Latest / Conversations for Equal Pay / #2, Interview with Jenn Stowe, Exec. Director at the Nat'l Domestic Workers Alliance
Transcript
- 0:00Speaker 1: Across the board, women continue to earn less than men.
- 0:05White women make about eighty cents to a man's dollar,
- 0:10Black women earned sixty six cents, Native women and latinas
- 0:17just fifty eight cents, and Asian American women, though often
- 0:24reported higher earnings, still face wide pay gaps depending on
- 0:30ethnicity and industry. The numbers tell a story about the
- 0:38urging need for change. I'm Juline Allen, and this is
- 0:43Conversations or Equal Pay, where we talk with leaders, innovators,
- 0:51and change makers about closing the gap and uplifting women
- 0:55of color in the workplace. Conversations for equal Care. So
- 1:07we're talking to Jen Spoke today, the executive director of
- 1:11the National Domestic Workers Alliance. As a tireless advocate and leader,
- 1:17she is at the forefront of the movement to uplift
- 1:21domestic workers and ensure they have the respect, rights and
- 1:26protections they deserve. Jen, the National Domestic Workers Alliance has
- 1:33been at the forefront of securing protections for millions of workers.
- 1:39From your perspective, what are the most significant legislative or
- 1:44policy barriers that still exists for domestic workers to achieve
- 1:49fair and equal pay?
- 1:53Speaker 2: Well, Juline I'm so happy to be with you. And
- 1:56just to give a little more context to who domestic
- 1:59workers are. These are the women who are the nannies, housecleaners,
- 2:04and the care workers who are in our lives, taking
- 2:07care of our homes and our loved ones, often in
- 2:10private homes. And these women are largely women of color,
- 2:17lots of immigrant women who are domestic workers. And so
- 2:21what we see as a real barrier are domestic workers
- 2:25as a sector of workers being excluded from labor protections
- 2:28that a lot of workers benefit from in this country.
- 2:32And that exclusion has been in existence since the New Deal,
- 2:37since the nineteen thirties, when other workers got protections such
- 2:40as overtime pay, sick leave, freedom from harassment, domestic workers
- 2:48were not granted that protection and so we've been really
- 2:51fighting naturally to ensure that they can get the protections
- 2:54that they deserve.
- 2:56Speaker 1: Thank you for doing the work that you're doing. You've
- 3:00made it clear how well, basically it's eye opening to
- 3:04hear about these gaps that it still exists today.
- 3:11Speaker 2: Yeah, we know that they exist, you know for a reason.
- 3:16The way that care work is viewed, the way that
- 3:21the women are viewed who do this work is very
- 3:24racialized engendered. Back in the nineteen thirties, when other workers
- 3:29were granted those critical protections, we know that the majority
- 3:35of folks who did care work and work in the
- 3:37home they were black women, and so they were purposely
- 3:41excluded from those protections. So those exclusions still exist today,
- 3:46like I said, and a lot of it is because
- 3:48of racism. So so much of the work that we
- 3:51do really has a racial justice and gender justice lens
- 3:55as well as labor justice.
- 3:57Speaker 1: Yeah. Could you share a story about a specific campaign
- 4:03or victory that the and DWA has had that directly
- 4:08resulted in better pay and working conditions for a group
- 4:11of workers.
- 4:13Speaker 2: Yeah, of course. So we are advocating every day to
- 4:19pass what we call the Bill of Rights on the
- 4:22national level. This is a bill that would ensure the
- 4:25domestic workers are really included in other benefits that workers have.
- 4:32But while we're advocating at the national level, we've been
- 4:36able to pass bills across over a dozen cities and
- 4:39states to ensure that domestic workers in places like New York,
- 4:44the state of California, in places like the city of Philly,
- 4:48places where you have a real density of domestic workers,
- 4:52where they can have those rights. So I think look
- 4:54at that as such a big win and wins that
- 4:59will continue to keep the drum beat on, you know,
- 5:01in subsequent years, making sure that we can get as
- 5:06many domestic workers covered as we can.
- 5:08Speaker 1: Yeah, And when I think about other places, I think
- 5:11about my own city, Chicago. Yes, be has a high
- 5:16immigrant population and I'm sure has a demographic of domestic workers.
- 5:25Speaker 2: It does, Julian, And you should know also that we
- 5:29are the Alliance is an organization of affiliates and chapters,
- 5:35so we do work across the US to advocate for
- 5:39the rights, dignity and respective domestic workers. And we have
- 5:42a big president presidence in Chicago. So we do a
- 5:45lot of organizing with domestic workers in Chicago and have
- 5:49been able to pass legislation and do a lot of
- 5:52good work there.
- 5:53Speaker 1: Yeah. So how is the work you do with domestic
- 5:58workers tied to the broader fight for racial and gender justice.
- 6:02You kind of touched on that a little bit already.
- 6:05Speaker 2: Mm hmmm. I said that the majority of domestic workers
- 6:08are women over ninety percent, so many women of color,
- 6:13largely immigrant women. And I think that raising standards for
- 6:19domestic workers really speaks to pay equity and pay gaps
- 6:24in a different way. A lot of times when people
- 6:26think about pay equity, in my experience, they'll they'll talk about,
- 6:31you know, more like white collar jobs or sectors that
- 6:35are really geared towards folks who are higher earners. And
- 6:42you know, when we think about women of color being
- 6:44in low wage jobs and we think about working families,
- 6:48you know, we think about pay equity in a different lens.
- 6:51It's really about just advancing economic justice. It's about the
- 6:56advancement of like reproductive freedom and autonomy. It's about really
- 7:03investing in care broadly being the investment in racial and
- 7:09gender equity, just because of what we know about the
- 7:12history of the workforce and the sector, and that so
- 7:16many exclusions and ideals about the work were really built
- 7:22upon like racist like Jim Crow laws and sentiments. So
- 7:27dismantling that is about like dismantling racism as well, and
- 7:34it is about ensuring that people can take care of
- 7:37other families while not sacrificing that care for their family too.
- 7:41A lot of members will often tell me, like, you know,
- 7:44how they love doing their jobs. You know, it's that
- 7:48they want to be paid a fair wage and they
- 7:50want to be able to take care of their family
- 7:53as well.
- 7:54Speaker 1: Yeah, you highlighted how these issues are not separate, there
- 8:00so intertwined, and really the lack of legislation or protection
- 8:08for domestic workers really stem from African Americans being the
- 8:14ones that were doing this work on and so they
- 8:19were not protected because of you know, racism. But yes,
- 8:27these issues are intertwined.
- 8:30Speaker 2: Yeah, we know that black women who were enslaved did
- 8:34this work. You know, like when we think about chattel
- 8:37slavery in the US, we know that that black women
- 8:42and black people were the folks who were caring for
- 8:45folks and doing it for free, and so that has
- 8:49kind of dictated the how the work has been like
- 8:53historically valued, and so much of our work is about
- 8:56changing that perception.
- 8:58Speaker 1: Yeah, so what drew you to this work and what
- 9:02does it feel like to lead an organization that is
- 9:05so deeply connected to the lives of so many.
- 9:09Speaker 2: I think, like a lot of folks, I came into
- 9:14this work and really came into the realization of my
- 9:17own care story and how the you know, every step
- 9:22in my life has been dictated by who I've cared
- 9:26for or who I've had the privilege of uh being
- 9:30taking care of by And so I was a younger mother.
- 9:36I had my daughter when I was in college, and
- 9:39I know firsthand how difficult it was to find affordable childcare,
- 9:45for example. So I had a deep understanding as I
- 9:50came up into my understanding of like systems, that it
- 9:54wasn't just a personal problem, you know, that it was systemic,
- 9:58and that there's so many people people in this country
- 10:02that are doing you know, what is perceived to be
- 10:05everything right, you know, and they still have issues finding
- 10:09you know, childcare, making sure that their loved ones can
- 10:13get taken care of. So realizing that and like having
- 10:17such rich experiences with folks who were caretaking really gave
- 10:23me a good understanding of the women who do this work. Also,
- 10:29just speaking about folks who took care of me, my
- 10:32grandmother was one of the folks who took care of me.
- 10:35She was a house cleaner for most of her life
- 10:38in Charlotte, North Carolina. She had such a respect for
- 10:42her work, and so that is always kind of gave
- 10:45me a good understanding of how I was to think
- 10:49about her work too. She did it in such a
- 10:51dignified way. It was such decent work to her, and
- 10:55so that has always been my understanding of it, and
- 10:59coming into to be able to have the privilege to
- 11:01lead this organization has given me a newfound appreciation for
- 11:06being able to organize alongside care workers. I also think that,
- 11:11you know, the organizing that we do is so special,
- 11:15you know, just because of the demographics of the women
- 11:18that we serve. We know that they are coming to
- 11:22us and we're their home because they're domestic workers, but
- 11:25their mothers, sisters, nieces, their grandmothers, a lot of them
- 11:30are paid to do care work and their family caregivers.
- 11:34So just really appreciate, like organize alongside them and having
- 11:39such appreciation for their whole selves. That has been one
- 11:43of the just amazing benefits about being able to do
- 11:46this work, traveling across the country and meeting so many
- 11:49like amazing women.
- 11:51Speaker 1: Yeah, your story is certainly inspiring and it's good to
- 11:56hear about your conviction to do this work. I was
- 12:01telling Christina earlier that a couple of family members take
- 12:05care of my grandmother, and really that we are somehow
- 12:14connected to this, or we're related to this in some way,
- 12:21and many of us, probably at some point or another,
- 12:26had to find a caretaker for our children or a
- 12:32caretaker for an elderly or disabled person in our lives.
- 12:36So we're intertwined and interconnected with.
- 12:40Speaker 2: This absolutely as black women too. I feel like Juline
- 12:44is quite cultural, you know, like the collectivity of just
- 12:49like black black people and black women and like matriarchal families.
- 12:54I think just gives us such a different perspective on
- 12:58the work. And I would say, I'm thirty nine years old,
- 13:01and something that I reflect on is the fact that
- 13:05women who are my age and older there's most likely
- 13:11a connection to care work or care workers in some way,
- 13:14whether we're descendants of care workers, we come from a
- 13:17lineage of people who are domestic workers, and we're kind
- 13:20of coming into an understanding about that, or we're like
- 13:24caretaking ourselves. Sometimes we don't have the words to say,
- 13:27like I'm like taking care of my grandmother or my aunt,
- 13:31you know, but a lot of what we do is
- 13:33care is caretaking, and we're doing care work, you know.
- 13:35It's it's unpaid care work, but it's care work. So
- 13:39I think just the awareness of the cultural aspects is
- 13:44just given a different layer in doing this work, you know.
- 13:49And we are a multi lingual, multi ethnic, multi racial movement,
- 13:55and so I see the threads of that work and
- 13:58the collectivity, really see it across the way that we
- 14:02do the work, the way we're community with each other
- 14:04and we're always singing and dancing, like it shows up
- 14:07in so many different ways. So it's a real privilege.
- 14:11Speaker 1: So what is the one thing you wish more people
- 14:14understood about domestic worker industry?
- 14:19Speaker 2: I spoke a little bit about how you know, there's
- 14:22there's paid work and as an industry, and then there
- 14:27is unpaid work. And I wish people knew that that
- 14:33industry care work period. If looked at you know, all together,
- 14:38it's huge. It's like a one trillion dollar industry, you know,
- 14:42such a large piece of the economy, and women are
- 14:46so central, you know, women are doing that work and
- 14:50propping up, you know, so much in this economy. So
- 14:53that I wish people I wish people really knew that
- 14:56and understood it. I think oftentimes women do this work
- 15:02as a calling, they do it as an expectation, they
- 15:06do it because they want to do it, they're expected
- 15:10to do it, and I think sometimes it has the
- 15:13ability to not give us the fullest picture about how
- 15:17many people are impacted, or the exact dollar amount you
- 15:21know that this industry is worth when you zoom out,
- 15:25So it's a lot of money, you know, in our economy.
- 15:27And that's what I wish people understood.
- 15:31Speaker 1: It is an important reminder for many of people who
- 15:34might take this for granted, that care workers, domestic workers
- 15:41bring in tremendous value to our economy and it and
- 15:47to our worlds. They are people that are at the
- 15:52center of things. During COVID, they were they still had
- 15:59to work, they didn't have the luxury of staying at home,
- 16:05and we're in the reliant on domestic workers.
- 16:10Speaker 2: Yeah, and we find, Julie that like often in crisis,
- 16:15you know, domestic workers and care workers are on the
- 16:18front line. We found that out during COVID, you know,
- 16:21with the lack of ppe and other protections. And we
- 16:24find that in you know, the environmental crises that we're
- 16:28seeing as well, whether it's the fires in California or
- 16:31some of the hurricanes. We know that like often times,
- 16:34domestic workers are taking care of people in their homes
- 16:37and they are you know, considered essential. They're being asked
- 16:41to do really difficult things and often are on the
- 16:46front lines. And so they really deserve extra protections, you know,
- 16:51due to that.
- 16:53Speaker 1: Yeah, So have you ever had to fight for fair
- 16:58pain or reconie in your all career and if so,
- 17:02how has that experience shaped your leadership.
- 17:08Speaker 2: It's a great question. I've been really lucky to work
- 17:10alongside a lot of strong women. I was working in
- 17:15reproductive rights early in my career, and I transitioned into
- 17:21working in electoral politics, and I remember getting a new
- 17:27job and I was up for a promotion, but I
- 17:32had no real understanding of the amount of money that
- 17:35I should be asking for. So I'll never forget that.
- 17:38I had a conversation with my coworker who still remains
- 17:42my friend to this day. Her name is Danielle, and
- 17:46she just just told me, you know, this is what
- 17:49I'm making, this is what this person is making, and
- 17:52this is what this person is making. She really laid
- 17:56it out and was very clear, like she like told me,
- 17:59you know, this is what I'm making. You should ask
- 18:01for at least this, this is what your peers are making.
- 18:04So that just was so like clarifying for me. I
- 18:07read an interview about the View where Sherri Shephard actually
- 18:12said that like Rosie o'donald did that for her. She
- 18:15was like trying to advocate for her pay and she
- 18:18was like, Rosie o'donnald was like, look, I make two
- 18:20million dollars, you know dollars, here's what this person makes
- 18:23in this person. So I think that has the ability
- 18:26to unlock, you know something, And I'm very thankful that
- 18:30Danielle did that for me. And so yeah, I think
- 18:33that it's oftentimes, like you know, women like supporting each
- 18:38other and being very like transparent, I think is what
- 18:42I have definitely been a beneficiary of and very aware
- 18:48of the ability to carry that forward too in the
- 18:52way that I navigate.
- 18:55Speaker 1: And K brings up another conversation about that there should
- 18:59be more trans parency around how much we're getting paid,
- 19:03and fellow employees should be able to tell each other
- 19:08how much they're paid, and it's still this level of
- 19:11secrecy and surrounding how much we get paid, and companies
- 19:18tend to not like that very much. But I'm sure
- 19:22you're thankful that you had a friend that opened up
- 19:26to you about how much they were getting paid and
- 19:29how much your colleagues were getting paid. That look, that
- 19:32is a.
- 19:34Speaker 2: A valuable thing to have it really is, And Danielle
- 19:39is a white woman. I want to know as well.
- 19:41And I think that I don't know if you've experienced this, Julane,
- 19:45but like I had to unlearn a lot of like
- 19:50you know, shame, you know that I had around money,
- 19:53just like my thoughts about money, how I valued it,
- 19:57how I talked about it, you know how what really
- 20:00relationship I had with it. I really had to like
- 20:02grapple with that and realize that some of the conversations
- 20:07that I, you know, didn't want to have were really
- 20:10about like not knowing how to navigate and not growing
- 20:14up in a household where that was like okay to do,
- 20:17and also like being like it's a lot wrapped up
- 20:20in there being Southern, you know, being being polite, you know,
- 20:25taught to not be assertive in this way.
- 20:28Speaker 1: So yes, it.
- 20:29Speaker 2: Comes up, and you know, I will say, like it
- 20:31comes up across our membership too. I love, you know,
- 20:35sitting in and hearing some of our members just talk
- 20:37about negotiations, give each other wise counsel on how they
- 20:42negotiate their own pay, different tactics that they use, you know,
- 20:47how to know when you're you should ask for a
- 20:49race so it's really illuminating and it gives me a
- 20:53good understanding of how they navigate their roles because you're
- 20:57you're in a private home and there are so many
- 21:00like power dynamics and on display. But let me tell
- 21:04you something, they have no problem being like, oh, you're
- 21:07being asked to walk the dog, wash the dishes, and
- 21:11wash the baby's clothes. Okay, that's like separate jobs. You
- 21:14need to renegotiate. So they've like taught me a lot
- 21:18too about like being very clear, you know, and negotiating
- 21:23and like understanding like you're worth you know. So I
- 21:27love like sitting in on their conversations as well.
- 21:30Speaker 1: And that's the power of being a part of an organization.
- 21:34If you if you don't have the pure support within
- 21:38your workplace, but being a part of an external organization
- 21:43there is power. And being a part of something like
- 21:46that where you're able to have pure support and people
- 21:51that will cheer you on along the way.
- 21:55Speaker 2: Yeah, it's about having that community, you know, and people
- 21:58that you can turn to so important. Whether it's a
- 22:01Danielle at your job who you can just get on
- 22:04the zoom and say, girl, what's going on with these salaries?
- 22:07Or it's with other people who work in the same
- 22:10sector as you, or a part of an organization and
- 22:13a member of an organization that you can really be
- 22:15honest with and talk to.
- 22:19Speaker 1: So, for our listeners who want to be allies, what's
- 22:22the most effective way for them to support the NDWA
- 22:27and help advance your mission.
- 22:30Speaker 2: You know, we are the organization that fights for and
- 22:35represents the two point two million domestic workers in this country,
- 22:39but we are building a powerful movement of people who
- 22:44really understand care and understand the struggle and the difficulty
- 22:49around like taking care of our loved ones. So I
- 22:52would say that one thing that I would implore folks
- 22:56to do is to go to our website and it's
- 22:59Domestic Workers dot org and really sign up to be
- 23:03on our list, can stay on our email list, get
- 23:06more information whether we're fighting for bills at the national level,
- 23:10whether we're asking you to call your elected official. Will
- 23:15always really like give you things to do if you're
- 23:18politically minded, like we have a sister organization called Care
- 23:23and Action, So really tap into our movement is what
- 23:28I would.
- 23:29Speaker 1: Encourage folks to do.
- 23:30Speaker 2: Go on our website and learn about everything that we do,
- 23:33and sign up so that you can learn more and
- 23:36stay connected with us.
- 23:38Speaker 1: Thank you for sharing that, and it's definitely encouraging that
- 23:42there are some concrete steps that we can take.
- 23:47Speaker 2: Yes, the other the last thing I would say is
- 23:49telling your story oftentimes, like if you say, you know,
- 23:54can you talk about you know a time where you've
- 23:57cared for somebody or they cared for you, and can
- 23:59you tell us about your care story, people will just
- 24:03have such rich stories and experiences and it can unlock
- 24:07so much for other folks. So I think storytelling is
- 24:12how we connect with each other and have a good
- 24:15understanding of the things that tie us together. So go
- 24:18to Domestic workers dot org. But also tell the story about,
- 24:23you know, how someone took care of you and really
- 24:26transform things for you, or tell stories about how you
- 24:30take care of other folks. I think it's really important.
- 24:34Speaker 1: It is it is really critical work and definitely it
- 24:39is definitely needed, and I hope that domestic workers get
- 24:46the rights and privileges that they deserve. Thank you, Julie.
- 24:51Speaker 2: We're fighting for it every single day.
- 24:54Speaker 1: Well, Jan that's all the questions I have for today.
- 24:57Thank you for joining me. It's been an honor. Thank
- 25:00you that's it for this episode of Conversations for Equal Pay.
- 25:05To tune into more episodes, lock onto our website at
- 25:09Conversations forequalpay dot org. You're listening to Conversations for Equal
- 25:18Pay