Latest / Saladin: The Muslim Leader Who Defeated Crusaders — Fexingo History / Saladin's Generosity: The Sultan Who Paid His Own Ransom
Transcript
- Lucas: So we've talked a lot about Saladin's generosity — ransoming prisoners, giving gifts to enemies, that sort of thing. But there's a side to that generosity that we haven't really dug into: how he paid for it. And honestly, the answer is a bit of a shock. Lucas: Saladin, the sultan who conquered Jerusalem, who stood up to Richard the Lionheart, often didn't have the money to pay his own troops. He'd give away his own treasure to the point where he'd have to borrow from his emirs just to keep the army fed. His own chroniclers, Baha ad-Din ibn Shaddad and Imad ad-Din al-Isfahani, both mention this repeatedly, almost with a kind of affectionate frustration. Luna: Wait, the sultan couldn't pay his own soldiers? Lucas: Yeah, it sounds wild, but it's true. I mean, at times he literally had nothing. Baha ad-Din tells a story from the siege of Acre in 1190, where Saladin was so short of cash that he couldn't distribute the usual pay to his troops. And you'd think that would cause a mutiny, but the troops actually stayed loyal, which says a lot about his personal authority. Lucas: But there's a more famous incident — and this is the one I want to focus on today — where Saladin, the great sultan, didn't have the money to pay his own ransom. He was actually captured once, early in his career, and his own ransom was a problem. Luna: Saladin was captured? When was that? Lucas: This was in 1167, during his time in Egypt, before he was sultan. He was serving under his uncle Shirkuh, and they were fighting against the Franks and a rival vizier. In one battle, Saladin got separated from the main force and was captured by the Franks. And the ransom that was demanded — I think it was something like fifty thousand dinars — was way more than he had on him. Lucas: He ended up having to borrow from some of his own men, and eventually the ransom was paid, but it was a humiliating moment. And the interesting thing is, later in his life, he made a point of never letting that happen to anyone else if he could help it. He'd pay ransoms for his own soldiers, for captured emirs, even for Frankish prisoners when they couldn't pay. Luna: So he basically projected his own bad experience onto everyone else. Lucas: Exactly. And that's a pattern we see again and again. His generosity wasn't just a policy; it was personal. Baha ad-Din records multiple instances where Saladin gave away sums that he didn't have, and then had to go to his treasurer, al-Qadi al-Fadil, and ask for an advance on his own treasury. Al-Qadi al-Fadil would often refuse, saying, 'You've already given it all away.' But Saladin would insist, and sometimes he'd even have to sell off his own possessions. Lucas: There's a story from after the Battle of Hattin, when he was distributing the spoils and the captives. He gave so much to his emirs and his soldiers that he didn't have enough left to pay the wages of his own personal guard. And his guard, the asa, they didn't complain — they knew he'd make it up to them eventually. But it's remarkable that he could command that kind of loyalty while being essentially broke. Luna: So how did he actually manage to run a kingdom if he was always broke? Lucas: That's the paradox. He had a lot of revenue coming in — from taxes, from iqta lands, from tribute and conquest. But he spent it as fast as it came. And he also had this habit of treating the treasury as if it were his own personal purse, to be given away to anyone who asked. His chroniclers both note that he found it hard to say no to a request for money, whether it was a poet, a soldier, or a widow in distress. Lucas: One of my favorite stories comes from Imad ad-Din. After the fall of Jerusalem in 1187, Saladin was walking through the city, and a poor woman came up to him, asking for money to buy food for her children. He didn't have any money on him, so he asked one of his emirs for a loan, and then gave it to her. That's a small gesture, but it shows how he operated on a daily basis. Luna: That's really touching, but also kind of irresponsible for a ruler, isn't it? Lucas: You're not wrong. Some of his own advisors thought so. Al-Qadi al-Fadil, who was his closest counselor, often warned him to hold back, to keep a reserve for emergencies. And Saladin would listen, agree, and then go out and give away more money the next day. It drove al-Qadi al-Fadil crazy, but he also respected that it was part of what made Saladin beloved. Lucas: And it wasn't just about charity. His generosity was also a political tool. By being open-handed, he bought loyalty, he bought alliances, he bought peace. The emirs who served him knew that if they were captured, Saladin would ransom them without question. That's why they stayed loyal even when he couldn't pay them on time. Luna: So his financial irresponsibility was actually a strategic asset? Lucas: In a way, yes. But it also had a downside, especially in the later years of the Third Crusade. There are accounts from the siege of Acre, in 1191, where Saladin's army was short on supplies, and he had to send urgent requests to his brother al-Adil and to other emirs for money and food. Some of them were reluctant to send it, and there was even talk of his authority being challenged because he couldn't pay his troops. Lucas: And then, after the defeat at Arsuf, he had to face Richard the Lionheart, who had a much more disciplined approach to finance. Richard could pay his soldiers, he could pay for supplies, he could even pay for mercenaries. Saladin couldn't do that consistently. So in a way, his generosity put him at a strategic disadvantage against Richard. Luna: I never thought of it like that. So Richard was more financially prudent? Lucas: Richard was very good at extracting money from his own kingdom — he famously said he would sell London if he could find a buyer. But he also knew how to use money to keep his army together. Saladin, on the other hand, treated money as something to be given away, not hoarded. And there's a poignant moment in the negotiations after Arsuf, where Richard actually complained to Saladin's envoys that Saladin was too generous, that he was setting an impossible standard. Luna: Richard said that? That's almost ironic. Lucas: It is. Because Richard was also known for his own acts of chivalry, but he was much more calculated about it. Saladin's generosity was more instinctive, almost compulsive. And it's one of the reasons he's remembered so fondly in both Western and Eastern sources, even among his enemies. There are stories of Frankish knights who, when they were captured, asked to be ransomed by Saladin rather than by their own kings, because they knew he would treat them well. Lucas: But that generosity had a cost. Baha ad-Din tells us that when Saladin died in 1193, his personal treasury was so depleted that he didn't have enough money to pay for his own funeral. He had to borrow from one of his emirs. And that's a striking image — the man who gave away a kingdom couldn't afford his own burial. Luna: That's so tragic and noble at the same time. Lucas: It's a perfect example of who he was. And it's something that his chroniclers wanted us to remember. They didn't hide his financial troubles; they presented them as a testament to his character. In the Islamic tradition, there's a hadith that says the generous are close to God, and Saladin seems to have taken that to heart, literally to the point of bankruptcy. Lucas: So when we think about Saladin, we often focus on his military victories or his diplomatic skills, but his real legacy might be this model of leadership — where you lead by giving, not by hoarding. And it's a model that's hard to sustain, as we've seen. But it's one that earned him a place in history that few other rulers have achieved. Luna: You know, listening to this, I'm struck by how human he was. He wasn't just a legend; he was a guy who couldn't say no to a request for money, even when it hurt him. Lucas: Exactly. And that's what makes him so fascinating. He was a man of contradictions: a warrior who preferred peace, a ruler who couldn't manage his own finances, a conqueror who was beloved by his enemies. And if we're honest, those contradictions are what make history feel real, not just a list of dates and battles. Lucas: And that's also what makes this show worth doing. We get to dig into the human side of these figures, the parts that don't make it into the textbooks. And if you've been enjoying these deep dives, you know how much work goes into them. Honestly, if today was worth a coffee to you, that's the link — buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. It keeps us going, and it's the smallest ask we make. Luna: Yeah, and it really does help. We put a lot of love into these episodes, and knowing people appreciate that means a lot. Lucas: Alright, back to Saladin. There's one more story I want to tell you, because it ties everything together. It's about the siege of Jaffa in 1192, right before the treaty with Richard. Saladin had been trying to take the city, and he was running low on everything — men, supplies, money. But he still found a way to pay his troops. How? He melted down his own golden goblets and distributed the gold to his soldiers. He literally gave away his own tableware. Luna: He did that? That's... that's actually amazing. Lucas: And that's the image I want to leave you with. Not just the sultan in his tent, but a man who, when he had nothing left, gave away his own plate so his men could eat. And it's that spirit that made him a legend, even if it left him broke. So next time you hear about Saladin's generosity, remember it came at a cost — and it was a cost he was willing to pay, over and over again.