Latest / Gaming The System - The Feminist Gaming Podcast / Lying and Duplicity Part 1 (Episode 301)
Transcript
- 0:15Hello, everyone.
- 0:15Welcome back to another episode of Gaming the System, the podcast where three intersectional feminists examine gaming and games through a feminist lens.
- 0:24Today, I am your host, Matt, and I'm joined by my friends Alex and Jem.
- 0:29Before we get started, if you want to support us, you can subscribe to our Patreon at patreon.com/gamingthesystem for some exclusive content, or you can send us a one-off donation via PayPal to our email address, wearegamingthesystem@gmail.com.
- 0:48So today we are going to be exploring the topic of lies, deception, and duplicity in gaming because not everyone is honest all the time, and dishonesty inside games is always a, a critical thing because without dishonesty and deception, there's no mystery.
- 1:09And if there's no mystery, then it's all gonna be very predictable.
- 1:15So there is certainly a positive place for deception, but there's also negative places.
- 1:22So we're gonna go through, uh, start off with our own relationships with lies, deception, and duplicity.
- 1:31How we all, uh, how we do it ourselves, if we do, how we react to it, and, uh, yeah, we'll see where we go.
- 1:42So to start off with, are either of you particularly good liars?
- 1:48Or deceivers or- I don't feel like I am because my face is very expressive, as I'm sure you guys have got to know, um, since we've been making this podcast together.
- 1:59I have trouble hiding my facial expressions.
- 2:02Um, so I do f- think I would be easy to spot if I had to lie for a prolonged period of time, uh, or be deceptive like in a social deduction game, for example.
- 2:16But I think everyone has an ability to tell the odd white lie every now and then, um, and kind of pass it off as, as something that's true.
- 2:27But I don't know if I feel...
- 2:29I definitely don't enjoy having to come up, having to lie or...
- 2:35'Cause if I have to come up with a lie that's not a white lie, then I feel a, a lot of pressure, and I find it very difficult.
- 2:43Um, and I'm generally quite an honest person.
- 2:46I think sometimes I feel like I'm too open and honest sometimes.
- 2:51Um, but that's just how I am.
- 2:54I like to tell people how I think and feel and, uh, and that.
- 2:59So yeah, I, I think I generally find...
- 3:02I find staying closed quite difficult.
- 3:06I don't know if that's the same as lying.
- 3:07No, it's not, is it?
- 3:08But it's an interesting topic, definitely.
- 3:12Did you say staying closed?
- 3:14Closed, yes.
- 3:15Yeah.
- 3:15So like, as in not having an opinion or- Or not, not sharing, not sharing how I f- how I feel about stuff or like, even if it's just mundane stuff like what, what holiday I'm planning next or like what I watched on TV the other night.
- 3:30Like, I, I tend to share it with people who I'm friends with and stuff because, you know.
- 3:36Or even like at work, you know.
- 3:38Some people are very, they have very strong boundaries between their work life and their personal life, but I think I'm relatively open, you know.
- 3:48And I don't know, I guess, I don't know if that feeds into how I feel about lying, but yeah.
- 3:56Mm.
- 3:56It's an interesting- Yeah.
- 3:58Yeah, that is interesting.
- 4:00I think I don't like lying.
- 4:03I, I ha- I feel really uncomfortable lying, but I'm s- can be surprisingly good at it which like often takes me by surprise because I feel a bit sort of like unco- yeah, uncomfortable at how good I can be at lying and how easily sometimes I can do it.
- 4:26And I'm a bit sort of like,"Oh." Um, I think it's be- I'm better at lying- In, in an, in a sort, in a moment as opposed to, you know, planning a lie.
- 4:40Um, but I, but I once, um, was told that the best way to tell a lie is to tell as much truth as possible around it so that the actual lie is, is a tiny, tiny part of the whole story.
- 4:59Um, partly because that makes it easier to be consistent and to maintain the lie going forward, but also because I think we all have quite good sense for when people are lying to us.
- 5:14And so the smaller the actual untruth can be, the better.
- 5:20So I feel, I feel like, yeah.
- 5:23But I don't like lying, so I don't do it very often, and it makes me feel really, really guilty and uncomfortable if I do.
- 5:32So I will often, if, if I've ever had to lie, I usually come clean at some point in the future.
- 5:40So I'm not very good at maintaining it What do you think about the parental lying to children?
- 5:48I think there is, I think there's definitely scenarios where it's necessary- Yeah to, to do that, where actually you are helping somebody in some way.
- 6:01Um, uh, I think that's very s- sort of specific circumstances where that's, that is the right thing to do.
- 6:09Overall, it, when it comes to bigger things, I think it's really important to tell the truth.
- 6:14Like, I think it's important to be honest about, um...
- 6:18You know, like I d- I don't like it when people won't argue in front of their children or, you know, cry in front of their children or show distress, because I think that there's, there is a balance, obviously.
- 6:33You shouldn't be having, like, you know, massive, full-blown scary fights in front of kids.
- 6:38That's, that's one thing.
- 6:39But showing a child that you can have an argument, then you can sort it out, then you can, you know, move on is, uh, is a really healthy way of sort of presenting the world.
- 6:51So I think there's, you know...
- 6:53But then I definitely told my daughter that Father Christmas was a thing and, you know, we, we tried to do the, um, uh, tooth fairy.
- 7:05She was much more suspicious about the tooth fairy.
- 7:08Um, and, you know, those sorts of things.
- 7:12And I don't feel, I don't feel ashamed of that because that's, that's about bringing wonder into somebody's life and, and- Mm magic, as far as I see it.
- 7:23I know there are lots of people out there who disagree but, um, yeah.
- 7:27So I think lying to your children is m- is very, it, it, whether it's right or not depends very much on the circumstances.
- 7:36The same as with a partner, you know, and it, there are times when, when, uh, you know, you'll, you'll say like,"No, you look fine," or or, you know,"That, that project, that, that, that decision that you made was exactly the right thing," you know, when maybe you don't think that.
- 7:53And you do that because it doesn't always need to be honesty.
- 7:58And also, just because I think something doesn't make it the truth.
- 8:02It ma- it ma- it makes it my truth, but it doesn't make it the truth.
- 8:05So yeah, I think it's very circumstantial.
- 8:10Situational definitely.
- 8:12I've, yeah, it's interesting when, um, you brought up the example of lying to partners about, like, how they look and stuff.
- 8:20I tend to be blunt with Tom, but he knows that's just how I am with him.
- 8:25Um, and he's fine because he's like,"Well, I'll do what I want." And I'm like,"Okay then, carry on." And then we're fine.
- 8:32But, uh, yeah, and I do feel bad sometimes when I'm like,"I should be nicer probably." Mm-hmm.
- 8:37I'm not horrible all the time, obviously.
- 8:40I just have set opinions about certain, uh, bits of attire that he has.
- 8:46And I'm like,"Are you sure that's appropriate?" That's kind of how I'll phrase it.
- 8:49And then I'll be like,"Actually, I need to just shut up and sit down." And then I'll be fine.
- 8:54Mm-hmm.
- 8:54Mm-hmm.
- 8:54Um, but yeah.
- 8:56It was funny.
- 8:57It did make me laugh when you said that,'cause I f- I, I, I think he, he would know if I said,"Oh, that looks fine." He'd know that I'm lying completely.
- 9:07Um-'cause he would just be able to tell that I wouldn't find it fine in any way.
- 9:12But yeah, I think we know each other too well to, to be able to tell when each of us is- Yeah covering what, how we really feel.
- 9:20Definitely.
- 9:21Yeah.
- 9:23Yeah.
- 9:24I've, I find I've got far too much very fucked up stuff in my head, thoughts and feelings about things that to try and- Just I find like omission and, uh, just holding, holding back certain things is my biggest thing because I don't need everyone to know everything inside my head.
- 10:02And I believe it doesn't matter what you think or feel, it matters how you treat other people.
- 10:12And the idea that I can, I can be a good person while having this-- I have an incredibly rich inner life, and I'm glad I have that.
- 10:29And I That, that c- that cuts both ways because it's always meant that I, I find communicating with people extremely difficult, and I have done a massive amount of work trying to change the way that I communicate, because I've always tried to come across as neutral, and'cause I felt like that was the safest way to be around other people.
- 11:08But I've recently come to the conclusion that, that, that's the worst way to be because it means that you just, you sort of, you'll just...
- 11:18You'll be a gray thing in, in the room, and that That I can...
- 11:31Actually, people might like me for the honest, the honest, well-communicated things that I, that I say.
- 11:39And what a revolutionary idea that is for me.
- 11:44And so an example was the other day when we were talking about Dungeon Crawler Carl, and from, like, the first sentence Jem said describing it, my first thought was,"That sounds awful." I still think you like it.
- 12:01And, and all the way, all the way through you and Alex talking about it at the start, I was...
- 12:07I'd go,"That sounds awful." And that's my, that's my, my truest thought and feeling, that that's the root.
- 12:17And I, I've...
- 12:18It's, it's, it's fascinating because I f- I feel incredibly strongly and think incredibly strongly about most things, and I've always tried to squash that down and not express that clearly so that I, I'm not offending anyone or upsetting anyone.
- 12:41But having that moment of, I'd say, like, that's my initial strong thought and feeling, and all the way through the two of you talking, I was listening and going,"How can I present this in a, uh, a neutral, non-offensive," like Not revealing way.
- 13:03And I got to the point where I, I was ready to speak, and it was a real wrench of will for me to just go,"It sounds awful," and have that, that clear starting my, my position as clearly as possible and as honestly as possible.
- 13:23So then the conversation we had after that really had my unique input- Mm into it.
- 13:32And- I think there's a, there's an element of trust, uh, that has to be in place in order to be able to do that as well- Yeah isn't there?
- 13:40Because it's like when you first meet people, you, you often sort of hold back on a lot of that, um, information and, and m- maybe- Which one?
- 13:53Oh, yeah keep your- I can jump on that one responses more neutral and say, um- And then y- and then you realize- I think she was gonna say when you first meet people- as you gain trust, um, in the other people you're trying to be...
- 14:02Oh, sorry, Jem.
- 14:02You, uh, you froze for some time there.
- 14:05Don't know- It...
- 14:05I, I keep, I, I keep freezing.
- 14:07I'm gonna, um, disconnect and come back.
- 14:09Mm.
- 14:10I don't know if there's an issue with my internet or- It's okay if there's an issue with, um, the connection to this.
- 14:16So what I'll do is log out and come back in again and see where we're at.
- 14:21Is that okay?
- 14:22Yeah.
- 14:23Yep.
- 14:24Go for it.
- 14:25Carry on, Ash.
- 14:25So, um, it's funny, when I was talking about how I am in work and being relatively open, that's with the people I get on well with at work.
- 14:33If it's people who are, like, acquaintances or just general, like, strangers or people who I want to make a good impression with, I will be what I like to call diplomatic 100% of the time- Mm which is not how I actually feel.
- 14:47But I will be that way because it's the least offensive way of being, and that I feel is definitely, um- rooted in the need to please people also, which is, you know, generally if you do it too much it can be quite unhealthy I think.
- 15:06Um, because, you know, you put a lot of pressure on yourself to, to be a certain way and to be quiet and calm and, uh, and go with the flow of the, of the general, general sort of consensus of things.
- 15:22But, um, so it's nice to have those spaces where people I'm closer with and who I have that trust with, where I can say how I really feel because I feel comfortable enough telling people how I really feel.
- 15:37Um- And that that's the way, that's the, that'll be the reason why people like spending time with you.
- 15:43Mm.
- 15:44Is that when you present that,'cause I always worry that my, my true self will horrify people and they'll run away from me screaming.
- 15:54Whereas the actual truth is that people, people like spending time...
- 16:01That, that, those, those insane things that I think might be shameful or, uh, or just, just whatever, they can actually be reasons people might like me.
- 16:13Mm.
- 16:14And I can, I have a very extreme sense of humor that, um- I'm, uh, it's just your sense of humor is something that y- you, you just have.
- 16:28That's, that's your sense of humor, and I, I always realize that I, I feel like I'm the only person in the world that has that, and if I share it with anyone, then they're gonna run away screaming from me.
- 16:44But then I realize that there are countless hundreds of millions of people that have my exact sense of humor, that if I was to reveal that sense of humor in its entirety to them, they would actually want to spend time with me as opposed to not wanting to spend time with me.
- 17:05And I had a really good moment in the I don't know if I've talked about on the podcast yet, the, uh, like, my first t- tabletop RPG game that I played a few weeks ago, which was a game called Paint the Town Red.
- 17:24And it was the game master, and me, and two others.
- 17:30And we got started, and like you said, Alex, with new people, I find y- you have to pace yourself as you f- as you get to know them, as you sort of'Cause I'm not, I'm not at that place where I can just come in and bluntly go,"Right.
- 17:49This is, this is all that I am," and come in, just come in and just come in like that.
- 17:56Um, and so we came through, and I, I, I am One of my things I'm proudest about is my imagination.
- 18:03I can, I can, I can go sort of off into the distance like With like just whenever really, and I really enjoy doing that.
- 18:15And this, the tabletop RPG is my, like, it's the perfect opportunity to really lean into that kind of creativity.
- 18:24But because it was people I haven't met yet, I wasn't sure, like, where the line might be.
- 18:30And fortunately, the, one of the guys who was, who was there came out at one point...
- 18:37So this is a vampire-based game, and I brought in, we were sneaking into a nightclub as, as separate characters.
- 18:45And I brought in, I snuck in, um, as one of the band'cause I stole a jazz flute, and then I went up on stage and sat behind him.
- 18:54He was a guitarist, and I leant the f- the flute by my chair and then went off to do my thing.
- 19:00And then this, this, uh, m- m- mess, uh, chaos actually erupted on the dance floor with all these vampires suddenly started attacking the mortals on the dance floor.
- 19:13And the games master said,"All your, the, all this blood and chaos is really making your vampiric urge come out, and you've got to roll a dice to try and repress that urge." And, uh, this guy rolled his dice and failed his one.
- 19:31So, and then the games master asked,"Right, how are you going to act out your extreme, like, vampire bloodlust?" And he said,"Right, I, I turn around and I see the flute.
- 19:44I pick up the flute and look around at the..." I think it was the bass player.
- 19:50"And I stab the throat, the, the flute into his neck and then start chugging blood through the flute." And that is my, that, that is just utterly my kind of thing that I find creative and funny and surprising.
- 20:11And so immediately that set the bar of I going, right, if he's h- if he finds that, if that, he and the games master, I'm not entirely sure how the other person felt about it, but the games master and him find that funny and, and surprising and just good fun.
- 20:28And so that gave me that, that line in the sand of going, right, if he's happy with that, I can come up with a load of stuff up to that line and slightly around it So that just gave me an instant thing of going, oh yeah, I am right about being able to bring that, that feels like you're the only person in the world part of you, and have people like that, not just tolerate it, but enjoy it.
- 21:00So that's, uh, that's a, that's a wonderful thing that's happened recently with it.
- 21:07Um, if, uh, either of you have come up with it, uh, the plan is to tell one truth and two lies each, and then by the end of the second episode we'll try and work out which of those things are.
- 21:24Um, depending on, I haven't got any'cause I've not had space today, but if either of you have, uh, want to get started with it.
- 21:33I can go, yeah.
- 21:35All right.
- 21:35Go for it.
- 21:36Okay.
- 21:37So first thing is I've played over 200 hours of Slay the Spire 2 Um, I have learnt three dead languages And when I was once coming back from a night out drunk at university, I lost a McFlurry in the mud and never found it again after falling over.
- 22:05So we've got 200 Slay the Spire.
- 22:08Slay the Spire two.
- 22:09Yes.
- 22:10200 Slay the Spire two.
- 22:12Uh, what was the second one?
- 22:16I'm glad I'm writing these down.
- 22:18So it's over 200 hours in Slay the Spire two.
- 22:21Now Alex is frozen.
- 22:22I've learnt three dead languages.
- 22:23Slay the Spire two, third one was McFlurry.
- 22:25Oh yeah, three dead languages.
- 22:26And once I was so drunk coming back from a night out at uni that I lost a McFlurry falling over in the mud and never found it again.
- 22:34You lost a McFlurry?
- 22:37Yes.
- 22:37I was carrying it, carrying it home in a taxi, got out, fell over in the mud.
- 22:44Then realized I'd dropped my McFlurry.
- 22:46Looked around for it with my phone torch.
- 22:47Couldn't find it anywhere.
- 22:49Gave up.
- 22:49Had to go back to the flat.
- 22:51Opened the door to my flatmates, who saw me covered in mud, and all I could say was,"I've lost my McFlurry." Uh, and they were like,"What happened to you?" Yeah.
- 23:04It was very, it was very upsetting.
- 23:08That's awesome.
- 23:10Oh.
- 23:16Okay.
- 23:17I'm gonna close the...
- 23:22I'm gonna stop recording, start a new room.
- 23:26Okay.
- 23:27And then we'll go from there.
- 23:33So Alex has just revealed her one lie and two truths, and we're going to, uh, try and work them out at the end of this episode.
- 23:41Oh, I thought it was one truth and two lies.
- 23:44That's what I said, isn't it?
- 23:45Okay.
- 23:46Yes.
- 23:46One truth, two lies.
- 23:48I might as well not be very confused, but yes.
- 23:50Yeah.
- 23:51So yeah, try and work that out at home.
- 23:56And carrying on, we'll do...
- 24:01Uh, I've got a question So carrying on from that one truth and two lies There...
- 24:15How do you both find when you meet new people?
- 24:23What, like how much of ourselves do we feel that we can reveal?
- 24:28Yeah.
- 24:29How do you ap- Mm how do you approach it?
- 24:31I think, uh, I think it's, I think it is just about building up.
- 24:36I mean, well, well, no.
- 24:37Firstly, it depends how, how I'm meeting them, what the circumstances are, and, uh, you know, how, what the environment is.
- 24:47So, you know, uh, how I would approach somebody who I met through a work related thing is different to how I might approach somebody who I met through a family party or, you know, how I might meet somebody at Fantasy Forest or something like that.
- 25:05So, you know, if it's, if, if I meet them in, in certain settings, then certain elements of my personality are more likely to come to the fore than others.
- 25:16'Cause I sort of view myself as, uh, as multifaceted, and I have different aspects that I will give more prominence to depending on who I'm interacting with and what aspects of myself I want to share with them.
- 25:36Um, so it took me quite a long time to realize that the thoughts that I had in my head...
- 25:43This is why I was quite interested about what you were saying about that earlier, Matt, that the thoughts that were inside my head were not out in the world unless I chose to let them be out in the world.
- 25:54So I used to find it quite difficult when I was younger, and I would be cross or upset with a friend because I'd be thinking, like, all these, like bad things about them.
- 26:04But that, I wouldn't actually say them because I'm not a very confrontational person.
- 26:09So I would, I would be thinking them and feeling them, but I wouldn't be saying them.
- 26:13But my, my mind kind of felt like I was saying it to them, so I would often feel like,"Oh no, they're gonna be really cross with me," but obviously they didn't know.
- 26:24And so s- so sometimes it'd be quite frustrating because I could be really annoyed with somebody, and they were just fine with me, and I'd be like,"What?" And but, of course, it was'cause they, they can't read your mind.
- 26:36And so once I realized that, I think that helped me quite a lot to not feel bad about the things that maybe I don't have in common with people, or the things that I fi- think about them, or think about the situation, or things that I think that might be, have a conflict, I suppose.
- 27:03So- I think now I'm...
- 27:08I f- feel like in the last sort of five to 10 years I've much more come into myself, and I think that is part of the part, place in life that I'm at.
- 27:19So I'm a, I'm a more mature person, I'm a mum, I'm, I'm a, I'm, I'm, you know, I'm, I'm a daughter, I'm a wife, I'm, you know, I'm, I'm many different things.
- 27:31And I've...
- 27:32And I have got to a point where it's like, well, you take me or leave me as I am.
- 27:38And there are some things that I recognize that people aren't gonna be interested in.
- 27:41So I don't talk to everyone about my gaming, but I don't hide my gaming anymore.
- 27:46I don't, I don't feel ashamed of it in certain circumstances, or in...
- 27:50No, maybe not ashamed.
- 27:51I've never really felt ashamed.
- 27:52But I don't feel embarrassed by it.
- 27:55I will happily discuss it with people if it comes up in conversation.
- 27:59But I also recognize that there's plenty of people out there who do not care about that sort of thing and are not interested, in the same way that I don't talk to everyone about my pond plants business or my, you know, or, or my trials and tribulations as a parent.
- 28:16You know, there are certain circumstances where those aspects are just not gonna be interesting to the people around me.
- 28:24Ha- if they come up in conversation, then I will be honest about my thoughts on them and my position on them.
- 28:29And I think The other thing that I've realized is that most of my positions and my opinions about things have been built up over a long time with a lot of thought and care and interest.
- 28:44You know, I don't hold my political, social, moral, what have you, positions because I just pulled them out of thin air.
- 28:53I hold them because I've spent a lot of time thinking about them and looking into them.
- 28:58So that's given me more confidence in standing by them, and I feel that, you know, that doesn't mean that everyone has...
- 29:06I don't feel like, oh, everyone has to agree with me, or even that everyone does agree with me, but it means that I can feel more confident in, in saying,"Well, you know, this is my position, and, you know, that's, that's how I feel about this," um, and not get as anxious about what that means people might think of me as a result.
- 29:33But it's taken me such a long time to get to that point.
- 29:36It's not...
- 29:36It was not an easy...
- 29:38It's not been easy, and it certainly isn't constantly there all the time.
- 29:41So with new people, I will always just feel it out, see how, how people are, and, you know, they don't, they don't deserve to see, you know, all of my, you know, as- facets and, you know, straightaway, and they, they also need to earn a little bit along the way.
- 30:04So, uh, it, yeah, it's definitely a work in progress, I think, in that respect What about you, Alex?
- 30:11No, I was thinking of situations where if I'm meeting someone, it also depends on whether it's just them that I'm meeting or if it's a whole group of people or we're in a group setting generally as well.
- 30:26Um, and also how extroverted or introverted they are compared to me, uh,'cause I'm quite introverted and I'm quite softly spoken.
- 30:36So if they're incredibly extroverted and they like to talk, I often don't get a word in edgeways.
- 30:43So it can be hard for me to build up, um, you know, for them to get a picture of me if they're spending-- if I'm letting them, well, not letting them, but, or if there's no room for me to actually be a part of the conversation.
- 30:58And sometimes even in group settings, I'll try and engage in conversation, but sometimes I just won't be heard'cause I'm so quiet.
- 31:07Um, which can be a frustrating thing sometimes, but that just depends also on where we're meeting.
- 31:13If it's a very loud place as well, sometimes that can be difficult.
- 31:17Um, but yeah, I think if it's a one-to-one type situation and the other person gives me space to respond and take on board what I'm saying, I'm gonna be more likely to build a better relationship w- with them from that starting point because I'll be like,"Okay, now I, I have room to speak and kind of share how I feel." And sometimes it does-- um, it is difficult sometimes to feel confident and, you know, like Uh, comfortable in speaking about stuff generally, if you don't often have a chance to in those sorts of social situations.
- 31:59Because you're like,"Well, no one, no one will really care what I have to say because I just like to sit and listen." I'm very much a listener a lot of the time in, in group situations as well, so.
- 32:11I think I can always tell when there's another person who's like that, and I tend to gravitate a bit more towards them and be like,"Oh, it's loud here, isn't it?" Or something like that.
- 32:21And then we just talk about how loud it is or, you know, just general...
- 32:25You get a vibe, you get a vibe from people, and if I get vibes from people where I'm like,"Oh, th- they're, they're gonna be making me feel uncomfortable in probably five minutes because they'll be really loud or something," then I'll tend to not be drawn to them as a person as well, which I know sounds very rude to all of the very extroverted, loud people out there.
- 32:47You're, you're fine, but I just have, I have sensitive ears.
- 32:52Let's put it that way.
- 32:54Um, yeah.
- 32:56Yeah.
- 32:57My biggest thing that I've, my, like, route of how I'm trying to deal with things now is the phrase,"I can't imagine what someone else is thinking." Mm.
- 33:08'Cause that's the absolute- Mm truest thing, and people can't imagine what I'm thinking.
- 33:15It almost feels like I'm completely transparent, but that is an impossible thing, and the idea that the way that you think about yourself is the way that other people are gonna automatically think about you.
- 33:28Um, we've just hit our 30-minute mark, so unfortunately we're gonna have to leave you on a cliffhanger as to how, uh, Alex's truth and two lies is gonna play out.
- 33:40So you have to come, and we'll do it at the start of next episode.
- 33:43So until next time, you know where to find us every Thursday, and we'll be streaming on Twitch every now and then.
- 33:49And, uh, yeah, we'll see you next time.
- 33:51Bye-bye.