Latest / Identity at the Center / #394 - How Digital ID Can Solve the Fraud Crisis with Sarah Clark
Transcript
- 0:04This is identity at the center. Welcome to the Identity at the
- 0:10Center podcast. I'm Jeff, and that's Jim.
- 0:12Hey, Jim. Hey, Jeff, how are you?
- 0:13Oh, not so bad yourself. Still fantastic.
- 0:15Remember here at the Gardner I am Summit 2025, the last
- 0:20conference of the year for me. How about you?
- 0:21Yeah, me too. My last trip of the year.
- 0:23I think I'll have 98, maybe 99 flights by the time I'm done
- 0:29with this week. You.
- 0:30Bear me at the most the least status of the.
- 0:33Airline, well, I'll tell you, Diamond status with Delta does
- 0:37not absolve you of poor visibility at the Atlanta
- 0:40airport yesterday. So this is Sunday before Gartner
- 0:43kind of officially kicks off today, and that cost me 6 hours
- 0:47of delays getting from Asheville to Dallas area.
- 0:52Yeah. And yeah.
- 0:54That's a bad time of like flying this time of year.
- 0:58But what's really great, like we're here now.
- 1:01I want to thank a couple organizations, one's Gardner for
- 1:04setting us up as this awesome room.
- 1:07I wanted to thank RSM for getting us out here and kind of
- 1:11always supporting the podcast. And by the way, I think a lot of
- 1:15people don't realize that's our day job is that we do consulting
- 1:18during the day. The podcast is not a full time
- 1:20job for us. So thank you to RSM and then
- 1:24thank you to you too, Jeff. I mean, I know you're not an
- 1:26organization unto yourself. I am.
- 1:29Oh, sometimes I wonder if you think you are, but no.
- 1:34Could you keep taking our technology game to a new level?
- 1:37I think when people see this podcast, all the cameras we
- 1:40have, the new wide angle, I mean, it's impressive.
- 1:43Yeah, we'll see how it goes. I just realized that I have a
- 1:46new camera over there and I'll be looking away from it for the
- 1:49most part. So, you know, we'll, we'll
- 1:51figure it out. But yeah, you don't want to look
- 1:53good and sound good. So I'm trying.
- 1:56I'm trying for you. Yeah, I think, I think
- 1:58everyone's grateful. But yeah, we're going to
- 2:01knockout 3 episodes while we're here, and I think we can
- 2:06probably get jumped into the first one here.
- 2:09Yeah, why don't we go ahead and and introduce our guest, Sarah
- 2:12Clark. She's been with us before.
- 2:13She's joining us. She's with Hope now.
- 2:15I had to answer. Ask her how to pronounce that.
- 2:17Just make sure you get it right. But welcome back to the show,
- 2:20Sarah, because you're a second time here.
- 2:21Yeah, no, it's a pleasure to be here and there are a lot of
- 2:24cameras here, so feeling a little nervous, but.
- 2:28It's just the conversation about identity amongst old friends,
- 2:32that's it. Exactly.
- 2:34So you were with us a couple years ago at the Authenticate
- 2:36conference in 2022. That was episode 179.
- 2:39So I'm not going to make you go back and like give us your I am
- 2:42origin, origin story because we've already covered that.
- 2:44Go back and check that out. But tell us a little bit about,
- 2:47so it's been 3 years, I guess at this point.
- 2:49What have you been up to since then?
- 2:51And tell me a little bit more about Hope, because it's a name
- 2:53I've heard before, but I'm not sure if we're familiar about it,
- 2:55especially here in the US. Yeah.
- 2:57So in 2022, when I was last on the show, I was leading
- 3:02something called the ID. The ID network at MasterCard all
- 3:06about ensuring that digital ID credentials can be shared
- 3:10globally seamlessly with assurance and all the good
- 3:14stuff. So that was amazing.
- 3:19However, MasterCard decided to no longer pursue building a new
- 3:23network. So I ended up leaving in 2024.
- 3:28And you know, of course, that decision was a bit
- 3:31disappointing. You know, very, I was very
- 3:33enthusiastic about the business, as was the team.
- 3:36So I decided to take a little bit of time off to decompress
- 3:40and figure out my next steps. Well, little time off turned
- 3:43into a year off and I spent the year buying rainforest in Costa
- 3:49Rica for the sole purpose of preservation.
- 3:52So that of course, took quite a bit longer than I anticipated,
- 3:57and I got pretty deep in that. And I ended up becoming very
- 4:01passionate about saving dogs from the shelters in Southern
- 4:06California. And I'd just like to say, please
- 4:09adopt, don't shop. So did that for a while, tried
- 4:13to help the situation by developing an AI agent and sort
- 4:18of a long story, but I got sidetracked with some passion
- 4:22projects, Really enjoyed the time.
- 4:25After a year I decided I'm ready to jump back in and Hope A
- 4:30actually found me. And the vision of Hope A is very
- 4:35similar to what we were seeking to do at MasterCard.
- 4:38So Hope A is building the digital identity infrastructure
- 4:43of the future. And at a high level, there's two
- 4:47main parts to that. The first is something called
- 4:51Hope A Connect. And Hope a Connect is all about
- 4:55connecting the world's government issued digital IDs to
- 5:01be used seamlessly by the private sector.
- 5:04So we enable identity verification companies,
- 5:09authentication platforms as well as enterprises to access
- 5:15government issued digital IDs as well as government issued
- 5:18credentials. So all about making that
- 5:22seamless, easy providing the network, providing the one line
- 5:26of code type approach to get to all of those.
- 5:30The second part of our focus is enablement of issuance.
- 5:36So working with governments that are launching digital IDs so
- 5:42that they can have the wallet and the infrastructure to be
- 5:45able to issue those to their citizens, as well as private
- 5:49enterprises that can benefit from having a wallet to issue
- 5:53their own credentials. Because maybe they're solving
- 5:56for data silos, maybe they're solving for having subsidiaries
- 6:00and user journeys that span multiple things.
- 6:03So Hope a connect the global Eid hub and the Hope a wallet all
- 6:10about enabling issuance. So that's what we're up to.
- 6:14I joined as Chief Product Officer and GM of North America,
- 6:20and I'm just super excited to be continuing my work on that
- 6:24vision because I really do believe it is the unlocking
- 6:27mechanism to a more secure future with a lot less fraud.
- 6:33That's really cool. And I'm really interested to
- 6:36understand what the governments are doing with the digital
- 6:42identity, digital credentials. I'm just wondering what is the
- 6:46problem that governments are trying to solve with those
- 6:49identities, the digital identities?
- 6:52Yeah. So at this point there are,
- 6:56let's see, I have a little CHEAT SHEET, 186 out of 198 countries
- 7:02are moving forward with government issued digital IDs
- 7:06and I'm going to shorthand that to Eids because that's a lot to
- 7:11keep saying. So 186 governments moving
- 7:15forward with Eid programs. So that is 94% of all countries
- 7:20on Earth, which I think is just absolutely amazing.
- 7:23Some of them are released, some of them are in progress.
- 7:28So they're all at different stages, but huge adoption.
- 7:31So before COVID, you know, this was definitely becoming a hot
- 7:37topic. There was awareness that having
- 7:41a sound digital ID infrastructure could help uplift
- 7:47economic metrics for a country. Lifted GDP, allow for easier
- 7:53access to financial services, allow for inclusion, that type
- 7:59of thing. COVID hit, and of course, many
- 8:02governments were slammed with the same problem, right?
- 8:06Lockdown and standing in line to access government services did
- 8:12not mix. They were the, you know, polar
- 8:14opposites of each other. So a lot of acceleration
- 8:18happened to solve for access to government services through
- 8:23digital channels. And, you know, we certainly saw
- 8:26that here in the US with, you know, inability to get
- 8:30unemployment benefits because of that friction.
- 8:33And that happened everywhere. So there was a lot of
- 8:36acceleration driven by the problems with government
- 8:40services during COVID. And at that time there was a bit
- 8:44of debate, you know, would governments open these Eids to
- 8:47the private sector? How would they do it?
- 8:50I would say now that debate is over and in general all
- 8:54governments see the benefit of enabling the private sector with
- 8:57government issued Eids. So why is this valuable to the
- 9:01private sector? It is an unlocking mechanism to
- 9:06solving for just absolutely egregious fraud levels that
- 9:10we're seeing right now. So if you think about any
- 9:13private sector company that's regulated, they have to do KYC,
- 9:19financial services, gambling, you know, other regulated
- 9:22sectors. Beyond that you have, you know,
- 9:26sharing economy marketplaces that may not be regulated like
- 9:31payments and financial services, but they also need trust, which
- 9:35means they need identity verification.
- 9:39The current state of identity verification generally is you
- 9:43capture a photo of a physical ID document.
- 9:47You pair that, you know, with a selfie and that's sort of the
- 9:51process that people go through the physical ID document photo
- 9:56is analyzed by algorithms that try to figure out if it looks
- 10:01authentic. And, you know, that's
- 10:04probabilistic. In the end, AI, as everybody
- 10:09knows, has accelerated and it's very easy to create, you know, a
- 10:14very good fake ID document. So basically that method has
- 10:19been, you know, breached. It's vulnerable to AI, so that's
- 10:25just no longer reliable anymore. Deep fakes, you know, all the
- 10:29different things that are happening.
- 10:32Juniper Research recently did a study or or a research report
- 10:37where they predict that fraud just within financial services
- 10:43identity fraud is going to surge to 59 billion in the next few
- 10:48years. Like this is a huge problem and
- 10:51the existing method of capturing physical documents, even
- 10:56layering that with risk signals, it's no longer good enough.
- 10:59So I've been talking about this for years.
- 11:02The reality is finally coming. The private sector to reduce
- 11:07this fraud needs to connect the root of trust, which are the
- 11:11government issued digital ID's. And that's the horizon that
- 11:16we're entering. So that's great for fraud.
- 11:18It's also great for user experience.
- 11:20Yeah. And just so you mentioned I
- 11:22think a few different benefits, right?
- 11:25There's the fraud reduction part, which you hit pretty heavy
- 11:28there at the end. But you also talked about
- 11:31security, efficiency, inclusion. And I'm wondering like from a
- 11:37government standpoint, and maybe there's not just one answer, but
- 11:40what, what's the main driver, what is like top of the list
- 11:44that they're trying to drive forward?
- 11:47I would say that a foundational digital ID drives economic
- 11:55activity, right? It drives inclusion, it drives
- 12:01safety, it drives less fraud outcomes.
- 12:04I mean, I guess there isn't just one answer, right?
- 12:06There's sort of a holistic benefit to society.
- 12:10And I think that can differ depending on a developed economy
- 12:13versus a developing economy. You know, we can get into what
- 12:18the EU is doing, but one of their driving motivations is
- 12:22also all around data privacy for their citizens.
- 12:26So I'm happy to kind of dive more into that.
- 12:29But I think part of it is, you know, regional, but the top line
- 12:33benefit is sound digital identity drives safe, you know,
- 12:41enhanced economic activity overall, which benefits
- 12:45everyone. I had major jealousy or, you
- 12:50know, wishing I had one. There were some folks going
- 12:54through airport security and using mobile driver's licenses,
- 12:58and it just seemed like it's a better user experience for the
- 13:02person who has it. It's probably better security as
- 13:06well, right? Oh, yeah, yeah.
- 13:08I mean, again, there are different ways that different
- 13:12governments are proceeding with their platforms.
- 13:15There's kind of a few different models, and we can get more into
- 13:18that. But overall, the themes are, you
- 13:21know, cryptographically secured, you know, kind of tokenized
- 13:27identity protected by biometrics.
- 13:32Some of them are wallet based, some of them are centralized.
- 13:36But any way you look at it, it's just more secure.
- 13:40You know, one of the things I figured with the those digital
- 13:44driver's licenses is not going to work for everybody.
- 13:47Like who's used the example of my dad, right?
- 13:49Like my dad's not going to do that.
- 13:54It's not for him. And so they're still going to be
- 13:57the the plastic driver's license right there.
- 13:59Yeah. So the digital I did or what we
- 14:04call them Eids, that's not going to be an overnight light switch,
- 14:07right. They're still going to have to
- 14:09be the physical world version for people.
- 14:12So I'm wondering like, what is that adoption curve typically
- 14:17like? Well.
- 14:19Again, I think that is varying from country to country.
- 14:24So, you know, maybe I can start with some countries that have
- 14:28seen tremendous adoption and adoption is fueled by acceptance
- 14:36or where you can use it, right. So you're talking about mobile
- 14:39driver's licenses as an example. You've observed through airports
- 14:44in the US. That's pretty much one of the
- 14:48only use cases that's available at this point in time.
- 14:51So some people that have heard of it are going to use it, but
- 14:54it's not super compelling because where else can you use
- 14:58it? You know, am I going to bother
- 14:59or just big enough to check out my license versus my phone?
- 15:05So the adoption curve here is, you know, starting off a little
- 15:11like not, you know, shooting up into the right quite yet.
- 15:15I think that's going to change and we can talk more about that.
- 15:18Other parts of the world, there's been more enablement and
- 15:24more ways that it's accepted throughout the country.
- 15:28So some places that have huge adoption right now would include
- 15:34the Philippines. So they recently announced that
- 15:3780% of their population of 117 million have their national
- 15:45digital ID and are using it for different things within their
- 15:49country. I think most people are familiar
- 15:52with India having Adahar as their digital ID platform.
- 15:57So they've effectively on boarded, you know, all of the
- 16:00adults and their population of 1.4 billion.
- 16:04So a staggering number. And they've measured metrics
- 16:08that show benefits in terms of financial inclusion and other
- 16:12things. They're continuing to modernize
- 16:16or evolve, maybe I should say, to make their ID available as a
- 16:22wallet. Now on someone's phone, they
- 16:25have something called a Digi locker.
- 16:27So it's not just about your foundational digital ID
- 16:31credential. It's also about other things the
- 16:35government issues to you that can be important for enhanced
- 16:39user journeys. So imagine signing up for a loan
- 16:41and you can have, you know, proof of the various things that
- 16:45you need that go beyond your foundational ID.
- 16:47That's all there for their citizens and obviously widely
- 16:52adopted because it's used for a lot of things right now in
- 16:56India. We have Brazil, I think is a
- 17:01really interesting case where 50% of the population has a
- 17:06driver's license. So they don't have quite as many
- 17:08drivers as a percentage of the US, But those are all in a
- 17:12digital form. And they just announced a very
- 17:15sweeping program to create a centralized multimodal digital
- 17:20ID where they plan to have 100% effectively of their population
- 17:25onboarded across the next five years.
- 17:29So these are examples of governments that are really
- 17:32solving for both adoption and enablement of use cases within
- 17:36their country, and that's why they're getting high adoption
- 17:38rates. I.
- 17:39Think it's like, you know, I think a lot of the technology we
- 17:42have Silicon Valley in the US and our adoption is relatively
- 17:48poor compared to these countries.
- 17:49So just an observation that I think is worth noting.
- 17:55Out of curiosity, like adoption rates, I would think that age is
- 17:59a major factor in demographics. Especially you mentioned
- 18:03financial ability because you do need a smartphone for this to
- 18:07work, right? Well, it depends on the model.
- 18:12So yes, if the approach is to enable with a wallet type
- 18:19container for a verifiable credential that would be used
- 18:24from a smartphone, But some of these countries that have less
- 18:28penetration of smartphones are using approaches that you know,
- 18:33may not be as dependent, you know, on a phone.
- 18:36So it kind of depends on if it's a centralized model versus a
- 18:40decentralized model. So there are different factors
- 18:43and if you look at the more decentralized or smartphone type
- 18:50models, I would point to, you know, the US and the EU
- 18:54especially as an example of that.
- 18:57And you know, I talked about a bunch of other countries, but
- 19:01the EU was really kind of the shining star, at least in my
- 19:05view, that sort of leading the charge to the most kind of well
- 19:09formed program with the most regulatory kind of teeth, right?
- 19:16That's, you know, I'm a person that cares deeply about
- 19:20transforming the Internet to be privacy preserving.
- 19:25So their approach is very in line with those ideals.
- 19:30So I'm really excited about what the EU is doing.
- 19:33And when you talk about adoption, I think we're going to
- 19:36see adoption very, very quickly in the EU.
- 19:39In fact, they're predicting that 80% of their citizens will be,
- 19:44will not only have a digital ID or an Eid wallet, they will be,
- 19:49you know, using it within the next several years.
- 19:53So they're expecting a very steep adoption curve, but they
- 19:57also have a lot of, you know. Support right from the
- 20:02government where it will be mandated in some ways.
- 20:06So maybe we can talk a bit more about the EU.
- 20:08Yeah, I want to because I think Jim still a little bit Thunder.
- 20:11I feel like the US is behind right now and I based that on
- 20:15conversation that we actually did an episode with Christina
- 20:18Souza and Dr. Torsten from German Spring Group is kind of
- 20:21responsible for the E for the digital wallet for Germany.
- 20:26One of the things that I learned from that conversation when we
- 20:28were at EIC earlier this year was there is financial implement
- 20:32implications for each of the member states of the EU if they
- 20:36do not have this interoperability set up.
- 20:38I think it's by the end of 2026. Don't quote me on that, but it's
- 20:42relatively soon coming up. I feel like that's a great
- 20:46incentive for countries, governments to say, OK, we're
- 20:50going to have this thing put together and there is a
- 20:52financial implement implication. If not, yeah, I don't know how
- 20:57well that would work in the US. We're 50 states.
- 21:00Mobile driver's license is probably, I don't know, like I'm
- 21:03pessimistic. And I feel like we're 1520 years
- 21:05out because it's going to take that much time for each state to
- 21:09adopt it to figure out how we want to do their
- 21:11interoperability, blah, blah, blah, and stuff like that.
- 21:14And so I have this sort of jaded opinion that, oh, man, the US is
- 21:18behind when it comes to this idea of a decentralized digital
- 21:24identity wallet of some sort. Am I being too pessimistic?
- 21:28Is there hope coming, you know, for us in the US?
- 21:31Or are we going to continue to kind of, you know, not lead in
- 21:34this space? You know, EU is probably the
- 21:37leader right now. Do we catch up at some point?
- 21:41So I think the US will catch up and fun fact, we already do have
- 21:4520 states that are issuing MDLS. We also have the three major
- 21:50wallets. I think probably a lot of people
- 21:53have seen that news where Apple, Google and Samsung all support
- 21:58uploading and MDL into the wallet.
- 22:01And these aren't, you know, 1 to one, right?
- 22:05So 20 states have MDLS, Not all states support all wallets.
- 22:10So there's sort of this patchwork, right, that is
- 22:13happening with that. But that's all starting to come
- 22:16together in addition to having the state app for your MDL.
- 22:20So the fact the wallets are supporting the upload means the
- 22:24next step is the wallets will plug into the private sector and
- 22:28there will be more use cases. So with more use cases comes
- 22:32more adoption. And 20 states have them.
- 22:36I don't know the exact number that are in progress or are
- 22:39scheduled, but there's a bunch. So I think all the states are
- 22:44seeing that they need to do something that is digital.
- 22:50For the most part, they're supporting A consistent set of
- 22:54standards, which is basically the M doc standard for MDLS.
- 22:59But then again, nothing is completely consistent.
- 23:02So the problem exists, you know, kind of when you zoom out, you
- 23:07know, the US is a microcosm of a bigger fragmentation issue
- 23:12globally. So for the private sector to
- 23:15plug into MD LS, it might seem OK, Apple Wallet supporting it,
- 23:20I'll plug into that. Wait, some states don't do Apple
- 23:24Wallet. What about Google?
- 23:25What about Samsung? What about direct?
- 23:27So there's always going to be an issue with fragmentation that's
- 23:30going to slow down kind of the ultimate adoption.
- 23:33But I think you are being a little pessimistic because there
- 23:37is a lot happening in the US I'm.
- 23:39I'm fine with that, not. Nearly as much as what's
- 23:42happening in the EU. So we have 50 states.
- 23:46The EU has 27 member states, so half, but still a bunch, right?
- 23:53450 million citizens, so about the same population wise.
- 23:59And like you said, they do have, you know, a sweeping regulation
- 24:07that's coming into effect and that's EI desk too.
- 24:11So by the end of 2026, each member state must make available
- 24:19at least one ID wallet to their citizens.
- 24:24And by the end of 2027, it is mandated that regulated entities
- 24:33as well as Vlops, which is very large online platforms.
- 24:38Vlops, I guess. Yeah, yeah.
- 24:43Are you a VLOP? You must plug in, but they must
- 24:47support the EU digital identity wallet for identity verification
- 24:56as well as customer authentication flows.
- 25:01And I believe it says as the first choice.
- 25:05So 2026, every citizen needs to have access to a wallet, at
- 25:10least one in each member state. So the word at least means some
- 25:16member states are going to have more than one.
- 25:18So there's going to be a bunch of choices out there and then
- 25:21every regulated entity and BLOP need to plug in, make it
- 25:26available for identity verification, authentication as
- 25:30the first choice by the end of 2027.
- 25:32So if you're an IDV company, if you're a regulated entity, if
- 25:37you're a VLAP, the time to start looking into this is now because
- 25:42this is mandated by their regulations.
- 25:45So they are pushing acceptance along with the issuance side.
- 25:49And it's just amazing because these are digital identity
- 25:53wallets. They're privacy preserving.
- 25:55The individual gives consent to data sharing.
- 25:58There's so many elements in here that is just like a good model.
- 26:02And I talked about Brazil, I talked about a couple different
- 26:05places. I know South Korea is has done a
- 26:08lot of work with digital identity.
- 26:10A lot of countries, they're looking at this as the template
- 26:14for how they should evolve or introduce their systems to their
- 26:19citizens, and I think that's tremendously good news.
- 26:22I can't imagine there's a balance of, you know, citizen
- 26:27demand and government required use cases.
- 26:33I think of that identity verification process and with
- 26:37the Eid is really enabling those processes to be more efficient
- 26:42and better. And that seems to be the
- 26:45transition where it's actually a government service that
- 26:49enterprises can leverage these technological improvements.
- 26:56Am I zeroing in? Is that kind of that linkage?
- 27:03I'm not sure I completely understood your point.
- 27:06Yeah, so my point was. In my world.
- 27:08No, no, no, you, you kind of talked about the identity
- 27:11verification piece in the beginning and it's like, yes,
- 27:14those are the mechanics, but it seems to me the verifiable
- 27:17credentials and this transition to EIDS kind of greases the
- 27:23tracks for that. For the identity verification.
- 27:27Yeah. Yeah.
- 27:30I mean, so the EIDS and the verifiable credentials transform
- 27:36the consumer, the individual's experience from, you know, a
- 27:41hassle to one click. So I don't know if your average
- 27:45person has intrinsic demand for this, right.
- 27:50Like a lot of people aren't walking around saying I wish I
- 27:53had an identity wallet. However, the average person
- 27:56knows that signing up for things can be a pain.
- 27:59They know that they don't enjoy password resets and text
- 28:04messages and you know all this stuff.
- 28:06And they know that fraud is rising.
- 28:09So they want solutions to that. Those are their kind of jobs to
- 28:14be done right, to use product lingo.
- 28:17So this is, and people want data privacy too.
- 28:21You know, I, I don't think your average person understands that
- 28:24centralized databases collecting their data getting breached lead
- 28:28to identity fraud. I mean, this is stuff that we
- 28:30understanding in the industry, but you know, people want to
- 28:34access things easier and to feel safe.
- 28:37But I think we've gotten jaded. You know, there's a breach every
- 28:40day, every week. It's like OK.
- 28:42I ignore. What did I do about it?
- 28:44Nothing. Not just this.
- 28:44At this point, yeah, you know. So that idea of like, well, it's
- 28:48centralized, it's already centralized.
- 28:50So how? How are we supposed to fix that?
- 28:55Well, that's what the, you know, some of the regulation and data
- 29:01privacy, you know, regulations that are also in effect, like
- 29:04these things are certainly being pursued by the European Union
- 29:10and fixing, it's not going to be overnight, right?
- 29:13But this is the whole kind of philosophy right behind Web 3
- 29:16and decentralized approaches. I mean, just even beyond the
- 29:20identity fraud, we are all giving our data to centralized
- 29:26places to then monetize our data instead of we benefit and
- 29:30monetize our own data. So if you think more broadly
- 29:33just about all of that, you know, that's flipping, you know
- 29:37the script. So this is a microcosm of that.
- 29:41So you share only the data that is needed to be shared.
- 29:47And, you know, there is liability and risk for
- 29:51organizations to be storing too much personal data, especially
- 29:56as the regulators catch up and there begin to be penalties for,
- 30:01you know, breaches and other, you know, liability, right, for
- 30:06allowing data to be misused or breached.
- 30:09So there's a lot of work to be done, right, to completely solve
- 30:13what you're talking about. However, this is a significant
- 30:17step in the right direction. So that's all coming.
- 30:21That's going to be in place. It's going to be mandated by the
- 30:25end of 2027. However, you know, it sounds
- 30:29great on the surface, right? Private sector is going to
- 30:33benefit by also having less fraud and offering better user
- 30:37experiences. However, there are 27 member
- 30:41states. Even though the, you know,
- 30:45overall framework is consistent, there still are different
- 30:49standards, different states. Each state has their own trust
- 30:54registry. Working with each government to
- 30:57gain access like these are all challenges where even though the
- 31:02EU is unified, it's still challenging for a single entity
- 31:09to plug into the wallets of all member states.
- 31:13Even just the effort of testing with, you know, at least 27,
- 31:18possibly double the number of wallets depending on how that
- 31:21all emerges with the different protocols.
- 31:25There's Open ID Connect, there's Open ID for VC, there's the ISO
- 31:32standards, like there's just different things to consider
- 31:36from a technology protocol level.
- 31:39There's the trust management, there's the key management,
- 31:43there's keeping up with, you know, any of the regulatory, you
- 31:47know, things that need to be kept up with with respect to
- 31:50integrating to each ID wallet. So the EU has also defined
- 31:55what's called an intermediary role.
- 31:57So this is basically the network or the hub that takes the
- 32:03responsibility for sorting through all of that and creating
- 32:06the integration to the 27 member States and then allowing the
- 32:11private sector to connect to make it easy to have it
- 32:16normalized to take all that complexity out.
- 32:18So the intermediary is also a certified role in the EI desk to
- 32:25framework. And that's also a really big
- 32:28unlocking mechanism that the EU has put into place and made an
- 32:33explicit role that requires, you know, certain certifications
- 32:38and, again, data privacy being front and center.
- 32:42So where do we go from here? Because it doesn't sound like
- 32:44this is a technology issue. We have standards, we have
- 32:48different components for interoperability.
- 32:50So I'm curious like where's, where's this going next?
- 32:53Are there any specific trends or things that you've kind of
- 32:55identified? And then my follow up to that
- 32:58is, OK, so there's probably some trends you're going to tell us
- 33:00about. Is there a specific area that is
- 33:03quicker like historically? And what I'm thinking is like
- 33:06finance, you talk about fraud, nobody wants to lose money.
- 33:10Finance might be a leader in this, but are there is, is that
- 33:13right or are there other other industries or verticals that you
- 33:16think are adopting, you know this idea faster?
- 33:20Well, I think age verification is something we haven't really
- 33:23touched on and that's, you know, a subset, I would say of digital
- 33:28identity. So we certainly see a lot of
- 33:31legislation globally around age verification, particularly with
- 33:38protecting restricted, protecting minors from
- 33:42restricted content. So we see that in Australia, we
- 33:46see that in the UK, we see that in certain states in the US.
- 33:49So again, a bit of a fragmented landscape.
- 33:53You know, however, there's a lot of interest in privacy
- 33:56preserving techniques, making it simple because it's something
- 34:00that has a high frequency of use and that's, you know, usually a
- 34:03really important determining factor for kind of taking all
- 34:06the friction out of a user experience.
- 34:08So that has been a driver in certain areas that's creating
- 34:13another, you know, path to adoption and awareness and
- 34:18causing private enterprises to plug in these types of
- 34:21capabilities. Financial services, as you say.
- 34:25As you say, I would say that kind of global fintech firms
- 34:31tend to be on the leading edge. Something that I'm personally
- 34:35really excited about is, you know, this movement, this sort
- 34:40of parallel movement on the financial side to stable coins,
- 34:44to tokenized assets, You know, all of that results in money
- 34:49being able to move cross-border with instant settlement instead
- 34:52of, you know, the various waiting processes that exist in
- 34:56the legacy framework with anything instant, you need to
- 34:59have really, really great also instant deterministic identity
- 35:05verification, government issued ID's are the solution to that.
- 35:09And most of those businesses do tend to have a global scope.
- 35:13So certainly plugging into both developed and developing
- 35:15countries to do that I think is really important.
- 35:19And we see demand and drivers there.
- 35:22And just in general, financial services, I mean, they're
- 35:25getting hit with a ton of fraud. This is a solution even if it
- 35:29doesn't cover every person. As the coverage begins to take
- 35:34place, if you can start solving for it, start plugging it in to
- 35:39the user journey, start experimenting with it, measure
- 35:43the different outcomes. You know, we're starting to see
- 35:45that moment momentum now. I've personally seen a huge
- 35:48interest, even though it's still pretty nascent, but financial
- 35:53services, fintech, marketplaces, social media sharing economy,
- 36:01they all want to plug into mobile driver's licenses.
- 36:04It's just a matter of sort of creating the right pathways
- 36:08because the value is there. And if they can do it for a
- 36:12segment, you know, and work their way up, you know, there's
- 36:16a lot of interest in starting those tests today and then
- 36:19you're going to sue the adoption that you're asking about.
- 36:22So we then we're still in that fragmented environment, right?
- 36:25Where it's like, OK, 20 states have it.
- 36:27I'm in a state that doesn't have it.
- 36:29Is it all of a sudden now the, you know, the citizens or the
- 36:34residents of that state are pushing their local government
- 36:38to adopt this? Is that one way to kind of get
- 36:41this to move faster? Because it'll never move as fast
- 36:43as everyone wants it to and it'll never be 100%.
- 36:46But I feel like at least in the US, until we have all 50 states
- 36:50on it, which means now it is distributed like a driver's
- 36:53license, that will be one thing that really kind of drives the
- 36:58adoption to move things forward. The other thing that I, I, I
- 37:01kind of get concerned about is we talked about KYC on the fraud
- 37:05side of things. What about know your employee,
- 37:08right? There's a lot of instances of
- 37:09fraud where people are getting hired that aren't who they say
- 37:11they are and there's really no Kye know your employee, know
- 37:16your contractor, know your, you know, whoever may be that.
- 37:19I think there is an opportunity to take identity verification
- 37:21down that route versus just my customer, which tends to be
- 37:26more, you know, a commercial sort of environment.
- 37:30Oh definitely. And I should have mentioned that
- 37:33in the use cases that are drivers, I mean, know your
- 37:36employee workforce management, there is, you know, just new
- 37:41vectors of fraud in in all of that.
- 37:44So, and this is an example where, you know, an employer
- 37:49might even have a need to have, you know, their own sort of
- 37:53wallet for their employees for access for events, for, you
- 37:59know, providing different benefits that maybe need to go
- 38:02seamlessly. So like your imagination can
- 38:06really run wild, right, with different things you can do for
- 38:09your workforce. If you had this concept of a
- 38:12secured, you know, credential wallet, you could issue
- 38:16different credentials for different things.
- 38:18So there's all sorts of stuff that you can do, but workforce
- 38:21management definitely is one area.
- 38:24And that's something that's becoming more and more regulated
- 38:27as well, like enabled through a digital channel.
- 38:30Because it wasn't that long ago. And I've worked with some
- 38:33customers in the UK where they would be bringing on remote
- 38:37employees and that remote employee would have to drive 3
- 38:39hours to come in just to show their passport in person and
- 38:44all. Those people got hired during
- 38:45like, COVID, had to go to somewhere.
- 38:48I remember I had to do this, you know?
- 38:50Yeah, it's a pain. Yeah, it's a pain.
- 38:53And so that's changing. So I I guess in summary I agree
- 39:00with you. Great.
- 39:01I'm going to isolate that and that'll become, you know, the
- 39:03theme for the show. I want to wrap up the
- 39:06conversation with something that we that you originally started
- 39:08with. You mentioned you took some time
- 39:09off and you mentioned rainforests and you mentioned
- 39:12adoption of dogs. So I have two adoptions of my
- 39:15own, probably going to be adopting another one here when I
- 39:18get back. I want to hear about your dogs
- 39:22and tell me a little bit more about that because I'm with you.
- 39:24Adopt, you know, dog shop, right?
- 39:27And they are such a big part of our family now.
- 39:29So I want to pivot to dog talk. Dogs all day, tell me.
- 39:34About how many dogs do you have? You know, give me, give me some
- 39:38insight into what's happened. I personally have three dogs, I
- 39:42have a German Shepherd and I have two Pitbull Husky mixes.
- 39:48Because that's a loud house. That's a loud house.
- 39:51It's there. Well, coyotes like to visit my
- 39:54house and they howl to my dogs and then my dogs howl back at
- 39:59them. The pit bull Huskies, do you
- 40:02know, they're all high energy dogs, So I got to say they keep
- 40:05me in shape. They're all rescues.
- 40:08And the third one I rescued during my time off and I went up
- 40:14to the shelter in LA. And I learned more about the
- 40:18situation where there's just a record number being surrendered.
- 40:22And I decided that I had to do something about it.
- 40:24So I started working with the volunteers and the rescue
- 40:27organizations, and I started specifically looking at how to
- 40:31facilitate out of state adoptions because we have a
- 40:34really bad situation here in California with just the
- 40:37shelters. They're at like 200% capacity.
- 40:40And most of the dogs in there are just wonderful pets.
- 40:43All three of my rescues are the best dogs ever.
- 40:47You know, they can be a bit of a pain.
- 40:49The Husky mixes they like to bowl.
- 40:51Dogs are the best people you know.
- 40:52The dogs are the best people and they're grateful.
- 40:55They know they've been rescued. And it just breaks my heart
- 40:58because, you know, all dogs deserve to have love and a good
- 41:03home and a leader and all that good stuff.
- 41:05So I decided to see if I could help facilitate out of state
- 41:10adoptions. So I worked on that for a while.
- 41:13I was trying to figure out how to make the process slower.
- 41:16I mean, honestly, it's just a really heart wrenching,
- 41:19difficult, very manual thing to do with sharing and trying to
- 41:25find people to adopt the dogs, arranging for logistics.
- 41:29You know, I looked into things like finding extra capacity with
- 41:34truckers to help drive dogs to different locations.
- 41:37So I I just did a bunch of work and trying to figure out how to
- 41:40facilitate mainly out of state adoptions and to get some dogs
- 41:44out of the shelter so. My wife volunteers for Mountain
- 41:48Pet Rescue in the Asheville area, so shout out to Mountain
- 41:50Pet Rescue. I know they're listening to the
- 41:52identity center guys, but you know, being part of those
- 41:56convoys, right, where it's kind of like they'll take them from
- 41:58here to here and then someone else, you know, they move from
- 42:01one car to another to get them across state lines or to large
- 42:04distances. It's amazing that volunteer
- 42:06effort that is taking place. And it's such a grassroots thing
- 42:09because it seems like every shelter is overflowing.
- 42:11And so I can't imagine our house without the dogs that we've
- 42:16adopted. They are such a big part of our
- 42:18family. Now we have 3.
- 42:20We lost one last kind of Christmas.
- 42:22And so now we're, I get to pick the next one.
- 42:24So we'll hit to the, the, you know, to the shelter probably
- 42:27when I get back from Grapevine and, you know, figure out, you
- 42:30know, what makes sense, you know, from a family dynamic and
- 42:34making sure and, you know, letting our dogs be part of that
- 42:36as well because they've got to get along too.
- 42:38So it's a big part of it. But I just, I can't imagine, you
- 42:41know, what would life be like without those dogs?
- 42:44I know. Me neither.
- 42:45I've got three dogs. I also have two cats.
- 42:48The smallest cat with little stubby legs and he's kind of
- 42:51chubby. He's the pack leader of the
- 42:54animal ecosystem in my house. They have their own, you know,
- 42:57thing going on, but the little cat is the leader of everyone,
- 43:02including the big dogs. That's.
- 43:03Personally say it's not just dogs, it's also cats.
- 43:06I'm sure other pets as well. Goats, chickens, I mean bunnies.
- 43:11Yeah, I have to. I have to draw the line
- 43:13somewhere. I don't want to turn into like a
- 43:14farmyard, but I'm good with dogs.
- 43:17I'd like to adopt A pig and I'd like to have chickens.
- 43:20But you know, it's there's, it's a lot of work to maintain.
- 43:25We feel like I'm always clean enough after now that my kids
- 43:27are older, I keep adopting animals and, you know, my
- 43:30husband is like, OK, can we stop?
- 43:32You know, you don't need to just keep filling the house.
- 43:34I'm like, I don't know, I just, I like to take care of other
- 43:37living beings and. We have chickens sort of like in
- 43:40the area of our where we live, but we also have black bears and
- 43:44those things attract things along with, you know, mountain
- 43:48lions and all kind, you know, hyenas and not hyenas, but Cody
- 43:51coyotes and stuff like that. Like there's those are
- 43:55definitely dangers that we have to kind of take into account.
- 43:59We've we've had several close calls of bears and our dogs
- 44:01where a bear will come through our front yard and kind of
- 44:04around and, you know, the dogs are outside and next thing you
- 44:07know, it's like, you know, if the bears typically don't want
- 44:10anything to do with it and they'll kind of scurry away.
- 44:12But yeah, that's that's not something that I know who's.
- 44:14Going to win that fight, right? Yeah, right, right.
- 44:17So I'm, yeah, again, I'm not interested in testing it, but
- 44:20that's, that's kind of where we're at right now, Yes.
- 44:23One one of my dogs jumps our fence to go play with packs of
- 44:27coyotes. We had to extend our 6 foot
- 44:30fences to 9 feet and she managed to launch off a boulder in our
- 44:35backyard. And actually I, I was like
- 44:37standing out there and I saw her do it and she launched over a
- 44:40nine foot fence to go play with the coyotes.
- 44:42I was like, all right, I give up.
- 44:45Can't stop the can't stop containment.
- 44:47It's like what it is what it is. I appreciate you taking time
- 44:50with us. It's been a while since we got a
- 44:52chance to talk, so it's kind of good to reconnect.
- 44:53And I feel like there's so much hope here that we can be
- 44:57glomming onto. And I'm going to try to be more,
- 44:59you know, positive to try and get there.
- 45:04But I just, I want to go faster. Like decentralized identities,
- 45:08digital wallets sounds great. Yeah.
- 45:12But get me there faster. That's my plea, You know, to the
- 45:16people who are listening, that actually can make those happen.
- 45:18But get there faster. Yeah, yeah.
- 45:20I couldn't agree more. Big benefits.
- 45:23But you know, the acceleration curve has really just steepened
- 45:29in the last couple years. So it's going to keep going
- 45:32faster. I know it.
- 45:34OK. We'll go and wrap it up.
- 45:35Jim, anything else? No, sounds great.
- 45:37OK, All right, we'll go ahead and leave it there for this
- 45:39week. Thanks everybody for watching
- 45:41and or listening. You'll find us on the web
- 45:42idacpodcast.com. Let's see idacpodcast.tv, the
- 45:47YouTube like subscribe that helps us get great guests like
- 45:50Sarah to join us. And yeah, so thanks everyone for
- 45:53watching or listening, and we'll talk with everyone in the next
- 45:55one. I've been listening to Identity
- 46:00at the Center. We hope you've enjoyed the show.
- 46:03Make sure to like, rate and review, and we'll be back soon.
- 46:08But in the meantime, hit the website at
- 46:10identity@thecenter.com. See you next time on Identity at
- 46:16the Center.