Latest / The Sperrins: Mining, Power & Community in Northern Ireland / #No.54🎙️ Public Inquiry Gold Laundering Risk Week 4 Day 3
Transcript
- 0:04I Someone told me today that the podcast about the public inquiry
- 0:08had become essential breakfast listening, and for an instant, I
- 0:12was like a rabbit frozen in the headlights while to make the
- 0:16effort to gather today's information and then work on it
- 0:20to turn it into something that people might actually listen to.
- 0:24I kind of never expect anyone to listen so it always comes as a
- 0:28surprise when someone mentions it. It seems I have unwittingly
- 0:34stumbled upon some latent skill buried deep, which, upon
- 0:39release, has turned me into a podcaster that I didn't know I
- 0:42wanted to be when I grew up. However, here we are back to the
- 0:48business of today, some very big topics covered today. Each one
- 0:52of them would merit their own podcast. We range from money
- 0:57laundering to policing to explosives to timetables and
- 1:01everything in between. After some early questions of clarity
- 1:06by the Commission to dalradian, Linda Sullivan was first out of
- 1:11the blocks for the third parties with a question for dalradian
- 1:15asking, how can they calculate 4% which is due to the Crown
- 1:20Estate for all gold mine if they don't know what's in the
- 1:24concentrate. The reason this question was asked as there was
- 1:30a court case in Northern Ireland in which an employee of
- 1:33Galantis, the only other gold mine in Northern Ireland
- 1:38recently abandoned, was reprimanded for whistleblowing
- 1:42after allegedly manipulating in house laboratory gold yield
- 1:47figures to make the situation appear a tad more favourable for
- 1:51investors. So naturally, we the third parties are concerned.
- 2:00Cormac McAleer drew the attention of the commission to
- 2:03the number of name changes dalradian has had over the
- 2:06years, as they've been here from the 1970s while there's nothing
- 2:12wrong with this whatsoever, he also pointed out that there have
- 2:16been numerous shell companies created by dalradian. He noted
- 2:21that statutory bodies have a responsibility to implement
- 2:24appropriate fraud prevention measures. He suggested that
- 2:29factors such as the potential presence of complex corporate
- 2:33structures, possible gaps in due diligence, limited transparency,
- 2:41when combined with optimism bias, could pose risks,
- 2:45including potential social costs and implications for the public
- 2:49purse. So Mary Broly then highlighted the following. Go
- 2:59laundering is an issue that we believe is of critical
- 3:02importance to any devolved government when it comes to gold
- 3:06mining operations anywhere in the UK, it should be central to
- 3:10discussions on public revenue. In November 2023 the UK National
- 3:18Crime Agency NCA issued a red alert titled gold based
- 3:24financial and trade sanctions circumvention to raise awareness
- 3:29it highlights the importance of due diligence and notes that
- 3:33enablers often try to obstruct others from carrying out those
- 3:37checks. The NCA the Royal United Services Institute and the
- 3:45Financial Action Task Force, all of which the UK has long been
- 3:50involved with, identify key Red Flag Warning Signs of gold
- 3:54laundering. These include things like sudden changes to company
- 4:00names, firms registered in tax havens, despite operating
- 4:05elsewhere and complex webs of shell companies spread across
- 4:10multiple jurisdictions. A December 2025, OECD policy brief
- 4:17on illicit flows of gold concentrates also warns that the
- 4:21global trade in unrefined containerized gold is
- 4:25particularly vulnerable to exploitation. It recommends
- 4:30stricter licencing and better monitoring of processing plants
- 4:34traders and smelters to improve traceability. Now to be
- 4:40absolutely clear, raising these issues isn't about pointing the
- 4:44finger at any one company or any specific project. It's about
- 4:48recognising that these risks exist globally and they're well
- 4:52documented. What we're really getting at here is this gold
- 4:59laundering is. In some niche issue. It's a major global
- 5:02problem, and governments ignore it at their peril. If Northern
- 5:07Ireland or anywhere in the UK is serious about developing gold
- 5:11mining, then tackling this has to be part of the conversation.
- 5:14From day one, we already know the playbook. Criminal networks
- 5:19hide behind renamed companies, offshore registrations and
- 5:23layers of shell corporations to disguise where gold is coming
- 5:27from and where the money is going. Even the trade in raw
- 5:31gold concentrates before it's refined is now recognised as a
- 5:36weak point that may be exploited. So the question isn't
- 5:42whether the risk exists, it clearly does. Real question is
- 5:47whether departments like DFI or DFE or the wider executive have
- 5:52actually put safeguards in place to deal with it, because if they
- 5:56haven't, they're potentially leaving the door open to a
- 5:59system that drains billions from the public purse here and across
- 6:03the world. When DFI were asked if due diligence had been
- 6:08carried out, the response was, it wouldn't be usual, adding
- 6:14that, in my understanding, there are separate regimes who deal
- 6:17with this, excuse me in advance, but what the I won't say it,
- 6:24what kind of response is that it is breathtaking in its
- 6:29cowardice, in its indifference, in its lack of accountability,
- 6:33in its complacency in a sheer Abnegation of Duty. Mary Brawley
- 6:39suggested that was highly unusual answer. Added that we've
- 6:43just alerted the department to a source of hypothetical fraud
- 6:47with a potential source of billions of lost revenue, and
- 6:51their response is this, you could not make it up. From here,
- 7:00we moved on to policing, which quickly led us to the fact that
- 7:0444,000 tonnes of explosives are being used during the life of
- 7:09the mind. And how was the policing costed by the
- 7:13applicants, and where did it appear in the magic invisible
- 7:16economic modeller, when asked by the Commission, is policing
- 7:21required for the proposal? Mr. Beatty, counsel for dalradian,
- 7:25answered it is a matter of assessment by PS and I on a page
- 7:29by page basis, seeming to suggest that no policing would
- 7:33be needed. He seemed to forget that we were in Northern
- 7:37Ireland, envisioning the police dropping off the explosives at
- 7:42the gate of the mine and then going back to the station. So
- 7:46yes, they eventually clarified that there was no calculation of
- 7:50policing costs, all in a climate of heightened dissident
- 7:56terrorist activity, with a car bomb going off outside a police
- 7:59station in the last 10 days, and national security alert
- 8:03escalation, and then we have the readily available explosive
- 8:08materials down at the mine. Roll up, roll up. Get your Semtex
- 8:12here. Other topics covered today were, while there might be
- 8:16blasting twice a day, it's now termed as extensive meaning it
- 8:21be going, could be going on on several faces of the mine at the
- 8:25same time. I'm not sure what the implications of this are, except
- 8:30it doesn't sound good. We also discussed the closure of the
- 8:33mine and the associated bond costs. Both this and the
- 8:37blastings will be covered on the Don't mind us website in the
- 8:41next 24 to 48 hours. So look for the details there. Finally,
- 8:46there was another attempt to sort out the timetable. No
- 8:49progress yet. We should know more on Tuesday, and that's it
- 8:53for another week. Thanks for still listening to me, and we'll
- 8:58see you soon.
- 9:02You