Latest / I Love You Keep Going with George Haas / Attachment in Spiritual Practice: Transference, Projection & the Teacher Relationship
Transcript
- 0:01You're listening to the I Love You, Keep Going podcast with
- 0:04George Haas. For more information, please
- 0:06visit our website at www.medigroup.org.
- 0:10That's www.m ETTAGROU p.org. So welcome everybody.
- 0:19This is I love you. Keep going.
- 0:21It is Thursday, August 28th, 2025.
- 0:24It's 7:37 PM Pacific Daylight Time, and one of the questions
- 0:32that comes up quite a bit is, is there any relationship between
- 0:37attachment conditioning and what happens in spiritual practice?
- 0:43And how does that affect different relationships with
- 0:47communities and also with teachers?
- 0:50And like all things, because attachment is attachment
- 0:54conditioning is essentially the platform from which everything
- 0:58is constructed. You could make a case that the
- 1:03dynamic within the community and the dynamic within the
- 1:07relationship to the teacher is all a reflection of what the
- 1:12underlying attachment conditioning is.
- 1:14You might even make a case for who moves toward the front of
- 1:18the room and wants to be in the role of the teacher, and who
- 1:22stays in the back of the room and likes to be attached to a
- 1:27teacher, but not take on that responsibility.
- 1:35And you might even make the case that this is a cynical telling
- 1:44or maybe just personally informed from my own experience.
- 1:48I'm going to mute everybody. I'm hearing some feedback in a
- 1:56caricature type way of thinking about it.
- 1:58You might say that dismissing people like to be at the front
- 2:03of the room. So they like the the adulation
- 2:07of being in the teacher role. And then the way that that sort
- 2:16of plays out, the people that are drawn to a dismissing figure
- 2:21in the front of the room would be a preoccupied people.
- 2:26Do we think that people that are well adjusted, that have secure
- 2:31attachment, that are, that are engaged in the pursuit of life
- 2:38as it's laid out in front of them, are, are are the ones that
- 2:42come for meditation practice? Or is it people that don't fit
- 2:47in so well that have more of a drive toward the meditation
- 2:54world? Now, if you lived in Myanmar or
- 2:59somewhere in Asia, where for millennia the the instruction
- 3:05around this was central to the culture, you would think that
- 3:09then the mainstream of society would be motivated toward that.
- 3:14Much like in the Judeo-christian world, you're, you're drawn
- 3:18toward the spiritual practices that are central to the
- 3:25community that you grow up in. In the West, of course, this is
- 3:31Christianity or Judaism or Islam.
- 3:39So I say that mainly because during the the Middle Ages with
- 3:50the the holy rewards, there's a big mix in in Europe of of a
- 3:55different face with various times Islam coming up into
- 4:02Europe. So there that's been that
- 4:08millennial long debate. We don't seem to pay so much
- 4:13attention to the the series of the culturally relevant
- 4:18religious philosophies, let's call them that preceded the
- 4:27current set that we have. But if you grew up in a largely
- 4:32Christian or Judaic Islamic grouping and suddenly you're
- 4:40you're pivoting toward something that's completely different than
- 4:44that, we would want to to question what was the motivation
- 4:50for that. We also have the whole structure
- 5:00that's getting even close to 2 centuries old of Western
- 5:05psychology as a way of addressing the the discontent.
- 5:12And I find a lot of the people that turn toward meditation are
- 5:21looking for something that would be helpful to them that they
- 5:26weren't able to find in Western mental health practices.
- 5:35And then we have the the the the way in which that appeared to us
- 5:40culturally. If you look at the United States
- 5:43for its for as an example, what you're looking at is a society
- 5:49where teachers who have made a significant impression on us
- 5:54really came over in the 50's, the 1950s.
- 5:57So not even 100 years ago, Suzuki Roshi in San Francisco in
- 6:04the Bay Area being a prominent 1.
- 6:07And then Maharishi was very popular in the 60's.
- 6:13The Beatles of course, helped with that in terms of promoting
- 6:18it, the the the the first wave of psychedelia was there as
- 6:25well. If you dump that into the
- 6:29conversation about the way that resources are distributed along
- 6:36the class system in our culture, particularly after the Second
- 6:41World War when the development of these standardized tests
- 6:51came, came along. And then depending on how well
- 6:54you were able to do on these standardized tests, open the
- 6:59door to a lot of resources for your education.
- 7:02And if you didn't test well, close the door on a lot of the
- 7:05resources that you would have completely, in my, my way of
- 7:14thinking, arbitrary to favor people who test well over people
- 7:19who don't test well as a way of resources for education.
- 7:25Because there's such a diversity in the way that people think can
- 7:29be able to comprehend information and also what to do
- 7:33with that that might be of benefit to us, rather than this
- 7:36very narrow funneling of a certain type of thinking being
- 7:45rewarded and other types of thinking being excluded.
- 7:50I think in some sense it became a way of reinforcing our
- 7:58invisible class system. It's invisible from conversation
- 8:02because it's not allowed, but it's evident everywhere else.
- 8:09So all of that creates this pressure that pushes people
- 8:14outside of the the membership into what is mainstream culture,
- 8:21the big picture of culture. And so, but that doesn't exclude
- 8:26these smaller societies, the smaller subcultures from
- 8:30developing. And that really is at least in,
- 8:36in my experience of where the, the, the movement toward
- 8:42meditating came from in the United States.
- 8:47Of course, we have a culture of it's, you know, I'm, I have, I
- 8:58had surgery a few weeks ago and I'm, and I had general
- 9:02anesthesia in it. It's created a kind of brain
- 9:04fog, which is an amazing thing to be sitting in because I have
- 9:10literally said the word that I'm trying to say now thousands of
- 9:14times and and it just arrived. Appropriation.
- 9:22We have a culture of appropriation without
- 9:24attribution. I don't think we can get rid of
- 9:28that as a feature of our culture because we would have nothing
- 9:31left. We take, we take, we take
- 9:38whatever looks shiny and pretty from whatever cultural group it
- 9:46arrives in. We dissociate it from the the
- 9:51the structures that it, it comes in that that you might say, we
- 9:55throw out the packaging and then we just have the object.
- 9:58And how that works in the meditation community, of course,
- 10:01is people grab techniques that they like that that that makes
- 10:05sense to them, but they pull them out of the Dharma map that
- 10:09they came in. And you do a succession of these
- 10:12different techniques in a kind of mishmash of Theravada, Zen
- 10:17and Tibetan practices. Maybe throw in some Kabbalah,
- 10:22you know, some contemplative prayer and you mash up these
- 10:26sort of spiritual concoctions that don't actually lead
- 10:31anywhere. One of the things you know about
- 10:35meditation is that you have the insights that the meditation
- 10:40technique offers you. And when you, you don't have a
- 10:46sense of the arc of the, the development of the insight into
- 10:53enlightenment, the mixing and matching of the, the different
- 10:57traditions and the different techniques produce a series of,
- 11:02of insights that may or may not lead anywhere.
- 11:09And so it isn't that that sudden awakening that you see that this
- 11:15is the path to enlightenment, which is what is talked about in
- 11:19each of those lineages. This is the Theravada path.
- 11:22This is the Zen path. This is the Tibetan path.
- 11:31And we'd like to secularize things, you know, in, in our
- 11:34culture. So we strip it all down to
- 11:36mindfulness and that that really is a dissociated collection
- 11:45practices, which becomes actually a stabilizer for the
- 11:52the values of our conventional culture, but not necessarily
- 11:58something that would lead to insight stress reducer makes you
- 12:07feel good. The also the United States, of
- 12:21course is this place where we've been inventing religious sects
- 12:26since the very beginning, since the pilgrims or religious sect
- 12:30came over. The two groups, the the
- 12:35religious, the religious excluded from Europe and the,
- 12:43the conquerors who wanted to enrich themselves.
- 12:50And that, that devaluing process.
- 12:56You know, the civilizations that were here when we arrived had
- 13:03this rich history of art and culture and symbolism.
- 13:09And at the peak of it, of course, it was made out, made in
- 13:13a way that was quite precious, which was of no value to the,
- 13:18the marauders that came over and said they just simply melted it
- 13:21down and shipped it back as the material it was.
- 13:25And so we we have lost in in so much of that understanding that
- 13:33was here. And so devalued.
- 13:36You know, you, you're on the losing side of a genocide and
- 13:40you're just devalued and everything that your culture
- 13:44represented is devalued to the point of no interest at all.
- 13:52So we don't know that. So still, I would say that the,
- 14:02the majority of people who come to practice meditation and have
- 14:07a sense of wanting to find something that's deeply
- 14:12meaningful to replace the, the alienation that they feel to the
- 14:17central culture does so because of their inability to relate to
- 14:27the central culture. And we could look at that as an
- 14:32expression of the loss of epistemic trusts.
- 14:35So epistemic trust is where you believe that people are telling
- 14:39you the truth and you believe that the reason that they're
- 14:42telling you what they're telling you is that they're meaning to
- 14:46be helpful to you. And what do we mean by that?
- 14:50They're meaning to be helpful to you.
- 14:51They're, they're the point of it is to help you discover the
- 14:56things that are meaningful to you, that will matter to you,
- 15:00that will give you a sense of purpose in life, a sense of
- 15:04direction in life. If you look at the arc of
- 15:12attachment conditioning in the development of epistemic trust
- 15:16and the loss of epistemic trust, you see in early childhood that
- 15:21the, the, the, the child attaches to the caregiver and
- 15:25forms a bond with them. And in the way that the
- 15:28caregiver interacts with the child, the child develops a
- 15:32working model of themselves and they develop a working model of
- 15:36the world. The world being other people.
- 15:40But children, you know, the brains of children are these,
- 15:43these wild Warrens of disconnected axons, which are
- 15:49meant to be able to SOP up an amazing amount of information
- 15:53really fast about the world, but it makes for very poor cognitive
- 15:58thinking. And so you move through early
- 16:03childhood where you form that, that working model of self and
- 16:08working model of the world and how that works.
- 16:11That's the early Crucible of attachment conditioning.
- 16:16If your caregiver comes good enough, they recognize you, they
- 16:20empathetically connect to you, they help you regulate your
- 16:24emotions, they attune to what's interesting to you, and they
- 16:28support and encourage you in discovering that.
- 16:35Then you have a sense of epistemic trust.
- 16:39They are telling you the truth, and what they're telling you is
- 16:42meant to be helpful to you. They're reliable to you.
- 16:45You can use them to develop a sense of yourself in in the
- 16:50world. And if they don't come reliably
- 16:54and they don't offer that to you, you, your perspective
- 17:01changes. And because children grow at an
- 17:06astonishing rate through that early period, throughout a
- 17:12childhood, what we are also doing is growing a brain that
- 17:16matches that. It's not so easy to shake
- 17:19conditioning because we've grown a brain that matches our
- 17:23experience. And humans are one of the one,
- 17:26one of the few creatures that whose brain develops outside of
- 17:31the womb, engaged directly with the environment.
- 17:36You know, we're born with a brain stem that's pretty well
- 17:38formed, a partially developed right brain and not much of a
- 17:42left brain. And all of those structures
- 17:46develop in direct interaction with the environment.
- 17:53So if you have if you're neglected in childhood and who
- 17:58you are isn't important, if your caregivers are present but not
- 18:05engaged with you, you develop a brain that suppresses the
- 18:11arousing aspect of the. I'm also dyslexic, so I can see
- 18:31the word in my mind, but I can't pronounce it.
- 18:35Amygdala that's transmitted to the hippocampus, which is in
- 18:40back and you, there's a hyperactivation of that.
- 18:44If you talk about it in terms of systems and somebody who's
- 18:48avoiding you, you suppress the sympathetic nervous system and
- 18:52you hyperactivate the parasympathetic nervous system,
- 18:56which then enables you to shut down the emotional system as
- 19:00well. That's the conditioning.
- 19:09It's the opposite if you end up preoccupied.
- 19:11So in a preoccupied person, somebody care comes and takes
- 19:17care of you and helps you emotionally regulate enough that
- 19:20you reorient toward them as your emotional regulator.
- 19:25Dismissing people are simply auto regulating.
- 19:27They never really turn to somebody else for help.
- 19:31That inconsistent care, sometimes you get it and
- 19:36sometimes you don't. And there's no real good
- 19:38explanation for why that would be.
- 19:51I've just figured out that if you hold your hand up like this,
- 19:54the system will raise the hand for you.
- 20:00What's it coming too soon? We'll just have to sit here and,
- 20:04and, and emojis will arise and people will know what we're
- 20:07doing. In that inconsistency, what
- 20:14happens is you you remain oriented toward the the the
- 20:18regulator. Dismissive people are really
- 20:21good at exploring. Off they go, they don't come
- 20:25back, they don't share what they found out, what matters to them.
- 20:29They tend to keep really private.
- 20:36Preoccupied people, on the other hand, don't learn to explore
- 20:39because they need to stay proximate to their caregiver who
- 20:42regulates them. If they were to separate, to go
- 20:45and attempt to explore, they would be dysregulated and not be
- 20:52able to regulate themselves. This is the dilemma.
- 20:57Then we have the trauma line fall down if the caregivers
- 21:01either don't pay enough attention to the kids that
- 21:05people outside of the family can harm the children, or the
- 21:09caregivers themselves are the ones who harm the kids.
- 21:14The attachment system is is in some ways shattered, you might
- 21:19say, or becomes very complex, becomes disorganized.
- 21:30When I first came to retreats in Southern California, how long
- 21:37ago would that be, 35 years ago or 30 years ago?
- 21:43We used to have to sign a form that said we did not have mental
- 21:49health issues, which I would say was the driving force of
- 21:57disorganized people coming toward an alternative way of
- 22:02addressing what was going on with them.
- 22:05And because they were disorganized and all over the
- 22:11place and hard to manage the and easily overwhelm the the people
- 22:20who were operating the retreats. So that if you had, there was
- 22:25always some form. Are you now or have you ever
- 22:31been mentally ill? If so, you can't come on our
- 22:33retreat. Yes or no?
- 22:36Which would you? Which little box would you
- 22:39check? No.
- 22:44What? You used to fly from the United
- 22:46States to Europe when you entered.
- 22:51This is all the way through the early 80s.
- 22:53Even so, not so far ago, not so long ago, all of the immigration
- 22:58forms would say are you now or have you ever been a homosexual?
- 23:03And we would all gleefully check no and laugh.
- 23:16What do you do when the whole system doesn't work for you and,
- 23:21and, and you're lost and you need to find a place to go that
- 23:25can make sense of it for you? So I think that that's at least
- 23:30was my earliest experience of the meditation world.
- 23:33That's who is coming. And one of the things about
- 23:40disorganized people, of course, they mentalize poorly and
- 23:43meditation, particularly in the Pasa and a Theravada strand of
- 23:47meditation, really good at developing mentalizing skills.
- 23:50So you could make these fantastic leaps forward doing
- 23:54the meditations strategies that then gave you a deeper insight
- 23:59into the nature of things. But still appeared that the the
- 24:15disorganized I I I I harp on the disorganized, the status of
- 24:20disorganized people, because that was the the state I found
- 24:23myself in not doing so well. And the the cool common
- 24:34collected teachers in the front of the room, not always, but
- 24:38often. And this longing I remember
- 24:48finding Chin Zen and and and really having this strong desire
- 24:52to be somebody that he he liked. And I had an experience with him
- 24:59that I don't know, maybe half a dozen people over the years
- 25:05sitting with him and shared with him is that on the last day of
- 25:10the retreat, as I was walking down the hall, he he popped out
- 25:14of the doorway and he said, oh, I'm so glad that I found you.
- 25:18I have this really important thing that I need you to do for
- 25:22me. Come along.
- 25:24And and I thought, Oh my God, finally he sees me.
- 25:27He recognizes my worth and me go into his room and he points at
- 25:32his suitcase and said would you take that to the car?
- 25:45Which I did this, this, this idea I had this projection of my
- 25:55need to him and, and the way that he, he managed that I had
- 26:02myself have this insanely high bar of the minimum level of
- 26:07kindness that you need to express toward me for me to be
- 26:10able to, to take you on as a teacher.
- 26:13And it's unusual to find that. And it was the thing about
- 26:17Qinzen that drew me to him initially was that he was
- 26:21unfailingly kind, which is something I needed because of my
- 26:24early experience was one of such cruelty.
- 26:30And so we're also coming toward people and listening to the way
- 26:36that they describe the world and looking for somebody who
- 26:43describes it in a way that we recognize.
- 26:46So we don't have to do a lot of transliteration in order to
- 26:49understand what they're telling us.
- 26:52And this is also, I think one of the things that happens when you
- 26:56find somebody who, who, who you can establish epistemic trust
- 27:00that you can believe them and you can believe that they're,
- 27:04they have your interest in mind. And then they talk about the
- 27:09world in a way that you can relate to the experience of the
- 27:13world. And I think that that's one of
- 27:17the reasons why we have so many different voices.
- 27:20And also the the different traditions can be of such value
- 27:24as you to move into the the description of it.
- 27:36The I of course am a smart ass and so I need to express all of
- 27:45this stuff in a way. So I asked Shinzen about the
- 27:51disclaimer for the mentally ill that was in his release and he
- 27:57explained it to me as you have to have a self before you can
- 28:01have a no self. You have to have a strong sense
- 28:05of self before you can deconstruct it.
- 28:08I, I completely disagree with that, but I, I, I appreciated
- 28:14that it was that it was based on some, some consideration.
- 28:23The, and you know, the Theravada focuses so much on that no self
- 28:27experience, that seeing through the ephemeral nature of the self
- 28:35experiences. You hear me talk about that
- 28:38quite a bit. That the, the self experience is
- 28:40the witness to the actual self and what the self is doing.
- 28:43That the the body mind activity of you is fully unconscious and
- 28:48all of that conditioning and all of the decision making and all
- 28:52of the defining and meaning signing comes through that
- 28:59process. And then it's like the self is
- 29:04the printer in the the vast computer system and you get a
- 29:09bulletin about what the body mind is about to do in case it's
- 29:13a really bad idea and you need to veto it.
- 29:15But there's no decision making in that process.
- 29:18It's simply this is a bad idea. Don't do it.
- 29:21It's what that witnessing function is.
- 29:25And it also works as a way of ordering experience so that you
- 29:32can present it to someone else in a way so that you actually
- 29:35can have a, a dialogue with somebody, a collaborative
- 29:39dialogue with somebody where they understand you and you
- 29:44understand them. And you, you have that
- 29:48mentalizing model. You understand the meaning that
- 29:52you give to your experience of the present moment, to
- 29:55understand that it's your meaning and your experience.
- 29:59You understand what about that you would like to share or
- 30:02express to somebody else. You understand how to express it
- 30:06to them so that they understand you.
- 30:10If you define everything with definitions that are yours and
- 30:17everybody else is doing the same thing and they're just, they're
- 30:21defining everything with their definitions, how do you bridge
- 30:25that gap of meaning between what you mean, what they mean?
- 30:29That's the that process. So you make an expression and
- 30:34make sure that they understand what you mean, and then they
- 30:36respond to you and you make sure that you understand what their
- 30:40responses, and then you can adequately modify your
- 30:45understanding of the experienced between you.
- 30:50And if you can't do that, it's very easy to get into conflicts
- 30:57that are really arising because you can't see each other
- 31:02clearly. Is that making sense?
- 31:15What did you come to practice for?
- 31:17What was it that you wanted? I remember when I moved to LA
- 31:24and 92 and I went to to sit with somebody in Venice and on the,
- 31:37and I took a, an intro to meditation class and the teacher
- 31:47said, why did you come to meditation?
- 31:50And in that I grew up in Chicago.
- 31:54So I like to say in that Midwest eagerness that we have out
- 31:59there, but not here, I said, I want to be enlightened.
- 32:08And there was just a, a default from the other students, but it
- 32:15wasn't kind. It was you idiot.
- 32:18Like that's something that you can get from this practice.
- 32:24And I thought, why would you do this if you could get
- 32:27enlightened? That makes no sense. 10
- 32:31lifetimes from now, 10 incarnations from now.
- 32:35No, no, no, I want enlightenment in this incarnation.
- 32:39It's one of the things that also drew me to Shinzen, which which
- 32:44was his claim that we could get stream entry in in this
- 32:48lifetime. But my, my mind was very
- 32:56scattered in the beginning. Not much concentration, couldn't
- 33:01hold an object at all. So what was that like for you
- 33:09when you came? Shenzhen used to say
- 33:18enlightenment is much, much better than anything you could
- 33:21ever imagine and not nearly as good as what you did.
- 33:28And so when I think of those, you know, 30 or so years ago, I
- 33:36wanted to be enlightened and I had a strong sense of what
- 33:40enlightenment would be, which would, which was succinctly,
- 33:47I'll never have another problem. And somehow I will magically
- 33:58transform my ability to respond to the things of the world and
- 34:02that there will be no problems left.
- 34:05This, however, did not turn out to be related to enlightenment,
- 34:10but to magic. It tends to be more related to
- 34:22old age, sickness and death, which you learn gradually, which
- 34:26I think is a good thing if you live long enough.
- 34:33How do you how do you accustom to it?
- 34:39I I lived through the AIDS crisis in New York in the 80s.
- 34:47And my friend Kenny O'Brien, who who died I guess 91 or so, used
- 35:03to say I'm totally fine with this except for one thing.
- 35:06And I said, what's that worrying about?
- 35:08What's going to go next in terms of his ability to function in
- 35:13the world, that worry about what's going to go next, which
- 35:17is kind of the, I like to call the joy of aging.
- 35:21What's going to go next? How do you sit with that, be at
- 35:28peace and carry on with the things that matter.
- 35:31And as your energy changes and as you're able to do less, you
- 35:37pull up the bottom of the list of things that are less
- 35:40important so that you, we can focus your energy on the things
- 35:44that matter to you. But if you don't figure out what
- 35:48that is, you could spend the energy on things that don't
- 35:51matter to you. And it, and it creates a sense
- 35:53of despair being alive. You have attachment conditioning
- 36:04and you can work on that attachment conditioning if it's
- 36:07in the insecure, disorganized category to, to make it more
- 36:13functional, more secure. We call it earned secure.
- 36:18And then that can make relationships work much better.
- 36:23You don't get into the patterns of transactional relationships
- 36:26with the patterns of trauma bonded relationships.
- 36:29You're actually able to be in a collaborative relationship and
- 36:35in a collaborative relationship, if you're, if you hold the
- 36:39anxiety of abandoned below the threshold for authentic
- 36:42expression, You can relate the things that are authentically
- 36:47important to you. And then use this practice
- 36:51actually to move into a place of deep and profound insight into
- 36:59the the nature of what's meaningful to you.
- 37:02And you can reorganize your life in such a way that that's the
- 37:06thing that you spend, I like to say the best part of each day
- 37:13doing and then do the secondary exploration stuff and what's
- 37:20left of of the day after. After that pursuit of meaning is
- 37:25there and that you're able to put around yourself a group of
- 37:29people that are interested in that and delighted by your
- 37:34succeeding in the discoveries of what matters to you and want you
- 37:40to regale them with the the insights that you've discovered
- 37:47about it. In exchange, they regale you
- 37:52with the things that they've understood.
- 37:54But if you find somebody who was relatable to you in a way, you
- 37:58could use that also in your own exploration.
- 38:01There's a synergy that happens. Is that all making sense and not
- 38:12get stuck in a rigid teacher student relationship that simply
- 38:21reinforces a native an unfortunate native attachment
- 38:29conditioning, which I think happens quite a bit Christian.
- 38:36You know that I imagine it's a kohan, not a not some new age
- 38:40wisdom that like phrase that if you ever meet the Buddha on the
- 38:44road, you should kill him. It's a a Zen story, yeah.
- 38:49I always thought that it was kind of funny that with the, you
- 38:53know, the Buddha of Bamiyan, the statue in Afghanistan.
- 38:58The one that blew up what it could.
- 39:00Do it was only the Taliban that could actually that that could
- 39:04actually do that. This is the the iconic and
- 39:13iconic debate about the representation of the idea of
- 39:21the spiritual teachers, I guess. Fundamentalism versus something
- 39:34dynamic. I tend to be more on the side of
- 39:46freedom than on the side of confinement.
- 39:55Sure, I maybe I was being cute, but it it's interesting to me
- 39:59that it I wonder if like. That's the hardest thing to do
- 40:09for people that are actually practicing Buddhists.
- 40:13Which? To like to to kill the Buddha
- 40:18and whatever that might mean or to, to to not, you know, to like
- 40:22let go of their teachers and their their idea of their
- 40:25teachers and. Whatever their idea of what
- 40:28enlightenment is. Right.
- 40:31Taliban to. The Taliban of the by actually,
- 40:38I'm not sure you do need that. What do you what do you need to
- 40:40do is to pay attention because you can eventually see what it
- 40:49is and in the contrast of what you thought it might be, can
- 40:55even help with that. Let go of of what you wanted it
- 41:02to be and and and replace it with what is it?
- 41:08What is it? Maybe simply you're going to get
- 41:16old, you're going to get sick and you're going to die and
- 41:18there's nothing you can do about that.
- 41:20And in the meantime, take care of everybody.
- 41:27Mudit. Hey, George.
- 41:32Hey. Yeah, the idea of not of.
- 41:41Imagine two different friends having two different viewpoints.
- 41:45The shift. How did that shift happen in
- 41:48terms of not associating the beingness with somebody's
- 41:53viewpoints in how we see another person as their own, their
- 42:00viewpoint, not separate from their viewpoint that causes so
- 42:05much conflict. I also find that very hard to
- 42:09imagine if somebody close to me or some good friend of mine who
- 42:15has opposing beliefs, that it's hard for me to separate my
- 42:21conflict to to tell myself, oh, that's just a viewpoint that
- 42:26he's having and that's not his beingness.
- 42:30And then do you make a distinction between viewpoint
- 42:33and action in the world? Can you elaborate?
- 42:41Well, it's one thing to have a a opposing viewpoint or a
- 42:53different viewpoint, and it is. It's another to insist that you
- 43:02adopt my point of view, and then if you are unwilling to adopt my
- 43:07point of view, that I put in place physical structures that
- 43:10will compel you to adopt my point of view.
- 43:15Right. Oh, I see.
- 43:18No, it's just the the sense of closeness tends to get disturbed
- 43:25if somebody has opposing viewpoints.
- 43:27And I was wondering what that is.
- 43:29Well, this is then the question of safety really in the
- 43:33abandonment sense. Does somebody express to you a
- 43:40variation in a point of view or a different point of view that
- 43:46that is done in such a way that it doesn't make you frightened
- 43:51for whether or not they will then be reliable in, in taking
- 43:58care of you. If you get to a place where the
- 44:02way, the way in which they express the point of view
- 44:05suggests that they will not be reliable and taking care of you,
- 44:09then the there's no way to settle that, right?
- 44:19That's what I was, I would think because as you may know, notice
- 44:24that everybody's point of view changes.
- 44:29You look at the flexibility of somebody's thinking.
- 44:33If you have somebody who's very open and constantly looking for
- 44:37information and constantly doing their evaluations, their point
- 44:42of view is changing all of the time.
- 44:44It's when they get quite rigid and deflecting of any contrary
- 44:49information making a judgement and and then that becomes it.
- 44:56There was an interesting study about the distance of neuronal
- 45:03tubes in the prefrontal cortex. You know, the the five layers of
- 45:07the prefrontal cortex are connected by neuronal tubes that
- 45:13that information flows between the layers.
- 45:16And I'm simplifying. So if you're a brain scientist,
- 45:19please don't send me an e-mail or do I don't care that at one
- 45:31end of the distance between the neuronal tubes is autism and at
- 45:37the other end of the bell curve is dyslexia.
- 45:42And when you get toward the the end where the neuronal tubes are
- 45:47really packed together, they become very concrete and they're
- 45:52thinking and very inflexible and they're thinking.
- 45:55And then at the other end of the curve, dyslexic people are the
- 45:57most rangy and dynamic in the way that they think because the,
- 46:04the length of the axons that connect the, the neuronal tubes
- 46:11is so leggy that it tends to connect to a wider range of
- 46:18subjects and ideas. And the closer they are
- 46:23together, the less range there is and the more concrete it
- 46:27becomes. So part of it is also beyond
- 46:31simply conditioning, but the, the actual hard, you know, the,
- 46:35the actual wet wear of the person.
- 46:39And so as you're mentalizing the, the nature of the
- 46:42conversation with them, are they really concrete and, and, and
- 46:46pretty much everything And they, they quite range.
- 46:49Can you expect them to adopt totally different ideas and jam
- 46:54them all together? It's it's that great insult for
- 46:57the concrete thinkers of a flip flopper.
- 47:00They keep changing their mind. Whereas, you know, you have to
- 47:03make a decision, you have to come to an idea or on the other
- 47:08end, the constant change and fluctuation.
- 47:11So where are you in that? And what is a is a good amount
- 47:17of flow in that. But the thing that undermines
- 47:22the safety is the is the sense that that if you don't adopt
- 47:30their point of view, that there'll be a loss of care, loss
- 47:35of attention, you'll be abandoned.
- 47:41It's a silly example for in this case, like you're talking about
- 47:44Shenzhen. Yeah.
- 47:46Like imagine if somebody comes and talks against Shenzhen to
- 47:49you. I was like, is this or just
- 47:51opposing somebody that you care about very much?
- 47:56And I realized that situations there is the I'm not sure if
- 47:59it's abandonment, but there is this internal hurt or fear that
- 48:06tends to. That also, I think, is nuanced.
- 48:23If I thought that I had been bamboozled, it would be quite
- 48:29problematic, right? I thought I'd been lied to her,
- 48:34that they had misrepresented something, manipulated me for
- 48:40something that they wanted. That would be quite troubling.
- 48:44I've, I've never had that experience with Shinsen.
- 48:47He's always been totally straightforward, easy, quirky,
- 48:58and so I don't know that unless I was frightened for him for
- 49:13some reason in the way that they addressed it, that it would be
- 49:16difficult to hear. And by difficult to hear you
- 49:24mean is there fear or is that just simply an internal
- 49:28disturbance? Well, I would know that
- 49:32everybody's experience of Shinzen is from their
- 49:36perspective and they each have a relationship to them.
- 49:39And, you know, teachers are these massive projection
- 49:43objects. Everybody just dumps all of
- 49:46their projections on them. And So what also is fascinating
- 49:50in descriptions of the failures of teachers is the catalog of
- 49:56projections that somebody is actually telling you, which is
- 50:01about them, not about the future.
- 50:08So the I don't know that that is so much, but I do do feel it
- 50:30more on the side of having been fooled, and that makes me
- 50:36frightened. That has a way of undermining my
- 50:42confidence in my own ability to discern reality, which is a
- 50:46frightening place. Yes, yes, absolutely.
- 50:52Exactly. Yeah, which happens.
- 50:57But you know, one of the things about going really slowly into
- 51:03relationships and knowing people over a year or two before you
- 51:09make really substantial commitments to them is that that
- 51:12also doesn't happen very often. It's only when you get when you
- 51:17rush in because the the love bombing is so beautiful and that
- 51:26Toto runs across the room and pulls the curtain back.
- 51:35So everybody's OK. Did you want to do some
- 51:40practice, a little bit of love and kindness maybe or a quick
- 51:47IPF or some the pasta? Which would you like?
- 51:54Not IPF because I have to head out.
- 51:57OK, if you can't have it, nobody else can.
- 52:09Which one? All right, going to decide for
- 52:20myself and do meta. OK, let go of the meditation.
- 52:27How's that? Good.
- 52:29So on September 13th, I'm starting a meditation and
- 52:35attachment level one Saturday mornings from 9:00 to 1:00, the
- 52:4113th, the 20th, and the 27th. On September 15th, I'm starting
- 52:53a Level 2 meditation and addiction, which is Monday,
- 52:56Wednesday and Friday from six to seven and that runs through 12
- 53:01weeks. I'm going to do a meditation and
- 53:05attachment workshop. We like to also call it how to
- 53:09date Like a Secure Person, even if you're not.
- 53:14So an hour of dating tips if you need them.
- 53:23What else we're going to do on October 21st, We're going to
- 53:31start a meditation and attachment Level 2 on Tuesday
- 53:34afternoons from 4:30 to 6:30. Don't forget that we have
- 53:40Kaleidoscope which is a meeting of just the General Sanga.
- 53:45We usually have a, a period of Q&A about your practice and you
- 53:52can come with any practice questions.
- 53:55And then I always have some topic to talk about.
- 54:05And then in November, because the holiday season is upon us,
- 54:10I'm going to do the this 1/2 day retreat that we do every year on
- 54:16the 15th of November, which I like to call family archaeology,
- 54:22which is how to use your trip home to as a way of
- 54:29investigating your early attachment conditioning.
- 54:34If you're unclear how you actually are operating
- 54:37attachment wise, all you have to do is go home and watch how
- 54:40everybody else is doing it. It's often more apparent in
- 54:43other people than it is in yourself and you get a sense of
- 54:46how your family system operates. And then we're already at the
- 54:56end of the year, amazingly so I'm doing a a dating workshop on
- 55:09the 19th of December, but it's quite a ways away.
- 55:12Anyway, take a look at it. It's up on the website.
- 55:16Ioffer the teaching freely. But I do hope if you're
- 55:19resourced and you can make a donation, you will.
- 55:21There's a link on the website. It helps support me and also the
- 55:24work that Medigroup does. Thanks so much for your
- 55:26practice. Really appreciate it.
- 55:28I look forward to seeing you soon somewhere along the path.
- 55:32Bye. Thank you for teaching George.
- 55:35It's good to see you again. Good.