Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Immigration Relief: An Introduction with Habiba Simjee
Transcript
- 0:03Thank you for joining us today at Immigration
- 0:06Relief and Introduction. I'm Alapoli Castro,
- 0:09CLE advisor for the Beverly Hills Bar Association,
- 0:12and today I am delighted to introduce our speaker,
- 0:15Habiba Simji. Habiba is the director of Pro Bono
- 0:19at Council for Justice, where she leads efforts
- 0:21to expand access to justice for those underserved
- 0:24communities seeking to assert their legal rights.
- 0:27She has dedicated her career to advancing immigrant
- 0:30rights and has supported legal aid leaders across
- 0:33California through her previous work at OneJustice
- 0:36and the University of California system. Habiba
- 0:39also teaches immigration law as an adjunct professor
- 0:41at the University of La Verne College of Law
- 0:44and Public Service. We can't wait to hear what
- 0:46you have to share with us today, Habiba. Thank
- 0:50you so much for that introduction. Right, let's
- 0:54go ahead and get started, everyone. So, as mentioned,
- 1:01I'm with Council for Justice and today I'm going
- 1:03to do a very broad overview of immigration relief.
- 1:09Excuse me, Habiba. It looks like we're sharing
- 1:11the wrong monitor. Okay, thank you. Apologies
- 1:16for that. So, while I share the correct monitor.
- 1:24Today I wanted to talk about the forms of relief
- 1:30that we screen for in our immigration legal services
- 1:36clinic, the Immigration Legal Assistance Project,
- 1:39also known as ILAP at Council for Justice. So
- 1:43to start. We're going to talk about just some
- 1:46basic fundamentals so that we're all on the same
- 1:50page about terminology and what we're discussing
- 1:53with the client. Once that come in, that's going
- 2:01to be the bulk of our discussion today with a
- 2:04focus. on what we see most in the context of
- 2:09our pro bono immigration legal services. And
- 2:11then we'll close with a little bit of discussion
- 2:13on inadmissibility. Spoiler alert, we will have
- 2:17so much to talk about with pathways to legal
- 2:19status that we're not going to have a lot of
- 2:21time to talk about the very important topic of
- 2:27of inadmissibility. However, we have materials
- 2:34on inadmissibility and also the pathways to legal
- 2:38status for more details. And of course, I'm always
- 2:41happy to answer questions. So I'll be putting
- 2:44up my email, well, the Volunteer Council for
- 2:47Justice email on this slide, which routes to
- 2:51me and then again, at the end of the presentation.
- 2:54So Council for Justice, just as a quick note,
- 2:58we actually have a few issue areas that we work
- 3:01on. By and large, our largest project is the
- 3:05Immigration Legal Services. project and that
- 3:08is, we've been doing that for 50 years. We're
- 3:12actually celebrating our 50th anniversary this
- 3:14year. We also have our domestic violence restraining
- 3:17order clinic located at Stanley mosque. And we
- 3:22also serve veterans and we have a new housing,
- 3:25a multiple detainer answer clinic. So let's go
- 3:29ahead and get started with the fundamentals.
- 3:34So first off, We want to make sure that everyone
- 3:39is kind of familiar with who are the key players
- 3:43in the field when we're talking about the agencies
- 3:48that we're dealing with with our immigrant clients.
- 3:55Some of you may have heard about the Immigration
- 3:59and Naturalization Services, INS. So INS used
- 4:04to be the department or the agency that was kind
- 4:11of in charge of all the immigration applications
- 4:14and services and now since over the last 20 plus
- 4:20years now since September 11 we now have the
- 4:23U .S. Department of Homeland Security and there
- 4:26are three branches under the U .S. Department
- 4:28of Homeland Security that we're primarily concerned
- 4:32with. U .S. Citizenship and Immigration Services,
- 4:37which adjudicates applications for immigration
- 4:40that we're going to talk about. U .S. Customs
- 4:44and Border Protection, or CVP, as we hear about.
- 4:48That's who we see at the airports and land border
- 4:53entries, supports of entry. And then US Immigration
- 4:59Custom Enforcement, ICE, that's been in the news
- 5:02quite a bit. So I imagine everyone's familiar
- 5:05with these agencies now. And then we have a few
- 5:10other departments that are tangentially involved
- 5:14in the immigration process. Under the Department
- 5:19of Justice, we have the Immigration Court System,
- 5:24so the Executive Office of Immigration Review,
- 5:26or EOIR as it's called, and the Board of Immigration
- 5:30Appeals that actually sits under the Department
- 5:32of Justice. Then we have the Department of State,
- 5:37aka DOS. And that deals with the visa issuances
- 5:43and consulates. So if anybody is getting their
- 5:47process completed abroad, like getting their...
- 5:51visa, whether it's an immigrant visa or non -immigrant
- 5:55visa, for example, a tourist visa on the non
- 5:58-immigrant side, or family petition completed
- 6:01abroad, then they would go to their consulate
- 6:05in their home country, which is run by the Department
- 6:08of State. Department of Labor takes care of employment
- 6:11-based petitions, the underlying labor certifications,
- 6:18excuse me. And then the Department of Health
- 6:20and Human Services is involved in refugee resettlement
- 6:27and unaccompanied children programs. Some more
- 6:32basics. So I like to parse out who we're talking
- 6:37about when we talk about non -citizens. And that
- 6:40includes individuals who are lawful permanent
- 6:45residents, AKA green card holders. We have non
- 6:50-immigrants, so as I just mentioned, individuals
- 6:54who hold temporary visas. tourist visas, or business
- 7:00visas, or folks have heard of H -1B, or agricultural
- 7:05worker visas, for example. So non -immigrant,
- 7:10that term is odd, but it really just signifies
- 7:16people who don't have the intention of living
- 7:19in the U .S. permanently. That's why they're
- 7:21on temporary non -immigrant visas versus immigrant
- 7:25visas, like for family petitions or employment
- 7:28-based petitions where people have the intention
- 7:31of obtaining their permanent residence and eventually
- 7:35their citizenship. And then we have undocumented
- 7:39immigrants who have no form of legal status in
- 7:44the United States except for, and I'll go to
- 7:48the next slide. individuals who are considered
- 7:55undocumented but have maybe like a temporary
- 7:57just form of protection. So at the bottom here,
- 8:01and I want to acknowledge all the contributors
- 8:04to these slides over the years that I have been
- 8:09using. So lovely graduate student here created
- 8:12this at UCLA. But the temporary protective status
- 8:17and deferred action for childhood arrivals that
- 8:20have the red X next to them. We consider them
- 8:24under the undocumented bubble, for example, because
- 8:27what we're referring to here with TPS and DACA
- 8:30are not. long -term forms of immigration relief.
- 8:35They do not lead to a pathway to a green card
- 8:40of citizenship in and of themselves, and neither
- 8:42are they non -immigrant visas. And so we see
- 8:46certain categories kind of float within the undocumented
- 8:51immigrant bubble. And then, so this chart really
- 8:55helps us understand that there's kind of a spectrum
- 8:58of options as we move towards gaining US citizenship.
- 9:05So people who are on the pathway to citizenship
- 9:09can be obtaining it potentially through family
- 9:13or employment based petitions or some of the
- 9:15humanitarian forms of relief that I'll be talking
- 9:17about in just a few moments. And through that,
- 9:22they can obtain a lawful permanent residency
- 9:25or LPR status or green card. All those are used
- 9:30interchangeably. And then after a certain amount
- 9:33of time in LPR status, you can apply for naturalization.
- 9:40And the big asterisk there is that folks always
- 9:44need to be screened for anything that might you
- 9:49know, causing issues at the point that they're
- 9:52applying for things like inadmissibility for
- 9:56a green card or issues that might bar them from
- 10:00naturalization. So big asterisks there that we
- 10:03won't actually have a lot of time to get to today.
- 10:07But we're going to go ahead and get into that
- 10:10pathways discussion. It's going to be the majority
- 10:13of our time together here right now. So the pathways
- 10:18to permanent residence include, as I mentioned,
- 10:22family -based. We're going to talk about the
- 10:25two subgroups under family -based. And then employment
- 10:31-based. So employment -based includes some non
- 10:35-immigrant or temporary categories that can have
- 10:39the opportunity to maybe transition into a pathway
- 10:44to Green Card. But really the main folks who
- 10:49are on the pathway to permanent residence are
- 10:54employment -based. options are in the employment
- 10:57based preference categories. And I'm not going
- 11:02to actually discuss the employment based. opportunities
- 11:06for permanent residents today. I'm going to leave
- 11:10that to our amazing colleagues who are in the
- 11:14private bar. This is, you know, not an area that
- 11:19a lot of legal aid or nonprofit legal services
- 11:24works on. And so As such, I'm going to focus
- 11:29on kind of what we see with respect to individuals
- 11:33who may not have those kind of opportunities
- 11:36in the employment -based category. I'm also not
- 11:38really going to talk about diversity visas because
- 11:41it's a lottery system. And so it's really just
- 11:44that quota and kind of folks applying to this
- 11:49lottery for countries that have fewer individuals
- 11:54who immigrate to the US from. I will focus more
- 11:59on some of the humanitarian forms of relief,
- 12:03which tends to be more the bread and butter of
- 12:07the legal aid sector and when we do consultations
- 12:11in the pro bono context. So we're going to talk
- 12:16about asylum, the Violence Against Women's Act
- 12:19or VAWA. the T non -immigrant visa, U non -immigrant
- 12:23visa, and special immigrant juvenile status researches.
- 12:29So what I want to walk everyone through is the
- 12:33pathways to legal status as we discuss it with
- 12:40in our sort of community facing methods. So with
- 12:46INCAKE, how we ask the questions. So that can
- 12:51help us get to the pathways to legal status.
- 12:55So with. family -based petitions. The first question
- 12:59that we generally start with is do you have any
- 13:02immediate family members with legal status? Are
- 13:05you married or have you ever been married? If
- 13:08so, what is your spouse's legal status? Do you
- 13:12have any children? If so, what are their ages
- 13:15and what is their legal status? Do you have any
- 13:17U .S. citizen siblings? What are any of your
- 13:22parents, step parents, or grandparents US citizens?
- 13:27Has anyone ever submitted an immigration application
- 13:30to help you gain legal status in the US? If so,
- 13:33when? And have any of your immediate family members
- 13:37ever served in the US military or armed forces?
- 13:41So this is kind of a long list of questions that
- 13:46allow us to get to What are some of the options
- 13:50that an individual might have through family?
- 13:56As you can see, there's a lot of questions here
- 13:58that we have to parse through with folks. And
- 14:00this is actually not even the full, full list
- 14:05of questions. Trying to make it a little more
- 14:09slide friendly by giving some of them a little
- 14:13more general or combining questions. So some
- 14:16intakes you'll see might even be much more specific
- 14:19with even longer questions. But really, we're
- 14:22trying to get to a couple different things. family
- 14:26-based petition. First of all, are there immediate
- 14:29family members who might be able to petition
- 14:32the individual who's seeking legal status and
- 14:38how they could go about that. So there are different
- 14:43options. For example, the question, the last
- 14:50question related to US military armed forces,
- 14:54family members being in US military armed forces
- 14:56has to do with. a form of what we call parole
- 15:02in place, military parole in place. So just to
- 15:06give you context as to why we ask that, individuals
- 15:10who have immediate family member who served in
- 15:13the US military armed forces may be able to benefit
- 15:17by not only having that family member submit
- 15:21a petition for them, but because we have so many
- 15:25individuals who entered the country without inspection
- 15:30and thus have challenges actually following through
- 15:35on the pathway to obtaining their green card.
- 15:39What happens when we have a family member who
- 15:42petitions for them, who have been in the military
- 15:47armed forces, they can petition the family member
- 15:52through parole in place, meaning they don't even
- 15:55need to leave. the country and trigger certain
- 15:58inadmissibility issues which we'll touch on at
- 16:01the end that would otherwise cause them significant
- 16:06barriers to being able to adjust their status.
- 16:09So that's just one example as to why we ask these
- 16:12detailed questions. So with these questions,
- 16:15what we're getting at is really the core of family
- 16:21-based petitions. which are divided up into immediate
- 16:26relatives and preference categories. So individuals
- 16:32who fall under the immediate relative category
- 16:35as defined under immigration law are beneficiaries
- 16:43of a certain U .S. citizen or U .S. citizens,
- 16:47and the beneficiaries are somewhat specific here.
- 16:50So as we can see, the unmarried under 21 children
- 16:55of U .S. citizen. So. Note there that here, immigration
- 17:01law defines child as under 21, not under 18.
- 17:06That's super important for us in our screenings
- 17:11because age 21 is a major cutoff. in family -based
- 17:18petitions in particular, of course, but any situation
- 17:22where family members are trying to include their
- 17:27children in their application. So they must be
- 17:32under 21 to be considered a child for the purposes
- 17:36of immigration and unmarried. So again, children
- 17:41of US citizens, parents of U .S. citizens where
- 17:46the U .S. citizen is over 21. So the adult son
- 17:54or daughter, which is how we distinguish between
- 17:57child and an adult child in immigration laws,
- 18:04we say adult son or daughter versus a child,
- 18:07which is under 21. So an adult son or daughter
- 18:10who's a U .S. citizen can petition for their
- 18:13parent And then the spouses of US citizens are
- 18:18also considered immediate relatives. So those
- 18:22categories seem to be a little more straightforward.
- 18:26Preference categories is where we see things
- 18:29getting more complicated. So here under preference
- 18:35categories, we have a matrix of options. And
- 18:40the category that an individual is in is very
- 18:44important, as we'll show on the next slide, because
- 18:48it has to do with how long they have a wait time
- 18:52in the visa bulletin. So that's where we go back
- 18:57to the Department of State and sort of the cap.
- 19:02the calculations regarding wait times for immigrants.
- 19:10So immediate relatives, the most important takeaway
- 19:14there is that they have no formal wait time.
- 19:19If it takes time to gain legal status through,
- 19:26say, a petition as a spouse of a US citizen,
- 19:30that's because of processing time and sort of
- 19:33reviewing and adjudicating the application. But
- 19:36other than that, there is no waiting in line
- 19:40to get an immigrant visa as an immediate relative.
- 19:44preference categories, the second matrix is much
- 19:50more complicated because we have to look at the
- 19:53wait times, which I'll show you in the next slide
- 19:55in just a moment. So we have five categories,
- 20:01really four, but one of them split into two,
- 20:04where we see that folks who fell outside of the
- 20:09scope of immediate relatives may have other opportunities.
- 20:13So for example, when we talked about the adults,
- 20:18sons and daughters of US citizens. even though
- 20:21they're no longer immediate relatives, they can
- 20:26still be petitioned by a US citizen parent, but
- 20:32they'd either fall under F1 or F3, depending
- 20:37on whether they're married or unmarried, as you
- 20:40can see. And so they will have wait times unlike
- 20:45their younger siblings who are under 21, for
- 20:49example. We also have options through lawful
- 20:56permanent resident petitioners. So if someone
- 21:00has a green card, they can petition for their
- 21:04spouse and children, again, children unmarried
- 21:06and under 21, and they can actually petition
- 21:09for their adult sons and daughters who are over
- 21:1221, but no, only unmarried sons and daughters
- 21:16over 21. married sons and daughters. So in addition
- 21:22to the many benefits there are to naturalizing
- 21:26in the U .S. and encouraging our community members
- 21:28who are able to naturalize and become U .S. citizens.
- 21:32There's benefits that are wider ranging that
- 21:35have implications for the family members as well
- 21:39and ability to petition more family members.
- 21:42Lastly, we have the F4 category for brothers
- 21:45and sisters of U .S. citizens, which is why we
- 21:49asked in the last slide any questions about whether
- 21:54they have siblings who are U .S. citizens. So
- 21:59the visa bulletin is available on the State Department
- 22:07website. Here's the link on the slide. I often
- 22:12just Google it for the most recent version, so
- 22:15you don't have to write down this whole hyperlink
- 22:17or even click on the slide later. As long as
- 22:21you go to travel .state .gov. and as you can
- 22:25see um so I took a screenshot of the most recent
- 22:30visa bulletin that's putting together these slides
- 22:33and so this is the current visa bulletin for
- 22:37the month of july 2025 and the way that we read
- 22:41it is it lines up in terms of the categories
- 22:46so the rows f1 f2a f2b f3 and f4 with what we
- 22:51talked about in the previous slides with respect
- 22:54to the preference categories. So we see what
- 22:58the categories signify. And then what we see
- 23:02is five different lines for waiting. I've heard
- 23:06this described in really interesting and some
- 23:09funny ways, like your ticket at the deli line
- 23:13and waiting for your ticket to get cold. But
- 23:18then there's five lines at the deli, depending
- 23:21on what country you're from. So I've always loved
- 23:24that explanation. And basically, the reason we
- 23:29see these sort of four columns for China, India,
- 23:33Mexico, and the Philippines is because those
- 23:35are major sending countries and there are more
- 23:39individuals from those countries who are applying
- 23:44in these categories than there are from all the
- 23:47other countries in the world. And because of
- 23:50quotas and some complex calculations, I certainly
- 23:53won't have time to get to today, we see that
- 23:57the timeline can look different for folks from
- 24:02those categories. Although, if you if you look
- 24:06closely at the China column, for example, right
- 24:09now, interestingly, it actually tracks with the
- 24:13rest of the countries in the world. So China
- 24:16is sort of a superfluous column right now because
- 24:18it's actually the same as for everyone else except
- 24:22India, Mexico, Philippines. And I know that this
- 24:26is not a new webinar. So I will I won't be asking
- 24:31for shout out answers, but I general, we like
- 24:34to pause here and just test our reading of the
- 24:38visa bulletin so that we know what to tell folks
- 24:42when they ask us. Someone who is the brother
- 24:51or sister of a U .S. citizen and this individual,
- 24:57let's just say a brother of a U .S. citizen,
- 24:59is from the Philippines, and he says that his
- 25:06U .S. citizen brother petitioned for him at the
- 25:12beginning of last year, so January of 2024. How
- 25:18long will it take for that petition, according
- 25:21to today's visa bulletin? How long will it take
- 25:26for that petition to get adjudicated? So how
- 25:30we read this dates on here is that it's done
- 25:35with sort of the international style of dates.
- 25:38So month, or sorry, I still did it the American
- 25:40way, day, month, year. So we're going to first
- 25:44go to the category that was mentioned. So they
- 25:48said brother or sister of US citizens. We're
- 25:50going to F4. So that last row. And then I mentioned
- 25:55that they're from the Philippines, and so we're
- 25:58going to go to the last columns, that very bottom
- 26:00right corner of this table, and we see that it
- 26:04says 1st of January 06, so 2006. So that is,
- 26:10that references the date of the petitions that
- 26:14they're currently that are currently up for a
- 26:18visa. So again, that ticket at the deli line
- 26:22being called is the analogy that I appreciate.
- 26:26And so if they're now calling petitions that
- 26:31were filed as of the 1st of January, 2006, and
- 26:35this person tells you that their brother filed
- 26:38a petition for them in January, 2024, that means
- 26:42we're looking at an approximate 18 year wait.
- 26:46And that's at a minimum because a visa bulletin
- 26:50can change and often the times get longer, not
- 26:54shorter. So again, I don't want to harp on the
- 27:00calculations and the complexities of the quotas,
- 27:04but it does help us understand. why there are
- 27:11so many folks who are, you know, waiting to be
- 27:14able to adjust their status or gain legal status
- 27:18in the US is there's a lot of family members
- 27:21who are either waiting for their petitions, or
- 27:25they may qualify, even as immediate relatives
- 27:28like lots of parents of US citizens, but they
- 27:31have certain disability issues which we'll get
- 27:33to at the end. So I want to transition to talking
- 27:38about the humanitarian forms of relief. And again,
- 27:42I'll start with some of the questions that we
- 27:45ask in the intake process to help us understand
- 27:51a client's story and what may impact their immigration
- 27:58options. So I'm going to start with the Violence
- 28:01Against Women's Act, or VAWA, which is actually
- 28:05gender -specific. I know we see the term women's
- 28:08in there. However, VAWA is gender neutral and
- 28:14individuals who don't identify as women can apply
- 28:18it also. The question that we start with is have
- 28:22you ever been threatened or harmed by a U .S.
- 28:26citizen, spouse, parent, step parent, or adult
- 28:31son or daughter? And also, and I apologize that
- 28:36we don't have the second part of the question
- 28:37here, it's US citizen or permanent resident.
- 28:42And again, the reason I'm starting with this
- 28:44humanitarian form of relief is it's the most
- 28:47closely related to the family -based petitions.
- 28:50So I'm gonna actually go back again. The reason
- 28:54that we have these vowel protections is to untether
- 28:59an immigrant from their abuser who is in charge
- 29:07of petitioning them for their immigration status.
- 29:10So again, when we revisit that question. The
- 29:14idea is that for a non -citizen spouse or child
- 29:20of a U .S. citizen or lawful permanent resident,
- 29:23they can become a vowel self -petitioner, so
- 29:26they don't have to depend on the U .S. citizen
- 29:29or permanent resident who's the abuser to petition
- 29:33for them. And to qualify under INA 204A, the
- 29:39Immigration and Nationality Act, apologies, the
- 29:44individual must have suffered abuse by the U
- 29:46.S. citizen or permanent resident spouse, parent,
- 29:50or stepparent, or is the child, whether the child
- 29:53was directly abused, of a parent who was abused
- 29:57by a U .S. citizen or permanent resident spouse.
- 30:01Also, as we see in the immediate relative categories,
- 30:07we see that parents of U .S. citizens who are
- 30:10over 21 are also eligible as immediate relatives
- 30:14to be petitioned. And so there is also a carve
- 30:17out for the abused non -citizen parent of a U
- 30:23.S. citizen. So basically in a situation where
- 30:27there's elder abuse. So the vowel has been intended
- 30:33to allow individuals who would otherwise qualify
- 30:38to be petitioned by, again, a spouse, parent,
- 30:43or stepparent, or in the case of a adult son
- 30:48or daughter who's a U .S. citizen and the abuser,
- 30:52to allow immigrants to not have to be petitioned
- 30:57by them and submit their own forms. And of course,
- 31:05for all of these categories that we're going
- 31:07to talk about with respect to humanitarian relief,
- 31:09we could spend at least an hour on each of these
- 31:14categories, discussing the details, discussing
- 31:17evidentiary needs and, you know, kind of what
- 31:23else do people need to know. flag that someone,
- 31:27for example, may meet the definition under VAWA,
- 31:32like what do we need to gather from them? What
- 31:35are the next steps and additional information?
- 31:38I'm going to put up some resources at the end
- 31:41so that if you'd like to do a deeper dive into
- 31:44any of these topic areas, there are some excellent
- 31:47short training videos that are available that
- 31:51do deeper dives and walk us through. um each
- 31:56of these these petitions. So next um I'm going
- 32:01to go through asylum which um a lot of folks
- 32:04have probably um heard about and asylum is tracks
- 32:12with the international definition of a refugee
- 32:17under the Refugee Convention. And so the Immigration
- 32:21Nationality Act, which is the core set of statutes
- 32:27for immigration law, basically adapted the Refugee
- 32:31Convention's definition of a refugee. So what
- 32:34we ask folks to kind of start that conversation
- 32:38and start broadly. So we can, you know, gather
- 32:41more information rather than sort of ask in a
- 32:46way where they might, you know, give us a yes
- 32:50or no answer or in a way that would not allow
- 32:56for more discussion. So these questions are very
- 32:59broad and then we narrow down from there. The
- 33:02question I like to ask folks is, have you ever
- 33:05been harmed or targeted in your home country?
- 33:08Or do you fear you might be harmed or targeted
- 33:11if you are forced to return to your home country?
- 33:15And so if someone says yes, then we need to get
- 33:20into why they were harmed or targeted. or why
- 33:27they're afraid and so the definition here that
- 33:31we have of a refugee which again is we use the
- 33:40term refugee and asylum seeker synonymously as
- 33:44it relates to the definition under immigration
- 33:50law, under the Refugee Convention, the only difference
- 33:53being a refugee is outside the United States
- 33:56and being processed internationally, whereas
- 33:59an asylum seeker has already in the U .S., has
- 34:02already gotten to the U .S. seeking sort of refugee
- 34:09status within the United States. So this is an
- 34:13individual who's outside any country of their
- 34:17nationality. or for a person who has no nationality,
- 34:22basically they're stateless, is outside any country
- 34:25where they last originally resided, and who is
- 34:28unable or unwilling to return and is unable or
- 34:33unwilling to avail himself or herself to the
- 34:36protection of that country because of persecution
- 34:40or well -founded fear of persecution. on account
- 34:44of and here's the really important piece is the
- 34:48on account of triggers a nexus analysis and there
- 34:53are five protected grounds for which someone
- 34:57can claim asylum. That's because they're being
- 35:00harmed or targeted or persecuted or they hear
- 35:04that because of their race, religion, nationality,
- 35:10or membership in a particular social group or
- 35:13political opinion. Now the membership in a particular
- 35:16social group is like a very lengthy, interesting
- 35:23discussion because on its face, it doesn't, we
- 35:28can't really glean anything from what that exactly
- 35:31means, but it's sort of a category that is left
- 35:39to left open for argument so that individuals
- 35:44who are, for example, identify as LGBTQIA, for
- 35:50example, or individuals who are another category
- 35:57that's come up quite a bit under this membership
- 35:59in a particular social group. nexuses women in
- 36:05countries where or in communities where they
- 36:08practice female genital mutilation. So those
- 36:11are some areas where we see that membership in
- 36:15a particular social group come up. So again,
- 36:19this is why we ask sort of these broader questions
- 36:23and then start to narrow down so people can explain
- 36:26their stories to us. And then moving on to our
- 36:32non -immigrant status visas. So these are oddly
- 36:38named because of the way that these were created
- 36:43in 2000 for survivors, but there's a U non -immigrant
- 36:49status or U visa and the T non -immigrant status
- 36:52or T visa, which we'll talk about in a moment.
- 36:54So the U visa as per individuals who are survivors
- 36:59of crimes in the United States. And so we ask
- 37:03people, again, very broadly, have you been harmed
- 37:05in any way since arriving in the US? And if so,
- 37:10very important to the UNISA specifically, were
- 37:14you able to talk to law enforcement? And this
- 37:19is, again, very broad. But what we're getting
- 37:22at is a requirement under INA 101 -815 -U that
- 37:27define what qualifies an applicant for a U visa.
- 37:36So it's for individuals who are survivors of
- 37:39a statutory list of serious crimes, which are
- 37:43on the form for a U visa. And basically it's
- 37:46any crime involving harm and that you must show
- 37:52that you've suffered substantial physical or
- 37:55mental abuse as a result of that certain specified
- 37:58criminal activity. So that can include domestic
- 38:01violence, sexual assault, kidnapping, and attempted
- 38:08murder, for example. You must be helpful in the
- 38:13investigation or prosecution of the crime. And
- 38:16so that's where that second part of the question,
- 38:19the being able to talk to your connect to law
- 38:22enforcement about this crime is super important
- 38:26because the applicant must obtain a law enforcement
- 38:33certification that basically corroborates that
- 38:38they have been helpful, are willing to be helpful.
- 38:43or are any sort of in the process of being helpful
- 38:48in the investigation or prosecution of the crime,
- 38:52whether that's with like a local police department,
- 38:55the FBI, or in the case of like For example,
- 39:02when family law and domestic violence, a family
- 39:04law judge can sign off on this as well, or the
- 39:08Department of Child and Family Services relates
- 39:10to child abuse. So there are different law enforcement
- 39:15agencies that an individual can cooperate with
- 39:21that can sign this certification and say, yes,
- 39:24this person is indeed a victim of one of the
- 39:28qualified crimes, that they've suffered substantial
- 39:31physical or mental abuse, and they have been
- 39:33helpful in the investigation or prosecution.
- 39:37And then one thing to note is that, as I mentioned
- 39:41in the family -based petitions, that there are
- 39:46ways that family members can include their family
- 39:52members in an immigration petition. So with the
- 39:55EU visa, you can include the principal applicant
- 40:00who is the survivor of a crime and include their
- 40:03spouse. their children under 21, their parents
- 40:10if the petitioner is under 21, and siblings under
- 40:1518. So this is where the survivor is under 21
- 40:21and their siblings are under 18. So that's a
- 40:24little bit weird when we've been talking about
- 40:2621 is the 18 here specifically. But one thing
- 40:30to note about the UP says that actually because
- 40:34unfortunately a lot of immigrant community members
- 40:37have been victims of crimes. uh that there are
- 40:41a lot of applicants and the unisa has a very
- 40:47generous waiver for grounds of inadmissibility
- 40:51so a big one for many people is simply that they
- 40:55enter the country without inspection so they
- 40:59don't have a lawful entry into the united states
- 41:02But the view visa, you can ask for a pardon or
- 41:07forgiveness. However, a lot of people understand
- 41:09that terminology in the community. But basically
- 41:13it's a waiver that allows them to say, you know,
- 41:17I have these issues, but because I'm applying
- 41:20for this humanitarian relief. and requesting
- 41:24a waiver. So I've had clients who have multiple
- 41:28unlawful entries, even have had some criminal
- 41:32issues, or they've had removal orders, and they've
- 41:38never left the country, and they've been granted
- 41:41visa status because of how generous that waiver
- 41:43is. The downside is that because there are so
- 41:49many people have applied and the statutory cap
- 41:52is 10 ,000 and it's never been raised from 10
- 41:56,000, there are well over 200 ,000 petitions
- 42:02in the queue. And the wait time for a U visa
- 42:06is now at least 15, if not more than 20 years
- 42:11currently. So that is a huge challenge that we're
- 42:16up against. And it impacts people who are currently
- 42:19being picked up in these ICE raids because some
- 42:22folks have had U visa petitions pending for a
- 42:26long time. And there are arguments that, oh,
- 42:30that, well, they can't just stay here while they're
- 42:33U visa. a petition is pending, which was not
- 42:35the case in the past. So we're seeing a lot of
- 42:39challenges with our current, you know, the current
- 42:41backlogs and lack of change in our immigration
- 42:49systems, including something as simple as raising
- 42:51the cap on new visas. Okay, so as I mentioned,
- 42:56there's a similar non -immigrant center known
- 43:01as a T -visa as well. And this is specific to
- 43:06the crime of human trafficking. So T -visas are
- 43:10only for people who are survivors of a severe
- 43:13form of trafficking in person. The way that I
- 43:20like to ask individuals, again, to cast a wide
- 43:24net and learn about their situation is, has anyone,
- 43:30did anyone bring you to the US by force or were
- 43:33you tricked to come to the US to work? Have you
- 43:36ever been forced to work with little or no pay?
- 43:40And here we see that, In asking individuals that
- 43:47question, what we're trying to get at is whether
- 43:50they meet the definition under the federal code
- 43:55of severe form of trafficking in person, including
- 44:00commercial sex acts or involuntary servitude,
- 44:05peonage, debt bondage, or slavery. So there is,
- 44:11again, a specific definition. And the analysis
- 44:16that we use when we're making sure that the individual
- 44:24qualifies for under the severe form of trafficking
- 44:28in person's definition, and what we kind of outlined
- 44:32in a brief is... is the process, means, and analysis.
- 44:39And so we understand that as someone who was
- 44:43recruited, transported, harbored, or obtained,
- 44:47like obtained as a person, by force, fraud, or
- 44:52coercion for the purposes of involuntary servitude,
- 44:58peonage, debt bondage, or slavery. And so all
- 45:02of those need to be met. to for the applicant
- 45:08to be meet the definition as someone who is a
- 45:13survivor, a severe form of trafficking persons.
- 45:16So once we determine that that has happened,
- 45:20we must also prove that that person is in the
- 45:23United States on the account of the trafficking.
- 45:26Often, if we, for example, meet agricultural
- 45:31laborers, so farm workers who were recruited
- 45:36and then by fraud or coercion are basically in
- 45:41a debt bondage or slavery type situation and
- 45:46they're found and they get help. They can, for
- 45:52example, easily show that they're here in the
- 45:55U .S. on the account of the trafficking. And
- 45:58then for individuals who are over 18, this is
- 46:01similar to the new visa, but not as strict. There's
- 46:05an element of complying with law enforcement,
- 46:09reasonable request for assistance in the investigation
- 46:12of prosecution in here under the TV sets specifically
- 46:16of the trafficking. And again, we see that there's
- 46:20a law enforcement agency certification component.
- 46:25But again, it's not as strict. So there are multiple
- 46:30reasons why an individual may not be able to
- 46:34report to a law enforcement agency, including
- 46:37that they're under 18, so that's not even required,
- 46:41or because of serious psychological trauma and
- 46:46fear. And so you can write like an attorney declaration
- 46:49explaining that. I've done that before and had
- 46:54my case granted without issue and then must show
- 46:58that there would be extreme hardship involving
- 47:00unusual and severe harm upon removal from the
- 47:03United States if they don't succeed in getting
- 47:06a T visa. So that's going to be an individualized
- 47:10sort of assessment. Something that I want to
- 47:14highlight is that The severe form of trafficking
- 47:19in persons and the way that we often read about
- 47:21it in the news, we hear about sort of like the
- 47:28larger group cases, for example, the sex trafficking
- 47:32rings and the massage parlors, for example, or
- 47:37like I mentioned, the agricultural workers. um
- 47:40there are situations that have that what we call
- 47:43of like crossover so one that's really important
- 47:46that i want to highlight is domestic violence
- 47:49and human trafficking crossover so there are
- 47:52individuals who who may describe to you what
- 47:56they um think is just domestic violence but really
- 48:01when you when you parse out what's happened to
- 48:04them like you know brought to the us and harbored
- 48:09by their trafficker, like forced to stay at home,
- 48:12not allowed to leave the house. Like there's,
- 48:14you know, the elements of control and abuse,
- 48:17but they're forced to basically be like servants
- 48:22in the home, caretakers of extended family members.
- 48:29And they're held in by forced fraud, coercion
- 48:34through the abuse. they too can make an argument
- 48:40that they've been trafficked. And again, I've
- 48:44had a case of that approved without issue where
- 48:48we explained how that a piece of relationship
- 48:52was really a severe form of trafficking. And
- 48:55the reason I mention this is because the T visa,
- 48:59while it's similar to the U visa, has a much,
- 49:01much a smaller number of applicants. So the cap
- 49:08for T visas is 5 ,000, which is half of that
- 49:12of the U visa, but that cap is never met. Like
- 49:17there's never enough applicants. And so for my
- 49:21T visa clients, they've gotten their T visa so,
- 49:26so much faster, like. many, many years sooner
- 49:30than the UV compliance. And so they're on their
- 49:33pathway to getting a green card and citizenship
- 49:36much sooner. So lastly, I will mention the last
- 49:40humanitarian form of relief is special immigrant
- 49:44juvenile status, also known as SIGIS or SIJ.
- 49:48And this is for individuals who are under 21
- 49:51and unmarried. And we ask, are both of your parents
- 49:57present in your life? So this is only for individuals
- 50:01who are under 21 who are asking this to unmarried
- 50:03and under 21. And another sort of question relatedly
- 50:10is have either of them harmed or neglected you?
- 50:13So as Ella mentioned, I used to work in the University
- 50:18of California system. So I came across a lot
- 50:20of individuals who are under 21 and were coming
- 50:24from single parent households or were had been
- 50:28raised by other guardians like aunts, uncles,
- 50:33grandparents. And found is that they. almost
- 50:38always qualified for special immigrant and juvenile
- 50:41status where they could not be reunited with
- 50:44one or both parents because the either the absent
- 50:47parent or absent parents were abusive or neglectful
- 50:52or abandoned them and they and then this the
- 50:57step that where we really got involved was getting
- 51:01them a state court order either in probate court
- 51:05for guardianship or if they're still under 18
- 51:09in family law through, family court through parentage
- 51:14or in a custody situation, declaring them the
- 51:19dependent of the poor or legally committed to
- 51:22an individual like a guardian or the single parent.
- 51:26and that the court finds that it's not in the
- 51:29immigrants' best interest to return to their
- 51:31country of origin. So we just really want to
- 51:34flag this. It's a very important form of relief
- 51:37for our youth. And again, I know that this is
- 51:42a lot of information and that I'm trying to condense
- 51:45so much in a pretty short period of time, so
- 51:48I'll of course have our email up at the end to
- 51:51ask any follow -up questions and to provide additional
- 51:54resources again. So to round out this conversation
- 51:58on the pathway's delinquent status, here's a
- 52:02chart for the admission process. So what happens
- 52:05once we identify from those intake questions
- 52:09that an individual might qualify either for a
- 52:12family -based petition or one of the humanitarian
- 52:16forms of relief. Well, they have to submit that.
- 52:20underlying petitions. So like, for example, these
- 52:24numbers here, like the I -130 is for family -based
- 52:27petitions, I -140 is for employment, or in the
- 52:32I -360 we use for special and juvenile status
- 52:36or Valo applicants. There's others like the I
- 52:40-918 or I -914 for the UNT non -immigrant visas.
- 52:45Anyways, so we have that as like the basis of
- 52:49why qualify for permanent residence. And then
- 52:53the second step is whether you're actually eligible
- 52:56to get the permanent residence or obtain the
- 52:59green card. And so with that, there's either
- 53:03someone is eligible to adjust their status within
- 53:06the United States by submitting Form I -485.
- 53:10or if they did not enter the country lawfully
- 53:15and do not qualify for a waiver like we mentioned
- 53:20under the UNT non -immigrant visas. then you
- 53:27may have to go to your consulate in your home
- 53:31country and do the DS -260 and consular process,
- 53:37which can present really significant issues,
- 53:40as we talk about in just a moment, and our last
- 53:42item, inadmissibility. The adjustment of status
- 53:46is far more advantageous because it's within
- 53:51the United States, it's adjudicated inside the
- 53:54United States, whereas consular processing by
- 53:56its nature is outside of the United States. And
- 54:01I have that little green bubble for the inadmissibility
- 54:03waiver. I will not have time to talk about this
- 54:06long list of important factors that hamper individuals'
- 54:14ability to uh adjust status aka get their green
- 54:19card or permanent residence in the inside the
- 54:22united states however um one of the handouts
- 54:25um that was provided as part of your materials
- 54:28i think does a really good job of providing an
- 54:32overview of the most common forms of inadmissibility
- 54:36that we see that impact individuals and whether
- 54:40they even have the opportunity to ask for a waiver
- 54:44and potentially still move forward with their
- 54:48green card or permit resident application. So
- 54:52the biggest one we see is unlawful presence.
- 54:56So unlawful presence is any time spent in the
- 54:58United States where you're without lawful status,
- 55:01whether it's after a visa expired or whether
- 55:05it's after entering the United States without
- 55:08lawful documents and you're over the age of 18.
- 55:12Another one that we see commonly is alien smuggling,
- 55:18basically helping other individuals enter the
- 55:20United States, which happened very commonly with
- 55:23parents who, you know, of course brought their
- 55:27children with them, failure to appear at a removal
- 55:31hearing or having removal orders. In your past,
- 55:37there's fraud, misrepresentation, false claims
- 55:39of U .S. citizenship, what sometimes people get
- 55:42caught up in when they're taken at the border,
- 55:46and they don't know what to do, but they don't
- 55:50want to, of course, be in detention. And then
- 55:53there's other serious issues that may be a little
- 55:56more difficult, like political and national security
- 55:58grounds. There's criminal and invisibility grounds,
- 56:01which is like, full other really long -term discussions
- 56:07and then economic grounds, mainly like public
- 56:11charge, which we've been hearing about. So we'll
- 56:14try to end this somewhat on time and leave a
- 56:18moment or two for questions, if there's been
- 56:20any questions in the Q &A, which I haven't had
- 56:22a chance to look at. and also know where we can
- 56:28find additional resources. So as I mentioned,
- 56:34I highly recommend, if you have a moment, please
- 56:37read that handout. That's part of your material,
- 56:42the grounds of inadmissibility for permanent
- 56:44residence by our... friends at Citizen Path.
- 56:50It's a really great set of online resources on
- 56:53their website. But this one I thought was my
- 56:58favorite, it's been my favorite handout in terms
- 57:00of explaining inadmissibility. And it is kind
- 57:04of client facing, so it's really easy to understand
- 57:07for folks who are not in the day -to -day practice
- 57:10of immigration. And then, the re -screening for
- 57:17relief. handout which basically goes over everything
- 57:22that I discussed plus a little more and it's
- 57:25very timely as put out by the Catholic Legal
- 57:28Immigration Network Clinic at the start of the
- 57:32year because so many folks who have temporary
- 57:36protected status, for example, or other temporary
- 57:39forms of protection have had that stripped in
- 57:44our limbo situation since the start of the new
- 57:47administration. And so something that folks are,
- 57:52you know, scrambling to figure out is whether
- 57:55they have other options available to them. And
- 57:58so this rescreen for relief is a great guide,
- 58:01because it basically provides a rubric for consultations
- 58:05in general, but it is a little tailored to the
- 58:10individuals who are, you know, very affected
- 58:15by the new administration's rollback of protection.
- 58:19And lastly, as I mentioned, there's a number
- 58:21of follow -up videos that you can watch for each
- 58:28of the forms of relief that I mentioned and the
- 58:30ones that I didn't get to under employment based.
- 58:34So under the Pro Bono Training Institute, PVTI,
- 58:39which, you know, shout out to my previous organization,
- 58:42OneJustice, that... provides this platform and
- 58:47hosts all these great videos. I send this video
- 58:53series to our volunteers so that they can watch
- 58:55on their own time and go into as much detail
- 58:59as they'd like. There's an Immigration 101 series
- 59:04that basically covers what I just covered, but
- 59:07in a little more depth because there's more time
- 59:12in the videos. a series on justice status, for
- 59:17example, series on asylum, U visa, et cetera.
- 59:21I highly recommend it as a follow -up. And then
- 59:24lastly, if you have any questions or are inspired
- 59:29to volunteer with us at Council for Justice,
- 59:33please contact me at volunteercouncilforjustice
- 59:36.org. That is routed to my inbox. So I will see
- 59:42these emails. And also, as I mentioned in the
- 59:47beginning, we're celebrating our 50th anniversary
- 59:50of our immigration assistance project. And so
- 59:55stay tuned. We'll be sending the HBA a follow
- 1:00:00up on our save the date for our September 10th.
- 1:00:07event for our celebration of our immigration
- 1:00:10work at Council for Justice. So again, thank
- 1:00:13you very much for your time and I'll stay on
- 1:00:17for a few moments for questions here. Okay, so
- 1:00:24it looks like we have A few questions. One of
- 1:00:29them from a Sherry Diamond asked, given the years
- 1:00:32and decades long backlog, what happens when an
- 1:00:34individual ages out of their respective category?
- 1:00:39Great question, Sherry. So I didn't even get
- 1:00:42to Agile or Child Status Protection Act. So depending
- 1:00:46on the type of relief that is applied for, there
- 1:00:51might be protections from Agile. For example,
- 1:00:56immediate relative petition, your age is frozen
- 1:01:01as of the date that you apply. So like I had
- 1:01:05a student who was turning 21. I still remember
- 1:01:09this on November 17th. And we begged USCIS to
- 1:01:17schedule the mom's naturalization interview on
- 1:01:21November 14th. And as soon as she completed the
- 1:01:26naturalization interview and took the oath. we
- 1:01:30submitted the petition the next day and her age
- 1:01:33was frozen as to under 21 for that purpose. Not
- 1:01:38all categories benefit from that and so it is
- 1:01:41a specific case by case specific inquiry about
- 1:01:46the type of petition and where that individual
- 1:01:52fits in like as a derivative principle etc. Okay,
- 1:02:02and then I have another question from a Mr. Jack
- 1:02:07Russo. He's mentioning a hypothetical, a startup
- 1:02:13founder who just graduated with an MBA at Stanford,
- 1:02:18but no money, ask for help. What is possible?
- 1:02:22Yeah, that I will. gladly admit is out of my
- 1:02:28wheelhouse in the sort of legal aid world. There
- 1:02:32are amazing attorneys in Los Angeles, and if
- 1:02:38they're still in the Stanford area, Bay Area.
- 1:02:41in a private bar who work on employment -based
- 1:02:46options for individuals who have professional
- 1:02:49degrees or, you know, might be, might even qualify
- 1:02:53in their, like, an entrepreneur category. And
- 1:02:56so I highly recommend reaching out to one of
- 1:03:01our colleagues who does those type of cases.
- 1:03:06And I'm happy to provide referrals if you'd like
- 1:03:08to email us. Great, thank you. And then I do
- 1:03:16have someone asking about, I'm trying to see
- 1:03:20if you can rephrase a question regarding the
- 1:03:23due process rights for undocumented individuals.
- 1:03:29Let's see. I guess we'll just make a plug to
- 1:03:33Know Your Rights or KYR presentations. And while
- 1:03:37those may not cover every issue area and there's
- 1:03:41kind of different forms of Know Your Rights and
- 1:03:44we used to do them in the federal building where
- 1:03:48our clinic is housed for individuals who are
- 1:03:51going to have immigration court hearings and
- 1:03:53ICE check -ins. There's a lot of wonderful Know
- 1:03:58Your Rights resources out there about the rights
- 1:04:02of our immigrant community members who are, you
- 1:04:07know, subject to being at risk for detention
- 1:04:12or deportation proceedings. And so it is a very
- 1:04:19difficult time as folks know out there and there's
- 1:04:22been a lot of violations and challenges. And
- 1:04:26so again, happy to share kind of like current
- 1:04:29events and resources if you are looking for something
- 1:04:33specific and want to email me. Alrighty, great,
- 1:04:39thanks. So that's just about it for questions.
- 1:04:41This concludes today's presentation. We would
- 1:04:44once again like to thank our speaker, Habiba
- 1:04:46Simji, for such an excellent presentation. And
- 1:04:49of course, a big thank you to our audience and
- 1:04:51our members for learning with us today. Have
- 1:04:54a great day, everybody.