Latest / Markets to Menus by ArrowStream / Corn, Beef, Golden Corral's Mission?
Transcript
- speaker-0: Our culture is deeply rooted in service, service to others, and that service extends beyond our four walls of our restaurants. Since our founding, we've focused on taking care of our guests and communities we serve. That commitment is reflected in initiatives like we do a military appreciation night, we sponsor Camp Corral, Project Healing Waters, GC Cares, all of which are built on the values of service, gratitude. Just caring for others. The generosity of our guests, our franchisees, our employees, our Golden Corral restaurants have raised like over $40 million to support military families, veterans through partnerships with organizations such as the Disabled American Veterans, Camp Corral, and Project HLA Waters. You asked earlier about how our purchasing team kind of works with that and how's that, right? So that culture translates into how our purchasing and distribution team operates. Serve our restaurants, but ensuring we have the right products, the right partners, the supply chain support needed to deliver really good guest experiences. speaker-2: Welcome to Markets to Menus. I'm your host, David Maloney. On today's episode, Aerostream senior commodity analyst John Goodwin joins me to break down the challenges facing the corn crop and the Trump administration's latest move to lower ground beef prices and whether it will actually work. Then Kelly Smith, Senior Vice President of Purchasing and Distribution at Golden Corral, shares how the iconic buffet brand not only survived COVID. But came out the other side stronger than ever. Today's episode is brought to you by Aerostream Commodity One, 40 years of experience paired with cutting-edge deep learning AI, helping a large portion of the food supply chain anticipate and execute through commodity volatility. Speaking of commodity volatility, let's get into the markets. Grain markets were firm last week and corn led the way. Most of these markets are trading 20% plus above a year ago. Part of this is due to the ProFarmer Crop Tour last week. Do we have a problem with this corn crop? We just might, which we're going to talk about more with John in a moment. Dairy markets, mixed. Cheese and butter pretty much range browned at engaging price levels. But check this out. Nonfat dry milk, nine week highs. We also got a milk production report on Friday, which continued to be encouraging. And chicken, output last week, roughly 1.5% up. Versus the same week last year. That's a far cry from the gains we saw earlier this year, however. Most of the markets were lower, two exceptions: boneless, skinless thighs and boneless, skinless breasts were firm, but still historically tractive. And don't look now, but chicken tenders last week had their lowest weekly average since February 2023. And also, table egg markets sharply lower last week. And pork production was Up 1.1% last week versus the prior week, down six tenths from the same week last year. Year-to-date output is up four tenths, and that's in due entirely to heavier hog weights. Most of the markets were lowered last week. Bellies and Hams led the way, falling 5% each last week alone. And the markets continue to trade well below year-ago levels. In beef, output last week up 1.1% from the prior week. Down 4.5% from the same week last year. Year to date, down 5%, due entirely to cattle slaughter, which is tracking a whopping 8% lower than last year. In the markets, both the choice and select boxed beef cutouts, think index of boxed beef markets, were higher last week, with Chucks and Loins leading the way. The cutouts are still down about 5% from this time last year. Two exceptions that are treat of markets that are trading above a year ago are briskets and ribs and the trim markets, mostly a soft undertone in those markets. And that includes the imported markets. On Friday, the Trump administration announced a deal to import beef at a discount. We're going to talk about that further here in a moment with John. And energy, markets continue to firm. Crude oil this month, it could have its highest monthly close in three months. Gasoline prices higher last week, nearly a dollar higher than this time last year. Diesel last week, twelve week highs, and nearly two dollars higher than this time last year. All right, John, the million dollar question. Do we have a problem with this corn crop? speaker-1: Yeah. Last week we had Pro Farmers Annual Crop Tour, which is a really well followed event, especially for corn and soybeans in the grain sector. And soybeans was kind of a snooze fester. I mean there were some interesting takeaways, but it ended up being pretty close to expectations once the final estimates were released on Friday. The big story was corn. I mean the state by state yield estimates came in below the USDA's expectations almost across the board. And yeah, when I say below the USDA's expectations, you kinda have to remember that there always is a difference between pro farmer's yield estimates and the USDA's pro farmer be the first people to tell you that. So I'm talking more about what the USDA expects how the USDA expects yield to perform year over year versus how pro farmer expects yield to perform year over year. So pro farmer twenty twenty five versus pro farmer twenty twenty six and USDA twenty twenty five versus USDA twenty twenty six. So that they're expecting larger year over year decreases in yield, I think, across the board. Maybe I think Minnesota was the only one who came in close to the USDA's expectations. So yeah, I'd say we do have a little bit of an issue. I think, you know, the weekly crop conditions, August crop production report kind of gave the trading maybe overinflated idea of how the supply side of the balance sheet is going to look in the new marketing year. And now I think the trades kind of trying to wrap their head around what those balance sheets are gonna look like if the USDA were to adopt something more similar to ProFarmers estimates in the September Wazdi and beyond. And yeah, corn was going into this crop tour with an already historically pretty tight balance sheet. So obviously it could get a lot tighter if these yield estimates are closer to reality. speaker-2: And not good news for those chicken producer margins we talked about in the last episode, huh? speaker-1: Yeah, sure already kind of under a lot of pressure anyways. speaker-2: Yeah. So eventful day on Friday, folks. Not only we get the pro farmer crop tour estimates, but Trump administration announced, or should we say, posted on social media a deal to import three hundred thousand metric tons of product for ground beef over the next ninety days at a twenty-five percent discount. Discount to what? We don't know a lot of the details are missing. This is just an announcement. Nothing's been executed yet, but it's widely accepted at this point that an executive order is going to be signed to suspending the twenty-six point four percent out of quota tariff on beef imports for ninety days. It sounds great, okay? But however, Australia and New Zealand, two of the largest US suppliers of imported lean trim, which goes into our hamburger here in the United States, already operate with generous quotas. And essentially zero tariffs to date. So that will limit the impact for them. Now, perhaps the biggest beneficiary will be Brazil. As they have a much smaller quota, we could see meaningful price relief from products from Brazil. But I can't help but think that the impact on the overall markets may be nominal. We already are importing record amounts of beef here in the United States. Further, the imported trim markets. Are trading at record discounts already to the domestic markets. So the incentive is there for those who can use imported trim to do so. And many of you know on a spec, particularly a hamburger spec, it can be sensitive to how much imported or frozen trims used in that product. I don't see many large buyers changing their spec for a temporary suspension. Of an import quota tariffs. So I think the impact potentially could be nominal on the markets. Now, let me say one other thing here. The tendency in the wholesale ground beef in the beef trim markets is to move lower in the fall. Case in point, beef 90s have averaged lower in December versus August in 10 of the last 12 years. 8119 ground beef, again, this is wholesale, averaged lower in December versus August in nine of the last 12 years. So potentially this could be claimed as a political win down the road. But remember, seasonally the tendency is for these markets to move lower. So lots of other stuff going on out there, right, John? I mean, we've talked a lot about hormuz, but there's some things going on in the Black Sea that are concerning. speaker-1: Yeah, I mean, I've heard a lot of people compare the Black Sea and its role in the wheat market to the Strait of Hormuz and it but it is a pretty apt comparison, to be honest. Russia's the world's largest wheat exporter has been for the past few years now. Ukraine is maybe they're a top ten exporter, maybe like sixth or seventh for this new marketing year. And I think maybe a little over a month ago at this point, you know, they started trading strikes on commercial shipping, damaging a lot of ports in the Black Sea, Sea of Azov connected to the Black Sea. So massive chunk. I mean, I think close to all of their export infrastructure for both Russia and Ukraine are offline right now, shut down. And despite this, I think the wheat market has been the weakest performer of the big three in the grand sector of the past month. And I heard someone say that the market doesn't really believe in supply shocks anymore ever since the initial spike in wheat prices following Russia's invasion of Ukraine in twenty twenty two. But I mean, at the same time, it's just I haven't seen anything to lead me to believe that we're gonna get some kind of diplomatic solution to these attacks coming anytime soon. I haven't been giving a reason to hope for that kind of thing yet. And it kind of seems like the market's not taking this as seriously as they probably should so far. But I mean, the longer we go without an agreement, I only imagine price will continue to climb from here. One thing that just came to me, I think yeah. The main thing is I think traders are waiting for the disruptions in the Black Sea to kind of show up in the US, affect our export sales. And that's fair. Like we already have pretty expensive wheat as a result of the really poor state of the hard red winter crop in the southern plains, something we've talked about a lot on this podcast. But if we do see a jump in export sales, I imagine prices will Start to shoot higher. speaker-2: All right, Tully, welcome to the show. Tell us a little bit about yourself. speaker-0: Hey, David. Hey, thank you so much for having me on. I really appreciate it. It's a privilege to be with you today. So Kelly Smith, Golden Corral Restaurants. I've been here for 35 years now. Started out washing dishes when I was in high school and then just stayed on, went through the management program, stayed on after high school, went through college and worked my way through a number of positions at through Golden Corral, mostly operations out in the field. I mean, at one point I had All the restaurants in Iowa, Nebraska, Missouri, Oklahoma, and Arkansas. I did a lot of traveling. I met my wife out there and traveling became less important, especially when children became part of the picture. So moved to North Carolina in 2008 and started doing supply chain work. Started out with equipment and then moved into purchasing. I've been doing that now for about 15 years. So it's been an honor and a privilege to work with such a great group as Golden Corral. speaker-2: And before we kind of step into that, that's a unique background, right? Being in operations. How did that extensive background in operations impact your role and your decision making is in supply chain? speaker-0: Great question. So I was on the receiving end of my supply chain that I manage today. So for many years, I knew what the challenges were. I also knew how to call balls and strikes on different things where what was real and what was not real. So as far as the challenges are concerned, I just knew late deliveries, shorts and outs. That was just a part of life as an operator. So getting into the role where I could manage and affect that environment. for our restaurant operators, I wanted to do better for them than what was done for me. So it very much impacted how we go to work on a daily basis. speaker-2: Yeah, that's very interesting because a couple episodes ago, I interviewed James Butler from Brinker, and he said he spends something like thirty percent of his time in the stores. So he can understand supply chain can understand who they're serving, which is the customers and the stores, the operators. speaker-0: Absolutely. Yeah. And I listened to that podcast and it was very interesting. I too spend a lot of time in our restaurants. Uh-huh. I visit our operators. I want to hear from them. When things are going well, I particularly want to hear what the challenges are. So we can come back to our team here and I work with some really great folks. Matt Ertle and Lee Snyder are some of the best in the business. And they're able to kind of translate a lot of the stuff that we see in the field into hacking. speaker-2: Good stuff. So as we jump in though, tell us a little bit about Golden Corral and quite honestly, what makes it so special that someone like yourself would stay there for 35 years? speaker-0: Great question. So for me, this is not a job. This is a mission. This is a purpose. So it's something that I started doing at a very young age. Like I said, I was sixteen years old washing dishes in high school. And that was my first real introduction to the restaurant industry. And it just became something I got good at. And what really makes the difference is the culture. Our culture is very deeply rooted in service. And that service is to our guests, that service is to our partners, our supplier partners, our service is to our franchisees, our service to the military. We do a lot of philanthropic work with the military. So it's just such a culture. It's less work, more family for us. speaker-2: Interesting. So maybe we take a step back and just in case somebody isn't familiar with Golden Crow, can you walk us through the restaurant? Because it's not your typical casual dining or QSR restaurant, right? speaker-0: Absolutely. So we are very proud that we are the nation's leader in the buffet industry. We have restaurants in 40 states, over 350 locations with restaurants under construction as we speak. We offer 150 choices on a daily basis. There's no competitor that we have in the industry that can say that. But we've got over 150 choices. Our goal is to be value leader. In fact, we own. variety, abundance, and value when it comes to serving our guests. That is something that we're very proud to say that there's no one else in the restaurant industry that can do what we do when it comes to giving our guests the ultimate variety. speaker-2: Yeah. And I think, at least from a personal standpoint for me, what strikes me about Golden Corral when you go in there is not just the breadth of the choices, but also there are foods in there, quite honestly, that I ate as a kid. Right? That's right. That bring back and I'll tell the story when I first went in there, for whatever reason I was ⁓ probably twenty five years ago, I ate cream chip beef on toast every time I was in there. Because that's what my grandmother made me, right? Right. And you really can't find that anywhere else. That's right. Right? So all those choices, and people would make fun of me because I was eating cream chip beef on toast. But it just brought me back to my grandmother, right? And that I think is something unique with Golden Corral. Speaking of unique, I mean, COVID happened, right? It did. And a lot of buffets, I mean, the restaurant industry struggled, buffets struggled considerably. Some of those buffets didn't make it. Why did Golden Corral make it? speaker-0: Yeah, that was a very challenging part of our history there. Yeah. It was a time when there was a lot of uncertainty. The news was broadcast almost daily. Don't go to church, don't go to gyms, don't go to bars, and don't go to buffets. We were specifically called out, our segment was. So we went from having over 350 locations open one day and then another day we were closed. Mm-hmm. So through a lot of the leadership, Lance Terneri, our CEO, just a fantastic leader. He worked with a lot of state organizations, federal government organizations, really lobbied to help the restaurant industry reopen and recover from the COVID closures that happened. Another thing that we realized very early on is that we had not done as well as we should have with our off-premise, our meals to go. Guests didn't think of us at the time as an off-premise meal occasion. So that didn't help us during that time. So we've worked really hard to become a much bigger player in the off-premise marketplace today than we were back then. speaker-2: Yeah. And it's true that Golden Corral's still found or owned, is that right? speaker-0: It is. We are privately held. We are founder owned. Mr. James Maynard, who founded our company, is still regularly involved in the business today. His daughter, Easter Maynard, is the chairman of our board and extremely involved in our business. And we are, again, very proud to be privately held. And we feel like that's an advantage for us in this marketplace. speaker-2: stuff. Okay. So let's transition to supply chain because sure. So what's your day like? Like I have to imagine with all 150 menu items, your skew count or the number of products that you're ordering is pretty broad. But what's your day like and how does the impact of all those products impact your day that might be different from let's just say a pizza shop or something like that. speaker-0: Sure. So I mentioned earlier we have 150 choices. So those 150 choices change on maybe a daily or weekly basis. And they could be different choices depending on the season, depending on what promotional window that we're in. Those 150 choices come from a database of almost a thousand recipes. So we have a fantastic food and beverage department led by Dr. Daryl Mickler and Deborah Olson. And all day, every day they just work on recipes, recipe variants, new things, things to help our guests see new products, whatever's trending, whatever's new. They work on that stuff. So I mean our operators are pulling from this large database. So inside that database we're probably seven hundred and fifty SKUs that make up those hundred and fifty items, right? Each thing has variable ingredients that help create each recipe. So my team really focuses on the top movers. So we may have 750 SKUs that we manage. Probably 30% of them we may only touch once a year, twice a year. Probably the middle 33% or whatever, we may touch once a month or once a quarter, whatever. But our top one-third of items we touch almost daily and weekly. And then when it comes to our top 50 items, where we really look at What our guests' favorite items and the ones that move the most to our system? You asked what my day was. I mean, every morning, myself and my team, we pull up inventory, we look at movement across our top, I guess, 50 items or so, and look for opportunities. Your company helps us with that. Aeroscream software, their tools that they offer us really help us kind of alert us to. Pricing issues. They alert us to stocks, out of stocks. They alert us to any potential things down the road. So that's a critical part of our day. speaker-2: Cool. Thank you. And thank you for being a longtime Aero Stream customer. Absolutely. And a longtime Commodity One American Restaurant Association customer, right? So what's your biggest challenge in your supply chain today, would you say? speaker-0: So the challenge is, and again, it's stuff that you help us with, but it's the commodities are not any easier to purchase today than they were 20 years ago, but there's just a lot more dynamics going on with them. Particularly beef. The American consumer loves beef. Some of your charts and graphs show me that. Our guests, Golden Crow guests, just love our steak. They love our meatloaf. They love our pot roast. So beef purchasing is probably the thing that keeps us up. most nights just to try to stay ahead of the historically small herd size. There's been some news of plant closures in the last week. There's just a lot of dynamics with it. So myself and my team, particularly me, we spend a lot of time on beef. But then just outside of that though, we try to make sure our products are relevant to our guests. Our items stale, we try to keep things new, relevant items that are Trending. So we're constantly trying to come up with new and exciting ways to delight our guests with different ways to prepare our proteins. So we do a lot of work with pork, we do a lot of work with chicken, a lot of work with shrimp and seafood. There's just a lot of work that we do to try to keep those items relevant. speaker-2: And has that changed with these record beef prices? speaker-0: It has and it hasn't. We've tried to focus on other items other than beef to try to make that offering again. We don't have the luxury of some of our competitors where they can engineer a plate, where they can engineer the cost and drive guests towards different items on their menu. We're all you can eat buffet. So we have to try to make our other proteins, our other offerings as attractive as possible on the buffet. speaker-2: Okay, cool. So there's some other challenges in the supply chain right now as well, right? Freight rates to fuel prices. If you had to grade the supply chain as a whole, where it's at, not Golden Corral, but just amongst the food service industry, what would you grade it and why? And it doesn't have to be a letter grade, just however you want grade it. speaker-0: That's a great question, David. I'd say that I'd probably give our supply chain probably a solid B minus. Okay. And the reason for that is and a lot of that happened during COVID because of and during and the after effects of COVID. Pre COVID, it was kind of a carnal sin for any supplier or distributor to short products for any reason. And then during COVID, the supply chain crunch that the world went through. It became commonplace and almost they got permission to be more laxed with fulfillment rates during COVID. And that honestly, that's kind of carried on. Folks have a little bit different attitude towards just-in-time delivery. It's a lot more lax than it used to be. We work with some fantastic partners, fantastic distributors, some great suppliers, great distributors. Some of these guys are some of the best people I've ever worked with. But at the same time, just the general shift in fulfillment has changed a lot since COVID happened. And where it used to be they would kill themselves to go out of their way to make sure a product arrived on time. Now it's kind of like we're short, we're sorry, please reorder. That seems to be more of the general attitude. speaker-2: Yeah. And I think at least since the beginning of COVID, right, distributors have probably gained more leverage in the supply chain. Is that fair? speaker-0: Agreed. Actually that's fair. speaker-2: So interesting. All right, Daley. So where's the supply chain headed? I mean, a lot going on in the supply chain, right? A lot of talk about AI, consolidation. You mentioned the Tyson plants announcing some closures and sales last week, labor. Like, what's the biggest structural shift you're watching and where do you think it's headed? speaker-0: Well, I mean, as far as our suppliers are concerned, there's a lot of consolidation. Consolidation is a huge shift. We've seen it with a number of large organizations recently where they've either consolidated divisions, eliminated divisions, or they've split off into several divisions. I think there's more and more of that happening today, and I think it's probably overdue. They're all just trying to match the marketplace and trying to work themselves into right size themselves into the right shape and size to match their customer base. We've also seen a big shift in organizations with line extensions. I mean if you've got a kettle operation, there's folks doing a lot more with that. Instead of making soups, they're doing a lot of things like they're moving into mac and cheese. They're moving into a lot of things. So you've got a lot of companies, a lot of supplier organizations shifting Into what their food service organizations would look for. I mentioned mac and cheese earlier. A few years ago, there were probably a handful, just a few companies that commercially made mac and cheese. Now there's 20 and probably some I've never heard of, but there's a lot of companies shifting into morphing into something that they once were and were known for, moving into something else. speaker-2: Interesting. So if I'm a listener and maybe I'm a smaller chain or an emerging chain and I don't have a supply chain team or much of a supply chain team, what advice would you give that operation today? speaker-0: Good question. So I guess first and foremost, you need a data partner. So another shout out to Aerostream. You guys have done a great job for us, but knowing what you're selling, where you're selling it, and how much you're selling it is critical. So that's something that myself and my team, we're a small team. I mentioned a couple of folks earlier, Matt and Lee. My team is three. So we manage over 700 SKUs, over 600 million in spend with three people. So the only way we're able to do that is because we have great tools at our disposal. So I guess for a small chain, that's the advice we really give is be able to see invoice level detail, be able to use do some modeling with your data to come up with some of your forecasts. All your forecasts will be wrong. Know that going into it, but at least you have good data and you have good reasoning behind why you made the decisions. And then the other thing I'd say is. Set your standards. If your standards are you're going to use this specification, you're going to ensure that all your restaurants are going to serve these products at this time. Enforce those standards. Set those standards, enforce those standards. But don't be afraid to break some of those non-negotiables from time to time. Be limber, be agile, be willing to change and go in different directions. I know a lot of older operators, they don't deal well with change. I mean they have to graduate beyond the whole who moved my cheese and to think of better and different ways of thinking. speaker-2: So but before we close, I listened to a podcast with your CEO about a year ago with Jonathan Mays and was just really impressed with the culture of the company and some of the stuff you do outside of food service. Well, I mean, I guess it's within food service, but to help people. Can you expound upon that for us? speaker-0: Yeah, good question. Thank you. And I'm really, really proud of this one. Our culture is deeply rooted in service, service to others. And that service extends beyond our four walls of our restaurants. Since our founding, we've focused on taking care of our guests and communities we serve. That commitment is reflected in initiatives like we do a military appreciation night, we sponsor Camp Corral, Project Healing Waters, GC CARES. All of which are built on the values of service, gratitude, just caring for others. The generosity of our guests, our franchisees, our employees, our Golden Corral restaurants have raised like over $40 million to support military families, veterans through partnerships with organizations such as the Disabled American Veterans, Camp Corral, and Project Healing Waters. You asked earlier about how our purchasing team kind of works with that. How's that leg, right? So That culture translates into how our purchasing and distribution team operates. We serve our restaurants by ensuring we have the right products, the right partners, the supply chain support needed to deliver really good guest experiences. speaker-2: Right. That's wonderful, Telly. Thank you for all that great work and wanna thank you for being on the show. speaker-0: Absolutely, David. Thank you so much for having me. speaker-2: That's wrap on today's episode of Markets to Menus. A big thank you to John Goodwin and Tully Smith for their time and insights. Always a pleasure. If you found today's conversation valuable, please take a moment to leave your review and share the episode with a colleague. And don't forget to visit Aerostream.com to learn more about Commodity One. 40 years of experience backed by cutting-edge deep learning AI built to help you stay ahead of commodity volatility. Until next time, I'm David Maloney. Thanks for listening.