Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / A Battle With The U.K. Bare Trust—Let's Settle This Once And For All!
Transcript
- 0:06Welcome to a battle with the UK Bear Trust. Let's
- 0:09settle this once and for all. My name is Courtney
- 0:12Patton, and I'm the co -chair of BHBA's Trust
- 0:15and Estate section. Before we begin, I'd like
- 0:18to take a moment to thank our sponsors, including
- 0:21the Sanborn Team, Bond Services of California,
- 0:28Liberty Mutual Assurity, California Title Company,
- 0:33and Pickford Escrow Company. Now I'm delighted
- 0:36to introduce today's speakers, Laura Zwicker
- 0:38and Stephanie Lipson. Laura chairs Greenberg
- 0:42-Glusker's Private Client Services Group, advising
- 0:45individuals and families on international and
- 0:47domestic tax and estate planning issues and business
- 0:50succession planning. Laura's practice focuses
- 0:53primarily on counseling ultra high net worth
- 0:56individuals and their families in connection
- 0:59with domestic and international estate and tax
- 1:01planning issues and business succession planning.
- 1:04advising financial institutions with regard to
- 1:07fiduciary and custodial issues, forming, advising,
- 1:10and dissolving nonprofit organizations, and probate
- 1:14and post -death trust administration. Stephanie
- 1:17is a partner in the private client services group
- 1:20at Greenberg -Gloucester, where she leads the
- 1:23family office advisory practice. She provides
- 1:26comprehensive tax counsel to domestic and international
- 1:29families, family offices, real estate and tech
- 1:33entrepreneurs, high -profile entertainment figures,
- 1:36private investors, and closely held business
- 1:39owners in all aspects of personal wealth and
- 1:42succession planning. Stephanie advises on proactive
- 1:45wealth transfer, income and property tax planning
- 1:48strategies, pre -liquidity transaction planning,
- 1:51and pre - and post -death administration. She
- 1:54has focused expertise in generation skipping
- 1:57transfer tax, escort planning, California real
- 2:01property tax, privacy structures, and cross -border
- 2:04trust planning and residency issues. And with
- 2:07that, I will turn it over to Laura and Stephanie.
- 2:11Thank you so much, Courtney. Hi, everyone. Thank
- 2:14you so much for joining us today and spending
- 2:16a little bit of time with us on a battle with
- 2:19the UK Bear Trust. Let's settle this once and
- 2:21for all. I'm Stephanie Lipson here today with
- 2:24my partner, Laura Zwicker, and we are really
- 2:27looking forward to talking with you folks on
- 2:31this topic today. So we're going to tell you
- 2:35a lot about this topic, but there's a few things
- 2:38that we want to sort of say at the outset about
- 2:41this topic and the intersection between US law
- 2:44and UK law. Great. So to provide context, Stephanie
- 2:50and I are both California qualified lawyers,
- 2:53neither of us is qualified in the UK. So what
- 2:55we're giving you here is a high level overview
- 2:58of UK inheritance tax laws so that you have context
- 3:03and can understand how the treaty interplays
- 3:07with domestic law in the US and in the UK. There
- 3:14are many, many nuances to UK law that we are
- 3:16not covering. We do, I believe, have participating
- 3:20today Robert Brodrick from Panehex Beach in London.
- 3:24And to the extent we need to call in an expert,
- 3:26we will send him an email, and he'll give us
- 3:28the answer, no doubt. So just keeping in mind
- 3:33that there are many, many things that we are
- 3:35not going to cover. So please don't take this
- 3:37as a comprehensive or complete summary of UK
- 3:42gifted inheritance tax law. We will not be talking,
- 3:46we're focusing mainly on the changes that came
- 3:48into. effect at 6 of April of this year relating
- 3:53to the inheritance tax, so we're not covering
- 3:55any income tax changes. We are also not covering
- 3:59any of the business property relief changes or
- 4:01agricultural property relief changes in the UK,
- 4:04really focused on the inheritance tax and how
- 4:08it interacts with trusts that straddle the two
- 4:10jurisdictions. So with that, let's go ahead and
- 4:15get started. Just a very quick overview for you.
- 4:19Also very high level on the U .S. estate and
- 4:21gift tax system. Of course, we have an exclusion
- 4:24against U .S. estate and gift tax of this year,
- 4:2713 .99 million. That's for every U .S. citizen
- 4:30and U .S. resident. And when we talk about resident
- 4:33in this context, we're not talking about the
- 4:34income tax residency test. We're talking about
- 4:37somebody who is considered domiciled in the U
- 4:39.S. for the amounts over that 13 .99 million,
- 4:43which of course is a unified exclusion between
- 4:45life. lifetime gifting and transfers on death.
- 4:47It will be a 40 % tax, and that is assessed against
- 4:50the worldwide assets. For somebody who's non
- 4:53-U .S., non -U .S. citizen, non -U .S. resident,
- 4:56they will only be taxable on U .S. Citus assets,
- 4:59but there's also only a $60 ,000 exclusion before
- 5:03the 40 % estate tax will apply. U .S. gives an
- 5:06unlimited marital deduction for outright transfers
- 5:09or transfers into a qualified marital trust.
- 5:12For a U .S. citizen spouse, we can of course
- 5:14We also get the benefit of a marital deduction
- 5:17upon death to a non -citizen spouse using a qualified
- 5:20domestic trust structure. During lifetime, gifts
- 5:25to a non -citizen spouse will be limited this
- 5:27year, $190 ,000 annually with an inflation adjustment.
- 5:31And then, of course, we also have our unlimited
- 5:33charitable deduction for transfers to a qualified
- 5:36charity. That's, of course, during lifetime or
- 5:38upon death. So we'll start out like many things
- 5:42between the US and UK. We think we're on the
- 5:44same track, and then it turns out the tracks
- 5:46have diverged at some point. So there is a 40
- 5:49percent inheritance tax in the UK, but there
- 5:53credit, which they call the nil rate band, is
- 5:55only 325 ,000 pounds. And even though the pound
- 5:58is much stronger than the dollar, stronger every
- 6:01day, it still doesn't get us anywhere near close
- 6:04to the $14 million credit that we have in the
- 6:07US. That applies now after the 6th of April to
- 6:11UK long -term residents who are persons who are
- 6:15income tax resident under UK domestic law for
- 6:1910 out of the last 20 years. then would apply
- 6:23to people who cease to be long -term resident
- 6:26in the UK with a tail that varies or decreases
- 6:32over the increases over the length of time you've
- 6:37been long -term resident. So here's where we
- 6:41vary even more. When a settlement is made on
- 6:45a trust, when you contribute assets to a trust
- 6:47that is is viewed as a real trust for UK inheritance
- 6:50tax purposes. There's an immediate 20 % charge
- 6:54when the assets are contributed to the trust,
- 6:57and a 6 % charge every 10 years. And then on
- 7:00top of that, if it's kind of like a revocable
- 7:03trust, you thought it was a revocable trust for
- 7:05US purposes, and you got caught in this trap,
- 7:08there would be an additional 40 % charge if the
- 7:11settler has an interest at death. So you can
- 7:15tell this is a very different method of taxing
- 7:18trusts than we see in the US. Once a trust has
- 7:22been caught in this net, it will be subject to
- 7:26this UK inheritance tax, the 6 % charge every
- 7:29year, I'm sorry, every 10 years for the trust's
- 7:32entire duration. That isn't something that just
- 7:34exists while the settler has an interest. Like
- 7:38the US, there is inheritance tax relief for transfers
- 7:41to spouses. We're gonna cover the nuances of
- 7:44that a little bit later. And relief. for gifts
- 7:49or bequests to UK registered charities. And again,
- 7:54we'll focus on that a little bit more later.
- 7:57So the question is, what's different now as a
- 8:01result of the changes, the UK tax law changes?
- 8:05Under the prior UK tax regime, which was really
- 8:08focused on domicile, there were these concepts
- 8:11called domicile of origin and domicile of choice,
- 8:13and it wasn't this long -term residency test.
- 8:16And so now, and often we were concerned when
- 8:20working with a client in the US, if they had
- 8:23ties and connections to the UK, whether they
- 8:25were going to still be considered to have domicile
- 8:28in the UK, where we needed to be concerned that
- 8:30funding a trust here in the US, particularly
- 8:33just a revocable trust, used primarily for probate
- 8:36avoidance purposes, was somehow going to trigger
- 8:39a UK inheritance charge if the trust was deemed
- 8:42a settlement. So now where we have somebody who
- 8:45was otherwise a UK domicile and has moved to
- 8:49the US, perhaps it's a little bit clearer under
- 8:51these new laws whether or not you still need
- 8:53to be concerned about a UK inheritance tax charge
- 8:56as to whether or not the US revocable trust is
- 8:59going to be a settlement or the alternative of
- 9:02being a better trust. were focused on the other
- 9:06of these two, which is the circumstance where
- 9:08you have someone who's a U .S. person, for example,
- 9:12a U .S. citizen, and they are domiciled or they
- 9:17have been U .S. domiciled, but they spend a lot
- 9:19of time in the U .K. Under the prior rules, perhaps
- 9:23you weren't concerned about whether or not they
- 9:25were going to be subject to U .K. inheritance
- 9:27tax other than with respect to U .K. But under
- 9:32these new rules, the question is, are they going
- 9:34to be considered long -term resident and have
- 9:36they been long -term resident there for a long
- 9:38enough period where there's actually now a question
- 9:40of dual taxation in the other way. Just to be
- 9:45clear, today's presentation is really primarily
- 9:47focused on sort of the basic US revocable trust
- 9:51structure and how these rules interplay with
- 9:54that. Not so much focused on transfers to irrevocable
- 9:58gifting structures here in the US. All right.
- 10:04So I was talking to an English lawyer last week,
- 10:08and we're talking about a bunch of different
- 10:09structures and saying, well, we're not sure what
- 10:12that means under our law. And she said, well,
- 10:15but I know exactly what a trust is. And I said,
- 10:17oh, really? Because I'm not sure I know what
- 10:19a trust is in England, because what I think a
- 10:22trust is is something different than what you
- 10:24seem to think a trust is. So a bare trust. is
- 10:31what we used to hope for and dream for when we
- 10:34had clients who had a domicile of origin in the
- 10:38UK and we weren't sure whether they had broken
- 10:41that domicile of origin, which would have tied
- 10:43them back to the UK inheritance tax. And what
- 10:46I've found working with many different wonderful
- 10:51tax lawyers and private client lawyers in the
- 10:53UK is they all have a slightly different definition
- 10:58of what a bare trust is and what their comfort
- 11:00level is in terms of the terms of the settlement
- 11:04or the trust deed or the trust document and what
- 11:09powers can be retained and can't be retained.
- 11:12And what you see here is sort of a compilation
- 11:14of what we have, what advice we've gotten from
- 11:17different English lawyers and even something
- 11:20as simple as a privacy trust. We've found that
- 11:24some that some English lawyers can't get comfortable
- 11:26with, even though for us, it's really just a
- 11:29nominee arrangement. So you see on the left -hand
- 11:34side the sort of technical definition of what
- 11:39a bare trust is. And the practical advice that
- 11:45we've gotten is we have to have the settler plus
- 11:49someone who can act on behalf of the settlor,
- 11:52even in the case of incapacity, who has the full
- 11:56powers with respect to the trust, the power to
- 11:58amend, revoke, withdraw. And we need to be sure
- 12:03that the trustee's duties are not owed to anyone
- 12:07other than the settlor during the time that we
- 12:09want a trust to be a bare trust. So this is something
- 12:16that we were constantly working with and striving
- 12:20toward when we were dealing with UK -connected
- 12:22people in the US. And maybe we don't need to
- 12:25worry about it anymore now that we have the more
- 12:27certain long -term residence test. And we'll
- 12:30know either we care because they are still in
- 12:34the tail period or we don't care anymore because
- 12:37they're outside the tail period and we don't
- 12:40have any exposure to UK inheritance tax. So one
- 12:44thing to note here, again, slightly off topic
- 12:48from where we're going in this presentation,
- 12:49but to the extent that you do have US -UK connected
- 12:54clients that you've been working with and they
- 12:56had unfunded revocable trusts because there was
- 12:59a concern about whether or not it would be a
- 13:02transfer and deemed a settlement in the UK. As
- 13:05a result of the changes in the UK law, it's probably
- 13:08a good idea to go back and work with UK council
- 13:10to understand whether they would be long -term
- 13:13resident at this point in time, whether any of
- 13:15those tails would apply to them in terms of when
- 13:18a UK inheritance tax charge could still apply
- 13:21if they were to transfer assets to a revocable
- 13:23US revocable trust and decide whether or not
- 13:25there's additional planning for that group of
- 13:28clients that these changes implicate, where there's
- 13:32perhaps something that can be done on a go -forward
- 13:34basis that couldn't have been before. But we'll
- 13:38sort of focus on the other. So, Laura, what happens
- 13:40if it becomes becomes a settlement? So what happens
- 13:45if it becomes a settlement is we fall into that
- 13:48inheritance tax charge that we just discussed.
- 13:50If we have a transfer to a trust that we're thinking
- 13:53is just a simple everyday plain vanilla revocable
- 13:56trust and. the UK tax authorities disagree and
- 14:01say, no, no, no, you settled assets on a real
- 14:05trust, not a bear trust. There would be the 20
- 14:08% inheritance tax charge at the time of settlement
- 14:11and a 6 % charge on the fair market value of
- 14:14the assets every 10 years. And then, since it's...
- 14:20a standard plain vanilla revocable trust, our
- 14:23settlor is going to have an interest in the trust
- 14:26at death. So the assets will be exposed again
- 14:29to that 40 % inheritance tax at the time of death.
- 14:34And the trust, as it continues on, because it
- 14:37was exposed once to the UK inheritance tax, is
- 14:40going to be subject to that 6 % charge every
- 14:4310 years for the duration of the trust's existence.
- 14:48And this would be the case for a long -term residence
- 14:52worldwide assets, even if the contribution were
- 14:55made before they were long -term resident, unless
- 14:59we get some magic treatment under the treaty.
- 15:04There was a category of trust called excluded
- 15:06property trust that people often funded before
- 15:10they became UK tax resident or deemed domiciled
- 15:15in the UK, those trusts went away under the new
- 15:18law. So if you know about those, you can just
- 15:20forget about them and know that they're subject
- 15:22to tax. So let's talk a little bit about tax
- 15:28and what happens if you sort of fall into this
- 15:31situation where the US is going to assess its
- 15:37tax and the UK is going to assess its inheritance
- 15:40tax. So there are really two potential routes
- 15:44that we look at. One of them is going to be whether
- 15:48or not their statutory credit would be sufficient
- 15:50under the circumstances. And that's the statutory
- 15:53credit provided under US law, under the Internal
- 15:57Revenue Code. And then, of course, the alternative
- 16:00is whether or not a treaty position and treaty
- 16:02relief is going to be more favorable. It is an
- 16:06either or. You do not get the statutory credit
- 16:09and treaty relief. But sometimes the statutory
- 16:14credit can... be sufficient under circumstances.
- 16:18Most times that's going to be because the basis
- 16:20of taxation is simply going to be the situs that
- 16:23there's property situs in another jurisdiction
- 16:26that is being taxed by that jurisdiction. So
- 16:28if both countries would seek to impose tax on
- 16:32the worldwide assets of the decedent, then often
- 16:34the statutory credit is unlikely to get you far
- 16:39enough for where you want to go. Very briefly,
- 16:42certainly not the focus of today's conversation,
- 16:44but important for context, is that there is a
- 16:47statutory credit under US law. It is against
- 16:49foreign death tax. It does not apply to the gift
- 16:52tax, just to be clear. It is applicable to a
- 16:55US citizen or resident. Again, remember, we're
- 16:57talking about, when we use the term resident
- 16:59in this context, a domiciliary, where both US
- 17:03and the foreign country would impose a tax. It
- 17:07is a foreign death tax that is actually paid
- 17:11It has to be with respect to property that is
- 17:13situated in that foreign country and property
- 17:15that's includeable in the decedent's gross estate.
- 17:18For example, in a very basic example, if somebody
- 17:22owns property in the UK, but as a US citizen,
- 17:27the US is going to tax the decedent's worldwide
- 17:30assets, but the UK would also seek to tax the
- 17:33UK Citus property. The statutory credit would
- 17:36potentially be available in that circumstance.
- 17:39It's also available for substantially equivalent
- 17:41taxes, so it doesn't have to be identical. Obviously,
- 17:44there's differences between inheritance taxes
- 17:46and the US estate and gift tax. The key factor
- 17:50is really going to be whether or not it's being
- 17:52the taxes imposed on the value of the property
- 17:55that is being transferred from the decedent to
- 17:57the beneficiary. But again, where the statutory
- 18:01credit is going to be helpful is going to be
- 18:04in specific circumstances, such as the example
- 18:07I gave. All right. So we're inching toward the
- 18:14treaty. So you see below, and we've really covered
- 18:18already, how each of the US and the UK determine
- 18:24under domestic law whether they have a right
- 18:27to tax. So in the US, it's whether you're a citizen
- 18:30or a domiciliary. And this is, as Stephanie has
- 18:34already said, domiciliary is a subjective test
- 18:42looking at all the facts and circumstances, whereas
- 18:44citizenship, that's easy. We should be able to
- 18:47know that. For the UK, we no longer have the
- 18:51subjective domicile test, but we have a fairly
- 18:55clear test based on whether you have been a long
- 19:00-term resident under UK domestic income tax rules.
- 19:04Now, that test itself may have some subjectivity,
- 19:07but whether you are a long -term resident or
- 19:09not will have been determined fairly objectively.
- 19:16While this is a purely domestic test, it is actually
- 19:20the gateway to the treaty. And we'll see in a
- 19:24minute that we use this domestic test to determine
- 19:29as a first point whether there is crediting available
- 19:36under the treaty. And as Stephanie was saying,
- 19:40as is true for the statutory crediting test,
- 19:45under the treaty, you need to have matching taxes,
- 19:50and you need to not have a disconnect in timing
- 19:55in order for you to get relief under the treaty.
- 19:59So, for example, the 20 % entry charge into a
- 20:06revocable trust that we would view as a revocable
- 20:09trust in the US, we probably don't have a matching
- 20:13tax in the US because there would be no gift
- 20:16tax going into a purely revocable trust. Whereas
- 20:19if the UK viewed this trust as a settlement rather
- 20:23than a bear trust, we would have that 20 % charge
- 20:25and there would be no... help coming from the
- 20:29treaty because we don't have two taxes being
- 20:32imposed at the same time. Similarly, if you had
- 20:37a completed gift for UK purposes, you would have
- 20:42a capital gains tax imposed rather than a gift
- 20:44tax. So again, the question is, are those substantially
- 20:48similar taxes that would be available for crediting
- 20:53under the treaty? Let's move into the treaty.
- 20:59Get ready. So before we dive deep into the US
- 21:04-UK state tax treaty, we're going to just provide
- 21:07a little bit of context because I think often
- 21:09there is a sense of sort of going in through
- 21:12the looking glass when you are immersed in the
- 21:16treaty and the language of the treaty itself.
- 21:18So first of all, the US has 15 existing estate
- 21:23tax, death tax treaties. Within the treaties,
- 21:27when we talk about countries or jurisdictions,
- 21:31the treaty uses the term contracting states,
- 21:33the two states who have come together to form
- 21:35the treaty. But they're not called treaties.
- 21:39You'll hear conventions, bilateral agreements,
- 21:42double tax agreements, those are used both in
- 21:46sort of conventional conversation about these
- 21:49treaties, as well as in the language of the treaty
- 21:51themselves. Rarely are they actually identified
- 21:55in the language as treaties. So there's two different
- 21:58types, two categories of treaties, really. The
- 22:02older category of treaties is what are referred
- 22:04to as Citus -based treaties. So just as a preview,
- 22:08the US -UK treaty is a domicile -based treaty.
- 22:11The Citus -based treaties were really focused
- 22:13on assigning jurisdiction to tax, really on an
- 22:17asset -by -asset basis by creating rules for
- 22:20where assets are going to be considered situs
- 22:22for tax purposes. It's not about the taxpayer's
- 22:25connection or affiliation, domicile, residence,
- 22:28nationality, with the jurisdiction. Domicile
- 22:33-based treaties really start from the perspective
- 22:36of focusing on personal affiliation, essentially
- 22:39what we've been talking about here, very similar
- 22:42to the domestic law issue of the US has its domestic
- 22:46law where it has jurisdiction to tax and the
- 22:48UK has jurisdiction based on its domestic law
- 22:51to tax. It starts there, but also has a scheme
- 22:54for determining domicile under the treaty itself,
- 22:57which is often referred to as fiscal domicile.
- 23:01where fiscal domicile would be assigned to both
- 23:05of them under the rules, then there was a series
- 23:07of tie -breaking rules to determine which jurisdiction
- 23:10gets priority jurisdiction to tax. But even separate
- 23:14from that, there is then a category that it looks
- 23:17a lot like the Citus -based treaties, where there
- 23:19are specific categories of assets most commonly,
- 23:23what they call a movable property, real property,
- 23:25or permanent establishment, which is often referring
- 23:28to a business with fixed base of operation. that
- 23:31are going to be taxed on a situs basis in terms
- 23:34of which country, which jurisdiction has priority
- 23:37jurisdiction to tax. Then there are a series
- 23:39of different credits that are applied. There
- 23:43are provisions for how deductions are going to
- 23:46be taken into account, whether those are expenses,
- 23:49whether those are the marital deductions, charitable
- 23:51deductions, as we were talking about. And then
- 23:53the other thing to just keep in mind is that
- 23:55generally speaking, these are going to be applied
- 23:58to national taxes. it's not going to apply to
- 24:00state and local taxes. So in California, we don't
- 24:03have a California state, a state tax, but certainly
- 24:06in other jurisdictions within the U .S. that
- 24:07we do, the treaty is really a U .S. U .K. arrangement
- 24:12and is not going to address those state taxes.
- 24:15And just before we leave this, there's some more
- 24:17terminology that you might want to know about.
- 24:20So you'll hear about the treaty and the protocols.
- 24:23So it sounds like the protocol is like how you
- 24:26engage with the treaty or something, something.
- 24:29Very official. Very official and very specific.
- 24:32Turns out it just means amendment. So if there's
- 24:34been an amendment to a treaty, it's the protocol.
- 24:37And then there is always a technical explanation
- 24:40that goes with the treaty. That's the official
- 24:42technical explanation. And each country will
- 24:45issue their own technical explanation in their
- 24:47own language. that is always the first place
- 24:51to start understanding the treaty is it gives
- 24:54you some explanation in plain language. The other
- 24:58thing to know about treaties is there is very,
- 25:00very, very little guidance. It's very frustrating
- 25:02because they use all these terms that could mean
- 25:04a bunch of things in a bunch of different contexts,
- 25:07and there is very little guidance. So we start
- 25:11with the technical explanation. Then we might
- 25:14go to the OECD model treaty, and it's explanation,
- 25:19and often the OECD model treaties in the gift
- 25:23and estate tax area don't have very much in terms
- 25:27of explanation. So we may look to the OECD model
- 25:30income tax treaty and its explanation, but then
- 25:34concepts don't really translate between income
- 25:36tax and gift and estate tax, and that's true
- 25:38in the treaty context as well. Sometimes there'll
- 25:41be some IRS rulings, very few in the treaty area.
- 25:45Sometimes there'll be some tax court cases, but
- 25:47again, very few. So we may look to cases from
- 25:52countries who are completely unconnected to this
- 25:55particular question that we have about this particular
- 25:58US -UK treaty provision just to try to get a
- 26:01little bit more guidance. So not only is the
- 26:04language of the treaty dense and using language
- 26:08that We might understand one way in normal English,
- 26:12and in fact it has another meaning, but there
- 26:15is very, very little guidance. So a lot of fun
- 26:18when you're dealing with the treaty. I think
- 26:20that that even holds true with the official title
- 26:23of the US -UK estate tax treaty, which we've
- 26:25provided here just for context. The convention
- 26:28between the government of the United States of
- 26:30America and the government of the United Kingdom
- 26:32of Great Britain and Northern Ireland for the
- 26:34avoidance of double taxation and prevention of
- 26:36fiscal evasion. It sounds very sordid. With respect
- 26:39to taxes on estates of deceased persons and on
- 26:42gifts, and you can see that it's been around
- 26:44since entered into force in 1979. And this is
- 26:52just so you get a sense of the structure of the
- 26:57treaty, the US -UK treaty. And you'll find if
- 27:01you're looking across other domicile -based treaties,
- 27:05that their structure is going to be very similar.
- 27:07So the language tends to be similar, and the
- 27:10structure tends to be similar. But from treaty
- 27:13to treaty, because these are actually negotiated
- 27:16between two countries, it isn't like the IRS
- 27:18putting out its own interpretation. This is actually
- 27:23negotiated language. There'll be differences
- 27:27and there'll be subtle differences and you'll
- 27:32wonder why does this treaty leave out this particular
- 27:38word in its definition of permanent establishment
- 27:41and this one has it in and what is the significance?
- 27:46Often there's not a lot of guidance. But anyway,
- 27:49the one other thing I wanted to say on this page
- 27:52is the US -UK treaty and a few other treaties,
- 27:55including the US -France treaty, say that they
- 27:57cover generation skipping transfer tax, but then
- 28:00it doesn't seem to fit into the way we think
- 28:03about generation skipping transfer tax. So to
- 28:06the extent that you have a tax issue, a double
- 28:12tax issue involving generation skipping transfer
- 28:15tax, don't feel too comfortable if you find that
- 28:19your treaty does include that because it may
- 28:22not provide you a clear answer. And off to time,
- 28:27it's going to be difficult in terms of finding
- 28:29a match with timing of when attacks might be
- 28:32imposed. We're spending a lot of time focused
- 28:37on really understanding sort of the structure
- 28:39of the treaty and where these come together.
- 28:43We pulled this from the technical explanation
- 28:45from the US UK estate tax treaty because ultimately
- 28:49I think it's important that we kind of understand.
- 28:51So much is focused on domicile. The old UK rules
- 28:55were focused on domicile. The US focuses on domicile
- 28:58when it's not a bright line citizenship test.
- 29:01The treaty is going to be focused on the term
- 29:04that used as fiscal domicile, but very similar
- 29:07in terms of the different conversations and tests
- 29:10that are being applied. And so the question is,
- 29:12why does that matter? And the technical explanation
- 29:15makes it clear that it's the country of domicile
- 29:19that is going to have primary jurisdiction. to
- 29:21tax based on worldwide assets other than with
- 29:24respect to those Citus -based assets. And it
- 29:29does not mean that the country, the non -Citus
- 29:32country doesn't have a right to tax. It's who
- 29:34has priority right to tax and which country is
- 29:37going to be required to provide crediting based
- 29:40on tax imposed if there is in fact going to be
- 29:43dual taxation. So with that context in mind,
- 29:47we are going to, in fact, go down into the treaty
- 29:50now. I'm going to interrupt Stephanie for one
- 29:52quick thing before we move forward. So we've
- 29:56been talking about the fact that there's been
- 29:58this change on April 6th as to how the UK imposes
- 30:03taxing jurisdiction or takes taxing jurisdiction.
- 30:06And instead of focusing on domicile, we're now
- 30:09focused on long -term residents. Clearly, the
- 30:12US -UK treaty has not been renegotiated between
- 30:15April 6th and today. But there has been informal
- 30:18guidance from the UK government that, for now,
- 30:22they will sort of use the term long -term resident
- 30:27in place of domicile when they're interpreting
- 30:31the application of the treaty to the UK inheritance
- 30:34tax. Under the treaty, Article 4 is where we're
- 30:39going to find the fiscal domicile provisions
- 30:42as well as then the tie breaking provisions if
- 30:45it turns out that you have fiscal domicile or
- 30:48domicile under the treaty in both jurisdictions,
- 30:50at least as a starting place. So this is a place
- 30:54where I think sometimes it's easy to get a little
- 30:56bit turned around. I know I have on occasion
- 30:58and had to sort of step back and then step back
- 31:00in. We applied our domicile tests before when
- 31:04we were talking about domestic law, but the starting
- 31:06place under the treaty is going to be applying
- 31:08domicile according to the domestic laws of each
- 31:11jurisdiction. So that sounds a little bit confusing
- 31:13in some ways because we already did that, which
- 31:16is why we're looking at the treaty. But there
- 31:18is particularly, especially with the US, a distinction
- 31:20because we're not applying the test for jurisdiction
- 31:24to tax, right? In the US, we talked about the
- 31:28US having jurisdiction to tax based on either
- 31:31citizenship or US residency domicile. Here, we
- 31:35really are only focused on the domicile test.
- 31:38So, whereas before, if you had a U .S. citizen
- 31:40that was subject to taxation by the U .S. on
- 31:42their worldwide assets because of citizenship,
- 31:44we no longer are looking at that bright line
- 31:46test for that particular individual. We are,
- 31:49in fact, applying the domicile -based test, even
- 31:52though they are a U .S. citizen. And so under
- 31:55the U .S., we have various rulings, court rulings,
- 31:59helping us to understand and apply the subjective
- 32:02facts and circumstances test. of domicile, but
- 32:05it is facts and circumstances. So whether somebody
- 32:07is living there for a brief period of time with
- 32:09no definite present intention of removing there
- 32:12from the true fixed permanent home and place
- 32:15of habitation, where they would return to after
- 32:18having been absent. Generally, a U .S. born individual
- 32:24who has domiciled here is going to remain domiciled
- 32:26here unless it can be really truly established
- 32:28that they have decided to live permanently somewhere
- 32:31else and indefinitely in a new country of residence.
- 32:34So that is where we start from as far as domestic
- 32:38law. But under the treaty, there are some additional
- 32:41provisions. And we understand that under the
- 32:43treaty, somebody will be considered to have U
- 32:45.S. domicile if they are in fact domiciled under
- 32:47U .S. domestic law under the test above. or if
- 32:51they were domiciled, they're a U .S. citizen
- 32:53and they were domiciled under the above test
- 32:56at any time in the three years prior to the date.
- 32:59So you sort of get a three -year window where
- 33:01you keep that U .S. domicile as far as the treaty
- 33:04is concerned. As Laura has said, under the U
- 33:08.K., There's a bit of right now the guidance
- 33:10that's out is letting us know that the long -term
- 33:14residency is being used as an approximation for
- 33:18somebody who has UK domicile. If under the treaty
- 33:23test with these additional considerations, you
- 33:26have somebody who is nonetheless still considered
- 33:28domiciled in the US and domiciled in the UK as
- 33:32far as the treaty is concerned, then you're going
- 33:34to have to utilize the tie -breaking rules of
- 33:36the treaty to determine which country is going
- 33:39to have priority jurisdiction if you're taking
- 33:41a treaty position in terms of who has the right
- 33:43to tax. Right. So in both cases, and we'll start
- 33:50with the US, if you are not a UK national, but
- 33:56you are a US citizen, you will be deemed to be
- 33:59domicile under the treaty. Or you'll be, yeah,
- 34:04your treaty domicile. since we have to break
- 34:07the tie, will be the US if you have not been
- 34:13income tax resident in the UK for seven or more
- 34:17of the preceding 10 years. And similarly, if
- 34:20you're not a US citizen but you are a UK national,
- 34:23you will be treaty domiciled in the UK if you
- 34:28have not been income tax resident in the US for
- 34:30more than seven of the last 10 years. So often
- 34:35for clients who haven't just moved somewhere,
- 34:40we're going to fall outside of this tiebreaker
- 34:44one test, and we're gonna have to look farther
- 34:46down the list. And so the next test, which is
- 34:50sort of, these are separate, but combined into
- 34:53tiebreaker two, we will look at the country where
- 34:57an individual has a permanent home available.
- 35:00Now that sounds super clear. We have a permanent
- 35:03home available. But when the treaty has been
- 35:08interpreted, it turns out that the home doesn't
- 35:12really need to be that permanent, and it doesn't
- 35:14need to be what we think of as a home. It has
- 35:18to be a place where you can go freely, so it
- 35:22can't... necessarily be like a hotel room, but
- 35:25it's a place where you can go freely that's sort
- 35:28of held open for you. And the most recent U .S.
- 35:32tax court case on this was a pod versus commissioner.
- 35:36It's a 1998 case looking at the U .S.-Canada
- 35:39income tax treaty. And they found that having
- 35:45a room in the family home in Montreal where there
- 35:50were some personal items as well as sort of a
- 35:54home office and some cars, that was a permanent
- 35:58home. But there was also a permanent home in
- 36:00the US where the taxpayer went to, which was
- 36:04his fiance's home, owned by his fiance, where
- 36:07he had a fax machine set up. So to me, if I read
- 36:11this and said permanent home, I wouldn't think
- 36:14of either one of those as being the permanent
- 36:16home. So it's it's more complicated than the
- 36:19language of the treaty would let on, not objective,
- 36:22actually quite subjective. And if using that
- 36:26sort of subjective test, you learn that the person
- 36:29has a permanent home available to them in both
- 36:32the US and the UK, which is going to be the case
- 36:34much of the time with our clients, then you're
- 36:39going to look at the country where the individual
- 36:42center of vital interest is located. That sounds
- 36:46something very technical and like we should have
- 36:48a treasury regulation that tells us what the
- 36:51center of vital interest is, but we don't. And
- 36:55this test is actually even more subjective than
- 36:59the permanent home test. And you're gonna look
- 37:01at where the family connections are, where social
- 37:05relations are, where their occupation is carried
- 37:08out, where their political and cultural activities
- 37:11take place, their place of business, their drivers.
- 37:14license, their health insurance. And so not only
- 37:20is it sort of like our domicile test, we look
- 37:22at this whole litany of different connections.
- 37:26It's not clear, and different countries have
- 37:28come out differently, whether your business connections
- 37:31should be the most important or whether your
- 37:34personal connections should be most important.
- 37:37So likely for any client who's spending any significant
- 37:40amount of time in both jurisdictions, it's not
- 37:43going clear where their center of vital interest
- 37:45is located. And if that's the case, then we go
- 37:49down to the next prong of the tiebreaker and
- 37:52look at where their habitual abode was located.
- 37:55So, again, that sounds very clear and objective,
- 37:59but it's not. And maybe a little bit clearer
- 38:03than center of vital interest, you're going to
- 38:05be looking at where the frequency and duration
- 38:09of their time spent is. So it's very much a durational
- 38:12test. You want to look at where they're spending
- 38:15the most time. And that may be very difficult,
- 38:22especially if they're spending time in the US,
- 38:25UK, and several other jurisdictions. Where is
- 38:28their habitual abode? The nice thing about the
- 38:33next prong is it's clear. If we can't figure
- 38:37out where they have a permanent home or they
- 38:39have a permanent home in both places, and we
- 38:41can't figure out where their central vital interest
- 38:43is, and we can't figure out where their habitual
- 38:47abode is or whether there is one habitual abode
- 38:51or two, we then come down to which country are
- 38:56they a national of? And in most cases, that will
- 38:58be the end of our journey. Unfortunately we have
- 39:04many clients with dual or more nationalities
- 39:08and then we are left with competent authority
- 39:13where you are essentially turning it over to
- 39:17a different governing body under the treaty from
- 39:20the two jurisdictions to determine really how
- 39:24to break this tie. And never mind, obviously,
- 39:28that you can't necessarily know how that's going
- 39:30to be resolved. Just as a practical matter, being
- 39:32able to make plans and plan both for reporting
- 39:39purposes, for tax purposes, timing purposes,
- 39:42there's a tremendous amount of uncertainty. And
- 39:44so we really do... When we have a situation with
- 39:48a client where these first two series of tie
- 39:51breaking tests are not clear, the question really
- 39:54becomes, are there steps that can be taken to
- 39:57make it clearer? If you have somebody who is
- 40:00spending a lot of time in multiple jurisdictions
- 40:02or has multiple nationalities, what ties and
- 40:07connections can be focused on so that you do
- 40:10not end up in a scenario where you are reliant
- 40:12on the competent authority determination in order
- 40:15to break the tie on which jurisdiction is going
- 40:19to have priority to tax. But it is very, very
- 40:22much going to be facts and circumstances. So
- 40:26not so much facts and circumstances. A little
- 40:28bit more bright line are the two categories.
- 40:32that assign priority jurisdiction to tax, not
- 40:35based on domicile, but actually based on situs
- 40:37of assets. So even though this is a domicile
- 40:39-based treaty, as we said, there are these two
- 40:42categories of assets, the first of which is referred
- 40:44to as immovable property. I just think of it
- 40:48categorically as real property, but that does
- 40:51apply to a broader category than just the land
- 40:55or building. It does not include ships, boats,
- 40:58aircraft. doesn't include debt secured by mortgage.
- 41:02But even in this category, there is sometimes
- 41:04going to be ambiguity, certainly where we have
- 41:07an entity interposed and the entity owns real
- 41:10property. That's going to raise questions about
- 41:13what the site is, what site is jurisdiction is.
- 41:17I'm going to turn it over to give enough time
- 41:20to Laura on permanent establishment, which is
- 41:23certainly a much more in -depth conversation.
- 41:26And we're going to go through this fairly quickly
- 41:29so that we can get to the end and talk about
- 41:32settlements. So permanent establishment is kind
- 41:36of a mystery wrapped in a riddle. So we know
- 41:40that a permanent establishment is a fixed place
- 41:43of business through which the business of an
- 41:45enterprise is wholly or partly carried on. Okay,
- 41:48again, that seems like it's clear enough. And
- 41:51then the treaty goes on to be super helpful and
- 41:53says it includes especially a branch in office,
- 41:56a factory, a workshop and a mine. an oil or gas
- 41:59well, a quarry, any other place of extraction
- 42:01of natural resources. And they're, again, super
- 42:04helpful to tell us what it is not. So we will
- 42:08not include the use of facilities solely for
- 42:10the purpose of storage, display, or delivery
- 42:12of goods or merchandise, the maintenance of stock
- 42:15solely for the purpose of storage and display,
- 42:18or for the purpose of processing by another enterprise,
- 42:21and on and on with these things that seem very
- 42:26specific to a certain set of activities and not
- 42:31applicable to what most of our clients are engaged
- 42:35in. And then when you start looking at the technical
- 42:39explanations and the cases and rulings interpreting
- 42:43what a permanent establishment is both in the
- 42:45gift and estate tax context and in the income
- 42:48tax context, it becomes even more unclear. You
- 42:51don't actually need an owned or rented premises
- 42:54in order to have a fixed place of business. A
- 42:57certain amount of space at your disposal is determined
- 43:02to be a place of business. But you do have to
- 43:06actually be carrying on business at that place.
- 43:11So examples have been given in case law where
- 43:15you have, for example, a a catering business
- 43:21that is providing catering services for a film
- 43:26crew, that will be a permanent establishment
- 43:30because they're going to the same place every
- 43:32day for a specific period of time to provide
- 43:34these services. I wouldn't have guessed from
- 43:37reading the treaty that a catering service for
- 43:41a film crew that's on site for three weeks would
- 43:43be a permanent establishment, but it is. So Laura,
- 43:46let me ask a question. We have certainly had
- 43:50this question come up when a client wants to
- 43:55be clear that any permanent establishment is
- 43:59here in the US, for example, and they say, well,
- 44:02how about I just... How about I just rent an
- 44:05office? I mean, we can have an office. We can
- 44:08keep the records there. I mean, I don't ever
- 44:10plan to go there. I don't need to use it. I mean,
- 44:12I just do my business wherever I need to take
- 44:14care of my business. And where I am is where
- 44:16I do my business. Would that give us a permanent
- 44:19establishment in the US? It feels like it wouldn't.
- 44:23It is a place of business, but you're not doing
- 44:25business there, right? None of the business is
- 44:28happening there. On the flip side, where we have
- 44:33clients who have companies of some sort and to
- 44:40try to make sure that their permanent establishment
- 44:42is maintained in the U .S., they've elected officers
- 44:47and directors who are physically located in the
- 44:50US, and they haven't retained any authority in
- 44:54the governing instruments to transact business
- 44:57on behalf of this enterprise. But in fact, the
- 45:04client is negotiating agreements, entering into
- 45:07binding contracts, signing binding contracts
- 45:11in the UK. I think that that exposes us to a
- 45:17permanent establishment in the UK, because they're
- 45:19probably doing this in their home or some other
- 45:22space where they regularly go. And even though
- 45:26we've said the permanent establishment of this
- 45:29business is in the US, and here are the people
- 45:31who are sitting in this office doing this work,
- 45:34so it isn't even an empty office, but actually
- 45:36the full authority is somewhere else. And there
- 45:40is some interpretation. of the permanent establishment
- 45:45provision that found that where you have a person
- 45:51who has authority to talk about business, but
- 45:56they don't have final authority. You need to
- 45:59sign off from the home office in LA to enter
- 46:02into the contract. In fact, someone in the home
- 46:04office in LA has to actually enter into the contract,
- 46:07has to sign it. If you have basically done everything
- 46:12that needs to be done other than sign off, the
- 46:15permanent establishment will be where all of
- 46:17that activity is occurring, not where the final
- 46:19sign off is. So where you're trying to stay out
- 46:22of a country in order to avoid a permanent establishment
- 46:24there, you not only need to have the sort of
- 46:28facade of being in the US, you actually have
- 46:32to be disciplined, and be sure that you aren't
- 46:36actually conducting the business, you aren't
- 46:37actually doing the negotiation in the country
- 46:40you're trying to stay out of. So we're going
- 46:44to move ahead and go a little bit quicker through
- 46:47some of the taxing provisions under the treaty
- 46:49and where deductions are and potential double
- 46:53taxation so that we can, as Laura said, get to
- 46:56the question of the bare trust versus the settlement,
- 46:59all of which this leads up to, we promise. Article
- 47:055 of the US -UK Treaty is where we're going to
- 47:09see the assignment of the priority jurisdictions
- 47:12to tax, basically. And there are reciprocal provisions
- 47:15for the US versus UK. Basically, the fiscal domicile
- 47:19that's determined is going to have priority jurisdiction
- 47:21to tax, except for those Citus -based assets
- 47:24under Article 6 and 7, the immovable property
- 47:27and the permanent establishment. If you are a
- 47:31fiscal domicile, that jurisdiction will have
- 47:34the ability to tax worldwide assets. The Citus
- 47:39location will have the right under priority jurisdiction
- 47:41to tax the Citus base, but that does not mean
- 47:44the other jurisdiction is not allowed to tax.
- 47:47There are just going to be required crediting
- 47:50under Article 9 of the treaty. But before we
- 47:54can even get to the crediting under the treaty,
- 47:56we need to understand how much tax is really
- 47:57going to be imposed. And just like under US domestic
- 48:00law, we need to first address potential deductions
- 48:03and also the opportunity for mismatches between
- 48:06the two jurisdictions. Article 8 is where we
- 48:16will find the deductions under the treaty, and
- 48:20that's going to include also expenses, but today
- 48:23we're just going to very briefly focus on the
- 48:25marital deduction and the charitable deduction
- 48:28in order to understand both where there is not
- 48:31necessarily alignment under the domestic laws,
- 48:34but also where the treaty may not actually provide
- 48:36relief. and either there is a potential for double
- 48:40tax or this settlement exception where applicable
- 48:43could be very valuable and helpful in avoiding
- 48:45this mismatch. Article 8 tells us in determining
- 48:48the amount on which taxes to be computed, it's
- 48:51going to permit deductions basically under the
- 48:53domestic law of each state that is going to be
- 48:55the starting place just as it was in terms of
- 48:58determining domicile. But then there is a treaty
- 49:01overlay. So as we know, under US domestic law,
- 49:05there is an unlimited deduction for transfers
- 49:07outright or in a qualified trust for a US citizen
- 49:10spouse that applies during lifetime or upon death.
- 49:13We only have a transfer to a qualified domestic
- 49:16trust upon death for a non -citizen spouse or
- 49:18the lifetime annual transfer of up to $190 ,000
- 49:23with an inflation adjustment, again, for a non
- 49:26-citizen spouse. And in the UK, somewhat similar
- 49:30to the US, but slightly different, where both
- 49:35spouses have the same domicile, then the spousal
- 49:41exemption for UK inheritance tax is unlimited.
- 49:44However, where you have a disconnect, where the
- 49:47deceased spouse is UK domiciled or long -term
- 49:51resident and the surviving spouse is not, then
- 49:54the spouse exemption is limited to an additional
- 49:56325 ,000 pounds, which may be reduced by lifetime
- 50:02gifts if death occurs within seven years. So
- 50:07the treaty then has its own overlay of how it
- 50:10is going to provide and allow deductions depending
- 50:13upon sort of which fact pattern it is. And we're
- 50:16not going to go through each of them in this
- 50:18today, but the couple important takeaways for
- 50:23today is. Just because it qualifies under domestic
- 50:26law, it doesn't mean there's going to be reciprocity
- 50:29under the treaty to the full amount. And so you
- 50:31can see, for example, under certain UK circumstances,
- 50:34there's only going to be potentially 50%. As
- 50:38Laura and I were thinking about this and talking
- 50:40about this, one of the things we also were recognizing
- 50:43is that the US -UK estate tax treaty was put
- 50:46into effect. It was signed in 78 and put into
- 50:49effect in 79. We didn't have an unlimited marital
- 50:53deduction at that point in time. Certainly US
- 50:56domestic law has also changed since the time
- 50:59that this was put into effect. One thing to keep
- 51:02in mind is If you have somebody who is exposed
- 51:08to both US tax and UK tax, saying that the estate
- 51:13or the trust is going entirely to the surviving
- 51:16spouse does not necessarily mean everything is
- 51:19fine, no problem, we don't need to worry about
- 51:21it. Because how those marital deductions get
- 51:23applied could be different depending upon, you
- 51:26know, again, whether you are looking at it on
- 51:28the US side or on the UK side, and then how the
- 51:31treaty applies. And if there isn't also if there
- 51:34isn't a full offset. So for example, if you are
- 51:37limited to the 50 % deduction, but got 100 %
- 51:41on the US side as an example, then there is going
- 51:44to be a section that is subject to tax that maybe
- 51:47you are not expecting, but also there's no offset
- 51:49because it's not subject to tax by both jurisdictions.
- 51:52It's only being taxed by one jurisdiction. So
- 51:55this is on the marital side, but we also wanna
- 51:58cover briefly today on the charitable deduction
- 52:01side. Right, and just as Stephanie was saying
- 52:04on the marital side, just because you're saying
- 52:07everything's going to charity, doesn't mean everything's
- 52:11great. You don't need to worry if you have US
- 52:14and UK connections. So in the UK, there's only
- 52:21charitable relief for gifts going to UK registered
- 52:24charities. And the UK taxing authorities do not
- 52:30have the same substantial equivalency process.
- 52:39In the U .S., when we're looking at giving to
- 52:42non -U .S. charities, we can say, okay, as long
- 52:45as that charity is substantially equivalent to
- 52:48what a U .S. qualified charity would be, we're
- 52:51going to be okay. So going from the U .S. side,
- 52:54we're much more likely to get a charitable deduction
- 52:58for gifts made to non -U .S. charities than you
- 53:01are in the U .K. So if we're giving everything
- 53:04to Cedar Sinai, it is unlikely that that gift
- 53:07would qualify for charitable relief from UK inheritance
- 53:13tax because Cedars -Sinai is clearly not a registered
- 53:17charity in the UK. So what can you do if you
- 53:21have a very charitably inclined client who we
- 53:25think is going to be UK long -term resident and
- 53:28therefore exposed to UK inheritance tax on their
- 53:31worldwide assets? You can look at giving to just
- 53:36UK registered charities, which may not be consistent
- 53:39with their wishes, you can look to dual qualified
- 53:44donor advised funds. And there are several out
- 53:48there who are US and UK qualified. And that is
- 53:53a simple, fairly easy, very low cost option,
- 53:58as long as the client is comfortable with that.
- 54:03If you have a very significant client with very
- 54:07charitable intentions, you could look at creating
- 54:09a custom structure that would qualify in both
- 54:12jurisdictions, or you can look at a friends of
- 54:16organization so that you're getting your full
- 54:18charitable deduction and you don't have that
- 54:20surprise of having tax that's not eliminated
- 54:24by the treaty because it's only being imposed
- 54:26by one jurisdiction. Right. And that's ultimately,
- 54:30we've covered a lot of the concept of crediting
- 54:33against double tax and the timing of the tax.
- 54:37But that's ultimately sort of what the takeaway
- 54:40is. You really do need to have a situation in
- 54:42order for the tax crediting to apply, where both
- 54:45countries are at the same time imposing their
- 54:48tax. And certainly, you're only going to get
- 54:51crediting to the extent that the rate of tax,
- 54:54up to the rate of tax. So if one country is imposing
- 54:57tax at 20 % and the other is imposing it at 40%,
- 55:00it's not eliminating entirely the double tax.
- 55:03You'll get credited. for the 20 % or vice versa,
- 55:07depending upon which direction you're going.
- 55:10But in these examples where you have a marital
- 55:13deduction mismatch or a charitable deduction
- 55:15mismatch and one country is not imposing a tax
- 55:17and the other country is, there isn't a double
- 55:20tax to credit. And that's the important component
- 55:23to take away. So let's take a look at under this
- 55:28sort of new scenario with the long -term residency
- 55:31in the UK, where we have a little bit more clarity.
- 55:35under certain circumstances, perhaps you have
- 55:38a US citizen or US domiciliary who at this point
- 55:42in time is not UK domiciled under the treaty,
- 55:47but under the new long -term residency tests,
- 55:50could very well become UK domiciled. If you're
- 55:55concerned about going through that tiebreaker
- 55:57test, the US -UK estate tax treaty actually has
- 56:01an exclusion within it for certain property that
- 56:05is settled into a trust. So it's transferred
- 56:08to a trust that is deemed a settlement from the
- 56:11UK's perspective. And the settler was domiciled
- 56:14in the US and is not a national of the UK at
- 56:18the time that it's settled. If you have that
- 56:21type of scenario, rather than focusing on our
- 56:25bare trust and trying to avoid having it become
- 56:27a settlement, it is possible that actually purposefully
- 56:30causing assets to be funded into a settlement
- 56:34trust in that circumstance, and I'll emphasize
- 56:36non -UK assets, so not Article 6 property, the
- 56:39immovable property, not Article 7 property, permanent
- 56:42establishment, UK permanent establishment property.
- 56:45Transferring those types of assets and settling
- 56:47them onto a trust while the person is US domiciliary
- 56:52and is not a national of the UK and is not UK
- 56:54domiciled would exclude it from taxation under
- 56:57the terms of the US -UK estate tax treaty. if
- 57:00you have that scenario and can sort of qualify
- 57:04this grouping of assets, and we'll talk about
- 57:07what that means, you can eliminate the concerns
- 57:11that you have about double taxation, as well
- 57:14as the concerns when you have mismatch on the
- 57:16deductions, for example, on the charitable deduction
- 57:18or on the marital deduction. But you have to
- 57:21also be very careful about the type of assets
- 57:23that you're talking about and the circumstances
- 57:25of when you're funding these assets in. So as
- 57:28one example, we need to think about what does
- 57:31it mean to make additions to the trust particularly
- 57:33if the person is the reason that this is being
- 57:37done is because there's a concern that the individual
- 57:39could become UK domiciled long -term resident
- 57:42and what happens if there are assets transferred
- 57:44after that and so you know as we look at this
- 57:48you would want to for example sort of cut off
- 57:53assets going into that trust at the point that
- 57:55it becomes a settlement so that you don't have
- 57:57a taint from additional assets. And then you
- 58:04need to think about what is an addition, right?
- 58:06So clearly, if I take an additional account and
- 58:11I add it to the trust, that's clearly an addition.
- 58:13But there are many more nuanced additions that
- 58:17could occur. So if you had a business entity
- 58:23that the client was active in, as well as having
- 58:30that business entity hold assets that increase
- 58:32in value. If the assets simply increase in value,
- 58:36that shouldn't be an addition to the trust. But
- 58:38if the value of the business entity increases
- 58:40as a result of additional services that the client's
- 58:44providing to the business entity, that likely
- 58:46would be an addition. And so we need to think
- 58:50about maybe segregating that asset or splitting
- 58:52the business and saying, okay, this is all historical
- 58:55stuff that's just going to roll in. And then
- 58:58any new services that you're going to provide
- 59:01are going to be provided through a new entity
- 59:02that we're not going to contribute to this. We
- 59:04know that these are exposed. We're not trying
- 59:06to protect those. We're just trying to protect
- 59:08what is clearly protectable. And the other interesting
- 59:14question is, do we have a taint if we have an
- 59:19asset that was a permanent establishment at one
- 59:21point in the past and we think we've cleaned
- 59:22it, do the proceeds of that continue to be a
- 59:27permanent establishment? So this is our culmination
- 59:34slide. We've come to the end, even though we're
- 59:36basically out of time, but we're going to talk
- 59:38about it for just enough time so you understand
- 59:40why we're so excited. So we've talked about bare
- 59:46trusts and UK practitioners having different
- 59:50definitions of different comfort levels with
- 59:55what's a bare trust. Now we want to know what's
- 59:57a settlement. And again, what you see on this
- 1:00:00slide is a compilation of advice from across
- 1:00:05a large group of UK practitioners we've worked
- 1:00:08with over the years. And it's clear that a settlement
- 1:00:13is a situation where the trustee owes fiduciary
- 1:00:17duties to the settlor and to successive trust
- 1:00:21beneficiaries. And the trustees must have sole
- 1:00:24discretion to decide to whom, when, and what
- 1:00:28distributions will be made. So clearly, we have
- 1:00:31to be in a jurisdiction in the US where we can
- 1:00:34override that duty to the... person with the
- 1:00:39power to revoke. So in California, under probate
- 1:00:42code 15800, we know that the trustee during the
- 1:00:46period of revocation only owes duties to the
- 1:00:48settler. So the question is, how can we, in a
- 1:00:52way that would be valid and enforceable under
- 1:00:54California law, eliminate those? And in some
- 1:00:58jurisdictions in the U .S., it may be easier
- 1:01:00or less easy to do that. And we want to be sure
- 1:01:04that the settler doesn't have sole authority
- 1:01:09as trustee, even in a fiduciary capacity. We
- 1:01:12want to ensure that there are a class of current
- 1:01:15beneficiaries in addition to the settlor to whom
- 1:01:18discretionary distributions can be made, and
- 1:01:21potentially limiting the broad powers of the
- 1:01:23settlor to amend and revoke. And none of these,
- 1:01:26again, there's no bright line test. We can't
- 1:01:29say, oh, we've checked these three boxes, and
- 1:01:31therefore, it's a settlement. And one of the
- 1:01:33things that Stephanie and I were talking about
- 1:01:36before the presentation is, our revocable trust,
- 1:01:43we started out at the beginning being told by
- 1:01:45our UK advisors, oh, these aren't bare trusts.
- 1:01:48There are all these things that are wrong with
- 1:01:50it. And we think, okay, good. as long as we leave
- 1:01:52it the way it is, then we must have a settlement.
- 1:01:54But then we turn around and talk to our UK advisors
- 1:01:57and say, I don't know, there are these things
- 1:01:59that are wrong with it. So it turns out that
- 1:02:02what we think of as our standard revocable trust
- 1:02:04won't really work to be a bare trust and won't
- 1:02:07really work to be a settlement. And when you're
- 1:02:11dealing with cross -border clients in all sorts
- 1:02:14of circumstances, one of the most important takeaways
- 1:02:18is Talk to the client's UK advisor. Do not agree
- 1:02:23to act for a client who doesn't have a UK advisor
- 1:02:26or one who won't let you communicate because
- 1:02:29all of this stuff is really complicated and when
- 1:02:32we see words that we think we know what they
- 1:02:34mean, not only do they not mean the same thing
- 1:02:37in the treaty, they aren't going to mean the
- 1:02:39same thing in the other jurisdiction. we need
- 1:02:42to all be working together to make sure that
- 1:02:45we can come up with a dictionary so that we understand
- 1:02:49what we mean when we say trust and we say settlement
- 1:02:52and we say discretion because all of those things
- 1:02:57are going to be interpreted slightly differently.
- 1:03:00So I think we're just about out of time for the
- 1:03:03day. We want to thank everybody for sticking
- 1:03:05with us and exploring the bear trust and settlement
- 1:03:09and this dive into the world of the US and UK
- 1:03:12estate tax treaty. We really appreciate your
- 1:03:15time this afternoon. Thank you so much. You may
- 1:03:18be eligible for CLE credit in your state. Visit
- 1:03:21bhba .org slash podcasts for more information.