Latest / Crimes and Consequences / EP189: Where is Erica Baker?
Transcript
- 0:00This episode may contain content of a graphic nature, including descriptions of physical and
- 0:05sexual violence against adults, children, and animals. Listener discretion is advised.
- 0:12Hi everyone, I'm Tanya and I'm Talia, and we are Crimes and Consequences,
- 0:18a true crime podcast. Hi Talia, him Tanya. Welcome back everyone
- 0:40to an exciting episode of Crimes and Consequences. I'm not going to ask you
- 0:44how you are because I'm sick. Yeah, you're not feeling well today.
- 0:47I don't know what's wrong. My kids, they're filled with germs storm factory.
- 0:53My daughter was sick and now I'm sick. I hope you don't make
- 0:57me sick anyway. Get over it, it over. It's not deadly,
- 1:02hope not. I don't think so. It's only day one, so wash
- 1:06your hands. I have a story today that was suggested by Jess m and
- 1:11Johnnifer s Oh, two people. Two people suggested this case. And before
- 1:17I start telling you, I would just like to remind everyone to hit the
- 1:19subscribe or follow button on your favorite app. And I'm gonna get into it.
- 1:23So two people suggested it is in a famous case that I wouldn't know.
- 1:26I didn't know this one. Okay, it is about nine year old
- 1:32Erica Baker. Don't worry. It's not child abuse, don't it's not that.
- 1:36I'm just telling everyone I can't do that. Okay, it's not it's
- 1:40not. But in February nineteen ninety nine, nine year old eric Baker vanished
- 1:45from her neighborhood in Kettering, Ohio. Have you ever been to Kettering?
- 1:49I don't think I have been to Ohio, but yeah, I've been to
- 1:52Ohio. I've driven through Ohio a few times. Okay. The investigation that
- 1:57would follow would shake residence to their core. Kettering was once considered a safe
- 2:01place to raise children, but now you know, they feel like a madman
- 2:06was on the loose when this happened, because she disappeared. Yeah, what
- 2:09was she doing once she disappeared? I'm going to tell you. I'm sorry.
- 2:13I'm sorry. I get excited. Okay. So, as I said,
- 2:15Kettering, Ohio. It's in Montgomery County. It's in Ohio's southwest.
- 2:21Okay, I think so, oh I got you there? I know?
- 2:24Is that Kentucky? Yeah it is right map anyway. Anyway, it's considered
- 2:31the inner suburb of Dayton, oh Dayton and Kettering's really connected to Dayton.
- 2:38In nineteen ninety nine, Kettering had a population of about fifty eight thousand people,
- 2:43so it's not huge way, but it's not small. It just was
- 2:46considered a safe place to raise a family. There was lots of school and
- 2:51educational facilities, so it seemed like a great suburb to live. Parents instilled
- 2:54the motto stranger, danger and children. You know you told your kids,
- 2:59I'm sure mine? Are you kidding me? I literally would ride by with
- 3:02her playing and be like, I'm sorry, I lost my puppy. Could
- 3:07you help me find it? Would you like some candy? Did they ever
- 3:09fall for it? And they're just like you, They're like, mom,
- 3:13what are you? What are you doing? You're embarrassing me? Exactly in
- 3:20nine year old Erica. She obviously was given this talk two so. Erica
- 3:24was born on June twenty second, nineteen eighty nine, to her parents,
- 3:29Melissa, who went by Misty, and Greg Baker. Unfortunately, the relationship
- 3:34between Misty and Greg did not last, and the two eventually divorced. Erica
- 3:38was the youngest of four children, and she was the only girl. Greg
- 3:44Baker stated that his daughter was a real daddy's girl. The two love to
- 3:47spend daddy daughter time together, and Erica enjoyed camping, hiking, and fishing.
- 3:53And despite being small, like she was just a little girl, Erica
- 3:58matched the energy of her three brothers and she was very much the baby of
- 4:00the family. Like her brothers were really protective of her. Erica could often
- 4:05be seen wearing pink, and it's safe to say it was her favorite color.
- 4:10Her childhood friend Katie reminisced, saying that the pair would often make up
- 4:15dance moves and wear matching outfits at sleepovers. I feel like you're gonna make
- 4:18me really sad, and you said you wouldn't. Well, I told you
- 4:21wasn't child abuse. I didn't say anything about not being sad, all right,
- 4:27Tanya, Katie and Erica were inseparable, partly because Katie lived just a
- 4:32couple doors down from Greg Baker. Erica was doing well at school and she
- 4:36was interested in cheerleading. She also loved animals. Like most little girls,
- 4:42she loved getting her hair done and like wearing bows and braids. She loved
- 4:46all that stuff. Yeah, she loved to look her best and always flashed
- 4:50a smile and everyone she met. Those who knew Erica described her as a
- 4:56kind, sweet and innocent young girl who was incredibly popular. By nineteen ninety
- 5:01nine, Missy was living with her mom, Pam Schmidt, and Missy and
- 5:05Greg were sharing custody of their four children. This arrangement worked well for the
- 5:10family, and Erica looked forward to spending her weekends in the Indian Riffle Park
- 5:15with her dad. The park was close to Erica's home, and she often
- 5:17wandered to the park for a day of adventure. There's also a recreation center
- 5:24and a senior center. I feel like that's already you're going to say,
- 5:28a fishing pond, and the school Erica attended was within the park. There
- 5:32was always something for Erica to get into. There are adults watching Erica in
- 5:38the park. I don't know. I don't, no girl, I listen,
- 5:43okay, you know, go ahead them. So On February seventh,
- 5:46nineteen ninety nine, this was just a regular day and Kettering. The temperature
- 5:50was moderate, but it was rainy and dreary a little bit. On that
- 5:56day, Greg had the children, including Erica, and the five of them
- 6:00were getting ready to return to their mother's house. Greg bundled his children into
- 6:04the car and drove to Misty and Pam's house. While in the car,
- 6:09Greg and Erica talked about the father daughter dance that was taking place at the
- 6:13rec center that night, the one that's in the park. Erica had asked
- 6:16her father to go with her. She had been asking him for weeks,
- 6:19but Greg wasn't able to get tickets like it sold out. What he called
- 6:24around, he can make an exception, come on, not a Taylor Swift
- 6:28concert. He called around to friends and family. He was just desperate to
- 6:35put a smile on little Erica's face because he knew she really really wanted to
- 6:40go, and he should just sneak in. Would They'd have been funny,
- 6:44that would have been I know, No, you can't come here with your
- 6:46daughter all dressed up in pink, right, They really turn away? Sorry?
- 6:51Sorry. When Erica learned that her father hadn't secured the tickets for the
- 6:58dance, she was just heartbroken. And Greg felt a lot of guilt after
- 7:02Erica's disappearance because the dance took place around the same time she disappeared, and
- 7:09he just beats himself up to this day, thinking like if I had just
- 7:13taken nerves dance. I had just gotten those tickets. If I would just
- 7:15busted in that place, right exactly, I'm sure that's the thoughts that go
- 7:19through his side. I would. I mean, he probably kills himself with
- 7:23guilt every day. So, as I mentioned, Greg and the kids are
- 7:28on their way to Misty's house. So after a short drive, they get
- 7:32there and the children hopped out of the car, waiting in line to hug
- 7:35their dad goodbye, give him a little kiss. When Greg held his arms
- 7:41around his little girl, he had no idea it's to be for the last
- 7:45time. I know. I'm sorry. Just before Eric had stepped into the
- 7:47house, Greg promised her that he would make up for missing that father daughter
- 7:53dance. Erica put her disappointment to the side when she saw her mom,
- 7:57Misty. She told her what she'd up to with her dad that weekend,
- 8:01like, we just had a lot of fun and whatever. As I mentioned,
- 8:03so it's a little bit rainy, and Pam, who is Misty's mom
- 8:07and Erica's grandma, remembers the weather very well. February seventh is just forever
- 8:13etched in her mind. At around three pm, Erica had donned her favorite
- 8:18Winnie the Pooh sweater and pink raincoat. At first, Pam and Misty didn't
- 8:22want Erica to go outside in the rain, but she had promised to wear
- 8:26her raincoat. I love being in the rain. Oh me too. So
- 8:30after pleading with her mother and giving the please, please please, I got
- 8:35to go to the Daddy daughter day. Let's just go the rain exactly?
- 8:37Can I just go outside? Pam and Misty said, Okay, fine,
- 8:41you can go outside. Erica told her mom she was heading to Indian Riffle
- 8:46Park to take Jamie. And Jamie is a shitsu dog. She was gonna
- 8:50take Jamie for a while. So if her parents didn't live that far from
- 8:54each other, no, no, they didn't. Some sources say that Jamie
- 8:58was the family dog, but others say that the dog belonged to Erica's aunt.
- 9:01So I can't say, oh, she took her dog, you know,
- 9:03I'm not sure. Nevertheless, Erica laughed at about three thirty, and
- 9:11people recalled seeing her in her pink raincoat walking toward Indian Riffle Park. Missy
- 9:16and Pam trusted that Erica could walk the dog safely on her own. Indian
- 9:22Riffle Park was just a stone's throwaway from their house, and the community was
- 9:26regarded safe and peaceful. Witnesses and people who knew Erica and her family recall
- 9:31seeing her in the park, walking and playing with Jamie. One witness would
- 9:35later come forward to investigators saying that they saw Erica standing by the bleachers alone
- 9:41in the pouring rain. So it's wondered, like, why was she alone?
- 9:46Was she waiting for someone? Like, what's going on? That's a
- 9:50question that's never been answered. Well, maybe she was just chilling for a
- 9:52second. Ye she was alone at the park, and it's maybe she was
- 9:54under the bleachers. Just two joggers making their rounds in the parks. Did
- 10:00Erica playing with Jamie? These two joggers are regarded as some of the last
- 10:03people to see Erica. Are you calling and I'm sorry? According to Missing
- 10:09Erica Baker and Missing Erica Baker is a podcast by Dayton twenty four seven Now
- 10:16the podcast, a lot of the information in the podcast was used in this
- 10:20and our pasts. Yes in our podcast. So according to Missing Erica Baker,
- 10:26there was also an elderly couple who recalled seeing Eric in the park day
- 10:28afternoon. But I'll talk about that a little bit later, when Pam looked
- 10:33up through the basement window and saw that it was getting dark outside, she
- 10:39rushed upstairs to see if Erica and Jamie had returned. Like most children,
- 10:43Erica was scared of the dark, and Pam hadn't heard the front door slam
- 10:48shot that afternoon. Yeah, there's no way in nine year old girls may
- 10:52hanging out a park. No. I wouldn't even hang out in a park
- 10:54in the dark. Hell no, not today. They would fuck that.
- 11:01No, I would not be hanging out of the park in the rain in
- 11:05the dark. No, thank you. That's where the creepers go. Exactly.
- 11:09So Misty was equally worried. Erica had never failed to return home for
- 11:13dinner like most of us. When faced with a horrific situation, Misty ran
- 11:18to her mom, like, what are we gonna do? I'm gonna call
- 11:22him police. Yes, Well, before they called the police, they put
- 11:24on their coats and went to the park to look for Erica. Pam and
- 11:28Misty's that podcast I mentioned that Missing Erica Baker podcasts Pam and Misty. They
- 11:33are interviewed on this podcast and they're featured pretty heavily in it. Pam commented
- 11:39that during the initial hours of Erica's disappearance, she searched in bushes, trees,
- 11:43cars, and any other spot that she could think of. The two
- 11:48began calling Erica's friend's house to see whether she had taken shelter there, but
- 11:52she hadn't. I was just call nine one. Then that hysterical mom,
- 11:56Oh my god, I know, right, but I mean I'm not no,
- 12:00no, I know. Erica's brothers quickly figured out what was happening,
- 12:03and they took off to look for their baby sister. The group also searched
- 12:09the school in Indian Riffle Park, which Erica attended, along with the rec
- 12:13center where the father daughter dance was taking place at the same time. Ye,
- 12:20Missy hoped, yeah, Eric had wandered into the dance, that maybe
- 12:24she had begged someone to let her in, But their hopes were shattered when
- 12:28the searches turned up no sign of Erica. After failing to locate her in
- 12:33the park, Pam ran home and placed the nine one one call. Pam
- 12:37provided exact detail in the call to eight operators and getting the call through with
- 12:41correct information. She hadn't even finished giving the nine one one operator all the
- 12:46details when she saw a swarm of flashing lights. That's awesome. Yeah,
- 12:50they were quick. Around six pm, Greg's homephone rang. He was in
- 12:56the middle of dinner, so he gets up from the table and he answers
- 12:58it and it's Misty. His head just started to spin as he listened to
- 13:05his ex wife and the other of his children tell him that their daughter Erica
- 13:09was missing. In a state of panic and shock, Yeah right, Greg
- 13:15sped down to Misty's house. He was also in the Missing Erica Baker podcast
- 13:20and he told them that seeing the sea of Cuttering police cars outside of the
- 13:24home just cemented to him that this is serious, this is real. He
- 13:28just described the whole thing as being surreal. A command center was created in
- 13:33the park that Indian Riffle Park, and the Cunning Police Department immediately began plans
- 13:39for the search for Erica. Dozens of residents poured into the park to see
- 13:41what was going on, and this is when they learned of Erica's disappearance.
- 13:46The Cuttering Police Department deployed helicopters, search teams that's yeah, in sniffer dogs
- 13:52to try and locate Erica as soon as possible. Sniffer dogs sniffer dogs.
- 13:56Okay, some dogs what they call all right, sniffer whatever. Okay,
- 14:03okay, okay, I'm not getting hum up at them. Pam and Misty
- 14:07were told to stay home in case Erica returned, but they really wanted to
- 14:11be part of the investigation. They wanted to look for Erica. Yeah,
- 14:13well too, I'd have like one person can stay home, right, right.
- 14:18So this desire to want to be a part of the search just became
- 14:22too much and they ended up returning to the park not long after they had
- 14:26stayed home for a little bit. Word of Erica's disappearance had spread like wildfire.
- 14:31By this point, Cattering was very interconnected in a close knit community,
- 14:35and over three hundred residents turned up to the rec center to help look for
- 14:39her. Volunteers headed out with police units to scour every inch of Indian Riffle
- 14:43Park. Hours after the Cattering Police Department were alerted to Erica's disappearance, they
- 14:48also received a call about the dog Jamie. Remember she was with Jamie.
- 14:52An elderly couple in their sixties had been walking through the park that afternoon with
- 14:56their dog Muppet. That's an elder couple you were talking about. Earlier.
- 15:01Yeah, when they spotted Erica and Jamie playing. And they said, though,
- 15:05but one moment she was there and the next she was gone, okay,
- 15:11and they didn't see anything else. No, and they didn't see anything
- 15:13else. And they told investigators that at around five PM, that's when they
- 15:18found Janie alone. The dog was soaking wet and terrified, and her collar
- 15:24and her leash were still attached. And this became just crazy because Erica would
- 15:30have never left the dog right. That couple wasn't aware of the significance of
- 15:35their discovery at the time, and Jamie was taken to a local pound like
- 15:39they didn't know, but she was later reunited with the family and tracker dogs
- 15:43tracker dogs sniffer dogs. Investigators were now slowly piecing together Erica's last movements to
- 15:50her family had just made no sense. She would leave Janie alone. She
- 15:54was a social butterfly that would talk to anyone, but she also loved animals.
- 16:00At ten thirty, Detective Bob Green received a call. Now, Detective
- 16:03Green was a new detective, had only been a detective for seven months,
- 16:10but he was known for having impeccable interviewing and interrogation skills. And he had
- 16:15no idea that this call would change the course of his career. He was
- 16:19briefed about Erica's disappearance. Anne was asked to get down to the makeshift command
- 16:23center as soon as possible. When he arrived, he spoke with fellow officers
- 16:27to get a handle on the situation. And before I tell you more,
- 16:32we're going to take a break. The detective's first thought was that maybe Erica
- 16:37had fallen into There's a pond in this park and it's like two point nine
- 16:41million gallons. Oh, it's huge. It's the size of a football field,
- 16:45and according to the CDC, drowning is leading cause of death and children
- 16:51under four. Did you know, Anne, I didn't know that. I
- 16:52didn't know that. I think poisoning is up there too. Really, I'm
- 16:56accidentally eating something that they shouldn't. The water level in this pond were unusually
- 17:00high due to the heavy rainfall that the area had gotten recently. Detective Green
- 17:06immediately set us sights on the pool. Well, if there's rainfall, wouldn't
- 17:08there be footprints and things? You would think so, right, because it
- 17:11was raining, Yeah, it was raining. When you see like little footprints,
- 17:15Yeah, I'm not a detective. I know, I'm not a detective
- 17:18either, but you would think so, right, I don't know. Pam
- 17:22and Misty watched as officers began to search the pond. They immediately knew in
- 17:27their hearts that Erica wasn't in the water. She was described as a strong
- 17:32swimmer and had fished dozens of times in the park with her dad. Grag.
- 17:37She also knew how to get herself out of the water. But nonetheless,
- 17:41it happens. Yeah, kids round and so it gets searched. Volunteer
- 17:45searchers continue to look for Erica throughout the night. The Kettering Fire Service also
- 17:51joined the search. Immedia CRUs had solowly begun creeping into the park. Media
- 17:56yeah. Media. By the next morning, Erica's disappearance had made Kettering news
- 18:02and everyone was talking about it. Suspicions immediately flew Greg's way. I don't
- 18:07know, you know how people are people. I know he couldn't even take
- 18:11her to a daddy daughter. Damn right, exactly right. The people of
- 18:14Kettering had once considered Greg a friend, they now considered, hey, he
- 18:18is the one that's responsible. How horrible is that You're people think you did
- 18:23it? I know, people avoided him on the streets. It was just
- 18:26bad. They can off right. Neighbors and colleagues of the family began to
- 18:33talk to airing any secrets that the pair, like Greg and Missy, may
- 18:37have divulged in innocent conversations, and all of a sudden things that weren't suspicious
- 18:42before. Right, all of a sudden, you look at it a different
- 18:45way. Yeah, exactly, Katie, Erica's best friend that I told you
- 18:52about before. She remembers that the neighborhood children were no longer allowed to walk
- 18:56to the bus stop alone or play outside without supervision. The entire town was
- 19:03on edge, and the children of Kettering were just confused. Why it was
- 19:07Erica's school desk empty? When was she coming home. Katie also said she
- 19:11had no idea Erica was missing until she saw it on the morning news or
- 19:15parents didn't even tell her. I know. When the sun came up on
- 19:19February eighth, nineteen ninety one, Greg and Missy realized that their little girl
- 19:23wasn't coming home, breaking my heart right now, I'm sorry. The notion
- 19:27hit both of them incredibly hard. While officers searched and drained the pond,
- 19:33the FBI was notified and they arrived on the scene shortly thereafter. Detectives and
- 19:38FBI agents held two briefings daily at eight am and four pm. For the
- 19:44next few months months, detectives would work sixteen hours a day, seven days
- 19:48a week to find Erica. This is not like New York City's fifty eight
- 19:52people in it, right, It's just like a suburb of Ohio. It's
- 19:59just sad. For the next two to three days, the Cutting Police Department,
- 20:03assisted by experts and other agencies, drained that two point nine million gallon
- 20:08pond. The operation continued until the last drop was gone, and they didn't
- 20:15find anything. They didn't find anything. No, I always think they'd find
- 20:18a body or something like a bicycle or some something. They didn't find anything.
- 20:22Panamisty knew that Erica hadn't been in the water, but this really gave
- 20:26them no relief. She wasn't in the pond, So where is she?
- 20:30Yeah? So where is she? That's not a better scenario, not think
- 20:33about it. Shortly after Erica's disappearance, remember that elderly couple I told you
- 20:40about. Yeah, yeah, they agreed to be interviewed. The man Rackx
- 20:45told investigators everything he knew and agreed to be put under hypnosis. Oh I
- 20:49love hypnosis, Yeah, to see if there was any subconscious memories. He
- 20:56told the police department that the condition of Janie struck them as odd. Rex
- 21:02recalled that the park was empty and that Erica and Jamie were playing near the
- 21:04bleachers. One moment she was there, the next she was gone. All
- 21:10known sex offenders in the area were questioned, as well as Erica's family.
- 21:14They didn't see any cars there or anything. No, no, missy,
- 21:18Pam, Pam's partner, and Greg were all interviewed. This interrogation did little
- 21:25to quell the rumors of Greg's involvement. They're being interviewed, Yeah, the
- 21:29police are talking to him. In one instance, he walked into a restaurant
- 21:33and kettering and noticed that everyone pulled their children away from I mean, come
- 21:37on, people are just idiots sometimes. Yeah, but then they don't know.
- 21:41They might think he did. And what if he did? I know.
- 21:45He was actually asked to leave as the waitress felt it was too sad
- 21:51to serve him. Despite what the townspeople said, Greg continued to search for
- 21:56his little girl. As the investigation progressed, the center moved from the parking
- 22:00lot to the rec center, the same rec center where the dance, The
- 22:04Dandy Daughter Dance was held. Is this months later? Still? I don't
- 22:08know how long? How long it is? Yeah, it's months later.
- 22:12Greg felt tinges of pain and regret that he couldn't take Erica to the dance,
- 22:18and like I said, he still has this feeling today. Pam and
- 22:21Misty spent as many hours as possible the rec center manning the phone lines.
- 22:26A dedicated tip line had been created for Erica, and the tips poured in
- 22:32the National Center for Missing and Exploited Children, and the FBI stayed with the
- 22:36investigation at no cost to the city of Kettering. On June twenty second,
- 22:41nineteen ninety nine, well how long is this? She's disappeared? February?
- 22:47This is four months later. Misty brought a sheet cake to the command center
- 22:51and celebrated what would have been Erica's tenth birthday. Heartbreakingly, she cut the
- 22:56first slice and said she would freeze it to say for Erica when she came
- 23:00home. Oh, man, I know. Pam, Misty and Greg displayed
- 23:07resilience and mental fortitude throughout the investigation. At least they didn't blame each other.
- 23:11Yeah, right, the fingers at each other. You know, that's
- 23:15at least they stuck together. Yeah, Like you said, their dedication helped
- 23:18to keep Erica's case alive, and they're the reason that Erica's case continues to
- 23:25make headlines. Tips and leaves poured in, but they often led to dead
- 23:30ends. The residence of Kettering were on edge thinking that a child killer was
- 23:33on the loose. Kettering is about five miles from Dayton, like from Downpound
- 23:37Dayton, and most residents felt that these types of crimes only happened in the
- 23:41bigger cities. In July nineteen ninety nine, Pam picked up the phone and
- 23:47received a tip that would change the course of the investigation. The caller uttered
- 23:52one name, Christian Gabriel to Pam. Yeah, because she's at the command
- 23:56center. Remember Christian Gabriel and his girlfriend at the time, Jan Franks,
- 24:03were known to the Kettering Police Department the periods drugs and often found themselves in
- 24:07trouble with the law. Around the same time, Detective Green received a call
- 24:11from Clifford Butts, a prisoner who had recently watched America's Most Wanted Erica's case
- 24:18had been featured, and he told Detective Green he knew what happened to Erica.
- 24:22Detective Green sprung into action and immediately drove to meet with Clifford. This
- 24:27is where Erica's case takes a buzz our turn. Oh boy, Christian,
- 24:32we got a guy in prison that was watching America's most wanted said, hey,
- 24:36I know what happened. Okay, you got to talk to this guy,
- 24:38Clifford. Clifford butts. Clifford told the detective, you got to talk
- 24:44to Christian, okay. So this is one of the stories that Christian told
- 24:48the police. During Clifford's meeting with Detective Green, he said Christian confessed to
- 24:56accidentally killing Erica on February seventh. That afternoon, Clifford, his wife,
- 25:03Christian, and Jan, which was Christian's girlfriend. So Clifford was out of
- 25:07jail. Yeah, Clifford was out of jail. They were in the parking
- 25:10lot of a supermarket. Christian left his van and he said that's when the
- 25:15accident happened. So it's believed that Christian and Jan were high end crack at
- 25:21the time. Sack Man and this account of what happened would later change.
- 25:26So this is Clifford's account. Yeah, what happened. Then Detective Green brought
- 25:30Christian in for interrogation and a lie detective tests. Oh and he agreed.
- 25:36Yeah, I guess so. During the initial interview, Christian maintained his innocence
- 25:40and told officers he didn't kill Erica, he didn't know who did, and
- 25:44he didn't know if her body was somewhere. He had no idea. Detective
- 25:48Green was determined to discover the truth, even if it was going to take
- 25:51him like the rest of his life. And you told me, he's really
- 25:53good at interrogation. Yeah, and he knew that something about Christian's story just
- 25:59wasn't right, so he continued to apply the pressure. Investigators were also interested
- 26:03in Jan Frank's that was Christian's girlfriend. Yeah, you got to get the
- 26:07woman the right because Clifford Butts also said that Jan was there in the van
- 26:12that day. But they would come to find out that Jan was married while
- 26:17she was dating Christian, so she immediately lawyered up. Anne was assigned a
- 26:21federal public defender named Beth Lewis, So that means they charger. Yeah,
- 26:26she's assigned. Why they would I don't know why they would charge her charger
- 26:30with her. She's assigned an attorney. I mean, she's charged with some
- 26:33bullshit misdemeanor being in a park when she should be whatever. Applying the pressure,
- 26:40Beth Lewis was determined not to let the Kettering Police Department nor the FBI
- 26:45talked to her client Jan throughout the nineteen nineties. In the early two thousands,
- 26:49Beth continued to create a wall of silence around Jan. So Bath is
- 26:53Jan's attorney, Yep, and she's doing a badass job. Yep, she's
- 26:56defending her client. Yeah. Then two thousand and one, Jan Franks passed
- 27:02away due to an overdose. So who knows what she knew? I feel
- 27:07he has an attorney. I'd be like, Okay, now I can write
- 27:10that book, right, I know? But can't you want to know?
- 27:14You know? I told you like Jan was married. Her husband couldn't break
- 27:18that attorney client confidentiality privilege. But he decided after she died, he was
- 27:25going to do what was right her husband, and he went to Erica's family
- 27:30because, I mean, there's no marital privilege anymore. She's dead, right,
- 27:34Who's gonna question that. Jan's husband wanted Beth to go to Erica's family
- 27:40and be like, Okay, we have to come clean. But Beth continued
- 27:45to stay quiet. She argued her case for several years. That was until
- 27:48she was hit with a contempt of court order. The Ohio Supreme Court unanimously
- 27:55decided Beth Lewis had to talk in two thousand and four as an attorney,
- 28:00Yeah, how is that possible? I don't know. They made her though.
- 28:03The prosecutor, Matthias heck Junior told AP News, quote, anything and
- 28:07everything we can get is what we're after. We want every bit of information
- 28:12we can about what happened, where Erica is and what happened to her.
- 28:17After the Supreme Court ruling, Beth Lewis had no choice but to talk and
- 28:21guess what, she had no viable information for the least. To this day,
- 28:26nobody knows why Beth went to extreme lengths to protect information that wasn't even
- 28:30useful. Yeah, I mean, if you know, I don't know,
- 28:33I don't know. Listen, I'll talk to you guys. This is what
- 28:37mc clients said. Didn't say shit. I know in this process she picked
- 28:40up a contempt of court charge. I've never had one of those. I
- 28:44haven't either not yet not yet. She likely ruined her professional reputation. I
- 28:52mean, I don't know, or she got more publicity and people called her
- 28:56all the time. Yeah that's true, Say shit, I know, right,
- 29:00so, but I don't know what she's doing today. The pressure on
- 29:03Christian was also mounting. He had found himself a new girlfriend, Jane was
- 29:07married to somebody else and Plush passed away, and this girlfriend had no idea
- 29:12about his possible involvement in Erica's case. The National Center for Missing and Exploited
- 29:18Children decided to up the ANNIE and showered the area where the pair lived with
- 29:23Erica's missing persons posters and flyers. At one point, Christian's new girlfriend demanded
- 29:30to know what was going on. This moment was captured during a recorded prison
- 29:33call while Christians he was serving time on unrelated charges. I demanded, no
- 29:38on a prison phone. Yeah if you killed somebody? Okay, Well girl,
- 29:44I ain't telling you shit. I'm on a prison phone, so Christian's
- 29:47new girlfriend. She was then contacted by Detective Green. He briefed around the
- 29:52case, and when cattering Police Department officers arrived to her door, she was
- 29:57exceptionally forthcoming. Living in the area, she had heard of Erica's case,
- 30:02but she had no idea that her boyfriend and the father of her child,
- 30:06Yeah, had been interviewed and viewed as a suspect. When she welcomed the
- 30:11officers into her home, she guided them toward the kitchen. The officers were
- 30:14confused at first. In the kitchen, she approached the fridge, removed herself
- 30:19from view, and stop pointed to Erica's missing poster, but she had placed
- 30:23there, Okay, all right. She also revealed that Christian had relapsed and
- 30:29began smoking crack again. As Christian had found himself incarcerated once more, Detective
- 30:33Green decided it was time to pay him another visit. Detective Green said,
- 30:38So, I had a chair right next to him, and I moved over
- 30:41him. I said, why don't you tell me more about that? And
- 30:45as in listening, I said to myself, I will never forget this for
- 30:48as long as I live. On July nineteenth, two thousand and four,
- 30:52Christian confessed to Detective Green that he jan Frank's, Clifford Butts, and Clifford's
- 30:56wife had been in his vand that day after me at the supermarket. Like
- 31:00I told you, they were driving on the intersection of Glengarry Drive and pow
- 31:06Wotton when they heard the thud of something hitting the van. But it wasn't
- 31:11something. It was Erica. I know this story, you now, I
- 31:15do. Christian claimed that she darted out into the middle of the road and
- 31:21there was nothing he could do to stop. According to Detective Green, Christian
- 31:25could describe both Erica and the dog, Jamie, right down to the minute
- 31:29details of Jamie's adorable little doggie mustache. He then claimed they all panicked,
- 31:34threw Erica into the back of the van, and drove to his apartment.
- 31:38Christian couldn't remember whether Erica was alive or dead when he threw her into the
- 31:41van. Instead of calling police or seeking help for Erica, they drove back
- 31:45to his apartment, left her body in the van, and then the four
- 31:49smoked crack, okay, just to take the edge off. And while they
- 31:55were smoking crack, they decided what they were going to do with Erica.
- 31:57As Detective Green pointed out, they could have driven Erica to a nearby hospital,
- 32:01but they are smoking cracked. They could have left her at the entrance.
- 32:06I mean, they didn't even have to just crawled anonymously, right,
- 32:12But instead they're going to do something really stupid. After finishing their crack smoking,
- 32:17apparently, Jan hopped into the driver's seat and assured Christian that she knew
- 32:22a great spot to hide a body. Oh that's nice, and that little
- 32:24Airica would never be found. Oh that's fucking great. I know. The
- 32:28defective Green would later question the validity of this confession. Is Jan Franks couldn't
- 32:34drive a manual car. Oh it was a stick shift. Yeah it was
- 32:37a stick shift. I can't drive one even I Can'm bad ass. They
- 32:40don't have them anymore, but I tried to learn once when I had owned
- 32:45a Mustang, but I bought an auto. Man Mustang such a bad ass
- 32:49to it was a convertible. I love it. Ah, of course she
- 32:52would, And then I got pregnant. He had to get rid of it.
- 32:54Yeah that's right. You got him a minivan instead. One day.
- 32:59I'm gonna get that must back another convertible one day, and it's going to
- 33:01be an automatic because I can't drive a stick anyway. The four drove to
- 33:07Huffman Dam, and again Christian gave varying stories. At first, he told
- 33:12Detective Green that he could take them to where Erica's body was, which was
- 33:15a fifteen or thirty minute walk into the woods. Then he changed his story
- 33:19and said that he had stayed in the van while the others went to get
- 33:22rid of Erica, and that he was drunk and high. He also threw
- 33:24in details such as Clifford coming back without a coat, and also said they
- 33:29had possibly driven to Caesar Creek State Park, a whole twenty six miles away
- 33:32from Huffman. Dam what the fun man? And where the fuck is it?
- 33:37Like? Where where did you go? I may not get your cracked
- 33:39out? But come on, I know, come on. According to Detective
- 33:44Green, Christian asked for a bathroom break like during this confessional pee I know,
- 33:49And as he was leaving the room, he turned a Detective Green and
- 33:52said, what would I get for tampering with evidence, gross abuse of a
- 33:57corpse, and vehicular manslaughter. At this point, Christian had pretty much confessed
- 34:01to driving the van that day, and Detective Green knew he had what he
- 34:06needed. It would take several months, but on December thirteenth, two thousand
- 34:09and four, Christian Gabriel provided the Kettering Police Department with a written confession.
- 34:15Part of his confession read I'm really sorry, missus Baker for what has been
- 34:19done. Nothing was done to her after she was hit. She wasn't raped
- 34:22or anything like that. I know, because I'm not that sick of a
- 34:27person that wouldn't rape a girl he hit on a road. I know,
- 34:32I could just hurt some and then it's sick, like when somebody makes a
- 34:37mistake in it's s I c like, so they fucked it up. He
- 34:39wrote something fucked up here, like it didn't make sense. So I could
- 34:44just hurt some that is so precious in God's eyes. Again, I'm sorry.
- 34:47So I think maybe he meant I couldn't hurt someone, but I could
- 34:52put her in the trunk and go smoke crack and if she's alive or daddy.
- 34:57Yeah. But he yeah, Okay, he's got standards. He can
- 35:01fuck off, I know. Right. In October two thousand and five,
- 35:05just three days before the Statute of Limitations was up. It was a six
- 35:08year statute for what the vehicular man so well, he was indicted on charges
- 35:14of tampering with evidence and gross abuse of a course. Several weeks later,
- 35:19he was found guilty on both counts and sentenced to a shocking six whole years
- 35:22in prison. While Pam, Misty and Gregg were relieved that someone had finally
- 35:27been held accountable for Erica's disappearance, the sentence nor the charges really felt like
- 35:32justice. And we don't even know if he's fucking telling the truth about any
- 35:36of this. I know he couldn't be charged with murder because according to Ohio
- 35:39law, a body must be found before someone can beg an old law.
- 35:45Christians story has changed so much over the years that nobody believes him at all.
- 35:49Was it really an accident or was Erica targeted? Christian claimed that he
- 35:52wanted to take Erica to the hospital, but Jane, who was no longer
- 35:57alive to dispute this, said it would get them in trouble. Some believe
- 36:00the group didn't turn themselves in due to the drug use prior convictions, or
- 36:06maybe the fact that they likely had drugs in the van. No DNA evidence
- 36:10was ever found in Christian's van, and by the time it had been forensically
- 36:15searched, had been cleaned and given to a new owner. Better have some
- 36:19sort of closure for me, Tanya, As if this case doesn't have enough
- 36:22twists and turns, they're still more in June twenty eleven, Christian was released
- 36:27after serving his measly six year sentence. The residence of Cattering were anticipating his
- 36:31release and was shot that a car was waiting outside the prison for him.
- 36:37Insight, said a woman. But it wasn't Christian's mom, who had stood
- 36:40by him throughout the case. It was someone else's mom. He fell in
- 36:44love in fucking prison. No, it was Pam. Pam, yeah,
- 36:47grandma, yeah, grandma. Yes. When Greg Baker heard that Pam had
- 36:52picked Christian up from prison, he was living What the fuck is this shit?
- 36:57I know, he was pi. Christian been convicted of abusing a corpse
- 37:02and tampering with evidence, and now Pam's given him ride home. She must
- 37:07believe his sorry tale. Well, she said, she said, you know,
- 37:10this is how she defended herself. She said the only reason she picked
- 37:14him up on his release day was because she wanted to talk to him face
- 37:16to face. She practically begged Christian to take her to her granddaughter's body,
- 37:22and even told him that she had a shovel in the boot of the car
- 37:25ready to bring Erica home. Oh man, I know, she told Fox
- 37:30nineteen. I've done everything I can to try and convince him to tell me.
- 37:35I even picked him up and took him to his mother, hoping he
- 37:37would talk to me. Okay, well, I I mean I guess I
- 37:39see she's lost it. Yeah. Unfortunately her this move didn't pan out.
- 37:45Yeah, and Christian just feigned ignorance. Pam was just shattered. She thought
- 37:50she could somehow reach his soul, but she didn't realize he has So he
- 37:53has no fucking soul, right, somebody would know soul does something like this.
- 37:57You accidentally hit somebody, if that's what really happened, you just bury
- 38:00their body because you panicked and don't remember where you yeah, and don't yeah,
- 38:05exactly because you bury so many bodies, right, come on. Pam,
- 38:07Misty and Greg continued to advocate for Erica and want her remain so they
- 38:13can give her the burial she deserves. As of two twenty three, Erica's
- 38:16case is still being investigated. Stop I wanted an end, and although a
- 38:21Detective Bob Green is now retired, he does not say that Erica's case is
- 38:24cold, and neither do those still working on it in the Kettering Police Department.
- 38:30And twenty twenty two, a new witness came forward who stated that they
- 38:32had seen Christians Van in Huffman Dam on the evening of February seventh, nineteen
- 38:37ninety one, and that's one of the places he had said. Yeah,
- 38:39yeah, this witness did not come forward earlier because they feared repercussions. How
- 38:45would you remember that? Like I wouldn't remember for a song. They might
- 38:49know him. Maybe maybe that's why they feared repercussions. And of course they
- 38:53has to drive a van exactly right, no offense all the other van drivers.
- 38:59But you know what I'm saying. The police department continued to do searches
- 39:02and such, and during one of these searches recently in twenty twenty two,
- 39:07forensic investigators came across bones at Hoffman Dam. Unfortunately, they were later determined
- 39:12to be non human, but to find has only encouraged the Cattering Police Department
- 39:16to keep looking. Texas Equisearch has also sent officers and resources to Cattering sniffer
- 39:22dogs. Sniffer dogs were also brought in and these dogs hit on two locations
- 39:30close to a creek. Interestingly, the area that was searched and where the
- 39:34dogs alerted was smack dab in between Hoffman Dam and there's another state park like
- 39:39that other state park that Christian had talked about. Detective Green I mentioned has
- 39:44long since retired, but he was present for the twenty twenty two search that
- 39:47was brought about. He celebrates Erica's birthday every year and vows to never forget
- 39:52her. Her case is one of the only ones in his career that remain
- 39:57sort of unsolved. Technically, it sounds we don't really know what happened,
- 40:00right, And he's made it his mission to bring the family closure before he
- 40:05and they pass away. Misty and Pam have moved away from Kettering. They
- 40:09were unable to stay in the home that held so many memories and so much
- 40:13pain for them. I'll be able to stay in that town either. Pam,
- 40:16Missy and Greg celebrate Erica's birthday every year. I'll drive around all the
- 40:21time, just so right, and I like searching woods and you know,
- 40:25losing my mind. Christian Gabriel has since dropped off the face of the earth.
- 40:30Nobody knows where he's really no, I mean, nobody knows exactly where
- 40:34he's at. Authorities believe he might be living in Oregon, but nobody knows.
- 40:37Pam has said that the only real closure that she would have would be
- 40:40if Erica walked through the door, you know, if she's still alive,
- 40:45Erica would be thirty three years old today. And anyone with information is asked
- 40:50to contact Detective Mason of the Kettering Police Department at nine three seven two ninety
- 40:55six two five five, quoting case number nine nine zero two sixty six.
- 41:01And that's the random story. And I know, I think they probably were
- 41:07on crack and hit her. Probably, I mean, I wouldn't doubt it.
- 41:09I sound they're a bunch of fucking idiots on crack. They didn't know
- 41:13what to fucking do. And yeah, how is there no blood on the
- 41:16dog leash? I know, like I'm thinking maybe the dog get away from
- 41:20her and she ran to go get it. She ran to the street and
- 41:22these idiots are coming by baryling down. Yeah, and they could not cranking
- 41:27some music, smoking some c I mean, that could have happened. I
- 41:30don't know who knows. That's sad. I know, I'm sorry, I'm
- 41:35sorry. I want a sad one. The story is sad. Yeah,
- 41:40you're right, it's usually about someone being murdered, that's true. But some
- 41:45touched me more than others. Yeah, I know what you mean. Yeah,
- 41:49I mean, well, we got some shout outs. Oh, we
- 41:53had to do that. These are our favorite people ever and if you're wondering
- 41:58who they are, these are people that have signed up for our Patreon yep.
- 42:00And if you're an Apple subscriber and we'll like a shout out, Apple
- 42:04does not give us your name or share any information about Apple doesn't share shit.
- 42:07Yeah, so you have to contact us directly and you can email us
- 42:12contact at Crimes and Consequences dot com. So anyway, these are our shoutouts
- 42:16Patreon dot com, slash t NT crime TNT crimes. We have Mike M,
- 42:24Denise W. Tisha Pe Sam G kay T, Tammy S. Frank
- 42:30C. I'm gonna mess this person's name out. No, we always do.
- 42:35Fan T it's t h A n H. I don't know as I'm
- 42:37sorry if I said it Roight Fan, I'm sorry, Lauren H Leanne f
- 42:45und G. We have a member from Iceland. Oh yeah, welcome,
- 42:52Welcome, Barbara D, Laura N. Luffy Pede let sure who that is?
- 42:58Luffy Bluffy P. Who's Lucky I don't know Lucky P? Though,
- 43:02Zoey N. Sarah F Michelle Y, Mackenzie B Erica B, Robert C,
- 43:08Nicole tbrah W Sean As, Holy shit, there's a lot we haven't
- 43:14done it in a while. Jennifer G, Monica Vie, Jennifer m Ainsley,
- 43:19ka Anna G, Trista S, Kai D, Max F, subin
- 43:24A, jene H Brianna G, Megan S, Jennifer P Ashley S,
- 43:30Nicole S, Sinnah c Amelia P, Naomi F. There's a lot of
- 43:36peas going yeah, Vanessa F, Nicolette G, Nicole P, Jordan J
- 43:40and Melinda L. Who Thank you cool people. You guys are rock so
- 43:49yeah, bless you God bless We love all of you. So we've told
- 43:53you about our Patreon. You can also find us on social media at Hardcore
- 43:57True Crime on Facebook and Graham and until our next episode, don't kill each Other byee