Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / Onramp Webinar Series E001: Bitcoin’s Full Potential Valuation
Transcript
- 0:00Thank you for joining us. This week.
- 0:01We're excited to bring you a webinar that was recorded in
- 0:04December of last year, now available for public
- 0:06consumption. This webinar hosted by On RAMP
- 0:09Media is led by On RAMP Co Founder Jesse Myers and On RAMP
- 0:12Chief Strategy Officer, Brian Cabela's, who are joined by Mark
- 0:15Connors, Head of Research at 3 IQ.
- 0:17In light of Bitcoin's most recent having, we're inclined to
- 0:20resurface this insightful discussion which covers Bitcoin
- 0:23supply dynamics and its full potential valuation.
- 0:26Before we start, a quick reminder that the On RAMP
- 0:28webinar series is for informational and entertainment
- 0:30purposes only and nothing should be construed as investment or
- 0:34legal advice. At On RAMP, we believe that
- 0:36Bitcoin will be the most important asset to own in the
- 0:3821st century. Our multi institution custody
- 0:41solution is the safest and most secure way to ensure that your
- 0:45Bitcoin remains in your and your family's possession for decades
- 0:48to come. Multi institution custody
- 0:50maximizes security and minimizes counterparty risk.
- 0:53Leveraging Bitcoin's native properties to eliminate single
- 0:56points of failure that have historically complicated Bitcoin
- 0:58ownership on RAMP provides Peace of Mind for your Bitcoin
- 1:02journey. For more information check us
- 1:04out at on rampbitcoin.com. OK, so with that out of the way,
- 1:08my name is Brian Cabela's. I'm the head of Strategy and
- 1:11research here at On RAMP. I am joined by our Co founder
- 1:15and CEO Jesse Myers. And we're.
- 1:17Thrilled to have a special guest with us here today, Mark
- 1:19Connors, the Head of Research at 3 IQA Digital Asset Management
- 1:23Company. Mark has an extensive background
- 1:26in the traditional finance space and has a wealth of knowledge
- 1:30about the global asset landscape, the macro environment
- 1:33and of course, Bitcoin. So we're honored to have him
- 1:36join us for the first session of the On Ramp Webinar series.
- 1:42And so the the purpose and the intent of this series is really
- 1:46to provide individuals, investors and allocators with an
- 1:50interactive forum to explore the investment case for Bitcoin, its
- 1:54fundamental merits and really allow folks to broaden their
- 1:58understanding of this asset. As such, we, we would love to
- 2:01hear from the audience. So please submit any questions
- 2:04you may have in the Q&A box throughout the presentation and
- 2:08we will try to answer as many of those as we can in the last 15
- 2:11minutes of the call. Also note that this presentation
- 2:15is being recorded. And before we jump into the
- 2:19discussion, I also wanted to introduce Cam Stromie on RAMPS
- 2:22Head of Private Wealth to speak a bit about on RAMP for those
- 2:26who may not be familiar with our business.
- 2:28Cam. Thanks Brian.
- 2:31So for anyone who's newer to on ramp, we are a Bitcoin asset
- 2:35management platform and built on multi institution custody.
- 2:39So a little bit about us and why we've developed this.
- 2:43You can think about our firm in a few different parts.
- 2:46The first part being education first and foremost, We've been
- 2:48educators personally, but then also professionally as a team
- 2:52for half a decade now or more in this space and view that as
- 2:55critically important. So appreciate your attendance
- 2:58here. The webinar is 1 facet of how we
- 3:01help folks to understand Bitcoin at a fundamental level and then
- 3:04at its highest level as well. We're focused on helping
- 3:07investors, family offices, institutions, pensions institute
- 3:12and corporations to buy and hold the asset for the long term.
- 3:16So then how do you hold the asset for the long term?
- 3:20As many of you may already know, there's a custody element to
- 3:23allocating to this asset class, which is not something that
- 3:26we're used to as investors. Looking across the landscape,
- 3:30there's a lot of nuance in custody.
- 3:33Michael and I have professionally dedicated over
- 3:35half a decade to understanding custody at its deepest level,
- 3:39talking with thousands of clients, helping onboard
- 3:41billions of dollars into Bitcoin, and helping investors
- 3:45to navigate that custody landscape and understanding what
- 3:48custody solutions are are best for them.
- 3:51Historically they have at we've only had two options for
- 3:54custody. It's either been you trust a
- 3:56single institution to hold your funds.
- 3:59That historically has had a number of pitfalls.
- 4:02FTX being the most recent and prominent example.
- 4:05The other fork in that road was self custody.
- 4:08Investors had to dig in and learn how to hold cryptographic
- 4:12material with 100% downside risk if those keys were mismanaged or
- 4:17lost. So on ramps provide the third
- 4:20option that has never existed before at the custodial level
- 4:24where 3 institutions on ramp, bit, go and coin cover each hold
- 4:28one key and it eliminates single points of failure, meaning that
- 4:33even if one firm fails for the first time ever, a client's
- 4:36Bitcoin is absolutely safe. So that's what we do at a high
- 4:40level. We'd love to chat with you
- 4:41individually after this webinar, so feel free to go to our
- 4:45website, schedule a call and I personally would love to talk
- 4:48with you. Thanks, Cam.
- 4:51So just a bit about what we're going to be talking about today.
- 4:54So this first sessions topic of discussion is Bitcoin's full
- 4:58potential valuation. Jesse Meyers published a report
- 5:02on this topic about a month or so ago and we really wanted to
- 5:05take the opportunity to dive deep on his analysis and broadly
- 5:09discuss discuss different valuation frameworks for
- 5:12Bitcoin. While the sort of high level
- 5:15thesis for Bitcoin I would argue is sort of increasingly well
- 5:18understood, it can be difficult to grasp sort of the magnitude
- 5:22of the opportunity. So we're also going to touch on
- 5:25some key catalyst for Bitcoin and and how those may impact its
- 5:28trajectory moving forward. So without further ado, I'm
- 5:32going to kick it to Jesse to big begin with an overview of his
- 5:35report and then we'll dive into more of an open discussion on
- 5:38the aforementioned topics. Jesse.
- 5:41Great. Thank you, Brian and and thanks
- 5:43Cam for that intro to on ramp. Yeah.
- 5:46So we're going to get into it now that the meat of it here of
- 5:51what is Bitcoin's full potential valuation.
- 5:54And you know, the the spirit of this sort of exercise is, is,
- 5:59you know, it's the the problem that we all face when we
- 6:02consider Bitcoin as an investment.
- 6:05You know, there's. This there's the spot price of
- 6:07Bitcoin today. That's what it's trading at.
- 6:09But obviously for anyone who's considering investment, you're
- 6:13only going to invest if you think that the future value of
- 6:16it is higher than what it is today.
- 6:19But that requires having a perspective about where this
- 6:22thing could go and why and and specifically how high it could
- 6:27go. So what?
- 6:28Is the full potential for bitcoins valuation?
- 6:31Well, it's kind of an impossible question, right?
- 6:35Impossible to know. And people approach this in
- 6:39different ways of, you know, how to value Bitcoin and where is it
- 6:43going. And that'll be a big part of the
- 6:45conversation that Brian and and Mark and I have after we go
- 6:49through this report here. But my effort was really kind of
- 6:53bringing my management consulting tool kit to how do
- 6:58you triangulate a a a decent answer based on a a variety.
- 7:04Of estimates and and a methodology for for what's
- 7:07possible here. So if we scroll Scroll down into
- 7:10this report here you know the the the starting point for and
- 7:17and and I should mention that this report is available on our
- 7:20website and for anyone to download and we'll we'll make
- 7:25the link to download it available in the in the chat and
- 7:30we can also. Follow up with that as well.
- 7:33So the first question. Is you know what is what is
- 7:37Bitcoin? What is this asset what market
- 7:39is it competing in what assets is it competing against.
- 7:43And and the reality is this is a store of value asset.
- 7:46This is digital gold. It has the properties of gold,
- 7:51but digitized and in in many ways improved upon, nearly
- 7:56perfected gold and what gold, really?
- 8:00Is is a. Store of value asset it's it.
- 8:02It has value because it there's not much additional gold being
- 8:07created every year and as a result of that you don't have
- 8:12much supply dilution of the value that you store today.
- 8:15And so value that you put into gold today propagates through
- 8:19time relatively effectively and that's a store of value asset.
- 8:25And so Bitcoin is is a store of value asset.
- 8:28It's it has many of those properties that in fact takes it
- 8:31to an even more perfected version of it.
- 8:36And that is really the way to think about Bitcoin as an asset
- 8:39is a store of value that if you put value into Bitcoin today, it
- 8:45can propagate into the future without much dilution.
- 8:49And and that is a very attractive thing especially in a
- 8:52climate like today where we are dealing with inflation, $34
- 8:57trillion of of national debt in the US, sovereign debt crisis
- 9:03all over the world. And the potential that you know,
- 9:07we may see a high level of of inflation going forward as a
- 9:11result of sovereign nations needing to service their debt
- 9:15and print money to do that. So Victoria, that's that's the
- 9:19the nature of where Bitcoin fits in.
- 9:20If we Scroll down a little more to the next page and you know
- 9:27this is a a way to conceptualize how do you, how does Bitcoin
- 9:31stack up against other types of assets, right.
- 9:34Because every every asset has its own properties and not all
- 9:38assets are are made the same. Obviously you consume some
- 9:41things and some things depreciate and then there's
- 9:46investments that grow in value over time.
- 9:48But they they don't, they're not all the same.
- 9:51A investment in in land is going to be a a fairly stable
- 9:58investment that will appreciate over time.
- 10:01But it's not generating necessarily generating cash
- 10:04flows the way that equities might be and that like
- 10:08investment in like a a tech company might outperform that
- 10:13land. But here's Bitcoin, which in my
- 10:17opinion has properties that allow it to outperform any of
- 10:22these investment assets, the various options in an investment
- 10:26landscape. And that's what we've seen over
- 10:28the last 15 years of Bitcoins emergence as an asset from from
- 10:32nothing, from from an, from a a toy with 0 value to today where
- 10:38where it's an $800 billion asset and still still very early in
- 10:45its global adoption. But you know people watch on to
- 10:49the volatility along the way. If you were to smooth out that
- 10:52volatility and and represented on a on a logarithmic scale like
- 10:57this, it's something like a straight up and to the right
- 11:00approach. And so in my view and and over
- 11:05bitcoin's 15 year history, it does outperform any other
- 11:09investment asset because these specifically because of these
- 11:12properties of its increasing scarcity and the fact that it's
- 11:16early stage and it's global adoption.
- 11:18OK. Next section.
- 11:22So the next part of this piece of this puzzle is to think about
- 11:28what is the ceiling for various assets, What sets the ceiling?
- 11:34And when it comes to commodities, Bitcoin is a
- 11:37commodity. Typically what sets the ceiling
- 11:40is the amount of new supply creation every year that has to
- 11:45go out into the market and be absorbed by the market.
- 11:48So you know, if if gold is a is a $12 trillion asset and 2% more
- 11:57of it is made every year, well that's $240 billion of of gold
- 12:02that's created every single year that has to go out into the
- 12:06market and be absorbed by demand and just for the price of gold
- 12:11to go sideways. And so if gold was to suddenly
- 12:1510X in value, well, now that it's not $240 billion of new
- 12:22supply creation every year, that's $2.4 trillion of supply
- 12:26creation every year. And there's just not enough
- 12:29demand for that. So that amount of new supply
- 12:35coming onto the market would suppress the price, drive the
- 12:37price back down back to this equilibrium that gold has
- 12:40established over time. And that equilibrium nature of
- 12:44how commodities end up finding their price ceiling based on the
- 12:50amount of supply being created every year versus the existing
- 12:53demand for that asset in general, that's how these,
- 12:56that's how commodities end up setting their price ceilings.
- 13:00And so that's an important piece to introduce because Bitcoin is
- 13:03different. So next section here.
- 13:08So in the world of commodities, Bitcoin is different.
- 13:12It's the first digital commodity and it's the invention of
- 13:16digital scarcity. And that is a one time
- 13:20phenomenon because you can have copies of digital scarcity that
- 13:23aren't themselves scarce, because it's always possible to
- 13:26have an incremental copy of a system of digital scarcity.
- 13:30But there's the original instance of digital scarcity and
- 13:33it's Bitcoin and and so this is a part of the you know the if
- 13:38you Scroll down a little bit here the the Internet
- 13:42revolution. Here the digital revolution,
- 13:44which is really two pieces. We we've lived through the
- 13:47digitization of information which is the the Internet.
- 13:51That's how we went from a world of analogue information to a
- 13:54digital world of information. But you couldn't put value onto
- 14:00the Internet because it's always possible to copy and paste and
- 14:04and that doesn't work for value. You can't have that.
- 14:09And so Bitcoin is this invention of a system of digital scarcity
- 14:13that allows for the digitization of value, this complementary
- 14:18digitization of value to the digitization of information that
- 14:23I believe we will end up looking back on as the second Internet.
- 14:27So we I think are in the early 90s for the Internet of value.
- 14:34If you Scroll down to the next page and the the important thing
- 14:40here to link this back to the topic of what sets the ceiling
- 14:43for commodities, for commodity valuations is that Bitcoin has
- 14:47these, this very unique attribute in the commodity
- 14:51landscape which is it's increasing scarcity.
- 14:54So you see this, this chart on the page here is the supply
- 14:58schedule for Bitcoin. The asymptotic curve up and to
- 15:02the right is how much Bitcoin exists and you can see that flat
- 15:08line at the top there. That's the total that will ever
- 15:10exist. There will only ever be 21
- 15:12million Bitcoin. The orange bars are the amount
- 15:15of Bitcoin being released every every 10 minutes across these
- 15:22four year periods and you can see that that amount gets cut in
- 15:26half every four years. The result of this is, is
- 15:30increasing scarcity. So yeah, every four years the
- 15:34amount of new supply issuance of Bitcoin gets cut in half and
- 15:37that ties directly back to the conversation about what's its
- 15:41commodity price ceilings. Because Bitcoins supply issuance
- 15:47goes to zero over time, it keeps dropping asymptotically to zero.
- 15:53And that means that this the market has to absorb less and
- 15:56less new supply and that allows for the potential that the
- 16:00ceiling price of Bitcoin to scale endlessly.
- 16:05And that's different from any other commodity ever in the
- 16:07history of investable assets, because that was never possible
- 16:11in the physical world. It's only possible in the
- 16:13digital world. And and this is the one and only
- 16:17instance of digital scarcity. So it's only really possible
- 16:20with Bitcoin. OK.
- 16:22So if we we then put these pieces together.
- 16:24Next section, yes. And so that Bitcoin has an
- 16:32unthinkable property. It gets more valuable over time
- 16:35because of this reducing issuance, this increasing
- 16:37scarcity. So that's that.
- 16:39Go to the next section, then. OK.
- 16:45And now we need to take stock of OK, how much value is out there?
- 16:50What is Bitcoin in the global asset landscape?
- 16:52As you can see on on this this graphic it well it was 500
- 16:57billion. Dollars in value.
- 17:01Two months ago when I made this graphic it it has now grown to
- 17:05$800 billion of value. But the the global asset
- 17:09landscape hasn't hasn't shifted. There's $900 trillion of value
- 17:13out there in these various store value buckets, real estate,
- 17:17bonds, equities, money itself. That's how much value is sitting
- 17:22in these different types of assets.
- 17:24And now here's this tiny little thimble in this ocean of value
- 17:28that has these properties that we've just talked about that
- 17:32make it more attractive as a store value asset than any of
- 17:35these other assets because of its increasing scarcity
- 17:38specifically. So then we have to think about,
- 17:42OK, all the value sitting in these different buckets.
- 17:45Will some of the value in these buckets want to reallocate to
- 17:50this more attractive asset when they evaluate these things, you
- 17:57know and and take a serious look at Bitcoin.
- 18:00And so then we can go to the next section and and come up
- 18:05with how we would do that. Scroll down a little further.
- 18:13So if we were to take stock of all those those buckets of value
- 18:19and add up their trillions of dollars in each of those buckets
- 18:23and then think about OK, if I'm an investor who's holding a lot
- 18:28of bonds, for example, and what is what's a bond doing for me in
- 18:32My Portfolio? It is promising a certain
- 18:35nominal return, you know 4 percent, 5% return into the
- 18:41future, which doesn't account for inflation risk of of the
- 18:45units that you're receiving dollars.
- 18:48And you know most most commonly here, but that's the that's the
- 18:54point of holding a bond is that you are receiving some reliable
- 18:59nominal return for parking your value in that asset.
- 19:04But if Bitcoin has this increasing scarcity function
- 19:07that reliably delivers increasing value over time, if
- 19:12you hold the Bitcoin for four years or more than that might
- 19:17serve you better than it's a small nominal return of dollars,
- 19:23which is an asset that's that's being debased over time with
- 19:25with inflation. And you know, you by holding a
- 19:28button, you may or may not actually receive a a positive
- 19:32real yield. So you might be receiving a
- 19:35negative real yield just by holding a bond.
- 19:38Or you could switch part of that bond portfolio into this asset
- 19:42that delivers a guaranteed increasing scarcity because of
- 19:45its supply mechanics, and that increasing scarcity manifest as
- 19:51increasing value over time. How much of that of your bond
- 19:54portfolio might you, you know, want to reallocate to Bitcoin?
- 19:59I don't know. It's it's up for anybody's
- 20:02interpretation here. In this Bitcoin Capture column,
- 20:06I put forward my conservative estimates of what I think
- 20:12holders of these different asset classes.
- 20:14How much of the value park there might.
- 20:18Want to overtime reallocate to this asset that I think has more
- 20:23attractive properties than any of these other store value
- 20:26assets in the physical world. Maybe it's 30% for bonds, maybe
- 20:31it's 5% for bonds, maybe it's 90% for bonds.
- 20:35It's really up to everyone out there to determine for
- 20:39themselves what they think is possible here given the
- 20:43properties of Bitcoin that we've talked through with these
- 20:47numbers, with these assumptions here, which I think are
- 20:50conservative and you know you can argue with me on them and
- 20:54and you can come up with your own numbers and I encourage
- 20:56people to do that. You can take the same table,
- 20:59plug in your own numbers and then see what that bottom right
- 21:02number spits out in terms of the potential valuation in your mind
- 21:06for Bitcoin using this framework.
- 21:08And if the if that value is is greater than $40,000 per
- 21:13Bitcoin, you are you inherently believe that that Bitcoin is
- 21:18underpriced today. My numbers resulted in a a crazy
- 21:24valuation, something I'm you know for some time was almost
- 21:27embarrassed to share with people because it sounds so absurd.
- 21:31But this methodology arrived at $200 trillion of value for for
- 21:37Bitcoin in the long term. In today's dollars, which is to
- 21:41say this, this, this will take decades, This could be a 30 year
- 21:45endeavour. But I believe that Bitcoin can
- 21:49absorb 20 to 20 to 25% of the world's store of value assets
- 21:56into what is currently a tiny little thimble in the in the
- 22:01ocean of of global asset value. So that's my full potential
- 22:05valuation for Bitcoin. I think that Bitcoin can can
- 22:10reach as high as $10 million per Bitcoin in today's dollars over
- 22:15the next several decades. So that's the this whole report
- 22:20here. If anyone's interested in in
- 22:21downloading it, the link for it is in the chat and you can also
- 22:27find it on our website. And so now I'd love to open it
- 22:30up for for Mark and Brian to you know provide any thoughts they
- 22:36have on on this approach and then we can talk about other
- 22:40ways to value Bitcoin and where this asset is going long term.
- 22:45Well, Brian, why don't you kick it off?
- 22:46Because I know you, you're there working a little bit with Jesse,
- 22:50so you might connect it to the body of work.
- 22:54Yeah. So, you know, I would say at a
- 22:56high level, I think Jesse's analysis is incredibly useful
- 23:00for for a number of reasons. But you know it it helps provide
- 23:03investors with the context for bitcoins potential.
- 23:06You know, I think when approaching this asset it's it's
- 23:09can be very difficult for investors to grasp its real
- 23:13potential. And the reality is that you know
- 23:16investors and and humans generally have never observed an
- 23:19absolutely scarce asset go through a monetization process
- 23:23like this. So it can be almost difficult to
- 23:26fathom, you know what the ultimate price ceiling for for
- 23:29this thing could be. And so I would also say that you
- 23:32know I historically have personally struggled with
- 23:34specific price predictions because I think you know it's
- 23:37certainly more of an art than a science.
- 23:39And I think you know Jesse's analysis is a is a fantastic
- 23:42effort to sort of triangulate a a plausible trajectory here.
- 23:46But for me personally when I, when I think about Bitcoin's
- 23:49valuation, I really think of it as more of a directional
- 23:53analysis. So you know if we distill
- 23:56Bitcoin's price appreciation down to its core levers some of
- 24:00which Jesse walked through it, it's really all about supply and
- 24:05demand. And so we know what the supply
- 24:07distribution is and we know that there will only ever be 21
- 24:11million bitcoins. So given that static eventual
- 24:14supply the, the critical lever to to really assess is whether
- 24:19demand is continuing to increase.
- 24:21So you know all else equal if demand continues to increase,
- 24:25Bitcoin's price will continue to increase.
- 24:26And so for me I I tend to focus on assessing really the drivers
- 24:31of demand and and sort of trying to identify those key indicators
- 24:36that demand is in fact increasing.
- 24:38And so you know that that would include metrics like unique
- 24:42wallet creation, transaction activity, hash rate growth and
- 24:47and so I think you know it's important to recognize that
- 24:50Bitcoin is more than just a financial instrument or a a
- 24:55digital commodity or a currency. You know at the at the protocol
- 24:58level this is a piece of technology that enables A
- 25:03globally accessible permissionless payments network.
- 25:06And so part of the demand for the asset stems from the
- 25:10expanding utility of the protocol itself.
- 25:12So I like to think and and sort of focus on the development of
- 25:16second and third layers like the lightning network that are
- 25:19enabling activities not possible on income and payment rails.
- 25:24So like I said, you know a great example of that is the Lightning
- 25:26network which has a lot of interesting implications in sort
- 25:30of the realm of micro payments. Another example is, is totally
- 25:34separate from that in the realm of Bitcoin mining.
- 25:36You know the, the process of Bitcoin mining effectively
- 25:39eliminates the notion of stranded energy which is pretty
- 25:44powerful. You know humans are now able to
- 25:45monetize sources of energy in a location agnostic manner.
- 25:49So from that perspective, you know Bitcoin has these other
- 25:53forms of utility that are outside of purely price
- 25:56appreciation. So you know natural gas
- 25:58producers out in Texas that would otherwise be flaring
- 26:01methane into the atmosphere, they're now able to capture that
- 26:04methane and monetize it on site through through Bitcoin mining.
- 26:07And so I think, you know, that's one of many powerful concepts
- 26:11that I think, you know, most of the investment world is, is
- 26:13still largely oblivious to. And I think, you know, it's it's
- 26:16these sort of endogenous factors, you know, specific to
- 26:20the Bitcoin network, the asset, the protocol.
- 26:23But it's also important to consider, you know, the
- 26:25exogenous factors that drive demand for Bitcoin.
- 26:27So, you know, namely, you know, the fallibility of the incumbent
- 26:31Fiat system. So as more people recognize the
- 26:34unsustainable path of debt creation that should actually
- 26:36reference and and you know the debasement of Fiat currency, I
- 26:38think the signal of Bitcoin becomes more and more evident.
- 26:42So I tend to look at it a bit more of in a vacuum and not try
- 26:46to put a specific price point on it, but just say what is the
- 26:49sort of trajectory here? How can we look at this
- 26:51directionally and assess weather demand is continuing to increase
- 26:55and like to likely to increase in the future.
- 26:57And I think a lot of that has to do with, you know, the network
- 27:00itself, the sort of different forms of utility that it enables
- 27:04as well as sort of, you know, reflecting on the incumbent
- 27:08system and why Bitcoin as a pristine store of value makes a
- 27:12lot of sense in a portfolio today.
- 27:17Yeah, awesome. It does.
- 27:19Yes, it does, Brian. And if it's OK, I'd like to jump
- 27:23in. And I love this page in Jesse's
- 27:26report because I just can visualize why all why the value
- 27:33that he laid out in the other page on the allocation will fly
- 27:37from real estate, bonds money in.
- 27:40And So what I'd like to share is the thesis which developed while
- 27:44I was at Credit Suisse, a bank that no longer exists and
- 27:48disappeared overnight because their job of printing equity to
- 27:53sell to the Qataris and others wasn't enough to keep them
- 27:58afloat because of bad behaviors. So excuse me, what?
- 28:11So the thesis that I developed by watching the banks.
- 28:30Sorry about that. Had a little phone call that
- 28:32came on there because we are an emergency here and the the the
- 28:40traditional finance debt load has gone to a level that will
- 28:47lock out a lot of people from being able to accumulate gold,
- 28:56art, equities, real estate, bonds and money.
- 28:59So everything you see here, the wages no longer allow wealth
- 29:06creation and wealth accumulation.
- 29:09So that's a major problem and the way that we've shown that is
- 29:13the growth in financial assets versus the growth in wages which
- 29:17basically puts home ownership out.
- 29:19So that's a major problem. We start at, like that Maslow
- 29:22hierarchies level, you know, very, very baseline.
- 29:25And that has gotten that resonates with people because
- 29:30when we look at the investment world, we basically are trying
- 29:33to solve, you know, to serve human interests, to wealth
- 29:39creation and what's the best way to do it.
- 29:42So there's a problem in traditional finance and there's
- 29:44a remedy in Bitcoin, and there's an urgency.
- 29:47It's those 3 words. And we started it a few years
- 29:51ago, and we still lean on that. The problems keep accumulating.
- 29:55We had that thesis before SVB Bank went under.
- 29:59We had that before the US got its third downgrade watch list.
- 30:04We did it before the debt ceiling issues.
- 30:06So there's a problem and the problems just mount.
- 30:08And all that's happening is you're having more government
- 30:11intervention, do things like create more of the money.
- 30:16The Federal Reserve only accounted for about 10% of the
- 30:20entire monetary supply in the US Now they account for 40.
- 30:24There's a centralization of the US financial system because it's
- 30:29become too fragile. Muhammad Aleri talks about this
- 30:31all the time. The financing of treasuries is
- 30:34now a nail biter there. Some people don't show up.
- 30:38So this is happening in real time.
- 30:39So let me go back to Jesse's point here and and I just want
- 30:44to share another part of our model in case it helps.
- 30:47Within that problem, remedy and urgency call to action.
- 30:51We look at the world through an economic lens.
- 30:54How's GDP doing? How's employment?
- 30:56We look at that through markets because that's our best way of
- 30:59getting information on where the votes are for different asset
- 31:02classes, equities, credit rates, currency.
- 31:04Some of the things that Jesse shows here, The last one are
- 31:07players, that's people, that's central banks, that's investors.
- 31:11So when I look at this chart, I see real estate, it's being
- 31:17held. It is, it is a store of value.
- 31:19It's moved from a place to live to a place to pass on to your
- 31:23children. That's not the way it was
- 31:24previously. But with debasement, these
- 31:27finite assets are held and they're becoming money.
- 31:31They're starting to be broken up through Airbnb.
- 31:34People are actually compart, you know, breaking apart their their
- 31:38homes, but they can't move them. So Bitcoin does a better job of
- 31:42storing value and disseminating money will go from real estate
- 31:45to Bitcoin. It will go from equities.
- 31:49It's a Bitcoin and certainly as Brian stated, money will go from
- 31:55Fiat into Bitcoin. You know, we haven't even gotten
- 31:58into the remittances, you know, 1.5 trillion where people pay 8%
- 32:03a year. So is the case for Bitcoin
- 32:07there? Absolutely.
- 32:09There's a trash can fire in traditional finance.
- 32:13That's what we spend a lot of time focusing on to get people
- 32:16alert to this. So I'll stop there.
- 32:18Thank you for watching. Whether you've been buying
- 32:20Bitcoin for years or just getting started on your journey,
- 32:23our multi institution custody solution is the safest and
- 32:26easiest way to custody or Bitcoin.
- 32:28With on RAMP and our partners at BITCO and Coin Cover, you can
- 32:31sleep soundly at night knowing that your Bitcoin is safe from
- 32:34exchange failures, the loss of seed phrases and broken hardware
- 32:37devices, and now a word about on RAMP heritage.
- 32:41Bitcoin inheritance planning requires addressing both key
- 32:43management and legal title transfer to beneficiaries,
- 32:46necessitating comprehensive estate planning.
- 32:49We have a guide that provides A detailed overview of the
- 32:52intricacies associated with Bitcoin inheritance planning and
- 32:55the role of multi institution custody in preserving Bitcoin
- 32:57ownership across generations. Additionally, we will be hosting
- 33:01a webinar on the topic on May 22nd and will include the
- 33:05registration details in the show notes.
- 33:07Visit on rampbitcoin.com/heritage to
- 33:10learn more about Bitcoin inheritance and estate planning.
- 33:13It's it's a fantastic added point there of this this image
- 33:19is really the outcome of the current system and and 50 years
- 33:23of Fiat money which is to say unbacked paper money as our
- 33:28monetary standard. And the result of that is is
- 33:31real estate prices going so high.
- 33:35Real estate has become money. It's become our savings account.
- 33:39We you know the the the conventional wisdom has become
- 33:44get a mortgage and Max out your 4O1K and that's how you will
- 33:50save you know for your retirement that that means that
- 33:54we're treating those assets as money because we're not saving
- 33:58dollars for a rainy day. You're you're plowing your value
- 34:03into these other assets to serve as money and that's how these
- 34:07buckets have gotten so big relative to the the rest of the
- 34:11picture. It's because the nobody wants to
- 34:13hold the the money. So you end up holding these
- 34:17other assets instead and bidding up the value of them relative to
- 34:21other assets in the global asset landscape.
- 34:23And then Bitcoin represents this this potential to restore the
- 34:29value of holding money because money will not be debased over
- 34:33time and you can rely on it for a rainy day without it and
- 34:36suddenly the money supply having doubled since the time you
- 34:40originally you know stashed away that that those savings and and
- 34:45you know so I think Michael Saylor has been using this this
- 34:49chart it. So it's been a a quite an honor.
- 34:53Recently he's been using this for some presentations.
- 34:55And. And and starting with the, the,
- 34:58the line of there's a a constant ongoing global war for value and
- 35:05where you know between assets, for, for where you want to park
- 35:10your value. And that's that's the story of
- 35:13store value assets. And that's why this tiny little
- 35:18asset that's currently 1212 thousandth of of the almost one
- 35:25one thousandth now of the of the value in the global asset
- 35:29landscape is different from the rest of these buckets because of
- 35:33its digital nature. It is dematerialized and
- 35:36therefore it has absolute scarcity because you can always
- 35:40make more real estate, you can always start more companies, you
- 35:44can always find more gold, you can always make more art, You
- 35:47can certainly print more bonds. We've been doing that at A at an
- 35:51incredible rate of nearly $6 trillion annualized over the
- 35:55last four months. And Jesse, can I jump in for one
- 35:59second about this? A a minute ago you were talking
- 36:01about, you know, like a war and you know the there is a
- 36:06friction. Not everyone wants to have this,
- 36:09this animal of this decentralized global asset get
- 36:15adoption because you said the word mortgage to buy a house,
- 36:19usually get a mortgage, A bank gets paid for that, bonds get
- 36:22issued, there's a fee to issue them like this.
- 36:25This is feeding a traditional banking system in a very
- 36:28inefficient manner. But we understand, I was in the
- 36:31space, you went after transactions, even if they
- 36:34weren't efficient, even if they really didn't, you know, serve
- 36:36the greater good over a period of time.
- 36:38So you're going to get the FUD like what Jamie Dimon said
- 36:41yesterday or say don't want to have this store value, this,
- 36:46this thimble you said in the ocean, grow into an ocean liner
- 36:50like, but it's going to happen, you know.
- 36:52So I think that's something to bring up to our audience because
- 36:56you're going to be hearing some negative things just because
- 37:00incentive structures aren't aligned to have Bitcoin grow.
- 37:05It's a fantastic point that that there's this, there's this
- 37:08disconnect between the economic reality of Bitcoin with this
- 37:11increasing scarcity that's built in.
- 37:13And it happens every four years because it's in the code that
- 37:16everybody's running on their computers.
- 37:18When you're participating in the Bitcoin network, it's
- 37:20inescapable. Increasing scarcity will happen.
- 37:24And that based on the logic presented in this report, means
- 37:28the value of Bitcoin goes up over time as as there's less new
- 37:33supply being introduced to the market going out to meet demand
- 37:37and that allows the the, the ceiling price of this commodity
- 37:41to to increase over time. That is so different from the
- 37:45noise that we hear that that is not rooted in any economic
- 37:49reality of about concerns about Bitcoin, about how Bitcoin you
- 37:53know how it can can be used by criminals and or it's it's bad
- 38:00for the environment. All these things that are are
- 38:02are very thin arguments and and in fact when you dig into them
- 38:07quite to the contrary of reality.
- 38:10But there are these justifications for why Bitcoin
- 38:13should not be adopted that are coming from, of course, the
- 38:17existing system. But you know, you can't stop the
- 38:20economic reality that is simultaneously playing out in
- 38:24Bitcoin. So it's up for everyone in the
- 38:26world to to grapple with that dissonance and figure out what
- 38:34they believe will happen. Will economic reality continue
- 38:38playing out, or will narratives from the traditional system stop
- 38:43that? Yeah.
- 38:45I think what one other thing to consider here is just the
- 38:49juxtaposition of Bitcoin versus all of these other buckets in
- 38:53terms of basically the the ability to foresee what is going
- 38:59to happen in the future, right? Like we know that Bitcoin supply
- 39:03issuance is transparent, known and immutable.
- 39:05All these other buckets, there's question marks in terms of new
- 39:09supply coming on to the market, new businesses being created,
- 39:12gold coming out of the Earth or from some asteroid in space that
- 39:15we haven't found yet. So there's there's I think going
- 39:19back to my earlier point about, you know, focusing on the lever
- 39:23of increasing demand, I think for me it comes down to the
- 39:28likelihood that humans are going to increasingly want to store
- 39:32their value into the future and something that they reliably can
- 39:36predict the supply of, right. And so I I think it's it that
- 39:41juxtaposition just becomes more and more clear as we see sort of
- 39:45the mounting debt levels, deficit spending, interest
- 39:47expense on the debt, all of these things that we're aware of
- 39:51that should raise questions in your mind about storing value in
- 39:54all of these other buckets. And I think sort of the purity
- 39:57and simplicity of of bitcoins supply issuing schedule I think
- 40:02is something that is going to become more and more attractive
- 40:05for people over time. And it's it's just a matter of
- 40:08people sort of being able to wade through the FUD, wade
- 40:10through these really false narratives that that are out
- 40:14there and understand that this is.
- 40:16This is a piece of technology and it allows you to propagate
- 40:19your value into the future better than anything else we've
- 40:21ever seen. And so I think that's what I,
- 40:25that's what I sort of always come back to is like what are
- 40:28the levers that are going to make demand continue to
- 40:30increase. And it's it's ultimately it's
- 40:32people getting the knowledge, people, you know, attending
- 40:35webinars like this and understanding sort of the
- 40:38fundamental attributes of this thing and why relative to all
- 40:42these other assets that you could store your value in, it's
- 40:45pretty attractive. Yeah, I, I, I, I'm noticing that
- 40:50we we're having a bunch of great questions about that I think we
- 40:54can incorporate into this conversation about Bitcoin and
- 40:57Bitcoin's value from the audience here.
- 41:00So Blake Cornfield asks about how does this valuation
- 41:07approach, how is it influenced by by high inflation?
- 41:11If inflation was to increase into the future what does that
- 41:14do And and he also asks you know if if if the numbers I presented
- 41:20in this report are are the conservative case what's the
- 41:23what's the bullish case for Bitcoin.
- 41:26So I guess I'll start with with that part there of one of the
- 41:31one of the memes that that you'll see in the Bitcoin space
- 41:35is, you know, the eventual value of Bitcoin is, is everything
- 41:41divided by 21 million, which sort of implies that all of the
- 41:45value in the world will be, you know, funneled into Bitcoin and
- 41:51represented in Bitcoin. But I think that that's not
- 41:55possible. That's A2 extreme version of
- 41:58what's, you know, the bullish scenario because that assumes
- 42:01that nobody wants to hold anything else.
- 42:04But of course you're going to want to have, you know, a house
- 42:09land people are going to want to hold the the Monet paintings
- 42:13that are their prized possessions.
- 42:16And so there's value to other assets.
- 42:17But the question becomes for everyone, you know to decide for
- 42:22themselves what percentage of the total global asset pie does
- 42:28a perfect money end up winning versus every other asset.
- 42:33And I think you can draw that line wherever you think is
- 42:37possible. You know is that, is that 5% of
- 42:40the total, is it 50% of the total That's up for everyone to
- 42:44decide. With regard to the inflation
- 42:47part of this, if we enter a if inflation is to increase versus
- 42:53what we've seen over the last few years of this.
- 42:55If this spike in inflation has been a prelude to what's coming
- 43:01with with the amount of sovereign debt.
- 43:03And and I think the level of printing that's going to be
- 43:06necessary to service sovereign debt with given our multi
- 43:09trillion dollar deficits every year.
- 43:12While we might be seeing high inflation and and more higher
- 43:16inflation over time and it could be higher and higher inflation
- 43:20over time too. So this problem could continue
- 43:22to get worse as that if that was to happen then the value of any
- 43:30assets that is based on future cash flows from those assets
- 43:36changes. So in a in a high inflation
- 43:39environment a a, a company that is you know whose value is based
- 43:45on future cash flows that those future cash flows are worth less
- 43:49and so that you discount the value of that company more and
- 43:53it becomes it's a less valuable company.
- 43:57And so the stock prices suffer and that's true of of of you
- 44:02know commercial real estate as well rental properties.
- 44:06The future value of those cash flows is discounted more.
- 44:08So then you, you don't want to be holding that asset.
- 44:12Bonds sell off in that environment too.
- 44:15And so you know the higher inflation goes, the more
- 44:19valuable an asset that is immune to inflation becomes.
- 44:23And so you know if that is to happen that trend continues and
- 44:26grows. Bitcoin becomes more and more
- 44:29attractive relative to the existing option set.
- 44:33Anything, anything else you get Mark, Brian, you guys want to
- 44:36add to that or we can you can pick a a a Q&A question in the
- 44:41in that Q&A tab to to address 'cause these are some really
- 44:45great questions from the audience.
- 44:47Maybe maybe just one clarifying point on what you just walked
- 44:50through. I think and you mentioned this
- 44:51when you were originally going through it, but you know $10
- 44:54million per Bitcoin is in today's dollars, meaning today's
- 44:59purchasing power. So yes, if if inflation
- 45:02continues to sort of get out of hand 1020 thirty years into the
- 45:06future, the sort of nominal price per Bitcoin could be far
- 45:10higher than 10 million. But what we're saying and what
- 45:13Jesse is arguing in in this report is that he's saying $10
- 45:17million per Bitcoin in today's purchasing power.
- 45:20So I think that's just an important sort of caveat to to
- 45:23include. There.
- 45:26Perfect. And the and on the on the
- 45:29historical side about inflation, you know, people think
- 45:33inflation, you know, hurts Bitcoin or even gold because it
- 45:39costs more to store gold or people will buy bonds and not
- 45:43buy Bitcoin. In the 70s, in that inflationary
- 45:47period, you saw Bitcoin return 14X.
- 45:51Equity. Sorry I'm I'm I'm projecting
- 45:55Jesse there and that's next decade mark so so such a
- 46:02clairvoyant and so it people finally.
- 46:06But they didn't wake up to what I love about that August 71
- 46:09Sunday night massacre by Nixon is that markets kind of opened
- 46:12up the next day unchanged. We take a while to figure stuff
- 46:16out like in in O8 when the crisis was going on and DC was
- 46:20figuring stuff out. Our research team came up to the
- 46:23CIO when I was at a hedge fund and we said we think the number
- 46:27might be a trillion dollars of the bailout.
- 46:29We were wrong. It was 700 billion but no one
- 46:33had a trillion in their mind in O 8.
- 46:35So things have happened so fast that we just are lagging.
- 46:39This is a that's why I love this chart you have here because then
- 46:42you get to look at everything. Everyone's like, yeah, real
- 46:44estate's kind of a weird market now and and people are atomizing
- 46:47it and monetizing it. And yeah, money is slow.
- 46:51You know the velocity of money is slow and bitcoins faster.
- 46:54That that makes sense. Bankers understand that.
- 46:56And and that's the part that we have to do I think as as
- 46:59educators is is just take little nibbets and say it's not really
- 47:03working today and and it's not going to go away.
- 47:06But that little thimble, again, just keep an eye on it.
- 47:09I mean that's, you know, get curious.
- 47:12Do your own research. Get off 0.
- 47:13And that's why I love this, this this webinar and this page in
- 47:17particular. So I'll, you know, go back to
- 47:19the Q&A, Brian 'cause there's some good questions.
- 47:22Yeah, I I have, I have one Jesse from from David Lewis and he's
- 47:27I'll I'll try to summarize, but he's basically saying you know
- 47:30BTC is largely seen as a store of value, encourages people to
- 47:33hold it longer term rather than trade it and the creation of
- 47:36spot ETFs will have to physically hold the underlying
- 47:38asset. And he's asking ultimately here
- 47:42about the price multiplier effect and how does that, how
- 47:46could that potentially change this analysis.
- 47:48And I think that's another caveat to point out that you and
- 47:51your analysis did not account for any multiplier effect, but I
- 47:54know you have some thoughts on that.
- 47:55So that that could be interesting.
- 47:58Yeah, that's a great point. And and Gary Winters also
- 48:02touched on in in his question, what happens here with with the
- 48:06ETFs. And I I think for everyone out
- 48:09there who's who's curious like what's going on with these ETFs,
- 48:12all the first of all, it seems likely, very likely that they
- 48:16will be approved about a month from now at the next deadline.
- 48:21And that is at least according to the Bloomberg ETF specialists
- 48:24who have have pegged it at a 99% likelihood as of now that these
- 48:29are approved. And So what does that, what does
- 48:31that create for Bitcoin as an asset?
- 48:33It creates this additional tailwind because this is added
- 48:37demand. It's a it's a new channel for
- 48:40people to gain exposure to Bitcoin, which means additional
- 48:44dollars flowing into Bitcoin the asset because the ETFs have to
- 48:50purchase spot Bitcoin and hold it for their investors.
- 48:55And so that that's that's a tailwind that's happening right
- 48:58now. And and as that process plays
- 49:03out, you know that that's price discovery the the additional
- 49:07demand will go out and meet supply and that will change the
- 49:12price over time because there's more demand than there used to
- 49:15be And that'll be a slow steady process in my opinion.
- 49:20And then there's the multiplier question there of, you know,
- 49:24during a bull market, we do see that every dollar that flows
- 49:28into Bitcoin has some multiplicative effect on the
- 49:31total value of all the, all the Bitcoin that exists.
- 49:34Because if you were to buy 111 Bitcoin for $1.00 more than the
- 49:42previous trade, well, that new price point that that's $1.00
- 49:47higher applies to all 21 million Bitcoin.
- 49:50And so in in that in that instant there's a 21 million X
- 49:54multiplier on your $1.00 of inflow.
- 49:58But that Nets out against all the selling pressure as well.
- 50:02And we see that in the bull market there's more demand than
- 50:05there's supply. That's why the price, then
- 50:07there's selling pressure. So that's why the price goes up
- 50:11and there is a some amount whether that's 1 1/2 to Bank of
- 50:17America at the very top of the last bull market quoted UP118X
- 50:21multiplier for every dollar of inflow to Bitcoin.
- 50:25But my perspective is that the bear markets wash that out and
- 50:30so the same negative multiplier effect happens in the bear
- 50:34markets. And I think that we reach you
- 50:38know effectively either A1X or you know something below, below
- 50:442, below 2X. That's my sense because the
- 50:47alternative is that if if 50% of the value in the global asset
- 50:52landscape flows into Bitcoin and it's a it's 100 X multiplier,
- 50:57you've suddenly grown the total value of all that wealth in the
- 51:01world by 50X and that that just doesn't make sense.
- 51:04So I think that over time, you know the the the amount of
- 51:09purchasing power can't expand just because there's a
- 51:13multiplier effect. Ultimately wealth is a
- 51:16representation of your what percentage of the world's
- 51:19resources you can command with that wealth and it doesn't
- 51:23necessarily mean growing the pie.
- 51:26Gary Winters also asked you know where are we in the four year
- 51:30Bitcoin cycle if if you know this is based on if increasing
- 51:35scarcity that happens every four years is the the main driver and
- 51:40and so Gary, I I think that you know we are we are where we have
- 51:44always been a few months before the next having which is to say
- 51:50we've gone through 3, 1/2 years. Of.
- 51:54Volatility that was triggered by the prior having, so you know
- 51:58the last having was in 2020. We saw volatility to the upside
- 52:02over the ensuing 18 months and then volatility to the downside
- 52:08in the 12 months that followed that.
- 52:10And since then we've been kind of stabilizing somewhere in the
- 52:13middle and that's what has happened after each having
- 52:17historically for the last 15 years and here comes the next
- 52:20having coming up in in four months, now 4, four months and
- 52:26change. And my expectation is the same
- 52:29process will play out of volatility to the upside, a bull
- 52:32market and there will be you know volatility to the downside
- 52:37afterwards and we'll find some sort of equilibrium in the
- 52:41middle only for the next having to arrive four years later.
- 52:43And so you can see how that, that process is the the value
- 52:47proposition of Bitcoin as a savings technology.
- 52:50Yes, there's volatility along the way, but if you can hold for
- 52:53four years or more, you end up at a higher point than you were.
- 52:58And so that's I think where where we're at, which is to say
- 53:01that I'm I'm cautiously extremely optimistic about 2024
- 53:06into 2025. Yeah.
- 53:10And just maybe another comment going back to what you were
- 53:12saying around the approval of ETFs.
- 53:15Jesse, You know, I think it's certainly going to be impactful
- 53:20just from the sort of purely functional dynamic of of these
- 53:25issuers having to go out and and buy spot Bitcoin and that
- 53:30that'll be a a near term price catalyst for certain in my mind.
- 53:34You know, I actually think the bigger element here is more from
- 53:38a narrative perspective. You know, I think there have
- 53:40been ETF applications out for, for several years now and and I
- 53:44think there's been, you know, there's been a reason why that
- 53:48they've, they've been sort of hesitant to be approved.
- 53:52And I think part of it is that they know once they are
- 53:54approved, it significantly shifts the narrative for
- 53:58institutional allocators, not just in the US but around the
- 54:01globe. When you know the most prominent
- 54:04regulator in the world signs off on this thing and gives it the
- 54:07green light, I think the narrative impact, you know is is
- 54:11arguably more important than sort of the the driving spot
- 54:14demand impact. But Mark, I'm curious your
- 54:15thoughts on that. So on the on the ETF, we'll go
- 54:21back to it's going to happen. And the reason why we think it's
- 54:26going to happen, and I'll go back to your question Brian, is
- 54:29because a judge ordered it and for everybody who's still
- 54:34looking at the SPF debacle, which you know, he only got
- 54:37clinked up here in a month ago, that's natural.
- 54:41And they're missing what's going on.
- 54:43Bitcoin went through its default cycle where the bad actors got
- 54:47stripped away from the good asset and it went through the
- 54:50court system that was critical. So that's that narrative, Brian.
- 54:53It's it's it's well earned because it's not just coming
- 54:56from now influencers, but from a judge.
- 54:59A federal judge called the SEC's argument The last word in her 21
- 55:04page opinion on August 29th was the word unlawful.
- 55:08I mean it was a it was a crazy argument about futures versus
- 55:11spot that made no sense. She called it arbitrary and
- 55:14Capri and capricious. We all know that term now used
- 55:17eight times and the fact that it was more than a rolled up
- 55:21newspaper that she took in her opinion to smack Gensler right
- 55:25in the nose with the last word was unlawful.
- 55:27In other words try me. And that's why they didn't
- 55:31appeal in October and bitcoins gone up since for good reason.
- 55:35So that narrative was started by BlackRock in June when they
- 55:42filed I think in support of Coinbase when they got Coinbase
- 55:45got sued 2 weeks prior by the SEC and that's an as a business
- 55:50people they have incentive, they realize that they see the skew,
- 55:53they know it works really well in a balanced portfolio.
- 55:56They're going to just get their advisors out there into the
- 55:59sovereign wealth funds to put in there in the in into their
- 56:02portfolios that's why they're doing it.
- 56:04But later when the courts heard it, they had no choice but to
- 56:11use the rule of law. And that rule of law is really
- 56:14what we why our conviction is high, why we finally came out
- 56:18with only after Jesse and team here with it, with evaluation,
- 56:23because you have to speak price because now it's going to be
- 56:26institutionally adopted. So that's it.
- 56:29People aren't going to understand Bitcoin.
- 56:31I don't think unfortunately before they buy it, they're just
- 56:33going to listen. BlackRock buys and they're going
- 56:35to do it. And that's why we're doing this
- 56:37because you can be shaken out and you know, we can go back to
- 56:41the questions, but we don't want you to buy it because BlackRock
- 56:44does it. But we're going to tell you that
- 56:46unfortunately that's what's going to drive adoption for the,
- 56:49you know, for the near term. Yeah completely agree with with
- 56:55all that and and and and and Mark appreciate your like extra
- 57:01level of insight and awareness of all the machinations going on
- 57:07behind the scenes about about why the ETF approval is imminent
- 57:12because I think it I I'm I'm personally guilty of it has been
- 57:16so long with you know ETF proposals being last second
- 57:21denied that I I sort of am lulled into a false sense of you
- 57:27know ETFs are nowhere near but the reality is they're they're
- 57:31probably one month away And that's not to say that that will
- 57:35you know suddenly lead to a a spike in bitcoins price on the
- 57:39day but it will at that point in time and going forward add a
- 57:43tailwind to Bitcoin. There's a there's a great
- 57:47question in here from from Mark Quigley about you know what are
- 57:52the considerations in various Bitcoin investment vehicles,
- 57:59these ETFs, how they can stack up versus each other and and
- 58:04then you know what are what's the right offering to get
- 58:08exposure to Bitcoin with and and Mark I I think I think the the
- 58:15high level answer is, is buyer beware first of all because
- 58:20there are certain clauses. I took a a a close look at the
- 58:26Bitcoin at the BlackRock S1 in June and put together a report
- 58:32that's also available on the on RAMP Bitcoin website about the
- 58:38shortcomings of that proposal. And you know, it comes back to
- 58:43the the fact that Bitcoin has certain properties that are
- 58:46extremely desirable and the way that most ETFs are are done kind
- 58:54of undercuts some of those advantages of of holding Bitcoin
- 58:58as an asset. For example, can you take in
- 59:04kind redemption from from these investment funds?
- 59:08They'll all have slightly different approaches to it and
- 59:11and the SEC has been pushing back on that.
- 59:13So some have caved on allowing that at all.
- 59:16BlackRock is sort of taking fighting on that and trying to
- 59:20stick up for that which is an interesting development.
- 59:23But still within still with these major asterisks of only
- 59:28authorized participants are allowed to withdraw Bitcoin in
- 59:33kind and and that ultimately means that there's a small list
- 59:37of broker dealers who have a separate agreement with
- 59:40BlackRock who are white listed and and allowed to withdraw
- 59:45Bitcoin in kind. Everyone else has to withdraw
- 59:48dollars, which means you have a taxable event when you're
- 59:51withdrawing. So if you want to go from from
- 59:54some of these ETFs or some of these investment funds, GBTC
- 59:58today for example, if you want to go from that fund and then
- 1:00:02take control of your own Bitcoin, you have a taxable
- 1:00:05event because you have to sell your your position in that fund
- 1:00:10into dollars taxable event and then use those dollars to go buy
- 1:00:15Bitcoin. So you could in that one moment,
- 1:00:18you know. See your Bitcoin holdings cut by
- 1:00:2330%, so they're not all created equal and it it's hard to tell
- 1:00:30on the surface what are the potential pitfalls of them.
- 1:00:34At at on RAMP, we have a a private placement trust that is
- 1:00:40designed to to keep as many of those qualities of Bitcoin that
- 1:00:46are desirable to investor as possible in kind redemptions
- 1:00:49without a taxable event being a major one there.
- 1:00:53So do your research I guess and and know that in particular
- 1:00:59folks who are coming from traditional finance and the
- 1:01:02traditional ETF world are structuring these products to to
- 1:01:08fit Bitcoin into what they know. And that doesn't always work
- 1:01:12because Bitcoin has these other properties.
- 1:01:16And so Bitcoin native companies or or at least people who
- 1:01:20understand Bitcoin deeply, when they create a a a vehicle it
- 1:01:25you're you're likely to have much more attractive properties
- 1:01:28for that vehicle. Mark, anything you want to add
- 1:01:31to that or? Yeah.
- 1:01:32So I'll focus on the on the ETF and then bring it out to what
- 1:01:35you just did is the spectrum of qualities that are muted in
- 1:01:39certain regulatory wrappers like an ETF.
- 1:01:42So the ETF is you know is constructive.
- 1:01:45We have them. We have Bitcoin funds at our
- 1:01:47firm. Fred Pie found this you know
- 1:01:51took the regulator to a open court in order to get it done.
- 1:01:55And he and in the spirit of what you said about trying to capture
- 1:01:59and transfer the as much of bitcoins unique properties our
- 1:02:04Bitcoin fund does allow for in kind redemption.
- 1:02:06So you can take it on the annual redemption.
- 1:02:09You know ETFs offer liquidity for this round.
- 1:02:12I agree with you is you would love to see the ability to have
- 1:02:17in kind but I I don't I don't think you're going to see that.
- 1:02:20So the fee part certainly important.
- 1:02:24The other one though is just tracking error.
- 1:02:26So you you you want to be able to see not right away but over
- 1:02:29time are they compounding your dollars well and you know I
- 1:02:36guess back to what you're saying, it does serve a purpose,
- 1:02:39a regulatory wrapper for one thing.
- 1:02:41The other one though is eventually even our firm which
- 1:02:45provides regulatory products which means that they aren't
- 1:02:50custody like yours, we offer courses or or not courses, but
- 1:02:56but we do talk to people about self sovereignty.
- 1:02:58That is the ultimate goal. And so we think the ETFs are a
- 1:03:02step along that way. So we don't discount them.
- 1:03:05It is my business. So we're talking my own book up
- 1:03:07a bit here. But we recognize that it serves
- 1:03:10a purpose but as you said know what you're getting know it's
- 1:03:13how it's structured, which is no small potatoes.
- 1:03:18And you guys, I'll leave that to you because I think you are that
- 1:03:21end game about about offering that to clients.
- 1:03:24So thank you, serve a great obviously role for people.
- 1:03:31I think we started the call off with Cam talking about it.
- 1:03:34Custodianship is the hardest concept to understand.
- 1:03:37So BlackRock is saying I got you 3 IQ says I got you, yes.
- 1:03:41And understand it because it's not, it's.
- 1:03:44It's not the same process as ADTC.
- 1:03:47Eligible security, yeah, Yeah and and and we're we're slightly
- 1:03:52over on time here so we'll we'll shift into the wrap up phase.
- 1:03:56But to that point if anyone out there is you know curious to to
- 1:04:01talk more about specific considerations that that you
- 1:04:04have with your certain circumstances with regard to
- 1:04:08these products or on RAMPS products.
- 1:04:12We would love to talk with you. So you can schedule a
- 1:04:14consultation with us just reach out to on our website big button
- 1:04:19right there to schedule a consultation and talk with one
- 1:04:22of us about your particular concerns or situation and Yep
- 1:04:28and the the the link for that just popped up in the in the
- 1:04:31chat window there. Mark, I know you, you, you
- 1:04:34wanted to make sure to talk about something that you were,
- 1:04:38you know, wanted to put in a a pitch for.
- 1:04:42Sure, so the our problem remedy and urgency.
- 1:04:47The urgency is flashing a bit here with the ETF and we have a
- 1:04:5212 page document called the Advisor's Care Kit.
- 1:04:56Basically when you get that call from people saying what, what's
- 1:04:59going on with Bitcoin, I want to buy it, but I heard about it's
- 1:05:05used for crime etcetera. So all of that talk that Jesse
- 1:05:08and Brian talked about that's incorrectly you know all the
- 1:05:12shade being thrown in Bitcoin by people trying to protect their
- 1:05:15own turf because they're not incentivized for bitcoins growth
- 1:05:19whether it be energy use etcetera.
- 1:05:21We have a a quick answer so you can get capture that order and
- 1:05:25not have them sell equities and buy Bitcoin away.
- 1:05:28So it's it's a way to preserve your book as an advisor because
- 1:05:31the demand is coming and you have to answer the call.
- 1:05:35And and where can they find that report mark?
- 1:05:38That would be on our It'll be attached to our weekly, so it'll
- 1:05:42be in our website threeiq.ca tonight under Research and
- 1:05:47Insights. Right, fantastic.
- 1:05:51And and yeah, sorry we didn't get to everyone's Q&A questions
- 1:05:55again. You know, please schedule a
- 1:05:57consultation and we can have a one-on-one conversation with you
- 1:06:00about about any of your questions and concerns.
- 1:06:03And again this report, the Bitcoin's full potential
- 1:06:07evaluation is available on our website.
- 1:06:09At the top there there's a button you know that says
- 1:06:13Bitcoin's full potential evaluation.
- 1:06:14You can also find it in the link in the chat and and Brian if you
- 1:06:18want to talk about webinar series going forward, yeah, we
- 1:06:22we are hoping to do this on sort of a quarterly cadence and.
- 1:06:26We'll sort of be covering different topics ranging
- 1:06:30anywhere from, you know, Bitcoin's fundamentals to just
- 1:06:33various ways to the to be thinking about this asset.
- 1:06:36And it'll usually coincide with some research reports that we've
- 1:06:39written. So really excited that everyone
- 1:06:43was able to make it for this first one and hope that you'll
- 1:06:46make it for the next and and just wanted to say a special
- 1:06:48thanks to Mark for joining us. It was a great conversation and
- 1:06:51really appreciate it. Yeah.
- 1:06:53Thanks, Brian. Jesse.
- 1:06:54Thank you, Mark. It was awesome.
- 1:06:56Well, that's all we have everyone.
- 1:06:57Thank you for joining and hope to catch you next time.
- 1:07:00Thank you for listening. If you found the information
- 1:07:02valuable, please share the episode with a friend or leave a
- 1:07:05rating on your favorite podcast app or on YouTube.
- 1:07:07All the links we discussed in today's webinar will be in the
- 1:07:10show notes. Regardless of where you are on
- 1:07:12your Bitcoin journey, we'd love to hear from you.
- 1:07:14Visit on rampbitcoin.com Contact to schedule a consultation with
- 1:07:18one of our private client advisors.