Latest / MBA Training Marketing / Influencer ROI: measure repeat purchases, not likes
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the Leaders Insights Podcast.
- 0:07Today's episode, Measuring Influencer ROI Past Vanity Metrics, a CMO's playbook.
- 0:13Every CMO I know brags about influencer campaigns pulling 10 million views.
- 0:18So tell me straight, does a view mean anything?
- 0:21Almost nothing.
- 0:22A view means a phone was somewhere near a screen while a video auto-played.
- 0:26That's the marketing equivalent of counting how many people walked past your store without
- 0:30checking if a single one came in.
- 0:32Harsh, but those are the numbers agencies put in the deck.
- 0:36Of course they do, because they're easy to inflate and impossible to argue with.
- 0:41Likes and follower counts are what we call vanity metrics, numbers that look impressive
- 0:46and connect to nothing you can bank.
- 0:48The follower count is the calorie label on a bag of chips.
- 0:52Technically true, tells you nothing about whether it's good for you.
- 0:56So where does a CMO actually start if they've been living on likes?
- 0:59You start by picking one business outcome per campaign.
- 1:02Revenue, retention, or brand equity.
- 1:05The value of your name in someone's head.
- 1:08Not all three.
- 1:09If you chase all three at once, you measure none of them properly.
- 1:13Fine, say I pick revenue.
- 1:15How do I connect a TikTok video to a sale?
- 1:17Three tools in order of honesty.
- 1:20First, unique codes and links.
- 1:22Which influencer gets their own, so you see exactly which sales trace back to them.
- 1:27Cheap, clean, and it undercounts, because plenty of people see the video, buy nothing
- 1:32that day, then Google you a week later.
- 1:35So the code makes the influencer look worse than they are.
- 1:38Right, which is why you add the second tool, post-purchase surveys.
- 1:42One question at checkout.
- 1:44How did you hear about us?
- 1:46Everyone ignores this because it's low tech, but it catches the buyers the codes
- 1:50miss.
- 1:51HelloFresh has leaned on this, how did you hear about us question for years?
- 1:55Precisely because their tracking links leak.
- 1:57And the third?
- 1:59Hold out testing.
- 2:00The grown up version.
- 2:01You run the campaign in some regions and deliberately go dark in others, then compare
- 2:06sales.
- 2:07If the influencer regions outperform, that gap is your real lift.
- 2:11It's the only method that survives a hostile finance director.
- 2:15That sounds expensive and slow.
- 2:17It is.
- 2:18So you only do it for your big bets.
- 2:20The six-figure deals.
- 2:22For everything else, codes plus the survey get you close enough.
- 2:25You don't run a clinical trial to decide whether to buy the sandwich.
- 2:29Let's talk retention, because you keep mentioning it.
- 2:32Why shouldn't influencer care whether customers stick around?
- 2:36Because the source of a customer predicts how long they stay.
- 2:39Track the churn, the share of customers who cancel or stop buying, by which influencer
- 2:44brought them in.
- 2:46Jim Shark found buyers from fitness creators who actually use the product stuck around
- 2:51far longer than buyers from a generic celebrity post.
- 2:55Same acquisition cost, wildly different lifetime value.
- 2:59The total money a customer spends before they leave.
- 3:02So a cheap influencer with loyal followers beats an expensive one with a broad, indifferent
- 3:07audience.
- 3:08Often, yes.
- 3:09And you'd never see that if you stopped at the first sale.
- 3:12The Vanity Metrics crowd would have crowned the celebrity and quietly bled money for a
- 3:17year.
- 3:18What about brand equity, the fuzzy one?
- 3:20How do you put a number on whether people think better of you?
- 3:23Brand lift surveys.
- 3:24You poll people exposed to the campaign, and a matched group who weren't.
- 3:29And measure the difference in, would you consider buying this?
- 3:33Vendors like Kantar sell this.
- 3:35And all flag Chari, it's their product.
- 3:37So treat their benchmarks as a starting point, not gospel.
- 3:40But a 10-point jump in consideration is real signal.
- 3:44Give me the one number a CMO should put on the dashboard tomorrow.
- 3:47Incremental revenue per thousand dollars spent.
- 3:50Per influencer.
- 3:51Not reach.
- 3:52Not engagement.
- 3:53The actual extra sales you got that you wouldn't have otherwise.
- 3:57Divided by what you paid.
- 3:58And if an influencer can't produce that number?
- 4:01Then they're an entertainer you're subsidizing.
- 4:03Not a channel you're investing in.
- 4:05Both can be fine.
- 4:07Just know which one you're paying for.
- 4:09So the takeaway?
- 4:10Tomorrow, add one column to your influencer spreadsheet.
- 4:14Incremental revenue per thousand spent.
- 4:17Anyone who can't fill it in gets a hard conversation, not a renewal.
- 4:21Done.
- 4:22Want to know where you actually stand?
- 4:23Take the CMO self-assessment at MBA-training.com.