Latest / TheThinkingAtheist / Why Isn't the West Talking about Islam? (with Nuriyah Khan)
Transcript
- 0:05The Thinking Atheist. It's not a person, it's a symbol, an idea.
- 0:10The population of atheists in this country is going through the rule, rejecting
- 0:14faith, pursuing knowledge, challenging the sacred. If I tell the truth,
- 0:20it's because I tell the truth, not because I put my hand on a
- 0:24book and made a wish and working together for a more rational world. Take
- 0:29the risk of thinking. Feel so much more happiness. Truth, Usian wisdom
- 0:33will come to you that way. Assume nothing, question everything, and start
- 0:40thinking. This is the Thinking Atheist podcast hosted by Seth Andrews. There is
- 0:56video of this conversation. YouTube. Blame is in the description box of the
- 1:02show. I'm always fascinated by the stories of ex Muslims, people who can
- 1:08give us an inside out look at the world's second most popular religion. Naria
- 1:15Khan is such a person, an ex Muslim and an activist, and she
- 1:21joins me here. So nice to have you, thanks for coming, Thank
- 1:23you so much for having me. Seth excited to be here. I can't
- 1:27get the West excited. Well, it's an overstatement. When I post a
- 1:33video about Christianity, Scientology, Mormonism, I don't know whatever I will get
- 1:40a certain level of engagement. Islam is a harder sell in the United States.
- 1:46We're up to our eyeballs in Christian nationalism, so obviously that's our main
- 1:49point of focus, but I just can't seem to get a whole lot of
- 1:53traction. I'm sure this video will be seen, but by a tinier fraction.
- 1:59Do you feel that the West has a blind spot when it comes to
- 2:02Islam. I think absolutely it does, and I think it's part and parcel
- 2:07to also do with kind of not just the claims that Islam makes for itself,
- 2:12but also the kind of level of vitriol that one gets trying to even
- 2:16touch the subject of Islam, and how successful they've been trying to push kind
- 2:21of, you know, words like Islamophobia out there into the mainstream, and
- 2:24it's kind of seeped into the Western psyche. Is something to be ever so
- 2:29scared of kind of being labeled racist or Islamophobic go hand in hand, particularly
- 2:34in the UK context. I think here we've got a massive problem. I
- 2:38think the Islamism is slightly more kind of under check in the USA, and
- 2:44again that's got to do with I guess the way that just I guess the
- 2:47country is set up in general, but the flow of immigration and the way
- 2:52America hasn't kind of regressed into these almost ghetto like Sharia dominated parallel because in
- 2:59the UK, for example, we've got UK courts and then we've got Sharia
- 3:02courts running parallel in major UK cities. But I think the West definitely has
- 3:07a blind spot because of a the vitriol that you get when you touch a
- 3:10subject or religion like Islam, and the pushback that we see for Muslims and
- 3:14all the silencing going on. And then again it's sad because mainstream politicians do
- 3:19kind of bend over towards the voting bank, which again in the UK context,
- 3:23a lot of the Muslim votes managed to hold sway when it comes to
- 3:29things that not even politicians but mainstream media channels propagate. So yeah, there's
- 3:34definitely something here that needs to be looked into across the board. I guess,
- 3:37whether it's the US or the UK, or any Western country for that
- 3:39matter, because Islam is something where it's dormant until it's not. I have
- 3:45to come back to the word ghetto. This is not a pejorative about the
- 3:50Muslim culture. Are you saying that there are like impoverished areas. Where does
- 3:54that word come from? Help me understand? Sure? So I mean again
- 3:58in the UK context, for example, there are so what I mean by
- 4:01guess is like a it's almost like a situation where waves of immigration have come
- 4:08and then it's ended up in a birds of a feather flocked together type situation,
- 4:12because like with something like Islam, it's a kind of all encompassing ideology.
- 4:16So whichever communities settle together, halal shops are going to come up,
- 4:20moss are going to come up, They're going to stop the building of other
- 4:24kind of religious schools or institutions. So over time that area gets more and
- 4:29more concentrated by one particular demographic. And again in the UK context, that
- 4:33demographic is overrepresented when it comes to accessing social welfare, council housing, being
- 4:41unemployed, things like that. And then that kind of just goes hand in
- 4:44hand to strengthen the fervor of Islamisism, and we get people who are for
- 4:49all, for lack of a better word, they're kind of lost in life
- 4:53or they don't have that have access to the opportunities that they would if you
- 4:58know, let's say, assimilation had as a project been undertaken better in the
- 5:01UK, and so then they get drawn into facets of fundamentalism or things that
- 5:06they hear at the Friday sermon in the masques, or you know, things
- 5:11that Islam promises them that they're currently not being able to achieve in their everyday
- 5:15lives. Is it a purposeful desire not to assimilate into the laws of the
- 5:21UK. I guess what I'm asking is, would someone who is adhering to
- 5:27Sharia under the eyes of Allah consider laws of the UK illegitimate. I think
- 5:33the crux of the matter is that if you are a good Muslim or a
- 5:39goran abiding Muslim, let's say, then theoretically speaking, you absolutely have to
- 5:44be at loggerheads with let's say, whether it's Western or secular laws or the
- 5:48law of the land here in the UK. Under the theology of Islam,
- 5:53you are meant to always kind of strive for a state where Sharia as a
- 5:58Sharia law is redundant as a well, because Sharia is the law, but
- 6:00where Sharia reigns supreme, and until then there are always various levels of struggle
- 6:05at place. So whether it's like a personal struggle in the way of doing
- 6:11whatever you can on an individual level once you have emigrated to a non Muslim
- 6:15country, and then there's various levels of scholars who talk about infiltrating from within,
- 6:20and we have to bide our time until we get strong enough or power
- 6:25of numbers so as to overthrow the current status quo so to speak, and
- 6:30instare Sharia. So I think the problem fundamentally when it comes to being a
- 6:33good believing Muslim, in your heart of hearts, you know that until you
- 6:38are living under Sharia, which is God's divine law, then you're not actually
- 6:44living in the best state as of Muslim Umma. So when I say ummah,
- 6:46I mean the entire nation of Muslims. So in terms of like a
- 6:50worldwide struggle, it is that. And fundamentally, if you look at Sharia
- 6:56and its tenants, and its punishments and its governings of all things, it
- 7:00is fundamentally like it comes into contention with whether it's the Human Rights Charter or
- 7:05the kind of secular laws that we've established for ourselves wherever in the West,
- 7:11those two things cannot exist together. We're going through a flavor of that with
- 7:15Christianity. We've got people who are like, well, the Great commission right,
- 7:19go ye into all the world. We have dominion over all the earth,
- 7:23God said so. So it's going to be Christian schools, Christian Congress,
- 7:28see at Christian White House. There's this desire to sort of take over
- 7:30the culture, and I see reflections of that and any fundy faith that certainly
- 7:35Islam qualifies. The first of February was World Hijob Day. This is an
- 7:43annual event. I'm going to draw from their own website and you can comment
- 7:46the annual event encouraging women of all religions and backgrounds to experience the hi job,
- 7:54spread awareness and celebrate this expression among Muslim women. I've expressed my own
- 8:00thoughts on World Hitjob Day. I would like to hear yours, says an
- 8:05ex Muslim, what is the hijob and what's your take on World Hitjob Day.
- 8:11I'm really glad you asked that, Seth, because a lot of us
- 8:13who have come from Islamic backgrounds and understand what goes on behind closed doors to
- 8:18you know, in most situations anyway, and in different parts of the Muslim
- 8:22world, we have just expressed complete despair at there even being such a thing
- 8:28as World Hitjob Day. So we've kind of counted it this year with no
- 8:31hijob Day, and we will continue to do so so long as they,
- 8:35you know, continue to purport world hit job Day. But essentially the rationale
- 8:39behind that is that a lot of people in the West, and especially Western
- 8:43feminists as well, but a lot of Muslims in the West who also consider
- 8:46themselves feminists, which is highly oxymoronic, but they claim that the hijab is
- 8:52a free and fair choice, and you know, it's almost like any other
- 8:54religious symbol or what have you, completely discounting the experience and the real lived
- 9:01trauma that women in let's say, countries like Iran and even Afghanistan at the
- 9:07minute are going through. And it's turning a blind eye to, for example,
- 9:09what happened to Masamini and the way that she was tragically killed for showing
- 9:13two strands of hair, and then the protests that ensued after that, and
- 9:18hearing the cries of Iranian women who are saying, enough is enough. We're
- 9:22absolutely done with being policed this way, and the backlash whether you know,
- 9:26you look at even Muslim countries that don't necessarily say that we have a mandated
- 9:31hijab law, women that have to wear hijab in those countries, for example,
- 9:35a lot of parts of rural Egypt. There's been video circulating on social
- 9:39media where even if you were to think about taking off your job, how
- 9:41would your family members react? And the things that have been said casually in
- 9:46passing about how fathers or sons or husbands or brothers or uncles would you know,
- 9:52take matters into their own hands, and what they would do to these
- 9:54women for even thinking about taking the hir job off. So there is so
- 9:58much jura and shunning and intimidation and coercion and physical abuse that goes behind putting
- 10:05on the veil, let alone taking it off. So I mean absolutely until
- 10:11it actually is, with no qualms and no restraints at all, a free
- 10:15and fair choice for women in the Muslim world. Until then, we can't
- 10:18celebrate this as a day or a cloth to be celebrated. In fact,
- 10:22if anything, it is a tool of oppression and Islam. The fact that
- 10:26you know it can be found in the Garan and it kind of goes back
- 10:30to this is the word of God. And if you've got Islamic regime such
- 10:33as the Taliban in power or even the regime in Iran. You will see
- 10:37that as soon as quote unquote true Islam comes into play. It is mandated
- 10:41for women, and not even women, young girls. So again it calls
- 10:45into question, how can there be a choice and how is their free and
- 10:48fair consent when girls as young as three are being forced to wear hijab and
- 10:52it's being celebrated and their face is covered up. So it just reinforces hyper
- 10:56sexuality, rape culture, modesty culture, purity culture, everything that we're trying
- 11:01to kind of fight against. Do you feel like Saudi, Arabia, Iran,
- 11:05Afghanistan, etc. Have weaponized world hit Job Day is part of their
- 11:11desire to overtake the culture. I mean, you know, it's a marketing,
- 11:13it's Christmas, you know, as far as trying to make the hijob
- 11:18a positive do you feel like that governments may be helping to fuel that fire?
- 11:22I think so. Obviously it's a bit different, I guess countrywide across
- 11:26the Muslim world, for example, like Saudi is kind of especially with MBS
- 11:31and power, he's taking a slightly different approach. But for regimes like the
- 11:35one in Iran for example, and the Taliban as well, absolutely they would
- 11:39lap it up and the fact that it plays right into the hands of like
- 11:43I said, you know, progressive Western feminists here. I mean some of
- 11:48the videos I saw coming out of schools in the UK where they've just set
- 11:52up stalls and you know, they're allowing little girls from all faiths to come
- 11:56and just try and wear the hitjob and see what it's like, almost as
- 12:00if like it's some kind of gimmick and as you said, rightfully, like
- 12:03a pr strategy of some kind. Again, my issue is that at the
- 12:07minute, we're not that powerful, we're not really out there in the mainstream
- 12:11as ex Muslim activists. So what I always try and do is, especially
- 12:15here in the West, people who have access to our you know, videos
- 12:18and resources, is to also go right back to show them the origins of
- 12:24the hijab in Islam and how it came into Islamic theology, which is,
- 12:28you know, it's a massive red flag in itself because, especially coming from
- 12:31a Sunni Muslim background. In the Hidith, we find that it wasn't even
- 12:37something that the prophet Muhammad wanted for himself or that was a direct command from
- 12:41Allah. It actually came from one of the Prophet's companions at the time.
- 12:46Omar ibn h'adab, and it's a very embarrassing story of why it was revealed.
- 12:50The verse of veiling was revealed, and again it's very dark in terms
- 12:54of why it's obligated for Muslim women whereas other women aren't. Actually they're encouraged
- 12:58not to wear it, so you can differentiate between the two. So I
- 13:03always try and kind of bring that back into the forefront as well, just
- 13:05to kind of you know, counter this this or they've had free reign over
- 13:09this pr for so long. I've mentioned the West and my frustrations on this
- 13:16end, and you know, it's hard here. I am. I'm a
- 13:18white, middle class ex Christian, you know, corn fed Oklahoma and trying
- 13:24to address Islam. Some people say that I am not qualified because I am
- 13:28not an ex Muslim, because I'm not engaged or surrounded in the culture.
- 13:33How would you address that? Do I get to participate in this? What
- 13:37do you think? Absolutely? You two set them. Please don't let them
- 13:41try and stop you, because this is this gatekeeping again, has been going
- 13:45on for so long. I mean, if they try and gatekeep us people
- 13:48who are you know, from the communities and left or dissented and according to
- 13:52Islam, we're now causing fitna or mischief in the land, and what we've
- 13:58done is akin to treason. But the same tactics they use to shut down,
- 14:01especially people who they think that they can apply the Islamophobic or the racist
- 14:07trope to and also you know that classical trope of you don't understand Arabic or
- 14:11you're not a scholar, and all of these kind of things, which is
- 14:15just any line of critique that they fear is coming to or towards Islam.
- 14:22They've used these strategies to shut down in silence people for so long. And
- 14:26again that's why I'm very grateful now because before somebody like myself even would probably
- 14:30be a bit wary of criticizing Islam because I bought into this. You know,
- 14:33I thought, even when I was leaving Islam, I did have those
- 14:35moments where I thought, you know what, I am not a scholar,
- 14:39and you know what, I don't speak this classical fussthart Arabic that the Gouran
- 14:43was revealed in. So you know, do I really have the wherewithal to
- 14:48question this and leave it? But once you know what the Internet's done,
- 14:52now, these these mystical resources that were that were in Arabic and only available
- 14:56to on the bookshelves of scholars. They are now there our fingertips. So
- 15:01to be honest, Islam is absolutely fair game for everybody to criticize as an
- 15:05ideology, and I implore everyone to do that. And again with Islam,
- 15:09it's a beautiful thing to criticize it because it makes such grandiose claims for itself
- 15:15that as soon as one thing falls, the entire pyramid crumble, so to
- 15:18speak. Personally, I grow weary of all of these people who seem eager
- 15:24to find disqualifiers. You know, we want to advocate for people across the
- 15:30color and culture, and religious or non religious, you know, the sexuality,
- 15:35whatever whatever differences we might have. People seem far too eager to say,
- 15:39well, you're not us, therefore you cannot participate. But if we
- 15:43see each other as the human condition, right then this Oklahoma redneck ex Christian
- 15:50can join hands with Nariya Khan, the ex Muslim living in the UK,
- 15:56and you and I can stand shoulder to shoulder. I mean, I find
- 15:58that refreshing, right, and you feel like advocates like us are necessary and
- 16:03the West is missing the opportunity. Am I reading that right? I think
- 16:08margin NOAs has coined the term in the UK. He used to be an
- 16:12ex his boo the hery member, but he coined the term the bigotry of
- 16:15low expectations. And I think the problem or like what's lacking in the West
- 16:21in terms of, you know, really realizing these advocacy movements or you know,
- 16:26what certain activists are doing, all these organizations that are coming together,
- 16:29is falling into the trap of of the bigotry of low expectations. For example,
- 16:33oh, that's maybe you know there, let's say Eastern traditions or that's
- 16:37their culture. And oh, even if you think that that's happening in that
- 16:41element of society, and let's say, you know, young girls are being
- 16:44married off, or there's you know, x amount of child marriage going on
- 16:48or FGM is taking place, then oh, that's just those people. But
- 16:51surely you know that can't be ingrained into their actual religion or what they truly
- 16:56believe, or they're not really acting on the right commands of God. They're
- 17:00skewing things, or culture and religion have meshed in it in a negative way.
- 17:04And when you do that, the fundamental problem for example, in Islam,
- 17:07it's very easy, like I said again, because the Quran is the
- 17:11word of God. It's not inspired, it's not a collection of other people's
- 17:15interpretations. It's actually the literal word of God. It's infallible, it's eternal,
- 17:19it's timeless. So when you've got a document like that that is giving
- 17:25rise to so many of some of the darkest horrors of society, there is
- 17:30no time for us to hide behind the bigotry of low expectations, or you
- 17:33know, for people who genuinely care about human rights or secularism and more progressive
- 17:40values in the West to give the Quran, or let's say even some of
- 17:42these Christian fanatic pulls a carte blanche to you know, this is just some
- 17:48bad apples. But the doctrine is okay. Now, Islam is a religion
- 17:52of peace, don't you know, right? I mean, we hear a
- 17:55lot of that. I want to talk to an x Moleuslim about the insanity
- 18:02going on in the Middle East, Israel, Palestine, Amas, etc.
- 18:07We'll get into it next. My patrons get the broadcast early and commercial free,
- 18:18and your patronage helps me do what I do. Thank you so much
- 18:22for your support Patreon dot com slash Seth Andrews continuing my conversation with ex Muslim
- 18:32Nriea Khan, there is so no I'm going to talk about your story in
- 18:37just a second, Narrea, as an ex Muslim. First of all,
- 18:41I guess I'm going to do some housekeeping. Can you explain the difference between
- 18:45the Shia Muslim and the Sunni Muslim? I mean, can you give me
- 18:51the basics? Sure? So, in a nutshell, essentially, the split
- 18:56between some news and she has happened basically after the death of the prophet Muhammad,
- 19:03so and it's all to do with his succession, and she has believed
- 19:07that it should have gone to Ali because he was like that from the bloodline
- 19:11of the prophet, whereas Sudney's don't really go with the lineage or the bloodline
- 19:15argument. And they think that Mohammed's rightly guided one of his companions, the
- 19:19four rightly guided Caliphs were actually entitled to the succession after Mohammed. So there's
- 19:26a massive split there. And then the Shias go and kind of split amongst
- 19:30themselves as well. So they've got an entire their own kind of body of
- 19:33literature, and the only thing that Sudney's and she has kind of really agree
- 19:37on is that the Quran as the word of God, because after that our
- 19:41secondary sources, which is still extremely important, are completely different. Do they
- 19:45hate each other? I don't know how else to ask the question, but
- 19:49you know, is there a rift? Did they despise the other? Because
- 19:52that's a false faith. There is a massive beef. Yes, there is
- 19:59a lot of beef. Okay, you were I'm trying to picture you in
- 20:03the hijab or the nikob under the veil? Were you the submissive Muslim woman?
- 20:08So I was more of the younger, curious Muslim. So interestingly,
- 20:12when I was living in the UK, I was nine years old, and
- 20:17just through my daily moss classes and what we were told and what my Koran
- 20:21teacher would tell us, when I turned nine myself, I decided to wear
- 20:25hijab because that's the age where you know, nine is where things really kick
- 20:29off for a Muslim girl. So I thought that this is what Allah has
- 20:32commanded me to do, and I decided to wear the hijob. I'm an
- 20:34anomaly in the sense that, as I was saying before, the hijob is
- 20:38rarely ever a free and fair choice without duress or psychological kind of you know,
- 20:45an emotional manipulation behind it. But in my case, it genuinely was
- 20:48a situation where the decision was all mine. In fact, I was weirded
- 20:52out that nobody else was wearing it because it was, you know, it's
- 20:56the path to heaven. Obviously I wanted to get to heaven. So funnily
- 21:00enough, when I moved to such a heavily Islamic country like Saudi Arabia,
- 21:04and the am baya was mandatory after a certain age, about nine ten,
- 21:08so you can't leave the house without the kind of full black abaya. You
- 21:11weren't mandated to wear a hijab until you're kind of in your mid teens,
- 21:15i'd say. In Saudi it was the case that I was getting more and
- 21:18more liberal just by virtue of the school I was in. It was extremely
- 21:23international. There were so many different sets of Muslims that I had never even
- 21:27come across. All I was told in the UK was with Sudney, and
- 21:30there's Shias out there, and there's other non Muslims, but Shias are also
- 21:36considered non Muslims in the eyes of many Sidney. So yeah, Interestingly,
- 21:40enough, I was more more Islamic in the UK than I was in Saudi
- 21:42Arabia. I'm interested in Saudi Arabia, a human rights nightmare. Frustrating that
- 21:48the United States has such a cozy relationship with Saudi Arabia. We just seemed
- 21:52to sit on our hands and take the money. I don't know, do
- 21:56you have an observation from your vantage on the world old the US Saudi Arabia.
- 22:02Well, I think you're you're on the mark there because I think it
- 22:04goes both ways. Like in terms of this bilateral relationships, it's money talks
- 22:10over everything. And even the way that Saudi have approached the US, you
- 22:14can clearly tell that when it comes to the leadership. When I lived there,
- 22:18there was a lot more control by the So you've got the royal family
- 22:22and then you had the Olemma, which was kind of like the religious clergy,
- 22:25and they held a lot of weighted in terms of Saudi's foreign policy and
- 22:30just the way that Saudi kind of projects itself on the international stage. And
- 22:34since I've kind of come like since nine to eleven, and obviously now since
- 22:38MBS has taken over, their influence is slowly but surely kind of being weaned
- 22:44away from them and the powers being more conscious concentrated within the actual ruler and
- 22:49within the royal family. And again I just Saudi Arabia has realized now that
- 22:56they need to go down a similar path to let's say, what UAE and
- 23:00Qatar and things like that have been doing. But in terms of their relationship,
- 23:04I think even when you come look at Muslim countries like Saudi Arabia or
- 23:08the UA before it, money is so much when it comes to economics and
- 23:14progressing and tourism and attracting experts, Islam goes under the bus very easily.
- 23:21We were congratulating Saudi Arabia for finally allowing women to drive a few years ago,
- 23:27and I thought, I just don't understand, ironically said, even once
- 23:33they let women drive legally, the women who were the activists that had fought
- 23:37for the right for women to drive were still languishing in prison and then home
- 23:41arrest so sorry, under house arrest. So again it was like this pr
- 23:47stunt to the world, but again deep down the human rights of the very
- 23:51women that fought for that, you know that they still weren't even allowed to
- 23:53leave the country for some time. So there was that going on in the
- 23:56background. Talk to me about you and the Korean? Did you know your
- 24:02scripture? So essentially in the UK, growing up again, going to mosque
- 24:07every single day, first and foremost, I guess this is the story in
- 24:11most Muslim households, but you are taught to and encouraged to read it in
- 24:14Arabic. So I was doing that, and I'm not sure if this is
- 24:18replicated across the country here, but in my particular mosque, they actually had
- 24:22a book of translations published, so it was the Quran in English, but
- 24:26again it was quite old English, I'd say even Shakespearean English, so seven
- 24:32eight nine year old me is not really you know. I memorized kind of
- 24:34the first few verses, and I memorized the English for it as well,
- 24:38but then there was no way I could keep up so effectively. I'd read
- 24:41the Qoran twice but in Arabic, and then I just know the verses like
- 24:45as you said that the cherry pick verses that you need to get through the
- 24:48prayers. How dies Naria Khan the Muslim become Narya Khan the ex Muslim.
- 24:53What happened? Ah? So there was a number of things that was just
- 25:00things that I'd pushed to the back of my mind having grown up in Saudi
- 25:03Arabia and the UA, particularly Saudi Arabia. You can imagine as a young
- 25:07child going from England to Saudi Arabia and then hearing about headings and things taking
- 25:12place after Friday prayer, and all of a sudden, most of life is
- 25:17segregated. Even going to restaurants, you sit in a family section, all
- 25:21boarded up. So I was being exposed to this kind of Islam that was
- 25:23very different from what I imagined Islam to be. And at the time,
- 25:26I was just being told by you know, my parents what I'd questioned them,
- 25:30that this is a Wahabi form of Islam, and they here in Saudi
- 25:33they've taken it to the nth extreme. This isn't really the Islam that we
- 25:37follow. So I was kind of plasated with that for a while. Then
- 25:41we moved to the UAE and I thought, wow, this is a great
- 25:42mix of East meets West, and this is how Islam should be. You
- 25:45know, it's not like shoved in your face, but it's there enough to
- 25:49be like, we're a Muslim country. You hear the call to prayer,
- 25:52but you're not forced to cover up, you can intermingle with the opposite sex
- 25:56like things seem relatively normal. And then I was still very much a believer.
- 26:02I'd come back to university in England, I studied some modules in Islamic
- 26:06law. I was defending ludicrous things in essays, like for marriages and women
- 26:11getting half inheritance and their testimony being worth half in court. And I was
- 26:15defending these with actually Quronic and Islamic jurisprudence texts. But then it wasn't until
- 26:21I went back to the UE as an adult, was in a horrible marriage
- 26:26that I try to escape and get out of, and when I had finally
- 26:30escaped from that marriage, the lure to try and bring me back against my
- 26:34will, where my ex husband had got a lawyer who went back into ancient
- 26:41Sharia. They've had discussions about this concept of disobedience, especially in Egyptian and
- 26:45Tunisian courts, but it goes all the way back to the Quran, where
- 26:49even if you fear disobedience from your wife, you know you're entitled to these
- 26:53measurements, including beating her. So they've interpreted first of all, fear disobedience
- 26:59in many ways, and me just leaving the house and my own volition and
- 27:03not wanting to live there anymore constituted disobedience for the purposes of the Sharia clause.
- 27:08So essentially the UA police were trying to forcibly arrest me and take me
- 27:12back there, and I wasn't allowed to leave without my husband's permission the house
- 27:17ever, So this is like hardcore Islam that was put down on me.
- 27:21But again at the time, I was a staunch believer in Allah and you
- 27:26know the true Islam that I thought, so I imagine this was just men
- 27:30in positions of power abusing their power, and they've distorted the word of God.
- 27:33When I eventually managed to leave the country and I was advised to come
- 27:37back to the UK, where these things don't apply, just for my own
- 27:41safety, I looked into again, still as a believing Muslim, I thought
- 27:45that I'm going to be told many a time if I share my story that
- 27:48oh, this is what happens under Islam, or you know, this is
- 27:52what happens under Sharia, And I was trying to defend my position. So
- 27:56I tried to understand, as now with an adult mind, that how have
- 28:00some men got something so twisted out of such a divine message from God and
- 28:04Sharia by virtue of it being derived directly from the Quran. I went to
- 28:10the Quran, and instead of being all mystified and oh my gosh, I'm
- 28:12coming face to face with the words of God, I thought, let me
- 28:17legally read this text and see how from this verse you can get this legal
- 28:22stipulation. And then when I read the Quran ver betim and English honestly seth,
- 28:27it was like just the rug being pulled from under my feet. And
- 28:30then I went back to Muhammad's life, the hadith that I mentioned earlier,
- 28:33which is so important for Sudney's I went back and read the life of the
- 28:37prophet, and I was sick to my stomach. Did you find yourself defending
- 28:42I don't know how to say it, Muhammad the pedophile? Right? Mary
- 28:47did six consummated at nine? Right? Was it aisha? Where's the name
- 28:51of the girl? Did you find yourself defending that story at some point?
- 28:55Absolutely not? And again this is what's so insane. As a Muslim,
- 29:00I had no idea. I absolutely they taught me hours and hours of things
- 29:04in mosque and in grand class, and not once was I told that his
- 29:07youngest wife was six years old, let alone that he consummated the marriage at
- 29:11nine. The first time I came across that was as an adult back in
- 29:15the UK, where I could actually freely research these things, because you have
- 29:18to remember as well, growing up in the UAE and Saudi Arabia, everything
- 29:22was monitored online, so even using VPN, you couldn't even be seen to
- 29:27be looking at websites that were contrariant to Islam or had any kind of differing
- 29:32opinion, if you know what I mean. So I never knew I get
- 29:36angry, or at least frustrated with casual moderates, even somewhat disconnected Christians,
- 29:42people who use the Christian label and they aren't outraged by the extremism. They
- 29:48aren't engaging with the people who were trying to take over the culture and oppress
- 29:53others. And I found myself going, get off your ass, right,
- 29:57come help us. And I feel the way that I feel about Christians,
- 30:03moderate Christians, I feel that way about moderate Muslims. Is that misplaced?
- 30:07Like part of me is thinking you are kind, good, wonderful, loving
- 30:11people who will support humanistic values. You are not aligned with the gi hottists,
- 30:18but you're awfully quiet, and we could surely use you. I don't
- 30:22know, is that wrongheaded? Nari? What are your thoughts? To some
- 30:29degree, you're definitely right, because you know, there's even memes out there
- 30:33which I think encapsulate this idea really well. But sometimes you know, they
- 30:36say like, the extremists are like the snakes, and the moderates are the
- 30:40grass that they hide amongst. And in a way, you know, even
- 30:42for example, if an extremist is let's say something like with the apostasy laws,
- 30:47an extremist of the view that apostate of Islam should be killed, there
- 30:51are moderates out there who know the extremist is saying that, and as you
- 30:56said, they're either awfully silent on it and they're saying, well, we
- 30:59won't do it, but he will in the name of our God. And
- 31:03that's when it becomes a serious issue because this doesn't fall across the board for
- 31:07all Muslims, because I have to for example, even in my situation,
- 31:11there are genuinely Muslims out there, and this is the craziest thing is that
- 31:15they don't know the extent to where the extremist mindset is coming. From and
- 31:19how readily available it is to start believing in that extremist mindset just from your
- 31:25text itself. A lot of these like moderate, let's say, or liberal
- 31:29Muslims, still have the Quran just covered in a nice piece of cloth on
- 31:32the top shelf of their bookshelf. And even with the Hidith collection, for
- 31:36example, there are hundreds of thousands of Hidith. There's no way that anybody's
- 31:40gone through them all. So usually it's the case that you know, it's
- 31:44these extremists who know their religion really well and they've really learned to play to
- 31:48the innocence of these moderates and liberals by saying, we're just working towards inn
- 31:53Islamic or a Muslim ummah, and you guys should be part and parcel of
- 31:57that struggle. And that's that's sometimes the only way that Muslims can hold onto
- 32:02their identity or whatever concept of this a month they have is yeah, there
- 32:07is something that binds us all together, and what is that? That is
- 32:09Alam or the concept of being united under Islam. But absolutely, you are
- 32:15right. There are times when, for example, even what we've seen in
- 32:17the wake of what's happening in the Middle East, and things like that.
- 32:20Really, if Islam is getting such a bad rap, you'd expect that the
- 32:23moderates would come up and want to distance themselves from these people. Well,
- 32:28you just don't see that wide and large enough by any means. Here's a
- 32:32hot button. You can tackle it, you can skip it, no pressure,
- 32:37Gaza, Palestine, Israel, right, it's insane, And I've been
- 32:43watching everybody put it into a box here in the United States, especially the
- 32:46American evangelical supports Israel under any circumstance, right because it's part of our Biblical
- 32:52apocalypse narrative. For thank of a better way of saying it, Zion must
- 32:57be established and therefore Israel can do whatever it want. And then there are
- 33:01others who say that Israel is the evil one. I don't know, It's
- 33:05just I don't know how you can reduce this into a binary model. Do
- 33:08you have any thoughts, opinions, perspectives on what's happening right now? So,
- 33:14just for some context, Seth So, I came from, like I
- 33:16said, growing up in Saudi Arabia. There were times when I would be
- 33:21chanting free Palestine, and all of the symbolism in the school would be just
- 33:25a wash with the Palestinian flag, and there was no way living in Saudi
- 33:30Arabia that you'd even hear the other side or you'd entertain the other side.
- 33:34So I've kind of been conditioned in this whole conflict, and you know,
- 33:38just seeing it for all these years play out to only see it one side,
- 33:43and Israel was the enemy all across the board. There was no qualms
- 33:46about it. Israel was one hundred percent of the enemy, and we wanted
- 33:50to free Palestine. And it's only once I am just talking about my personal
- 33:54journey here in terms of how I once viewed this conflict as to now how
- 33:58I'm trying to kind of, you know, take a step back and understand
- 34:00the various elements of it, because there are so many different facets to this
- 34:04and it's in no way a situation where you can break it down into like
- 34:07a dichotomy or pick a side or binaries or anything like that. But for
- 34:12example, October seventh, for me, with my crystal clear understanding of what
- 34:17as a good Muslim I need to feel, believe, and do according to
- 34:21Islam, it was just way too in line with that and everything that I've
- 34:25been taught. So I never confronted the actual levels and depths of anti Semitism
- 34:34and hate it for pretty much everybody else, but actual the core anti Semitism
- 34:38that comes from the Quran, and like I said, the Sunni literature.
- 34:42I'm sure even the Shia literature is filled with it, but Sunny literature in
- 34:45particular. And again, I've had to personally just to understand this conflict a
- 34:52bit better, even if people say it's not just a religious conflict. To
- 34:54understand the religious element of it, I had to honestly go to courses about
- 34:59anti semit and things like that to unlearn basic ideas that will put into my
- 35:04head whether it comes to Jews or Israel or all the most far fetched conspiracies
- 35:09that you could think of. And you know, Israel and America working in
- 35:13tandem because those are the biggest enemies, and especially when you take a religion
- 35:16like Islam, those are the two enemies that you continuously focus on. And
- 35:21this is kind of where in the larger at the broader Western world as well.
- 35:24But this is weather concept of daral Islam and Daryl Harb really comes into
- 35:29play, which is the house of Islam versus the house of War. And
- 35:32until America and by extension, Israel are in power and more powerful Islam will
- 35:38continuously be in a state of Daryl harb in an effort to attain daral Islam.
- 35:45So yeah, it's from a humanitarian perspective, it's extremely tragic what's happening.
- 35:52But then when you see that Harmas have absolutely no care in the world
- 35:58for their own civilian casualties and the channeling of funds and things like that,
- 36:02and the fact that you know the ceasefire was broken on October seventh, I
- 36:07wasn't quick to like, I didn't want to be quick to react and just
- 36:09have like a knee jack reaction to it. But I feel like it is
- 36:13my job as an ex Muslim to also show that, you know, this
- 36:15isn't just some benign geopolitical I guess it's like a toxic conflict if anything,
- 36:22but it is more than that. And when people try and play down the
- 36:25religious elements behind it, I would implore them to look at like you said,
- 36:30even from the Christian and you know the perspective of Judaism, there is
- 36:34going to be a final end blow here. But Muslims are trying to bring
- 36:37that as on just as much as the other side. So both sides are
- 36:42to blame heavily when it comes to this and the fanatical elements that religion allows
- 36:46for to be where we are today. As we talk about you mentioned you
- 36:51sort of graced over the fact that we tend to be reductive. I've heard
- 36:55that. Well, you know, Palestine loves Hamas, they voted in Hamas,
- 37:00they support Hamas. They've got it coming, right, They're all guilty.
- 37:04So if we bomb the shit out of them, they kind of deserve
- 37:07it. Perspective on that, well, I think Palestine, even what's happening
- 37:14now with videos coming out of Gaza, you see that the Garzens themselves are
- 37:17getting sick of Hamas and they just they're begging just to leave, to live
- 37:22in peace and for you know, the bombings and things to stop. So
- 37:25yes, there's been polls where the majority of Garzens, let's say, would
- 37:29still favor Hamas. But the more that this conflict is going and then the
- 37:34more the world is seeing how many you know, young lives and innocent lives.
- 37:37I would say innocent in the sense that they are also victims of this
- 37:42evil ideology and they're victims of these fanatical fascist Islamists who, to be honest,
- 37:49are living the most luxurious lifestyles abroad in the GCC, particularly in Qatar,
- 37:54and the people. It's trickling down now to the people where if they
- 37:59are a pre idf soldiers and saying that we appreciate you more than Hamas,
- 38:05then there's seriously something to be looked at here. Because the people themselves now
- 38:09are done. They can see the Islamists for what they are. Hamas does
- 38:14not want peace. They have made it extremely clear, and obviously these things
- 38:17are you know, clear as data see in their charter, and their charter
- 38:22links all the way back to Islamic doctrine. So again, this is when
- 38:25I say toxic. It's just because when you've got those religious elements at play
- 38:29here as well, and you've got this concept of domination and the point of
- 38:32contention that this is such a holy site, I worry for for the safety
- 38:37in the lives of all these gardens who genuinely are done. Next up,
- 38:42let's talk about Islam as a racist religion. Question mark, Let's get the
- 38:49perspective of my former Muslim special guest after this. It's funny when I do
- 39:00shows like this Sometimes when I talk about Christianity. People come into the comment
- 39:05sections and say, well, why aren't you talking about Islam, you coward?
- 39:09So we talk about Islam as we're doing on the show today, and
- 39:14I'm sure in the comments we're going to see, well, why are you
- 39:15talking about Islam when you live in the United States? Christianity is the biggest
- 39:22threat, you coward. You're just no pleasing everybody, right, And I'm
- 39:25not in the pleasing everybody business. And I think we can and should be
- 39:30talking about the second most popular religion on planet Earth. I am doing so
- 39:37now with an ex Muslim and an activist, Nara Khan. I've heard x
- 39:44Muslims say this talk about a hot button. Is fundamental Islam a racist faith?
- 39:54You want to skip this one? Not enough? That's fine. It
- 39:59was just a very good question. Well what I hear you? And we
- 40:01mentioned the anti Semitism, right. I remember a while back I had seen
- 40:07this. It was on YouTube. There was a fundamentalist, hardline Islamic children's
- 40:14TV show and the children had a mascot which looked a little bit like our
- 40:19Mickey Mouse, and to indoctrinate hate into the kids, they had a Jew
- 40:27come in and kill the mascot and the children were crying and they were horrified,
- 40:35and the message that they came away with was that these Jews the animals,
- 40:39you know, they all deserve that they're beyond redemption and they will kill
- 40:44everything that we hold dear. Now, these you know, six seven year
- 40:47old children talk about victims. And so I have to ask about is there
- 40:53rampant racism within fundamentalist Islam itself? I would have to I would have to
- 41:01argue, yes, there is. If anything, I'd say it starts off
- 41:05with Islamic supremacy one hundred percent. That's kind of like the benchmark. And
- 41:10as you rightly said, as a young Muslim, again, I feel awful
- 41:16for even the way that my own mind was conditioned. And like I said,
- 41:21it's again depending on the sect of Islam, but fanatical Islam most definitely
- 41:25is is racist and hierarchical, if anything, because even within let's say the
- 41:31Islam that they want to establish, there's going to be Muslims, and let's
- 41:37say whatever sect is dominant, the other Muslims would also kind of be,
- 41:40you know, not considered Muslims for those purposes. But when it comes to
- 41:45Christians and Jews and polytheists. The Polytheists are very much at the bottom of
- 41:51the hierarchy when it comes to Christians and Jews. The Koran does refer to
- 41:55them as people of the book, obviously, and you know, Islam latches
- 42:00onto a lot of the prophets that are mentioned in the Bible, the Old
- 42:04Testament and the New Testament, and they kind of make that connection, but
- 42:07you know, again it's very much overshadowed by all their books have been corrupted.
- 42:12They are the scum of the earth, all of these things. And
- 42:15obviously, in Muhammad's lifetime, what he experienced and the interactions that he had
- 42:20with Jews and some of the times that he was mocked, and even the
- 42:23fact that I think, I personally think the fact that a Jewish woman,
- 42:27according to Sidney scripture, had a hand to play in his death has also
- 42:31kind of really emphasized this hatred in the Islamic psyche for anybody that is not
- 42:39not Muslim. And that's what Islam is so good at doing. It's us
- 42:43versus the other, now the other's everybody falls into that category. So even
- 42:47when I was growing up as a young Wislim girl here in the UK,
- 42:52I was taught that Shias are not proper Muslims. I was taught to not,
- 42:54you know, truly befriend Christians and Jews, all of these. And
- 43:00it comes so naturally when you're a young child and your brain is like a
- 43:02sponge and you know you're absorbing information. You're absorbing this information from figures of
- 43:07authority who you naturally look up to. It can be very, very problematic.
- 43:13And you could only imagine if if this is happening within families where you're
- 43:16at least still exposed to other ideas and progressive values at school or by society
- 43:22as a whole, when this is happening in enclosed spaces, within modresses where
- 43:28you have no alternate thought, it just intensifies and intensifies, and you really
- 43:34view the other as, you know, completely not worthy of anything human.
- 43:39And this is also the way that Muslims currently treat us, the way they
- 43:43refer to x Muslims. If you were to see on exceth if they call
- 43:46you, they call us Merthods and Murdadines and garf. It's all these are
- 43:51all slurs. These are very pejorative slurs to make you feel like, you
- 43:54know, you're subdued, the same thing that the grand says to what you
- 43:59need to implement in Again, like I said, in a perfect Islamic state
- 44:01that the fanaticals want Christians and Jews would be dimmis. So Dimmi is a
- 44:07second class citizen who you're essentially paying protection money to the Muslim rulers and leaders
- 44:14just to exist. So, whether you want to call it racism or you
- 44:17know, some level of human hierarchy or division, it's an extreme form of
- 44:22Islamic supremacy. Are the attacks more vitriolic do you feel because you're an ex
- 44:28Muslim woman? I would say so, yeah, in terms of like they
- 44:34are more crude, and you know they as Islam is very sex obsessed anyway,
- 44:38a lot of the insults aimed at women are just ex Muslim women are
- 44:43mostly to do with, you know, their looks or what they've now become
- 44:46since they've left Islam, and you know, all of those kind of like
- 44:51more sexually I guess, repugnant insults and threats to kind of lure you back.
- 44:57But yeah, again, it just speaks volumes about the Muslim psyche and
- 45:00the mentality. So the more it's exposed, the better, I guess.
- 45:05Do you feel like that a lot of these misogynist men are total hypocrites,
- 45:10if you're because I've heard reports that all the things that they say you're not
- 45:15supposed to do, the things that are haram, when nobody's looking, they're
- 45:20doing them. I don't know, is there a sub culture? Is there
- 45:22maybe the culture of these patriarchs who are doing all the sins that they preach
- 45:29about in public. Yeah, I mean even if you just look at like
- 45:32the British Muslim community in the UK, for example, it's hypocritical on so
- 45:37many levels. You know, you've got Muslims who are seemingly believe in Muslims,
- 45:44and yet they'll be at the casino on a Saturday night, or you
- 45:46know, they'll be drinking whiskey, but then they'll draw the line at a
- 45:49ham sandwich and go ape shit at somebody else, but even having a bite
- 45:52of a ham sandwich. So we joke about people's like halal to haram,
- 45:57ratio just being whatever is they want. But you're right as well, like
- 46:00all of these countries that you know have Islam and this segregation and everything as
- 46:07Islam should be. For example, a country like Pakistan, highly patriarchal society,
- 46:12highly aggressive sexually repressed, yet they are the highest ranking country when it
- 46:17comes to the number of porn watchers, and not just watching kind of you
- 46:21know, standard porn, but you know, really obscure and dark categories of
- 46:28porn. And so it's just kind of like you're outwardly saying one thing,
- 46:32but these are the same people who behind closed doors are engaging in, you
- 46:37know, everything they supposedly stand against. All their religion stops them from engaging
- 46:42in and seth It goes back to the promise of Islamic heaven as well.
- 46:45It's just, you know, you're not allowed to eat pork and drink in
- 46:49this life, but in heaven you've got a brothel full of seventy two virgins
- 46:53and God will feed you alcohol from his own hands. So it's weird if
- 46:59it's in this life and a reward in the other. It's a strange contradiction.
- 47:04As we draw to a close, what do you need from us?
- 47:07Like, what is the ex Muslim community? What is the Muslim community as
- 47:12we fight for human rights looking over the ocean, not really understanding Islam,
- 47:19not really understanding the plight of the ex Muslim, not understanding the hitjob.
- 47:23Hell I don't know what do we do and what can we do? Do
- 47:27you have any thoughts? Oh, that's a really good question. I think,
- 47:32like you said initially, just to bring this conversation a full circle,
- 47:37I think first and foremost dialogue. The fact that we're here today and the
- 47:40fact that I can show my face and have this conversation with you knowing that
- 47:45I could probably live to see another day. It means that we've definitely got
- 47:49somewhere. Not that that's saying much because I live in the UK and it
- 47:52should be. It should be, you know, it shouldn't be a second
- 47:55thought that that should be the case. But there's so few of us,
- 48:00but people like yourself who you know, have come out of religion. There's
- 48:05so much common ground, there's so much overlap. There are so many things
- 48:09that are the reason that we speak out against those things because we understand the
- 48:15root cause. So I think if we can come together and really push dialogue
- 48:19and not in a way where we isolate Muslims necessarily, because I find that
- 48:22to be very unproductive, so I usually go down the you know, completely
- 48:27taking the mick out of religion. I think everything with a slash of comedy
- 48:30is a bit easier to digest or to completely just say, look, let's
- 48:35be intellectually honest and let's scrutinize these sources, because why not. We should
- 48:39be able to, and we need to use the mte of the internet to
- 48:44do that. But having voices like yourself obviously just you know, be like,
- 48:49help our push that narrative that when we talk about these other religions so
- 48:52candidly or we're dealing with these problems, we need to include Islam in the
- 48:58narrative. And yes, we need to bear in mind that Muslims are also
- 49:02victims of Islam. Many of them are unaware. I mean, my own
- 49:07family did not know that Islam had a deathshed punishment for apostasy. They,
- 49:10as British Muslims, very educated and progressive, could not fathom that. And
- 49:15in their heart of hearts, they don't believe that I should be killed again.
- 49:19I could argue that they're not good Muslims for thinking that way, but
- 49:22they're damn good human beings. So there is that kind of little area we
- 49:28have to just have dialogue. It's a very sensitive area. But people like
- 49:31yourselves and conversations like this, I think, I just this is exactly the
- 49:35need of the hour, and we need to stop kind of you know,
- 49:37walking on eggshells around this. This is why I follow Nria Khan on Twitter,
- 49:44which I still refuse to call X by the way, and I'm going
- 49:46to include that link in the description box. Thank you, thanks for helping
- 49:51to paint a three dimensional portrait of what this religion is, what it does.
- 49:55I know there is a rising underground of ex Muslims, right would?
- 50:00I mean the many haven't shown their face, but there seems to be a
- 50:02ground swell of x evangelical Muslims just waiting for their day in the sun?
- 50:09Am I reading that right? Yeah? We're coming out of the woodwork,
- 50:13slowly, visually and honestly seth when when things lift in terms of postacy,
- 50:19and you know, we have better surveys coming out of the Middle East of
- 50:22the numbers should be astonishing in the next few years. Wonderful. The work
- 50:25you do is so important. Thanks for sharing an hour with me and we'll
- 50:30continue to follow you online. Okay, thank you so much for having me.
- 50:34It was the pleasure. Follow The Thinking Atheist on Facebook and Twitter for
- 50:37a complete archive of podcasts and videos. Products like mugs and t shirts featuring
- 50:43the Thinking Atheist logo, links to atheist pages and resources, and details on
- 50:47upcoming freeth on events and conventions. Log onto our website, The Thinkingatheist dot com