Latest / Bloomberg Law / SEC In-House Debate, Challenges to JetBlue's Spirit Takeover
Transcript
- 0:02Speaker 1: You're listening to the Bloomberg Law Podcast. Catch us weekdays
- 0:05Speaker 1: at ten pm Easter on Bloomberg dot Com, the iHeartRadio
- 0:09Speaker 1: app and the Bloomberg Business App, or listen on demand
- 0:12Speaker 1: wherever you get your podcasts.
- 0:16Speaker 2: Welcome to the Bloomberg Law Show. I'm Greg Store.
- 0:18Speaker 3: And I'm Kimberly Robinson. Jin Grasso was out this week ahead.
- 0:22Speaker 2: In this hour, a challenge should Jet Blues Spirit takeover,
- 0:25Speaker 2: could keep the merger from getting off the ground.
- 0:27Speaker 3: But first, a challenge to the SEC's long standing in
- 0:30Speaker 3: house tribunal system came before the Supreme Court last week.
- 0:34Speaker 4: That seems problematic to say the government can deprive you
- 0:39Speaker 4: of your property, your money, substantial sums in a tribunal
- 0:45Speaker 4: that is at least perceived as not being impartial.
- 0:50Speaker 3: That was just as Brett Cavanaugh during arguments November twenty ninth,
- 0:53Speaker 3: He and his conservative colleagues cast out on the SEC's
- 0:56Speaker 3: ability to extract civil penalties through in house action, instead
- 1:00Speaker 3: suggesting that those accused of securities fraud have a right
- 1:03Speaker 3: to have their cases heard in a federal court. With
- 1:05Speaker 3: a jerry.
- 1:06Speaker 2: To help us walk through this, we're joined by a
- 1:08Speaker 2: securities lawyer Susan Hurd of Austin and Bird. Let's start
- 1:12Speaker 2: where Justice Kavanaugh left off with the notion that SEC
- 1:15Speaker 2: administrative proceedings might not be impartial. So you're a defense lawyer.
- 1:19Speaker 2: From your standpoint, what is the problem with the SEC's
- 1:23Speaker 2: in house judicial system.
- 1:25Speaker 5: Well, the problem is, I guess, first of all, they
- 1:29Speaker 5: almost always win when there was an active use of
- 1:35Speaker 5: alj's for disputed securities fraud claims. I can't remember what
- 1:42Speaker 5: the statistic was because it's been several years ago, but
- 1:44Speaker 5: they almost always won, and they had a much lower
- 1:48Speaker 5: success rate bringing those same claims in federal court. You
- 1:54Speaker 5: also lose if you're a defendant, you know, defending yourself
- 1:59Speaker 5: and front of the administrative law judge, you lose the
- 2:03Speaker 5: jury trial. A lot of the rules of evidence don't
- 2:06Speaker 5: apply or sort of apply at the whim of the ALJ.
- 2:11Speaker 5: You don't have the same protections that you have to
- 2:15Speaker 5: pursue discovery. You know, your ability to take discovery on
- 2:21Speaker 5: what the SEC knows is truncated.
- 2:25Speaker 3: So there are a.
- 2:26Speaker 5: Lot of things where the DAX feels like it's stacked
- 2:31Speaker 5: against you. When you're actively fighting against fraud allegation in
- 2:38Speaker 5: front of the ALJ. And then you know, there's the
- 2:42Speaker 5: problem that you don't see a federal court judge and
- 2:46Speaker 5: you don't get the opportunity to have a Article three
- 2:50Speaker 5: judge review the SEC's decision. This used to be the
- 2:56Speaker 5: law without exhausting all your remedies through the SEC. So
- 3:03Speaker 5: you had the ALJ go through what was usually not
- 3:07Speaker 5: a quick process of reaching a determination. Then this then
- 3:12Speaker 5: the SEC looked at what the ALJ did, and you
- 3:16Speaker 5: had to wait for them to decide whether they were
- 3:19Speaker 5: going to approve what the ALJ you know, did. And
- 3:23Speaker 5: only when after you jumped through all of those who
- 3:27Speaker 5: and there was an adverse signing against you, did you
- 3:30Speaker 5: get access to a federal court, the Court of Appeals
- 3:35Speaker 5: to argue that the ALJ and the SEC got it
- 3:38Speaker 5: wrong and you really didn't violate the securities laws. There
- 3:41Speaker 5: are a lot of things about that that people didn't like.
- 3:44Speaker 3: So can we talk about the particular case that was
- 3:47Speaker 3: argued at the Supreme Court. The case started out as
- 3:49Speaker 3: an investigation into hedge fund fraud. How did it morph
- 3:53Speaker 3: into this major challenge to the SEC's enforcement power. Can
- 3:56Speaker 3: you tell us how all this started?
- 3:59Speaker 1: Yeah?
- 4:00Speaker 5: Yeah, So basically classic securities fraud claims were brought against
- 4:07Speaker 5: mister Jarticacy, and he tried to go to federal court. Well,
- 4:14Speaker 5: the SEF he chose to sue him UH in its
- 4:17Speaker 5: administrative proceedings. He tried to go to federal court to
- 4:21Speaker 5: stop the administrative proceedings because he felt like they were unconstitutional.
- 4:26Speaker 5: The issues that were argued yesterday before the Supreme Court,
- 4:30Speaker 5: and the Federal Court in that instance says that we
- 4:33Speaker 5: can't hear you right now. You've got to go through
- 4:36Speaker 5: the entire process with the sec in order to get
- 4:41Speaker 5: the right to come to us and complain later. So
- 4:44Speaker 5: this case has been kicking around for an incredibly long time.
- 4:48Speaker 5: Mister you know, Jargas had to fight against the claims
- 4:52Speaker 5: that he had made misrepresentations to investors about the funds
- 4:58Speaker 5: that he managed, and he had to lose both in
- 5:02Speaker 5: front of the alj and in front of the Commission
- 5:06Speaker 5: before he got to raise his issues with the Court
- 5:10Speaker 5: of Appeals, and the Court of Appeals agreed that the
- 5:14Speaker 5: entire process that he had been subjected to for years
- 5:18Speaker 5: was unconstitutional.
- 5:19Speaker 2: By the way, One thing that happened in the Supreme
- 5:21Speaker 2: Court argument that I know I appreciated is that mister
- 5:23Speaker 2: Jercracy's lawyer told us all how to correctly pronounce his
- 5:26Speaker 2: client's last name, so it is Jocracy. Yes, we're on
- 5:31Speaker 2: the same page.
- 5:31Speaker 6: There.
- 5:32Speaker 2: Give us a sense, Susan, if you would about what's
- 5:35Speaker 2: at stakes for the SEC. How many cases are we
- 5:37Speaker 2: talking about at the SEC that go through this in
- 5:40Speaker 2: house process every year?
- 5:42Speaker 5: So when we're talking about classic securities fraud claims that
- 5:46Speaker 5: are disputed where the individual or the entity is fighting
- 5:51Speaker 5: the SEC on the allegation that they violated the securities
- 5:56Speaker 5: laws and in particular the fraud provisions of the security's laws,
- 6:00Speaker 5: there are literally no cases like that right now in
- 6:05Speaker 5: front of the administrative law judges. There used to be.
- 6:09Speaker 5: There used to be when mister Jargacy was originally pursued
- 6:14Speaker 5: by the SEC. But because of all these constitutional challenges
- 6:20Speaker 5: to the SEC's use of the ALJ that have been
- 6:23Speaker 5: floating around for years, the SEC said, you know what,
- 6:27Speaker 5: we're not going to fool with the ALJ process if
- 6:31Speaker 5: we've got an active disputed fraud claim. So they already
- 6:36Speaker 5: bring all those claims in federal court. So if the
- 6:41Speaker 5: Supreme Court agrees with mister Jargacy, that makes no difference
- 6:46Speaker 5: whatsoever to those types of claims and the SEC's current
- 6:52Speaker 5: processes associated with those claims.
- 6:55Speaker 3: Right, So, before we get to what impact that could have,
- 6:58Speaker 3: wondering if we can spend some time talking about what
- 7:01Speaker 3: the Justice has spent most of their time talking about,
- 7:04Speaker 3: which was this constitutional right to a jury. What's the
- 7:07Speaker 3: argument that's being made here.
- 7:10Speaker 5: First of all, there's just kind of a fundamental fairness
- 7:12Speaker 5: argument that's being made that it doesn't make sense for
- 7:17Speaker 5: the government to decide when somebody has a constitutional right
- 7:21Speaker 5: or not. That was the point that Chief Justice Roberts
- 7:26Speaker 5: made where he said, and I'm not quoting him, but
- 7:29Speaker 5: essentially what he said is it just doesn't feel right
- 7:33Speaker 5: to say that a defendant has a constitutional right up
- 7:37Speaker 5: to the point when the government decides they don't want
- 7:40Speaker 5: them to have that constitutional right. That just does That
- 7:43Speaker 5: feels wrong, that feels unfair. And so that seemed to
- 7:48Speaker 5: be the tenor of a lot of the questions and
- 7:52Speaker 5: a lot of the discussion that was happening, And that
- 7:56Speaker 5: kind of rings true to me personally, because if you're
- 7:59Speaker 5: looking at at what constitutional rights a defendant has, particularly
- 8:06Speaker 5: the jury trial right, it shouldn't matter whether they're being
- 8:10Speaker 5: sued by the government or they're being sued by a
- 8:13Speaker 5: private litigant. That constitutional right is as important, maybe even
- 8:19Speaker 5: more important, when the government is coming after you than
- 8:24Speaker 5: if a private litigan does.
- 8:26Speaker 2: There was justice barrit in particular, was making a distinction
- 8:31Speaker 2: between different types of claims that the SEC might press
- 8:34Speaker 2: civil penalties versus disgorgement, which is basically trying to give
- 8:37Speaker 2: money back to victims. Do you see coming out of
- 8:41Speaker 2: this a world where in some types of SEC cases
- 8:45Speaker 2: a defendant will have the right to go to federal
- 8:47Speaker 2: court and in other types here or she won't.
- 8:50Speaker 5: I think that's where some of the members of the
- 8:54Speaker 5: Court are trying to steer things. I think it's possible,
- 8:58Speaker 5: although no one can predict accurately what the Supreme Court
- 9:02Speaker 5: is going to do, it's possible that the Supreme Court
- 9:05Speaker 5: could uh pull together enough votes to say the particular
- 9:10Speaker 5: type of fraud claim that mister Jargacy faith has to
- 9:15Speaker 5: be brought in federal court and he has to have
- 9:20Speaker 5: the option of a jury trial. And the reason for
- 9:24Speaker 5: that is the type of claim and the and the
- 9:28Speaker 5: remedies that the SEC sought against mister Jargacy. They do
- 9:33Speaker 5: have an analogous provision at common law. A lot of
- 9:37Speaker 5: federal agencies pursue violations of the law that were unheard
- 9:42Speaker 5: of and undreamed of at the time the Seventh Amendment
- 9:47Speaker 5: was passed, but not the claim against mister Jargacy. He
- 9:53Speaker 5: was accused of fraud. And while there was some quibbling
- 9:56Speaker 5: about how a fraud claim has been tweaked in the
- 10:00Speaker 5: hands of the SEC, it has a common law brethren.
- 10:07Speaker 5: And that's what could potentially be the hook that allows
- 10:13Speaker 5: the Supreme Court to narrow its ruling to having an
- 10:17Speaker 5: impact on the SEC in this particular context and leave
- 10:22Speaker 5: untouched the other federal agencies that everybody seemed to agree
- 10:27Speaker 5: shouldn't have major changes and how they operate.
- 10:32Speaker 2: Susan, let's hold there for a moment. Coming up on
- 10:34Speaker 2: the program, we're going to talk more about the SEC's
- 10:36Speaker 2: enforcement power and potentially the impact on other agencies with
- 10:39Speaker 2: Susan Hurt. I'm Greg Storr and I'm Kimberley Robinson.
- 10:43Speaker 3: This is Bloomberg.
- 10:51Speaker 1: You're listening to the Bloomberg Law Podcast. That's the program
- 10:55Speaker 1: weekdays at ten pm Eastern on Bloomberg Radio. Tune it up,
- 10:58Speaker 1: Bloomberg dot Com and the Bloomberg Business app. You can
- 11:01Speaker 1: also listen live on Amazon Alexa from our flagship New
- 11:05Speaker 1: York station. Just say Alexa play Bloomberg eleven thirty.
- 11:10Speaker 3: I'm Greg Storr and I'm Kimberly Robinson in for June Grosso.
- 11:13Speaker 2: We're talking about the Supreme Court November twenty ninth argument
- 11:16Speaker 2: on the SEC's use of in house judges. Justice Elena
- 11:20Speaker 2: Kagan was incredulous when lawyer Michael McCulloch argued that Congress
- 11:24Speaker 2: might not have the power to let a federal agency
- 11:26Speaker 2: enforce a statute through its own administrative tribunals. She pointed
- 11:30Speaker 2: to a nineteen seventy seven president known as Atlas Roofing,
- 11:33Speaker 2: which involved enforcement of the Occupational Safety and Health Act.
- 11:37Speaker 4: That's settled. Well, it's settled only to the extent.
- 11:40Speaker 7: No one's brought it up and forced this issue.
- 11:44Speaker 1: Since Atlas Roofing h carea is contact. Nobody has had
- 11:48Speaker 1: the you know, kutzpa to quote my people to bring
- 11:55Speaker 1: it up since Atlas rufing.
- 11:57Speaker 2: Kegan in case it isn't clear, is Jewish.
- 12:00Speaker 3: We've been speaking with Susan Hurd about the Supreme Court
- 12:03Speaker 3: case that could upset a key enforcement tool used by
- 12:06Speaker 3: the Securities and Exchange Commission in enforcing the federal securities laws. Susan,
- 12:11Speaker 3: will the court have to overturn that nineteen seventy seven
- 12:13Speaker 3: President if they're going to rule in favor of the
- 12:16Speaker 3: challengers here, I.
- 12:19Speaker 5: Don't think they need to. And that was sort of
- 12:22Speaker 5: mister Jargaci's lawyer's point that prompted the comment you just played.
- 12:29Speaker 5: If you read the Atlas Roothka, it turned on the
- 12:34Speaker 5: fact that a federal statue created a new duty, and
- 12:41Speaker 5: it was you know, OSHA rules, and the fact that
- 12:45Speaker 5: before anybody was injured on a job site, Congress had
- 12:51Speaker 5: created a vehicle by which I think the term they
- 12:56Speaker 5: used was you could prophylactically address dangerous situations before somebody
- 13:02Speaker 5: was injured. So that was a new duty that had
- 13:07Speaker 5: not existed at the common law. So I think you
- 13:10Speaker 5: can distinguish between the particular type of securities fraud claim
- 13:15Speaker 5: that mister Jargacy faced, which isn't a new duty. You know,
- 13:20Speaker 5: back in seventeen ninety one, you had a duty not
- 13:22Speaker 5: to defraud people, not to misrepresent, and so it isn't
- 13:28Speaker 5: a new duty. Given the particular nature of the claim
- 13:34Speaker 5: that was being pursued against mister Jogacy. I think Kagan's
- 13:39Speaker 5: comment about gen nobody's raised this with us, so it
- 13:43Speaker 5: must be settled law again is kind of missing the point,
- 13:50Speaker 5: because the sec hasn't pursued these claims administratively in quite
- 13:55Speaker 5: a while because they didn't want to face these constitutional challenges.
- 14:00Speaker 5: So the only way this gets to the Supreme Court
- 14:04Speaker 5: is based on conduct from a while ago. That takes
- 14:10Speaker 5: that long period of time that we talked about to
- 14:13Speaker 5: percolate through the Commission and through the Court of Appeals
- 14:19Speaker 5: before it's even ripe to come to, you know, before
- 14:25Speaker 5: the Supreme Court. So I think the delay between the
- 14:30Speaker 5: Atlas Roofing case and the present appeal can be explained
- 14:35Speaker 5: to a certain extent by the fact that, you know, uh,
- 14:40Speaker 5: the SEC just isn't bringing these claims anymore, and you know,
- 14:46Speaker 5: I don't think they have to overrule Atlas of Roofing.
- 14:51Speaker 5: In fact, that was mister Jargracy's lawyer's point at the
- 14:55Speaker 5: oral argument. I think they're a way, there's a way
- 14:57Speaker 5: to distinguish.
- 14:58Speaker 2: That case, susan the other issues that the Justice has
- 15:02Speaker 2: spent very little time on. I want to know whether
- 15:05Speaker 2: you were surprised by that. Let's start with it was
- 15:07Speaker 2: actually the third issue in this case, the notion that
- 15:10Speaker 2: the SEC judges have an unconstitutional level of job protection.
- 15:15Speaker 5: Yes, I wasn't surprised that that didn't get more attention
- 15:22Speaker 5: because it's a very dry kind of academic constitutional challenge,
- 15:32Speaker 5: and you know, the Court has already kind of looked
- 15:34Speaker 5: at appointment procedures for Aljs and Lucia and it's kind
- 15:44Speaker 5: of a technicality. I think the seventh seventh Amendment issue
- 15:52Speaker 5: is sexier. It's more readily accessible, it's more compelling, and
- 15:58Speaker 5: the Court doesn't have to reach all three of the
- 16:01Speaker 5: issues on which the Fifth Circuit based it's ruling. All
- 16:06Speaker 5: it needs to do is find one constitutional violation and
- 16:12Speaker 5: they can they can reserve ruling on the other issues.
- 16:15Speaker 5: They don't have to take on all three. So I
- 16:18Speaker 5: wasn't surprised at all by the focus on the one
- 16:21Speaker 5: issue that, like I said, is just flat out sexier.
- 16:26Speaker 3: I'm not sure that I've ever heard the Seventh Amendment
- 16:28Speaker 3: referred to as sexy. But there was also this issue
- 16:33Speaker 3: that the SEC has too much discretion to decide which
- 16:36Speaker 3: cases go to court, which ones are going to be
- 16:39Speaker 3: happening before the administration. They didn't spend a lot of
- 16:42Speaker 3: time on that one either. Is this sort of what
- 16:44Speaker 3: you're talking about, They can sort of pick and choose
- 16:46Speaker 3: and this you know, any reason why this wasn't an
- 16:50Speaker 3: interest for them.
- 16:53Speaker 5: They didn't spend time on that. The particular way it
- 16:59Speaker 5: was brief The way it was briefed was this again
- 17:02Speaker 5: an academic kind of doctrine called the non delegation doctrine.
- 17:07Speaker 5: This issue about whether it's appropriate for the SEC to
- 17:11Speaker 5: control somebody's access to constitutional rights got discussed a lot,
- 17:17Speaker 5: but just in a different way. So you know what
- 17:21Speaker 5: had prompted I think mister Jargesi to say, this isn't
- 17:26Speaker 5: right for the SEC to get to choose where they
- 17:30Speaker 5: consume me that piece of it did get captured, and
- 17:35Speaker 5: yesterday's argument they just put it under what they thought
- 17:39Speaker 5: was the more compelling bucket, if you will, of a
- 17:45Speaker 5: well established constitutional right to a jury trial. So I
- 17:49Speaker 5: think that flavor was still there yesterday. They just felt
- 17:54Speaker 5: like that concept of fundamental unfairness that the SEC calls
- 17:59Speaker 5: all the shots that just got packaged under a different
- 18:05Speaker 5: constitutional doctrine.
- 18:08Speaker 2: Susan, what's your best guess as to how this case
- 18:11Speaker 2: comes out. It certainly seemed like mister Jarksey was going
- 18:14Speaker 2: to win. Did it seem to you like it was
- 18:17Speaker 2: going to be that relatively narrow possibility that you discussed
- 18:22Speaker 2: earlier where it may affect the SEC, but not necessarily
- 18:26Speaker 2: other federal agencies.
- 18:28Speaker 5: That would be my guess. You'll recall there was some
- 18:31Speaker 5: frustration from certain members of the Court that what the
- 18:37Speaker 5: broad potential impact could be of some of these arguments
- 18:41Speaker 5: had not been fully briefed to their satisfaction. So I
- 18:45Speaker 5: think the Supreme Court is always going to try to
- 18:49Speaker 5: get away with the most narrow opinion they can, because
- 18:52Speaker 5: that's how you build consensus amongst the justices, that's how
- 18:57Speaker 5: you get the votes that you need. And also they
- 19:01Speaker 5: don't want to be causing unintended, potentially negative impacts to
- 19:10Speaker 5: players who really weren't in front of the court and
- 19:14Speaker 5: they didn't get the benefit of their viewpoints. So I
- 19:18Speaker 5: think they're always going to try to get the votes
- 19:21Speaker 5: and build a consensus on a narrow version of a ruling.
- 19:25Speaker 5: And I think the SEC. You know, they have this
- 19:29Speaker 5: unique situation that they brought a claim against mister Jargacy
- 19:34Speaker 5: that had a companion version at common law, and that
- 19:39Speaker 5: really sets the SEC's claim and the SEC's use of
- 19:43Speaker 5: an alj in contrast to what happens every day with
- 19:47Speaker 5: these other federal agencies. So I think it is possible
- 19:51Speaker 5: to thread the needle. And they're really smart people, and
- 19:55Speaker 5: if there's a will, there's a way, And I think
- 19:58Speaker 5: they could write an opinion that is confined to the
- 20:01Speaker 5: particular type of fraud claim that mister Jargacy was facing,
- 20:06Speaker 5: and they don't have to worry that they're opening the
- 20:09Speaker 5: floodgates to brand new securities federal court suits because they
- 20:14Speaker 5: already all happen in federal court anyway.
- 20:16Speaker 3: Susan, One thing I wanted to touch on before we
- 20:19Speaker 3: wrap up is that there's really seem to be a
- 20:21Speaker 3: lot of skepticism, particularly among the more conservative justices, about
- 20:25Speaker 3: the so called administrative state. We saw Chief Justice John
- 20:28Speaker 3: Roberts really noting that, you know, the impact on American's
- 20:32Speaker 3: daily lives from these agencies is quite different than it
- 20:35Speaker 3: was fifty years ago. So I'm wondering, how does that
- 20:39Speaker 3: factor into this case, and should it factor into this case?
- 20:43Speaker 5: Yes, So you know, Justice Thomas has written articles basically
- 20:49Speaker 5: saying that you know, this whole thing jumped the shark
- 20:54Speaker 5: many many years ago, and we should completely start over
- 20:57Speaker 5: when it comes to the administrative state. So there's definitely
- 21:01Speaker 5: sentiment on the Court that this whole administrative state has
- 21:07Speaker 5: morphed into something that no one intended. And there there
- 21:13Speaker 5: was certainly you know, I think it was Justice Gorschik
- 21:17Speaker 5: who said, it's not your father's SEC. So there is
- 21:23Speaker 5: a perception that we have to to take a look
- 21:27Speaker 5: at how the system is functioning currently. We can't have
- 21:32Speaker 5: blinders on. But they're they're going to want to stay
- 21:38Speaker 5: away from the appearance that they're making policy. They're going
- 21:44Speaker 5: to want to be deferential to Congress and the legislative branch,
- 21:49Speaker 5: and I think the way to do that is to
- 21:56Speaker 5: look at what was unique about the particular claims that
- 21:59Speaker 5: the sec be brought. You know, you can't, like I said,
- 22:03Speaker 5: you can't have blinders on and create a rule of
- 22:07Speaker 5: law that's going to be going to have negative consequences
- 22:13Speaker 5: and potentially rolled a constitutional value. But by the same token,
- 22:19Speaker 5: they can't they can't do what I think Justice Thomas
- 22:23Speaker 5: wants to do, which is just throw out the baby
- 22:26Speaker 5: with the bathwater and start over. Again that there won't
- 22:30Speaker 5: be the votes to do that. So they're mindful of
- 22:33Speaker 5: the current state of the administrative state, but they'll be
- 22:39Speaker 5: careful in their opinion to try to stay within the
- 22:44Speaker 5: role of what the judiciary is supposed to be doing
- 22:49Speaker 5: and leaving, you know, leaving matters that have been traditionally
- 22:55Speaker 5: a legislative function or an executive branch function to those
- 22:59Speaker 5: other branches. They'll be thoughtful about how they attack the issue. Well.
- 23:04Speaker 3: Our thanks to Alsin and Bird Susan Hurd. Coming up
- 23:07Speaker 3: on the Bloomberg Law Show, we'll talk about the government's
- 23:10Speaker 3: effort to block Jet Blue's three point eight billion dollar
- 23:12Speaker 3: takeover of Spirit Airlines. I'm Kimberly Robinson.
- 23:16Speaker 2: And I'm Greg Storre. This is Bloomberg.
- 23:25Speaker 1: You're listening to the Bloomberg Lawn Podcast. Catch us weekdays
- 23:29Speaker 1: at ten pm Easter on Bloomberg dot Com, the iHeartRadio app,
- 23:33Speaker 1: and the Bloomberg Business App, or listen on demand wherever
- 23:36Speaker 1: you get your podcasts.
- 23:39Speaker 3: I'm Greg Store and I'm Kimberly Robinson. In for June Grassow.
- 23:43Speaker 2: Trial is coming to a close in the Justice Department's
- 23:46Speaker 2: effort to block Jet Blue Airways from buying Spirit Airlines
- 23:50Speaker 2: for three point eight billion dollars. It's part of a
- 23:52Speaker 2: US crackdown on airline consolidation. Here's Jet Blue CEO Robin Hayes.
- 23:58Speaker 6: We agree with a lot of concerns that the partner
- 24:00Speaker 6: the Justice have expressed about airline competition. I've actually been
- 24:04Speaker 6: making comments on this for years and years and years.
- 24:07Speaker 6: We just believe the best thing that we can do
- 24:10Speaker 6: to make a more competitive industry is to enable a
- 24:12Speaker 6: bigger Jet Blue. When Jet Blue flies on the market,
- 24:15Speaker 6: fares come down and service improves.
- 24:19Speaker 2: He made those comments back in February, just before the
- 24:22Speaker 2: Justice Department filed suit. Join us to discuss the trial
- 24:26Speaker 2: is Bloomberg News anti trust reporter Leah Nylan. Can you
- 24:29Speaker 2: just talk about how this deal came about?
- 24:31Speaker 6: It?
- 24:31Speaker 2: It's been quite the saga, hasn't it.
- 24:34Speaker 7: Yes, So, Spirit Airways initially had a bid to be
- 24:39Speaker 7: bought by Frontier. Those are both you know, you probably
- 24:42Speaker 7: know them as very low cost airlines. They're the ones
- 24:44Speaker 7: who have unbundled pricing, meaning when you buy a ticket,
- 24:47Speaker 7: you're actually just buying a seat on the plane, sort
- 24:50Speaker 7: of like if you are buying a bus ticket, and
- 24:52Speaker 7: if you want to buy anything else, like if you
- 24:54Speaker 7: want to pick which seat you're setting in, if you
- 24:56Speaker 7: want to bring bags, even sometimes if you want water,
- 24:59Speaker 7: you have to pay for it separate. So those two
- 25:01Speaker 7: companies were considering a merger, and then Jet Blue got
- 25:05Speaker 7: a little bit jealous and made a counter offer. Spirit
- 25:08Speaker 7: Airways actually was not that thrilled with the counter offer
- 25:11Speaker 7: because they were worried about the anti trust concerns and
- 25:14Speaker 7: they had this big presentation that they gave to all
- 25:17Speaker 7: of their investors about how it would be like a
- 25:19Speaker 7: really big problem for anti trust. It was definitely going
- 25:22Speaker 7: to get challenged by the regulators. But then Jet Blue
- 25:26Speaker 7: offered them a lot of money to go through with
- 25:28Speaker 7: it anyway, So they ended up picking that deal over Frontier.
- 25:33Speaker 7: The Justice Department then did end up suing, and we've
- 25:36Speaker 7: been in trial since Halloween.
- 25:38Speaker 3: Sometimes you don't want to be right, right. So Jet
- 25:42Speaker 3: Blue and Spirit say the deal is necessary to compete
- 25:45Speaker 3: with the big four airlines American, Delta, United, and Southwest.
- 25:49Speaker 3: So why is the government trying to stop the deal.
- 25:51Speaker 7: Yeah, so the government doesn't necessarily want you to fly
- 25:55Speaker 7: Spirit Airlines. I mean, if you want to, they're cool
- 25:58Speaker 7: with that. But the thing that they found is that
- 26:01Speaker 7: when Spirit tends to start flying a route, it really
- 26:04Speaker 7: ends up reducing prices on all of the airlines. They
- 26:07Speaker 7: found that there's this thing called the Spirit effect, and
- 26:09Speaker 7: so when Spirit starts flying a route, it tends to
- 26:11Speaker 7: reduce the prices that are charged by the other airlines
- 26:14Speaker 7: as much as seventeen percent, and so it does have,
- 26:18Speaker 7: you know, a really big effect on everybody else. And
- 26:21Speaker 7: the government is worried that if Jet Blue ends up
- 26:24Speaker 7: taking Spirit out of the market, that this price lowering
- 26:28Speaker 7: effect is not going to happen for the other airlines.
- 26:32Speaker 7: Jet Blue, you know, says that it really needs to
- 26:34Speaker 7: bulk up to better compete with the big guys, but
- 26:38Speaker 7: it like freely admits that it's going to eliminate a
- 26:41Speaker 7: lot of seats on Spirit's planes. It also says it's
- 26:44Speaker 7: going to raise fairs by as much as thirty percent.
- 26:46Speaker 7: So it's not even like walking back from that idea.
- 26:49Speaker 7: It's just saying, you know, bigger is better in a
- 26:52Speaker 7: regulated industry like airlines.
- 26:54Speaker 2: So what kind of evidence did we see at this
- 26:57Speaker 2: very long trial what the government present?
- 26:59Speaker 7: I mean, they called Jet Blue CEO Robin Hayes, who
- 27:02Speaker 7: you know, freely admitted some of these plans that they
- 27:05Speaker 7: have to reduce the number of seats that they have
- 27:08Speaker 7: on flights and raise prices. There was another thing that
- 27:13Speaker 7: came out at the trial when Robin Hayes was there
- 27:15Speaker 7: that was pretty interesting. Jet Blue has had a lot
- 27:19Speaker 7: of anti trust problems lately. This is actually the second
- 27:22Speaker 7: anti trust trial they've had in the past year. Last year,
- 27:27Speaker 7: the Justice Department seed them over an alliance they had
- 27:30Speaker 7: with American Airlines, the largest airline to partner up in
- 27:35Speaker 7: the Northeast, so Boston, New York area. There was a
- 27:38Speaker 7: trial over that. A federal judge in Boston found that
- 27:41Speaker 7: it violated the antitrust laws and they had to unwind it.
- 27:44Speaker 7: But Jet Blue had this plan to sort of bulk
- 27:46Speaker 7: itself up. First it was going to pair up with American,
- 27:49Speaker 7: Then it was going to buy Spirit, then it was
- 27:51Speaker 7: going to buy Alaska.
- 27:54Speaker 2: Hayes the state of the airline.
- 27:58Speaker 7: This is not Donald Trump by in Greenland, this was
- 28:00Speaker 7: the airline. So they had these like plans to really
- 28:04Speaker 7: bulk up because they sort of decided that's the only
- 28:06Speaker 7: way that they're going to be able to compete. So
- 28:08Speaker 7: it was like what we call a roll up in motion.
- 28:12Speaker 7: So the Justice Department has focused a lot on that.
- 28:15Speaker 7: One of the ways that Spirit and Jet Blue have
- 28:17Speaker 7: tried to sort of remedy what the Justice Department says
- 28:21Speaker 7: is anti competitive is by saying, Okay, yeah, we do
- 28:24Speaker 7: have a lot of flights that overlap, but we'll sell
- 28:26Speaker 7: off some of the gates and such at some of
- 28:29Speaker 7: the slat constrained airports so that another airline can come
- 28:32Speaker 7: in and fly some of these routes. So they've come
- 28:35Speaker 7: up with a plan to sell some of those to Frontier,
- 28:38Speaker 7: an Allegiant some of the other low cost airlines. But
- 28:42Speaker 7: the problem with that is Frontier and Allegiant don't have
- 28:46Speaker 7: enough planes to actually fly all of these. And you
- 28:49Speaker 7: may have heard that there's a little bit of a
- 28:51Speaker 7: pilot shortage right now. There's also a little bit of
- 28:54Speaker 7: a plane shortage because so many of the airlines, you know,
- 28:58Speaker 7: sort of stop buying new planes during the pandemic and
- 29:00Speaker 7: now want to get them, and there's a little bit
- 29:03Speaker 7: of a backlog, sort of a supply chain crunch on everything. Still,
- 29:06Speaker 7: so it's not clear that Frontier or Allegiant would have
- 29:10Speaker 7: the pilots or the planes to actually pick up some
- 29:13Speaker 7: of these roots.
- 29:14Speaker 3: I wonder how the deal is being received by other airlines.
- 29:17Speaker 3: Have we gotten any hint of how they view, you know,
- 29:21Speaker 3: sort of combining forces of Jet Blue and Spirit.
- 29:24Speaker 7: There's been a little bit you know, Spirit and Jet
- 29:27Speaker 7: Blue have called a number of the other airlines to
- 29:29Speaker 7: come testify. There was someone from United in addition to
- 29:33Speaker 7: someone from Frontier. You know, a lot of the airlines
- 29:37Speaker 7: have taken some cues from the way that Spirit flies.
- 29:40Speaker 7: You may have noticed that a lot of the big
- 29:42Speaker 7: airlines now have something called basic economy, in which, you know,
- 29:46Speaker 7: it's sort of the same idea, here's a seat, you
- 29:49Speaker 7: don't get anything else. That's sort of what they adopted
- 29:52Speaker 7: from the Spirit. But unlike Spirit, where everything on the
- 29:56Speaker 7: plane is this basic economy, a United or an American flight,
- 30:00Speaker 7: there's you know, maybe a handful of seats that are
- 30:03Speaker 7: basic economy. So while they've taken the idea, they're not
- 30:06Speaker 7: applying it to the whole plane because they still want
- 30:08Speaker 7: those lucrative business travelers upfront. The other thing that was
- 30:12Speaker 7: really interesting is it came out that there's this sort
- 30:14Speaker 7: of practice within the industry known as flashing. So all
- 30:17Speaker 7: of the airlines have to put the amount of money
- 30:21Speaker 7: that they're going to charge for a seat into this
- 30:24Speaker 7: computer system called APCO, and it turns out that they
- 30:27Speaker 7: sort of use this to signal each other a little
- 30:29Speaker 7: bit about how much they're going to price.
- 30:31Speaker 3: It sounds problematic.
- 30:33Speaker 7: It is a little bit problematic. You're not really supposed
- 30:37Speaker 7: to like tell all of your competitors what you're charging,
- 30:42Speaker 7: but they do this thing sometimes where if they notice
- 30:44Speaker 7: that somebody is charging a lot more or a lot less,
- 30:47Speaker 7: they'll send a sort of flash across the wire where
- 30:51Speaker 7: they're like they raise it really high for a minute
- 30:55Speaker 7: and then drop it back down to sort of send
- 30:57Speaker 7: a signal to everybody that someone is out of life.
- 31:01Speaker 7: And like some of the people who acknowledge that this
- 31:03Speaker 7: happens said, you know, we know, we're not really supposed
- 31:06Speaker 7: to do that, but it didn't seem to hurt anything.
- 31:10Speaker 2: Were the Justice Department lawyers taking a lot of notes
- 31:13Speaker 2: at that point, yeah, preparing for the next case.
- 31:15Speaker 7: The point of highlighting this is that, you know, the
- 31:19Speaker 7: airline industry is already really consolidated, and if there are
- 31:23Speaker 7: problems like this that already exist in the marketplace, if
- 31:26Speaker 7: we allow it to get more consolidated. This sort of
- 31:28Speaker 7: thing is only going to happen even more. That's sort
- 31:31Speaker 7: of the purpose of them raising that at the trial.
- 31:34Speaker 2: Okay, so it's not sounding so good for the companies
- 31:37Speaker 2: at the moment. What is their defense, What is their
- 31:39Speaker 2: case that they are making in court for why, despite
- 31:42Speaker 2: everything you've been saying, this this merger is actually pro competitive?
- 31:47Speaker 7: Yeah, well, they say, you know, we do need to
- 31:49Speaker 7: compete against the Big four. You know, those are the
- 31:52Speaker 7: biggest airlines in the country. They often charge a lot
- 31:56Speaker 7: and we'll charge less. You know, we are still like
- 31:59Speaker 7: the lower cost case than somebody like American or Delta.
- 32:02Speaker 7: So you know, they say it would be good for
- 32:04Speaker 7: consumers because you will have this lower cost option. But
- 32:08Speaker 7: really a lot of people think the fact that this
- 32:10Speaker 7: went to trial at all is because jet Blue offered
- 32:13Speaker 7: Spirit a lot of money to let them go through
- 32:17Speaker 7: with this. So if the Justice Department wins at trial,
- 32:21Speaker 7: jet Blue has to pay Spirit seventy million dollars and
- 32:25Speaker 7: then Spirit shareholders four hundred million dollars, and you know,
- 32:29Speaker 7: that's a pretty good deal. All Spirit has to do
- 32:31Speaker 7: is sit there and like not along. Well, jet Blue
- 32:35Speaker 7: makes this case, and then they might get seventy million
- 32:37Speaker 7: dollars at the end.
- 32:39Speaker 3: So the trial's been going on for a while. Now
- 32:40Speaker 3: where does it stand.
- 32:42Speaker 7: Yeah, so the closing arguments are Tuesday, and then anti
- 32:47Speaker 7: trust trials are heard by a judge, not a jury,
- 32:50Speaker 7: So usually it takes somewhere between thirty and ninety days
- 32:53Speaker 7: before we get a decision. So we'll probably have a
- 32:55Speaker 7: decision out of the judge sometime early next year.
- 32:58Speaker 2: So Leah, has the judge in this case given any
- 33:01Speaker 2: indication of how long it will take for a ruling
- 33:04Speaker 2: to come down.
- 33:05Speaker 7: He hasn't. Really. In general, these sorts of cases take
- 33:09Speaker 7: a couple months afterwards, you know, the government is seeking
- 33:12Speaker 7: a permanent injunction and in general, like the because mergerers
- 33:16Speaker 7: have timelines, they try and get these things done quickly.
- 33:20Speaker 7: So usually it's thirty to ninety days after closings is
- 33:23Speaker 7: when judges normally issue things. The judge hasn't yet indicated
- 33:28Speaker 7: when he might rule. We're sort of expecting he might
- 33:30Speaker 7: say something at closings, but he has asked a lot
- 33:33Speaker 7: of questions about the proposed remedy. As I mentioned, you know,
- 33:37Speaker 7: both Jet Blue and Spirit plan to divest some of
- 33:41Speaker 7: their roots to Frontier and Allegian, and he has been
- 33:44Speaker 7: really interested in whether that's actually enough to resolve the competition.
- 33:49Speaker 7: And a lot of the previous airline mergerers that the
- 33:52Speaker 7: Justice Department had allowed in previous years, they did on
- 33:56Speaker 7: the condition that the airlines divest routes. So the most
- 34:01Speaker 7: recent one that you might remember is American Airlines US Airways,
- 34:06Speaker 7: which was the Obama administration mid twenty tens. The Justice
- 34:10Speaker 7: Department originally sued over that one, and then they agreed
- 34:14Speaker 7: to eventually allow it through after those airlines agreed to
- 34:18Speaker 7: divest some gates at Reagan National Airport and up in
- 34:22Speaker 7: New York at some of those airlines. But what the
- 34:26Speaker 7: Justice Department found is when the airlines sold those gates off,
- 34:31Speaker 7: the new airlines didn't always fly the same routes. So
- 34:34Speaker 7: American might have been flying, say DCA to Minneapolis, but
- 34:39Speaker 7: the new company that took over Frontier might fly DC
- 34:43Speaker 7: to Denver. And so even if you divest these gates,
- 34:47Speaker 7: you don't necessarily replace the competition that's lost because there's
- 34:52Speaker 7: no guarantee that the person who takes over is going
- 34:54Speaker 7: to fly the same thing.
- 34:56Speaker 3: So, stepping back a little bit, under Joe Biden, the
- 34:59Speaker 3: government has really sought to crack down on airline consolidation
- 35:03Speaker 3: after really decades of approving deals with little resistance. Tell
- 35:07Speaker 3: me what does that look like in the current administration.
- 35:10Speaker 7: That has been very interesting. The Biden administration is very
- 35:13Speaker 7: focused on competition in a way that previous administrations were not.
- 35:17Speaker 7: And so the interesting thing about this one is not
- 35:19Speaker 7: only did the Justice Department challenge it, but the Department
- 35:22Speaker 7: of Transportation very vocally also says that it's opposed. So
- 35:26Speaker 7: on the same day that the Justice Department announced that
- 35:29Speaker 7: they were filing this lawsuit, the DOT said that they
- 35:32Speaker 7: are also concerned and while they're waiting to see what
- 35:36Speaker 7: the judge decides, even if he decides that it doesn't
- 35:38Speaker 7: violate the antitrust laws, they still might take some action
- 35:41Speaker 7: because in a case like this, the Department of Transportation
- 35:45Speaker 7: has to approve the transfer of some of the licenses
- 35:48Speaker 7: between the airlines, and so they have said that they
- 35:51Speaker 7: may end up having a long proceeding about whether to
- 35:56Speaker 7: actually transfer those licenses if the Justice appris doesn't block
- 36:00Speaker 7: this merger outright.
- 36:02Speaker 2: And is this approach from the Biden administration just about
- 36:04Speaker 2: airlines or are we seeing this in other industries as well,
- 36:06Speaker 2: concerned about consolidation.
- 36:08Speaker 7: The concern about consolidation is economy wide. I mean, one
- 36:11Speaker 7: of the things that Biden has said is that he's
- 36:13Speaker 7: very concerned about the number of industries that have become
- 36:17Speaker 7: very concentrated, particularly regulated ones like airlines, and that's why
- 36:22Speaker 7: he created an executive order in twenty twenty one that
- 36:26Speaker 7: ordered various federal government agencies to look into ways that
- 36:29Speaker 7: they could try and improve competition across the board, and
- 36:32Speaker 7: that has resulted in a lot of different initiatives. You know,
- 36:36Speaker 7: we've had this focus here on airlines, but there's been
- 36:42Speaker 7: focus also on pharmaceuticals, on meat packing because there are
- 36:46Speaker 7: only a few meat packers left out there actually, and
- 36:50Speaker 7: all sorts of different industries that you might never have
- 36:53Speaker 7: thought of. So yeah, I would say this definitely isn't
- 36:55Speaker 7: just airlines specific, but even the Service Transportation Board, where
- 37:00Speaker 7: railroads have been involved, has been getting in on this
- 37:02Speaker 7: competition side stuff.
- 37:04Speaker 2: That was Bloomberg News's Leah Nylan talking about the Justice
- 37:07Speaker 2: Sparatman challenge to Jeff Blue's attempt to take over of
- 37:10Speaker 2: Spirit Airlines. That does it for this edition of the
- 37:13Speaker 2: Bloomberg Law Show. I'm Greg Storr.
- 37:16Speaker 3: And I'm Kimberlee Robinson. This is Bloomberg