Latest / Destiny Community Podcast / Firing Range Ep. 64 - BUNGIE INTERVIEW!
Transcript
- 0:00Hello everyone, Thank you very much for joining us, and welcome to Firing
- 0:03Range, a podcast to talk about all things destiny, weapons, abilities,
- 0:07loadouts, and the Sandbox at large. And we haven't been around for a
- 0:11while, but we had an opportunity to come back and have a nice discussion
- 0:16with former co hosts of the show. Now a member a game dev at
- 0:21Bungee, please join me in welcoming mercu Les. Hello everyone, the gentle
- 0:30wave to the camera. Yeah, so tonight it's going to be me,
- 0:34Cammie Drew and merk Cool Guy will not be joining us, but we have
- 0:39a lot to talk about because the last two twigs up on Bungee dot net
- 0:45over there have been pretty interesting and going over some stuff regarding the future of
- 0:52the Sandbox and PvP changes going forward. Starting I believe Murky, correct me
- 0:56if I'm wrong. March fifth is correct, Ye is correct. Excellent.
- 1:02So yeah, we actually have a bunch of questions submitted by the community,
- 1:07submitted by y'all. So for those of us joining live right now for the
- 1:11streamed version of this podcast, be aware this is not an opportunity to fire
- 1:17off a bunch of questions at mercules. I mean as much as we would
- 1:19all like to these. You know, he works on the weapons team,
- 1:25so he is at liberty to talk about what he is at liberty to talk
- 1:29about. We're not gonna mercules. Do you have authority to talk about everything
- 1:34under the sun at Bungie? Yes? Oh no, you don't, okay,
- 1:38Roger? That okay. So with what he is permitted to talk about,
- 1:46well, we'll go ahead and hit him with the questions that y'all have
- 1:49submitted. So again, thank you for doing that. And if we have
- 1:53opportunities for a discussion on any question, that'll be great. Murk. I
- 1:57believe you also have the list of questions somewhere. Great, I do,
- 2:01indeed excellent. Did you want to go into order or was there anything burning
- 2:06on this list that you wanted to start off on a particular order or a
- 2:10particular you know, a particular step or note or something. We can probably
- 2:16just go top to bottom because they're all kind of categorized into various things.
- 2:22So like, I think it'll make it easier for listeners to follow along if
- 2:24we talk about all of the stuff that relates to to one topic in one
- 2:29place, as opposed to bouncing around. Sounds good and I do apologize.
- 2:34If there is any strange audio in the background on my end, I will
- 2:37try to mute very quickly something going on in my neighborhood. But more on
- 2:40that another time. So firing off with question number one, which says I
- 2:45thought Bungie said they wouldn't try and make Checkmate into the default PvP experience when
- 2:50it first entered labs, but we are now getting a special Ammo economy reminiscent
- 2:55of Checkmate, paired alongside ability cool down nerves. Is this a case of
- 3:00changes on paper sounding more daunting than they are. Yeah, I mean,
- 3:05that's actually a super fair question. We did clarify on Twitter and I quote
- 3:10it is not our intention to make the original Checkmate into the core PvP experience,
- 3:15but we are experimenting with the current iteration of Checkmate to gather data,
- 3:20lessons and feedback we can use to eventually tune the base PvP sandbox. So
- 3:24the original Checkmate that we got is pretty substantially different from the tuning that's going
- 3:30to happen in the March update on March fifth. There are some similarities in
- 3:34that, like we tuned ability cool downs across the board, we tuned primary
- 3:38weapons and we used a nammometer to grant special AMMO. But the way those
- 3:45things interact is pretty substantially different. And Checkmate was like a huge swing in
- 3:52one direction, right, Like when you played Checkmate, you knew for a
- 3:53fact you were playing something different, right, Whereas the changes that we're putting
- 3:58in to the March fifth update are more They're designed to where you can feel
- 4:02them, Like you can feel that your abilities are maybe a few seconds slower.
- 4:06You can feel when you hit a body shot that's not as effective as
- 4:11hitting a crit. But they're not designed to be such large swings that the
- 4:15game feels unfamiliar on the whole, right, Like we're not trying to remove
- 4:20abilities from your kit. We're not trying to slow down everything across the board.
- 4:27It's really a more refined and like a narrower focus on what we try
- 4:30to balance in that one. Yeah, removing abilities from the kid, that
- 4:33would be what a shoot hardware is for, right is that a Yeah?
- 4:39That is literally what hardware is for, and that's something players have been asking
- 4:41for for a long time. Like I'm just don't take these numbers that I'm
- 4:45going to throw out as like take these numbers, Yeah, like, don't
- 4:47take these numbers as like the gospel. I'm just going to use numbers as
- 4:51like an example of like the type of tuning that this is. Right,
- 4:56It's like if primary weapons were fifty percent of VP, like in the March
- 5:01fifth update, they might be like sixty percent of PvP, right, It's
- 5:04not like we're trying to make them ninety percent of PvP where the only thing
- 5:09you can do is use double primary. You know, like we tuned health
- 5:13by fifteen percent, right, we tuned ability cool downs by fifteen percent.
- 5:17Like that's kind of generally the window where we were looking to move the things
- 5:23is like about fifteen percent. It's not you know, this thing is no
- 5:27longer able to be used ever under any circumstances. Put it in your vult,
- 5:30don't take it out for me. It's not that type of tuning,
- 5:31if that makes sense, got it? You know? The always the interesting
- 5:34thing is when we have you on here, when we are fortunate enough to
- 5:39speak to anybody at Bungie, I'm always dying to ask like a million follow
- 5:42up questions, But like I'm sure some of them it might be a natural
- 5:46conversation. To others, it might be a a not so natural conversation.
- 5:49I'm just so interested, Like, I'm sure you've got your hands in the
- 5:53dough plenty for what is coming down the pipe on March fifth, based on
- 5:56everything, I mean that you just all that everything that you mentioned about how
- 6:00it feels like you took a certain sized swing but not a gigantic swing,
- 6:06right, Like, does it does it feel good? Like I'm I'm super
- 6:10interested in I mean, I like it a lot. Speaking for me personally,
- 6:14play tested it for a very long time. I personally have a lot
- 6:18of fun in it, and I think the changes that we as a team
- 6:23made were good changes for the health of the game overall. We all obviously
- 6:28read the original Sandbox Twitter where we outlined the problems that the Sandbox kind of
- 6:31has, right, and those are real problems. They are really affecting the
- 6:35game. They are really affecting our ability to onboard players to retain players.
- 6:41So like, those are things that need to be addressed, and that's what
- 6:46we took a swing in doing, is addressing those things. And I personally,
- 6:50again think from my time playing it in playtests that it did a pretty
- 6:55good job of it. But you know, we will see when everything ship
- 7:00out Live. I'm sure everyone in the community will have lots of feedback about
- 7:01it, and we'll be listening to that feedback and we'll take what everyone says
- 7:06to heart because it's a lot of variables changing all at once. For sure.
- 7:10It's probably one of the bigger sweeping sandbox changes we've done for BVP,
- 7:15maybe since Forsaken. Honestly, Oh, really interesting, Okay, So I
- 7:19mean we're changing a lot of variables at once, and people have already brought
- 7:21up stuff like, well, why didn't you guys do this, or why
- 7:24didn't you guys do that? And like, at a certain point, it
- 7:26came down to there were a lot of changes in flight and we had to
- 7:29kind of draw a line and like put the stuff out there and let players
- 7:31play with it and see where it is, and like, yeah, some
- 7:34stuff did get a little bit left behind and some stuff is maybe too hot,
- 7:39but we have confidence that we can act quickly on those things, okay,
- 7:44and tune and iterate and stuff like that. And there's a couple of
- 7:46other questions later on in the document that I think we'll touch on, like
- 7:50specifics of stuff that people were concerned about. So can't wait. We're going
- 7:54to move on to the next question here. Oh by the way, also,
- 7:58if we are super fortunate to have you here, and I want to
- 8:01be respectful of your time, So if at any point, I mean usually
- 8:03we do what an hour and a half, but if at any point you
- 8:07know, you got to tap something like that, you just let me know.
- 8:09I blocked off the whole night for it. So my band, let's
- 8:13go until we had all the time. I can take the next one.
- 8:15If you want full please go ahead, CAMMI, Yeah, this one's close
- 8:18to home for this. How are the perks like overflow, shoot a loud
- 8:22disaster plan, spark a momentum on the art classes where you slide over the
- 8:26special Ammo How is that going to work in the new economy? Are there
- 8:30any changes planned? So we want to start by saying like we are not
- 8:35finished iterating on the AMO system, Like we are not finished iterating on the
- 8:39special Ammo economy. We iterate a bunch all through labs and through Checkmate,
- 8:46and we made some changes. And the version that you're going to play is
- 8:48different than any version that you've had, you know before. Once that version
- 8:52goes out, we expect to continue to make iterations and not only that,
- 8:56but at the same time that the Special Ammo Meter goes into the wider Crucible
- 9:01sandbox, we're also going to be testing special Ammo crates in crucible laps,
- 9:05right, And in the Special Ammo Crates system, guardians do drop special Ammo
- 9:09when they die if they have it, and so you can pick up special
- 9:11Ammo bricks and trigger all of those perks in that system. If we do
- 9:16decide that the version of the Special Almo Economy that we want to use for
- 9:20the future does not have Ammo drops in it, then we would likely go
- 9:24through and retune some of those perks as needed so that they can still trigger
- 9:28on a similar cadence, right, and they can still provide their benefits to
- 9:33a certain extent. Though it is like not a guarantee that every perk is
- 9:37going to function in every facet of the game all the time and entirely equally.
- 9:43Sometimes we have perks that are like really high up time and PVEE and
- 9:46literally don't work at all on PvP, and so we'll have to decide when
- 9:50that time comes where we want all those perks to land. So it's not
- 9:54a guarantee that like every single perk will get refactored. Some of them we
- 9:56might just be like, okay, well this one's just going to be,
- 10:00you know, a PD perk, or this one's gonna have a completely different
- 10:03effect than what it did before, right, if that makes sense? Okay,
- 10:07good answer. I recently got a darkest before Gune that landed with overflow
- 10:13full auto. I knew you had that on your brain. Gonna be such
- 10:18a sick weapon. That's why we're refreshing all those parkpoles, right, damn
- 10:22right? You mind if I take the note? Yeah, go for it?
- 10:24Yeah, I like this question says what's the design philosophy of SMGs versus
- 10:31ars? Bungee is mentioned. They don't want an AR meta, but let's
- 10:37SMGs run wild. It says, please ask about SMGs and why they're still
- 10:43remaining untouched, not talking about target lock. And I'm gonna end there because
- 10:48it kind of goes right. These questions have been grouped together because many questions
- 10:52were asked in the same vein going, yeah, this one runs on,
- 10:56so to hit on that first part, like the difference between ars and SMGs.
- 11:03Ars have significantly more ranged and SMGs and some of them kill almost as
- 11:07fast, right, like a lot of ars are easily hitting thirty five to
- 11:11like thirty nine meters, and not only that, but ars also have a
- 11:15really shallow damage and ame assist fall off, so they're still pretty effective even
- 11:18outside of that. Like high impact ars, which actually are pretty slept on
- 11:22right now, Like people think, you know they're bad because the RPM and
- 11:24stuff like that, but like they're actually pretty slept on. They're easily hitting
- 11:28forty five meters on their effectiveness and they're out ranging all but like the rangiest
- 11:33pulse rifles, which is kind of crazy, right and outranging almost all hand
- 11:35cannons. So the reason we don't want an ar meta is because there's a
- 11:39much wider envelope that those weapons can be used in. And a secondary thing
- 11:45is that ars are already like the hard meta at lower skills, like the
- 11:48hardest of hardat is a lower skills right now, right, So in order
- 11:52for ars to be meta across the board. We've talked about this before,
- 11:58but like they are weapons that you have to remain on target, you can't
- 12:00peak, you, you can't really jiggle shoot with them, right, So
- 12:03in order for them to be meta at the highest level, they have to
- 12:05just kill faster than everything else, and if we make ars meta at the
- 12:09highest level, that means that there is literally nothing else in the game that
- 12:13matters at the lowest level, which you know, filters up and it isn't
- 12:16a great experience, right. SMGs conversely, on the other hand, and
- 12:20I know that this is going to sound hard to believe, but SMGs actually
- 12:22do have a little bit of a skill curve to using them, to the
- 12:26point that they are the least effective primary weapon for low skill players, like
- 12:30worse than bows and scout rifles, the least effective for low skilled players.
- 12:33Literally, literally, they are the least effective primary weapon for low skilled players,
- 12:37and the reasoning behind that is because they are range capped to a certain
- 12:39extent, and like the inside of twenty meter range in our sandbox is like
- 12:45the zone of death. There's like a ton of stuff that can kill you
- 12:48inside of twenty meters and you can kill you pretty fast. And so for
- 12:50lower skilled players whose reaction times might not be as fast or who aren't as
- 12:54good with their positioning, like, it's actually difficult for them to use those
- 12:58weapons pretty well and a lot of times better off using an auto rifle that
- 13:01has more range that they can play a little bit more safely, and as
- 13:03far as like SMG's being untouched, I went back and I pulled a bunch
- 13:07of stats from this. We have a historical document that we track, like
- 13:11balanced changes that we make, so we can see like when and how often
- 13:15we've tuned something. I went back and looked at SMGs. So since season
- 13:18nineteen, we have nerved SMGs directly eight times, and we have nerved SMGs
- 13:24indirectly five times, so like we have actually touched SMGs more than any other
- 13:28weapon type over the last year and PDP. In addition to that, during
- 13:33Lightfall, SMG's peaked at thirty three percent of kills and PDP and they're down
- 13:37to fourteen percent of kills now, so we've decreased their kills by sixty percent
- 13:41over the last year and PDP. And then the third thing is that SMGs
- 13:46are negative effectiveness across the board and PvP except for one specific cohort, which
- 13:52is high skill players who are playing a very specific subclass so or a very
- 13:58specific class. So it is like SMGs are still frustrating in the right hands,
- 14:03and we know that, and that's why we nerved target lock in the
- 14:09March update, and that's why we Also if you notice the values that we
- 14:13tuned these weapons around, like we decreased body shot damage on SMGs in the
- 14:18March update, and also we didn't increase their critical hit damage as much as
- 14:22other weapons got increased. Right, So we're still not done. But you
- 14:28know, SMGs are not anywhere near the menace that they have been in the
- 14:31past. And it's not quite exactly truthful to say that we've been letting them
- 14:37run wild and we haven't touched them, because you know, statistically we've hit
- 14:41them more than any other single type of weapon in the game. So I
- 14:46know you can't see my webcam right now, but I'm I would be imitating
- 14:50the Kylo ren More gift right now. That's and that's fine, and we'll
- 14:56see, right, but there's you know, at a certain point time,
- 15:00but there's a reason we hit peacekeepers most recently, right. Sure, the
- 15:03effectiveness of SMGs, even at high scial on Hunters and Warlocks is significantly different
- 15:09than the effectiveness on Titans, right, And it's the Titan kit is completely
- 15:13different, and so it benefits a specific play style really, really heavily,
- 15:16and it doesn't benefit other play styles quite as heavily, right, So we've
- 15:20already functionally driven SMGs like pretty into the ground on for a majority of players
- 15:28in the game, right, and continuing to pound SMGs down is not you
- 15:35know, it's not addressing like the root the root concern anymore. So we're
- 15:39looking for other options. And obviously we hit peacekeepers before, and we'll continue
- 15:43to make other changes. But at a certain point in time, you know,
- 15:46it might not necessarily always be like the weapon itself, which is entirely
- 15:50broken. So is the reason I'm trying to get a brief paraphrase summary here
- 15:54is while we are recording this line up, there will be the opportunity for
- 15:58y'all to listen to this podcast later. It's your leisure. But for those
- 16:00who are listening right now, kind of scrambled to put it together just because
- 16:04I misplaced some stream key information. Uh so we are streaming on my channel
- 16:11instead of the usual DCP channel, and I forgot to turn off ads.
- 16:15So for a brief you know, thirty seconds there you were talking right when
- 16:22Murk revealed where the one piece was, the ads may have come off.
- 16:26I've turned off ads now, so my bad. I scrambled to do that,
- 16:30but A is a succinct paraphrase to say. So you said that the
- 16:34you have nerved SMGs. What was the number like, sixteen times? What
- 16:40was it like, we've so we've nerved SMGs directly eight times eight kind of
- 16:44those nerves are so, we nerved all SMG range, we nerved lightweight SMG
- 16:49specifically, we nerved iclos, we nerved aggressive SMGs, we nerved Shiraz,
- 16:53we nerved I mortal, we nerved stability on SMG's globally, and then we're
- 16:57nerving damage in the March updates. And then as far as indirect nerves go,
- 17:03the range and zoom changes that we did indirectly nerved SMG range, the
- 17:08Peacekeepers changes nerved SMGs, and then we have NERF target lock three times because
- 17:14of SMGs and the third time and the March update is literally a nerve to
- 17:18target lock just on SMGs. So and in the future you also you're so
- 17:22SMG more SMG nerves are not necessarily off the table, but you said that
- 17:29it could be you also want to continue to effect to change what you think
- 17:33might be root causes. You know, is that when SMGs are across the
- 17:44board or nearly across the board wildly ineffective, right, even at high skill.
- 17:48So like global high skill, all classes, all subclasses, SMGs are
- 17:53less effective than pulse rifle, side arms, auto riffles, and hand cannons
- 17:56in terms of like, not their usage, right, but their actual effectiveness.
- 18:03So if we filter that data and we look at how effective they are
- 18:07on like warlocks and Hunters, they are extremely not effective at all. So
- 18:12the only place they still retain positive effectiveness is high skill players playing on Titan,
- 18:18right. And so we have to look and we have to say across
- 18:21the game, for a substantial swath of players, SMGs are not a strong
- 18:26choice. In fact, a lot of players who are using SMGs would probably
- 18:29be better off using side arms, to be like completely honest. So at
- 18:33a certain point in time we have to say, is it really a problem
- 18:37with the weapon or is it a problem with something like Peacekeepers, which is
- 18:40only available to one class, right and which seems very high usage. And
- 18:44that's why we hit Peacekeepers. And when we hit Peacekeepers, we saw an
- 18:48impact on the effectiveness of SMGs on that class. So maybe that's the right
- 18:52path as opposed to continuing to drive SMGs themselves into the ground. I see
- 18:56what you're saying, gotcha. I think what people probably most want to hear
- 19:02is that you're not just like, all right, well we're done. You
- 19:04know, we hit us some g's. You know they're you know, they're
- 19:07perfect forever where they are. It's more of a continued examination in making sure
- 19:11you're monitoring the effectiveness and if if they're out of pocket from you know,
- 19:17from what they think that you should, what you think they should or where
- 19:19you think they should be, you know, what do you have to be
- 19:22with? Then it's a continued, a continued effort, right, a never
- 19:26ending battle. We're not like the March update isn't going to go out live
- 19:30and we're going to like turn off allotics and just like shut down our social
- 19:33media and be like, all right, we're done here. That's good enough.
- 19:36We don't need to change anything else. Like the March update is going
- 19:38to go out, and that sandbox has SMGs nerved in it, especially in
- 19:45comparison to Side Arms, and it also has more special AMMO than what we've
- 19:49experienced previously and the iterations of checkmate that we've played in labs, right,
- 19:55and part of what keeps SMGs in check is things like shotguns and fusion rifles,
- 20:00other close range weapons like sidearms. Right, and compared even to the
- 20:03last iteration of checkmate that we played in trials, all of those things are
- 20:10or at least two of those things are more prevalent than they were in that
- 20:14iteration. Right. So sure, you know, we'll see how it goes.
- 20:18If we ship that and SMGs are still super hot, you know,
- 20:22just across the board, then we'll tune them again, and and so it
- 20:26goes fair if I uh, just one follow up question, because you mentioned
- 20:32that effectiveness is different than usage rate, I'm just so curious if you can
- 20:36share any insight on and if you're not at liberty to say, you know,
- 20:40what's in the secret herbs and spices like, that's fine, I guess,
- 20:42but it's just I'm so intrigued about the difference in what makes up effectiveness
- 20:49from a from a data standpoint, because you've had you know, different than
- 20:52usage rates, right, yeah, So usage is obviously just like the percent
- 20:56of time that something as a qui of course, right, you know,
- 20:57compared to everything else. Right, and even you know, even the community
- 21:02has been able to figure out like a rough measure of effectiveness by looking at
- 21:04the percent of kills that a weapon gets. Right, But all the community
- 21:08is able to do with the tools that they have is look at like usage.
- 21:12You know, kills divided by usage basically, So imagine that you have
- 21:17that, but you can also filter it by pretty much every variable imaginable,
- 21:22so ammo type, weapon type, date, playlist, subclass, skill,
- 21:27everything else like that, Right, so we can basically see like, Okay,
- 21:32a weapon is equipped you know, x percent of the time for this
- 21:36cohort of players, and it nets this percentage of kills for this cohort of
- 21:40players during this specific date range on this specific map. Right. So it's
- 21:45just a really really detailed way of looking at whether a weapon is like overperforming
- 21:49or underperforming compared to other other atoms in the sandbox or other elements in the
- 21:53sandbox. Got it? Thanks? Can I ask this question just for clarification,
- 22:00just because this was a talking about the difference between ars and SMGs.
- 22:04What do the mean like actual attributes of the weapons that are different, because
- 22:07I'd be like wanting that clarification too. You mentioned a little bit of amosis
- 22:11mentioned, uh, like the amssists drop off or fall off. I believe,
- 22:15like what is like the mein like just leverage like differences of an AR
- 22:19and SMG like quickly if possible. Yeah, So if ars generally have obviously
- 22:26they're generally slower firing, right, not all the time, like we have
- 22:29seven twenty hours, we have seven twenty SMGs, we have six hundreds both,
- 22:32right, but in general slower firing, bigger magazine, higher zoom,
- 22:37and then the the damage profile for the range and for the amssist fall off
- 22:42because it's a shoulder fired weapon and not a handheld weapon, is significantly shallower.
- 22:47Right, So, if an SMG starts damaged fall off at like twenty
- 22:51two meters, it might bottom out at like twenty seven meters and it's just
- 22:56like totally worthless outside of that range, right, Whereas an auto rifle might
- 23:00start damaged fall off at thirty five meters and not bottom out till like fifty
- 23:03five meters or something like that. Right. So, because it's a shoulder
- 23:07fired weapon, that's how all of our shoulder fired weapons work, scout rifles,
- 23:11pulse rifles, auto rifles, all the rifles. Basically they have a
- 23:15more gradual damage amos's falloff profile, and they also have higher zoom. Right,
- 23:21Because their shoulder fired weapons, it makes sense that they're longer range.
- 23:23Meanwhile, our hand held weapons, hand cannons, side arms, SMGs,
- 23:29lower zoom, sharper profile in terms of how the falloff works, right,
- 23:33If that makes sense. Yeah, is there any considerable difference between like accuracy
- 23:40and a misses on it too? I'm just from my personal I mean yes,
- 23:48but it's probably not enough to It's probably not enough to where the general
- 23:56player is going to be able to tell in general gameplay. So auto rifles
- 24:02have like by default a little bit tighter of an accuracy cone than SMGs do.
- 24:06But because of the way am assist in damage fall off works in our
- 24:10game, a lot of the time the game is telling you like, you're
- 24:14outside of range before the accuracy cone actually makes you start missing, right,
- 24:18it's telling you like, hey, you're doing less damage, or hey,
- 24:21your amosist is start to fall off, and it warns you that you're getting
- 24:25outside of the optimal range of the weapon before the accuracy cone kind of comes
- 24:27into play and you actually start missing shots because your target is too small compared
- 24:33to the size of the accuracy cone on the weapon. Right, amossists.
- 24:37There are also some values like SMGs have a fair amount of amosist. Most
- 24:44primary weapons are within the same general area, and some are just slightly higher
- 24:48than others, right like bows, handcannons. SMGs are pretty high. Yeah,
- 24:55stuff like that. But they're all about the same. It's not like
- 24:57it's a huge difference between one in the other. They're all pretty close to
- 25:00each other, so it's like, you know, fractions of a degree.
- 25:04Basically cool. Thanks, boys, we get on that. I know we
- 25:11could probably spend the entire night talking about this one topic. But any additional
- 25:17follow up questions before we continue on with this laundry list of questions we have
- 25:22excellent? Okay, we could potentially circle back later. I'm sure Mark would
- 25:26love that. Okay, here's the next one. Some players have expressed concerns
- 25:30with the upcoming Sandbox changes that the upcoming Sandbox changes will lead to a team
- 25:34shot slash deathball meta like Destiny two year one. What lessons were learned from
- 25:41previous iterations of the game to address this and what options would players have to
- 25:45contest this play style? The March update Sandbox is not really very similar to
- 25:53the d two year one Sandbox. It's much closer to like the forsaken e
- 26:00sandbox. I guess I would say, like, there's very little that is
- 26:03similar to the D two year one sandbox and D two year one. We
- 26:06had slower optimal ttks on all weapons by like a pretty wide margin. We
- 26:11had significantly reduced, significantly reduced special AMMO to the point that it was power
- 26:15amo, right. We had slower player mobility. We had abilities that were
- 26:22both less lethal and less common. Right, So, pretty much across the
- 26:26board, even after the March update, everything we have is a far cry
- 26:32from what it was like in D two year one. So you know,
- 26:37highly skilled players still should have a lot of tools at their disposal to break
- 26:41up death balls, right. I mean, I would also point out that
- 26:45currently right now in the sandbox, even as it stands, it's still always
- 26:51a good idea to group up with your teammates, right, Like team shotting
- 26:53is stronger than doing something solo that happens right now already. So I don't
- 27:00know that we're necessarily going to see a substantial increase in it from what's already
- 27:03happening, but we're not exactly removing all of the tools that you would have
- 27:07to counteract such gameplay, especially if you're a high skilled player. Because high
- 27:11skilled players who are hitting their crits, your optimal TTK is the exact same
- 27:15as it is and live. But for players who can't hit their crits,
- 27:19it's not. So. If you're good with that primary and you're playing against
- 27:23people who aren't as good with the primary, like, you're going to notice
- 27:27the difference in the success rate of your engagements, especially compared to what's in
- 27:30live. That's all fair. I'd like to remind the people at home that
- 27:34yes, we are these are these are community submitted questions. I'm glad for
- 27:38the extensive answer on that. I feel like I was having a similar discussion
- 27:42with my Twitch chat when this came out and it was like they're turning it
- 27:45into year one. It was like are they though? But like are they?
- 27:48It's pretty differently the most yeah is that one right there. I have
- 27:55some choice words for that one, but I'm not gonna like side tangent it.
- 27:59No. Yeah, I mean as well, it's just it's not it's
- 28:00not D two your one like we'll play it when it ships, Like we'll
- 28:07all play it when it ships. And another thing is that if there are
- 28:12facets of the March update that aren't working great, Like we can iterate and
- 28:18we can tune them. Like what we're shipping in March is not the final
- 28:22stop for PvP. It's not going to be like we ship it and then
- 28:27we're like, all right, we did our part. We're done. Like
- 28:30we're going to ship it, We're going to get feedback, We're going to
- 28:33continue to work on it to improve in to make it better. Right,
- 28:36So nice, I can keep going, Cammy, do you want to do
- 28:41you want to keep going in a circle here? Or yeah, we can
- 28:44do that, Go ahead, buddy, all right. So, based on
- 28:47the changes to more primary focus gameplay, do you guys think hybrid weapons such
- 28:52as Revision, Zero Vex and Hawk Moon will see an increase in usage?
- 28:56I think they will. We think they will, But there are, like
- 29:00there are built in skill checks required to run those weapons and to be able
- 29:03to take advantage the exotic perks that they offer, and just those like built
- 29:08in skill checks kind of prevents them from seeing you know, like massively wide
- 29:14usage. Right, Like we'll talk about this later. I think when we
- 29:18talk about wish Under and like Devil's Ruin and stuff, but if we put
- 29:22like a kill trigger on something it will like instantly cut usage like fifty percent,
- 29:30just because for a large amount of players in PvP specifically, not necessarily
- 29:33in PD, but in PvP specifically, just because like there's a large amount
- 29:37of players who can't reliably net the kill needed to use the thing and then
- 29:42get a second kill using the thing, right, right, So for a
- 29:45large amount of players, putting something behind a kill trigger is just like,
- 29:48well, I'm never using this in PvP again, and really so yeah,
- 29:52and so things like hawk Moon requires even more than a kill. It requires
- 29:59you know, typically their head shots, same with the revision zero, right,
- 30:00like, technically their head shots, but it's more than it kills worth
- 30:04of head shots that you have to get. So like you can farm them
- 30:07by sitting in the back and just like plinking away. But it's not really
- 30:11very effective, and it's not really you know, you're for most players are
- 30:15probably better off just doing something else with your time. Right, So the
- 30:18built in skill checks are kind of going to keep those those things in line.
- 30:22But we think it's a it's a fun you know, it's a fun
- 30:26choice to make, right, Like, Okay, well I'm less likely to
- 30:29get sniped, do I want to run Revision zero now because I might be
- 30:32able to be the one who gets the sniper bullet when no one else has
- 30:34one, and that makes me more powerful. But the trade off is like,
- 30:37well, if I'm using Revision zero, I can't use no time to
- 30:41explain or something. So man, it's just I've you put the thought in
- 30:45my head that since a lot of people apparently don't lean into weapons and PvP
- 30:49that have you know, kill specific kill specific requirements. Excuse me? Are
- 30:55you telling me that so many people out there will never know the joy of
- 30:57using the Cryosthesia PvP? We should probably hope that a lot of people out
- 31:03there don't ever learn the joy of that gun is disgusting me, Like it's
- 31:07really really disgusting, Like yes, yeah, okay, moving on, Oh,
- 31:15Drew, go ahead, cool. Any thoughts on the DMT in its
- 31:21current state, and I mentioned here especially on console you go, yeah,
- 31:26a little bit more in depth and it says the exotic perk feels kind of
- 31:29men nowadays. One twenty aggressive scouts is an archetype. Are you pleased on
- 31:36where they sit today? It feels like they were made to hit fire but
- 31:38kind of sucked at it. That's question Yeah, so DMT we definitely agree
- 31:45on that we're gonna buffet a little bit. And the final shape, the
- 31:49final shape has like a bunch of exotic tuning and stuff that's coming along with
- 31:55it, right, and so in the final shape we're buffing it. We're
- 31:57gonna increase the hip fire rate of fire from one thirty back to one forty,
- 32:00so it's going to match, you know, an adaptive handcannon. We've
- 32:05increased the magnetism fall off scale, which obviously affects controller, so it's going
- 32:09to buffet on controller a little bit. We've removed the PvE only damage buff
- 32:15and added a fifteen percent damage bonus at maximum cranial spikes, so it's going
- 32:20to be stronger when you hit max, and we've done a couple of other
- 32:22things. I think it also now grants stability in addition to the am assist,
- 32:27and it increases the reload speed a little bit more. I think to
- 32:30offset it, we like may have reduced the accuracy benefits slightly, but again
- 32:34that's something that usually only comes into play when you're using it like extremely long
- 32:37range. So yeah, DMT is definitely getting a buff you know, it's
- 32:43at times in the past, it has been a horrifying weapon and PvP.
- 32:47Yeah, I feel like that gun is it rides the line between either like,
- 32:52oh my god, it's insane, I must use it. It will
- 32:53destroy people, or it's like, all right, I'll put it on the
- 32:57shelf for a while. And as far as one twenties as a whole,
- 33:02We're going to kind of talk about this in the next question as well,
- 33:07but we are buffing the text bounce stock origin trait in March, which all
- 33:10the current Aggressive Scouts have as an origin trait, so that would be good.
- 33:15The Trials one is coming out, which is like kind of a step
- 33:17monster, and also it has I can probably spoil this. I hope the
- 33:22snipers won't kill me for doing it. But it has like hip fire grip
- 33:24and one slot and off han strike in the other slot, and you can
- 33:28obviously put the free handgrip mod on it, so like pretty hip fiery.
- 33:34And then in addition, like the March update PvP Sandbox one twenty scouts get
- 33:40a buff by proxy because they maintain their two crit one body through all resiliences,
- 33:45whereas one twenty hand cannons do not, right, So yeah, so
- 33:52they kind of get a little bit of a buff by proxy. We got
- 33:53to be careful with super rangy stuff like that. The same way we don't
- 33:57really want an ar meta across the board. We don't really want to scout
- 34:00riffle meta across the board because scout rifles have dar near unlimited range on most
- 34:04of our maps, and especially with sniper's getting nerved and sniper up time being
- 34:07reduced and bo is getting nerved, like, the counters to scout rifles have
- 34:13come down a bit. So we buffed lightweight scouts like Mida. That's obviously
- 34:16one thing we talked about. And you know, the aggressive scouts are getting
- 34:21the buffs that we just talked about. So we'll see how it goes.
- 34:23We'll see if we can ride that line. I'm just looking over at the
- 34:27at the camera, trying to see Drew's face as Murray is like, oh,
- 34:30you know, mine a multitool, you know, a little nerd to
- 34:31You're just like all right, moving right along here. In the new system,
- 34:37even a little damage drop off from one forty rpm hand cannon can result
- 34:42in a four shot kill instead of a three tap. Effectively, this is
- 34:45a nerve to their optimal range. Is this intentional. Yeah, I mean
- 34:52it is intentional. Almost every other weapon in the sandbox got its cred to
- 34:58body ratio forgiveness reduced by a little bit like one bullet or sometimes two bullets.
- 35:04And we could not reduce one forty hand cans at all because they already
- 35:07took three crits to kill, right. And we saw in the early iterations
- 35:10at Checkmate when we moved everything around, one forty hand cannons and one forty
- 35:15hand cans stayed where they were at, like it was pretty much just free
- 35:19reign for them in that sandbox, right, So we brought their optimal damage
- 35:24down comparatively, meaning we buffed it less than we buffed other options, which
- 35:29puts them like right on the edge of they're doing just enough damage to kill
- 35:32in three crits, right, So that means, yeah, if you have
- 35:35stepped into damage fall off, you're not going to be able to three crit
- 35:37anymore. And what we seen in the last couple iterations of Checkmate, when
- 35:39this damage shooting was already in there, is that it did a lot better
- 35:43job of balancing them without it's it was a different lever for forgiveness, right.
- 35:47So part of forgiveness is the crit to body ratio in terms of like
- 35:52how often can you miss the headshot and still get your optimal TTK. We
- 35:54talked about that in the TWID. Another part of forgiveness is how far outside
- 35:58of your optimal range can you be and still get your optimal TTK? Right,
- 36:01So, because we couldn't affect the crit to body ratio, we took
- 36:06a different tact for forgiveness and we affected how far outside of your optimal range
- 36:09you can be and still get the optimal TTK. And in this case it's
- 36:12zero understood. Love that? Okay, I think this is my question now.
- 36:24Sure, I am interested to hear what the team's thoughts are on special
- 36:28weapons that are functionally primaries like Forerunner Arianas vow. It feels like they're hit
- 36:32hardest by these special amo change so I'm wondering if they have any thoughts on
- 36:37how they might keep them competitive. Yeah, this is one of those areas
- 36:40that we talked about where there were a lot of variables in play and we
- 36:45didn't want to tune too many levers at one time, right, So we
- 36:47could have made it to where these weapons all did massively increased damage to account
- 36:52for the lower up time or they had tons of AMMO given to them on
- 36:55the m trans matts, and those are things we thought about, but we
- 37:00wanted to see how they worked in live first. Before we did that,
- 37:05we did tune four Runners damage up a little bit. That's mostly to make
- 37:07sure that it continues to three crit at all resilience levels. Right, So
- 37:10we did tune four Huners damage up a little bit. But the new AMMO
- 37:15systems, both the Create system and the AMMO meter system, offer us like
- 37:20a pretty decent amount of granularity as far as how we can tune AMMA values
- 37:23for these weapons. So if for example, Forerunner or Areanas are just not
- 37:27seeing any use at all and they're really not feeling like good choices in the
- 37:30in the upcoming sandbox, we could say, okay, well, now four
- 37:32Runner gets twelve shots instead of eight per AMMA pool, right, and we
- 37:37could actually lean more heavily into this is a primary special weapon hybrid as opposed
- 37:43to where they sit right now, which is kind of like, yeah,
- 37:45it's a primary special weapon hybrid, but it's really just a special weapon and
- 37:47PvP. Is there a world where they could probably get the kill credit towards
- 37:52the special meter or is that like going to four screw that is probably that
- 38:01might king make them. I don't know, we would We would probably have
- 38:05to talk about that internally. I mean, I believe it just makes but
- 38:09well you should. You should give traces a shot because people are sleeping on
- 38:15them. And I'm telling you, man I, Traces are maybe my favorite
- 38:20special weapon, and both of the two, specifically in the Create system.
- 38:23I think in the in the Create system, I could agree, but like
- 38:27thinking the Checkmate system, yeah, just I would have to run a primary,
- 38:30right, and so I'd have some range problem eventually. Yeah, well,
- 38:34you know, we'll see how it goes if if Traces are still too
- 38:36weak. The damage buff did a lot, if you call a few patches
- 38:39back. When we buff Traces, we buff their damage, but like a
- 38:42minuscule amount. It was like one damage or like half half of one point
- 38:47on the body shot damage and like point one on the crate damage. And
- 38:52it was because like when we move them any higher than that, they were
- 38:57just like absolute monsters to play against. And we buffed them by twenty percent
- 39:00in the new system and after the March update, and like part of that
- 39:07was to offset the fifteen percent increase to health. But they got a twenty
- 39:12percent buff to damage, so it more than offsets the fifteen percent increase to
- 39:15health at it like kicks them up a notch. And I think I think
- 39:17they feel pretty good, so we'll see. I guess that sounds great.
- 39:21The bigger snack to me was the nerve to Handcanon Flinch output that with Trace
- 39:25rifles. Now I'm excited, Cammy. Do you find that Trace rifles are
- 39:30pretty uh? Do you feel effective with them on mouse and keyboard? Question?
- 39:34For camp very effective, like as in, if I load into rumble
- 39:37with the Prometheus lens or something, it's gonna cook. I guess I just
- 39:40haven't been using the weapon type that much. I play the vast majority of
- 39:45PvP these days on mouse and keyboard, and I kind of stay in my
- 39:49lane for what feels good to me, and like mause and keyboard, trace
- 39:52rifles just don't feel that good to me. Then again, I haven't used
- 39:55them in a couple opinion wise, I think the lens is kind of built
- 40:00different compared to the other exotics, and then the legendaries are a tier below
- 40:04that. For as far as that that secret sauce of the gun sticking just
- 40:07kind of feels like somebody so so try on the Prometheus is my my training
- 40:10wheel? Entry back to trace rifle m m K yes, fair enough,
- 40:14thank you, and then when you get goaded with it, go to cold
- 40:16heart. This like snap targeting with cold heart is wild? Gotcha? So
- 40:21we're doing like Goku like weighted training or like we're trying to get to different
- 40:24levels. You should have seen Shroud on that back in the early seasons.
- 40:30Is oh damn? All right? Uh, Drew, you want to take
- 40:32the next one scrolls with the doctor brother? Yeah, I might trying to
- 40:38remember where I think we're at the reducing forgiveness on weapons. I think the
- 40:45one hand cannon right there. Yeah, okay, I see all right,
- 40:52So a lot of the focus seems to be on reducing forgiveness on weapons.
- 40:54One twenty hand cannons took a big hit. Now people are looking at perks
- 40:59like precision instrument to take back some of that forgiveness. Right, What are
- 41:02your thoughts about this? This could make these perks feel mandatory. I mean,
- 41:09by definition, they're not mandatory if they get forgiveness right, Like not
- 41:14everyone needs that forgiveness, Like at a certain skill level, that forgiveness might
- 41:19not be doing a ton for you in most of your engagements, So then
- 41:22that frees you up to take something that potentially increases your damage or increases you
- 41:25know, any or plays into your play style a little bit differently. Right,
- 41:30So, I think, as it stands right now, we're all right
- 41:34with a perk that increases forgiveness of a weapon being a perk that a lot
- 41:38of people choose, as long as there is a level above that where people
- 41:44will be like, you know, seventy five percent of the time I hit
- 41:47the three kriit, I don't really feel like I need precision instrument for that.
- 41:51I'm going to go with something that ups my damage or ups my range
- 41:53or changes something else, right, So we'll keep an eye on it.
- 41:57It's kind of like the way headseeker works right now on polls rifles, right,
- 42:00Like headseekers like an steer perk on pull sh rifles. But if you're
- 42:02two bursting people anyways without it, like you know, headsecer might help some
- 42:07engagements, but you might get more mileage out of a perk that does something
- 42:09else for you as oppose to a perk that offers you forgiveness, mean you
- 42:13don't necessarily need it. And I know that, like there's the argument between
- 42:15like when you know, I think cool guy calls them win now and win
- 42:17later, or like consistency or kill chaining perks, right, And some people,
- 42:22even at the highest skills, we'll take consistency over everything else one hundred
- 42:25percent of the time, no questions asked. And that's fine, Like that's
- 42:29entirely you know, that's entirely valid. Uh. And some people are like,
- 42:34I'm going to hit those those shots, and I want something that's going
- 42:37to allow me to absolutely obliterate the rest person who walks around the corner.
- 42:39Right, So that's fair. I had a question about the resilience. I
- 42:46guess it would be is it is? Is it seven resilience? I know
- 42:51there's some talk like between like is it seven or eight? That bumps the
- 42:53one twenties? Do you have? I believe it's eight eight. Actually I
- 42:59can check. I have my little spreadsheet. So seven resilience. Let's see,
- 43:08so six resilience. Uh, yeah, it is seven resilience. Actually
- 43:12I was incorrect. Seven resilience is where they go to a three crit instead
- 43:15of a two kreit one body and then you go first. Okay, sure,
- 43:22I was gonna say I have a personal more like personal philosophy of in
- 43:25game build craft, some question that I was going through with my stream today.
- 43:30So keeping in mind that you mentioned like there is a higher level of
- 43:34players that could say, like I'm just gonna hit the three three crit do
- 43:38you invest in the seven resilience to bump that margin of error or no?
- 43:45Do I? Yeah? Would you I do? I would yeah me personally
- 43:52if you're talking about me, Yeah, I run. I run higher resilience.
- 43:54I run seven resilians on my hunter currently I'm live. Now that'd be
- 44:00said. I think this is kind of a decent question because I think the
- 44:04next question was actually about resilience changes in PvP, and we know that there's
- 44:08like a frustration, especially among hunters about like having to deal with resilience.
- 44:14We actually were really careful with these changes to push a lot of the resilience
- 44:17thresholds down from what they were, right, So yeah, one or one
- 44:22twenties now have that resilience threshold at seven, But it used to be that
- 44:29a lot of our resilience thresholds sat at about six or seven, And now
- 44:32most of the resilience thresholds in the new Sandbox are down at three, right,
- 44:37So we've actually taken that like base level of resilience that you kind of
- 44:40felt like you needed to hit to get the most effectiveness out of it.
- 44:43We've actually pushed it down so it's easier to hit. And yes, that
- 44:45has introduced a couple of new resilience checks at the upper end, but it's
- 44:51a lot smaller number than it was in the previous Sandbox, So we were
- 44:53actually like tried pretty hard to slide that down the scale as opposed to the
- 45:00other way around. So we didn't want to make resilience more effective in this
- 45:02right, So players, should you know, feel free to be like,
- 45:07oh, I don't want to have to invest everything seven on a hundred.
- 45:08We don't necessarily need to now because especially like the resilience check at seven for
- 45:13a one to twenty, like you're already getting two Kriit one bodied right now
- 45:16in the Sandbox by one twenties, right, It's not like it's changing you
- 45:21know, that behavior specifically. And then they also asked about like there's some
- 45:25weaponarch types that will be affected by someone being at ten resilience, where like
- 45:29TTK shifts them, and it's like, I think there's two of those,
- 45:31and neither one of them are meta options right now, So like, I
- 45:36really don't think anyone's going to be building into ten resilience to shift a rapid
- 45:39fire auto from a point seven to seven ttk to a point eight three ttk
- 45:44right, Like you wouldn't even be able to tell the difference in that in
- 45:46your gameplay. And that's also they have to hit one hundred percent crets anyways,
- 45:50so it's like it's really probably not that effective, but if it is,
- 45:53and like rapid fire auto is just like fall off a cliff because of
- 45:57it, Like we can tune the rapid fire auto damage up, you know,
- 46:00a fraction of a of a point to prevent that from happening. So
- 46:05that's which I landed on seven to three anyway, for different reasons in the
- 46:09line because apparent apparently for precision instrument on one twenties, it's like you have
- 46:15to go for one of the permutations or combinations like apparently nine stops it would
- 46:20you ever care to stop? That? Would in your personal game play?
- 46:23Like no, wrong answer, No, No, I'm not going to invest
- 46:27that much and you're going to me personally, Yeah, I'm probably gonna go
- 46:30seven but I'm also going seven because I think I probably, I think I
- 46:35actually probably look at resilience. And again this is me talking personally about my
- 46:37gameplay and PDP. Yeah, I think I look at resilience differently than a
- 46:40lot of people do. I actually care a lot less about like the weapon
- 46:44breakpoints, and I care more about like, there are a lot of sources
- 46:47of damage that are incoming right and those things stack up, and the amount
- 46:52of times I survive engagements with what literally looks like one HP of health uh
- 46:58is enough to keep me running the higher resilience levels. And it's not necessarily
- 47:01because I hit somebody's breakpoint with one weapon. It's because I got hit by
- 47:07a combination of three things, and that combination of three things added up to
- 47:10just enough to not kill me. But if I'd been running like five resilience,
- 47:14I would have died. So I look at it like there's a lot
- 47:16of sources of damage in this game, and those combinations are not really something
- 47:22that's scrutable to me as a player. But I have obviously played a lot,
- 47:25and I've played a lot at a bunch of different resilience levels, and
- 47:29I noticed myself surviving with a fraction of health at higher resilience levels, just
- 47:35enough to keep me wanting to invest in that even when the the precision breakpoints
- 47:40go down for a bunch of weapons or the optimal t TA breakpoints go down
- 47:45for a bunch of weapons. But you know, I sacrifice things in my
- 47:47belt crafting to do that. So cool. Yeah, I was gonna say
- 47:52for mine started to interrupt on that one was whenever damage resistance taken into account,
- 47:58like Stacy's crystal or the oculis or something like that. I picked seven
- 48:01and three for entirely different reasons. It's to make sure that they cannot waveframe
- 48:07disruption break or bow disruption break. Me. It's so funny to see it
- 48:09come up. My follow up question was going to be wood precision instrument three
- 48:15tap overshield Titans at ten resilience. Oh that's a good question. Uh.
- 48:22I think if you hit body, I want to say, if you hit
- 48:25body, creit credit well head headhead on overshield. Oh sorry yeah, head
- 48:31headhead, Yeah it should because that's going to give you twelve extra damage.
- 48:37I think maybe prepared for me, I could have looked up this day.
- 48:45I think it does right now, but I'm not sure if with the extra
- 48:49thirty if the math adds up to that, and that's like one of the
- 48:52things I'm most curious about, since it may be surprising that I don't know
- 48:57literally every value of every weapon and ever can and just off the top of
- 49:00my head, I feel like I'm pretty close. I feel like I'm pretty
- 49:02close, but I don't know all that off the top of my head.
- 49:05But I think it's a was it's like four four percent bonus per thing,
- 49:12so and it feels like it'd be pretty close. Right they do eighty eight
- 49:15to the head And now see now you got me doing on my phone calculator
- 49:17because now I'm curious about it, and you car yourself, John Bungeee,
- 49:24you should have this infoe ready to go. Bro. I think it will.
- 49:29I think don't quote me on this, Okay, I know that someone's
- 49:31gonna post on Reddit the game that I work on, but like, I
- 49:35think it should do enough to where precision instrument will let you three credit.
- 49:38Every should tighten. Okay, then that's locked in for me. Yeah,
- 49:43I was gonna say lock that in right now. Yeah. Cool. Actually,
- 49:46so you did mention that there is an upcoming question on this document regarding
- 49:51health changes. There is a question before that just kind of makes me giggle
- 49:55a little bit. Someone wants to know what is the purpose of rapid fire
- 50:00shotguns and PvP? Is there even one? So? Is there? Uh
- 50:07so? Kind of like when we talked about perks earlier, it was like,
- 50:09not everything needs to have a place in all facets of the game.
- 50:13It's okay for something to be good in one place and not good in other
- 50:15places. I think I'm not saying that rapid fire shotguns necessarily have that niche
- 50:20right now. It might be that we need to buff rapid fire shotguns and
- 50:23PDE to make them better so they have a niche right and then it's like
- 50:27kind of okay that they're not great in PvP. But we did something pretty
- 50:30interesting with the Ammo Crates system, which is maybe a little bit of a
- 50:34gamble, but I'm pretty excited to play with it personally, where the Ammo
- 50:37Crates give you a percent of your magazine size for Ammo instead of giving you
- 50:43just like a flat amount for I think exotics. We hand tuned so exotics
- 50:49get like a fixed the amount, so like cloud Strike is not going to
- 50:51get three sniper shots right out of an AMMO cron, it's just gonna get
- 50:53right, and like conditional finality will just continue to get too, even though
- 50:57it's mag sizes too. But for show, rapid fires by default have a
- 51:02much higher mag size, and so rapid fires will get three shots out of
- 51:06an AMMO crate instead of two, whereas other shotguns, if you want to
- 51:08get three shots out of AMMO crate, you have to invest in a mod
- 51:12or a mag or something like that to boost your mag size. And some
- 51:15of them, like Aggressism not even sure you can get three shots, So
- 51:17that might give them a little bit of an edge where it's like what is
- 51:21the purpose of rapid fires? Right, like the you know, the Rick
- 51:23and Morty, It's like, what is my purpose? It's like, your
- 51:25purpose is you get fifty percent more AMMO than every other shotgun and PDP at
- 51:30the cost of like you're not quite as lethal. So's would that archetype magazine
- 51:37scaling apply to the checkmate system of building up the special meter now in the
- 51:42future, so the checkmate system is fixed values across the board. Yeah,
- 51:46so it's just the AMMO crate system that uses that type of modifier, all
- 51:51right, just for the viewers out there. Then the point of rapid fire
- 51:53shotguns is to bank up all this AMMO and checkmate just to use on that
- 51:58one dude who's going to solo sere for you. Go ahead and do it.
- 52:00Fourth Horsemen, go ahead the fourth Horseman plan. Yet I also agree
- 52:04with you just in general that you know, I can't imagine that every weapon
- 52:08in the game is like this must have a place in every corner of the
- 52:12right, like I feel like some weapons are more built with a purpose to
- 52:15be used in PvE. Other weapons are more built with a purpose to be
- 52:20used in PvP, right, And I think that's okay for the most part.
- 52:22I'm not personally clamoring for rapid fire shotguns to rise up in PPP or
- 52:30anything like that. But something the new Sandbox does well is and we're not
- 52:35going to see a ton of this in the original iteration of it, just
- 52:37because again a lot of variables. We wanted to make sure it just went
- 52:39out the door solid first. And this actually comes from a question someone asked,
- 52:44which was like, in playtesting, do the new health and damage values
- 52:46give underperforming archetypes of more competitive spot and they specified like lightweight pulses adaptive SMGs
- 52:52or scout riffles, right, And we talked about for aggressive scouts for one
- 52:54twenty as it does. But there's also other stuff that, like, because
- 53:00all of our weapons were so forgiving. In the previous iteration of the Sandbox,
- 53:06it didn't really make sense to use a weapon just because it was forgiving,
- 53:08because like everything was forgiving, right, Why would you use a one
- 53:10eighty hand canon that two crits two bodies when you could use a one twenty
- 53:15hand cannon that two crits one bodies. Right, Like the delta there between
- 53:20those two things was not wide enough to really make it worth using something because
- 53:25it was forgiving. Right. But in the new Sandbox, because the body
- 53:30shot ttks have been increased as much as they have, there's actually a lot
- 53:35more room for us to do some tuning there, and we can really say,
- 53:38like, you know, one eighty one eight hand cans are going to
- 53:42go out the door at three krit one body, But what if we put
- 53:45one eighty hand cans back to two crit two body in the future. Now
- 53:47they're super forgiving, especially compared to everything else, and maybe that makes up
- 53:52for a little bit of their of their shortcomings, right, Like it's a
- 53:55it's a much bigger difference. Even a three crit one body is a big
- 54:00difference between three crits then two crits two bodies and two crits one body.
- 54:05Is right when we're talking about one eighties versus one twenties on the handcan scale,
- 54:07So if it actually gives us room to make guns that specific purpose is
- 54:14to be forgiving and actually differentiate them from the super strong weapons that just either
- 54:20kill fast or deal tons of damage. You know. Fair. Yeah,
- 54:27So the next question I'm gonna skip because you kind of answered it on the
- 54:30one twenty handcan in question, it was something regarding resilience. But moving on,
- 54:35why were wish ender in Double's ruined nerved in ways that seem to maintain
- 54:37the issues that make them hard to play against? Why not give them kill
- 54:40triggers so that a player has to earn wallhacks or the charge beam and they
- 54:45can't have an endless supply. So I kind of answered that earlier when I
- 54:49talked about kill triggers. But it's like, if we just wanted to actually
- 54:52remove something from play like MPDP, we can add a kill trigger to it.
- 54:59That kind of stinks for those weapons, like what makes them unique?
- 55:04Is the wall hacks. What makes them unique is the charge beam. And
- 55:07yes, those things could be frustrating, but especially initially when we're doing like
- 55:10a first tuning pass on these things, that'll become problematic, Like we don't
- 55:15want to go straight to the nuclear option and just like dismantle them for PDP.
- 55:19We'd really like to be able to maintain what it is that keeps them
- 55:22unique and find a place for that uniqueness where it can coexist alongside the rest
- 55:28of the sandbox. And it still does the thing, but maybe it doesn't
- 55:31do the thing so often or so strongly that it's really frustrating to play against
- 55:36all the time. But it still allows people to use it if they choose
- 55:37to. That's that's fair. I'm just thinking of how maybe horrible, wonderful,
- 55:49horrible and wonderful it would be if I were in charge. I feel
- 55:52like I would do like that because I understand the philosophy of like, yeah,
- 55:55let's not overhit it too hard, right, let's see if we can
- 55:58make it. Let's live and let live. Right, Yeah, are they
- 56:00frustrating, Sure, Let's let's gradually slide down that hill into a place of
- 56:04comfort. And I'd just be like hit it with a bat, Oh I
- 56:07hit it too hard to eye? Let's let's let's bring it up, can't.
- 56:08Let's Sometimes that has to happen, right, especially on things that we've
- 56:13judged multiple times in the past before and it hasn't made a difference. Like,
- 56:15sometimes the core design of a thing is just going to be frustrating,
- 56:20you know, regardless of how many little levers we move around it. Right,
- 56:23Like antaeas wards was that thing special, ammolfrs were that thing. Oh
- 56:28God, Like, sometimes we just have to crush something and be like,
- 56:31stop using this, right, It's really unfortunate to do that because there are
- 56:37players who legitimately really enjoy using things, and like the net fun of those
- 56:43things may be pretty heavily negative when they're meta, right, But a lot
- 56:47of times when we hit them that hard, they not only go from like
- 56:51not being meta, they go to like not seeing us at all, Like
- 56:54they literally don't exist in that sandbox anymore. And that's a little bit of
- 56:59it to mind. Right, Like everyone you know recently has been pretty upset
- 57:05about bos and like bow usage and PvP, Right, Yeah, BO usage
- 57:07went from like four ors like like four and a half percent of primary weapons
- 57:13to like five point seven percent of primary weapons, right, and everyone was
- 57:17like bows are everywhere, it's a bo meta like bows are ruining the game.
- 57:21Stuff like that, And if we were to just nuclear option bows,
- 57:25which it sounds like we hit bos pretty hard because of the combination changes,
- 57:30and maybe we did, and maybe we'll have to revisit those and pull those
- 57:31back, right, But actually, Bose are still very capable of doing what
- 57:35they are intended to do, which is have really long range and deal a
- 57:39ton of damage in a single shot. Right, Like, they're great.
- 57:43They're great support weapons, they're great team shotting weapons. They can still do
- 57:45that stuff and the sandbox they're just slightly less frustrated to play against because instead
- 57:50of you having two hundred health and you getting hit for one hundred and fifty
- 57:52on a KRIT, which is seventy five percent of your health gone, you
- 57:55have two hundred and thirty health and you get hit for one hundred and thirty
- 57:59on a KRIT, right, which is a lower percent of your health gone.
- 58:00So it can still too tap you, but it's less frustrating for you
- 58:04as the victim to see that much of your health go away all at once.
- 58:07But like if we were to actually crush those things and they were to
- 58:09disappear, like the net fund then shifts the other way. We're like,
- 58:14people weren't really really unhappy about those when they were at four percent, and
- 58:19the people who are using those were very happy about using those. If we
- 58:22drop bow usage down to zero, well, now the rest of the sandbox
- 58:27or the rest of the players, like their happiness hasn't exactly gone up because
- 58:30bo usage went from four percent to zero percent, but the four percent of
- 58:32players who were using bows, their happiness has gone way way down, right,
- 58:37And that's the type of stuff that we want to try to avoid if
- 58:39we can at all help it. Like we're we're not going out to try
- 58:43to destroy things. I know people think that we destroyed Fighting Line, right,
- 58:46but we tried Fighting Line in fairness to Fighting Line, we tried it
- 58:50with a ten percent nerve and the health bump, and people were spamming it
- 58:53like the entire first you know, a couple weeks of Checkmate, you know,
- 58:58so like, yeah, it's sounds like in this sandbox that that would
- 59:00kill it because in this sandbox, Special mma gls have way higher up time
- 59:05and Special AMMA has way higher up time. And a Checkmates sandbox. There
- 59:07may still be some use for it, but if it's not, again we
- 59:10can iterate on this stuff like this isn't necessarily where fighting line is going to
- 59:15be forever and always. If Fighting Line just completely falls out of the game
- 59:17and nobody's using it, then we'll revisit fighting Line and we'll try to bring
- 59:22it back up to a place where the people who really care about it can
- 59:23use it without it being a frustrating experience for everyone else. Stopped to deal
- 59:27with that all makes sense. I was not to upset the bow mains in
- 59:34the chat right now, but I was pleased. I guess, for lack
- 59:38of a better word, that the upcoming changes two bows in the March fifth
- 59:43PvP update. Guys still want people to have fun, right, I want
- 59:45people to use it. They want to use and have fun, but it
- 59:47can be you're the joy really frustrating to fight a bow. Part of the
- 59:52joy of Destiny is that there's a lot of stuff in the game, right,
- 59:54and you can use a variety of things, and not everyone wants to.
- 59:59Like some people just want to use what the strongest thing is or what
- 1:00:00the thing is, and that's fine, but there's a lot of other elements
- 1:00:05of the game that you can choose to partake in, and I think for
- 1:00:07a number of players myself included, like part of the fun is finding something
- 1:00:12that maybe not everyone else is using, and using that thing and being good
- 1:00:15and being effective with it and still being able to compete at a high level,
- 1:00:20you know. So we want to try to keep that aspect in the
- 1:00:23game. But at the same time, I think that I actually think the
- 1:00:28next question is like about glaves, and so this is kind of prescient,
- 1:00:31but like we have made a concerted effort to limit the effectiveness of some of
- 1:00:37these cheesier bills. I think bo swapping is probably one of the better examples
- 1:00:40of it, because like, if you play someone who's good at botswapping,
- 1:00:45there's very little that you can do to counter it, right, And it
- 1:00:49feels like like there is a skill gap that is required to be good at
- 1:00:52boatswapping, Like you have to put in some time, you have to put
- 1:00:54in some effort, you have to learn the muscle memory of the timing and
- 1:00:57stuff like that. However, it was pretty forgiving to do in the previous
- 1:01:00sandbox, where you could, like, you know, krit with a bow
- 1:01:04which is super easy. Follow up with the body shot. You barely even
- 1:01:06have to aim. You effectively just vaporize the person on the other side who's
- 1:01:09receiving that. We want to limit that effectiveness, like just a little bit,
- 1:01:15right, sure, because that playing against that, especially at a high
- 1:01:19level, is the amount of effort that it takes to counter that is significantly
- 1:01:23higher than the amount of effort do it? If that makes sense? It's
- 1:01:29es uh, who's uh? Whose turn is it? Here? Is it
- 1:01:35my turn? No? I definitely just went I think it is you really
- 1:01:38or maybe it's true? Now it's actually true. Yeah, yeah, you're
- 1:01:42right. Take that. Take that Glave question there, Drew, you can
- 1:01:45go for every one. Oh yeah, all right fine. Have Glaves reached
- 1:01:49their peak in terms of potency after the recent rework given their niche play style,
- 1:01:53How would would more powerful perkoks like chain Reaction or chill Clip be considered?
- 1:01:59How do they think they will perform going forward? Curious if they have
- 1:02:02any more changes planned out in the future. I think at Base for PvP,
- 1:02:10we think they probably are about as strong as we really want them to
- 1:02:14be, especially in the post March updates Sandbox where they got their damage buffed
- 1:02:20a little bit. That being said, like that's the base glave. Yeah,
- 1:02:28putting perks on them like chain reaction. We actually might be able to
- 1:02:31do that in the future because in I want to say it's in the final
- 1:02:36shape, we are reducing the effectiveness of chain reaction on special weapons. But
- 1:02:40we're doing that so we can put it on more special weapons. Like,
- 1:02:44we haven't been able to put chain reaction on a lot of special weapons because
- 1:02:45it's super super strong. So we're going to reduce the effectiveness so we can
- 1:02:49start putting it on more special weapons, which is a you know, a
- 1:02:52pretty fun thing. So yeah, something like chain reaction might totally be possible
- 1:02:54on a glave and then we can kind of spice glaves up a little bit
- 1:02:58with perks like that. Well, we don't have a legendary stasis slave yet,
- 1:03:04so AO, don't don't freaks in the chat like Jingleheimer, don't encourage
- 1:03:10people like this murk. He's I appreciate Jingle's edge of concurrence clips. Those
- 1:03:15are those are pretty good. Yeah, you know how much damage it does,
- 1:03:20but it is like one of the highest damage single events that you can
- 1:03:22do in PvP. Yeah, do you know who doesn't appreciate those clips.
- 1:03:25Those poor bastards on Xbox quick Play, who jingles out there farming? That
- 1:03:30man is a menace to the bottom. Yeah, I play against Jingle a
- 1:03:37fair bit because I'm also an Xbox So that's right. Yeah, okay,
- 1:03:43Drew, you can you can jump in on that one there. Sure.
- 1:03:46I feel like we kind of went over this question already, So do we
- 1:03:50want to hop over to the general weapon questions? Sure? Yeah, we
- 1:03:57like we covered we didvery much everything. Yeah, right, we recovered that
- 1:04:00we did, Yeah, sure, go ahead, go ahead. It was
- 1:04:01it was basically just the question about do the less I perform the less performing
- 1:04:10weapons see any sort of above from the health thing, and we talked you
- 1:04:12even you went over that, right, Yeah? Cool? Right? General
- 1:04:16weapon questions a hand cannon or sidearm with cascade point question mark. Uh so
- 1:04:25we actually tried this. We I tried when when we were working on uh
- 1:04:31oh geez, malfeasance, the catalyst for malfeasance. My original idea was cascade
- 1:04:35point really, and we tried it, and it is super uncontrollable. It
- 1:04:41was legitimately uncontrollable, like it is unused. And we Desperado on a one
- 1:04:45twenty hand canon at the point in time, and like it's just wildly uncontrollable,
- 1:04:48and I know everyone's like, well, the last word, the last
- 1:04:50word has a ton of custom tuning to make it like usable while you're doing
- 1:04:55that. So, uh, you know, we think maybe long term it'd
- 1:04:58be pretty funny to put a rate of fire altern perk on like a hand
- 1:05:00cannon or a side arm, But short term, like we can't just slap
- 1:05:04the existing perks on there and call it a day, because it's like pretty
- 1:05:08funny for a meme, but actually using it in game would be pretty pretty
- 1:05:12darn your no one. Okay, So I'm just to clarify you say uncontrollable,
- 1:05:15meaning like it's just literally so wild that like you wouldn't be able to
- 1:05:18Okay, got it. It's a little bit like context. Yeah, I
- 1:05:21go for it. It's literally like sending your aim like straight to the ceiling,
- 1:05:25like no matter what, Oh I got the context. I experience this
- 1:05:29outside of the craft and air sometimes the last word can bug out where it
- 1:05:32loses seemingly the custom tuning and it turns into like a completely different archetype and
- 1:05:38recoil pattern. It's like a one twenty that quadruples the recoil and it hits
- 1:05:43the damage value differently too, So I call it the protagonist last word.
- 1:05:46Whenever that bug happens, it's so funny. Yeah, maybe even I remember
- 1:05:53experiencing it. I'm a I'm so in the mindset of like, come on,
- 1:06:00bro, give it to us, like you're giving us a challenge right
- 1:06:02here, like, oh, it's it's uncontrollable. I can I can feel
- 1:06:06like the the fizzles, like the top level PvP players like try me,
- 1:06:11Bro, like let's let's try and I'll spend all weekend pulling that mouse down
- 1:06:15and trying to figure out the recoil pattern and YadA YadA. Yeah crafting,
- 1:06:20I think Nerve had a clip of it. I would love to get it
- 1:06:25for you, but I know there's clips of it somewhere because you pub I
- 1:06:27definitely would have it. Yeah, maybe Camo's classic O. Those were some
- 1:06:32crazy rumbles. We all had costume guns, but nothing like too crazy.
- 1:06:39It's always hilarious to me that ninety nine percent of the community during the craftenning
- 1:06:43was like, quick, like make a broken amate so we can finally go
- 1:06:46to the lighthouse. And like came and Drew are like, oh what if
- 1:06:50what if this gun had this perk? Like you spend all of the craft
- 1:06:53inning in a private lobby. It's just like the most Cammy and Drew thing
- 1:06:56I made her whis classic. It's just hopefully I loved it. I just
- 1:07:00wanted to shoot straight. I love it. It's all I wanted. All
- 1:07:04right, but go ahead, Candy. Yeah. I feel like that next
- 1:07:08question feeds into exactly what we're already talking about, which is like, is
- 1:07:11the angal to have deterministic recoil on all exotics or at least the PvP ones
- 1:07:15like be Wing? And then are there any plans to retroactively add determined deterministic
- 1:07:19recoil patterns to old weapons or only to weapons moving forward? So honestly,
- 1:07:25we're still evaluating deterministic precol and like how it's affecting the sandbox and if it's
- 1:07:30something we want to continue to move forward with, Like right now, we
- 1:07:32plan to continue putting it on new legendary weapons UH and exotics as needed.
- 1:07:39We do not plan to go back and add it to other weapons unless we're
- 1:07:42one hundred percent sure that it's going to be a benefit. VID wing was
- 1:07:45a special case because for a while, the recoil pattern, like the recoil
- 1:07:50pattern was set up in such a way because back in D two year one,
- 1:07:54you used to be able to put like counter bounced pods on your armor,
- 1:07:57right, so you could change the recoil direct of an exotic, which
- 1:08:01is something you can't really do that right now. So yeah, so the
- 1:08:06recoal pattern has kind of like hampered the weapon. But when we changed the
- 1:08:12recoil direction stat it just made it like way too easy to use, right
- 1:08:15because like it just made it vertical recoil for everyone. So instead, what
- 1:08:19we did is we found a recoil pattern that is pretty close to what the
- 1:08:27natural recoil feels like, but with the randomness reduced, So you can learn
- 1:08:30the recoil pattern and you can get the effect of having a counterbalance pod just
- 1:08:34through the muscle memory of having shot the gun enough to understand how it works.
- 1:08:38Right, So it kind of rewards players who put the skill in with
- 1:08:42vigilance wing. The gun will be really really good for those players without being
- 1:08:46just like super strong for every single person who picks it up. I'm super
- 1:08:50excited about that. Has the Uh, are you able to talk about the
- 1:08:58general feeling on the experiment with deterministic recoil, like is there a has it
- 1:09:03been received in general favorably or is it maybe different per particular weapon. Uh,
- 1:09:14we think it's been a mixed bag. Like I think the goal of
- 1:09:17deterministic recoil, we think the goal of deterministic recoil is a valid one,
- 1:09:21And we do think that some players are seeing that, right, Like the
- 1:09:24determinacy recol changes the way a gun feels, and it leads to experimentation with
- 1:09:28the recoal direction stat to try to find the best value. And then once
- 1:09:31you've like locked that in, you can you really feel like you can master
- 1:09:34the weapon, like you could learn it in a way that you couldn't really
- 1:09:38before. At the same time, it's not super easily surfaced to the player,
- 1:09:45right, and so it can kind of be confusing. Whereas all of
- 1:09:47our stats are generally just like more number better, all of a sudden,
- 1:09:51with recol direction, it's not necessarily more number better anymore, right, Right,
- 1:09:55And so I think that's kind of hard to grasp from a player perspective.
- 1:09:58So we'll see continue to investigate it, We'll continue to put it on
- 1:10:01more weapons and continue to listen to feedback and we'll go from there. Okay,
- 1:10:05for visual examples, cool Guys been been a really good resource for looking
- 1:10:11at that across all the new guns, I would agree with that. Yeah,
- 1:10:15uh, okay, next question on our list here, are there any
- 1:10:18exotic weapons where catalysts have been made but not released due to the weapon already
- 1:10:24being too good? Not? Since I have been at Bungee, And I
- 1:10:30asked Chris as well, since he's been there longer, and he said,
- 1:10:31I've been a Bungee. We do sometimes build the hooks, which is the
- 1:10:38internal talk for like the back end investment set up for a catalyst. We
- 1:10:42build those like right when a gun is like an exotic is created, so
- 1:10:45that we don't have to go back and build them later. When we want
- 1:10:47to add a catalyst to it, we just add the catalyst to it,
- 1:10:49right. But usually we hide that stuff so it doesn't like get out and
- 1:10:55so people don't see it. And I think a couple of times we have
- 1:10:57forgotten to hide that and so it looks like a guy has a catalyst,
- 1:11:00but we actually haven't built the catalyst. It's just like the investment set up
- 1:11:03is there to support a catalyst, and so people will like look in the
- 1:11:06API and be like, oh, this gun's got a catalyst, and it
- 1:11:09doesn't actually have a catalyst. We just forgot to hide that stuff before we
- 1:11:12like chip the weapon got it. So yeah, uh yeah. The only
- 1:11:16catalyst that I've ever seen built was there was like an experimental malfeasance thing that
- 1:11:23was built years and years and years ago. I think back in like the
- 1:11:25Forsaken era, that that didn't end up shipping for whatever reason. But I
- 1:11:30don't think it was because malfeasans was too strong. It just might have been
- 1:11:33the catalyst like functionally literally didn't work or something like that. There's a myth
- 1:11:40in the community about a last word catalyst. It was something like high noon
- 1:11:44or something. I don't know if that's but I know that's like what everyone's
- 1:11:49speculating here. Wasn't there a guy or something that like got it on a
- 1:11:54gun like literally I made a video about that. Yeah, fellow reached Yes,
- 1:12:00a fellow reached out to me that he had he We tried for hours
- 1:12:04to recreate it. He had somehow gotten I think it was on the dire
- 1:12:09promise. He had an old dire promise and uh, somehow he was getting
- 1:12:13a perk active on his HUD called high Noon, and he was smoking people
- 1:12:19with it in PvP. And then we tried fiddling it with it together and
- 1:12:25we changed up his bill a little bit, and he lost it and we
- 1:12:27were unable to get it back, and we were like trying to restraight,
- 1:12:30we retrace his steps to like the tea to bring it back, but we
- 1:12:34but we never could. Uh, that is not a catalyst. I don't
- 1:12:40actually know what that is. I can investigate it, but now it's not
- 1:12:43like a hidden the last word catalyst or anything like that. Sorry to shoot
- 1:12:46down the urban legend, which win and don't we blamed by curious visions?
- 1:12:56Uh? Dree, I think you're next year? Okay, so we have.
- 1:13:02Is there a consideration of the OG checkmate primary weapons slower TTK being brought
- 1:13:08more into the base game. I feel like over the past few years the
- 1:13:11primary weapon TTK has been faster and optimal TTK has been easier to hit.
- 1:13:16Again, Like a pretty prescient question. To address the latter part of the
- 1:13:20question first, Like that's exactly what we were alluding to in the sandbox Twid,
- 1:13:26Like we have not made primary weapons kill faster, and on the most
- 1:13:31part, we haven't made primary weapons more forgiving than they were in Forsaken Right.
- 1:13:39It's literally just players have played more with the weapons and have gotten them,
- 1:13:43and the average skill of the player has increased, and a much higher
- 1:13:46percentage of people can hit optimal ttks now than they could before, you know,
- 1:13:50compared to the player base as a whole. So that's one of the
- 1:13:53things that we were trying to address with the Sandbox tuning. As for the
- 1:13:59original Checkmate primary weapons and the slower time to kill, we are bringing Checkmate
- 1:14:02back in the April update, and primary weapon times to kill are going to
- 1:14:08be tuned to be slower across the board. To answer the question directly,
- 1:14:13we are not currently interested in increasing optimal times to kill and the weapon sandbox.
- 1:14:17Not to say we would never do it, but no, that's not
- 1:14:20something that we're interested in doing right now. So okay, I think I'm
- 1:14:30ready to move on go for it. Will the element changes to the Prophecy
- 1:14:34weapons be retroactive, like will the a Sudden Death shot e change from ARC
- 1:14:39to void with the update, or will it be like the night Shade reprisal
- 1:14:43where the old versions are kinetic and the newest Strand. Well, these questions
- 1:14:45are easy. No, it's not going to be retroactive. So the new
- 1:14:50Sudden Death is going to be void and the old one is going to be
- 1:14:54ARC, so completely different weapon. Basically, can I take this one full
- 1:15:03out? Sure? Go ahead? Okay? Is there any need for AE
- 1:15:09to remain in the game and do you think it has been more damaging than
- 1:15:12helpful for the Sandbox? I know some of us still don't like it.
- 1:15:15Is there any intent to reconsider it, especially now that airplay didn't explode like
- 1:15:20expected after Strand. We've spoken about this before, I think we've specifically spoken
- 1:15:28about it on this podcast. But AE has always existed in some form in
- 1:15:32the game. It just wasn't a player face stat until we surfaced it.
- 1:15:35Right there was there has always been airborne effectiveness in some form, and prior
- 1:15:42to Forsaken, there was just no way you could modify it at all.
- 1:15:45It was just always like bad secretly there. Yeah. Yeah, So like
- 1:15:49if you jumped in the air pre Forsaken, even in D one, your
- 1:15:53guns were just like wildly inaccurate comparatively, And in Forsaken we introduced you know,
- 1:16:00heat rises and Icarus grip, and those were the only two ways that
- 1:16:02you could increase your AE value behind the scenes. And because we only had
- 1:16:05two ways to increase the value, there was no reason for us to like
- 1:16:09build a whole stat around it, right because we only had two options.
- 1:16:14So now what we currently have with AE, if we were to remove AE,
- 1:16:19which we're taking to mean going back to the system before we surface the
- 1:16:24stat, right, we would be reducing accuracy in air by like three hundred
- 1:16:29percent from what it is right now, right, Like, we would be
- 1:16:31making your weapons way less accurate in the air than they are at base.
- 1:16:36Specifically, things like asuspade, chaperone exotics that couldn't get Icarus before would feel
- 1:16:44awful in the air. That being said, we hear the concerns about AE.
- 1:16:51We hear what people are talking about. What it really is is the
- 1:16:56lack of amecist, Like that's really what's going on. Like you jump in
- 1:16:59the air, yours gets cut down by seventy five percent. It's really hard
- 1:17:01to hit stuff. Right. At zero AE, you have like half the
- 1:17:06am assist you had prior to us surfacing the system, and at one hundred
- 1:17:12AE you have like one hundred and ten percent or something like that. It's
- 1:17:14some value that's bored that's higher than what you can get before, right,
- 1:17:16So the ability is there to get that, to get that am assist back,
- 1:17:19but it's just really hard to get up to that point. Right.
- 1:17:23So what we're going to do is in the final shape, we've actually built
- 1:17:26a set of stackable helmet mods based off I'm sure you guys remember there's one
- 1:17:30in the artifact like way back when, right, So we basically taken that
- 1:17:32mod. Instead of just being a one time mod, it's going to be
- 1:17:34a stackable mod that goes in the helmet. It gives you plus fifteen AE
- 1:17:38for one, plus twenty five for two, plus thirty for three. Right,
- 1:17:41So you'll be able to much more easily build into AE and get up
- 1:17:45into those values where you can start really feeling the am assist like kick in
- 1:17:47if that's what you want to do. Right. So, it should be
- 1:17:51like trivial on most primary weapons to get fifty plus AE now compared to what
- 1:17:57it was before, Whereas right now, like it's still kind of hard to
- 1:18:00do that if you don't have a perk or subclassibility or something that's giving it
- 1:18:03to my desk is in shambles right now. I have a quote written down
- 1:18:09from you somewhere among the papers from the last time we had this discussion about
- 1:18:15AE, about the current value of the current AE being better than it was
- 1:18:19in the past with you, Do you please tell me you can help me
- 1:18:23finish the mental puzzle in my brain right now? Yeah? So I mean
- 1:18:29like at your primary weapon, your primary hand can in your rose, right,
- 1:18:32Yeah, if you have done nothing to it to get a right,
- 1:18:34it is more accurate than how accurate it was with Icarus before we surface this
- 1:18:41system without you and I'm putting on it, it is more accurate than it
- 1:18:45was with Acris when you're in the air. The difference is that although it
- 1:18:47is more accurate, it has significantly less amosist than it did prior. Right.
- 1:18:53So, the old AE system, the way it worked is that you're
- 1:18:57as soon as you jumped, your amssis was cut in half and it stayed
- 1:19:00that way no matter what. It stayed that way, regardless whether you had
- 1:19:02heat rises or whether you had Icarus. It was just always cut in half.
- 1:19:06Right, And the airborne accuracy penalty that you got, like it's like
- 1:19:12imagine your normal accuracy cone of the gun when you jumped, it expanded like
- 1:19:15three times its normal size, so it got super inaccurate, but you still
- 1:19:19had half of your normal amasist. Right, So your accuracy cone expanded three
- 1:19:24times its normal size, your amesist got cut in half. That's still quite
- 1:19:26a bit of amasist. We have pretty generous amssists in this game, so
- 1:19:29even cutting it in half, that's still quite a bit of amasist. Yeah.
- 1:19:31So then what you could do is when you put on Icarus, it
- 1:19:34shrank that cone that had expanded, so instead of it expanding three times its
- 1:19:40normal size, it expanded by like twenty five percent, right, So instead
- 1:19:43of expanding by three hundred percent, it expanded by like twenty five percent,
- 1:19:45right, right. And then you you maintained the same amount of amosis,
- 1:19:49which is fifty percent of your normal crowded amecist. And then when you put
- 1:19:53on heat Rises, instead of it expanding by it expanded by five percent.
- 1:19:57Right. So now when you hit sixty ae on a primary weapon, your
- 1:20:02cone does not expand at all when you jump, literally not at all.
- 1:20:05There is no expansion. You have the exact same accuracy that you have on
- 1:20:09the ground. The difference in this system is that although it is far more
- 1:20:14accurate at base, So like zero AE in this game is the same accuracy
- 1:20:17cone expansion that you were getting from Icarus before. Right, So we've cut
- 1:20:21out all of that super low accuracy stuff. We've cut all of that out.
- 1:20:25That's all gone. It doesn't expand that much anymore when you jump,
- 1:20:28even at zero AE, when you jump up in the air, your accuracy
- 1:20:30cone hardly expands at all. Right. Instead, what we did is we
- 1:20:34said, okay, we're going to give them back accuracy. But at zero
- 1:20:36AE you only have twenty five percent of your grounded amossist, right, So
- 1:20:43you used to have fifty percent, Now you have twenty five percent, and
- 1:20:45then up at one hundred AE you have I don't know, sixty percent or
- 1:20:49whatever it is. It's some value more than what it was prior. So
- 1:20:53at one hundred AE, at one hundred AE, you are better than anything
- 1:20:58you could have gotten before we see face the ae step. Just like objectively
- 1:21:01across the board, your accuracy is better, your amssist is better. You
- 1:21:04are literally better than you were with heat rises at one hundred AE in the
- 1:21:09current system, right, right, So that's that's why we say that and
- 1:21:13so we're not entirely saying that AE is perfect as it is, because it's
- 1:21:17not. We wouldn't be adding the mod if we thought it was perfect,
- 1:21:19right, But the scale that AE resides on right now is actually a pretty
- 1:21:25generous scale. We're at the high end, it's better than it ever was
- 1:21:28before, and at the low end, your accuracy is way better than it
- 1:21:30was before. We just cut your am assist by like a substantial amount.
- 1:21:34Right, So follow up question on that, because I mean, again,
- 1:21:40it's not that you just that BUNGEI was like, we're going to introduce this
- 1:21:44system like it's been in the game since D one, it just hasn't been
- 1:21:49what did you say, player a player facing stat? That's what you said.
- 1:21:53Yeah, so every time you've jumped from D one on you've always had
- 1:21:57this system affecting no way surface. It as like a player facing stat that
- 1:22:01you can modify your your microphone is playing fun game of peekaboo there, But
- 1:22:06how is it? Wow, Mike's over here. You just it's better than
- 1:22:14now. But yeah, So the question I was going to ask was,
- 1:22:16ever since the introduce the introduction of it becoming a player facing stat that you
- 1:22:23can you know, continually tweak and modify. You guys have been kind of
- 1:22:27making adjustments and tweaks here and there since that point. Any plans for further
- 1:22:36minor adjustments in the future. We've mentioned the the cutting of the amassist,
- 1:22:43any uh, internal discussions on possibly looking at the amount of amosists being cut.
- 1:22:50And this is me basically while you're speaking about the system, reading through
- 1:22:55the chat, and this is being the players love their amssist merk, let
- 1:23:00me boil. Let me tell you from reading this chat, any internal discussions
- 1:23:04on possibly continuing the system in the form of evaluating the number being cut or
- 1:23:11anything to that degree. Yeah, but we're going to see how the mods
- 1:23:15shake out first, right, Because the goal of the system is not for
- 1:23:17you to be able to have zero investment in it at all and be flying
- 1:23:20through the air with the greatest of ease like you're at the circus, Right,
- 1:23:24That's not the purpose of the system. Like, the purpose of the
- 1:23:27system is you invest in it, and you if you invest in it,
- 1:23:30your reward is that you're better than you ever could have been before, especially
- 1:23:33if you're like a hunter or of Titan. Right, like heat Rises was
- 1:23:36only available on warlocks, right. The goal was to provide that level of
- 1:23:42airborne gameplay to all players should they choose to invest in it, not to
- 1:23:46provide that level of airborne gameplay to all players with no investment. So I
- 1:23:51think it's possible that we reevaluate that we reevaluate like the am assist curve on
- 1:23:58that scale. But we're going to see how the mods, you know,
- 1:24:01work. It might be that you slap the mod on an Icarus and you're
- 1:24:04like, oh, I'm good to go, Like it feels great now.
- 1:24:06So is the mod specific or generic? There's been like generic, so it
- 1:24:12would work for my Handcanon Ami Sniper. At the same time, it's just
- 1:24:15it's literally just for everything you put the model, you get plus fifteen A
- 1:24:18for everything. That's amazing. I'm definitely looking forward to that. H Any
- 1:24:27additional follow up questions boys regarding that that particular question, Nope, think you
- 1:24:32hit it okay. If I had to comment on it, I would say
- 1:24:35even after the initial eighty changes, I notice like, oh my goodness,
- 1:24:40I can hit yellows with hawkmon in the air for the first time ever.
- 1:24:43So yeah, I think it has been in some facts. So for people
- 1:24:45who couldn't access heat rises people or people who are using weapons that couldn't benefit
- 1:24:50from acharus. This system has been a flat out buff like there is no
- 1:24:56way to cut it. Where this system is like a nerve for those weapons.
- 1:24:59If we to go back to the old scale, those weapons would feel
- 1:25:03like horrendous in the air, basically because their accuracy cone was so massive that
- 1:25:10it didn't matter that you had more atheist, Like you weren't going to hit
- 1:25:13anything with an accuracy cone that's blown out three hundred percent, Like you're not
- 1:25:16hitting anything even with assist. But when the accuracy cone was shrunk down to
- 1:25:20only be blown out twenty five percent, like that amount of amosist is going
- 1:25:24to make it to where you can still hit stuff. So yeah, that's
- 1:25:26kind of how it works. Okay, let's see where are we in the
- 1:25:30document here? Are there any more plans for aggressive burst hand cannons? Oh
- 1:25:35lord, especially for M and K players. Warden doesn't feel good as controller.
- 1:25:41I agree with this guy? Or are there new models coming? It
- 1:25:44talks me. I totally didn't submit that one. So yeah, so that
- 1:25:48was that was kind of a little bit of a snafoo on our end.
- 1:25:51So we were experimenting with some stuff and we've talked before that like mouse and
- 1:25:56keyboard has more am assist than controller does, and we were doing some weird
- 1:26:00things and somehow that like slipped onto this gun and so it shipped with like
- 1:26:04twenty five percent less amossis than intended in hip fire and when airborne, which
- 1:26:09definitely contributed to it not feeling great. So we're going to fix that in
- 1:26:12the March update, which is good. And then in the final shape,
- 1:26:15we're also buffing the stability of the heavy burst archetype, just like in general,
- 1:26:19so we're gonna make it more stable, which should also help, especially
- 1:26:25on mouse and keyboard. And then we've got two new heavy burst handcannons coming
- 1:26:30in in the final shape, and we also gave an intrinsic bonus to the
- 1:26:35heavy burst who I hope the sniper doesn't kill me for saying this, but
- 1:26:38it's a pretty small pint of list, but we gave an intrinsic bonus to
- 1:26:41the heavy burst frame, which reduces incoming flinch by a small amount too.
- 1:26:45So interesting, Okay, yeah, because I was reading all that stuff about
- 1:26:48like, oh yeah, we're gonna make it better with the hip fire and
- 1:26:53the airborne shooting, and I was like, hmm, what if it feels
- 1:26:57bad outside of that for me? Well, that's what the changes in final
- 1:27:00shape are for. Terrific. All Right, I think I know my new
- 1:27:03main weapon. I mean, yeah, these boys, you guys are like
- 1:27:08addicted to anything that can reduce flinch like, like, I completely understand it's
- 1:27:15very annoying to get flinched. Flinch hater, all right, Drew, take
- 1:27:23it, okay, So if you question her says if you were given the
- 1:27:29green light to make an entirely new weapon or weapon type, it says example,
- 1:27:33dual wielding, I'm definitely not biased. What what would it be well?
- 1:27:40And or what design obstacles would you have to overcome to get it off
- 1:27:44the ground. I actually don't have that question on my shield ahead. Where
- 1:27:48is where are you reading from? Question? In there? I don't know,
- 1:27:51so I have to wait that What was the question? Drew going rogue?
- 1:27:58I got a rope question, but it's this one. I'm not gonna
- 1:28:00lie I but I'm waiting, but this one's going off. It didn't sound
- 1:28:04like something that I couldn't It didn't sound like something that I couldn't answer.
- 1:28:08It was, I'm gonna simplify it, Okay, if you're given the green
- 1:28:13light to make an entirely new weapon or weapon type, what would it be
- 1:28:15or what design obstacles would you have to overcome to get it off the ground.
- 1:28:23An entirely new weapon or weapon type. I mean, geez, we
- 1:28:27have so many weapons like in the game already, like you know, part
- 1:28:30of me feels like there's a little bit of space for a different type of
- 1:28:33melee weapon than what we've already got, Like we've got glades, we've got
- 1:28:36swords, but I feel like there could be uh like a like a I
- 1:28:42don't know, something different as far as melees go, like a rain melee
- 1:28:45basically like our like our I don't know, like numb chucks or something like
- 1:28:50that right now. Not necessarily a spear, although that would be pretty funny,
- 1:28:55uh like a boomerang or something like that, right I don't know,
- 1:28:57But I think I think I think I would have to go with the low
- 1:29:00hanging fruit, which is I have been dying for, like a Halo three
- 1:29:04mauler, which is like a a handheld like sidearm that's a shotgun. Yeah,
- 1:29:10like that type of thing. Like I think see, yeah, I
- 1:29:14think that'd be pretty sweet if I if I had just like if I was
- 1:29:16just like building something random as far as what you have to navigate to do
- 1:29:19that a lot like a lot, because it's not just like us building the
- 1:29:25gun in investment. You have to worry about hard surface, making the new
- 1:29:30gun model. You have to worry about animation, You have to worry about
- 1:29:32sound design. Right you have that might cut out right there for me might
- 1:29:41get up. I think the bunch of said Lord the bungee sniper or back
- 1:29:45at it, I'm like doing like that. I thought we thought we lost
- 1:29:50you for a minute there in the middle of me going off about how difficult
- 1:29:54it is to make a new gun. So I don't remember what was the
- 1:29:57last thing I said. I think I said, you have to worry about
- 1:29:59sound design or something. I thought, yes, yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 1:30:01So there's a lot of other things that are tied into making a weapon
- 1:30:04that aren't necessarily something that we can do buy ourselves. On weapons design,
- 1:30:10there's a whole host of teams that contribute to every single weapon that gets built
- 1:30:14right, and so you got to think of all their contingencies as well.
- 1:30:15And then in addition to that you have to think about how it fits into
- 1:30:17the sandbox and how it's balanced. Right, Like, if you make a
- 1:30:23handheld shotgun, it obviously you know is it is it going to be primary
- 1:30:27AMMO? Then, because if it's special AMMO, like is that not just
- 1:30:30a rapid fire shotgun that looks different? You know, so it's probably primary
- 1:30:33AMMO. So if it's primary AMMO, can you let it one hit kill?
- 1:30:36Because if you let it one hit kill, it's probably too strong,
- 1:30:40So then it has to two hit kill. Well, if it two hit
- 1:30:42kills, you know how fast you want it to fire, Like there's a
- 1:30:45whole there's like a whole cascading tree of stuff that you're going to have to
- 1:30:47think about when you make something like that. And generally what happens is you
- 1:30:51throw together a paper design and you're like, this is this is generally what
- 1:30:55I'm thinking about doing, and you get it in enough, you know,
- 1:31:00good enough for government work basically, and then you just build something and you
- 1:31:03check it into the game and you start playing with it, and you play
- 1:31:06with it as a little like gray box where it looks just like a little
- 1:31:09gray pistol that's in your hand and you run around and you do the thing
- 1:31:12and you see how it feels and you and you kind of iterate from there,
- 1:31:14and it's a lot of iterations every single day, using it in play
- 1:31:16test, iterating on it, changing it, and proving it. Like that's
- 1:31:20kind of what Final Warning was. Like. Final Warning was a gun that
- 1:31:24I just had in my head. I was like, man, wouldn't it
- 1:31:26be sweet to make you know, like the they're called like whistling Birds and
- 1:31:30the Mandalorian where he has like those rockets that are in his his like buntlet
- 1:31:34and he fires them out and they track all the targets that were around him.
- 1:31:36And I was like, damn, it'd be sweet to make a gun
- 1:31:39that does that. So that's how Final Warning came about. And Final Warning
- 1:31:43took a ton of work to get it to a place where it was and
- 1:31:48then it shipped and I was like, man, you would think a gun
- 1:31:50that is an auto tracking gun would be like an easy to use gun for
- 1:31:54nubes kind of like kind of like how Yoten is, But it ended up
- 1:31:57being like really hard to use and having like a pretty skill seiling, but
- 1:32:00it's so impossible to use that, Like most people just tried it once and
- 1:32:04we're like, I don't understand this thing works and put it down. So
- 1:32:06it's it's kind of funny how that stuff ends up. But that was a
- 1:32:11good answer. Where are we in the actual document? I scrolled trying to
- 1:32:18find the question that said said said the list of the real question list and
- 1:32:25not the I'm worried that he's going to read out one of those ones that's
- 1:32:28like one of the ones that is destiny. No, not that one.
- 1:32:32I have a document here, and I thought we were all on the same
- 1:32:34one, but clearly not. I mean it's been you know, it's like
- 1:32:41twenty out of twenty one have been the same sot in there we're on.
- 1:32:46It's really funny because the next the next question about can can it flitch?
- 1:32:49Right, that's the next question. Great, Okay, we're doing that.
- 1:32:55Who's who's doing that? You do it? Do it? Do it?
- 1:32:58Do it? For real? Drew? Sure, real question with the adjustment
- 1:33:03to handcan and flinch versus other players, are there any plans or internal discussion
- 1:33:08about reducing or removing primary versus primary flinch for all primary weapons And it says
- 1:33:15you're accept bows and primary jails. Yeah, I mean it's actually something that
- 1:33:20we have been discussing internally, not removing flinch entirely, but reducing it.
- 1:33:27We're interested in investigating how it would affect gameplay. Obviously, we've taken like
- 1:33:31one step in that direction with the reduction of handcan flinch that's provided to players.
- 1:33:38I wouldn't be surprised to see further investigations, but something more topical that
- 1:33:42I think y'all actually might be more excited about. We recently got some new
- 1:33:45tools in our sandbox, like not the game sandbox, but in our sandbox
- 1:33:50that we're hoping will allow us to tune like sniper and LFR flinch better,
- 1:33:57right, because they're at a weird place now where like if you get shot
- 1:34:00while you're using a sniper or a special l FR, like the camera just
- 1:34:03goes like wild and like shoots all the way upwards. But yet people are
- 1:34:08still able to shoot through that flinch like somewhat regularly, which is pretty frustrating.
- 1:34:12So we got some new tools in place. I'm actually going to be
- 1:34:14digging into them tomorrow, but we're really excited. We think it might enable
- 1:34:17us to potentially hopefully address that problem a little bit in a future patch,
- 1:34:24right and make it so where it's not so easy for snipers and la fars
- 1:34:27to kind of shoot through the what seems like a ridiculous amount of flinch that
- 1:34:30they're taking. So not on the subject of primary weapon flinch, but it
- 1:34:35is flinch related. So no, I have like one this is unrelated like
- 1:34:42one fantom question that you could shut down again, I'm doing it. This
- 1:34:48is why I don't want to Earlier I was going rogue. I'm going rogue.
- 1:34:51Now what does fan fire on the last word? Do do you have
- 1:34:57it? If you don't have a hand you can just say, like,
- 1:35:00I don't know, I don't have that handy. I mean, doesn't it
- 1:35:02do what the perk says it does, where it like greatly increases the accuracy
- 1:35:06and am assist when you deal damage. I don't know. I always wonder
- 1:35:11what it's actually doing, Like it feels like it does something, but I've
- 1:35:13always wondered what does it do? Not having the investment data in front of
- 1:35:16me, I would guess that it probably changes the precision, like it probably
- 1:35:21does do exactly what it says it does. It probably increases accuracy, and
- 1:35:25it probably increases amosist, and it probably increases the precision angle threshold, which
- 1:35:30is something that's normally set to like zero when you're hip firing. We've talked
- 1:35:31about that with AE before, but basically, when you're in like a non
- 1:35:35optimal firing state, the am assist will give you a body shot if you're
- 1:35:41off target, but it won't give you a headshot. It will be like
- 1:35:45you weren't actually pointed at the head. You don't get a headshot for this,
- 1:35:47but you were within the am miss cone. So we're going to give
- 1:35:49you a body shot. When you hip fire. That value is always by
- 1:35:53default set to zero unless you have a perk like hit fire grip or like
- 1:35:57free hand grip, or like off hand strike or like the BXR back that
- 1:36:00changes that value. Right, So the only way you hit a headshot when
- 1:36:03you're hit firing is if you are directly on the head. Based on me
- 1:36:09using the last word, my assumption would be that it changes that value and
- 1:36:13opens that value up, so it effectively makes the am assist more likely to
- 1:36:16give you crits. Ope. Thanks, Are we satisfied with our with our
- 1:36:24off path? Yea? All right? CERTI, all right, next question
- 1:36:29we have written down here. Have they ever thought of reducing the potency of
- 1:36:32opening shot on special weapons. I hate this as currently they feel a mandatory
- 1:36:38on any one hit kill weapon that can roll with it, most especially snipers
- 1:36:42and pellet shotguns. I've been dreading the potential answer to this question for a
- 1:36:45long time. Now, why do you like opening shot? That is just
- 1:36:50bear shit in the woods? Not only have we thought about it, you
- 1:36:57actually we'd already done it. Like opening shot gets fifty percent of the benefits
- 1:37:01on special weapons, right, so it's already, you know, greatly reduced
- 1:37:04on special weapons compared to how it is on primary weapons. Maybe even with
- 1:37:11that, it's still too strong. But we kind of think that we could
- 1:37:15hit it a small amount, don't really think we want to hit it a
- 1:37:18ton. Probably the bigger concern is there's really just like a distinct lack of
- 1:37:23competition in that slot for those type of weapons, right, Like, there's
- 1:37:28nothing really better than opening shot in the same trait slot that opening shot rolls
- 1:37:33in for snipers or shotguns. So it's like, why would you pick anything
- 1:37:38else when you have opening shot? And so the way we end up addressing
- 1:37:42this might be twofold. We might nerf it a little bit just to like
- 1:37:45bring it more in line with other stuff. But maybe we'll also build a
- 1:37:48perk that competes with it and that slot, and you know, maybe that's
- 1:37:53the way we address it. Man, that would have to be some hella
- 1:37:57good competition, brother, And I'd be like, oh, you'd be put
- 1:38:01on this perk gives you like extra amosists, a little bit of range and
- 1:38:04leaves the twenty dollars bill under your pillow every night. Like, I'm trying
- 1:38:08to think of what kind of perk on paper? What do you guys?
- 1:38:12What do you guys value on shotguns and snipers right? Like a lot of
- 1:38:15it's like cracked handling, and you're pretty reliant on left column perks for that
- 1:38:18stuff throughout detective snapshot sites. So what if we gave you a right column
- 1:38:23perk that gave you fifty percent of the range benefits of opening shot, but
- 1:38:27it also gave you a crazy amount of handling That meant you were no longer,
- 1:38:30you know, reliant on those left comparks. Like, there are ways
- 1:38:32that can be done right, it's just finding the right combination of things that
- 1:38:35players care about on those weapon types and you know, turn in the thumb
- 1:38:41screws a little bit. That makes sense to answer your question on that A
- 1:38:45lot of like what we would take over opening shot. I think high impact
- 1:38:48reserves on some market types is really good on snipers, and then Mulligan's also
- 1:38:54pretty good. And then I think the damage perks are nerved with the plus
- 1:38:59thirty hells, so those don't really apply anymore. Yeah, and damage parks
- 1:39:02have never been super optimal. But you know, we also tried with barrel
- 1:39:06constrictor. I don't know that that's going to move the needle on it,
- 1:39:09but barrel constrictors like super cracked now after you get a kill, But what
- 1:39:13do we say when you put it when you lock stuff behind a kill trigger?
- 1:39:15Right, for a lot of players and DVP, it's not necessarily the
- 1:39:18thing, but it is way better than opening shot for a pretty long period
- 1:39:23of time after you get a kill. So how like how effective do you
- 1:39:28assume like it is? Because like can you really like visually tell based only
- 1:39:33when you shoot a wall per se or is that like truthful information? It's
- 1:39:39close enough, right, Like those are decals that get applied to the wall,
- 1:39:42uh in like the general area where the pellets hit, So like,
- 1:39:45yeah, it's close enough but I think it's a I want to say,
- 1:39:47it's like a twenty percent decrease in pellets spread, so it's substantial. All
- 1:39:53right, fallo out. There was a second person back in the day one
- 1:39:56two punch to kill the bubbles. At some point PB got that nerved.
- 1:40:00That is true. That was very sad. But now we don't need one
- 1:40:03to punch anymore to kill bubble titans. We get condition. We got conditional,
- 1:40:08bro I'm in mind. I guess sure do you sure do? Sure?
- 1:40:19Jesus, where were we? We're on game mode and math questions wonderful,
- 1:40:25the first of which is can we get more party type game modes?
- 1:40:29Who control? Yes bit of this question? Uh so the answer is yeah,
- 1:40:35And like it's not it's not on all It's not like you get more
- 1:40:40party modes, which means you don't get more core modes, right, Like,
- 1:40:43we have Collision coming out and the actually I think next week we have
- 1:40:47Collision coming out and going into Labs, which is a mode that I personally
- 1:40:50really enjoy. I think it's a very very fun motives like purpose built for
- 1:40:54threes and for comp and stuff, and it's quite enjoyable. It's a super
- 1:40:57different take on an objective, even though it's still you know, zones,
- 1:41:00it's like a different take on objective than what we have. It's a lot
- 1:41:01more mobile than a lot of our other objective modes, right, so it's
- 1:41:04pretty fun as far as party game modes. Like, yeah, I think
- 1:41:09we said it in the twid But the goal is kind of to continue to
- 1:41:13experiment with things that are interesting, different takes on the Destiny Sandbox because we
- 1:41:18think that there's a lot of fun to be had there. You know,
- 1:41:21some people really love Momentum. Some people have really been enjoying Relic. Momentum
- 1:41:26is always super popular. Sorry mayhem, some people love Momentum is always super
- 1:41:30popular. And like hardware is the next one that we have coming out,
- 1:41:33which hardware has been something that people ask for for a long time. Yeah,
- 1:41:38yeah, I mean hardware is a really interesting take on Destiny Sandbox.
- 1:41:44It's very very different than normal Destiny, and I think some people will really
- 1:41:47like it. Some people will be like, this isn't really my cup of
- 1:41:49tea. But the goal is to kind of have a lot of those modifiers
- 1:41:54in the game and to start putting them all into private matches so that you
- 1:41:58can apply those modifiers to any game mode if you're choosing in private matches and
- 1:42:01kind of play with your friends and mess around with stuff. Like even Checkmate's
- 1:42:04weapon tuning is going to be a modifier that's going to be in private matches
- 1:42:08in I think in the final shape, so you can like apply Checkmate just
- 1:42:13the weapon tuning. You can apply Checkmate to any game mode you want,
- 1:42:15and then you can pick which AMMO system you want to go along with it.
- 1:42:18You can pick respawn with am you can take AMMO creates, you can
- 1:42:21pick the meter system. Right, So there's going to be a lot more
- 1:42:26options, and I think we're going to continue to experiment on both sides of
- 1:42:30this coin, and we're going to try to make cool new party modes that
- 1:42:32are pretty fun that people can kind of goof around in. And we're going
- 1:42:34to continue to make really good core game modes that are that are there for
- 1:42:39the players who want to, you know, who want something a little bit
- 1:42:42more serious. So that sounds incredible. One step closer to the MLG rule,
- 1:42:45said, I was going to say, one step closer to Forge mode.
- 1:42:53All right, Dore, you want to take this one? Sure?
- 1:42:57I feel like you kind of mentioned this but it says, if hardware is
- 1:43:02a success, is it possible to make it a core playlist? We'll movement
- 1:43:04mechanics such as chorus, Dash, dodge and tightened shield bash still be available
- 1:43:11to use, so it won't end up being a core mode where like it's
- 1:43:15available all the time like control is. But it would end up if it
- 1:43:20were successful, it could end up being something like what momentum in Mayhem are,
- 1:43:24where they like cycle through pretty regularly into the main pdp uh. The
- 1:43:29only abilities that you can use are your power jumps. No acharis, dash,
- 1:43:32no dodge, no shield bash. It's just power jumps. That's it.
- 1:43:39Oh, stab me in the heart with a knife mark it may It
- 1:43:44makes sense no, because then everybody would be acres dashes and scorched. I
- 1:43:49was like, dude, you just shattered dived. It's not fair. Yeah,
- 1:43:54that's fair. It makes more sense of what hardware is supposed to be
- 1:43:58I'm assuming at its core, or why it was made to begin with.
- 1:44:04Okay, let's see next step. We have a question that says, I
- 1:44:08know the Crucible can never have a quote perfect form into the player base at
- 1:44:12large, but what direction is the strike team pulling toward in terms of overall
- 1:44:16balance and how the Crucibles should feel. So our goal on the Strike team
- 1:44:21is pretty much what we said in the TWID, which is we want Crucible
- 1:44:28to be rewarding for the players who want to play it, and we want
- 1:44:31to provide a variety of experiences so that there's always something in Crucible that's fun
- 1:44:38to play for those type of players. And we've mentioned before that we are
- 1:44:44angling ourselves to provide a better experience for like the dedicated PvP players, And
- 1:44:47I think a lot of players kind of take that in their heads and they're
- 1:44:50like, oh, that means like the high skill players exclusively are like one
- 1:44:55specific cohort of players, But there's actually dedicated players who play a bunch of
- 1:44:59different stuff. There's dedicated scorched players who just play a ton of scorched,
- 1:45:03like a really absurd amount of hours of scorch, right, Like, there
- 1:45:06are dedicated players all the way across the spectrum who play everything from the super
- 1:45:12goofy game modes to the sweatiest of trials players, right, And it's those
- 1:45:16players, all of those players that were kind of angling towards making Crucible a
- 1:45:21fun place. So yeah, I mean it's it's a variety of experiences,
- 1:45:27and it's making it rewarding to play. And some of that reward is intrinsic
- 1:45:31reward by making the sandbox better and more fun and rewarding you for improving at
- 1:45:36the game. And some of that reward is external rewards by just giving you
- 1:45:41more ingrams or more guns or more Glimmer or something like that. So I
- 1:45:47don't know, I think I really like this next question take it. Are
- 1:45:53there plans for a big team battle like PvP Experience and Destiny? So we're
- 1:45:59investigating it? Really? Yeah? We actually, we actually are investigating it
- 1:46:03as an ongoing active investigation at Bungie. There is some really weird tech stuff
- 1:46:08that happens when a bunch of players load into an activity in Destiny. I'm
- 1:46:12sure you guys are aware of that from like the big team rage. Yeah,
- 1:46:17but it is something we are actively investigating. We want to make sure
- 1:46:20that we can make it happen in a way that ends up being fun and
- 1:46:25stable, Like the stable part is being key. I can't explain it,
- 1:46:30man, I know that like big team Battle is just often like a big
- 1:46:33goofball fest. I am strangely drawn to it. Like I love I played
- 1:46:39a ton of comp in the past like two weeks, really very much enjoying
- 1:46:43it. I love trials. I very much take the serious PvP experience over
- 1:46:48like the let's go play scorched or something like that. I cannot explain.
- 1:46:53I love big team battle. I love the thought of that somehow existing in
- 1:46:58the world of destiny. So there's something that happens where the more players are
- 1:47:02in a game, the less each person's individual contribution is necessarily like required for
- 1:47:10success. And like, so the more people in the game, the less
- 1:47:13stressful the game can be, right, And I think that there's something to
- 1:47:16be said. The game feels a lot more like a playground or a sandbox
- 1:47:20when it's eight v eight or something than it does when it's three v three
- 1:47:24or two v two or one v one. So like, as you decrease
- 1:47:28the amount of players in a game, the experience or the experience can get
- 1:47:32more stressful because more of a percentage of the team's success relies on an individual
- 1:47:38player's shoulders. When you increase the amount of players in a game, it
- 1:47:41decreases that amount to a very small amount, and you can functionally like kind
- 1:47:44of just goof off and have fun. And I think that's why, you
- 1:47:45know, Halo Big Team Battles was so successful and fun. We think it'd
- 1:47:50be something really really fun, you know, if we can do it and
- 1:47:54destiny, but we got to make sure that we can do it first,
- 1:47:57right then, on that same note, the upcoming announced maps vary in size,
- 1:48:01like Javelin versus the Stung Shan versus Cauldron. Do you know if the
- 1:48:05new PvP maps will have their own playlists at launch or would they be weighted
- 1:48:10separately from the current pool. So can answer the second part of that question,
- 1:48:14but the first part of the question about the map size. They are
- 1:48:20all about Javelin four sized. So these maps were built with a focus on
- 1:48:27three B three game modes, and they will be available in like the Control
- 1:48:30playlist, right, and at least one of them, in particular, we
- 1:48:36really think is going to be like very very good map, even for sixes.
- 1:48:39But these maps were designed to be three V three maps, so none
- 1:48:42of them are super teeny tiny like Exodus Blue. They're all about Javelin four
- 1:48:47sized, so like medium to medium small maps as opposed to like small or
- 1:48:53extra small maps. That being said, on the maps, there are a
- 1:48:57variety of siteline distances, so it's not like, oh, this is SMG
- 1:49:00is the map, right, Like we have gone through and really, yeah,
- 1:49:05we have gone through and really like messed with the geometry a ton even.
- 1:49:11You know, up until recently, we've been working a lot on the
- 1:49:13geometry that the maps to make sure that there's a variety of engagement distances.
- 1:49:16And so we didn't want to do something that was like disjunction where it's like
- 1:49:20scout rifles and bows on the outside. But we also didn't want to do
- 1:49:25something where it's like anomaly, where it's just like you know, abilities and
- 1:49:28SMGs and shotguns and nothing else, right, We tried really hard to find
- 1:49:32the middle ground there where you can use a pulse rifle, you can use
- 1:49:35a handcan, and you can use an auto rifle, you use any of
- 1:49:38that stuff and feel like there's a place for you to play. That's a
- 1:49:44good answer. I like that answer. Awesome. Here's one that says why
- 1:49:48are there so many nodes in matchmaking parameters and crucible? So this goes back
- 1:49:54to what we said in the twitter and what I said earlier, but like
- 1:49:57there really isn't a one size fits all strategy that's going to make PvP fun
- 1:50:00for everyone. A good example of this, like we've it might be hard
- 1:50:05to tell from a player perspective, but over the last year or so,
- 1:50:10since like maybe season nineteen or season eighteen, we've actually been experimenting a lot
- 1:50:14with like the layout of the crucible and matchmaking and stuff like that. Like
- 1:50:19you've probably seen that, Like, oh, it feels like every couple updates,
- 1:50:21we like changed something or tweaked something right, and like we moved a
- 1:50:25bunch of playlists around, and we renamed a bunch of playlists, and we
- 1:50:28combine some playlist and we got rid of some playlists, and we brought some
- 1:50:30playlists back, and all of that was experimentation to try to really find like
- 1:50:35the optimal mixture for PvP. And what we found is that as an example,
- 1:50:41like merging the Clash and Control playlist into one playlist, which we called
- 1:50:45quick Play, and we were thinking, like, oh, well, you
- 1:50:47know, you've got one hundred thousand people playing Control and fifty thousand people playing
- 1:50:51Clash. You put those two together, you get one playlist with one hundred
- 1:50:54and fifty thousand people in it, and everyone's happier because they find games faster
- 1:50:58connections are better. Well, it turns out that those playlists form a VEN
- 1:51:01diagram, and the center part of the VN diagram where people like both control
- 1:51:04and clash, is much smaller than the sum of the two parts. Right,
- 1:51:09So we combine those two and what we actually found is that the people
- 1:51:13who don't want to play both just stop playing. Right, Like when we
- 1:51:15got rid of Rumble, we were like, oh, well, if we
- 1:51:18get rid of Rumble, those people will play control. They don't play control,
- 1:51:21they just stop playing. So like, yeah, maybe ten percent of
- 1:51:26those players go into the main playlist, but that was kind of what happened.
- 1:51:30So we've through all this experimentation, we've kind of found a good allotment
- 1:51:33of playlist that give us a variety of experiences for the player. You've got
- 1:51:41Control and Iron Banner with outlier protection. You've got a three v three and
- 1:51:45a sixty six quick play playlist. You've got Rumble, you've got Competitive.
- 1:51:47Each one of those offers something different than the other ones. And then of
- 1:51:51course we have crucible labs and long term, the goal is kind of to
- 1:51:58make it so there's not as much overlaps a playlist aren't competing with each other
- 1:52:00in terms of experiences. So for the players who want the experience, there's
- 1:52:03always a place for them to go and find it, and we don't end
- 1:52:06up hurting ourselves by having two playlists that have like a similar experience and then
- 1:52:11we split with the population between the two, if that makes sense. It's
- 1:52:14the same thing with matchmaking. Not everyone likes skill based matchmaking, not everyone
- 1:52:18likes connection based matchmaking. When every playlist is one or the other, some
- 1:52:24players are not going to want to play. So the best thing we can
- 1:52:26do is put outlier protection into control an iron banner, and for players who
- 1:52:32want that, they can go play there. And we also are going to
- 1:52:35offer open skill matchmaking you know CBMM as you guys know it, open skill
- 1:52:40matchmaking in quick Play and open skill matchmaking and Rumble and open skill matchmaking in
- 1:52:45the Trials challenger pool, and that experience is there for those players who want
- 1:52:48it. So I feel like that was a long answer, but hopefully that
- 1:52:53makes sense the long answers are appreciating on it's better better than a short answer.
- 1:53:00I think we already covered this next one regarding private game options and stuff
- 1:53:03like that, So from here on out, it's all regarding matchmaking, everybody's
- 1:53:09favorite discussion topic that no one ever gets upset about. I'll just keep going
- 1:53:15down the list here. What factors go into deciding a person's skill bracket.
- 1:53:20Pretty much everything that's on the scoreboard goes into deciding a person's skill bracket,
- 1:53:25So kills, assist, death's objectives, revibes, pretty much anything that's on
- 1:53:33the skill The scoreboard gets all combined at the end of the game, too,
- 1:53:39like a total sum behind the scenes, and then that gets basically like
- 1:53:43stack ranked against every other player that's in the game, and it shows like
- 1:53:46where you stat like where you fell. Like if there's twelve players in the
- 1:53:49game and you were the sixth highest ranked player coming into the game, and
- 1:53:55you were the highest scored player in the game, like your skill is going
- 1:53:58to go up because it's like, oh wow, you over right, Whereas
- 1:54:00if you're the first highest ranked player and you were twelve, it's going to
- 1:54:03be like, oh wow, you really under Your skill is going to go
- 1:54:06down. And it does that across you know, a great many games.
- 1:54:09Now our skill is tracked by like playlist bundle, so like your comp skill
- 1:54:15is only for comp There are no other playlists that affect your comp skill,
- 1:54:18right, So just because you do really well in control doesn't mean your games
- 1:54:21are going to be harder and competitive. I see, Yeah, so we
- 1:54:26we isolate those things so you're not punished for like doing really well in a
- 1:54:29social playlist, which then makes your you know, your ranked experience harder or
- 1:54:32something like that. Although your ranked experience just goes off your rank except for
- 1:54:35placement matches, so that doesn't really matter anyways. So you're telling me that
- 1:54:39when Iron Banner Fortress comes back, I should destroy less turrets major laugh counted
- 1:54:46Technically, if if that counts, if that counts as an objective for the
- 1:54:50purposes of like what is being tracked in that, which I'm sure it does
- 1:54:54because it's on the scoreboard, then yeah, I mean that counts as an
- 1:54:56objective thing. So if you want to kill less turrets to try to tank
- 1:54:59your skill, then you're more than welcome to try to do that. Are
- 1:55:02there any non visible factors heat maps, et cetera. I don't know the
- 1:55:12answer to that question. I don't think in the skill system we're using right
- 1:55:15now, which is skill Z, I don't think that there are. I
- 1:55:17think all of the factors that could be contributed to our visible Yeah, I
- 1:55:26think they're all visible. We had another skill system for a while that had
- 1:55:29some other stuff in it, but I only learned about that when I was
- 1:55:31here in like twenty eighteen and I was talking to one of the engineers about
- 1:55:34it. And I don't know, I don't know if. I don't think
- 1:55:36we use that for anything anymore. I think everything we do is run through
- 1:55:39SKILLSZ Now, Okay, I didn't know they used dragon Ball as the naming.
- 1:55:46Yeah, oh, okay, I'll take the next one. Please do
- 1:55:53Why are you guys doubling down? I don't know why I'm reading this like
- 1:55:56I'm mad. I'm mad for the person writing the question. Why are you
- 1:56:00guys doubling down on fire team based matchmaking when the player data shows trios to
- 1:56:04significantly lower player account wise? Uh? You know, we think we explain
- 1:56:11this pretty well in the twit, but just to like go over it again,
- 1:56:14like, yeah, we are aware that trios is suffering population wise,
- 1:56:20and we have taken steps to alleviate that by making trios exclusively more rewarding and
- 1:56:27not tying those two win outcomes. Right, so you can go into trios
- 1:56:31with a couple of buddies, and you could lose one hundred out of one
- 1:56:33hundred games and you're still going to be rolling in trials Ingram's and weapons and
- 1:56:38experience by the time you're done with that, right, And we also made
- 1:56:42two passage changes, like pretty serious passage changes where losses are just generally like
- 1:56:46less punishing now, so that you can play with friends of mixed skills and
- 1:56:50if you lose, it's like, oh, well, I'm still making progress
- 1:56:54on all this stuff. Right, So that being said, like, well,
- 1:56:58the data shows that Trio, well, the data shows that Trio's population
- 1:57:02is decreased. Trios still have the highest flawless percentages of any fire team configuration.
- 1:57:09It's just on average takes them more games, but they still go flawless
- 1:57:12more than duos percentage wise, and more than solos. And in addition to
- 1:57:16that, the other metrics that are not Trio specific are much much better,
- 1:57:20much healthier. For trials. Right now, we're experiencing far less skill creep
- 1:57:25over the course of seasons. We are seeing less of like a player drop
- 1:57:32off over the course of seasons, and a lot of that is because the
- 1:57:35solo and duo qu experiences exist and players can fall back onto those, right.
- 1:57:41The nice thing about being in solo a duo que is that it's not
- 1:57:45a guarantee that you're matching up against you know anything. You might get a
- 1:57:47really good player on your team or on the other team, but if you
- 1:57:50play enough, you know, you can kind of get lucky. When we
- 1:57:56if we were to remove fire team based matchmaking, short term, it would
- 1:57:59be improvement for trios, right, but long term it would likely harm everyone's
- 1:58:03experience, and it kind of calls the trios ecosystem interior rate. And we
- 1:58:06know this because we've done this in the past before. Solo and duo players
- 1:58:13do not show a willingness to stick around when they are being placed in the
- 1:58:17matches that they're basically guaranteed to lose just by favor of being a smaller fire
- 1:58:21team, right, And it really doesn't matter how much rewards we give them.
- 1:58:27It doesn't keep them in the playlist long term. It might keep them
- 1:58:30in the play of the short term, but once the duos and solos start
- 1:58:34to bleed out of the playlist, the lower skilled trios can't really compete anymore
- 1:58:39because they were relying on playing smaller fire teams to win their games, and
- 1:58:43so now the lower skilled trios are matching higher skilled trios, and the lower
- 1:58:47skilled trios can't compete and they start to drop out too, because there's no
- 1:58:50soloer duo experience to fall down to, right, so they start to bleed
- 1:58:57out, and then the trio's experience ends up much right back where it is
- 1:59:00now. But there's the added negative of there's nowhere else to go to escape
- 1:59:04it, like there's just the trios, and that's what Trials has done twice
- 1:59:09in the past before when we did that. So yes, like we understand
- 1:59:13the trios experience is not optimal, and we are working to try to improve
- 1:59:17the trios experience and make it better. But removing fire team based matchmaking is
- 1:59:24not the solution to that because, like I said, short term it would
- 1:59:27benefit, and then long term we would end up exactly where we've been in
- 1:59:30the past, which is the trial the situation Trials has, you know,
- 1:59:33the vibes of deteriorated. Basically, I think it's an interesting idea trying to
- 1:59:39lean into making trios more rewarding, because I thought that was a nice touch,
- 1:59:44because yeah, I I definitely don't play a lot of trios these days.
- 1:59:48It's just yeah, and I mean, I see, I see.
- 1:59:50Defissle even said in the chat, like douo is being removed would guarantee trios
- 1:59:55growing, and it would, but not by very much. We saw this
- 1:59:58during freelance weekends where do were not protected, like duos were matched against trios
- 2:00:02and solos were completely isolated by themselves, right, Like, that's effectively removing
- 2:00:06duos because you know, going in as a duo is basically like suicide unless
- 2:00:11you were super super stacked, right, and then it was just a challenge.
- 2:00:15What actually ended up happening is only like maybe a fifth of the people
- 2:00:20like became trios. Most of them just went to become duos. So the
- 2:00:27trio's population went from like at the time it was like twenty percent and it
- 2:00:31became like twenty four percent, right, and the solo's population went up by
- 2:00:39like twenty percent. So the vast majority of players, if we remove duos,
- 2:00:44they're not going to become trios, and the ones that are are going
- 2:00:47to be pretty highly skilled players. For clarity of the recording, he typoed
- 2:00:51when he said that, but oh, continue and we'll edit that aut so
- 2:00:56he looks like he doesn't know what he's talking about. All good, it's
- 2:01:00a valid thing, Like we see that a lot like that is legitimately the
- 2:01:01probably that is probably the most requested thing that we see about trials is like
- 2:01:09just remove duos, and removing duos will make trios feel better, And it
- 2:01:14really won't make trios feel better because the people who come up to trios are
- 2:01:16going to be good, so it's not going to like inflate the player pool
- 2:01:19in a way that is meaningful and the best way to play trials if duos
- 2:01:25goes away for most players is going to be solo, which is not with
- 2:01:29any friends at all, And so it feels like that's the worst of two
- 2:01:33evils, where like, at least now if you can't play trio, you
- 2:01:38can play duo with one friend. And it feels like saying like your only
- 2:01:42options are trios are solo is moving in the wrong direction, so to speak.
- 2:01:48He yeah, he wanted a clarify and chat, he said, I
- 2:01:50meant that it wouldn't. Sorry, Yeah, it's all good. Defise is
- 2:01:54a good dude. I just happened to catch his name as it was scrolling
- 2:01:57up the thing, and it said the thing, and I was like,
- 2:01:58oh, I can address that because I see that a lot. You would
- 2:02:00not believe the amount of dms that I get on Twitter telling me to do
- 2:02:03that. And I was like, right at the time, nobody even knew
- 2:02:05I worked on the Strike team. They were just telling me it anyways,
- 2:02:08even though I thought I was a weapons designer. So who's up next here
- 2:02:14with these with these questions here, I'll take the next one. I guess
- 2:02:18sure says in comp I recently ran into an ascendant player with a Katie under
- 2:02:25one point zero, and I'm wondering, can you explain how it is possible
- 2:02:28that a player who goes negative can be that high of a rank? Uh?
- 2:02:34I feel like a question could be It's an interesting perceived either direction.
- 2:02:39So like, there are going to be two different answers to this. One
- 2:02:45of them is that we originally had an anti carry mechanic built into ranked,
- 2:02:49which was that if your skill was way below your rank, it was going
- 2:02:54to start decreasing the amount of points you would get for wins. And that
- 2:02:58was designed basically to prevent people from being carried to a high rank because if
- 2:03:01you weren't performing, if you weren't you know, contributing enough to these victories,
- 2:03:06like it was not going to give you enough points to where you could
- 2:03:09rank up. And players didn't like that. They said it felt unfair,
- 2:03:12like it was stifling their progress, like they wanted it to really just be
- 2:03:15more focused on wins and losses. So we removed that system. So now,
- 2:03:20regardless of your skill, if you win enough, you will move upwards
- 2:03:24in rank, right, and you could do that by playing with someone who's
- 2:03:27significantly better than you, who basically you know, is able to carry you
- 2:03:31upwards. The second thing is just because someone has blow one point zero and
- 2:03:36not make them a bad player. If the player is in ascendant and exclusively
- 2:03:42matching other ascendant players, you're not going to expect them to have a very
- 2:03:45high KD because they're matching other very good players, right. So an ascendant
- 2:03:49player playing at ascendant and getting a point nine is still probably likely better than
- 2:03:55someone who's playing at silver and has like a one point five, right,
- 2:03:59because the opponent that they're facing is much higher than in other places. So
- 2:04:03KD, especially in comp, isn't really a great indicator of skill because you
- 2:04:10know, comp is about winning, and if the way you win is by
- 2:04:13playing the objective or getting assists and that doesn't necessarily contribute directly to kills.
- 2:04:18Like that doesn't mean you're a bad player. Uh, it just means you
- 2:04:23know, you're playing to win, and you might sacrifice your KD a little
- 2:04:25bit to do that. You taken like pr classes. Man, you're getting
- 2:04:29like dch level good at like talking like like you're just you're on the fucking
- 2:04:33ball, Doude. Like it's just like I just get lectured a lot for
- 2:04:38saying the wrong things and I actually try to learn from mistakes and yelled at
- 2:04:42enough this man that was coming out with these public speeches. Yet that was
- 2:04:44a great example at the end though the color Rold players you face like it's
- 2:04:47I think that's pretty real. Like even if you look at like, I
- 2:04:49know, this is like the top of the top level of competition, but
- 2:04:53in like actual like you know, tournaments for some games, it's like they're
- 2:04:57you know, one one KD is like you if you're in the announcers voice
- 2:05:00and they're going through the stats, the stat analysts, they go, oh,
- 2:05:03man, he's popping off today. He has a one point one right
- 2:05:08right, yeah, yeah exactly. Yeah. Also, you mentioned that you
- 2:05:12mentioned the playing the objective and what is what is that? What is that
- 2:05:16word that you used? Yeah, I know that I'm a streamers. Some
- 2:05:23people don't like objectives in in Destiny, uh, but like objectives are kind
- 2:05:28of a core part of like a competitive game, right, because, like
- 2:05:30there is slayer skill, but there's also a lot of other skills to go
- 2:05:34into being good at a game. There's map awareness, you know, the
- 2:05:38ability to manipulate spawns. There's knowledge of when to push, when to push
- 2:05:41with your teammates, when to fall back positioning. Like, there's a whole
- 2:05:44host of other things outside of just the ability to slay out that don't get
- 2:05:49as much like FaceTime when we don't offer objective modes, right, And so
- 2:05:56moving forward, we do want to keep objective modes in the game on one
- 2:05:59where another. And we tried it with Rift and obviously Rift wasn't super well
- 2:06:03liked. I thought Rift had some good stuff about it, but there were
- 2:06:05some issues that it had. And we tried it with Countdown Rush, and
- 2:06:09we'll try it with Collision and we'll you know, we'll continue to iterate on
- 2:06:12all that stuff. But objective modes are you know, a good thing,
- 2:06:15especially for a competitive environment, it's good to have stuff that's not just straight
- 2:06:18slayer, which I say that, and now that I've said that, I'm
- 2:06:21more that might be a super controversial take. But how dare you? Yeah,
- 2:06:27yeah, I'm not gonna lie. I like the obj mod it's not
- 2:06:29I like the objective. Yes, I like you just play a ton of
- 2:06:32mold comp. I played it like accomp man. I mean, how was
- 2:06:36your experience? Saying honestly, I'm maybe walking myself into a can of worms
- 2:06:41here, but like, how was the experience? Now? Honestly, let
- 2:06:43me Okay, this is an interesting to tour YouTube video coming next week.
- 2:06:47I played twenty four hours a comp. Here's what happened. But in a
- 2:06:49nutshell, I actually had a much better time playing than I thought I would.
- 2:06:56Honestly, I am goddamned, amaze amazed at the number of players in
- 2:07:02comp who don't look at the scoreboard and run into an engagement when their team
- 2:07:10already has the win and there's like four seconds left on the clock. I
- 2:07:14cannot tell you how many wins, guaranteed wins have been thrown into the trash
- 2:07:20because we're up like two oh three, oh Like, it's just like and
- 2:07:25like you're just they're pushing in with like twenty twenty five seconds left, It's
- 2:07:29like, what are you doing? Like, I I want to reiterate that
- 2:07:33I had a great time playing Camp. I did hit a sentence which was
- 2:07:36very fun. Yeah, shocked, amazed, bamboozled by the amount of people
- 2:07:43who simply would be so much higher rank if they just looked at the scoreboard.
- 2:07:48But game sense, right, Like game sense is a real thing.
- 2:07:51And yeah, you can have super super great thumb skill or you know,
- 2:07:57arm skill if your mouse and keyboard and be really good at slaying out,
- 2:07:59but that doesn't necessarily mean that you have great game since and like that's that's
- 2:08:03what elevates some players above other players. It's like the ability to read a
- 2:08:07situation and react accordingly. I would legit recommend. I'm not even kidding because
- 2:08:11before going into camp, it was my experience in PvP currently is just the
- 2:08:16pie chart is like, uh, you know, control or trials. It's
- 2:08:22just those two things. If it's like if it's the weekend, I'm gonna
- 2:08:24play trials. If it's just not the weekend, dig around play control,
- 2:08:28right, I was just like comp eh, whatever, you know, I
- 2:08:31got a god roll Rose, who gives a shit? Right, Like,
- 2:08:35I'm not going to go in, but I legit would actually recommend that people,
- 2:08:39if you haven't played COMP in a while, you at least try it
- 2:08:43out, you know, for not only for the rewards. But again,
- 2:08:46I shockingly had a very good time. Uh yeah, it was a positive
- 2:08:52experience, which I honestly was not expecting. Yeah, I mean, we've
- 2:08:58done a lot of work on COMP recently and like not everything, you know,
- 2:09:01I'm sure not everything's a hit for everyone, but like we've been trying
- 2:09:05really hard to make COMP into a like better ladder experience, and part of
- 2:09:09that was making a change to rank based matchmaking, and you know, part
- 2:09:11of that was updating game modes and rules, and we're continuing to experiment and
- 2:09:16like, you know, we just tested out three or three clash and labs
- 2:09:20and now we're putting it in a quick play and we're popping Collision into labs,
- 2:09:22and like we're we're definitely putting a focus on some of those three three
- 2:09:26modes with with a goal of like improving the COMP experience and making it something
- 2:09:28that's actually like fun and rewarding to play. So sure, Drew went rogue
- 2:09:33one time. I'm gonna I'm gonna go rogue one time, just the one
- 2:09:37time. Please. It's just you don't even have to say anything. You
- 2:09:39can just you can just sit there and smile and not like you know,
- 2:09:43like Mona Lisa or something like that, like yeah, more, whoever's in
- 2:09:46charge, because I know this isn't you, So it's just this message in
- 2:09:50a bottle, right, whoever's in charge of getting more unique, cool,
- 2:09:54badass emblems into COMP? Do that? I like that? Like I really
- 2:10:01enjoy like unlocking that emblem and like putting it on. It's an awesome feeling.
- 2:10:05Like I'll chase that high, bro, like when I'll keep doing that,
- 2:10:09Like just get I can make one for I can make like a P
- 2:10:11and G and paint and it's like fall out is cool written and crown literally
- 2:10:16do that. I will maim it. I don't care how shitty it looks,
- 2:10:18just like like you drew it with your left foot. Like just more
- 2:10:22emblems and COMP. Thank you appreciate that? All right? Who's Who's next
- 2:10:33year? I got? I'll tell you why not? Next question A couple
- 2:10:37times mentioned is a snake draft. As far as matchmaking, can you explain
- 2:10:41what that means for matchmaking for those who don't know. Whoever submitted this doesn't
- 2:10:46play fantasy football. Yeah, so snake draft is basically like what you would
- 2:10:50do if you were out at recess at school and like trying to form two
- 2:10:54teams for like football or kickball or something. Right, Like, each team
- 2:10:56gets a captain and then the two teams go back and forth picking play.
- 2:11:00The difference for snake draft is that like the best player gets put on Team
- 2:11:05A, and then the second and third best players get put on Team B,
- 2:11:09then the fourth and fifth, the sixth and seventh, the eighth and
- 2:11:11ninth to tenth and eleventh and twelfth, Right, So it goes back and
- 2:11:13forth because obviously if it's just t went one, two, three, four,
- 2:11:16like one team would be skewed higher than So. Yeah, so that's
- 2:11:20what snake drafting is. And so what it does is it allocates the available
- 2:11:26skills more evenly between the two teams compared to something like skill averaging. Skill
- 2:11:33averaging literally tries to make the average skill of each team the same. And
- 2:11:37that's the thing that I think a lot of high skill and low skill players
- 2:11:39are frustrated with because what it'll do is it'll be like, oh, there's
- 2:11:43two good players. We're gonna put these two good players on a team,
- 2:11:46and then we're going to give them the four worst players in the game,
- 2:11:48and that makes their average skill the same as six average players. But what
- 2:11:52actually ends up happening is that you have four players on your team who are
- 2:11:54worse than all six players on the other team, and they're just getting stomped,
- 2:11:58and it's up to the two players at the top to try to carry
- 2:12:01like the weight of that team. And so that's what average skill does.
- 2:12:05Like numerically, those two teams might be even, but the actual gameplay experience
- 2:12:09isnt always necessarily the best. So what snake draft tries to do is it
- 2:12:13tries to say, hey, we care less about the average skill and more
- 2:12:18about making sure that there's always like someone better than you and someone worse than
- 2:12:22you on the other team, so that you don't end up getting like,
- 2:12:24wow, I'm worse than literally all six players on that team. Like that
- 2:12:26feels really bad unless you're the worst player in the lobby, in which case,
- 2:12:30like that's always going to be the way it is. But you know,
- 2:12:33for everyone else, it's a little bit more even sure, I think
- 2:12:37we have one final question on this matchmaking and that might be the last question
- 2:12:41period, one final planned question before we away with on the mic, which
- 2:12:50it reads, can you clarify what is meant exactly by this example below with
- 2:12:54some numerical examples. Unless I missed it last week, this was glossed over
- 2:12:58a bit, and the example is updated competitive Matchmaking to be rank based and
- 2:13:03update seven point three point five. We will also cap the win and loss
- 2:13:07min max values to make them less variable, which should make point rewards more
- 2:13:13predictable. Yeah, I will answer that question. I did see in chat
- 2:13:16that someone was complaining about the lobby balancing and Trials. There is no lobby
- 2:13:20balancing in Trials. It's just completely random. Like trials balancing is literally just
- 2:13:24random. It just randomly sorts the teams when you get into a game,
- 2:13:28and so like it's not the game's not trying to screw you, it's just
- 2:13:33Rang is a fickle mistress, right, and sometimes it's just really unlucky and
- 2:13:37the way it works, and like that's that is. I think the only
- 2:13:41place in the game in our PvP where there is literally no lobby bouncing is
- 2:13:45trials. So trials is you know, trials, it's a it's a special,
- 2:13:50a special thing, so it doesn't have any lobby balancing. But everywhere
- 2:13:52else in the game, we're experimenting with snake draft or some iteration of it,
- 2:13:56UH to try to, you know, come up with a good system
- 2:14:00that checks allar boxes. But to this question, which is can you explain
- 2:14:05what it means by capping the win and lost men max values? So right
- 2:14:09now, when you finish a game of comp the amount of points that can
- 2:14:11be rewarded is like really widely variable. It's between five points which is the
- 2:14:16minimum, and I want to say it's like two hundred and fifty or two
- 2:14:20hundred and seventy five points is the maximum. So there's a super wide delta
- 2:14:24of points that you can get. And the things that change how many points
- 2:14:28you get are are you below your expected rank? So like is your does
- 2:14:33your skill say you're like an ascendant player, but you're playing in platinum right
- 2:14:39now, it'll say, okay, we expect you to be higher than this,
- 2:14:43so we're going to accelerate you out of these ranks. So in that
- 2:14:45case, you'll you'll lose less on a loss and you'll gain more on a
- 2:14:48win. That's one modifier. The second modifier is was the other team significantly
- 2:14:54better significantly worse than like your team, right, And that's to say,
- 2:14:58like, okay, because we have ranked matchmaking, it's now possible for like
- 2:15:01really good players to be playing at like platinum against players who are much worse
- 2:15:07than them, because that's what their rank is. Their rank is platinum,
- 2:15:09but they're much better than platinum, so they're playing at platinum, so they
- 2:15:11could like destroy a team of actual platinum players. So we know that that
- 2:15:16feels bad. So if you lose to a team that's like way better than
- 2:15:18you, it decreases how many points you lose. And simultaneously, on the
- 2:15:24other side, if you beat a team that's way better than you, it's
- 2:15:26going to give you a ton of points because it's like, congratulations, you
- 2:15:28beat a team that those way better than you. But those values were swinging
- 2:15:31so wildly because the minimum was five and the maximum was two hundred and fifty
- 2:15:35something, so it was making it feel really unpredictable how many points you were
- 2:15:39going to get at the end of the game. So we've just compressed those
- 2:15:43values, like we've compressed that scale a little bit, and we didn't do
- 2:15:46it a ton at first because we wanted to make this change and see how
- 2:15:52it plays. So I think the value now is like fifty to two hundred,
- 2:15:56right, So it's like a relatively small compression, but it is a
- 2:15:58compression. So hopefully it makes the point values that you get at the end
- 2:16:03of games feel a little bit more predictable and a little bit less like why
- 2:16:05did I get seventeen points for that game and two hundred and forty seven points
- 2:16:09for another one? Right, So hopefully it doesn't feel quite like that anymore.
- 2:16:13But it's something that we're going to continue to iterate on once this change
- 2:16:16goes live and we get some feedback on it. Good call. Uh.
- 2:16:22So yeah, that is the end of the pre arranged, pre discussed question
- 2:16:30list that we have from community submitted questions. So first of all, thank
- 2:16:35you MRK, because really appreciate all the discussion. All those answers were pretty
- 2:16:39detailed and lengthy. Good good job, buddy, appreciate Thank you Bunjie for
- 2:16:43trusting Murk to come down here again. Definitely will be creat If Mirk was
- 2:16:48like, oh they don't know I'm here, I stuck out, stuck out
- 2:16:54late at night, I wait for them all to go to bed, and
- 2:16:54I hopped a podcast Chris Proctor looking at his phone, he's doing what is
- 2:17:01there anything that you did not get a chance to talk about that you have
- 2:17:09the authority to talk about? I don't think so. I think we actually
- 2:17:15covered pretty much all the questions that were in that were in the little list.
- 2:17:18Yeah, I want to ask if you can talk about collision war.
- 2:17:26It felt like confusing in the explanation. Yeah, so I got that a
- 2:17:31lot today. Yeah, so you can just go off of what you can
- 2:17:33say. So collision is, uh, it's kind of like crazy king.
- 2:17:39It's kind of like a hard point. So obviously, if you look at
- 2:17:41a standard map, there are like five possible points on the map. Right,
- 2:17:48There's a B and C for control or zone control, and then there's
- 2:17:50the three tiebreaker zones for dominion. And usually one of those tiebreaker zones is
- 2:17:56always on B or like very close to B, and then the other two
- 2:17:58are also a neutral point. So total there's like five control points on the
- 2:18:01map. Right, So what collision is is it is one of those control
- 2:18:07points is active at a time, and the zone itself is actually like larger
- 2:18:09than a normal control zone, right, So it can't just it it's not
- 2:18:13like gigantic, right, Like, don't get me wrong, it doesn't cover
- 2:18:16like the entire nation. Yeah, but it's just like bigger than a normal
- 2:18:18control zone, so it can't be like entirely covered up by a bubble or
- 2:18:20whatever it is. But the point, you capture the point, and as
- 2:18:24you hold the point, you accrew score. I think it's like you get
- 2:18:30one point every two seconds or something like that. It's first to one hundred,
- 2:18:33and after an amount of time if that zone being held, the zone
- 2:18:35rotates to somewhere else around the map, and so you have to move around
- 2:18:39the map and fight in all these different locations to try to capture that one
- 2:18:43point. And the thing that's really fun about it is because only one team
- 2:18:46can score points at a time, you're technically never out of a match,
- 2:18:50Like if you are losing ninety nine to zero, if you prevent the other
- 2:18:54team from ever capturing a point, you can literally win a game from ninety
- 2:18:58nine points down by just like playing better than the other team. And we've
- 2:19:03had some super super fun, really heated playtest with that, especially in like
- 2:19:09our Sweat play test, which is like our high engagement play test, which
- 2:19:11is where all like the sweaty PvP players like play against each other and it's
- 2:19:16a it's honestly like really really fun, and so it's going to go in
- 2:19:18the lab. Yeah, it's going to go into labs and we'll obviously take
- 2:19:22feedback and iterate on it. But I then question, is there a mercy
- 2:19:28rule that type of comeback as possible? Nope, there's no mercy rule.
- 2:19:31Oh that's so good. So it's so good that annoys me in so many
- 2:19:35other modes where I was like, yeah, I can come back here.
- 2:19:37Why'd you stop? Because the CRIS is no place for mercy. Yeah,
- 2:19:41so we made it like the way we aligned the points and the timer,
- 2:19:45like the game will eventually end at like ten minutes, but like the way
- 2:19:48Collision works, the game should never end at time, right like it you
- 2:19:52there should never be a point in the game where you're like, we can't
- 2:19:56come back from this, Like the the intent of the game mode was that
- 2:20:00doesn't matter how many points the other team has or how big your deficit is,
- 2:20:03you should always feel like, if we play well enough, we can
- 2:20:05still win this game. So Mark, I want to let you know that
- 2:20:09the uh, the two questions in Chad coming up the most which you may
- 2:20:15or may not be able to speak on. One of them is uh,
- 2:20:18I mean you're on the weapons team right craftable hawk moon question mark. And
- 2:20:24the other one is why are you wearing sleeves right now? I'm a professional.
- 2:20:30Now, this is my business formal attire, Like I can't just can't
- 2:20:35just rip the sleeves off all the time. I'm representing the company. I
- 2:20:37got it. Uh, you know, I got I feel like you want
- 2:20:41to have those pythons represent the company for sure, right crafted hawk Man?
- 2:20:46I don't know, man, maybe one day. Not not my not my
- 2:20:50area to speak on that stuff. So, I mean you'd put Zerr out
- 2:20:54of a job, right, poor poor sir Heyby already, you know,
- 2:21:00look looking kind of rough over there. I don't know if he's been getting
- 2:21:01too many strange coins any So, I mean related, not related. I've
- 2:21:05been using Revision zero. That is a pretty good pulse both modes. Thanks,
- 2:21:09I think so too. I'm about to hit twenty thousand PvP kills on
- 2:21:13mine. That's nuts. I've been shoveling both input devices on it. It's
- 2:21:16been really really good. Yeah, and I've got a PvE one too that
- 2:21:20I think I'm over like ten thousand Feetz and PDE on it. So I
- 2:21:24spent a lot of time on the revision. I'm not that dedicated. I
- 2:21:26just use my PvP one in PvE it's really good at PVEE, Like it's
- 2:21:31the heavy burst mode in particular is phenomen and when you get vocal weapon and
- 2:21:35four times the charm and everything pretty good. Well, if there's nothing else
- 2:21:41that you have the ability to comment on, Drew, you got something.
- 2:21:46I got a few? Okay, great, these special one So I think
- 2:21:54you mentioned I'm like trying to remember off the top of my head that Collision
- 2:21:58is featuring this special AMMO system, right. Is that coincided with the mode
- 2:22:05somehow? Or is that like just it does a system that's taking place being
- 2:22:11pried out debuting in the mode. So Collision, we'll have to see how
- 2:22:18the feedback goes. Like right now, Collision and the special AMMO. So
- 2:22:22the special EMO crates just like the special emometer and just like the respawn system
- 2:22:26in private matches, they're both they could be applied to anything at all,
- 2:22:31right, but right now Collision is being tested with the special Emo crates.
- 2:22:33Hardware when hardware comes out, will have the special Emo crates. Those modes
- 2:22:37were designed like alongside special Emo crates. If people really hate special Ammo crates,
- 2:22:41we could put the meter into into those modes instead, right, But
- 2:22:46they play pretty well with the crates because the crates offer additional points around the
- 2:22:52map, right, and because of the way the crates are laid out,
- 2:22:54the crates are near the places where zones are, you know, so you
- 2:22:58never feel like you're having to run really far out of the way to get
- 2:23:00a crate. And there's you know, four crates. I think we explained
- 2:23:03this in the twid, right, like there's one crate by A, B,
- 2:23:05and C zones, and then there's another neutral crate, and that neutral
- 2:23:09crate is by one of the trials that's there, you know. I think
- 2:23:16it's neat stars are hitting them. Yeah. I enjoyed the crate system,
- 2:23:20especially it's like Clash, like I think, really really well, you're connections
- 2:23:22bugging just a little bit. Yeah, man, I just started talking about
- 2:23:26the good stuff, But I was gonna say I enjoyed the create system and
- 2:23:30something like Clash because Clash otherwise doesn't really have an effected force movement around the
- 2:23:33map, and I think the crate system kind of helps with that. So
- 2:23:37we'll see. But like with meet meter system, we put it into PvP,
- 2:23:41we take feedback on it, we iterate with the crate system, we
- 2:23:45put it into PvP, we take feedback rate, and hopefully through a combmation
- 2:23:50of all that stuff, we can come up with, you know, a
- 2:23:52really really good assistant terms. Okay, not a question, but something I
- 2:24:00saw in chat and observation Tommy's matchbook bugged hit registration just saying it. So
- 2:24:05they're like, yeah, Camy mentioned it. Is that like a questions like
- 2:24:11I'm Ron Murgandy, Like I don't know, I like Scotch. I got
- 2:24:16no comment on that. So yeah, have you tried gut shot in the
- 2:24:20news? So obviously body shots are worthless now, like less damage. Have
- 2:24:26you have you personally tried guts shot yet in the new Sandbox? And if
- 2:24:31so, what do you think about? Yeah? I mean it's good.
- 2:24:33It does. It counteracts the it counteracts the penalty that the mode kind of
- 2:24:39inflicts, you know, on you for hitting body shots like especially side arms
- 2:24:43and stuff with gut shot are like really really strong in that mode. I
- 2:24:46think the almet with gut shot is quite good, like the aim assist penalty
- 2:24:50the gut shot gets is now, I think it will be overcome by,
- 2:24:56you know, by accurate players, So I don't think it's really that bad
- 2:24:58anymore. That's another one of perks, just that precision that's going to offer
- 2:25:01you on amount of forgiveness and can potentially change the way some guns play in
- 2:25:07that mode. I don't think it's gonna be great on everything, don't get
- 2:25:09me wrong, but there are definitely some things that's pretty strong cool. I
- 2:25:15could definitely still hear your answer, but it sounds like somebody at Bungee is
- 2:25:18giving you the crowd to treatment right now, and you're like, they're the
- 2:25:22fill in my hed, pulling the ethernet cord out a little bit and try
- 2:25:26and try and keep mirk down. Damn a shame. Oh well, we
- 2:25:33uh, I guess that's got to be it for me today. You guys
- 2:25:35can't hear them anymore. I was just about I was getting so close to
- 2:25:39revealing all the secrets about but yeah, no more. I was about to
- 2:25:43comment about sex finally being added to D two after years of Twitter request.
- 2:25:48Oh it's it's always been in D two. You guys just haven't found out
- 2:25:52yet. Christ oh man, uh I Drew you got more. I feel
- 2:25:58I want to make sure again we're being respectful of Merks time. He's been
- 2:26:01a really great sport. But you can ask one more. That's it for
- 2:26:11this is like, this is gonna be one that's like I know is probably
- 2:26:13like I'm shooting my shot and you can just be like you can be quiet
- 2:26:18now, all right, So we talked. I only thought of this because
- 2:26:22of the question about the cascade point or crafting and guns. Yeah, crafting
- 2:26:31and guns, castcade point or dust brought on the hand cannons mm hmm,
- 2:26:35box breathing on a one eighty ink. You can you can forgot you don't
- 2:26:46have to. You don't have to. I gave you precision instrument on a
- 2:26:50one eight hand can. How much more do you need? Done? That
- 2:26:52lets you three tap some resiliences. It might not anymore in the new sandbox,
- 2:26:54unfortunately, but I don't know if anymore. But I've actually been using
- 2:26:58it, to be honest, like I've actual you had a good deal of
- 2:27:00fun. It's like the way that I treat the perk right now is like
- 2:27:03it's just it's better forgiveness majority of the time because everyone's like playing like yeah
- 2:27:07what times being popular, It's like everyone's out like barely. Anyone's at a
- 2:27:11low resilience level. But if it happens, like I'm shooting as if it's
- 2:27:16going to happen, and if it does happen, I get a little surprised
- 2:27:18and I'm like ah. But also, transferring between targets is really cool,
- 2:27:24Like you can really get into like a rhythm because you have a bit more
- 2:27:26time to play with I think than like something my target lock. So if
- 2:27:28you start like transferring damage between targets, it's really cool. It kind of
- 2:27:33makes your one ad essentially did the same thing as a So that's new.
- 2:27:39I'm glad. Do you like that perk? That was one that I was.
- 2:27:41I was pretty pretty thrilled to make. I thought it was a fun
- 2:27:43idea. So yeah, all right, yeah, there you go. Well
- 2:27:48done. We'd like to give again another thank you everybody in the chat right
- 2:27:54now. Thank you to merk I, thank you to Bungee for allowing Mark
- 2:27:58to come here here allegedly and speak to us about the past two PvP twigs.
- 2:28:03We really appreciate the extra insight in the in the follow up and the
- 2:28:07all the conversation that you brought to the table. I I'm looking forward to
- 2:28:13March fifth. I mean a lot of it sounds right up my goddamn alley.
- 2:28:18So I mean, I'm sure you're gonna be in there. Are you
- 2:28:22gonna be playing on March fifth, Murker, Are you gonna be doing yeah?
- 2:28:26Nice? Yeah, when whenever we have a big release, we get
- 2:28:28time set aside at work to like actually play in live that's alongside the release
- 2:28:33Jingleheim or better show up no more special. I mean maybe his hours are
- 2:28:39numbered, but yeah, thank you very much, Murk. We really do
- 2:28:43appreciate it. I'm happy to do it. Damn right, damn right,
- 2:28:48really quickly, two seconds? Can we tell the people where they can find
- 2:28:52you. Don't worry about that. Oh cool, great games. That's the
- 2:28:56d forum. Just go sub to cool guy please, And I'm gonna go
- 2:29:01ahead and let the auto host speech