thought BlackRock was going to launch one of these
- 19:57things at some point. But if you had asked us before
- 19:59BlackRock filed, I would have told you they're not going to be
- 20:02in the first wave. They're going to wait and then
- 20:03they're going to jump in and they're going to launch their
- 20:05own product. I did not.
- 20:07I was not, I was shocked when Larry Fink that summer that they
- 20:11filed. Basically went on in a full
- 20:14throated rigging endorsement of Bitcoin as a hedge against
- 20:17currency debasement. A store value asset like that
- 20:20was not on my bingo card. So I think all of that kind of
- 20:23gives cover for other people to allocate to the space.
- 20:26And as more and more really smart, well respected
- 20:29individuals are taking this more seriously, I think it's forcing
- 20:32other people to be like, OK, maybe those preconceived notions
- 20:35from 20/16/2017, even 20/19 were not the right notions and
- 20:41they're kind of reconsidering it.
- 20:42But again, as I said, I hinted desert, there's plenty of other
- 20:44people that are still stuck in like FTX is a fraud, it's all a
- 20:47scam. This is just a Ponzi scheme and
- 20:50they have not done any due diligence to understand how
- 20:52these blockchains work or consensus protocols.
- 20:55They they have. There's there's no deeper dive.
- 20:58Yeah, that James, I was going to be part of my follow up question
- 21:02was like you sort of you referenced this, this natural
- 21:04version from the the traditional finance person.
- 21:07And I sort of feel this viscerally from my prior life
- 21:10and private banking where there's I think there's a few
- 21:13different components. But I'm curious like what you
- 21:15attribute it most to? Is it the lack of education and
- 21:18actually taking the time to understand what these things
- 21:20are? Is it the conflation with
- 21:22broader crypto and, you know, people calling this a Ponzi?
- 21:27Or is it is it sort of this another element of like this
- 21:31error sophistication of like a person who's, you know, made a
- 21:34lot of money in Tradfy, done their own research and
- 21:38investments in various other asset classes.
- 21:40And because they missed it, like they've heard about Bitcoin a
- 21:43few different times, but they've never actually allocated.
- 21:45And so there's this natural bias to to think it's still going to
- 21:48fail because you have no exposure.
- 21:50I'm curious, like which of those elements do you attribute much
- 21:52most of the sort of tradfy normie brain aversion to to
- 21:56Bitcoin generally? So I think it's all of those
- 21:59things. The one that you didn't say that
- 22:01I think is critical here is kind of the Vanguard reasoning, which
- 22:04there's a lot of investors. If you're a CFA, like you value
- 22:07something based on its cash flows and its earnings and
- 22:09ability to produce, you know, cash flow producing assets, like
- 22:13that's how you value things. Dividends is it have, does it
- 22:15have earnings? And Bitcoin has none of that.
- 22:18So a lot of people like there's also plenty of people out there
- 22:20that don't believe in gold as an investment, like fine, use it as
- 22:23jewelry, use it in technology, what have you, but they don't
- 22:26believe it as an investment. A lot of those types of trad Phi
- 22:28traditional investors. I used to be one of those
- 22:30people. That was my view for a long time
- 22:32because like I'm focused on things that are producing value
- 22:35and cash flow and income and Bitcoin doesn't do that.
- 22:38So it requires like, if you don't believe in gold and you
- 22:41would not put gold in your portfolio, you are way less
- 22:44subject to adding something like Bitcoin to your portfolio.
- 22:48But like, the, the, the facts of like, currency debasement that
- 22:51have happened, what gold's performance, it, it doesn't
- 22:54meant there's nothing that gets through to them.
- 22:55And I think the other part of it is like, let's be real.
- 22:58There is a lot of fraud and BS. And like, negative people, when
- 23:02you have an asset that returns and as strong as it had, this
- 23:05has been over the last few years, you're gonna attract some
- 23:08pretty bad people, people that are trying to scam people out of
- 23:11money. And when you have a preconceived
- 23:13notion that this place is filled with fraud and manipulation, and
- 23:15then you see stories about fraud and manipulation, your initial
- 23:19reaction is like, see, you're on my fire.
- 23:21Yeah, my theories are confirmed. And then to your other point, I
- 23:25I think this is, this isn't, I'm not the first person to say this
- 23:27by any chance, But if you were somebody on the news side or
- 23:30research side that covered this early and maybe you didn't
- 23:33dismiss it or you did dismiss it and said it was stupid.
- 23:35It was Beanie Babies, what have you.
- 23:37And then you watch it go up from $1000 or under $1000 to
- 23:41$124,000, you are like more inclined to hate it even more.
- 23:45Like you're just like, I had the chance to buy this thing.
- 23:48I thought it was stupid. So I can't be wrong.
- 23:50It's a lot harder to do what Larry Fink did.
- 23:53Larry Fink called Bitcoin an index of money laundering in
- 23:562018. And like, was this negative on
- 23:58crypto in general as recently as 20/20?
- 24:00He was kind of one of those blockchain, not Bitcoin or
- 24:03blockchain not crypto type of people.
- 24:05And he did the work and he had the frame of reference to kind
- 24:08of change his mind. It's a lot harder to do that.
- 24:11And if you talk to a lot of people that are full throated
- 24:13believers in Bitcoin, myself included, they go from this is a
- 24:17joke, this is stupid, it's a Ponzi scheme, whatever reason
- 24:20you come up with. And then like they come back to
- 24:22it and they're like, actually maybe this kind of makes sense
- 24:24and they kind of rewire some things.
- 24:26And that's, I think that's how a lot of people are.
- 24:29So there's probably a lot of people right now that were on
- 24:31that initial path that are rethinking it again, in my point
- 24:34of view. So I mean, there's a whole host
- 24:36of reasons and also like, let's just be clear, crypto,
- 24:38blockchain, Bitcoin, it's it, it goes after Wall Street and a lot
- 24:43of these people's livelihoods and how they've lived their
- 24:45lives and stuff like that. So the kind of to what you were
- 24:47talking about, people have had success in the environment that
- 24:50we've had over the last 5050 ish years and they think that's the
- 24:53right way to do things and anything new, you know, I don't
- 24:57like it. Yeah.
- 24:58Just just really quickly on that topic because you hit on two
- 25:01things that I don't think it gets talked about enough.
- 25:04And to the extent you can share, because we don't know for
- 25:06certain, but like how much letter of Inc actually believes
- 25:08in it versus talking the book of an asset that has, you know,
- 25:12potential to grow and having a big market because we saw the
- 25:15ESG, you know, quick pivot. And similar to what you just
- 25:18said, what Larry Fink says has a lot of undertones.
- 25:22To your point, if you go down long enough rabbit hole, when
- 25:24you think about eating into other passive funds and just
- 25:27natural referencing, you know, a debase currency changes the cost
- 25:31of capital or the return on capital.
- 25:33So a lot of the traditional investments BlackRock would be
- 25:35pushing in front. If you go down that progression,
- 25:37it don't make any don't make much sense.
- 25:39Just curious, like, do you think he's thought that far through or
- 25:41these are just the talking points?
- 25:43Because he knows that's the the the sentiment where we're going
- 25:46and that's how you're going to get the flows and show black
- 25:48rocks fully behind those. Yeah, I mean black.
- 25:51I mean, I don't know this for sure.
- 25:53I've never met Larry in person, but he would not have gone on
- 25:57Fox business or news shows and said those things in full
- 26:01throated ringing endorsement of Bitcoin as a hedge against
- 26:03currency debasement and a hedge against inflation and things
- 26:05like that. If he didn't believe them, like
- 26:07there's no way he he, there's plenty of products he's launched
- 26:10that he's not an investor in or a buyer of and he's he's not he,
- 26:13he would say, we want to put pride these for our clients.
- 26:15There's a lot of clients that want this demand.
- 26:17There were many ways for him to go about saying we launched this
- 26:20because there's a lot of demand. We see a lot of growth here.
- 26:24Again, ESG is like the the the caveat here, like you said, he
- 26:27there, he's very full. Third, I think he really does
- 26:29believe in the ESG principles. He's just realized that it's
- 26:32like it's too much of 1/3 reel topic for for BlackRock as a
- 26:35company. They have plenty of people who
- 26:37are against some of the ESG ideals that are massive clients
- 26:39of theirs and I think he's stepped away from that.
- 26:42So I guess like I think he really did change his mind.
- 26:45I, I've talked to people inside BlackRock.
- 26:47There was a, this was not like a everyone agreed that that we
- 26:50were going to do this. There was factions, there was
- 26:52people fighting that people don't like this, didn't like
- 26:54this within BlackRock. And believe me, if Larry Fink
- 26:56did not believe the stuff he was saying or did not believe in
- 26:59Bitcoin, they would not have been filed.
- 27:01When they did, they could have waited until these things and
- 27:03saw what the demand looked like and then jumped in and tried to
- 27:05compete. They went in early.
- 27:07So I'm, I'm fully in the camp that Larry believes what he's
- 27:10saying and I think a lot of people at BlackRock believe in
- 27:14it too. Is it also beneficial that it's
- 27:16a huge growing part of their revenue stream?
- 27:19Is it one of the most successful ETFs they've ever had?
- 27:22Is that make it even more endorsement from them
- 27:24internally? Probably.
- 27:25But it doesn't really matter at the end of the day.
- 27:26I would, I would heavily bet on the fact that he believes what
- 27:29he's saying. It's not just a gimmick.
- 27:31I think it's, it obviously is helpful to his bottom line that
- 27:35they have a growing asset base and, and fee revenue from this
- 27:38thing. But I I don't think it's just
- 27:39solely from that. Hope you're enjoying the
- 27:42episode. If you are, if you could please
- 27:43leave a like, I'd really appreciate it.
- 27:45If you're on YouTube, subscribe, leave a comment, listen to the
- 27:49comments. I really enjoy reading them.
- 27:51So if you can leave a comment, good or bad, I would appreciate
- 27:55it. You know, I would always improve
- 27:58the show. And so if you leave constructive
- 28:01criticism, that helps to inform better episodes going forward.
- 28:05And if you like the show, I always appreciate reading that
- 28:09you did like it. And so if you can leave a
- 28:10comment, that's great. And then on Spotify, Apple, if
- 28:13you could just leave a five star review, that really helps.
- 28:17I mean, we're trying to get this message out here.
- 28:19We show up every single week. We're booking guests, we're
- 28:22editing the show, we're preparing for the show, we're
- 28:23distributing it. We're doing all these things.
- 28:26And it does take a lot of time, but we enjoy doing it and we do
- 28:29it because we know people find value in it.
- 28:31And if you can please just show a token of your appreciation, a,
- 28:34like comment please, goes a long way.
- 28:38And, you know, I it makes my day.
- 28:39I like to respond to those comments.
- 28:41So thank you in advance for doing that.
- 28:43And I hope you enjoyed the rest of the episode.
- 28:46Yeah, I mean, James, I love that you're fired up right now
- 28:49because I'm kind of fired up myself.
- 28:51And there are a lot of things you said in the past five
- 28:54minutes that I wanted to riff on for a little bit.
- 28:58And I was just. I was thinking about this last
- 29:00night actually, because it is remarkable to me that every time
- 29:05I post on LinkedIn, I have pretty much the entire if the
- 29:09post makes it out of escape velocity and gets like more than
- 29:12a few thousand impressions. Everyone in the comments section
- 29:14is just telling me how much of an idiot I am and it's it's
- 29:18honestly hilarious. And I've been thinking more
- 29:21about this. I posted something on my
- 29:22personal newsletter because Michael doesn't want me to take
- 29:24the spicy takes of the business newsletter.
- 29:26But the whole idea that Bitcoin's a Ponzi scheme is
- 29:30actually just of the fact that the US dollar debt based system
- 29:34is a Ponzi scheme and Bitcoin is merely a reflection of that.
- 29:37And so I want to go on record and say that because if you look
- 29:39at the chart of the federal debt, that is clearly the Ponzi
- 29:44scheme. And then if you juxtapose that
- 29:46to Bitcoins price over time, a lot of bitcoins price and
- 29:49clearly the demand for a scarce asset like Bitcoin exists for
- 29:53the most part, I'm not going to say only, but for the most part
- 29:56because of government irresponsibility and the fact
- 29:59that the dollar needs to be continuously debased.
- 30:01So I just challenge people on the fact that perhaps the system
- 30:05you're already living in is the Ponzi scheme and Bitcoin is
- 30:08merely just a way to kind of step outside of that.
- 30:11And you don't necessarily need to react on that.
- 30:13But it's just kind of frustrating to me that we're
- 30:16still in 2025 and the same, the same, you know, the same
- 30:20discourse is happening that was happening like 7-8 years ago.
- 30:24The other thing to that as well is I wanted to touch on the gold
- 30:27and the, the Bitcoin thing. It was something we wanted to
- 30:29talk about. And I came from traditional
- 30:32finance background as well, James.
- 30:34And I remember in the investment strategy calls, I worked on the
- 30:37alternative side of the business, but there was an
- 30:39investment strategy call for all the advisors to listen into and
- 30:43gold was rarely ever mentioned. And this is back, let's call it
- 30:462020-2021 gold was barely mentioned outside of if you had
- 30:50a bearish view on something or if you had a bullish view on
- 30:53another thing, you may want to have like a 1% allocation, 2%
- 30:57allocation. But what I think is happening,
- 31:00and I'm curious if you, if you see this the same way is that
- 31:04we're getting disconnected from the fundamentals, right?
- 31:06So asset prices are all time highs across the board.
- 31:10And it's because we've, the past five years in particular, we've
- 31:13driven into more of a macro focus market versus micro.
- 31:17And so gold and Bitcoin really stand as macro assets in that
- 31:21context. And this is the first year ever
- 31:24that Bitcoin and gold sit at #1 and #2 compared to all asset
- 31:29classes across the board. And so I just wonder if we're
- 31:32kind of at an inflection point here.
- 31:34I wonder if you see the same, if you want to step into like the
- 31:36precious metals ring for a second, if you have similar
- 31:39thoughts around precious metals, maybe making it more into, you
- 31:43know, the traditional portfolio allocation or if you maybe
- 31:46disagree on that and think that Bitcoin and digital assets kind
- 31:49of eat away at that demand. Yeah, I mean, so first thing I'd
- 31:54say on, on what you started with is like the problem, like can
- 31:58you talk to certain people like just admit you were wrong?
- 32:01Like people have been calling for the collapse.
- 32:03Like if people have been calling for the collapse of Bitcoin and
- 32:06crypto since Bitcoin was under $1000, right.
- 32:08Like at some point, like if you've been bearish and
- 32:11negative, these people still calling it a Ponzi scheme, still
- 32:14calling it a joke, said multiple 80% corrections and they're
- 32:17doing touchdown dances when that happens.
- 32:19And like, yet the trajectory is one way.
- 32:21So like the same thing happens with analysts covering different
- 32:24markets, equity analysts and stuff in, in my world.
- 32:27Like you called for one thing and you were wrong and they just
- 32:30kind of changed their call or like alter their argument rather
- 32:34than like, OK, I was wrong about this.
- 32:36I got XY and Z wrong. But I still think blah, blah,
- 32:38blah. But that's not what most people
- 32:40do. They just kind of like move on
- 32:41and act like they were right. I mean, Peter Schiff is a clear
- 32:44example. He'll highlight the fact that
- 32:45gold is outperforming Bitcoin over whatever time period
- 32:48recently. And then like, OK, add three
- 32:50years to that. Like it's not even comparable.
- 32:53So yeah, I think more people would benefit from just like
- 32:56admitting they were wrong, which is impossible for people to do
- 32:59because when you're very publicly anti and think this is
- 33:02stupid and don't really do your due diligence to understand
- 33:05exactly how this works. I find that very many people
- 33:08that are super bearish or negative and think this whole
- 33:10place is a joke, have no idea what a blockchain is, have no
- 33:13idea what goes into it, have no idea all the research that went
- 33:16into this in the 80s and 90s and early 2000s.
- 33:19Like they have no idea. They just think it's somebody
- 33:21made-up this thing in the Internet and it's stupid.
- 33:23They don't understand the value adds from what's been created.
- 33:26So that's the first part. As far as gold and silver and
- 33:29precious metals and and Bitcoin, I think part of it is that
- 33:33people are, look, let's be honest, people have been worried
- 33:37about that. You can go back to the 1970s and
- 33:391980s and people are complaining about the debt and the
- 33:41trajectory we were on. They're adding the debt double s
- 33:44every 10 years roughly. Like it kind of has always been
- 33:47a problem. I think this is one thing that
- 33:50Bitcoiners over index on. Like people like to point out
- 33:54debt to GDP, right? We're at 130% right now and
- 33:59we're worried about inflation. I mean, look at Japan, Japan's
- 34:01too. I don't even know what the
- 34:03number is. It's way higher than whatever
- 34:05our thing is. And like, if you look at debt as
- 34:07like in the asset base underlying it, like we're OK,
- 34:11it's not that bad. The debt isn't good.
- 34:13The trajectory you're on is pretty bad.
- 34:15I will not say we're like super healthy, but we're also not like
- 34:19about to go through hyperinflation in my opinion.
- 34:21And if you talk to a lot of economists, is the way they do
- 34:22it, Like if you look at it like debt to GDP is a stock to flow
- 34:25ratio, right? You're looking at something from
- 34:27the balance sheet comparing to the income statement.
- 34:30So a better comparison would be like, what are the assets of the
- 34:32US economy and private industry and US individuals?
- 34:36And like, if you look at it like that, OK, the debt is really
- 34:38high, but so are our assets, which is like, I feel like you
- 34:41need to always kind of put a denominator on there.
- 34:43And obviously, again, trajectory is not right, but I think that
- 34:46is kind of over indexed still. People are getting more
- 34:48concerned. I think Bitcoin itself has
- 34:50brought this up to the front more so all the printing of
- 34:53money that we saw in 2020 and 2021 has livened up people's
- 34:58ability to understand what's going on with inflation.
- 35:01So I don't know what puts that genie back in the bottle, but I
- 35:03think the topic of Bitcoin and Bitcoiners talking about this
- 35:06has driven up people's interest in, you know, hedging against
- 35:09currency debasement, hedge against inflation, types of
- 35:11risks. And yeah, so I think they go
- 35:15kind of hand in hand. I think they're kind of, they're
- 35:17part of the same trade. I view them as complementary
- 35:19assets in a portfolio. A lot of people like to think
- 35:21they're supplementary. You need to have one or the
- 35:23other. I think like gold is way more
- 35:25stable, like it's going to hold value a much longer time period.
- 35:27Theoretically, it's not going to go through these massive ups and
- 35:30downs that Bitcoin is bitcoins, more like gold as a teenager
- 35:33will often say, or like I view it as a call option on store
- 35:36value asset. It could go down like a lot,
- 35:38even to 0, maybe not to zero anymore.
- 35:40But that was my argument in 2017.
- 35:41If it's like a call option on a store value asset, so there is a
- 35:45lot more risk, there's a lot of volatility, but that risk and
- 35:47that volatility is coming down over time.
- 35:49The problem is like as that volatility comes down, like
- 35:52theoretically lower risk, lower reward.
- 35:54So we shouldn't see the same sort of like massive upside
- 35:57returns over that time period. So I'm not somebody that thinks
- 36:00like we're going for the collapse of the US dollar and
- 36:02the US economy. I know some people, very
- 36:05prominent Bitcoiners do. I also am an American, so I
- 36:08really hope that doesn't happen. I'd much prefer like a slow
- 36:11grind up. They continue debasing things at
- 36:132 to 4% a year with inflation and and money printing.
- 36:17And I if you're holding Bitcoin or gold jerk and you're not
- 36:19going to be subject to that. And honestly, the other part of
- 36:22it is a lot of Bitcoiners miss like they talk about holding the
- 36:24dollar. Like if you just held
- 36:26treasuries, you'd be ahead like over any time period for the
- 36:28most part. That's again, using CPI, which I
- 36:31know some people have problems with CPI is maybe understated
- 36:34versus like what real inflation is.
- 36:36But the other part of it is like I maybe it's because I'm from, I
- 36:40have an understanding of finance, but like I never
- 36:42thought I would keep money in dollars in a checking account.
- 36:45Like I put my excess savings into something that is going to
- 36:48earn assets and take a risk, S&P 500, things like that.
- 36:51So like, it's not like you couldn't avoid the debasement in
- 36:54any way whatsoever. It's just that a lot of people
- 36:56just don't understand what's happened to the dollar and
- 36:59aren't putting their money in, in, you know, cash flowing
- 37:01assets. Yeah, there there's a couple
- 37:03things there. I think there's a different
- 37:05lines of the curve on coming from finance and then some of
- 37:09those conceived notion because with in a kind way what you
- 37:13shared is a little bit of a fallacy because not everyone a
- 37:16understands finance has access to S&P and shouldn't actually
- 37:19have it. You don't, you shouldn't have to
- 37:20become, if you're a doctor, physician or a firefighter, have
- 37:24to understand that your money that you already put at risk
- 37:26needs to be put. That's like the definition of
- 37:28money and why gold is money for hundreds and thousands of years.
- 37:31Which ties back to some of the colleagues and peers you
- 37:33referenced where their antagonistic nature to Bitcoin
- 37:36is perceived or comes from gold because you reference they don't
- 37:38even believe in gold. And like you said, they're the
- 37:41same. It's the same thing.
- 37:42It's bitcoins, gold with wings. But going back to what Jackson
- 37:48said about debt, debt and inflation are the same or
- 37:51different sides of the same coin.
- 37:53And the debt, to your point, is almost worthless talking about
- 37:56because all people have heard about is forever and it's
- 37:59ephemeral. It's out there and the numbers
- 38:01go from hundreds of billions to trillions of dollars.
- 38:04The thing that isn't ephemeral is not being able to either buy
- 38:07your jet, buy the vacation more expensive, your retirement being
- 38:11reduced because of inflation, or ultimately not being able to buy
- 38:13eggs for your family. And that's the key part of the
- 38:16other side of the debt because at the end of the debt day, the
- 38:19debt doesn't, it doesn't exist in a vacuum that as the debt
- 38:25increases, you have to service more debt to keep it from
- 38:27delevering. And then that's where inflation
- 38:29rears its head. And ultimately we're at escape
- 38:32velocity there. And that's where the, the, the
- 38:35debasement trade comes in. And if you look at, yes, the, we
- 38:39talked about this a lot like the CPI, I'll hedge and say it's,
- 38:43it's carefully gas lighting. I will, I will.
- 38:47You know, if you look at anything you buy, it's
- 38:49definitely over 2 1/2% year over year anything that you want to
- 38:52buy. And the point being is you can
- 38:55start to make the case that prior to post 2020, real versus
- 39:00nominal returns from like the S&P or now you're in the in the
- 39:03block or you're in the negative because of inflation post 2020,
- 39:07the amount of money supply that the S&P, if it's eight to 10%.
- 39:12And this is where the gold Bitcoin trade in the past five
- 39:14years, gold and Bitcoin have outperformed the S&P.
- 39:16And specifically that even just this year that that's that like
- 39:20narrative of moving back to sound assets that just have a
- 39:24reduced inflation, right? Gold to what 2 1/2 percent
- 39:26Bitcoin, wherever inflation year over year is what we're seeing
- 39:31sovereigns go to. And then specifically just this
- 39:33past week was Harvard with $100 million plus position sizing.
- 39:37I think that's the narrative we end up going back to is just you
- 39:41just hold a better form of money.
- 39:43And the the interesting thing is all the people in finance, he
- 39:46said referencing don't even understand or believe in gold.
- 39:48And gold is money for hundreds or if not thousands of years.
- 39:51That's just a very like broken structure to build your whole
- 39:55financial career on that. Like I don't believe in gold is
- 39:57anything other than like a a pet rock.
- 40:01Yep, I mean, we would Eric spoke with this last time where we're
- 40:05writing a book and we're like saying gold is a pet rock is
- 40:08like saying a church is just a building.
- 40:10Like there's a lot more to it. And I would make the same
- 40:13argument for Bitcoin as well. The other part I would argue is
- 40:16like the people you're talking, they're very much Keynesian
- 40:19economics believer. I don't know what my the
- 40:22economics framework really is, but even if you had like John
- 40:25Maynard Keynes on here and he looked at what was happening,
- 40:27like the theory with Keynesianism is like, you're
- 40:30going to run a deficit, run it hot to help support the economy.
- 40:33When times are bad, right, the government's going to support
- 40:36the economy. And then when times are good,
- 40:38you're going to go back, you're going to do a little austerity.
- 40:40You're not going to run as hot of a deficit.
- 40:42And like we've just blown that up since 2008.
- 40:46Like we're, we're still like even he would be like we're
- 40:48running at 7% deficit when the economy is ripping.
- 40:51The stocks are great, like all these things, right?
- 40:54So there's plenty to be concerned about with the way
- 40:56things are running. I just also think like people,
- 41:00we, we, people get up and go to work every single day, right?
- 41:04They're they're busting their ass to get ahead in life and
- 41:06like investing in stocks in the broader economy is a way to bet
- 41:10on the US economy to continue doing.
- 41:12It's a bet on people doing stuff and getting up and going to work
- 41:15everyday. And like, I think a lot of
- 41:17bitcoiners like discount, like what that means for a portfolio
- 41:21in the growth over time, right. So I think we, we have this
- 41:25joke. It's like very easy to get
- 41:26orange pill, but it's not easy to get like, I don't know, 7030
- 41:29pilled like people who are it's like you go down this rabbit
- 41:32hole and it's like once you go there, it's hard to come back
- 41:35and realize there actually is value in holding some of these
- 41:37cash producing assets or earnings producing assets.
- 41:41So yeah, I think it's more complex than a lot of people
- 41:45tend to make it out to be, I guess is what I would say.
- 41:50Yeah, I mean, those are all fair points.
- 41:52And I come from that same world, so I understand.
- 41:57I'm kind of like somewhere in the middle.
- 41:58Personally, I'm far above what any normal person would allocate
- 42:02to Bitcoin. I'm just about all in between
- 42:05working in the space and having my savings in it.
- 42:08But I think maybe I'm a little bit more open to the idea that
- 42:13that's not the right choice for a lot of people for many
- 42:15reasons. And the fact is, well, I will
- 42:18agree with you, James, like I do think net, net even since 2020,
- 42:23the if you were dollar cost averaging into the S&P 500, I
- 42:26think you're still net real inflation, but not by much, not
- 42:30by like to the extent people's advisors tell them that they
- 42:33are, not to the extent if they're a self-directed
- 42:34investor, they think that they are.
- 42:36But net net, I still think they're making like marginally a
- 42:39little bit of growth there. But it's just a little bit
- 42:42deceptive in the sense and maybe not intentionally.
- 42:44I think, you know, we're still early in the sense of like
- 42:46advisors even exploring Bitcoin or even gold for that matter
- 42:50within portfolios, right? So they're still, they're in
- 42:53many cases still working from a framework of you do the safe
- 42:57thing, which is you have SBY exposure and you have some
- 43:00amount of fixed income exposure. And then maybe you have some
- 43:03alternative investments as well for if you're like an accredited
- 43:06investor or whatever. But yeah, I mean, I just think
- 43:10that there's still so much misunderstanding about what
- 43:13Bitcoin is. I even saw, it was actually
- 43:16Eric's podcast this week, I saw a clip about the head of JP
- 43:20Morgan Asset Management and he cited a lot of the same things
- 43:23we've already discussed, right? There's no cash flows, it's
- 43:25volatile. I don't think we're going to be
- 43:26offering any asset management products for Bitcoin.
- 43:28So that's one of the largest firms in in the country.
- 43:31So it's still like, you know, first inning or so of people
- 43:34actually coming to terms with what is actually going on here.
- 43:38Yeah. So a few things on that.
- 43:41The wait, I forgot my train of thought.
- 43:43Where was I going with that? You you talked about the first
- 43:48thing you said when you said like you're over indexed.
- 43:50So we're doing a lot of interviews for a book and we're
- 43:53talking a lot of people and like, what is the right
- 43:55allocation to Bitcoin, right? Like asking the question like,
- 43:58OK, you've been orange peeled. Have you ever had have you ever
- 44:006040 peeled somebody? You know, do you ever get people
- 44:02to come back to like fully believe in stocks and whatnot?
- 44:06But what we find, I can't think of a single person, every single
- 44:10person we ask, like, what do you think is a good allocation to
- 44:12invest? The people who answer it will
- 44:15say, you know, 5 percent, 10%. Maybe some people will go much
- 44:19higher. But like Rick Edelman went went
- 44:23pretty high. He's very famous for saying, you
- 44:25know, up to 40% depending on your allocation.
- 44:27But for the most part, people were saying 5 percent, 10%.
- 44:29And then you follow up the question with like, what is your
- 44:31allocation? And they're like, oh, way
- 44:35higher. Like the lowest we heard from
- 44:36people in this space was like 30%.
- 44:38They're recommending clients 5%. A lot of them are even higher
- 44:42than that, like well over 50. Like some of the people Bitcoin
- 44:45podcasters we've interviewed are like basically at 100%.
- 44:47And then they're also levered, if you think about it, because
- 44:49their income is tied to this asset doing well.
- 44:52Like you guys, you're, you're kind of tied to the industry.
- 44:54So even whatever your portfolio allocation is, like your
- 44:56earnings worth and net worth is, it's going to be tied to what
- 44:59this asset does. And like, it's funny, it's like,
- 45:01OK, you're recommending people do this, but you are like way
- 45:04over index because everyone who's in this space is an
- 45:06extremely strong believer. And if you believe Bitcoin could
- 45:09become what a lot of Bitcoiners believe it will be, I mean,
- 45:13you'd be stupid not to be over allocated to this for something
- 45:16else on a, on a market cap basis.
- 45:17The other thing I would say is like people don't realize like
- 45:21the, the, the default allocation to crypto and Bitcoin at this
- 45:24point isn't 0. So like by not allocating at all
- 45:28at this point, I mean it's a 3 trillion plus dollar asset
- 45:30class. Bitcoin itself is over 2
- 45:31trillion. Like if you're, if you're like,
- 45:34or somebody who's an index fund investor, you're just investing
- 45:36in total markets and you're investing in the bond market and
- 45:39equities like the correct allocation.
- 45:41Like if you're just neutral, like the neutral allocation is
- 45:44something so like if you're at zero, you're making an active
- 45:47decision not to participate in this whatsoever.
- 45:49And anything above that is, is also an active decision
- 45:52obviously. And I feel like that also is
- 45:55that that conversation isn't happening yet.
- 45:57Like for the most part people are like, no, we're not off 0,
- 46:00but really like global markets. If you believe in market market
- 46:03cap based investing, you should probably have some sort of
- 46:06allocation to the space. Yeah, I think that's a, a
- 46:09critical point and it, it relates to the Harvard news,
- 46:13right. Because their, their allocation
- 46:14is roughly a in, in my mind, like a market neutral weight,
- 46:170.2% of their portfolio. And if you take Bitcoins market
- 46:21cap as a percentage of the 900 trillion of global asset value,
- 46:25it's right around 0.2%. So I think that that that is a
- 46:28very strong signal of, to exactly your point, the, the
- 46:31default allocation is like at least a market neutral weight.
- 46:34And, and if you're, if you're going to be at zero, you, you
- 46:37better be ready to defend why. And and in reality, like I don't
- 46:41think people have many good reasons as to why they'd still
- 46:44be on zero, at least it with respect to Bitcoin.
- 46:47Yeah, completely agreed. The other thing I would say if
- 46:49we want to get to some of the 13 F stuff, we have to be careful
- 46:53because like there have been situations with endowments or
- 46:55pension funds that have allocated and like that wasn't
- 47:00just like a net long, they were also short futures.
- 47:03It was a basis trade in many instances of other institutions
- 47:05that have invested over time that had big names.
- 47:08And I mean the basis trade is huge in Bitcoin and Ethereum.
- 47:12It's also going to be huge in these other coins, Solana, XRP,
- 47:15like the yields on and just simply doing a basis trade,
- 47:18which for listeners who don't know, you're basically selling
- 47:20the futures contract, whether it's a month out or two months
- 47:23out and you're buying the spot asset.
- 47:24And most institutions can't touch the inlying assets.
- 47:27So to touch the spot asset, they're just buying the
- 47:29underlying ETF. And the annualized yield on
- 47:32these things like for, for Bitcoin at one point in December
- 47:35earlier this year after Trump was elected was like up near
- 47:3820%. So like there's a lot of
- 47:41institutions that will throw a ton of money.
- 47:43So that's why we saw a ton of money come in and then come back
- 47:45out earlier this year. For the most part, it hasn't
- 47:47really picked up too much for Bitcoin.
- 47:49Again, Ethereum, there is a huge base, a decent basis trade.
- 47:52And like there's other assets I talked about.
- 47:54But like if you look at the 13 F holdings one, the vast majority
- 47:58of holders of these Bitcoin ETFs are retail investors.
- 48:01We, we, we have less than 30% of the holders known right now.
- 48:06Again, you hinted before we don't have the full response
- 48:08yet. I'm going to be writing a note
- 48:10next week that looks at like, OK, what is the what is the
- 48:12breakdown of the holders of the Bitcoin ETFs now here in the US?
- 48:15But for a while, the first few, the first year essentially of
- 48:18these Bitcoin ETFs launching the number one holder type outside
- 48:21of retail, because we only had like, you know, a certain subset
- 48:23of people that filed holding it was hedge funds.
- 48:26And some of them I'm sure we're long only to Bitcoin.
- 48:30They believe in Bitcoin, but for the vast majority of them, they
- 48:32don't give a SH. They could care less what
- 48:34Bitcoin is like. They are doing an ARB trade,
- 48:36they're doing the basis trade, they're doing some sort of
- 48:38volatility trading and but that has changed now.
- 48:41So hedge funds are the second largest holder investment
- 48:43advisors, which are the biggest holders of ETFs in general over
- 48:47any time period. The investment advisors love
- 48:49ETFs. They are now and still are the
- 48:52largest holders of the Bitcoin ETFs.
- 48:55Which also maps to bitcoins history, right?
- 48:57It's on a larger scale, but individuals often you, you know,
- 49:01during your interview series, I imagine you talk to a lot of
- 49:03people that were trading early on and then we're like, what am
- 49:05I holding? And then they became that
- 49:07believers in long term holders part of I think James, you and
- 49:12Eric are insanely fascinating in the most positive way that you
- 49:15guys are open to these different concepts.
- 49:17And you have two like feet in different worlds that you're
- 49:19interviewing and, and coming on podcasts like this and talking
- 49:22to folks holding over 50% while also referencing the basis
- 49:26trade. And also, you know, peers that
- 49:28think this is kind of like rat poison squared.
- 49:31And because you, because we did this with Eric where the
- 49:33beginning was like, Coinbase is fine.
- 49:35And if they have any kind of mishap, the government bail them
- 49:38out. Towards the end, he left.
- 49:39Like, wait, tell me more about, you know, either what you guys
- 49:42do or like, maybe that is a problem.
- 49:44And you kind of said two things in the the past discussion where
- 49:49you are referencing 6040 lives and, and people.
- 49:53I wonder who goes backwards. But then you also reference
- 49:55anybody that's been net long, this long enough realizes it
- 49:58just continues the increase in price, which are like basically
- 50:00contradictory to the, to the position over a long enough time
- 50:03horizon. And it's kind of ties into this
- 50:05podcast called the last trade because the, the belief is once
- 50:08you look long enough at this asset, you, you look at it from
- 50:11its properties and the specific properties of like reducing
- 50:13counterparty risk. And you know, the, the fixed
- 50:17supply is really the big deal. And the notion of, OK, well,
- 50:21maybe this is the last trade for a bit.
- 50:23It's not to say that equity market doesn't exist.
- 50:25It's just once you go far enough, you start to realize,
- 50:28well, if I'm going to give up my Bitcoin for equities, then I
- 50:31need to outperform Bitcoin. And so the idea is that most
- 50:35equity, specifically private or public are just from
- 50:40deflationary tech like SAS based tools.
- 50:42AI is the big buzzword, but just think about software as a
- 50:44service and how many corporates and publicly traded companies
- 50:47don't even aren't even running efficiently on that level.
- 50:49I mean, without speaking about your firm, I'm sure you see some
- 50:52efficiencies you guys can have. Think about AI and how many
- 50:55people are gonna miss that boat. And the idea is effectively that
- 50:58these companies are kind of propped up by this false, you
- 51:02know, signal, which is the money supply.
- 51:04And ultimately, until that gets corrected and fixed and we're
- 51:07seeing this like you're starting to see glimpses of the notion of
- 51:09bit bonds or the pub Co, the Treasury, the Treasury.
- 51:14I think we, at least us three, agree that the Treasury shell
- 51:16company is a is a kind of like, you know, a glimpse into, you
- 51:20know, what could potentially be the downfall of this cycle.
- 51:22But the notion of a business, a productive business holding a
- 51:25better unit to reserve its cash flows and be able to take
- 51:28opportunistic bets makes a lot of sense.
- 51:30And you can see how this starts to enter insert into a lot of
- 51:34assets and then people will invest in them when they start
- 51:36producing more Bitcoin than is invested.
- 51:38That's how you kind of like get back to, you know, the market
- 51:41being a a less distorted version of it.
- 51:45I don't know, I said a lot there, but that's kind of like
- 51:46just going back to a few conversations ago about the
- 51:49notion of 64. And it's not to say that these
- 51:51things don't exist specifically equities and that you should
- 51:53invest in American capitalism. It's just the reality that those
- 51:57price earnings multiples, we all know we're a little bit
- 51:59distorted. And where do you know those
- 52:01signals are and who's actually has a viable business in this
- 52:04new world where deflationary technology is just going to like
- 52:07RIP to shreds a lot of business models?
- 52:09Yeah, I mean on the on the price, like on a long enough
- 52:13time frame, if you are fully a Bitcoin believer like these,
- 52:16these companies are going to adopt some level of Bitcoin or
- 52:22you know, they're they're going to get involved in this some way
- 52:24no matter what. If it really gets to the full
- 52:26end game that a Bitcoin maxi would believe it would get to
- 52:29right. So at the end of the day, you're
- 52:31still investing in a income producing asset or earnings
- 52:34producing asset or cash flow producing asset, whatever you
- 52:37want to say. The other thing I would say is
- 52:38like people have been saying the PE on these things is way too
- 52:42high for as long as I've been in finance.
- 52:47And if you look at some of these like the Mag Sevens, like their
- 52:50earnings growth has proved it right.
- 52:52Like and if you look at Google, it's at the lowest PE it's ever
- 52:55had. So like the market isn't as
- 52:58crazy or stupid as people make it out to be.
- 53:00I mean, obviously there's also one thing that I wanted to go
- 53:02back to that we didn't touch on is like the difference between
- 53:04price inflation, CPI versus like money printing and like the, the
- 53:08actual level of M2 in the market.
- 53:10So like some people are like, CPI is not really inflation.
- 53:14Inflation is like how much dollars are created in the
- 53:16inflation of the money supply, which also like you, you were
- 53:20talking before about nominal versus real returns.
- 53:22Like you talk to a normie on the street, like 99% of people have
- 53:27no, have no clue what the hell a nominal versus real return is.
- 53:32And I think that that really, I think finally started to change
- 53:35in 2020 because I mean, all of us are probably around the same
- 53:39age. Like inflation was not anything
- 53:41like most people really were concerned about.
- 53:43Like you need to keep it low enough that people don't notice
- 53:45it, but you want it to be slightly positive in, in the
- 53:48current economic world view. Like that's the goal, right?
- 53:51And like that was blown out of the water.
- 53:53And one thing I would say, like going back, like talking about
- 53:56the denominator on the debt, the thing that really does matter is
- 53:59like government spending as a percent of like total spending.
- 54:03And like if you look at a chart of what that actually looks like
- 54:06over time, I can see if I can find it.
- 54:08Like that is what really caused the inflation number.
- 54:12So like in 2020 into 2021, those numbers went absolutely bonkers.
- 54:16And that's when you saw inflation RIP.
- 54:18And I don't think they're going to make that same mistake again
- 54:21if they ever do that. That's it.
- 54:25That's all I'll say on that front, I guess, Sorry.
- 54:29So it's all good. I was trying to find that chart,
- 54:30but we can move on. Yeah, I was also looking for a
- 54:33chart. It was the one that I'm sure you
- 54:36guys saw the IT went viral like a week ago.
- 54:39Which of the 30 age 30 from like the 1950s I think it was 50s or
- 54:4570 from it dropped from like 50%.
- 54:48I believe that. Homeowner, Homeowners and
- 54:50married. Married from 30 but underneath
- 54:53it. Yeah, I know exactly what you're
- 54:54talking about. But underneath it was the one
- 54:56that kind of ties in to like everything we're talking about.
- 54:58It shows 1970 and real earnings or earnings versus the price of
- 55:03a house. And it was basically like a
- 55:05parody. And then you see over the 50
- 55:07years that Delta, and I think that's the embedded real versus
- 55:11nominal, while people's wages have increased at a couple
- 55:14percentage points per year, the real cost of the home, you know,
- 55:18the natural good that everyone needs has just like come
- 55:21completely run past that. I think that's like the crux to
- 55:24your point post 2020 people feel.
- 55:27Yeah, yeah, No, think the housing market is so freaking
- 55:30out of whack right now. Like if there's anything that's
- 55:32broken in the economy right now, it's that's the it's the housing
- 55:35market is frozen. If you bought a house before
- 55:392020, mid 20/20/20, like 21 and before they started hiking rates
- 55:44like that is the haves and have nots.
- 55:47So like we were talking about inflation before.
- 55:48Like one thing I like to point out to people is like if you
- 55:51owned a home and you have a low interest rate, like you did not
- 55:54suffer anywhere near the level of inflation as anyone who is
- 55:57renting or was trying to buy a home.
- 55:59Like if you had a fixed rate mortgage, you were sitting
- 56:02pretty. Not only did your expenses not
- 56:05go up, but your balance sheet actually went up over that time
- 56:07period because houses went through the roof.
- 56:09And like 60 something percent of people in the US own their home.
- 56:13So like that's the other part. Like a lot of things on
- 56:16inflation, like people like focus on stuff.
- 56:18But like yes, a lot of people were hurt, particularly younger
- 56:21generation like we were just talking about.
- 56:23But there's plenty of people who are older boomers who who own
- 56:26their house or have a mortgage, who own the house outright or
- 56:28have a have a fixed rate mortgage sub 3%.
- 56:31And like they don't give a shit that rates went up.
- 56:34They don't care about any of this.
- 56:35All they see is their house out value went up and they're
- 56:37sitting pretty. Yeah.
- 56:39No, it's interesting because James, you mentioned two things.
- 56:43One on the equity markets with P multiples.
- 56:45I hear you. People have been talking about
- 56:47that for a long time and some people have come on the show
- 56:49before and, you know, said there's a crash imminent in
- 56:52equity markets and I just don't buy it.
- 56:55I feel like I I index to the side that everything goes up
- 56:59because there's just, you know, the denominator is expanding,
- 57:02right? You just have more liquidity
- 57:03entering the system. You have this post GFC low
- 57:07interest rate for a while, 0 interest rate policy.
- 57:10You had Trump talking this week. He he's like, but he said
- 57:14something like with a pen stroke, we can get rid of a
- 57:16trillion dollars of spending because he just wants rates to
- 57:18be as low as possible. So it's like we're going to get
- 57:22back to lower rates at some point.
- 57:23I just can't imagine a scenario. Maybe I'm naive, but I just
- 57:26can't imagine a scenario where we see like a significant equity
- 57:29market crash. You have so much passive flows
- 57:31going in there. To your point, people, most
- 57:33people are just like setting up the four O 1K match or they, you
- 57:36know, put money into an IRA each year.
- 57:38They put it into the market and they forget about it and move on
- 57:41with their lives. They don't really care what PE
- 57:43multiple they're buying at. And they just know that it's
- 57:46better than leaving their their dollars in a checking account
- 57:49earning 0%. So I agree with you there.
- 57:52I think, you know, PE multiples, while they're stretched
- 57:55historically, I don't really see like a big equity crash
- 57:58happening. And then the second piece on the
- 58:01home ownership, yeah, a lot of people have been pointing out
- 58:04that home prices are falling, but it's very regional.
- 58:06Regional, I mean here where I'm in the Philadelphia area,
- 58:10Michael likes to make fun of me. I'm just getting like Max bid by
- 58:13boomers. We're going to put a hold on.
- 58:15We're going to put a hold on the home purchase for now.
- 58:18We're going to be renting out of the city.
- 58:19But yeah, I mean these homes just like fly off the market.
- 58:23They're under contract and you know, like same day, sometimes
- 58:25two or three days later and gone to a couple of open houses over
- 58:29the past like several months. And a lot of times the buyers
- 58:33are the people that are interested in buying are in
- 58:35there and they're like 50-60, seventy years old and they're
- 58:37just like all cash offers, no inspection.
- 58:40So the housing market is cooked. Unfortunately I'm I'm on that
- 58:44chart with the the declining home ownership and guess it'll
- 58:47be like that for a little bit. Yeah, so few things.
- 58:51One, I'm going to share my screen because I did find that
- 58:53chart I wanted to share, if that's OK.
- 58:56So this this, this shout out to Colin Roche, who is he runs his
- 59:00own ETF. He's like a economics guy.
- 59:03But like that chart, this is the federal government expenditures
- 59:06as a percent of gross GDP like this, this is the, this is like
- 59:11if this happens again, if we ever get levels like that, like
- 59:13that's what causes like, I think the severe levels of inflation.
- 59:17And then going back to what you were talking about with the, the
- 59:20housing market, I mean, people are like, we need to cut rates
- 59:23and, you know, save all these things and we're going to save
- 59:25money. Like one it take doesn't take
- 59:28into account that like a decent amount of the debt is already
- 59:32like revalued, like it's, it's not really going to be affected
- 59:35too much. Like it's already like recycled
- 59:39every year, what have you. The other part of it is like we
- 59:42cut rates a bunch of times last fall and you know what happened
- 59:45to mortgage rates over that time period, they went up.
- 59:49Like we cut rates and mortgage rates went up.
- 59:51So if we're expecting inflation, like things aren't necessarily
- 59:54going to get better. And then the final thing I
- 59:57wanted to say is like, if you look at PES, the other part of
- 1:00:01it is like these companies are unlike any other company we were
- 1:00:04seeing for the mag Sevens, the growth, the amount of money that
- 1:00:06they're pulling out, the low required of investments.
- 1:00:09Like if you compare it to historical PES, like you're
- 1:00:11looking at like. Manufacturing firms like these
- 1:00:15softwares, the service companies have like very little overhead
- 1:00:18besides like office buildings and paying their employees and
- 1:00:21then they're just like charging insane margins on what they're
- 1:00:24building. So you look at the mag 7 it's
- 1:00:25like they're just like also like it's in finance.
- 1:00:28You never say this time is different, but really like these
- 1:00:31companies are this time is different.
- 1:00:33Like nothing is. People have been saying this
- 1:00:34since like 2010, right? 2011 when things really started
- 1:00:38heating up. People are like, oh, this is it.
- 1:00:40It can't keep going. And these guys just keep
- 1:00:42producing numbers. And now we have the AI boom and
- 1:00:44maybe that'll finally be, you know, the top of it.
- 1:00:46Like it's the the CapEx expenditure on AI isn't going to
- 1:00:49be justified by the future earnings.
- 1:00:51Who knows? But things are like kind of
- 1:00:53softening a little bit. But yeah, I the housing market
- 1:00:56is the one area that I'm like, I don't know, man.
- 1:00:59Like things are just not right. It's just it's, it's unfair to
- 1:01:02anyone who's trying to buy a home.
- 1:01:04All right, so check this out. We just launched Bitcoin Dynasty
- 1:01:07Trust Services here at Onramp. I'm excited about this.
- 1:01:10It's really blending the best of both worlds on the custody side
- 1:01:13and with South Dakota trust law. If you come to our homepage here
- 1:01:17on rampbitcoin.com, you can read more about it just launched.
- 1:01:21You click that banner and then here's some things you quickly
- 1:01:23call out. No, 40% of state tax at the
- 1:01:26federal level if you set up a trust, perpetual asset
- 1:01:29protection against creditors maintaining privacy.
- 1:01:32I know that's a big one for Bitcoin owners and then other
- 1:01:35things as well. You can tap in with Bitcoin back
- 1:01:37loans without having to sell your Bitcoin and really just a
- 1:01:41nice sleek solution. We launched it just last week.
- 1:01:44We released a podcast to go into detail.
- 1:01:46And so if you're looking for just a better way to plan for
- 1:01:50inheritance, protect your assets from creditors and optimize for
- 1:01:54taxes, great solution here. You can reach out to us directly
- 1:01:57on the homepage and book a consultation or you can reach
- 1:02:00out to me, Jackson, at on rampbitcoin.com.
- 1:02:03Be happy to speak to you and tell you a little bit more about
- 1:02:06the product here. Yeah, now I hear you there for
- 1:02:11sure. So a couple of the things I know
- 1:02:13we have a little bit of time left here, maybe a throw it over
- 1:02:17to the group, see if there's any strong inclination of where we
- 1:02:19go. But James, I was curious if
- 1:02:22there were anything or anything else worth mentioning.
- 1:02:25We briefly touched on the 13 FS, but I'm more so curious if like
- 1:02:30anything stood out to you. Brian brought up the Harvard
- 1:02:32allocation and you said, you know, could be spot long, could
- 1:02:35be basis trade, but I'm curious if like anything else stood out
- 1:02:38so far. I know the deadline's tomorrow.
- 1:02:39So we haven't seen every everything yet.
- 1:02:42And you can also maybe pair that in with just like general
- 1:02:46thoughts on demand going forward, you know, through the
- 1:02:49end of the year if you want to. And then one other topic I think
- 1:02:53could be interesting if you want to get into it is just ETF
- 1:02:57demand versus let's say Bitcoin treasury companies or what the
- 1:03:02new term, the DATS, the digital asset treasuries.
- 1:03:06Yeah, if you want to talk about that as well, I'd be curious
- 1:03:08like any thoughts on appetite there?
- 1:03:12But yeah, maybe just start on the 13 F stuff.
- 1:03:14Yeah, let's start on the 13 F stuff.
- 1:03:15I mean, like you said, we don't have everything.
- 1:03:17We probably won't have everything or I won't be able to
- 1:03:19see everything until like after market closes tomorrow.
- 1:03:22So realistically next week, and I'm actually off next week, but
- 1:03:26we're going to be covering this a bit, but there's a few big
- 1:03:29names in there. The only really big one that's
- 1:03:31new that like stands out has already been mentioned at
- 1:03:34Harvard. Again, we don't know exactly
- 1:03:36what the position is. The one thing the trend is
- 1:03:38continued advisors are increasing their allocations,
- 1:03:41which makes sense. It's what we've been calling for
- 1:03:43to happen. It's been our biggest bull case
- 1:03:45for ETF demand this year. I don't know if I necessarily
- 1:03:48expected the amount of demand to come from Bitcoin treasury
- 1:03:51companies as has come. So I cover ETFs, you know, but
- 1:03:55like that's been a huge part of it.
- 1:03:56And they're also the etherium Datcos are going crazy.
- 1:03:59So are the sole salon. There's Datcos for everything
- 1:04:02essentially, and it's getting a little bit out of hand.
- 1:04:04I'm fully with you guys. Like right now, this is a
- 1:04:06flywheel spinning in a positive direction for the underlying
- 1:04:09asset prices. There's no, there's I, I, I, I
- 1:04:12don't know how much or any way to better, but some of these, at
- 1:04:15least one, if not multiple of these firms in some world are
- 1:04:18going to cause the flywheel to spin the opposite direction and
- 1:04:21what they're doing, they're going to, it's not going to be
- 1:04:23pretty. But going back to the advisor
- 1:04:26side of things on the 13 FS, the one thing that a lot of people
- 1:04:30don't understand about advisor networks, wealth platforms,
- 1:04:34brokerage platforms, like an ETF is launched and it's not that
- 1:04:38everyone can buy it immediately. What you guys are familiar with
- 1:04:40this already? There's like a process for
- 1:04:42getting approved on the platform.
- 1:04:43And the way I've been liked, I've liked to describe to
- 1:04:45different people is it's almost like a stoplight.
- 1:04:48There's three different levels. There's red, nobody can buy
- 1:04:51this, walk away. Stop.
- 1:04:53I don't care what your reasoning is, you can't buy it on a
- 1:04:55platform. There's a bunch of people like
- 1:04:56that, including Vanguard, which is very strange to me, which you
- 1:05:00can go down that rabbit hole if we want.
- 1:05:01There's plenty of other huge platforms with trillions of
- 1:05:04dollars in assets and wealth on them.
- 1:05:06Or you just cannot buy it underneath circumstance.
- 1:05:08The vast majority of these wealth platforms where advisors
- 1:05:10are for the most part is in this middle range where it's either
- 1:05:14A, they need to meet all these requirements, whether it's like
- 1:05:18some level of wealth, some level of income, some willingness and
- 1:05:22ability to take risk needs to be met before you can say they can
- 1:05:25buy this. Or the client needs to come to
- 1:05:28you specifically and say like, OK, I want exposure to Bitcoin,
- 1:05:31you know, give me exposure to Bitcoin solicited versus
- 1:05:35unsolicited. So that's the middle ground.
- 1:05:37And then the final green light, if you will, is like, I can just
- 1:05:41recommend it to my client in a 3% allocation.
- 1:05:44And like, I think this process of moving things from red to
- 1:05:47yellow, yellow to green over the next year plus is what's going
- 1:05:51to drive a lot of the demand for the ETFs.
- 1:05:53Obviously, the price performance right now has also brought in
- 1:05:55retail, but we're still seeing growing demand from those
- 1:05:59investment advisors and those those platforms come in.
- 1:06:02And a lot of the biggest platforms in the world still are
- 1:06:04not allowing their advisors to buy it.
- 1:06:06And you talk to a lot of these advisors, in many cases, they're
- 1:06:08like, yeah, I own it, but I don't recommend it to my
- 1:06:10clients. Exactly.
- 1:06:11I love this chart. This is this.
- 1:06:13This stable is so good. Yeah, exactly.
- 1:06:16This is from Tougher Digital and we've pulled this up on the show
- 1:06:19a few times in the past few months, but this is a perfect
- 1:06:21encapsulation of everything you're talking about, like the
- 1:06:23just building out the plumbing and giving people that green
- 1:06:26light column goes slower, but it just goes slower than you would
- 1:06:29anticipate like. And so this is the their most
- 1:06:31recent one, which is a week or so ago and they've been doing it
- 1:06:35sort of quarterly and the only changes over the past quarter
- 1:06:39were those Gray shaded boxes. So like there was no new
- 1:06:42entrance to like the fully unrestricted exposure area, but
- 1:06:46just people slowly sort of moving in that direction.
- 1:06:48Yeah, it's, it's, it's positive. The direction of flow is
- 1:06:51positive. It's just this is stratified.
- 1:06:53These are, you know, massive oil tanker ships like it's, they
- 1:06:57don't move quick. Yeah.
- 1:06:59And that's where I think we're on the same side of the belief
- 1:07:02of we end up in this naturally elongated cycle because the
- 1:07:04flows are still in process of getting turned on from the FAA
- 1:07:08side, but also the banking side. When you think about credit
- 1:07:10unions all the way into the big four, what's their game plan,
- 1:07:13who they're going to use for custody, sub custody building,
- 1:07:17Maybe a little bit of fun stuff to chat about because it doesn't
- 1:07:19get talked about enough. And I'm sure you'll have deep
- 1:07:21thoughts is a like you and Eric who ends up more further down
- 1:07:26the orange filling and just like believe where it goes because he
- 1:07:29shared a little bit of interesting insights into part
- 1:07:31of the the book you guys are working on on like what let's
- 1:07:34play this out post ETF world. And what if Bitcoin becomes
- 1:07:37money or it takes a further like a bigger piece of what people
- 1:07:41are expecting? Because this is uncharted
- 1:07:43territories when you think about it, right, like the chart that
- 1:07:45shows the Black Rock ETF and exposure is just an insane
- 1:07:48chart. And it's like, well, where does
- 1:07:49that go? What's the top?
- 1:07:51And part of that is OK, well, how does custody play out?
- 1:07:54Is this all set on Coinbase? Because there's already
- 1:07:56heartburn in small circles about 800 billion sitting at Coinbase,
- 1:08:00right. Well, what is it 1.2?
- 1:08:02Is it 1.8? Like where do banks end up
- 1:08:04sitting? How do individuals like, how do
- 1:08:05you think about as this asset grows, it just starts to insert
- 1:08:09itself in the kind of like traditional space?
- 1:08:11And you know that that I don't call it asking for a top, but
- 1:08:16like everyone would believe there's it's kind of an
- 1:08:19interesting proposition because you either have to your point,
- 1:08:21the hardcore Bitcoin maximus believe this thing becomes
- 1:08:23money. And that's already like
- 1:08:25somebody, somebody put their flag in the ground there and
- 1:08:28then everyone else hasn't actually said anything about
- 1:08:30like what the hell is happening? And where does this go?
- 1:08:32Because you can look at Amazon and be like, OK, this is where
- 1:08:34it goes. You can look at Google,
- 1:08:36Microsoft, but there's actually no way to like underwrite
- 1:08:39Bitcoin except for it becomes money or it's just a speculative
- 1:08:43asset. I can make a little bit of money
- 1:08:44on when you really like bring it down.
- 1:08:48Yeah, so I mean it they're they're absolutely massive.
- 1:08:51So one thing I do want to point out, as I was talking about, I
- 1:08:53said over 130 billion, these things now have over 150 billion
- 1:08:57in assets. So as of today, it's like 150
- 1:09:01three 1:00-ish. And then as far as how much they
- 1:09:04own, the ETFs alone own 1.3 million Bitcoin.
- 1:09:08So, and then as you mentioned, a huge chunk of that is actually
- 1:09:12custody by Coinbase. So one of the things I've been
- 1:09:15saying and I thought was going to happen is there was going to
- 1:09:16be diversified custodians. We've seen that some of the
- 1:09:18filers have basically said they're going to use multiple
- 1:09:20custodians, which usually you, you don't have to worry about in
- 1:09:23traditional assets. The only example where we've
- 1:09:25seen this happen is gold. And honestly, that makes
- 1:09:28complete sense, right? Like there are ETS out there
- 1:09:30that use multiple custodians or there's ETFs in gold that
- 1:09:33compete because there's their vault is in Switzerland where
- 1:09:36your vault is in New York or London.
- 1:09:37Most of them are technically in London.
- 1:09:39There was even one that was in Perth, Australia for a little
- 1:09:41while. So yeah, these things have $1.3
- 1:09:44million, one point 3,000,000 Bitcoin.
- 1:09:47And at what point is too big, right?
- 1:09:50I mean, I don't know, my my view is kind of like the protocol is
- 1:09:55built in such a way that this isn't going to matter for the
- 1:09:58underlying Bitcoin, but maybe it does at some point.
- 1:10:01And I would argue that like Coinbase is to bring a term from
- 1:10:05Tradfi, it's a a sippy, it's a systemically important financial
- 1:10:09institution for the crypto and ETF world, I mean for the crypto
- 1:10:12and Bitcoin world. But yeah, I think people are
- 1:10:15cognizant of it. I think they're planning to to
- 1:10:17move these things around, but yeah, go ahead.
- 1:10:21Yeah, this ties some some into that where you're referencing
- 1:10:24them out. So you see iShares, this is our
- 1:10:26own version of the the Bloomberg Terminal, the on ramp terminal
- 1:10:29just kind of breaks down analytics specifically to
- 1:10:31Bitcoin. But this is the key thing.
- 1:10:33We're doing something the other day for a different show and I
- 1:10:37was looking at the numbers. So this is top 100, it's
- 1:10:40including MSTR and the ETFs. But what's interesting is it
- 1:10:45shows 15% of total BTC, but it's actually 20% because it takes
- 1:10:49into account that, you know, by estimates whether it's Satoshi's
- 1:10:52coins and then lost coins, there's roughly 4 million out of
- 1:10:54the 19.6 that I believe are, you know, available today.
- 1:10:58So there's 20% already. We're only at 120 K and we just
- 1:11:01talked about banks and ETF's are barely online.
- 1:11:05This narrative will only pick up and you know, we focus some
- 1:11:09stuff on that on our side of the business, but it's just an
- 1:11:11interesting dynamic to see play out and how it'll how it'll
- 1:11:15naturally grow. Our thesis is like over time, as
- 1:11:18individuals get more exposure, they start to just like
- 1:11:21understand the underlying and they're going to seek out better
- 1:11:23solutions. In the same way that maybe when
- 1:11:26you or another individual starting a cash app and then a
- 1:11:28different third party exchange, they naturally take those assets
- 1:11:31off because they heard about, you know, Mount Gox or Celsius
- 1:11:34or Block Fire FTX. And I think that's just going to
- 1:11:37be a big thing that in my personal opinion, watching what
- 1:11:41happened in 2022, I think very a lot of people specifically in
- 1:11:45traffic, I had no idea how bad it was.
- 1:11:47And the, the concepts are going to like effectively repeat
- 1:11:52itself because you have this digital bearer asset, which is
- 1:11:54effectively just data the private keys to secure them.
- 1:11:57And we all know that, you know, the PII is out from everyone.
- 1:11:59Fidelity is the worst to pick on because it's Fidelity and they
- 1:12:02lost all their clients, PII. And so like nobody is absolved
- 1:12:05of that risk of losing the data and it's going to take another
- 1:12:09massive swing for enough of the market to understand, well,
- 1:12:11maybe we should centralized this asset.
- 1:12:15The problem is nobody's gotten fired for going to Coinbase.
- 1:12:17And that's why you have these ETFs there and institutional
- 1:12:20investors just, you know, basically defaulting to Coinbase
- 1:12:22without asking anything. Yeah, I mean, you, you said
- 1:12:27nobody gets fired for going to Coinbase.
- 1:12:28That's kind of like in in the ETF world, no one gets fired for
- 1:12:31bringing a BlackRock or Vanguard ETF.
- 1:12:33Like it's just like easy to do it.
- 1:12:34So I think by having BlackRock in this space was extremely
- 1:12:38helpful for the space overall because they are like arguably
- 1:12:41the only other person that would have I, I don't even think they
- 1:12:43would have been as big of a deal.
- 1:12:44But the only other, yeah, the, the biggest person to get in the
- 1:12:47space to help it from an ETF and asset management point of view
- 1:12:49did it when BlackRock and Larry Fink did it.
- 1:12:53So yeah, I think that's absolutely completely massive.
- 1:12:59So I, I was going to say something else, but I lost my
- 1:13:01train of thought, thinking about the Larry Fink side of things.
- 1:13:03What? What were you saying just before
- 1:13:05that talking about? Some of the banks and just
- 1:13:09exposure. No, this is what I remember.
- 1:13:11Yeah, if if, if the banking system went through what the
- 1:13:15blockchain, crypto, Bitcoin system went through in
- 1:13:1820/22/2021 like it never, it wouldn't have been able to
- 1:13:23recover like the. Which is the, which is the key
- 1:13:26point I referenced to Eric where like, if you listen, that was
- 1:13:29where he kind of like was going in a full circle because it's
- 1:13:33like, well, what happens to Coinbase?
- 1:13:34He's like, well, the, the, the government would step in and I
- 1:13:36referenced, will they print more Bitcoin?
- 1:13:37And he said yes, because that is so like built into our DNA that
- 1:13:40that's why to go back to that point where you show 2020 and
- 1:13:45that we'll never do there by definition of doing that, we
- 1:13:47will do it again. Because when you insert that
- 1:13:49number of monetary units, it doesn't all go to productive
- 1:13:52assets. So naturally it either D levers
- 1:13:55because the debt isn't, you know, productive or sustainable,
- 1:13:57or you have to insert more debt. That's why this is just a self
- 1:14:00fulfilling like continue of debasement.
- 1:14:02And that's the concept of there are no bailouts.
- 1:14:07And that you probably haven't seen this chart, which will
- 1:14:10probably be fascinating because you see most charts is the total
- 1:14:14Bitcoin supply. And we're a vast percentage of
- 1:14:17it, like call it 50% sits in these little plastic devices.
- 1:14:21And it's not because people are Luddites or ideological.
- 1:14:24It's because this was a bottoms up industry and all the people
- 1:14:27had to understand if you trusted a third party, you ultimately
- 1:14:29were going to get rugged on a long enough time horizon.
- 1:14:32And everyone's saying this time is different when the hardcore
- 1:14:36people are saying I don't know about that.
- 1:14:38And the funny part is you've never seen it being bottoms up
- 1:14:41or the most sophisticated. But by nature of being longest
- 1:14:44in the market, you are the most sophisticated because you've had
- 1:14:46the most time to look at the problem.
- 1:14:48It's why those people you interviewed are over 50%.
- 1:14:50It's not that they're just crazy, it's that they've just
- 1:14:52looked at it and their life got a lot easier by being over
- 1:14:55allocated to the asset. The other part to that over
- 1:14:57allocation is a lot of them were early or at least relatively
- 1:15:01early. And rather than it's not
- 1:15:03necessarily maybe that they're they're allocating still a bunch
- 1:15:05of money to it. It's that they bought early and
- 1:15:07just haven't sold and it's outperformed and crushed every
- 1:15:10other asset in their portfolio, which was another huge part of
- 1:15:13it. It was like, look, I haven't
- 1:15:14really been buying Bitcoin as much over the last few years.
- 1:15:16I don't really buy it, but I also haven't sold it.
- 1:15:19So it's now 30% of My Portfolio or more, 30% of my net worth,
- 1:15:23you name it. So I think that's another huge
- 1:15:25part of it is like people who buy this again, they don't turn
- 1:15:28back. Like it's, there are plenty of
- 1:15:30examples of people buying and selling at a top because they
- 1:15:32don't believe in it. But there's plenty of people who
- 1:15:34buy it and just hold it forever in one of those wallets or, or
- 1:15:38actually on an exchange like Coinbase or what have you.
- 1:15:41But yeah. Yeah, there's nowhere else to
- 1:15:43go. The only downside is I can't
- 1:15:46live in my Bitcoin, so we got to do something about that at some
- 1:15:48point. But yeah, no, I hear you.
- 1:15:51And people like to hear that they're still early.
- 1:15:54So if you're listening to this, don't worry, you're still early
- 1:15:57to Bitcoin. But seriously though, it kind of
- 1:15:59is like it certainly is early. And it's even justified, James,
- 1:16:04by some of the points you made earlier that a lot of firms are
- 1:16:06not even participating in this and would love to hear your
- 1:16:10thoughts. I know we're wrapping soon, but
- 1:16:12Vanguard, you said you might have some takes on Vanguard.
- 1:16:15Why are they not? Why are they not on board yet?
- 1:16:17Are they are they coming around to it soon or are they going to
- 1:16:20lose business because of that? What are your thoughts?
- 1:16:22I mean, they've unquestionably lost some business because of
- 1:16:24it. Like if you held so for example,
- 1:16:30I can tell you, I'll be frank, I had GBTC in an IRA on Vanguard
- 1:16:35and in order to like rotate out of GPTCI had to move my IRA from
- 1:16:38them. So I had to move a bunch of my
- 1:16:40money from being a Vanguard client.
- 1:16:41And I've talked to plenty of other people who have done
- 1:16:43something similar. Look, Vanguard's going to be
- 1:16:45fine. They are the most successful
- 1:16:46asset management company in the world, bar none.
- 1:16:49They own like 30% of the US market.
- 1:16:52They are taking in billions of dollars every single day.
- 1:16:55Like it dwarfs what's happening in in Bitcoin for the most part.
- 1:16:58So they are going to be fine. That's what I want to say that
- 1:17:01up front, but I think this whole crypto, Bitcoin, not allowing
- 1:17:06them to trade on their platform was a huge own goal.
- 1:17:09Like the platform is self-directed.
- 1:17:11So if somebody's if you want to go out and like not allow people
- 1:17:14to invest in like a triple leverage ETF or something along
- 1:17:16those lines, you want to make sure people understand what
- 1:17:19they're investing in. They're playing with the power
- 1:17:20tool. They could chop their hand off
- 1:17:22something along those lines, but to outright disallow it is like
- 1:17:25it in my view. It went too far.
- 1:17:27I think they'll walk it back at some point.
- 1:17:29Do I think they'll ever launch a Bitcoin ETF or I do not?
- 1:17:33They don't believe in gold. They don't have a gold ETF.
- 1:17:35They do allow you to invest in gold ETF on their platform, but
- 1:17:38they are very much like the Bogle heads.
- 1:17:40The Jack Bogle view of things is cash flows and creating earnings
- 1:17:44and that's the way that you value an asset.
- 1:17:47And I like I said, I used to be 100% in that camp.
- 1:17:49I'm still mostly in that camp, but I also believe in a way to
- 1:17:52hedge against currency debasement.
- 1:17:55But yeah, so the like the ethos of Vanguard is such that they
- 1:17:58would never really do that. That said, they've done plenty
- 1:18:01of things that are against the ethos.
- 1:18:02They've kind of got into PEA little bit because they're
- 1:18:04trying to become an advisory business in in many regards.
- 1:18:08And like I think ultimately they're going to allow people to
- 1:18:11buy and trade Bitcoin ETFs and other digital asset ETFs on
- 1:18:15their platform at some point. When is it going to happen?
- 1:18:17I don't know, but I just view it as, you know, I think it was an
- 1:18:20own goal for them to, you know, say nobody can buy this on our
- 1:18:23platform. Yeah, the game theory ties into
- 1:18:26everyone having to opt in at some format.
- 1:18:29I know we won't have time here, but it's just worth pointing out
- 1:18:32like the capital market specifically on being able to
- 1:18:35lend against the asset and cross collateralization is just going
- 1:18:38to allow for a lot more liquidity to enter the space.
- 1:18:40Whether it's the cost of capital from banks never really being in
- 1:18:43the space to not have to sell your Bitcoin to having an in an
- 1:18:46equity like exposure via an ETF. And then using some of that lift
- 1:18:52and growth into investing in other equities.
- 1:18:54Like it makes zero sense to not let your clients have access to
- 1:18:57that because that growth is just going to go somewhere else.
- 1:19:01Yeah. I mean, Jackson, good for you.
- 1:19:02I mean, Bill Pulte made that announcement about basically
- 1:19:05saying that you should you should consider crypto and
- 1:19:07digital assets on your as a part of the client's balance.
- 1:19:10I mean, you can't exactly get a loan against it, but it should
- 1:19:14be considered when when getting a loan, which I guess is like
- 1:19:16one step forward at least. And I mean, there's plenty of
- 1:19:19other platforms out there now that are allowing you to, you
- 1:19:21know, borrow on an over collateralized basis to use it.
- 1:19:25So you can't live in it, but you can use it to get exposure to
- 1:19:27Fiat if you want to actually buy A to buy a house with it.
- 1:19:32One day, James, thanks for the kind words man.
- 1:19:34It's going to get me through the rest of the day.
- 1:19:38My wife will be happy to hear that.
- 1:19:39I'll have to clip that and send it to her.
- 1:19:41It's going to be OK. We're going to have a house one
- 1:19:43day, don't worry. We basically have a segment of
- 1:19:46Jackson's ills and being a millennial in trying to afford a
- 1:19:51home and and housing in in 2025. Whether or not to lever up.
- 1:19:55In whether or not to lever up. Or hey dude, I have.
- 1:19:58I have so many friends that are in a similar camp where they
- 1:20:00just been outbid repeatedly. Like no matter what they do it's
- 1:20:03funny. Like if you were in any part of
- 1:20:05the country you'd probably be fine though.
- 1:20:06Like if you were not in like the Northeast or like every other
- 1:20:10part of the country, the housing market is either shitting the
- 1:20:13bed or like at least not doing super hot.
- 1:20:16So you just happen to live in like the worst spot right now.
- 1:20:18Everyone else wants to live where you want to live, pretty
- 1:20:20much. Yeah, Michael wants us to move
- 1:20:22to Texas, but Michael's actually going to move to the Northeast.
- 1:20:25He just doesn't know that yet. But it was a fun one.
- 1:20:29I know you got to run. I want to be respectful of your
- 1:20:31time. But yeah, James, thanks a bunch.
- 1:20:34We'll include your Twitter X handle in bio for people to
- 1:20:38check you out there. Anywhere else you want people to
- 1:20:41get in touch with you? Really it's just if, if anybody
- 1:20:46hears a, if anybody listening is a Bloomberg Terminal client,
- 1:20:48that's where like 90 plus percent of anything I do is
- 1:20:51going to be. I share a decent amount of it on
- 1:20:53Twitter. I interact on Twitter pretty
- 1:20:55frequently. But like my real in depth
- 1:20:57analysis and research and tools that I'm building are all going
- 1:21:00to be available for anyone who has a Bloomberg Terminal.
- 1:21:02So that's where you can find me. And then I'm also, I'm on
- 1:21:07Bloomer TV and radio a decent bit, but you won't be able to
- 1:21:09find me there. But I'm also, I'm a regular
- 1:21:11recurring guest on Laura Shin's Unchained.
- 1:21:15Where do we do a show called Bits and Bits?
- 1:21:17But really it's Twitter for the average person.
- 1:21:19What you said it's at the start is where you can find me.
- 1:21:22Awesome, man. We'll have to meet up sometime
- 1:21:24in the Philadelphia area. When you wake, make your way
- 1:21:26down here. Yeah, sounds good, love.
- 1:21:28I love Philly. All right, man.
- 1:21:31Philly, the city. Thank you, Sarah, this is bum.
- 1:21:35Yeah. Thank you.
- 1:21:36Thanks guys. Thanks for listening to this
- 1:21:38week's episode of the show. If you found the information
- 1:21:40valuable, please share the episode with a friend or leave a
- 1:21:42rating on your favorite podcast app.
- 1:21:45All the links we discussed in today's show will be in the show
- 1:21:47notes inside your podcast app. Before we finish, a quick
- 1:21:50reminder that On Rat Media is for informational and
- 1:21:52entertainment purposes only, and nothing should be construed as
- 1:21:55investment or legal advice. Regardless of where you are on
- 1:21:58your Bitcoin journey, we'd love to hear from you.
- 1:22:01Visit onrampbitcoin.com contact to schedule a consultation with
- 1:22:05one of our private client advisors.