Latest / For the Missing: Missing Persons, Families & the Search for Answers / The Axe in the Coal Bin: Lizzie Borden’s Fall River Silence | For the Missing
Transcript
- Imagine standing in a house so quiet you could hear your own heartbeat, then realizing the person who loved you most is lying dead on the floor, and the only witness is you. What would you say? What would you do? Let’s set the scene. It is August 4th, 1892. The air in Fall River, Massachusetts, is thick with summer heat, but inside the Borden home, the atmosphere is colder than any winter wind. This isn’t just any house. It stands in an affluent neighborhood, yet it feels isolated, separated from the more fashionable Highlands where the truly wealthy lived. The Bordens are respected, or at least respected for their money. Andrew Jackson Borden built his fortune through furniture, caskets, and property. He was a director of textile mills, president of the Union Savings Bank. His estate is valued at three hundred thousand dollars—a staggering sum that equals over ten million today. But wealth doesn’t buy warmth. In fact, Andrew Borden was known for his extreme frugality. Despite having servants and living in a large home, there was no indoor plumbing. It was a common feature for people of means, but not here. Not for Andrew. The house felt rigid, controlled. And within those walls, tension had been building for months. You can feel it if you listen closely to the history. There were arguments about money, about property, about inheritance. Lizzie and her sister Emma had recently bought a rental house from their father for one dollar, only to sell it back to him weeks later for five thousand dollars. Money was moving like water, slippery and cold. And then, just days before everything changed, the entire household fell violently ill. A family friend later speculated it was mutton left on the stove too long. But Abby Borden feared poison. She wasn’t popular in town, and Andrew certainly wasn’t either. They were isolated figures, surrounded by silence. To understand the crime, we have to understand the life that preceded it. Lizzie Andrew Borden was born in 1860, the third child. Her older sister Alice died young, leaving Lizzie and Emma as the surviving daughters. Their upbringing was religious, strict. They attended Central Congregational Church. Lizzie taught Sunday school to children of recent immigrants. She served as secretary-treasurer for the Christian Endeavor Society. She was involved in the Woman’s Christian Temperance Union. On paper, she was the perfect daughter, the pillar of the community. But behind closed doors, relationships were strained. Andrew married Abby Durfee Gray three years after Lizzie’s mother died. Lizzie called her stepmother “Mrs. Borden.” She demurred when asked if they had a cordial relationship. She believed Abby had married her father for his wealth. Then there was Bridget Sullivan, the twenty-five-year-old live-in maid from Ireland. Bridget testified that Lizzie and Emma rarely ate meals with their parents. They ate separately. They lived parallel lives under the same roof. Just weeks before the murders, Andrew killed multiple pigeons in his barn with a hatchet. He believed they carried infections. Lizzie had recently built a roost for them. It has been commonly recounted that she was upset he killed them, though historians dispute the veracity of this story. Why does this matter? Because it shows a fracture. A small, domestic violence that hints at the larger explosion waiting to happen. The household was already breaking apart, piece by piece. It starts on a Thursday. The morning of August 4th, 1892. John Vinnicum Morse, Lizzie and Emma’s maternal uncle, arrived the evening before. He slept in the guest room. He came to discuss business matters, specifically property transfers. Tension was already high. Maybe his visit aggravated what was already a volatile situation. We don’t know exactly what was said, but we know the mood was heavy. Breakfast happens. Andrew, Abby, Morse, and Bridget are present. After breakfast, Andrew and Morse go to the sitting room. They chat for nearly an hour. Lizzie and Emma are elsewhere. We don’t know exactly what they are doing. This is where the timeline begins to blur, where the facts become slippery. At some point, Andrew goes downstairs. He is struck down. Abby follows. She is struck down. By whom? By what? The details are brutal, but we must speak them with dignity. Andrew suffered approximately ten axe blows to the head. Abby received five strikes. Some victims were struck multiple times. The violence was intense, personal, and final. When Bridget Sullivan discovered the bodies, the silence of the house was broken forever. Now, let’s talk about Lizzie. She returns to the house after being away. For four days prior, she had stayed in a local rooming house. Why? A family argument in July had prompted both sisters to take extended vacations in New Bedford. They returned a week before the murders. Lizzie chose to stay away for four more days. That distance matters. That choice matters. When she returns, the police are already investigating. They focus heavily on her. Why? Because she is the daughter. Because she is the beneficiary. And because her statements are inconsistent. She tells them where she was; she tells them something else later. The police find a blood-stained dress. Lizzie claims it was ruined by paint. Paint in a house without indoor plumbing? Paint in a house where the women rarely ate with the men? It raises questions. It raises suspicion. But here is the thing about forensic science in 1892. It was primitive. There was no DNA testing. There was no fingerprint analysis as we know it. There was only circumstantial evidence. And a hatchet. A hatchet was found in the basement coal bin. Initially, everyone thought it was the murder weapon. But later analysis determined it was too small for the wounds inflicted. Too small. So the weapon vanished into the ether. No definitive physical evidence linked Lizzie to the weapons or the blood. Just suspicion. Just a stained dress. Just a woman who didn’t cry enough. The trial took place in June 1893. It lasted only one day. One day to decide the fate of a woman accused of killing her father and stepmother with an axe. The jury was all-male. They looked at Lizzie. They looked at the evidence. They looked at the lack of evidence. And they acquitted her. Acquired. Not guilty. No one else was charged. No one else was ever charged. Lizzie Borden walked free. Think about the weight of that moment. The public outcry. The widespread publicity across the United States. People wanted a villain. They wanted a confession. They got acquittal instead. And Lizzie? She spent the remainder of her life in Fall River. She and her sister Emma inherited their father’s estate. They managed it until their deaths decades later. They never publicly discussed the case. Never. They lived in the shadow of the axe, but they also lived in the freedom of the law. It is a strange peace. To be innocent in the eyes of the law, but perhaps guilty in the eyes of history. Lizzie died on June 1st, 1927. She was sixty-six years old. She died of pneumonia. Nine days before her older sister Emma died. Two sisters, alone together in the end. The Borden murders remained a topic in American popular culture. Depicted in films, theatrical productions, literary works. And folk rhymes. The famous nursery rhyme: “Lizzie Borden took a ax / Forty whacks and then she fled.” We remember the rhyme. We forget the human. We forget that Lizzie taught Sunday school. We forget that she was involved in temperance unions. We forget that she was a daughter trying to navigate a complex family dynamic filled with money disputes and illness. Modern forensic analysis suggests that another person or persons may have committed the murders. No definitive physical evidence directly linked Lizzie to the crime. But the story stuck. The mystery stuck. Because sometimes, the truth is harder to accept than a fairy tale. Or a nightmare. We still wonder. We still ask. Who really did it? And why did Lizzie Borden remain silent? I’m Kimberley Callahan. Thank you for listening. Thank you for holding space for Lizzie, for Abby, for Andrew. For the complexity of a family torn apart by money and grief. Remember, dignity matters even in death. Truth matters in absence. And we keep searching, not just for answers, but for understanding. This story is drawn from public records and widely reported accounts. Our thoughts are with everyone affected.