Latest / I Love You Keep Going with George Haas / Intentional Positivity
Transcript
- 0:01You're listening to the I Love You Keep Going podcast with
- 0:04George Haas. For more information, please
- 0:06visit our website at www.metigroup.org.
- 0:10That's www.me Tta GROU p.org. So welcome everybody.
- 0:21This is I love you. Keep going.
- 0:22It is July 20th. 2023, It's 7:37 PM Pacific Daylight Time, and I
- 0:34thought that what I wanted to talk about tonight was
- 0:36intentional positivity. That occurred to me that that
- 0:40would be something and that is useful to consider and then also
- 0:49to practice. It really is a focus on the
- 0:52Divine abodes, as the way of cultivating that.
- 0:58One of the things that happens to us is that we develop these
- 1:01working models of ourselves and we develop these working models
- 1:04of the world. And depending on the
- 1:07circumstances of your early conditioning, you can create
- 1:12these patterns of of activations that are.
- 1:18Biased in the direction of negativity or biased in the
- 1:22direction of positivity in each moment.
- 1:27The way that we create the experience of self and world is
- 1:30by activating these working models.
- 1:32And what these working models really are about is these gists.
- 1:43Gists. Are these like little algorithms
- 1:46that activate? That create experience.
- 1:51When we make the gist in the beginning, we take in through
- 1:56the sensing experiences that we're having, the elements that
- 2:01we usually work with, the touching experience, the seeing
- 2:05experience, the hearing experience, the tasting
- 2:07experience, the smelling experience and mind, which of
- 2:11course collects all of these things.
- 2:14We develop a a preference for things that we like and things
- 2:18that we don't like. And so when we scan the
- 2:20environment, we tend to focus on the things that we like and
- 2:24avoid the things that we don't like.
- 2:26So we have these highly curated experiences of the collection of
- 2:31what's actually happening, and then we create conceptual
- 2:38reality from that highly curated selection of mind moments.
- 2:46Once we have the experience in consciousness, it's held in
- 2:50short term memory for a period of time, maybe 10 or 12 minutes.
- 2:55And then if it read, if it has a threshold of interest in a
- 2:59threshold of emotional intensity, it's translated from
- 3:03short term memory into long term memory, which is actually the
- 3:07creation of these gists, and then the gists are associated
- 3:13with. Experiences or I like to call
- 3:17the memory threads the gists activate and the way that they
- 3:25create experiences by causing a replay of this, the patterns and
- 3:33that the sense gates originally collected that making sense so
- 3:37far. Why this is an interesting thing
- 3:43is because if you created a memory in your five year old
- 3:48sensing recorder and you're now in a 40 year old or a 60 year
- 3:53old body, you can't actually play with any accuracy the gist
- 4:01that creates these memory experiences because you don't
- 4:05have the equipment to play them anymore.
- 4:08That making sense? So if you have a 5 year old
- 4:11memory, it was created in a 5 year old body with a 5 year old
- 4:16sensing apparatus and also the cognitive capacity of a 5 year
- 4:20old body. And interpreting it was created
- 4:23into a gist which is really pretty stable.
- 4:26And so when you activate that, now, you're playing it in the
- 4:30body that you have now with all of the sensing capacities now,
- 4:34but also the cognitive capacity to interpret that experience.
- 4:40If that remembering of that or that activation of the gist
- 4:44creates a memorable experience, that is to say an experience
- 4:49that has a high enough emotional content with it to make it
- 4:52across the bridge between short term memory and long term
- 4:56memory, then it's re remembered. And so that just then plays not
- 5:03only with the original data that was in court encoded.
- 5:08But every time you replay the memory and it's remembered
- 5:12again, Have you ever, when you were a kid, discovered a copy
- 5:18machine and then copied a copy, and then copied a copy, then
- 5:22copied a copy and then copied a copy, it gets further and
- 5:32further away from what actually happened and what was the actual
- 5:36cause of the. Just from being created in the
- 5:401st place. Also understand that we don't
- 5:43have a video recorder in the mind that collects all of the
- 5:46data and and preserves it for us.
- 5:50We really have these highly curated sensing experiences, and
- 5:55what we remember out of that is not what happens, but what it
- 6:00means to us and then when we remember what it means to us.
- 6:05We include in the the memory, the experience of remembering
- 6:11it, So what it meant to us when we remember it again.
- 6:16And so you have these rather complex gists that are then
- 6:21associated with different kinds of experience that all making
- 6:25sense so far. Because it takes strong emotion
- 6:31to create these gists in the 1st place, and we tend to be biased
- 6:35toward urgent or dangerous experience a lot of times, we
- 6:42can create gists that have a negative bias to them.
- 6:47And in our creation of these more complex working models of
- 6:52experience that are loaded with all all of these different
- 6:55experiences, the sense of self. Being the one that I'm really
- 7:00concerned with here, the sense of self arises and we know that
- 7:05it's our experience of self because of all of the
- 7:09activations of gists that create a pattern of experience that we
- 7:13we have identified as the experience of self makes sense
- 7:23if you grow up in adverse childhood conditions where there
- 7:26was a lot of difficulty. Then a lot of the associations
- 7:30that you make to the activation of the sense of self are going
- 7:33to be difficult. And if there is a enough of a
- 7:39lopsidedness on the negative side of things when the sense of
- 7:43self arises and is activated by circumstances, then you can have
- 7:52an adversive experience of the self arising.
- 7:57There isn't that much you can do to prevent the self arising.
- 8:01It's usually a reduction of stimulation.
- 8:04So you withdraw more and more from active stimulation if you
- 8:08have an adverse experience of self over and over again.
- 8:13But that adverse experience of self can harden into what we
- 8:20call in the West, self hatred. But really what that is, is this
- 8:24activation of the experience of self, which is largely negative,
- 8:27that we become averse to having the experience of.
- 8:32Then we cascade into this hard, aversive response to the
- 8:39experience of who we are. Now, mind you, when we create
- 8:45these working models of self, we're not creating them through
- 8:48our direct experience of ourselves.
- 8:50We're creating them through the reflection of the caregiver.
- 8:54So we are spontaneous. We're without really limits.
- 8:59We express that activity of ourselves.
- 9:03And then the sensitive enough caregiver hopefully takes that
- 9:07in, interprets it for us, reflects it back to us with a
- 9:11sense of delight so that we delight in the sense of who we
- 9:15are. We delight in our capacities and
- 9:17the things that we find. Interesting in the way that we
- 9:20relate and then they also provide a way of of providing,
- 9:26they also provide the care that we need so that we can respond
- 9:32to the experiences of life that we're having and in this secure
- 9:38loop we express ourselves are sensitive of caregiver.
- 9:43Interprets it, reflects it back to us with a sense of delight,
- 9:47and then takes care of us in the way that we need so that we have
- 9:50a sense of safety about ourselves, our demands of the
- 9:55world, and also the world itself.
- 9:59But if you don't have those experiences and something else
- 10:09happens. Let's say you're a colicky baby
- 10:12and you overwhelm the capacity of your caregiver to take care
- 10:15of you. And instead of reflecting back
- 10:18to you the the, the challenges as a delightful experience, they
- 10:24reflect back at at you an aversion to it or a sense that
- 10:28you're difficult or overly demanding.
- 10:30And that builds up over time and we begin to create these working
- 10:35models of ourselves where we are demanding or a burden.
- 10:41Difficult. This doesn't mean that all
- 10:46people would have responded to us that way just in the
- 10:49circumstances of our childhood. Our caregiver in those moments,
- 10:53responded in that way, and at the different ages of that young
- 10:59beingness we, as we are creating for the first time the working
- 11:04model of ourselves we embed into.
- 11:09Ourselves, the sense of who we are based on that reflection,
- 11:15that making sense. And then each time the sense of
- 11:19self arises, that working model activates and activates all of
- 11:23these little gists so that we create this pattern of sensing
- 11:26experience that we then recognize as the self
- 11:31experience. And if you don't have the
- 11:34insight into the nature of these processes.
- 11:38You can actually believe that that's an accurate
- 11:40representation of yourself, even if it isn't what's accurate,
- 11:46because it isn't an accurate experience that we have.
- 11:51It's an experience of what it means to us, that making sense.
- 12:00So what we want to do in this practice is begin to evaluate
- 12:05whether or not the working model that we have of ourselves is an
- 12:08actual is an accurate reflection of who we are and what our
- 12:13capacities are, and that we're not limiting ourselves in by
- 12:20believing in the solidness of the self experiences and
- 12:25unchanging, fixated things. We would call that.
- 12:31Fixed views or self limiting beliefs.
- 12:39But you can't actually just make an intellectual decision about
- 12:43the nature of the conditioning of the self experience, because
- 12:47it does arise in each moment and it does activate these patterns
- 12:51of experience that then create the self experience interacting
- 12:57with the environment. That we experience, but we have
- 13:02to do instead is begin to evaluate the balance of positive
- 13:07and negative States and then intentionally associate positive
- 13:13states with our sense of self and then also intentionally
- 13:18associate positive states with the people that that form our
- 13:24experience of the world and Buddhists.
- 13:29Cosmology, self and world means self and the other people that
- 13:33you engage in your life that making sense?
- 13:41Did you have a question, Edward? No, it's all making sense.
- 13:51So in the meta, a positive way of practicing the the positive
- 13:55side or the inside side is pulling apart all of this stuff
- 14:01so that we can see what is actually happening moment by
- 14:04moment. And then on the meta side or the
- 14:07heart side, the divine abode side, intentionally generating
- 14:12positive states that we then can associate with ourselves and
- 14:16also with the other people that we know and interact with.
- 14:24And depending on how lopsided you currently are in terms of
- 14:28the negative side as opposed to the positive side, it might be
- 14:31quite a lot of work to begin to adjust that balance and push it
- 14:35over into the positive side. It isn't so much an elimination
- 14:40of the negative side that is the fix.
- 14:45You have to also do the development of the positive
- 14:50side. That making sense?
- 14:54So then we engage in these practices in the loving kindness
- 14:59practice. The.
- 15:05What we're doing is developing an antidote to the experience
- 15:12of. We pull this up by thinking
- 15:17about this and trying to create a.
- 15:20The definition of this, that's accurate.
- 15:22Enough the. Far enemy of loving kindness is
- 15:31anger or hatred and so that it selfhatred in its sense is the
- 15:36is this anger at the experience of the self, the aversion to the
- 15:42experience of self. It's arising and the and often
- 15:45the frustration around it. The near enemy.
- 15:51And when we talk about the the mind state itself, the near
- 15:56enemy of the mind state and the far enemy, the far enemy is
- 16:03really the opposite of the near enemy is something that's close
- 16:06but not actually what we're going for the near enemy of.
- 16:13The loving kindness is sentimentality and the reason
- 16:18why I think sentimentality is the near enemy is because it's a
- 16:22self generated emotion process in the way that we talk about it
- 16:25at Meta Group that you think thoughts that generate positive
- 16:29feeling states in the body. And as long as you think those
- 16:32thoughts that you're engaged in the experience of positive
- 16:38emotional states arising in the body.
- 16:41But it is taking you out of the present moment, into the
- 16:45experience of thinking and generating emotion.
- 16:50So you can develop phrases, often elaborate phrases that
- 16:56generate these positive states, but they do so only when you're
- 17:00in the act of generating them, when we talk about exploring the
- 17:06views of the divine abodes. We talk about a loving kindness
- 17:12view between ultimate reality and conceptual Reality is where
- 17:17the view goes or the mind state goes.
- 17:21Then it acts like a filter, distorting the creation of a
- 17:25conceptual reality. From the sensing experience of
- 17:29ultimate Reality, you incline the mind in a certain way by
- 17:34distorting the view of it. Christian.
- 17:40George, because this is a kind of distortion, is there a way in
- 17:46which this practice can be used in like for bypassing where it
- 17:51maybe it's inappropriate or unskillful to use the practice?
- 17:54Or do you have some thoughts around that?
- 17:57I would think that the bypassing practices are mostly the near
- 18:01enemy of sentimentality rather than actually holding the mind
- 18:05state of the view. You're still fully engaged in
- 18:08the experience of the present moment, and you recognize that
- 18:12you're holding the mind state and also the way in which it
- 18:15inclines the experience. So you're not actually bypassing
- 18:20any of the negative experience by avoiding it.
- 18:23It also is useful in a way, because you can respond to anger
- 18:30and hatred in a much more loving, kind way.
- 18:35Holding the view of it because the the perception of anger is
- 18:39distorted by the view. And also it because you are so
- 18:47centered in the present moment and watching all of these things
- 18:50happen, it's much harder for the sense of self to take hold and
- 18:55then feel attacked by the experience of anger that's
- 18:59coming at you that making sense. That you can see clearly that
- 19:05this anger is coming because it's diffused in a way by the
- 19:09view. You're then able to respond in a
- 19:12much more helpful way. But let me talk about how I like
- 19:20to think of this mind state. I like to say, or actually it
- 19:23was say that indica would say. It's always cool, always kind,
- 19:29open, friendly, curious. It's inclining towards someone.
- 19:36It's not passive or detached. It's lively, it's energetic.
- 19:43When we say cool, what we mean is there's an absence of the
- 19:46heat of desire, so it's not complicated by that.
- 19:51There's an absence of the heat of anger that arises from
- 19:54frustrated desire. So.
- 19:56Lobo was the term that he meant, which is a specific type of
- 20:00anger that arises when you're satisfaction and desire isn't
- 20:06available. When we say kind, what we mean
- 20:10is a generous consideration and assistance for somebody without
- 20:15the expectation of return. So that when you're confronting
- 20:19somebody who's angry, you come from this place of kindness
- 20:23where you're. Consider it an attempting to be
- 20:26helpful without the expectation of return.
- 20:29It's open, so an absence of the heat of rejection.
- 20:34One of the things that happens when you're confronted with
- 20:36anger of course is the mind closes and defends and then you
- 20:40become rejecting in and that has a tendency to accelerate the
- 20:46anger. Friendly, which is a helpful
- 20:51affection and non harming stance.
- 20:55Curious as an eagerness to find out about somebody else that you
- 20:59experience the anger not as a shutting down, rejecting
- 21:05experience, but as an open, curious experience that you're
- 21:10inclining toward the experience you're interested in.
- 21:13What's causing the person to act in the way that they do.
- 21:18It's lively and energetic. I think when we talk about the
- 21:24whole set, equanimity is also lively and energetic.
- 21:31But the near enemy of equanimity is detachment or disinterest.
- 21:38But this is not a disinterested, detached state.
- 21:42It's a lively active state, fully engaged, I'd like to say
- 21:50fully engaged in the experience of the moment, not withdrawn and
- 21:53detached from what's happening. That's the mind state.
- 22:00And so we, we trained the mind First off to recognize mind
- 22:05states. I think that's the first part.
- 22:08Did you grow up in a family system where your caregivers
- 22:12were interested in what your mind states were?
- 22:14And so they inquired about what your mind states were?
- 22:19They asked you about them. They asked you to tell them what
- 22:24was happening so that you would actually have to investigate
- 22:28what was happening and then describe it to them.
- 22:33If you had a caregiver that all through your life asked you what
- 22:36was going on with you, do you remember being around kids and
- 22:40some adult saying use your words, I don't know what's going
- 22:45on with you. That's this process of teaching
- 22:48a child to mentalize their mind states or views and then express
- 22:54them. You seem angry.
- 22:56Are you angry? You seem happy.
- 22:57Are you happy? You seem excited.
- 22:59What are you excited about? All of these inquiries into the
- 23:03the internal states of a child that then the child needs to
- 23:06explore and then be able to translate them into
- 23:11communication with somebody else is the exercise of that.
- 23:17Did you grow up in a household where they're they weren't
- 23:19particularly interested in your mind states or your views?
- 23:24What was going on with you? That happens often, and if it
- 23:29did, you're going to have a harder time understanding what
- 23:34we're we're talking about here. I like to say with all of these
- 23:38things, when you have to learn them now it's a pain in the ass,
- 23:44but you can still learn it. A child could learn this.
- 23:46So as an adult you could learn this.
- 23:48It's not even remotely impossible.
- 23:56One of the things that so so happens if you that comes up
- 23:59quite a bit you have visual thinkers and you have auditory
- 24:04thinkers. And often when we're in this
- 24:06dialogue of self reflection and people don't have an auditory
- 24:11track, they think they don't have that capacity but they need
- 24:16to tune into then the visual experience, the visual thought
- 24:20process to begin to understand that rather than just rely on
- 24:25the auditory aspect. So we want to, through the
- 24:36viposinous side, investigate how our conditioning is set up all
- 24:40of these systems and to begin to mitigate the negative aspects of
- 24:46them. But we also then have to
- 24:49intentionally develop the positive side of them.
- 24:54That typically is done through these hard practices.
- 24:59So in loving kindness practice, we learn the view and we we
- 25:04learn to establish the view and make that the object of
- 25:07meditation. The mechanism that's happening
- 25:10there is we're developing agency to create a particular view that
- 25:14we want, and we're creating the capacity to sustain the view so
- 25:19we can recognize whether it's there or not.
- 25:22And when we get good at it, we can do it on the fly.
- 25:25So if there's an angry response to something, we can push the
- 25:29angry view out and replace it with the positive view.
- 25:35This is the cultivation of intentional positivity.
- 25:42So loving kindness is the antidote to anger.
- 25:44Compassion, which is one of the practices, is the willingness to
- 25:51hold the suffering experience of someone else.
- 25:56The near enemy of compassion is sympathy.
- 26:06Sympathy is different than sentimentality.
- 26:10Sentimentality is a thought processes that produces positive
- 26:14feelings. Sympathy is still viewing the
- 26:20suffering experience of someone else, but it's a non empathetic
- 26:25response. So compassion is the only
- 26:28practice of the divine abodes. That's an empathetic practice,
- 26:33which is to say you connect emotionally to the other person,
- 26:37they connect to you and in that exchange of emotion, you have
- 26:46the potential to emotionally Co regulate somebody else so you
- 26:51experience the suffering experience of someone else has
- 26:57an empathetic experience. 3 levels of empathy here.
- 27:01The first is just the visceral response to witnessing somebody
- 27:05else's physical or emotional pain.
- 27:08The 2nd is where you're able to see and interpret emotional
- 27:14expressions in body language and facial expressions.
- 27:18And the third is what we call compassionate empathy, where you
- 27:22feel a facsimile of the emotional experience of someone
- 27:26else in your body. When you bring your emotional
- 27:36regulations skills to the empathetic experience of someone
- 27:40else, and it's transmitted back to them through the empathetic
- 27:43exchange, they receive a version of their emotions which is more
- 27:47regulated. And then when they have an
- 27:50empathetic experience of you and your emotions are more regulated
- 27:56than theirs, they have an empathetic experience of you
- 27:58that's more regulated. That process is regulating for
- 28:02them. They come back into an emotional
- 28:05balance. So the near enemy is
- 28:10sentimentality. So it's disconnected from the
- 28:15empathetic experience, but it's still attending to the suffering
- 28:22experience of someone else. It's just an internal experience
- 28:27of that. And then the far enemy of
- 28:30compassion is cruelty. Cruelty is the most common way
- 28:35that we disconnect from the experience of regulating them,
- 28:40that making sense. An example of that would be they
- 28:46deserve the suffering that they have.
- 28:48They've done it to themselves. It's their own fault.
- 28:51All of that stuff is a disconnection from holding
- 28:56space, holding the suffering experience.
- 29:03We have to be willing to hold the empathetic experience of
- 29:08someone else to be able to do this.
- 29:10So we have to have good skills for emotionally regulating not
- 29:13only our own emotion, but the emotion of the other person.
- 29:17We reflexively reject the experience of pain and turn away
- 29:22from it. And so this training really
- 29:24formally is about turning toward the experience of somebody
- 29:29else's suffering. But when we talk about self
- 29:33compassion, what we mean is we turn toward our own suffering
- 29:39experience and open to it. The bandwidth of consciousness
- 29:45is very narrow, and it's easy enough to exclude our own
- 29:50suffering experience so that we don't have awareness of it, or
- 29:54it's easy to disconnect from our own suffering experience by
- 29:59cruelty. So that's part of this process
- 30:02of aversion to the self experience, this cruel reaction
- 30:08to the difficulty of the self experience arising rather than
- 30:13opening to the suffering experience.
- 30:18We're all condition beings, of course, and the conditioning
- 30:22affects our capacity to respond to things.
- 30:26And our mentalizing can collapse, our emotional
- 30:30regulation can collapse, and those things are based on the
- 30:34skill set that we learn in the family systems.
- 30:38We grow up in the reflection of our conditioning, and so we can
- 30:43witness ourselves not functioning very well, and
- 30:46instead of responding with a compassionate embrace of that,
- 30:51come with a cruel disconnection. So this training is to disengage
- 30:58from that open the space of our own suffering so that we can
- 31:02attend to it. Sympathetic joy is a joyfulness.
- 31:09I like to use the word delight. It's it's more connected to the
- 31:13the attachment vocabulary, a delight in yourself, delight in
- 31:19other people, and in pursuing primary exploration.
- 31:25So it's another aspect that comes from the attachment world,
- 31:29rooting for someone to succeed in their primary exploration and
- 31:34they're finding meaningfulness in this life.
- 31:36That's what we want to do. The near enemy of sympathetic
- 31:43joy is rooting for somebody because you get a direct benefit
- 31:48from their succeeding in in a sense of pure delight, you're
- 31:57simply delighting in the beingness of the other person,
- 32:01not whether you get a benefit out of that or not.
- 32:04And then the far enemy is envy. Jealousy.
- 32:11Envy is typically around material and social position.
- 32:18Jealousy tends to be more around relationships.
- 32:26I I think for most people who feel jealousy or envy, you know
- 32:31the bitterness of that experience.
- 32:36And if you have the capacity for delight, then you also know the
- 32:39the richness and the the joy of that.
- 32:45So it's, it seems to me, almost a nobrainer that you would want
- 32:48to go in the direction of delight because the experience
- 32:51itself is so pleasant and away from the experience of envy and
- 32:55jealousy because it's so bitter. But then again, we are we bump
- 33:00up against our conditioning. It isn't so easy to just switch
- 33:03that. You have to practice it.
- 33:05You have to build out the structures that allow that to
- 33:09happen, and that's through this practice of sympathetic joy,
- 33:18tensional positivity, rooting for somebody.
- 33:22And in our culture, where success is celebrated so much,
- 33:28really, being on somebody's team when they succeed is a great
- 33:31thing. And if they don't see it as a as
- 33:35a quid pro quo, it's even better.
- 33:39They love to share that with you.
- 33:41And then you have that experience of delight and ease
- 33:45in the world that you don't have otherwise.
- 33:47So in some sense you do get that.
- 33:52And then of course you have people to share your
- 33:54exploration, your successes with, and the delight that comes
- 33:58at you for you doing well. And that really takes you out to
- 34:03the far edges of what you can find out that you need to know.
- 34:08Whereas if you don't have that kind of support, you begin to
- 34:11limit the risk that you might take, so you have less and less
- 34:15of that. And then the last one is
- 34:21equanimity. In the early years of my
- 34:29practice, I really did have the idea of equanimity as
- 34:33detachment, not reacting. And I remember the story of the
- 34:45Zen master and the warlord. Do you know this one?
- 34:50So a warlord is entering into a village and all of the monks are
- 34:54gathering everything and rushing out of the monastery, heading
- 34:58into the hills because they're so frightened about what the
- 35:01warlord will do to them. But the master simply sits in
- 35:05meditation waiting. Everybody has left the monastery
- 35:10except for the master and a monk runs back and says master,
- 35:14master, we have to leave now or the warlord will come and kill
- 35:18us all. And the master sits in
- 35:21meditation in the the young monk flees and then the warlord comes
- 35:26into the meditation hall and says, don't you know who I am?
- 35:31The master sits in meditation and then the warlord draws his
- 35:36sword and says to the meditation master, don't you know that I
- 35:40could run you through with my sword with without a second
- 35:47thought? And the meditation master opened
- 35:51his eyes and said, don't you know I could sit here and allow
- 35:55you to run me through this with the sword without a second
- 35:59thought? And then the warlord bowed and
- 36:03left. So that was interpreted, I
- 36:12think, early on for me, as complete detachment from
- 36:15everything. And then sitting with Dan Brown
- 36:21and listening to him describe equanimity.
- 36:24What became apparent to me was that it's super lively, super
- 36:30energetic and at the same time and perfect balance.
- 36:34So then the image I have is this surfboard stuck out of a 60 foot
- 36:40wave with the the surfer in the distance appeared completely
- 36:46still, but if you zoomed in on his feet you'd see he'd be
- 36:50moving a little bit, here, a little bit.
- 36:51They are constantly in this process of balancing, engaging
- 36:57in each moment and adjusting each moment.
- 37:01Lively, energetic. And so that's how I, I, I come
- 37:05to think of this piece of equanimity.
- 37:08It's this really lively, fully engaged way of being in the
- 37:14experience of the world and constantly adjusting so you
- 37:17don't lose your balance. The near enemy then of
- 37:22equanimity is detachment, and the far enemy is craving,
- 37:27aversion and unconsciousness. You get swept up in desire, get
- 37:35swept up in aversion, you get swept up in the content of
- 37:42everything and lose the capacity to monitor it.
- 37:52Then you're just lost. And then we look at these
- 37:58practices of the divine abodes and the cultivation of
- 38:02intentional positivity as an integrated skill set,
- 38:08recognizing the arising of the unskillful mind States and
- 38:13understanding which approach is then the antidote to that.
- 38:19So we do have to intentionally develop each of these specific
- 38:24skills so that we have them and can orchestrate them together in
- 38:31a robust, intentionally positive response to the vicissitudes of
- 38:41our experience. We often focus on loving
- 38:46kindness practice, but I think that you should devote an equal
- 38:49amount of practice to each of the different abodes until you
- 38:54really have clarity about the mind states in the beginning.
- 38:59Sometimes identifying the loving kindness mindset, identifying
- 39:03the compassion mindset, the sympathetic joy mindset, and the
- 39:07equanimity mind state might be difficult, and so you need to
- 39:13really develop clarity and understand how they're
- 39:15different. It's Christian.
- 39:22When your conception of the equanimity mind state changed,
- 39:26did you find it? Like, did you have to go through
- 39:29a period of searching for sort of a new conception of that mind
- 39:34state or like what? How was that?
- 39:35If you had maybe a different idea embedded for yourself
- 39:38before, well, I think that I it was a really easy adjustment for
- 39:45me because it it actually mapped on better to what was actually
- 39:51my experience. I was always noticing the
- 39:53liveliness, the energy of it and in some sense attempting to damp
- 39:58it down because it didn't it wasn't flat.
- 40:03So I think that if you look you know listen to the morning
- 40:06meditation recording say from 10 or 15 years ago, I was was
- 40:11really describing equanimity as a flatness and then as a.
- 40:17But I never could actually flatten anything out.
- 40:20It always was energetic. And so I know in the Terravada
- 40:26world, in the way that they practice that that tends to have
- 40:33a different effect than the way Zen people practice or Tibetan
- 40:37people practice. Dan Brown and Judd Brewer did a
- 40:42study of the different effects of that and they noticed that
- 40:46the the Theravada practices have a tendency to shut down the the
- 40:51self experience where as the Tibetan practices tend to
- 40:59activate the spaciousness of things.
- 41:03And so in that no self shutting down of the self experience,
- 41:11flattening that out, that tends to be kind of the descriptors of
- 41:15it. Whereas in the the spaciousness
- 41:18which is the Tibetan style of practice, there's no need to
- 41:22shut anything down because it becomes so expansive.
- 41:24Nothing is intense. One of the things that is
- 41:34impeded my practice or supported it equally, I would guess, is
- 41:41that because I came from such a cruel upbringing, the the level
- 41:49of kindness that I require in my teachers is extraordinarily
- 41:53high. It's unusual to to encounter
- 41:58somebody who has a sufficient level of kindness for me to
- 42:03really settle in and be safe. And without that, without that
- 42:09epistemic trust, it's very hard to learn from some So and then
- 42:18having sat for so long with Shinzen, with the understanding
- 42:24that we were doing a traditional the positive practice that as my
- 42:29understanding of this deepened and I could see that actually
- 42:33that's not what was happening. It was confusing to use the
- 42:39vocabulary of Theravada practice when actually what we were doing
- 42:44was not that And then the expectations that come not so
- 42:49much in Chinzen's community but in related communities and
- 42:55texts. So I think that that it's an
- 43:02interesting aspect of trying to figure out because in the West
- 43:11where it's so adaptive and and feel so free and changing
- 43:19things, revocabularizing that when you read a more traditional
- 43:28text and it describes the expectations that you should
- 43:31have from practice and and people are vocabularizing the
- 43:37practice that you're doing it as that even though the cool light
- 43:45of dawn you can see that it isn't actually.
- 43:49That was. Was.
- 43:52Shinzen Young's practice that you thought was I can't remember
- 43:58what you said, but you thought you were practicing the pastana.
- 44:03But in fact it was Was it more Zen?
- 44:07Or he's not Tibetan, right? He's more Zen.
- 44:11Well, he was in a Japanese Vatriana monastery.
- 44:15Oh, OK And he studied with Sasaki Roshi for 30 years and
- 44:22also studied with in Taiwan with the Terravada master.
- 44:30And so in his synthesis of all of that he he offered a way of
- 44:35practicing that was actually a mashup of those.
- 44:41And in his in secularizing it and making it available for
- 44:47beginners, those distinctions I think, were were lost.
- 44:55I see. Yeah.
- 44:58Did you find that it was kind of watered down, or it was just a
- 45:00synthesis that was easier for Westerners to pick up?
- 45:06No, I didn't think it was watered down.
- 45:07I definitely agree with him that it's industrial strain.
- 45:11I just don't think that he offered the the footnotes.
- 45:22You know, if you don't attribute the practices to one particular
- 45:26way of teaching or another, and they're combined creates an
- 45:32experience of practice, but you don't have the same effect that
- 45:39you would have in in a in a more traditional sense.
- 45:49Because you're following a tradition that's established
- 45:53and. As markers and pointers, and you
- 45:58tend to have the experience that is a result of the practice that
- 46:01you do. And so when these lineage
- 46:05practices where they're confined to these traditional ways of
- 46:10practicing, you tend to have these predictable outcomes from
- 46:13the practice, which are then described in the literature.
- 46:18If you don't do that, you have an experience of practice that's
- 46:23different than what you would expect if you did the
- 46:26traditional way of practicing. But when you use the same
- 46:30vocabulary for a traditional way of practicing with it, with a
- 46:34series of practices that are not in that tradition, the outcomes
- 46:39that you have are more in accordance with the practice
- 46:42that undertaking and not and don't match as well as in the
- 46:46descriptions of what's supposed to happen.
- 46:48And I think, I think that that was my experience of it.
- 46:52I see. So it sort of needs a new
- 46:54vocabulary, tweaked vocabulary, Yeah.
- 46:59I think that the more you know, there's these resistances that
- 47:06maybe are particular to me. I'm, I tend to be curious and
- 47:09when I get a bone, I really want to go into it.
- 47:13And when when you have a secularized practice, you get a
- 47:18general term and not a specific term.
- 47:21And because in English we use English words to cover many of
- 47:26the traditional practice words, you can be thinking, which is
- 47:31what happened to me, that I was exploring something that was
- 47:34actually what was being taught when it wasn't.
- 47:39But I didn't have the depth of practice to recognize that I
- 47:42hadn't aligned it properly in the beginning.
- 47:47That's a very valuable feedback for me because I've been in a
- 47:51lot of different lineages and it's very confusing.
- 47:55But if you stick with one, then there are predictable outcomes
- 47:58because you're following that teaching that over, you know,
- 48:04years and years have fine-tuned how you get there.
- 48:08But if you're bouncing around, it's you're going to lose it,
- 48:11yeah. So you're not.
- 48:12You're going to have the outcome of the practice that you have,
- 48:16which is not going to match the descriptions of what's expected
- 48:19from the practice if you follow the lineage.
- 48:26Yeah, that makes sense. So go ahead.
- 48:31Well, I'm interrupting, but I can wait.
- 48:36No, I You're good, Cindy. Well, I have a question on
- 48:42perception that was earlier on, but I don't want I.
- 48:47Should I go or Edward? Yeah, go ahead.
- 48:50Yeah. So earlier on you were talking
- 48:51about perception and I was wondering that perception is
- 48:57based on sensory inputs and meaning making.
- 49:03So I wondered, is there ever such a thing as true perception
- 49:06or accurate perception? Because perception seems to have
- 49:10a bandwidth of being way off versus pretty pretty direct, But
- 49:15is there such a thing as true or accurate perception?
- 49:20I think that you might say that ultimate reality was the true
- 49:23experience and then conceptual reality is what you make it
- 49:27into. But that's different than
- 49:30perception, right? Well, you take the ultimate
- 49:34sensing experience, which is true, that's what's happened,
- 49:38right? And then you compare it to the
- 49:41perceptual database and link that to previously interpreted
- 49:49experience. Sensing experiences.
- 49:52And if there's a close enough match, it rolls into conceptual
- 49:55reality, which is always going to be distorted in some way.
- 50:01So can you give an example of the difference between
- 50:04perception that is accurate and true versus a distorted 1?
- 50:12Well, if we use the word perception to mean the raw
- 50:19sensing data. So you are your eyes see in the
- 50:21way that they see. If there's enough light, they
- 50:23take in data, there's sound and you you're hearing, you taking
- 50:28the sound. If there's temperature, you take
- 50:30in temperature. If there's emotion there, you
- 50:32take in emotion. All of that is the the array of
- 50:36raw sensing data, the perception of that in terms of what your
- 50:42capacity to senses is going to be accurate, right?
- 50:47Is it? Couldn't it be distorted?
- 50:50Well, it could be distorted depending on the quality of the
- 50:54mind, but for the most part, the raw data, they call it ultimate
- 51:01reality because that's the basis of what what you can know about
- 51:05what's happening based on being in the human body.
- 51:10But the raw data is interpreted different by every single person
- 51:14exactly. So that's conceptual reality.
- 51:17That's not ultimate reality. The ultimate reality is the raw
- 51:21data. Yeah.
- 51:23Before it's been conceptualized. Right.
- 51:28So we can't. Ever.
- 51:30Know it well. What we can know is the word in
- 51:34Apalis tajapanati. We can compare what the the raw
- 51:40data is to what we make it into. And in that process of going
- 51:44back and forth, this is the data.
- 51:47This is what I made. This is the data.
- 51:49This is what I made. This is the data.
- 51:51This is what I made. See if there's any distortions
- 51:56in there, and then if we see that the mind is a quantumous
- 52:00and that the reflection is good, we can interpret what we made it
- 52:07into as a as a fairly accurate reflection of what it means to
- 52:13us. Yeah, but I'm still getting a
- 52:19little lost because I it just seems like once it goes into
- 52:24conception you. You can never have an accurate
- 52:30raw data reception as true and accurate every time.
- 52:37Just by its nature you're you're never perceiving fully
- 52:43accurately. It's all a fabrication of the
- 52:46data coming in and what you make of it.
- 52:49It's all, yeah, your capacity to descends and then what you make
- 52:53it into. Right.
- 52:55So there is no direct experience of perception.
- 53:00What you sense is not made into anything.
- 53:04Right. If you were to be able to
- 53:06experience that, you wouldn't have made meaning of it, right?
- 53:12I think I'm getting or. I'm confused though.
- 53:16It was like. You just are always fabricating,
- 53:20so you're never having the. Full on true accurate perception
- 53:25because it doesn't really exist. You don't necessarily need to
- 53:29fixate anything, you can just be in the sensing.
- 53:35And that, oh, and not make meaning out of it, right?
- 53:38Not fixated into anything. Fabricated.
- 53:42Fabricated. Yeah.
- 53:43Then you're just in that ultimate reality experience.
- 53:47OK, that kind of starts to make sense.
- 53:50I don't know if I experienced that.
- 53:52Is that part of meditation? You just it is, yeah.
- 53:55OK, I'm not there yet. OK.
- 54:00All right, Edward, Shall we do some practice?
- 54:05I didn't know if Edward had it. Oh, Edward, ask your question
- 54:08well. I'm getting by this recent
- 54:11conversation. I'm one thing I'm thinking of is
- 54:13I love the Course of Miracles expression Projection makes
- 54:17perception. Making is not the same as
- 54:20creating, but then I'd have to get into the metaphysics.
- 54:24But yeah, it's duality. But I thought about, you know,
- 54:29ultimate or absolute reality as rigpa and and then we get in, in
- 54:36course of Miracles terms, the happy dream.
- 54:39Or I like to sing after enlightenment.
- 54:42Some Zen guy said walking through hell is like walking
- 54:45through a beautiful park on a beautiful day.
- 54:48So he's not you know, he sees quote UN quote hell, but it's
- 54:52not his hell because he's in he's in heaven, you know.
- 54:56So yeah, it's you know all the, you know these different systems
- 55:01you know use different words. But Rigpa is you know, it's
- 55:06beyond mind. I I would say it's beyond good
- 55:08and evil and karma. I think good and evil and karma
- 55:11operate in the realm of in the relative realm.
- 55:13But anyway, leaving that aside. Well, I was curious, did you
- 55:18talked about because of your your childhood you you needed to
- 55:22have an extraordinary sense of trust let's say or no kindness
- 55:26observed in the teachers. So I was wondering if that's
- 55:29something you saw in Shinzen in my brief encounter with him.
- 55:33I I didn't pick that up personally.
- 55:36But anyway, you don't even need to answer that.
- 55:38But I'm just saying that it's something that struck me
- 55:41curious. Oh, I found Shinzen to be
- 55:44unfailingly kind. The way that he expressed it is
- 55:49by a delight and interest in everybody's inquiry.
- 55:58It's it's quite unusual for him to get irritated by people's
- 56:06presentation. One little thing that I remember
- 56:11that he was at the community. Meditation center after you left
- 56:15I BMCI don't know what your years were with him, but anyhow,
- 56:19it doesn't matter. I just he would say after
- 56:22meditation period, he said Now comes the hard part.
- 56:25And that would be going up to the refreshment table and
- 56:28interacting, interacting with people.
- 56:31And I thought, I remember thinking, right on, Yeah, OK,
- 56:37I'm done. Let us do some meditation.
- 56:41Would you like to do loving kindness, compassion,
- 56:44sympathetic joy, or equanimity? Equanimity based on their talk,
- 56:54right? I mean, I'm only one person, but
- 56:58yeah, equanimity. So I'm going to write the
- 57:02equanimity phrase because it's long.
- 57:13OK, let go of the meditation. How'd that go?
- 57:27I couldn't remember the phrases. I wanted to read them, but I
- 57:31thought that's not the way to do a meditation.
- 57:35Yeah, it's a long one. It's the only one that's.
- 57:40It's the only one, that's what it's the only one that's long.
- 57:45All the one that all the other afraid that are short.
- 57:50OK, yeah, I need to memorize. Yeah, Christian.
- 58:02Think I think I resonate with the liveliness that you
- 58:04mentioned. Like I I don't know if it's
- 58:08getting into meta territory, but usually when I do equanimity
- 58:10there's like. There's kind of like an inner
- 58:13smile to it. There's like a little bit.
- 58:16There's like a little bit of like a positive feeling for me.
- 58:19Yeah. It's not like I'm doing anything
- 58:22to particularly generate it that I can tell, so that seems to
- 58:28kind of resonate. It feels like a nice easy
- 58:32practice rather than the what was the near enemy?
- 58:38Detached rather than detached. And also in regards to like the
- 58:45the ultimate reality thing that Cindy was asking about.
- 58:49I don't know if this is like a blasphemy, but whenever you say
- 58:51ultimate reality, I like I translated for myself as sensory
- 58:56reality or as what? Like sensory reality or yes,
- 59:01sensory perception. Just because the the word
- 59:05ultimate has like a baggage for me of like that's the thing.
- 59:12Right. Like that's the true thing.
- 59:13And I understand you to be not saying that when you, when you
- 59:19kind of talk about the rocking back and forth, it's almost kind
- 59:22of like a dialectical thing. Yeah, I think of it as the data.
- 59:28That's how I think of it, you know, And it's interesting
- 59:33because we live in these bodies that are just actively sensing
- 59:37all the time. And so it's a constant flow of
- 59:39sensing data and then we grab pieces of it and make it into
- 59:43something. And so that's really the process
- 59:46and you really want to, I think of it almost as a rocking
- 59:49motion. This is the sensing, this is
- 59:51what I made, this is the sensing.
- 59:53And you're just constantly doing that.
- 59:55And so there really isn't much grab to the the versions that
- 59:59you make because you're constantly making versions of
- 1:00:03things. And then that really is where
- 1:00:05the freedom comes is, because you don't.
- 1:00:07You're not devoted to any particular version of it.
- 1:00:11And you're constantly investigating whether the
- 1:00:13version that you've just made actually is reflective of what's
- 1:00:16happening in terms of the sensing.
- 1:00:21And so there's this. It's just an easy, flowy kind of
- 1:00:25experience of being. Then George, can I ask you a
- 1:00:32question at the end of this? If I can just like have a minute
- 1:00:35to stay on afterwards. OK, everybody good.
- 1:00:44We have a few things coming up. I did announce that we're going
- 1:00:46to do a Level 0 the first Thursday of the month instead of
- 1:00:50the I Love You keep going. So we'll be covering a a a
- 1:00:56presentation around the meditation and attachment
- 1:00:59approach that we have. We do have some level ones
- 1:01:08coming up and some level twos coming up at the end of the
- 1:01:11summer. If you're interested in that,
- 1:01:13take a look at the calendar. It's most of that should be up
- 1:01:17by now. Anyway, Ioffer these teachings
- 1:01:25on a Donna basis. Donna is the Poly word for
- 1:01:27generosity. That means I I give the
- 1:01:30teachings freely, but I do hope that if you're resourced, we can
- 1:01:36you can make a donation. It's helpful to me and also to
- 1:01:39the work that we're doing. Yes, everybody's invited to the
- 1:01:42the 1st of the month. It's just going to be a narrower
- 1:01:47focus rather than the the sort of free range approach with the
- 1:01:53rest of the time. So yeah, please come.
- 1:01:57And I think it'll be an interesting dialogue, hopefully.
- 1:02:06Lively, lively, energetic. Yes, perfectly balanced.
- 1:02:12Right. With all these new people.
- 1:02:15All right. Thanks so much.
- 1:02:17We'll see you soon.