Latest / Inside Commerce: Ecommerce Strategy, CX and Technology Podcast / EP134: Reducing In-Store Checkout Friction & Boosting Sales With Mishipay's Ecommerce Apps
Transcript
- 0:02Thanks for tuning three-part from podcast, sponsored by a and
- 0:05klaviyo. You're listening to myself.
- 0:06James, go to my co-host. Paul Rodgers, how are you today,
- 0:09mate, in tanks? I am.
- 0:11I forgot about podcast earlier, and I cycled, and so yeah, look
- 0:14at like, I'm about to go to the gym but aside from that will get
- 0:18how you did. Yeah, it's an active Monday for
- 0:20the, what Goldson owes a kickboxing?
- 0:23Personal training this morning. So let's hope we stay awake.
- 0:26Yeah, it starts the way. Hello, to all regular sniffs.
- 0:29Thanks for tuning in. Always.
- 0:30And if this is first time you joined us, we hope you enjoy the
- 0:32podcast. Do subscribe to get a new
- 0:34episode. Looks, we've got one every week
- 0:36and we'd love a like, on YouTube Spotify, app or do you like the
- 0:38content? So, let's set up what we're
- 0:39talking about today and then I'll introduce you to our
- 0:41guests. So, our topic is how mushy page
- 0:43install Tech. Is reducing checkout, friction
- 0:46and helping retailers, boost sales through e-commerce.
- 0:49And what we're going to cover is and talk about some of the
- 0:51common in-store purchase frustrations that lead towards
- 0:54the need for digital technology and stores the benefit of the
- 0:56digital Tech like barcode scanning for retail teams.
- 1:00And Integrations with Melanie, Commerce platforms.
- 1:02So, let's welcome our guest. Mustafa Kamala, who's the
- 1:04founder and CEO at miss you pay, how you do Mustafa.
- 1:09Ideas, I'm good. How are you?
- 1:11Yeah, good. Thanks for joining us.
- 1:12So before we ask you, loads of annoying questions, you want to
- 1:15give you four people have not come across miss, you pay before
- 1:18you given the Novia, what what do you do, and why?
- 1:21Yeah, of course. So yeah.
- 1:23Once again, I'm going to finally found reality of mushy pea.
- 1:26I started the company now close to seven years ago.
- 1:30And, since day one, our mission has actually been the same,
- 1:32which is that we want Shoppers inside the store to have a
- 1:36better experience because I I had the idea for my GPA which is
- 1:41the ability for a user to scan the barcode of an item pay for
- 1:44an item inside the store and leave the store with your item
- 1:47without having to ever wait in a line.
- 1:49When I was waiting in a line myself, I waited 20 minutes at,
- 1:53you know, little in Tottenham Hill to buy a Coke and in my
- 1:56mind it just didn't make sense in the 21st century.
- 1:59Shortly was possible on the cash, register should be
- 2:02possible on my phone and that was just the first time lucky
- 2:05for me. You know I've trained as a
- 2:07mechatronic and killer There. So I was able to build the first
- 2:09prototype by myself and realize it's actually possible in
- 2:12reality and then we went out to go build it after which, you do
- 2:16my best friend and co-founder join me a few months after and
- 2:20then the rest of the team. Whose now, you know, over 40
- 2:22people between our offices in London Bangalore.
- 2:26And then we also have offices in us and very soon in Dubai but
- 2:31the focus Still Remains the Same which is that we believe
- 2:34Shoppers love to shop inside the store but the store The points
- 2:38you are perhaps which is the best moment where you decide you
- 2:42want to buy something and then when you get to the till you're
- 2:46having to wait in a line and then go ahead and pay for this
- 2:49too much friction between the point of wanting to bite and the
- 2:52point of actually buying and if you think online is almost the
- 2:55exact opposite, you don't have a great browsing experience, but
- 2:58when you've decided you can find out all the information, you
- 3:01could possibly ask for you can add it to your basket by
- 3:04ourselves and by so you have the autonomy of your purchase.
- 3:08So what Mischief is looking to do is bring the best of that
- 3:10online checkout, experience into the physical store, starting
- 3:14with the ability, for the user to scan Bago, and eventually
- 3:17taking over hopefully all the transactions inside of the store
- 3:21through our other. You know, more supplementary
- 3:24products to scan and go with the beginning.
- 3:26For us is standing go because it's something that can just be
- 3:29put live inside the store without any need for Hardware or
- 3:32software to structural changes on the retailer site, right?
- 3:37So Allah says Question. Yeah, really interesting one so
- 3:41what's your view on the current state of foot fall within
- 3:45physical retail? We've got a few clients.
- 3:48Have been really positive about London stores recently but yeah
- 3:52what's your view on kind of now that pre-pandemic levels and
- 3:56kind of how retailers are finding things at the moment.
- 3:58So almost across the board most of our retailers in stating that
- 4:04they they're above 29 game levels now, right, In terms of
- 4:08sales. Now a lot of them are not
- 4:11counting footfall separately to sales but where they are
- 4:15counting football separately, the sales they are saying
- 4:17footfall is up compared to 2019 levels.
- 4:20This could also be the surge that has come back in tourism.
- 4:23You know, almost all the covid, really all the covid
- 4:26restrictions are off in London, people are traveling back.
- 4:30You know, recently I was at a good restaurant near our office
- 4:35in SoHo and then the person there was saying that All of
- 4:38our, you know, foreign customers particularly are our customers.
- 4:42And our, our Chinese customers, all of them seem to be back
- 4:46story, not the Chinese, the error cluster is in the Indian
- 4:49customers because they Chinese, they're still having a more
- 4:52restrictions in there, so they're not back to the same
- 4:55levels, but they were talking, particularly about their care of
- 4:58customers from the Middle East. They were saying they were fully
- 5:00back and, you know, spending like they used to in London.
- 5:03So that's basically having a clear Trend.
- 5:05And and we see that not just in the UK We see that with our same
- 5:09customers in the Middle East, with our customers in the u.s.
- 5:13they're all back to or above free dynamic levels in terms of
- 5:17their sales. Now, I don't know how a
- 5:19potential recession could impact that again and and whether it
- 5:23will create another downturn that they would have to deal
- 5:25with. But at least for now, in the
- 5:27first two quarters of this year, they seem to be above 2019
- 5:30levels. Okay, great.
- 5:33And then and your product focused on the kind of digital
- 5:36experience Within Still and kind of reducing friction or removing
- 5:41friction. And you talked about the piece
- 5:43around, you know, delay is via cues or kind of your first
- 5:47experience and led to building the business.
- 5:50What are other kind of? Yeah, frustrations it customers
- 5:53tend to have the your business can help self.
- 5:59The time is the biggest thing from a user's perspective.
- 6:02I think from a Retailer's perspective, then there's a few
- 6:05other things from a user's perspective.
- 6:07First and foremost, we want to save them time if they would
- 6:10have normally spend Latina 30 minute shopping Journey, they
- 6:14spent 25 minutes shopping and five minutes checking out.
- 6:18Our first goal is to make them spend 29 plus minutes shopping
- 6:22at a few seconds. Checking out with me.
- 6:24She pay so your time and store could potentially still be the
- 6:27same. You're just spending.
- 6:28More productively and a higher quality of your total time,
- 6:33because you're spending it where you enjoy the store, the most,
- 6:36the trial room in the aisles, you know, looking through the
- 6:39items and browsing. Then you consider the second
- 6:43thing right there which is discovery of the items, right?
- 6:46Because whether user is spending more time in the US, check out
- 6:50is no longer the problem. The next thing is you know, how
- 6:52do I find what I'm looking for? So product Discovery begins to
- 6:57become another Important piece. This is where we brought in our
- 7:00product recommendation, engine where, for us.
- 7:03The user gets the ability to scan an item and say, hey people
- 7:07who bought this. Also bought this very similar to
- 7:10what you're getting used to seeing online on Amazon or
- 7:13really most good e-commerce website.
- 7:16They will recommend you based on what you've scared already added
- 7:19your basket or what item page you're on.
- 7:22So we realize that inside the store, you can also do it.
- 7:25It just happens today through the through them.
- 7:28Gross stuff. Who's usually very knowledgeable
- 7:31about people saying that okay, if you're buying this white
- 7:33shirt, I know that this car will go well with it.
- 7:36Or I know that your taste is of this type.
- 7:39So this other shared is going to be interesting for you.
- 7:41They're doing a lot of it but they're doing it one to one and
- 7:44they're not able to program it into being a fixed set of rules
- 7:49that you can apply right? Or put it into a machine
- 7:52learning algorithm so that it can consist consistently
- 7:55evolved. So, when you add in a new staff
- 7:57member like is Going across the whole retail Spectrum today,
- 8:01that had to let go of so many people or so many people, so,
- 8:05left for other reasons. Now, they're rehiring, you have
- 8:08to retrain them. But with with an engine that's
- 8:11using best using data for recommendations, you don't need
- 8:15to retrain it every time, every time they use it as a purchaser
- 8:18become smarter. So that's what we're really
- 8:20happy about with helping with product, Discovery inside the
- 8:23store. And then finally, when it comes
- 8:26to the user leaving the storage help, Understand when to come
- 8:30back, my keeping them abreast of latest offers latest, you know,
- 8:35new new products, new releases that come into the store.
- 8:38Sits maintaining that a link with their customer, which
- 8:41again, the retailers have gotten very good at doing with
- 8:44e-commerce and they found no good way apart from traditional
- 8:49loyalty programs to do that with their in store customers.
- 8:52And in traditional loyal, customer program specially in
- 8:55like fashion is, does not have more than 10 at most 20 percent
- 9:00penetration of the user. So you're still having a lot of
- 9:03users who are not logged into that.
- 9:06So that's what we can help with in the last piece which is which
- 9:09is furthering your loyalty program or adding a loyalty
- 9:12where you don't have one by yourself because effectively
- 9:15mushy pay still gets all the data about the user, not just
- 9:18what they're buying but what they're thinking of buying and
- 9:21why, because we can see whatever your scan.
- 9:23What did you add to basket them. What did you eventually by so
- 9:27which were the abandoned baskets?
- 9:28The middle or abandon items in the middle that you were
- 9:31interested in which we can. Now you're draw some behavioral
- 9:36analytics from, I understand that.
- 9:38Okay, Paul is this type of Shopper or James is this type of
- 9:41Shopper? Let's say one of them is only
- 9:43interested in items, which are on sale.
- 9:45So there's no point recommending something which is not on sale
- 9:48for you. So those, those kinds of areas
- 9:50are key for us to help the user on and then when it comes to
- 9:53the, to the retailer, I think any B2B company that sells Is
- 9:58into a business has to eventually have some way to save
- 10:04money through their product, or make money through their
- 10:06product. You have to be able to boil it
- 10:08down to one of those two areas for us.
- 10:11Luckily we can, we can help with both because on one end we
- 10:14reduce the need for cash or staff and cashier spots.
- 10:18So you can use that resource elsewhere in the store.
- 10:20All the sales floor in the back office wherever you want to as a
- 10:23retailer, but then you also have the ability for the user to buy
- 10:27more than they were. Because of that engagement
- 10:29during the journey, the better quality of their time and the
- 10:32fact that they can keep coming back to the store more awesome.
- 10:37What level of store do you typically work with it?
- 10:40You agnostic to size of store or taught or Petit.
- 10:45It's a key. It's a keyboard actually.
- 10:47Because we were we started off by saying, you know, really
- 10:50anyone who wants to work with us.
- 10:52Let's start with them. Because when you're a startup
- 10:54especially selling be to be in the physical Store retail, it
- 10:57can be very difficult. And because retailers operate
- 11:00on, you know, much longer Cycles inside the store.
- 11:03They're much lower than when they make changes on their
- 11:06website and there's so many other factors we have to
- 11:09consider so it's really hard. So in the beginning, we said you
- 11:12know what, we will try to get any retailers who want to work
- 11:15with us, anyone who's interested and we made some mistakes.
- 11:18We went to retailers where we didn't really give ourselves the
- 11:21best chances of success, right? We ended up starting some Pilots
- 11:26where there was no need for the solution.
- 11:28Is that first use was not clear. So we started to realize that,
- 11:32you know, we have to have three key criteria that first one,
- 11:36which is the obvious one you would think about is
- 11:38high-traffic, right at some point in the store.
- 11:41During the whole day, you have to have some element of a line
- 11:45forming right. If that is there, then you have
- 11:48the first key criteria because the user will in that line,
- 11:53immediately, see the benefit of mushy pea if you pitch it to
- 11:56them they'll say okay. You I can skip this line and
- 12:00I'll say five minutes of time. Right now, it makes sense.
- 12:04Show me how to do it right. There are there's a segment of
- 12:07users that you can immediately begin to convert so that's
- 12:10important. When you have a line inside the
- 12:12store, we typically look for traffic in terms of numbers.
- 12:17As you know, a retailer with more than three transactions per
- 12:21square meter per day. Typically, if you have more than
- 12:24this number, you start to form a queue inside the store.
- 12:28What we also see is that repeat frequency is important because
- 12:33for instance, an electronics store, a pure electronic store
- 12:36in the traditional sense. Think like a curry spicy world
- 12:39may have queues at some point in the, in the day.
- 12:42But if you typically visit that store once in a year once in two
- 12:46years, so even if we spend on customer acquisition, the beta
- 12:50is going to be very slow and there.
- 12:53The recall value is almost zero for the customer at that point.
- 12:57They're not coming back. Often enough.
- 12:59So that's why we also look for a repeat frequency where the user
- 13:02is. Coming to the store once in
- 13:04three months or more often. And finally, we look for
- 13:08transferability of transactions. So what that means is that
- 13:12nearly hundred percent of the items should be available for
- 13:16scam and go if there's too many items which are not available
- 13:20because of a regulation, point of view because of some form of
- 13:24ux that we can incorporate into the app.
- 13:26For example prescription drugs. Is there more than 25 percent of
- 13:30the sales of the store? It doesn't make sense for us to
- 13:33start with that store for a pilot.
- 13:36When were in the early stages of achieving Network effects in a
- 13:39single City because they're, we're constraining ourselves too
- 13:43much and try to fight for two smaller piece of the pie.
- 13:46So that's that's then the different criteria that forms in
- 13:49when you put these three together.
- 13:51Typically, you end up with convenience stores, grocery
- 13:54stores and fast fashion or fast accessori like Flying tiger or
- 14:00certain Cosmetics Brands. They will still fit within that
- 14:04first accessories label. Yeah, that makes sense something
- 14:08that's nice and clear criteria as well.
- 14:10But question, I've got for you is historically, there have been
- 14:14resistance among some offline teams, when embracing digital
- 14:17technology jet typically down to the fear of cells
- 14:19cannibalization. Why do if everything's going
- 14:21through an app? It's online?
- 14:24It's not going to count to my my retail sales.
- 14:28How If you helped, uh, clap because how, how does sales
- 14:31teams get rewarded for this? How does the data get back to
- 14:34back so that they have that visibility?
- 14:37Yeah that's the that's the key actually door that says in terms
- 14:40of lie in store operation what mothers while you look for other
- 14:44right stores you make sure technically that your correctly
- 14:47integrated. If the store stuff themselves
- 14:50don't want you to be successful. Then it's a really really steep
- 14:54uphill battle for you to be successful inside the store with
- 14:57the adoption of Technology, but it starts on the tech side
- 15:01actually. So whether recolors convinced on
- 15:03the value we bring in terms of reducing costs or Raising sales.
- 15:08The next question from their perspective is always about what
- 15:11does it take from my end to make this live inside the store first
- 15:15technically, right? And if that means that their
- 15:17technical teams have to do any work to change their
- 15:20infrastructure, this becomes really difficult, but this is
- 15:23what the sap and Microsoft Dynamics, and these type of
- 15:28brands have to deal with, but they're used to.
- 15:30And they're used to that 12-18 months cycle.
- 15:33There is hundreds, if not thousands of vendors out there
- 15:35who do the work for the ring. Taylor.
- 15:37And that's what they're used to, but a starter can operate that
- 15:40right for us. An ethos, we had to build for
- 15:44two and a half years ago. Is that we require the retailer
- 15:47to do no additional work. We plug into their existing
- 15:50systems. Whether that is the product
- 15:52catalog, the POS, they loyalty program the promotions and we do
- 15:58it so that they don't change any infrastructure.
- 16:00They look at us as an existing till except we're in the cloud
- 16:04but they send files to us. They do the same way they do
- 16:06today. There's and they receive files
- 16:08from us the same way they do from the others that way
- 16:11internally, even though it's an online sale, the payment is an
- 16:16online payment is recorded as an in-store transaction, right?
- 16:21So as a user, yes, you're paying with your credit debit card or
- 16:25apple pear, Google pay the way you would on an e-commerce
- 16:28website, but the sale is still recorded to the store.
- 16:32And that way, we can still record it to an individual sales
- 16:36person. If we Like when betting there,
- 16:39for example, their ID into a lanyard with a QR code, so there
- 16:44you can always track back the sale to where it originated
- 16:47from. You can also have the ability to
- 16:51go back and, and inside the store match the commission and
- 16:56the kpi of the staff, with what will be successful for mushy
- 17:00breaks. So, we spend a lot of time and
- 17:02effort inside the inside. Retailers compensation structure
- 17:09to understand. Okay?
- 17:11Are they compensated on Mac sales inside the store?
- 17:14So revenue is it max number of transactions is there max number
- 17:18of loyalty members signed up and then we try to align that with
- 17:22how we can help that kpi for the staff.
- 17:24So we spend time for them to to approve that once the
- 17:28transaction is done, then the scales are attributed to the
- 17:32correct store because inside that original QR code to onboard
- 17:35with mushy, pay you all So have the store ID.
- 17:38So as a user just to explain, once again, the the journey,
- 17:42like you walk into a store for example, mooji or flying tiger
- 17:46in London, any of their stores will have mushy pea, you will
- 17:49see a QR code that says, hey to skip the lights can hear or for
- 17:53scan. And ghosts can hear this has a
- 17:55QR code inside. This QR code.
- 17:57You have embedded, the store ID, so that you don't need to give
- 18:01any location when you scan it and the access to our web app.
- 18:05So you scan this as a There with your iPhone or Android and you
- 18:09will end up in Safari or Chrome straight on the scanner page,
- 18:13where you can start scanning items inside the store, you scan
- 18:16the item and you get name, price and name and price.
- 18:20At the very minimum. If there's any promotions, you
- 18:23will get it right there. If there are no promotions on
- 18:26the item, it will not show. So all this data comes to you
- 18:30live from the Retailer's system because we're pulling this
- 18:33today, we have more than 21 million items worth of data.
- 18:37Data or databases today when we pull this and we apply the
- 18:42promotions, we're applying it. Also through our own promo
- 18:44engine, which is calculating the logic to say.
- 18:47Okay, if you have these two items and this third one for a
- 18:51meal deal, for example, I'm be prompt you to do that as a user.
- 18:55When you add that item and you're ready to pay you go ahead
- 18:58and pay. So the payment goes typically
- 18:59through either the Retailer's own Gateway, like an idea and or
- 19:03a world spay or through gateways, that we hand over.
- 19:07The Legend on records, this is becoming more and more popular
- 19:10because again, the region has to do less work on there.
- 19:12And when we call process the transaction, yes, it's an econ
- 19:16transaction. But the money goes to the
- 19:19account that the store is transferring into.
- 19:21And the sale is recorded through what is something called the t
- 19:25log or costs law that we send into the retailer system into
- 19:29their physical store. So they will say that look in
- 19:31the store. For example, the Oxford Street
- 19:33store just had a sale were ten pounds and still went Uma.
- 19:37She pay. So they know what to expect the
- 19:39money through that different process.
- 19:43What is amply ants? In a word, it's Freedom, the
- 19:47freedom to build a digital experience as Limitless as your
- 19:50vision create preview schedule, and manage.
- 19:54All your content in one easy place.
- 19:57Find out more at a lien. Start calm and plants experience
- 20:02freedom. Great.
- 20:06So that was very detailed answer so I'll I'll ask the next
- 20:09question. So at the start of that answer
- 20:15you mentioned that you typically try and kind of Leverage
- 20:19existing Integrations. Not imagine POS is going to be
- 20:22your most common starting point in terms of kind of stock feeds
- 20:27and everything else would you ever do kind of additional Dev
- 20:31to allow for things like endless aisle or kind of All
- 20:35functionality as well. Yes, it makes a lot of sense to
- 20:38us after we're successful with, get involved because see the,
- 20:44the Gap in the market, which is just a general view, right of
- 20:48physical storm. Is, there is a big difference
- 20:52between the capability of the current POS at most retailers,
- 20:57and they demand of the customer experience from the user.
- 21:01There's a big gap between this in what the users are.
- 21:04Landing inside the store, the discovery of items, the easy
- 21:08checkout, better connections to their, you know, to to payment
- 21:14methods. They want to use all nights.
- 21:15The ability to have more loyalty and points through that.
- 21:19All these things, when you try to build it with the traditional
- 21:23POS, which does not have an innate capability to do that
- 21:26you're talking about years of time and millions of dollars
- 21:30that these retailers have to spend.
- 21:32Okay, it's extremely expensive and very Time-consuming.
- 21:36And the worst part is that it may still not be enough when
- 21:38they come to the end of that project, but useless demands
- 21:41have evolved, right? By that point because this is an
- 21:44evolving customer experience. Inside the stores.
- 21:47You can say that, you know what, we've built this, it took us
- 21:50three years. The user is still where they
- 21:51were three years ago, that's not really true.
- 21:54So what you need is something that can move quick and still
- 21:56adopt and evolved to what the user wants.
- 22:01And we believe that we are, we can do that because we're mobile
- 22:04first. First, you know, web as well as
- 22:07IOS and Android we can change ourselves as needed.
- 22:10So our pitch to The retailer is really that you start with
- 22:13scanning go. It's the easy win that you can
- 22:15get the low-hanging fruit. We plug into your systems in
- 22:19just two weeks and when you start within the first three
- 22:22months, you should see 10 to 15 percent of your store,
- 22:25transferring over to paying with their own device after that,
- 22:29once we achieve that, then yes, the next step is to for us to
- 22:32try to take over near 100% of the Actions.
- 22:35So that we can effectively be the front end of the store and
- 22:39use the retailer still uses their own POS as backend for the
- 22:45inventory, management, promotion, creation accounts
- 22:48type functions. They could either use an Erp or
- 22:51they could use parts of their POS because it's good for that,
- 22:54it's good for back office, but we are good for the front end of
- 22:58the store and the applications that we would go to the very
- 23:02next one. After scan and go is our own
- 23:04Asian of the self-checkout kiosk, this is a very
- 23:07minimalistic kiosk on built on an Android tablet with the
- 23:10scanner. So it uses the users existing
- 23:14behavioral training that they've had for the last 10, 15 years
- 23:18seeing this technology in their groceries.
- 23:21So they gravitate towards it automatically, they start
- 23:23scanning and paying with it at the end, we give them an option
- 23:26to transfer the musket to scan and go for a discount.
- 23:30So again, it acts as a user acquisition Channel, or they can
- 23:33finish the transaction there on its own.
- 23:35This probably gets us another 60 55 to 60% of the transactions
- 23:41inside the store. So now we're really touching
- 23:43that point of being 7075 percent.
- 23:46And for the remaining, then by adding further use cases like,
- 23:50you know, endless aisle. You mention, we've already
- 23:52launched that we did a pilot in France with Emma SLI.
- 23:57You know, the the mattress company.
- 24:00They launched the first pop-up that they ever had in Paris in
- 24:04end of April beginning of May and Mississippi was the primary
- 24:07way to pay inside the store because they didn't go with a
- 24:10traditional POS, they went with us.
- 24:12Whether user came in, they scan mattresses and when they were
- 24:16ready at the end, they pay if they paid with Apple or Google
- 24:19Play. We took their home address from
- 24:21inside that and just fulfill sanity fulfillment to the a
- 24:26sleep service and where they paid with his card.
- 24:30They have to just enter the address details, but
- 24:32effectively, that endless aisle could be put You to one of our
- 24:35existing stores which already has scanning go as an additional
- 24:39method when your basket goes over a certain price for
- 24:42example, or if you're willing to pay for it separately, then we
- 24:47have click and collect, which we've done for Meucci and
- 24:50London, as well as lots of coffee shops around Soho and
- 24:54Covent Garden where the user can order a head for the coffee and
- 24:57then go pick up. Now, we don't want to just do
- 25:00this business on its own. It's a, it's a crowded space and
- 25:04there's Many players but as in addition to scan and go as an
- 25:08add-on for our users, it makes a lot of sense because they just
- 25:12gone to a store, will help them skip the line so they trust us
- 25:15and they like what they've just done with the application, then
- 25:18they're more likely to do other transactions with the same
- 25:21application, if even if that is at their coffee shop.
- 25:25And of course, is that is at the grocery or if that's at the
- 25:28online retailers, they're like to buy from.
- 25:30So we're simply leveraging that first user acquisition that
- 25:33we've already thought. And the Action with that user of
- 25:36coping, and skip the line and save time, right?
- 25:39And then, so you state that the ROI within three months for each
- 25:44client is between 14 and 35 percent increase in Revenue via
- 25:50the app versus Tails. And obviously, you've talked
- 25:52about a few different ways that you kind of add value compared
- 25:56to a traditional transaction by or tell, how do you measure the
- 26:00incrementality of this. Yeah, that's the main question.
- 26:04Sure. So you're saying that how do we
- 26:09know that that increase in sales is us and it's not just you
- 26:14know, an increase in general in the store.
- 26:16It's not just because the more expensive baskets have moved to
- 26:19Michigan, is that correct? Yeah.
- 26:21I guess and yeah and oversee those different variables and
- 26:24things and it is something that you report back on as well.
- 26:28Yeah, yeah. Because remember our weird be
- 26:31our case studies that you see online with, you know, mooji
- 26:34seeing a 5% increase in the sales in basket value.
- 26:38Sorry Flying Tigers in 35% increase in basket value.
- 26:42Eros, kissing 14 percent increase in per user Revenue.
- 26:46All of these name, the Retailer's, right?
- 26:49So they're publicly corroborated by the retailer saying, yes, we
- 26:53have got this increased so that requires them to be completely
- 26:57agreeing with what we're saying, right?
- 26:59And we've had to prove ourselves.
- 27:00So we've done all that research and Analysis analysis on Each of
- 27:06those case studies to say that this is in fact that go to the
- 27:09highest possible degree confirm that this is from missha pay and
- 27:13I'll explain how that it's first.
- 27:15Have to understand the nuances of the of the type of increase
- 27:19in suppose there's three different types, right?
- 27:21The first one is the increase in sales from removing abandoned
- 27:25baskets. This typically happens at
- 27:28convenience stores and Convenience Store.
- 27:32The store is on the way to somewhere.
- 27:34It's not your destiny. Nation, right?
- 27:36So you're on the way to catch a flight.
- 27:38They're on the way to catch a train, you're filling up your
- 27:41gas when you're on the, on your travels.
- 27:44And then you have a store at this store, you're having a much
- 27:48higher propensity to abandon the basket because the item is not
- 27:52actually something you can there to buy in particular, right?
- 27:56You're on the way somewhere. So you're not going to miss your
- 27:58flight for the sake of the Coke, or the Red Bull, or the water.
- 28:03And your customers, very likely to abandon the basket and they
- 28:07clearly lose somewhere between five to seven percent of the
- 28:10sales due to this abandoned basket problem.
- 28:14Here we have been able to A/B test and show that on days with
- 28:19similar traffic and similar number of sales.
- 28:23When we push mushy, pea versus when we don't push me sugar,
- 28:26there's typically a 75 to 80 percent reduction in the
- 28:31abandoned. Baskets.
- 28:32When you do push mushy, Pea in particular, in a store that we
- 28:36just induce towards we tested this app at two different
- 28:39airports. We saw that the abandoned
- 28:41baskets came down from about 18 a day to about two to four a
- 28:46day. When we did not push mushy pea
- 28:49versus when we pushed me she takes.
- 28:50So that's a clear increase in sales because those are sales
- 28:53the store would have completely lost without us.
- 28:56Yeah, that sounds we can show that they can be proven at the
- 29:00grocery store. It's different at the grocery
- 29:02Toward the increase in sales is through the user coming back
- 29:05more often. This is because normally, when
- 29:09you're going to your grocery, you're going between two to four
- 29:11times a month. Sometimes even more often your
- 29:15your timing yourself so that you don't end up going at the high
- 29:18peak tabs. So that you don't end up going
- 29:21when you just want to buy a small piece you know a milk for
- 29:25example and you won't end up going at the peak time because
- 29:28you know you'll get stuck. What's happening with Mischief?
- 29:31Here is the users no longer afraid, they're going in
- 29:34whenever they want for whatever type of purchase because they
- 29:38know they'll be in and out in the same amount of time and
- 29:41yourofsky the third largest grocery in Spain was able to see
- 29:45this because they could see that.
- 29:46Okay, to users, let's say Paul and James who have their loyalty
- 29:51part so they know exactly how many times they come and what
- 29:54they buy they could see that these two users used to come
- 29:56three times a month and by 100 euros worth of goods.
- 30:00Now one of them has moved over to Mischief a that person is
- 30:04coming four times a month and 114 euros worth.
- 30:08Whereas James is still that say just coming three times, I want
- 30:11them by hundred years with but not using the shipping and they
- 30:14were able to see this clearly as a trend across hundreds of
- 30:17users, each of whom had a loyalty card, so they could
- 30:20clearly test weight and without mushy pea and they saw that net
- 30:24increase of 14 percent in per user Revenue, due to users
- 30:28coming back more often. And then the final one that you
- 30:31are talking about the Flying Tiger 135 percent increase in
- 30:35basket value or mooji, 25%, the reason is because of the
- 30:40engagement in the app because you see the promotions because
- 30:43you spend more time in the in the right areas of the store.
- 30:46But also because your total time inside the store as a percentage
- 30:50is much more higher productivity, right?
- 30:53You don't spend any time, checking out.
- 30:55So all that time inspector shopping, it has an immediate
- 30:58impact of busted value but the We confirm that is true
- 31:01like-for-like analysis. So we say, let's take two
- 31:04stores, one with mushy pay one without, right?
- 31:07We see what against let's say the month of June, how they both
- 31:11have perform, We compare that to the month of May and then we
- 31:15take a comparable year, let's say for any 19 and we compare
- 31:18May and June. So 2019.
- 31:20None of those stores had mushy Bay.
- 31:22We compare their neighbors, their tune in 2022.
- 31:26One of them has mushy Pea from June onwards.
- 31:29And did not. Not in May and we compare their
- 31:31May and June for both the source.
- 31:33So that may be any difference. In the impact is what we would
- 31:37see because if you have both the stores, having a difference of,
- 31:40let's say 10 percent between them in 2019.
- 31:43If the difference in 2022, is 15% from 10% that increase in
- 31:48five percent is, what is attributable to Michigan.
- 31:51That's one way of looking. At the second way is that when
- 31:55there's an increase in basket value, we provide received it
- 31:58corresponds to the penetration, Time the store so easily a
- 32:01temptation of the transactions and we have a 25% increase in
- 32:05basket value. It should roughly be a 2.5
- 32:08percent increase in the store sales overall and we look for
- 32:11that as well. So only when all these markers
- 32:13are confirmed to be put on the case study like that now fly
- 32:18high enough. I'm sorry taste out.
- 32:21So I have one sub question that was more just something that I
- 32:25wanted to know the answer to out of Interest.
- 32:27How do you typically work for my kind of price?
- 32:30Ting modern perspective. Is it based on kind of number of
- 32:33transactions? Is it flat fee is incremental a?
- 32:37Yeah, how do you typically charge your customers?
- 32:42Yeah, this is business had a few changes over the years.
- 32:46I can give you a general view of it.
- 32:49I cannot mention very specific numbers because it is a little
- 32:53bit sensitive in terms of the data.
- 32:55But the first piece is an is an integration.
- 32:59See, this is just at cost for what it costs us to make a new
- 33:03retailer. Go live, right?
- 33:04That two weeks worth of effort or end.
- 33:07We almost always charge the retailer, some time, going to
- 33:11integration fee. Depending on the complexity of
- 33:14the Integrations. This one is is typically small.
- 33:18You're talking about, you know, tens of thousands of pounds of
- 33:21the at the lower end. So the lower lower five-digit
- 33:26level of thing, you know involves but then the running
- 33:32phase. The actual long-term face-first
- 33:34or are between subscription and transactions, right?
- 33:39A subscription fees, typically purse or per month.
- 33:42And a transaction fee is a percentage on every transaction
- 33:45and the way to think of it is almost like on a seesaw on one
- 33:48and you have all subscription and zero percent transaction on
- 33:53the other end. You have high transaction fee
- 33:56and zero subscription. Our preference is together a
- 33:59terror somewhere in the middle with the small subscription fee.
- 34:02A couple hundred pounds per store per month as well as a
- 34:06small transaction fee. Something like 1 to 2 percent
- 34:08per transaction. But if this if Most retailers
- 34:13actually go over the extremes because smaller retailers would
- 34:16prefer to take your transaction and not pay subscription and
- 34:20larger retailers with large storage States, prefer to pay
- 34:24all on the subscription site because they don't want to have
- 34:28any kind of Revenue share. And they know that when this
- 34:30becomes a big part of their stores, transaction, that is
- 34:33actually a much higher fees event.
- 34:35So really, it's a, it's a fight between those two these days
- 34:38ago, almost always, we have some element of such Description, add
- 34:43some element of a transaction of promissory tell.
- 34:45It's just the size of it that changes, because our power in
- 34:49the negotiations is increasing. Give it our scale and size that
- 34:52is destroyed. I have.
- 34:56Is that the Falcons? The question enough for you to
- 34:59be able to get a review of seconds.
- 35:02Yep, absolutely. Just wanted to bring bring the
- 35:05question background in the integration stuff because you
- 35:07talked about the the fact that you integrate your back-end
- 35:09systems Cerritos. Don't need to put additional
- 35:12Hardware, which obviously is a stock stock movement is always
- 35:16challenged retailers. Have known how much time they've
- 35:18got not overselling because somebody could be physically
- 35:23picking up an item in the store for a customer versus a
- 35:26customer's going and picking items up.
- 35:28So how do you handle that piece? So, how what point is the store
- 35:33stock fold deprecated? Is it a point of purchase is it
- 35:36when they create a basket in Mission Bay?
- 35:38How does that piece work? Whenever they're each other
- 35:41ones, there's the answer, right? The first our capabilities to do
- 35:45it in real time. Every time you see a transaction
- 35:48of mushy pea, we update the retailer system.
- 35:51This is what we want to do, but unfortunately, a lot of
- 35:54retailers. Have the capability to accept
- 35:57files in that speed, right? Or that number during the day.
- 36:01So the, the Spectrum would go from that level, which is
- 36:05real-time every transaction. We update them immediately all
- 36:09the way to once a day, which is the most common one right in the
- 36:13middle, you have some retail to prefer 15 million patches one,
- 36:17our Bachelors, if they can take it.
- 36:19So it really is about the capability of the system into
- 36:22which we send this data. We typically send it.
- 36:25Via sstp something called a boss Lor t.
- 36:28Log in the US as the mentioned before, which contains the Full
- 36:32Sail from missha based perspective.
- 36:34So the skills that we've sold the store, I need the tax
- 36:38calculations. The total basket value as well
- 36:40as the stock units that are sold and we send that to the
- 36:44Retailer's system. So it's attributed to the
- 36:47correct store. The sales are recorded
- 36:49correctly, commissions are recorded correctly and the stock
- 36:52is updated but for them. They need to be able to accept
- 36:57this promise in real time if they want to update it real
- 36:59times. What you will see typically is
- 37:01retailers with a lot of buy online, pick up in store, orders
- 37:05or click and collect, fulfill from the store orders.
- 37:08They will have the capacity to accept this in real time because
- 37:12they've had to build it for themselves in generally.
- 37:14So there we send it no very often or in real time.
- 37:19But those retailers who don't have a lot of clicking collect
- 37:22orders, who don't have a lot of And pick up and store order,
- 37:26they would not have yet. Built out this capability
- 37:30traditionally, unless they've got a new age Erp like a
- 37:34Dynamics 365 or something like that, then okay, they have the
- 37:37capability, but they're not using it.
- 37:39But in most cases, if they've got the capability is because
- 37:42they had to build it for other applications and we can then
- 37:45reuse. Yeah, I think that was used to
- 37:47solve things about you Roy. They were people online, click
- 37:50clack to or Biollante, and store, where they could have.
- 37:54They could have an intact. Stock.
- 37:55But if they're not taking regular updates and how do you
- 37:59promote a point of view tool? SFTP are there other mechanisms
- 38:02and you have an open API. How can people with existing
- 38:05systems plug in and grab that data?
- 38:08Yeah, really typically just on a broad level, it would be file
- 38:12transfer or API? Wait, those are the to do with
- 38:15in which we would exchange the types of files, you know, range
- 38:20from XML Json to CSV dog, deity, whatever the retailer.
- 38:25He's using again, we don't ask them to make any changes here,
- 38:28the same format of their file. The same data that's inside
- 38:31their file that they use for the POS they use for us that way
- 38:34there's you know, bulky heavy lifting is on our side.
- 38:37In terms of interpreting what those files are saying,
- 38:40converting the format to something our systems understand
- 38:43and then sending it back in the format that they wanted.
- 38:46So we do all that work for them. But yeah typically its file
- 38:49transfer over SFTP or really any other protocol.
- 38:53The retailer wants to use we Had a few other types of systems.
- 38:57Sometimes you do we have to be part of a, VPN to be able to
- 39:01send and receive some of these files.
- 39:03Otherwise we set up our system for them to send and receive
- 39:06from there. And then in the case of been a
- 39:09pi, you know, we we just call the information when we need it
- 39:13that way. We don't have a lot of storage
- 39:15that we keep, but unfortunately not a lot of retailers systems
- 39:20have apis capable of what we need.
- 39:22Because if you think about it, inside the mushy pea, Bab you're
- 39:26calling the product details so many times, right?
- 39:28You're typically calling a product API like 10, 15 times
- 39:32because you add items, you take out items.
- 39:34It's not like at the cash register where you're all ready
- 39:37to go to fix basket, right? You're scanning everything in
- 39:40there, then there's promotions. That's what we had to build our
- 39:43own promo engine because with one transaction on Bishop a, you
- 39:47typically called the promoter Region 5 to 10 times because
- 39:50you're adding an item, we update the promotions that are
- 39:53available, not just better apply That are available to be applied
- 39:57or that are applied. Then you change the quantity, we
- 40:00recalculate, you add a new item. We recalculate, you take out an
- 40:03item. We recalculate at the till
- 40:05that's not. What's happening at all?
- 40:08Your items, remove whatever you want, and then they calculated
- 40:11once or twice at most per transaction.
- 40:14So again, there are the capability required here is much
- 40:17higher in terms of what we do, and how about returns because
- 40:21that returns is always a challenge from a process and A
- 40:25technology wise for omni-channel retailers.
- 40:28How good you've got that? The scanner going.
- 40:30You've got purchased going through your app but most people
- 40:33will return an item to the store physically, but they might send
- 40:37it through an online portal. How do you close the loop on
- 40:40that? So that they're all of these
- 40:42systems are think to have like order status is, I recommend a
- 40:46little ways to build a refund on them issue being dashboard.
- 40:51This is the staff based application that we Add, which
- 40:55is like a back office on which they can see in real-time all
- 40:59the transactions being done inside the store, they can
- 41:03University analytics of which users on which platforms have
- 41:07made those transactions, which type of payment methods and
- 41:09venues they can use it for scanning the QR at the end of
- 41:12The Journey for verification and security against test and they
- 41:16can use it for refunds. And when they use it for
- 41:20refunds, that we will ensure the money goes back at exactly the
- 41:23same payment method. The real, the user use, we
- 41:27update the in a perceived as well as sending back the
- 41:30possible for a refund to the retailer.
- 41:32So, when you do it from the dashboard, everything is
- 41:34synchronized. Now some some retailers do not
- 41:37want to call it that. So they may do a refund on their
- 41:40traditional POS at a different payment method than the one that
- 41:44you use for pain. And then we have to be in form
- 41:47separately or they made to the refund at the POS.
- 41:51But we still refund the actual money.
- 41:53So at the POS they simply Record that you send back your item
- 41:57they do they're checking as they would in the role normal
- 42:00procedure and then they inform us that XYZ items out of this
- 42:04basket have been refunded so that we go to that basket and
- 42:08actually just read from those items.
- 42:12But because we're sending the worst logs, everything
- 42:15synchronized into their own POS. Let's save the frequency.
- 42:18Is once a day within 24 hours of your purchase, your transaction
- 42:23is on their tail as well. So, if they want, they can do
- 42:26their same traditional paper written procedure or they can
- 42:31actually choose to return with mashita, which is much cleaner
- 42:34and much more synchronized into their systems.
- 42:42And last question this has been a really interesting episode and
- 42:47yeah, I think there's a lot more to this than I thought.
- 42:49Maybe for the start, the episode, definitely lots of good
- 42:53stuff. And I guess, where, where do you
- 42:56intend to go next? I guess the pandemics probably
- 43:00been quite interesting from like an adoption perspective.
- 43:03Lots of new features, Etc. And what are you looking to do
- 43:07next? What else you looking to build
- 43:08into the product whilst on your road map?
- 43:12Yeah, the been doing has been really a hero up and down for us
- 43:15in terms of adoption, as well as business success.
- 43:19Because, you know, times, when all the stores were closed where
- 43:23were really tough and scary times, you know, because we had
- 43:26a lot of retailers, not, not a lot of growth story, right?
- 43:30We were still just starting out with the first few grocery
- 43:33retailer, so their souls were completely closed During certain
- 43:36points of the pandemic, and that was not easy, but what was
- 43:39really good When they reopen, we had retailer signing like never
- 43:44before, right? So we made it out of the
- 43:46pandemic, net positive. Like, I think from March, 22,
- 43:51March 21. We were up like three to
- 43:55three-and-a-half facts on our business and then March 21 to
- 43:59March 22. We're up again by, you know,
- 44:02another trading effect. So we have eventually been made
- 44:05it very well through the pandemic, but it did take a lot
- 44:08of effort to get there. R.
- 44:11I think the user side of the adoption, though has also seen a
- 44:15big increase that across the board.
- 44:18We're seeing almost every weekend report is some form of
- 44:21self-checkout, right? You're seeing this with fashion
- 44:25retailers are Uniqlo. H&M also starting self-checkout
- 44:29kiosks based systems, right? The same as what we were seeing
- 44:32in the groceries. We thought they would never come
- 44:34to Fashion. All I think universally every
- 44:37fast fashion retailer. We've spoken to a thinking about
- 44:40So I think that it's also had that shift because the users are
- 44:44ready to use these inside the store, they're becoming more and
- 44:47more you know accepting of these methods you do you go to a
- 44:52McDonald's today and most of the time there's no one at the cash
- 44:55register. Everyone has to make the order
- 44:58to the chaos, right? You same thing.
- 45:01When you, when you go to a test course in space, now there's
- 45:05very few times that someone is going to the actual, you know,
- 45:09cash register with a human. Behind it just because they use
- 45:13a degree tell supposed to their across all the other markets as
- 45:17well. They're considering this option
- 45:18now and the waiter thinking about it is on a spectrum.
- 45:22On one end of the spectrum, you have the traditional subset of
- 45:25chaos. On the other end, you have the
- 45:27computer vision Amazon goes time, right?
- 45:31We are in the Middle with mushy pay.
- 45:33When you compare these three on aspects of capex of pécs
- 45:38reliability scalability. Value generated in terms of
- 45:43reducing cost increase in sales. And finally the ux for the user
- 45:48you see that, you know the the kiosk have some great benefit in
- 45:51terms of reducing costs super reliable for what they do for
- 45:54you but users hate using them and their big capex.
- 45:58The computer vision is extremely expensive, capex or objects but
- 46:02the users love using them. However, there still unproven at
- 46:06scale and still not so reliable. So when you come down to
- 46:09mistreat a we've been in hundreds of stores, we prove it
- 46:12or increase in sale as well as reduction in cost combat
- 46:14capability, very easy and cheap to start within reasonable to
- 46:19run as an Opex but also where our user MPS is over. 75 users
- 46:24love to use us. We see that this ability to scan
- 46:28and go is probably what is most impactful most effective for the
- 46:33broader swath of the market because we are practical yet
- 46:37effective. The next stage though will be
- 46:40about the the kinds of vendors and the systems which can take
- 46:46over nearly all the transactions inside the store.
- 46:49Because if you stick to just one just the ability to scan in go,
- 46:53then you will still miss out the the kiosk customers, you will
- 46:56still miss out endless aisle. You will still miss out.
- 46:58Clicking collects. You will have to find a way to
- 47:01cover all. But start somewhere start with a
- 47:04with a clear practical yet, impactful area, which is what
- 47:07we're doing with. And go.
- 47:08And I think this will be a trend that continues.
- 47:10You will see more and more fashion, retailers reduce the
- 47:14number of cash registers, and either bring in self-checkout
- 47:16kiosk or bring a scan and go like us or a mixture of both.
- 47:21Like we are doing at Flying Tiger ourselves and and we are
- 47:24soon to do a true G as well. So, you know, we know that that
- 47:28this will come as a way to reduce the Reliance on the man
- 47:31cash register and the ice for retailers were also opened when
- 47:36they had to let go of so many stuff and Now, almost
- 47:39universally that struggling with rehiring, the stuff even higher
- 47:42salaries than they were offering before.
- 47:44They're just not able to get the same number of stuff to come
- 47:47back. Yeah, I think that is a common
- 47:50problem of seeing some more clients, the recruiting the
- 47:53right caliber, right level of people quickly enough but it's
- 47:56interesting about the kiosk is there's a real cultural shift
- 47:59that's required. People are very used to shopping
- 48:03with a person at a deal point but you're right.
- 48:06The food played mean, I shopped in Lyon restaurants and they
- 48:09shifted to the self-service kiosks and and initiates about
- 48:12all hanging them in it and you have to get just but it makes
- 48:15sense because then they focus people on the serving and
- 48:18speeding. That's a you don't wait as long
- 48:22so interested and myself. I look really, really enjoyed
- 48:26this. There's the as Paul said there's
- 48:27some elements of of the product and understood learn more about
- 48:31this great. I'm sure our listeners will love
- 48:34would learn a lot about, you know, where it's relevant and
- 48:36what it's doing. If people want to learn more
- 48:39have got any specific technical questions.
- 48:40How do they reach out? They can just read out on this
- 48:44ship, a.com or if they want to reach out to me on me
- 48:48specifically and I just must have heard me to bid on cam.
- 48:51And again they can send me an email but of course they can
- 48:54also find the team's email there on Michigan.com with this is go
- 48:58to our website or any of our social channels, LinkedIn
- 49:01Instagram Twitter, they can reach out to us there as well.
- 49:05And thanks to everyone for listening.
- 49:09As always, we hope you found it interesting episode to keep an
- 49:12eye on Any route to the next one?
- 49:13We learned them every Tuesday. Do subscribe, to get weekly
- 49:17alerts. And we'd love a Rachel apples
- 49:18Spotify or YouTube take care of buddy, see you soon more
- 49:28information on this topic, head over to re-platform dot.
- 49:31F m, for our audio podcasts to discuss a project or if you like
- 49:34to chat about any of the topics covered in this episode in more
- 49:37detail. Please reach out to myself,
- 49:39James guard, and my co-host, pull Rogers, via LinkedIn and
- 49:41Twitter. Thanks again for listening and
- 49:43keep your ears peeled for the next episode.