Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / The Psychology of Jodi Arias - (Chapter 2)
Transcript
- 0:00So Berto, this is chapter two in our deep dive on the psychology of
- 0:04Jody Arius, and I thought we would start off this chapter by talking about
- 0:11why are cases like these cases like the Jodi Arias case and the trial,
- 0:18Why are they so fascinating to us as a culture? Why are they highlighted
- 0:23in the media? And the first thing I want to go into is even
- 0:28supporting that hypothesis that it is unusual that it is highlighted. You know,
- 0:34there are things about this case. You know, people say, well,
- 0:37you know, it's a it's a murder, it's fascinating. But let me
- 0:40give you some stats as to differentiates to why would this kind of case.
- 0:45So if we look at statistics, these are twenty twenty stats. By the
- 0:49way, percentage of murderers that are committed by men before identify as man.
- 0:54What percentage in the United States of murders are committed by men eight seven eighty
- 1:00seven. Now you know, it's still thirteen percent, either people identify as
- 1:03very high or other. But you know a lot of murders, vast majority
- 1:08committed by percentage of intimate partner murders committed by men. Oh my goodness.
- 1:15Okay, so I'll go very good, seventy eight percent. So there's a
- 1:19higher rate of overall of women killing men, but overall it's still a vast
- 1:26majority of men who you know, who are the committers of murder of a
- 1:32partner. Percentage of murder victims who were black, so victims victims who are
- 1:38who are black from overall murders. Well, so let's start off with what
- 1:44is the percentage of Americans who identifies black? Oh, I see um twenty
- 1:53So what percentage? So if everything was equal to be twelve percent of murder
- 1:59victims were black. But what do you think the real percentages percent of murder
- 2:02victims that are black is like fifty good, fifty six so much more likely
- 2:10percentage of murder victims who are black fifty six percent, fifty percent, even
- 2:16though black people amount to twelve percent of the American population. Now, we
- 2:21could, of course talk about all the historical and systemic racism that's involved in
- 2:25that, and police brutality and poverty and oppression and all that stuff, of
- 2:31course, but those are the facts that the vast majority of murders are committed
- 2:38by men, and the vast majority of victims of murder right are probably black
- 2:43men or at least black people. Yeah, and it seems though that white
- 2:49women are way overrepresented in the media when it comes to these kinds of stories,
- 2:53not only if they're the perpetrator, but also if they're the victim.
- 2:57You know, there's been a lot of talk more recently in the media,
- 3:00but in my field and my discipline, we've been yambering about this for decades
- 3:05that you know, if a black woman is raped and killed across town,
- 3:09the media just doesn't even mention it. But but if a white woman is
- 3:14abducted, then it's you know, international yeah, literally, Yeah, you
- 3:19know that woman who you know, tragically Gabby Petito a couple of years ago.
- 3:24All of these are tragedies, all of them. Yeah, it's awful,
- 3:28and of course they deserve to be told, and you know, and
- 3:34attempted to find the perpetrator or find her because she was missing for a while.
- 3:38But at the same time, there's you know, so many other people
- 3:42in more likelihood of other sorts of people that from other groups that are not
- 3:46being reported. All right. There are also a lot of movie depictions that
- 3:50are way over representative of women perpetrators of of intimate partner murder or violence or
- 3:58control this kind of thing, that's true. I mean, can you think
- 4:01of any movies on top of your head, gone girl spoiler alert, Yeah
- 4:06right, yeah, well it's another fatal attraction attraction. Yeah, um,
- 4:12play Misty for me, single white female. Yeah, The Hand that Rocks
- 4:15the Cradle. There's a lot, isn't that with Rebecca de Morney. Yeah,
- 4:19The Crush with Latin All about Steve two thousand and nine with Bradley Cooper,
- 4:26SANDERD. Bullock, The Boy next Door twenty fifteen, Jennifer Lopez,
- 4:30Ryan Guzman, and many others. Yeah, you know, we we have
- 4:33a fascinating now. You say, well, you know there's a lot of
- 4:36movies about men who are obsessed with women or who who stock women. Well,
- 4:41I could only think of a few. For example, Phantom of the
- 4:45Opera, which was made into a movie, Fear with Marky Mark and Reese
- 4:48Witherspoon. It's kind of a classic. But you could also say that any
- 4:53of the like Psycho and American Psycho, and like any there's a lot of
- 4:57guy psycho movies. The guy is the bad guy Michael Myers, Jason Vorhees.
- 5:02Yeah, but maybe not specifically focusing on one individual like like, oh
- 5:10yeah, yeah, it's more like, yeah, that's true. Those they're
- 5:11just generally psycho, right, But with fan of the opera and fear and
- 5:16with the crush and hand that rocks the cradle fail attraction, this is someone
- 5:21that is not just a psychopathic, sadistic killer. It's someone who is obsessed
- 5:26and stalking and maybe even trying to kill this one romantic at Just You the
- 5:30TV show on Netflix. But and I'm sure there are a few other examples,
- 5:35but in my anecdotal analysis, we as a society are much more likely
- 5:41to be interested and tell stories when women are abusing their men, their intimate
- 5:47partners that are men, and trying to kill them. You know. So
- 5:51if you if you just if aliens watched our movies, they would think that
- 5:55women are the perpetrators of that crime. And I think probably because in general,
- 6:00we want movies and fiction that is not day to day stuff. Okay,
- 6:03so that's one of the theories. So let's list them out, like
- 6:06that's why we have Jaws, you know. Okay, so that's one of
- 6:12the theories that it's novel, right, it's it's unusual this case where you
- 6:15have a woman, you know, the argument everyone understands that most of the
- 6:20time, when an intimate partner is stocking and killing their former partner, yeah,
- 6:26it's a man, a man killing a wife, but you know,
- 6:28that's mundane, it's it's a given. But when a woman does it,
- 6:31that's newsworthy. Okay, so we could throw that out there. It's hard
- 6:34to know exactly what motivates the public, but we could throw that. What
- 6:36are some other hypotheses. Well, there's the fact that it's a woman,
- 6:41but also the kind of woman, because like, this appears to be a
- 6:45a I hate to say it, but it's uh, it's someone that you
- 6:48would not expect to do it from our preconceived notions of society because they probably
- 6:54you would imagine they live in a better part of town, They are lighter
- 6:58skinned, they seemed to whether they do or not, they seem to have
- 7:02more means at their disposal, blah blah blah. And so we're like,
- 7:05whoa, what we thought all criminals looked like this, and we're you know,
- 7:09um, So there's the sex, also the race, also the socio
- 7:12economic status. Um. Also the probably the demeanor in this in this case,
- 7:17you know, the it's not like yeah, and I'll kill them all
- 7:19and I'll do it again. I'm like psycho. Right, It's like I
- 7:24don't know, I don't know, officer. You know. So a lot
- 7:28of those factors. That's another idea. Um. There's also a timing issue,
- 7:31which is I think you said that there were two that year. There's
- 7:36probably a lot every year. But I think maybe the media picked up on
- 7:40both because they were they were close to each other. Oh you know,
- 7:44one became a media sensation and then the other one was like the media,
- 7:48this is a new casey anthem. Yeah. Yeah. Um. There's also
- 7:53the level the egregiousness of the situation, because again there's probably a lot of
- 7:58case. In fact, there are a lot of is where a woman did
- 8:01kill her partner, maybe even in stocked and killed the partner. But then
- 8:03when you start stacking all the additional circumstances like the cross state lines, the
- 8:09over the top nature of the killing itself, the over the top nature of
- 8:13the line, like all those kinds of things make it also stand out.
- 8:16If the story was like it was a woman she killed her husband, and
- 8:18then you see the interviews like yeah I did it, it was horrible,
- 8:22Like okay, well fine, but it's not. It's there's layers and layers
- 8:26and layers, and every single aspect of it is over the top. So
- 8:30yeah, given that, it could arguably be said that this is the first
- 8:35live streamed on the internet. You know, if you say Casey Anthony was
- 8:39the first social media based crime, meaning that all the social media pictures that
- 8:46were mined as a way of trying to not only convict her and demonstrate that
- 8:52she was guilty, but also to throw at the press so that everyone could
- 8:56talk it. You know, you could say that OJ Simpson was the first
- 8:58live television you know, a trial of the century, and then the Jodiarius
- 9:05trial was the very first YouTube right live streamed. I mean, it's like
- 9:11the OJ example. It is like how often do you have a world famous
- 9:16star in a chase on Life TV after brutally you know, allegedly murdering.
- 9:22It's like if it happened ten years earlier, we would have read in the
- 9:26newspaper the next day that that O. J. Simpson was on the road,
- 9:31and you know, they'd summarize it, but you wouldn't really have felt
- 9:33it the way that you felt it when we were watching that Life And given
- 9:37the fact that there's so many details to pour over and talk about online,
- 9:41and you know, keep you watching that said Lizzie Borden. You know that
- 9:46name, right, She was a famous female killer back in I don't know,
- 9:50late eighteen hundreds, early nineteen hundred, and how many killers must there
- 9:54have been all those years at all times, yet I know the name Lizzie
- 9:56Borden. You know. It's like, think, maybe for a long time,
- 10:01things like this stood out, Well, why would that be? I
- 10:05mean, at the same time in the late eighteen hundred's presumed for the similar
- 10:09reasons because you know, it's like the same thing. You know, I
- 10:13imagine, you know, we rewind the clock six hundred years and it's like,
- 10:18oh my gosh, you're not gonna believe it. There was a raid
- 10:20in the town next door. It's like yeah, yeah, I know it
- 10:22sucks, but remember there's raids like every few months around here. Okay,
- 10:26but the elements like dude, you're not gonna believe it, Like you know,
- 10:30Melinda, she just like brutally murdered her family, Like that stands out.
- 10:35Yeah, so now we're going to tell a story about that. Yeah.
- 10:37Yeah, So I'm saying that absolutely novelty could be affect. The other
- 10:41things I could think of is that she fits a story trope or a cultural
- 10:48trope, if you will, a cliche of the ultimate ex girlfriend nightmare.
- 10:52Right. You remember this video around ten years ago. I remember was floating
- 10:56around where it became a vi one of those viral videos that I remember anyway,
- 11:01And this guy was in front of a at least I think this is
- 11:05how it went down. He was in front of a whiteboard and he's just
- 11:07a regular guy or something, and he's talking about how there's this matrix or
- 11:11a graph that you can depict women on two axes. So these are all
- 11:16heterosexual women that he's talking about, and he's like, oh, this sounds
- 11:18familiar. Yeah, the axes. The axes are between good looks, how
- 11:24good looking she is? Well, anyway, I can't remember exactly how,
- 11:28but they were saying that the more good looking a woman gets, the crazier
- 11:33she has to be. And so there's a quadrant on the axes graph area
- 11:41that you can't have a woman that is both extremely hot but is not crazy.
- 11:46Point is is that, yeah, it's disgusting in sexist, but it
- 11:50is absolutely an idea that's floated around by by misogynists and society. You know,
- 11:56we could speculate as to why, but it's definitely not supported by the
- 12:01science. Well there, okay, but there is one aspect that I think
- 12:05is this this concept of hey, this person is like really wild in bed
- 12:11or you know, just very open liberally sex, sex, whatever, and
- 12:15they're also very and then there's a whole bunch of other issues with them.
- 12:18Well, it is possible that people with more trauma, more abuse, more
- 12:22things happen to also have more extreme behaviors in general, which can include sexual
- 12:26behaviors. So people over time might generalize and say, yeah, yeah,
- 12:31that's a thing. Right. So this is a trope, and I think
- 12:33it was particularly prevalent in really mainstream male culture ten years ago, and this
- 12:39case slotted exactly into that, right, sure, I mean can you see
- 12:45how people would look at her that way? Absolutely, it'd be like,
- 12:48well there you go, that proves the theory. Yeah, because I haven't
- 12:52we haven't gotten into details, and we won't a lot, but there are
- 12:54a lot of graphic sexual details about this case, right, and the recordings
- 13:01of them talking together, her own descriptions about their relationship on the stand.
- 13:05Yeah, I mean, it was described in detail, so many data points,
- 13:11and they had the pictures before the murder like everything. Yeah, it's
- 13:15just like on display. Yeah. I mean they literally had sex and took
- 13:18pictures of each other minutes before she was brutally murdering him. Yeah. So
- 13:24that's one hypothesis I would throw out there as to why our society is so
- 13:28fascinated by this case and others like it. Another is that it just involves
- 13:31sex. I mean, let's be honest, anything that involves sex is something
- 13:35that society is going to talk about, right. And also there's this notion
- 13:39of the sexy woman, right who commits a crime Foxynoxi in Italy, that
- 13:45kind of thing. And also the fact that he's a religious man trying to
- 13:48be pure and this tractive, sexy temptress succubus comes in and and you know,
- 13:54tempts him to the other side. Another factor that could be present is
- 13:58the rutality of the murder. There are, like we've been saying, probably
- 14:05daily murders like this, or at least weekly or I don't know what the
- 14:07rate would be, but it's you know, it's frequent, but often it's
- 14:11a gunshot to the head or just a couple stabs, but the brutality and
- 14:16the fact that we have like at least one picture of it happening at the
- 14:22time, you know, it's a picture gets taken accidentally, seemingly by her
- 14:28while she's murdering him. And then also they released the pictures of his body
- 14:33in the shower when they found him. Yeah, a week later, those
- 14:37like how does that serve the public good? Like imagine yea, like where
- 14:43can I sign? Let me put this? Where can I sign to ask
- 14:46cops, media, everyone like, please don't release pictures of me when I
- 14:50get brutally murdered, Like, just don't do it. Please. Well,
- 14:52there's this thing called prepaid legal burdo. Have you heard of it? I
- 14:56haven't tell any more. You sound very charismatic. I should follow you.
- 15:00Another factor is sexism, pure and simple. Our society loves to attack women.
- 15:05And I don't know how to word it. Is it men trying to
- 15:09balance scales, you know, because there's a lot of men out there,
- 15:11the red pill people, the MiG tao and sell people that will be like,
- 15:13well, you know, women abuse men too sometimes, and it's just
- 15:18like yeah, totally absolutely, but you know, it doesn't deny the fact
- 15:22that society is sexist. So when there's an example like this, it just
- 15:26gives the in cells this massive amount of fuel to push back on what they
- 15:31believe to be unfair identification of sexism and society. Absolutely, I call this
- 15:37the duck scale, Like this is this has been going on for thousands of
- 15:41years, right, It's like there's a witch, we can burn her.
- 15:46You know, I recently will watch that movie. Another thing is you know,
- 15:50racism. That it sounds counterintuitive, but the fact that white stories are
- 15:56told in the media and not other people's story is another possibility. Another factor
- 16:03is potentially agism because you know, most people at the time of this murder,
- 16:08they were older than Jodiarius was. And our society loves to look at
- 16:14especially I think, young women and find reasons to hate them, and so
- 16:18I think this could be another factor. And the final hypothesis I have is
- 16:22that you know, you and I don't live in this world, but there's
- 16:25a religious world, and there are people that live in this religious world and
- 16:30this is a philosophy or lifestyle that dominates their life, which is fine,
- 16:33And there are some people within the religious world that are in a constant battle
- 16:38trying to convince themselves to deny their carnal nature. They are single and twenty
- 16:45years old and they're being told that they can't have premalital sex. Or you
- 16:48have elders in the religious community that are trying to tell the younger people not
- 16:53to have sex and talk about a cautionary tale. Yes that see, see,
- 17:00this is what we've been talking about. I wonder if if the Yodi
- 17:04Jodi trial is mandatory viewing in some I mean, I would not be surprised
- 17:11that it's brought up because it holds all of the markers because she, you
- 17:18could argue, manipulated herself into the Mormon Church just to be with him.
- 17:23She was obsessed with it. He was the way that the media portrays Travis
- 17:26as he was this, you know, this pillar of society, and he
- 17:32was loved by all, and he was a pure man. And this this
- 17:36you know Madonna horror thing. This this you know, dirty secular and non
- 17:41religious outsider. She's from California and she comes in and just completely overtakes him
- 17:48with her sexual hunnish practices. Yeah, well, with her attractiveness and she
- 17:56seduces him and then she kills him. And yeah, I mean, certainly
- 18:00she's an awful person. But if you frame it in a certain way of
- 18:04a cautionary tale, or if you've been really trying to convince the young kids
- 18:10not to have premariable sex or to not date people that aren't Mormon or not
- 18:15of your religion, you could see how this story would be a very convenient
- 18:18selling point if you This is the don't drink and drive equivalent. Yeah.
- 18:22Right, So those are the theories. Let us know in the comment section
- 18:26if you have other ideas or comments about why these stories are so fascinating.
- 18:32Now, I will say that I'm fascinated with the story, So I'm not
- 18:36saying that there's something wrong with being fascinated with a story. I would like
- 18:40to think that I'm not fascinated fascinated with it for some of the problematic reasons
- 18:45that we've mentioned, But I do think that it is fascinating because of the
- 18:48brutality, and I guess because of the novelty, but also because of how
- 18:52much psychology is in this and also just how many things that you can learn
- 18:57from this case as just someone in life that I think there's a lot to
- 19:02be learned about stalking, about how to respond to stalking, about how to
- 19:07help people when they're when they're suffering, about you just never know. I
- 19:12guess to me one of the fascinations because I had a similar, a similar
- 19:18feeling watching all the Jody interviews and the when she was talking and stuff that
- 19:25I had with with the Casey stuff. And it's also the same feeling I've
- 19:30had watching some of the psychopaths we've talked about in the past. I'm not
- 19:33saying these are all psychopaths, but I'm saying that that that feeling I get
- 19:37is this uneasiness of I like almost disbelief of how easy it comes to lie,
- 19:45and how I feel sort of helpless and helpless that I imagine myself confronting
- 19:49or interacting with a person like this and and thinking, Wow, reality and
- 19:55facts are not a thing that matters in this case. And you can tell
- 19:59me whatever you want without caring that what that means to me or what it
- 20:03might how it might hurt me. And it's like it's a little scary,
- 20:06it's frightening. So there is that fascination for me. Maybe it's a morbid
- 20:11fascination, but it is a fascination of Wow, these are real human brains
- 20:15and this is how they work. Yeah, that fascination with psychopaths. I
- 20:22think another as a subset of that. Another possibility that popped into my head
- 20:26is that, in a weird way, you know, this similar way as
- 20:32to why we might like horror movies or mafia mob of movies, is that
- 20:37we get to play out our potential fantasies of getting revenge against someone that broke
- 20:47up with us, getting revenge against someone who broke up with us. You
- 20:55got to find out how slowly I type right now, and that sounds a
- 20:59horror and not very likely. But I think that there's a possibility that subconsciously,
- 21:06while we're watching this in a similar way that when we're watching a like
- 21:08I said, a horror movie or a mob mafia movie, that we get
- 21:14a subconscious satisfaction watching someone else do what we wouldn't actually want to do,
- 21:18but we have feelings that are of anger and revenge. That we wouldn't want
- 21:23to murder our past partners, but we would want to get back at them,
- 21:26we would want to humiliate them. So I have It's interesting because I
- 21:30have this sort of one hundred and eighty degree different reaction when I'm watching a
- 21:36horror movie, I hate to admit it, but oftentimes I am under the
- 21:41surface, not explicitly, but I'm sort of rooting for the bad guy in
- 21:44the horror movie in the sense that that's kind of what the plot of the
- 21:48movie is. You're seeing this psycho killer kill more, and so there's that
- 21:52part of my brain that's like, Okay, how is he going to keep
- 21:56killing more? Right now? Obviously, then just a moral part of me
- 22:00he goes like, well, no, obviously, we want this to stop.
- 22:03That's when I'm watching a horror movie. What's interesting is when I'm watching
- 22:06these cases, a lot of my subconscious fantasy steers towards the other aspect,
- 22:11which is how I want to get revenge on this criminal. Like I'm like,
- 22:15oh would how would I would like and I would torture them for years.
- 22:18And then I have to fight against myself too, going like no,
- 22:21stop. You know that that's like throwing your life away to think that way.
- 22:23Because you grew up with the drug cartels and I was the enforced they
- 22:30called me, who were terrorizing your community, and you literally had bullets,
- 22:37right, So you're right, So I had a lot of time to fantasize
- 22:40about how unjust that was and how much I wish justice would come to these
- 22:45people, that Superman would come down to throw them into the ocean or something.
- 22:48And yeah, so that's another thing. And I think that's another reason
- 22:51why we like mob movies, mafia movies and horror movies. And I think
- 22:55stories like this is because we both get the satisfaction from both sides. We
- 22:59both get the satisfaction of getting revenge on our former partners, and we get
- 23:03the satisfaction of watching the bully get a consequence. You know, the story
- 23:10for Jodi Arius doesn't end well well. And I would say because, for
- 23:15example, the Casey story, I don't I don't think there was any part
- 23:18of me that I was like, Oh, this is how I would get
- 23:22back at my kid or something. Right, that's a horreendous thought. But
- 23:25there was definitely that thought of like, how could I get back at this
- 23:27monster? Right? Right? And in a mob movie, I'm like,
- 23:30oh, how can Tony Soprano get away with it? At the same time
- 23:34he kind of rooting for him to get caught, but not really but yeah,
- 23:37totally so Berto. In this chapter, we're gonna be going into the
- 23:41relationship and all the details between Travis and Jody, the love bombing, the
- 23:47back and forth, the religious aspects, the sexual aspects, the stocking,
- 23:52and in this chapter will probably end up getting to the details of the murder,
- 23:56which I spent a lot of time going over the data and also reading
- 24:02a lot of people's hypotheses about what really happened, because none of us really
- 24:04know what happened during the murder, but there's a lot of evidence to pour
- 24:08over, and I found someone that had hypothesized about the different events. And
- 24:15also there's the prosecution's narrative, and it explains a lot because there's a lot
- 24:19of blood, there's a lot of also the clean up. And there's also
- 24:23some theories that I came across that actually felt a lot more satisfying, like
- 24:27the fact that she put the camera in the washing machine, and she's also
- 24:33a professional photographer, so she probably knew about how those things work. And
- 24:40also she could have just brought the camera with her, right and she did.
- 24:44She brought the knife and the gun with her. Why wouldn't she bring
- 24:47the camera, And so because I first, yeah, and I do too,
- 24:52you know, And it's interesting that at first, because I think most
- 24:55people just think that she's a dumb girl who didn't understand that just putting in
- 24:59the washing she wouldn't necessarily do anything. But it's interesting that we would think
- 25:03that instead of trying to figure out some other answer, and especially when you
- 25:07consider she's a professional photographer. She really studied photography and grew up with digital
- 25:12photography, probably knew a lot about it, a lot more than maybe even
- 25:17you and I know about it, So probably did know a lot more that
- 25:19you and I. So we're gonna go over all that. But this episode
- 25:23is just going to be for patrons of the podcast, because usually when I
- 25:26spend many days prepping for an episode and spending a lot of time on it,
- 25:33I like to really reward the patrons with that because because the only reason
- 25:38why I can even spend that amount of time is because they literally pay my
- 25:42bills so I don't have to work at the university, so I can spend
- 25:45sixteen hours a day for a number of days just studying the Jody areas data,
- 25:51of which there is so much to go over. And I almost wanted
- 25:55to postpone this episode to next week. I wanted maybe another week to go
- 26:00everything, but I figured out I just pulled the rip chord and let it,
- 26:03let it rip, so Berto in one sentence, why should people become
- 26:07a patron podcast and listen to this episode, Well, besides to support my
- 26:12co habit, because I don't like Pepsi anymore. I think there is a
- 26:17wealth of great, great content if you care about psychology, if you care
- 26:22about some serious deep times like collegiate you know, like the kind of thing
- 26:26you would read in a book that you bought for six hundred dollars from the
- 26:29library at Stanford, you know, like really important stuff. Plus a lot
- 26:32of bs coming from my mouth. But it's really interesting topics all over the
- 26:37place. Like we've covered almost everything that's important. But if you like it
- 26:41and you want to see it, keep going supporting. Yeah, literally,
- 26:44it's the only way we can keep going and become a patron But otherwise the
- 26:48episode will end now. And take care of yourself because you deserve it, even