Latest / Surrounded / Gen Z’s Being Fed Fascism
Transcript
- 0:00You think MSNBC is radical?
- 0:02You think MSNBC is radical?
- 0:03Do you think,
- 0:04what do you think is radicalizing more people,
- 0:05Nick Fuentes or MSNBC?
- 0:07Probably MSNBC.
- 0:07A lot of times they return to the idea
- 0:10that MSNBC or the Democratic Party was radicalizing people.
- 0:14And I guess the broader point
- 0:16in this segment that I was trying to get towards
- 0:19is
- 0:20which side it comes from in a top-down manner.
- 0:22So every time I see people in power on the right
- 0:26talking about the.
- 0:27Democratic Party,
- 0:27they're using incredibly incendiary rhetoric,
- 0:30whether it's Stephen Miller or Caroline Leavitt,
- 0:33and then when I see people in power on the left,
- 0:35I feel like they're always more conciliatory.
- 0:37So after Charlie Kirk died,
- 0:38every single politician unanimously was trying to tone things down.
- 0:42The people that are extreme on the left were protesting outside of the DNC,
- 0:47but the people that are extreme on the right are inside the RNC on a daily basis.
- 0:52They're inside the turning point.
- 0:55Adam,
- 0:55welcome to the surrounded follow-up.
- 0:57Uh,
- 0:57it's
- 0:59great to finally meet you.
- 1:00I've been watching your content for some time,
- 1:02hearing yours,
- 1:02and,
- 1:05uh,
- 1:05yeah,
- 1:05it was great to see your episode.
- 1:07You haven't seen any of the,
- 1:08the footage yet,
- 1:09have you?
- 1:10I've seen nothing from the episode except for like a 12th snippet,
- 1:14and we filmed it 2.5 months ago,
- 1:16basically.
- 1:17So you'll see that my hair is way different.
- 1:19My hair is really.
- 1:21Sure,
- 1:21I don't think I've cut it since then.
- 1:22So now I've got a long ass haircut.
- 1:24No,
- 1:24I,
- 1:24I don't even remember a lot of it.
- 1:26It's starting to worry me.
- 1:27It's slipping my mind.
- 1:28Well,
- 1:29you did film it a while ago.
- 1:31Um,
- 1:31I'll show you some clips of it today,
- 1:33and we can kind of react to it.
- 1:35But I'm curious,
- 1:36just,
- 1:36you know,
- 1:37with what you can recall,
- 1:39how did you feel about it
- 1:40going into it,
- 1:41um,
- 1:42because I,
- 1:42you know,
- 1:43we were closer to the assassination of Charlie Kirk,
- 1:45that was more fresh on people's minds.
- 1:47So yeah.
- 1:47What was kind of going through your,
- 1:48your,
- 1:49your mind going into being on the show?
- 1:51I've done a lot of debates this year,
- 1:53and as I do them,
- 1:55I feel more and more confident.
- 1:56So
- 1:57I wasn't exactly nervous going into this one,
- 2:00but this one I was more intimidated for
- 2:02than most of my other recent appearances.
- 2:04I mean,
- 2:04I've done some really good CNN hits.
- 2:06I've done some Piers Morgan debates,
- 2:08other debates on air.
- 2:09This one had me a bit intimidated just because of the uncertainty of 20 versus.
- 2:15one.
- 2:15I remember being in the green room,
- 2:17and I hear like 20 voices out there,
- 2:20you know,
- 2:20rumbling and talking,
- 2:21and I'm just imagining all the different ways it could go.
- 2:24And yeah,
- 2:25the uncertainty was a little bit nerve-wracking,
- 2:27but overall,
- 2:28I'd like to think that,
- 2:29um,
- 2:30that it felt pretty good.
- 2:31And then on the,
- 2:31on the way out after it was over,
- 2:33I remember feeling pretty confident,
- 2:34like super confident that it went well.
- 2:37I really connected with all the Trump supporters there in such a way that like,
- 2:41you know,
- 2:41we took selfies.
- 2:42I think we were all just like chatting and talking and it was a cool experience.
- 2:46Oh great.
- 2:46Yeah,
- 2:47there was,
- 2:47there was a camaraderie.
- 2:49There were several times during the episode where you kind of just applauded or
- 2:52commended whoever was in the center with you for making a good argument.
- 2:56So yeah,
- 2:56let's,
- 2:57I wanna dive into your first claim and then we
- 3:00can watch the first clip just to refresh your memory,
- 3:03the first clip I want to react to is in response to your first claim,
- 3:06which was there's a rise of fascism.
- 3:09Um,
- 3:10happening in your generation,
- 3:12something roughly along those lines.
- 3:14Um,
- 3:16Before we watch the clip,
- 3:17do you feel like
- 3:19this is unique
- 3:21to your generation,
- 3:22which,
- 3:22uh,
- 3:23you know,
- 3:23Gen Z,
- 3:24this,
- 3:24this kind of
- 3:25exposure to fascistic.
- 3:28Ideology.
- 3:29I think it's happening across generations,
- 3:31but the way it's manifesting in my generation is unique.
- 3:35So like the week before we recorded this,
- 3:37there was a new group chat.
- 3:39There's a new article about the young Republican
- 3:41group chat where a bunch of Republicans,
- 3:43like 20 to 30 years of age,
- 3:45were saying uniquely.
- 3:47This far right stuff about gas chambers and all of that.
- 3:51So it was at the top of mind because the griper movement has been,
- 3:54you know,
- 3:54talked about a lot lately.
- 3:55I think that there's a lot of fascistic
- 3:57elements that have manifested throughout all generations.
- 4:00Um,
- 4:01I'm not even saying people are fascists.
- 4:02I just think like the denying of elections or the worship of one person.
- 4:07But I think that in my generation,
- 4:08it,
- 4:08it,
- 4:09it is manifesting in unique ways.
- 4:11But I guess that one of the counters somebody could have come up with is,
- 4:14hey,
- 4:14it's not just in our generation,
- 4:16it's all generations.
- 4:17That would have actually been a pretty good counter like,
- 4:19yeah,
- 4:19you're right.
- 4:19OK,
- 4:20so that cues up perfectly what we're gonna watch.
- 4:22So let me share this clip with you.
- 4:23This is you,
- 4:25um,
- 4:26Debating Sarah.
- 4:28The difference is that young leftists genuinely worshiped
- 4:31the murder of Charlie Kirk and Luigi Mangion,
- 4:34who are people committing genuine acts of violence,
- 4:37and they genuinely condone that.
- 4:38So that's the big difference,
- 4:39because,
- 4:40I mean,
- 4:40I saw literally graffiti on college campuses saying kill all Charlie Kirk's.
- 4:44They are inciting violence,
- 4:46and that is a totally like normalized thing to say to like celebrate the fact,
- 4:49and that.
- 4:50Serious and the political group chat was a joke,
- 4:52and you know that.
- 4:53OK,
- 4:53so your concession is that,
- 4:55you know,
- 4:55people talk like fascists in private sometimes,
- 4:57but you're worried that leftists are using increasingly violent
- 5:00rhetoric like the people that you were talking about.
- 5:01Luigi Mangioni is serious and one thing is a joke.
- 5:04OK,
- 5:04I want to ask you one thing.
- 5:05Did one Democratic politician support what Luigi did?
- 5:07Can you name any actual democratic politician?
- 5:09Uh,
- 5:10no,
- 5:10but it doesn't matter because on the other side,
- 5:12you're talking about the rise in the generation.
- 5:13You're not.
- 5:14Talking about politicians in their speech.
- 5:16I am talking about politicians as well.
- 5:17So on the other side,
- 5:19you're,
- 5:19no,
- 5:19no,
- 5:19no,
- 5:19no,
- 5:19let me,
- 5:20let me clarify.
- 5:21What about young leftists?
- 5:22What about,
- 5:23what about the violence that young leftists?
- 5:24Let me clarify very,
- 5:25very quickly.
- 5:26So you're trying to point to young leftists on the left,
- 5:29but on the right,
- 5:30there are politicians in power,
- 5:31people like Stephen Miller,
- 5:32who says the Democratic Party is a domestic extremist organization.
- 5:36Caroline Levitt just the other day,
- 5:37as I said.
- 5:38said that the entire base is Hamas terrorists and criminals.
- 5:41So when you have people in power on the right,
- 5:44wait,
- 5:44wait,
- 5:44wait,
- 5:45they're using this rhetoric and normalizing it that goes downstream.
- 5:48So and you have left wing media like
- 5:49MSNBC cheering backstage when Charlie Kirk was murdered.
- 5:52Wait,
- 5:52you think people are being murdered because of MSNBC?
- 5:54You think MSNBC is radical?
- 5:56Yes,
- 5:56I do.
- 5:56You think MSNBC is radical?
- 5:58Do you think,
- 5:58what do you think is radicalizing more people,
- 6:00Nick Fuentes or MSNBC?
- 6:02Probably MSNBC really more so than Nick Fuentes.
- 6:05I hear someone laughing behind me and that's kind of,
- 6:06hm,
- 6:07it's interesting because a lot of times they return to
- 6:11the idea that MSNBC or the Democratic Party was radicalizing people
- 6:16and I guess the broader point
- 6:17in this segment that I was trying to get towards
- 6:20is
- 6:21which side it comes from in a top-down manner.
- 6:23So every time I see people in power on the right
- 6:27talking about the Democratic Party,
- 6:29they're using incredibly in.
- 6:30Icendiary rhetoric,
- 6:31whether it's Stephen Miller or Caroline Leavitt,
- 6:34and then when I see people in power on the left,
- 6:36I feel like they're always more conciliatory.
- 6:38So after Charlie Kirk died,
- 6:40every single politician unanimously was trying to tone things down
- 6:44when,
- 6:45when something happens like that,
- 6:46I just see left wing politicians operating in a different way.
- 6:50Now people in our generation on the left do hold
- 6:54sometimes extremist views,
- 6:55but I just don't see it manifesting in the same way like the difference would be.
- 6:59The people that are extreme on the left were protesting outside of the DNC,
- 7:04but the people that are extreme on the right are inside the RNC on a daily basis.
- 7:09They're inside the Turning Point USA floor.
- 7:12Yeah,
- 7:12and this,
- 7:13this argument came up multiple times.
- 7:15We kind of circled back to this throughout the episode
- 7:17and
- 7:18I just kind of repeat back what.
- 7:20I'm hearing from you,
- 7:22you can see there are
- 7:24cultural elements of extremism that we see on the left,
- 7:28but you're saying those aren't
- 7:29representative of
- 7:31political leadership on that side.
- 7:33But on the right,
- 7:34we have extreme
- 7:36sentiments being expressed by people who hold much more power,
- 7:40um.
- 7:41And I mean,
- 7:43this isn't necessarily
- 7:45political extremism,
- 7:46but the recent
- 7:47Rob Reiner tweet,
- 7:49you know,
- 7:49it does support
- 7:51that argument to some degree,
- 7:52you know,
- 7:53people celebrated when Charlie Kirk died,
- 7:55but they weren't,
- 7:56you know,
- 7:56it wasn't major politicians,
- 7:59um,
- 7:59but they went on social media and did that.
- 8:01But then,
- 8:01you know,
- 8:01you have this famous director
- 8:04die in a horrifying way and you have the president of the United States
- 8:08tweeting
- 8:09an incredibly bizarre.
- 8:11You know,
- 8:12kind of mocking,
- 8:13um,
- 8:14message about it,
- 8:16uh.
- 8:17From,
- 8:18you know,
- 8:18the official
- 8:19POTUS account,
- 8:20um,
- 8:21is that kind of,
- 8:21does that support and sort of reinforce what you're trying to express?
- 8:25Yeah,
- 8:25that happened like 2 months after we filmed it,
- 8:27but that would have been the prime example at the moment,
- 8:29of course,
- 8:30is that the President of the United States
- 8:32was,
- 8:32I mean,
- 8:32like
- 8:33people on Twitter in real time had their argument undercut.
- 8:36So after Rob Reiner was killed,
- 8:37which was tragic,
- 8:38for the next 12 hours.
- 8:40The right wingers are patting themselves on the back in a masturbatory way,
- 8:43saying like,
- 8:44look,
- 8:44look how good we are,
- 8:45we're not going to make fun of him and then Trump came out and swooped
- 8:49that entire argument under the rug by just saying
- 8:51like it shatters it shatters the entire argument.
- 8:54So like,
- 8:54yeah,
- 8:54of course there's going to be extreme elements of the left,
- 8:57but when I see the rise of this sort of
- 8:59nihilistic fascistic wing,
- 9:02especially of the Nick Fuentes roper.
- 9:04I mean,
- 9:05some people in that room have tweeted some crazy far right shit before.
- 9:09So it's,
- 9:10it's like,
- 9:11I,
- 9:11it's crazy that their representatives trying to say that there's not a far right
- 9:16swing
- 9:17when I've seen people tweet like some crazy shit.
- 9:19Yeah,
- 9:20if we were to rewind to,
- 9:21you know,
- 9:22the your concession of like,
- 9:23you know,
- 9:24the Luigi Mangioni,
- 9:26um.
- 9:27Sort of fan
- 9:29base that it does exist on the left or you know even
- 9:31some of the more extreme things expressed by someone like Hassan Piker
- 9:36or the people who celebrated Charlie Kirk and you know the
- 9:39the catch fascist engraving that was on the bullet.
- 9:43How concerned are you about those symptoms of radical
- 9:47Politics on the left,
- 9:49it concerns me.
- 9:49I push back on that type of rhetoric all the time in my own fan base.
- 9:53I think it's important for leaders on the left to have moral clarity about all of this
- 9:58at all times.
- 9:59So when I saw people celebrating Charlie Kirk's
- 10:02death or saying they're like spit on the,
- 10:04on the new change my mind,
- 10:05I'm like,
- 10:06no,
- 10:06no,
- 10:06no,
- 10:06guys,
- 10:07this is America,
- 10:07this is a democracy.
- 10:08I try to have moral clarity about violence.
- 10:11It does concern me,
- 10:12but again,
- 10:13it's just the same,
- 10:14it
- 10:15doesn't
- 10:16manifest.
- 10:16Institutionally like it does on the right.
- 10:19It reminds me of this clip from Nick Fuentes where he said,
- 10:21phase one is complete.
- 10:23We've normalized our rhetoric,
- 10:25phase one is complete.
- 10:26I'm on Tucker Carlson,
- 10:27now we go to phase two,
- 10:28which is getting all of our groper to hide their power level
- 10:31and infiltrate all of the institutions like the young Republican group chat,
- 10:35and eventually,
- 10:36in 10 years,
- 10:37we take our mask off and then we like push our ideology.
- 10:40I don't see that same type of institutional push from the
- 10:43Hassan Pikers of the left or the people on the left.
- 10:46Who think that Luigi Mangioni is really,
- 10:48really sexy and are writing him love letters or whatever,
- 10:50like,
- 10:50yeah,
- 10:51that's some
- 10:51weird,
- 10:52weird stuff.
- 10:53And obviously you shouldn't idolize Luigi Mangioni.
- 10:55I will always be pushing against
- 10:57uh any sort of thing that like weakens the social cohesion of America in that way,
- 11:01but I,
- 11:02I just don't know if I see it manifesting in the same way on the left.
- 11:06I,
- 11:06I think they are kind of 22 different beasts.
- 11:08I would agree with you there.
- 11:09On the Nick Fuentes of it all,
- 11:11you kind of have the Ben Shapiro approach,
- 11:14um,
- 11:14and the maybe.
- 11:15JD Vance approach,
- 11:16like
- 11:17JD Vance is,
- 11:18is trying to be a unifier,
- 11:20he's trying to downplay conflict.
- 11:22Um,
- 11:22he said some pretty,
- 11:24um,
- 11:24he kind of had some apologetic things to
- 11:26say about the group chat that we're discussing,
- 11:28whereas Ben Shapiro has been surprisingly
- 11:32aggressive towards condemning that type of rhetoric and that faction of the right,
- 11:36and he thinks it's kind of an existential
- 11:38risk to the political ambitions of the right.
- 11:41What do you think about that divide?
- 11:42Who do you,
- 11:43who do you think has um
- 11:45The right approach,
- 11:46I guess from a political standpoint.
- 11:48I think that Ben Shapiro's moral clarity approach is right and it's necessary.
- 11:53I had a clip recently that went viral where I
- 11:54was on CNN and I was basically just saying,
- 11:57it feels like.
- 11:59Right-wing commentators were OK with any form of
- 12:01bigotry until it began to affect them personally.
- 12:04So Vivek Ramaswamy was OK with bigotry towards
- 12:07other forms of immigrants,
- 12:08gay people,
- 12:09trans people,
- 12:10women,
- 12:11uh,
- 12:11Somalis,
- 12:12Haitians,
- 12:12any sort of minority.
- 12:13But right when the bigotry hits Indian-Americans,
- 12:17Vivek Ramaswamy has a lot of moral clarity.
- 12:19Ben Shapiro was OK,
- 12:21he was,
- 12:21you know,
- 12:21blind to trans hatred in the Republican Party for years.
- 12:25But then right when it hits like Jewish people,
- 12:27he calls it out,
- 12:27as he should.
- 12:28I think that he should have moral clarity
- 12:30uh at the very,
- 12:31very beginning.
- 12:32There's one Republican Representative,
- 12:33Randy Fine.
- 12:34He's like talking about Ilhan Omar and Zoran Mamdani saying to deport them,
- 12:38calling them nasty names,
- 12:40but then
- 12:41he's jaw dropped shocked when they,
- 12:43whenever there's like anti-Semitism within his wing of the party.
- 12:46So I do think Ben Shapiro
- 12:49is,
- 12:49is a lot closer to being right.
- 12:51He,
- 12:51uh,
- 12:52he stands up on stage,
- 12:53he has moral clarity,
- 12:54and listen,
- 12:55Ben Shapiro is somebody who has pushed back on
- 12:56anti-Semitism and bigotry of all forms for many,
- 12:59many years.
- 13:00So Ben Shapiro is actually an example of someone who I think
- 13:02has done a good job of having moral clarity.
- 13:05JD Vance is playing this weird game where he won't outright condemn the ropers,
- 13:10and he's kind of softly playing defense for the ropers,
- 13:14but um,
- 13:15it's not gonna manifest,
- 13:16it's not gonna be good.
- 13:17Yeah,
- 13:17he's got a wife who is Indian American,
- 13:19and there's a lot of Indian-American hatred that is boiling up within
- 13:22the Grober movement within a lot of young far right people.
- 13:26So I think JD Vance needs to be more like,
- 13:29uh,
- 13:29Ben Shapiro and have some moral clarity now,
- 13:31like go on stage now and say,
- 13:33hey,
- 13:33all of this is not welcome in the movement.
- 13:35When he
- 13:36took the stage at AMFest,
- 13:38he was really like soft about it.
- 13:39He would not take a clear stance.
- 13:42Mm mhm.
- 13:43Yeah,
- 13:43so you're of the mindset both sides should
- 13:46take up the task of policing their extremists,
- 13:48you know,
- 13:49or,
- 13:49or doing cleaning up the extremists internally.
- 13:52Yeah,
- 13:53no,
- 13:53it's it's very bizarre to
- 13:55witness that happening
- 13:56because it has felt like that was a reckoning that
- 13:58was going to happen on the right for some time.
- 14:01And then,
- 14:01you know,
- 14:01they have like the,
- 14:02what's his name,
- 14:03clavicular,
- 14:04um,
- 14:05of it all,
- 14:06saying,
- 14:06you know,
- 14:06he would.
- 14:08Vote
- 14:09for Gavin Newsom over
- 14:12JD Vance purely off of looks.
- 14:14It's a strange,
- 14:15strange strand of politics going on there.
- 14:17He mocks him 10 out of 10 times.
- 14:19Yeah,
- 14:20OK,
- 14:21so I'm gonna move on to,
- 14:22uh,
- 14:22the next clip.
- 14:24This is in the context of,
- 14:25I think,
- 14:26your
- 14:28second claim,
- 14:28which was
- 14:29economics.
- 14:31This was an exchange you had with Martin.
- 14:32You,
- 14:33you called Martin back,
- 14:34um,
- 14:35but he kind of gets you tongue tied,
- 14:36and I,
- 14:37I want to give you an opportunity to,
- 14:38to complete your thoughts there.
- 14:40The,
- 14:41the left always speaks in these like just,
- 14:42you know,
- 14:43abstracts.
- 14:44Like that's actually like what are the barriers?
- 14:45The increased barriers are when people are.
- 14:47Vulnerable and already working part-time and then you cut them off of Medicaid.
- 14:51Yes,
- 14:52people can get Medicaid with this,
- 14:53but the problem is when 18,000 people like
- 14:55in Arkansas are kicked off of their Medicaid,
- 14:57no,
- 14:57the,
- 14:58the 18,000 people were kicked off of their
- 15:00Medicaid because they couldn't get access to it.
- 15:01What happens then is that they have to dig into their social safety,
- 15:04they have to dig into their,
- 15:06how do they not get access then?
- 15:07But because the barriers are increased.
- 15:09What are the barriers?
- 15:10The only barrier you listed,
- 15:11the only barrier we talked about is work requirements,
- 15:13and that's working 20 hours a week.
- 15:14Yeah,
- 15:15but it's the work requirements
- 15:16increasing is just,
- 15:18yeah,
- 15:18it's not.
- 15:18So wait,
- 15:19can you concede,
- 15:21so,
- 15:21so we agree work requirements are a good thing.
- 15:22So what were you trying to express to Martin?
- 15:25What are,
- 15:25what are the barriers that are preventing people from
- 15:28accessing
- 15:29their Medicare?
- 15:30He got me there.
- 15:31It's essentially just increased paperwork or increased,
- 15:36uh,
- 15:36it's,
- 15:36it's just increased paperwork.
- 15:38That's all it is.
- 15:38That's what I was trying to illustrate.
- 15:40That's what they add,
- 15:41which makes it a little bit harder,
- 15:42and I guess I should have had,
- 15:44you know,
- 15:45a more fleshed out way of explaining that.
- 15:47Mhm.
- 15:48You,
- 15:49you call him out and you kind of congratulate him.
- 15:51Hey,
- 15:51you got me there,
- 15:52good job,
- 15:52and you actually called Martin back in,
- 15:54um,
- 15:55to the center at the end of the episode final debate.
- 15:58Yeah,
- 15:59how
- 16:00has there been kind of an evolution in your debating style,
- 16:03um,
- 16:04because you've,
- 16:04you've come of age during the Trump era,
- 16:07during the COVID era,
- 16:08kind of a,
- 16:09a poli politically tumultuous time.
- 16:12Have you had to learn how to admit when you're wrong,
- 16:16um,
- 16:16or just admit when somebody has a stronger argument than you?
- 16:19Yeah,
- 16:20of course.
- 16:20I mean,
- 16:20there's
- 16:21I'm young,
- 16:22so as a function of my age,
- 16:24I don't know everything at every single moment,
- 16:26and that's usually why when I'm going into these CNN debates,
- 16:29for example,
- 16:30or the jubilee debates,
- 16:31I prep super,
- 16:32super hard.
- 16:33So,
- 16:34I,
- 16:34the reason I entered debate in the first place was actually
- 16:38because I wanted to have good faith conversations at Trump rallies.
- 16:41I saw a lot of liberals.
- 16:42going to Trump rallies,
- 16:44and their goal was to be as condescending as possible.
- 16:46It was like,
- 16:46how much of an asshole can I be to this person
- 16:49and how dumb can I make this person look?
- 16:50So I started going to the Trump rallies,
- 16:52and I would have these decent,
- 16:54you know,
- 16:54actually good-hearted conversations with Trump supporters,
- 16:57and we would reach some sort of middle ground.
- 16:59And a lot of times I would learn something new,
- 17:01just as a function of my age.
- 17:02I would be talking.
- 17:03To someone who's like,
- 17:04you know,
- 17:0447 years old,
- 17:05and I flew out from Indiana to Pennsylvania to meet them or to go to this rally.
- 17:09I meet them,
- 17:10I have a conversation,
- 17:11and it ends up teaching me some stuff.
- 17:13So there are a lot of times where I would be wrong.
- 17:15And um,
- 17:16yeah,
- 17:16in this situation,
- 17:17I just,
- 17:18I should have had a more fleshed out
- 17:20worldview.
- 17:20But yeah,
- 17:21I mean,
- 17:21it's never,
- 17:22uh,
- 17:22it's never gonna like,
- 17:24ruin me too much.
- 17:25There's going to be moments where
- 17:27You know,
- 17:27you don't have the flawless argument.
- 17:30Yeah,
- 17:31no,
- 17:31it's,
- 17:31it,
- 17:32it's always good to,
- 17:33it's just good to have that flexibility
- 17:35to not have to kind of triple and double down on everything.
- 17:39Um.
- 17:40Uh,
- 17:41building off of kind of the economic
- 17:44arguments against Trump,
- 17:45I actually think this is where Trump
- 17:47has consistently had
- 17:50the most strength and has
- 17:53I think the left,
- 17:54um,
- 17:55or more liberal leaning
- 17:57commentators and,
- 17:58and politicians have
- 18:00been outplayed by him and I would even make that
- 18:03argument or I've even had that observation this past year,
- 18:06you know,
- 18:06going into the tariffs,
- 18:08we were told.
- 18:10This is going to tank the economy.
- 18:11We did see the economy
- 18:14crash,
- 18:15you know,
- 18:15momentarily
- 18:16before
- 18:17surging to record highs,
- 18:19and I think currently we're
- 18:20we're kind of like either
- 18:21at a record high for the S&P 500 or hovering
- 18:25near one.
- 18:26And so,
- 18:27yeah,
- 18:27what do you think?
- 18:29And obviously time will tell,
- 18:31but what do you think looking back on this past year,
- 18:34what,
- 18:34what,
- 18:34what should the left learn about
- 18:37Trump's economic policies and
- 18:40Whether or not
- 18:41they have,
- 18:42uh,
- 18:42you know,
- 18:42it's lived up to the fears that they've messaged.
- 18:45Yeah,
- 18:46so the,
- 18:46the Trump tariffs are sort of confusing because
- 18:49he made a bunch of announcements without actually
- 18:51placing the tariffs for like another 90 days.
- 18:54So you get kept getting caught up in these announcements,
- 18:56then loops where it'd be like a 90 day delay.
- 18:59When he did do the tariffs,
- 19:00the stock market ended up tanking,
- 19:02and I,
- 19:02I,
- 19:03I,
- 19:03the tariffs
- 19:04did not raise prices as much as liberals thought.
- 19:06We definitely overestimated the impact of tariffs,
- 19:10but.
- 19:10Trump also kind of backed off of a lot of his worst tariffs,
- 19:14and even when beef started to get too expensive,
- 19:16he backed off tariffs there,
- 19:17uh,
- 19:18conceding that it just raised the prices a bit too much.
- 19:21I think that
- 19:22liberals definitely have a lot to learn about messaging regarding the economy,
- 19:25especially after the Biden era where the Biden
- 19:28administration's policy was essentially kind of just gaslighting,
- 19:31saying that everything
- 19:32is fine when it's not.
- 19:34Since then.
- 19:35I think the Trump admin has taken that strategy and like
- 19:38blown that out of the water by gaslighting even further.
- 19:41When there's a lot of inflation embedded in the economy,
- 19:43there's a lot
- 19:45of economic problems that people are still facing.
- 19:47I mean,
- 19:47youth unemployment has gone up a lot since Trump took office.
- 19:51Unemployment for black Americans is still skyrocketing.
- 19:54I,
- 19:54I just think that overall tariffs weren't the economic
- 19:57catastrophe that we claimed they were going to be,
- 20:00but I think people are still struggling.
- 20:01A lot.
- 20:02Yeah,
- 20:02and we see that in,
- 20:03you know,
- 20:03some of the data around the labor market.
- 20:06And so there's for sure a lot of uncertainty.
- 20:08I don't think anybody's looking back at 2025.
- 20:10Well,
- 20:10that's not true.
- 20:11Some people are saying it's a golden age.
- 20:13It's actually kind of a tale of two
- 20:15predictions.
- 20:15Some people think we're
- 20:17we're really facing
- 20:19a dire 2026 or a very recession
- 20:22like 2026.
- 20:23Some people think that
- 20:24the AI boom is just about to kick in.
- 20:27What do you anticipate going into 2026?
- 20:29Do you think like we just have yet to feel the full impacts of this economic policy or
- 20:35Or are you kind of unsure?
- 20:37Yeah,
- 20:37so tariffs are inflationary,
- 20:39and like I said,
- 20:39Trump
- 20:40placed a lot of tariffs and backed off a lot of them,
- 20:42but on August 7th,
- 20:43that's when the Liberation Day tariffs fully went into effect,
- 20:47and I do think it's going to cause more inflation.
- 20:49Inflation was going down when Trump took office.
- 20:52It went from 3%,
- 20:54then it went down to like 2.4%. It was going down,
- 20:57then sometime around his.
- 20:58Liberation Day tariff it started going back up.
- 21:01So if he can just back off some of the craziest economic policies,
- 21:04I think we'll be fine.
- 21:05We could stick the landing,
- 21:06but right now the direction we're going is not good.
- 21:09It feels like we've been teetering for a while
- 21:11at this point where unemployment is going up,
- 21:14where interest rates
- 21:16are kind of starting to go down,
- 21:17but after Trump bullied the Fed,
- 21:19uh,
- 21:19I guess we'll see,
- 21:20but
- 21:20I'm not too bullish on the economy right now.
- 21:23Mhm.
- 21:24Martin made the argument,
- 21:25and I'll probably pull this clip into the edit,
- 21:27you know,
- 21:27he made the argument that
- 21:29a lot of these tax cuts that are benefiting the wealthy in the Big Beautiful bill,
- 21:33they're there so that the wealthy has the necessary cash that they need to invest
- 21:39in AI which he said would be exponentially,
- 21:41you know,
- 21:42it would have exponential growth for the US economy.
- 21:44And so there's this
- 21:45Big bet on the,
- 21:46the golden goose of,
- 21:48of AI.
- 21:50Do you think AI is gonna deliver,
- 21:52you know,
- 21:52levels of prosperity that,
- 21:54that
- 21:54we're hearing?
- 21:56I am bullish on AI.
- 21:57I'm not sure if like a top marginal tax rate
- 21:59of 37% versus 38% for corporations would be like,
- 22:03really affect their ability to
- 22:05invest in businesses like that.
- 22:06I think that
- 22:08AI is the future.
- 22:10I'm very bullish on it.
- 22:11If we can get it in the right hands.
- 22:13I've always said that if like the richest of the rich are manipulating it
- 22:16to hurt the working class people,
- 22:19then it's probably not gonna lead to the best outcomes.
- 22:22But if we can get an AI that is
- 22:24leading to a more equitable future,
- 22:26leading to a future where people at the bottom can be more comfortable,
- 22:29and it can,
- 22:30they can lead to like strength and safety nets,
- 22:31that would be great.
- 22:33I'm bullish on AI.
- 22:34So are you,
- 22:35um,
- 22:36Someone who
- 22:38is kind of more even-handed on,
- 22:39on like the billionaires,
- 22:40uh,
- 22:41who
- 22:42have kind of the keys to
- 22:44these AI engines or,
- 22:45or to
- 22:46um
- 22:47the investments that are trying to build this AI future,
- 22:49because I hear,
- 22:50this is something I hear a lot.
- 22:52of different
- 22:53opinions on,
- 22:54and I'm kind of wondering where the left is gonna go,
- 22:56where the,
- 22:56the core messaging is gonna go.
- 22:58Is it gonna be more middle of the road,
- 23:00like,
- 23:00yes,
- 23:01we need AI,
- 23:01we should be bullish,
- 23:02which I'm hearing from you,
- 23:04or are we're gonna be more in this kind of Bernie camp.
- 23:07Bernie recently,
- 23:08um,
- 23:10This was like I think a matter of a week or two ago,
- 23:12said that we should put a moratorium on these data
- 23:15centers.
- 23:16He really thinks AI is a risk
- 23:19of putting way too much wealth in the top
- 23:210.1%
- 23:23of the population.
- 23:24He thinks that's too much power.
- 23:26Where do you think the party is going,
- 23:28because I,
- 23:29I kind of hear both things.
- 23:30I think that if the Democrats cede ground on AI and we just say we
- 23:34don't even want to touch this and cede it all over to the Republicans,
- 23:38they will take the most extreme position on AI and
- 23:41use it to hurt the working class and suppress people.
- 23:43So I think the Democrats need to maintain narrative control.
- 23:46Pete Buttigieg is.
- 23:47Come out with some pro AI platforms that regulate it in a smart way,
- 23:52but also use it for growth and use it to help the economy and help the working class,
- 23:56help people who need it,
- 23:57the most vulnerable Americans.
- 23:59I think AI
- 24:00can make healthcare way less expensive,
- 24:02can make teaching our kids way more effective.
- 24:05There was one
- 24:06school that was using AI to do an eight-hour school day.
- 24:09In like 3 hours.
- 24:10Now,
- 24:10I'm not saying every single school should integrate that immediately,
- 24:13but over time,
- 24:14I'd like to see AI make America more efficient.
- 24:17Um,
- 24:18that could be the Democrats' slogan,
- 24:19make America more efficient with AI or something like that.
- 24:22And I think that,
- 24:22uh,
- 24:23yeah,
- 24:23it would just be a mistake to cede all of that ground
- 24:25to any other country or to the Republican Party as a whole.
- 24:29I think sometimes.
- 24:30People on the far,
- 24:31far left can take too hard of stances on the billionaires.
- 24:34I think if billionaires are creating value
- 24:36and the value matches the billions that they're worth,
- 24:38that is totally fine.
- 24:39Now,
- 24:39obviously some billionaires take it to the extremes.
- 24:42Wealth hoarding is not good when inequality is a big problem.
- 24:46But yeah,
- 24:46uh,
- 24:46overall,
- 24:47I think Democrats should be bullish on AI
- 24:49because if we're not,
- 24:50then the Republicans may control the entire narrative on it.
- 24:53Mm mhm.
- 24:54OK,
- 24:54so moving on to
- 24:56your next claim.
- 24:57This was actually kind of a claim.
- 24:59I'm gonna share a clip,
- 25:01um.
- 25:02Of a discussion you had with Kai,
- 25:04and this was in regards to your claim around,
- 25:07and,
- 25:07and I actually kind of want to talk about this.
- 25:08Children are would be safer in a room with
- 25:10the average illegal immigrant than with Donald Trump.
- 25:14And so this is really kind of a character comparison.
- 25:18Why
- 25:20And there was a lot of pushback just on kind of the framing of the prompt.
- 25:22Why did this feel like an important prompt to bring into
- 25:26this episode?
- 25:26Because I think it's kind of hard to defend.
- 25:28I think that
- 25:30that's why I wanted to choose it.
- 25:31It's hard to defend,
- 25:33but it also
- 25:34gets to the point
- 25:36that,
- 25:36you know,
- 25:36Dean Withers asked this question recently in one of your guys' debates,
- 25:40and I thought it was just perfect.
- 25:41He asked it perfectly because I talked to him a bit about this before.
- 25:44And the question is essentially,
- 25:46would you let somebody cross the border in a.
- 25:49manner
- 25:50if they had 20+ sexual assault allegations
- 25:53and were convicted of 34 different felonies.
- 25:55So if you take the standard
- 25:56of the president of the United States
- 25:59and you try to apply it to any random immigrant,
- 26:02most conservatives would want those immigrants,
- 26:04that immigrant deported immediately,
- 26:06but you take it
- 26:07to the next step.
- 26:08If you take the average person who is here illegally,
- 26:11they do commit less crimes than native born citizens.
- 26:15Every single study shows this,
- 26:16that they commit less crimes than the native born citizens.
- 26:19Trump commits more crimes than the average native born citizen,
- 26:22so I thought it would be a fun prompt to throw in there.
- 26:25Um,
- 26:25I was gonna do one about like Israel,
- 26:27I was gonna do one about Gaza,
- 26:29I was gonna do one about Ukraine and Palest or Ukraine and
- 26:32Russia,
- 26:32but all the foreign policy stuff seemed a little bit,
- 26:35um,
- 26:35at the moment,
- 26:37uh.
- 26:38Just like it was moving fast.
- 26:39I didn't know how long this would take to edit,
- 26:41so I was like,
- 26:41let's just do a,
- 26:42let's do a prompt like this,
- 26:43a fun one.
- 26:44It,
- 26:44it had me kind of thinking cause,
- 26:46well,
- 26:46here,
- 26:46let me play this clip of,
- 26:47of you and Kayi and then we can kind of dig in more.
- 26:50The framing that you're saying the framing that you are providing,
- 26:52if we were to be statistically,
- 26:54um,
- 26:55consistent,
- 26:55would say that with the average illegal immigrant,
- 26:58you are safer than with the average black American.
- 27:00Would you agree with that framing?
- 27:01With the average illegal immigrant,
- 27:02you're safer with the average black.
- 27:03Yeah,
- 27:04yeah,
- 27:04because black Americans commit crimes at a disproportionate rate.
- 27:06No,
- 27:07yeah,
- 27:07yeah,
- 27:07sure.
- 27:08OK,
- 27:08so you understand how framing can significantly shape
- 27:10the way that we engage in these conversations.
- 27:12I don't think every black person is going to kill me,
- 27:14but there is a disproportionality around it.
- 27:16But the thing is,
- 27:17not every immigrants,
- 27:18listen,
- 27:18not every immigrant's going to abuse you.
- 27:20100%.
- 27:20Every one of those 1000 Donald Trump's will abuse their power dynamics.
- 27:23Absolutely.
- 27:24OK,
- 27:25so.
- 27:26You know,
- 27:27I,
- 27:27I thought Kai had kind of a good retort.
- 27:29It's like,
- 27:30look,
- 27:30we can frame this in a way where it's almost a little bit of a dog whistle
- 27:34for anti-black policy or stereotypes against the black community.
- 27:38Like if we're kind of
- 27:40doing these character attacks
- 27:42like your prompt,
- 27:43um,
- 27:44or like your,
- 27:44your claim,
- 27:46you can kind of spin that in a way,
- 27:48uh,
- 27:48to
- 27:49push any narrative that you want.
- 27:50And this is something I have kind of seen.
- 27:53You know,
- 27:54done,
- 27:55especially online for like the last 10 years.
- 27:57What did you think of kind of how Kyle was,
- 27:59was deconstructing your claim?
- 28:01I think it's a good point,
- 28:03but again,
- 28:04I don't think that every single
- 28:05black American will abuse power if they have it.
- 28:08But 10 out of 10 times,
- 28:10Donald Trump has shown that whether it's him walking into
- 28:12the dressing rooms or like grabbing women or doing this,
- 28:15he will abuse power.
- 28:16So
- 28:17broadly,
- 28:18it's a pretty good flipping of my framing.
- 28:20I thought it was really,
- 28:20really clever,
- 28:21but at the end.
- 28:22At the end of the day,
- 28:23I just don't see
- 28:24immigrants or illegal immigrants abusing power dynamics in
- 28:27the same way that Trump repeatedly does,
- 28:29and that was a framing I kind of tried to bring it back to repeatedly as well,
- 28:33is that Donald Trump abuses power every single time he has it 10 out of 10 times,
- 28:38and a lot of the minorities,
- 28:40a lot of like immigrants don't even have that power to abuse.
- 28:44Mhm mhm.
- 28:45We're in this moment now where there's,
- 28:46you know,
- 28:46pushback on DEI,
- 28:48there's pushback on,
- 28:49on
- 28:50Biden's border policy.
- 28:51In this episode,
- 28:52you,
- 28:53you know,
- 28:53said you didn't,
- 28:54you thought Biden did a sloppy job at the border,
- 28:56you wouldn't defend his administration on the border.
- 28:59What do you think the big lessons
- 29:02are that the left needs to learn about kind of how they approach identity politics?
- 29:06The border was both like
- 29:08a legislative issue,
- 29:09uh,
- 29:10you know,
- 29:10a security issue for the country,
- 29:11but it also was very
- 29:13heavily laced with identity
- 29:14and,
- 29:15you know,
- 29:15there was a lot of discussion about American character and how we treat immigrants.
- 29:20Do you think that sometimes
- 29:22liberals get too caught up in these emotional broad
- 29:25characterizations of other people
- 29:28that kind of corners them into these
- 29:30indefensible
- 29:32stances on issues like
- 29:34being overly sympathetic towards immi.
- 29:36Immigrants,
- 29:37specifically illegal immigrants,
- 29:39and then having just a very,
- 29:40very weak
- 29:41border security policy.
- 29:43Yeah,
- 29:43overall,
- 29:44Biden's border policy
- 29:47really
- 29:49Bothered me
- 29:50over the past year,
- 29:51like I,
- 29:51and
- 29:52after he dropped out of the race,
- 29:54the manifestation of the border and all of this,
- 29:57I really think hurt the Democratic Party's credibility nationally,
- 30:01and it's because he was weak.
- 30:03He should have earlier on taken a stance
- 30:05so that,
- 30:06you know,
- 30:06right wingers weren't able to go and fill the
- 30:08vacuum with the most far right uh stance possible.
- 30:11I think that there is a version of
- 30:14the Democratic Party that is more like what Obama
- 30:16would say about the border where he had a.
- 30:18Very,
- 30:18very strong policy on the border.
- 30:21He wanted everybody to assimilate,
- 30:23uh,
- 30:23speak English.
- 30:24He thinks that you have to go through the proper procedures,
- 30:27but Biden just lost that for some reason and wasn't able to put his foot down.
- 30:31I think partially because he was too worried about the far left
- 30:33flank calling him racist or he was too worried of appeal,
- 30:37appearing racist like Trump did.
- 30:39At the end of the day,
- 30:40the identity politics stuff is really bothered me too.
- 30:42It's got to stop in the Democratic Party.
- 30:45We've got to stop purity testing people or pushing
- 30:47people out of the coalition or finger wagging.
- 30:50That's not how you win over young men.
- 30:52And I think a lot of the race stuff too,
- 30:55uh,
- 30:55also,
- 30:56like there's,
- 30:56don't get me wrong.
- 30:57There's a lot of very valid conversations to be had about redlining,
- 31:01about so many different things and systemic racism,
- 31:04but we can't always inject these academic
- 31:07conversations into the average person's,
- 31:09you know,
- 31:09daily life.
- 31:10Yeah,
- 31:10do you worry that
- 31:12that has become too
- 31:14much of
- 31:15the plat,
- 31:16you know,
- 31:16the platform for the Democratic Party,
- 31:18because it has felt to me,
- 31:20this is just something I'm kind of thinking out loud here,
- 31:22you know.
- 31:23The hesitance for Democratic candidates to
- 31:28take middle of the road stances on
- 31:30the border or transgender issues such as transport,
- 31:34transgender athletes,
- 31:36not,
- 31:36you know,
- 31:36just
- 31:37transgender people altogether.
- 31:39There's always been a reluctance to
- 31:42take kind of a middle of the road stance as though it
- 31:44might alienate so many voters to hurt their chances of winning.
- 31:48Do you think that the
- 31:49Democratic voters just
- 31:51You know,
- 31:51they are really a pro DEI pro.
- 31:55You know,
- 31:56trans acceptance on
- 31:57almost unconditionally
- 31:59voting base,
- 32:00um,
- 32:01because that's sort of how
- 32:03Democratic leadership has behaved as though that
- 32:06that's what they believe their voters want
- 32:08and demand.
- 32:09Yeah,
- 32:09it's weird.
- 32:10It's like the Democratic leaders have been beholden to the
- 32:13farthest left activists who don't even really vote for us.
- 32:17So like the people on the far right,
- 32:18like I was saying earlier,
- 32:20a lot of these far right people at the end of the day,
- 32:21they'll fall in line and they'll vote for the Republican Party,
- 32:25so they technically are a part of the broad right coalition,
- 32:28but on the left
- 32:29we have certain like pro-Palestine activists or trans active people in the far.
- 32:34Far left that are representing us
- 32:37and um
- 32:38on online Twitter spaces that our politicians feel beholden
- 32:42to when that doesn't represent the broad base,
- 32:44like the broad democratic base wants trans rights,
- 32:47we want equality,
- 32:48but we're OK with at least having the conversation about trans people in sports,
- 32:53but there was a while there where it felt like that conversation
- 32:55was being shut down inside the party because people thought that was.
- 32:59Too extreme of a conversation to have or it was too bigoted to have.
- 33:02So I think that
- 33:03we should at least be willing to take stands on these
- 33:06topics and have moral clarity about them and stand up for minorities
- 33:11without always curtailing to the loudest online voices.
- 33:15And in a strange way that,
- 33:16that has felt like the path from my observation that's led to
- 33:19someone like Steven Miller being the enforcer of our current immigration policy.
- 33:24You know,
- 33:24I think most people,
- 33:25conservative or liberal,
- 33:27would probably,
- 33:28if they had a conversation with Steven Miller,
- 33:30would find themselves
- 33:31seeing him as
- 33:33pretty far
- 33:35to the right or pretty extreme in what he thinks is appropriate levels of
- 33:39illegal immigration enforcement,
- 33:40and that to a large extent is what we're seeing
- 33:43executed right now,
- 33:44a very aggressive
- 33:46growing ICE that
- 33:49is
- 33:51using technology
- 33:53as best it can to
- 33:55track people down
- 33:57and even if it means separating families.
- 33:59And I kind of wonder if
- 34:02that is the result of,
- 34:04if you're if you're extremely
- 34:07incompetent on an issue,
- 34:09you
- 34:11give
- 34:11the most extreme
- 34:13opponent.
- 34:14You kind of justify them and it's,
- 34:16it's like,
- 34:16you know,
- 34:16Stephen Miller having the keys to ICE
- 34:19now feels as much
- 34:20a result of kind of radical
- 34:22views
- 34:23on the right as it does,
- 34:25um,
- 34:26poor
- 34:27policy and enforcement on the left,
- 34:28like the,
- 34:29the Biden admin didn't have a clear stance and it created a
- 34:32vacuum so big that Stephen Miller was able to fill that vacuum.
- 34:36That's exactly how I see it.
- 34:37When you leave a vacuum and clarity on your side,
- 34:40you,
- 34:40you like the American people.
- 34:42Don't have that pushback.
- 34:43So then,
- 34:44when there's no pushback on the left,
- 34:46the resistance just goes all the way off to the right.
- 34:48That's exactly how I see it.
- 34:49Who do you think,
- 34:50I,
- 34:51I ask a lot of people who are more left leaning on this show,
- 34:54who do you think is the future voice in the Democratic Party though that,
- 34:58that can kind of inoculate the left from
- 35:01what,
- 35:01what we're discussing or,
- 35:03or
- 35:03who,
- 35:03who is kind of.
- 35:06Yeah,
- 35:06just
- 35:07having a fresh approach to issues.
- 35:09It's hard to tell,
- 35:10you know,
- 35:10I always say,
- 35:11if you ask somebody this in 2005 after the Democrats lost,
- 35:14no one would have really said that Barack Obama is going to be our next,
- 35:17you know,
- 35:17leading voice.
- 35:18Or
- 35:18if you ask the Republicans this in 2013,
- 35:21no one would have said that Donald Trump will be the next guiding voice.
- 35:24No one would have said that.
- 35:25So
- 35:25we may not know who it is.
- 35:27Most betting markets show AOC and Gavin Newsom as the current.
- 35:31Next prediction leaders of the party,
- 35:33Andy Beshear,
- 35:34I think is really good.
- 35:35He,
- 35:35uh,
- 35:36he's got the juice right now.
- 35:37Jon Ossoff has got the juice.
- 35:39Pritzker,
- 35:39my state of Indi or Illinois,
- 35:41sorry,
- 35:42um,
- 35:42Pritzker is great.
- 35:43I think that
- 35:44we've got some great leaders,
- 35:46but
- 35:47right now,
- 35:48Newsom seems to be the one that's capturing the most attention of the public.
- 35:52Mhm.
- 35:53But what do you think because
- 35:55This is just really interesting to me.
- 35:57The state of California though is so emblematic of kind of this
- 36:02being held hostage by the most,
- 36:04you know,
- 36:04the far left.
- 36:05I,
- 36:05I think,
- 36:06and so it's unaffordable
- 36:08and this is like the affordability election.
- 36:10It's the most unaffordable state.
- 36:11I,
- 36:11I asked this too.
- 36:12I don't know.
- 36:13I don't know how he'll do on the national stage.
- 36:15Like it's rough.
- 36:17Is there somebody you lean more towards though,
- 36:19like of the,
- 36:20if we're going AOC or Newsom,
- 36:21is there somebody you see yourself more aligned with,
- 36:24um.
- 36:26You could punt this too if you.
- 36:27No,
- 36:27no,
- 36:27it's really hard.
- 36:29It's really hard because right now
- 36:31I just want someone to punch back.
- 36:32So when I see Newsom punching back,
- 36:34it makes me feel so satisfied and it's cathartic,
- 36:37right?
- 36:38But I don't know how he'll do on the national stage.
- 36:40Like I genuinely don't know if he'll make a
- 36:42good national candidate due to the affordability issues and
- 36:45because he just looks like a California politician.
- 36:47He's like a slick back,
- 36:48but
- 36:48if he can prove that he's on the national stage,
- 36:51the best swinger,
- 36:52then great.
- 36:53I love AOC,
- 36:54but the problem with AOC is,
- 36:56you know how that 1 2019 ACLU clip screwed Kamala over
- 37:00because she was like trans people should have surgeries in prisons.
- 37:03I'm pretty sure AOC has like
- 37:0520 different clips like that and from like 2023.
- 37:08Like AOC is pretty far left,
- 37:10but
- 37:11AOC is not Kamala and she's definitely not Hillary.
- 37:13She's got the juice.
- 37:14It's really hard to tell.
- 37:15It's really hard to tell.
- 37:16So I basically just did just punt your question because I don't know,
- 37:20you know.
- 37:21Yeah,
- 37:22well,
- 37:22AOC,
- 37:22if you're listening to this,
- 37:23you should do an episode of Surrounded,
- 37:25because we'd love to have you.
- 37:27Um,
- 37:27OK,
- 37:27that kind of cues up the last clip that I want to react to with you.
- 37:32So this is where you called,
- 37:33um,
- 37:35Merrick Garland,
- 37:36a pussy.
- 37:37Do you see the double standards here?
- 37:39And
- 37:40no,
- 37:40you don't,
- 37:40not,
- 37:40not at all,
- 37:41because it's a throughout this entire debate,
- 37:43you guys are able to draw connections even with Pam Bondi.
- 37:45You said that Biden,
- 37:46there's no actual proof of Biden asking Merrick Garland to do this,
- 37:49but the proof of Trump asking Pam Bondi to do this isn't enough proof.
- 37:52Again,
- 37:52there's enough proof is that Merrick Garland on
- 37:54day one did it after being appointed.
- 37:55Biden.
- 37:55He didn't.
- 37:56He slow walked it.
- 37:57He did not do it on day one,
- 37:58and Biden never asked him to do that because
- 38:00there was a clear Merrick Garland was a pussy.
- 38:02He was somebody who slow walked every single case.
- 38:04He was absolutely a pussy.
- 38:05I mean,
- 38:05if he was actually as strong as you guys thought he was,
- 38:08then Trump would probably be in jail for
- 38:09trying to overthrow the 2020 election right now.
- 38:11There is no crime there,
- 38:12but time,
- 38:12time's out.
- 38:13Thanks so much.
- 38:16Good work,
- 38:16man.
- 38:18Definitely
- 38:19true.
- 38:20I think that,
- 38:20um,
- 38:20so
- 38:21this,
- 38:21this is a debate that I have all the time,
- 38:24and it's whether or not
- 38:26Trump
- 38:26or Biden,
- 38:27it's,
- 38:27it's basically if Trump weaponizing the DOJ was just
- 38:30tit for tat for Biden weaponizing the DOJ.
- 38:33It's kind of a debate that drives me crazy
- 38:35because Donald Trump posted on his Truth Social,
- 38:38hey,
- 38:38Pam,
- 38:39can you please,
- 38:40please,
- 38:40please get these 3 people.
- 38:42And then 2 out of those 3 people were indicted within like 2 weeks,
- 38:45like Pam Bondi immediately went after them.
- 38:48And people say that Joe Biden did the same thing,
- 38:50that it's justified to weaponize your DOJ cause Joe Biden did the same thing,
- 38:53but there's like no good example
- 38:55of Joe Biden doing that.
- 38:56And I guess the example they point to is
- 38:59Trump's trials,
- 38:59but Trump
- 39:00literally tried to like coup the government via
- 39:02January 6th and the fake elector scheme,
- 39:04and it still took Merrick Garland two years or a
- 39:07year and a half years to even open that investigation.
- 39:09He slow walked the entire thing,
- 39:12and then
- 39:13he ended up uh.
- 39:15It was too late.
- 39:16Trump ended up winning.
- 39:17Do you think it was a mistake to convict Trump of,
- 39:20you know,
- 39:20of the felonies that he was convicted of?
- 39:23Um,
- 39:24yeah,
- 39:24it was pretty dumb.
- 39:25Yeah.
- 39:26And,
- 39:26and how come?
- 39:28I think that
- 39:29if you're gonna.
- 39:30See,
- 39:31the thing is,
- 39:32it wasn't some coordinated top-down scheme among a
- 39:35bunch of Democratic officials to indict Trump.
- 39:37So
- 39:38because of that,
- 39:39I can't just ask them,
- 39:40like there's not actually a reality where we can
- 39:42just pick which case we want to go first.
- 39:45These were actual things that he did.
- 39:47But I think that
- 39:48if there were like a broad strategy and we were to look at each one,
- 39:52when you're gonna go.
- 39:53And try to make a case to the public against a
- 39:56former president and say that a former president did something bad,
- 40:00ideally you want to lead with your best
- 40:02evidence and your best case.
- 40:03You want to have put your best foot forward.
- 40:05And again,
- 40:06it's not like Letitia James and Jack Smith were actually coordinating,
- 40:09so there's no way for them to like
- 40:11think about it.
- 40:12There was no strategy,
- 40:12they're just trying to apply the law,
- 40:14but ideally,
- 40:16we have the.
- 40:17January 6th case first,
- 40:19and we're making the case to the public like,
- 40:20hey,
- 40:21this dude literally tried a fake elector scheme,
- 40:23and it's really bad,
- 40:24and he,
- 40:25he's on the phone,
- 40:26on the phone saying that he wants these votes.
- 40:28Like,
- 40:28I think that would be way more compelling,
- 40:31and we probably wouldn't have a second Trump
- 40:33term if we actually made that compelling case,
- 40:35but instead,
- 40:36it was.
- 40:36Like 34 counts of falsifying business records with
- 40:40the intent of covering up another crime.
- 40:42How do you even explain that to the average person?
- 40:44I don't know.
- 40:45Yeah,
- 40:45January 6th is really strange to me because I do,
- 40:48I agree with you.
- 40:49If there was
- 40:50one thing that stood out
- 40:52from Trump's first presidency,
- 40:53I mean,
- 40:54January 6th was for sure it.
- 40:56Do you really think though that there was a convictable
- 41:00Crime,
- 41:00like a winnable case there.
- 41:02Yeah,
- 41:03Jack Smith has been coming out for the past few weeks,
- 41:05and he said with certainty,
- 41:07he is so certain they would have gotten a conviction,
- 41:10especially on the elector scheme.
- 41:11The fake elector scheme was crazy,
- 41:14I mean it was a,
- 41:14it,
- 41:15they did like a RICO charge against Rudy Giuliani and everyone.
- 41:18Yeah,
- 41:19that was some pretty crazy shit.
- 41:20So that was,
- 41:21you know,
- 41:21an attempt,
- 41:21like very kind of aggressive.
- 41:25Attempts to
- 41:27engineer the election prove that there was,
- 41:30well,
- 41:30just to kind of change the outcome essentially.
- 41:32Yeah,
- 41:32like I don't even think the big,
- 41:34like the biggest
- 41:35concerning thing about January 6th isn't just the
- 41:38fact that those idiots stormed the Capitol,
- 41:40right?
- 41:41Trump around that time
- 41:43was manufacturing claims.
- 41:45Fake fraud.
- 41:46Then in 7 different swing states,
- 41:48he had 7 different electors ready.
- 41:50Like he had electors ready
- 41:52to forge their signature,
- 41:53go in the Capitol and claim that Trump was the winner of all 7 swing states.
- 41:58He was going with brute force rig the election.
- 42:01It didn't,
- 42:01it didn't work,
- 42:02and
- 42:03there should have been consequences for sure.
- 42:05Do you think he'll give up power
- 42:07peacefully,
- 42:08um,
- 42:09as this
- 42:10term winds down?
- 42:11I think so.
- 42:12I think he'll be pretty old,
- 42:13yeah.
- 42:14Mhm.
- 42:15I don't think he's going for a 3rd term.
- 42:16I think he,
- 42:17I think him and Steve Bannon use that as a troll a lot because Steve Bannon
- 42:21is the master of throwing shit at the wall to like scare the enemies,
- 42:24and Steve Bannon is always the one that's harping on the Trump 3rd term thing.
- 42:27So I think he's just doing it to distract.
- 42:29That's my theory.
- 42:30So then we get into kind of like the Merrick Garland was
- 42:34a pussy kind of argument,
- 42:35um,
- 42:37which is.
- 42:38You know,
- 42:38we have these Steve Bannon's on the right,
- 42:40these
- 42:41Donald Trumps,
- 42:41these,
- 42:42these very aggressive,
- 42:44not held to norm
- 42:45type personalities that have really
- 42:49become the,
- 42:49the,
- 42:50the leading
- 42:51minds on the right,
- 42:53and they have
- 42:54crafted this unbelievable political ascent.
- 42:57What you're kind of arguing is like
- 42:59the left needs to play,
- 43:00you know,
- 43:01you need to fight fire with fire,
- 43:02you need to play.
- 43:04Hardball,
- 43:05um,
- 43:05to,
- 43:07to compete.
- 43:09But then what I'm also kind of hearing from you
- 43:11and what I also feel sometimes in my own discussions is
- 43:15that the left needs to appeal to centrists and
- 43:19and not be as extreme.
- 43:20And so there
- 43:21there's kind of these contradicting
- 43:23things,
- 43:24you know,
- 43:24Merrick Garland is somebody who's kind of a very processed guy.
- 43:27He,
- 43:28he's not extreme by nature.
- 43:29He,
- 43:30he was a centrist and so he was kind of doing what he thought was a
- 43:35The least lawfareli approach.
- 43:37But then,
- 43:38you know,
- 43:39that doesn't really win against
- 43:41the Trumps of the world.
- 43:43But if you play by Trump's rules,
- 43:45do you sort of lose part of your soul in the process?
- 43:49Do you,
- 43:50do you feel that tension?
- 43:52Definitely,
- 43:52and I think that Biden and Merrick Garland were just
- 43:55sort of misreading the moment as a return to normalcy,
- 43:58status quo moment,
- 43:59and that's not where the American people are,
- 44:01that's not where centrists were either.
- 44:02They weren't at a return to normalcy status quo moment
- 44:06because they immediately ended up re-electing Trump right after,
- 44:09who ended up choosing Pam Bondi,
- 44:11which is like the polar opposite of Merrick Garland in terms of process and
- 44:15prestige and having a.
- 44:17Steady hand
- 44:18there's a quote where it's like,
- 44:19like norms in a democracy work a lot like consent in a relationship.
- 44:23You,
- 44:24you can't have meaningful consent if only
- 44:26one side is engaging consensually that's not consent
- 44:29and you can't have meaningful norms if only one side is engaging in the norms.
- 44:33So we can't just continue to go high while they break process over and over and over.
- 44:38I think we have to at the very least match the energy of Republicans.
- 44:42Mm mhm
- 44:43yeah,
- 44:44I could see that
- 44:45and.
- 44:46Yeah,
- 44:47I will say this going into kind of this next presidential election cycle,
- 44:51which,
- 44:51you know,
- 44:51I,
- 44:52I admit,
- 44:52I,
- 44:53I look forward to because I'm very engaged in politics,
- 44:56but I know a lot of people are,
- 44:58they,
- 44:58they're over it.
- 44:59They,
- 44:59they really don't want to think about politics for another two years.
- 45:03Uh,
- 45:03this is kind of the biggest question on my mind is,
- 45:05is where does the character of Democrats
- 45:09go,
- 45:10you know,
- 45:10more towards this Bernie messaging,
- 45:12more towards this Buttigieg messaging.
- 45:14And,
- 45:14and who tries to fill the big shoes
- 45:17of Donald Trump if he truly does step back,
- 45:20um,
- 45:21do you think JD Vance has the sauce?
- 45:23Not to fill Trump's shoes,
- 45:25I don't think anyone can fill Trump's shoes right now.
- 45:27JD Vance already sees cracks in the coalition because the gripers hate him.
- 45:31Clavicular thinks he
- 45:33gets mogged to death by
- 45:35Newsom.
- 45:36I don't think anyone can,
- 45:37it's gonna be interesting.
- 45:38We're already seeing the cracks in the MAGA coalition.
- 45:40And does JD Vance take the pro-Israel position?
- 45:43Does he split from it?
- 45:44Does he go super anti-Israel?
- 45:46It's gonna be,
- 45:47it's gonna be interesting to see.
- 45:49Definitely will.
- 45:50Um,
- 45:50OK,
- 45:50so,
- 45:51going into a new year,
- 45:53um,
- 45:53before we wrap up,
- 45:54Adam,
- 45:55what,
- 45:56I want to give you the opportunity.
- 45:57What are your biggest predictions for 2026?
- 46:00Damn,
- 46:01I think that we're gonna see a blue wave.
- 46:03I think that
- 46:04more jubilee episodes will come out,
- 46:06more
- 46:07debate shows will launch.
- 46:09I'm gonna be launching a debate show in 2026.
- 46:12I think it's gonna be a good year for democracy.
- 46:14It's gonna be tumultuous,
- 46:15of course,
- 46:16because the Trump admin is still in power.
- 46:18They're gonna do anything they can to cling on before the midterms come,
- 46:22but
- 46:22we're gonna keep pushing.
- 46:23Well,
- 46:23thank you,
- 46:24Adam,
- 46:24so much for,
- 46:25for doing this.
- 46:26Surrounded Follow up.
- 46:27Thank you for having me on.
- 46:28If you want to see more follow-up episodes of Surrounded,
- 46:30be sure to like,
- 46:31leave us a positive review,
- 46:33comment if you're watching the video on YouTube.
- 46:36Uh,
- 46:36you can subscribe to Tubili,
- 46:37Jubilee's second channel.
- 46:39You can also subscribe to Jubilee to see full
- 46:41surrounded episodes.
- 46:43But however you want to support us,
- 46:45just thank you so much for listening.
- 46:46Remember,
- 46:47you could be wrong,
- 46:48so could I.
- 46:49Keep your mind open
- 46:51until next time.