Latest / The KAJ Masterclass LIVE / Outcomes Of India-US 2+2 Ministerial Dialogue: Irina Tsukerman's Analysis | KAJ Masterclass
Transcript
- 0:00This time, let's start with II. US 2 + 2 dialogue recently
- 0:05happened. Let's touch upon that.
- 0:11Indeed, it has been so far the biggest and most important one
- 0:15out of the series that US and India have been conducting over
- 0:20the past several years. There are also other countries
- 0:23and there are also new new new countries joining into this
- 0:27format, including UK 2 + 2 means essentially 2 counterparts from
- 0:34each country meeting to discuss foreign policy, defence
- 0:37relations, commerce, economy and other issues.
- 0:40And this time US and India touched on such important issues
- 0:46as critical minerals cutting the exchange in cutting edge
- 0:50technologies that is actually progressing and moving forward.
- 0:58Cooperation on issues such as student visas for Indian
- 1:02nationals coming to the United States.
- 1:04And also issues that the issues related to Indo Pacific security
- 1:10as well as concerns and differences over matters such as
- 1:15in guess relations with Russia and Indian Russian defence
- 1:19relations, the arms situation. Why India cannot simply drop it
- 1:25as a partner. So all of these things came to
- 1:30the surface and it was a very fruitful and important
- 1:33discussion. And hopefully the next step will
- 1:36be the continuity of building on this relations, building on on
- 1:41cooperation. And one of the most important
- 1:44outcomes from an economic perspective is the discussion of
- 1:48a joint development and not merely a production or trade of
- 1:55various technologies and elements that we were talking
- 1:59about. So we are seeing more integrated
- 2:03levels of Economic Cooperation. Right, right Edina, this is,
- 2:09this was the 5th, you know, US, India 2 + 2 ministerial
- 2:15dialogue. So the where are we heading
- 2:19towards this sort of, you know, arrangement between the two
- 2:22countries? Are there challenges?
- 2:24Also differences also that they have not been able to look
- 2:28towards a very intently and that needs to be taken care of?
- 2:36I think the biggest issue is the issue of trust building.
- 2:39I wouldn't say it's so much a challenge in the sense that it's
- 2:43you know that there's some hostility that needs to become.
- 2:46It's the fact that the relationship has built begin
- 2:50building relatively recently in in, but at a very quick phase
- 2:56phase from certain issues there. It's just a matter of time and
- 3:00it's going to take time to build up these relations, for instance
- 3:04in the area of security cooperation, in the area of arm
- 3:08straight US. Obviously, once we get to move
- 3:13away from dependency of Russian on Russian weapons, that's a
- 3:16critical the issue. But the problem is, of course
- 3:19India's relationship with Russia has been very long standing
- 3:24historic and logistically speaking, it is not an easy
- 3:27thing to do because Russia actually controls some of the
- 3:30technologies that that are critical to India's
- 3:36infrastructure. India has also been looking to
- 3:38develop its own industry. It has been diversifying it's
- 3:44technologies, buying more from from France, from Israel and
- 3:48other countries. US will probably want to
- 3:52eventually transition into selling more of its technologies
- 3:56and more of its arms to India. But this is the trust part that
- 4:00I am talking about. I think this is the main
- 4:02obstacle to why do sales have not happened yet?
- 4:05I think it will take time before US is ready to sell some of its
- 4:10more advanced weapons to India. And of course, the question is
- 4:16whether the chicken or the egg should come first, whether India
- 4:19should first move away from working with Russia or for the
- 4:26OR the US should first some of its technologies.
- 4:29It's a it's a complicated situation because of course
- 4:33there is concern about American weapons from into their own
- 4:36hands. On the other hand, India cannot
- 4:38do that some of the those critical weapons.
- 4:42So I think US is simply waiting until India gets enough weapons
- 4:46from other Western countries or other allied countries that it
- 4:51is no longer quite as dependent and then US can compliment them
- 4:55and start providing more advanced technologies.
- 4:58I think that is the main right now concern.
- 5:02There is also the fact that the India in general is moving away
- 5:07economically from China. But it also takes time to
- 5:10decouple gestures is it will take US to decouple probably
- 5:14decades, not not years, it's a matter of decades.
- 5:18But there is an interest in helping move that forward
- 5:22because India is becoming a very welcome destination for American
- 5:25industry and there is scope that the and that this business
- 5:31friendly environment will accelerate and become faster
- 5:35integrated with US businesses over time as well.
- 5:38Again, this is not so much an obstacle challenge, but it's
- 5:42just also a matter of building up capacity and simply a matter
- 5:48of moving in the right direction over time, right?
- 5:52Right. Do you know, You see India has a
- 5:54lot of this 2 + 2 ministerial dialogues including Russia,
- 5:59Australia, We had just recently had that meeting.
- 6:02We already have one with Japan, we have got with the UK.
- 6:06So the world is moving more towards 1 to one talks though in
- 6:10the 2 + 2 format and rather than talking less at the
- 6:15international level. So is it the norm that is going
- 6:18to be happening globally much more and and how does this is is
- 6:24different than the other formats it means the global all these
- 6:27big forums will actually you know there will be only much
- 6:31more for optics and less for actual talks.
- 6:34More talks will happen globally in this format.
- 6:37What is what is your understanding of this?
- 6:39I just want to understand, you know, the way global diplomacy
- 6:44will move forward with this sort of dialogues?
- 6:47Well, to be honest, I think we are going through phases.
- 6:50I think there periods of time and a lot of it depends on who
- 6:56is in, who is in power in any given country, particularly in
- 7:00the US but also elsewhere. And there are different vast
- 7:05differences in preferences among administrations.
- 7:08The Obama administration was very much in favour of big
- 7:11format. The Trump administration was
- 7:13not. The Biden administration was
- 7:16very much initially in in favour of big diplomacy, but the
- 7:21polarization and the various conflicts created a lot of
- 7:25differences in among even NATO countries, much less anyone
- 7:29else. There's been a building up of
- 7:32new alliances and I think they discovered that logistically
- 7:35speaking, smaller groups of countries and one and bilateral
- 7:38relations just make it easier to work out individual differences
- 7:43and to come to arrangements that faster.
- 7:45However, it is inevitable that some forms of multilateral
- 7:51discussions will stay. The court, for instance, is a
- 7:55welcome format because you do need groups of countries
- 7:58coordinating among themselves against common threats and in
- 8:02favor of Commons problem solving.
- 8:05But of course, I think the future is kind of in smaller
- 8:09regional alliances rather than huge huge alliances.
- 8:15I didn't think very big groups of countries talking to this is
- 8:19efficient. I think there are too many
- 8:21divergent interests and problems and issues and it's just very
- 8:24difficult to coordinate. So I think most likely the
- 8:27future is going to be a mixture of bilateral and small
- 8:31multilateral gatherings, bilaterals to coordinate
- 8:35individual relations and to work out those separate conversations
- 8:39that you need to have privately one-on-one and multilateral to
- 8:43small multilateral to coordinate in a flexible format.
- 8:50And the issues that are joined of joint common interest and
- 8:54they are going to be based on common interest more and less or
- 8:58just strictly geographical locations and and in all sorts
- 9:04of previous criteria, they didn't really make much sense.
- 9:10Absolutely, absolutely. And now let's move on to the
- 9:14Gaza. What is happening there means I
- 9:17just read statements from both the parties and both our parties
- 9:21we are reaching towards a solution, towards some sort of,
- 9:24you know.