Latest / Consumerpedia / 47 - Guide to Buying New Windows
Transcript
- 0:02It's fun to window shop, but in this episode we're shopping for
- 0:05Windows, and that's a lot of work.
- 0:07You know, today's windows are technological marvels.
- 0:10The frames and panes for even basic models provide much better
- 0:13insulation than the old configurations, reducing drafts
- 0:17and cutting home energy costs. Modern windows are also easier
- 0:20to clean. No need to teeter on
- 0:22highlighters. Simply tilt in or remove them
- 0:25and wash them inside your house. But these benefits come with
- 0:28very high price tax and checkbooks.
- 0:30Found that some companies abuse customers with high pressure
- 0:34sales tactics and substandard installations.
- 0:37I'm her Weisbaum, the consumer man, a contributing editor at
- 0:40checkbook.org. Welcome to
- 0:42consumerpedia@checkbook.org. We're the nonprofit that helps
- 0:46consumers select services, avoid trouble, and save money.
- 0:50Because we don't accept any advertising or take money from
- 0:52any business we recommend. You can rely on checkbook.org to
- 0:56be completely independent and objective.
- 0:59Now here's the host of Consumer Pedia America's consumer expert,
- 1:03the consumer Man Herb Y Spam. The type of windows you choose
- 1:07will affect your home's appearance, the amount of light
- 1:09that gets through, and your comfort.
- 1:11Plus, some windows last longer than others.
- 1:14Checkbooks executive Editor Kevin Brassler is here to
- 1:16explain your choices. Cut through the hype about
- 1:19expected energy savings and explain how to find a reliable
- 1:22contractor to install those new Windows.
- 1:25Hello, Herb. So if I were still on the radio,
- 1:27I would have started this segment with Johnny Nash.
- 1:30I can see clearly now and said something like buying windows is
- 1:34a pain, but Kevin Brassler is here to make it a painless
- 1:36process for us. And then the audio guy would
- 1:38have dropped in a rim shot and you would have left.
- 1:41Yeah, I'm not sure I can promise to make this an easy process.
- 1:46One thing we found, and we'll get into this, is that a lot of
- 1:49Winslow installation companies really have deceptive selling
- 1:53techniques. A lot of them do just terrible
- 1:56work also. And so you really do need to
- 1:58protect yourself. These are very expensive
- 2:00purchases these days, and you want to make sure that the
- 2:03installation work that's being done and the windows you're
- 2:05being sold are top quality. Absolutely.
- 2:08So let's start with the overall premise that energy savings is
- 2:12one of the big reasons why many homeowners replace their
- 2:14windows. So, reality check How much will
- 2:17new Windows reduce my energy bills?
- 2:19Yeah. One big problem is that a lot of
- 2:21window installers promise huge energy savings if you buy their
- 2:25products. Some even say things like, oh,
- 2:27you know, it's. Expensive, but it'll pay for
- 2:29itself because you're going to have the lower utility bills.
- 2:31And it's true, if you replace really old, really drafty
- 2:35Windows, you will see lower utility bills.
- 2:38But it's impossible for me to tell you know, listeners out
- 2:41there, oh, you know, on average you're going to save this much.
- 2:44Because how much you will save depends on your location, how
- 2:47much air leakage your old windows allow, the types of
- 2:51replacement windows you buy and select, and the quality of the
- 2:54installation itself matters too. If your old windows are really,
- 2:58really drafty and leaky, I mean it's possible you might save 2
- 3:02to $400.00 per year on energy costs, but most of us, we won't
- 3:06save nearly that much. So while this may be a smart
- 3:09purchase, there's no way the cost of new Windows are going to
- 3:11pay for themselves, which is what some companies claim.
- 3:14Right. They will save you on energy
- 3:16bills. I'm not arguing otherwise.
- 3:19But for most of us, you know, in terms of the cost benefit, it's
- 3:22really not even close. Even for those of us who live in
- 3:25areas with really cold winters and have really old and drafty
- 3:28windows, as I used to have in my old house, you're still not
- 3:32going to recoup the project costs of redoing all your
- 3:35windows. Even within 15 or 20 years?
- 3:38And is that because the windows are just simply so darn
- 3:40expensive? Yeah, I mean, it's really
- 3:42astonishing that new Windows are so expensive.
- 3:44We found when we shopped window installers that even you know
- 3:48the least expensive vinyl replacement windows often cost
- 3:51more than $500 each, and good quality of vinyl replacements
- 3:56costs between $750 and up, including installation per
- 4:01opening if you want top quality wood or composite windows.
- 4:05Which look and function better than vinyl ones, then you'll pay
- 4:08even double that. Some of those windows, they cost
- 4:11more than $2500 per opening. So even if you have a small home
- 4:16and and you replace only 12 windows, I mean your job's going
- 4:19to run you more than $8000. And, you know, so these fancy
- 4:23new Windows, you know they're not going to cut your energy
- 4:25costs by $8000 or triple that, depending on what you're buying.
- 4:30Over those windows lifetime, they will indeed save you
- 4:33energy, but not nearly as much to cover project costs.
- 4:36So just to be clear before we move along, if a window
- 4:38installation company claims huge energy savings, you got to
- 4:42beware. Yeah, I mean, it's possible that
- 4:44your old windows are so drafty that you will see huge energy
- 4:47savings. But when these companies tell
- 4:50customers, oh, you know this project, it'll pay for itself.
- 4:53I can't believe that's ever true anymore given the cost of new
- 4:57Windows. And this is a big problem in the
- 4:59industry is a lot of winds of installation.
- 5:02Companies are quite dishonest about energy savings and other
- 5:05matters. There's a lot of competition in
- 5:08this business, and many companies use questionable
- 5:11selling and marketing tactics. So another example is several
- 5:15years ago one contractor told my motherinlaw.
- 5:18That their products were unique, that they applied this coating
- 5:21to their windows that was used by NASA and the Empire State
- 5:25Building, and that no other companies could offer such a
- 5:28thing. And I'm still baffled as to why
- 5:30they thought, you know, the latter, the Empire State
- 5:32Building was so impressive. I mean, if you're going to say
- 5:34you installed them and the White House or the Pentagon, you know,
- 5:37not the thing King Kong climbed decades ago.
- 5:40I mean, it was just absurd. And it was complete BSI mean.
- 5:43Everything they said was completely untrue.
- 5:46It seemed good, but it wasn't true.
- 5:49And we also find that, you know, the window companies that
- 5:51advertise on the radio constantly in most metro areas,
- 5:56Those companies are especially notorious for making outlandish
- 5:59and false claims and for doing terrible work.
- 6:02You know, according to the ratings we collected, these
- 6:04really big outfits that advertise heavily for the most
- 6:07part, really kind of overwhelming that even for the
- 6:09most part don't get good ratings from their customers.
- 6:13And it's really important that you get good quality
- 6:15installation work. That work can greatly affect how
- 6:19long your windows hold up, how well they prevent drafts.
- 6:22It's just really important to select the right company for
- 6:24these types of projects. So obviously energy savings is
- 6:27only one reason why you might want to replace the windows.
- 6:30You may just have bad windows that are leaky, or look
- 6:33terrible, or falling apart, or you can't open and close, or
- 6:36whatever. For sure, and that's why I've
- 6:37replaced Windows before. I mean, if you have old windows
- 6:40that are drafty and they make rooms uncomfortable or they just
- 6:43look terrible. I mean, that's a good reason to
- 6:45replace your windows. And if you're looking to save
- 6:48energy, new Windows is not the place to start.
- 6:51As we discussed in Consumer Pedia episode Eight Ways to Save
- 6:54Energy at Home, there are a lot of simple repairs and
- 6:57improvements you can make that will yield big energy savings.
- 7:00Yeah, so I'm glad you were paying attention during that
- 7:03episode, Herb. Try to.
- 7:04As we discussed then, and as we discussed in our section on
- 7:07saving energy at home at checkbook.org.
- 7:10There are many projects that are geared towards saving energy
- 7:13that cost very little to do but yield big savings off utility
- 7:18bills. So for example, just making sure
- 7:20that you have weather stripping installed around all your
- 7:23exterior doors or if you have exposed ductwork that making
- 7:27sure that it's well sealed or even you know, buying and
- 7:30installing a programmable thermostat.
- 7:33Those things yield big, big savings and costs next to
- 7:36nothing to do. Things that require a little bit
- 7:38more spin, like improving your attic insulation, well, you know
- 7:41you're going to have to pay to do that, but the payback period
- 7:45in terms of recouping those costs is very fast.
- 7:49And these days, if you need to replace a furnace, you should
- 7:51definitely opt for an efficient model or consider buying a heat
- 7:55pump instead. The federal government will soon
- 7:57offer very generous rebates. To do that and many other
- 8:01projects. So what should you look for when
- 8:03buying new Windows? We're going to talk to Kevin
- 8:05about that next. I'm Herb Weisbaum, the consumer
- 8:08man, and this is Consumer Pedia, powered by checkbook.org.
- 8:12Want ratings for local window installers in your area?
- 8:15Checkbook has ratings for dozens of companies in and around these
- 8:18seven cities Boston, Chicago, Philadelphia, Seattle, San
- 8:23Francisco, Minneapolis, Saint Paul, and the Washington, DC
- 8:26area. To find out more, visit
- 8:28checkbook.org. Our advice is always free
- 8:31ratings of local services are available with a subscription.
- 8:35If you live in one of these seven areas and haven't joined
- 8:37Checkbook yet, check us out. Get your free 30 day
- 8:40subscription at checkbook.org/consumer Pedia.
- 8:44And if you like what you've heard, we hope you'll consider
- 8:46becoming a consumer pedia supporter by using the link at
- 8:49the bottom of the show notes to make a small contribution each
- 8:52month. All right, you've decided to buy
- 8:56new Windows. What should you be looking for,
- 8:58and are there ways to judge the quality of these products?
- 9:01Yeah, so one thing you shouldn't get too impressed about is if
- 9:04companies tell you that they manufacture their own windows.
- 9:07Lots of companies assemble windows themselves.
- 9:11The good news is that all windows sold today are required
- 9:13to be pretty energy efficient. They don't leak much air, and
- 9:17all of them are going to be of pretty high quality.
- 9:19So all new Windows, for example, they must consist of two panes
- 9:22of glass with some insulation in between to again meet the
- 9:26Department of Energy's requirements for new Windows.
- 9:29But among the different windows are available, there are still
- 9:32big differences. Vital windows.
- 9:34As I mentioned before, they're the least expensive types, but
- 9:37sometimes they don't look great. Wood windows, they look better,
- 9:41but companies often clad them in vinyl and so and they do that so
- 9:44they don't have to be painted each year.
- 9:46But then it kind of makes them look like vinyl windows.
- 9:50Some companies are also now selling composite windows.
- 9:52These are made of wood and other materials.
- 9:54These windows and high quality wood and vinyl ones.
- 9:57They look great. But in general, you know, the
- 10:00fancier the window, the better it looks, the more you're going
- 10:03to pay for them. Some windows cost each $2000 or
- 10:07more. Wow, that's a lot of money.
- 10:09So we often recommend consumers look at differences in
- 10:13warranties and guarantees when they're comparing products.
- 10:16That would definitely apply to Windows.
- 10:18Yeah, I mean, you know, depending on their construction,
- 10:20windows can last for decades or they can rot and fail within a
- 10:24few years. So it's really important to at
- 10:27least start out by checking consumers.
- 10:28Reports window ratings. They periodically test about a
- 10:32dozen best selling models for resistance to rain and wind.
- 10:36But the problem there is that Consumer Reports they test only
- 10:39a small number of models, and so you might have to do some
- 10:41homework on your own. One way to do that is to check
- 10:44guarantees. Better sealed window units tend
- 10:47to come with 20 year or longer warranties, and they don't
- 10:52prorate reductions in the covered value as time passes.
- 10:55So in other words, after 10 years, if you find a product
- 10:58defect, they're not going to pay you just half of what you pay
- 11:00for the windows. They'll actually pay to replace
- 11:02the windows themselves. The other thing to do is talk
- 11:05with Windows salespeople about durability.
- 11:08You know, try to talk with several installers and get their
- 11:11opinions on which window brands they find have been most
- 11:14reliable. A lot of times with energy
- 11:16saving sort of things, there are tax credits or incentives.
- 11:19Are there any tax incentives or credits for replacing Windows?
- 11:22There's a federal tax credit. It's equal to 30% of the cost of
- 11:27eligible improvements made during this year, all the way up
- 11:30to 2032. But.
- 11:33For Window and Skylight installs, the maximum annual
- 11:36credit is going to be $600.00 and to qualify for that credit
- 11:41you have to buy products that meet Energy Stars, which is a
- 11:43program of the Department of Energy.
- 11:46Its most efficient criteria, so the cost per window for those
- 11:50types of windows is pretty high. It's more than double that
- 11:53annual $600.00 tax credit app per window, right?
- 11:57So the maximum you can take per year is $600.00 for your
- 12:00project, and each window costs more than double that.
- 12:04So I guess you could, you know, replace just one window per year
- 12:07and takes the tax credit over and over again, you know,
- 12:10$600.00 per year. But you're gonna have a problem
- 12:13finding window companies willing to do that, you know, install
- 12:16one window per year. A lot of window companies, you
- 12:19know, they have four window minimums.
- 12:21They just don't want to deal with someone who wants to
- 12:23replace one window at a time. But I think it's notable that
- 12:26the government, the federal government, and most utilities
- 12:29really don't offer generous tax credits or other types of
- 12:32incentives and rebates for Windows.
- 12:35The reason is is that, again, the cost benefit doesn't make as
- 12:39much sense. Is making other improvements
- 12:41around your home geared toward energy savings?
- 12:44Interesting point you made because I always hear on the
- 12:46radio or see on TV we make our own windows here locally.
- 12:50It's not like you're buying produce that it's a big deal
- 12:52that it's coming locally. Is is it a better window if it's
- 12:55made locally? Is that something you should
- 12:56even consider? I mean, most window installers
- 13:01assemble windows themselves in their own shops and then bring
- 13:04it to you. Is that just puffery?
- 12:58Marketing puffery. I mean, these things have to be
- 13:07usually somewhat customized to fit your opening because homes
- 13:11have various different sized openings.
- 13:13And so, you know, it's not necessarily a mark of a good
- 13:16window or a good installer that they do that assembling work
- 13:19themselves. Most companies that specialize
- 13:22in window installations, especially for vinyl windows.
- 13:25Are doing that themselves. You really have to check and see
- 13:28how is it assembled. If it's a vinyl window, is
- 13:31everything fully fusion welded and it's a better quality window
- 13:35than simply windows that are screwed together.
- 13:38And so we're kind of getting into this technical jargon that
- 13:40we describe more at checkbook.org in terms of.
- 13:43You know ways to spot quality, but the fact that a company just
- 13:46assembles its own stuff doesn't mean much.
- 13:48So getting the right Windows is clearly important.
- 13:51So is finding a good installer. Some advice on how to do that?
- 13:54Straight ahead. I'm Herb Weisbaum and this is
- 13:57Consumerpedia, powered by checkbook.org.
- 14:01Consumerpedia Fast Facts The word window comes from Old
- 14:06Norse. It's a combination of vendor
- 14:08wind and Aga I. It literally translates to I
- 14:12hole. According to Wikipedia, the
- 14:14first known glass windows were produced by the Romans, who
- 14:17exploited a technology first developed in Roman Egypt.
- 14:21Those windows were extremely thick and almost impossible to
- 14:24see out of. It would be almost 1000 years
- 14:27before Windows became transparent, as they are today.
- 14:32Choosing a good installer is as important as choosing the right
- 14:35Windows window. Companies get a disturbing
- 14:38number of complaints, often for doing sloppy work, Kevin
- 14:41explained. So when we survey consumers
- 14:43about window installers they've used, we see really big
- 14:47variations and customer satisfaction scores among the
- 14:50various window companies that we evaluate more so than most other
- 14:54types of home services. I mean, some companies in this
- 14:58category get really highly favorable reviews from almost
- 15:01all the customers we survey, but many others get absolutely
- 15:06dreadful ratings. I mean, it is really crucial
- 15:09that you hire a contractor that will do good work and stand
- 15:12behind the products they provide and install, in addition to big
- 15:16differences in service quality among window installation
- 15:19companies. Our undercover shoppers found
- 15:21huge price differences when we asked them to quote on
- 15:25essentially the same installation jobs.
- 15:28So you must get several bids. At least three, but five is
- 15:32better from highly qualified companies.
- 15:35Doing this will ensure that you're not overpaying, that
- 15:37you're hiring a company that just simply charges high prices.
- 15:40We found that some companies for window installation work charge
- 15:443 or even 4 times more than others.
- 15:47For essentially the same windows and installation.
- 15:50So it sounds like from what you just said, for our listeners who
- 15:53don't live in the seven cities where Checkbook has ratings, you
- 15:56better take the time to make sure you got a good company.
- 15:58Check references, talk to other people who've had the work done,
- 16:01maybe check with a Better Business Bureau, something like
- 16:03that, to make sure you're not getting one of these guys that
- 16:05do lousy work. Yeah.
- 16:06I think it's crucial that you make sure, as when hiring any
- 16:09kind of contractor that's dealing with an outfit that will
- 16:13stand behind its work, that will offer you strong guarantees.
- 16:17And take other steps to make sure that you're protecting
- 16:20yourself from someone who will do lousy work.
- 16:22And in the case of window installers, as I keep saying,
- 16:25there are a lot of bad actors out there in terms of companies
- 16:30that just do terrible work. And as usual, checkbook found
- 16:33You can't assume that a high price indicates good work.
- 16:36We once again here found that the saying you get what you pay
- 16:39for is a myth when it comes to window installations.
- 16:43We found that great companies, those that get really high
- 16:45ratings from their customers in our surveys, that they were just
- 16:48as likely to quote low prices as high prices.
- 16:52The key is to identify good companies, which we did by
- 16:55surveying consumers. And then collect bids from
- 16:59several of those. Doing this will likely save you
- 17:02thousands of dollars on your job because companies just have
- 17:06highly variable pricing out there.
- 17:08And as with any home improvement job, before you agree to hire a
- 17:11company, get everything in writing, including any
- 17:13warranties or guarantees. Check to make sure the
- 17:16contractor carries liability and workers comp insurance coverage.
- 17:21And get a schedule estimate of when the job should start and
- 17:25finish. I mean, almost all window jobs
- 17:27can be done in just one day. Most can be done in just half a
- 17:31day. It's a pretty quick process, so
- 17:33there's no reason to have to pay anything more than a small
- 17:37deposit before work starts. It's not like they're going to
- 17:39be in your home for months and you need to pay them as they go.
- 17:43That doesn't apply here in terms of window installation work.
- 17:47And by withholding most of your payment until the work is
- 17:49complete, you maintain leverage to make sure the work gets done
- 17:53and is satisfactory to you before that final payment is
- 17:56made. It means that you get to say
- 17:58when the job is done. So if the contractor says we
- 18:01need a bunch of money up front because we're making these
- 18:03windows for you, you know they're custom made for your
- 18:05home, That's a red warning flag. Yeah, it means you're dealing
- 18:08with the wrong installation company.
- 18:09Good contractors should have good credit, and good
- 18:12contractors should be willing to, you know, extend themselves
- 18:16to you. And make you feel comfortable
- 18:18about the payment arrangements. And the best payment
- 18:20arrangements are those where you, the homeowner, gets to pay
- 18:24most the cost of the job at the end.
- 18:26So bottom line, this is a big purchase.
- 18:29It's a big project. You need to take the time to
- 18:31find the right windows and the right installer.
- 18:34Yeah. It's really important that you
- 18:35not get rushed. A lot of these companies, they
- 18:38have very sophisticated salespeople who come out and try
- 18:41to pressure you into something. As we mentioned before, a lot of
- 18:44these companies make promises that just aren't true or make
- 18:48claims that are false. It's really important to take
- 18:51your time. This is a really expensive
- 18:53purchase and treat it that way. Don't assume that a company just
- 18:56because it claims to have something unique or does great
- 18:59work or installed windows at the White House or the Empire State
- 19:02Building or some nonsense like that is gonna do good work for
- 19:07you. By the way, the first podcast
- 19:09you and I did together two years ago, Consumer Pedia Episode one
- 19:12is all about choosing a good contractor.
- 19:14So we're going to put a link in the show notes to make it easier
- 19:17for you, our listeners, to check it out.
- 19:18Kevin, I got to say, you did make it painless.
- 19:21Good job. Thank you.
- 19:23Thank you. Well, that's it for this edition
- 19:25of Consumer Pedia. We hope you'll rate this episode
- 19:28and follow us on Apple Podcast, Spotify, or wherever you listen
- 19:31to your podcast. Remember, we release new
- 19:34episodes every other Thursday. Another way you can support this
- 19:38show is to follow us on Consumer Pedia on Facebook and Instagram,
- 19:42and at my Consumer Pedia on Twitter.
- 19:44I'm her Weisbaum. Thanks for listening.
- 19:47Consumer Pedia is a public service of checkbook.org.
- 19:51We're a unique nonprofit that helps you save money and make
- 19:53smarter choices. You can count on Checkbook to
- 19:56help you find the best services and avoid the worst with local
- 19:59ratings that are accurate and unbiased.
- 20:02If you live in or around these seven cities and haven't joined
- 20:05Checkbook yet, check us out Boston, Chicago, Philadelphia,
- 20:10Seattle, San Francisco, Minneapolis, Saint Paul, and
- 20:13Washington DC To get your free 30 day subscription, go to
- 20:17checkbook.org/consumer Pedia. If you like what you've heard,
- 20:21we hope you'll become a supporter by using the link at
- 20:24the bottom of the show Notes to Make a small contribution each
- 20:27month. Consumer Pedia Empowering
- 20:29consumers to save money and make smarter choices.