Latest / The Film Hobbyist / You Can't Take it with You (1938): A Love Letter from a Lily
Transcript
- 0:11Come on in and spend some time with the film
- 0:14hobbyist. My name is Lydia, and I love movies.
- 0:32We're here in my attic room. You're sitting on
- 0:36a forest green Walmart futon. I'm in an old desk
- 0:40chair. Behind me is my desk. It's not a very
- 0:45impressive piece of furniture, just a hand -me
- 0:48-down L -framed construction, simple metal frame
- 0:51with black vinyl boards on top. But it's fairly
- 0:55full. There are stacks of papers, notebooks,
- 0:59reference texts. There are also bits of yarn
- 1:03and thread, some stray needles, coils of wire,
- 1:06bags of beads. I love movies. But I think it's
- 1:12important to remind you that I'm a film hobbyist.
- 1:16As in, I have no professional history or training
- 1:20in film whatsoever. I didn't go to film school.
- 1:24I didn't study it in college. Watching movies,
- 1:29reading about them, talking about them, this
- 1:32is what I do for fun, for pure interest and enjoyment.
- 1:38I actually do have a career, something I've studied
- 1:42and practiced and invested years of my life in.
- 1:46I'm a novelist. I'm also very slow at revision,
- 1:50so I'm not actually published yet. But I'm waist
- 1:54-deep in a final draft on one project, and I
- 1:57have multiple completed drafts of other projects,
- 2:00plus a smattering of things I can finish when
- 2:03I want to. I love writing. I love being with
- 2:08my characters and knowing them intimately. I
- 2:12love the thrill of imagining and of chiseling
- 2:16out a first draft, watching a story emerge from
- 2:20the white page as if it already existed fully
- 2:23formed in my subconscious. I'm also a craftsperson.
- 2:28I crochet dolls and plushies. It's so much fun.
- 2:33It's like three -dimensional illustrations. I
- 2:37try to capture faces and characters with just
- 2:40yarn and thread. It's a delight. If you look
- 2:44behind me, you can see the two -foot -long dragon
- 2:47I've been working on, Haku from Spirited Away,
- 2:50crocheted in embroidery thread. He's almost done.
- 2:55That one's for my husband. But other works I've
- 2:58sold. I've done commissions and craft fairs.
- 3:02It's not much, but it's enough to feel satisfied
- 3:06in my work and its skill. I love stories, and
- 3:12I love making things. It's hard to articulate
- 3:16the joy these things bring me, the crafting of
- 3:20a book or a doll, the joy of creating and imagining
- 3:25and discovery, of work well done. But sometimes,
- 3:32You find stories that articulate it for you.
- 3:35And that's how I feel about 1938's You Can't
- 3:39Take It With You, directed by Frank Capra. I
- 3:44first discovered Frank Capra the way most people
- 3:46do. Through his masterpiece and notorious flop,
- 3:50It's a Wonderful Life. It bombed so hard at the
- 3:54box office that it bankrupted its independent
- 3:56studio, Liberty Films, and ended up in the public
- 4:00domain. So when TV channels were trying to fill
- 4:03Christmas programming slots, they didn't have
- 4:06to spend money to use it. The nostalgia of seeing
- 4:10it broadcasted year after year led audiences
- 4:14to re -evaluate the film, which led to its place
- 4:17as a Christmas classic. Growing up, we owned
- 4:21it on VHS. And I watched it young enough that
- 4:25the character I identified most with was Zuzu.
- 4:29the protagonist's youngest daughter. In middle
- 4:33school, we watched Mr. Smith Goes to Washington
- 4:36as part of my social studies class. It's an idealistic
- 4:40civics lesson and a cynical political drama all
- 4:43in one. Not a bad way to show what we hope for
- 4:47America and what we painfully discover it truly
- 4:50is. And I recognized Capra's name. From the library,
- 4:55I watched Capra's other classics. Mr. Deeds Goes
- 4:59to Town, It Happened One Night, Arsenic and Old
- 5:03Lace, movies that are remembered and discussed
- 5:06and enjoyed. So I also grabbed You Can't Take
- 5:11It With You out of a sense of completionism.
- 5:14It's a Frank Capra film with Jimmy Stewart. Lionel
- 5:18Barrymore's in it too. And yes, it won Best Picture.
- 5:22Isn't that funny? One of those Best Picture winners
- 5:26that... don't get talked about as much anymore.
- 5:29But what I found instead was a movie that spoke
- 5:33to my soul, that captured feelings I already
- 5:37had, hopes I had for my life. If you read a description
- 5:43of this film, it will inevitably be called a
- 5:47romantic comedy or a screwball comedy. I think
- 5:51the latter is more accurate. although it still
- 5:54fails to capture the real thrust of this story.
- 5:58Yes, it is a comedy, and yes, there is a romance,
- 6:02but I think it's more accurate to describe this
- 6:06as a philosophical debate between two patriarchs
- 6:10over their worldviews. On one side, we have Anthony
- 6:15P. Kirby. a Wall Street banker returning from
- 6:18a successful trip lobbying in D .C. for a contract
- 6:22that would allow him to force his competition
- 6:25into an aggressive merger. He is a man who cares
- 6:30about money and power and his financial empire.
- 6:35His life is his business. His legacy is his business.
- 6:42Which is why he's promoted his son to be vice
- 6:45president. After all, he's Anthony P. Kirby Jr.
- 6:49The work is his inheritance. On the other side,
- 6:54we have Grandpa Martin Vanderhoff. Years ago,
- 6:59he worked at a big, important job. But one day,
- 7:04on his way to work, he realized that he didn't
- 7:07enjoy it, and that he'd much rather spend his
- 7:10days doing what he enjoyed then grinding at a
- 7:14job that only gave him money in return. After
- 7:17all, when you die, you can't take it with you.
- 7:22So he went home and devoted his time to collecting
- 7:25stamps and instilling his family and community
- 7:29with his sense of value. He already owned his
- 7:33house. What more could he want? So in that house
- 7:37with him lives his sprawling family. His middle
- 7:41-aged daughter, a playwright of melodramas, her
- 7:45husband who invents fireworks in the basement
- 7:48with their former Iceman, a full -grown granddaughter
- 7:52who makes candy and is an aspiring dancer, married
- 7:56to a printer and xylophonist, and another granddaughter,
- 8:00Alice, who, while having the perfectly ordinary
- 8:03aspiration of being a stenographer, enjoys sliding
- 8:07down the banisters and having the freedom of
- 8:10her own opinions. These two men, their families
- 8:15and their worldviews are thrust into conflict
- 8:18in two ways. First, in order to complete his
- 8:23aggressive merger, Anthony P. Kirby, or AP as
- 8:28he's called, needs to buy up the 12 blocks that
- 8:31surround his competitors' factories. And he has,
- 8:35with the exception of a single house. Grandpa
- 8:41Vanderhoff's house. AP thinks he can offer Grandpa
- 8:46a pile of cash and the man will move on. After
- 8:50all, money is the most important thing in the
- 8:53world, second only to business and power. Offer
- 8:57a man enough money and he'll do whatever you
- 9:00want. But of course, Grandpa doesn't care about
- 9:05money. is the real plot engine of the story.
- 9:13As I said, AP has a son, Tony. He's made Tony
- 9:19vice president of his whole operation. But this
- 9:22is a complete and utter nepo hire. Tony doesn't
- 9:27really want to have anything to do with the whole
- 9:29thing. He's bored out of his mind. In college,
- 9:34he did have ambitions. We find out later that
- 9:39he had big dreams of scientific breakthroughs
- 9:42and technological advances. He was kind of a
- 9:46proto -solar energy guy. He wanted to study chlorophyll
- 9:51to see if understanding how plants turn sunlight
- 9:55into food could be harnessed to address food
- 9:58insecurity, a definite alternate energy difficulty
- 10:02of his day. But then he realized the difficulty
- 10:06of funding and labs, and there was all this pressure
- 10:10from his dad, so he gave it all up. Tony is played
- 10:15by Jimmy Stewart, and this is maybe the most
- 10:18unlikable role I've ever seen him in. He's bored,
- 10:22a little entitled, has a kind of shiftless energy.
- 10:28Although you can see in moments a real, vibrant
- 10:31human being under all that nonsense. Anyway,
- 10:35here he is, bored, listless, in a job he doesn't
- 10:40want to do, stuck in his office all day, not
- 10:44doing much except hanging out with his stenographer.
- 10:48Because, of course, he has a stenographer. And
- 10:53who's his stenographer? Why, it's Alice, Grandpa
- 10:58Vanderhoff's granddaughter. Jean Arthur plays
- 11:02her as this spunky, lively kind of woman, utterly
- 11:07charming and endlessly fascinating. I've seen
- 11:11a lot of summaries and discussions of this film
- 11:14calling Alice the only ordinary one in the family,
- 11:18and I don't agree with that take at all. Her
- 11:21aspirations might be ordinary. But she isn't.
- 11:26Grandpa's philosophy isn't about making art.
- 11:30It's about doing what you enjoy and caring about
- 11:34people and community more than caring about money.
- 11:38Alice isn't a stenographer to make money. She's
- 11:42a stenographer for the fun of it. It's good work,
- 11:45and she enjoys doing it. Although, of course,
- 11:49she isn't doing much work at Tony's office. We
- 11:54meet the two of them pretty far into their romance.
- 11:57You get the sense that since she got the job,
- 12:00she mostly spends the day hanging out with him,
- 12:03like two high schoolers working at a job in a
- 12:07resort town in the off -season where there isn't
- 12:10much to do but talk and goof off. You can see
- 12:14immediately why Tony would fall for Alice, and
- 12:18with her all spunky and wonderful, She brings
- 12:22out the life in him. He's playful and absolutely
- 12:27delighted with her. And when he proposes in their
- 12:31first scene together, she says yes. The next
- 12:35step is, of course, for their families to meet.
- 12:40It is this romance that brings these two philosophies
- 12:44crashing into each other. exacerbated by the
- 12:47screwball contrivance of AP's business deal and
- 12:51Grandpa's house. You know that there will be
- 12:54hijinks and laughs and some cringing, as well
- 12:58as a happy ending. It's a delightful ride to
- 13:01go on, one I highly recommend. Track it down
- 13:05through your local library, or look around online.
- 13:08Last I saw, it was on YouTube, free with ads.
- 13:13But... The piece of this movie that really stuck
- 13:17with me, really washed over me, was the core
- 13:21of Grandpa's philosophy. He calls himself and
- 13:26his family lilies, referencing a passage from
- 13:29the Bible, part of what's called the Sermon on
- 13:32the Mount in the Book of Matthew. Consider the
- 13:36lilies of the field, how they grow. They neither
- 13:40toil nor spin. Yet I tell you, even King Solomon
- 13:45in all his splendor was not arrayed like one
- 13:49of these. But if God so clothes the grass of
- 13:53the field, which is here today and tomorrow is
- 13:56thrown into the fire, how much more will he clothe
- 14:00you? Grandpa says he and his family are lilies.
- 14:06They might toil and spin a little, but they don't
- 14:10need to worry about money. or financial gain,
- 14:13what good would that be? They trust that all
- 14:18their needs will be provided for. And so they
- 14:22can be generous with their time and attention
- 14:25and their home. We see that Grandpa and his family
- 14:30are beloved in their community. Their table is
- 14:33open to guests. The music and the candy and the
- 14:37fireworks make enough money for them to get by
- 14:40and bring life to their neighborhood. Not all
- 14:45of this film holds up to modern values. Grandpa
- 14:50has strong opinions on not having to pay taxes,
- 14:53and the family employs a black cook whose depiction
- 14:57doesn't do much to challenge 1930s racial stereotypes.
- 15:03But I think... Their community investment, and
- 15:07their trust that all their needs will be provided
- 15:09for as they work at what brings them joy, continues
- 15:13to challenge the status quo. And, as I said,
- 15:19it meant a lot to me personally. I decided I
- 15:25wanted to be a writer when I was 12. Settling
- 15:29on the answer to that ubiquitous, frankly terrible
- 15:32question we ask children, what do you want to
- 15:35be when you grow up, had taken me a lot of time
- 15:39and energy and thought. I loved to sing and to
- 15:44act too, but writing struck me as the kind of
- 15:47work I could spend my whole life pursuing. It
- 15:52didn't come effortlessly. But the fact that I
- 15:55needed to focus my efforts more, that I would
- 15:58need to study and practice and grow, was delightful
- 16:02to me. A joyful challenge. So I finally started
- 16:08telling the adults in my life. I thought they
- 16:11would be thrilled. I had finally decided on an
- 16:15answer to the question I'd been asked as long
- 16:17as I could remember. But they merely countered
- 16:22with another question. How are you going to make
- 16:26money? I didn't have a good answer. I've always
- 16:32been a notoriously bad teacher. Storytelling
- 16:36and explaining aren't the same thing as practically
- 16:40passing down skills, especially to those who
- 16:43aren't interested. I knew even back then that
- 16:47I struggled with planning and administration.
- 16:51and I'm definitely stronger with intellectual
- 16:53and people skills than physical labor. During
- 16:59my years in middle school and high school, I
- 17:02took at least five separate career tests. I think
- 17:07that as a small school district in rural Appalachia,
- 17:12they were hoping to encourage their students
- 17:15to make plans. to know that they had options
- 17:18beyond what their parents did or working at Walmart.
- 17:22Options that might require leaving home permanently
- 17:26or just long enough to get a degree and come
- 17:30back. So I took five separate career tests. And
- 17:36frustratingly enough, every single one of them
- 17:40said the same thing. I should work in the arts.
- 17:46This didn't answer the burning question. It made
- 17:50it worse. I finally decided to start telling
- 17:55people that I was going to work whatever minimum
- 17:58wage job I could find and live in a garret. That's
- 18:03a 19th century attic room, the cheapest, worst
- 18:07kind of place to live, hot in the summer, cold
- 18:10in the winter. It was frequently associated with
- 18:14writers and artists. because it was what they
- 18:17could afford. It's the capital R romantic signifier
- 18:21of being a starving artist. And it was a good
- 18:24answer, because it diffused the tension with
- 18:27a joke. I could toss off the phrase with an air
- 18:31that left room for something else. But there
- 18:35was nothing else. What on earth could I do? I
- 18:42couldn't imagine living my life Spending my time
- 18:46doing anything else but participating in the
- 18:50arts. The gift You Can't Take It With You gave
- 18:56to me was that of an alternate view. Grandpa's
- 19:01family isn't rolling in dough. They're put under
- 19:04financial pressure in the course of this story.
- 19:08But they know there has to be another way of
- 19:11living than what society expects. What good is
- 19:16spending an entire third of your life toiling
- 19:19at what feels like death and what encourages
- 19:22death for the accumulation of a legacy that ends
- 19:26with you? Over the course of this story, AP's
- 19:31assumptions are challenged, and he realizes how
- 19:34fragile it all is, this scrapping, bean -counting,
- 19:38anti -humanity accumulation of wealth. It isn't
- 19:43wrong to earn money. It is wrong to care about
- 19:48money more than people, the accumulation of money
- 19:51more than the act of creating or of participating
- 19:55in life. I know all this can easily be dismissed
- 20:01as idealism and sentimentality. That's the brush
- 20:06with which Frank Capra's films are usually painted,
- 20:08and it's why Mr. Smith Goes to Washington is
- 20:11shown to middle schoolers and not college students.
- 20:15Capra, the argument goes, is more fit for the
- 20:19young, the starry -eyed. It's films of later
- 20:23eras that got to the truth of real life, of the
- 20:26necessity of struggle and striving. I do have
- 20:31a different perspective on Capra's work now that
- 20:34I'm a full -grown adult with years of pain and
- 20:38suffering and real life under my belt. These
- 20:42days, You Can't Take It With You doesn't hit
- 20:45me like it did in high school as a sort of manifesto
- 20:49for how I hoped to live my life making art in
- 20:52my garret. These days, You Can't Take It With
- 20:58You makes me cry. I'm not a published novelist.
- 21:07I'm waist -deep in a final draft of a novel,
- 21:10struggling through revision, trying to write
- 21:14actual good sentences. My crochet business is
- 21:19in flux these days, waiting to see if the next
- 21:23craft fair will be a better fit for my product
- 21:26than the last. I spend most of my days, as a
- 21:31full -time parent, trying to find meals that
- 21:34everyone in my family will eat. You Can't Take
- 21:39It With You makes me cry because it tells me
- 21:43that I made the right choice. Maybe I could have
- 21:49buried my artistic ambitions underground and
- 21:52concentrated on making money, forcing myself
- 21:55into a corporate job that I hated and took up
- 21:59all of my time and energy. Maybe, if I had given
- 22:03up having a family or sleeping, I could have
- 22:07continued to make art, making that my monetized
- 22:10hobby. I could have striven. I could have slaved
- 22:14to make that happen. Or maybe I could have turned
- 22:18my writing into a machine, forgetting about good
- 22:21sentences and just pumping out books for the
- 22:24self -publishing market as quickly as I could.
- 22:28Again, there's nothing wrong with corporate jobs
- 22:32or monetized hobbies or professional writing.
- 22:36There's nothing wrong with being a stenographer,
- 22:39if that's what brings you life and brings you
- 22:42joy and family and community. It just wouldn't
- 22:48have been that way for me. I couldn't see a way
- 22:54to answer that question of acquiring money that
- 22:57made me feel alive. What I find in Grandpa Vanderhoff's
- 23:03philosophy is that reminder that I don't have
- 23:07to worry about what I achieve or accomplish.
- 23:11That I can trust that everything I need will
- 23:15be provided for. That I can live as a lily, toiling
- 23:21a little bit, but getting to participate in the
- 23:25making of art and the building of community.
- 23:29A community that, guess what, includes you. So
- 23:36thank you. Thanks for coming.