Latest / Newcomer Pod / Blood Sport (w/ Erin Griffith)
Transcript
- 0:05Welcome, Hello everybody. Welcome to this week's episode
- 0:15of dead cat. This is Tom dote on doing intro
- 0:18duties of for you. I'm here with Eric newcomer
- 0:20Katie banner and our special guest Aaron Griffith reporter at
- 0:24the New York Times, who has been all over the theranos trial.
- 0:29She has been one of the The lucky reporters that has
- 0:31traveled down to the peninsula, to check out the proceedings of
- 0:36text trial of the century. And it was like we have a try of
- 0:40this Century every decade but yeah, yeah, that's right.
- 0:43Okay. So so yeah, this is a really
- 0:44short Century so far. So the bar is kind of low.
- 0:48Yeah, we can take the decade though, no, once the plants at
- 0:50that, although the Robert Durst trial attacks text.
- 0:54No, it's the startup fraud trial of a generation.
- 0:56That's what I said, great. That's my really, is that
- 1:00Printing. Is that if any more times
- 1:02official that somewhere? Nice.
- 1:06I mean, No One's Gonna dispute that.
- 1:07It was, we will Define Our Generation by what we remember
- 1:10of the, the more specific you are.
- 1:12The greater your hyperbole can be.
- 1:15Yeah. How so you going?
- 1:18How often are you going to try? So it's three days a week,
- 1:21Tuesday, Wednesday, Friday. Although this week, they added a
- 1:24Thursday and so I'm going Tuesday, Wednesday in our
- 1:26reporting fellow Aaron. Woo is going down on Fridays, so
- 1:30So, you know, a couple days a week and explain to me even just
- 1:35the experience of showing up because I like the from reading
- 1:37the stories, like the first day it seemed like a bit of a circus
- 1:41and there were people like this was the big moment.
- 1:43This was the reveal you know what is Elizabeth Holmes going
- 1:46to be wearing? That's the question on
- 1:48everyone's mind. No, but seriously don't like
- 1:52what? When you arrive at the
- 1:53courthouse here? Does it have a circus-like
- 1:55atmosphere? Yeah, it definitely did during
- 1:58the jury selection. To a limited degree.
- 2:01And then for sure, on the first week of the opening arguments, I
- 2:04mean that was when pressed from all around the country bunch of
- 2:09people from New York flew in, you know, that's when everyone
- 2:12who's not going to maybe go to the day-to-day of this three to
- 2:15four-month trial are going to. They're going to come for the
- 2:18first the first day the first week.
- 2:19And so that was definitely a circus Vibe.
- 2:22I mean, I showed up at like I don't remember like 5:00 in the
- 2:26morning. I think I got a hotel the night
- 2:27before. Just really didn't want to make
- 2:29that drive and And I was no. I mean, because San Jose is like
- 2:33setup for conference like, you know, just tons of conferences
- 2:37and those are not fully back yet.
- 2:38Like my hotel room was actually shockingly cheap.
- 2:41And anyway, so there's just already, there's already people
- 2:43there. Somebody had deputized
- 2:45themselves to like, make a list and put us on order.
- 2:47And I think I was, you know, maybe the somewhere between like
- 2:50number 7 and 13 or something, and then, in terms of what see
- 2:53you would get know in terms of the line, because before there's
- 2:57a pre line and then there's a line at like 7:00 or 7:30.
- 3:00Actually, like open up this gate where you can start sanding an
- 3:03official line. So everyone's kind of gathered
- 3:05or is this just a random person who cared about fairness, who's
- 3:08doing the Promenade? This was the oldest was a person
- 3:13who worked for a certain a TV network who had they had got,
- 3:18they want to make sure they were yeah.
- 3:20They had a lot of resources and their people were understandably
- 3:23at the top of the list and then yeah we wait in line for hours
- 3:26and hours and hours of courtroom doesn't actually open until
- 3:28like, I don't know, eight, I think.
- 3:30And then you go through security and while you're while you're
- 3:33waiting in line outside still, there's just like tons and tons
- 3:36of cameras. There was a guy with like a
- 3:38helmet with a GoPro on it. And, you know, everyone is kind
- 3:41of like waiting and waiting and waiting and then homes walks in
- 3:45and it's just like Madness, like people sprinting toward her and
- 3:49getting in her face and she's like, trying to, you know, she's
- 3:51got her whole Posse with her and trying to make her way in and
- 3:54then she has to, like, go through security and take off
- 3:56her shoes and like show her ID and do all that and Like taking
- 4:00pictures of her. So that part is like a little
- 4:02crazy. One of the days, there was a
- 4:05woman who was like, you're a good mom Elizabeth, great job.
- 4:09Like we're rooting for you and everyone's like, what?
- 4:13Because it's mostly media in the line and that woman got in
- 4:18trouble for potentially causing a mistrial because she's like,
- 4:21there might be jurors around and she's like, potentially, we
- 4:25can't have people know that. She's a good mom, right?
- 4:26Introducing, you know, right? No.
- 4:28No. I mean I mean This stuff I guess
- 4:31things get incredibly sensitive. Yeah.
- 4:33I mean people have been really, was axle of the jurors like just
- 4:36trying to stay away from them to not you know, like accidentally
- 4:40say something in front of them because like that would be a
- 4:42real nightmare to be the one who messes it up, you know, a good
- 4:45mom person was. No it was it was strange like
- 4:48pretty much every day. All the journalists are trying
- 4:50to figure out who everyone in the courtroom is because right,
- 4:54it's calmed down now, where it's not pet.
- 4:56It's not packed like I can show up at like 859 basically and
- 4:59still See in the courtroom. Are they letting you type on
- 5:02your laptop sister? Yes.
- 5:03Yeah although we have gotten in trouble for typing too loudly,
- 5:08like the judge has repeatedly chastised the Press gallery for
- 5:12like we're supposed to have silent keyboards which I don't
- 5:14even know what that is but but there's been times when he's
- 5:17like if your clam shell isn't silent you should get a new one.
- 5:20And and like you can just tell when there's somebody who's
- 5:23doing something really, you know, saying something exciting.
- 5:25You can hear the like kind of like low Roar a keyboard, a
- 5:29good, a good. Warning to the jury to start
- 5:31paying attention when the video is, yeah, tight with a clam
- 5:35chowder, especially, especially, because we're not getting any
- 5:40heads-up on who the Witnesses are the order of the witnesses.
- 5:42And so there's people who don't matter really at all to the
- 5:47news. Like, yesterday, there was a guy
- 5:49who from the New York fed who literally his job is to explain
- 5:52what a wire transfer is and confirm that there are nose has
- 5:55indeed done them so they can make the case that concern us
- 5:57commit wire fraud. So like there's that kind of
- 6:00Boring procedural stuff. And then there's you know like
- 6:02Rupert Murdoch or Henry Kissinger.
- 6:04And so we have no idea who's going to be next.
- 6:07And so every time those people testified already, the big at
- 6:10the highest-profile testimony so far has been James Madison.
- 6:12And I guess that was kind of actually a surprise that he
- 6:15apparently had some opening and his schedule and they're like,
- 6:17let's get them in and I kind of I mean I thought it was it was
- 6:19like pretty credible. You almost feel kind of bad for
- 6:22him in a way. Like there was some really cute
- 6:24moments where he was like when I joined their noses board like I
- 6:28didn't know why she wanted me because I have no Uncle
- 6:30background and he's like and so I got some books about how to be
- 6:34a board member and I read them and know he was nice.
- 6:37I mean, it was, it was funny. There were there were emails
- 6:39that they showed from him too Elizabeth and every single one
- 6:42he called her young Elizabeth. So you could tell that he had
- 6:45this like kind of Grandfather Levi with her young.
- 6:49Yeah, that's the prequel. Yeah, so, yeah, he was he was,
- 6:54he was one of the most interested that, right?
- 6:57I mean we've talked about that a bit on the show but like You
- 7:00know, one of the things that it seemed like Elizabeth Holmes was
- 7:03very targeted about when she was picking investors in people.
- 7:06For the board was like an older you know, man who is you know,
- 7:10not necessarily part of the medical world that seem to, you
- 7:14know, buy her story. Yeah.
- 7:16Without too many questions. And so what we'd like it's funny
- 7:18it seemed like she did her job pretty well.
- 7:21Getting someone like James Madness to refer to her as young
- 7:23Elizabeth every time. It's like, yes, I mean, I don't
- 7:25know how much of that was really intentional on her part or it's
- 7:29just, that's who she. That's Ooh, she was able to
- 7:31convince like I think she she tried to convince people who
- 7:33have the expertise and didn't get as far with them.
- 7:36And the ones that took the bait were basically George Schultz
- 7:40and then through the Hoover Institute at Stanford.
- 7:43And then he's the one who recruited all the other, like,
- 7:47Admirals generals, you know, high-profile kind of older
- 7:51powerful men. So, the Rupert Murdoch hasn't
- 7:54testified yet. No, no, I think he will.
- 7:58I hope he, I hope he will. He's one of their biggest
- 8:01investors. It was like more than 100
- 8:02million from Rupert Murdoch? Yeah.
- 8:04Yeah. He would come in to prove that
- 8:07there was harm or do. Well, he's technically the like
- 8:10victim in this case, right? Which is one problem, or one
- 8:13challenge. Because early, I've said on this
- 8:16podcast that I support him being defrauded side.
- 8:20I just like to be, we have said that that is strictly Eric's
- 8:22point of view, and we are not endorsing that no feelings in
- 8:25any way that reflects us or Publications.
- 8:27Yeah. So the investors are technically
- 8:29the victims. Here at the indictment initially
- 8:32included, patients, and doctors. But they were able to get that
- 8:34thrown off because they didn't lose money because they have
- 8:38their insurance paid for it. So it's technically about the,
- 8:41the only, the investors, not even somebody who result, the
- 8:43misled them or anything. They're not victims of wire
- 8:46fraud. In this case, they have
- 8:47testified though, they've already had one patient in one
- 8:50doctor testify and they're supposed to be more everything
- 8:53is so highly negotiated. And one of the things that they
- 8:55fought over is whether the patients can talk about their
- 8:58feelings Getting a wrong result. So they were not able to talk
- 9:03about this woman who basically had three miscarriages.
- 9:05She then got pregnant and theranos test told her that she
- 9:10had miscarried again and it turns out she was pregnant and
- 9:13it was a viable pregnancy. She had the baby.
- 9:15So she testified about that. Traumatizing experience, but she
- 9:18wasn't able to say that it was traumatizing.
- 9:20She just had to like lay out the facts and let the jury kind of
- 9:22fill it in. That was that was an interesting
- 9:24one, because most of the witnesses have not worn masks.
- 9:28Everyone else in the courtroom is wearing a mask.
- 9:30But during the testimony there like if you're vaccinated and
- 9:32unvaccinated, let's not wear masks and so they don't.
- 9:34But that woman had like this plastic almost kind of Bane
- 9:40looking mask over her face and it was very distracting and I
- 9:45found it like and you couldn't hear and it was like getting all
- 9:47steamed up and like I found it hard to actually even fully
- 9:51follow because of that. So there's like some weird kind
- 9:53of logistical things there too. But you could tell it was it was
- 9:56powerful because the defense didn't even ask her a single
- 9:58question they were just like okay Oh cool.
- 10:01Remind me here. I mean, the things that she is
- 10:03being charged with aren't necessarily related to the
- 10:07accuracy of the tests, right? I mean, right, it's about how
- 10:10she departed investors about invest ability to receive,
- 10:15right? Yeah.
- 10:15But it almost like, you know, I imagine if this was about
- 10:18building, like a character case against her and the Damage that
- 10:23the alleged fraud, cause you could definitely go to town
- 10:26bringing all the people who got an accurate test.
- 10:28But if it's not going to be as germane, to the point, like I
- 10:30feel like the Offense could pretty easily say like this is
- 10:33not relevant to the charges here and you could probably dismiss a
- 10:36lot of these Witnesses. I don't know.
- 10:37K to you. You cover this stuff a lot so
- 10:38you probably sorry that I'm coming in and I had a call even
- 10:44though I'm technically off today.
- 10:45Aaron did you go walk are all of the listeners through what it is
- 10:49exactly but Elizabeth Holmes is being charged with the city just
- 10:53Dove right in and we were talking about as a lying
- 10:56outside, the door of the courthouse, which is what yeah,
- 10:58listeners. And I made a really want to
- 11:00know. Talk about what Elizabeth was
- 11:02wearing. Aaron you wrote this great
- 11:04story, taking us inside the courtroom.
- 11:05You wrote it with Aaron. Whoo, and from your story, you
- 11:09wrote that homes. The disgraced founder is being
- 11:12tried on 12 counts of fraud, charge with misleading investors
- 11:16about her company's technology. Oh yeah, the case is different
- 11:19from perhaps the lawsuits and all the other kind of things
- 11:22that their nose has gone through and that she's being very
- 11:24specifically charged with wire fraud and conspiracy to commit
- 11:29wire fraud. So, it's all about what she
- 11:31told. Told investors that turns out to
- 11:33be a lie that they made an investment based on and lost
- 11:36their money. I'm so curious, why do you think
- 11:39this case has captured the public imagination to the extent
- 11:44that it has? I mean, when you're describing
- 11:45the scene there people lined up to watch what you very
- 11:49accurately described as it does mind-numbing lie dry testimony
- 11:53testimony that's filled with jargon about wire fraud.
- 11:58So what is it about this case? Do you think Made people want to
- 12:02line up to see. I mean, that's something I think
- 12:05about a lot. Like, I've had a lot of people
- 12:08send me messages asking about the logistics and how to get in
- 12:11and they always ask, like, like regular people.
- 12:14Yeah. Yeah.
- 12:15People in the tech industry or just in just general and
- 12:18business people who are kind of Legally legal tangential Point
- 12:22like paralegals and lawyer types and they they always ask like
- 12:25can I see? Can you see her or do you get a
- 12:27glimpse of her? It's like yeah, she walks over
- 12:29me in the hallway every day when I'm sitting on the floor.
- 12:31Floor charging my laptop. But I think there is a little
- 12:34fascination with her as a person because she did build herself up
- 12:38into such a cult of personality. And then to discover that a lot
- 12:42of it was lies or was was, you know, misleading or not.
- 12:47True is just so juicy. You know, it's like almost a
- 12:52tabloid story in a way that I think is like so hard for people
- 12:56to look away from. And that a story that I did last
- 13:00weekend was kind of Get to why people are so obsessed with True
- 13:03Crime and murder stories. And I think a piece of it is
- 13:06like, we're glad we're not the victim that it didn't happen to
- 13:10us. And so, and part of it is also,
- 13:12we want to get inside the mind of someone who could pull
- 13:14something like this off, because we never could and or even think
- 13:18to do such a thing. And then here's this person and
- 13:20look what they did. It's almost like, like, in a
- 13:23sick way, it's like almost impressive, you know, you're
- 13:26like, how do they do it and what motivated them and why?
- 13:28So, I think there's like a fascination with that.
- 13:31How much is a bad blood in the background?
- 13:33There are there was a fight over.
- 13:34Whether John Kerry Rue could come in the courtroom right and
- 13:38quickly here we should say. John Kerry roux is the Wall
- 13:42Street Journal reporter who broke the initial and a lot of
- 13:45the biggest stories about fairness and he wrote a book
- 13:48about it called Bad Blood which has been used as the basis for a
- 13:51bunch of TV documentaries. And he at this like concurrently
- 13:54is also doing a podcast documentary or like you know,
- 13:58podcast report about the trial. So he's like very much Figure in
- 14:02this whole story and the podcast is is pretty interesting.
- 14:06So yeah, he was there for jury selection and opening arguments,
- 14:10but he is listed by the defense on the witness list.
- 14:13And so he is the case and as is the case in most Charles
- 14:17Witnesses are not allowed to hear testimony.
- 14:20And so he would be banned from the courtroom.
- 14:23His lawyers have argued that they put him on that list as in
- 14:26bad faith to keep him out of the courtroom because of it was with
- 14:31her. Holmes, quote, animus toward him
- 14:33and he someone as they pointed out who had people chant.
- 14:39Fuck yes. Fuck you carry right?
- 14:43One of his lawyers. No animists whatsoever.
- 14:46Right? One of his lawyers brought that
- 14:47up as an example in the in the there was a mad separate
- 14:50magistrate hearing of resume about this matter yesterday and
- 14:54basically a magistrate judge ordered that a curry Roux.
- 14:57Can what can be granted, an exception on can come into the
- 14:59courtroom. Now he basically Called him an
- 15:01expert witness, which I initially thought was a really
- 15:03weird argument, but the judge can delete it out that he will
- 15:07not be testifying about things that he personally witnessed.
- 15:11He'll be testifying about things, other people told him
- 15:13and his own reporting. So I mean we'll see if he even
- 15:17gets called the right. Hard to believe the homes.
- 15:20He hasn't gotten a subpoena, I don't believe.
- 15:22Yeah, he has not gotten a subpoena and the homes Camp
- 15:24basically was saying like, we don't know if we're going to
- 15:26call, I can't promise. We don't know what we're going
- 15:28to do. We might not put on any defense
- 15:30whatsoever. And and so the judge was kind of
- 15:32like yeah sorry so bad blood definitely looms large it,
- 15:36particularly during jury selection, it was so hard for
- 15:39them to find jurors who had not heard of Elizabeth Holmes or
- 15:42ther knows a lot of them cited that, you know, they were aware
- 15:46of bad blood, they listen to a podcast or like, you know, saw
- 15:49interviews with Carrie Rue promoting the book, A lot of
- 15:51them knew about the documentary, you know, one person was like, I
- 15:55just I don't know much about her.
- 15:56I just know she loves black turtlenecks that disqualify the
- 15:59person, or are you allowed to know that?
- 16:01That person did not get selected, I don't know if that
- 16:04was that played into it or not. I this election was actually
- 16:06kind of done very quickly and a little bit behind closed doors.
- 16:09So there's a media Coalition that is fighting to get the
- 16:12juror questionnaires made public in that has like led to all
- 16:15these other weird delays. The judge told the jury that
- 16:18they would be private turns out not to do that.
- 16:21The jury drama has been so fascinating, I don't have to
- 16:23understand whatís. The food is on the verge of
- 16:27tears woman, I felt really bad for her basically My read is
- 16:32that it seems like she was getting to the point where she
- 16:35realized that she might have to vote to convict and that it
- 16:39upset her so much and she couldn't like, she just couldn't
- 16:41stand the idea of like being responsible for somebody going
- 16:45to jail and she even volunteered to stay on the jury as an
- 16:49alternate. As long as she doesn't have to
- 16:51vote, it was just to be a warm body.
- 16:53I don't know what that well, yeah, I mean there's there's
- 16:56there were five alternatives to start were already down to
- 16:58including her. And this 19 year old woman who
- 17:01Turns out didn't have permission from her or she wouldn't be
- 17:03getting paid to be off work for four months so they just missed
- 17:06her anyway. The jury drama has been very
- 17:08interesting. This is something that we talked
- 17:13about earlier with the Ellen, Pao trial.
- 17:15We've seen this happen in all sorts of Criminal Justice
- 17:17matters, where the narrative around what happened is more
- 17:19powerful than what it is. The investigation results find,
- 17:24you know, that happened with Ferguson as well.
- 17:27The Justice part put an entire huge report about why the police
- 17:30officer in that case did not illegally harm.
- 17:34Michael Brown but the narrative is going to live on that he was
- 17:37unjustifiably shot. So Do you think that the, that
- 17:42the outcome in the case will impact the narrative?
- 17:45Say the jury acquits her? Will it matter in terms of the
- 17:48bigger narrative around Elizabeth Holmes?
- 17:51And that's interesting because I think one thing that I've been
- 17:53really surprised by in covering, this is how much every person
- 17:58who has any inkling of knowledge about this believe she is guilty
- 18:02and has already convicted her and so whenever I write
- 18:06something that is, you know, balanced and says here's what
- 18:09the defense said. Here's what the, you know,
- 18:11here's one way this could go. I just get bombarded by people
- 18:15being like, you're so like, how dare you like, give her any
- 18:19credibility whatsoever. She's a fraud.
- 18:22She's guilty, she's going to jail beaubois and like I have to
- 18:24keep explaining to people like these jurors have never heard of
- 18:27her. They're getting a very
- 18:29negotiated view of you know, highly negotiated and highly
- 18:32limited view of one specific aspect of what she did.
- 18:36Like you have to consider it through that lens.
- 18:38And so I think that if If she is acquitted, there will be such
- 18:41outrage like and cynicism in basically like Silicon Valley
- 18:46and our justice system in like Business Leaders.
- 18:50It kind of is the same sentences in that you see when people talk
- 18:53about how Adam Newman, you know, who was not our lawyers.
- 18:57And like me to say ever accused of criminal fraud, they're being
- 19:00very proactive, it seems like Newman has people out and about
- 19:03me, I believe the lawyers who have that much money would you
- 19:06hire lawyers, are they I was saying is that he there's
- 19:12cynicism because he remains a billionaire even though he
- 19:14messed up so bad. And so I think that will just be
- 19:17just add to that. He was really good at what he
- 19:20did. He was very successful.
- 19:22I had think that it was that he did anything about Elizabeth.
- 19:26Oh no, she's in court right now. I feel like that is, you've
- 19:30you're in trouble, not very good at navigating and are many, many
- 19:33accident, merican lives. But Newman Newman is clearly
- 19:36view is angry that the narrative About himself like he really got
- 19:41so much money is money, doesn't matter to me.
- 19:43But these people even if they're billionaires,
- 19:56they don't like being tweeted at night.
- 19:57It's the same thing as house arrest.
- 19:59So Adam Newman is going to be forever, yoke to the guy who you
- 20:03know, bilked SoftBank out of billions of dollars.
- 20:07That's not cool as you pointed out in an another story.
- 20:10And talking about Ozzy which is you know, there are no lawsuits
- 20:13that we know of so far when it comes to, you know, the fate of
- 20:16that media organization and Carlos Watson but now there's
- 20:19lawsuit. So there's there's no federal
- 20:21criminal charges criminals, right?
- 20:23No criminal suits and I you know it would probably would surprise
- 20:26me if their work has its kind of small potatoes compared to well
- 20:31the kinds of things. Look at the look at the other
- 20:33thing. The other cases, the Silicon
- 20:34Valley cases the Aaron mentioned in that story.
- 20:36And have you heard I mean, And I don't, I'm just going to say, I
- 20:41don't know that the world had heard of some of these companies
- 20:46before they were indicted. By federal prosecutors has, been
- 20:51has been was head spin right scare.
- 20:52How do you heard of had to spend one?
- 20:54That was at some sort of fecal, matter started, but I'm going to
- 20:57have testing startup. I don't think anybody had
- 20:59thankfully heard of you buy them, until there were any sort
- 21:04of allocation. We're, it's still the
- 21:07prosecution right now, right? Yeah.
- 21:10And it's, I mean, there's 200 and some 30, some people listed
- 21:14on the witness list and we are moving very slowly through them.
- 21:18Like the defense spent like four days, doing cross-examination of
- 21:23Adam rosendorf, the lab director, this.
- 21:25So he was almost an for a total of six days.
- 21:27Like it's, it's slow going and I'm, I'm worried from the jury's
- 21:32perspective. What do you think was the most
- 21:35important testimony or what? If they heard so far?
- 21:37I've been sort of trying to remember to To look over to see
- 21:41how engaged they are during various testimonies and I feel
- 21:45like they were super engaged during Erica.
- 21:47Chung's testimony, she was just super like well-spoken.
- 21:51I mean, she's had four years to like home this story, she was
- 21:53the whistle one of the reasons. She was one of the
- 21:55whistleblowers and she I think it was like also relatable.
- 21:59It's like here's this woman right out of college gets her.
- 22:02First job is so excited and bright-eyed and then like as
- 22:05disillusioned and tries to raise flags.
- 22:08And, you know, are red flags and You know is rejected and then
- 22:11she gets stocked and by apis and like gets these cease-and-desist
- 22:15letters and so that I thought was like pretty compelling they
- 22:19the defense's strategy was just to like bore and complicate.
- 22:25So they had her go through and just like read the entire org
- 22:29chart of the entire lab right now.
- 22:31Her seem like she's a very small insignificant person who didn't
- 22:35know what their nose was actually doing and like just
- 22:38long and kind of tedious and like Like like, you know, trying
- 22:41to frustrate her a little bit to make her seem less Savory, it's
- 22:43like and I don't know if that worked or not and, you know,
- 22:47four days of like cross-exam of this lab director, who was also
- 22:52carry revealed. One of his main sources in the
- 22:54first Wall Street Journal article.
- 22:55Like I don't know if they if they significantly like poked
- 22:59holes in his story or if the jury is kind of like just
- 23:03confused and doesn't know what to think.
- 23:05That's a key. Question is just what homes new
- 23:08versus. What some Abstract sense of the
- 23:11company. Yeah, that's a big.
- 23:13And it's a how much new and how much she was responsible for and
- 23:15what, how much evidence is there Ben.
- 23:17That's one thing that's that I've noticed is very repetitive
- 23:20with every witness is that they're like, a particularly
- 23:23with the Walgreens this week. They did, Walgreens and Safeway
- 23:26execs who struck Partnerships with the company.
- 23:28And it's like, what did she tell you what was that based on?
- 23:32Did you invest based on what she told you?
- 23:34And then it turned out to not be true.
- 23:35Okay. Cool.
- 23:36We got the check, it's like checking the boxes, you know,
- 23:38and with the with a lot of The people who are raising red flags
- 23:41from within a, ther knows it. There's always these questions
- 23:44of like Elizabeth look, Elizabeth Holmes with CC, do not
- 23:47email who was in charge of this, was it Elizabeth and like, so
- 23:50they're constantly trying to tie that in like make it clear that
- 23:53she was aware of this stuff because that was definitely one
- 23:56of the defense's key things in their opening statements was
- 23:59like, she's just this naive person who trusted everybody
- 24:02else around her and they they misled her and she thought she
- 24:05was doing it right? And sure she came up short but
- 24:08failing, a business is not a crime.
- 24:10You know, that was kind of their their message, which I mean, I
- 24:13could, I could work, it could work.
- 24:15And, and and, and basically, they're reasonable doubt is like
- 24:17it's possible. She did not have all of the
- 24:20answers or did not have all the data to be making definitive
- 24:24claims. Like she was just old enough to
- 24:26say, well I think we're doing this and if you can make that
- 24:28point, then you could prove enough reasonable doubt that
- 24:31it's like this was not willful. You know, fraud or willfully
- 24:34misleading investors, I guess is what they're going to try to do.
- 24:37Yeah. Aaron have you covered a trial
- 24:39before? The only a trial of covered is
- 24:42epic so I've never covered a criminal trial epic versus Apple
- 24:45which was right antitrust lawsuit kind of.
- 24:49I mean yeah, that was it that was way less fun than this now.
- 24:53So what is it? What it in terms of reporting?
- 24:57How was covering a trial different?
- 24:59Is it fun? What's the terrible stuff?
- 25:01What's boring, okay? So one thing that's really crazy
- 25:08is, I don't know that I've been in many situations where there
- 25:12have just been dozens, of, of my competitors writing the exact
- 25:17same stories as me every day and so comparing like what they got
- 25:22out of it. Versus what I got out of it has
- 25:24been fascinating, there's so many times I read other stories
- 25:28about the same thing that I wrote a story about and I'm like
- 25:31I was sitting there in the courtroom and I literally don't
- 25:33remember anyone saying this like I was talking with Adam Le
- 25:35schinsky who's covering it for business.
- 25:37Writer. And he was like, Oh, I thought
- 25:39that about your story to. I didn't remember this one part
- 25:41and I was sitting there and I like, how is that possible?
- 25:45So, that's been kind of fascinating and then some
- 25:48because you think it's hard for people to focus so, constantly
- 25:51or you because you think people are inventing know.
- 25:55I think it's part of it is just yeah I'm not I'm not paying, you
- 25:58can't pay that close. It's very hard to pay that close
- 26:00of attention the entire time while also taking notes while
- 26:02also tweeting, while also competing for like well well
- 26:05also goes rabbit, errs asking you what's Yes, the storytelling
- 26:08you're telling her editor what's happening while?
- 26:10Also trying to rewrite your story.
- 26:12So, you know, it can be out at a reason like by print deadline.
- 26:15So yeah. But you'll filing how weekly
- 26:18daily, we're doing a weekly wrap up now and then like, when
- 26:22there's a really big witness will do like an individual
- 26:25story. I think the Wall Street Journal
- 26:27is like they have. I think they like, maybe
- 26:29pre-written stories on like, certain Witnesses because
- 26:31there's some or they just like put it out and they've got 1,500
- 26:34words already like on someone who's testified for 15 minutes
- 26:37and Like, how'd you guys know but they're, you know, they're
- 26:40really covering it extensively. Some people are like,
- 26:42live-tweeting it and filing every day.
- 26:44Other people are just kind of like picking off stories around
- 26:46the sides. So is there anything really high
- 26:48news value little courtroom value or like what was the
- 26:52opposite of important to the jury?
- 26:54But super important to the Press.
- 26:56They spent a long time talking about, for example, stock option
- 26:59backdating, which like is interesting to some of the
- 27:02financial journalists who are like Aha and I cannot imagine
- 27:07the jury got Anything out of that.
- 27:08Just even seeing how the CEO of Safeway emailed with homes like
- 27:14the metaphors? He used the, like the he's got
- 27:17like, it almost was this like, increasingly sad relationship
- 27:21where he's constantly sending her emails, like becoming
- 27:24discouraged, increasingly disappointed and like you don't
- 27:27get like continue. Like the, the partnership is
- 27:30falling apart and you see it before your eyes and you're
- 27:32like, oh, this poor guy. It's like you staked his
- 27:34reputation on it. That's the those parts of it are
- 27:36like, kind of fun for me. But I don't know if the jury is
- 27:39like really cares and well it is like your your consumption of it
- 27:43is not all together. Like all not all two different
- 27:46than the jury's, right? I mean they're obviously not
- 27:48able to pay attention to everything that's happening
- 27:51today's testimony and you know they'll have the transcript and
- 27:54things that maybe they will examine a during deliberations.
- 27:58But I guess this is all incumbent on the lawyers to tell
- 28:02a narrative that does stick in the things if they can manage to
- 28:05get you and three other reporters to Simultaneously,
- 28:08right? The same narrative.
- 28:09They've basically done their job right.
- 28:11There are still kind of like laying foundation.
- 28:14So there's been so many times when they have like asked all
- 28:17these questions and we don't know why they're asking and I
- 28:20can't quite like figure out what they're getting at and they
- 28:22never say and huh here's the Smoking Gun.
- 28:25Like it's always just okay and now moving on like they dwelled
- 28:29this week so much on this National Rollout idea.
- 28:32And the only thing that I can imagine is that later that later
- 28:35down the line when like Rupert Murdoch are whoever comes along
- 28:37They're going to say, and did you invest?
- 28:39Because she told you X about National Rollout and they're
- 28:42going to say yes. And then it's the aha moment,
- 28:44but, like they haven't had that many of those so far.
- 28:48So it's been hard to cover. There's these documents that in
- 28:51the opening arguments, they claimed that she basically, put
- 28:53the logos of pharmaceutical companies on this like
- 28:56validation report that they did not, in fact, approve of and
- 29:00sent them around to investors. And so they're basically
- 29:02accusing her of falsifying documents and they showed those
- 29:05in court this week but they didn't.
- 29:07Ever get to the falsification part they're just like and did
- 29:09you invest based on this in the Walgreens guys?
- 29:11Like yes. And so there's a lot of those
- 29:14things where we're building but we haven't like landed any like
- 29:17real punches yet and so I think everyone's still kind of waiting
- 29:21for that because you haven't heard from the real victims, you
- 29:23haven't heard from the investors, right?
- 29:26We haven't heard from Walgreens was an investor and I see a
- 29:29juicy piece of it this week that I loved was that they so
- 29:32Walgreens invested. It's been written a million
- 29:35times invested, 100 million dollars and then also in, Today,
- 29:3840 million dollar convertible note, but I don't think anyone
- 29:41fully understood that that hundred million dollars was
- 29:43literally just an innovation fee for the privilege of partnering
- 29:47with their nose. So they didn't get Equity or
- 29:52they got the equity was through a 40 million dollar, convertible
- 29:55note, hmm. But the hundred million dollars
- 29:58it had, like certain Milestones that they had to hit in order to
- 30:00pay it, but then there's also emails of homes, asking for them
- 30:03to accelerate the payments even though they haven't hit any of
- 30:05the Milestones, which was just like, was it good?
- 30:07So, yeah, kind of wild but I was just like, Innovation fee.
- 30:11What in the world? I feel like one of the things
- 30:14that has come out of this trial and then the story that you
- 30:17wrote looking at their nose and Ozzy, Why is this idea of the
- 30:20massive amounts of schadenfreude around these failed companies?
- 30:24Because to your point, retail investors can no longer get into
- 30:29private companies because they don't go public for so long so
- 30:31they don't see that growth. And we're living this age where
- 30:35wealthy people are only getting wealthier.
- 30:37People are getting more disgruntled.
- 30:38On every front groups of people who supposedly have it all and
- 30:43are the smartest best and brightest in the country.
- 30:45Get bilked. For some reason seems very
- 30:47satisfying, these days and I was You know, if you can talk about
- 30:51that a little bit and do you think that that that that will
- 30:53have any impact on a jury? That's a challenge that the
- 30:56prosecution has is like making this jury care that like The
- 31:01Waltons and Betsy DeVos and Rupert, Murdoch lost their money
- 31:06investing. Yeah.
- 31:08Yeah. And so that's why they're
- 31:10bringing in all this other all the you know all the other stuff
- 31:12around it with the patients and like the bad test and you know,
- 31:16making you feel sorry for the employees and trying to you.
- 31:19No make her out to be unethical but one piece of this that, like
- 31:24everything that you said is exactly what I wrote and agree
- 31:27with and like, yeah, we like people hate billionaires now.
- 31:29It's like they're not like these benevolent like oh, you know,
- 31:33Bill Gates, Warren Buffett, it's more like like there is a very
- 31:37strong attitude that you see out there of like, fuck the rich but
- 31:40I don't know how much of that is a piece of.
- 31:42This will be a piece of his knee and I'm not really sure what you
- 31:45guys think. That's what's interesting about
- 31:47it to me because you know, As the lawyers here, you know, as
- 31:51far as the prosecutors The Narrative that you create has,
- 31:55you know, you're trying to prove your case, so that you win.
- 31:58But also, you know, part of the things that can help you win are
- 32:01the greater narratives, you know, if you are a member of the
- 32:04jury you are doing Justice, not just by punishing this person
- 32:07for a specific crime, but by setting an example and can be
- 32:10seen more broadly as and other people.
- 32:12If you're thinking of doing that, this will happen to you,
- 32:13which is why I'm so curious about, you know, you're saying
- 32:17this will fuel the cynicism Awesome.
- 32:19Yeah, I'm Tech. It's like that's a lot to put on
- 32:22the prosecution of say not only does Elizabeth Holmes need to be
- 32:25charged for wire fraud but also she needs to be charged for
- 32:28being duplicitous in a way that Silicon Valley represents
- 32:31misleading promises about what this technology can do.
- 32:35And I, you know, do you think that that's a case that they are
- 32:40trying to build? And that has any sort of
- 32:41salience with the jury because this is also taking place in
- 32:44Silicon Valley, a lot of people do work for tech companies or
- 32:47they certainly know people that work.
- 32:49That companies there. And so do you want to try to
- 32:51punish an entire industry or or the CT the sense of an industry
- 32:55for the wrongdoings or alleged wrongdoings of one person?
- 32:58I why? I'm so eager to see the jury
- 33:01questionnaire. The juror questionnaires to see
- 33:03what the background of these jurors are.
- 33:07We've learned, we've heard from a few of them, but like in the
- 33:10word are, but I think that will affect the case that they make
- 33:13and to some degree because, yeah, if these are people who
- 33:16work in the tech industry, and maybe have worked at a start-up
- 33:18and can Relate to that feeling of scrambling or Blitz scaling
- 33:21or whatever. You know, startups do to like,
- 33:25you know, try to make it work then then maybe they might like
- 33:29sympathize with her a little bit.
- 33:31But I think odds are, if you work in the tech industry, you
- 33:33probably heard of her and were dismissed.
- 33:36But if you are someone who works in Silicon, Valley lives and
- 33:40works in Silicon Valley and in the tech industry and its wealth
- 33:43and power is looming large over you all the time and you kind of
- 33:45like heat that then you know she could come to symbolize a
- 33:49Privilege that like, is oppressing you all the time, and
- 33:52that could also be a part of it. They haven't, really.
- 33:56In fact, they've already argued a little bit about whether or
- 33:58not she can use the defense of like, but in Silicon Valley,
- 34:01everyone does it. And the judge basically said,
- 34:03she's not allowed to argue that she was singled out, but they're
- 34:06allowed to talk, broadly about the culture of Silicon Valley,
- 34:09but they really haven't, like focused on that too much.
- 34:12What I say I was going to add one thing that I've found.
- 34:17So fascinating about, this is how ow and it's been going on.
- 34:20Since the initial article happened in the Wall Street
- 34:23Journal is just like how aggressively the VCS and Tech
- 34:27leaders are distancing themselves from this and how
- 34:30angry they are to hear that this is a case about forget them Marc
- 34:34Andreessen seem to be blocking people back in the day when they
- 34:38would attack her on Twitter and like there was definitely a
- 34:42where we talking on this podcast.
- 34:45I mean, there are lots of cases where Regulators their insurer
- 34:49capitalist, there was a request argument for why this is not a
- 34:52Silicon Valley case, you know what's the best?
- 34:55Your UBC said, it's a diagnostic.
- 34:58She didn't raise from any, the only real, like classic Silicon,
- 35:03Valley venture firm that she raised from was Tim Draper.
- 35:05And so they're like he doesn't count.
- 35:08And and then it was super earn, it was harsh Helen, right?
- 35:13And you could almost make a case.
- 35:14And I think Carrie, His books and interviews has made the case
- 35:16that it's like lookin Angel investment in an idea.
- 35:19It's not really frightened me. Yeah.
- 35:21You you invest in all kinds of things that don't pan, right?
- 35:24It really got to be a lot hairier when it was, you know,
- 35:26at the Betsy DeVos Rupert Murdoch level right, but that's
- 35:29what she was making those like, actually false Revenue
- 35:32projections, and she was saying, will make a billion dollars in
- 35:34revenue. And when they literally had
- 35:35zero, like, that kind of stuff is, that's when it gets into
- 35:40fraud, but it's totally normal and that's why Silicon Valley
- 35:43these season. It initially had that Civ like
- 35:45knee-jerk response where they're like just give them time and
- 35:48they'll figure it out. And then as more info came out
- 35:50than it was clear that there was some, you know, major
- 35:53misrepresentations happening that's when they all were like,
- 35:56well, this isn't actually really Silicon Valley, even though it's
- 35:59in Palo Alto connected to to Stanford, you know, like it's
- 36:04like it was also well and she used to play vibrated by.
- 36:08She was celebrated by the community.
- 36:09I thought that was one of the strongest cases people have made
- 36:11is that like whether or not she raised the money, she drank
- 36:14their Kool-Aid. Did she replicated their fucking
- 36:17fashion style? I'm just yeah.
- 36:20Sadly. There would have been days.
- 36:23When I thought about, like, I've looked in my closet grabbed a
- 36:26black turtleneck and be like, I cannot wear this into the
- 36:28courtroom, they'll think I'm mocking her own, not the court.
- 36:34I've just been wanting to know this what are the what are the
- 36:36lawyers like or what sort of the vibe on each side in terms of
- 36:42stop their style homes? Lawyers are like Williams
- 36:46Connolly which is like a very prestigious Law Firm they're
- 36:49well known and they look slicked, they very nice suits.
- 36:53Nice watches nice shoes, but it's what's what are the
- 36:57prosecutors do? They seem like they went to, you
- 37:00know, they're their own school or whatever the prosecutor.
- 37:03He seemed very competent. They're they're very so the
- 37:06judge has a really like soft and kind of like meticulous and
- 37:11orderly Vibe. And so that's been for the most
- 37:14part, the vibe in the courtroom. Like it's almost like quiet in
- 37:17there except for on the cross examination of dr.
- 37:21Rosendorf. When Lance Wade was just like,
- 37:23really kind of like attacking and like that was there's only
- 37:25been one witness so far where they have really like attacked,
- 37:28do you think this is catching on with the broader public?
- 37:31It's always hard to know as a What are your traffic numbers?
- 37:35And I purposely never looked at that and whenever I do it upsets
- 37:39me because you know, there's always like one story.
- 37:41I cared a lot about that. No one reads and the really,
- 37:44really the one I popped off that was just so of course, all we
- 37:48care about is our tweets. That's really.
- 37:50Yeah, so that all on the Twitter front, I have been surprised at
- 37:52some of the day's. I've kind of like, live tweeted
- 37:54it and I've been surprised with like people are really following
- 37:58along and engaging and I'm like this is really getting in the
- 38:01weeds here people. And they seem to like Be
- 38:04fascinated by it. I mean there may be because the
- 38:06access to it is so limited, you know, a lot of other trials that
- 38:10have been happening in the pandemic era have had at least
- 38:12like, like a hotline where you could listen in when they're not
- 38:15doing that. So people have seemed really
- 38:18interested in like kind of like what I was saying before for the
- 38:20same reason that people are interested in true crime.
- 38:22In general. Like one of the people who told
- 38:24me who wrote to me that said they wanted to come to the
- 38:26courtroom said that she was a fan of white collar crime which
- 38:31side of it. Yeah.
- 38:33I was like, generally has a crack.
- 38:36You mean, like, you're like a fan of like stories about white
- 38:39collar crime, but I think that's what she meant, but it was just,
- 38:42it's still my meal. And there have been multiple
- 38:44book clubs that red bad blood that have come to the trial.
- 38:49Oh, that's extra credit. That's nice.
- 38:51And some of them have, you know, said that they expected it to be
- 38:53more exciting because it's not, you know, it's there's like the
- 38:56thing that you do that you get misled about on like you know,
- 38:59TV trials is that like there's so much boring, tedious
- 39:02procedure Stuff and so much fighting over procedure.
- 39:06And what can? And can't be said, what do you
- 39:08do for lunch? It's will be.
- 39:12The judge is the schedules always weird and we don't get
- 39:15very long breaks and so I generally am like chugging a
- 39:20Starbucks sandwich, it's so sad. That's like grammar that
- 39:23horribly depressing interview that my guys.
- 39:26It gave to Grub Street where he said he would voluntarily.
- 39:29Eat seeing what? Yeah, just as like a practice,
- 39:33what's wrong? Our brains that I know what Mike
- 39:35Isaac likes like if I was in a trivial League, like I would get
- 39:38that before. Like, some question of History,
- 39:40like know what? Mike, Isaac Starbucks.
- 39:46I think it was so bad, that that you couldn't help but like, have
- 39:49it burned onto your brain. But yeah, I feel like I'm now
- 39:51channeling that. So, we had this conversation
- 39:53with Ben Smith for he kind of alluded to this idea that the
- 39:57startup World, especially in start-up media.
- 40:01It's it always feels like sort of Rod, adjacent your own.
- 40:06I love that. He said that you're always
- 40:07hustling. He didn't use those words.
- 40:09I'm paraphrasing him right now. But do you think that the valley
- 40:13acknowledges that in any way? Do you think that things like
- 40:17the fairness trial and sort of more high-profile blow-ups,
- 40:21cause the industry to look inward as a moment to be
- 40:25introspective? Or do you think it's like a,
- 40:27this is a one-off freak Show a few bad apples.
- 40:31Look the other way, proceed kind of Thing.
- 40:34Yeah, I wish that it was causing introspection but I think if
- 40:39that was going to be the case it would have happened in 2016 when
- 40:44all this stuff was collapsing and I think I wrote a story
- 40:47about it at the time like it was not just their nose.
- 40:49It was like the the mayonnaise mayonnaise company that was
- 40:52buying its own mayonnaise from the stores.
- 40:54It will enter Greek, they change their name and they are still
- 40:58doing it. So anyway, Josh was that
- 41:01retrospection would have happened.
- 41:03Then, and there were many other, you know, examples of it.
- 41:05And you guys interviewed Parker Conrad like they were, they were
- 41:08cheating on tests and there's lots of places where Stars
- 41:13Corners. You know, clicking along I'm
- 41:15sorry I'm not going to whatever technicalities whatever it was
- 41:19exactly. But they were they were anyway
- 41:23yeah there that is kind of baked into the culture a little bit
- 41:26and it is a part of like starting something from scratch
- 41:29is that you have to convince investors of a vision of the
- 41:31world that does not yet. Exist that you hope to make
- 41:35exist. And if you come up short, are
- 41:38you, are you a fraud? Or did you just like fail?
- 41:41And that's like, kind of where that line is.
- 41:43And so, I think most people are just like, oh, well, she
- 41:46obviously crossed, like, very clear lines, and that would
- 41:49never happen to me. So I don't think that there has
- 41:51been a connection that is made. You think there's a big
- 41:55difference between coming close to sort of line suggestive,
- 42:00saying, we can be big and like the bright line.
- 42:03I'm crossing to me, the bright line is very important and it's
- 42:06a big difference not just sort of a difference in terms of
- 42:10increment that's definitely something that the defense has
- 42:13tried to. They tried to muddy that and
- 42:15complicated a lot like there's a few very, very clear instances
- 42:19where she said we have all their notes is being used and medevacs
- 42:22and on the battlefield in Afghanistan and it obviously
- 42:25wasn't but then there's many other instances where she said
- 42:29were validated by Pfizer and like Pfizer did do a validation
- 42:33test I did give them some money early on for some kind of
- 42:35clinical thing in. Like, if you like, they're just
- 42:38trying to like complicated enough.
- 42:39So that it's like, well, some of what she said, seemed kind of
- 42:42right ish? Close enough.
- 42:43But Allah, maybe she didn't get all the details, right?
- 42:45And so, they're like, a lot of the things that she that's being
- 42:49that's coming out in the evidence.
- 42:50Now is what you're talking about, which is like, just a
- 42:54little bit fudging things, not egregious, bright Line crossing
- 42:57like a clear, a clear lie, what we've seen the last, like, five
- 43:02years is stuff, And Silicon Valley has gotten even crazier.
- 43:05Diligence has gotten like even crazier because ideas and
- 43:12investors are saying, you should just 10x your your Revenue
- 43:16projections even though you're never going to hit that.
- 43:18Like that's how you'll raise your next round of funding.
- 43:19So like just say you're going to be 10 x even though that's like
- 43:22so the council the counter argument to that is multiples
- 43:25have gone up, right? If it was all just were
- 43:26inflating future Revenue projections than the multiples
- 43:30could stay the same but they are biting the bullet and No.
- 43:34We're willing to pay 100 x Revenue not 10x.
- 43:37So there is a reality to which the prices are just what the
- 43:41standards for prices are check the price of reflection of how
- 43:44much money is out there to be invested.
- 43:46Right. Right.
- 43:47Right. But they're not, they're not
- 43:50lying. It's not like the multiples of
- 43:54the future Revenue have stayed the same the multiples of future
- 43:57Revenue. The multiples have gone up which
- 43:59is a level which is an honesty about but not about your future.
- 44:03Our Revenue that's a little bit the multiple that somebody will
- 44:06pay on future Revenue as an investor.
- 44:08I think you're conflating that with what the company itself
- 44:11says, it will make in the future.
- 44:13That's different, right? I'm just saying we don't have is
- 44:16there strong evidence that future guidance is more inflated
- 44:21than it has been in the past. Or is it just the case that
- 44:24investors are willing to pay more for the same future
- 44:27guidance? I think the, I think the the
- 44:29point is, it's about diligence and the ability to just not Have
- 44:33to be definitely gone to not have anything to, not have
- 44:36anything, you said verified. So that a lot of creates the
- 44:39environment where if you are inclined to stretch the truth, a
- 44:42little bit or exaggerate or say you have this customer when in
- 44:45fact, it's not fully locked in, like that's your chance to be
- 44:48able to play my best. Marc Andreessen, one of the
- 44:51biggest problems with America right now is that we're too slow
- 44:55to do new things. There were two apprehensive and
- 44:57so sure, maybe it's sad that like 5% some percentage of
- 45:01companies are going to Be able to lie and get some money and
- 45:05ultimately probably still fail but the idea that we're
- 45:08deploying Capital faster for people doing interesting.
- 45:11Things is good. That's better than just sitting
- 45:15on our hands and not having that percentage that's faulty.
- 45:19But maybe like in closing here about this and thinking about
- 45:23reflection for Silicon Valley. I think it's interesting that
- 45:27the bulk of their noses time, you know, when it was Raising
- 45:30all this money and had all these outlandish projections happened
- 45:32in, What 2015 2016 think about, how much more money is in
- 45:38Silicon Valley. Now I was provision that
- 45:40provision fund. Yeah, to me it would seem like
- 45:43as more money comes into the system.
- 45:45There needs to be a broader industry correction for there to
- 45:48be real introspection, but at the end of the day, if your
- 45:51Sequoia Andreessen Excel, whatever you didn't invest, like
- 45:55you're like, our processes work like if you avoided that
- 45:58company, That that is why you can't be indicted on your
- 46:03process because you didn't make the investment.
- 46:05I think that their nose is the most extreme version of what
- 46:09we're talking about here and there are lots of less extreme
- 46:12versions out there and so that's kind of like if you're a drug
- 46:14dealer being like, well I'm not El Chapo.
- 46:16You know, that's like the most extreme ones are the ones that
- 46:20fail first. I think we might see a lot more
- 46:23of this with specs. I mean that's where a lot of
- 46:26these problems with like the Nicola thing.
- 46:29The guy Rolling the truck down the hill to show that it drove
- 46:31itself companies that are going public.
- 46:33Lots to do. Yeah, the companies that are
- 46:37going public a lot sooner with a lot less to show and are using
- 46:40this backward way that avoids having to do certain disclosures
- 46:44is, I think that is much much more likely to result in some
- 46:48kind of terrible blow up than, like the private investing that.
- 46:52We're talking about where Rupert Murdoch, rbc's, lose a lot of
- 46:55money. All right?
- 46:55Are we should? We should probably let you go?
- 46:57I'm sure you've enjoyed not sitting in a Courtroom for for
- 47:00several hours but you still had to have listened to my pleasure.
- 47:05Yeah, thanks so much for joining us.
- 47:09So what kind of salad, goodbye, goodbye.
- 47:18Goodbye goodbye. Goodbye, goodbye.
- 47:21Goodbye.