Latest / Crimes and Consequences / EP200: When Teenage Girls Kill
Transcript
- 0:00This episode may contain content of a graphic nature, including descriptions of physical and
- 0:05sexual violence against adults, children, and animals. Listener discretion is advised.
- 0:12Hi everyone, I'm Talia and I'm Tanya, and together we are Crimes and
- 0:17Consequences a true crime podcast. This episode may contain content of a graphic nature,
- 0:37including descriptions of physical and sexual violence against adults, children, and animals.
- 0:43Listener discretion is advised. Hi everyone, I'm Talia and I'm Tanya,
- 0:49and together we are Crimes and Consequences a true crime podcast. Hi Tanya,
- 1:08Welcome back everybody to this week's Crimes and Consequences. We are so happy to
- 1:15have you guys back. Definitely, if you haven't done so already, hit
- 1:19the follow, subscribe like whatever button you gotta hit. Tell your friends because
- 1:26we have an awesome story today. Is it really awesome? Right word?
- 1:33Not the right word? I feel bad saying it. It's gruesome. Guys,
- 1:36haven't followed us before. We do swear and we do go into details
- 1:44in this episode. It's really it's pretty great. It's it's horrible. But
- 1:51with that being said, are you ready to go? I am okay?
- 1:57So, do you remember being a teenage. Were you ever a teenage girl?
- 2:00Never? Yes, absolutely I was. I hated yet middle school was
- 2:07terrible, horrible, was worse. They're all assholes. Yes, everybody's an
- 2:10asshole. I have teenage kids. Everybody knows. I think teenagers are assholes.
- 2:17M it's really hard in school being a teenage girl. I'm sure it's
- 2:23hard as a boy in a different ways, in a different way. So
- 2:30this story is about a group of teenage girls, and it's just really sad.
- 2:38So that interroduction, thank you, thank you for the warning. I'm
- 2:44gonna start it. It's gonna bring you back to the reasons why you load
- 2:51high school, middle school. You know, we all talk about boys,
- 2:57boys whatever growing up. I mean, they made a movie about teenage girl
- 3:01bullies, mean girls, mean girls. Okay, yeah, well we all
- 3:05had everybody had boys. But now it's a big thing. So this is
- 3:08a case even more dramatic. This is more of I don't know how to
- 3:15describe it out. You know, I'm just gonna tell the story, Just
- 3:17tell it. So. Shanda was born in Pineville, Kentucky, on June
- 3:23sixth, nineteen seventy nine. Her dad was Steve, her mom was Jacqueline
- 3:29and she had a fairly normal upbringing, but they ended up getting divorced,
- 3:34and her mom got divorced a couple of times, she moved a little bit.
- 3:39The second time, they moved to Albany, Indiana. And this is
- 3:43in June of nineteen ninety one, and she was about twelve years old.
- 3:47She was enrolled in Hazelwood Middle School. She was considered a good kid.
- 3:52She had a bright future, she's smart, she had hair look yours,
- 3:55curly hair, curly blonde hair. She had a good future. She didn't
- 4:00have any problems, and prior to moving, she didn't you know, had
- 4:05good grades, was participating in school, all those things. When she got
- 4:10to the new school, she gets nervous. I mean, it's hard to
- 4:14fit in when you're twelve new school. When I was twelve to a whole
- 4:18new school, you did, I did, honestly, I did, truly.
- 4:23I wish I could have when I was twelve, but it was difficult.
- 4:25Yeah I can't. Yeah it'd be horrible. So she's trying to impress
- 4:29the kids fit in. On her third day of school, she was trying
- 4:33to prove how good she could be and offered to help this new friend she'd
- 4:42made on the first day of school break up with her boyfriend. Oh okay,
- 4:46okay, she didn't know that this boy was a cousin. Okay,
- 4:50follow me on this okay, was the cousin of an older girl named Amanda
- 4:57heavn Evren. I think it's Hevren. We always pronounced things wrong, right,
- 5:00Yes, it's so. When she is when Shanda's trying to facilitate this
- 5:09breakup, Amanda, the older cousin walks up and tries to intervene with a
- 5:16Shanda and says, you know, you need to mind your own business.
- 5:21Of course Amanda should have probably her own her own Yeah, and then they
- 5:27got into a physical flight. Oh no. Now there's a sixteen year old
- 5:30girl. Her name is Melinda Loveless, and there's a reason why her last
- 5:35name is loveless because she's got no love. She had, well, not
- 5:41in her heart. No. No, she had quite a history despite her
- 5:47young I mean she's sixteen. And when I say she has quite a history,
- 5:51she was pretty fucked up. Yeah. Unfortunately she was a little background
- 5:57on her because she is part of this story. She was born in New
- 6:00Albany, Indiana, in nineteen seventy five. She's the youngest. She was
- 6:05the youngest of three daughters. She her mom's name was Marjorie and her dad's
- 6:12name was Larry Loveless. Marjorie's Larry's wife later described him as a perpet.
- 6:24Oh no, would wear her and her daughter's underwear stop it and make up,
- 6:30stop it. And you know, he always cheated, and there was
- 6:35this mixture of jealousy and fascination when he would watch her have sex, okay,
- 6:43with other men and women. So I don't know exactly what's going on
- 6:46in this household, but in this household a dad were in like your underwear,
- 6:53your sister's underwear, your mom's underwear, makeup, and watching his wife
- 6:58have sex with other people. Yeah, okay, sure that Melinda knew that,
- 7:01but yeah, Throughout most of their relationship, Larry was pretty unfaithful to
- 7:09his wife, and as I hinted at or just came out and said they
- 7:15had open marriage, he would often share Marjorie with some of his friends from
- 7:20work. Oh no, his friends from work. She didn't really like it,
- 7:28and they would have orgies with other couples at their house. Marjorie didn't
- 7:33really want this, and she didn't want her husband wearing her underwear and like
- 7:38daughter's underwear. There was a lot of Larry's ideas. Yeah, and so
- 7:42she tried to commit suicide. Oh no, she tried to do that quite
- 7:46a few times during Melinda's childhood. Okay, so you understand little Melinda's background.
- 7:54When Melinda was nine years old, Larry forced Marjorie to participate in a
- 8:00gang bang. Oh no, this just gets worse and worse. And afterwards
- 8:03she tried to drown herself. Poor Marjorie's doing things she really didn't want to.
- 8:09Yeah, after that, Marjorie's like, I'm done, I'm I'm not
- 8:18gonna have I need no sex for a while. And he ended up violently
- 8:24raping her in front of her daughters. Are you kidding me? Oh my
- 8:30gosh, this household is disgusting, so terrible, beyond terrible, right,
- 8:37Marjorie, Poor Marjorie, all those kids, all those kids. In the
- 8:41summer of nineteen eighty six, after she would not let him go home with
- 8:48two women, they were out at the bar. They're still together. That
- 8:52they met at a bar. He beat her so severely she was hospitalized and
- 8:58he got arrested for it. There are a lot of court later on court
- 9:03testimonies. And I'm just gonna skip a little bit ahead just because it goes
- 9:09to the background that claimed that he fondled Michelle, which was Melinda's sister as
- 9:16an infant, molested Marjorie's thirteen year old sister more his kids. But this
- 9:26is Marjorie's thirteen year old sister. Oh, Marjorie's Okay, I understand molested
- 9:33Melinda's cousin Teddy from the age of ten to fourteen, and both of her
- 9:39older sisters said that he molested them. Wow. But Melinda never ever stated
- 9:50molested her. Okay. She did sleep in the same bed with him until
- 9:56he abandoned the family eventually at the age of fourteen. Wow. Okay,
- 10:00Mmm, I'm very uneasy, I'm very uncomfortable. In court, Teddy described
- 10:09later on an incident which Larry had tied all three girls, Melinda, her
- 10:15two sisters up in a garage and rate them in succession. But the sisters
- 10:20didn't confirm this account. That's right, you said, Melinda never said that
- 10:26he did anything to her. Okay. So I described Melinda, and I
- 10:31told you about Amanda. Remember she's a cousin to who Sandra is trying.
- 10:39Sanda and remember I told you about Amanda starting to fight, Oh yes with
- 10:46Shanda. So Melinda, now follow me on this. Melinda and Amanda are
- 10:56lesbian lovers, Okay, very open about it at least, I mean they
- 11:03were open about it, but it wasn't accepted at the time. Right.
- 11:07They were a really serious relationship for more than a year, even though sixteen
- 11:11years old, how serious can they be? They had like an obsessive relationship,
- 11:20and so maybe you know, when you're sixteen, fifteen, sixteen,
- 11:24you've been with somebody for a year, it's like you've been married twenty years.
- 11:28You guys like know your soul. Right. So their relationship Amanda Melinda's
- 11:35fizzles out. And even though Shanda and Amanda had had that physical altercation,
- 11:41they're teenagers, right and forgive and forget, Okay. So they started spending
- 11:48more and more time together and these passed notes between each other, and there
- 11:56was a school dance coming up, and Amanda agreed to be Shanda's date.
- 12:05Okay, well, I mean she's twelve though, no, maybe she just
- 12:11idolized Amanda is older. Okay. Melinda didn't like it. Wow, oh
- 12:16boy, she showed up and she got really pissed off. She was threatened,
- 12:22and she warned when she found out, she warned, Shanda brought her
- 12:26stay away from Amanda even though they're broken up. Ye, well, I
- 12:31know, well when your teenage girls are you really broke up. I don't
- 12:37know. But Shanda didn't. No, no, no no. Through this
- 12:46time passed, Shanda began doing worse in school. So she's in this new
- 12:50school. Her grades are poor, and she was hanging out with Amanda more
- 13:00and more and more. And I told you, Amanda is troublemaker. She's
- 13:05not somebody you want your kid to be hanging out with. Okay, every
- 13:09time Shanda got in trouble, it was always with Amanda. Oh. Her
- 13:16mother thought of Amanda as a thug. Oh no, and a horrible influence
- 13:24on her daughter, which she was. She was, she was. She
- 13:26was always getting in trouble, it sounds like. And so her mom tells
- 13:31Shanda, you're done, you are cut off. You are not allowed to
- 13:35hang out with Amanda. No, but did you obey? I didn't care
- 13:45what they know. I was going to find a way around that ship.
- 13:46Absolutely. When I was growing up as a team, important to you and
- 13:52you get a window or whatever, I never snuck out a window. No,
- 13:56I was the backdoor for me. But you get what I'm saying.
- 14:01Yeah, So, I mean, her mom couldn't couldn't stop the lossoming friendship
- 14:07slash potential romance going on. They began seeing each other behind her mom's back,
- 14:16and then one day Shanda's mom intercepted a letter from Amanda that Amanda had
- 14:22written to Shanda, and it was revealed what the true extent of their relationship
- 14:28was. It was romantic, and her mother was flord I mean, she's
- 14:37twelve and with an older teen in a lesbian relationship. And so her mom
- 14:48actually was so upset she removed Shanda from the school. Wow, yes,
- 14:54and she enrolled her at Our Lady of Perpetual Help CAPTA at school. She
- 15:01went to Catholic school. Catholic school. Boy. Yeah, she took her
- 15:05right on my public school. We're done. We're done with that public school
- 15:09bullshit. She just realized that this my daughter's changing, This is bad,
- 15:16she's getting into trouble. She's too young for this, and took her out.
- 15:22Within three weeks, she'd made new friends at her new school, and
- 15:26she tried out for cheerleading. Oh nice, and Amanda kept trying to stay
- 15:31in touch with her, but Shanda had moved on. She got this new
- 15:35school, cheerleading, new friends. It's not like she can hop in a
- 15:39car either and go visit Amanda. I mean, and it's not like she
- 15:43had a lot of ties to Hazelwood School because she hadn't been there that long.
- 15:50So Shanda kind of let her go. You know, Amanda began sending
- 15:58her letters asking her, you know, why aren't you responding to me?
- 16:03And there's evidence that Shanda was writing a letter to one of her friends,
- 16:10seeing how she wished Amanda would stop writing letters and following her. She was
- 16:15following her, Yeah, and just leave her alone. Wow, I mean,
- 16:21she was just ready to move on, but there was no stopping Amanda.
- 16:27And this, I told you, this is gruesome. There's a reason
- 16:32why I didn't do this in our other I don't know, two hundred episodes,
- 16:37because it's so bad telling you okay, yes, you're like yes,
- 16:41yes, it's just gonna get when I say bad. So now we're on.
- 16:48We're in the morning of Saturday, January eleventh, nineteen ninety two,
- 16:52and we're in Indiana. Two quail hunters were headed to their favorite spot,
- 16:59and it's Jefferson County. Never been there, and they found they saw this
- 17:03strange object in a soybean field near Lemon Road. At first they thought it
- 17:12was a rubber blow up doll someone had discarded and burned. Oh no,
- 17:19burns like I mean a bow. I don't know, I don't know,
- 17:25I've never owned one, and throw it away. Oh no, Well,
- 17:33they didn't want to think it was anything else but a blow up out.
- 17:36I'm sure that it was burned. Oh that's terrible. And they got closer
- 17:40and the reality of what was before them, it's traumatizing. Obviously it wasn't
- 17:49a dollar. Was the charred remains of a human body. There was a
- 17:56pair of panties on the body, but the rest of the body naked and
- 18:02burned. When I say burned, I mean extensively burned from the waist up,
- 18:08like horrible chart chart. The legs of the body were spread out as
- 18:18if it'd been posed, and the arms were stretched skyward and clenched, fists
- 18:29lunched. The victim was a pure to being young woman, but the chest
- 18:36had been burned so badly that it was really difficult to tell. But I
- 18:41mean they guessed it was a young woman. This is so horrible to say.
- 18:48The most horrifying of all of this was the victim's face. The eyes
- 18:53were empty, there was no color. The mouth was wide open, and
- 19:00it exposed teeth clenching tightly together on the victim's tongue. Oh, she had
- 19:08bit her tongue and her fists were clenched. Oh. I can't even I
- 19:15didn't even want to picture this. Don't picture it. So they call the
- 19:18police. The Jefferson County sheriff his name was Buck Shipley, and a bunch
- 19:25of detectives and all the investigator and crime scene people. They come out and
- 19:29they do forensic evidence of the scene. A forensic expert his name was Sergeant
- 19:36Wells. He arrived at the crime scene a little later and he recorded it
- 19:41with a video camera and he took photographs and there were tire tracks around where
- 19:49the body was and footprints, and so they're doing this examination. They're doing
- 19:55casts of all of that. They're getting evidence. With Sergeant Wells, he
- 20:00was very experienced forensic detective and he had a ton of knowledge, and it
- 20:07appeared to him that something had intentionally been used, some sort of flammable substance
- 20:17to destroy physical obits. This body didn't just be lit on fire, like
- 20:23there was something poured on her. Okay. Examining the genital area of the
- 20:33body, he noted that the victim's panties had been pulled to one side,
- 20:38and the condition of the body indicated enal molestation either prior to or immediately after.
- 20:48That just fucked up. Yeah, this one's bad, I know,
- 20:52that's why. So he's examining the body and he discovers a metal plastic body
- 21:00containing trace amounts of gasoline, and that was in the weeds nearby. The
- 21:07corner arrives on the scene. They collected some hair samples from the victim.
- 21:12They removed a ring from the victim, and when they were examining the ring
- 21:18that was free from the victim's hand, he discovered that it was When he
- 21:23was looking at the ring, he discovered that it said Jeffersonville High School class
- 21:27ring with the initials s G H engraved on it. And what I mean
- 21:36he thought that spart was bad. Oh, no, there's more. It's
- 21:38worse. It's just the investigation. It's so bad. And Tony and I
- 21:48always say we're dead inside, right right, Well, this one rings feeling
- 21:55and emotion to me, Yes, this is bad, so let me go.
- 22:00First, investigators thought the killing was maybe a drug deal gone bad.
- 22:03I don't know why they thought that, but they couldn't make sense of why
- 22:08someone would display the body, pose the body, and leave it out in
- 22:11the open, like I wouldn't eybody do that. It had been apparent that
- 22:15the body had been dragged twenty yards into like a brush area. Like had
- 22:21it been dragged twenty yards where it was located, it might not have been
- 22:26discovered for years. It was a remote area, but they left out in
- 22:30the open. It was out in the open, like in a spot where
- 22:33as I was saying, the quail hunters could see versus just right. The
- 22:41only logical explanation was that whoever did it had assumed that the body would be
- 22:47burnt so badly that it wouldn't they wouldn't be able to it wouldn't be identifiable.
- 22:52That's what the investors thought, So we can leave this body out in
- 22:56the open because no one's going to know what it is, who it is?
- 23:00YEA. Later that day, these detectives ten and Glenda Lawrence. Okay,
- 23:10okay, so there's still more people involved. There's a lot of people
- 23:15involved, and it's hard when there's a lot of people involved. But we
- 23:18have Melinda right, we have Amanda right, and we have Shanda, yeah,
- 23:25okay, Shanda a victim. Later that day lived In and Glenda Lawrence.
- 23:30They're spending their Saturday afternoon watching television when their daughter, now her name
- 23:37is Tony, she's fifteen. She walks through the front door. She's followed
- 23:42by her best friend Hope Anne Hopes parents, Oh, Carl and Gloria Rippy.
- 23:52Something was obviously wrong. So we have one victim. Four teen age
- 24:00girls, Tony, Hope, Amanda, and Melinda. Okay. Before her
- 24:08parents, Tony's parents could say a word, Tony just starts babbling incoherently.
- 24:14She's really upset. She's in a state of shock. Basically, they were
- 24:19really concerned, you know, what's going on? And so Tony's mom,
- 24:25Glenda, takes her into another room while her dad talks to Hope's parents.
- 24:32The Rippy's what is going on? What the hell is happening? Carl Rippy
- 24:40told Clifton that the girls had said this is Tony and Hope, that they
- 24:45witnessed some murder earlier that day. He said the details are sketchy. Now,
- 24:52imagine as a parent, he's going over to another parents' house, letting
- 25:00those parents know, Oh, hey, by the way, your daughter and
- 25:03my daughter witnessed a murder, right, what the fuck is that? He
- 25:08says, the details are really sketchy, but he believed them. He believes
- 25:12these girls are telling the truth. So you have Clifton and he's just trying
- 25:18to understand, you know, what is happening. And he said, let's
- 25:23go to the police station. That's what he's telling the Rippy's but they said,
- 25:29no, they're getting an attorney. Well we're attorneys. I mean,
- 25:33I kind of understand me, so like, yeah, part of me is
- 25:37like, oh, let's go to the police right away. The other part
- 25:41is, I don't think of what I'm calling it to call my attorney,
- 25:44but a murder, I know, murder unless my kid was involved, right,
- 25:52and it'd be an attorney and the cops. Yes, after the attorney.
- 25:57Yeah, if it was just witnessing it, like I got, I
- 26:00stumbled upon somebody getting murdered, you still would call it. It's just after
- 26:08nine pm and that's when Tony's parents they go to the Sheriff's office. The
- 26:15department. When the sheriff's deputies here about this young girl talking, this young
- 26:22girl telling them about claiming to have information regarding a murder. They come on
- 26:30in, come on in, let's talk. And they talked to Tony and
- 26:34she said, like the following she spent the previous night with two friends.
- 26:40Hope, what told you about Hope? Rippy? She's fifteen. Now we
- 26:45got another girl to add to the story. Okay, my name is Lori
- 26:48Tackett. She's seventeen. The three had driven to New Albany and Lori Tackett's
- 26:56car and they picked up Melinda Lovelace again. She's sixteen. She's a friend
- 27:00of Laurie's, whom Tony had never met before. After picking up Melinda,
- 27:08they'd gone to a hardcore punk rock show for a few hours and then they
- 27:14just kind of had it back. Tony said that on the way back,
- 27:18Melinda began talking about a girl named Shanda, seeing that Shanda was trying to
- 27:26steal her girlfriend, and that she really wanted to kill Shanda, which is
- 27:33Tony's ever even met Melinda. And here this girl is saying she's fifteen.
- 27:37You're like, why, okay, whatever, Although I think I kind of
- 27:41remember being a teenager, and my emotions were kind of intense. And if
- 27:45I said I wanted to kill somebody, I didn't really mean I wanted to
- 27:47kill somebody. Except it's a little different this time, right, it is
- 27:49a little different this time. Before the lawrence has left the police station,
- 27:53they informed Sheriff Shipley of the Ripley, of the Rippy's plan to attorney up,
- 28:03to get an attorney, Okay. As the sheriff was deciding what do
- 28:08I do next, he received a missing person's report from Clark County. Oh,
- 28:14Sanda share Wow was reported missing eight hours earlier, but for some she'd
- 28:22been missing eight hours. His heart, the sheriff's heart just sink. He
- 28:30read the description of her blonde hair. She's only about five feet tall.
- 28:34Oh, she was little and one hundred pounds, Oh, very little,
- 28:37And that described the Jane Doe Eddie. Yeah. He started paperwork to get
- 28:47warrants for the He started paperwork. He wanted to get warrants based on what
- 28:52Tony had said for the arrest of Laurie and Melinda. And there was a
- 28:57rush put on it. As you know, it's basically an emergency warrant where
- 29:02someone calls the judge late at night. They get that all done, and
- 29:04as they're doing their paperwork, they received word that teeth of the victim.
- 29:11So I guess I wouldn't really be an emergency one because we can get them
- 29:15at night. But as they're processing, and I should say that in match
- 29:18the dental records that were provided by Shanda SHARE's mom. That has to be
- 29:26awful. But give me take my daughter's dental records to the police and then
- 29:32having to tell there's a match. It was almost two am by the time
- 29:38that Sheriff Shipley and Detective Henry got arrest warrants for Laurie Melinda. Laurie's vehicle
- 29:47had been spotted at Melinda's mother's house, so the investigators went there to get
- 29:52the warrants. The next morning, doctor George Nichols did an autopsy. Shanda
- 30:02so bad, like everything is, it's so bad. The procedure revealed that
- 30:07she suffered multiple injuries. There were ligature marks found on her wrists by these
- 30:15girls. She had lacerations to her head, her neck, her legs,
- 30:21her fingers were so distorted that they had to cut them off to take prints.
- 30:30Because I remember I was telling you clenched fists. Oh that's terrible.
- 30:34And they had removed her jaw to help make the positive identification. The upper
- 30:41part of her body. It's covered in fourth degree burns, not third degree.
- 30:48Fourth degree. It's bad, it's I mean, there's nothing, Yeah,
- 30:53there's like oh not there really like And I told you her tongue was
- 31:00protruding out of her lunched teeth. She had last rations to her anus rectum
- 31:07indicated a blunt object had been sort of at least three three and a half
- 31:12inches. Oh, by these girls. Unbelievable. The set us Partania and
- 31:22why haven't E gotten to all the set us? But most revealing was there
- 31:26was suit o. Sorry, most revealing is there was in her airway.
- 31:36Oh no, she's been alive. Oh no, she was set on fire.
- 31:41That is so cruel. That's I'm sorry, I mean it's horrible.
- 31:48Yes, okay, So investigator's question Melinda and Lori. And then they transported
- 31:56them because they had those warrants to Indiana sort court and that's in Madison,
- 32:00Indiana. I don't know where that is. A single count of murder was
- 32:05entered against both girls, and of course they get quarter pointed attorneys, right,
- 32:10in a separate hearing, the judge his name was Ted Tad, we've
- 32:15both girls from the juvenile system, and determined that they should be tried as
- 32:20adults. Oh yeah, yeah. And then prosecutors ended up speaking with Hope
- 32:27Rippy's attorney. Remember she's the one turn it up regarding her involvement. And
- 32:35by this time, everybody heard about this, the media, it was swarming.
- 32:40I even heard about this case. Who knows what you were doing.
- 32:45I don't know what I was doing in nineteen ninety two. I mean,
- 32:49I know what I was doing, but I still know about this case.
- 32:51I'm not going to say why we're recording what I was doing. But it
- 32:54made national headlines. It's terrible, and there was the public demanding justice for
- 33:01Shanda. The immediate attention, I mean, it was just massive, tinya,
- 33:07it was massive because you have all these teens, right, these teens.
- 33:12It's shocking, it's shocking. Apparently more and more started coming out,
- 33:19and Melinda and Lori had fast two three people who reported that to the police,
- 33:30so you know they're teens. They told everybody, Yeah, we're just
- 33:32chatting about about it. You wouldn't believe what I did last night. Oh
- 33:37this girl. Wow, who said teens you can't shut your mouth from the
- 33:43teen gossip whatever. So everything started falling into place, and the muscators slowly
- 33:47pieced together what happened to Shanda. Everybody. Of course, when you have
- 33:55a group murder, everybody shifts them to everybody else. Right, what you
- 34:04did, yes, minimizes what they they are. I was just watching.
- 34:07I told them not to write. So each girl downplays their own role in
- 34:13the murder. But there are statements in general matched up as to what happened,
- 34:17and there's a picture that's formed based on their confessions and the statements by
- 34:23other people, even though it's here say about what they confess to, and
- 34:29the evidence uncovered by investigators. So we know what happened and Shanda's last hours
- 34:37of life. And I I Am going to have a really hard time telling
- 34:45you about it because it's really fucked up, and we we do the most
- 34:49fucked up stories. Yes, and as you say, buckle up, yeah,
- 34:52buckle up everyone. It's a gruesome skill. So it's by the night
- 34:59of Friday, January tenth, This is nineteen ninety two, Melinda Loveless had
- 35:06she lost her mind with jealousy, right, jealousy over Amanda, over Amanda
- 35:09who Shanda isn't interested in anymore, and she really wanted to show out how
- 35:16serious she was about Amanda's affections or Shanda. Laurie. Laurie came over,
- 35:27and Melinda knew that Laurie would be a good enough friend help her put the
- 35:31plan that she had in her head into action. Linda had always thought Lurie
- 35:37was strange because Laurie dabbled in the occult and she claimed to have another personality
- 35:45that was a vampire. Okay, okay, okay, okay, he needs
- 35:53girls. I tell you what the fuck I never claimed. I mean,
- 35:57I was weird, but I never I'm avaire now. But she was a
- 36:01voted friend and she'd often talked about killing someone for fun. Yeah, that's
- 36:07why she knew she'd be She's like, oh, she's gonna help. Yeah,
- 36:10yeah, absolutely. So that's when Laurie picked up two of her friends
- 36:15and then went to Melinda's house. You know, she got Hope and she
- 36:21got Tony. And I told you Tony had never met Melinda before. Hope
- 36:27it met her once, maybe twice, but she didn't like they were just
- 36:31acquaintances. When the girls got to Melinda's house. They all went upstairs and
- 36:37they began talking about what the night had in store. All of them had
- 36:43already lied to their parents earlier that day, telling them, Oh, I'm
- 36:45spending the night at this person's house. Well I'm spending the night at this
- 36:47person's house. Blah blah blah. They all sat together and they're talking and
- 36:52Melinda pulls out a large kitchen mine from her purse. What what the fuck?
- 37:00You probably hung out with people like that. I just blocked it out.
- 37:02But what? And she she said she was going to use it to
- 37:07scare someone. She told Hope and Tony about all the problems she'd been having
- 37:12with Shanda, and Linda got out Shanda's address, and before long the girls
- 37:19were on their way to Shanda's house. They had a difficult time finding it
- 37:24at first, But I mean, back then there was no Google Maps.
- 37:29Now, I can't even do it with Google Maps. By the way,
- 37:30I can't do it with you know maps whatever, you all on my phone,
- 37:35let alone try to do it back then, but then it was more
- 37:37difficult, definitely, Yeah, yeah, but I'm still I'm still struggling with
- 37:40There wasn't even anyway, so they have a difficult time at first, and
- 37:46they have stopped multiple times asked for directions, and eventually they found it went
- 37:52around. They parked a half of black away. Since Hope and Tony had
- 37:59never met Shanda, Melinda told them to go to the door. Claiming to
- 38:01be friends of Amanda. Melinda wanted the girls to lure Shanda out of a
- 38:10car. So, Hi, we're Amanda's friend, I don't you know?
- 38:15They knocked on the door, Shanda answered. Tony and Hope explained to her
- 38:21that they were friends with Amanda and that she was waiting for her. She
- 38:25wanted to talk and that she was at a deserted building in the woods called
- 38:32the Witch's Castle. I'd be like, no, thank you, Yeah I
- 38:37would. I would definitely not go. Shanda said, I can't go right
- 38:42now, my mom's still up, but said, do you know what,
- 38:45I'll sneak out later, come back around midnight if they wanted to, and
- 38:51if they did, she'd go with them. Tony and Hope agreed and they
- 38:55had it back to the car. Melinda was really angry Shanda didn't want to
- 39:00go with them. She was upset because she was ruining plans, but eventually
- 39:07she calmed down, and now they had some time to think about things,
- 39:13more time to kill no pun intended. So they decided to go to a
- 39:21concert at any nearby state park. Yeah, they went to a punk concert
- 39:23or something. That's where they went to that hard Well, you know what,
- 39:25why we're waiting, so let's just go check this concert out. Right.
- 39:30It was about twelve thirty by the time they made it back to Shanda's
- 39:34house. Tony didn't want to go back out to the door. I mean,
- 39:38I don't I wouldn't knock on someone's door. I mean, it does
- 39:43make sense to me, But Hope and Laurie agreed to. Melinda was the
- 39:49only one of the bunch that Shanda knew, so she hit it in the
- 39:53backseat under a blanket because Shanda knew me. Linda didn't like her, right,
- 40:00right, So she's hiding under a blanket. And Shanda's young, yeah,
- 40:06and she's tall. She's like, oh, well, you know,
- 40:08sneak out with some teen girls and go me, Amanda and talk to her.
- 40:14I mean, I am not judging absolutely shit. And if you listen
- 40:19to our other episodes, shit I did as a teen. Okay, there's
- 40:22no judgment. So they get there, the Shanda is actually waiting at a
- 40:29side door. When Laurie and Hope start walking up, they tell her,
- 40:35oh, Amanda's you know, waiting for you, and you know, we
- 40:38came back to pick you up. And Shanda was hesitant at first, but
- 40:45Hope was able to convince her to go, and they all ended up going
- 40:50and getting into Laurie's car. Tony slid out of the front passenger seat so
- 40:55that Shanda like that's where she had been, so Shanda could sit in the
- 41:00middle, and they were on their way. Lori explained to Shanda that the
- 41:05Witches Castle was just a short drive away in Utica, the city of Utica,
- 41:12and then it used to be one of one of the homes of nine
- 41:16witches. Oh, the Witch's Castle, yes, who controlled the town.
- 41:21Oh, what a fun story. Again, That's why I'm not going in
- 41:25the middle of the night to a place that was girls. I don't know,
- 41:31not much any of it. No, not Halloween scares me like that
- 41:37ship. But no, no, I'm not going with strangers to them.
- 41:39I don't want, I don't know, I mean no. So they're driving
- 41:44to this castle and Hope ask Shanda questions about Amanda and their relationship. And
- 41:50suddenly, now keep in mind, the front seat is being occupied by these
- 41:55girls. Melinda pops up from the back seat. She grabs shand up by
- 42:00the hair and put a knife to her throat. Oh they must have scared
- 42:06the ship out, she cried, Oh yeah, and begged Melinda, please
- 42:08don't hurt me, Please don't hurt me. But for the remainder of the
- 42:13ride, Melinda berated her, called her a bitch, all while holding this
- 42:19knife tightly against her throat. Sanda was sobbing. She was She was sobbing
- 42:24uncontrollably. By the time they reached the Witch's Castle, Melinda and Laurie pulled
- 42:31her out of the car and held her by her arms tightly as Hope and
- 42:37Tony music. I believe it was a flashlight too highlight the trail. I'll
- 42:43know it was lighters to highlight the trail to the castle. It was pitch
- 42:49black. I'm sure the middle of the Witch's Castle with people you don't know.
- 42:53She knife. So there is this I don't know what exactly what the
- 43:00Witch's Cats was, but it was this building is it was like a stone,
- 43:02abandoned stone brick. Me thinking like cedar, not seed, a cinder
- 43:08black kind of brick building. And there they pulled her out of the car.
- 43:14They held her arms. There's lighter's guiding the way. It's a nightmare.
- 43:20It's the nightmare. Once they get inside, Melinda tied Shandah's hands as
- 43:24Hope started taunting her. You know it's group it's a group thing. Yeah,
- 43:32you get enough people together, you would do something you wouldn't normally do
- 43:37by yourself. You know, I'm always floored when you hear these types of
- 43:40stories where like or five plus people get together and they all just participate on
- 43:46each the hell Hope was actually holding a knife. Oh, holding the night.
- 43:52Melinda took off a lot of Shanda's jewelry she had on, and she
- 43:59had Tony put it on her take herself. Hope decided she liked a musical
- 44:06Mickey Mouse watch that Shanda was wearing, so she took it from Shanda herself.
- 44:13So it's start in this castle. Larry Laurie took an old T shirt
- 44:20and she started fire some light. As the flames grew, Lorie pointed at
- 44:25the fire and told Shanda that that was what she was going to look like
- 44:30before the night was over the burnt shirt. But before I tell you more,
- 44:37we're gonna take a quick break. Shanda was so frightened she couldn't speak,
- 44:45like catatonic, like paralyzed. Yeah, she's sobbed uncontrollably. Lorie was
- 44:53growing nervous because there were some cars that were driving by the road that the
- 45:00castle was on, and she started saying, maybe we should leave, Maybe
- 45:05we should go to another place by my house. So the girls dragged Shanda
- 45:13back to the car and they drove off with her. When they ended up
- 45:17stopping it up five Star station. It's gas station, and Shanda was stopped
- 45:23behind the backseat and covered with a blanket as Melinda stood guard outside of the
- 45:30car. Or we pumped some gas to get some gas they were running out
- 45:37while Hope went inside to pay and Tony called a front from a payphone.
- 45:42Hey girl, what's up. During the conversation, Tony didn't mention anything about
- 45:46she end up being held captive or all the crazy shit going on were just
- 45:53kidney. A girl still isn't real. I don't know. I don't know.
- 46:00For someone who later claimed to be really distraught over the night's events,
- 46:04she didn't she could have called somebody, she could have stopped something. As
- 46:08soon as she Tony got off the phone, they took off. It took
- 46:14nearly an hour for the girls to reach Madison. The city of Madison,
- 46:19Laurie pointed out her house and a few miles later they ended up pulling onto
- 46:23a logging road and they stopped open. Tony got out of the car and
- 46:29Melinda and Laurie yanked Shanda from the back seat. Now, at this point,
- 46:36Shanda's hands had been tied. Melinda untied them and ordered Shanda to remove
- 46:45her clothes. Ah, and it's really it's cold out. That's so humiliated,
- 46:52Yeah, right right, it was cold, hoping. Tony ended up
- 46:57getting back into the car and they took positions by the window so they could
- 47:04watch what would happen. Shanda stripped down. Yeah, she's threatened with a
- 47:10knife by Melinda, and Melinda then scooped up her clothes and threw them in
- 47:15the car. So now you have this twelve year old cold naked. And
- 47:23when Melinda threw the clothes into the car, she kept saying, all these
- 47:29will be souvenirs for you girls. Pope picked up Shanda's polka dot bra and
- 47:37put it on. As Tony turned the radio on what That's just weird?
- 47:45Lorie grabbed both of Shanda's hands and held them behind her backs so that Melinda
- 47:52could punch her. Oh. Shanda begged them to just let her go and
- 47:57swore I will stay away from Amanda, but each time she said anything,
- 48:04she just got punched and told her shut up. Suddenly, Melinda punched Shanda
- 48:13as hard as she could in the stomach, and Shanda collapsed to the ground.
- 48:19She was gasping for breath and she begged, please just stop, please
- 48:23stop hurting me, but Melinda didn't care. Melinda picked her up by the
- 48:29hair oh and repeatedly slammed Sanda's head into her knee. Oh. Ouch,
- 48:37Oh, your knees pretty hard, dude. This is this is terrible.
- 48:43The multiple blows caused Shanda's braces to cut her lips and blood started coming out
- 48:50of her mouth. I'm sorry, I get I have teen girls and Okay.
- 48:59So she's laying on the ground now and she's moaning, and Milinda pulls
- 49:02out the knife and she tries to cut her throat. But the knife that
- 49:06Melinda had brought, that she carried in her purse because whatever she's seventeen year
- 49:10old, asshole. It was too dull to cut the skin. So Hope
- 49:15gets out of the car and she helps hold Shanda down as Winda tries using
- 49:22her foot to help force the knife like the pressure biparker, but that still
- 49:30didn't work. They couldn't slice her throat, so Melinda and Laurie took turns
- 49:37stabbing her and the chest with a knife. Oh but the words, the
- 49:42wounds from that knife, they weren't severe enough to cause immediate death. So
- 49:49Laurie decided, we'll let strangle her, and she went back to the car
- 49:54and was looking for something to use to strangle her. In the meantime,
- 50:00Shanda is bagging for her life, and while she's bagging for her life,
- 50:07Melinda gets in her face and starts laughing, bitch, dude. Yeah.
- 50:15When Laurie returned, she actually had some rope bench Sandy, and she put
- 50:22her around Shanda's neck and she pulled with all her might until Shanda's body went
- 50:29limp. They didn't know if she was dead not, but she was unconscious,
- 50:36so they put her body in the trunk and they had to Laurie's house,
- 50:39which was I told you a few miles away. When the group got
- 50:44there, the girls went upstairs to Laurie's room and Laurie pulled out some stones
- 50:50to try to read their future. Really really what. Just as Laurie said
- 50:58that their futures looked good, her dog started barking, and when the girls
- 51:02listened out the window, they could hear Shandah's muffled screams, oh no,
- 51:08coming from the trunk. Oh no. Lorie ran into the kitchen and she
- 51:15grabbed a pairing knife, and she ran outside and she opened up the trunk,
- 51:20and without warning, she started stabbing Shanda multiple times with a pairing knife.
- 51:27M When the screaming and the like muffled the sounds, I'm sorry the
- 51:34sounds from the trunk. When Shandah stopped making sounds, the trunk was closed
- 51:42on her and Lorie returned to her room where everybody was waiting. Yeah,
- 51:47she was covered in blood. After a repause, Lorie announced that they needed
- 51:52to go for a ride. That's when I hope and Tony are like you
- 51:57know what, nah? When they were were some Linda and Laurie left by
- 52:05themselves. So they're driving around trying to figure out what do we do next?
- 52:13And then at one point they stopped to see if Shando was dad or
- 52:16not. When they opened the truck. When they opened the trunk lid,
- 52:22Shanda set up card and blood. Poor girl with her eyes rolled back like
- 52:30rolling back in her head. She tried to speak, but could only mumble
- 52:37the word mommy, Oh, this is so look at I have goose bumps
- 52:43and I know the story. Yeah, I just got them too, told
- 52:46her this is horrible. This is why I didn't do it for years,
- 52:51for years. Laurie then reached into the trunk, picked up a tire iron
- 52:57and struck Shanda on the head, and she closed the trunk and they drove
- 53:02off. Short time later, they're traveling down these winding roads and they could
- 53:09hear some like sounds coming, and they stopped and by the trunk they were
- 53:15girgling sounds, and Laurie quickly, you know, she's they're over on the
- 53:21side of the road. They pulled over the side of the road, and
- 53:22she's trying to figure out, what do we do? What do we do?
- 53:27Melinda stays inside the car and Laurie walks to the rear of the car
- 53:31and she opens the trunk and Shanda she's still alive, alive. She's lying
- 53:39on her side. She looked as though she'd been painted red and was making
- 53:45these strange gasping and gurgling noises. They were sounds coming from her chest wounds.
- 53:53Laurie took the tire iron again and hit Shanda and the head more times.
- 54:01One of the blows was so severe that a chunk of her skull.
- 54:07Oh no. So at that point, Laurie is certain that she's dead.
- 54:14She's got to be dead, right, So she shuts the trunk and she
- 54:17walks back towards the front of the car. When she got inside, she
- 54:22put the tire iron under her nose and she smelled, smelled it for a
- 54:27second, and she began laughing. Yes. And she just said to Linda
- 54:35as she put it under her nose, like, smell this. You're laughing.
- 54:39Ah, these girls are psychotic, psychotic. So this is when going
- 54:45on for hours, right, the sun is starting to rise, and it
- 54:50started around twelve thirty. They decided to head back to Laurie's near Laurie's house
- 54:55to burn her body. Along the way, they stopped several times because they
- 55:02could hear Shanda, Oh right, it is true. Hold on, I'm
- 55:10sorry along the way, they stopped several times to try to quiet Shanda because
- 55:17she was still making sounds. They hire iron unbelievable. They ended up bag
- 55:24at Laurie's and they woke up Hope and Tony and they bragged about how they
- 55:30just what they did, and they explained they had a new plan and they
- 55:36wanted Hope and Tony to come with them to what Laurie considered to be the
- 55:42burn pile. Oh so Laurie had a burn pile at her house. Basically
- 55:49that was her burn pile. And the girls quickly discovered, Okay, this
- 55:52isn't going to work because there's frost over it, and I don't. They're
- 55:58teen girls, it's not gonna work. It's called trust. They're plant stupid,
- 56:01and so they don't. They don't know what to do. So they're
- 56:05talking about it, and they didn't have any gasoline, they didn't have any
- 56:08waiting to really start a fire. So instead Lourie decides to show Hope her
- 56:15handiwork. Oh no, he says, let's go to the trunk and let
- 56:22this check this out. Tony wouldn't go. I mean, she didn't want
- 56:27to look at the body. So since she didn't want to look at the
- 56:30body. She was told to get in the car and start it up,
- 56:32and if she heard any screaming from Shanda, to rev up the engine to
- 56:37like drown the skins. Yes. Yes. Laurie opens the trunk and Hope
- 56:44notices a bottle of windecks next to Shanda, so she picks it up and
- 56:50she begins spraying Shanda with wind decks, and the winds would fizzle until oh,
- 57:00you're not ready for this. You gotta get ready, Okay, Shanda
- 57:04somehow finds the strength to sit up. This is amazing, like in a
- 57:09horrible, the worst way possible. Yes, that's why this poor girl suffered
- 57:15for hours. It's been putting windecks on man, everybody's sock. I fucking
- 57:22hate people. I can't even tell you I hate most people. No,
- 57:27I don't hate Tony. I don't hate you guys, right, but most
- 57:30especially a lot of peopkers we cover in these says. She's covered in blood.
- 57:38Her eyes are described as pure white. They beat, and she's just
- 57:45she's destroyed. She's swaying back and forth, and Lorie talks to her,
- 57:51but she doesn't respond. At some point, evidence suggests that that is when
- 58:00they sodomized. They annually rate Shanda with a tire iron. Why would you
- 58:07do that? These are just none of them ever admitted to doing it,
- 58:13to doing that. They don't have any knowledge of the wounds inflicted into her
- 58:19anal cavity. That's I think Laurie did it beyond cruel. It is,
- 58:28but I don't know for sure. It is alleged. Okay, what she's
- 58:31convicted? Not of that? Think not of that. Okay, you're right,
- 58:37Laurie's just stop. You're a lawyer, innocent and totally guilty. Yes,
- 58:42And I don't want to get sued. Do you want to get sued?
- 58:45Give them. Laurie's mother then yelled out the door for Laurie, and
- 58:51Laurie slammed the trunk down on Sanda Shanda's head. Once Lori returned from the
- 59:01house, the girls decided, Okay, we need to make her die once
- 59:07and for all. They're driving. They're driving down the road, and they
- 59:15concluded together that the best way to get rid of Shanda was a burner.
- 59:21H really, really, they've already tried stabbing, guarding throat, r hitting
- 59:30donny times. So Lorie pulls into Clark Oil gas station it's it's just north
- 59:37of Madison and get some more gas and tells Tony basically to take a two
- 59:45leader bottle and fill that with gas. So there's two were safe a two
- 59:52leader bottle? What the fuck? I know this isn't well thought out.
- 59:55They're gonnam finished what they started and the girls drive down Lemon Road. Hope
- 1:00:04was familiar with the area and she actually suggested a good spot to get rid
- 1:00:09of. I know the perfect place. It was fuck an old logging road
- 1:00:15I told you about before they turned in and they stopped the car. Laurie
- 1:00:22opened the trunk and Melinda and Hope helped her pick up Shanda with the blanket
- 1:00:29which they had covered her. They covered her earlier before slammed the trunk down
- 1:00:34when Honor basically had when Lori's mom called out for Tony chose not to help,
- 1:00:43and she sat in the car and she watched as the girls carried this,
- 1:00:47you know, the limp body, but a little tiny Shanda, I
- 1:00:52mean she's set, I know, hundred pounds, poor kid. And they
- 1:01:00carried her several feet behind the car and then they laid her on the ground.
- 1:01:07Hope took the two little gasoline and poured it onto and then Laurie struck
- 1:01:14a match and they threw it down on her gas soap body. The gasoline,
- 1:01:22of course they already know. Instantly, Yeah, ignited and to the
- 1:01:29girls it looked like the burning was going well. M m. They hopped
- 1:01:35back in the car and they began to pull away when Melinda became really nervous
- 1:01:39and said, you know, Laurie's driving. Says Laurie, let's turn around.
- 1:01:44She just wanted to make sure that the body was still burning. They
- 1:01:47go back to the scene. Melinda, she grabbed the bottle and there was
- 1:01:52some gasoline still in it, and she ran over to Shanda's body. She
- 1:01:58stood there and stared momentarily as Shanda was curled up in the fetal position and
- 1:02:07her tongue was starting in and out of her mouth as she burned alive.
- 1:02:16After she felt she'd seen enough, she poured the remaining gasoline on Shanda's body
- 1:02:24and went back to the car. Linda thought, Shandah's death. What's the
- 1:02:32word throws death? Yeah? I guess death, throes of death, yeah,
- 1:02:37death, burning to death. It's funny. And she later, I
- 1:02:42told you told people about it, remember, because they can't mouth. This
- 1:02:45is funny. They thought it was super funny that because they had seen her
- 1:02:50tongue going in and out. Oh hilarious, as she's burning alive child.
- 1:02:57Finally, Sanda was out of Melinda's life, and Laurie seemed to enjoy herself
- 1:03:02during the crime. Well, you know, she always wanted to kill somebody,
- 1:03:06and Hope and Tony maybe they were caught up in the moment, I
- 1:03:09see, like what the fuck right? I mean, because they had multiple
- 1:03:15opportunities. I mean, this lasted hours upon hours upon hours, and they
- 1:03:21chose not to you know what, you can say it at Laurie's house for
- 1:03:27probably a couple hours. They took an they slapped and went back. They
- 1:03:34could have laughed, They could have called the police. I mean, do
- 1:03:37you know what they did next? What they weren't to make dum? Oh?
- 1:03:40Well, you know, killing makes you work up in the appetite,
- 1:03:44you know what them I know, I'm sorry, believable, I fucked them.
- 1:03:52Well, they're having breakfast, Maria Melinda joked around several times how sausages
- 1:04:03they were eating reminded them of Canada. Oh, because they were charred,
- 1:04:12these fucking girls. They had decided earlier that Lorie would sleep over, but
- 1:04:20because it's it's still like early morning. But they first wanted to make some
- 1:04:28calls and they wanted to brag to people before they decided to call it a
- 1:04:33morning or whatever a night. So that is collectively what we know happened.
- 1:04:43It didn't take long for the prosecutor, his name was Guy Townsend, to
- 1:04:45bring charges against Hope Tony. I mean they came in right and they were
- 1:04:54both charged with murder, arson, battery with a deadly weapon, aggravated battery,
- 1:04:58criminal confinement, and intimidation. During that arraignment, the judge decided they
- 1:05:02would be tried as adults too. They had a brief appearance where they were
- 1:05:08taken to jail. Later that same after noon, Melinda Lovelace and Lori Tackett
- 1:05:15they were bought I told you, brought before the judge and they were charged
- 1:05:19with all those crimes, including chadlstation oh No. A month later, on
- 1:05:26April ninth, nineteen ninety two, additional charges for felony murder were filed against
- 1:05:31Melinda and Marie So. August seventeen, nineteen ninety two, Tony was found
- 1:05:39slumped over in her cell oh She was rushed to the hospital and it was
- 1:05:45determined that she'd taken an overdose of how do you pronounce it, Lorizia Laura
- 1:05:49Pram. Yeah, isn't like a xanax anti depressant. She'd been saving them
- 1:05:58up. Oh, to kill herself. Did it work? No, Well,
- 1:06:03initially she was in a coma. Yeah. She ended up being in
- 1:06:08intensive care for eleven days before she even regained consciousness, so she was pretty
- 1:06:14serious about it. Yeah. After she recovered, the judge had her transferred
- 1:06:17to a mental health facility. M Hm, you and I talked about it.
- 1:06:24Got mixed feelings. She's fifteen, right, but what happened so fucked
- 1:06:29up. But she's fifteen, I got I have mixed feelings. You we
- 1:06:33all know how you feel. Gil Mall, gil mall, but lock him
- 1:06:39up for block him up forever? Yes. Yeah. She ended up being
- 1:06:43in the mental health hospital until in the October of nineteen ninety two she went
- 1:06:48back to jail. All four girls were tried as adults, as I told
- 1:06:53you, and to avoid the death penalty, they all accepted plea bargains.
- 1:06:57Laurie, and you're not gonna like the outcome of this story. Laura Melinda
- 1:07:02were sentenced to sixty years. Okay, okay, Indiana Women's Prison in Indianapolis,
- 1:07:09with time reduced. Stop it. They were both released in twenty eighteen
- 1:07:15and two thousand nighteen. We're just gonna cut the chase. They're released.
- 1:07:17They're out. Yeah, okay, that's wrong. That is so wrong.
- 1:07:23They are out. They are out, Okay, living their best lives.
- 1:07:27I'm sure maybe not hopefully not listening or watching this. Well, they probably
- 1:07:33google themselves all the time. Yeah, so yeah, they're out. Was
- 1:07:39given sixty years, but she got a suspension for ten years as long as
- 1:07:44she you know, limitigating circumstances and stuff. So she had medium supervision and
- 1:07:50basically a long story short, I just know she was She did do some
- 1:07:58time. I shouldn't say she didn't do some time. But she was released
- 1:08:01in two thousand and six, so less than Melinda and Laurie. Tony was
- 1:08:06sentenced to twenty years in prison and she was released in two thousand, so
- 1:08:12she was everyone's out, Everyone's out. In March of two thousand, I'm
- 1:08:20library reporter. His name is David Lare sent a letter to each of the
- 1:08:25convicted murderers and really, yeah, is there I mean, yeah, why
- 1:08:29not, And he wanted to know their opinion on why someone would kill.
- 1:08:34Only one responded, and that was Lori Taggett. Two responded, sorry,
- 1:08:40that's okay right. Only two responded. The first was Lori Tagett. She
- 1:08:46responded, it's amazing this is what she wrote. Okay, Well, I've
- 1:08:53often wondered what motivates someone to commit murder myself? Really, she thought about
- 1:08:59it long and hard. Okay, she did it. Yeah, no,
- 1:09:04murderer has the same motivations as all the others. In my opinion, I
- 1:09:11believe killers are really deep individuals who are searching for some kind of release,
- 1:09:17are they? Whether it be mental, physical, or spiritual, it's always
- 1:09:21a release. There's always a purpose for one's actions. There could be many
- 1:09:27reasons. Let's say, for instance, I know a couple of people who
- 1:09:30kill simply for the fear that they see in their victims eyes and for the
- 1:09:36sight of blood in their on their bodies. My opinion is that they do
- 1:09:41it feel superior or high, and they get high on the victim's fear,
- 1:09:46and they're first, and they're thirsty with a spill of blood. Wow,
- 1:09:51she really had an opinion. She thought long and hard about this. How
- 1:09:56about maybe someone had a mental breakdown and lost it snapped. No, no,
- 1:10:00no, no, no, no, it's it's very deep, you
- 1:10:03see, for the spill of blood. They're deep individuals. Whatever it was,
- 1:10:11just instead of saying somebody, why didn't she just say me? Yeah?
- 1:10:15Right right? I mean, is that a Freudian slip, like a
- 1:10:17very long si? That's what I'm thinking. The only other reply came from
- 1:10:21Tony. In some ways, her views were similar. She said, I
- 1:10:29think the first time one kills, they killed to get a high that they
- 1:10:34would never be able to obtain any other way. Why would you respond to
- 1:10:41this? You know what's going to go in the newspapers or on the internet
- 1:10:45or wherever. Yeah, why would you even after this? Poor girl,
- 1:10:51poor Shanda was torture, tortured, She was tortured for hours and then murder.
- 1:11:00Why would you respond? What makes someone murder? People? Well,
- 1:11:02let me tell you. And then they read a whole fucking thing about it.
- 1:11:05Blood spit stop, and I would have came up with some better,
- 1:11:10Like I said, I'd running. I don't know, dude, I'd have
- 1:11:13no idea, right, I have no idea. Why are you're asking me?
- 1:11:15Yeah? The other two were smart and didn't respond. Yeah, I
- 1:11:19do know that, and I don't want people to lie like hate me.
- 1:11:25But some of them have made better lives for themselves. I mean, they
- 1:11:30were young. There is redemption, Tanya, there's redemption. There is redemption.
- 1:11:39And I do think I saw something that said she had his mom has
- 1:11:43forgiven them, and if she can, I guess we can. I don't
- 1:11:46have to know. You don't know, and I'm not going to I do
- 1:11:49know that that some of them do have strong regrets and have tried to better
- 1:11:56their lives. I would hope so, but fuck them. Sorry, you
- 1:12:02know how I feel. I don't, and I think it's probably a million
- 1:12:06times. I know, because when you go through it and you go through
- 1:12:09the details, you think your child, it's really big. I mean,
- 1:12:14I could never be able to get my kid never. Never. I can't
- 1:12:17believe. I mean I can't believe because they have. I obviously said it,
- 1:12:20but I just can't believe somebody has that strength that's willing to forgive someone
- 1:12:26that's murdered their child. I mean just playing murder, but horrifically tortured her.
- 1:12:31I mean that person, her mother is so strong, way stronger than
- 1:12:36me. I would be like, I would be still angry. But I
- 1:12:41guess a lot of people say, you know, they have to do that
- 1:12:45to move on. Yeah, and you can't live with that because you're just
- 1:12:47destroying yourself. That's that's true. But I think I would just destroy myself
- 1:12:50and live with anger. I know. But maybe I would be a better,
- 1:12:56bigger maybe like her. I don't know. I don't know. I
- 1:13:01sitting here at this moment, I don't know if I could. I haven't.
- 1:13:05I mean, thank god, I haven't gone through it. It screwed
- 1:13:08up. As I was as a teen, this kind of shit never crossed
- 1:13:13my mind. No, no, we used to be like, oh,
- 1:13:15she likes my boyfriend, I'm gonna go beat her ass. I mean that's
- 1:13:18as it went, pull her hair and then smoke a Dubie and some cigarettes
- 1:13:23and go to the football game. I never thought to kill anybody and wild.
- 1:13:28So this is just this is one of the worst stories I think that
- 1:13:31I've heard. We've had some bad yeah, yeah, horrika horrible, horrific,
- 1:13:38Yeah, terrible to them, yeah yeah. Go through our Oh today's
- 1:13:42our two hundred is it two hundred thousand, two billions? So you can
- 1:13:47listen to the other one hundred and ninety nine episodes. Right, So,
- 1:13:51we want to thank you guys all for take the time to listen and view
- 1:13:56us. It's really exciting for us to be able to do this. We
- 1:14:00hope you hit the like, follow, subscribe, Tell your friends, let
- 1:14:06them know about Crimes and Consequences. I'm Talia. This is Tanya, and
- 1:14:13we hope you see you next week. Yeah, and well we won't see
- 1:14:16you, but you'll see us. Don't kill each other until our next episode.
- 1:14:21Wait, we sucked that up said it's okay, don't kill each other.
- 1:14:28Bye bye,