Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / Scarce Assets E017: Avik Roy – Then They Fight You
Transcript
- 0:00Let's be clear, Bitcoin is an international asset.
- 0:04We are spending like drunken sailors.
- 0:08Bitcoin is the only economic entity.
- 0:10Where the supply is unaffected by the demand.
- 0:15If you want to preserve your wealth, you have to convert that
- 0:18currency into an asset that's scarce, desirable, portable,
- 0:23durable, and maintainable. Hello, my name is Andy Edstrom,
- 0:32and I'm happy to welcome you to the 18th episode of Scarce
- 0:36Assets, a show that examined scarcity, the most fundamental
- 0:39driver of economics and markets, and the scarcest asset of all,
- 0:42which is Bitcoin. It's great to be here with my Co
- 0:45host Jesse Myers and our guest, Ovic Roy.
- 0:48One of the reasons I'm fascinated to talk with Ovic is
- 0:51that he's already on his fourth career.
- 0:54He trained as a scientist and as a doctor at MIT and Yale.
- 0:58Then he worked in the investment business for Bain Capital.
- 1:01He started publishing on healthcare policy, first on his
- 1:04own blog and then in the Wall Street Journal, the New York
- 1:07Times, the Washington Post, and a number of other great
- 1:10publications. And he actually became policy
- 1:14editor at Forbes as well. So meanwhile, he became a policy
- 1:18advisor to governors and senators and multiple
- 1:22presidential candidates, and he's now president of Free OP,
- 1:26the foundation for research on Equal Opportunity.
- 1:30Now he's also a senior advisor at the Bitcoin Policy Institute.
- 1:33And I first encountered OBEX work in 2021 when he published
- 1:38an article in National Affairs magazine entitled Bitcoin in the
- 1:42US Fiscal Reckoning. This article was so good that I
- 1:45printed it out and I gave it to my wife and a bunch of other
- 1:48people, and I told them they had to read it.
- 1:51I think it's a brilliant framing of how Bitcoin can be helpful to
- 1:54the United States and U.S. citizens.
- 1:57But I also think it's just one facet among many of Ovic's much
- 2:02broader work on providing Americans with opportunities to
- 2:05lift themselves up. So I'm very happy to talk with
- 2:08him today about that. Ovic, how are you?
- 2:11Thanks, Andy. I'm doing all right.
- 2:12How are you doing? Doing well, Doing very well.
- 2:17Thinking about that article three years ago and some of the
- 2:22seeds that I think it planted for recent policy proposals
- 2:26within Bitcoin. But I want to table that
- 2:28conversation for the moment. And I'd love for you to hit some
- 2:32of the highlights of your background and career and maybe
- 2:35weave that into how those events and activities and milestones
- 2:40brought you to to founding Free OP.
- 2:43Well, you, you had on a, you had on a bunch of it, I think.
- 2:48I think what's interesting for me, you know, in terms of like,
- 2:52how did I get into Bitcoin? I've been been fortunate to have
- 2:55friends who are in the kind of Austrian econ world very early
- 3:00on. So I mean, I heard about Bitcoin
- 3:01from the beginning, but was just too intimidated by all the
- 3:03technical elements to get involved myself in those early
- 3:06days. And I had a pretty intense and
- 3:09busy career as a biotech investor, which took up all my
- 3:12time, didn't have bandwidth to pick up new hobbies.
- 3:15And, but as time went on, you know, I felt like it was
- 3:20important to start building that uncorrelated asset or at least
- 3:25then uncorrelated asset into My Portfolio and, and did so at a,
- 3:29at a scale that has worked out for me and, but still kind of
- 3:33kept that to myself. And, and, and just kind of what
- 3:37I, what I found is that as Bitcoin became a more
- 3:40significant part of my own portfolio, I had to pay more
- 3:42attention to it. And, and as the regulatory
- 3:47radar, as, as Bitcoin kind of hit the radar of Washington
- 3:50more, I felt like a lot of the skills and, and, and
- 3:58professional background that I had was maybe became more useful
- 4:01to the Bitcoin community. And I wanted to try to be useful
- 4:04to the Bitcoin community by bringing that, you know,
- 4:07Washington experience into the Bitcoin community and vice
- 4:10versa, to help Washington people, policy makers and the
- 4:14like, and the think tank world, sort of under the conventional
- 4:16think tank world, understand why Bitcoin was not a passing fad
- 4:19while I was, why it was going to be important and more relevant
- 4:22as time went on. And that's what motivated me to
- 4:25write that piece, Bitcoin, US Fiscal Reckoning to help
- 4:29Bitcoiners understand why Washington was important for
- 4:34them to take into account back, you know, 10 years ago, seven
- 4:37years ago. You know, 2017 was really when
- 4:41the SEC first started to crack down on crypto more broadly.
- 4:46But at that time, Bitcoiners had this kind of like, hey, you
- 4:49know, we're not crypto, we're fine.
- 4:51You know, the Bitcoin network will will keep going regardless
- 4:55of what governments think, which is technically true.
- 4:59But I think my view was that it it gave short shrift to the
- 5:04degree to which governments can make it hard for Bitcoin to be
- 5:07as maximally useful as possible. Take something as simple as in
- 5:11the US, technically speaking, if you want to pay for coffee with
- 5:15your Bitcoin, you have to file a capital gains transaction, you
- 5:20know, every time you do that. And that's because of U.S. tax
- 5:22policy, right? That has nothing to do with the
- 5:24functioning of the Bitcoin network.
- 5:26That's a very simple example. I could give you 20 more
- 5:29examples of how laws and regulations in the United States
- 5:32make Bitcoin less useful than it could be.
- 5:36And similarly for Washington, I think that they've generally
- 5:41seen Bitcoin the standard view in Washington as Bitcoin is just
- 5:44something that money launderers and tax evaders use and
- 5:47criminals use. It's not something that anyone
- 5:50who has a sincere interest in in money would would care about.
- 5:56And, and I, I did my best in that article to explain to them
- 6:00why actually Bitcoin is an exit strategy for those who worry
- 6:05about the debt and the money printing that goes on to
- 6:09basically support the, the rising and growing federal debt.
- 6:14And so, you know, it's always, it's, you never know how
- 6:18anything is going to get taken. You know, how people are going
- 6:20to take something when you, when you put it out there.
- 6:22But I was certainly very amazed by and grateful for the reaction
- 6:26from, from guys like you and so many others in the Bitcoin
- 6:29community and in the Washington community.
- 6:30So it was, it was worth the effort to put that piece
- 6:34together and, and I've been working on it.
- 6:36What you might call a sequel to that piece.
- 6:39I'm on the, as you mentioned, I'm on the board of the well, I,
- 6:42you mentioned that I'm a senior advisor of Bitcoin Policy
- 6:45Institute. I'm also on the board of the
- 6:46Texas Bitcoin Foundation and the Texas Bitcoin Foundation, which
- 6:51is led by Natalie Smolensky is in in, in is about to publish a,
- 6:56a book called the Satoshi Papers.
- 6:59And I have a chapter in that book called Then they fight you
- 7:04perfect chapter, which we can talk about today is basically
- 7:09about what you might call the sequel to this.
- 7:11So this original article of the Bitcoin, the US fiscal
- 7:13reckoning, which is OK, let's say this fiscal reckoning
- 7:16actually happens. Let's say the US does go broke.
- 7:19There is a fiscal and monetary crisis.
- 7:22Will the US go the path of Latin America and say, OK, we're just
- 7:26going to crack down and establish capital controls and
- 7:28basically prevent, even more so than they do today, people using
- 7:32Bitcoin and converting the US dollar to Bitcoin and vice
- 7:35versa? Or will the US try to adapt to a
- 7:39world in which Bitcoin is is a stronger and more widely used
- 7:44monetary mechanism than it is today?
- 7:49Will US try to adapt to that much?
- 7:51As some Latin American countries have said, OK, we're going to
- 7:54dollarize and we're going to use the dollar as our official
- 7:57currency to kind of prevent our own central bank from from
- 8:02making the mistakes that they are inclined to make.
- 8:06Might we just kind of take that out of our hands?
- 8:08So there's precedent for both, right?
- 8:10There's precedent for countries going to sort of Venezuela
- 8:13approach or the Argentina approach, pre Malay Argentina
- 8:16approach. And then there's the president
- 8:18for countries taking the opposite approach like say
- 8:21Panama, where they pegged their currency to the US dollar and
- 8:24kind of have outsourced or El Salvador pre Bitcoin, right?
- 8:26The old El Salvador in 2000 converted, got rid of their own
- 8:30currency, the Cologne, and converted to the US dollar.
- 8:32And that worked for them reasonably well from 22,000 to
- 8:36say, what was it 2021 when, when, when they adopted the
- 8:41Bitcoin standard. So I would say that there are
- 8:44these questions, what is the US going to do when they're when
- 8:46people are increasingly fleeing to Bitcoin, assuming that does
- 8:49happen, and this article explores some of the
- 8:52possibilities thereof. At Onramp, we believe that
- 8:55Bitcoin is the most important asset of the 21st century.
- 8:59The hard part is securing it right There are shortcomings
- 9:02with keeping your coins on an exchange, but also with setting
- 9:05up your own self custody arrangement.
- 9:08Onramp solves for these concerns.
- 9:10Our multi institution custody solution maximizes security and
- 9:14minimizes counterparty risk, ensuring that your Bitcoin
- 9:17remains securely in your possession and provides built in
- 9:20inheritance planning to ensure your family is protected as
- 9:23well. Onramp provides Peace of Mind
- 9:26for your Bitcoin journey, whether for your whole stack or
- 9:29for part of it as a compliment to your existing self custody
- 9:32setup. For more information, check us
- 9:34out at onrampbitcoin.com. Please, please.
- 9:38So if I'm not mistaken, Satoshi papers.org, you can find more
- 9:44information. But yeah, hit us with the hit us
- 9:46with the preview with the sneak peek on, then they fight you.
- 9:51So the basic, the basic thing I try to do in this paper is
- 9:54explore three different scenarios, what what I call the,
- 9:59the restrictive scenario, the palsied scenario and the
- 10:04munificence scenario. So you can kind of grade them
- 10:07sort of negative, very negative to somewhat negative to
- 10:10positive. There's not really a neutral
- 10:12scenario. It's more like a somewhat
- 10:14negative scenario. So the, the very negative
- 10:16scenario is a bit what I was describing just a minute ago.
- 10:20Let's say there's a crisis and the US says, you know what,
- 10:25we're going to respond to that crisis by completely cracking
- 10:29down on Bitcoin because we see people fleeing the US dollar for
- 10:33Bitcoin. And we're going to prevent that.
- 10:35Kind of like Roosevelt did in 34 with the executive order on gold
- 10:39Or, you know, China and other countries do today where they
- 10:42say, look, we're not. We're going to basically shut
- 10:43down the exchange of U.S. dollars for Bitcoin, which they
- 10:46can do. They can shut down, they can say
- 10:48to Coinbase and Kraken and all the big exchange, you're not
- 10:51allowed to convert U.S. dollars to Bitcoin and vice versa.
- 10:54They could for example say all if you want to own own Bitcoin,
- 10:58you have to do it through ETFs which we can regulate.
- 11:00You can't own the Bitcoin directly in cold storage.
- 11:04Of course people might not comply with that, but they
- 11:06could. They could.
- 11:07They could say that it's illegal to to have self custody Bitcoin.
- 11:13For example. They could say they could crack
- 11:15down on the exchange of U.S. dollars for Bitcoin.
- 11:17They could force everyone to convert their Bitcoin into these
- 11:20ETF type products. They could do a bunch of things
- 11:23like that to basically make it very hard for people to own
- 11:26Bitcoin and and for and and also maybe to convert U.S. dollars to
- 11:30other foreign currencies, not just Bitcoin as a way of saying
- 11:33forcing people to own and save in the US dollar even though the
- 11:37dollar is losing its value. That's again exactly what we did
- 11:40in 34. Effectively, that's what we did
- 11:41in 71 when we broke the finally broke the connection between the
- 11:46US dollar and the value of gold under Nixon.
- 11:50So we could have that kind of approach, we could do a bunch of
- 11:52things like that. And look, that's, that's hardly
- 11:55a, that would be hardly shocking at this point.
- 11:57When we look at what happened during the pandemic, what
- 12:00happened during the financial crisis, We have so many examples
- 12:03in U.S. history, let alone in the history of other nations
- 12:06where the emergency of an economic crisis.
- 12:09So again, let's go back to this emergency point because I think
- 12:13Bitcoin as Bitcoin Bitcoiners tend to understand that an
- 12:16emergency, a future emergency or future crisis is possible.
- 12:20But for those who may think that's like unlikely or like,
- 12:22look, the US has run these debt, you know, built this debt for a
- 12:26long time. Nothing bad seems to really
- 12:27happen. Is that is there really going to
- 12:29be a crisis? One thing I do in in the paper
- 12:32is walk through my argument that we basically have about 20 years
- 12:37plus or minus before the math gets out of control with the
- 12:42size of the debt relative to our tax revenue.
- 12:45Because we're already seeing the interest costs relative to our
- 12:50revenue and spending reach escape velocity.
- 12:53We for the first year in 2024, how much we spend on interest on
- 12:57the federal debt has exceeded what we spend on National
- 12:59Defense, which to me is a real threshold number.
- 13:04And again, if there's any crisis in the future, let's say China
- 13:07invades Taiwan or something else happens in the world, another
- 13:09pandemic or financial crisis, things get really bad really
- 13:13quickly. So if you think about interest
- 13:15cost is something that can kind of run away from you, we're
- 13:20getting close to that threshold. So basically, I have, I have
- 13:23young children by the time they're in their 20s, we're,
- 13:27we're going to be, we're going to be in a really tough spot
- 13:29where the debt to GDP ratio could be 400%.
- 13:33Right now it's about 100%. The, the, the, the official
- 13:37government projections as to what the debt to GDP ratio will
- 13:39be in 20 years are very optimistic.
- 13:41They're based on rapid economic growth, steady population
- 13:46growth, interest rates remaining moderate to low.
- 13:50And if any of those things go wrong, especially the GDP
- 13:53growth, we're, we're going to get crushed.
- 13:56And I think it's likely the GDP growth, economic growth is
- 13:59slower over time than it has been historically, let alone at
- 14:03an above average clip, which is what the G what the CBO
- 14:06projects. CBO projects 3.6% economic
- 14:09growth forever, which would be like Reagan, Clinton era
- 14:12economic growth. I just don't see it under an
- 14:15environment where we have this massive debt and the increasing
- 14:18regulatory burden and other problems that we have in this
- 14:21country. So the first part of the article
- 14:23really goes through the fact that the debt to GP is ratio is
- 14:28going to get far worse than the what could the Congressional
- 14:31Budget Office projects because of these factors where their
- 14:35their projections are optimistic.
- 14:37And that's why we have about 20 years before things get really
- 14:40bad in my view. Look, I hope I'm wrong, but but
- 14:43this is what I see. And then if so, if you project
- 14:46that and then then basically article goes on to say, OK, in
- 14:482044, what are the scenarios? And let's say scenario number
- 14:52one is this massive crackdown that I talked about the
- 14:54restrictive scenario where we're restricting people's economic
- 14:57freedom in order to protect the US dollar.
- 15:00Very easy thing to imagine given again, all the aggressive
- 15:04restrictions that we've endured in just the last 15 years of our
- 15:08lives between the financial crisis and and the, and the
- 15:12pandemic. So if that happens now, the
- 15:15problem is if that happens, it's a short term solution, right?
- 15:19You're, you're only going to encourage people to leave the US
- 15:23dollar if you're cracking down in that way.
- 15:26If the US decides that, well, we've got to prevent people from
- 15:30fleeing to gold or Bitcoin, then people are going to flee to
- 15:34gold, Bitcoin, they're not going to, they're not going to stick
- 15:37around because they, they understand that if you, if you,
- 15:40as the government are worried about them fleeing to Bitcoin
- 15:43because then then people are going to, the market's going to
- 15:45look at that as you basically admitting that gold and Bitcoin
- 15:48and particularly Bitcoin are superior stores of value.
- 15:52So it will, it will not solve the problem and lead to massive
- 15:56economic stagnation of crisis and possibly even more dangerous
- 16:00outcomes. I mean, you one could imagine
- 16:03the weakness of the United States at that time, leading to
- 16:06a lot more war, a lot more violence around the world, very
- 16:09unpredictable. We've, we've taken for granted
- 16:12US leadership around the world for, for the last 100 years or
- 16:15more if you count World War One. So it's a pretty dangerous
- 16:20environment when there's a sudden shock and a sudden
- 16:22collapse. Let's hope that that isn't the
- 16:25outcome. So that's scenario number one.
- 16:28I can stop there if you want. We can talk about that before we
- 16:30get into the other scenarios. Yeah, no, I think, you know, the
- 16:33terms I always think of are in the interest of national
- 16:39security of the United States. You know, dot dot dot all the
- 16:42things you just explained, right?
- 16:45It's a bitcoiners frequently underplay the possibility of
- 16:50this scenario and you know, granted things could get worse.
- 16:55Generally in order for that to happen, I always think of
- 17:00executive order 61 O 2 and that, you know, it took a depression
- 17:05right for that to to get implemented.
- 17:07So that's. No different, yeah.
- 17:09Yeah, exactly. This would be no different.
- 17:11It absolutely could happen. Yeah, so and and look, I think I
- 17:16think yeah. So anyway, so that's center
- 17:18number one and we'll get to like how do I, how should we respond
- 17:21to that in a minute? Let's go through the three
- 17:24scenarios and we'll talk about the real take away the article.
- 17:27So the second scenario is what I call the palsied scenario,
- 17:31meaning a kind of paralysis with various like, you know, you
- 17:37know, as a medical term, palsy means it's kind of paralysis
- 17:39with various kind of jerky movements here and there.
- 17:43And, and that's kind of like what the scenario would be.
- 17:45So imagine a world in which, you know, you don't have the first
- 17:49scenario like the aggressive government restrictions, but
- 17:51rather because of the polarized and distributed nature of power
- 17:57in the United States, you're not able to actually do a lot of the
- 18:01most aggressive restrictive things because maybe the courts
- 18:05strike it down, or maybe Congress is controlled by one
- 18:08party in the White House by another.
- 18:10And so they, they kind of argue with each other and the most,
- 18:13you know, aggressive restrictions don't get enacted.
- 18:16But at the same time, for the same reason, because of the
- 18:19polarization and the distributed nature of power in the US,
- 18:23neither do you solve the problem.
- 18:24You don't reform entitlements. You don't get the deficit under
- 18:27control. You don't do the things that we
- 18:29would need to do to actually fundamentally solve the problem.
- 18:32So you neither solve the problem nor do you enact the most
- 18:35restrictive policies to, to try to stem the tide of outflows
- 18:40from the US dollar. So what happens in that case?
- 18:43Well, the outcome is still fairly negative, right?
- 18:46You still have capital outflows. You still have a lot of people
- 18:49leaving the US system, which would weaken the US and and
- 18:53weaken the currency for those who are left holding the bag so
- 18:56to speak. But you would have the ability
- 19:00to flee the US with your capital under at least more of an
- 19:05ability to do so relative to the the the first scenario, the more
- 19:08restrictive scenario. So still bad, still bad for
- 19:11America, but maybe a little bit better for people who are
- 19:15already in Bitcoin in that they can they can have that escape
- 19:19hatch relative to the first scenario.
- 19:23And then the third scenario, what I call the munificent
- 19:25scenario is one in which there's a kind of Malay type figure in
- 19:33the US who's who's charismatic and maybe wins the presidential
- 19:37election of 2044 and says, hey, we have this crisis.
- 19:41We've got to do extraordinary things to get out of it.
- 19:44We're all going to have to accept some sacrifices, but
- 19:47we've got to do it to get the US out of this ditch.
- 19:50And we're going to do it. And he gets elected on that
- 19:53premise and is able through his mandate, his electoral mandate,
- 19:58to pass the kinds of reforms that would get us out of the out
- 20:02of the ditch. And the way I describe the
- 20:04munificent scenario is much like a bankruptcy, bankruptcy of a
- 20:10large company. It's not a, it's not like the
- 20:14old Paul Ryan type scenarios from 12 years ago where, you
- 20:17know, you, you shave a little bit off Social Security here and
- 20:20you shave a little bit off Medicare there.
- 20:22And gradually everything over time gets back into balance.
- 20:25By 2044, we won't have the luxury of those more gradualist
- 20:29approaches. You're going to have to do some
- 20:31major surgery and that will involve, in my view, a partial
- 20:36default on Treasury securities in exchange for entitlement
- 20:41reform. So you basically say to
- 20:43bondholders, you're going to get maybe $0.50 on the dollar, but
- 20:49you're we're gonna do the things to Medicare and Social secure
- 20:53and everything else to ensure that this never happens again.
- 20:56We're going to put, you know, kind of like if you think about
- 20:57the auto bailouts from the financial crisis, right?
- 21:01So GM and Chrysler went bankrupt.
- 21:04The the owners of the equity and the debt got took a bath, but
- 21:08they were able to use bankruptcy to rework a lot of their, their
- 21:11contracts with the labor unions and, you know, get back on their
- 21:15feet afterwards, right? That's kind of how a bankruptcy
- 21:17works. So similarly, one can imagine a
- 21:21bankruptcy of the United States in which there's this that you
- 21:25take a haircut if you're an investor in these bonds, which
- 21:27will lead a lot of banks to go under if they're too heavily
- 21:30exposed to, to Treasury securities.
- 21:33But by then a lot of a lot of banks may not be heavily exposed
- 21:36to Treasury securities for the reasons we've just described.
- 21:39And, and, and we fixed the problem so that we take this one
- 21:44time haircut and we come out of it the other, other side, which
- 21:47again is countries have done this.
- 21:49Countries have emerged from defaults in a stronger position
- 21:53with, with real reforms. So that's not, it sounds crazy,
- 21:57but it's not actually that crazy if you look at fiscal and
- 22:00monetary history and in other countries.
- 22:03But I would have to say of those 3 scenarios, the first one is
- 22:08the most probable because that's the one that you see most
- 22:11countries undertaking when when they are in a fiscal and
- 22:16monetary crisis. So while we hope for the best,
- 22:19we've got a plan for the worst. Yeah, it does kind of seem like
- 22:23the third scenario. Well, I think it's probably the
- 22:26most prudent in terms of actually solving problems.
- 22:30It seems like the only example I can think of is is Argentina,
- 22:34after decades of suffering, like to get the political will for
- 22:39the people to, you know, accept tough talk as the the prudent
- 22:44path forward rather than, you know, buying into delusion of
- 22:50invincibility that some politician is promising.
- 22:53It feels like you have to go through an awful lot of pain
- 22:56before you can get there. Do you think it's possible for
- 22:59the US to for the electorate to see that reason before, you
- 23:05know, in advance of a lot of pain?
- 23:09It's possible, but there are it's going to the road ahead is
- 23:13not there. There's a lot of there's a lot
- 23:17of risk and a lot of challenges that those of us who believe in
- 23:21Bitcoin face to get to that positive outcome.
- 23:25And I talk about some of these in the article.
- 23:27One of them is the fact that today, if you actually look at
- 23:32the distribution of Bitcoin wealth, it's very, very skewed
- 23:38to the top, right? If you were an OG, you were a
- 23:40miner, you have a lot of Bitcoin.
- 23:45And if you're a humble SAT stacker who's putting 50 bucks a
- 23:50month away, that's great. You should be doing that, but
- 23:53the amount of Bitcoin you hold relative to people who got in
- 23:56very early, obviously very different.
- 23:58I actually in the article I compare the distribution of
- 24:03wealth in U.S. dollars relative to the distribution of wealth in
- 24:07Bitcoin. And the distribution of wealth
- 24:09in Bitcoin is much more skewed to the top relative to the
- 24:14distribution of wealth in dollars.
- 24:17Now it's, it's a little tricky to measure these things because
- 24:21some of the large wallets, maybe exchanges and lots of people who
- 24:26have a lot of Bitcoin actually split it among much smaller
- 24:30wallets, especially because most of the, the cold walls today
- 24:33encourage that kind of that kind of storage, right?
- 24:37So, so you know, you, there's some, there's some asterisks and
- 24:40people can quibble about the exact way you calculate this
- 24:42stuff. But I would say given the latter
- 24:45factor, which is to say a lot of people own a lot of Bitcoin,
- 24:47actually split it up on into smaller units, a smaller
- 24:50holdings at different addresses. You know, it's, it's, it
- 24:55possibly is more concentrated actually than we know based on
- 24:58wallet distribution today. All that to say that if there is
- 25:02a crisis in 2044, it's going to be very easy for a populist
- 25:07politician to say, attack Bitcoiners and say these
- 25:11Bitcoiners want to hoard their wealth.
- 25:15And they're, you know, they're the ones who are selling out
- 25:17your U.S. dollars and they're selling out America to, to hold
- 25:21Bitcoin and we got to stop them. You could imagine a, a populist
- 25:26politician saying something like that and, you know, people
- 25:30really going after and targeting Bitcoin holders in that way.
- 25:34So one of the things that it's very important for Bitcoiners to
- 25:38do is to expand the the number and volume of stakeholders who
- 25:45actually have a stake in Bitcoin success.
- 25:47Not merely by owning Bitcoin, that's also important, but it
- 25:51could also be through Bitcoin based businesses like Onramp or
- 25:55many others where you know, you may not have a lot of Bitcoin,
- 25:59but if you build a great business that's part of the
- 26:02Bitcoin ecosystem, then you may also have a great stake in
- 26:07Bitcoin success, even if your wealth is in in a kind of Fiat
- 26:11denominated format such as equity, an equity stake in a
- 26:14Bitcoin based business, right. So the, the, it's really
- 26:18important for us to do everything we can today to
- 26:23encourage as many people to hold Bitcoin so that if the
- 26:26government cracks down on Bitcoin later, you as a citizen
- 26:31have a stake in his Bitcoin success.
- 26:33That's that's one of the most important things that that we
- 26:37have to do. And I talk about a number of
- 26:38others in the article. Yeah.
- 26:41Well, that perspective, I wonder, I'm a little more
- 26:44optimistic myself about the concentration issue, partly
- 26:48because I sometimes think in terms of adjusting for the size
- 26:52of the asset. In other words, I don't know, I
- 26:55think about NVIDIA stock or something like how concentrated
- 26:59was NVIDIA ownership when NVIDIA was at a trillion dollar market
- 27:02cap, which is roughly where we are on, you know, a network
- 27:05value for for Bitcoin. And I like to think that
- 27:08actually your average trillion dollar asset is still kind of
- 27:13concentrated in terms of its holder base, but I could be
- 27:17wrong about that. Do you do you have a?
- 27:19Do you have a finer view on that?
- 27:22You know, that's also a tricky one, right?
- 27:24Because you know, if you look at a 13F filing of you know, say
- 27:27NVIDIA and the top shareholders are basically ETFs and things
- 27:33like that, that are indexed to the NASDAQ 100 or the S&P or
- 27:36what have you, which obviously most people have in their 401 KS
- 27:40and their portfolios and things like that.
- 27:42So it's, it's somewhat tricky actually to assess the
- 27:45distribution of ownership of of those highly valued companies.
- 27:48And so again, I think that's more true of large blue chip
- 27:53companies than it is a Bitcoin because you know, we're on ETF's
- 27:57are in the in at least in the US context of pretty new
- 28:00development. So we'll see.
- 28:04But it's going to be important, right?
- 28:06It's going to be important to, to, to, to expand.
- 28:11It's, it's important for all of us to make it easier for people
- 28:14to buy and hold Bitcoin and to use it to pass it on to their
- 28:17relatives and not worry about losing passport pass passwords
- 28:22or, you know, private keys, things like that.
- 28:24And obviously there are people working on that.
- 28:26So that's great. Another thing that that I would
- 28:31mention is it's really important to make the conversion of Fiat
- 28:37currency to and from Bitcoin as resilient to government
- 28:43censorship as possible. So today the conversion of Fiat
- 28:49to Bitcoin is basically on centralized exchanges, right?
- 28:55But there are people working on using technologies Light
- 28:59Lightning and Noster and and others.
- 29:02Is it possible to create peer-to-peer decentralized
- 29:06exchanges of Fiat and Bitcoin? To me, that's a really that's
- 29:13the arguably, from a technological or technical
- 29:15standpoint, the most important thing we can do to make Bitcoin
- 29:20resilient to this restrictive scenario in the future.
- 29:25Because basically the real Wick weak point of Bitcoin today is
- 29:30the fact that if you want to buy more Bitcoin with your Fiat,
- 29:33you're dependent on government permission to do so.
- 29:36So if we can make the conversion of Fiat to Bitcoin permission
- 29:39list, then we're really off to the races.
- 29:42But we're we're not there yet. But I think that's something
- 29:45that I would love for the listeners of your show to invest
- 29:49their energy into. Yes, absolutely agree with that.
- 29:54And and I guess I have hope that you know, we are it is early
- 29:58days and the tinkering that's possible will eventually
- 30:05cumulatively add up to some breakthroughs in in that Holy
- 30:09Grail really. And and also going back to the
- 30:14the distribution question, this is I think you're right.
- 30:18That is probably the greatest risk for persecution for
- 30:20Bitcoiners. I do have hope, though, the the
- 30:25historical analog that I found very helpful and I wrote an
- 30:29article about this was the California Ranchos.
- 30:32So the California Rancho system was how Mexico parceled up
- 30:35Southern California to friendly land, land owners, you know,
- 30:4310,000 acres at a time. And that's how all of Southern
- 30:47California was divided up 150 years ago.
- 30:50And now there's basically none of those anymore because they've
- 30:53all been parceled up and distributed by generations of
- 30:57the descendants who were looking to cash in some of the
- 31:01appreciation in the value of that those land holdings.
- 31:04And so in that way, we have this nice historical analog of real
- 31:08estate on the frontier does distribute over time after its
- 31:11price appreciation, you know, is is is due to be captured and you
- 31:17know, you diversify into other assets.
- 31:19So that gives me hope in the long term.
- 31:21But I think in that 20 year timeline that you're specifying,
- 31:25it is a little dicey. That's, that's yeah, that's
- 31:29right. I think, I think it's, it's a
- 31:30very interesting analogy. But we don't have 150 years
- 31:35under my thesis, right? We have 20 years.
- 31:38And you know those, those are the people who didn't get the
- 31:41land in in New Spain 150 years ago.
- 31:44They didn't get to vote, right? That was a, a monarchy, an
- 31:47empire. So the in our system, people who
- 31:53don't own Bitcoin get a vote and and rightly so, but, but, but
- 31:57that's, that makes it more urgent to expand the stakeholder
- 32:03community. And again, it doesn't have to
- 32:04just be by owning Bitcoin and you don't look, you don't have
- 32:06to own a lot of Bitcoin to care about it.
- 32:08I think one of the insights of tax cutters in the 80s, for
- 32:13example, So when, when Ronald Reagan and Democrats cut taxes
- 32:17in the 80s, which was one of the first major tax reforms of, of
- 32:21the late 20th century, the, you know, there were a lot of people
- 32:25said, oh, this is never, you know, this is not going to
- 32:27succeed politically because the beneficiaries of the tax cuts
- 32:31are going to be rich people. And so Democrats who oppose
- 32:34Reagan said this is tax cuts for the rich.
- 32:36It's really terrible. But what Republicans did and,
- 32:39and the Democrats who worked with Republicans on these tax
- 32:41reform, because they were bipartisan, what what they did
- 32:45is they cut taxes for everybody. And so if you were a middle
- 32:48class person making thirty $40,000 a year and you got a tax
- 32:52cut too, you didn't care that the millionaires got tax cuts
- 32:56because you got one too. So you're like, hey, everybody
- 32:58gets a tax cut. I get one too.
- 32:59And yes, the dollar value of my tax cut might be smaller than
- 33:02the millionaires, but for me that's real money.
- 33:04And so I'm fine. Similarly with Bitcoin, like you
- 33:08can, if, if you have, if you have a significant amount of
- 33:11your net worth of Bitcoin, but your net worth is, you know,
- 33:14$30,000, then it's still meaningful to you and you have a
- 33:17stake in Bitcoin success. So you don't have to, I'm not
- 33:21saying like you have to have this kind of Marxist
- 33:24distribution of an equal amount of Bitcoin for every person in
- 33:27the country. But what you, what you have to
- 33:30do is you have to get people off 0.
- 33:32So you don't have to get them to OG level Bitcoin.
- 33:35You just have to get them off 0. You have to get them at a point
- 33:37where it's a meaningful investment for them.
- 33:40It's a meaningful mechanism for them to save money.
- 33:43And so that if if the government is basically saying their hard
- 33:47earned savings are going to be wiped out, then they're going to
- 33:50care. Yeah, I think it's a really good
- 33:53point in pursuit of keeping America safe for both Bitcoin
- 33:58and Bitcoiners. Speaking of getting of.
- 34:01Right, Like part part of the thing too is like, it's not just
- 34:04about you making Bitcoin, making, you know, America safe
- 34:07for Bitcoin. It's about helping America
- 34:10benefit from Bitcoin, right? Which is another part of this
- 34:14whole thing is can we actually get to a point where through
- 34:16this munificent scenario, maybe part of it is not just that we
- 34:20have this, you know, structured bankruptcy with the entitlement
- 34:24reform, but you also promised to back the US dollar with Bitcoin
- 34:28going forward so that investors in Treasury securities in the
- 34:33dollar have that security in the future.
- 34:36Yeah. So I'm glad you raised that
- 34:38proposal. You proposed it in your Article
- 34:413 years ago. I think what you proposed was
- 34:45rotating some of the government's gold holdings into
- 34:48Bitcoin, a portion of percentage, I want to say it was
- 34:51like 10%. Three years later, multiple
- 34:54presidential candidates have talked about something along
- 34:58these lines publicly and one US Senator I think is introduced to
- 35:02build of this effect. Can you put a finer point on the
- 35:07idea, how you think it would be optimally implemented?
- 35:12You know, in the face of some passage of time and and some
- 35:17greater discussion on it? Yeah, sure.
- 35:20So in that article, as you mentioned, we proposed that much
- 35:26like our our analogy was simple. You know, we have this massive
- 35:29gold reserve in Fort Knox and other places in the Federal
- 35:33Reserve Bank of New York and elsewhere.
- 35:35We store the US gold reserves. Why not say that 1010% of the
- 35:42gold that we own we convert to Bitcoin.
- 35:44That was the idea that we put out there three years ago.
- 35:46And you look, there's different variations on the idea.
- 35:49You could say, well, we don't have to sell the gold we have.
- 35:51You could just take, you could just say analogous to the gold,
- 35:55we just add in some Bitcoin. That's one way to do it.
- 35:59Another idea is, well, we actually the US government, the
- 36:03federal government is already one of the largest holders of
- 36:05Bitcoin in the world because of all the Bitcoin it's confiscated
- 36:09from criminals. So just don't sell it.
- 36:11We tend to auction off the Bitcoin that we seize, for
- 36:14example, from the Silk Road seizure and things like that.
- 36:17You don't have to, you don't have to auction it.
- 36:19You can just hold it. And that's another idea out
- 36:22there, right? So there's a number of different
- 36:23variations now that since that original concept was thrown out
- 36:27there that people have have iterated on.
- 36:30And I think these are all interesting and useful ideas.
- 36:32I think, yeah, if you just say let's not sell the Bitcoin, we,
- 36:36we, we get through these kind of criminal proceedings, but we
- 36:39also try to strategically build a reserve with with that goal in
- 36:44mind. I think that's all very useful.
- 36:47I think there have been some overly optimistic claims about
- 36:52how a Bitcoin reserve could solve the, the, the, the debt
- 36:56crisis. Unless Bitcoin goes to like a
- 36:59billion dollars a coin, you're not going to be able to solve
- 37:03the debt crisis by simply holding Bitcoin.
- 37:06You still have to reform the fact you have to reform the, the
- 37:10fiscal structure, the US where we spend more than we take in
- 37:12every year. So even if you somehow wiped out
- 37:15the debt, you know, a 35 trillion a debt, we're going to
- 37:19accumulate another several $100 trillion of debt in the next 20
- 37:22years. So 35 trillion isn't going to be
- 37:25enough. So to those people who who
- 37:27who've argued that we can just wipe out the federal debt with a
- 37:30strategic Bitcoin reserve, I would say the math doesn't
- 37:33doesn't get us there unfortunately, but.
- 37:37I'm shocked you're saying there are bitcoiners out there who are
- 37:39overly optimistic about the power of Bitcoin to solve all
- 37:42their problems. You look, I mean, I, I
- 37:44appreciate the enthusiasm for sure, but but for those of us
- 37:47who are trying to think hard headedly about this dangerous
- 37:51scenario in the future, we've got to be sober about and we've
- 37:54got to realize that it's not going to solve all our problems
- 37:57and have a Bitcoin reserve. And, and to the we want to
- 37:59persuade skeptics to, to, to take on this idea, then we got
- 38:03to not oversell it, right? We got to, we got to be
- 38:06realistic about it. And, and what's the realistic
- 38:09benefit of having a strategic Bitcoin reserve is that it
- 38:12strengthens the US balance sheet.
- 38:14It makes us a little bit more resilient to problems.
- 38:18If there is a crisis in the future, we have a little bit
- 38:21more leeway in, in how we deal with it.
- 38:24Maybe a little bit more runway, maybe we don't have to, you
- 38:27know, crush. You don't have to have a severe
- 38:29and austerity plan and things like that.
- 38:32The austerity plan will still have to be there, but it may be
- 38:35less severe if we if we have a Bitcoin reserve.
- 38:39So it's the more, the more we do it, the better it is.
- 38:43But we're, you know, if we, if we don't fix the, the, the
- 38:47runaway cost, Medicare and Social Security Bitcoin Reserve
- 38:51at the scale we're talking about is not going to not going to
- 38:54solve the problem again, unless Bitcoin really explodes in a way
- 38:57that I think even the most optimistic Bitcoiners at this
- 39:00point are not anticipating. Does your Bitcoin custody set up
- 39:03keep you up at night? Maybe you still have coins
- 39:05sitting on an exchange. Worried about hackers?
- 39:08Or maybe you've set up your own self custody but don't feel safe
- 39:10with your Bitcoin savings stashed on a little plastic
- 39:13device in your desk drawer? Gain Peace of Mind with Onramp
- 39:17and our multi institution custody solution.
- 39:20Here's how it works. Onramp creates a dedicated multi
- 39:23sig vault just for you. 3 separate institutions each hold
- 39:27a key, Onramp bit go and coin cover, but none can move funds
- 39:32unilaterally. Instead, only you have control
- 39:35over your coins with on ramps multi institution custody.
- 39:39You'll sleep better at night knowing your Bitcoin is stored
- 39:42with best in class security on chain with fault tolerant multi
- 39:45sig. If you believe your Bitcoin is
- 39:47going to be worth a lot someday, don't jeopardize that future by
- 39:51exposing your coins to hackers on exchanges, $5 wrench of tax
- 39:55in the real world, or perhaps most importantly, the risk that
- 39:58you might screw something up with a highly technical self
- 40:01custody set up. On ramps, multi institution
- 40:04custody, eliminates single points of failure, reduces your
- 40:08personal attack surface and technical burden, and provides
- 40:11access to financial services that allow you to confidently
- 40:14secure your Bitcoin, including inheritance planning, insurance
- 40:18backed warranties for all balances and transactions, low
- 40:20cost trading and more. Bitcoin is a once in a species
- 40:24asset. Secure it right.
- 40:26Learn more at on rampbitcoin.com.
- 40:29I think the math, I think you were right.
- 40:31It's literally a billion dollars if you, if you add 220 trillion
- 40:35in unfunded liabilities and 35 trillion in, in hard debt, that
- 40:41and, and the US ends up with 1% of of the Bitcoin, that'd be a
- 40:44billion dollars per Bitcoin, right?
- 40:46So that's not going to happen. Yeah, I mean, look again, we can
- 40:50you know, in a, in a sense, we, we, those of us who hold
- 40:53Bitcoin, you, we, you could think, oh, that's great.
- 40:55Bitcoin is a, is a billion dollars a coin.
- 40:56I'm rich, but if Bitcoin's a billion dollars a coin, that
- 41:00means civilization has collapsed, which is not good.
- 41:04So in a sense we, we, you know, we should be, we should be be
- 41:07careful what you wish for effectively with that scenario.
- 41:11Yes, indeed. I wonder, have you thought
- 41:13about, you know, a timeline for adoption?
- 41:16One of the things I think about, well, first of all, 20 years, I
- 41:19hope we had that long in terms of the reckoning.
- 41:22We may not. We may not.
- 41:24Yeah, I've sort of thought in terms of 10 years, but I hope
- 41:28you're right. I guess with respect to
- 41:32government policy in Bitcoin, should there be sort of a, a
- 41:36timeline, a multi year evolution, you know, either with
- 41:41respect to the the reserve or other policy.
- 41:45I mean is that is that is time on our side with respect to not
- 41:51making big jerky, you know, palsy like movements.
- 41:57So that one of the things I, I, I think I put this in the
- 42:00article and if I didn't, we can talk about it here, which is
- 42:02that that 20 year time horizon is assuming no other dramatic
- 42:07crises. It assumes less robust economic
- 42:11growth, slightly higher interest rates, optimistic population
- 42:17growth. So pretty, you know, it, it
- 42:19involves slightly less optimistic projection, the CBO,
- 42:23but not like super negative projections.
- 42:25Yeah, but imagine there's another pandemic or financial
- 42:27crisis or war which requires us to spend a lot of money that we
- 42:30don't have above and beyond current law that then
- 42:35accelerates a crisis. I think the COBIT really did
- 42:37that for us. I mean, Co bid pushed the
- 42:39timeline much closer to us in terms of a fiscal class because
- 42:42we spent six trillion, we didn't have that monetary inflation was
- 42:46massive during that period, another 6 trillion and monetary
- 42:49inflation or more. And so Co bid that this Co bid
- 42:52period really did a lot of damage in terms of pushing all
- 42:56these timelines upward. And there is absolutely no
- 43:01guarantee that we won't have further crises in the future in
- 43:03which we say, well, this time is different.
- 43:05We got to throw money at the problem, what we'll deal with
- 43:08the consequences later. And we just never do.
- 43:10We just never do. Yeah, as as like the BTFPA year
- 43:14ago or two years ago would suggest.
- 43:17Yeah. And you know, look, I mean, I
- 43:19think it's, it's, it's hard. It's, it's hard always to, to
- 43:24project these things, right. I don't think anyone could have
- 43:27predicted the exact trajectory of the way Bitcoin has has
- 43:31turned out the last couple years.
- 43:32I know there are people who think they've got a magic
- 43:34formula that predicts exactly what how the price cycles of
- 43:37Bitcoin work. But empirically, there's a lot
- 43:40of reason to to argue that those, those relatively
- 43:44simplistic formulas are not, are not actually what we're
- 43:47observing. And the ETFs, I think are real
- 43:51game changer in that regard because the ETFs lead to a very
- 43:55different market behavior for Bitcoin than what we had before
- 43:59ETFs. Just because of the mechanics of
- 44:01how you maintain the ETF peg and the hedging strategies people
- 44:05use in the arbitragers who try to basically make sure that ETFs
- 44:08are hewing to the actual Bitcoin price.
- 44:11There's a lot of stuff in the guts of the financial system
- 44:14with that that really starts to transform the way Bitcoin is
- 44:18bought and sold. Yep, all makes sense.
- 44:22All makes sense. Well, let's I think maybe pivot
- 44:25the conversation a little bit here, Ovic, I want to talk about
- 44:29free up. I want to talk.
- 44:31You know, if you could give us a little bit of history as to how
- 44:36you focused on freedom of opportunity.
- 44:41You mentioned the influence of friends who were big on Austrian
- 44:46economics. Perhaps that played a role
- 44:48there, but can you tell us about how you're thinking evolved and
- 44:52then tell us about the organization's focus and
- 44:55activities today? Sure.
- 44:58So it's it's it's related to the conversation we've been having,
- 45:01which is if you if you understand that we have a debt
- 45:05crisis, it's getting worse every year.
- 45:08How do we solve it? Well, you're not going to solve
- 45:11it through a kind of Iron Rand approach where you say you poor
- 45:15people have to take your alarm, said we're going to cut off your
- 45:18Social Security and Medicare. That's not going to fly.
- 45:21People aren't going to vote for that.
- 45:22Politicians who depend on voters support are not going to vote
- 45:26for that. So you you can't, you can't have
- 45:30that kind of approach if you want to solve these problems.
- 45:33And for too long the narrative and the conventional wisdom has
- 45:37been you have to you have to aggressively harm vulnerable
- 45:45populations in order to solve the federal debt.
- 45:50To take one example of many issues.
- 45:53And my view, having been in the wars on, on, on on healthcare
- 46:00reform and fiscal policy, is that unless you can reform
- 46:05entitlements in a way that protects and advances the
- 46:09economic interests of lower and middle income Americans, you're
- 46:12never going to have the votes for meaningful reform.
- 46:16And you may, you know, you, you can like that or not like that,
- 46:18but that's just a reality. The reality is it's just never
- 46:21going to happen. You're never going to get 60
- 46:23votes in the Senate so long as we still have a filibuster.
- 46:26You're never going to get 60 votes in the Senate, let alone
- 46:2850 for a policy that the majority of Americans feel is
- 46:32not in their interest, where you're, where you're perceived
- 46:35fairly or unfairly to be throwing granny over a Cliff.
- 46:39So you've really got to solve for that.
- 46:41It's an engineering problem You've got to solve for how do I
- 46:44reform these entitlements in a way that protects the economic
- 46:48security as much as possible of lower and middle income
- 46:53Americans? And that's not just true of
- 46:56entitlement reform and fiscal policy.
- 46:57It's true of almost every issue. If we want a freer economy in
- 47:02which people can build great businesses and, and have better
- 47:07job opportunities and wage growth and better educational
- 47:10opportunities, all these things can be advanced through more
- 47:14economic and individual freedom. But too often people in politics
- 47:19and also in the Bitcoin community have this kind of
- 47:21attitude of just leave me alone and let me keep my stuff and,
- 47:25and you take care of your own problems.
- 47:26Don't bother me with your problems.
- 47:29And that I understand that as a, as a point of view, but from a
- 47:33political standpoint, it just doesn't work right.
- 47:37The, the people who's, who have the problems, they're not going
- 47:39to buy that. They're not going to buy that.
- 47:41If that, if you want to be left alone, that that's OK with them.
- 47:45They know they don't want, they don't want to be left alone.
- 47:47They want someone to help them out.
- 47:48And so you've got to come up with a strategy for dealing with
- 47:51that. And so the idea behind Freak was
- 47:55there's so many issues where the pro freedom solution is the one
- 48:00that actually disproportionately advances the interests of of
- 48:04people on the bottom half of the ladder.
- 48:06Economic and individual freedom have been the greatest engines
- 48:09of economic equality that the world has ever seen.
- 48:13That's why America is the richest country in the world
- 48:16where people with humble origins can have incredible success.
- 48:20These stories continue to emerge every single year.
- 48:24There are new stories of people with humble origins who do
- 48:26incredibly well here. And that's not true in systems
- 48:30where you can't get your business off the ground or you
- 48:32can't get your career off the ground because of restrictions
- 48:35and cronyism and bureaucracy. So we have to those of us who
- 48:40believe in economic freedom, if we don't lead with how that
- 48:45economic freedom is going to help people on the bottom half
- 48:48of the ladder, we're not going to have the public support for
- 48:51the kinds of reforms that can unlock the economic and
- 48:55financial growth that we all want to see.
- 48:58So the basic idea behind Free OP is the most progressive social
- 49:04and economic and political outcomes are the ones that rely
- 49:08on individual and economic freedom and Marshall them in the
- 49:10service of people on the bottom half of the ladder.
- 49:13So Free Up, the Foundation for Research on Equal Opportunity,
- 49:17was founded with that spirit where every every issue we work
- 49:20on, every issue we do research on, every issue we publish a
- 49:23white paper on. We center our arguments around
- 49:27how economic and individual freedom, technological
- 49:31innovation and pluralism can advance the interests of
- 49:34Americans whose incomes or wealth are below the US median.
- 49:37If it doesn't meet those two tests, we won't work on it.
- 49:40And in that way, we really try to identify things like, how do
- 49:44you deal with the rising cost of housing?
- 49:46Well, let's start by, you know, making it easier to build more
- 49:50housing. Let's let's challenge the
- 49:53Federal Reserve, which by keeping interest rates at 0
- 49:56drives massive asset bubbles, including real estate bubbles.
- 50:01So more economic freedom through sound money and deregulation can
- 50:05lead to more affordable housing. Same with same is true with
- 50:09energy. Same is true with healthcare.
- 50:11Same is true with all sorts of things that right now, through
- 50:15barriers to entry, through regulation, through subsidies
- 50:19that are unwisely designed, we make these things more expensive
- 50:23than they need to be. Yeah, I really appreciate your
- 50:26pragmatism with respect to you got to get it, get things past
- 50:31the voters. I shouldn't say get you got to
- 50:32get support of the voters is really what?
- 50:34I should say you got to respect that they're, they're making
- 50:37rational decisions. If you're telling them that in
- 50:39order for financial markets to work, I've got to screw you,
- 50:43they're going to be like, well, I don't care about financial
- 50:45markets. I care about, am I going to have
- 50:47health insurance? Am I going to, are you going to
- 50:49take my Social Security away? The thing I rely on, I'm
- 50:51retired. You know, people are going to be
- 50:53very concerned about that. So you've got to address those
- 50:55needs. And look, it's not that, you
- 50:57know, people haven't been trying, but I think our argument
- 51:01is that you can't trying is not enough.
- 51:04You've got to, you've got to lead with that.
- 51:06You've got to, you've got to make that your North Star with
- 51:08everything you do. And is there an area, particular
- 51:12area, I mean you mentioned a few, you mentioned housing in
- 51:15particular. Is there an area that's most
- 51:18actionable, either most actionable in the near term or
- 51:25has such a huge magnitude potential of impact, you know
- 51:30that you're that you're really focused and interested on that
- 51:34area in particular? We have issue areas that that
- 51:38address each of the meeting, each of those questions or each
- 51:42of those buckets, you know, to take the last one first.
- 51:45I think healthcare and entitlement reform is the one
- 51:47where the scale of the problem is so large because it's the
- 51:50biggest driver of our deficit and debt, other than rising
- 51:52interest costs that any modest success, any modest reforms in
- 51:58healthcare have just because of the law of large numbers.
- 52:00We spend four or five trillion a year in healthcare.
- 52:04And you know, if you, if you just fix it a little bit and you
- 52:06save a couple $100 billion, that's real money.
- 52:09So, so Healthcare is 1 where the scale, the problem is such that
- 52:13even modest improvements can make a big difference.
- 52:16And so we do a lot of work in healthcare.
- 52:19An example of an issue that where we think we're making real
- 52:22progress is housing, where actually on the, there's a
- 52:27progressive movement towards deregulation of housing
- 52:32construction called the YIMBY movement.
- 52:35That's very aligned with everything that that we've been
- 52:38talking about since we started Free Op in 2016.
- 52:41An issue that's kind of in between where the scale is very
- 52:43large and we feel like we're making a lot of progress in
- 52:45terms of implementing reforms, but we're not, we're not, we're
- 52:49not there yet, but we're, we're very close.
- 52:51I think is higher education reform where, you know, Biden's
- 52:55approach is let's deal with the high cost of higher education
- 52:59and the student debt problem by just bailing the students out
- 53:02and forgiving the debt and putting it on the taxpayer.
- 53:05Well, that's a terrible idea because first of all, it's
- 53:09profoundly unfair because it's the top third of the income
- 53:12distribution that goes to college and goes to grad school,
- 53:15and the bottom 2/3 don't. So it's highly regressive
- 53:18policy. But more importantly, if you
- 53:21bail out these loans, then colleges and universities say,
- 53:25this is great, I can double my tuition and it doesn't matter if
- 53:29people can't pay me back because the taxpayer will be on the hook
- 53:31for the remainder that you're incentivizing higher prices by
- 53:35bailing out the universities. So what we really need to do is
- 53:39completely reverse the incentive structure.
- 53:40Or we say to universities, if the return on investment for
- 53:44that degree is negative, meaning what you pay upfront in tuition
- 53:49and room and board is more expensive than what you're going
- 53:53to get back in terms of increased salary for getting the
- 53:56degree. That we shouldn't be subsidizing
- 53:58that through subsidized student loans and and other forms.
- 54:01We should be telling that university or college or
- 54:04institution of higher education, we're not going to subsidize,
- 54:07subsidized that. If a student wants to do that on
- 54:09their own accord, that's fine. But taxpayers shouldn't be
- 54:12expected to be on the hook for $150,000 master's in film
- 54:16studies at Columbia, where the graduates are working at Walmart
- 54:19afterwards and making minimum wage.
- 54:21So there are politics. So we've actually pioneered
- 54:25something where we actually have a searchable database at our
- 54:28website where you can literally look up for every degree program
- 54:32in the United States, whatever major it is, whatever kind of
- 54:35degree it is. It could be a vocational degree,
- 54:37it could be medical school, it could be college, Whatever it
- 54:39is, you can look up the institution and the course of
- 54:42study and find out if that degree has a positive or
- 54:45negative ROI. And our hope is not just that
- 54:49it's a tool for students and parents can use that as a tool
- 54:52to say, you know what, we're going to stop forcing taxpayers
- 54:55to bail out colleges that want to charge overcharge for a
- 54:59degree that doesn't give you the economic return.
- 55:03Well, I love that That's a that's.
- 55:05A very handy tool. I mean, how many young
- 55:08Americans? First of all, they're so early
- 55:11in their lives, they're making this giant financial decision
- 55:14that they're I'll equipped to make.
- 55:16How many would benefit from that ROI return on investment
- 55:20analysis to make a more informed decision about what's arguably,
- 55:27for many people, either the most important or maybe the second
- 55:31most important financial decision that they're ever gonna
- 55:34make in their lives and what what happens sometimes.
- 55:38The real tragedy is there are a lot of cases where somebody goes
- 55:42to college or trade school or what have you and, and, and they
- 55:47don't complete it because of the financial pressures that they're
- 55:50under. Maybe, maybe you're a single mom
- 55:52and you're balancing having your kids with trying to get your
- 55:55degree done and you can't get it done for one reason or another.
- 55:58Or you have some economic set back in life and you drop out
- 56:03And so you spent all this money on a degree you don't have.
- 56:06So you, you, you, you've taken on the debt, but you don't have
- 56:10the the professional advantage that comes from having that
- 56:14credential. And there's a lot of people who
- 56:16fall into that bucket. That's the worst possible
- 56:18outcome. And, you know, you'll hear these
- 56:22university administrators say, well, you can't put a price on
- 56:25the education that we're offering, which is wonderful
- 56:30sounding, you know, rhetoric, But they actually do put a price
- 56:34on it. They charge you.
- 56:35So if they they are very capable of putting a price on it, they
- 56:39just don't want to be held accountable for the returns on
- 56:42it. And that's something that's got
- 56:43to change. And it's starting to change
- 56:46because we are at a point now where people who are graduating
- 56:49from high school are looking at the cost of going to these
- 56:51schools and saying, I'm not going to do it.
- 56:53And I think we're going to see, you know, we're starting to see
- 56:57college enrollment is declining. It's peaked and it's declining
- 57:01for that reason. There's schools that are closing
- 57:04and, and, and so and, and more, perhaps more need to if they
- 57:08can't get their costs under control.
- 57:10But our, our hope is that what colleges and universities start
- 57:14to do is say, you know what? We've been living, you know,
- 57:17high on the hog with these inflated tuition payments.
- 57:20We don't actually need that in theory, the cost of education
- 57:24should be crashing because of technology.
- 57:27You think about YouTube, you think about Khan Academy, you
- 57:30think about all these tools, Coursera that people have to
- 57:33learn things that they couldn't learn before.
- 57:36It should be much less expensive to get a college level education
- 57:41than it is today. And we we just through
- 57:44government policy made it more expensive.
- 57:46That's so there's a lot of areas of public policy like that.
- 57:50Think about nuclear energy. We could basically massively
- 57:54slash our carbon emissions for those for whom that's a big
- 57:56concern. This is relevant to the Bitcoin
- 57:59thing, right? So to the degree that people
- 58:00talk about, oh, Bitcoin is this energy hog, that only matters if
- 58:04you believe that consumption of energy is inherently a carbon
- 58:09intensive process. But it doesn't have to be.
- 58:12If we build nuclear power plants all across the country, we can
- 58:16generate more energy than we need with 0 carbon emissions.
- 58:21We just have chosen not to do that.
- 58:24So this whole idea that somehow bitcoins energy consumption is a
- 58:28threat to the planet, it's only a threat to the planet because
- 58:31we've refused to build a high high density, low carbon
- 58:38electricity grid grid using nuclear power.
- 58:41We could have done that 50 years ago.
- 58:43We can still do that in a lot of our work and energy policy is
- 58:45showing that. If you look at France, you look
- 58:47at Ontario, you look at places where they get a high percentage
- 58:51of their electricity generation from nuclear, they, they are 0
- 58:55carbon, you know, the carbon neutral today are close to it
- 58:58because of their reliance on nuclear energy.
- 59:01And in America, what we're doing is we're doing the opposite.
- 59:03We're closing nuclear plants. We close nuclear plants in New
- 59:05York and their end result is more use of coal, which is just
- 59:10colossally dumb. Same with Germany, they're doing
- 59:12the same thing, right? So nuclear energy as a result,
- 59:16because we regulate it basically out of existence or certainly
- 59:18new nuclear generation capacity, we've made it incredibly
- 59:22expensive to build new nuclear plants.
- 59:25It doesn't have to be expensive. It's only expensive because
- 59:28we've chosen to make it expensive because of the
- 59:30regulatory hurdles that we force nuclear generators to go
- 59:34through. So there's so many examples of,
- 59:36of what we can do to make America less expensive and more
- 59:41abundant and more competitive. And, and the good thing, the
- 59:45encouraging thing is that some of these ideas are taken up by
- 59:48Democrats and others by Republicans.
- 59:50So this is not a partisan issue. We think, you know, some people
- 59:52have a pet perception that economic freedom is inherently a
- 59:55Republican issue. I don't think that's, that's
- 59:57really true today. I think there's parts of
- 59:59economic freedom that are embraced more by Republicans and
- 1:00:02parts that are more embraced by Democrats.
- 1:00:04And, and we, we take all comers, we engage everyone whose
- 1:00:07interest in our ideas. Well, that's the right spirit.
- 1:00:12Make America's economy free again.
- 1:00:16I know you've got, in addition to the tools you mentioned, I
- 1:00:20think you have a conference as well.
- 1:00:22Maybe maybe as we close here, is there anything else you'd like
- 1:00:26to talk about either with respect to the conference or or
- 1:00:29other activities that you've got going or in ways that people can
- 1:00:34support the effort and get involved?
- 1:00:37I appreciate you mentioning the. Conference so.
- 1:00:40We're recording this in the summer of 2024.
- 1:00:43Every fall in November, Free Op has a an annual conference in
- 1:00:47Washington DC at the Park Hyatt called the Freedom and Progress
- 1:00:51Conference. This year it'll be held from
- 1:00:53November 17th to 19th at the Park Hyatt in Washington, and we
- 1:00:59cover a lot of these topics of how to how to solve a lot of
- 1:01:02these seemingly intractable problems using economic and
- 1:01:06individual freedom and technology, including how how to
- 1:01:09use Bitcoin for that purpose. You can learn more about the
- 1:01:13conference at our website at freeop.org/events slash freedom
- 1:01:18Dash Progress Dash 2024. And it's, you know, it's, it's
- 1:01:25an energy, it's an energizing conference every year that you
- 1:01:28know, you know, it's, it's so easy to get pessimistic and
- 1:01:30hopeless about all the big problems that we have.
- 1:01:32And we've talked about some of those big problems today.
- 1:01:35But you go to this conference and you realize there are
- 1:01:38talented people working on real solutions that can attract
- 1:01:42bipartisan support and get us out of some of these challenges
- 1:01:46that we have. And it's it's, it's always an
- 1:01:49incredibly rewarding event with a lot of really incredible
- 1:01:52people who come. So if people are interested in
- 1:01:55coming, they're welcome to. And if you're interested in
- 1:01:57supporting our work, we certainly welcome that as well.
- 1:02:00We are A5O1C3 nonprofit. We are supported entirely by
- 1:02:05donations. Another thing I'll mention that
- 1:02:08could be interesting to your audience is that we're producing
- 1:02:11a documentary that's kind of the, the movie version of
- 1:02:14Bitcoin in the US fiscal reckoning, where we, we, we try
- 1:02:17to engage the, you know, the popular audience, particularly
- 1:02:21young people, and helping them understand that these, these
- 1:02:25problems of the debt and deficit are the, the, the great social
- 1:02:29challenge of their time. Much like An Inconvenient Truth
- 1:02:32convinced people that climate was the thing they had to worry
- 1:02:34about 25 years ago when Al Gore made that movie.
- 1:02:38Our ideas, let's do something like that for the federal debt
- 1:02:41where we show people why actually it's the federal debt
- 1:02:43in the fiscal crisis that should animate their their political
- 1:02:47activism going forward. So that the working title for
- 1:02:50the movie is The Buck Stops. And we're also taking donations
- 1:02:54to support the production of that.
- 1:02:56Wow. Well, that's incredible.
- 1:02:58I'd love to see see what's going on with the buck stops.
- 1:03:02I'm wondering what are you going to use for polar bears?
- 1:03:04You need a, you need a polar bear like polar bear on the sun.
- 1:03:07That's. You know, that's a great.
- 1:03:10Yeah, that's it's. You know, it is really.
- 1:03:13Important, I think with this stuff to not just get to not
- 1:03:15just have inundate people with charts, but to give them the
- 1:03:17emotional power of what a debt crisis really looks like.
- 1:03:21And we are very actively that that's a that's a real point of
- 1:03:25emphasis for us. We want there to be emotional
- 1:03:28power of this film. We want people to really come
- 1:03:30out of that, that, that, that screening feeling like, OK, I, I
- 1:03:34know why this is the most important thing I have to do
- 1:03:36with my life. To the degree that I'm engaged
- 1:03:38in politics and advocacy. Well, Vic.
- 1:03:43It's been a tremendous conversation.
- 1:03:45Thank you for your time. We're going to leave it there.
- 1:03:47I look forward to learning more about the film, checking out the
- 1:03:50conference, and I encourage our listeners to do the same.
- 1:03:55So thank you so much for coming on Scarce Assets.
- 1:03:58Thanks a lot guys. Thanks for.
- 1:04:00Listening to this week's. Episode of the show.
- 1:04:03If you found the information valuable, please share the
- 1:04:05episode with a friend or leave a rating on your favorite podcast
- 1:04:07app. All the links we discussed in
- 1:04:09today's show will. Be in.
- 1:04:10The show notes inside your podcast app.
- 1:04:12Before we finish, a quick reminder that on Rat Media.
- 1:04:14Is for informational and entertainment purposes only and
- 1:04:17nothing should be construed as investment or legal advice.
- 1:04:20Regardless of where you are on your Bitcoin journey, we'd love
- 1:04:23to hear from you. Visit onrampbitcoin.com contact
- 1:04:27to schedule a consultation with one of our.
- 1:04:29Private. Client advisors.