Latest / The Team House / Where Does This End? The Downside to Deterrence | EYES ON | Ep. 3
Transcript
- 0:00Hey guys, it's Jack. I just wanted to talk to you today about
- 0:03a way that you can help support the podcast. If you're not already,
- 0:07we would really appreciate it if you guys went and reviewed us on Apple or
- 0:10Spotify. Those reviews really help people find the podcast and help it get recognized,
- 0:16and you know, if you've been enjoying the show, we really appreciate
- 0:19your support. Another thing that you can do to support the channel is to
- 0:24become a Patreon member. So we have Patreon memberships that started just five dollars
- 0:29a month, and when you sign up, you get access to all of
- 0:32our episodes add free. That's the big bonus for that. I mean,
- 0:36we also do some Patreon bonus episodes for our subscribers, But this is the
- 0:42biggest and best way that you can support the Teamhouse channel and podcast if you'd
- 0:48like to, and we really appreciate that, So go and check us out
- 0:51at patreon dot com slash the Teamhouse. Hello everyone, Welcome to another episode
- 0:56of Eyes on, a reasonably well informed discussion of geo political events and about
- 1:00the time it takes you to pet, drive to work, or whatever else
- 1:06it takes you to do. In thirty minutes or so. I'm Andy Milburn
- 1:10for MA Marine Infantry and Special Operations officer now toiling for the team House d
- 1:15Over to you. Thanks. Andy. Yeah, really excited about this one.
- 1:21It's kind of a continuation from our last episodes, which I'd love for
- 1:25everyone to check out if they haven't about our hits on, you know,
- 1:30the IRGC and their proxies in Syria and Iraq, and we're gonna touch on
- 1:34like the continued strikes on the Houthis and Yemen, and I think talk a
- 1:42little bit more about a broader sense of like, you know, deterrence.
- 1:47And because I've had this, I've been reading it like almost every day.
- 1:51There are some folks on Twitter and Instagram who talk about deterrence and I don't
- 1:56even know exactly what it means in terms of like deterring what's going on,
- 2:00because it doesn't seem, you know, we got the strongest military in the
- 2:01world by a lot, and it doesn't seem we don't seem to be deterring
- 2:06much. No, that's a that's a great point and a great question.
- 2:09Without making it a war college class, I've dive into and I'll give you
- 2:15a you know, kind of a five minute answer on that and hopefully make
- 2:19it entertaining. But backtrack. Yes, So the Department of Defense just released
- 2:28the BDA, that's battle damage Assessment on Twitter for the attacks in let me
- 2:37see, it was in Iraq. Actually it was all together attacks Iraq,
- 2:43Syria and in Yemen. Okay, so they report eighty This must be just
- 2:50Iraq and Syrious. Sorry about this because they're talking about eighty five targets.
- 2:53Eighty of eighty five targets have suffered serious damage or were totally destroyed. Casualties
- 3:00of militia members expected to be around fifty to sixty. Okay, We've got
- 3:05to ask ourselves, right, how come those fifty to sixty dudes did not
- 3:09get the word after a week of publicly telegraphing that we were coming. Less
- 3:15surprising, no members of the IRGC or Iranian nationals were killed. Okay,
- 3:21that was official DD release. Certainly not in the strikes. Interestingly enough,
- 3:28though not not widely reported, but one of a senior Iran backed figure within
- 3:38the MILITIASNR G L Kabi, was assassinated by unknown gunmen in Mason, Iraq.
- 3:45Okay, coincidence, I don't know, totally don't I'm not right,
- 3:49But it's kind of interesting that, Yeah, we didn't kill any guys in
- 3:52the strikes, but this one dude did disappear, you know. But that's
- 3:57kind of a distraction, I think, and he can I cut in.
- 4:00What does I r g L mean? Sorry this for me because I'm a
- 4:03dumb No, I I r g C. Right, he was an actual
- 4:06I r GC guy. Okay, no, no, no, he was
- 4:11uh actually no, good good point, he was not he was he was
- 4:15a rocky, he was the but he was a senior PMC member. Noticed
- 4:19in the strikes, no senior PMC members were killed. Yeah, you know,
- 4:24so I think it was mostly kind of remember when we we bombed the
- 4:29Chinese embassy in Belgrade and killed if you know, I mean killed essentially the
- 4:34teening stuff. Yeah, I'm not saying that that's what happened here, but
- 4:38certainly, you know, you wonder about these guys. Maybe they would provided
- 4:44you know, maybe that was their resume line. B d A, that's
- 4:47that's what that's your wrong anyway, Yeah, I digress. My point is
- 4:53it's a distraction because we didn't kill any senior members of the Islamic Revolution srik
- 4:59on core all right, I'm not saying, you know, I'm not you
- 5:01know me. I mean, I'm not saying never, never, extolling killing
- 5:06for the sake of killing. But but it's hard to know how we can
- 5:11detract from capability without removing the guys who are stly involved in the transfer of
- 5:17knowledge, you know, technical know how. So yeah, and yeah,
- 5:25when you look at the list of stuff destroyed, there's that dramatic, dramatic
- 5:30footage of the stuff cooking off in ourchime, you know. I mean that
- 5:34whole area though, as is Yemen is just one giant ordinance dump, and
- 5:41it's quite easy to have left some order AMMO in a warehouse to give some
- 5:48some dramatic effect. So anyway, yeah, I mean I don't and I'm
- 5:55getting somewhere on this day. I'm not just diminishing the strikes by any means
- 6:00I am, but I'm saying that's my job. I'll do it. Yeah,
- 6:02maybe that's a wider picture, but you know, there's it's a tremendously
- 6:10difficult task. I mean, we're trying to reduce capability in an area where
- 6:18there is just a massive amount of ordinate so they're only reliant on the Iranians
- 6:23for certain key components, all right, for the missiles to come through,
- 6:27and it's very and these are relatively small components and quite easy to smuggle.
- 6:32So it's not the yes, we are destroying things, you know, and
- 6:40it looks great on video, But as far as removing capability or even disabling
- 6:47the Iranians ability or rather these properci's ability to act for even for a period
- 6:54of time, it's not. You know, I don't think I don't think
- 6:57we're achieving it. Okay, So anyway, to your so it doesn't look
- 7:00like we're achieving deterrence, I'm going to come back to that specific question.
- 7:04But an answer to yours, I can't remember the War College definition, and
- 7:10I have an abhorrence of people who do read things out from doctrine. But
- 7:14it's but deterrence is very simply, you know, it's a practice of discouraging
- 7:18or restraining someone in world politics that's usually a nation state from taking unwanted actions,
- 7:26okay, And it involves an effort to stop or prevent an action,
- 7:30as opposed to making someone or trying to make a state do something, which
- 7:40is compellants, all right, which is something different. Okay, this is
- 7:44more than this is slightly more than semantics. Okay, and because they there's
- 7:48really when we talk about deterrence, you may say, in fact, they
- 7:54should have primed you to say this, Hey, Andy, how are we
- 7:57deterring after the fact? Okay? And a lot of people get confused by
- 8:01this. You know, something happens, we're really responding, and you'll see
- 8:03the military comes up with terms like flexible deterrent option and flexible deterrent response,
- 8:11but they essentially they come down to the same thing as far as objective.
- 8:15Because if you are responding and the way that we are, our intent is
- 8:20to threaten escalation. Right, We're not simply punishing. The implication is,
- 8:26hey, we will do this and worse if you continue. All right,
- 8:30So response to terrence all wrapped into one. It's meaningless to distinguish between the
- 8:35two. And these packages that the military puts together involve various options for the
- 8:43president to decide between. You know, it's just like a sushi menu.
- 8:46All right. What's interesting now, like deterrence by punishment, the other de
- 8:54terrence, but denial, that's when you put a force, you know,
- 8:58you prevent you you make the enemy's objective less attainable, all right, and
- 9:03it might be you know, sticking US troops in Poland or all the Baltic
- 9:07states, you know, and so they would be in the path of a
- 9:09Russian invading force, which makes it less likely that the Russians are going to
- 9:13want to invade. Blah blah blah. The terrance by punishment historically is less
- 9:18effective. And then when I say historically the last three decades, okay,
- 9:24but we United States use the term to terrence all the time, and it
- 9:31is deeply embedded in our national security strategy. You know, in Europe,
- 9:35it's the basis of our containment of Russian adventurism, as well as actions in
- 9:43the Gray Zone. You know. Of course, in Korea it's you know,
- 9:46it's policy to de tear North Korea, not just from invading, but
- 9:52just further provocations. And then throughout Asia, of course we're trying to deter
- 9:56Chinese belligerents and Gray zone encroachment on areas subject to territorial disputes. So,
- 10:03you know, de terrence is it when when it comes to US, I
- 10:09would argue, I'll tell you what, you know, when the terrence fails,
- 10:11it's because one of the key components is missing. This is not from
- 10:16doctrine. But you know, one of the one of the things that I
- 10:20think we United States miss, and it's perhaps the most important aspect of deterrence,
- 10:26is this critical fact, and it is the perception of the potential aggressor.
- 10:31In other words, it is how that guy views the world that matters,
- 10:35not not the actual prospects of success I'm sorry, not yeah, not
- 10:41actual prospects of victory, of his success or any other objective measurement. So
- 10:50we've got to be careful not mirror imaging. Wow, this would really hurt
- 10:52us. Imagine, it's really hurting the Iranian regime, you know. And
- 10:56and we've seen the terreance go awhyd with Putin too, because we tend to
- 11:03mirror image and we haven't tried to really understand our adversary. So, you
- 11:07know, any any strategy to prevent aggression, you've got to understand your enemy.
- 11:11You know, his interest, motives, his imperatives. Because because when
- 11:18when an aggressor acts, it's not it's usually not war opportunism. He's answering
- 11:24some other need. It may be domestic, but it's an immediate need.
- 11:28We need to understand that need and maybe find in some other way of delivering
- 11:33it to him, you know. And the last part so so yes,
- 11:37you've got to you know, you've you've got to step back from your ego,
- 11:41and you've got to look at things from from the enemy's perspective, and
- 11:46you've got to take a combined arms approach. Okay, or you know,
- 11:48a lot of our military guys will it will understand what I mean about by
- 11:52this. What I mean is that when you engage the enemy with a weapon,
- 11:54you don't want to just engage them with one weapon. You want to
- 11:58engagement with a weapon that forces him to do something that makes him vulnerable to
- 12:01another weapon. Classic cases, you know, direct fire weapons and indirect fire
- 12:07weapons. Okay, same thing applies to economic sanctions, all right. By
- 12:11imposing one sanction making them hurt there, you drive them in another area where
- 12:16you can hurt him even more, which means that you can't compartmentalize dime or
- 12:22PERMISSI. All right. Dime is diplomatic, information, military, economic.
- 12:28You know, it's a way that we separate all the elements of national power.
- 12:33I'm saying when we approach the terrence, we've got to act as who
- 12:37all of this has to be fully integrated and that is actually why you hear
- 12:41the term integrated de terrence as a buzzword. I would argue, yes,
- 12:46we're very good at using that term. We're less effective than actually doing it.
- 12:50You know, I'll give you that's a fair assessment. Yeah, okay,
- 12:56So the other thing we do, you know what I mean? And
- 13:00I guess another principle, I'm just making this stuff up. But you can't
- 13:05forget the carrot, all right, you know, I mean we talk about
- 13:07karts stick. You can't just totally forget about that. Preventing aggression, it's
- 13:13not all about making threats. It's also about offering assurances. All right.
- 13:18Can you believe that's a marine saying that? But it is. You know,
- 13:24you've got to leave him an open door. You've got to leave him
- 13:26a face saving exit that's going to make him look good to his domestic audience.
- 13:31And if you can get it enable him to achieve his objectives otherwise,
- 13:37but in a way that doesn't hurt your interest, then by all means,
- 13:39go ahead and do so. This is what I mean about not standing on
- 13:43ego. But it again, it involves very intensive strategic communication. That's another
- 13:50aspect where we often fall short. With the terrence. Okay, it's everything
- 13:56is about Owaii. Ask me WHATAI stands for? Already know? Do you
- 14:01already know from the team house? What does it mean? Operations in the
- 14:07information environment. I'm very careful about acronyms, so I now never try and
- 14:13spell out acronyms more than three letters after my dreadful debacle with AOB But yeah,
- 14:20so operations in the information environment, Okay, We've got to think about
- 14:24kinetic actions relationship to information as supporting and supported, Okay, which means you
- 14:33know, typically we say, yeah, information operations support kinetic actions. But
- 14:37no, I mean we have to think of military actions supporting operations in the
- 14:45information environment. Right, So you know, moving a US brigade to Estonia,
- 14:50A brigade is not going to do anything against Russian advance, but it's
- 14:54a it's a significant you know, military although military terily negligible, Uh,
- 15:01it is a significant strategic right because like, why would the Russians wipe out
- 15:07a brigade? Yeah and start a Yeah, it's a it's a trip line.
- 15:11I mean, it's early morning, whatever you want to call it.
- 15:16But the point is it's it's an escalatory. You're pushing you're you're pushing uh,
- 15:22Russia can't can't threaten the Baltic States, for instance, without under war
- 15:26with the United States. Yes, everyone may know that conceptually, but but
- 15:31by putting your blood on the line, you are really you know, you're
- 15:35literally putting skin in the game and demonstrating that. Okay, which no,
- 15:41yeah, no worries in terms of like what's going on now if Iraq Iran
- 15:46in their proxies and cuts force, basically running amok in the region, and
- 15:52I would argue, asserting, uh a lot of dominance. What do we
- 15:58docifically there to deter them from, like, are trying to get them to
- 16:04reel their proxies in? Ah? Yeah, So persuade who do you because
- 16:11we get into the crux of the problem here. I mean, I guess
- 16:14it's Iran persuade wrong, Okay, what do I know? People don't want
- 16:18to talk about like you know, people are like you know, even when
- 16:22you when you hear everyone speaking, okay, it's always Iran back to It's
- 16:27like a buzzword that people Well, let me say, let me wrap up,
- 16:33let me wrap up very quickly, your excellent question about the terrence.
- 16:37Okay, So because it leads into an answer to your next question. So,
- 16:40so, successful deterrence typically involves combination of taking, uh, you know,
- 16:45these combined arms actions, taking the aggressive motivations, seriously understanding them,
- 16:51being clear clear about your intent what you want to you know, the the
- 16:56aggressive to do. So all of those things, and it's you know,
- 17:00think about the times it has worked. We've done all those things, and
- 17:03it's really you know, worked most famously in the longest period of time in
- 17:07Korea since nineteen fifty three and during the Cold War. All right, but
- 17:11it's not working here. Okay, why isn't working here? One one answer?
- 17:15Maybe And this is not me, you know, this is a US
- 17:18intelligence officials. I thought I'd never use that term, but so so,
- 17:25you know, it's semi official. They assessed that Iran does not exercise full
- 17:30control over the proxy and part of militia groups that are attacking US personnel,
- 17:36so that by that it you know, neither the huthis nor all the constellation
- 17:42of Iranian backed militia groups in Iraq are taking their orders directly from the head
- 17:51of Kotzwass. And there's probably a combination of factors. Okay, the kind
- 17:55of the cult of personality of Sulimani was able to exert these leaders is gone
- 18:00Ghan. He's a different type of individual. And you know, the kids
- 18:06have grown up, they're ready to leave home. They have been armed to
- 18:10a level of sophistication that was, you know, it just couldn't be imagined
- 18:15five years ago. And I mean, look at the hoothis. The hoothis
- 18:21for God's sake. I mean, are disabling oil refineries and bringing and you
- 18:27know, taking action that have global reverberations far beyond the the Babe Mandebb and
- 18:37Iran cannot control it anymore. That's that's pretty scary, right, you know.
- 18:44And and and so the attacks continue, I mean twice into Syria at
- 18:48Basis mission, you know, Mission support site Euphrates. Are you the picture
- 18:56the picture of our militia attacks on US base is in the chat. I
- 19:02always find it helpful to see a map, but you'll see there that the
- 19:06attacks have been mostly focused on the Middle Euphrates Valley, certainly in this last
- 19:11week to include an attack on on the Alma oil fields, well on a
- 19:22I'm sorry, on a combat outpost and the oil fields which killed seven members
- 19:30of the Syrian Democratic Forces. The SDF, who are our partners and fighting
- 19:34the Islamic Islamic State. No US casualties in that, So it does appear
- 19:41bottom line, as though the Iranians have lost control of their proxies in there.
- 19:48But you know, there's a lot of bluster going on too. They're
- 19:52not going to admit that, and they're issuing. You know, they issued
- 19:55a warning yesterday, right, warning the States against attacking their two surveillance ships,
- 20:03the Bashad and the Savies. So you know, they what makes it
- 20:08worse is they're on the posturing platform two and I'm not going to admit that
- 20:15that. They can't. You know, they can't lose the train, the
- 20:18train. The train has left the station. Yeah, they can't lose face
- 20:22at home, right, they still have to deal with their own internal politics
- 20:25and stuff like that. Still about regime security at the end of the day
- 20:27for them, Yeah, one hundred one hundred percent. And and while everything
- 20:33continues. You know, we haven't we haven't talked about Gaza, and I'm
- 20:38not going to you know, get into that topic today. But but as
- 20:42you know, I've I've been quite I've got a contract to write a book
- 20:45about about it. And in fact we're going to be doing a couple of
- 20:48episodes from from there towards the end of this month, and so you know,
- 20:56and and I'll i'll least be able to address the military campaign in more
- 21:02detailed there but elsewhere, you know, in the Middle East. So while
- 21:06all this is going on, our adversaries are certainly certainly exploiting our absence or
- 21:14our weaknesses. I can't remember if I already talked to you about this,
- 21:18d but it doesn't matter. We're talking with the audience now. But the
- 21:22chairman, all right of the Popular Iraqi Popular Mobilization Committee, the PMC and
- 21:30rock position. Remember I spoke about him on I spoke about him last week.
- 21:38Yeah, he's he was involved allegedly in the US on the attack on
- 21:44the US embassy in twenty nineteen. Well, he met this week with the
- 21:51Russian Ambassador to Iraq Krusher chef and met this week in Bagdad, and they
- 21:56talked about exchanging experiences, mutual yeah, and even mutual training. Okay,
- 22:02so who knows. Yeah, you know, I mean how the Russians love
- 22:06having these PMC literally PMCs. Now they've gone now I mean potential right there,
- 22:12influence in in Iraq that's I thought that was fairly, fairly notable.
- 22:18And at the same time, the Chinese visited as Beka Stan this week.
- 22:23You know, we've we us have been courting as bekas Stan well, I
- 22:30mean obviously since ninety eleven, but recently among the Stans, you know,
- 22:36as Bekastan has been one that we've been working with most closely. Chinese we
- 22:41can launch out of right well number of reasons. I mean it's politically,
- 22:45yes, it's a I mean, it's a very it's a really viable position.
- 22:48It became increasingly important after we pulled around Afghanistan. Ah, and you
- 22:56know, we provide I've been there a few times. That ship's beautiful country,
- 23:00and we provide soft support training their self military, which has become a
- 23:07little dodgy at times ahead of their special operations. Guy's a guy we trained
- 23:12left to join the Islamic State. So yeah, these things are always tough
- 23:18to manage. And here we are now the Chinese have signed or signed an
- 23:23agreement, a strategic agreement and all weather comprehensive strategic partnership. So I was
- 23:30looking for exactly what it was all weather. Yeah, So the only other
- 23:36country in the region who's part of this all weather agreement is Pakistan. Okay,
- 23:42So I mean it's a separate bilateral agreement, but it's the only other
- 23:47country that China has has called an all weather ally. So Bekistan all weather
- 23:55ally to China, fair weather friend in the United States. So is that
- 24:00that Pakistan they chose to do that, right, China aligning with Pakistan is
- 24:03to like kind of give it to India a bit. I mean, it's
- 24:08a little bit out of like what we're talking about, but that's my assumption,
- 24:11you know, say it again. So the reason, the reasoning why
- 24:17China has done that all weather strategic partnership with Pakistan is to deter or,
- 24:25for lack of a better word, India's like power in the region. Yeah,
- 24:30I mean China and Pakistan have always had close relationship is not quite the
- 24:37term, but it's a it's kind of a mutually supportive relationship. Yes,
- 24:44they've had you know, they've gone at it. I mean, they've had
- 24:48a arguments over the various things over the years. But you know, is
- 24:55your way of China and India have literally come to blows. Yeah, have
- 25:00caused you know, I mean, have killed each other's soldiers several times.
- 25:04In the last year, often in these extraordinary unarmed brawls, which which both
- 25:11sides seem to agree doesn't doesn't cross any red lines. But yeah, I
- 25:18mean, certainly Pakistan's within China's closer, within China's sphere of influence, and
- 25:25yeah, they both have a lot of mutual a lot of interests in Afghanistan.
- 25:29And those interests, of course are not necessarily ours. Sure of course.
- 25:33Hey like hey, last thing though, the I like this from oddly
- 25:38enough from a dude in Tel Aviv who you know, commented about the fact
- 25:45that that most that most American, even US military officials privately saying that the
- 25:53capabilities of who these have not been significantly degraded by the campaign. And this
- 26:00this researcher, intel avised military researchers says, you taking on the hoofis is
- 26:07like fighting fog, you know. Interesting. I mean the descriptions the same
- 26:11thing about hamas in Gaza. So no, no new lessons here. But
- 26:19what's what what will make progress like like, is it more of a covert
- 26:25thing? Is it more I don't know, drones or you know, I
- 26:30don't know what strikes. Strikes can be immensely effective, but they have to
- 26:36be, you know, if you want them to have military effect, and
- 26:38by that I mean take away capability. Obviously you can't telegraph them, okay,
- 26:42absolutely, and uh and and they you know, although thank god we
- 26:49got away from a traditional warfare and adding up a number of people killed.
- 26:56But you do, you do have to take off the board the guys with
- 27:00the expertise who cannot be replaced, right, not the fifty or sixty guys
- 27:06who are too dumb to have forgot the word that the US were coming.
- 27:11Right, And it's got to be combined with other things, to include working
- 27:15with partners on the ground. You know, you can't you can't do all
- 27:19this remotely. You've got to build relationships on the ground too. And there's
- 27:23got to be a carrot. Remember that, you know, I mentioned that
- 27:27we've got to start thinking how do we offer the who he's a carrot?
- 27:30How do we provide them an incentive because we can't deter them? Yeah,
- 27:36I mean what's going to deter them. They're not scared of particularly scared of
- 27:41death. They've been fighting all their lives. I mean, they're going to
- 27:45keep shooting stuff until they stopped having stuff the shoes, So let me ask
- 27:49you something like in terms for like the talking heads are like the opinion makers
- 27:55on Twitter, and no less of that. That's what we are leader right,
- 28:00absolutely, but like the thought leaders, I mean it, I don't
- 28:04think that's going to brief so well, like offering the hohothi's, well that
- 28:10looks some kind Well that's the thing. Well that's the thing, you know,
- 28:12But posturing and ego just don't belong into your politics. And yes,
- 28:22of course we played to a domestic audience. But at the same time,
- 28:26ultimately our criteria for success are that shipping is allowed to proceed unimpeded, you
- 28:33know, and that stability is restored. And if the Houthi's get something in
- 28:38that process that they wanted, yes, people can say oh, we gave
- 28:44in, or it can just you know, it's it's just a sensible approach.
- 28:49Otherwise we're going to be ten, fifteen, twenty years from now.
- 28:53Think about the cost in terms of the US defense budget. You know,
- 28:59just merchant ships cannot defend themselves against these missiles. There is no way you
- 29:03cannot. You cannot design a system that is going to be economically viable.
- 29:11The cost of these ships having to choose now between taking war insurance or going
- 29:17the long way round. The Cape is driving global costs up, all right,
- 29:22And it doesn't matter if your supply chain isn't directly affected by the Red
- 29:27Sea. Other supply chains that are interrelated probably are. It affects every country
- 29:34in the world tremendous. So, you know, do we want to salvage
- 29:38our sense of being America that strong and just you know, keep keep dropping
- 29:45bombs until literally we have flattened Yemen. Or do we take a little more
- 29:48intelligent approach? Yeah, you would think, you know, taking the intelligence
- 29:53and you know, I'm listen, I'm all about killing the enemy, you
- 29:57know that. And I'm saying you've got a throwing You've got to put an
- 30:00incentive in there too, by all means scare the crap out of it,
- 30:03but do it by going after his capabilities, hurting him, not not we'll
- 30:07be doing right now, which is kind of pinging. Yeah, absolutely,
- 30:11thinking well the that's probably I lose track of time here, but I think
- 30:17you're keeping us under there. I have a question. I have one question
- 30:22about Okay, well, since you've asked the question in terms of the Red
- 30:25Sea, we'll be enjoying talking to me. So that's a good sign.
- 30:27No, I am yeah, this is the best. So in terms of
- 30:32like the issues in the Red Sea with the Houthis and stuff like that,
- 30:34does it make sense to bring in a more broader coalition not just the UK
- 30:40because if it, I mean, it seems to affect the europe right away
- 30:44in the short medium term and then the rest of the world in the long
- 30:48term. Yeah, where's France, where's Italy? Where are the other NATO
- 30:52countries? Well, where's Egypt too, Like, why is in Egypt doing
- 30:57anything? Yeah? Well, there are a number of coalition countries involved in
- 31:02fact that there's a coalition Task Force. And I can't tell you all the
- 31:06countries that are involved in it, but I want to say that it it
- 31:11it either falls under the direction of H under nabsent direction or but but at
- 31:19least is coordinated with Nabsent And what's n I'm sorry, it's Naval Commands Central
- 31:26so what naval forces and Middle least. But yes, there is a coalition
- 31:30task force. It is it has largely and again you know, I know
- 31:37I'll be torn up if I'm wrong on this, but it's largely too date
- 31:41being focused on the Somali piracy problem. But the but the but there's there's
- 31:51crossover membership or an interest obviously in the Red Sea. So yes, coalition
- 31:56efforts are there are coalition coalition efforts underway. But you know, escorting ships
- 32:01is it's it's an incredibly time intensive and expensive proposition, you know, escorting
- 32:13ships. It's not like the sycon Moore wall where you're traveling along and conboy
- 32:16you're covering them with your at offense assets, right, which don't come cheap.
- 32:23Yeah, I mean, look at you know the so the US canne
- 32:28is shot down fourteen drones, all right, right, an SM two missile
- 32:32Okay, is you know I want to say two million dollars? I know
- 32:37it's in the millions, all right, So you know, supposedly say it
- 32:42just fired fourteen missiles. I mean we're talking twenty eight million dollars. Yeah,
- 32:47it's not exactly cost effective, right term solution probably eight you know,
- 32:52don't even add up to a million dollars. Yeah, So it's just not
- 32:58the way we're doing things right now. Is neither is just not cost effective
- 33:02and it's not militarily effective. Look I'm not pretending to be smart here.
- 33:08Look I was part of the problem. I'm just saying, it's a hard
- 33:13it's hard to find a solution. So please think I'm sitting here criticizing the
- 33:16guys who are just like me, who are trying to figure out a way
- 33:22to curb the thread and do all these things without bringing the United States into
- 33:27war. It's a tremendously hard problem. Yeah, it's an impossible needle to
- 33:32thread. You know, it's tough, but not impossible, but it's very
- 33:37difficult. Okay, but you know that's always anyway, No, absolutely,
- 33:45And I just want to mention, I know, like you know, you've
- 33:47served that. You know, Jack and Dave have served. Everybody who's on
- 33:51the show served, and like a lot of the folks that watch the show
- 33:53are veterans. Having said that, I mean, and it's not their fault
- 33:59at all. The escapade in Iraq is mainly to blame for Iran filling that
- 34:09power vacuum in the region. Yeah, I mean, I can't imagine that
- 34:15there's anyone out there who still thinks that invading Iraq was a good idea from
- 34:20the point of view of Unite US interest. I mean, if there is,
- 34:23we welcome of course, because we welcome alternate views, but it yeah,
- 34:31I you know I would tend to agree. Hey, you know before
- 34:36we sign off them when we talk about the effect that because sadly, because
- 34:42of our intervention we've seen, you know, we've left a bad taste as
- 34:45we leave for obvious reasons in Afghanistan and now in Iraq, for reasons that
- 34:52are partly not our fault but partly are. To be fair, you know,
- 34:57we've kind of said we kind of allowed those conditions to come to fruition
- 35:00extremists or politicians and power in Iraq who do not like us, know,
- 35:07and not talking about influencing elections. I'm just saying, turn we turned a
- 35:12blind eye for a long time to kind of the way the sheer power base
- 35:17was continuing to gather power there and ignoring our ignoring our advice. Hey,
- 35:23So anyway, on the last thing, on a bright note, that picture
- 35:29and chat and throw it up. That's as we talk about our adversaries and
- 35:37non aligned country is all kind of making plans for a while in which United
- 35:43States doesn't dominate quite the same way it has to date. And that photograph
- 35:47is of an Iranian military delegation to read, yes, indeed, ladies,
- 35:52and gentlemen and an Iranian military delegation to reacd unprecedented certainly in our lifetimes,
- 35:59I believe, and went very nicely apparently, So that's probably not I mean,
- 36:06that's not something that the Saudis made all that they did put that picture
- 36:08out on Twitter. But you see what I'm saying. You know, there's
- 36:13no one. There's no one. Very few countries aside from our traditional friends
- 36:17and European friends, are saying, oh, yeah, you know, good
- 36:22point. We we do. We should side with the United States because you
- 36:28still do represent democracy and liberal Western values et cetera, et cetera. That
- 36:34is so yeah, so he even said, yeah, sorry, even Saudi
- 36:42Arabia buddying up with Iran. Let's say we did pull out of the Red
- 36:46Sea in the Middle East, and the who he's keep going there. You
- 36:52know, eventually that peace dealer, that cease fire with Saudi arab is going
- 36:55to end. Let's say we stopped selling weapons like what happens when they're there's
- 37:00no free maritime travel in the Red Seat because we're not there. No.
- 37:05I mean I get it though, D because but everyone knows we're not going
- 37:08to do that, because ultimately global trade is an orange. I mean,
- 37:15the free free flow of commerce and global trade is definitely rock solid within our
- 37:23interests. In fact, you know, we've we're the one country that has
- 37:30so far not disappeared into a you know, even a moderate recession. I
- 37:36mean, we're still an economic powerhouse. We dominate the world in that sense,
- 37:42very much so. And so we more than anyone, stand again or
- 37:46lose by what happens to global trade. And I think some people, the
- 37:50isolationists, forget that. Yeah, not for sure. It's just interesting,
- 37:58like, yeah, you know, the Saudi Arabia flirting with Iran, or
- 38:00flirting with or Iraq flirting with the Russian delegation. It's like, at the
- 38:07end of the day, it's like, oh, pay attention to us.
- 38:08It's like, you know, they just it's like a cry for attention from
- 38:12them. I don't know, I think this is. I think it's these
- 38:15are deliberate, long term decisions based on an assessment of the of America's role
- 38:22in in the world. You know, I don't I'm not hopefully sounding like
- 38:28a you know, just banging extremists here, but yes, that is I
- 38:32think that is clearly evident. I mean, there's many other factors in play
- 38:37too, you know. But so even though we may think of the world
- 38:44as been as as fitting into certain patterns post you know, post Cobal right
- 38:53with you know, kind of the axis of whatever you want to call it,
- 38:59the actually resistance on the access of of evil or of just you know,
- 39:02the the angry men you know, North Korea, Russia, China,
- 39:08Iran, but they yeah, I mean absolutely the threat that it's not that
- 39:20any of them can supplant the United States, but they can certainly undermine the
- 39:23US's ability to defend its own interests. And that's what's happening. Yeah,
- 39:28I think we need to look at it like a market share of like any
- 39:30kind of market like if as long as we have the dominating share of it,
- 39:34like we're okay, first view. I think that's the way to look
- 39:39at it. That's a that's a great that's a great comment. Hey be
- 39:44for we Yeah, well, i mean we've got yes, absolutely, Hey,
- 39:49we've got we've got to get we've got to get our email or something.
- 39:54I mean, I'm sorry, I think for questions put up because someone
- 39:59sent me some really cool comments from last Yeah, and it shows to calm
- 40:04I'll aggregate some of the questions and we'll answer him at the tailor under Hey,
- 40:07I got this all right. I thought it's by a drone drone dude
- 40:13in in uh in Ukraine. I know him, in fact, he worked
- 40:19for me, all right, so I know this sounds like a team audience,
- 40:21but we don't have a you know, we have to use my contact
- 40:24info until we get one. Anyway, he said, if we assume similar
- 40:29employment in Ukraine as in Ukraine, all right, when we were we were
- 40:34out there. It seems the the shah head is designed such that if even
- 40:43with GPS, even with the jammer, it can still it can revert to
- 40:49inertial navigation, which makes makes it jam resistant. So unless he operated,
- 40:55this is this is my friend writing, So unless you operate, a mission
- 41:00planner had access to US flight plans and knew where when to program the shah
- 41:06heads so it would follow the US drone. It seems unlikely or was a
- 41:09crazy coincidence and timing, or they employed a different type of drone with a
- 41:15pilot fully in control during a flight and they had been observing US drone flights
- 41:19from the base. And then you know on my comment about Stinger, Yeah,
- 41:24correct, it hasn't shut down a drone. Neither has the Avenger and
- 41:29neither has the Sea Ram. But this guy outing of his first name is
- 41:37A he's a Stinger officer by background, so of course he's almost lost his
- 41:42friendship over that comment. But he does says say Stinger and theory should actually
- 41:45be very effective against shy Head type drones, although not cost effective for the
- 41:51reason they just said. But it would require a Stinger team ready to stand
- 41:54by receiving queuing from the sensor or at least doing their own visual searching and
- 42:00scanning. And you know, those of you who are air defense bubs and
- 42:02bore people at cocktail parties queuing as you know that they're being able to queue
- 42:08to shoot or sort with man pads, setting setting that up at their tactical
- 42:16level is always a challenge and so these things are difficult. Anyway, time
- 42:22about time to sign out at not going on the world. Okay, everyone,
- 42:29thanks again for listening to this episode of Eyes On. You can email
- 42:32or text your questions and comments to do. You will provide something in the
- 42:36chat and we will answer them, or depending on how many we get,
- 42:40we'll answer a selection of them. So we're releasing a new episode now on
- 42:45Wednesday and Sunday. Right there, yep, that's right. Yeah, And
- 42:49it's these these conversations focused on whatever happens to be front and center and the
- 42:53news scent the time. If you think we're talking too much about one particular
- 42:57topic or not enough about another, please send in your comments and they will
- 43:01be Julie noted and perhaps or ignored. And yeah, please feel free to
- 43:13send me messages by Twitter or follow me on Twitter. He's gonna post my
- 43:21address there, Okay, be over to you. I'll throw it up on
- 43:24the Thanks and Andy, Yeah, I'll throw all of Andy's info into the
- 43:30show notes and the descriptions of each show, whether it's video or audio,
- 43:34whether you listen to us on video audio, don't forget to like, subscribe
- 43:37or rate and review us five stars. It helps the channel big time.
- 43:42Uh. You can check out the Patreon help support the show. You can
- 43:45get ad free episodes of this show by going to the Patreon, so it's
- 43:50a little bit more streamlined. And yeah, check out the team house.
- 43:53Yeah, we read all your comments too, include yeah, and to include
- 43:58the YouTube comments. And someone went on a drunken brant and people who gets
- 44:06so drunk they can't even spell, but they there's quite a few anyway,
- 44:10Yeah, most of our listeners anyway. All right everyone, so you see
- 44:15you in a few days. Take care,