Latest / I Love You Keep Going with George Haas / Attachment Healing Practices: Meditative Tools to Feel Safe in Relationships
Transcript
- 0:01You're listening to the I Love You, Keep Going podcast with
- 0:04George Haas. For more information, please
- 0:06visit our website at www.medigroup.org.
- 0:10That's www.m ETTAGROU p.org. So welcome everybody, this is I
- 0:19love you. Keep going.
- 0:20It is Thursday, February 20th, 2025 at 7:36 PM Pacific Time.
- 0:26And today I, I thought I might talk a little bit about the
- 0:30dynamics of secure functioning relationships and in particular,
- 0:35particular around the aspect of safety or the, the feeling of
- 0:39safety in a secure functioning relationship.
- 0:44And what I would say is that this is really a a conversation
- 0:48about conflict resolution strategies and how they
- 0:54different differ person to person.
- 0:56You really grow up in a family system.
- 1:00And for most of us, we observe the way the adults in the, in
- 1:07the environment that we have access to present conflict and
- 1:11then also resolve conflict and in secure functioning
- 1:15relationships because the tenants, the main tenant of the
- 1:19relationship is this agreement where I take care of you in the
- 1:22way that you need to be taken care of and you take care of me
- 1:26in the way that I need to be taken care of.
- 1:29There is a lot of negotiation around how each person's
- 1:35conflict system operates. And then how do you integrate
- 1:40them? What you'll discover, I think,
- 1:43is that sometimes your conflict resolution system and the other
- 1:48person's conflict resolution system just mesh pretty well,
- 1:53and sometimes you'll find that there's a lot of difficulty in
- 1:56trying to bridge the two different strategies and so that
- 2:00they can come into agreement. If you're looking at a secure
- 2:07functioning relationship, what you're also looking at is a
- 2:10foundation of epistemic trust. Epistemic trust means that you
- 2:16believe what the person is telling you, and you believe
- 2:21that the reason that they're telling you what they're telling
- 2:23you is meant to be helpful to you.
- 2:25So there is a consideration of your needs in it, in the
- 2:28expression of that. And when we lose epistemic
- 2:32trust, it means that we either don't think that the person is
- 2:35telling us the truth or the we don't think that they have our
- 2:38interest in mind. And at that point, you can't
- 2:42learn. The, the reason it's called
- 2:44epistemic trust is because you can learn from the person who
- 2:47you believe is telling you the truth and who has your interest
- 2:51in mind. And you can't learn from
- 2:53somebody who you don't believe that to be true because you have
- 2:56to be defensive, You have to be protected.
- 3:02And so in a relationship where you're actually in a
- 3:05collaborative intimate exchange, you have to feel safe to be
- 3:09willing to be authentic and intimate.
- 3:11And if you don't believe that, you are defended.
- 3:15And it is then either transactional or in the
- 3:19disorganized end of attachment, a trauma bond.
- 3:25So I was always, I say this, I think every time I talk about
- 3:28it, but I just love the metaphor that Dan Brown used of for every
- 3:32bite mark, there's a set of teeth.
- 3:34And if you have a lot of trouble, what you're looking for
- 3:37is people whose teeth, whose teeth match your bite marks so
- 3:41that you you have an understanding about who they are
- 3:45and what they're capable of in secure, functioning
- 3:50relationships. One of the ways that safety is
- 3:53established is through these small offerings of trust.
- 4:00You make a small offering of trust and then you see how
- 4:03somebody does with that. What it what would a small
- 4:06offering of trust be, for example?
- 4:09Well, you make an agreement to go out to dinner and you say
- 4:13that you'll meet at a restaurant at 7:30 and when, when you get
- 4:16it to the restaurant at 7:25, there they are waiting for you
- 4:20to get there, right? Or they come at 7:30 or a few
- 4:23minutes late, whatever it is, but that they're there and they,
- 4:28they follow through on the things that they say they're
- 4:31going to do it in such a way that you don't worry about it.
- 4:34Once they say that they're going to do it, you just accept that
- 4:37that's their intention. It's likely to happen.
- 4:41And when they say they're that, that they're not going to do
- 4:43something, you don't worry about it because they don't do that.
- 4:46They don't deceive you in a way or manipulate you in any way.
- 4:54They tell you what they're going to do and not do and then they
- 4:57they do that. And so you don't really have to
- 4:59think about it. And it's consistent.
- 5:00It's reliable. That making sense.
- 5:04Small pieces of trust in insecure or disorganized
- 5:09relationships. There is some utility for the
- 5:14relationship in not having that, a sense of reliability.
- 5:18You don't know whether somebody's going to show up.
- 5:22There's a lot of energy, a lot of anxiety about whether they'll
- 5:25show up. When they do show up, there's a
- 5:26massive blast of dopamine that they've showed up or when they
- 5:31don't show up, there's a massive blast of adrenaline and cortisol
- 5:36and noradrenaline. All of these chemicals that feel
- 5:40intense, that feel lively, but it also consumes all of the
- 5:46energy of the relation, all of the energy that's available that
- 5:51you might use for exploration. If you have anxiety about
- 5:56exploration. What you really want is a is a,
- 6:00a reason not to be able to not to be able to explore so that
- 6:06that you accept, right that that you can use as justification for
- 6:10why you do it and not blame yourself for the fact that you
- 6:14don't do it. That making sense.
- 6:20So those little pieces of trust and then what you begin to do is
- 6:32present conflict in the relationship in a way that you
- 6:40can collaboratively and creatively solve the dilemma of
- 6:46the conflict in a way that feels like a win win for both people.
- 6:53One of the things about insecure, disorganized
- 6:56relationships, because there's often a power imbalance in the
- 6:59relationship, One party can impose on the other party a
- 7:02solution to a conflict that the other party actually can't live
- 7:05with. And the main way that that's
- 7:07done is by, as I like to say, throwing down the big A card,
- 7:11the big abandonment card. Either you do it this way or I'm
- 7:15out of here. So you throw down the
- 7:18abandonment cart for somebody who's attached to and they they
- 7:21capitulate. Everybody does.
- 7:23It's not something that really is unusual.
- 7:29But after a little while of trying to live with the deal
- 7:32that you feel like you're losing and you can't do it after a
- 7:34while. And so the the conflict
- 7:36resurfaces in the relationship and then if you negotiate it
- 7:41again in a way that there is a strong power and balance or both
- 7:44people don't feel committed to the solution that's come up, but
- 7:48it doesn't feel like a real win win.
- 7:51Then you capitulate or one person capitulates, but after a
- 7:56while they can't live with it and so it resurfaces.
- 7:59So what you notice the main differences between a securely
- 8:04negotiated solutions to conflict and the integration of the two
- 8:09people's conflict resolution systems is that in a secure way
- 8:17of negotiating, negotiating, it's a good faith negotiation
- 8:22and there's a creative solution to the integration.
- 8:25And it feels like a strong win for both parties so that they're
- 8:29both willing to maintain it over the long period.
- 8:34And if you do that, of course, those conflicts drop out of the
- 8:37relationships because they're settled.
- 8:40They don't rise up again because one person can't continue on
- 8:45with the bad agreement. Is that making sense?
- 8:49And the more of those that you do, the less conflict there is
- 8:52in the relationship, The steadier it gets, the smoother
- 8:55it gets. There's also no highs and lows
- 8:59that come from wondering whether somebody's actually going to
- 9:03show up for you or not. And one of the things that
- 9:06insecure and disorganized people have the hardest time with his
- 9:09giving up the highs and lows because it feels so much like
- 9:15love. It feels so much like a lively
- 9:20engagement. But what is not factored into
- 9:25this is the exploration piece that all of that energy that's
- 9:29consumed in stabilizing the relationship is then not
- 9:33available for the exploration, and that that those really real
- 9:37highs in life tend to come reliably from exploration, not
- 9:44from a relationship. The relationships are essential,
- 9:49of course, in supporting you so that you can take the big risks
- 9:53in your exploration so that you can find the meaning that you
- 9:56need to find and that if you don't have that, you don't take
- 10:01the risks that you might need to and so you find less meaning in
- 10:05exploration. It's not like we can just
- 10:13abandoned exploration and settle for.
- 10:22Unexamined life. There's a literary phrase about
- 10:26that. Something about the unexamined
- 10:28life is not worth living. Who did?
- 10:32You were just mentioning about the excuse for not exploring.
- 10:36Yeah. You reiterate that part and
- 10:40versus the person's attachment system being on, so he's not
- 10:44capable of exploring the differentiation.
- 10:47Is that the same thing? Well, the secure people have
- 10:53this dance that's pretty well established in the way that
- 10:58they're, they're a personality is structured that when they're
- 11:03frightened and perceive abandonment or some kind of
- 11:06threat, the attachment system engages and they see proximity
- 11:11to their attachment people. And then when they feel
- 11:16connected and safe, it turns off and the exploration system turns
- 11:19on. And then the different
- 11:21detachment strategies have different relationships to that,
- 11:26that toggle switch of attachment and exploration.
- 11:31People who grow up to be dismissing suppress the
- 11:34attachment system. And so it doesn't really turn
- 11:37on. So that leaves their exploration
- 11:40system to be on. But because they've grown up
- 11:43typically in households where they have to idealize what the
- 11:49caregivers want of them, and the caregivers often find that the
- 11:53authentic expression of the child is unacceptable.
- 11:57The dismissing person really holds very closely and hidden
- 12:01what's essentially what essentially matters to them.
- 12:05And they engage instead in secondary exploration, which is
- 12:10the gathering of time, energy, and resources to transact the
- 12:14care that they want. But they rarely let anybody in
- 12:20on what's really essentially authentic for them, which also
- 12:25means they don't explore the part that's essentially
- 12:29authentic because it's too painful to reveal it and then to
- 12:37attempt to pursue it. And so the solution for
- 12:42dismissing people is to begin to present themselves authentically
- 12:47and overcome the strong expectation of the rejection of
- 12:54the their authentic core self from other people and shift out
- 13:01of the secondary exploration into some kind of primary
- 13:06exploration where actually what they're doing is organized
- 13:10around meaning. But in the long way that I'm
- 13:20answering your question, if you're dismissing person and the
- 13:25the primary material is so well protected, the and the, the
- 13:31utility of the secondary exploration is essential in
- 13:39terms of transacting care. You have to have resources in
- 13:42order to transact care and you don't believe that anybody would
- 13:45just do that for you. The excuse that you use for not
- 13:51doing the primary exploration is that you have to gather the
- 13:54resources in order to to be taken care of.
- 13:58That that feels essential. Even when even when the
- 14:08resources are abundant, it still feels essential, which is the
- 14:13excuse not to do the primary exploration.
- 14:17And actually because there's been so little attention and
- 14:21investigation into what is primary, that may not even
- 14:26register that that would be something to explore rather than
- 14:30something just to protect. Makes sense.
- 14:35Preoccupied people, on the other hand, have the experience in
- 14:38childhood of their exploration being interfered with or limited
- 14:44in some way. You know, and it.
- 14:49Preoccupied people come in two main directions. 1 is the
- 14:54helpless end of it, and one is the controlling end of it.
- 14:58Let's say that you grew up in a household where your caregiver
- 15:01was a controlling, preoccupied person.
- 15:04They would so micromanage everything that you attempted to
- 15:08do and interfere with all of the development of the ways that you
- 15:15might do it. By insisting that you do it in
- 15:17the way that they think it would be done, that you lose any sense
- 15:22of being able to explore on your own, or any sense of how you
- 15:26would discover the way to do it. That would make sense, and you'd
- 15:29be in this bind that is both controlled and helpless.
- 15:34You're helpless to figure out the way that you might do it.
- 15:37That would be satisfying. And you have to satisfy the
- 15:40person that's in control or there's conflict.
- 15:43And so you abandon any sense of your own exploration in favor of
- 15:50this trap of control being controlled and helpless at the
- 15:56same time. On the helpless end of it, you
- 16:00simply recognize that the way to gather attention from your
- 16:05caregivers is by being helpless. And the way that that appears is
- 16:09really that the child presents himself as helpless and then the
- 16:13caregiver does it. Have you ever been around a
- 16:17caregiver who a child is asking for a question or asking for
- 16:22help to do something and the caregiver just pushes them aside
- 16:26and does that does it for them, which is emphasizing the
- 16:32helplessness of the child. So of course, if a child did
- 16:41break out of that, an attempt to explore on their own, which
- 16:45often happens what they're, they encounter when they return from
- 16:48their exploration. And in, in that exchange of
- 16:51exploration that we are all looking for, you know, you go
- 16:56out and you explore and you discover something and you come
- 16:59back to the people that are close to you and you tell them
- 17:02what you've discovered. And what you're hoping for, of
- 17:05course, is that they're interested in it, They're
- 17:08engaged in it. They're delighted that you're
- 17:10telling them because it's useful to them that you've discovered
- 17:14this and they love your point of view and your, your take on
- 17:18things, which is different than theirs.
- 17:20And because it gives them a, an expanded view of something that
- 17:24enriches their experience. But in the, the childhood of
- 17:29somebody who is, has the demand of being helpless, that attempts
- 17:36to explore, when they come back, of course they're punished for
- 17:38it. And so they begin to associate a
- 17:42loss of affection with exploration and succeeding and
- 17:47discovering what you need to know.
- 17:52And that creates this cycle of procrastination, or that's
- 17:58mainly how we think of it, procrastination or fear of
- 18:02success. The closer you get to
- 18:05succeeding, the greater the anxiety is, the anxieties about
- 18:09making yourself unlovable. It's not about whether the task
- 18:13is finished or not, or even about how the task is received.
- 18:16That is, if you finish something, if you explore
- 18:19something and you come back and you want to express it, you're
- 18:24going to be punished for doing that.
- 18:28And so you delay the punishment by delaying the the finishing of
- 18:34whatever it is that you're working on.
- 18:36Judy, hi. Troy Hi everyone, Is this also a
- 18:42Dharma class? This one.
- 18:46This is actually a Dharma class, yeah.
- 18:48Oh great, and. You're wondering how we're going
- 18:50to get there. I have that in mind.
- 18:59Oh, great, great. Hey.
- 19:03Did you have a question beyond that?
- 19:06I guess I am interested to about your Dharma lineage.
- 19:10I vaguely have an impression you study Theravada and Bon.
- 19:16Yes, both of those are true. So you study RB Dharma as well?
- 19:23I have. Oh wonderful, because I have an
- 19:28interest in learning it. Oh, I probably am not the
- 19:32teacher for that I. Started meditating in the 60s.
- 19:44I'm in my 70s so it's a long history, but I don't but I will
- 19:51give you the the sort of later part in in 92, I moved to LA
- 19:56from New York. In New York, I was really mainly
- 20:00involved in Trump Rinpoche's teaching and.
- 20:13But when I got out here, I studied at a place called
- 20:16Ordinary Dharma with Katyana Reid and Michelle.
- 20:24I think benzamin is how you say her last name.
- 20:27And they taught Teknad Han version of, I would say Zen
- 20:36Theravadin because you know, Technet harness was a Zen
- 20:41practitioner, but they, but they taught mindfulness basically.
- 20:47But I, I, I didn't find enough of a sense of safety there.
- 20:55And I, I would, I should really say that it, it had nothing to
- 20:59do with Katiana and the, the song.
- 21:01It's that I was really not able to integrate very well into
- 21:06different groups of people. And, and I agree, I have such a
- 21:13high standard of kindness from a teacher that the, the, the Zen
- 21:22brusque approach was, was too unkind for me.
- 21:28I, I couldn't bear it. And so I became a Dharma orphan,
- 21:35which I had been quite a bit, I would say most of my Dharma life
- 21:39I've been a Dharma orphan. A Dharma orphan is a teacherless
- 21:44student who attempts to understand the teaching of the
- 21:48Dharma through books and and personal practice without
- 21:55actually having any coaching. I strongly recommend actually
- 21:59that you don't do the Dharma orphan path or do as little as
- 22:04you can because you go so much faster if you have a teacher
- 22:09that you can listen to. In 1998 I started to study with
- 22:17Shinzen and Shinzen was absolutely kind enough for me
- 22:22and and disengaged enough for me that I didn't feel any pressure
- 22:27in terms of participating. And the the song have felt safe
- 22:31to me. And so I studied there for 25
- 22:34years and at at one time was a VSI facilitator.
- 22:43VSI is the Pasta Support Institute, which is his
- 22:46organization. Then I started to study at
- 22:52Against the Stream Buddhist Meditation Society, which was
- 22:54Noah Levine's group and I did teacher training there and and
- 22:58became an empowered meditation teacher through them.
- 23:03And there they were at that time part of the spirit rock lineage.
- 23:08And so the teaching was Terravada and a combination of
- 23:18the the different Tibetan practices practitioners that
- 23:23came through and Upadita and and the so the Vipassan approach and
- 23:31the loving kindness meta approach that Sharon Salzberg
- 23:35was teaching. And then in 2017 I started to
- 23:42study Bonn with Dan Brown. And mainly my personal practice
- 23:50is organized around Ma Mudra from from the bottom lineage.
- 23:59How's that good? I'm, I'm, I, I do prefer the to
- 24:15describe things in Buddhist terms rather than in mindfulness
- 24:18terms. Because you'll notice in Western
- 24:21particular in, in United States, in Buddhism, because we have our
- 24:27culture is the culture of appropriation.
- 24:31We just grab everything from everywhere, assemble it in its
- 24:36own thing and discard everything that we don't like.
- 24:38And so we have these kinds of mash ups of teachings that are
- 24:42really all of the lineages from everywhere rolled up into one
- 24:46thing. And then all of the terms are
- 24:48secularized. So you don't really have any
- 24:50idea at all what, what it is that's being taught to you under
- 24:54the, the rubric of mindfulness. So I am not an empowered bond
- 25:01teacher. When I said to Dan, I think I
- 25:05would like to become an empowered bond teacher.
- 25:08And he said, oh, no, no, you're, you're way too old.
- 25:14I said, really, how old do you have to be?
- 25:16And he he said, well, it takes 20 years to become a teacher and
- 25:24how old are you? And I said at the time I was 65.
- 25:29And he said, so you'll be 85 when you start teaching.
- 25:33We want to get 20 years of teaching out of you.
- 25:35So you're going to be 105 when you retire from teaching.
- 25:41I said no, I hope to be long dead by the time I'm 105.
- 25:49So he said we only take people in their 20s so that when in
- 25:52their 40s they emerge as a teacher, then we can get 20
- 25:58years of teaching out of them before they retire in their 60s.
- 26:02So that that was fine. So I teach what I I'm empowered
- 26:08to teach, and I don't teach. But I'm not empowered to teach
- 26:10because somewhere along the way I figured out that it's OK to
- 26:14follow the rules. Because that makes people feel
- 26:23safe, which is where we really started, right, With this whole
- 26:27conversation. If you feel safe with me
- 26:31teaching that, what that really means is you believe that I'm
- 26:35telling you the truth, right? That I'm intending to tell you
- 26:39the truth. And that the reason I'm telling
- 26:41you what I'm telling is because I'm intending to be helpful to
- 26:44you. And I'm not trying to get
- 26:45something from you that would be satisfying in some way to me
- 26:50that you would not, if you knew that that's what I wanted from
- 26:54you wouldn't want to give it to me, which would be some kind of
- 26:57manipulation, which I, I really don't do.
- 27:00And I'm, I'm so hyper vigilant around that because I grew up
- 27:08in, in such an exploitive, painful, harmful household that
- 27:15I, I can't bear the idea of doing it to, to anyone.
- 27:22And so I want to talk about. And the reason that I teach the
- 27:29way that I do and that you would ask the question about whether
- 27:31this is actually a Dharma talk or not is I want to do my job as
- 27:37the teacher, which is to transliterate the teachings
- 27:42through me and my experience and then language it in a way that
- 27:46is relevant to our culture. I don't, I have never found the,
- 27:55the poetry of 2500 years ago compelling as a source of
- 28:02information was it was too hard to translate it into what was
- 28:05relevant for me and and also relevant for the people who
- 28:10study with me. So I like to talk about it in,
- 28:14in, in the, the, the terms of our, our current culture.
- 28:21So that's mainly why I do this in, in the West.
- 28:26Of course, the way that we talk about resolving issues of
- 28:30personality is through psychology and psychology
- 28:35references. When I was talking to Dan about
- 28:39this, he said that what he thought actually was going to be
- 28:43the best benefit for the people in the West was a translation of
- 28:48the Buddhist teaching into Western psychological terms.
- 28:53And I know that that's something that some people appreciate and
- 28:59some people don't appreciate. In lineage holdings, there's
- 29:09often a a conflict around this. And I can give you an example of
- 29:13that related to the abidama. When I was in Mirren Mirror
- 29:18studying with Indica say it out, he presented the metagenas and
- 29:29compared them to the the posenagenas and the stages of
- 29:34that. And then the following day some
- 29:37western nuns presented the same thing, but they presented a
- 29:44different series of stages for Vipassana John.
- 29:50That is to say, he presented the The framework of the Vipassana
- 29:57John is from the Buddhist Canon and they presented the frame for
- 30:02the the positive John is from the Abidama, which are
- 30:06different. And so, you know, being a smart
- 30:10ass, I raised my hand and I asked the sad why there was a
- 30:15contradiction in the teaching between the two and which one he
- 30:20preferred. And he said that he preferred
- 30:23the language of the Abidama, but that he was a monastic in the
- 30:28lineage and had to teach the Canon because that was what the
- 30:32lineage demanded. Is that making sense?
- 30:40I am not constrained in that way.
- 30:43So I I'm free to make up a language of the teaching.
- 30:48And I think one of the things in the West that we're all looking
- 30:52for is somebody who relates the Dharma to us in a language that
- 30:57we can understand the meaning. And this is really one of the
- 31:01essential pieces in terms of the sense of safety that you have
- 31:05with somebody. You understand what it is that
- 31:09you want to what what you understand the experience that
- 31:13you are having. You understand what about that
- 31:17you want to express to somebody else and then you you
- 31:21transliterated into terms that they can understand what you're
- 31:26talking about. And then you receive from them
- 31:29their reaction to the teaching that you've offered, ensuring
- 31:35that you understand that they've understood you and, and you
- 31:38understand what their responses so that you can modify your
- 31:42understanding of the relationship in a way that then
- 31:45moves the, the understanding between you and the intimacy
- 31:49between you forward. Is that making sense?
- 31:53But when it comes to having a Dharma teacher, you want to, I
- 31:57think you want to have somebody where you don't have to
- 31:58transliterate it that much, right?
- 32:01Because it's too easy to get lost in the different meanings
- 32:07that each of us have. We don't live in a world of
- 32:11what's happening and we don't really share the experience of
- 32:15what's happening. We live in a world of what it
- 32:18means to us based on our particular conditioning.
- 32:21And what we're attempting to do is relate our conditioned
- 32:26response to things to somebody else and their conditioned
- 32:30response to something else. That's actually what that
- 32:33communication is. And so in the West, I really
- 32:38think that the preliminary practices are to be able to
- 32:41understand that because they begin to represent the obstacles
- 32:47to fruition on the path. And so you can have a dialogue
- 32:53of what is the ground or what is the groundless ground?
- 32:57What is the ground, you might say, of your condition, and how
- 33:03does it relate to the ground of my conditioning?
- 33:05So that we can begin to recognize the obstacles that are
- 33:09between our understanding each other.
- 33:14And if we can then remove those obstacles, we can actually
- 33:17succeed in relating to each other in a way that's intimate
- 33:21and caring. And we can actually learn how to
- 33:24take care of each other and then take on that obligation.
- 33:29Really the, the function of secure relationships is you take
- 33:34on the obligation to take care of somebody in the way that they
- 33:38need and they take on the obligation to take care of you
- 33:42in the way that you need. And there's that mutuality to it
- 33:45so that you're both well taken care of.
- 33:47What do you get out of that? You get a a caregiver for
- 33:51yourself who's really well taken care of, and they get a
- 33:54caregiver for themselves who's really well taken care of so
- 33:57that you can provide that care in an easy, ongoing way.
- 34:03Makes sense. So that we could be talking
- 34:08about, for instance, lust, or we could be talking about craving
- 34:13an aversion, or we could talk about restlessness and
- 34:16agitation, or we could talk about sloth and torp.
- 34:19Or we could talk about equanimity.
- 34:22But we could also talk about the view of an attachment strategy
- 34:26and its conditioning and how it makes the view of the world look
- 34:31to you, and how that view causes you to relate to other people in
- 34:36a way. And it seems to me to be richer
- 34:40to do the latter than than it is to talk about the poetry of 2
- 34:491/2 millennia ago. So that's my my preference.
- 34:55Obviously not for everyone, but for some people it works pretty
- 35:00well. That makes sense.
- 35:06So how do you feel safe in a relationship?
- 35:08You feel safe in a relationship because you believe that
- 35:13somebody's telling you the truth and you believe that they have
- 35:15your interest in mind. And you believe that if you show
- 35:20them in a vulnerable way what is authentically true for you, that
- 35:27they will receive that and often delight in who you are.
- 35:31That's how it goes. But in order to get there, you
- 35:35have to be able to go in these little steps.
- 35:38Now in order to be able to understand that, you have to be
- 35:42able to practice in a way that that is illuminated for you.
- 35:47And so one of the the practices that I really like in terms of
- 35:51understanding this is the metajana practice that
- 35:56Indigasaida taught because it teaches how to monitor view.
- 36:04Does that make sense? So we have the capacity to sense
- 36:09the object that can be sensed. When there's contact,
- 36:11consciousness of the sensing experience arises.
- 36:15It's evaluated for urgency. Does it need immediate
- 36:17attention? Does it not matter whether we
- 36:19get to it? Is there time for a pleasant
- 36:22experience? And then it's mapped on to the
- 36:24perceptual database. And if there's a meaning in the
- 36:29database that matches closely enough, that whole meeting
- 36:33thread is attached and it rolls into conceptual reality.
- 36:39Between ultimate reality and conceptual reality is a place
- 36:42where the views go and the views can be distorting.
- 36:46So we might say if the mind is filled with lust, it's as if, as
- 36:53the Buddha used the metaphor of a mirror, which was a bowl of
- 36:56water, the water is dyed a bright color.
- 36:58And so we don't experience anything directly.
- 37:01We experience it as a reflection off the the surface of the mind.
- 37:08And if the bowl is dyed a bright color, then the image that's
- 37:11reflected off the surface of the mind is filled with bright
- 37:15colors. You might say, in Western
- 37:17psychology, we might say glow, that the person in front of you
- 37:21is glowing because you recognize in them the likelihood that they
- 37:27will take care of you in the way that you understand what love
- 37:31is, which comes from the definitions of your family
- 37:34system. And so if you grew up in an
- 37:37insecure, a disorganized family system, what you're recognizing
- 37:42is somebody who will take care of you in the way that you were
- 37:45taken care of in your insecure disorganized family system,
- 37:49which might not be the ultimate choice for a secure
- 37:54relationship, but certainly they're glowing, right?
- 37:57Can you recognize when the mind is there or not?
- 38:04You might say that the mind is aversive or angry or filled with
- 38:10aversion. And then notice that the the way
- 38:14that the world appears to you, the way that other people appear
- 38:17to you, the way that you appear to yourself is distorted from an
- 38:23an economist point of view. Or is the mind restless?
- 38:27And how does that affect things? Is the mind filled with soft and
- 38:31torpor? Is the mind economist.
- 38:37So we wanted we want to track view.
- 38:39So the way that you track view and and the way that we practice
- 38:43is by doing love and kindness and learning to track the view
- 38:47of love and kindness. And in learning to track a
- 38:49particular view of loving kindness, you begin to recognize
- 38:54other views. Then you develop the agency to
- 39:00control which view you allow in the mind.
- 39:02The Buddha said that you want to guard the sense gates, you don't
- 39:07want to just leave them open so that any kind of experience can
- 39:11arise from that and then we need to understand our thought
- 39:16processes. The Buddha also talked about
- 39:18suppressing afflictive thinking in five levels, the first of
- 39:23which is simply straight up thought replacement.
- 39:27The third level, which is one of my favourites, is to shout the
- 39:31beneficial phrase louder in the mind than the mind is shouting
- 39:35the afflictive phrase. And the fifth one is to
- 39:41annihilate the afflicted thought at any cost, which I also
- 39:45thought was pretty good. Christian, I don't know if
- 39:51you've noticed, but the the level of violence is going up as
- 39:54the positivity is going up to. I don't know much much more than
- 40:02annihilate what comes after that love and kindness.
- 40:15I have a question about this. My question is, it makes sense
- 40:22to have like my understanding is to have good karma that take up
- 40:28the space so that it squeezes the back karma out out of down
- 40:33the line so that back karma is not ripening cause all the good
- 40:36karma is taking up space. And, and however, when we're
- 40:45talking about the annihilation and shouting, that is only like
- 40:57an attempt to replacing the bad karma of good karma, right?
- 41:00Because my my experience with observing negative afflictive
- 41:05emotion, especially in my clients is that the more they
- 41:09try to get rid of it that avoid which has something to do with
- 41:12they they are bad with emotional regulation, the more the bad
- 41:16karma actually stays and it gets stronger.
- 41:20You are thinking that emotion and thought and thinking are
- 41:28necessary the same, so you replace an afflictive thought.
- 41:36I'm a terrible person with a positive thought.
- 41:41I'm a good person. And if the mind doesn't just
- 41:46simply allow the swap, then you, the mind is saying I'm a bad
- 41:50person, I'm a bad person. And then you're in the chorus
- 41:52going no, you're a good person. No, you're a good person.
- 41:55No, you're a good person. The the activity of thinking.
- 42:04So the auditory visual thinking is 1 aspect and the emotion is
- 42:09another aspect. And they are omnidirectional in
- 42:11terms of their reactivity. But what the Buddha is talking
- 42:14about is the the the cognitive process, not the emotional
- 42:18process in that. OK.
- 42:22So policing your cognitive sense gate in a way that makes sense.
- 42:32That makes. Sense and also when we explore
- 42:36this with the different meditation strategies that we
- 42:39use, you have an emotion, the emotion exceeds the window of
- 42:45tolerance. And so you have an emotional
- 42:47event that needs to be regulated and then the mind switches on
- 42:51the thought pattern that you use to regulate the the thought
- 42:55that's exceeded the window of tolerance.
- 42:58And you learn that thought process in your family system as
- 43:02part of the conflict resolution system and how the your family
- 43:06manages that. And so then what you want to do
- 43:11is examine that. So part of this process is to
- 43:14examine the thought patterns that you use to regulate and
- 43:18then prevent yourself from using the afflictive strategy and
- 43:21insisting that the mind use a beneficial strategy instead,
- 43:24which would be a of a kindness technique, say, or a noting
- 43:28feeling states technique. And so each time you notice that
- 43:31the mind is using a, a negative anger generating thought, you
- 43:35prevent the mind from thinking that and you insist that the
- 43:39mind think a positive thought that generates a positive
- 43:44emotional response rather than say anger or fear or sadness.
- 43:52Neither thought is true, right? The thought that you're thinking
- 43:55to regulate the reaction to the present moment.
- 43:57Neither one of them is actually more than just a strategy to
- 44:02calm and regulate the mind. Which one is better?
- 44:04It's really the whole discussion.
- 44:07I see, that makes sense. So would it.
- 44:15Sorry to jump back on the safety piece, you were all, I think you
- 44:18almost reached at the disorganized stage of things.
- 44:23And I was wondering if the protocol of the three pillar
- 44:27approach is the only way and it's a very solo adventure,
- 44:32especially for working with people.
- 44:34I mean, I thought it's like the IPF, Do you see patients or
- 44:40suddenly doing IPF or the three pillar approach and feeling safe
- 44:44in everyday environment? The using ideal parent figure
- 44:54protocol to help a disorganized person overcome the perception
- 44:59that they're in danger is about visualizing protection.
- 45:06So the they visualize the ideal parent figures protecting them
- 45:10in all situations, and they visualize ideal parent figures
- 45:14as powerful enough to protect them in any situation or
- 45:18powerful enough to get them out of a bad situation.
- 45:23One of the things that characterizes disorganized
- 45:27people as dissociation, but what also characterizes disorganized
- 45:33people is a constant intrusion of past trauma.
- 45:38And so there needs to be some attention to that as well so
- 45:41that you can begin to resolve some of those intrusions.
- 45:46The reason why the intrusions are so difficult to manage
- 45:50usually is because they're dissociative states.
- 45:54So they're timeless and out of order in terms of the the
- 46:00timeline so that they can be experienced as if the threat is
- 46:04real now rather than the threat was something that was in the
- 46:07past. And so the, the that protection
- 46:13piece is necessary, but also in disorganized people,
- 46:18dissociation is the primary means of emotional regulation.
- 46:21So you have to teach robust emotional regulation strategies
- 46:27that you can use to replace a dissociation as the primary
- 46:30means. And that's the meditation stuff.
- 46:33Again, meditation based emotional regulation strategies
- 46:39that they can develop through practice that they can then use
- 46:44instead of the dissociation to regulate the present moment
- 46:47experience. The for disorganized people to
- 46:54feel safe, they would have to to be willing to present themselves
- 46:58authentically to somebody else. And because they're afraid that
- 47:03if they they express themselves authentically, the person will
- 47:07exploit them and harm them. They don't because it's too
- 47:15great of a risk. And So what needs to happen
- 47:18there is to develop the sense that you can pick people who
- 47:22will be harmful to you and people who won't be harmful to
- 47:26you. One of the reasons why
- 47:29disorganized people are convinced that they're going to
- 47:32be hurt over and over again, it's because they're so
- 47:35defensive in the way that they relate to other people that
- 47:40those defenses defeat almost everybody except people who are
- 47:44predators, because the predators are used to having to breakdown
- 47:48that level of defence in order to get in.
- 47:51And so for disorganized people, they they eliminate
- 47:54relationships with everyone else because nobody else is willing
- 47:58to attempt to get through the defenses.
- 48:01And so they end up in relationships over and over
- 48:05again with people who are willing to batter down the
- 48:08defenses to get in or they get seduced by it.
- 48:16One of the one of the chief means of seduction of
- 48:19disorganized people is kindness, because they overvalue kindness.
- 48:26They grew up in such astonishingly cruel environments
- 48:31where kindness was rare. They value kindness as a rarity
- 48:38and so that if you express it to them, they feel it's, you know,
- 48:41the almost tearful that you, you're expressing kindness to
- 48:46them. But if you grow up in a secure
- 48:49household, kindness is like air, it's like water.
- 48:52It is common, it is ordinary. It is the whole structure of
- 48:57the, the relationship basically. And so it's that is a more
- 49:02appropriate valuing than this, you know, this deeply moving
- 49:07expression and feeling that comes from really ordinary
- 49:13levels of kindness, if that makes sense.
- 49:18So you they're easily seduced through expressions of kindness,
- 49:22but they're also very defended and, and nobody sticks around
- 49:31for that level of defense really, except for other
- 49:33disorganized people, really, because you get a pass for that
- 49:40from another disorganized person 'cause they're doing it too.
- 49:45Funny insight that came to my mind recently is, you know,
- 49:48coming from India, where it's very ordinary for a rural or a
- 49:52normal person to express their protection through God.
- 49:56Like if you meet somebody, you're like, Oh no, it's, you
- 49:59know, this is very stressful, but I know God will take care of
- 50:03it. Right.
- 50:05And it's very, it's like a very common saying, like, you know,
- 50:08even my mom sometimes, like, you know, like she will take care of
- 50:11it. And I realized from that point
- 50:13of view, it's actually more secure, it's more protection
- 50:17giving than somebody who's an atheist who doesn't believe in
- 50:20anything and who's disorganized will be struggling much more.
- 50:25That is an expression of the expectation of a positive
- 50:27outcome, right? You expect it to turn out well
- 50:32because God is going to take care of it.
- 50:35Like it's like the same as IPF in some sense, right?
- 50:38You're visualizing a protective figure.
- 50:40Right. Who's going to take it from that
- 50:42point of view? The people there would be
- 50:45happier than an atheist. Who's?
- 50:47So you feel safe. Yeah, you feel safe and
- 50:50protected. Imaginary.
- 50:51Yeah. So I thought it was pretty cool.
- 51:02George, can you say more about the peripheral memory that you
- 51:07mentioned? And then is meditation a unique
- 51:10strategy to access that memory? And if IPF can be replaced with
- 51:16watching very wholesome movies or TV shows, since that's also
- 51:21fictional and imaginary. So intrusive memory is what you
- 51:30mean. Oh, no, peripheral memory.
- 51:33You said something about. Is it called peripheral memory?
- 51:38I said intrusive I think. Did I?
- 51:42From first class of level 1 you said something about.
- 51:46There's two types of memory. One is automatic, 1 is something
- 51:50start with. School.
- 51:51OK, I I got you now one is procedural.
- 51:57Procedural. One is autobiographical.
- 52:03Procedural memory is unconscious and autobiographical memory is
- 52:07conscious and the org and really the foundation of the self
- 52:11experience. Procedural memory is when you
- 52:18get up to walk across the room, do you have to think which
- 52:22muscles to trigger to get you to stand up and then which muscles
- 52:25to trigger to walk yourself across the room?
- 52:27You probably don't. That's procedural, do you?
- 52:32Do you have to remember how to drive a car?
- 52:34Do you remember how you learned to drive a car?
- 52:36If you can drive a car, right? 10:10 and 2:00 on the wheel and
- 52:42looking at the mirrors, looking all around and, you know,
- 52:46lurching forward, slamming on the brake, lurching forward,
- 52:48slamming on the brake. I taught my friend Mark Ellen
- 52:52to, to drive stick and she would inevitably stall and flood the
- 52:56car and we would have. So we'd lurch forward and have
- 52:59to sit there for 5 minutes so that she'd lurch forward and
- 53:03we'd have to sit there for 5 minutes.
- 53:05And we both found that hilarious.
- 53:08So really what we would do is lurch forward, stall blood and
- 53:14laugh for 5 minutes. And so it was a very pleasant
- 53:17experience to do it. But the people behind us, we're
- 53:20not so entertained. But eventually she could drive
- 53:27the stick, smoke a cigarette and drink a coffee and steer with
- 53:31her knee and it was all fine, right?
- 53:34That's that's procedural them. So the question then about those
- 53:40two? Like like you mentioned
- 53:47something in first class of level one that how meditation is
- 53:51very important, something about how it's fast enough so that you
- 53:56update the procedural memory. Is that how that works?
- 53:59Yeah. So meditation works at the
- 54:01procedural memory level. It doesn't work at the
- 54:04autobiographical memory level. You can sit there and think you
- 54:08have a, you've had a terrible meditation period and then
- 54:11nothing is happening and it's worthless.
- 54:13But then you'll notice that you're just different because
- 54:16the perceptual procedural memory has been changed, whereas the
- 54:20autobiographical memory just had a painful, unpleasant sit.
- 54:24So they're two different things. And meditation tends to change
- 54:28the perceptual database, and ideal parent figure changes the
- 54:33perceptual database. It doesn't do so much for the
- 54:35autobiographical memory because the self experience largely
- 54:39stays the same. You're what you notice if you do
- 54:44the work is that you're acting completely different than you
- 54:47used to act, and there's no explanation for it because the
- 54:50self experience is largely the same.
- 54:52You're just sort of going, I'm I'm doing something completely
- 54:56different than I have heard of before.
- 54:57It's just how it goes in that working because you're changing
- 55:02the database that you use to create the meaning of the
- 55:07present moment. And so, and admittedly these
- 55:12little visualizations that you stack into the database are just
- 55:19imagine imaginary, but the way that the the human body mind
- 55:26resolves novel experiences by using the imagination to create
- 55:32meaning. So it is, it's not outside the
- 55:35parameters in any way of what the system is.
- 55:37It's really just a keen understanding of what it is.
- 55:41But if you make these entries, which are remembered and you use
- 55:45them as the defining, the definition for the experience of
- 55:49the present moment, then you make a reality that you then
- 55:53remember. And so in addition to the
- 55:56visualized experience, you, you're actually stacking on top
- 56:00of it actual experiences or actual memory that comes from
- 56:05the, the perception of what's happening.
- 56:10And over time they become quite robust and you leave behind the
- 56:16the condition, the earlier conditioning because the new
- 56:22version works better and the mind is really calorie
- 56:25sensitive. If you can find a solution to an
- 56:28experience that's lower calorie than the one you've been
- 56:31currently using, the mind will abandoned the high calorie
- 56:34approach and go low calorie because it's all about
- 56:38conserving energy. So if you can notice that
- 56:45feeling frightened and withdrawing is a high calorie
- 56:49approach to relating, but actually going slowly and
- 56:54introducing yourself and expressing yourself is the lower
- 56:56calorie solution. The mind will do that.
- 57:00And then you'll find that the obstacles that had existed
- 57:03before that prevented you from doing that don't arise anymore.
- 57:06So you don't have to push through them anymore so that you
- 57:08can just go do it. But the experience of self
- 57:12watching you do it is the same, if that makes sense.
- 57:17It's a little bit of a paradox, but you you feel largely
- 57:20unchanged, but you're doing something that you've never been
- 57:23able to do before, with no explanation as to why that would
- 57:28be, except that you've done these dopey meditations for six
- 57:32months. All right, Cool.
- 57:39Exactly. Really cool.
- 57:46So we've gabbed away. What do you think about doing a
- 57:48little meditation? OK, let go of the meditation.
- 57:55How's that? Good.
- 58:01So Saturday we have the. What do we have on Saturday?
- 58:16It's the the last day of the meditation and addiction
- 58:19training, I think the level 1 and then we just started a level
- 58:262 and we will, we will close out the registration for that if
- 58:32you're thinking about it on the 4th of March.
- 58:37So you have until that time and then we're going to do a
- 58:42workshop on Friday night, this Friday night for people who are
- 58:49in the helping professions who are interested in our approach
- 58:54to attachment repair. So we're going to talk a little
- 58:58bit more on the technical side of the practice of that than I
- 59:02normally do with a a non helping professional audience.
- 59:13What else is happening? And then in March, we're going
- 59:18to begin a series of level ones for that particular cohort.
- 59:23So a deeper dive into the meditation and attachment
- 59:30process that we use, but also from the facilitate, we'll talk
- 59:33more openly about the facilitator side of it.
- 59:37And then we will begin in April a level 2 for the for that that
- 59:51group starting on the 25th of April.
- 59:54So that's the stuff that's coming up.
- 59:56If you're interested in any of it, take a look and then I hope
- 1:00:00to see you soon. Ioffer the teaching freely, but
- 1:00:04I do hope that if you're resourcing you can you'll make a
- 1:00:06donation. There's a link on the website to
- 1:00:09make a donation. Any amount is useful.
- 1:00:11Help support me and the work that Medigroup does.
- 1:00:14Really appreciate your practice. See you soon.
- 1:00:17Bye. Goodnight.
- 1:00:20George.