Latest / That's WILD! A Little Rock Zoo Podcast / Raccoons, Dogs & Wolves: How Wild Animals Shape to Our World with Dr. Raffaela Lesch
Transcript
- 0:03Welcome to That's Wild Podcast, the podcast that
- 0:06explores the amazing natural world that surrounds
- 0:08us and astounds us. I'm your emcee, Dustin Bean,
- 0:12and our hosts, Susan Altrui and Joy Matlock,
- 0:15will share insights and mind -blowing facts that
- 0:19will leave you saying, that's wild. It's all
- 0:22about inspiring you, the listener, to value and
- 0:25conserve our natural world. That's Wild is brought
- 0:28to you by the Arkansas Zoological Foundation
- 0:30and produced by the Little Rock Zoo. So with
- 0:33that, let's get wild. Susan, question for you.
- 0:38Okay. Have you seen that video on social media
- 0:41with the raccoon who likes to wash his cotton
- 0:44candy? I have. And I got to tell you, it's both
- 0:47hilarious, but also just a little bit upsetting.
- 0:50Because when he puts it in the water, it just...
- 0:53And he looks betrayed. I got to tell you, he
- 0:55looks absolutely betrayed. Yes. And exactly.
- 0:58That's, I think, probably why people love raccoons.
- 1:01They feel weirdly relatable somehow. You know,
- 1:03that is absolutely the case. And it's still a
- 1:06wild animal, but it has those tiny little hands,
- 1:10which are absolutely adorable and hilarious.
- 1:12But I think that also raccoons sometimes have
- 1:14questionable judgment. And that kind of goes
- 1:17to the heart of what we're talking about today.
- 1:19Why do some wild animals feel so familiar? Yes.
- 1:22Yes. That is an interesting question. Are they
- 1:25adapting to us? Are we changing them? Are we
- 1:28just projecting human behavior onto them? Things
- 1:32that we need to talk about, I think. You know,
- 1:35I have a funny story about the trash panda, if
- 1:38you will, that I want to share with you, which
- 1:39is a funny nickname we have for the raccoon sometimes.
- 1:42So my father is really into saving feral cats.
- 1:48And so he will set out. in his backyard and he
- 1:53will try to grab the cats in the trap and then
- 1:55he will have them spayed or neutered and then
- 1:57either re -release them or put them up for adoption
- 1:59we love my father for this very noble very noble
- 2:02and but you know here's the thing you know every
- 2:05once in a while a raccoon will get caught up
- 2:07in the trap except Except lately, though, that's
- 2:11not been happening because the very smart raccoon
- 2:14has discovered that he can walk around the outside
- 2:17of the trap and then put his little paw in it
- 2:20and then scoot the food out from the trap. But
- 2:24what's funny, though, is raccoons are very fastidious
- 2:27and he'll grab the food and then take it over
- 2:30to the water bowl that my father has set out
- 2:33for the cats and then clean the food in the water
- 2:36bowl first before he eats it. Very hygienic.
- 2:39Very hygienic, which raccoons are actually. And
- 2:42so smart. And so smart. So incredibly smart.
- 2:46Yes. That's awesome. That's awesome. So today
- 2:48we're talking about domestication, urbanization,
- 2:51and interspecies communication. So I'm excited
- 2:53for our guests that we're going to have and we're
- 2:55going to talk about. Me too. This is That's Wild
- 3:01from the Little Rock Zoo. And today we're joined
- 3:03by Dr. Raffaella Lesch. Hi. Thank you for having
- 3:06me. Thanks for being here. So we were just joking
- 3:09momentarily about how sometimes your students
- 3:13call you Dr. Leach, which I think is hilarious.
- 3:16I wish that was my name. That would be so much
- 3:19better. But, you know, working with animals,
- 3:22being called Dr. Leach. But also, too, where
- 3:24is the A in your name? I don't know how they
- 3:26get from Lesh to Leach, but, hey, you know, it
- 3:29is what it is. I think it might be like kind
- 3:31of like some of them might have the same problem
- 3:33that I do, just like, you know. Glasses. I avoided
- 3:35glasses for the longest time. Sometimes that
- 3:37suspiciously looks like an A. It's fair. Yeah,
- 3:42I got to a point where my doctor was like, you
- 3:44know what? Glasses. Yeah. It happens to all of
- 3:47us. It does happen to all of us. It can happen
- 3:49to all of us. Well, thank you for being here.
- 3:52You are a professor of biology at the University
- 3:55of Arkansas at Little Rock, where you have studied
- 3:57animal behavior, domestication, urbanization,
- 4:00and one of my favorite words, bioacoustics. Yes.
- 4:05Basically, how animals behave, communicate, and
- 4:08physically change when they live close to humans.
- 4:12Yes. Welcome. Thank you so much. And one of our
- 4:15producers on that note first came across your
- 4:17work through an NPR post on social media on the
- 4:20study that you did on raccoon, your raccoon research,
- 4:23which immediately caught our attention. Yes.
- 4:26However, but today we were told that we are only
- 4:29going to ask one raccoon question. Only one.
- 4:32Okay. And we're going to use it as a jumping
- 4:34off point. However, it sounds like your raccoon
- 4:36knowledge is immense. So we may have to talk
- 4:39a little bit more. You may have to entertain
- 4:41us about raccoons. This whole show won't be.
- 4:43about raccoons but yes sounds good yeah because
- 4:46what we really want to talk about is how wild
- 4:48animals live around us adapt to us and maybe
- 4:51even communicate with us more than we realize
- 4:53yes so welcome thank you thank you so much for
- 4:56having me yeah so on raccoons let's talk a little
- 4:59bit about raccoons first so tell us a little
- 5:00about raccoons and some of the research and the
- 5:03work that you've done with raccoons Yeah, I might
- 5:05just give you kind of like the background of
- 5:07how I ended up with raccoon research. So most
- 5:10of my other research was on already domesticated
- 5:13animals. And when I moved to the U .S., one of
- 5:16my first experiences on campus was just like,
- 5:18there's raccoons and semi -large animals pretty
- 5:21much everywhere. And especially one morning I
- 5:23walked on campus, threw away one of my healthy
- 5:26cans of Red Bull. It was empty. It was empty.
- 5:28I made sure I had drank the entire thing before.
- 5:31No one has a Red Bull on campus ever, right?
- 5:33Yeah. And threw it away in that trash can. And
- 5:36someone must have hit that big raccoon sitting
- 5:39in the trash can. The head popped out. And that
- 5:41was the first one I was like, I wonder if there's
- 5:45a way that we can study domestication from a
- 5:48different perspective, from a different context,
- 5:49where we don't purely have to rely on animals
- 5:52that currently are domesticated, but also use
- 5:55different animal species to maybe look at. earlier
- 5:59stages of domestication, or maybe to even look
- 6:01if there is any point in trying to look at domestication
- 6:05from that perspective and tie it more to urbanization.
- 6:08So when we hear the word domesticated, what do
- 6:12you think that that means? What do you think
- 6:14people think that that means? And what do you
- 6:16think it means? All right. So that is actually
- 6:18a pretty fun question because we are in the field
- 6:21of domestication. You would think that defining
- 6:24domestication or domesticated animals is easy
- 6:27and it turns out we're still arguing about it
- 6:29yeah because it's really we all have like an
- 6:32intuitive feeling of what a domesticated animal
- 6:34is but when you try to define it it becomes a
- 6:37little bit fuzzy so domesticated animals are
- 6:39usually animals that have been in close contact
- 6:42with humans over many many generations now the
- 6:47interesting thing here is though that These animals
- 6:50that we have that are domesticated, like dogs
- 6:52and cats, can hybridize with wild animals. So
- 6:56with wild cat species or dogs with wolves. So
- 7:00that creates a scenario where a clearly domesticated
- 7:04animal can have an impact, a genetic impact on
- 7:07wild populations. But that also means that technically...
- 7:10You could have a wolf -dog hybrid if like a wolf
- 7:14made it with a dog and you have that offspring
- 7:16in your house. You have like a hybridization
- 7:18event. So you're bringing in genetic material
- 7:20in both directions. And then on top of that,
- 7:23we have domesticated animals that become feralized.
- 7:27So feralized domesticated animals like classic
- 7:30examples would be pigeons, mustangs. All of those
- 7:33are animals that were domesticated. We brought
- 7:36them along and then they basically... remove
- 7:40themselves or were released from human care.
- 7:42So defining domestication is clear in the cases
- 7:47of like dogs, cats, but becomes more tricky when
- 7:51we think of animals that are under human care,
- 7:54but don't quite have the same impact on our society
- 7:58and on our like everyday lives. So we really
- 8:02do not have a great definition of domestication
- 8:05yet. There's a recent paper that, for example,
- 8:08brought up the discussion of are there types
- 8:11of insects or bed bugs, for example. Are those
- 8:14domesticated or not? So it was just... I would
- 8:17have never even thought to talk about bed bugs
- 8:19and domestication. It kind of brought up this
- 8:21interesting point of like... Like we tend to
- 8:24hyper focus on mammals and larger mammals. So
- 8:27where do we draw the point? I think bed bugs,
- 8:30that was pushing it with that definition. I usually
- 8:33just define domesticated animals as animals that
- 8:35over many, many generations have lived in close
- 8:38contact with humans, not necessarily active care,
- 8:41but close contact. Yeah. Yeah, and it's interesting
- 8:44that we talk about domestication and in the zoo
- 8:46world, we have to always correct people sometimes
- 8:49because we get some confusion. People think that
- 8:52the animals in our care are domesticated just
- 8:55because there's interaction with humans and because
- 8:59they're in our care. They are not domesticated.
- 9:01These are still wild animals. So we have to a
- 9:05lot of times explain, no, that's not the case.
- 9:07Just because there's interaction with humans
- 9:09doesn't necessarily mean domestication. So that's
- 9:12always something we have to deal with a lot of
- 9:14times in the zoo world is that issue. So let's
- 9:19talk a little bit about raccoons and why study
- 9:21raccoons when we're talking about domestication.
- 9:24Yeah. So ultimately, one of the core issues in
- 9:28all the research that I have done in the past
- 9:30is, for example, if you work with dogs and you
- 9:33compare them to wolves, you're really not comparing.
- 9:36the ancestral population that gave rise to our
- 9:39dogs you're comparing like a wild cousin same
- 9:42with cats you don't really have a really good
- 9:45comparison we have the like as close as we can
- 9:48get but it's not really a clean comparison um
- 9:51and there's domesticated animals where we don't
- 9:53have an ancestor species around anymore like
- 9:55um the arocs for example that gave rise to uh
- 9:59cattle We simply don't have that anymore. So
- 10:02I was curious to see whether there is potential
- 10:05in looking at animals that live in an urban environment
- 10:08and use those as a species to look at these very
- 10:13early stages of what would become a domesticated
- 10:16species through urbanization. Because the idea
- 10:19that I had was dogs and cats, for example. um
- 10:24started that pathway towards domestication because
- 10:26they would encroach into human space yeah because
- 10:29we produce a lot of trash so dogs would actively
- 10:31eat the trash that we produce we can see that
- 10:33in their in their adaptation like they have the
- 10:36ability to digest starch a lot more than any
- 10:39wolf would ever be able to do and cats for example
- 10:42were also attracted by those trash heaps but
- 10:44mainly because trash attracts a lot of rodents
- 10:46ah so okay trash seems to be pretty attractive
- 10:50for an omnivorous or carnivorous species. So
- 10:53I figured maybe there's a value in looking at
- 10:56species that we know is exploiting trash and
- 10:59is living in close contact with us humans. And
- 11:02that's really what drew me to raccoons and what
- 11:05inspired this first study to see whether it was
- 11:09worth it to look at this into more detail. Because
- 11:11that was really, I'm thinking about this study
- 11:13as like a first puzzle piece to understanding
- 11:17or... to get an idea of whether this is a framework
- 11:20that would help us unravel early stage domestication.
- 11:24So you kind of chose a modern day ancestral line.
- 11:26Yeah, kind of like where we still have populations
- 11:29where they're not split apart that far, where
- 11:31we still have populations that aren't under that
- 11:33selection pressure and populations that are,
- 11:35that are still fairly closely related, but have
- 11:38very distinct. pressures that they're under.
- 11:42That was the idea. We were talking earlier too
- 11:46about some of these raccoons that you're seeing
- 11:47at the university and just how clever they are.
- 11:50opening up the trash cans. Oh, yeah. Not just
- 11:52the big trash cans, the Big Daddy trash cans.
- 11:54Oh, yeah, yeah. They're just doing that on their
- 11:55own now. Yeah, 100%. I had a student, shout out
- 11:59to Kelsey. She also worked at the zoo. Yeah,
- 12:01yeah. Okay. And she put up wildlife cameras across
- 12:05campus because we kind of just wanted to get
- 12:07a feeling for what is it that they're doing across
- 12:09campus because the study of connecting the raccoons
- 12:15to the use of trash only really made sense if
- 12:17we knew if they even explore. like trash on on
- 12:22like when they have the opportunity to so she
- 12:24put out uh cameras all across campus and we caught
- 12:27raccoons opening those huge doors those huge
- 12:29dumpster doors amazing and facilities management
- 12:32for the longest time thought it was human error
- 12:34and they send out emails like you cannot leave
- 12:37those dumpster doors open right and then it turns
- 12:39out it was the raccoons with their little arms
- 12:41just like Wow. Yeah, pushing those doors open.
- 12:44Which is amazing that they're that strong, too.
- 12:46Yes. And scary, but amazing. Yes, yeah. So, yeah,
- 12:49that was very exciting. We got a whole bunch
- 12:51of, like, really cute footage. Also, like, one
- 12:53where we had a raccoon that was sitting on top
- 12:55of a cooling tower eating, like, a foot -long
- 12:57Subway sandwich. Oh, no. Oh, it's glorious. Shout
- 13:01out to Subway. Sponsor us. Yes. And it was just
- 13:07munching down to that, really close to that camera.
- 13:09So the footage we got from that was... is a mixture
- 13:12of adorable and really exciting yeah but we do
- 13:15want to we need to clarify though yeah domestication
- 13:17does not mean that they make good pets yes oh
- 13:20yeah yeah the study is really like this was looking
- 13:23at what maybe maybe could be the very very very
- 13:27very beginning stages of a domestication event
- 13:29could be could be like this is a first puzzle
- 13:31piece because that's also uh one thing you mentioned
- 13:34earlier about the confusion in the zoo of people
- 13:37calling an animal that is under human care domesticated.
- 13:41That is very different. Domesticated animals
- 13:44have been... through many generations of animals
- 13:47that have adapted to living in close proximity
- 13:50to humans, which is different from an animal,
- 13:52one individual having learned to coexist with
- 13:56humans. Which is what we're talking about with
- 13:58the raccoons, coexisting with humans. Yes, and
- 14:01that is something, if we're talking about domestication,
- 14:05we're talking about many generations adapting
- 14:07to what that means to live in close proximity
- 14:10compared to an animal that lives under human
- 14:12care, but is not. not basically living in a free
- 14:17breeding population alongside humans. And on
- 14:20that note with domestication, why do some animals
- 14:23become domesticated over others? Is there traits,
- 14:27certain things that makes one more of a viable
- 14:29candidate than others? So that's also a very
- 14:32interesting field of research. We have some suggestions
- 14:35and ideas of what might facilitate an animal
- 14:41kind of like taking that path down towards being
- 14:43domesticated. um it has to do or we think that
- 14:47it has to do with um just like the ability to
- 14:51for us to to somehow manage and tap into their
- 14:54social system their social structure it seems
- 14:56that very solitary animals are not really animals
- 15:00that tend to be domesticated um also we tend
- 15:04to domesticate animals or we that that's already
- 15:07kind of wrong because that initial process is
- 15:09not something that we actively start but it tends
- 15:12to be animals that are able to adapt their nutritional
- 15:18habits to an environment where we also exist.
- 15:21So, for example, medium -sized carnivores and
- 15:23omnivores like cats, dogs, potentially maybe
- 15:27raccoons would be candidates that we can look
- 15:29at. Then, of course, we also have animals like
- 15:31horses, goats, and those seem to have taken a
- 15:35slightly different pathway to domestication where...
- 15:38Us humans have played a more active role in like
- 15:40herd management and then kind of like started
- 15:44that process from there. So there seems to be
- 15:46a little bit of a difference in the traits that
- 15:50animals have and how we handle those different
- 15:52pathways. So let's talk about like, for instance,
- 15:54with dogs. Yeah. With domestication of dogs.
- 15:57And there's so many different breeds. There's
- 15:59so many different types of dogs, species of dogs,
- 16:03etc. With dogs, did dogs choose us or did we
- 16:08choose dogs? Oh, yeah, that is a big question.
- 16:11And did we know the answer to that? Oh, if time
- 16:13travel was a thing, I would just want to know.
- 16:17Those first interactions must have been so interesting.
- 16:21It must have been, we don't know for sure, but
- 16:24it seems there was a benefit to exploiting that
- 16:27human niche. So if you're living in close proximity
- 16:30to humans, that means there's fewer predators
- 16:33because humans are, aren't kind of dangerous.
- 16:35It means there's trash, easy food, but it also
- 16:39means you cannot afford to be rude or aggressive
- 16:43towards animals, towards humans. So there's also
- 16:46that selection pressure from the human side of
- 16:49if you're an aggressive individual, they will
- 16:52eliminate you from that population pretty quickly.
- 16:54So it is dangerous, but it comes with a lot of
- 16:57benefits also. So I would say initially it was
- 17:00kind of like, This coexistence of we tolerated
- 17:05them, they made use of the space that we were
- 17:08in, and from there on, this beautiful relationship
- 17:12emerged that we share now with those amazing
- 17:16creators. I hate to oversimplify, but it sounds
- 17:20like they were nice, they were hungry, and they
- 17:24wanted to hang out. that's kind of like what
- 17:29is that a saying that you have that you have
- 17:32in in english and german we have that saying
- 17:33that says uh love goes through the stomach basically
- 17:36like indicating that like if you're given food
- 17:39you know yeah yeah it builds relationships yeah
- 17:42builds the relationship that's a great way of
- 17:44saying it So I want to learn more about some
- 17:52of your work with bioacoustics. Yeah. Now, is
- 17:55this a newer area that you've gotten into recently?
- 17:58Have you kind of always had an interest in bioacoustics?
- 18:00First, what is bioacoustics? Let's define that.
- 18:03So bioacoustics is the study of sound production
- 18:08in the animal kingdom. And technically that could
- 18:10include humans, but usually humans... have their
- 18:13own feel like linguistics and all of that. So
- 18:15it's really, bioacoustics can include sound production,
- 18:18but also sound perception. And I originally started
- 18:22out in bioacoustics in domesticated animals and
- 18:26kind of, you know, when you start your PhD, you
- 18:30have these massive plans of what you're all going
- 18:33to achieve within your PhD. And one of the projects
- 18:37that I initially wanted to work on was a comparison
- 18:39of the voice boxes of dogs and wolves. I wanted
- 18:43to see like, are they anatomically different?
- 18:45And is that potentially tied to how like wolves
- 18:50tend to howl more, dogs tend to bark more? I
- 18:52was curious whether there was like an anatomical
- 18:55explanation to that. I started collecting CT
- 18:58scans of like dog. voice boxers dog laryngees
- 19:02and wolf laryngees um and i figured like naive
- 19:06me at that time when i when i did my phd is like
- 19:08how hard can it be to get CT scans of the heads
- 19:12and necks of wolves and dogs. Dogs turned out
- 19:15to be easy enough because there's a bunch of
- 19:18like pet dogs that are put in CT scans. Turned
- 19:21out getting wolves is a lot harder. So it took
- 19:24years to actually collect the data. And now my
- 19:27master's student inherited that project. And
- 19:30we published that project recently. So I think
- 19:33I started that project in probably 2016 and we
- 19:36published it 2000. No, that can't be right. Well,
- 19:41it took somewhere between like five to seven
- 19:43years. Wow. Closer to like seven, if not more,
- 19:46to go from data collection to actually publishing
- 19:49that. Yeah. And where does one get a CT scan
- 19:53of a wolf? Yeah, that was. So originally, I thought
- 19:57you just, you know, like that is also the joys
- 20:00of like figuring out science. It's like you just
- 20:02go places that have wolves and they'll have CT
- 20:05scans. People are usually like. They don't like
- 20:08being put in a CT, so we don't. And I'm like,
- 20:11that makes sense. That makes a lot of sense.
- 20:13It's tough to get animals into CTs. And not every
- 20:17facility has a CT. Exactly. That's the other
- 20:19thing. And then you need a resolution where you
- 20:21can actually see those little cartilages. Yeah,
- 20:25exactly. So I ended up collaborating with a veterinary
- 20:29school that is working with the Wolf Science
- 20:32Center in Austria. And anytime they had a wolf
- 20:35coming for a CT scan, that was related to some
- 20:37other like health issues, you know, as they get
- 20:39older, like they need some treatment. And that's
- 20:42where I ended up getting the majority of CT scans.
- 20:45We also had some CT scans of wolves that were
- 20:49donated to science in Scotland that had like
- 20:52a diet of old age. So that was the combination
- 20:55of where we got CT scans from. It was a lot more
- 20:58difficult than I thought it would be. Yes, you
- 20:59had to be very creative. So what did you find
- 21:00from that study? So we found that basically the
- 21:06anatomy of the larynx differs. So they differ
- 21:11in a way of wolves or dogs having shorter vocal
- 21:16folds and kind of like a compressed, a smaller
- 21:20larynx overall. The reason that was interesting
- 21:24is because there is a framework in domestication
- 21:28research that has the potential to explain traits
- 21:31that we readily observe in domesticated animals.
- 21:33So these traits that we see all over is called
- 21:36the domestication syndrome. Like we see floppy
- 21:38ears, shorter snouts, smaller adrenal glands,
- 21:41curly tails, white patches, all those traits.
- 21:46In this hypothesis that is called the neural
- 21:49crest domestication syndrome hypothesis, that
- 21:53hypothesis argues that these traits are linked
- 21:56to a change in development where domesticated
- 21:59animals have a slight deficiency in the migration
- 22:02and proliferation of cells that are called neural
- 22:04crest cells. And fewer of these cells arriving
- 22:07at target sites to build all those organ structures
- 22:09are creating that phenotype. And one interesting
- 22:13thing that we wanted to see is we wanted to test
- 22:17this framework, this neural crest domestication
- 22:19syndrome framework on an organ system that we
- 22:22know is tied to the neural crest cells, but has
- 22:26not been described in the context of the domestication
- 22:29syndrome before. And that was the larynx, the
- 22:31voice box. Basically, our line of thought was
- 22:35that if this hypothesis holds true, dogs should
- 22:38have smaller larynges because there's fewer of
- 22:40the cells arriving at the target site to build
- 22:43that structure. And that's what we found. That
- 22:46was really exciting. So dogs have smaller larynges
- 22:49and shorter vocal folds, which matches the predictions
- 22:53of this hypothesis. But the change in anatomy
- 22:56was not tied to... the howling or barking. We
- 23:01also included some... So you couldn't make a
- 23:03conclusion that that's why they howl or bark.
- 23:04Exactly. So it seems that the howling and barking
- 23:07is not purely tied to that change in an app.
- 23:11Okay. Well, that's good to know. Yeah. Wow. Good
- 23:13to know. That's fascinating. So we still don't
- 23:15know why they howl or bark. Correct. Yeah. We
- 23:17assume right now that it's something tied to
- 23:20more like the behavioral or physiological mechanisms,
- 23:24but... so far we don't know interesting interesting
- 23:27but now we know it's not because of the physiological
- 23:29which is what you find out when you do science
- 23:32yeah yeah that's right that's exciting things
- 23:34happen that's right walk in with one question
- 23:36and come out with another yeah with three more
- 23:38yeah you're like great i kind of maybe answered
- 23:41one and i created seven more fantastic So I saw
- 23:48another study you did on bioacoustics. I think
- 23:51it had something to do with women's voices when
- 23:55they're talking to dogs. I'm oversimplifying
- 23:58this. So tell us a little bit more about that.
- 24:02So there's two different studies that I've been
- 24:04involved in that was basically focusing on what
- 24:08we call pet directed speech. So the curious thing
- 24:11about how we talk to animals is that it is very
- 24:14similar to how we talk to infants or little children
- 24:16and babies. It's that like super high pitch.
- 24:19Yes, I'm guilty. Joy has never done this to her
- 24:23dog. And it's we do that automatically. It's
- 24:26something that we can't really help. And it's
- 24:28not just women. It's men as well. Yes. But the
- 24:30thing is. when we run these studies, we tend
- 24:34to have fairly low sample sizes. So we have to
- 24:36decide whether to use men or women in our study,
- 24:39just because there's different fundamental frequency
- 24:41pitches between men and women. So in this case,
- 24:45in one study, we focused on women only. In the
- 24:47other one, we had both men and women. But these
- 24:51studies really were looking at whether one looked
- 24:56at whether eye size which is tied to cuteness,
- 25:00would elicit a different response. That one was
- 25:02solely looking at email speakers. And then the
- 25:05other study looked at... If a stress test called
- 25:09the Ainsworth Strange Situation Procedure that
- 25:12was developed for kids where you're basically
- 25:14removing the, when I say it like that, it sounds
- 25:18so cruel. You're removing a contact person and
- 25:20you're making that child cry. That's like, it's
- 25:23not that bad. I have to work on how to present
- 25:28this thing. It's a very slow and like it takes
- 25:3230 minutes. It's a slow introduction of like
- 25:35you have an experimenter. the child is never
- 25:38truly alone in that room. But basically that
- 25:41study was adapted. because the purpose of this
- 25:45framework was to test the type of relationship
- 25:48and the attachment style that children would
- 25:50have with their parents. And in the study that
- 25:53we ran, we used that with dogs to kind of like
- 25:56see how it would affect the communication of
- 25:59the humans with their dogs when they were experiencing
- 26:03stress. And we found that both men and women
- 26:05responded to that stressor and would provide
- 26:08a pet directed speech. So this like very exaggerated
- 26:11high pitch, with like a lot of frequency range,
- 26:15both men and women. And the interesting thing
- 26:18is usually when you start these experiments,
- 26:20people are very conscious that they're being
- 26:23recorded. But over time, they forget. And even
- 26:27men, there were some men in the study that were
- 26:29impressive with like how high their frequency
- 26:32range would go. And the other study with the
- 26:36eye size, we saw that an increased... increased
- 26:40eye size would elicit a stronger response in
- 26:44like how the pitch, the voice pitch goes up.
- 26:47But... Also, when we asked people how cute are
- 26:52those images that you're presented, like with
- 26:54normal eye size, smaller eyes, and larger eyes,
- 26:57they rated all of them as adorable, which most
- 27:00likely is just the fact that they were looking
- 27:02at dog images. You don't want to be rude to the
- 27:04dog and say, like, you're less cute. This dog
- 27:09is a two. Chihuahua is a two. But this lab is
- 27:14a ten. Exactly. like the cuteness question is
- 27:19kind of tricky in that context because all dogs
- 27:23were rated as cute. Right, right. Personal preferences.
- 27:25Yeah, sure, sure, sure, sure. That's interesting.
- 27:28And that was interesting to me because coming
- 27:31from the zoo field, it's becoming very female
- 27:34dominated. That wasn't always the case. But the
- 27:38interactions that we see with our animals, that
- 27:41was an interesting study to me for that reason.
- 27:43So that's curious because we interact with our
- 27:46animals, and sometimes you see that in how our
- 27:49staff interact with animals, with the high -pitched
- 27:51voices and things of that nature. And you see
- 27:54it with the men and the women of how we interact
- 27:57with animals of all types. Even when you're talking
- 28:00to the tiger, well, how are you today, sir? It's
- 28:02true. Yeah, it's interesting that we do that.
- 28:06Yeah. Yeah, I find that very interesting. Yeah,
- 28:09and it's really, we can't help ourselves. It
- 28:10just comes out. And there's also, there's certain
- 28:14things that we do. So when we, that high pitch
- 28:17and that, how like the pitch goes up and down,
- 28:19we share that in like infants and pets or animals
- 28:23in general. But with kids, we hyper articulate
- 28:26because some part of us is aware that they're
- 28:28going to have to learn how to speak at some point.
- 28:30But we don't really do that quite. that way with
- 28:33like dogs and cats. So there seems to be some
- 28:36part of us that recognizes that this is like
- 28:39a way for us to interact with them, but they're
- 28:41never going to get up in the morning and be like,
- 28:44I want tuna today. Which would be kind of fun,
- 28:47but also I'm so glad my dog can't speak because
- 28:50she knows too much. She knows too much. And it's
- 28:55interesting because we do a lot of training with
- 28:58our animals more. for medical procedure, for
- 29:01helping to reduce stress in situations, and how
- 29:05your tone is a big thing that we work on. You
- 29:09can't go into situations with a high -pitched
- 29:11voice all the time. We literally talk about that,
- 29:14that you have to talk about how your voice sounds
- 29:18around animals. We literally talk about this.
- 29:20That was very fascinating to me. There's also
- 29:24this very interesting thing, and you've probably
- 29:27seen this, this visualization of, kind of like
- 29:30emotion in how we can look at it in animals where
- 29:34you have valence and arousal. And sometimes when
- 29:37you have this, when you use this high pitch,
- 29:39I'm sure you've done this like with your animals
- 29:41at home on purpose where you just like, you rile
- 29:44them up a little bit. And then they just explode.
- 29:48And the thing is, if you get the arousal level
- 29:51high enough, if you have an animal that isn't
- 29:55just like, just purely happy, but also kind of
- 29:58like, you know, like a bit anxious, you can have
- 30:00them flip from like happy, anxious to like, I
- 30:03need to bite something. And that can happen when
- 30:06they flip, basically they're high in arousal,
- 30:09but they flip from like positive to more negative,
- 30:11negative balance. And that is something also
- 30:13like when you mentioned training, if you're too
- 30:15high in arousal levels, you can sometimes flip
- 30:18that. Yes, absolutely. So we said, we would only
- 30:26limit ourselves to just one raccoon question.
- 30:29So if you're okay with us venturing, why do you
- 30:35think that raccoons are a useful animal to study
- 30:37for the kind of questions about domestication?
- 30:40Yeah. So I think that they have a lot of potential
- 30:44in, if we also approach domestication. from is
- 30:49there an overlap between domestication research
- 30:52and urbanization research, for example. So there's
- 30:55a lot of research in urbanization in reptiles,
- 30:57for example. And we know that domesticated mammals,
- 31:02some of them have shorter snouts, but we see
- 31:05that in lizards, for example, that live in urban
- 31:08environments, they don't necessarily have that.
- 31:10Some of them have longer snouts. So that is interesting,
- 31:13right? Because there's like an urbanized environment.
- 31:16And if we would argue that maybe urbanization
- 31:18can trigger domestication phenotypes, why do
- 31:21we see like something in the opposite direction?
- 31:24And I think the fun part here is that urbanization
- 31:28is, and this is me purely speculating at this
- 31:32point, that urbanization is not enough. It provides
- 31:35an environment where... potentially domestication
- 31:38processes could happen but the relationship that
- 31:41we have with that species matters so if you think
- 31:44about a nose on the wall we don't really register
- 31:47them right so if we don't have an area of friction
- 31:51or interaction with that animal it would not
- 31:54necessarily create any type of selection pressure
- 31:58on that animal or on that species that is connected
- 32:02to our human existence. They just don't even
- 32:05care that we're there. Exactly. They don't care
- 32:06and we don't care. It's just like it's a type
- 32:08of coexistence where there is no real interaction.
- 32:11It's just they do their thing, we do ours. But
- 32:13if we think about raccoons or other animals that
- 32:18we have this type of friction with, I think those
- 32:21are the species that would be worth looking at.
- 32:23It does matter. To see if that can cause these
- 32:27shifts. I think that is really like where I would
- 32:32love to see the mystication urbanization research
- 32:34heading is like, do we have overlap? Is there
- 32:38interaction? Are there phenotypes that come out
- 32:40of this that are consistent with this framework?
- 32:44So what's next in the study of raccoons? Like,
- 32:47where do we go from here? Like, what's the next
- 32:49thing we need to look at with raccoons, do you
- 32:51think? So the next thing, there's some amazing
- 32:53research that is currently happening right now.
- 32:57I think the University of Wyoming, shout out
- 33:01to Christina Sluko, she has also published work
- 33:04on raccoons and how their anatomy has changed,
- 33:06comparing also rural and urban. So what I want
- 33:11to do now is to really take a deep dive in the
- 33:15anatomy. So this study for me was kind of like,
- 33:17the question was like, is it worth to look at
- 33:20this into more detail? And the results that we
- 33:22got was like, okay. that seems to be something
- 33:25that is worth spending more time on. So now I
- 33:27would really like to move into these anatomical
- 33:32changes at a much more detailed level and see
- 33:34whether that pattern that we observe actually
- 33:36holds and really is there and answer more questions
- 33:41tied to the anatomy and ideally also have populations
- 33:46that are fairly closely related, but in very
- 33:49different... urban to rural environments to have
- 33:52like a very in -depth comparison of these types
- 33:56of selection pressures and pathways. If you see
- 33:59a raccoon, what should you do? Don't take it
- 34:03home with you. Leave it there. Don't touch. Their
- 34:07teeth are pretty impressive. So I would say just
- 34:11keep going. Keep walking. As long as you don't
- 34:16mess with them, they usually won't mess with
- 34:18you, even if they're sitting right there in a
- 34:19trash can. So they're really cute, but I would
- 34:23not recommend them as pets. Like just observe
- 34:26them from a distance. Please don't take them
- 34:29home as pets. Please, please, please, please.
- 34:31They're not, yeah, you don't need a raccoon in
- 34:35your house. I was telling my husband. Even though
- 34:41they're cute. I was like, look at how bad our
- 34:44house looks with one dog and one cat. Neither
- 34:47of them can open cabinets. We're good. We do
- 34:50not need more canals in our house. Could you
- 34:52imagine? Because they are smart. Yeah, they are.
- 34:55I know. It's so destructive. Yeah. So where do
- 35:03humans fit into all of this? How do we impact
- 35:07this world where we're talking about the interaction
- 35:10with urbanization and domestication? What's our
- 35:14impact in this? Yeah, so the urban environment
- 35:19and our impact on the environment in general
- 35:22is like a very fascinating topic. So to a certain
- 35:25degree, I think it's important to have the level
- 35:30of awareness that whether we want to or not,
- 35:32we have an impact on the species around us. There
- 35:35is going to be species that can make use of the
- 35:38urban environment that we create, and there will
- 35:40be species that can't. So that is one thing we
- 35:43have to consider, that as our settlements and
- 35:46our cities grow, certain species will do fine,
- 35:49or fine. Some species are able to adapt to that,
- 35:52other species won't. And then earlier we talked
- 35:55about feralization. So pigeons, for example,
- 35:58are feralized domesticated animals. So in our
- 36:02relationship with pigeons is kind of like a little
- 36:04bit of a rough one. If you think about historically
- 36:06all they've done for us humans and now we're
- 36:08like, look at those. I don't know if that's a
- 36:11thing. Would they call them flying rats here
- 36:12in the U .S. as well? I was about to say that,
- 36:13yes. We don't like them. Yeah, which also, by
- 36:17the way, rats are awesome pets. But back to the
- 36:20flying ones, the flying rats. Pigeons, we seem
- 36:24to not really appreciate them all that much.
- 36:27But they also create a food source for raptors,
- 36:32for example. It's very difficult to make like
- 36:37a clear statement. Ideally, of course, we want
- 36:39to have as little impact as possible on our environment.
- 36:43But reality is that we're having an impact, whether
- 36:46it's a conscious one or not. It's just we can't
- 36:51really, that is just the thing that is happening.
- 36:54So even if we think of like light pollution.
- 36:59I was working on a project in Turkey as an undergrad
- 37:03where we were patrolling the beaches where sea
- 37:08turtles would basically have laid their eggs.
- 37:10And we were patrolling the beach to see if the
- 37:14little turtles have hatched because they would
- 37:16turn around and walk towards the resorts rather
- 37:18than the ocean because of the light pollution.
- 37:20And then you would collect those that had turned
- 37:23around, went the wrong way and release them in
- 37:25the morning when the sun was up because that
- 37:26was a much stronger. So those are all just, there's
- 37:30so many aspects to how we and our existence interacts
- 37:34with wildlife that I don't think there is one
- 37:38clear answer on how we... should or shouldn't
- 37:42deal with that because it's so connected to anything
- 37:44from like lawmaking to how do we structure cities?
- 37:47How do we make it safe? It's huge. It's huge.
- 37:51The choices of where we eat. I mean, it's everything.
- 37:55It's things we can do every single day. We talk
- 37:57about at the zoo that there's things we can do
- 37:58every single day and choices we can make every
- 38:00single day that impact wildlife and wild places.
- 38:03Yeah, 100%. Absolutely. Well, thank you so much
- 38:06for being here today. This has just been fascinating.
- 38:09Thank you. you so much for having me yeah thank
- 38:12you appreciate your time sure thank you so you
- 38:20were saying about we're talking about macaques
- 38:22and how they got overfed or being overfed and
- 38:25they've learned how to trade the desired object
- 38:29for a treat. Yeah. So this is happening where,
- 38:32unfortunately, tourists are feeding macaques
- 38:35and it's developed a behavior. So this is why
- 38:38you don't feed animals in the wild if you're
- 38:40traveling somewhere or really just in general.
- 38:42But what's happened is park rangers in this particular
- 38:46area have been exchanging treats for lost items
- 38:51like sunglasses or other types of things. And
- 38:54so what has happened now is that the macaques
- 38:58have learned that I get a treat in exchange for
- 39:01a tourist item. So now these clever little macaques
- 39:05have started stealing the sunglasses off of people's
- 39:09faces because they know if I go up to the park
- 39:11ranger, I can exchange it for a treat. Clever.
- 39:15Clever. Very. But now destructive and dangerous
- 39:17because now they're stealing things off of people's
- 39:20faces. That is scary. So that's what ends up
- 39:21happening. That's why you don't feed animals
- 39:23in the wild. I have another little story about
- 39:26this with an animal that we had at our zoo many
- 39:30years ago named Rock. He was an orangutan. Okay.
- 39:32Very smart animal. So we have, and we do this
- 39:37with our zoo, with the great apes, that if something
- 39:39gets dropped into a habitat that our staff will
- 39:43go into the behind the scenes area and we'll
- 39:45trade a treat for that item. And so a pencil
- 39:50had been dropped down into the habitat. And so
- 39:53Rock went down underneath and one of our staff
- 39:57members went to go and retrieve the pencil. And
- 40:00so she held up the treat. So Rock held up the
- 40:03pencil. Right. And you would think, okay, exchange
- 40:05the pencil for the treat. Sure. Well, Rock took
- 40:09the pencil, broke it in half, and then exchanged
- 40:12the treat. And then he held up the pencil again
- 40:14and he broke it in half again to get another
- 40:17treat. Oh, wow. Pretty smart. Yes. Pretty smart.
- 40:21Oh, I hate I didn't get to know Rock. Oh, wow.
- 40:24Yeah. That's fascinating. Pretty smart. Very
- 40:27smart. Very smart. Well, I mean, that just is.
- 40:29Another piece of all of the interesting and fascinating
- 40:31things we learned today with Dr. Raffaella. She
- 40:34was so engaging and made her part of science
- 40:38fun and intriguing. Would you say there's something
- 40:42in particular that you learned? You know, I learned
- 40:44I really enjoyed what she had to say about bioacoustics.
- 40:48And I learned that the bigger the eyes, the higher
- 40:50our voices get. Yes. Which I found fascinating.
- 40:53What did you learn? Well, similarly, I thought
- 40:56what was interesting and funny that she said
- 40:57both males and females. do the higher pitched
- 41:00voices for the animals. That was interesting.
- 41:04That was interesting. And I have one kind of
- 41:05like lingering question that I wish I had asked
- 41:07her. Yeah. Because as we were talking about what
- 41:10she was talking about, those ancestral lines
- 41:12of animals versus the domesticated animals and
- 41:15how she wished she could go back in time to see
- 41:17those first couple of steps when the domestication
- 41:20process started. Yeah. I should have thought
- 41:23to ask her. If she could go into the future and
- 41:26see raccoons, see if they ever did actually become
- 41:30fully domesticated. What would they look like
- 41:32in the future? Yes. How far would it go? Would
- 41:35we have a PetSmart raccoon area? No. Not today.
- 41:41But maybe in 120 years. I mean, who knows? That's
- 41:45fascinating to think about. But anyway, it was
- 41:48another great episode. I'm glad she was able
- 41:50to come and join us. Definitely. It was a fascinating
- 41:52episode. Absolutely. So thanks so much for listening
- 41:56to this episode of That's Wild and for supporting
- 41:58the Little Rock Zoo. We thank you. Yeah. And
- 42:00be sure to like, share and to subscribe whenever
- 42:03you get your podcast or wherever you get your
- 42:05podcast, I should say, and follow along for more
- 42:07stories of the zoo and of animals. So until next
- 42:11time, stay wild.