Latest / Think Fast Talk Smart: Communication Techniques / 231. Secret Signals: Why We Rarely Say Exactly What We Mean
Transcript
- 0:03Matt Abrahams: While many of us focus on being direct, the reality is,
- 0:06being indirect strategically helps us accomplish much of our communication.
- 0:12My name's Matt Abrahams and I teach strategic communication at
- 0:15Stanford Graduate School of Business.
- 0:17Welcome to Think Fast Talk Smart, the podcast.
- 0:20Today, I'm super excited to spend time with Steven Pinker.
- 0:24Steven is the Johnstone Professor of Psychology at Harvard University.
- 0:28He studies language, cognition, and social relations.
- 0:31He has received many awards for his teaching.
- 0:33He's written twelve insightful and impactful books, and his latest is,
- 0:37When Everyone Knows That Everyone Knows: Common Knowledge and the Mysteries
- 0:42of Money, Power, and Everyday Life.
- 0:44Welcome, Steven.
- 0:45I've been looking forward to this conversation ever since we set it up.
- 0:49Steven Pinker: Me too.
- 0:49Thanks for having me.
- 0:50Matt Abrahams: Excellent.
- 0:51Shall we get started?
- 0:52Steven Pinker: Let's start.
- 0:53Matt Abrahams: Much of your work looks at language and cognition.
- 0:56You've distinguished between the what and the what you mean by it of language.
- 1:00What do you mean by this distinction and how can we use this insight to
- 1:04become more persuasive and effective in the communication we have?
- 1:08Steven Pinker: It's long been known by anyone who studies language that an awful
- 1:11lot of the time, we don't just blurt out what we mean in so many words, but
- 1:15we hint, we wink, we shilly-shally, we beat around the bush, we use euphemism,
- 1:20we use innuendo, counting on our listener to read between the lines,
- 1:24connect the dots, catch our drift.
- 1:26And as someone who studies language, this has always been a puzzle.
- 1:29Why don't we just blurt out what we mean?
- 1:30So just some obvious examples.
- 1:32Politeness, if you could pass the salt, that would be awesome.
- 1:35Now that's an awful weird thing to say.
- 1:37For one thing, it's certainly hyperbolic.
- 1:39It wouldn't be awesome.
- 1:40It might be nice, but also why are you pondering hypotheticals?
- 1:44We all understand what it means.
- 1:46Give me the salt.
- 1:47Why don't we just say, give me the salt.
- 1:49In more emotionally hot circumstances, there's uh,
- 1:53certainly a lot of indirectness.
- 1:55So imagine you're trying to bribe your way into a restaurant by slipping a
- 1:58fifty dollar bill to the maître d'.
- 2:00You probably wouldn't say, if I give you the fifty, will you less jump
- 2:03the queue and seat us right away?
- 2:05You might say like, I was wondering if you might have a cancellation, or is
- 2:08there any way you could shorten my wait?
- 2:10Or sexual come ons is a, as we all know, a big arena for indirectness and euphemism.
- 2:16You wanna come up and see my etchings, you wanna come up for coffee, you
- 2:19wanna come up for Netflix and chill.
- 2:21So in all these cases you might say, oh, plausible deniability.
- 2:25But, come on.
- 2:26How plausible is it?
- 2:27As if any grown woman could, could be in any doubt as to what, do you wanna
- 2:30come up for coffee, means late at night.
- 2:33So why do we do it?
- 2:34And the answer that I came up with is that we avoid common knowledge.
- 2:39Now my book is about common knowledge.
- 2:41And common knowledge has a, a technical meaning in linguistics, in philosophy,
- 2:46in economics, in game theory, and political science, and a lot of academia.
- 2:50What it means is, I know something, you know something.
- 2:52I know that you know it, you know that I know it.
- 2:55I know that you know that I know it, I know that you know that.
- 2:58I know that you know that I know it, ad infinitum.
- 3:00Common knowledge is important because it's necessary for coordination,
- 3:03for being on the same page.
- 3:05If you're the only one who knows that you're supposed to drive on
- 3:08the right and everyone else thinks that you're supposed to drive on the
- 3:10left, you better drive on the left.
- 3:12It's not enough that you know it.
- 3:13Even if you're right, according to the law of the land, it doesn't matter.
- 3:16What matters is what everyone knows that everyone else knows.
- 3:19Relationships are propped up by common knowledge.
- 3:21What makes us friends?
- 3:22You know, it's not as if we sign a contract, I know that
- 3:25you consider us friends.
- 3:26And what does that mean?
- 3:27Well, it's 'cause you know that I consider us friends and so on, or lovers, or a boss
- 3:33and a subordinate, or an authority and a person who recognizes their authority.
- 3:38We're two transaction partners.
- 3:39The relationship exists in our heads, and it's a matter of common knowledge.
- 3:43So direct speech, blurting something out, generates common knowledge.
- 3:47It's not a question of whether it's deniable, it's a question of whether
- 3:50you know that the other person knows what you meant is deniable.
- 3:53That is, is the common knowledge deniable.
- 3:56And common knowledge is what ratifies or annuls social relationships,
- 4:01and that's why blurting something out that contradicts assumptions
- 4:05of the relationship can blow everything up and be deeply awkward.
- 4:09Whereas hinting innuendo, they know, but they don't know you know they know.
- 4:13And that allows you to maintain the previous relationship.
- 4:16So in the case of, say, a sexual proposition, if Harry says, you
- 4:20wanna come up for coffee, and Sally says, no, she knows she's turned
- 4:24down a sexual overture and he knows she's turned down an overture.
- 4:26But does she know that he knows she knows?
- 4:30She could think, maybe he thinks I'm naive, maybe he thinks I, that I
- 4:33just turned down a coffee invitation.
- 4:35And he doesn't know that she knows that he knows.
- 4:37He could think maybe she thinks I'm dense.
- 4:39Maybe she thinks I just interpret it as turning it down for coffee,
- 4:42even though I know she really turned down a sexual overture.
- 4:45So without the common knowledge they can maintain the fiction
- 4:50of a purely platonic friendship.
- 4:52Whereas if he said, do you wanna come up for sex?
- 4:55And she says, no, it's never the same.
- 4:57They can try to go back to a platonic friendship.
- 4:59But once it was out there, once it's common knowledge, that changes everything.
- 5:03So when everyone knows something, it's really different than when
- 5:06everyone knows it and everyone knows that everyone knows it.
- 5:09Matt Abrahams: It seems to me that the context also plays a role in
- 5:13what we all know about each other.
- 5:15So taking flirtation, which I actually, in grad school, my
- 5:19research was on flirtation, not only because I wanted to get dates when
- 5:21I was that age, but I was always fascinated by strategic communication.
- 5:25And I think flirtation is a wonderful venue to study that.
- 5:28If you go see a doctor and the doctor says, how are you doing?
- 5:31That has one meaning.
- 5:32But if you're in a bar and somebody says, how are you doing?
- 5:34That has a very different meaning.
- 5:36Context seems to add an extra level of understanding of what you know and I know.
- 5:41And so we have to be aware, not just of what's being said, but the
- 5:44context in which it's being said.
- 5:45And clearly we can run into some mismatches if I'm not paying attention
- 5:49appropriately to the context.
- 5:52So it sounds to me like we have the ability to assess and judge these
- 5:55circumstances and try our best to fit within that optimal space.
- 6:00How do we learn to do this?
- 6:02I don't ever remember taking a class on indirect, ambiguous communication.
- 6:06How do we learn what's appropriate?
- 6:09Steven Pinker: Kids often charm us because they just blurt things out.
- 6:12They haven't mastered this yet, and it's, oh, grandpa just farted.
- 6:15Or, how come you have hair growing outta your nose?
- 6:18They just, you know, sort of say things, so you do have to master it.
- 6:22Some of it is from feedback.
- 6:24You say things that are, as you get older and the other kids
- 6:27stare at you, make fun of you.
- 6:29Some of it is just an extension of conversation.
- 6:32We don't lay out every last step in a logic of a conversation.
- 6:37Conversation would be impossible.
- 6:38There's so many missing links.
- 6:40It would be like a legal contract and a legal contract is written
- 6:44so that it would be immune to an adversary trying to exploit loopholes.
- 6:49When we have conversation, we start off cooperative.
- 6:51That's what we mean by to be on speaking terms.
- 6:53When you have two adversaries, there is no conversation.
- 6:57Two coaches of two football teams don't get together for a chat
- 7:00before the game, so conversation presupposes some degree of cooperation.
- 7:05That's a basic law of linguistics.
- 7:07When you're cooperative, you can leave things out so that the conversation
- 7:10doesn't take all day and you just know that the other person will figure
- 7:13out what you meant on the assumption that you're both aiming at the same
- 7:17thing, namely information coordination.
- 7:20And so knowing how a listener will connect the dots will fill in the blanks,
- 7:25allows you to sometimes to be creative in making one of these propositions.
- 7:29And there are formulas like, could you please pass the salt?
- 7:32No one even thinks about what that means.
- 7:34Literally, it's a idle question, not what it really is, which is an imperative.
- 7:39But still, that's the case where it's formulaic, but sometimes there
- 7:43is no formula and we think about something that's a prerequisite to the
- 7:47act, knowing that our hearer on the assumption that we're not crazy, that
- 7:51we're rational, that we really are trying to get at something, they then
- 7:54connect the dots and think, oh yeah, of course he wants me to do something,
- 7:57but he's too polite to boss me around.
- 8:00So he's stating the precondition.
- 8:02And we use our natural conversational skill at filling in the missing premises
- 8:07in order to convey the imperative.
- 8:10The reason that we do this indirectness, this musing, you know, do you
- 8:13think you could please, et cetera, is friends and, or just casual
- 8:18acquaintances don't like to boss each other around like they're servants.
- 8:21It's not like, Jeeves, bring me the butter.
- 8:23You don't wanna treat a friend like that, but still the butter's at their
- 8:26end of the table and you want it.
- 8:27How are you gonna get it without bossing them around?
- 8:30Matt Abrahams: So there's this level of metacognition that's
- 8:32required to pull this off.
- 8:34Steven Pinker: There is in novel.
- 8:35When they're novel cases.
- 8:36A lot of these circumstances are so familiar that we have formulas.
- 8:41Do you think you could pass the salt?
- 8:42Could you pass the salt?
- 8:43Where you don't have to engage in the metacognition, in that circumstance,
- 8:47'cause it's so familiar cliche that the English language gives you these formulas.
- 8:52But when it's a one time thing then, or a novel situation, and you're calibrating
- 8:58it to the other person, a sexual come on being a classic example, much more
- 9:02is at stake than getting the salt.
- 9:05Matt Abrahams: You mentioned in English, and I'm curious about cross-culturally
- 9:08if these things apply as well.
- 9:09I'll share an experience I had, I was teaching a student who was a
- 9:12non-native speaker of English, and he came into my class thrilled.
- 9:15I mean, he was elated, super excited.
- 9:17So I said, Hey, what's going on?
- 9:18Why are you so excited?
- 9:19And he looked at me and said, the woman that I'm very interested in told
- 9:22me that she just wants to be friends.
- 9:24And I'm really excited about that.
- 9:25And I had to rain on his parade because let's just be friends, when he looked it
- 9:31up, is exactly what he was looking for.
- 9:33But we all know that was saying something very different.
- 9:36So have you found that these ideas of what you know and other people
- 9:40know and using the strategic ambiguity crosses cultures as well?
- 9:44Steven Pinker: Do all cultures have some kinds of politeness?
- 9:47Some kinds of indirectness?
- 9:48The answer is yes.
- 9:49Cultures can vary and often tourist, travelers, businessmen have to get used
- 9:54to the level of indirectness in a culture.
- 9:56So Japan is famously indirect and polite, and there are many layers
- 10:01of honorifics and to the point where sometimes people get frustrated that
- 10:04you just never get down to business.
- 10:06You exchange so many pleasantries.
- 10:08Conversely, they're cultures like New York or Israel where people are famously
- 10:13blunt and people can easily get offended 'cause they don't realize that's just how
- 10:16you exchange information in that culture.
- 10:19But all cultures have some.
- 10:21Matt Abrahams: What it becomes really fascinating to me, is when you have people
- 10:23from lots of different cultures come together and they have conversation and
- 10:26you see this play out in how some people could be offended and others aren't.
- 10:30So it sounds to me at the end of the day that this indirect communication is, while
- 10:36many of us say, Hey, just I want people to be direct and honest with me, none of this
- 10:39doublespeak or hypocrisy, this is actually really necessary for us to function.
- 10:44Would you agree with that?
- 10:46Steven Pinker: Well, yeah.
- 10:46In the last chapter of, uh, When Everyone Knows That Everyone Knows,
- 10:49it's about, it's called radical honesty, rational hypocrisy.
- 10:53We're all kind of hypocrites about our hypocrisy.
- 10:56That is, we say, this hypocrisy is just such a waste of time, and it's
- 11:00so annoying, people beating around the bush, and roleplaying and rituals.
- 11:05Why don't we just cut the crap and say what we mean.
- 11:07Wouldn't life be better?
- 11:08The answer is no.
- 11:09It would be awful.
- 11:10A lot of our relationships really depend on common assumptions that
- 11:14are, at the end of the day, fictions.
- 11:16They're not literally true.
- 11:18One of them is that friends would do anything for each other and
- 11:22they value the other person's welfare as much as their own.
- 11:24They value the friendship.
- 11:26There's no limit on how much they value the friendship.
- 11:28Of course that can't be true.
- 11:29But if you were to say, okay, we've been on the phone for twenty-five
- 11:32minutes now, and twenty-five minutes is about all I can really take of
- 11:36talking to you and I, there are other things that I'd really rather do now.
- 11:39That is often true.
- 11:40But saying your friendship is worth only so much to me, but no more.
- 11:45That kills the friendship.
- 11:46It changes everything if you actually say it.
- 11:49Matt Abrahams: So this kind of communication really does provide
- 11:52the lubricant for these interactions and allows them to keep going.
- 11:56Steven Pinker: I wouldn't even say lubricants so much as the basis.
- 11:59That is, they, that's what being friends means.
- 12:02That's what being lovers means.
- 12:03It means that you accept certain things as the ground rules.
- 12:07You know that the other person accepts them, you know that they
- 12:09know that you accept them, and that's what makes relationships possible.
- 12:13Matt Abrahams: In your book, The Sense of Style, you argue that good
- 12:16writing and communication is about clarity, conciseness, and grace.
- 12:20I understand conciseness, but can you tell us a little bit more
- 12:23about grace, and then clarity?
- 12:25Steven Pinker: So what makes a lot of academese, bureaucratize,
- 12:30corporatize, what makes it so frustrating to get through is often
- 12:34what's called the curse of knowledge.
- 12:36The curse of knowledge is a psychological phenomenon in which, if you know
- 12:40something, it's very hard to imagine what it's like not to know it.
- 12:44That is, it's false common knowledge.
- 12:45You assume that your private knowledge is common knowledge.
- 12:48That's why in bad writing, the writer doesn't spell out the
- 12:52abbreviations, doesn't explain the jargon, doesn't give examples,
- 12:56doesn't allow for a concrete image.
- 12:58It doesn't occur to them because it's just so obvious, to them, and they don't
- 13:01realize it's not obvious to anyone else.
- 13:03So that's what goes into a lot of clarity, is just the empathy of
- 13:06what does the reader know and what can they see in their mind's eye?
- 13:11Sometimes clear writing may be a kind of graceless.
- 13:14It may be an instruction manual.
- 13:15It could be a memo.
- 13:17But when we try to persuade, to charm, even to make our writing pleasurable
- 13:22enough that other people will pay for it, we wanna get a job as a columnist
- 13:25or reviewer, we just want an audience, the prose has to be compelling.
- 13:29And there are many things that go into that.
- 13:31There's, first of all, just clarity.
- 13:33If you've got a struggle to figure out what the other person
- 13:35means, then you're gonna give up, and that makes prose graceless.
- 13:39Imposing on the memory load of a reader.
- 13:43If you've gotta hold too many words from the beginning of the sentence in
- 13:46mind before you get to the end of the sentence and know what they're doing.
- 13:49Or if it's not clear where the end of one phrase is and the beginning of the
- 13:54next one is, and the reader has to work hard, and if they're trying too hard
- 13:58to parse the syntax of the sentence, instead of seeing through to the
- 14:02meaning, that makes prose less graceful.
- 14:05But also even the melody and rhythm of speech.
- 14:08In this case, there is no speech.
- 14:09It's writing, but writing is mentally always speech.
- 14:13When you read someone's words, you're always sounding it out to
- 14:16yourself as if they're speaking.
- 14:17And so just the sheer mellifluousness of the sentence, as it would
- 14:22be said aloud, goes into grace.
- 14:25And one other thing is the vividness of the mental picture
- 14:28that the reader is supposed to get.
- 14:30And one of the things that makes bad writing bad is the reader doesn't
- 14:33have any image, nothing to grasp.
- 14:35Instead of someone describing a study with kids and they talk about the
- 14:39experimental stimuli instead of the Big Bird and Oscar the Grouch puppets.
- 14:44So being concrete, being visual, being vivid, is an important
- 14:48way for prose to be graceful.
- 14:50The other component of grace is, and I have a whole chapter in The Sense of
- 14:53Style on this phenomenon of coherence.
- 14:55That is, even if every sentence in a passage is a hundred percent
- 15:00comprehensible, the passage itself may be baffling if you don't know
- 15:05how one sentence leads into the next.
- 15:08And that's why we use connector words like however, nonetheless, on the other
- 15:13hand, moreover, that is, for example, in general, they seem like silly
- 15:18little fillers, but they're really not.
- 15:21They're the links, the glue that make one sentence flow into the next.
- 15:25And a lot of the feeling of coherence, flow, indeed grace comes when
- 15:30you just know why the writer is saying what he's saying right now.
- 15:34How does it fit into everything that I've read so far?
- 15:37Matt Abrahams: This idea of coherence that helps people to really understand the
- 15:41flow of the message, super important, and I like that as a key component of grace.
- 15:46You've discussed the concept of metaphors in language.
- 15:48What are these and what do they mean for the way in which we communicate?
- 15:52Steven Pinker: There are more metaphors in language than we realize.
- 15:56Often we're completely unaware of them.
- 15:58We know this from a brilliant work by the linguist George Lakoff and
- 16:01the philosopher Mark Johnson in a book called Metaphors We Live By, I
- 16:04think it's forty-five years old now.
- 16:06They noticed that some things that we talk about, we keep harking back
- 16:10to the same metaphorical image.
- 16:12So a relationship is a journey.
- 16:14We've gone through a lot together.
- 16:16We're at a crossroads.
- 16:17We might have to go our separate ways.
- 16:19Look how far we've come, or argument is war.
- 16:22I tried to defend my position, but he demolished it.
- 16:26Knowing is seeing.
- 16:28I see what you mean.
- 16:29But that argument is cloudy or murky.
- 16:31I can't make it out.
- 16:32We don't even realize we do it, but we do it all the time.
- 16:35Matt Abrahams: I have a colleague, Michele Gelfand, she likes to talk
- 16:37about mind your metaphors because in negotiation and influence and
- 16:41conflict, those metaphors impact how we approach it and the words we use.
- 16:46So if I see a negotiation as a battle versus a problem to be solved,
- 16:49I approach it very differently.
- 16:52Well, Steven, before we end, I'd like to ask you three questions.
- 16:54One I create just for you and the rest I've asked everybody
- 16:57who's ever been on the show.
- 16:58Are you up for that?
- 16:58Steven Pinker: Sure thing.
- 16:59Matt Abrahams: You have written about cursing, and it's fun to talk about, and
- 17:03I'm curious, how does cursing, swearing, how can we use it as an effective tool?
- 17:07What value does it provide?
- 17:09Steven Pinker: The thing that swearing does is it elicits
- 17:12involuntary emotional reaction.
- 17:15Your primitive part of your brain, maybe your amygdala just gets pinged,
- 17:18usually with some, not just an offensive thought, excretion, feces,
- 17:23urine, cuckoldry, copulation, death, misfortune, those are the subject
- 17:29matter of swearing across languages.
- 17:31But also there's common knowledge in the sense that when someone uses a profane
- 17:36word and they know that you're trying to get an emotional reaction out of them.
- 17:40That's why we avoid swear words when we have no interest in
- 17:44getting an emotional reaction.
- 17:46When you go into the doctor's office, the nurse might say, well,
- 17:48we'd like to take a stool sample.
- 17:49She wouldn't say, we'd like to take a shit sample.
- 17:51But shit does, it pings a little part of our brain.
- 17:55Now, there is a, a rule for taboo language if used rarely and
- 17:59judiciously it can express something you can't express it any other way.
- 18:03If you're angry, like, will you pick up your dog shit?
- 18:06It's not a very nice way of putting it, but it's appropriate
- 18:09to be anger at the moment.
- 18:10Matt Abrahams: Understood.
- 18:11That was a damn good answer.
- 18:13Thank you.
- 18:14There's some research that I've heard when I talk and try to help people
- 18:17feel more comfortable and confident in their communication, manage their
- 18:20anxiety, that swearing actually releases some neurochemicals that can blunt the
- 18:25cortisol that comes about from anxiety.
- 18:27So it can actually make you feel a little more confident or at least
- 18:31a little less unconfident, just by blurting out, not in front of public
- 18:34obviously, but you might do it behind the curtain before you get out on stage.
- 18:38Let me ask you question number two.
- 18:40Who is a communicator that you admire and why?
- 18:43Steven Pinker: Oh, geez.
- 18:44On the public stage, Barack Obama was a, has a deserved reputation as
- 18:49a communicator, particularly for the nonverbal component of trying to bring
- 18:53the country together in moments of crisis.
- 18:56Now, he didn't succeed with everyone 'cause there were factions that
- 18:59still hated him, but just by virtue of conspicuously making the
- 19:03effort to bring people together, I think that had a positive effect.
- 19:06Among writers, I think George Will has a way with words.
- 19:10He's been around for quite some time.
- 19:12Matt Abrahams: Obama certainly is recognized as a, as an amazing
- 19:15communicator, and I appreciate you highlighting the ability
- 19:18to bring people together.
- 19:20Last question for you.
- 19:21What are the first three ingredients that go into a successful communication recipe?
- 19:27Steven Pinker: Well, certainly empathy, not in the sense of
- 19:30necessarily feeling someone's pain, but getting inside their head.
- 19:33Overcoming the curse of knowledge, knowing what they don't know.
- 19:36The simultaneous awareness of the message to be communicated and the relationship
- 19:44that you have with your hearer.
- 19:46That's what all this euphemism and indirectness and innuendo
- 19:49is, is all about calibrating it.
- 19:51Finding the optimal level of directness or indirectness that's appropriate to the
- 19:56context, the nature of your relationship, the culture you're in, and the costs
- 20:01and benefits of the message going over your hearer's head or being so blatant
- 20:06that they know what you're up to.
- 20:08Matt Abrahams: So empathy, making sure that you balance out, or
- 20:12think through, the message and the relationship you have, and trying to
- 20:15balance among all of those factors in terms of directness around context,
- 20:20relationship, cost, benefit, and culture.
- 20:22Steven Pinker: Yeah.
- 20:22Optimal directness.
- 20:23Yes.
- 20:24Matt Abrahams: Optimal directness.
- 20:25Thank you, Steven, for all of the valuable insights.
- 20:28Truly a masterclass in how to be more effective in our communication,
- 20:32and you've uncovered many insights into our indirect communication.
- 20:37Thank you, and I wish you well with your newest book, When Everyone
- 20:40Knows That Everyone Knows: Common Knowledge and the Mysteries of
- 20:43Money, Power, and Everyday Life.
- 20:45Steven Pinker: Thanks for having me on.
- 20:48Matt Abrahams: Thank you for joining us for another episode of
- 20:51Think Fast Talk Smart, the podcast.
- 20:53To learn more about language and cognition, please listen to
- 20:55episode 91 with Valerie Fridland and episode 224 with Adam Aleksic.
- 21:00This episode was produced by Katherine Reed, Ryan Campos, and me, Matt Abrahams.
- 21:04Our music is from Floyd Wonder.
- 21:06With special thanks to Podium Podcast Company.
- 21:09Please find us on YouTube and wherever you get your podcasts.
- 21:12Be sure to subscribe and rate us.
- 21:14Also, follow us on LinkedIn and Instagram.
- 21:16And check out fastersmarter.io for deep dive videos, English language
- 21:21learning content and our newsletter.
- 21:23Please consider our premium offering for extended Deep Thinks episodes,
- 21:26Ask Matt Anythings, and much more at fastersmarter.io/premium.