Latest / SPEAK LIKE A CEO / The Trillion-Dollar Cost of Leaders Who Talk Too Much
Transcript
- 0:01We all like to think we're good listeners.
- 0:04Almost nobody is.
- 0:05Especially leaders.
- 0:07Only one in 12 employees says that their leader is very good at listening.
- 0:10And that's more expensive than you think.
- 0:12It's one of the biggest, possibly the biggest, undetected cost in the world today to global business.
- 0:19My guest today is Julian Treasure.
- 0:22His TED Talk on how to speak so that people want to listen is one of the most viewed of all time.
- 0:28And he's back on the show to talk about the other half of communication, listening.
- 0:31He will share the four C's of conscious listening, how you can build a listening culture from the top, and how you can become the one leader in 12 whose team says they really listen.
- 0:41And for context, my name is Oliver Hauss.
- 0:42I've helped over 300 CEOs and founders become master communicators.
- 0:46And this is Speak Like a CEO, the show where I help you become a top 1% communicator.
- 0:53Last time we spoke, we focused on speaking and writing so because you're one of the world's most famous public speakers.
- 0:59Wonderful books, massive, massive TED Talks.
- 1:02Not one, I think, you know, quite a few, five if I remember correctly.
- 1:05So today we want to talk about listening because you recently shared with me your mission, which is...
- 1:12to regenerate the world's listening.
- 1:14And it's badly needed, right?
- 1:16Because only one in 12 employees states that their leader is very good at listening.
- 1:21So 11 out of 12 say they're not really very good at listening.
- 1:24What's the consequence of that?
- 1:26Well, it's one of the biggest, possibly the biggest undetected cost in the world today to global business.
- 1:36Because if you don't listen to people as a leader, and we can come on to why that happens in a moment, but it is very common.
- 1:44If you speak, tell, but don't listen, what happens is two things.
- 1:50One is miscommunication, because you're not checking that they received what you sent.
- 1:55If you're standing in front of 50 people and you make a speech, there are 50 different things that have been received.
- 2:03You know, you're thinking, that's it.
- 2:05I've sold that.
- 2:05Everybody understands it now.
- 2:07No, they really don't.
- 2:09Fully aligned.
- 2:11So that's the first thing.
- 2:13If you're not listening to them, then it's very probable that they've misunderstood or there's been miscommunication.
- 2:19And we now know from recent research that miscommunication is costing American business $1.2 trillion a year.
- 2:29That's a day or week of wasted time per employee in America.
- 2:34for having to check back, for making mistakes, for misunderstanding what was asked of them, doing the wrong thing, whatever it may be.
- 2:41So that's the first thing that happens if you're not a listening leader.
- 2:45The second is even more serious, and that is disengagement.
- 2:50So again, if you're not listening to people, they start to feel unimportant, unheard, you know, not particularly motivated anymore.
- 3:00That good idea that they were going to come up with in the meeting, why do I bother?
- 3:04He never listens to me or she never listens to me.
- 3:08So you are throwing away a huge resource of creativity, of imagination, of innovation,
- 3:16And of course, people just don't work so hard if they don't feel part of the team, if they don't feel valued.
- 3:22We all as human beings want three things in the world.
- 3:26To be heard, to be understood and to be valued.
- 3:30Listening does all three of those at once.
- 3:33Not listening stomps all over all three of them, unfortunately.
- 3:38And again, we now have research about the cost of this in money, and that this is even more terrifying.
- 3:44This is a global survey that was done just a year or two ago, and it found the cost of disengagement to global business $8.8 trillion a year.
- 3:57So you add those two together, the other one's the world.
- 4:01I think it's safe to say that we are talking about a global cost of well over $10 trillion a year to business, simply arising from...
- 4:12leaders not listening and people not listening more generally to each other.
- 4:16So, you know, there is a massive return on listening, which almost nobody is appreciating at the moment.
- 4:23This is a huge problem.
- 4:26Why?
- 4:26Why is that, Julian?
- 4:27Why are so few people appreciating the upside of listening leadership and the cost and the downsides of not doing it properly?
- 4:35Well, partly because of the impact of reading and writing, which was only invented 5,000 years ago.
- 4:43You know, we've been speaking and listening with complex language for 150,000 years.
- 4:48And, you know, as part of our evolution, three million years, we've been using sound to communicate.
- 4:54So reading and writing, quite recent.
- 4:57And yet...
- 4:59Today we teach our children how to read and write.
- 5:02We do not teach them how to speak and listen.
- 5:05Now this to me is madness.
- 5:07Because the better people are at listening and the better people are at speaking, and you and I both have a passion for this,
- 5:15the more powerfully they can communicate, influence, inspire, enroll.
- 5:21And teamwork all relies on spoken communication mainly.
- 5:27So unfortunately, the rise of text-based communication, particularly among the digital native generations, Gen Z and below, has left us with a lot of people who are very uncomfortable doing this.
- 5:41simply don't know how to do it very well, have never been taught, would far rather send a text than pick up a phone, or even worse, go and see somebody face to face.
- 5:50Hence, we have these constant complaints from employers when they're interviewing people.
- 5:57themselves.
- 5:58They don't understand how to listen to my questions and respond.
- 6:02You know, I talk a lot about the fact that I'm faced with a wall of denial, really, because everybody likes to think they're a
- 6:14it's kind of associated with being a nice person.
- 6:18So, you know, if I were to say, do you know something?
- 6:21You're a really terrible listener.
- 6:23Oh, I mean, that hurts.
- 6:26That's like me saying you're a really bad person.
- 6:29So we all like to think we're good listeners.
- 6:32Almost nobody is.
- 6:35So self-awareness is really low when it comes to listening, right?
- 6:39Yeah, absolutely.
- 6:41So, you know, if you accuse leaders of not being good listeners, they probably get affronted.
- 6:47But of course, the more senior you get in an organization, the more difficult the whole thing becomes.
- 6:53First of all, we tend to promote loud, extrovert people.
- 6:57Secondly, as you're more senior, you're supposed to know stuff, aren't you?
- 7:01And tell people things and drive the whole thing, you know, not be quiet and listen and ask questions.
- 7:08And thirdly, you know, there's probably an ego-based thing going on here.
- 7:13Because listening is inherently humble.
- 7:16When I listen to you, I'm saying, Oliver, you're more important than I am at this moment.
- 7:20Yeah.
- 7:22And there are quite a lot of leaders who would have a bit of a problem with that.
- 7:26They like to be more important, which means talking, not listening.
- 7:30So what can leaders do to become better listeners?
- 7:35Well, first of all, it's become conscious of this.
- 7:37So the moment you walk through that door and become conscious that listening is a skill, it's an important skill which has got huge benefits for communication, for engagement, for inspiration, for connection with other human beings,
- 7:51which of course in an age of AI is becoming ever more important, then you become aware of the issue in your company.
- 8:00You can go around and start to improve it by spotting where it's not good.
- 8:04It may be that you've got people in noisy rooms the whole time where they can't hear each other properly.
- 8:09That's very common, open plan offices.
- 8:12can reduce productivity by up to two-thirds.
- 8:15And we unfortunately have imposed that on billions of people all over the world as a kind of default layout, simply because it's more condensed, you can get more people into it, but they can't work as effectively if they're doing solo working or concentrated working.
- 8:37So that's one aspect of it that's pretty easy to spot immediately.
- 8:40But...
- 8:41Also in meetings.
- 8:43You know, the way we structure meetings in most organizations is appallingly inefficient.
- 8:48They're always an hour.
- 8:50Why?
- 8:51Book a finish time as well as a start time when you book a meeting.
- 8:55Have an objective for the meeting that everybody agrees to.
- 8:58And if it's not relevant to them, then they don't need to turn up.
- 9:01And, of course...
- 9:03Here's a challenge for any CEOs or leaders listening to this podcast.
- 9:08How about in the next meeting you go in and say, tell you what, today I'm not going to say anything in this meeting.
- 9:14I'm going to have a listen.
- 9:15And don't say anything for the whole meeting.
- 9:19Now, what would that achieve in terms of suddenly those quiet people who've never said anything start coming up with some amazing ideas and you get to know who they are as opposed to you broadcasting the whole time?
- 9:33I had a CEO who...
- 9:36I very, very respected.
- 9:37I was working with him at the time.
- 9:39And he would, in a meeting, he would start with the most junior person who obviously was close to the data, to the product, et cetera, and say, hey, what do you think about this?
- 9:48And then went up the hierarchy, right?
- 9:50So that the junior person wasn't influenced by the more senior people in the room.
- 9:54So he could listen to what everyone really was thinking about the issue at hand.
- 9:59And I thought that was a very, very productive, very effective thing.
- 10:02way of running a meeting rather than the C-level person just talking and everyone is nodding, right?
- 10:07That's kind of at the opposite end of the spectrum.
- 10:10So how do you create a listening culture in an organization?
- 10:14Yeah, it is not trivial.
- 10:16It doesn't happen just by sending an email out that says, from next week.
- 10:21Let's listen.
- 10:22Yeah, that doesn't work.
- 10:24It comes from the top, Oliver, very much.
- 10:27So you have to have a listening culture at the top of the organization.
- 10:30And we've all worked...
- 10:31in organizations where the person at the top is a monster who won't have bad news, who shoots the messenger, who shouts, or even if it's a benevolent despot, somebody who is brilliant but talks the whole time and doesn't want other people's ideas because they know they're right about everything.
- 10:52So that kind of a culture at the top is never going to permit a listening organization to grow.
- 10:58So you need channels, you need ways for people to feed up the organization, ideas, comments, complaints, whatever it might be, without being shot, without it affecting their careers.
- 11:12You need to have a listening culture.
- 11:16So that may be in the official corporate culture.
- 11:18Certainly you need to look at the behavior and look at ways that people can listen to each other and communicate, whether it's in meetings, informally, the different structures that you've got in the organization, the different ways people connect with each other.
- 11:35And of course today with AI we've got incredibly easy ways for all of this to be collated and recorded, so you don't have to have so much sort of superstructure of people taking notes and minutes being sent around and all that kind of stuff.
- 11:50It's very easy now to have a record of everything automatically so people can focus on the connection.
- 11:58And of course, what about appraising people?
- 12:00What about in their 360 having a question like, is this person a good listener?
- 12:05Or how good a listener is this person?
- 12:07And having that appraised, I'm sure there are very few 360s which actually have that question in.
- 12:13And how about, my goodness, here's a radical one, rewarding people who are the best listeners for being the best listeners as well, with bonuses or promotions or whatever it may be.
- 12:25So, there are many aspects to this, recruiting people who are good listeners, and that's something that most organizations already do.
- 12:35It's one of the skills which is most in demand.
- 12:38The paradox comes when the person is recruited and it's all forgotten about.
- 12:43There's no training on it, there's no assessment on it, there's no focus on it, because you've recruited a good listener, so that's job done.
- 12:52Well, no, that doesn't do the whole thing.
- 12:56So a training program, an appraisal program, all of these things are immensely valuable and can start to reclaim some of that $10 trillion a year.
- 13:0890% of presentations are forgotten within a day, and even the best ideas get ignored.
- 13:13Over the last 20 years, I've felt hundreds of leaders prepare for stages like TED and South by Southwest, and the difference is always the same.
- 13:19Top 1% communicators, they use a system, and this system is called the Perfect Presentation Planner.
- 13:25Download it now, it's free, link in the description.
- 13:29Super fascinating.
- 13:29Before we double-click on the program, which I'm interested in, my observation is it's very much about the presence.
- 13:36And presence in a meeting room is one thing, as you said, we don't have to take notes anymore, that's covered, but especially online.
- 13:43But often I suspect people do emails, check other things, you know, the mind is somewhere else, so they're not really listening.
- 13:51And I think that's easier to do in a virtual setting than in an in-person workshop or meeting.
- 13:56Would you agree?
- 13:57And how can we fix this online?
- 13:59Very much so.
- 14:01I talk about four C's of listening in my teaching on this.
- 14:05And the first one is consciousness.
- 14:07Conscious that you're doing something.
- 14:09It's work.
- 14:10It's a skill that you're exercising.
- 14:12So if you're not conscious that you're listening, you're probably just hearing, which is a different thing.
- 14:17The second C is commitment, because it does take commitment.
- 14:21It means putting other things aside.
- 14:23If you're going to really listen to somebody.
- 14:25Now,
- 14:27I talk about listening positions.
- 14:29There are different places to listen from, many of them, and I'm not pejorative about it.
- 14:34So distracted listening is something we do a great deal in the modern world.
- 14:39There's nothing wrong with distracted listening if it's appropriate in a conversation.
- 14:44But if you're sharing something deep and painful with me and I'm tapping away on my phone, that is just not appropriate.
- 14:53So it's a question of asking, where's the best place I can listen from in this conversation?
- 15:00And as I say, there are many, many listening positions you can choose between.
- 15:06This is a much, much bigger subject than people generally think.
- 15:11So the third C is compassion.
- 15:14seeking to understand the other person, as opposed to judging them and making them wrong.
- 15:21Even if you disagree with them, you can seek to understand them.
- 15:26And you can then have conversations like, Oliver, I really don't agree with what you just said, but I do understand why you think that.
- 15:35Now, that's a very different outcome from Oliver.
- 15:37That's rubbish, which is simply going to escalate conflict.
- 15:41And the fourth C is curiosity.
- 15:45Always seeking to learn.
- 15:47And it may be that you're going to learn how not to do something by listening to somebody, but you'll always learn something.
- 15:53And the arrogance of...
- 15:55thinking there's nothing to learn in this conversation, judging books by covers, or simply the fatigue, you know, of being in a very long-term relationship and doing that thing where, oh, you're saying that thing again, you know, that kind of tiredness.
- 16:10Listen as if for the first time with people and let them surprise you again.
- 16:16And it's amazing what can be revealed.
- 16:19So consciousness, commitment, compassion, and curiosity.
- 16:25Right.
- 16:25And not judging in the moment and also not believing, I know what you're about to say, right, which is essentially killing the curiosity and is often wrong because often people, as I said, they do surprise us.
- 16:37Is there something specific about virtual meetings, though?
- 16:40I still would love to find out what can we do to get people to listen more in virtual settings?
- 16:47It does take more effort.
- 16:49So a couple of things I would suggest.
- 16:51First of all, set up nicely.
- 16:52I mean, you are and I am in this conversation set up appropriately.
- 16:56We're both looking at the camera.
- 16:57The camera is at eye level.
- 17:00So many people have a laptop on the desk with the screen tilted back.
- 17:04So the camera is kind of shooting up their nose.
- 17:07And often they have light behind them.
- 17:09You know, the effect at the other end is disastrous.
- 17:11And at that, I'm talking about CEOs just as much as anybody else.
- 17:15I've seen this so many times.
- 17:16Oh, yeah.
- 17:17And bad sound, they're in a very echoey room where you can hardly make out what they're saying anyway.
- 17:23So getting your scent as optimal as you can without necessarily going to the length of lights and green screens and whatever, you can certainly do that very easily and improve the whole thing enormously.
- 17:36Being more present on video than you have to be face-to-face is extra work.
- 17:43And that is worth doing because you don't have the little signals.
- 17:48You know, if you or I were sitting a couple of feet apart, I'd have a whole bunch more signals going on.
- 17:54You know, micro expressions, little gestures, body language, pheromones, whatever it might be.
- 18:00There's all sorts of stuff that we get.
- 18:02And so it's much richer when you're face to face with somebody.
- 18:06So there are levels of intensity, levels of information that we're getting.
- 18:12And this is better than just audio.
- 18:15However, it's worse than being face-to-face.
- 18:18And that means I have to work harder.
- 18:19And that's a conscious decision to make the effort to pay more attention to what you're saying.
- 18:26And I would also suggest, please, to anybody who does this a lot, don't schedule back-to-back video conferences or video calls
- 18:34you'll just get absolutely exhausted and your attention level will be so low
- 18:41And, you know, I would say in any organization, have an etiquette that you agree in the organization for these things.
- 18:48So if you've got a call with 20 people on it and 12 of them have got their cameras off, you know they're not paying attention.
- 18:55They're actually doing their email.
- 18:57Well, that may come down to the fact this meeting is not well constructed.
- 19:01It's too long.
- 19:01The wrong people are there.
- 19:02It doesn't have a clear objective.
- 19:04All of those things I mentioned before.
- 19:06Yeah.
- 19:07But assuming you've constructed an effective and important meeting, I would say in any organization that the etiquette should be camera on for everybody who's present all the time.
- 19:20You mentioned that you teach programs or introduce programs into organizations to enhance their listening skills so that these pointless additional costs they incur due to miscommunication, bad communication can fall.
- 19:34What does such a program look like?
- 19:37I've got two things actually which I'm very excited that I've just launched.
- 19:42Yes, I've just launched by the time this comes out.
- 19:44The first is all about practice because I can talk about communication skills in a speech to a couple of thousand people and have a big impact.
- 19:55And then two months later, is there any of that left?
- 20:00Even with the best world in the world, I doubt it.
- 20:02Because that's kind of like going to the gym once.
- 20:07That does not change your life.
- 20:09So what we need is something that's going to help people with daily practice, even just a few minutes a day.
- 20:15And I have now created that.
- 20:16It's an app called Master Conscious Communication.
- 20:20And we have just released that.
- 20:22So it's kind of like having me in your pocket, if that's a good idea.
- 20:25I don't know if it is.
- 20:2624 hours a day, seven days a week.
- 20:29And it's got AI, of course, inside of it.
- 20:33So it adapts to whatever anybody's real objectives are, whether that's conscious listening, powerful speaking, or indeed masterful presenting.
- 20:42So it does all three of those things.
- 20:45And it's less than a dollar a day.
- 20:47And in fact, I have created a special offer for your lovely listeners with a 25% discount on the first payment for that.
- 20:55So we'll put that out in the show notes, I'm sure.
- 20:58But come and have a look.
- 21:00Absolutely.
- 21:00There'll be a link.
- 21:02And I'm very, very excited that this is the practice.
- 21:06This is going to the gym.
- 21:08This is what does change your life in a big, big way.
- 21:12And the second thing that I've done, which has taken years actually for me to get around to doing, is I've just launched a focused course on public speaking, on presenting things.
- 21:25as a five-time TED speaker with the six most viewed TED talk of all time, which indeed is about this exact subject.
- 21:33I've kind of been, I think I've been withholding a long time.
- 21:37I'm very focused on listening most of the time, but everybody's been asking me for this, so I'm finally doing it.
- 21:43It's a cohort of just 12 people.
- 21:46And I'll be doing this multiple times over the next year and a half.
- 21:51And the first one starts on November the 24th.
- 21:54And it's called How to Be Heard Live.
- 21:58So it's me live working with just 12 people for four weeks and teaching them presentation skills.
- 22:03What's the key learning there?
- 22:05What takeaways?
- 22:06I assume there's a transformation in terms of their public speaking.
- 22:10How would you describe that?
- 22:12Yes, absolutely.
- 22:13I mean, of course, the app does this in a more gentle way over a longer period of time.
- 22:16But the four-week intensive, there are four 90-minute teaching sessions.
- 22:21They will record a talk four different times once a week.
- 22:25I will view them.
- 22:27And there are two half-hour individual coaching sessions with me for each person on the course.
- 22:33So it's really hands-on, practical stuff.
- 22:37I'll be teaching them about content, how to devise and create brilliant content.
- 22:43I'll be teaching them about delivery.
- 22:46I'll be teaching them stagecraft.
- 22:49And we will also touch on things like panel work, podcasting, dealing with difficult conversations, dealing with conflict, all of those kind of things.
- 23:00So it's pretty much everything I've learned over...
- 23:03nearly four decades now of doing this.
- 23:05Wow.
- 23:06Condensed into a very powerful four-week and very hands-on personal coaching approach.
- 23:14Amazing.
- 23:14We will absolutely link to all of these things.
- 23:16Thanks for sharing that, Julian.
- 23:17Thanks for the special offer and discount.
- 23:19That's much appreciated for us here.
- 23:22Our conversation about listening reminded me of a story you tell in your book, Sound Effects, that you visited the world's quietest place.
- 23:32Could you share that story?
- 23:34Yes, anechoic chambers are pretty spooky places to be in, actually.
- 23:40They are designed so that sound is absorbed by the walls, the ceiling, and the floor.
- 23:46So you walk on a kind of a grill and
- 23:50a metal grill, and underneath it are sound absorbers, just as there are on all the four walls and on the ceiling.
- 23:57So when you turn, it's the spookiest thing.
- 24:00If we're having a conversation in there, we could talk like this, and it feels very strange because nothing is echoing.
- 24:07But if I then turn around and face the wall and speak, you wouldn't hear me at all because nothing's coming back.
- 24:14Yeah.
- 24:16That is really strange.
- 24:18The walls soak up everything that hits them.
- 24:22You don't want to be in those kind of spaces for too long.
- 24:26You start to hear the blood pumping in your body.
- 24:29You hear tiny little noises.
- 24:31People talk about suddenly starting to hear, you know, nerve sounds in their ears and so forth.
- 24:38So all sorts of things start to reveal themselves that you don't normally hear.
- 24:44and it is pretty uncomfortable.
- 24:47So, not a place to hang out, but a mind-blowing experience.
- 24:52And I think the other end of the spectrum, I talk in the book, there's a place actually in Scotland, which was an underground storage bunker that was developed for fuel, I think, in the Second World War, which has got the longest reverberation time in the world.
- 25:06It's something like 120 seconds, I think it was.
- 25:09Absolutely amazing.
- 25:11So you clap your hands in there, and two minutes later, you're still hearing the reverberation of that.
- 25:16Wow.
- 25:18That's crazy.
- 25:20And there's no sound chamber.
- 25:22Where is it, and why does it exist?
- 25:24Well, the official quietest place in the world, I think, award is currently held by Microsoft's anechoic chamber, which is in Seattle.
- 25:33I mean, they're all very close to that, if they're well-designed.
- 25:38And so there are different places around the world.
- 25:41Most universities will have them and specialist audio organizations will have them as well.
- 25:49And why do they exist?
- 25:50Well, to test products.
- 25:52So if you've got a washing machine,
- 25:54and it says on it 42 decibel noise output, they only know that because they put it in an anechoic chamber with a sound pressure level meter, turn it on and measure the sound.
- 26:06You can't do that in a room where there's reverberation.
- 26:10because you're not measuring simply the device, you're measuring the room sound.
- 26:14Interesting.
- 26:15I will check this out.
- 26:16Maybe there's one nearby I can visit, but I thought that was fascinating that humans built these chambers that essentially know sound.
- 26:25And on the other end of the spectrum, obviously we deal with a lot of noise every day in the cities we live in in particular.
- 26:32So it's very rare that we have a quiet moment in terms of our surroundings.
- 26:37There's also the reason, by the way,
- 26:39Well, we had to move this recording by one week because there was some loud drilling going on in my place a week ago, which would have made this conversation about listening slightly absurd, let's say.
- 26:51So I'm glad that we found a new slot and could find a quieter time where we can actually focus on this conversation and listen to each other because podcast is very much about listening, right?
- 27:00I listen to you, you listen to me.
- 27:02And then there are listeners and viewers, of course, who also want to find out with their listening skills what's happening and how they can apply the knowledge that you've built over the last 40 years.
- 27:13So I think this is wonderful that you brought this up at the end.
- 27:16It's worth just pausing for a moment to reflect on silence.
- 27:20which is a very important sound, both in speaking and, of course, in listening.
- 27:26Listening, you have to be silent.
- 27:28So becoming comfortable with being silent is very useful to become a good listener.
- 27:34In speaking, it's a massive weapon.
- 27:37And I'm sure you train people on this.
- 27:39One of the biggest problems I see with speakers is that they won't stop.
- 27:45And they gabble, fill every moment with the sound of their voice, whether it's ums and errs, or you know what I mean, or whatever it might be.
- 27:52But simply speaking, being able to say something and then stop.
- 27:59It's extremely powerful.
- 28:00Just that little moment, it has a massive impact, people.
- 28:04And if you're on stage and you're comfortable with silence like that, it gives you an enormous impact.
- 28:10range.
- 28:11It's like suddenly having the valley next to the mountain, you know, it makes such a difference.
- 28:17This is so good.
- 28:17Thank you so much, Julian.
- 28:18I appreciate everything you're doing and teaching me about listening as well.
- 28:22What's the best piece of communications advice?
- 28:24I would say just one word, Oliver, and that is listen.
- 28:28It's the most overlooked part of communication.
- 28:32You know, these days I have a new symbol for my business, which is a triangle.
- 28:36It's a pyramid.
- 28:37The base of the pyramid is listening.
- 28:41The middle part is speaking, and the apex of the pyramid is presenting or public speaking.
- 28:49That's the way it works.
- 28:51And if you focus just on the top, for example, then you've got it resting on nothing.
- 28:56Even if you focus on speaking, that rests on your ability to listen.
- 29:01Every great speaker needs to be able to listen to the audience, to understand what it is they need, what you can give them, what's the gift you are able to give.
- 29:11So that's the way I see it.
- 29:14And the foundation is the thing that so many people miss.
- 29:16So listen.
- 29:18Indeed.
- 29:19Listen, indeed.
- 29:19Julian, thank you.
- 29:20Thank you so much, Oliver.
- 29:21It's been a pleasure.