Latest / Jew York Times / Israel Election: How Do Coaltiions Form? Is Bibi Netanyahu THAT different than Gadi Eisnkott?
Transcript
- speaker-0: So speaker-1: This is the issue with LA, and this is not a hot take at all. And the hot take that is not a hot take is that everyone there has dead eyes that they're hiding trauma from that they don't talk about. In New York, the second you walk into any room, everyone immediately is like, I'm cold, I'm not happy, I'm angry, I hate this, I hate you. You are making me feel bad. In LA, no one vocalizes anything wrong. So everyone just has blank stares where you know they're thinking stuff. You know that they have things that they don't that they don't like that they want to talk about, but they're in a universe of people who are just people pleasers because they are auditioning during every single interaction they have, whether it's ordering a coffee or whether it's talking to a Netflix executive, they're all worried about showing that they're potentially unhappy. So it just leads to this like dead fake thing that is Los Angeles. speaker-0: So I hear I mean you're you're correct, but I like that about them. I don't need to know. Like keep it to yourself. I don't need to know anything about you. Too much openness. I'm from here. I'm from Long Island. And everybody's sharing too much over there. I disagree. I don't need to know. speaker-1: Genny, where are you You know what the issue is, is that then you gotta go it's not the Midwest is the answer because they also don't talk about anything. It's like Boston, I think, is the right amount of gripe. Boston and Philadelphia. If you're not from New York speaker-0: More gripe than New York, that's extra gripe. speaker-1: What are you talking about, extra gripe? The issue, you know what the issue was with Seinfeld? I didn't like Seinfeld the show because I'd be watching Seinfeld. I'd be like, You call this Jewish gripe? My mom Jewish gripes ten times harder than Seinfeld ever did on any of his episodes. So I just watched, I'd be like, This is the Jews? No, I I they they my mom fights about nothing even more than this is a fight about nothing. speaker-0: My favorite thing you ever did was screenshot text with your mom about how you get news updates from your mother. It's the best thing you've ever done. speaker-1: ⁓ she's got some thoughts about the Ayatollah. Boy, does this woman hate the Strait of Hormuz? I'll tell you right now, there is no one that hates the Strait of Hormuz more than Irene Levine. She despises the Strait of Hormuz. The worst case scenario is that she gets a B12 bomber license and is like, I've got to open the Strait myself. Which we're this close to. If the Abraham Accords fall apart, I'm telling you right now, my mom is showing up to the Strait of Hormuz ⁓ with a Lockheed Martin sponsored jet. Just opening the thing up herself. And with that, ⁓ it is another episode of the Jew York Times a hundred and twenty angry seats, hour run up to the Israeli election. ⁓ and we're doing this in partnership with the Israel Policy Forum, partnership, whatever we want to call it, featuring Israel. speaker-0: Featuring Shani Reichman who works at Israel Policy Forum. speaker-1: That's the correct legal way to say it that I definitely did not get correct. ⁓ on today's episode, on today's episode, last episode, if you haven't listened to, go and listen to it. It the primer for this episode. Last episode, we gave a very nice basic rundown of how Knesset works up until the stuff we're gonna talk about today, which is how the different ⁓ political parties in Knesset are kind of formed and made. ⁓ so that's what we're gonna be talking about on today's episode. Before we go into today's episode, though, we of course have a little bit of news ⁓ coming in just on how political polling has been going. Last episode, we recorded and posted right before there was new polling that came out ⁓ that ⁓ showed that Gaudi Eisencott's lead over Bibi Netanyahu was at four points instead of two points. So we actually gained two more seats over the past couple of days. ⁓ I wanna get your thoughts on that. But before we go into that, I do have a very interesting thing that I've noticed because I am in Tel Aviv. Last night I did a show in ⁓ next to Pardez Hana ⁓ in in ⁓ in Israel. Pardez Khana, if you're unfamiliar, it's a polygamist religious commune ⁓ that that is next to ⁓ kibbutz in the north a little bit. It's like a very hippy-dippy town, basically, right? And it was the first time that I had taken like a taxi or that my friends were driving there, and it's the first time I had taken a ride through the highways of Tel Aviv. And I've noticed that there's two kinds of advertisements that are out there. And that is one, ⁓ my friend Matan Perez and Denny Avdia, and then a bunch of celebrities are selling ⁓ credit cards. So you see their face, that's one sign, and then the next sign is ⁓ Naftali Bennett hugging random people. And it's just Bennett hugging a lady, Bennett hugging an old woman. So you're driving through the highway and you just see. Matan Perez selling a credit card, Bennett hugging a man, Danny Abdia sell selling a credit card, Netali Bennett hugging an old lady, and did not see any BB Nissanyahu or Gaudi Isencott signs. And why that is interesting to me is that there was an article that came out that is showing that Gaudi Eisencott is actually buying ad space in Cyprus to advertise to Israelis who are on vacation or potentially want to come back for the election. I was curious if ⁓ you knew anything about that. This is something I kind of just like saw today. Any thoughts on that? speaker-0: I've never heard of that. It's a brilliant idea. Is that is he the first person to do that? Because that's a great, great choice on his part. speaker-1: I got no idea. And it kind of plays into the fact that we've talked about like potential pre-election fuckery is what we can call it, that could lead to the election potentially being fuckeried up with. And one of those things is the idea of people coming from out of town into ⁓ into Israel, ⁓ Israelis who are registered to vote, who are in America or abroad, coming back in just to vote. And there's ideas that like BB could potentially like screw up the planes or he can work with El or, you know, yada yada, create a war that shuts the airspace. It's like a real it you know, how how valid are those concerns? speaker-0: Very valid. ⁓ the other concerns are, you know, changing the rules of the game, changing how votes get I mean, we saw that in the United We're Americans. Like we know exactly the type of the type of things that you could see ⁓ when it comes to to elections. And remember, like Israel doesn't have a real constitution, so it's all up to the Supreme Court. And as you've seen, there is always the potential for a constitutional crisis in which the Supreme Court court says, You can't do that, and they say, We don't care. And then who knows what happens next. But that obviously has a massive impact on an election. ⁓ and there has been, I think, pretty legitimate conversations around ⁓ the flights coming into Israel. And remember, if there's a war, there's nothing to do, right? It's not technically his fault. Like I he might just start the war, but but if there's if there's a war, people can't can't fly in to vote and that's that. ⁓ a lot of people are planning to fly in to vote. ⁓ or remember it's a s pretty small country, like there's a bit of monopoly on who's flying in right now. ⁓ and so if you you know, anything changes in Alal, yeah, people won't be it's that could be half a million voters. I mean it's a huge difference. speaker-1: There was you know, there was another story ⁓ this week about how BB had ⁓ not BB, but there was Lee could had a vote on how they were gonna go forward with primaries even if there wasn't war. And ⁓ I was wondering so I had seen people varying degrees of like, wow, this is game changing to like, ⁓ it's not that big of a deal. ⁓ anything on that at all? Any thoughts? speaker-0: Likud primary. So Likud and the Democrats are the only, I think the only two parties that have like a real ⁓ a real prime, a real Democratic primary people vote instead of the head of the party choosing the list or some random rabbis choosing the list. ⁓ they are changing that a little bit in the Likud party. ⁓ so Netzanyao, it seems like he's going to be selecting ⁓ like a th a third of the seats, which is a lot because it ends up being almost half of the seats that actually make it in, and he's going to sort of hand select them, but their committee decided this. And within the Israeli context, for an American it's a little odd, but from an Israeli context, this is perfectly legit. Like most other parties are actually one guy is choosing the whole list. So if anything, Likud is still more democratic than in how they're selecting their seats compared to most other parties other than the Democrats. speaker-1: Yeah. Democrat lefty hero BB Netanyahu, and Lee could. speaker-0: That's exactly what I was saying. speaker-1: Exactly. ⁓ so this week also, ⁓ now that we got that out of the way, ⁓ Gotti Azakot up four seats in the polling. Do you think it's gonna stick? Do you think that this trending is gonna hit? And also, is there a chance that he kind of like burns out because it's three months, you know, three months away if he keeps on gaining seats? ⁓ is that a thought process at all? speaker-0: He could burn out, but I I mean I think there would be a reason for it. he's he doesn't need to keep gaining seats. He just needs to stay where he is. He doesn't need to gain that many more seats, right? ⁓ so the question is really can they be pulled away? But remember that he's running against the prime minister of the country who has enormous power to influence the game, right? We just spoke about. You could start a war. ⁓ there I mean, there's endless you could change the rules of the game. There's endless things you can do. you can normalize with Saudi Arabia. I'm not saying that's going to happen, but I'm saying like these are you could you have so much opportunity to change how influence how people see you compared to somebody who's just a guy. Not that he's a Gotti Eisengott's just a guy, but like legally he's just a guy. ⁓ and so he doesn't actually have the type of influence that can affect ⁓ how this election tur ⁓ turns out, whereas Netzanyao of course does, which has really ⁓ worked in his favor for the past a thousand years he's been in office. ⁓ truthfully since 2009. ⁓ other than the The small stint with Benilla Pede, Netzanyah was been the Prime Minister. Two thousand nine. That's a really long time ago. I'm not gonna tell you what I was in, but it was a long time ago. speaker-1: What grade was I in? Two thousand nine. I guess I was graduating high school like that year. speaker-0: As I think that was like my freshman year of high school something. Yeah. ⁓ this is the polling results. It's ⁓ an average of three different channels for the last few polls. Okay. So it's like it's not just one poll because I don't believe in just looking at one poll. I will say that I remove, I don't include channel 14 because channel 14 is crazy. If you look at the difference in polling from channel 11, 12, and 13 versus 14, it's they're operating on different. Planets. Like Channel 14 has Netanyahu's block at 62 seats. Okay, because they love Netanyahu. And everyone else has Netanyahu's block at 10 seats lower than that, at least, or 11. Now I'm looking through them. Or or twelve I see 12 below that. Like nobody is anywhere close to that. speaker-1: Historically, is this been has that been accurate to to like have they been an accurate polling source or is this them like showing speaker-0: think they're no they're just showing up for their dude I don't think they're more accurate than any of these channels and it's pretty obvious that they're not right now. But remember people like to get behind a winner. So if you think your guy's gonna win like you might be a lot more inclined to show up. ⁓ But in terms of the actual normal polling, ⁓ it's putting the what what you've coined the eisen block, the eisencot block. Is that no but speaker-1: On Twitter. speaker-0: And it's putting Netanyahu at 51. So fifty fifty-nine to fifty one. And then you have the 10 Arab 10 seats for the Arab parties. ⁓ and some of those are part of Mansurabas's Rom party, which theoretically ⁓ would go to Gaudi Isencott. ⁓ or could go to Gadi Isencott. He has not said that, but it's pretty I I think pretty clear that that's a likely scenario, ⁓ which is looking pretty good for him. That said, you know, you still you still do need to commit would need to convince every member of the Zionist opposition. to bring in Mansurabas, which is, I think, a likely scenario, but not a hundred percent certain. ⁓ and and Gotti Eisencott and Netanyahu in terms of getting the plurality of seats are really neck and neck. So yes, on a on di in different polling you see ⁓ Gaudi Isencod ahead, but you often they're it's really only by one or two seats. They're, you know, struggling for that top seat. ⁓ and I'll tell you what that means because by the way, that doesn't mean you're the prime minister. I I think I made that clear on the last side, the last ⁓ ⁓ podcast, but I'm gonna make it really clear on this one. That does not make you the prime minister. ⁓ getting a plurality of seats. By the way, if you didn't listen to the last episode, I'm not repeating things for you, so go listen. We're not no repeats here, okay? speaker-1: an indoctrinated Israeli by the time you get to episode two of this, okay? You're basically, you know it, you're using kapara around town. You're wearing sand kapara. Listen, I cannot be more American than I am. Mutarli La Lefet La Sherutin. speaker-0: Etan, why don't you tell us how do you think how do you think the Prime Minister gets chosen? speaker-1: How do I think okay, first of all, what people have to understand is that the prime minister is actually chosen in Cleveland, Ohio during the DNC. Okay. That's what it happens four years ago. Okay. How sorry, you answered. speaker-0: Okay. we're we're starting back with I don't remember exactly where we left off, so I might have lied and repeated a little bit, but speaker-1: Yes, yes, yes. Wait, before we start off, then I have one question that I want to ask because we are doing weekly listener mailbag ⁓ sections. And I did have I did it, but I do have an actual question. There were two there was a question that ⁓ I got from multiple different people, and that is that so this is listener mailbag, which we have to name something. The Mazel Tove mailbag. Actually, we're not naming it that way. So this week, we're not naming it the Mazzle bag, okay? So nobody asked for this. okay, fresh out of the Mazzle bag. You know, this week and over the last week, we've seen a lot of Gotti Eisencott making his way into American media. Now, an interesting thing that has popped up around Gaudi Isencott is that people are saying, as much as he's like the anti BB or the BB killer, people have asked, how is he actually different than BB when it comes to ending anything past like ending wars and stuff like that? So the question I have is structurally, what are the other things that Gotti is different than? Then B B or are we just getting B B but he's not B B again? speaker-0: Lot of things are different, but remember the key difference is not about the individual, it's who their coalition partners are. So even if as human beings they supported similar policies, one of them is much more is running basic with the ultra-orthodox and religious nationalists, and those are his coalition partners, and one of them is running not running with, I shouldn't say running with, but but part of an opposition block that includes left-wing parties and Arab parties. So it's a totally different makeup of a coalition. It's less a question to me as the of the individual and more a question of the The whole makeup of the block, which really influences them. Because I could say Netzanyao is an individual. I don't think he supports a Haredi draft exemption, but that's what he's been advancing for the past 10 years, right? Gotti Eisencott is clearly looking to avoid a to ⁓ enforce a draft, right? So they're really different on core policy issues. I would say they're different on a lot of policy issues that are coming up in this election. Commission of inquiry for October 7th, obviously Medjim Netanyahu does not want because it will make him look terrible, most likely scenario. ⁓ and Gaudi Isencode, that's his main thing. ⁓ but a lot of a lot of these issues have to do with ⁓ with ultra Orthodox and Arab communities, which as individuals, it's possible Nefsanyau agrees with Gaudi on a lot of these things, but he can't say that because he's bound by his ⁓ his partners on the right and in the religious communities. Does that make sense? speaker-1: Yeah. What about ⁓ West Bank politics? speaker-0: ⁓ would would be would be different because Netanyahu is of course, ⁓ Netzanyau is is again bound by his really far right, ⁓ his far-right coalition partners, but Salas Mudric in particular, who has taken a really leading role ⁓ in the West Bank, ⁓ which has allowed, enabled, encouraged many illegal outposts that are illegal under Israeli law throughout the West Bank. We're even seeing them in Area B, which is an a a part portion of the West Bank that you really never see Jewish settlements in, and now we are. ⁓ and of course you see settler violence that's quite ⁓ quite rampant right now. And again, that's not just enabled by the rhetoric, it's it's that the the people, the the institutions even within within the military ⁓ that are responsible for this are often falling under Batsala Smotrich's guidance. And so again, it's not Bibi, but BB is now giving this a really important post to Batsala Smothric. And that's the guy who's the problem, right? So without eliminating him, you can't eliminate this problem, and he is a core part of Netzanyah's coalition. ⁓ And and therefore, if Gotti Gaisan got to me, if Gotti Gaisan got to power, you will see a crackdown in a lot of these things. Certainly, ⁓ I would say illegal outposts and definitely settler violence. ⁓ broader conversations about the future of the West Bank, I think are being put on the back burner and will be ⁓ if there is an what is now the opposition comes to power. I think it will take them a long time to reach that point. ⁓ but that's ⁓ that's for another time. We're gonna do a whole episode on the West Bank so you can hear me yap about speaker-1: And last question on this difference between Gaudi and Bibi when it comes to Iran, Lebanon, and I mean Gaza seems to be, I don't know if there's really anything that can change there, but like Lebanon and Iran, is there a difference between Gaudi and Bibi? speaker-0: Nothing that's nothing substantial enough for me to say. I think that there's ⁓ there they probably would each say Gaudi would probably say that ⁓ they're very different. I th but I think the reality of it is that they would be quite similar, ⁓ quite hawkish on Iran, Lebanon, Syria. ⁓ that said, there are there have been a few moments over the past few years where I think Netanyahu has made choices, ⁓ especially in Lebanon and Syria, ⁓ that Gaudi might have done differently, but I don't have anything like official to report on it. speaker-1: Awesome. Okay. Shainee, let me just say that was probably my favorite muzzle bag that we've ever done. Okay, you hate that. speaker-0: It's it's I no, I actually I actually love it. I ac I swear I love it. speaker-1: No, we have to I I don't like it. I'm projecting my own hatred of the word Mazzlebag. It feels d it feels dirty in a way I don't like. We will you know what? If you if anyone out there has a better name than Mazzlebag, please send it our way. ⁓ you can DM me or Shanie or I would or you know what? Israel Policy Forum. Email them directly. ⁓ anyways, Sheney, episode two. Of 120 angry seats. Last week we talked about the Knesset and the formation of the Knesset with the election. Today I want to talk about the formation of the political parties. What do you got? speaker-0: Mm-hmm. Okay. So we're gonna fast forward to election night. We already spoke about how parties run together and they run apart because they need to get into the Knesset. We spoke about wasted votes and how if you don't hit a certain threshold, 3.25% of the total vote, you don't get in. And that could be anywhere between 100 and 200,000 votes, but it's maybe like high one over 150 a little bit. ⁓ and you also have vote sharing agreements. So The Likud Party and Betsala Smutzrich's party could come together and say, if we get extra votes, then at the end, if we make it in the Knesset, we can add those votes together for one seat if they equal one seat, right? So there's like really weird, sketchy things that happen. It's not sketchy, it's legal, but it's a very bizarre system to me. ⁓ anyhow, there's vote sharing agreements, there's mergers, all that happens. End of the day, election night happens. ⁓ nobody has yet won. Okay. There's no, I don't think sometimes there's an obvious winner, but the last five elections ⁓ or Four out of five of last elections, there was not an obvious winner, so I wouldn't assume that by any means. But there is gonna be a guy who has more seats, and it will be a guy. not more votes necessarily. Like it's not about how many votes they have, it's about how many seats they have. It could easily be a tie. Like it's very easy to imagine a scenario where Gaudi and Likud both have 22 seats, ⁓ or one could have a little more, one could have a little less. But again, it's a math problem. It's not about who ha actually got the most seats. For the One week after the elections, it is the president Bougie Hertog's time to shine. Okay? This is speaker-1: Can we go back on that point? This is an interesting difference between the American election and the Israeli election, where because it doesn't really matter, the popular vote does not matter in America. And you can really concede an al you can concede an election like fairly quickly, you know, if you just realize that you're losing, versus here because the seats have to be delegated out, you have to count every vote to understand how many ⁓ each seats everyone has. So it's like less. There's it's interesting because in America, the last like three elections, because these have been Trump elections, you've had the stop the vote, don't stop the vote, challenges, court cases, and everything that would end the voting system, or it was an anomaly if we got to an end where we would count every vote. We didn't know that Kamala had lost the popular vote until weeks later, and it didn't make a difference because she conceded, you know, on the first night when she went 0 for 7 on swing states and is still considering a run. Huh. Crazy things in America. So that's an interesting part. Big difference between the American system and the and the Israeli system is that you gotta count all the votes to know how the seats lie out. speaker-0: It's also an infinitely smaller country. I don't know by how many magnitudes, but it's infinitely smaller than the United States, right? The US is like maybe a hundred times larger in population. I mean, it's massive compared to Israel. So that's also why every seat r every vote really matters. So they count up the votes from the military and the the military ballots and they count up the votes from the prisons ⁓ a little bit later, and so everyone's always waiting on those votes because they do make a difference. They could push it right or left depending on the year, ⁓ and depending on what's going on, if there's a war or not, things like that. ⁓ speaker-1: Prisoners tend to vote. They go right away. speaker-0: I have no idea. Historically the IDF goes left. but I don't know if that's the case anymore. ⁓ speaker-1: And no, but the prisoners that you don't know speaker-0: I'll look into that. I'll look into That's interesting. speaker-1: Kind of curious about that. Yeah. speaker-0: We'll see. You know the heat map we spoke about? Maybe this maybe the heat map covers the prisons as well. So the president, his his time to shine, he meets with the head of every single party, he has a conversation with them in his office, and he tries to assess who they are going to recommend. So it's not just the heads of the two major parties, it's everybody else. ⁓ because remember, you need to add up to 61, and whoever wins is gonna have somewhere between 20 and 30 seats, probably, right? They're not gonna have speaker-1: Yeah. speaker-0: ⁓ they're definitely not getting anywhere near 61 on their own. So they need to merge. So he has to meet with all of the heads of the smaller parties and say, who are you going to go with? And then he needs to do the math himself and try to figure out who's gonna have the best shot at actually building a coalition, which means getting those 61 seats, 61 human beings to all agree, and probably maybe four to seven parties to all agree. Okay. ⁓ usually he picks the person with the biggest party, but it's really not always. ⁓ and then he hands, ooh, he sees. ⁓ and then he hands over to let's pretend it's Benjamin Netanyahu because in the last election it was. ⁓ hands over the mandate, they call it, and he now has twenty-eight days, but really, but really ⁓ six weeks, because you get an extension for two weeks, to talk to every person who's been like yelling at him for the past really years, but certainly election cycle. A bunch of people who want to set each other on fire, get together and they yell and they negotiate and they figure out if they can pull it together. If they fail, it passes to a second candidate. If he fails in theory, you could send it to another candidate, but I don't know if that's even ever happened. ⁓ and if everybody strikes out, they're back to elections again. ⁓ I'm gonna remind you that this actually did happen and I'll tell you all about it later on in the episode. But for now, just understand this is what happens af during those 28 days, during those, we'll call it six weeks, okay? ⁓ you have either it w who will probably be Isencott or Netanyahu. meeting with everybody and trying to get them to agree with him and to say, we're gonna vote for him, vote with you. Okay. It's not always about I I think negotiate's like a nice word. It's bribery. It's just like full bribery. Okay. It's not even about ideology. It's about, are you gonna give me a ministry? Are you gonna promise to do what I want? Sometimes it's policy. It's also like money for for specific issue areas, right? Mansur Abbas from the Arab sector, he may say, I want a big budget for education of Arab Israeli children. And that might be one of his prom I am not saying that's what he said, but like that could be the sort of thing, right? We saw in the for this current government, Etanyao had promised during these negotiations a draft exemption from the Ultra Orthodox, which he wasn't able to l deliver on. But the point is, this was one of the reasons he said that is because he needed them to come and work together with him. So they're sort of ⁓ haggling over all of these things. ⁓ who gets what cabinet ⁓ post, how much budget is going to which sector, things like that. This is why, ⁓ and by the way, at the end you have this written-signed agre coalition agreement, okay? But this is how you ended up with a with a country that has like 30 ministers, okay, for no reason. America, I check, they have like 15 of the equivalent. And again, this country is infinitely larger. Israel has a ministry of sports and culture. They have a ministry of heritage. They have a ministry of religious services. Okay. They they have both a d Minister of Defense and a Minister of National Security. I mean it's like ridiculous. And every time you hand out a ministry, it means you get a staff of advisors, you get a fancy office, you get a driver, you get a security guard. Okay. So it's a lot of money being wasted so that somebody can feel good about themselves and have theoretical power. Sometimes, by the way, they have real power and it and in the case of someone like Batsalas Mutrich, you create a position and then he takes power away from the IDF or or ⁓ another institution that's really not meant to be politicized. So all of these things have happened. Please. speaker-1: This is so comically similar to how most synagogues run their boards, is what I will say. This is a lot of annoying coalition building, and then someone's made the VP of Kiddish, and then there's a minister of Kiddish Club, and they're not in the same competitive. Someone's in charge of the Purim baskets, and someone's in charge of the cookies that go into the Purim baskets and stuff. Is this the most complicated version of assembling a government that you could possibly figure ⁓ you know, have is there a government that has a more complicated version of this? speaker-0: I wish I knew other governments well enough to say that. But I will say that in the UK they have had like a dozen prime ministers since I can recall. So I think they there's like something weird going on there too. I imagine that I'm just not as familiar. But compared to America, I think this is overly complicated for sure. Way too long. This takes way too long. ⁓ too long and too short, right? Like it's ⁓ it's kind of speaker-1: Yeah, America speaker-0: both of those things at the same time. But like you takes too long to figure out who who is actually the prime minister of the country. ⁓ ik unless it's Donald Trump and then there's like a whole fight about certifying elections and all that stuff. But in general takes much longer. ⁓ speaker-1: that's that's that old joke about the the Christian who converted to ⁓ the Christian who converted to Judaism and was asked about the restaurant that he just ate and he was optimistic and he said yeah well the portions were tiny but at least it was expensive you know that's the the version of this okay so the president who by the way you ⁓ you pointed out something that it last episode that i that I did like a lot about how the president does really is a it's a a a show job until this one thing. And then his big role is big time to shine is putting these ⁓ governments together and making sure that they stick. speaker-0: Yeah. I f it reminds me of the vice president certifying elections, but a little more powerful. It's like the first lady plus the vice president equals the president of Israel. That's how I think of it. I made that. speaker-1: Was there a mob of people that tried to hang ⁓ Herzog outside of it like they did with Mike Pence? Or is that not part of ⁓ speaker-0: No, that's never happened. It might be worse in America. I take back what I said. So under this system, ⁓ basically the s the smaller parties have a lot more power than you would expect because of how this system is built, right? ⁓ a really small party ha who has four, five, six seats can r can be still be the kingmaker if they are the most annoying. It is all about how stubborn you are. If you make it obvious that you are actually not willing to sit in that government, They just need to bribe you and bribe you and bribe you and give you everything you want until you agree. So the more stubborn you are, the better it is in this case. So it's not about, it's not like, ⁓ the second largest party has the most power. No. It's often the smaller parties because they are more extreme and they are more ideological and more annoying. ⁓ right. And so they th if they threaten to walk, you need to give them whatever you want because you don't want to go to another election or you don't want to let the other guy try to go to the elections. Okay. So I think. The other piece I should add is that if you end up going back to elections again and again and again, the ruling party stays in power. So you could keep a government that does not really technically have a mandate for power for a very long time. You can have at least another year, if not more, where you're just running the country. And we saw that in Israel where Netsanyao, like there were four elections and he just three elections, he just sat there ⁓ as they went on and he remained in power, which is a little bit bizarre. any questions on that before I move to how governments ⁓ fall and then I'll tell you what happened in twenty nineteen. speaker-1: You know, I'll save any questions of that for the muzzle bag. Okay. speaker-0: Okay, great. So you can now that you know how they're created, it's obvious to see how they fall, I think, which is that you need to get sixty one people who half of them hate each other to sit together and vote together. Any point in the four years where that drops below sixty one, which it easily could, you are like you're basically ending up ⁓ without a government and you're going to elections. So you convince Is that you can? speaker-1: Official process? Like is that like a like I am submitting paperwork that's saying like I am no longer part of the coalition? Or is that just like an informal, like, I'm not with you anymore? speaker-0: I think there has to be paperwork involved, but I'm remembering during the Bennett LePede government that Edith Silman, like Neftali Bennett found out in the news. They like they allegedly. Like he just opened up the newspaper and it was like, ⁓ she's left us and now we have an election. Okay. Well, it wasn't exactly that quick, but ⁓ the point being, like, I assume there's a formal process, but I have never heard of one. All I've heard is people announcing it and then like all of a sudden they're gone. ⁓ and then of course you do need to actually like vote out. So the other way is if you don't pass a budget by a certain date, you're you're supposed to automatically go to elections, right? Which is I think a lot better than our system, which is in America, the government just doesn't function if there's no budget and then you just don't get things. I think forcing an election is actually like a nice response to that because it kind of threatens the government that like you're not allowed to hold the American people hostage. You can't do that in Israel, which I think is a good thing. ⁓ although I don't know if we can handle that many election cycles. speaker-1: ⁓ you don't like it? You don't like a good ⁓ we got no budget so we're not gonna have any squ speaker-0: ⁓ There's there's no mail, like what is just weird. It's a crazy system. so the and it's a really big country to have a situation like that. ⁓ other option is a no confidence vote. So you could get 61 members of Knesset to agree on replacing the prime minister, technically, which is pretty insane. I don't know if that's ever I don't think that's ever happened. ⁓ and or the Knesset can just like vote to dissolve itself, which I don't like that because In theory, you could have someone like Netanyahu say, and this kind of has happened, I think it's better for me to go to elections now than to go wait until the four years are up or wait until some other time. I'm gonna choose like I'm gonna decide that we're gonna go to elections and basically get the Knesset votes to dissolve and go to elections. And I don't I don't think that's so democratic because you can choose what's a a pr good time for you to go to to to go to elections, right? And in Israel, it is really affected by what's going on in the discourse and in in frankly the geopolitical. elements. So let's say there was a huge win for Netanyahu. He gets Saudi normalization. He says, This is a good time to go to elections. I don't want to wait until the next war. I just got Saudi normalized with me. Now I'm going to go, right? Like that sort of thing is is acceptable here. speaker-1: When when you when you dissolve the government, does that so like let's say I got an election happening in twenty thirty, right? And it's twenty twenty-eight now, and I decide I'm gonna dissolve the government. Does that un and I could just have an election now? So I'm gonna have a twenty speaker-0: twenty twenty. speaker-1: Let's say I let's say Prime Minister Eton and his brutal regime has taken over and it's been, I would consider myself an immediate dictator. I came in there thinking that I would run this ⁓ democratically, and then I saw how much money to be made and I thought, you know what? I want to do this forever. So 2028, I decide I do not I I wanna have this election now. If I have that election now, you don't do the twenty thirty one or you do this in addition to the twenty. speaker-0: Correct. You don't do no no no. You restart the cycle. So then my question is twenty thirty one. speaker-1: So then it pushes it to twenty thirty two, basically. speaker-0: It's four year technically you have a a government for four years from whenever you start. And it doesn't matter when you start. Or until four years or until whatever ha whatever happens ⁓ somebody drops. speaker-1: So twenty twenty eight the the br the Eton Levine regime the Levine regime decides I I'm not gonna win in twenty thirty, so I'm gonna do this now and then I don't have to deal with this until twenty thirty two. speaker-0: My my point being, I think what you're trying to get that in the American perspective, like we think of like the we know what year is an election year. In Israel, you don't have that concept. Yes. Like you but you kind of know, but like you don't really so it's not like, ⁓ we know that every four years on the dot, regardless of what happens in between there's an election, they don't have that concept, right? Do you remember what happened in twenty nineteen? speaker-1: Yes. Bennett gets elected at Pri Bennett gets elected as Prime Minister, ⁓ and then ⁓ legendarily brings in the Arab ⁓ blocs and is not able to ⁓ the the and then his government dissolves because speaker-0: Stop talking. That was 2021. Stop talking. I'm gonna start. ⁓ sorry. Yeah, yeah. you could have just said no. ⁓ it's not wrong. You're not that wrong. You're only a little wrong. I'm gonna get there, but I by the way, listeners, if you do not care, like totally fair. But I think a lot of people started paying attention to Israeli elections a lot more recently. And in 2019, there was like a crazy situation and it's not out of the question that could happen again. So I'm gonna tell you what happened. It'll also help you understand who all these players are. Some of them are totally irrelevant now, which I also think is really fun. ⁓ but remember, there's a there's a kingmaker, okay? The kingmaker, when people call some a kingmaker, it means they're the most stubborn person who is potentially in the coalition. Okay. They're the person who's threatening to leave at all times and who you have to make them happy. That's basically what it means. Okay. Netanyahu governments in 2015, okay. Now it dissolves somewhere around 2018, a little bit earlier than it's supposed to. Why? Because the defense minister, Evigdor Lieberman, you may have seen him, he's a very grouchy Soviet man. ⁓ his party, Israel Baitinu, ⁓ which is very hawkish, ⁓ very Russian, they decided to leave because Bibi agreed to a ceasefire with Hamas after a flare-up, and he was very upset. He said, That's not right. He's he really wanted to crush Hamas, and the coalition ended up very precarious, and Antoniao ends up calling for early elections. ⁓ again, because he sees that he's going to clearly lose his his majority. Okay. April 2019, that's the election. That's when we start this cycle. Benny Gantz, who is now pulling below the threshold, not even making into the Knesset. Back in 2019, he was the star. He was the Gotty Isencott of 2019. He starts his blue and white party, which starts basically head to head with Netanyahu. Again, almost identical to what happened. He was also former IDF chief of staff, right? Very, very similar scenario. ⁓ I have a lot more hope in Gaudi Eisenhop, but you can't trust me I had hope in Benny Gantz too. ⁓ Gantz is clearly unable to form a coalition, ⁓ even though they're they're sort of head to head. Netanyahu fail ⁓ Gantz fails. Netzanyaou fails because Netzanyau cannot convince Evidor Lieberman to sit with the ultra-Orthodox and they hate each other. Okay. Lieberman is a ⁓ there's a there's a lot of contention with ⁓ former Soviet and Russian-speaking Jews in Israel, ⁓ who are are Many of them are pretty secular, some are patrilineal Jews, and you can imagine that puts them at odds with the ultra-orthodox. ⁓ so this it's very, very different ⁓ communities. And so he and he feels very strongly by them serving in the military too. So they won't sit together. Okay. And and he's kind of the the clincher because Netanyahu's coalition doesn't exist without both the ultra-orthodox and a Victor Lieberman at the time. Okay. By the way, it's not crazy that he would be the kingmaker again, I think, in this cycle, but not with Benny Gantz, of course. All right. ⁓ and so basically. This is the first time this happens in Israel's history that nobody's able to form a government. They go back to elections. So you have election number two, September 2019, a few months later. Okay. Netanyahu tries again, can't get his guys to work together. Bennett's involved too somewhere. Gans tries, Gans fails. Election number three, which is like at this point, everyone's like, this is the craziest thing that's ever happened. Okay. Netanyahu, ooh, Netzanyau, by the way, is still in power this whole time. Now you get to March 2020. By the way, Other things happening in March 2020, COVID starting, whatever, but you still squeeze in an election, all right? Likud's getting ahead of Gans, but Lieberman is is fed up with BB, decides he's gonna back Benny Gans, which actually gives him a shot at the mandate. ⁓ in all this process, Benny Gans, he's running as the anti-Netsanyao. So he's saying, I'm not gonna sit with Netzanyao. By the way, at this point, people are really talking about the corruption trials and all the bribery tires, okay? The net investigations of Netanyahu, people actually care about that cared about that back then. Now, like everyone's forgotten kind of, but At the time, this was really top of mind for people. So Benny Gans says, I'm not gonna sit with Netanyahu, okay? He promises. Meanwhile, nobody's able to form a government. Gantz and Netzanyau end up in conversation. Remember, it's COVID, so the excuse is kind of like it was an emergency, not an emergency, but like things were going a little bit crazy. We don't want to go to another election during COVID. This is kind of insane. Gans ends up negotiating a deal with Netanyahu where it's a rotating prime minister deal. This should not be allowed, but it is allowed, where you s two guys come together and they don't even have to have the most like most votes necessarily. Like you could do with Itamar Ben Gear if you wanted to. ⁓ and you say, I'm gonna be prime minister for a year and a half, you're gonna be the prime minister for a year and a half. Again, totally nutty thing to do, but they do and speaker-1: I love that though. That's beautiful. speaker-0: It's unhinged. It's the craziest thing of all of this. It's the craziest piece. ⁓ now what happens after 18 months of Netanyahu being the prime minister? He orchestrates that the budget doesn't pass, basically screws over Benny Gantz and makes sure they go to elections before he can become the prime minister. Okay. So if you if people talk about Benny Gantz in a negative light, it's often dating back to this, where he where he went back on his campaign promise, not a seven, and he got Totally screwed by him. Okay. speaker-1: Was was this also was this that run where they didn't pass a budget like over and over and over and over and over? Or I think about a different run. speaker-0: I don't know, but yeah, I think so because they they were preventing the budget from passing. Like Kud Party made sure the budget didn't pass basically, knowing it would force an election. And they pretend now pretended. He was like, I don't want to go to elections, but of course he it was very obvious he did. And it it made Benny look like what we would call like a friar. Like it made him look like he was being taken advantage of, which he was. He was kind of a sucker. Like he got ⁓ he got totally played by Netanyahu in that situation. ⁓ so now we're going back to elections. Okay. It's election number four in a two year period. Right. which is nuts. March twenty twenty one, ⁓ BB comes out ahead, but he is not able to actually build a coalition. He starts to talk to Mansoor Abbas from the Brahm Party. This is the first time in Israeli history that there's real like ser there's serious conversations about ⁓ an Arab party joining. There's actually potential for that happening. And again, I think it's important to say because there's so much delegitimization of partnering with the Arab parties, any of them, especially including Mansoor Abbas from the Rom Party, who's ⁓ very moderate on certain issues, and actually very conservative on different issues. Netanyahu is the one who legitimized that. He is the first one to meet with them. So remember that when all of these AI videos are coming up where Netanyahu is saying, I would never sit with these people, and you're so terrible and anti Zionist for sitting with for ta thinking about thinking about sitting with Mansoor Abbas. Remember that he is the reason this became part of the discourse. He's the reason this became okay. He legitimized it by having meetings with Mansoor Abbas. And there's a lot of evidence that this happened. And Mansur Abbas spoke out about it. And so as a result, it opens the door to everybody else, right? If Netzanyao can do it, why can't Benny Gantz? Why can't Yeur Lapide? Why can't Neftali Bennett start talking to Mansur Abbas? And so they do. And Year Lapid gets the Merits and Labor left-wing parties. He gets Benny Gantz. He gets Neftali Bennett's Yamina party, which is right wing. And he gets Ram Mansur Abbas's party to join together. ⁓ this is the first time in history you have an Arab party joining the coalition. And they did another one of these insane rotating prime minister deals, okay, in which you have Naftali Bennett and you have Yarlapid, and each of them gets their rotation turn as the prime minister. Okay. ⁓ but there was enormous pressure on the people, on the members of Knesset and Neftali Bennett's party. Enormous pressure. A lot of them came from the Likud. ⁓ they are all right-wing religious communities. And these people were being harassed. Their kids were being ⁓ were being threatened in school, their spouses being harassed in their workplaces. Like it was really horrible. So Edith Sealman, one of the lawmakers, ends up dropping. She was the f she was the defector, ⁓ the the main defector that people think about here. Because and she claimed it was about some law they were passing to allow bread into hospitals during Passover. but I I think I mean that was clearly all it guys. Yeah. and ⁓ Yeah. That's the funniest thing. That's why the answer the real the truth is sh it's one biggest thing I've mean. ⁓ she defects. That's what you call it. When you drop out, one other guy near Orbach resigns and then they dissolve the Knesset. They go to another election, twenty twenty two. That's the election where we get this current government, Israel's most right wing and religious government ⁓ in its history. ⁓ and here we are today. speaker-1: It is one Is there any worry in your head? Or talk to me about the worries, about how about not repeating that? About, you know, you you said that one of the reasons why, you know, you're generally not trustworthy, not trusting, or you're not like throwing your entire belief behind the fact that that Gotti like leading and everything, is because you've seen this play out in some capacity before. Do you see that kind of like coming here? Like, what are the forces that you see are more likely to to to Do some Israeli election fuckery, which I'll keep on using until I find out a better word for it. speaker-0: I'm I think there's a this is a complete possibility. First of all, it it already happened. ⁓ the political map looks different, but it doesn't look different enough. ⁓ you still even when you see the Eisenblock, as we've been calling it, it's still below 61 without the Arab parties. That means you need to bring in the Rom Party, specifically the Rom Party, which means you have to get everyone else to agree. Counted in the Eisencott block is Israel Beats Beitenu, a Vidor Lieberman, ⁓ a very hawkish guy who Is pretty resistant to sitting in a government with Mansourabbas and Arab parties. ⁓ never mind that basically everyone else also in the opposition also said we're not gonna sit with Arab parties. Again, I've told you I I don't think that that's the really the case for all of them. I think most of them are gonna change their tune when it comes time. But I wouldn't, I don't necessarily know that a future labor will be among them. And if they don't, if they don't all agree to include the Arab parties, then technically they're still below. Again, things could change. They could, they could go up in seats. We have several months to go, but if they don't, Or if they go lower, they're going to need Arab parties and I I don't see any guarantee. And Netanyahu definitely doesn't because he's made it pretty clear he's not sitting with Arab parties and he's very clearly below, ⁓ below the the requirement, the minimum requirements. Okay. What are speaker-1: What what's that negotiation like between like Lieberman or whoever doesn't want to work with the Arabs and the Arabs? Like if you're Gotti or if you're Gotti's political strategist, what are you telling them to get them both like on board? speaker-0: to get the Arabs on board. speaker-1: Or to g to get like the anti Arab ⁓ block. speaker-0: Okay. So I think the polling shows that most opposition voters are generally okay with it or they prefer it to the alternatives, right? ⁓ I just saw 44% of opposition voters support going with the Arabs, but then they're split amongst the other things. So you have like 20% say go back to elections, 20% say sit with the opposition, it's have a unity government, right? ⁓ which is also an option. So I I'm I'm I think that the polling shows that it's the right decision. I also think that Mansoor Abbas has come out pretty Zionist, has said he understands it's a Jewish state, he supports a Jewish state, right? He's sort of a special interest group, just looking out for his own community, cares about crime, education, funding, things like that. ⁓ so I I think it's a pretty good sell. Like I think that Mansur Abbas is a totally acceptable person to have in the government. ⁓ and I think that if you you can paint him in that light, they haven't like invested enough in doing that because the head of elections. I will ⁓ I imagine that during the negotiation periods, during the coalition agreements and reconfigurations, they'll start to do some of that work of explaining that Mansoor Abbas is not this boogeyman, right? ⁓ and and he really is not. ⁓ the other things that could change are there are small parties that could make it in or out, right? There's ⁓ there's a small party of a reservist party, ⁓ which is more to the right, and they could get involved, they could end up increasing or or joining with somebody else for vote vote sharing. And that could push up the the current Netanyahu block a little bit. ⁓ you could see the same on the left. There's a a new Jewish Arab party, ⁓ which could also sort of push up ⁓ the votes if they make it in the threshold. So those are the sorts of things that would really change ⁓ much more than anything else happening between the current ⁓ parties are these like new smaller parties, which I could you could see sort of merging with someone else. ⁓ with another party and trying and sort of picking up some votes. ⁓ especially if they bring in people who don't vote. So a Jewish Arab Party, Arab voter turnout in Israel is not as high as it could be. ⁓ this group is claiming that they are bringing in people who've never voted before. So that's the sort of thing that could really sh ⁓ shift. speaker-1: Awesome. This is interesting. I guess like the whole what I wanted to get away from this episode is that, you know, this upcoming election, seeing how previous elections and seeing how everything has kind of like happened and then like how it's dissolved and everything is something to look out for, specifically for the next election. And this like I think did a pretty good job at explaining that. speaker-0: Yeah. That's it. ⁓ I think it's a ⁓ the reason I explained twenty nineteen is is really because it we could see this again. So people should look out for it. ⁓ and the way to avoid it is to already start normalizing the relationship with the Arab party, specifically with Ram Mansoor Abbas. If there's if the there are they are normalizing to the public the idea of cooperating with him, that's sort of the best way to avoid this, in my view. speaker-1: The big difference between the Israeli parties and the American parties is that the American parties have been around forever and they're the same two parties, third party, you know, depending on the election, versus Israeli side where it is a couple of staples and then even the staples don't stay along ⁓ for eternity. There's a very good chance that, you know, we could be looking at ⁓ in an election too where Likud ha is struggling for eight seats. And ⁓ you know, just like speaker-0: The Labour Party ran the country for decades, okay? The idea that the Labour Party would would be so small that it has to merge with another party was unthinkable before. So things can change. ⁓ and and the belief that things can change for better or for worse is important to stay in the game. So speaker-1: you to be from Israel to be the Prime Minister or can you be from America and be the Prime Minister? speaker-0: I don't you don't I don't think you have to be born in Israel. speaker-1: No. I'm telling you right now get get comfortable with it. speaker-0: You have to do it. I'll see you next time, Aitan. speaker-1: Shadi, thank you so much for coming in. This has been another episode of 120 Angry Chairs Seats Chairs. The least I keep on screwing this up. I will never get anything, I'll never pronounce things correctly the first time. And I will definitely keep on unscrewing up this name until the end of our last episode on this on October 28th or whenever we wrap this up. But ⁓ thank you guys so much for tuning in. Make sure to tune in ⁓ next week, listen to the old episodes, ⁓ subscribe ⁓ to this. speaker-0: Yeah. speaker-1: ⁓ if you have any questions the election in general, send it out. Yes, Chanie. speaker-0: And go to Israel Policy Forum dot org forward slash one twenty, spelled out in letters, not numbers. speaker-1: The incredible resources. I would say up to date resources and stuff. ⁓ really great visuals. I don't know who your designer is, but incredible stuff. Once again, Prime Minister Zoran Mamdani would be proud when it comes to the graphics and everything. speaker-0: Next week. speaker-1: Mr. Mandani on the muzzle bag. ⁓ anyways, ⁓ we will see you guys next week on the now Barstuhl.