Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / Ethics Case - Therapist Texts Too Much
Transcript
- 0:00So, Bob, I have an interesting, juicy ethics case sent to me
- 0:03by my malpractice insurance HPSO, and I thought, well, maybe i'll talk
- 0:09about this with Rebecca. But this one involves something that you know about,
- 0:13so let's get into it. What do you say? Is it about some
- 0:16ethical violation that I'm familiar with because I did it? No, it has
- 0:20to do with DBT oh. Okay, So again, my malpractice insurance HPSO
- 0:27sends out these briefs as a way of helping us as ensured to manage our
- 0:34risks so that we don't harm ourselves by committing ethical violations. And HPSO saves
- 0:43money because if we're paying our dues and they don't have to pay money out
- 0:47to help us defend ourselves, then it's a win win with if they if
- 0:52they try to prevent people from committing these violations. So they'll summarize cases that
- 0:57they've been working on after completed, and they will erase any identifying information of
- 1:03course. Okay. So, I normally will actually go over the brief and
- 1:11change the wording to be my own wording, but this time I just thought
- 1:15I would just read it verbatim. Right, So here we go. The
- 1:18ensured in this case is a licensed mental health counselor referred to as the counselor,
- 1:23with three years of experience. So this chiming in meaning that they're not
- 1:29a social work or or a marriage of family therapist or a psychologist. The
- 1:33counselor had recently begun working as a solo practitioner when she started treating a client,
- 1:38a woman in her twenties. So we have a mental health counselor like
- 1:42yourself, Bob, three years experience, which is unlike you. I was
- 1:48recently thinking we're getting into our upper twenties years because we graduated in ninety seven,
- 1:55but really we started practicing in ninety six, as interns were in the
- 2:00twenty six, seventh, twenty eighth year almost anyway, Yeah, so this
- 2:06counselor had three years of experience, started working as a solo practitioner, probably
- 2:10after working at an agency, I'm guessing, and she started treating a client,
- 2:15one of her very first solo clients, woman in her early twenties.
- 2:20Clients intake form stated that she was seeking therapy for her borderline personality disorder.
- 2:24In other words, the client knew she had borderline what or suspected she had
- 2:30borderline, and the counselor's treatment planned for her included dialectical behavior therapy or DBT.
- 2:36During the initial session, the counselor learned that the client was also in
- 2:40recovery for an eating disorder and orexia nervosa, and she had a history of
- 2:46depression that was being managed by medication. So just chiming in here, Bob,
- 2:52that presentation is that typical to someone that might have come into your DBT
- 2:57group? Yeah, I'm actually thinking to somebody I knew way back when I
- 3:00started similar similar Yeah, background, Yeah, borderline, eating disorders depression are
- 3:07highly comorbid. You could argue that the depression is a symptom of the borderline
- 3:15and eating disorders have a similar history, a similar ideology, as as borderline
- 3:23does trauma and family conflict. This kind of thing going on here. As
- 3:28part of the counselor's treatment for the clients BPD borderline that included DBT, the
- 3:34counselor gave the client her cell phone number. Typically in DBT telephonic consultations.
- 3:39Telephonic. It's an interesting word, that word. Yeah, why why why
- 3:44it sounds like a word instead of like just telephone. Yeah, just say
- 3:47telephone consultations. But I think it's an older way of talking about things,
- 3:53you know, like you have to be more technical. I just say telephone.
- 3:58But you know, I guess it's maybe it's the official adjective version of
- 4:01telephone. Typically in DBT, telephonic consultations between a counselor and their client allow
- 4:08the clients to receive in the moment guidance that can help them apply the skills
- 4:12they have learned in therapy and everyday situations, especially during times of crisis.
- 4:15So what do you think about That happens all the time for folks who do
- 4:19DBT. This is part of their thing. Yeah, So why because that's
- 4:24not typical that a therapist would, especially in private practice, would say feel
- 4:29free to text me any time in between the session or call right because crises
- 4:33don't happen in the office during office hours. So the thought is that if
- 4:39you can help somebody in a moment of crisis, they'll learn how to manage
- 4:44more without resorting to what they would call target behaviors like that could be some
- 4:48kind of self harm behavior or whatever. And they have a rule they called
- 4:51the twenty four hour rule where therapists will not have contact with their clients,
- 4:56and unless there's already a scheduled session within twenty four hour of some kind of
- 5:00target behavior. Like so, for instance, if I wanted to cut myself,
- 5:03I got to call you, if you're my therapist, before I do
- 5:06it. If I do it and I call you, you'll tell me that
- 5:12we can't have contact for twenty four hours. Twenty four hours is you know,
- 5:15that's some a arbitrary, But the idea is that therapists tend to be
- 5:19sympathetic and you don't want therapy to reinforce that kind of behavior. So they'll
- 5:28have a twenty four hour rule and unless there's even like if the next day
- 5:31there was a scheduled session, then they would just go ahead and have the
- 5:34session, and they'd be talking, probably the whole session about what got in
- 5:38the way of you calling me beforehand, you know, or using X skill
- 5:43or whatever, and they would do a chain analysis, which is like,
- 5:46what are the dominoes that failed that led to the very target they called a
- 5:48target behavior because it's targeted in therapy to be eliminated. Right, Yeah,
- 5:53So interestally, I didn't know it was that focused on abstinence essentially, I
- 5:59mean it sounds along the lines of a drug and alcohol counselor. Yeah.
- 6:02You know, if you have a competent, caring, compassionate drug and alcohol
- 6:08counselor, even in spite of the compassion and the collaboration, they might be
- 6:14very focused because the client presumably wants that on relapse management and on abstaining skills.
- 6:23You know, client says, I drank over the weekend. And you
- 6:27know, because if a client tells me that, since I'm not a drug
- 6:30and alcohol counselor, I would say, do you want to talk about that?
- 6:33Because we could talk about that, but I'm not. It's not my
- 6:38agenda. So what do you want to talk about? And if the client
- 6:41said, I, you know, I binge drinked all last weekend and I'd
- 6:45rather not talk about it, I'd say, okay, but what do you
- 6:46want to talk about? You know, I might throw out some sentence about
- 6:50safety or about how it might affect treatment, depending on the situation. Of
- 6:55course, if it was just a general situation, but I'm not going to
- 6:59force the issue where a drug ANOTO counselor well, and so what you're saying
- 7:01what a DBT person is that they would be pretty pointed and say we have
- 7:05to talk about what happened instead of just being more collaborative and more open ended.
- 7:13Yeah, they have a hierarchy. The first order of business would any
- 7:16any target behavior like like self harm or something. Second order of business would
- 7:20be anything that's therapy interfering. So that includes things like showing up late,
- 7:25not showing up, anything that's getting in the way of therapy. It could
- 7:29actually be phone calls to the therapist, because just because the therapist is available
- 7:32doesn't mean that that doesn't that it wouldn't interfere with their life. They might,
- 7:36it might, and so then it be a therapy interfering behavior. The
- 7:40idea of being it's not about you know, punishing somebody because oh, you
- 7:44violated my boundaries. It's more like, hey, we got to make this
- 7:46work for both of us, So what are we going to do about you
- 7:49know, let's figure out what we're going to do about this. Because I
- 7:53am, on the one hand, available to you, and on the other
- 7:55hand, I cannot be available all the time. I just can't. So
- 7:59it's a dialectic. And then the third and then third order business, So
- 8:03you're saying that the therapist has to have conversations about I'm not available. What
- 8:11are you saying, what sort of boundary are there trying? Well, I'm
- 8:15thinking of a therapist I know whose client would call him in the middle of
- 8:18the night, in the middle of the night, which you know, he
- 8:22would be very plainly like, I'd rather you have called me in the middle
- 8:24of the night than he actually did self harm behavior and calling me in the
- 8:28middle of night is disrupting my sleep, and it's mucking with my day,
- 8:33and it's happening enough that this is actually a problem. If it was a
- 8:35one off, Okay, fine, it's a one off. But because this
- 8:39is happening more frequently, we need to talk about it because I have to
- 8:41be able to function for my other clients and for my partner and through the
- 8:45day. So, well, what's the conversation, Because say the client has
- 8:50ninety percent likelihood of if they're going to have a crisis, it's at three
- 8:54in the morning, what's the message that they're supposed to not call or they're
- 8:58supposed to like have a different set of symptoms that you know they can't.
- 9:03That's why they're in treatment. They're trying to get help for their symptoms.
- 9:05Yeah, exactly. So the idea would be the therapist and the client be
- 9:09figuring out, what are you going to do so you're not having crises at
- 9:11three in the morning, Like what skills are needed here, what's happening in
- 9:15your in your day as it unfolds that's leading you to this sort of thing
- 9:18happening at three in the morning, Like how is that occurring? And what
- 9:22can we do to interrupt it? So they just look for key moments where
- 9:26that could be interrupted so that it's eliminated. I mean, presumably it's in
- 9:31the client's interest do not have crises so well, in this hypothetical, let's
- 9:35say that the therapist emphasizes that the client agrees and apologizes, but isn't like
- 9:43saying I'm ashamed of myself. It's just it just so happens that that's soft
- 9:48and when I feel bad or I have shift work where that's my off hours
- 9:54and that's when I'm awake. And let's say that it continues. Does the
- 10:00therapists just suck it up or what happens? I think they would continue to
- 10:03address it. Yeah, they would just keep addressing it until so the therapist
- 10:07would, on the one hand, be sucking it up. On the other
- 10:09hand, if it was really disrupting their life, it would be in their
- 10:13interests to keep at it. That can be highly motivating because clients don't actually
- 10:18want to intrude on a therapist life. They don't. It's not like they
- 10:20want to do this. They may be grateful that a person is available.
- 10:24They also may feel really ashamed and guilty for needing to rely on somebody,
- 10:28but they don't want their therapist to suffer. So they're highly motivated because they
- 10:31care about therapists to shift behavior. You know, like, hey man,
- 10:35whatever gets you, whatever gets whatever road to rome we can find, then
- 10:39let's just take that road, including meaning using the leverage of trying to please
- 10:45the therapist to actually be more healthy. The downside of that, of course,
- 10:50is that the client would just lie and say I didn't do it.
- 10:52They could and they might. And I mean, if clients lie to me,
- 10:56they lie to me. Would I can't do that. The therapist could
- 11:01pressure a client to lie, essentially, could shame a client to lie.
- 11:05A bad therapist could yeah, or you know, you might miss the boat
- 11:11on something. I mean, it might actually evoke shame. That's not necessarily
- 11:13a just shame in itself isn't necessarily a bad thing. Yeah, you know,
- 11:18like, oh, you're not sleeping. I do feel bad about that
- 11:20because I'm relying on you. And if you're telling me that I'm having a
- 11:26negative impact on you, and I care about you so that I want to
- 11:30not call you at three the money, it just seems like a really hairy
- 11:33situation. Yeah, Harry, I'm sure that DBT therapists manage it well.
- 11:39And I had to say, as a therapist myself, I guess that's kind
- 11:43of a deal breaker for me with DBT in terms of that side of things.
- 11:48Right, I love my sleep and it is very off and on,
- 11:52so I you know, if something interrupts there's all I already have barrier internally
- 12:01to my own sleep, and if, yeah, I also have external barriers
- 12:05that I can control, then I'm going to get rid of them. Well,
- 12:07I have a good friend, it's a DBT therapist, and she says,
- 12:09you cannot call me after nine because it interrupts my sleep also my relationship
- 12:13with my partner, So I'm not available after nine. I think that's perfectly
- 12:18legit. If you know what your limit is and you're frank about that upfront
- 12:22with a client, and they may be a person who has crises at three
- 12:24in the morning. Okay, it's definitely a problem to be solved. It
- 12:28might mean that this isn't the right therapist for you. Okay, fine.
- 12:31If it isn't, then you know, work to find somebody. But if
- 12:33it is, or if you want to continue in therapy, then it's still
- 12:37to be managed. And it's there's a risk there, but I mean there's
- 12:39a risk anyways, it's a risk, so I guess it could slow down
- 12:43the therapy a little bit. Could mean that only eighty percent of the crises
- 12:50are addressed on the phone prior and some of them slip through the cracks because
- 12:54the client or the therapist has that boundary. Yeah. Yeah, yeah,
- 12:58just seems so hairy. It seems like you'd really of course, I'm sure
- 13:03the DBT practitioners are trained and practiced about this, that you have to be
- 13:09real buttoned up on boundaries, because there would be a temptation with some clients
- 13:15to overutilize that service, especially if you have someone that's moderate to severe borderline
- 13:20and pretty much wants constant contact with their therapist and has constant anxiety about how
- 13:26the therapist feels about them. You could reinforce, You could reinforce behavior if
- 13:31you mishandle how things go. Yeah. Yeah, So it wouldn't be unusual
- 13:35for a for any client, let alone someone with DBT to actually text when
- 13:41they're not in crisis and then the therapist I hear in what you're saying.
- 13:46The therapist would say, either in some way that is respectful and kind and
- 13:54not causing a rupture. They would say, so, when you texted me
- 13:56this past week, it didn't seem like you're actually in crisis, and so
- 14:03you know, that's not what this service is utilized form. Sorry, you
- 14:05know, well it depends. I mean, some therapists would say that is
- 14:09a good thing, and they would want to encourage that kind of behavior because
- 14:13it's creating a constant object. Well, they add, that's the point.
- 14:18Yeah, yeah, okay. And if the therapist is okay with that extra
- 14:24work because you don't get paid for it, well, some people will weave
- 14:28it into their fee, but mostly no, Yeah, especially if you had
- 14:31one client that did it every day at another client that literally never did it.
- 14:35Yeah, they're not charging necessarily you're the client more so as you could,
- 14:39but they don't generally do that. I think it's that's just one instance
- 14:43that one's pipmone's fee according to one's needs. So you're gonna be pretty mindful
- 14:48about that. Yeah. Yeah, So you're saying that if the client,
- 14:52if the therapist is okay with it, then you might have a client that
- 14:56we'll call in texts a few times every day, and therapists can be clear
- 15:01it's like I will respond to one of these a day or you I can't.
- 15:05I don't expect respond in an hour. I have other things that occupy
- 15:07my time, though I may not respond at all or whatever. But they're
- 15:11upfront about that, and it's like, yeah, if you want to text
- 15:13me, feel free to go for it, and I'll respond to one.
- 15:18And I suspect that most clients, even moderate to severe people with borderline will
- 15:24not bother the therapists very often. It's a bit of a myth that because
- 15:28I feel like everyone thinks that What About Bob the movie with Bill Murray and
- 15:35Richard Dreyfuss, is somehow, like, you know, halfway representative of what
- 15:39therapy ists like, and it's the dumbest, most cartoonish, most stigmatizing look
- 15:46at what a client is really like. You know, it just makes clients
- 15:50out to be whiners and hypochondriacts and wires and overly needy and overly emotional and
- 15:56ridiculous. And it's golly, it's not a good movie to represent clampitting.
- 16:03It's really funny, it's hard to watch. Um. I mean, it
- 16:07has some funny moments, but I don't know. I'm just so I'm just
- 16:11so fucking tired of Hollywood fucking up our industry. Oh yeah, it's just
- 16:18so bad. I mean, have you seen Shrinking? I think it is
- 16:21on I think it's on Apple TV. Have you seen it? I've seen
- 16:25some of it. The first episode with the senior therapist is Harrison Ford,
- 16:29right, I mean, I can't watch that. People have been asking me
- 16:32to watch that show and do reaction videos to it, and I might,
- 16:34But that first episode, I was just screaming at the television. The main
- 16:40therapist guy, this Jason Siegel, is a complete idiot. He's just a
- 16:45complete idiot. And okay, but but I'm like, okay, fine,
- 16:49are there complete idiot therapists? Yes? Okay, but every time, Hollywood,
- 16:55every time, we're always idiots. They don't write they really well because
- 17:00I think most writers probably don't understand it or our society loves to laugh at
- 17:06therapists and clients. But but so fine, you know that, Yeah,
- 17:10that shows a comedy as opposed to something else. But I'm fine, okay.
- 17:12You know, you have a portrayal of a therapist that is kind of
- 17:17possible, a burnt out, angry therapist that is lashing out of his clients.
- 17:22Fine, but they do a montage of clients that he has twenty I
- 17:26don't know, fifteen different clients I don't know in the first episode. And
- 17:30they're all idiots. They're all complainers. Oh yeah, they're all hypochondriacts and
- 17:37whiners, people who complain about dumb Yeah. You know, so my my
- 17:42my friend wanted me to go to a party and I didn't have anything to
- 17:48wear, so, you know, stuff like that. That's not an example,
- 17:52but it was in that vein every client. So fine, you want
- 17:55to make a show about an unethical therapist, they exist, and you're contrasting
- 18:00that with his colleagues played by I can't remember the woman's name, the actress
- 18:04who was on The Daily Show, I believe, and then Harrison Ford,
- 18:08who are also looking at Jason Seagle going like, what's wrong with you.
- 18:12Okay, but you're going to stigmatize clients too. It's just ridiculous. Now,
- 18:18I will say just a little bit. I did watch where he starts
- 18:22to provide in the field therapy for this young black man who has a violence
- 18:29problem. That was fine. A lot of people will attack him for that,
- 18:33like, you know, he takes them to a boxing gym. Now,
- 18:37of course, you would have to make sure that you have a lot
- 18:40of consent forms that are signed before you do such a thing. But that's
- 18:45not unheard of in the field. You've done in the field stuff where you
- 18:48go into the bathroom with a client and have him literally lick or I don't
- 18:52know what, do you have him do a toilet seat or something. Oh,
- 18:55we rubbed my lunch on the toilet seat. We both ate it.
- 18:56Yeah. So you say that to a group of people, be like that's
- 19:00unethical, it's unprofessional, it's criminal or whatever, and you're like, no,
- 19:03that's that's standard every therapist. That's standard. Yeah, if you're treating
- 19:07OCD or a phobia that around germs, that's that's one of the options.
- 19:12Everyone understands that. It's written in the books. It's called exposure therapy.
- 19:17It's what works, taking someone to the gym to have them try another outlet
- 19:22for their physical contact or I don't know. That would be harder to justify
- 19:27because there's some research suggesting that if you actually engage in violence as a way
- 19:33of purging your anger, you can actually amplify risk of committing violence in the
- 19:38future. But it's kind of mixed. It's kind of a mixed bag.
- 19:42At the very least, there's a long tradition of therapists who do experiential therapies
- 19:48gestalts, Whittaker satire. You could point somewhere in that general direction and say,
- 19:53like, it's not unheard of to think outside the box and see if
- 19:57it works. I went to a public the therapist one or were the client
- 20:00wants for to do? What so that he'd get you used to talking to
- 20:03men? Okay, yeah, so we went to a pub. Don want
- 20:07to hit on them or as a just to be friends. No, No,
- 20:11he wanted to have rheumantic relationship and he was nervous about speaking to men.
- 20:15So we went to a pub and he talked to them, and then
- 20:18I went to church with them. It was just sort of funny that I
- 20:22would do that, but I did, and it funny because I'm an atheist.
- 20:26Yeah, but I wasn't there because of God, it or anything.
- 20:29I won't hit you when you walked in. No, no, civil went
- 20:32okay, But we were there just monitoring his level of anxiety about being in
- 20:36a room full of people at church, which he really wanted to attend.
- 20:40I just stayed with them and checked in with him periodically about every two three
- 20:44minutes, how's your anxiety right now? How's it right now? And we
- 20:47didn't do it verbally because I would interrupt listening, just just by hand signals
- 20:51like how's it now, and he'd give me an indication with his hand about
- 20:53was it high or low or whatever. Yeah. So to be clear,
- 20:57he wasn't just like I want to meet dudes. He had a phobia about
- 21:02socializing social anxiety, and the treatment for that is exposure. Yeah, it's
- 21:07the only way. Yeah, cognitive therapy can work. Cognitive behavioral therapy can
- 21:11work, but the main behavioral intervention is habituation to the stimulus so that the
- 21:18body no longer has traumatic or fearful associations with that stimulus. Yeah. Okay,
- 21:25So we got way off track, mostly because of me. So it's
- 21:27take a break, we get back, let's continue what you say. Yep,
- 21:34all right, back from the break. So again, we have a
- 21:37counselor three years of experience working with a woman in her twenties DBT borderline,
- 21:45and she gave the client her cell phone number. And the way you describe
- 21:51the typical DBT approach is that it is pretty buttoned up, it's pretty focused,
- 21:56pretty professional, but there's some wiggle room there that if a client wanted
- 22:02to well, let me, let me ask you this. So and of
- 22:03course you don't know every DBT practitioner, but you were trained and you did
- 22:07work alongside a lot of these people for for many years. Yeah, meaning
- 22:11that you did the DBT skills class for decades, but you never did this
- 22:18side of therapy where you were that. I did a little earlier in my
- 22:22career, and then I stopped doing individual DBT. So let's see when was
- 22:27that. That would have been two thousand and four or five, and I
- 22:32stuck pretty much just the teaching skills, but I worked alongside individual therapists and
- 22:37I sat on a console team that met weekly, so I would hear a
- 22:41lot about the students and there were students to me, and they were clients
- 22:44to the therapists, and you'd hear about the phone and the texting image train.
- 22:48Why did you stop doing the individual portion? I had a client that
- 22:53killed herself, and I didn't want to assume that responsibility. And my person
- 23:00life was such that I wasn't available in the way that I thought a person
- 23:03would need if they had those kind of crises. So I just stopped doing
- 23:08that kind of work. That's that one client that You've only had one client
- 23:12that killed herself, right, and you hadn't seen her for a few weeks
- 23:18or months or something, you know, I well, I way, it's
- 23:22a long time now, it's almost twenty years, or maybe this twenty years.
- 23:26I think you were in the window place, if I remember, I
- 23:29was. I was that and I moved there when I in two thousand four,
- 23:34no, two thousand and three, somewhere in there in Greenwood, Yeah,
- 23:38in Greenwood, And that was that winner was whenever she and it was
- 23:44sort of like you meet with her one time and then boom, she kills
- 23:48herself. No, I met with her over a period of months. I
- 23:49mean you met with her for a session and then like a few days later,
- 23:55she kills herself something like that, And did you know she was at
- 23:59risk? I know we've talked about this before, but I had a different
- 24:02impression in my head. But did you know she was at risk? I
- 24:06don't remember if I knew that there was imminent risk. Though. When she
- 24:10started therapy with me, she told me that she intended to kill herself unless
- 24:15some circumstance in her life changed, but she didn't expect that it would.
- 24:19So the longer the short of it is pretty up there in terms of risk,
- 24:25but not imminent meaning that you would need to take. If I knew
- 24:30she were at risk, I would have moved heaven and earth to try to
- 24:34keep her safe. But I got a call from a neighbor that she had
- 24:38left a note for me then and with my phone number in the neighbor rang
- 24:42me when he found her. I don't know, we've talked about this before,
- 24:47but I feel like you're tearing up a little bit thinking about her.
- 24:51I was awful. Yeah, Look, I the truth is my personal life
- 24:55has set up such that I don't have the time or I don't have the
- 25:00I can't do that kind of work anymore. But I would in any ways
- 25:03that that was I'll never work with suicidal people again, not knowingly anyways,
- 25:10in any capacity. I mean, you know, people have thoughts. It's
- 25:12no big deal to have thoughts. And if somebody, if I had a
- 25:15client and that they hit a patch, I would stay with them. But
- 25:21for folks that who come into therapy with self harm or suicidal behavior, thoughts
- 25:30that sort of thing, I'll refer them to somebody else. But now it's
- 25:33all couples. Anyways, So did you blame yourself or is it just hard
- 25:37because it was hard to lose a client. There's always blame. Yeah,
- 25:42And the most helpful thing anybody said to me was my friend Katie said to
- 25:45me, she's man, one of the best therapists I've ever met DBT person.
- 25:51She's like, you know, when this happens, there's two possibilities.
- 25:55There's either the therapy failed or the therapist failed, which means we don't have
- 25:59therapy. Actually that will help everybody. So it might be that the therapy
- 26:03is it's great and it can't capture everybody. That would be the therapy failing,
- 26:08and then the therapist failing would mean that the therapist didn't follow the protocol,
- 26:14and that's what led to the person's death. So, I mean it's
- 26:18a bit of a I appreciate that point of view. I don't agree with
- 26:23it entirely, as long as you understand that no therapy it could be expected
- 26:30to be successful one hundred percent of the time, given the amount of variables
- 26:33that therapy or the therapists have no control over it exactly. There will never
- 26:38have a therapy that can cure everything. But that's just out of reach.
- 26:42You can just do better. So that of reason, though, is so
- 26:47that we don't get involved in blaming clients, right, well, yeah,
- 26:51or the therapist. But I don't know. I mean, it just kind
- 26:53of depends. Obviously. Obviously some therapists can be partially blamed. Sometimes clients
- 26:57can be partially make mistakes. So I think your question was what happened for
- 27:03me? Did I make a mistake? I honestly don't remember. Yeah,
- 27:07it's a long time ago. It was, yeah, And it's not like
- 27:10I like remembering the last time I were talking about this was years ago.
- 27:14Yeah, it was. I remember concluding that there was nothing you could have
- 27:18done, and I'm getting it mixed up. You know. It's kind of
- 27:22odd because I have a lot of therapist client, therapist colleagues and therapist clients
- 27:26for that matter. And I can only think of a handful of therapists who
- 27:33have lost a client to suicide, which is I think notable of two things.
- 27:38One the sort of therapists that I hang out with, and the focus
- 27:41is that they have professionally if you're a psychiatrist, or you work with people
- 27:48who are depressed, and there's going to be a greater likelihood, or you're
- 27:51a DBT individual therapist. So are you saying that none of your class students
- 27:56were have also completed suicide? Okay, this person, you are as connected
- 28:03to the person this this one. I had an individual client that killed herself,
- 28:08but not a but not outside of that one person, just one person
- 28:12in your class in in two two two, So someone in your class,
- 28:18one of them or two of them? Uh, two people that I taught
- 28:23DBT skills to committee killed themselves. So you had one client and two students.
- 28:30Yes, I died by suicide, and that was how did that feel?
- 28:34Awful? And um? Really, um man? Was I watching my
- 28:41students because that is that is a hell of a thing for them to stand
- 28:45next to. So um, meaning that they could be prompted to do it
- 28:51themselves exactly, and that did not happen. I'm grateful to say I need
- 28:56either time. And they were lovely and the individual therapist that was working with
- 29:03them. You worked with that individual therapist as well, and they were more
- 29:07front and center with the client around that. Well, let let me let
- 29:11me think the first one, yes, but the client I think only she
- 29:18did an intake and started treatment and then dropped out, drop dropped out,
- 29:23and the therapist made effort to reach her, but they hadn't had an established
- 29:26relationship. And then the client really did disappear, didn't respond, and then
- 29:32we read in the newspaper. Oh, you thought she just terminated or something,
- 29:37Yeah, well she did. And then we read in the newspaper some
- 29:40months later that she had killed herself some weeks or months. I can't remember
- 29:45the timing. The second one, I don't think I was working with the
- 29:48individual therapist. I don't think they were. We weren't. They weren't on
- 29:52our consult team, so I didn't. I don't. I'm even having a
- 29:56hard time remembering which didn't do you get contacted by anyone afterwards, because that's
- 30:04the I guess one of the concerns for us therapist is that will get sued
- 30:10or someone will blame us, or I don't know, did anyone do anything
- 30:14like that in all three cases for you. In in the case of my
- 30:18individual client, the neighbor contacted me and I had some phone calls with her
- 30:23because there was a memorial and I wanted to participate in it. And I
- 30:29reached out to my client's brother, whom she was as strange. She had
- 30:33two siblings, since she was a strange from both of them, and I
- 30:37reached out to one of them to offer my canolence, and I think I
- 30:44left a voicemail and they never called me back, probably overwhelmed with memorial stuff
- 30:51or who knows, who knows. They weren't at the memorial, her family
- 30:53weren't there. Heard the people that were there were her work friends. And
- 30:56you didn't go, oh no, I went, oh you did go.
- 31:00Yeah. I went with Emily, my co co leader, and she was
- 31:06cremated, and what she wanted was for us to spread her ashes at this
- 31:10park near her home she lived in she lived across the Sound, and us
- 31:14meaning you you specifically named no, not me specifically, but the people that
- 31:19were more she wanted her ashes to spread at this park, and we just
- 31:23several of us showed up. How many I don't know, maybe twenty and
- 31:27it was who who was it? Friends and friends and neighbors. Yeah,
- 31:33and not her family. I never met her family now yeah, so um,
- 31:37we each took part of her ashes and spread them in this park,
- 31:41which isn't legal, but it also is dangerous. So um which park is
- 31:45I don't recall in Seattle somewhere. No, No, it's across the sound
- 31:48oh Penezula. Yeah yeah, yeah, yeah, the whole spreading of ashes
- 31:55thing, It's like, what's the big deal. I don't know. I
- 31:57think it's just a taboo about death that we have. I think so too,
- 32:01like let it go. Yeah, so obviously, you know, don't
- 32:06just spray it into someone's picnic basket or something. But if you're just sprinkling
- 32:10it in the water or on in a field somewhere, like, it's just
- 32:16it's just dust. If you see cremate cremated now, sometimes cremated remains can
- 32:22have bits of bone, and so she had that too. Maybe people should
- 32:29be a little mindful of that because you don't want you don't want to be
- 32:31spreading that in an area where people would put down a picnic. Yeah,
- 32:36because that would be a little terrifying. Honestly, when I think about it,
- 32:38he'd be like, oh my god, was there a murder that took
- 32:40place right here? Do I call the authorities? So there'd be some thoughts
- 32:45of that, but yeah, I find the whole it's mostly benign. Yeah.
- 32:50I don't understand our society when it comes to stuff like that. So
- 32:53we did, and um, I was grateful and my friend went with me.
- 32:58Yeah, it's a hard Yeah, you're attached to her. I mean
- 33:00you you you liked her, I cared about her. Yeah, she's a
- 33:05lovely person, just really really tormented you work? Did you work? Were
- 33:09you in the trenches with her with her depression and suicide? N Yeah?
- 33:14Yeah. Did these experiences, particularly this one, damage you? Yeah?
- 33:20How so I don't work with suicidal people anymore. Um. I perhaps could
- 33:25have done that because it's too painful. It's too painful. I just do
- 33:30not want to feel the risk. So as a DBT skills trainer, the
- 33:37protocols real simple. It's like individual therapists do everything and the skills trainer's only
- 33:43job is to show up and teach. The class and keep that class running
- 33:45properly. So I got real good at that, but I didn't have any
- 33:50responsibility forum the welfare weell being of the students outside of the class time.
- 33:57So um, I could do that and feel safe enough. Yeah, it's
- 34:02interesting because for myself, I only had one client that died by suicide and
- 34:08I hadn't met him yet. He died the morning of our very first appointment,
- 34:13so I wasn't attached to the person. I had met the parents.
- 34:20It was a like an eighteen year old kid, and I heard about it
- 34:24afterwards because the parents came in, but I never met the kid himself,
- 34:30so I don't know what it's like. I've obviously worked with a lot of
- 34:32acutely suicidal clients over the years, of various different degrees, and I'm supervised
- 34:39a lot of people with suicidal clients, and I don't know if I've ever
- 34:44supervised a therapist who had a client die by suicide, though not to my
- 34:50knowledge. I think i'd remember something like that and it's yeah, it's awful,
- 34:54and I don't know if I would be that as affected. I might
- 35:00go to to a memorial. I might, I would probably cry. I
- 35:05would probably feel all the feelings. I would feel ashamed of myself and guilty
- 35:10and angry and scared. I was scared, scared and distancing myself, and
- 35:16yeah, hyper vigilant. But I don't know. If I don't know,
- 35:21you'd never know what you'd do in a situation like that. But I just
- 35:23have a feeling that because I've I've when I've had clients who were acutely suicidal,
- 35:29I've ran through my mind, what if they do in fact follow through?
- 35:34Not only have I done everything I need to do professionally, but how
- 35:37would I feel emotionally? So I don't know, and I've also hopefully never
- 35:43find out. Yeah, I've also worked with a lot of supervises on this
- 35:46question. It isn't important yeah, milestone and supervision and mentorship that I find
- 35:54that I don't know. I'd say sixty seventy percent of supervises needed tremendous amount
- 36:00of paradigm shifting when they have their first client that is ongoingly suicidal. I've
- 36:07even worked with therapists that were twenty years into their profession and they've yet to
- 36:14paradigm shift. You know, they're overly concerned, they take too much responsibility,
- 36:20They worry and fret all week long. It ruins their life. And
- 36:24so maybe through that I have drawn a boundary in my mind, because I'm
- 36:30often trying to help my bentees and my consultees and my superviss to draw boundary
- 36:36of be like, look, care, that's great, you care, you
- 36:38have compassion, You're a human being. It's goods. It's why you became
- 36:44a therapist. And if you continue to open your heart in this particular way,
- 36:49you don't have to close off your heart completely, but if you continue
- 36:52to open your heart in this full way with these particular kinds of clients,
- 36:57you'll burn out and you'll never be good for any therapist or your family or
- 37:00yourself, and you'll like for you, for example, like, it's totally
- 37:06fine, you made that boundary, but there's a possibility that there are a
- 37:09lot of clients out there that could have benefited from your work that you didn't
- 37:15do again. I you know, if I were your if I were there,
- 37:19even just as a friend, I would have thrown out there at some
- 37:22point of just like there is a pathway to recovery and to get back on
- 37:27the horse. As they think, yeah, if you want, you know
- 37:30what I mean? Everyone goes through this to some degree, and it's an
- 37:35option, So yeah, that's totally legit too. Yeah, so I will
- 37:43do a lot of that work with a therapists, not just obviously if a
- 37:46client dies, but in prep because of the anxiety and the over responsibility that
- 37:52kicks in when there's a risk is harmful to the therapists, harmful to the
- 37:57client because the client isn't getting the best therapist that they deserve. So yeah,
- 38:01I think maybe because of all that that I've done, I would imagine
- 38:07that if I did have a client that died by suicide, that I would
- 38:08I don't think I would. I don't know. I would have grief,
- 38:14I would cry about it, maybe even twenty years later, but I don't
- 38:17know if I would stop working with folks with suicidal Yeah. It's sad,
- 38:23but I did everything I could and I knew that this was a possibility,
- 38:27and that's what I do with my supervisees. As I say, when you
- 38:30signed it to be a therapist and you agreed to treat people that might have
- 38:36suicidal thoughts, you signed up for the possibility that one of your clients will
- 38:39die by suicide. I don't think I understood it. Yeah, And of
- 38:45course, on paper, every therapist understands that. Just on paper, that's
- 38:49all I understood intellectually, yeah, but in terms of their soul they did
- 38:53not accept. And I'm guessing that for physicians there's a very similar thing.
- 39:00When they sign up, they intellectually understand that one of their patients is going
- 39:04to die right there in front of them, right, but they didn't really
- 39:07let it sink in necessarily that a client is going to die right before.
- 39:12If you're a police officer or a first responder, right, of course you
- 39:15know that intellectually these things are gonna happen. But did you really fully wrestle
- 39:19with or you're a soldier, did you fully wrestle with the reality of shooting
- 39:24someone and killing someone? Right? And again it doesn't make it easy,
- 39:29but that journey is I think critical for our survival in this field. Yeah.
- 39:36So yeah, but anyway, yeah, I don't I don't want to
- 39:38downplay the pain that you went through, and it's certainly fine that you've made
- 39:40that choice. I'm cool with it. Yeah. So anyway, do we
- 39:45want to do the letter? Yeah? I didn't take a break actually,
- 39:51and then wake it back. Let's continued, Okay, we're back from the
- 39:57break. So getting back to the telephone calls to the DBT solo practice,
- 40:04you know, the individual therapist and DBT it does it also, so of
- 40:08course it includes non suicidal self injury risks. So they are having an upswing
- 40:16and motivation to cut, for example, and they are encouraged to call or
- 40:22text to get some crisis treatment on the spot so that they can reduce target
- 40:28behaviors. What other sort of target behaviors are possible in a DBT class and
- 40:34help me get the question? Well, are all quote unquote target behaviors?
- 40:37Cutting? Oh? Well, life threatening would be the first order business like
- 40:45what m so? Cutting? Cutting is increases the likelihood of premature and death
- 40:51either that episode or some future episodes, So you definitely want to get get
- 40:54it under control. So um, but life life threatening behaviors are the first
- 41:00priority. And what's another example besides cutting? Burning? So just non suicidal
- 41:06stelf injury? Yeah, not actual suicidal thoughts that they're both of a piece,
- 41:10they're both considered the first first priority. So if someone says I'm thinking
- 41:15about killing myself, I bought a gun, they should call oh yeah,
- 41:21or I got my gun back from my uncle or something. Right, then
- 41:25it's all in that category. Yeah, what if it was I'm thinking about
- 41:30getting back with my ex husband he called me, and I'm thinking about calling
- 41:32it back. So I'm not sure. You mean like if they were in
- 41:37a relationship but there was violence, right if or it's just a bad toxic
- 41:44relationship so to speak, and the therapist and the client agree that they probably
- 41:49shouldn't go back to their ex husband. Is that something they're supposed to call
- 41:52or text in between? Well, a client can call or text, you
- 41:58know, anytime they want. Let's see. I'm trying to I'm just trying
- 42:00to think how would a therapist handle something like that, because coaching calls aren't
- 42:06supposed to be they're supposed to be very short. They're not supposed to be
- 42:09a phone session. So a reminder of skills, yeah, a reor what's
- 42:15happening? Okay, what skills? Okay, go go do and I'll see
- 42:20you on Tuesday, or if we need to, you know, let's check
- 42:22in in a day or an hour or whatever it seems you know, appropriate
- 42:27for the for the moment. But if a client wanted to get back together
- 42:30with an X, I think I'd probably I think a DBT therapist would say,
- 42:34let's let's save that for our session, because we really let's we want
- 42:37to talk about Thanks for letting me know, let's talk about that in our
- 42:39session. Okay, not necessarily, there's not a skill that's needed in a
- 42:44moment like that, Okay, I don't think. Yeah, Well, the
- 42:46reason why I'm drilling down on this is because this ethics case has to do
- 42:51with what sort of things you talk about on these calls. Calls. That's
- 42:54that's why we went down this whole road. Oh okay, right on,
- 42:58So just reading this graphic. As part of the counsel's treatment for the client's
- 43:01BPD that included DBT, the counselor gave the client her cell phone number.
- 43:06Typically, in DBT, telephonic consul stations between counselor and the client allow the
- 43:12client to receive in the moment guidance that can help them apply the skills they
- 43:15have learned in therapy and everyday situations, especially during times of crisis. However,
- 43:20in the counselor's case, she simply encouraged the client to quote unquote text
- 43:23her anytime, so it's hard to know what went down with that, but
- 43:30I think that was at least used against the counselor here. But that's hard
- 43:35to because that's essentially what you're saying is the protocol is text me any time.
- 43:39But maybe it was in a context of text me about anything anytime,
- 43:45which would not be the protocol, right, I don't know. Marcia used
- 43:49to talk about when she would travel, the first day she would get to
- 43:52wherever she went, she would buy a bunch of postcards and send them to
- 43:58her clients so that they knew that she was thinking of them. Right,
- 44:00So, so ways in which you those are attachment strategies. So text anytime
- 44:07is potentially an attachment strategy. It might also be ignorant, you know,
- 44:10like the therapists didn't really understand DBT DBTS. That's there's a lot of nooks
- 44:16and crannies there. So, But but I can see as an attachment strategy
- 44:22someone might say something like that. You could also see a lawyer or a
- 44:27judge or a licensing review board not really understanding oh or having a different orientation.
- 44:36Absolutely. Yeah. And by the way, for those who don't know,
- 44:37Marsha is referring to Marshall Linahan, the famous and infamous founder of DBT,
- 44:45a very respected person here at the University of Washington anyway, So uh
- 44:52yeah, yeah, yeah, and I'm a proponent of that. You know,
- 44:55if people have attachment injuries, particularly you know, of the sort that
- 45:00is like borderline or histrionic or narcissistic or any of the personality sorts, aside
- 45:05from any social maybe even any social But the point is the fastest way to
- 45:09healing and the fastest way to symptom reduction is to have secure attachment, to
- 45:15have earned security. And however we get there, then that's how we get
- 45:19there, as long as we're not harming anyone. And the typical treatment plan
- 45:24is one hour a week therapy, which can be definitely facilitative of that,
- 45:30but ideally it's daily with a secure individual and therapists and therapy as an industry
- 45:39is just not really set up for that. It can be prohibitive regarding money,
- 45:45right, but you know, I wish that there was more flexibility around
- 45:47that. You know, you could, for example, the online therapy models
- 45:52that are out there. The better helps the talk spaces. These therapists depending
- 45:58will sometimes be available will twice a day Monday through Friday, maybe even more
- 46:02than that, and it's not an hour every time, but it's five minutes
- 46:07every time, and you know there's a possibility that that could be more rapid
- 46:14healing. And because you know, I would have borderline clients that would they
- 46:19would tell me that there was a cycle in between every session. They were
- 46:22replenished in our session and that night and maybe the next day. But then
- 46:27two days, three days, four days later, they started to a downward
- 46:30spiral and they started to go into this distorted space where they think that I'm
- 46:36I don't really care about them, and then they get angry, and then
- 46:37they start to distance themselves, and then by the time the morning of the
- 46:40session, they're like, I'm not going to see that fucker. He's not
- 46:44even here for me. He doesn't even really like me. He's trying to
- 46:45get rid of me. And then they forced themselves to come to therapy,
- 46:50and then it takes about half an hour to get them back into the zone.
- 46:53And then they're just like, you know what, I did it again
- 46:55this week. I entered that hole of a of assuming things and I don't
- 47:00why do I do that? And then it happened all over again. You
- 47:04know, we just we just plow our way through it. It would take
- 47:07years. But you can imagine another model where you spread that hour out,
- 47:12or you pay for two or three hours a week and you spread that over
- 47:15time that you might be able to stave off though, because those downward spiral
- 47:17moments you could argue, cause further damage, you know, create a space
- 47:22of reinforcing that vibe of I'm abandonable, no one loves me. And so
- 47:30Marshall Lenahan recognize that, perhaps because I think she admitted she she's on somewhere
- 47:35on the borderline spectrum right and recognizes that that is the best treatment bottle,
- 47:42and we don't have to follow some old school understanding of what therapy is supposed
- 47:45to always look like. And so the contact in between sessions is not just
- 47:52to check in on relapse preventions, so to speak, but also to facilitate
- 47:57attachment. That that's Marshall Lenahan's specific proposal, and the DBT therapists may or
- 48:06may not follow that. It sounds like I think most most of them,
- 48:09least the ones that in famil with do okay. And you know people will
- 48:15say, how do you draw boundaries? Well, you know, you just
- 48:16do it. And my friend Christina does not take calls after nine. Yeah,
- 48:21and she's a great DBT person. Yeah. And you know, you
- 48:22get you get good at if a client's particularly callie and wants to chat way
- 48:30longer than what is helpful or what is reasonable. God, I have good
- 48:34boundaries. It's like, if you're good for five minutes, then you got
- 48:38to hold to that, and you tell them and you just say, hey,
- 48:40you know, I'm really you could call and we'll chat for five minutes
- 48:44and and that's just my limit. And I do that with everyone and no
- 48:49offense. So you know, but feel free to call and I'm here at
- 48:52you know, we can check in. But I just understand that that's that's
- 48:57the limit here, just because otherwise I would I would always be working,
- 49:00and I would never have my own free time or my own I wouldn't be
- 49:04able to do chores or anything. Right, So, and you know,
- 49:07if you do it in a loving way, in a sterian way, then
- 49:12you know, you pull it off and clients might struggle with it, but
- 49:15you talk about it anyway. So you know, I'm wondering if this whole
- 49:21case is partially based on a bias against outside of the box treatment, Well,
- 49:27what happened? So let's read. At first, the client would only
- 49:30contact the counselor to help her avoid engaging in dysfunctional behaviors, probably cutting.
- 49:36But eventually the client began texting the counselor frequently throughout the day for casual conversations.
- 49:43Okay, I don't know what that means, but the client was initiating
- 49:46more casual So I'm guessing like, oh my god, my boss did it
- 49:51again or whatever, rather than addressing the client's therapy interfering behavior. So,
- 49:57rather than addressing the clients the therapy interfering behavior, that's a DBT jargon.
- 50:02Oh it is, Yeah, that's a that's a that's a DBT phrase.
- 50:07Yes, Oh what does it mean? You mean? Is that any behavior
- 50:09that either the client or the therapist is doing that get in the way of
- 50:13the therapy. So showing up late for a session is a therapy interviewing and
- 50:15behavior be rating your therapist because the potentially a therapy interfreing being. Potentially it
- 50:22doesn't necessarily or therapist be rating a client. That's that's therapy interfreing behavior.
- 50:28Um, it's anything that gets in the way of therapy goals. Yeah,
- 50:32So it's a crappy term. It is. It's really judgmental. I'm sure
- 50:38that DBT therapists pull it off in a way that isn't judgment because they don't
- 50:43have judgment about it. But it sounds I've never liked it. It just
- 50:46sounds crappy. I mean, I've never heard it before, but when I
- 50:49read it here, I'm like, yesh, I mean, the client is
- 50:53just wanting to reach out and there was, at least in terms of this
- 50:59summary, either there was no discrete recommendation or boundary given by the therapist.
- 51:06So the client is just being friendly potentially or wanting more contact when it was
- 51:13an open door policy essentially. So what's what's the problem. Why is it
- 51:17interfering with and how is it interfering with therapy? Yeah, rather than addressing
- 51:22the client's therapy interfering behavior, the counselor and the client began engaging in a
- 51:27close personal friendship. The client and the therapist began engaging in a close personal
- 51:32The counselor and client texted almost almost daily as they were close in age and
- 51:38had many interests and hobbies in common. So again, you say this to
- 51:44the general public, even general public therapists, you know, therapists in general,
- 51:49and they're going to be like, that's crossing the line. But given
- 51:52out all the things you're saying about the practice of DBT, I don't know,
- 51:57like we'd have to see the nature of the Yeah, of the text
- 52:00sounds fishy to me, because what if the therapist determines like Marshall Anahan,
- 52:07I mean, Marshall Anahan was sending postcards just saying hey, I care about
- 52:10you. That's that's what friends do. Um though, I don't think that
- 52:15she would engage with Oh you like quilting too, Yeah, let's go quilting
- 52:20together. She wouldn't do that. Well, what if it was just like
- 52:23a text just you know, and the client therapist talked about how the client
- 52:30really wanted to get back into quilting and consider that to be returning to herself,
- 52:35and the client texts would be like I did it. Look at this
- 52:39quilt I made, and the therapists like, it looks great. I'm so
- 52:43glad. Right, So if you look at that, you're like, well,
- 52:45that's a close personal friendship. You don't you don't do that with the
- 52:47therapist. But I wouldn't look at it that way. I would think when
- 52:52I when I hear this, but I hear is the therapist saying, hey,
- 52:55look at the quilt I made, right, or you know, but
- 52:58we don't know. Hey, what do you think about me taking my own
- 53:00quoting class? Right? We don't know that. That's how I that's how
- 53:04I hear it. So right, it sounds dicey to me. Could be?
- 53:07Could be? Could be? And then the fact that they point out
- 53:10that they're close in age and had many interests Okay, I mean hard hard
- 53:14to know. I wish they gave example. In addition, they began regularly
- 53:16socializing and exercising together. Oh yeah, I wouldn't do that. Yeah,
- 53:21okay, So now, so now we've crossed the line because normally I read
- 53:28these beforehand and know where we're headed. But I didn't even know where we
- 53:30were headed. Oh yeah, they began socializing and exercising together. Yikes,
- 53:37the counselor. And so let's drill down on why that's back, because you
- 53:40know, I think it's even so one the lay public, they'll be like,
- 53:44you're not supposed to do that, right, But I would say ninety
- 53:46eight percent of therapists they see that, they're like, that's wrong. And
- 53:50then when I asked them like my students, how is it wrong? They
- 53:53will have no answer. They'll say, well, it's inappropriate. Okay,
- 53:57why is it? Well it's unethical? Well why is it? Well it's
- 54:00breaking a boundary? But why like what boundary? What are we talking about?
- 54:04So why is it considered unethical? In all likelihood to regularly socialize,
- 54:10meaning just hanging out together and chatting outside of therapy and exercising together. It
- 54:17sets up the possibility that there's going to be erupture that could have been avoided
- 54:22by not engaging on this level. Okay, that's one that if, for
- 54:27example, the client or the therapist starts talking about their own politics or something,
- 54:32or the client asked the therapists to date, or the client asked the
- 54:37therapist to come to her birthday party and the therapist is like, well I
- 54:42can't do that, and she's like, well, I thought we were friends.
- 54:45So it creates a much greater likelihood of yea of erupture happening. Or
- 54:51if at some point the therapist just decides to downsize their clients and decides to
- 54:57terminate with them, or the client has recovered and the therapist is like,
- 55:00okay, we're terminating. And also I'm no longer your friend. You know,
- 55:04that could be really hurtful. What's another reason as to why we would
- 55:07avoid this, Well, that's all I got right now. Well, at
- 55:10harm treatment is another major umbrella. There's a lot of possibilities in there that
- 55:16for example, the client could stop seeing the therapist as a therapist and more
- 55:21as a friend. When you have friends, you're concerned much more about their
- 55:27feelings, you know much more about Yeah, and as a for example,
- 55:31just in terms of we were talking about earlier, the client might run into
- 55:36an urge to cut, but knows that the therapist is stressed out about work.
- 55:40Because the client knows that the therapist is overworked and struggling with her mom
- 55:47that's in and out of the hospital and is lonely, and thus the client's
- 55:52like, well, I don't want to text her with my little stupid urge
- 55:57to cut, so I'm not going to do that. Or the client might
- 56:01in session want to really focus on our own issues but would feel bad by
- 56:07dominating the conversation because they have an expectation of friendship. So there's a lot
- 56:10of different things that can come up around treatment being compromised. So that's why
- 56:16it's unethical, and there are other things we could talk about too. That's
- 56:20why we're concerned with what we call dual or multiple roles. It doesn't necessarily
- 56:25mean that it's unethical, but it raises a lot of risk and it's unnecessary
- 56:30as a therapist. You should have other people to socialize with an exercise with,
- 56:34Yes, you don't need your clients. Nope. The counselor and the
- 56:38counselor and client gave each other pet names, with the counselor repeatedly telling the
- 56:43client that she was her friend and that she loved her, so explicit statements
- 56:50of you are my friend and I love you. Now, could a therapist
- 56:55legitimately tell a client that they love them. I've told my clients that I
- 56:59love them, so saying that you love your client. But again, you
- 57:01say it to the general public, or you say it even to a lot
- 57:05of other therapies, they are going to gasp. Yeah, they'll say that's
- 57:08inappropriate. You can't tell your client that you love them. And it's like,
- 57:12okay, show me the ethical code or the book that says you can
- 57:15never say I love you too. We're part of therapy is fostering earned secure
- 57:22attachment and that's not about love. Come on. Yeah, Now, in
- 57:27the context of all this other detail, Yeah, yeah, no, don't
- 57:30get me wrong. I think there's something going on here that's definitely a problem.
- 57:32Yeah, yeah, particularly when we have regularly socializing and exercising. Really
- 57:38even just one time socializing and exercising. Unless there was a real clear clinical
- 57:44treatment plan aspect to it, yeah, then likely in this case. Yeah.
- 57:49The client also visited the counselor in the hospital. Following the counselor's emergency
- 57:53app endectomy, the client visited the counselor in the hospital after again, not
- 58:00a slam dunk, but you know, in light of everything, it's a
- 58:05problem. And of course I would never have a client come to me in
- 58:08the hospital. That would be just I'm weird. Yeah, I just can't
- 58:15imagine how that would ever happen. After the client's estranged father suddenly passed away,
- 58:21the client began to withdraw from the counselor, ignoring her text messages and
- 58:25missing appointments. The client also began to relapse and engage and disordered eating practices,
- 58:31and which is consistent with anorexia nervosa as the client as a client's eating
- 58:37disorder and BBD became worse, she stopped taking her antipressants. The counselor became
- 58:43increasingly frustrated with the client and allowed her frustration to be evident in her communications
- 58:49with the client. The counselor texted the patient messages such as, I can't
- 58:52help you if you won't help yourself, or I feel like I'm wasting my
- 58:57time talking to you. So yeah, pretty awful. Yeah. One day,
- 59:02as the client was driving herself home from work, she lost consciousness.
- 59:07The client had barely eaten anything for several days. Her car veered off the
- 59:12road and eventually came to a stop when it hit a treat The client was
- 59:15taken to a local hospital had admitted for treatment and observation for the minor injuries
- 59:21she sustained in the car accident. When the client's mother came to visit the
- 59:24client in the hospital, she saw multiple text messages come through from the counselor
- 59:30on the client's phone. After the client's mother became aware of the extent of
- 59:34the relationship between the client counselor, she and the client later filed a complaint
- 59:38against the counselor with the state Licensing Board. So yeah, I'm I'm just
- 59:43envisiting that in my head that you know, the client has been I don't
- 59:46know, indoctrinated or participated willingly in this boundary crossing. You could argue that,
- 59:54I mean, you wouldn't just argue, you would state that the therapist
- 59:58should be much more mindful that boundary. But at that point the client might
- 1:00:02not recognize that something is a skew. And then all these texts are coming
- 1:00:07through and the mom just notices like who is that? And you know and
- 1:00:12is that your So that's your therapist that doesn't look like a therapist kind of
- 1:00:15text and then starts to look into it and it's like, whoa, so
- 1:00:21this is your therapist, okay, and you're worse off than you were before
- 1:00:28you went into treatment, Like something's going on here, and you know,
- 1:00:31who knows. It's hard to know causality this, this could have happened regardless,
- 1:00:36but it does raise that possibility, right right, No, yeah,
- 1:00:39for sure, Like how would her ethical boundary violations? How could that have
- 1:00:45been a causal factor in the symptoms reemerging? Well, therapy isn't. I
- 1:00:53can imagine therapy not being focused on the reasons that a person showed up for
- 1:00:58therapy, if we're exercising together, or if we're you know, it just
- 1:01:02seems like the focus has become something other than why did the client hire the
- 1:01:07therapist in the first place. Maybe they hired them to get the eating disorder
- 1:01:12under control. Well, they're not paying attention to that anymore, right,
- 1:01:15And the therapist is not behaving in a way that promotes the therapist is engaging
- 1:01:22in therapy interfering behavior big time here. So they're doing they're doing things that
- 1:01:27actually get in the way of the initial goals that the two set together to
- 1:01:31you know. So uh yeah, this is uh, this is off the
- 1:01:36rails. Yeah, I mean, what if the client had died? Oh
- 1:01:40yeah, the therapists could be held morally liable, if not legally and ethically.
- 1:01:45I mean, my goodness, this is why you don't do this kind
- 1:01:49of stuff, right, all right? Board investigation, this is the state
- 1:01:53licensing board in the United States. The client and her mother accused the counselor
- 1:01:58of violating professional boundary is by engaging in a personal relationship with the client.
- 1:02:01Yeah. The state Licensing Board complaint also asserted that the counselor mishandled the transference
- 1:02:07phenomenon between herself and the client and failed to provide proper care for the patience.
- 1:02:13Borderline persone sort. So I'm just chiming. I'm guessing if they identified
- 1:02:19transference, they are either implying or there was a lot of evidence pointing towards
- 1:02:22that the client was sucking the therapist in and the therapist just went along with
- 1:02:29it, you know. You know, in terms of what we're talking about
- 1:02:31before, a lot of people with abandonment traumas will have a lot of need,
- 1:02:37a lot of transference to their therapists. It's well understood, as well
- 1:02:42known, it's expected. In fact, if you don't see it with someone
- 1:02:45like this, you should actually wonder about what you're doing because the therapeutic relationship
- 1:02:50hasn't progressed to a point where that starts to emerge. It you could be
- 1:02:53argued it's a failing of the therapist if there's no transference that's happening, so
- 1:02:59it's unders and to go along with it and to cause more problems anyway.
- 1:03:05Yeah, I mean, just think about for this borderline client, the betrayal
- 1:03:08and then the reticence to going to therapy again. Anyway, The licensing board
- 1:03:15investigators requested the counselor's client healthcare information records, billing records, and her personal
- 1:03:22mobile phone records. As part of the investigation, The board investigators also conducted
- 1:03:28interviews with the client and her mother. The client stated that the counselor exacerbated
- 1:03:32her mental health problems and stress, which contributed to her eating disorder relapse.
- 1:03:37The client also told investigators that the counselor prolonged the client's emotional distress with the
- 1:03:43counselor's ongoing attempts to contact her after she terminated their professional and personal relationship.
- 1:03:47Oh, I think I missed that part. They didn't write that part before.
- 1:03:52So the client terminated, and yet the therapist kept reaching out to the
- 1:04:00like those texts, right, you know, I feel like I'm wasting my
- 1:04:05time talking to you that kind of thing. That's pretty aggressive. Yeah,
- 1:04:09yes, Now, I think maybe some people might be thinking, well,
- 1:04:15isn't this a product of her being just three years postgrad? Might be h
- 1:04:23well, I don't know. I've seen people well into their career do this
- 1:04:27as well. Oh yeah, yeah, no, no, right right right,
- 1:04:29I think she's swinging without a net, like she's what she needs.
- 1:04:32What a good DBT therapist would have would be a treatment team. Yeah,
- 1:04:35and a treatment team would help her manage her own responses countertransference. Really though
- 1:04:45they don't say that in DBT. So that she's behaving in a way that
- 1:04:48promotes good therapy, and so she just didn't have it. It sounds like
- 1:04:53she didn't have a team. She was trying it on her own. Maybe
- 1:04:55she lives in a small community and there's enough the therapists of like mind to
- 1:04:59start a but yeah, yeah, right, no guidance, bad supervision.
- 1:05:04Who knows, But I don't know. I suspect that there's additional characterological problems
- 1:05:12with this with this therapist. Yeah, I agree, who knows, But
- 1:05:16when an inexperienced therapist goes off the rails, it doesn't look like this,
- 1:05:23you know what I mean, Like a typical inexperienced therapist who didn't have a
- 1:05:28treatment team, who didn't have good supervision. There's so many red flags that
- 1:05:33even an inexperienced, unsupported therapist would say, like, I don't think I'm
- 1:05:38supposed to be doing this, and yet she still did it. Yeah,
- 1:05:42right, right, right, I agreed. Often I find when I actually
- 1:05:45look into situations like this, it's narcissism, it's borderline themselves without even they
- 1:05:51don't even know their borderline, that kind of thing. And so in other
- 1:05:56words, massive levels of need that are not being that aren't being met in
- 1:06:00other ways, and also massive levels of distortion. Like with the narcissism,
- 1:06:05it's like, well I can, I could do this, you know,
- 1:06:09I don't need to follow the rules because I know better than the whole system.
- 1:06:15You know. I see that in some therapist sometimes in particularly therapists that
- 1:06:17break this rule, this boundary. They just have this idea, this like
- 1:06:23but I want to and so and I'm I'm superior anyway, and I'm really
- 1:06:28superior because I'm the clinician. So I get to do whatever I want to
- 1:06:31and there's really no consequence to that. Yeah, it's pretty awful. Yeah,
- 1:06:36who knows. I'm not diagnosing from AFAR, but I wouldn't be surprised.
- 1:06:40Okay. Resolution the board concluded that the counselor failed to safeguard the integrity
- 1:06:45of the counselor client relationship and place the counselor on probation for two years.
- 1:06:48Okay, so they put the counselor on probation. So this, you know,
- 1:06:55just reminding everyone that a licensing board can strip a license or at least
- 1:06:59suspend it for a while, but they didn't. Even in this situation,
- 1:07:03they didn't. Yeah, probation, does that mean like supervise? I think
- 1:07:09well so, as a part of the consent agreement with the board, the
- 1:07:12councilor was also ordered to pay twenty five hundred dollars in fines, so just
- 1:07:16twenty five hundred bucks and complete fifteen hours of continuing education in addition to other
- 1:07:23normally required continuing education courses. This matter took nearly three years to resolve and
- 1:07:30occurred more than eight thousand dollars in legal defense expenses. So what do you
- 1:07:33think about that sentencing? If you will, I don't think it's I don't
- 1:07:39think it seems to me that it's unlikely to actually protect the public from this
- 1:07:46therapist whatever's going on. Yeah, yeah, especially when you think about the
- 1:07:51other things available to a licensing port. Other typical things are supervision, required
- 1:07:58supervision. They didn't requit. What's probation? Do we even know what that
- 1:08:00means? I think it just means you're being watched essentially. How do they
- 1:08:04watch? Like? They don't say there's not a probation officer in situations like
- 1:08:10this, maybe there are check ins with the board. Maybe, I mean
- 1:08:14there's not listed. I don't know. I'm guessing it's like or if you
- 1:08:17commit another violation within those two years, oh right, then your license will
- 1:08:21be taken away or whoa can you imagine that? That's it is? You
- 1:08:26got to do fifteen hours of a class, pay these fines, and you're
- 1:08:30you're unnoticed for two years. If we if you show up, then we
- 1:08:33got problems. But otherwise, go ahead, Yeah, go forth. If
- 1:08:38you create, if you cause a problem, if you are on, if
- 1:08:41you create it, if you commit a violation, and if you get reported,
- 1:08:46right, you'd have to be reported, which is extremely rare. Even
- 1:08:50this old client didn't. It's likelihood, it's a likelihood that if the mother
- 1:08:55hadn't seen the text that this, no one would have reported because the client
- 1:08:59would have thought this was okay or ashamed or something, or didn't want to
- 1:09:03hurt their friend. So it's yeah, it's pretty insufficient. And and so
- 1:09:11there's two things. This one is this Like, on one hand, licensing
- 1:09:15boards I find can sometimes lack responsiveness to situations like this, and I wonder
- 1:09:25why that is. I wonder why is it that you are the buck stops
- 1:09:32with you. There's no higher you know, you have civil court, I
- 1:09:35suppose, and legal ramifications but not often. But in terms of the license,
- 1:09:42you're the end of the line. So if you don't do anything and
- 1:09:45the therapist continues to violate and harm the public, then what's on you?
- 1:09:50Especially if there were other things you could do? So what's the thinking?
- 1:09:56Why? What's the caution, what's the reticence? What's the hesitation to to
- 1:10:00increase the requirements? Because you can you can require a lot of things.
- 1:10:06The clinician could say, well, I forfeit my license because I don't want
- 1:10:10to do all those things. But you know, it's not hard to say,
- 1:10:15I mandate supervision. I also mandate not only just fifteen hours, but
- 1:10:20for the rest of your license, you have to attend this particular course,
- 1:10:26which is, you know, thirty hours a year or something UM finds whatever.
- 1:10:30You know, twenty five hundred dollars. It's not like therapists are typically
- 1:10:33rolling in dough, so you know, twenty five hundred could definitely sting if
- 1:10:39if and also just the three years of going through the process could also cause
- 1:10:44some issues. Stress for the for the therapist, so kind of like time
- 1:10:48served kind of a thing. But that's it, you know, it's there's
- 1:10:58also I think another layer that lycensing boards can impose, where the supervision involves
- 1:11:03actually checking in with all the clients, where the supervisor actually is paid by
- 1:11:10the therapist that committed the violation to not only supervise like an hour supervision a
- 1:11:14week, but also another hour a month, where the supervisor actually talks with
- 1:11:19the clients on the phone. It says, how are things going, Is
- 1:11:21there or any kind of issue you know, I'm not trying to interfere here
- 1:11:25about or the supervisor actually sits in sessions, or you know, just an
- 1:11:30ample because you know, an ethically violating therapist could lie to the supervisor and
- 1:11:35say everything's fine, right. Actually, we humans act in our own self
- 1:11:42interest, and that's a real possibility, and whatever led to this problem is
- 1:11:46probably still there for this therapist. So on one hand, there's a lot
- 1:11:53of situations where the board is underreacting. Yeah, and I don't this is
- 1:11:58just speculative. Of course, every state has a different set of board members,
- 1:12:02but I think there's this philosophy in some boards, maybe all of them.
- 1:12:08That they don't want the clinician maybe to sue them or something, or
- 1:12:15they think that clients are ridiculous, maybe they get a lot of ridiculous complaints
- 1:12:19and they just have a bias for clinicians, because that's often the assumption,
- 1:12:26like, well, the board must be like against clinicians, right, It's
- 1:12:29like internal affairs and a police department. It's like, well, those guys
- 1:12:32are those guys are anti cop, right, when they might actually be overtly
- 1:12:40pro cop in a lot of ways. You know, I also could be
- 1:12:44wrong in this that a lot of board members are former therapists themselves, or
- 1:12:46maybe current therapists should think they would be, wouldn't they I don't know.
- 1:12:50I don't quote me on that, but iagine being on one of those boards.
- 1:12:53Would you like to be on the licensing board? I mean, I
- 1:12:55think it would be interesting. Given how much I enjoy these kind of cases,
- 1:12:59I think if I had the time, I think it would be fascinating.
- 1:13:02Yeah. Yeah, I think it'd be pretty interesting to see how how
- 1:13:04it all works. And honestly, I would like to have conversations with some
- 1:13:10of these therapists and just be like, so, you know, this is
- 1:13:12not part of your sentence, but you're going to listen to me ramble for
- 1:13:15about twenty minutes about what I think went wrong, and I want to help
- 1:13:19you with this, right, it's not rambling at you for the sake of
- 1:13:23I want to hear myself. Or let's have a conversation, you know,
- 1:13:25about like what what went wrong here, because then we can actually apply,
- 1:13:31you know, a sanction that will actually help you to improve so that you
- 1:13:35can So I don't know if there's that kind of bias against the against the
- 1:13:40clients, or bias four therapists, or this over concern with making sure that
- 1:13:45there's enough therapists out there. I think sometimes that's part of it. They
- 1:13:49worry that there's a shortage of clinicians and they don't want to deprive the public
- 1:13:54of these clinics. I don't know. There's often bores will underreact, or
- 1:14:00we just hear about the times when they underreact. I'll tell you, I
- 1:14:02don't think I've ever heard of a board overreacting anecdotally where I thought, like
- 1:14:06whoa, that was not necessary. So I don't know, it just feels
- 1:14:12like it's so That's one thing. The other thing is is if you're a
- 1:14:15clinician, often without knowing what actually happens in situations like this. You'll have
- 1:14:21you know, the typical therapist that I talked to, they're terrified if they
- 1:14:26accept a five dollars gift card for Starbucks because they're worried that their license is
- 1:14:30going to be taken away. And so if you're one of those clinicians out
- 1:14:32there who has that very typical paranoia, let's remind ourselves of what actually happens
- 1:14:40when you commit overt, problematic, ongoing ethical violations that are demonstrated by pages
- 1:14:46and pages of text. There's just no way to avoid it, you know,
- 1:14:49because the therapist without this text record could say that didn't happen, or
- 1:14:55that's not the tone that I had. You know, I was following the
- 1:14:57DBT model and the client it's interpreted it. I didn't actually meet up with
- 1:15:01the client exercise. I don't know what she's talking about, you know,
- 1:15:03but there's this written record of the texts. And so even when you have
- 1:15:10all that going against you, and the client almost died as a result potentially
- 1:15:15of your of your unethical behavior behind the wheel in the hospital. In the
- 1:15:18hospital, and even with all that, the only thing that happens is a
- 1:15:24twenty five hundred dollars fine and fifteen hours of continuing ED, even though in
- 1:15:29a typical year you're probably going to get fifteen hours anyway, So this is
- 1:15:32just fifteen hours. So it's like it said, of fifteen hours that year,
- 1:15:35you take thirty and thirty hours, which some therapists do anyway. Some
- 1:15:40therapists get a lot of continuing ED just because they want to so, and
- 1:15:45it doesn't even say what sort of continuing it. I would assume it's it's
- 1:15:48ethical continuing it, but who knows the way it's written here is just like
- 1:15:51take any you could take on you know, therapeutic basket weaving or something,
- 1:15:57you know, as it has who knows. I'm guessing it to do with
- 1:16:00ethical education. But what if the insurer would drop her? Or can can
- 1:16:04the insurers actually make their own contingencies? Can they say, yeah, you
- 1:16:10can't have insurance with us unless you fill in the bank. I don't know,
- 1:16:14a good question, probably, but I don't think they worry about it
- 1:16:16because they only had to pay eight thousand dollars in legal defense expenses. You
- 1:16:21know, that's the malpractice part. So eight thousand dollars for malpractice. Yeah,
- 1:16:27it's pretty pretty low stakes considering all the all the premiums that they collect.
- 1:16:31Yeah, that's more in than going out and the bad press and bad
- 1:16:36publicity you would get if a therapist were to come out and say, like
- 1:16:41I thought malpractice insurance was supposed to help us, but I'm being penalized for
- 1:16:45this, you know, by my malpractice insurance, Like what's up with that?
- 1:16:47And then you'd lose other customers. So you know, there's with private
- 1:16:53malpractice insurance. They're interested in profit and so they need people to sign up
- 1:16:58and they need therapy to trust them and all that kind of stuff. So
- 1:17:00there's that tension there. Yeah, Hey, deserve listeners. It's just me
- 1:17:04recording right now. I'm editing this episode, and I thought I would make
- 1:17:10the rest of the episode for patrons only. We get into some personal stuff,
- 1:17:14and I thought it would be probably better just to have it for the
- 1:17:17patrons. And we've already been talking for long enough about the ethical situation.
- 1:17:23We also continue talking about the others, but we get into some specific things
- 1:17:27about our lives, so I thought I would make that patron only. So
- 1:17:30if you want to hear the rest of this episode's there's about an hour left
- 1:17:33of Bob and I talking, so become a patron now. Otherwise, please
- 1:17:39take care of yourself and know that you deserve it. You really, really do